id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
inlawrev-20850	1	1	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	2	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	3	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1	4	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1	5	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	6	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1	7	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1	8	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1	9	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1	10	decide	decide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1	12	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1	14	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	15	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	16	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	17	steve	steve	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1	18	c.	c.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1	19	gold	gold	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1	20	*	*	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1	21	introduction	introduction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	22	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	23	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1	25	long	long	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1	26	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1	28	stuffing	stuff	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1	29	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	30	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	31	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1	33	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	34	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1	36	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	37	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	2	1	high	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	2	2	stakes	stake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	2	3	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	2	4	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	2	5	complexity	complexity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	2	6	especially	especially	ADV
inlawrev-20850	2	7	elicit	elicit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	2	8	such1	such1	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	2	9	doctrinal	doctrinal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	2	10	misdirection	misdirection	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	2	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	3	1	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	3	2	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	3	3	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	3	4	exemplify	exemplify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	3	5	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	3	6	traits	trait	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	3	7	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	3	8	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	3	9	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	3	10	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	3	11	type	type	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	3	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	3	13	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	3	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	3	15	contemporary	contemporary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	3	16	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	3	17	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	3	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	4	1	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	4	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	4	3	comes	come	VERB
inlawrev-20850	4	4	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	4	5	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	4	6	surprise	surprise	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	4	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	4	8	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	4	9	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	4	10	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	4	11	preferences	preference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	4	12	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	4	13	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	4	14	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-20850	4	15	below	below	ADP
inlawrev-20850	4	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	4	17	surface	surface	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	4	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	4	19	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	4	20	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	4	21	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	4	22	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	4	23	nominally	nominally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	4	24	address	address	VERB
inlawrev-20850	4	25	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	4	26	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	4	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	4	28	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	4	29	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	4	30	proven	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	4	31	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	4	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	4	33	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	4	34	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	4	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	4	36	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	4	37	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	4	38	harm.2	harm.2	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	4	39	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	4	40	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	4	41	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	4	42	consequences	consequence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	4	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	5	1	stare	stare	VERB
inlawrev-20850	5	2	decisis	decisis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	5	3	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	5	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	5	5	influence	influence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	5	6	exerted	exert	VERB
inlawrev-20850	5	7	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	5	8	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	5	9	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	5	10	magnify	magnify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	5	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	5	12	effects	effect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	5	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	6	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	6	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	6	3	sets	set	VERB
inlawrev-20850	6	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	6	5	precedent	precedent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	6	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	6	7	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	6	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	6	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	6	10	perceived	perceive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	6	11	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	6	12	imperative	imperative	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	6	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	7	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	7	2	precedent	precedent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	7	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	7	4	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	7	5	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	7	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	7	7	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-20850	7	8	borrowed	borrow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	7	9	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	7	10	another	another	DET
inlawrev-20850	7	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	7	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	7	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	7	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	7	15	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	7	16	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	7	17	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	7	18	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	7	19	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	7	20	n’t	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	7	21	fit	fit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	7	22	quite	quite	ADV
inlawrev-20850	7	23	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	7	24	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	7	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	7	26	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	7	27	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	7	28	extended	extend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	7	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	7	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	7	31	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	7	32	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	7	33	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	7	34	unexpected	unexpected	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	7	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	7	36	unjust	unjust	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	7	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	7	38	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	7	39	unintelligible	unintelligible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	7	40	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	7	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	8	1	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	8	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	8	3	comes	come	VERB
inlawrev-20850	8	4	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	8	5	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	8	6	surprise	surprise	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	8	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	8	8	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	8	9	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	8	10	misapprehend	misapprehend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	8	11	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	8	12	misuse	misuse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	8	13	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	8	14	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	8	15	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	8	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	8	17	practical	practical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	8	18	concerns	concern	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	8	19	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	8	20	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	8	21	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	8	22	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	8	23	stake	stake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	8	24	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	8	25	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	8	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	8	27	theoretical	theoretical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	8	28	coherence	coherence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	8	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	8	30	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	8	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	9	1	scholarship	scholarship	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	9	2	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	9	3	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	9	4	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	9	5	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	9	6	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	9	7	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	9	8	consequences	consequence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	9	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	9	10	too	too	ADV
inlawrev-20850	9	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	10	1	hard	hard	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	10	2	problems	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	10	3	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	10	4	novel	novel	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	10	5	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	10	6	stimulate	stimulate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	10	7	academic	academic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	10	8	research	research	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	10	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	11	1	toxic	toxic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	11	2	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	11	3	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	11	4	presented	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	11	5	plenty	plenty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	11	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	11	7	both	both	PRON
inlawrev-20850	11	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	11	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	11	10	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	11	11	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	11	12	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	11	13	proven	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	11	14	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	11	15	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	11	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	11	17	most	most	ADV
inlawrev-20850	11	18	durable	durable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	11	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	11	20	controversial	controversial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	11	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	11	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	11	23	intractable	intractable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	11	24	difficulty	difficulty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	11	25	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	11	26	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	11	27	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	11	28	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	11	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	12	1	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	12	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	12	3	comes	come	VERB
