171 Razak Abdul Aziz’s Pepatah Episodes: Re-Imaging the Malay Proverbs through Piano Music Mohd Fairuz bin Zamani Universiti Sains Malaysia, Malaysia Submitted: 2022-09-29. Revised: 2023-02-08. Accepted: 2023-05-09 Abstract Proverb sits under the umbrella of figurative language and is used to sweeten speeches. In Malay, pepatah is the equivalent of this form of figurative language. Razak Abdul Aziz, a Malaysian com- poser, selected a set of Malay proverbs and adapted them into his piano work, Pepatah Episodes. The composer follows the tradition of piano programme music that uses figurative language elements championed by composers such as Alexander Scriabin, Claude Debussy, and Maurice Ravel. This paper aims to investigate the pepatahs chosen to be paired with the written music, expounding the programme in the movements for piano. Using the programme music analysis framework by Burkholder et al. (2014) and Kregor (2015), the finding shows that the composer chose the pepatahs for one of the three (3) portrayals: (i) imageries in the pepatah (ii) imageries in the meaning, and (iii) imageries in pepatah and meaning. The programme analysis shows that from the nine (9) movements written for piano, four (4) movements portray imageries in the pepa- tah, three (3) movements portray imageries in the meaning, and two (2) movements portray im- ageries in the pepatah and meaning. Razak Abdul Aziz challenges the conventions of programme music by having the pepatah set after the music is written, demanding the performer to read it aloud before performing and having the portrayal of the pepatah in the mentioned ways. This provides a different perspective for other composers to produce works using similar frameworks and scholars to analyse musical works. Keywords: proverb, piano programme music, Razak Abdul Aziz, programme music analysis, Malaysian contemporary composer How to Cite: Zamani, M. F. (2023). Razak Abdul Aziz’s Pepatah Episodes: Re-Imaging the Malay Proverbs through Piano Music. Harmonia: Journal of Arts Research and Education, 23(1), 171-186 Harmonia: Journal of Arts Research and Education 23 (1) (2023), 171-186 Available online at http://journal.unnes.ac.id/nju/index.php/harmonia DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15294/harmonia.v23i1.39275 on this composer, citing scholarly and non- scholarly sources. Proverb, pepatah, and Razak Abdul Aziz What is a proverb? Various scholars have made many attempts to define pro- verbs through time. Mieder (1996) defines proverbs as: concise traditional statements of ap- parent truths with currency among the folk. More elaborately stated, proverbs are INTRODUCTION This section provides the necessary background for this paper. It begins with an introduction to proverbs according to scholars from the English and Malay con- text and recognising it as part of a bigger literary umbrella – figurative language. It is then followed by briefly mentioning Razak Abdul Aziz’s Pepatah Episodes and short biography, and related past studies Corresponding author: E-mail: fairuzzamani@usm.my p-ISSN 2541-1683|e-ISSN 2541-2426 Harmonia: Journal of Arts Research and Education 23 (1) (2023): 171-186172 short, generally known sentences of the folk that contain wisdom, truths, morals, and traditional views in a metaphorical, fixed, and memorisable form and that are handed down from generation to generati- on (p. 597). Winick (2003) agrees with Mieder (1996, p. 595), stating that proverbs are “brief (sentence-length) textualized utte- rances which derive a sense of wisdom, wit, and authority, from explicit and inten- tional intertextual reference to a tradition of previous similar wisdom utterances.” As “proverbs are part of the language me- dium of every culture, certainly of every literature culture” (Honeck et al., 2019, p. 128), they are an important tool of commu- nication as “proverbs sweeten speeches” (Amuah & Wuaku, 2019, p. 134). Proverb belongs to a larger literary body called fi- gurative language. Katz (1998) stated that among the prominent and most studied forms of figurative language are metaphor, irony, idioms, and indirect requests, though Roberts and Kreuz (1994) listed eight (8) commonly used forms of figura- tive language: (i) hyperbole, (ii) idiom, (iii) indirect request, (iv) irony, (v) understate- ment, (vi) metaphor, (vii) rhetorical questi- on, and (viii) simile. In Malay literature, pepatah is the equivalent of a proverb. According to Ka- mus Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka, pepatah is defined as an “idiom that contains wisdom and the teachings of the elderly.” Mat Piah (1986) characterized pepatah as containing lessons, representations, and the values of the Malays (p.25). Bakar et al. (1981) stated the word pepatah derives from the doubling of patah (to break). Hence pepa- tah in Malay literature is a delicate way to “break off” arguments (usually opposing) using sarcasm and/or representation (p.6). In short, pepatah is a Malay proverb that holds wisdom, lesson, and representation, which is used as a delicate way to break arguments that typically contain sarcasm. These qualities of pepatah are made clear in Razak Abdul Aziz’s Pepatah Episodes. Furt- her discussion on this piece can be found in the latter part of this research. Razak Abdul Aziz (1959 - ) is a Malay- sian contemporary composer. Possibly the earliest of its kind in Malaysia (Zamani et al., 2019), he has been composing contem- porary music since the 1980s (Hall, 1988, p.30). Among his notable compositions in- clude 10 Pantun Settings, Maria Zaitun, For Violin and Piano, Etudes for Piano Solo, and 5 Early Songs. His works have been perfor- med on local and international platforms (Zamani et al., 2019). However, full-scale recitals consisting of works by this compo- ser alone only took