Analysis and Provenience of Minoan and Mycenaean Amber, IV. Mycenae Beck, Curt W;Southard, Gretchen C;Adams, Audrey B Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies; Winter 1972; 13, 4; ProQuest pg. 359 Analysis and Provenience of Minoan and Mycenaean Amber, IV. Mycenae Curt W. Beck, Gretchen C. Southard, Audrey B. Adams H OMER might have called Mycenae 17'OAV~AEIC'TPOC as well as 17'OAVXPvcoc: when Schliemann dug the shaft graves within the citadel (now Grave Circle A), he saw in some of them "enormous quantities of amber beads";1 Wace found amber in several of the chamber tombs, especially those dating to L.H. I/ll;2 most recently, the discovery of Grave Circle B has yielded a large number of amber beads and some spacers in Grave Omicron.3 The provenience of the amber of Mycenae has been an issue among archae­ ologists and chemists for almost a century. Schliemann early took a view which was at once cautiously con­ servative and highly sophisticated, a rare combination at any time. He wrote of the amber in Grave Circle A: "These beads have grown dark-brown, probably owing to their great antiquity, so that we at first mistook them for resin, but the analysis of Professor Landerer has shown that they consist of the purest amber. It will, of course, forever remain a secret to us whether this amber is derived from the coast of the Baltic or from Italy, where it is found in several places, but particularly on the east coast of Sicily; but it is highly probable that it was brought to Greece by the Phoenicians ... "4 It was sophisticated of Schliemann to recognize that the dark color of his amber finds was due to their age. Even today some archaeolo­ gists, knowing that freshly dug Baltic amber is usually of a light yellow color while southern amber is often brown or red, conclude too hastily that a dark color in archaeological amber artifacts indicates southern origin. It was equally sophisticated to refer the decision between 'resin' and 1 H. Schiiemann, Mycenae (New York 1878) 203; German ed. (Leipzig 1878) 235. 2 A. J. B. Wace, "Chamber Tombs at Mycenae," Archaeologia 82 (1932). 3 J. Papademitriou, Praktika (1952) 427-72. , Schliemann, op.cit. (supra n.l). 359 360 ANALYSIS OF MINOAN AND MYCENAEAN AMBER • amber' to a chemist at a time when that species of scientist had as yet shown little interest in archaeology and made few contributions to it. He turned to Xaver Landerer (1809-1885), a German chemist and pharmacist, who was then Professor of Chemistry at the University and at the Polytechnicum in Athens as well as personal apothecary to King George I, and who had earlier analyzed metals, glass and pig­ ments of ancient Greece.O We do not know what chemical tests convinced Landerer that the finds from the shaft graves consisted "of the purest amber," but Schliemann cautiously leaves open the question whether the amber is of Baltic or of Italian origin: either place fits Homer's clear indica­ tion that it was the Phoenicians who conveyed amber to Greece.s Schliemann was probably aware of Capellini's hypothesis that amber found in Mediterranean archaeological contexts might be of southern rather than of Baltic provenience, but when he wrote Mycenae he cannot yet have known of Helm's claims7 to be able to distinguish between the two. The chemist Landerer seems to have been less cautious. At the VIIIe Congres International d' Anthropologie et d' A rcheologie Prehistoriques in Budapest in 1876 he announced that the amber of Mycenae was of Sicilian origin. We have not found this statement in the comptes rendus of that congress,.which reproduces the lectures but not the discussions, but in his account of the Budapest meeting Chierici reports that Hil Landerer, come risultato di sue analisi, ci da per ambra della Sicilia la gialla raccolta dalle richissime tombe di Micene."8 This is corrobora­ ted by Brizio, who describes "una quantid di pallottole di ambra gialla della specie piu pura e proveniente, secondo l'analisi chimica del Prof. Landerer, dalle coste della Sicilia,"9 though without refer­ ence to the congress at Budapest. Again we do not know what chemical evidence led Landerer to his conclusion; Schliemann was either unaware of it or did not accept it, and the same appears to be true of Helm, who refers to "Canderer's" (sic) identification of the finds from Mycenae as "purest amber," but 5 J. C. PoggendorfI. Biographisch-Literarisches Handworterbuch III (Leipzig 1898) 770. 6 Od. 15.460. 7 O. Helm. "Notizen tiber die chemische und physikalische Beschaffenheit des Bern­ steins." ArchPharm 211 (1877) 229-46. 8 G. ehierici. BPI 4 (1878) 175. 9 E. Brizio. Nuova Antologia 1 (1879) 86. CURT W. BECK, GRETCHEN C. SOUTHARD, AUDREY B. ADAMS 361 not to his determination of its provenience.10 A detailed and critical account of all previous work, including Helm's analyses which led him to pronounce the amber of Mycenae as Baltic and which Schlie­ mann did accept,n has been given in the first article of this series.12 We therefore repeat here only that Helm's findings only increase the a priori probability that amber objects of such size and in such numbers as Schliemann found in the shaft graves of Circle A are of Baltic origin. Below we report our own spectroscopic analyses of the amber found at Mycenae to which we had access in the National Museum in Athens in the summer of 1965. For the sake of complete­ ness we also bring together all other amber finds from Mycenae which we have found in the literature. Grave Circle A SHAFT GRAVE I This is Schliemann's