inlawrev-20850	12	4	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	12	5	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	12	6	surprise	surprise	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	12	7	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	12	8	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	12	9	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	12	10	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	12	11	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	12	12	generated	generate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	12	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	12	14	sizable	sizable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	12	15	body	body	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	12	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	12	17	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	12	18	scholarship	scholarship	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	12	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	12	20	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-20850	12	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	12	22	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	12	23	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	12	24	*	*	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	12	25	professor	professor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	12	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	12	27	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	12	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	12	29	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	12	30	raymond	raymond	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	12	31	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	12	32	dearie	dearie	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	12	33	scholar	scholar	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	12	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	12	35	rutgers	rutgers	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	12	36	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	12	37	school	school	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	12	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	12	39	rutgers	rutgers	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	12	40	university	university	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	12	41	–	–	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	12	42	newark	newark	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	12	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	13	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	13	2	thank	thank	VERB
inlawrev-20850	13	3	dean	dean	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	13	4	andrew	andrew	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	13	5	klein	klein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	13	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	13	7	professor	professor	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	13	8	xuan	xuan	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	13	9	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	13	10	thao	thao	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	13	11	nguyen	nguyen	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	13	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	13	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	13	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	13	15	editors	editor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	13	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	13	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	13	18	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	13	19	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	13	20	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	13	21	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	13	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	13	23	opportunity	opportunity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	13	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	13	25	participate	participate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	13	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	13	27	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	13	28	symposium	symposium	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	13	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	14	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	14	2	acknowledge	acknowledge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	14	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	14	4	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	14	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	14	6	gracious	gracious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	14	7	care	care	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	14	8	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	14	9	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	14	10	timothy	timothy	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	14	11	cochren	cochren	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	14	12	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	14	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	14	14	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	14	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	14	16	symposium	symposium	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	14	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	15	1	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	15	2	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	15	3	benefited	benefit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	15	4	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	15	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	15	6	insights	insight	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	15	7	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	15	8	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	15	9	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	15	10	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	15	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	15	12	michael	michael	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	15	13	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	15	14	green	green	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	15	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	15	16	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	15	17	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	15	18	participated	participate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	15	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	15	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	15	21	symposium	symposium	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	15	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	15	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	15	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	15	25	joseph	joseph	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	15	26	sanders	sanders	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	15	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	16	1	kylie	kylie	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	16	2	huff	huff	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	16	3	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	16	4	invaluable	invaluable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	16	5	research	research	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	16	6	assistance	assistance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	16	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	17	1	sylviane	sylviane	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	17	2	gold	gold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	17	3	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	17	4	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	17	5	helpful	helpful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	17	6	editorial	editorial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	17	7	suggestions	suggestion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	17	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	18	1	jennifer	jennifer	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	18	2	aley	aley	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	18	3	supplied	supply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	18	4	motivation	motivation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	18	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	18	6	encouragement	encouragement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	18	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	18	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	18	9	proofreading	proofreading	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	18	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	19	1	errors	error	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	19	2	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	19	3	my	my	PRON
inlawrev-20850	19	4	own	own	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	19	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	20	1	1	1	X
inlawrev-20850	20	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	20	3	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	20	4	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	20	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	20	6	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	20	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	20	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	20	9	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	20	10	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	20	11	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	20	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	21	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	21	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	21	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	21	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	21	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	6	ch	ch	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	21	8	6	6	NUM
inlawrev-20850	21	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	21	10	special	special	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	21	11	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	12	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	21	13	proximate	proximate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	14	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	21	16	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	21	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	21	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	21	19	explaining	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	21	20	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	21	21	historic	historic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	21	22	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	21	24	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	21	25	proximate	proximate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	26	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	27	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	21	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	21	29	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	21	30	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	21	31	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	21	33	tended	tend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	21	34	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	21	35	obscure	obscure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	21	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	21	37	distinction	distinction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	38	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	21	39	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	40	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	21	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	21	42	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	21	44	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	45	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	21	46	limits	limit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	47	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	21	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	21	49	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	21	51	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	52	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	21	53	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	21	54	normative	normative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	21	55	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	21	56	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	21	57	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	22	1	2	2	X
inlawrev-20850	22	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	22	3	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	22	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	22	5	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	22	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	22	7	gen	gen	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	22	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	22	9	elec	elec	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	22	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	22	11	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	23	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	23	2	joiner	joiner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	23	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	4	522	522	NUM
inlawrev-20850	23	5	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	23	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	23	7	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-20850	23	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	9	148	148	NUM
inlawrev-20850	23	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	11	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	23	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	14	breyer	breyer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	16	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	23	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	18	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	23	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	21	exhorting	exhort	VERB
inlawrev-20850	23	22	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	23	24	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	23	25	especially	especially	ADV
inlawrev-20850	23	26	vigilant	vigilant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	23	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	23	28	prevent	prevent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	23	29	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	30	powerful	powerful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	23	31	engine	engine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	23	33	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	34	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	35	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	36	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	23	37	destroying	destroy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	23	38	innocent	innocent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	23	39	chemicals	chemical	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	40	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	41	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	42	lucinda	lucinda	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	23	43	m.	m.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	23	44	finley	finley	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	23	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	46	guarding	guard	VERB