place in 2019 and 2020, as Zamani (2021) reported. Last served at Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM) before retiring in November 2019, Razak Abdul Aziz is still active in composing new music and revising his older works. Pepatah Epi- sodes, which this paper intends to investi- gate, was first written in 2019 and revised in 2020, after the composer thought that he needed to make improvements to the work as his musical directions had slight- ly changed and matured over this period (Abdul Aziz, 2 August 2021). The idea of incorporating Malay proverbs in a piano composition derives from his knowledge and understanding of the standard piano repertory of Western classical music, whe- re past composers had used figurative lan- guage (mainly short and long poems) as their source of inspiration in writing pro- gramme music. However, instead of using poems, Razak Abdul Aziz wanted to be different and incorporated another form of figurative language – pepatah. The compo- ser wrote the piano music by re-imagining a set of pepatah to be suited to the written music. Further discussion on this will be revealed further down this paper. Literature on the Use of Figurative Lan- guage in Piano To position Pepatah Episodes in the piano literature, the author would like to continue this discussion by reviewing the standard piano repertory of Western clas- sical music. The review contains a brief overview of programme music and figu- rative language in music and discussions on several significant piano works by past Mohd Fairuz bin Zamani, Razak Abdul Aziz’s Pepatah Episodes: Re-Imaging the Malay 173 composers that had used figurative langu- age (poem) in their thought processes. The author chooses poems instead of proverbs because the use of proverbs in the stan- dard piano repertory does not exist (at le- ast to the knowledge of the author). Since poems and proverbs are under the umbrel- la of figurative language, the author belie- ves this commonality shall do justice to the reader’s comprehension of figurative lan- guage in piano programme music. Finally, the review will reveal how Pepatah Episodes is positioned in the piano literature in the context of programme music locally and globally. Programme Music and Figurative Lan- guage The use of figurative language in the standard piano repertory probably be- came prominent from the Romantic era, when programme music was adapted into the musical vocabulary. Programme music refers almost exclusively to works in the European classical music tradition (New World Encyclopaedia, 2019). Kami- en (2011) stated that “Romantic composers were particularly attracted to program(me) music – instrumental music associated with a story, poem, idea, or scene (p. 238).” Though the tradition of using the element of programme in writing instrumental mu- sic had existed as early as the Renaissan- ce through the Classical eras, the author would not be discussing it in this review as piano (as a musical instrument) did not exist during the Renaissance era and was not a prominent instrument in the Baroque era. Though piano started to gain more attention in the Classical era, this musical period was known for its peak in musical forms and absolute music (New World En- cyclopaedia, 2019). There is an array of programme mu- sic in the piano literature. However, the number of piano works that incorporated figurative language in the music literatu- re is relatively small. This statement might be controversial if one were to conduct a cursory examination on this matter, only to be confused perceiving works such as Franz Liszt’s Three Sonetto of Petrarca, Chopin’s Ballades, or Pyotr Tchaikovsky’s The Seasons as using figurative language elements when the fact is Liszt wrote pia- no transcriptions after his art songs of the same title. In contrast, Chopin, though deemed as “poet of the piano,” never in- tended his music to be programmatic. The Seasons uses epigraphs from various Russi- an authors that were chosen by the maga- zine editor, not the composer. The author would like to continue the discussion by reviewing a few pro- grammatic piano works that used figu- rative language (poem) in their creative processes. This is vital to position the use of this element to understand the thought and creative processes in the selected works from the perspective of composers and scholars, which would be an impor- tant component to link towards the centre- piece of this paper. Scriabin, Debussy, and Ravel Composers Alexander Scriabin (1875-1915), Claude Debussy (1862-1918), and Maurice Ravel (1875-1937) were kno- wn to have written some of the most notab- le piano works that incorporated poems as part of the compositional body. The author chose these composers and their selected works to represent the entirety of this ca- tegory, as these works could demonstrate the general idea of how poems are being translated into music, as discussed and analysed by various scholars. Scriabin was known to write his po- ems and set them to his piano composi- tions. For example, Bowers (1974) stated that Scriabin intended to write a piano bal- lade based on his first poem. “Oh count- ry of visions!