id	author	title	date	pages	extension	mime	words	sentence	flesch	summary	cache	txt
iiclr-17848	Barbato, Joseph M.	Scotland's Bastard Verdict: Intermediacy and the Unique Three-Verdict System	2005	40	.pdf	application/pdf	19995	1315	73	But the spirited dissent suggested that the majority should have tossed out the New Jersey indictment on double jeopardy grounds., 341 I submit, Judge Nygaard said, that looking behind jury verdicts to reconstruct the jury's thinking, or attempting to determine how it may have reached consensus, is pure speculation and contravenes our fundamental constitutional heritage of treating jury verdicts as unimpeachable., 342 Instead, his contention was that not proven verdicts should be treated as acquittals for collateral estoppel purposes. SCOTrISH OFFICE, JURIES AND VERDICTS: IMPROVING THE DELIVERY OF JUSTICE IN SCOTLAND 26 (HMSO, Edinburgh Press 1994)	cache/iiclr-17848.pdf	txt/iiclr-17848.txt