inlawrev-20850	23	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	23	48	gate	gate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	49	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	23	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	23	51	courthouse	courthouse	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	52	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	53	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	23	54	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	55	judges	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	56	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	23	57	using	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	23	58	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	23	59	evidentiary	evidentiary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	23	60	screening	screening	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	61	role	role	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	62	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	23	63	remake	remake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	64	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	65	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	66	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	67	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	68	49	49	NUM
inlawrev-20850	23	69	depaul	depaul	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	23	70	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	23	71	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	23	72	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	23	73	335	335	NUM
inlawrev-20850	23	74	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	75	362	362	NUM
inlawrev-20850	23	76	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	77	1999	1999	NUM
inlawrev-20850	23	78	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	79	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	80	criticizing	criticize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	23	81	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	82	breyer	breyer	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	23	83	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	23	84	joiner	joiner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	85	concurrence	concurrence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	86	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	23	87	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	23	88	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	89	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	90	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	23	91	making	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	23	92	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	93	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	94	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	23	95	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	23	96	guise	guise	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	97	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	23	98	determining	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	23	99	admissibility	admissibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	100	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	23	101	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	23	102	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	103	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	23	104	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	23	105	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	23	106	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	24	1	http://dx.doi.org/10.18060/4806.0064	http://dx.doi.org/10.18060/4806.0064	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	24	2	118	118	NUM
inlawrev-20850	24	3	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	24	4	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	24	5	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	25	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	25	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	25	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	26	1	49:117	49:117	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	26	2	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	26	3	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	26	4	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	5	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-20850	26	6	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	26	7	opinions.3	opinions.3	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	26	9	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	26	10	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	26	12	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	26	13	explore	explore	VERB
inlawrev-20850	26	14	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	26	15	phenomena	phenomenon	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	16	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	26	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	26	18	injection	injection	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	26	20	normative	normative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	26	21	judgments	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	22	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-20850	26	23	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	26	24	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	25	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	26	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	26	28	incoherent	incoherent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	26	29	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	26	31	precedent	precedent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	26	33	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	26	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	26	35	interaction	interaction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	26	37	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	26	38	scholarship	scholarship	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	39	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	26	40	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	26	41	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	42	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	26	43	making	making	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	44	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	26	45	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	26	46	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	26	48	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	26	49	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	26	50	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	26	51	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	26	52	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	26	53	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	26	54	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	26	55	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	26	56	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	26	57	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	27	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	27	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	27	3	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	27	4	georgiapacific	georgiapacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	27	5	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	27	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	27	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	27	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	27	9	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	27	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	27	12	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	27	13	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	27	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	27	15	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	27	16	rendered	render	VERB
inlawrev-20850	27	17	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	18	in4	in4	VERB
inlawrev-20850	27	19	favor	favor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	27	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	27	22	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	27	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	27	25	company	company	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	26	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	27	27	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	27	28	manufactured	manufacture	VERB
inlawrev-20850	27	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	27	30	sold	sell	VERB
inlawrev-20850	27	31	asbestoscontaining	asbestoscontaine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	27	32	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	33	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	27	35	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	27	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	27	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	27	38	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	39	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	27	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	27	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	27	42	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	43	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	27	44	survivors	survivor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	27	46	a5	a5	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	47	man	man	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	48	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	27	49	died	die	VERB
inlawrev-20850	27	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	27	51	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	52	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	27	53	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	27	54	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	27	55	introduce	introduce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	27	56	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	27	57	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	58	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	27	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	28	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	28	2	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	28	3	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	28	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	28	5	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	28	6	describe	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	28	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	28	8	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	28	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	28	10	procedural	procedural	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	28	11	setting	setting	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	28	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	28	13	bostic	bostic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	28	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	28	15	situate	situate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	28	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	28	17	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	28	18	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	28	19	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	28	20	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	28	21	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	28	22	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	28	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	28	24	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	28	25	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	28	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	28	27	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	28	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	28	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	28	30	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	28	31	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	28	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	28	33	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	28	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	29	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	29	2	part	part	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	29	3	ii	ii	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	29	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	29	5	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	29	6	argue	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	29	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	29	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	29	9	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	10	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	29	12	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	29	13	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	29	14	internally	internally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	29	15	inconsistent	inconsistent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	29	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	29	17	applies	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	29	18	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	29	19	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	29	20	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	29	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	29	23	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	29	24	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	29	26	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	29	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	29	29	fundamentally	fundamentally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	29	30	misapprehends	misapprehend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	29	31	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	29	32	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	29	34	producing	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	29	35	deeply	deeply	ADV
inlawrev-20850	29	36	flawed	flawed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	29	37	holdings	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	38	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	29	39	contradict	contradict	VERB
inlawrev-20850	29	40	elementary	elementary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	29	41	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	42	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	43	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	29	44	most	most	ADV
inlawrev-20850	29	45	notably	notably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	29	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	29	47	principle	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	48	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	29	49	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	29	50	tortfeasor	tortfeasor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	51	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	29	52	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	53	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	29	54	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	29	55	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	29	56	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	29	57	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	58	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	29	59	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	60	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	29	61	combining	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	29	62	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	29	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	29	64	acts	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	65	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	29	66	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	29	67	tortfeasors	tortfeasor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	29	68	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	30	1	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	30	2	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	30	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	30	4	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	30	5	roots	root	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	30	6	lie	lie	VERB