/ How different from life,/ Where I have no place,/ But there, I hear voices,/A world of beatitudinous souls,/I see.” However, this work was left unfinis- hed and later adapted into his fourth pre- lude from Preludes Op. 11. This feeling of “not belonging to the country of visions” yet appreciating the world of utmost bliss and happiness is translated into the music with beautiful melodies on both hands, Harmonia: Journal of Arts Research and Education 23 (1) (2023): 171-186174 indicated with tenutos, with the left-hand melody being perceived as the most exqui- site between the two (Hinson, 2003). Sc- riabin also wrote a poetic programme for his Fourth Piano Sonata. Possibly his most played sonata, Scriabin set the said work to the following poem (Scriabin, 1903-1904, in Ballard & Bengston, 2017): In a light mist, transparent vapor Lost afar and yet distinct A star gleams softly. How beautiful! The bluish mystery Of her glow Beckons me, cradles me. O bring me to thee, far distant star! Bathe me in trembling rays Sweet light! Sharp desire, voluptuous and crazed yet sweet Endlessly with no other goal than longing I would desire But no! I vault in joyous leap Freely I take wing. Mad dance, godlike play! Intoxicating, shining one! It is toward thee, adored star My flight guides me. Mad dance, godlike play! Intoxicating, shining one! Toward thee, created freely for me To serve the end My flight of liberation! In this play Sheer caprice In moments I forget thee In the maelstrom that carries me I veer from they glimmering rays. In the intensity of desire Thou fadest O distant goal. But ever thou shinest As I forever desire thee! Thou expandest, Star! Now thou art a Sun Flamboyant Sun! Sun of Triumph! Approaching thee by my desire for thee I lave myself in they changing waves O joyous god. I swallow thee Sea of light. My self-of-light I engulf thee! Ballard and Bengston (2017) describe the poem and sonata as erotic. Buranap- rapuk (2013) expounds on the correlation between the poem and this sonata. She concluded that the structure of the poem is similar to the structure of the piano work, stating “the contrasting affects (effects) of the poem – the first part sounds static, whi- le action occurs in the second part – cor- respond with the characters of two attacca movements of the Sonata (p.44).” Bura- naprapuk also explained how the colouris- tic elements in the poem were transformed into music using various harmonic pro- cedures combined with Scriabin’s conditi- on as a synesthete. Debussy was regarded as the first French Impressionist composer, though he rejected the label (Nichols, 1998). The composer had written several program- matic works using descriptive titles that are considered significant to the standard Western music repertory such as Prelude to the Afternoon of a Faun (1894), Reflection in the Water and And the Moon Descends on the Temple that was from Images (1901-1905), The Sounds and Fragrances Swirl through the Evening Air, Footsteps in the Snow, What the West Wind Has Seen from Preludes for Solo Piano Book 1 (1909-1910), and Moon- light (Clair de lune) from Suite Bergamas- que (1905). He was also inspired by works written by Stéphane Mallarmé (1842-1898) and Paul Verlaine (1844-1896), who were among the great French poets. Possibly Debussy’s most-played solo piano pie- ce that was inspired by the poem is Clair de lune from Suite Bergamasque (Debussy, Mohd Fairuz bin Zamani, Razak Abdul Aziz’s Pepatah Episodes: Re-Imaging the Malay 175 2007). Based on a poem of a similar tit- le by Verlaine, the music stands out from the rest of the set as it is the only piece in the suite that is not using dance form. Guo (2019, p. 28) concluded that Clair de lune’s beauty lies in its “simple musical texture, filled with delicate and romantic feelings, depicting the beauty of the moonlight.” A musical translation of Verlaine’s poem, Debussy stated, “it is inscribed in nature. It must be in intimate accord with the scene- ry” (Schmitz, 1950, p.53). Ravel was another French composer who was associated with the Impressionis- tic movement alongside his elder contem- porary, Debussy. Known to have written a vast number of musical works for various mediums of instrumentation, his contri- bution to piano music repertory is unde- niable, although he only composed fewer than 30 piano works that demonstrated his wide range of musical language (Ore- nstein, 1991). Possibly the most substantial set of work in the standard piano repertory to date, Gaspard de la nuit (1908) has a beau- ty and originality with a deeper inspirati- on “in the harmonic and melodic genius of Ravel himself” (Sackville-West & Shawe- Taylor, 1951, p.613). This three-movement solo piano work is a musical depiction of two (2) mystical creatures (Ondine [Water nymph] and Scarbo [Goblin]) and one (1) disturbing visual (Le Gibet [The gibbet]), portrayed in Aloysius Bertrand’s poems Gaspard de la nuit (1846). Tomić (2020) found that Ravel uses “diverse harmonisa- tions of thematic materials to manipulate the formal and harmonic outlook” to port- ray the water spirit in Ondine (p.84). The disturbing visual in Le Gibet is depicted in music using unclear harmonic progression and tonal ambiguity (p.85) while the mi- schievous Scarbo is characterised through Impressionistic harmony combined with Spanish musical folklore (p.92), conclu- ding that Ravel’s Gaspard de la nuit emp- loys timbre as its fundamental component (p.190). From the examination of Scriabin’s Fourth Prelude and Fourth Piano Sona- ta, Debussy’s Clair de lune, and Ravel’s Gaspard de la nuit, one could observe how each work translated the figurative lan- guage (poems) into musical elements. Understanding that figurative language could be translated into music through the composer’s personal musicality is essen- tial to appreciate how Razak Abdul Aziz translated figurative language (pepatah) into his Pepatah Episodes, which would be examined later in this writing. Research Background and Problem This section provides a brief descrip- tion of Pepatah Episodes, a table consisting of the pepatahs chosen with their respective literal translations and meaning (as provi- ded by the composer in the piano score), and the background problem for this stu- dy. Providing this information is vital to aid the reader’s comprehension in under- standing the succeeding sections, which are Methodology and Result and Discussi- on.Brief description of Pepatah