Vol. 17 NEWSLETTER OF THE . ~TOMETRIC HISTORICAL SOCIETY (243 North Lindb?fgh Boulevard, St •. L.auis.~.Mi~.~Q!J.t:L.~~141, U.S.A.) •PT8MtTRY UBRARY ~ I" I. I . . ........ ; July, 1989 ·· :~u -1n'v 9 rsrty ~umber 3 SEP 2.1986 ; SEP 2 :J ·1986 ; ~ Annual call for~~~n~~ . ... '· .~ ... ~ ' ' This year the call for nominations is unique. Unlike previous years when the objective was· to elect one executive board member, this year three are to be elected. As detailed in the April 1986 Newsletter, Article IV, Section 1 of the Optometric Historical Society By-laws now state that the executive board shall consist of seven members. In addition to the annual selection of the fifth board member, two more must be elected this year to begin their terms on January 1, 1987. Of the three board members to be elected one will serve for four years, one for three years, and one for two years. The executive board member whose five-year term will expire at the end of this year is Jerome Abrams. Nominations, or renominations for the three executive board openings are hereby requested for placement on the ballot which will be sent out with the October issue of this Newsletter. Submissions should be sent to Douglas Penisten, School of Optometry, 800 East Atwater, Bloomington, IN 47405. By all means, do not hesitate to include yourself as a candidate if such responsibility interests you. Please do not specify for which term (i.e., 4, 3, or 2 years) the nomination has been ma"CJ'e;" as this wi 11 be determined by a total vote ranking with the ballot nominee receiving the highest number of votes receiving the longest term. Ordinarily, merely the name of the person you are nominating will suffice especially if he or she is already well known to the O.H.S. members, but if you feel that a brief "pitch" should be made in your nominees behalf it will be most favorably considered for inclusion in the October issue of N.O.H.S •• Do it now. Southall, the man: The search for biographical information about James P.C. Southall ( 1871-1962) eli cited two more sources immediately after our April issue went to press. One was a copy of a letter of 5 April 1951 that Southall had written to the late Harold R. Barnes and signed "Daddy Southall." It was sent to us by Optometry Librarian Margaret Lewis of the Harold Kohn Vision Science Library at State University of New York with the suggestion that more information might be gotten from Maurice H. Bernstein, O.D., a former student of Southall's. Dr. Bernstein informed me that I should call Leo Hirschberg, O.D., retired, a former Columbia University teacher who had maintained a very close friendship with Southall. My call to Dr. Hirschberg was a sheer delight. He subsequently sent me a dozen or more copies of pertinent correspondence ranging from 1927 to 1954 selected from among many more in his files. -32- It was tempting to reprint the whole series in this issue, but with the exercise of nominal editorial restraint I decided to forward them, instead, to the International Library, Archives, and Museum of Optometry for permanent accessibility. The following excerpts, however, should convey the more personal nature of the man than can be derived frobtMl'tiSi ti!c:H~J~-M)I publications or Who's Who. ~~ ~.··:' t I:. : (~ ~ ~ ... 12 May 1927, in Department of Physics 1 etterh~~d to' "Leo, Hirschberg, Esq.": "Oear H1 rschberg, I want to tell you how m'M!ff'lf;'tf.lltl~tl~te your valuable help in the Clinic. We are exceedingly fortunate in having the benefit of your skill and loyal cooperation. From all I can hear, the work in The Clinic has made a very fine impression on outsiders. In my judgment, this is the best way to made optometry known to the public. I appreciate more than I can tell you all that you have done ever since you have been connected with this work. Sincerely yours, James P.C. Southall." 23 July 1936, in longhand from Charlottesville, Virginia, apparently in response to H1rschberg's wedding announcement: "Dear Hirschberg, The good news which reached me yesterday - thanks to your cordial note which was much appreciated- gave me a real thrill of delight. It is true I may have been, as you say, a little 'surprised' at first, but I have seen too much in my time not to know that the state of bachelor is a precarious existence at best and liable at any moment to what the French call a bouleversement! Both Mrs. Southall and I send you heartfelt congratulations. I feel also like congratulating the 'charming girl' because I know what a fine man she has captured. May you both have a long and happy life together with children to cheer and comfort you! I shall look forward to the pleasure of meeting your bride in the autumn." 