inlawrev-20850	30	7	deep	deep	ADV
inlawrev-20850	30	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	30	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	30	10	heart	heart	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	30	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	30	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	30	13	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	30	14	earlier	early	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	30	15	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	30	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	30	17	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	30	18	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	30	19	pharmaceuticals	pharmaceuticals	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	30	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	30	21	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	30	22	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	31	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	31	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	31	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	32	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	32	2	part	part	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	32	3	iii	iii	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	32	5	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	32	6	discuss	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	32	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	32	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	32	10	path	path	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	11	from6	from6	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	32	12	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	32	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	32	14	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	32	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	32	16	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	32	17	yields	yield	VERB
inlawrev-20850	32	18	insights	insight	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	19	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	32	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	32	21	evolution	evolution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	32	23	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	32	24	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	25	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	32	26	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	32	27	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	32	28	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	29	judging	judging	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	32	31	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	32	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	32	33	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	34	judges	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	35	read	read	VERB
inlawrev-20850	32	36	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	32	37	scholarship	scholarship	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	32	39	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	32	40	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	32	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	32	42	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	43	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	32	44	scholars	scholar	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	45	read	read	VERB
inlawrev-20850	32	46	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	47	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	32	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	33	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	33	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	33	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	33	4	poor	poor	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	33	5	resolution	resolution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	33	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	33	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	33	8	recurring	recur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	33	9	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	33	10	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	33	11	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	33	12	influential	influential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	33	13	court.7	court.7	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	33	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	33	15	confusion	confusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	33	16	evident	evident	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	33	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	33	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	33	19	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	33	20	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	33	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	33	22	limited	limit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	33	23	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	33	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	33	25	lone	lone	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	33	26	star	star	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	33	27	state	state	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	33	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	34	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	34	2	lessons	lesson	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	34	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	34	4	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	34	5	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	34	6	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	34	7	useful	useful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	34	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	34	9	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	34	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	34	11	scholars	scholar	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	34	12	far	far	ADV
inlawrev-20850	34	13	beyond	beyond	ADP
inlawrev-20850	34	14	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	34	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	35	1	3	3	X
inlawrev-20850	35	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	35	3	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	35	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	35	5	few	few	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	35	6	guides	guide	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	35	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	35	8	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	35	9	large	large	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	35	10	body	body	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	35	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	35	12	literature	literature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	35	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	35	14	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	35	15	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	35	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	35	17	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	35	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	35	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	35	20	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	35	21	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	35	22	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	35	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	36	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	36	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	36	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	36	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	36	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	36	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	36	7	28	28	NUM
inlawrev-20850	36	8	cmt	cmt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	36	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	1	c	c	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	2	reporters	reporters	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	3	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	4	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	6	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	37	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	8	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	9	michael	michael	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	10	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	11	green	green	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	12	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	13	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	16	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	17	guide	guide	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	18	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	37	19	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	37	22	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	37	23	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	37	24	center	center	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	26	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	27	manual	manual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	28	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	37	29	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	37	30	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	31	549	549	NUM
inlawrev-20850	37	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	33	630	630	NUM
inlawrev-20850	37	34	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	37	35	32	32	NUM
inlawrev-20850	37	36	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	37	3d	3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	37	38	ed	ed	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	39	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	40	2000	2000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	37	41	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	42	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	43	bernard	bernard	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	44	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	45	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	46	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	37	47	mary	mary	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	48	sue	sue	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	49	henifin	henifin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	50	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	51	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	52	guide	guide	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	53	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	37	54	toxicology	toxicology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	55	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	56	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	37	57	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	37	58	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	37	59	center	center	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	60	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	61	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	62	manual	manual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	63	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	37	64	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	37	65	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	66	633	633	NUM
inlawrev-20850	37	67	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	68	685	685	NUM
inlawrev-20850	37	69	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	70	3d	3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	37	71	ed	ed	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	37	72	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	37	73	2000	2000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	37	74	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	37	75	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	38	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	38	2	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	38	3	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	38	4	discussing	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	38	5	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-20850	38	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	38	7	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	38	8	literature	literature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	38	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	38	10	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	38	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	38	12	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	38	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	38	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	38	15	re	re	VERB
inlawrev-20850	38	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	38	17	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	38	18	orange	orange	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	38	19	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	38	20	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	38	21	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	38	22	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	38	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	38	24	597	597	NUM
inlawrev-20850	38	25	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	38	26	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	38	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	39	1	740	740	NUM
inlawrev-20850	39	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	39	3	e.d.n.y	e.d.n.y	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	39	4	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	39	5	1984	1984	NUM
inlawrev-20850	39	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	39	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	39	8	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	39	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	39	10	818	818	NUM
inlawrev-20850	39	11	f.2d	f.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	39	12	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-20850	39	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	39	14	2d	2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	39	15	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	39	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	39	17	1987	1987	NUM
inlawrev-20850	39	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	39	19	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	39	20	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	39	21	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	39	22	pharmaceuticals	pharmaceuticals	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	39	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	39	24	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	39	25	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	40	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	40	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	40	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	40	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	40	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	40	6	706	706	NUM