Episodes As mentioned earlier, Pepatah Epi- sodes was written in 2019 and revised in 2020. Zamani (2021) reported its premiere in early 2020, where he performed the 2019 version as part of his academic recital, as the revised version was only completed in October 2020 (Abdul Aziz, 2 October 2020). The revision consists of 12 short mo- vements, with one (1) pepatah assigned to each. The pepatahs, their literal translation, and their meaning (as written by the com- poser in the score) are as Table 1. Research problems Razak Abdul Aziz has been consis- tent throughout the interviews (2 Octo- ber 2020; 2 August 2021; 4 August 2022), stating that each pepatah was only chosen after he had completed writing the music. Though the composer had already plan- ned to use pepatah during the initial crea- tive process, he had yet to determine the exact pepatahs to use. Only after scoring the music in 12 short movements the compo- ser took a second look at the work, listened closely to the written music, and then de- termined and assigned one pepatah to each movement. This is true for both versions Harmonia: Journal of Arts Research and Education 23 (1) (2023): 171-186176 Table 1. Pepatahs, literal translation, and meaning Pepatah Literal translation Meaning Alah bisa tegal biasa. Poison loses its potency when one is accustomed to tackling it. Custom makes things easy. Air dicincang tak akan putus. Water does not break up when diced. Blood ties do not break. Kalau tak dipecahkan ruyung, manakan dapat sagunya? If you don’t break the kernel, how are you to obtain the sago? If you don’t expend ef- fort, how will you reap the reward? Yang bulat tidak datang ber- golek, yang pipih tidak datang melayang. Round things do not come rolling, flat things do not come flying. Nothing good comes from not putting in any effort. Kuman di seberang lautan nampak, gajah di depan mata tidak kelihatan. A germ across the ocean is seen, (but) the elephant in front of one’s eyes is not. We see someone else’s small faults, but not our big shortcomings. Hendak seribu daya, tak hen- dak seribu dalih When we want something, we’ll expend a thousand energies. When we don’t something, we’ll give a thousand excuses. Kokok berderai-derai, ekor begelumang tahi. The cock crows loudly, though its tail is coated with faeces. Someone who proudly proclaims his qualities but is unaware of his shortcomings. Ikut resmi padi, makin berisi makin tunduk. Jangan ikut resmi lalang, semakin tegak tiada berisi. Follow the way of the rice stalk, the fuller it becomes, the more it hangs down. Do not follow the way of the weed, whilst the blade grows taller, the content stays empty. The more successful one becomes, the humbler one should be. Melentur buluh biarlah dari rebungnya. Bend the bamboo while it is still sprouting. As the twig bend, so grows the tree (Start young). Alang-alang menyeluk pe- kasam, biar sampai ke pangkal lengan. If you’re putting your hand into the pickle jar, you may as well put in your arm. If you’re undertaking a task, do it wholeheart- edly. Alang-alang berdakwat, biar hitam. If you’re using ink, let the colour be dark (black). If you are intending to perform a task, do it as best you can. Terlajak perahu boleh di- undur, terlajak kata buruk padahnya. An overpassing boat can be towed back, an unfiltered word causes harm. A word once spoken cannot be recalled. ted that “one should be able to hear and imagine this without my help” and stood by this in the remaining interviews with the author. His stance may cause problems for other musicians in understanding the programme within the piano piece. Hen- ce, this opens an opportunity for the aut- hor to analyse Pepatah Episodes using the framework of programme music within the figurative language, offering one way to approach this work towards understan- ding the “re-imagining the selected Malay proverbs through piano music” process, (2019 and 2020). The first nine (9) move- ments are to be played on the piano while the last three (3) movements of this work require the performer to either partially sing the music or play the written music on any surface or a percussion instrument of choice. Although the composer mentioned that he had retrospectively chosen the pe- patahs, he never specified which section(s) from each movement inspired him to as- sign the selected pepatah. In the first inter- view (2 October 2020), the composer sta- Mohd Fairuz bin Zamani, Razak Abdul Aziz’s Pepatah Episodes: Re-Imaging the Malay 177 which would be explained in the following section. METHODS As this is a qualitative study, the aut- hor had chosen a case study as the research approach in analysing the programme of Pepatah Episodes by Razak Abdul Aziz. Hence, the research instruments used are non-directive interviews, document ana- lysis, and archival research. The author interviewed the composer Razak Abdul Aziz on three separate occasions, as men- tioned earlier. These interviews were cent- red around understanding the composer’s creative process in both score versions. The author chose the 2020 version for this study as the composer has finalised it. The aut- hor also did adequate archival research to help in analysing this piece, mainly using Burkholder et al. (2014) and Kregor (2015), while being supported by Beard and Glo- ag (2005) and Parker and Abate (1989). The author chooses the movements that consist of music written for piano only, as this is the focus of the study. This includes the works’ first nine movements – from Alah Bisa Tegal Biasa to Melentur Bulu Biarlah Dari Rebungya. The last three (3) move- ments (Alang-alang Menyeluk Pekasam Biar Sampai Ke Pangkal Lengan, Alang-alang Ber- dakwat Biar Hitam, and Terlajak Perahu Boleh Diundur Terlajak Kata Buruk PAdahnya) are not analysed as the first two (2) of these three (3) movements