10 February 1942: A long and sentimental letter from Charlottesville, typed, to Mr. Leo A1rschberg includes the verse: "Oft in the stilly night Ere slumber's chain has bound me, Fond memory brings the light Of other days around me." Also, he expressed emotional regret that he was not young enough to help fight the Nazis and the Japs, referred to surgeons as Messieurs Les Assassins, and described charmingly his retirement activities which 1ncluded an occasional lecture, writing a book on geometry, and writing letters to the newspapers, to the Secretary of War, and to others on "the way to win the war." 21 June 1942: Another similarly long and expressive letter to "Dear Hirschberg" expressing his continued interest in the program of the optometry at Columbia and his distress with the progress of the war. He added, "Unfortunately, there is no military genius in sight on our side of the far-flung battle." He reported occasionally doing "some scientific work for the army or navy ordinance department." 11 April 1942: Included in this letter was a brief account of a month in the hosp1tal for "four painful operations for stones in the bladder and enlargement of the prostate gland," but that he had attained the age of 75 with an extended "lease on life." -33- 14 March 1948: A similarly personalized letter expressing appreciation for another vernal equinox and anticipated visitations from his son and grandson and the Hirschbergs. He requested tolerance for his deafness and gave instructions on how to find his house. As in other letters, he included affectionate comments regarding Mrs. Southall's role in his life. 17 July 1950: In this letter he commented on the magnificence of the works of nature 1n the U.S.A., his regrets that Robert Bannon was leaving Columbia University, the utter misfortune that the optometry school was being removed away from the main campus, and the surprise that his letter to the editor of The New York Times in complaint of u.s. postal services was published. 24 October 1950: Some reminiscing of his summer of many years earlier at Berkeley, Callfornia, and further anxiety "about the status of Optometry in Columbia." In about February 1951, Harold R. Barnes, O.D., Isadore Finkelstein, O.D., and Hirschberg fonned a "James P.C. Southall Birthday Gift Fund" comm1tted to celebrate Southall's 80th birthday on April 5, 1951, by asking each alumnus to "contribute one dollar for every year since graduation" to provide a collective gift to "brighten this and subsequent days for Professor Southall during the trying times through which he is passing." Let your generosity reflect the human warmth that Daddy Southall radiated in all his classrooms." Among those solicited were Southall's former colleagues at the University. In a March 14, 1951, letter Professor George B. Pegram, Ph.D. pledged $100 and suggested several other academic colleagues who should be given the opportunity to contribute. The total amount of the collective gift exceeded $2,150.00. 5 April 1951: In a letter addressed to Barnes for the committee and contributors, s1gned "Affectionately, Daddy Southall," opening reference is made to the "heap of letter and messages ••• and telegrams of sympathy." He declared, "Never in my life have I been so stunned, gratified and overwhelmed with trembling from head to foot ••• and saw with my own eyes, dim as they are now, ,the biggest check I ever held in my hands! In another paragraph he added, "whereby I am enabled to pay my debts and once more look my fellow man full in the face without fear and without shame." He closed with the statement that if he had the "strength to write one more book, I think it will be a companion volume to Mueller's Life of Trust" because his bounty had now excelled that of Mueller. 7 April 1951: In a letter to Hirschberg, Southall referred to his wife's long 11 lness and last days of suffering and to her devotion to him and others. 7 April 1952: Responding to Hirschberg's birthday greeting and because his birthday was so close to the vernal equinox, Southall remarked, "Who would ever have dreamed of my having another birthday and beginning a new voyage inside the solar system?" He also reported that his vision was nearly all gone, due to glaucoma. -34- 6 April 1954: Having no teeth left, Southall described himself to be exactly 1n the same predicament as the lady at the religious revival where the evangelist laid much stress on the gnashing of teeth of the damned. "She rose from her seat and said a little indignantly; 'Sir. I'll have you to know, I have no teeth!' He retorted: 'Madam, teeth will be provided!" He expressed his grief over the cessation of optometric education at Columbia University, "for which I fought with all my might." "The worst of it is, I say ft with sorrow and deep affection, it [optometry] has only itself to blame." In the subsequent two paragraphs he gave his heartbroken interpretation of the circumstances and sequence of events that must have led to the termination of the optomet~ program at Columbia. Philosophically he sighed, "The best laid plans o' mice and men gang aft agley." Chronology of a man: Prompted by previous N.O.H.S. commentry on James Powell Cocke Southall, 1871-1962, Mrs. Marfa Dablemont and her staff quickly assembled a library packet of Southall fan items and excerpts from the ILA~to fi 1 es and shelves. Arbitrarily arranged in chronological order they say much about Southall's career. December 15, 1910, the Optical Journal and Review of Optomet~, Vol., 26, no. 28, p. 1547: Professor Charles Sheard, a 27 year old faculty member in the physics Department of The Ohio State University four years prior to start1ng the optometry program there, writes a glowing review of Southall's book, "The Principles and Methods of Geometrical Optics" calling it "an epoch-making volume as far as English and American writers are concerned" in spite of the fact that "nearly all the work of merit ••• has been done by the Germans." He also mentions Southall's prior original work in this field "which has appeared in the past in the Astrophysical Journal". 