inlawrev-20850	40	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	40	8	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	40	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	40	10	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	40	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	40	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	41	1	4	4	X
inlawrev-20850	41	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	42	1	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	42	2	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	42	3	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	42	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	42	5	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	42	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	42	7	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	42	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	42	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	43	1	5	5	X
inlawrev-20850	43	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	43	3	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	43	4	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	43	5	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	43	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	43	7	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
inlawrev-20850	43	8	called	call	VERB
inlawrev-20850	43	9	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	43	10	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	43	11	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	43	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	43	13	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	43	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	43	15	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	43	16	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	43	17	connect	connect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	43	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	43	19	smooth	smooth	VERB
inlawrev-20850	43	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	43	21	seams	seam	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	43	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	43	23	adjoining	adjoin	VERB
inlawrev-20850	43	24	pieces	piece	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	43	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	43	26	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	43	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	43	28	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	43	29	called	call	VERB
inlawrev-20850	43	30	sheetrock	sheetrock	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	43	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	43	32	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	43	33	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	43	34	cover	cover	VERB
inlawrev-20850	43	35	nail	nail	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	43	36	heads	head	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	43	37	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	43	38	sheets	sheet	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	43	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	43	40	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	43	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	43	42	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	44	1	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	44	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	44	3	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	44	4	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	45	1	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	45	2	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	45	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	45	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	45	5	320	320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	45	6	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	45	7	588	588	NUM
inlawrev-20850	45	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	45	9	591	591	NUM
inlawrev-20850	45	10	n.2	n.2	SYM
inlawrev-20850	45	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	45	12	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	45	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	45	14	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	45	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	45	16	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	45	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	45	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	45	19	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	45	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	45	21	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	45	22	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	45	23	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	45	24	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	45	25	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	45	26	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	45	27	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	45	28	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	45	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	46	1	6	6	NUM
inlawrev-20850	46	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	46	3	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	46	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	46	5	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	46	6	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	46	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	46	8	706	706	NUM
inlawrev-20850	46	9	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	46	10	7	7	NUM
inlawrev-20850	46	11	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	47	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	47	2	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	47	3	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	47	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	47	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	47	6	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	47	7	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	47	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	47	9	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	47	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	47	11	influence	influence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	47	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	47	13	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	47	14	estate	estate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	47	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	47	16	george	george	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	47	17	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	47	18	vermont	vermont	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	47	19	league	league	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	47	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	47	21	cities	city	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	47	22	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	47	23	towns	town	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	47	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	47	25	993	993	NUM
inlawrev-20850	47	26	a.2d	a.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	47	27	367	367	NUM
inlawrev-20850	47	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	47	29	377	377	NUM
inlawrev-20850	47	30	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	47	31	78	78	NUM
inlawrev-20850	47	32	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	47	33	vt	vt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	47	34	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	47	35	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	47	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	47	37	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	47	38	relying	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	47	39	heavily	heavily	ADV
inlawrev-20850	47	40	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	47	41	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	47	42	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	47	43	hold	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	47	44	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	47	45	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	47	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	47	47	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	47	48	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	47	49	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	47	50	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	47	51	abuse	abuse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	47	52	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	47	53	discretion	discretion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	47	54	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	47	55	considering	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	47	56	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	47	57	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	47	58	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	47	59	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	47	60	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	47	61	2.0	2.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	47	62	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	47	63	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	47	64	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	47	65	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	47	66	helpful	helpful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	47	67	benchmark	benchmark	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	47	68	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	47	69	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	47	70	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	48	1	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	48	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	48	3	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	48	4	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	48	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	48	6	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	48	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	48	8	119	119	NUM
inlawrev-20850	48	9	i.	i.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	48	10	situating	situate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	48	11	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	48	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	48	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	48	14	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	48	15	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	48	16	universe	universe	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	48	17	a.	a.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	48	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	48	19	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	48	20	setting	set	VERB
inlawrev-20850	48	21	timothy	timothy	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	48	22	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	48	23	died	die	VERB
inlawrev-20850	48	24	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	48	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	48	26	age	age	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	48	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	48	28	forty	forty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	48	29	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	48	30	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	48	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	48	32	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	48	33	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	48	34	invariably8	invariably8	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	48	35	fatal	fatal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	48	36	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	48	37	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	48	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	48	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	48	40	pleural	pleural	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	48	41	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	48	42	peritoneal	peritoneal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	48	43	lining	lining	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	48	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	49	1	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	49	3	generally9	generally9	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	49	4	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	49	5	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	49	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	49	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	49	8	signature	signature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	9	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	10	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	49	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	49	12	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	49	14	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	49	15	types	type	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	49	17	asbestos.11	asbestos.11	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	49	18	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	49	19	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	49	20	survivors	survivor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	21	sued	sue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	49	22	forty	forty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	49	23	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	49	25	alleging	allege	VERB
inlawrev-20850	49	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	49	27	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	28	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	49	29	liable	liable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	49	30	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	49	31	negligence	negligence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	32	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	49	33	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	34	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	35	theories	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	36	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	49	37	exposing	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	49	38	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	49	39	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	49	40	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	41	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	49	42	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	49	43	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	49	44	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	45	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	49	46	death	death	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	49	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	50	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	50	2	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	50	3	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-20850	50	4	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	50	5	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	50	6	except12	except12	VERB