require the performer to partially sing and the last demands the performer to play the notated rhythms on any surface or using a percussion instru- ment of choice. To understand the correlation bet- ween the chosen pepatahs to the written music, the author would be using mu- sic analysis defined by Beard and Gloag (2005) and Parker and Abate (1989), wit- hin the framework of programme music as proposed by Burkholder et al. (2014) and Kregor (2015). Music analysis is the result of an interaction between the music itself, music theory, aesthetics, and histo- ry (Beard & Gloag, 2005, p. 9). However, to go beyond mechanical conversions of musical notation into written words, the analysis must uncover something beyond or behind the mere sonic surface (Parker & Abate, 1989, pp.1-2). This includes ana- lysing musical effects that can express ide- as and programmes, which often involve harmonic and melodic innovations and instrumental colour. There have been discussions on the distinctions in programmatic music. Hoff- mann (1810) in Burkholder et al. (2014) categorized music with programmes into two (2); programme music and character piece. The earlier recounts a narrative of a sequence of events, often spelt out in an accompanying text, while the latter depicts or suggests a mood, personality, or scene, usually indicated in its title. Kregor (2015) gave more details on the definition of pro- gramme music. He stated that the building blocks of programme music are topics (a gateway through which music expresses and creates meaning) and character pieces, as programme music sought a dialogue with other arts, especially literature, a pur- suit that led to depictive character pieces, programmatic symphonies, symphonic poems, and tone paintings (Kregor, 2015). This is apparent in the examples of pro- gramme analysis on Henselt’s Etude no. 6 and Dittersdorf’s Ovid Symphony in Kregor (2015). RESULT AND DISCUSSION Using the framework of programme music analysis, the author would begin by quoting the composer Razak Abdul Aziz in one of the interviews. He claimed that the pepatahs were only chosen after the music had been written out, while quoting Schumann, as mentioned in Burkholder et al. (2014), saying: “(Schumann) did not always know the title of a piece until the music was writ- ten, making clear that the title is itself part of the composition, one that can be deci- ded at any stage from initial conception to final finish. The main function of titles for character pieces was not to specify mea- Harmonia: Journal of Arts Research and Education 23 (1) (2023): 171-186178 nings but to indicate possible avenues for exploration, inviting the player and liste- ner to enter the composer’s musical world and become in one sense cocreators of that world by devising their own narratives to explain how the music justifies the tit- le and vice versa (p. 610)” (Abdul Aziz, 4 August 2022). Having this in mind, the composer also claimed that the chosen pepatahs are represented in either one of the three (3) ways: (i) imageries in the pepatah (ii) ima- geries in the meaning, or (iii) imageries in the pepatah and meaning. Alah Bisa Tegal Biasa As this is the first movement of the piece, it introduces the harmonic language that is used in the entire work – non-fun- ctional, non-tonal harmony and non-pitch centric. This could be estranged for some listeners as this type of harmony is not so- mething the general audience is accusto- med to. Hence, the movement acts as an introduction, aurally paving the way into the audience’s ears. It is written at a mo- derate speed, chordal texture, simple note values, and utilises relatively loud dyna- mics (as shown in Figure 1). This combina- tion aids in fashioning the music easier to be perceived, making the composer choo- se this pepatah for its meaning to represent this movement. Figure 1. An excerpt from Alah Bisa Tegal Biasa Air Dicincang Tak Akan Putus. The second movement begins with two voices, each melodically, moving in- dependently in 2nds, and using various rhythmic divisions (quaver triplet, semi- quaver triplet, semiquaver quintuplet, etc.) to create polyrhythm, as shown in Figure 2. This creates the effect of interlocking, mimicking an attempt to “dice water.” The “attempt” later occurs at a higher register, written on the treble clef, as shown in Fi- gure 3. Figure 2. The first three (3) bars of Air Dicin- cang Tak Akan Putus Figure 3. The attempt to “dice water” recur- ring in treble clef This attempt to “dice water” inten- sifies when four (4) layers of voice are sounding simultaneously in both staff in treble and bass clefs, each voice having its own rhythmic pattern (as shown in Figure 4), creating intense rhythmic interlocking while these voices melodically move in- dependently in 2nds with a loud dynamic, emulating an intensified effort to “dice wa- ter.” Figure 4. The attempt to “dice water” intensi- fies Regardless of the recurring, multip- Mohd Fairuz bin Zamani, Razak Abdul Aziz’s Pepatah Episodes: Re-Imaging the Malay 179 le attempts to “dice the water”, these at- tempts ultimately failed as it is within the nature of water not to break. This can be seen in the last bar of this movement (as shown in Figure 5). Despite the continuous attempt to “dice” until the end, all four (4) voices finally come together at the end of the movement. With this programme, it is concluded that the composer chose this pe- patah for its literal imagery, imagining the act of “dicing water” when listening to this movement. Figure 5. The “diced water” finally comes together Kalau Tidak Dipecahkan Ruyung, Manakan Dapat Sagunya. Musically, this movement is quite like the first - being a continuity, where it reiterates the harmonic materials in chor- dal texture using a moderate pace, simp- ler note values, and