1913: Copy of the title page of the 1913 printing of the 1910 edition of Southall's book by The Macmillan Company and the Library of Congress card with the call number AC381.S7. The 1910 edition was printed by The New Era Printing Company, Lancaster, PA and dedicated by the author to Henry C. Lomb, Esq. July 23, 1914, op. cit., Vol. 34, no. 5, pp. 345-346: A reproduction of the Columbia University booklet describing the two year curriculum in optometry showing Southall teaching a course in each of the four semesters. October 8, 1914, op. eft., Vol. 34, no. 16, p. 1064: An anonymous report annou.ncf.ng the enrollment of 23 new students in the ff fth begf nni ng optometry class, their undergraduate activities, and the important role of Professor Southall. April 15, 1915, op cit., Vol. 35, no. 16, pp. 1061-1062: A review of the Columbia University optometry prospectus for 1915-16 showing Southall's key involvement. January 13, 1916, op. cit., Vol. 37, no. 3, p. 181: A report from the optometry student body in which Southall is cited. -35- 1918: Copy of the title page of Southall's first edition of "Mirrors, Prisms and Lenses" and the Library of Congress card with the call number QC385.S7. on which the book is described as "The outgrowth of a course of lectures on optics given in Columbia University" and as an abridgement of his earlier treatise. May-November 1919, Journal of the Optical Society of America, Vols. II-III, Numbers 3-6: Copy of the t1tle page shows J.P.C. Southall as an Associate Editor. January 1921, op. cit., Vol. 5, no. 1, p. 121: Southall elected President of the Optical Society of America for the year 1921. March 1921, op, cit., Vol. 5, no. 2: A statement of the object of the Society includes the declaration that "Its membership embraces: • [among others] Opticians, Optometrists and Ophthalmololgists intereseted in refractometry and the 1 aws of optics;." 1924: Copy of the title page of Vol. 1 of the three volumes of "Helmholtz's Treatise on Physiological Optics, Translated from the Third German Edition, Edited by James P.C. Southall, and Published by The Optical Society of America," and a copy of its Library of Congress card with the call number QP475.H485. December 11, 1931, The Optical Journal and Review of Optometry, Vol. 68, no. 24, p. 19: Extracts from Southall's rev1ew of "Die Optlschen Instrumente" by Professor M. von Rohr, "the di sti ngui shed German authority on the history of optics." Oct. 21, 1926, op. cit., Vol. 58, no. 17, p. 42: A letter from Southall expressing the fear "that we are not going to have enough students to take the new four year course. At present we have only 54 students, and nearly all of them are taking the old two-year course in University Extension." He is appealing for scholarship support from optometrists. The 1927 Year Book of Optometry, p. 49: An editorial appeal from Professor Soutnal I tor scnolarsn1p funds from state optometric associations to attract students to fill the optometry courses offered at Columbia University, the University of Rochester, Ohio State University, and the University of California. The 1928 Yearbook of Optometry, pp. 69-92: Southall participated in an intense three-way debate w1th Deputy Commissioner Downing of the New York State Department of Education and New York State Assemblyman Berg at the 1927 convention of the New York State Optometric Association in Syracuse. The question related to the title Doctor for optometrists. Op. cit., pp. 115-117: An editorial entitled "Professional Optometry" in which Professor Southall points out the need for optometrists to deal drastically with the transition from a trade to a profession. 1937: Copy of the title page of South a 11' s "Introduction to Physiological Optics", Oxford University Press, and of The Library of Congress card with the call number QP475.S6. May 1954, American Journal of Optometry and Archives of American Academy of Optometry, Vol. 31, no. 5, pp. 252-253: Ed1tor1al by Carel C. Koch on the Co I umb1 a Onwersi ty announcement of plans to terminate; its optometry courses. -36- February 1963, Journal of the American Optometric Association, Vol. 34, no. 7, p. 581: ~ 72 word ob1tuary on Professor Southall. February 1964: Journal of the Optical Society of America, Vol. 54, no. 2, p. 288: A 167 word ob1tuary on Professor southal I. Former Southall student writes: OHS member Elias Shaneson gently reminded us that we had misspelled Southall 1 s middle name Cocke and added the following: I read the April 1986 issue of the Newsletter of the Optometric Historical Society with interest, as I always do. I found your article on Professor James Powell Cocke