inlawrev-20850	50	7	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	50	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	50	9	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	50	10	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	50	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	50	12	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	50	13	settled	settle	VERB
inlawrev-20850	50	14	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	50	15	dismissed	dismiss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	50	16	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-20850	50	17	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	50	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	51	1	13	13	NUM
inlawrev-20850	51	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	51	3	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	51	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	51	5	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	51	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	51	7	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	51	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	51	9	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	51	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	51	11	understandably	understandably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	51	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	51	13	attracted	attract	VERB
inlawrev-20850	51	14	considerable	considerable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	51	15	evidentiary	evidentiary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	51	16	development	development	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	51	17	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	51	18	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	51	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	52	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	52	2	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	52	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	52	4	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	52	5	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	52	6	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	52	7	the14	the14	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	52	8	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	52	9	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	52	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	52	11	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	52	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	52	13	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	52	14	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	52	15	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	52	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	52	17	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	52	18	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	52	19	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	52	20	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	52	21	inhaled	inhale	VERB
inlawrev-20850	52	22	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	52	23	•	•	NUM
inlawrev-20850	52	24	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	52	25	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	52	26	childhood	childhood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	52	27	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	52	28	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	52	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	52	30	drywall	drywall	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	52	31	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	52	32	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	52	33	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	52	34	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	52	35	including	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	52	36	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-20850	52	37	manufactured	manufacture	VERB
inlawrev-20850	52	38	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	52	39	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	52	40	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	52	41	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	52	42	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	52	43	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	52	44	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	52	45	helped	help	VERB
inlawrev-20850	52	46	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	52	47	father	father	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	52	48	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	52	49	harold	harold	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	52	50	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	52	51	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	52	52	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	52	53	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	52	54	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	52	55	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	52	56	yourself	yourself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	52	57	home	home	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	52	58	projects	project	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	52	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	53	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	53	2	mixed	mix	VERB
inlawrev-20850	53	3	dry	dry	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	53	4	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	53	5	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	53	6	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	53	7	water	water	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	53	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	53	9	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	53	10	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	53	11	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	53	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	53	13	sanded	sand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	53	14	surfaces	surface	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	53	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	53	16	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	53	17	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	53	18	8	8	NUM
inlawrev-20850	53	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	54	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	54	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	54	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	54	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	54	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	54	6	336	336	NUM
inlawrev-20850	54	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	55	1	9	9	NUM
inlawrev-20850	55	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	56	1	fairchild	fairchild	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	56	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	56	3	glenhaven	glenhaven	VERB
inlawrev-20850	56	4	funeral	funeral	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	56	5	servs	servs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	56	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	56	7	ltd	ltd	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	56	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	56	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	57	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	57	2	2002	2002	NUM
inlawrev-20850	57	3	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	57	4	ukhl	ukhl	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	58	1	22	22	NUM
inlawrev-20850	59	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	59	2	7	7	NUM
inlawrev-20850	59	3	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	59	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	59	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	59	6	2002	2002	NUM
inlawrev-20850	59	7	]	]	SYM
inlawrev-20850	59	8	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	59	9	a.c	a.c	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	59	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	59	11	32	32	NUM
inlawrev-20850	59	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	59	13	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	59	14	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	59	15	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	59	16	eng	eng	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	59	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	59	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	59	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	60	1	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	60	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	61	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	61	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	61	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	61	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	61	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	61	6	337	337	NUM
inlawrev-20850	61	7	n.4	n.4	NUM
inlawrev-20850	61	8	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	61	9	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	61	10	joyce	joyce	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	61	11	k.	k.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	61	12	thompson	thompson	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	61	13	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	61	14	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	61	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	61	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	61	17	malignant	malignant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	61	18	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	61	19	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	61	20	development	development	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	61	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	61	22	therapy	therapy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	61	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	61	24	115	115	NUM
inlawrev-20850	61	25	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	61	26	cellular	cellular	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	61	27	biochemistry	biochemistry	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	61	28	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	61	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	61	30	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	61	31	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	61	32	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	61	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	61	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	62	1	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	62	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	63	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	63	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	63	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	63	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	63	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	63	6	367	367	NUM
inlawrev-20850	63	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	63	8	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	63	9	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	63	10	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	63	11	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	63	12	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	63	13	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	63	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	63	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	63	16	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	63	17	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	63	18	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-20850	63	19	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	63	20	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	63	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	63	22	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	63	23	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	63	24	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	63	25	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	63	26	treatment	treatment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	63	27	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	63	28	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	63	29	types	type	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	63	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	63	31	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	63	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	63	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	63	34	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	63	35	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	63	36	re	re	VERB
inlawrev-20850	63	37	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	63	38	litig	litig	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	63	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	64	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	64	2	900	900	NUM
inlawrev-20850	64	3	a.2d	a.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	64	4	120	120	NUM
inlawrev-20850	64	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	64	6	132	132	NUM
inlawrev-20850	64	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	64	8	del	del	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	64	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	64	10	super	super	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	64	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	65	1	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	65	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	65	3	2006	2006	NUM
inlawrev-20850	65	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	2	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	3	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	66	4	b]ackground	b]ackground	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	66	5	incidence	incidence	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	66	6	rate	rate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	66	7	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	66	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	66	9	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	66	10	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	66	12	basically	basically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	66	13	zero	zero	NUM
inlawrev-20850	66	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	15	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	17	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	18	joseph	joseph	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	66	19	sanders	sanders	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	66	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	66	22	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	23	every	every	DET
inlawrev-20850	66	24	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	66	25	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	26	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	66	27	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	66	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	66	29	beginning	beginning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	66	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	66	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	66	32	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	66	33	endgame	endgame	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	66	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	35	88	88	NUM