loud dynamics. This is to regain the attention of the listeners, harkening back to the ideas at the begin- ning of this piece. By gauging their atten- tion to continue listening to the work, the composer is preparing for what is to come in the later movements of the composition, which, the composer believes, is rewar- ding. Hence, this pepatah was chosen for its imagery in the meaning to describe the listeners’ effort to continue listening to this work and the reward that awaits the liste- ners in the following movements. Figure 6. The reiteration of harmonic materials alla the first movement. Yang Bulat Tidak Datang Bergolek, Yang Pipih Tidak Datang Melayang. There are two (2) distinctive image- ries portrayed in this movement – bulat (round thing) and pipih (flat thing). Bulat is attempting to roll, but the movement is somehow halted. This is portrayed in the music with the melodic movement on the LH, which begins smoothly in 2nds (as de- monstrated in Figure 7) at a lower regis- ter, within a range of an octave, and using small note values, creating the rumbling effect and imagery of a round object rol- ling back and forth. Figure 7. The portrayal of bulat on LH However, this smooth-moving line on the LH becomes increasingly disjunct with rapid changes of note register within almost two (2) octaves compass, with more rhythmic play, creating interruption – an attempt to halt the rolling movement of the bulat (Figure 8). Figure 8. The interruption of bulat movement on LH and introduction of pipih on RH One could observe that a new ma- terial is introduced in Figure 8 (RH of bar 72), portraying pipih – written using notes in a higher register and smaller, more int- ricate note values than bulat. Pipih (on RH) gradually begins to exist concurrently with Harmonia: Journal of Arts Research and Education 23 (1) (2023): 171-186180 bulat (on LH), before dominating the con- versation later, with more rhythmic play and notes of the higher register, imitating “small, flying things” (possibly small avi- aries), as shown in Figure 9. Figure 9. Pipih dominating the conversation Based on the programme analysis made, it is concluded that the composer had chosen imageries of objects (bulat and pipih) in the pepatah to pair this proverb to the movement. Kuman di Seberang Lautan Nampak, Gajah di Depan Mata Tidak Kelihatan. Two (2) distinctive imageries are mentioned in this pepatah – kuman (germ) and gajah (elephant). As kuman is diminu- tive and gajah is enormous by comparison, these imageries represent sarcasm – one noticing someone else’s small fault but not their own big weakness. The composer translated these imageries using two (2) contrasting note registers – low to repre- sent gajah and high to represent kuman – playing in loud dynamics (f, ff, piu ff), as shown in Figure 10. Figure 10. Gajah in the low register and kuman in the high register These imageries occur alternately and respond to each other as antecedents and consequents (question and answer) throughout most parts of this movement. This continuous alternation is to portray bickering between two parties – both yel- ling out each other’s weaknesses without acknowledging their shortcomings, as exemplified in Figure 11. Figure 11. The continuous alternation between gajah and kuman, portraying bicker between two (2) parties Mohd Fairuz bin Zamani, Razak Abdul Aziz’s Pepatah Episodes: Re-Imaging the Malay 181 Ultimately, both parties fail to over- power the other. Instead, they decide to bicker louder, gradually accentuating their arguments until they reach their peak. This is represented by the voices moving outward in contrary motion – ascending movement (kuman) and descending move- ment (gajah) – with both voices increasing their dynamics reaching ff. Figure 12. The voices getting louder and mov- ing outward in contrary motion Based on the programme analysis made, we can determine that the composer had chosen this pepatah for its imageries of objects (gajah and kuman) in the pepatah and imageries depicted in the meaning when reflecting on this movement. Hendak Seribu Daya, Tak Hendak Seribu Dalih Two (2) contrasting situations are portrayed in this pepatah – daya (energy/ effort) and dalih (excuse). Dalih occurs first in this movement. It is portrayed with the use of long, sustained chords, passive in- ner voices, and soft dynamics to depict minimal effort/energy, as shown in Figure 13. Figure 13. The portrayal of dalih using long, sustained chords, passive inner voices, and soft dynamics A new material is immediately intro- duced, with more active rhythmic gestu- res, louder dynamics, and frequent chords changes. This material represents daya, which would later be further developed. Figure 14. The introduction of daya material into the movement Harmonia: Journal of Arts Research and Education 23 (1) (2023): 171-186182 The daya material grows exponenti- ally with more complexity. The rhythmic gesture becomes significantly more active in all voices while the dynamic used is ge- nerally loud (f and piu forte). This material is also developed using a contemporary rhythmic notation called feathered beam, as shown in Figure 15 at piu forte. Feathe- red beams are used to notate the gradual transition from one note duration to anot- her in accelerando or ritardando mode (Lom- bardi, 2021, p.65). Figure 15. Daya material gets developed Daya gets more potent with a wider range of dynamics (from mf to piu forte), rapid change of register in chordal pattern, and more feathered beams at the climax of this movement. This is a depiction of the “thousand energies” described in the pepa- tah, which could also be observed from the visual perspective of the performance. Figure 16. The climax of daya From the programme analysis, the author deduced that the composer cho- se this pepatah for