Southall of special interest, since I had been his student at Columbia University in the years 1935-1937. I remember him well, but rather than describing my impression of him, let me tell you of an incident in my student life that may reveal a facet of his character. Although tuition at Columbia University at that time was $200 per semester, all entering students at the optometry courses had to buy a kit of refracting equipment (trial case, trial frame, May ophthalmoscope, Tait dynamic retinoscope) for an additional $365. This proved very burdensome to me, and although I tried to earn money working part time and borrowing from relatives, I later found myself unable to pay the tuition for the last semester of my senior year. I applied for a student loan but was turned down because of the outstanding debts I listed on my appli~ation form. Dejectedly I walked over to the Pupin Physics Building, where the optometry courses were being given and where Professor Southall had his office, and sadly told him that I would have to drop out of the optometry courses and graduation. He listened intently. I cannot recall our exact conversation now, but I distinctly remember his advice: 11 GO back to the bursar and talk to him again. Perhaps he will reconsider ... I did not just walk back -- I ran back. The bursar received me more cordially and offered me the loan on condition I get a suitable co-signer. This I was able to do and I graduated successfully. The first moneys I earned went towards repayment of that loan. In 1952, on the occasion of his 80th birthday, his former students presented him with a check for $1,000. He responded that he never held a check of that magnitude in his hands, ever. Oa that occasion I sent him a congratulatory letter and recalled to him the incident of the loan. He answered me with a letter which I treasure and which I keep in his book 11 Mirrors, Prisms, and Lenses... I am enclosing a copy of his letter which you may print if you feel it appropriate to do so. Now, perhaps I should put down some of my other recollections of him. His office was guarded by a formidable secretary; nevertheless, he was accessible to the students. Not many availed themselves of that privilege. MY attempt to solve a difficult problem proved more obfuscating after his explanation. -37- He was somewhat tall, mostly grey and balding with small wrinkled eyes, and a peculiar habit of scratching his left ear with his right hand. I admired his easy walk and relaxed manners, to me, then, the epitome of a southern gentleman. His Virginia accent was pronounced but not too heavy. He seemed to keep aloof of administrative and clinical problems. These were relegated to his associate, Professor Clifford Leroy Treleaven and staff. I never remember him visiting laboratories, examination rooms, or clinics. His domain was the lecture podium in the classroom. His soft mellifluous voice belied the difficult subject he expounded. I think of Professor Southall kindly. His vision of all professions, including optometry, as servants of mankind was lofty and ideal, and still to be completely realized. The following is the copy of the enclosed letter from Southall: Dear Shaneson JAMES P. C. SOUTHAL-L. ao.awooo L.ANC CHAALOTTIESVILLIE VU'IGINIA. 6 June 1952 Your kind and thoughtful letter, as welcome as it was unexpected, reached me yesterday. I am exceedingly grateful. I have no amanuensis, and now my eyesight is very dim. It is as much as I can do to write even a short letter, but I will not let your letter go unanswered; as I am obliged to do very often. This little note may be short in one dimension, but it is wide and deep in other ways; wide, because you opened my heart and let in much pleasure, and deep in token of mutual affection and remembrance. Fifteen ye~rs back is not far to go for me; I remember you well; yet I cannot remember the incident you recalled. It is enough for me to know that you still remember it, and it gives· me much pleasure to be reminded that I befriended you once when I was in a position to be of service. Nothing gives me so much delight as to get in touch with one of my old pupils, especially if he tells me that he enjoyed sitting at my feet, whether he is telling the truth or not. Not long ago a pupil whom I am sorry to say I had forgotten wrote me , "You are the one teacher I will never forget!" It was a little ambiguous, but I took it ·for a compliment. I like to think you have had a big reward and have won success. Optometry, as I regard it, is a noble profeseion, a high calling. It makes little difference what profession a man chooees and follows (medicine, law, teaching, etc.), it is a high calling to do good work and make an honest living. The trouble is that few are worthy of a high calling, their. hearts are not in it, and they debase it. In Optometry consider men like your old teachers in Columbia, Roberts, Barnes and Hirschberg, to mention the three I admire most: if Optometry was practissd all o~er the country by men of that type, it would rank at the top or the professions. Elias Shaneson, Esq. 1547 Genesee Street Buffalo 11, New York Affectionately ~"-·• 9, e:,,