inlawrev-20850	66	36	tul	tul	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	66	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	38	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	66	39	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	66	40	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	66	41	1153	1153	NUM
inlawrev-20850	66	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	43	1155	1155	NUM
inlawrev-20850	66	44	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	45	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	66	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	66	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	67	1	defense	defense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	67	2	attorneys	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	67	3	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	67	4	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
inlawrev-20850	67	5	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	67	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	67	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	67	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	67	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	67	10	print	print	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	67	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	67	12	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	67	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	67	14	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	67	15	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	67	16	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	67	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	67	18	mesotheliomas	mesotheliomas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	67	19	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	67	20	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	67	21	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	67	22	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	67	23	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	67	24	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	67	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	68	1	mark	mark	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	68	2	a.	a.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	68	3	behrens	behrens	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	68	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	68	5	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	68	6	’s	’	VERB
inlawrev-20850	68	7	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	68	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	68	9	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	68	10	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	68	11	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	68	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	68	13	28	28	NUM
inlawrev-20850	68	14	rev	rev	X
inlawrev-20850	68	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	69	1	litig	litig	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	69	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	70	1	501	501	NUM
inlawrev-20850	70	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	70	3	527	527	NUM
inlawrev-20850	70	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	70	5	2009	2009	NUM
inlawrev-20850	70	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	70	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	71	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	71	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	71	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	71	4	assertion	assertion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	71	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	71	6	difficult	difficult	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	71	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	71	8	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	71	9	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	71	10	everybody	everybody	PRON
inlawrev-20850	71	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	71	12	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	71	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	71	14	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	71	15	amount	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	71	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	71	17	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	71	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	71	19	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	71	20	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	71	21	quantities	quantity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	71	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	71	23	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	71	24	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	71	25	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	71	26	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	71	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	71	28	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	71	29	people	people	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	71	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	72	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	72	2	becker	becker	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	72	3	v.	v.	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	72	4	baron	baron	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	72	5	bros	bros	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	72	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	72	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	72	8	649	649	NUM
inlawrev-20850	72	9	a.2d	a.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	72	10	613	613	NUM
inlawrev-20850	72	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	72	12	618	618	NUM
inlawrev-20850	72	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	72	14	n.j	n.j	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	72	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	72	16	1994	1994	NUM
inlawrev-20850	72	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	72	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	72	19	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	20	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	72	21	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	22	believed	believe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	72	23	apparently	apparently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	72	24	idiopathic	idiopathic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	72	25	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	72	27	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	28	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	72	29	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	72	30	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	72	31	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	72	32	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	33	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	72	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	72	35	atmosphere	atmosphere	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	72	37	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	72	38	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	72	39	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	72	40	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	72	41	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	42	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	72	43	376	376	NUM
inlawrev-20850	72	44	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	72	45	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	72	46	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	47	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	72	48	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	72	49	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	72	50	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	72	51	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	52	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	72	53	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	72	54	amounts	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	55	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	72	56	chrysotile	chrysotile	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	57	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	58	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	59	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	72	60	capable	capable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	72	61	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	72	62	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	72	63	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	72	64	errors	error	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	65	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	72	66	eventually	eventually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	72	67	result	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	72	68	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	72	69	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	72	70	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	72	71	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	73	1	jinfei	jinfei	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	73	2	xu	xu	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	73	3	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	74	1	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	74	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	74	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	74	4	germline	germline	VERB
inlawrev-20850	74	5	mutation	mutation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	74	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	74	7	bap1	bap1	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	74	8	accelerates	accelerate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	74	9	development	development	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	74	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	74	11	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	74	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	74	13	induced	induce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	74	14	malignant	malignant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	74	15	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	74	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	74	17	74	74	NUM
inlawrev-20850	74	18	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	74	19	res	re	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	74	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	75	1	4388	4388	NUM
inlawrev-20850	75	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	75	3	4389	4389	NUM
inlawrev-20850	75	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	75	5	4395	4395	NUM
inlawrev-20850	75	6	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	75	7	96	96	NUM
inlawrev-20850	75	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	75	9	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	75	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	75	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	75	12	reporting	report	VERB
inlawrev-20850	75	13	experimental	experimental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	75	14	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	15	consistent	consistent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	75	16	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	75	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	75	18	hypothesis	hypothesis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	19	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	75	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	75	21	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	75	22	mutation	mutation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	23	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	75	24	individuals	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	25	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	75	26	susceptible	susceptible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	75	27	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	75	28	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	29	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	75	30	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	75	31	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	75	32	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	75	34	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	35	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	75	37	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	75	38	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	75	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	75	40	hypothesis	hypothesis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	41	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	75	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	75	43	mutation	mutation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	44	causes	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	75	45	individuals	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	46	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	75	47	develop	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	75	48	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	49	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	75	50	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	75	51	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	52	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	75	53	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	75	54	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	75	55	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	76	1	12	12	NUM
inlawrev-20850	76	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	77	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	77	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	77	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	77	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	77	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	77	6	336	336	NUM
inlawrev-20850	77	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	78	1	13	13	NUM
inlawrev-20850	78	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	78	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	78	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	78	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	78	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	78	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	79	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	79	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	79	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	79	4	320	320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	79	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	79	6	588	588	NUM
inlawrev-20850	79	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	79	8	590	590	NUM
inlawrev-20850	79	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	79	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	79	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	79	12	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	79	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	79	14	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	79	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	79	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	79	17	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	79	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	79	19	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	79	20	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	79	21	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	79	22	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	79	23	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	79	24	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	79	25	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	79	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	79	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	80	1	14	14	NUM