the imageries port- rayed in the pepatah to accompany this movement – one being passive and soft, representing dalih, and the other being aggressive and loud, representing daya. Kokok Berderai-derai, Ekor Bergelumang Tahi Similar to many previous move- ments, this pepatah has two (2) distinctive imageries; (i) cock (rooster) crowing loud- ly (ii) tail feathers coated (covered) with faeces. The first imagery of this pepatah is portrayed in two (2) ways – (i) a 4-part voi- ce in the middle and high registers (Figure 17) and (ii) a 2-part-highly-chromatic voice (RH of Figure 19) – both being very loud in dynamic (ff). The second imagery is also portrayed in two (2) ways; (i) notes on the low register in chordal pattern in modera- tely soft dynamic (mp) (Figure 18) and (ii) 2-part-highly-chromatic voice (LH of Figu- re 19) in very loud dynamic (ff). Figure 17. The first portrayal of “cock crowing loudly” Figure 18. The first portrayal of “tail feathers coated with faeces” The second portrayal of both image- ries begins to occur concurrently starting from bar 146 (as shown in Figure 19) and gets more intense for the next 12 bars, befo- re calming down at bar 157 onwards until the end of this movement (bar 164), getting rhythmically and dynamically more passi- ve with time, as shown in Figure 20. This is to depict the scene where the crowing Mohd Fairuz bin Zamani, Razak Abdul Aziz’s Pepatah Episodes: Re-Imaging the Malay 183 rooster finally realises that the tail is get- ting heavier due to the amount of faeces that gradually increases with the intensity of the crow and starts to tone down. Figure 19. The second portrayal of both imag- eries happening concurrently Figure 20. The crowing rooster starts to calm down after realising the condition of its tail feathers From the programme analysis made, the author deduced that the composer “heard” the imageries in the pepatah when he reflected on this movement – rooster crowing and the faeces-coated tail feathers happening alternately in the beginning and eventually become concurrent – hence decided to choose the pepatah to accompa- ny this movement. Ikut Resmi Padi, Makin Berisi Makin Tunduk; Jangan Ikut Resmi Lalang, Sema- kin Tegak Tiada Berisi This pepatah is like many previo- us ones; having the portrayal of two (2) contrasting imageries in its words: (i) rice stalks hanging low (ii) weed grass blades growing taller. These imageries are rep- resentations of two (2) types of personas. As the full rice stalk is a representation of a positive persona (successful, knowled- geable, and humble), the weed grass blade represents the opposite – a negative per- sona (empty-headed and arrogant). The positive persona is portrayed as “full and laying low” using chordal writing and mo- derately soft dynamic (mp) on both hands, as shown in Figure 21. Figure 21. The portrayal of the persona with substance using chordal writing and moder- ately soft dynamic On the other hand, the negative per- sona is portrayed as “empty-headed and arrogant” with the use of a single-line me- lody at a high register in a loud dynamic (f). This persona “talks over” the positive persona, having the former’s voice (the single-line melody) over a chordal passage as demonstrated in Figure 22. Figure 22. The negative persona “talks over” the positive persona The negative persona then takes over the conversation. This is translated into music by continually using loud dynamics, the addition of three (3) lower voices with these voices mimicking each other (Bass mimics Soprano, Tenor mimics Alto), with each voice using a very narrow range of notes, describing this persona as being full of itself yet shallow. Figure 23. The negative persona is full of itself and shallow Harmonia: Journal of Arts Research and Education 23 (1) (2023): 171-186184 This continues until the end of this movement, gradually getting softer to a soft dynamic (p). Possibly the superficial person is eventually ignored but persists in staying arrogant. Figure 24. The negative persona remains ar- rogant despite getting ignored From the programme analysis, the author deduced that the composer “heard” the imageries portrayed in the meaning when he reflected on this movement – two (2) contrasting personas; one of positive and the other, negative – hence decided to choose the pepatah to accompany this mo- vement. Melentur Buluh Biarlah Dari Rebungnya This pepatah mentions two (2) diffe- rent stages of growth of bamboo – a ma- ture bamboo (buluh) and a bamboo sprout (rebung), which is a representation of two stages of growth of man – mature and young, respectively. Buluh is materially hard and very difficult to shape and bend – an analogy of a mature person that is alrea- dy set with their habit. Changing the habit would be a monumental and delicate task to undertake. This is translated into music using loud dynamics (f and piu forte), rapid passages, heavy chordal patterns, and big leaps; all to be executed smoothly (legato). Figure 25. The portrayal of undertaking the task of bending buluh (changing the habit of a mature person) Unlike the hard buluh, rebung is young and still sprouting, hence shaping and bending it would be a much easier task, comparatively. This is an analogy for a young person, who is still growing and learning, hence shaping their habit and be- haviour is (although still a delicate matter) facile. Musical translation for this is made using softer dynamics (p, mp, mf), a calm chordal passage which begins quite passi- vely with longer note values that gradually becomes more intricate as the movement progresses to portray the gradual shaping process, and smooth articulation (legato). Figure 26. The portrayal of bending rebung (shaping the habit and behaviour of a young person) Figure 27. The music becomes progressively more intricate, portraying the gradual shaping process From the programme analysis, the author deduced that the composer had imageries portrayed in the pepatah and meaning when he reflected on this move- ment – buluh and rebung, and a mature and young person – hence decided to choose this pepatah to accompany this movement. CONCLUSIONS The programme analysis conducted in all nine (9) movements for piano found that four (4) movements inspired the com- poser to choose their respective pepatah for the imageries portrayed in the pepatah, Mohd Fairuz bin Zamani, Razak Abdul Aziz’s Pepatah Episodes: Re-Imaging the Malay 185 three (3) for the imageries portrayed in the meaning, and two (2) for both. Razak Abdul Aziz’s Pepatah Episodes challenges the convention of programme music in three (3) ways: (i) the pepatah is to be recited aloud before performing each movement, as other programme music does not require the performer to read out the programme (ii) the choice of pepatah is made in a retrospective manner rather than setting the music to predetermined pepatahs (iii) the portrayal of imageries in the music is either from the pepatah, its meaning, or both. This offers possibili- ties for other composers to explore music composition using a similar framework and compositional process utilised by this composer. It also provides opportunities for scholars to investigate and study works by Razak Abdul Aziz and/or other com- posers that are unique and worthy of scho- larly attention. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author would like to thank the composer, Razak Abdul Aziz, for permit- ting the use of the music scores (2019 and 2020 versions) and to conduct this study. This work is supported by Short-Term Grant of Universiti Sains Malaysia with Project No.: 304/PSENI/6315693. REFERENCES Amuah, J. A., & Wuaku, H. M. (2019). Use of proverbs as communicative tool in Ghanaian choral music composi- tions. Legon Journal of the Humani- ties, 30(1), 133-160. doi:10.4314/ ljh. v30i1.6 Abdul Aziz, R. (2020, 2 October). OnPepa- tah Episodes part 1 [WhatsApp con- versation]. Abdul Aziz, R. (2021, 2 August). OnPepatah Episodes part 2 [Personal interview]. Abdul Aziz, R. (2022, 4 August). OnPepatah Episodes part 3 [Personal interview]. Bakar, J., Esten, M., Surin, A., & Busri. (1981). Sastra Lisan Minangkabau. Pusat Pembinaan dan Pengemban- gan Bahasa. Ballard, L., & Bengtson, M. (2017). The Al- exander Scriabin companion: History, performance, and lore. Rowman & Lit- tlefield. Beard, D., & Gloag, K. (2005). Musicology: The Key Concept. Routledge. Bowers, F. (1974). The New Scriabin: Enigma and answers. David & Charles. Burkholder, J. P., Grout, D. J., & Palisca, C. V. (2014). A history of western mu- sic (9th ed.). W.W. Norton & Com- pany. Debussy, C. (2007). Favorite piano works. Schirmer. Guo, S. (2019). A Study of Claude Debussy’s Suite Bergamasque: Prelude, Menuet, Clair de Lune and Passepied (Unpub- lished doctoral dissertation). Univer- sity of Kansas. Hall, V. (1988, November 27). Razak Ab- dul Aziz: the reluctant composer. The Star. Hinson, M. (2003). Anthology of Romantic Piano Music with Performance Prac- tices in Romantic Piano Music: Book & DVD. Alfred Music Publishing. Honeck, R. P., Voegtle, K., Dorfmueller, M. A., & Hoffman, R. R. (2020). Prov- erbs, Meaning, and Group Struc- ture. In Cognition and figurative lan- guage (pp. 127-161). Routledge. Kamien, R. (2011). Music: An Apprecia- tion (7th ed.). McGraw Hill. Kamus Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka (n.d.) Pepatah. In prpm.dbp.gov. my. Retrieved August 1, 2022, from https://prpm. dbp.gov.my/ cari1?keyword=pepatah Katz, A. N. (1998) Figurative Language and Figurative Thought: A Re- view. Figurative language and thought. 3-43 (Katz, A. N., Cacciari, C., Gibbs, Jr., R. W., & Turner, M., Eds). Oxford University Press. Kregor, J. (2015). Program music. Cam- bridge University Press. Lombardi, P. (2021). Feathered beams. MusMat: Brazilian Jour- nal of Music and Mathematics, 5(2), 65–90. https://doi.org/10.46926/ Harmonia: Journal of Arts Research and Education 23 (1) (2023): 171-186186 musmat.2021v5n2.65-90 Mat Piah, H. (1986). Pencirian dan Analisis Kesusateraan Melayu Klasik. Univer- siti Kebangsaan Malaysia. Mieder, W. (2004). Proverbs: A Handbook. Greenwood Press. Mieder, W. (1996). Proverbs. In American folklore: An encyclopedia (J. Brunvand, Ed.) (pp. 597-601). Garland Publishing. Nichols, R. (1998). The life of Debussy. Cam- bridge University Press. Orenstein, A. (1991). Ravel: Man and musi- cian. Dover Publications, Inc. Parker, R. and Abbate, C. (eds) (1989). An- alyzing Opera: Verdi and Wagner. Uni- versity of California Press. Program music. (2019, June 16). New World Encyclopedia. Retrieved Au- gust 4, 2022, from https://www. newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/ Program_music Robert, R. & Kreutz, R. (1994). Why do people use figurative language? Psy- chological Science, 5, 159-163. Sackville-West, E., & Shawe-Taylor, D. (1951). The Record Guide. Collins. Schmitz, E. R. (1850). The Piano Works of Claude Debussy. Duell, Sloan and Pearce. Tomić, M. (2020). The role of harmony and timbre in Maurice Ravel’s cycle Gaspard de la Nuit in relation to form (Master’s thesis, Norges musikkhøgskole). Winick, S. D. (2003). Cognition, comprehen- sion, and communication: A decade of north american proverb studies: 1990- 2000 (W. Mieder, Ed.). Schneider Vlg. Zamani, M. F., Idrus, M. M., & Lin, G. Y. (2019). Razak Abdul Aziz: The For- gotten Composer. Asean Journal of Management and Business Stud- ies, 1(1), 76-83. doi:10.26666/ rmp. ajmbs.2019.1.11 Zamani, M. F. (2021). Music of Razak Ab- dul Aziz: Preparing chosen solo and collaborative piano works for two academic recitals. Wacana Seni Journal of Arts Discourse, 20, 79-85. doi:10.21315/ws2021. 20. 7