inlawrev-20850	80	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	81	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	81	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	81	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	81	4	592	592	NUM
inlawrev-20850	81	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	81	6	94	94	NUM
inlawrev-20850	81	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	82	1	http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/jcb.24642	http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/jcb.24642	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	82	2	http://dx.doi.org/10.1158/0008-5472.can-14-1328	http://dx.doi.org/10.1158/0008-5472.can-14-1328	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	82	3	120	120	NUM
inlawrev-20850	82	4	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	82	5	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	82	6	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	83	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	83	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	83	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	84	1	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	84	2	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	84	3	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	84	4	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	84	5	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	84	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	84	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	84	8	swept	sweep	VERB
inlawrev-20850	84	9	up	up	ADP
inlawrev-20850	84	10	dust	dust	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	84	11	created	create	VERB
inlawrev-20850	84	12	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	84	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	84	14	projects.15	projects.15	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	84	15	•	•	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	84	16	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	84	17	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	84	18	childhood	childhood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	84	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	84	20	adolescence	adolescence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	84	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	84	22	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	84	23	take	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	84	24	home	home	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	84	25	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	84	26	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	84	27	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	84	28	harold	harold	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	84	29	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	84	30	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	84	31	clothes	clothe	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	84	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	84	33	resulting	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	84	34	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	84	35	harold	harold	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	84	36	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	84	37	occupational	occupational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	84	38	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	84	39	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	84	40	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	84	41	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	84	42	employed	employ	VERB
inlawrev-20850	84	43	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	84	44	knox	knox	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	84	45	glass	glass	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	84	46	company	company	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	84	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	85	1	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	85	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	85	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	85	4	parents	parent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	85	5	divorced	divorce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	85	6	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	85	7	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	85	8	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	85	9	nine	nine	NUM
inlawrev-20850	85	10	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	85	11	old	old	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	85	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	85	13	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	85	14	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	85	15	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	85	16	smaller	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	85	17	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	85	18	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	85	19	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	85	20	otherwise	otherwise	ADV
inlawrev-20850	85	21	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	85	22	been.16	been.16	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	85	23	•	•	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	85	24	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	85	25	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	85	26	adolescence	adolescence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	85	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	85	28	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	85	29	summers	summer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	85	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	85	31	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	85	32	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	85	33	knox	knox	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	85	34	glass	glass	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	85	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	85	36	parts	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	85	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	85	38	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	85	39	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	85	40	spent	spend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	85	41	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	85	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	85	43	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	85	44	hot	hot	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	85	45	end	end	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	85	46	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	85	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	85	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	85	49	plant	plant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	85	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	86	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	86	2	knox	knox	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	86	3	glass	glass	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	86	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	86	5	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	86	6	cut	cut	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	7	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	8	cloth	cloth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	86	10	removed	remove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	86	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	86	12	replaced	replace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	86	13	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	14	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	86	15	machines	machine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	86	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	86	18	cleaned	clean	VERB
inlawrev-20850	86	19	up	up	ADP
inlawrev-20850	86	20	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	86	21	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	22	pipe	pipe	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	23	insulation	insulation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	24	repairs	repair	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	86	26	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	86	27	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	86	28	respiratory	respiratory	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	86	29	protection.17	protection.17	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	86	30	•	•	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	86	31	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	32	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	86	33	adolescence	adolescence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	34	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	86	35	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	86	36	summers	summer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	86	38	construction	construction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	39	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	40	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	86	41	palestine	palestine	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	86	42	contractors	contractor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	86	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	87	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	87	2	worked	work	VERB
inlawrev-20850	87	3	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	87	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	87	5	welder	welder	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	87	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	87	7	assistant	assistant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	87	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	87	9	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
inlawrev-20850	87	10	removed	remove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	87	11	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	87	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	87	13	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	87	14	pipe	pipe	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	87	15	insulation	insulation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	87	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	87	17	gaskets.18	gaskets.18	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	87	18	•	•	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	87	19	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	87	20	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	87	21	adolescence	adolescence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	87	22	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	87	23	adulthood	adulthood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	87	24	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	87	25	performing	perform	VERB
inlawrev-20850	87	26	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	87	27	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	87	28	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	87	29	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	87	30	yourself	yourself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	87	31	repairs	repair	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	87	32	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	87	33	automobile	automobile	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	87	34	brakes	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	87	35	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	87	36	clutches	clutch	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	87	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	88	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	88	2	estimated	estimate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	88	3	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	88	4	did	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	88	5	four19	four19	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	88	6	brake	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	88	7	jobs	job	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	88	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	88	9	year	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	88	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	88	11	ten	ten	NUM
inlawrev-20850	88	12	clutch	clutch	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	88	13	jobs	job	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	88	14	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	88	15	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	88	16	lifetime.20	lifetime.20	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	88	17	•	•	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	88	18	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	88	19	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	88	20	adulthood	adulthood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	88	21	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	88	22	performing	perform	VERB
inlawrev-20850	88	23	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	88	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	88	25	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	88	26	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	88	27	yourself	yourself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	88	28	remodeling	remodeling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	88	29	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	88	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	89	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	89	2	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	89	3	roofing	roofing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	89	4	shingles	shingle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	89	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	89	6	floor	floor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	89	7	tiles	tile	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	89	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	89	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	89	10	ceiling	ceiling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	89	11	tiles	tile	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	89	12	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	89	13	contained	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	89	14	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	89	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	90	1	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	90	2	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	90	3	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	90	4	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	90	5	involve	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	90	6	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	90	7	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	90	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	90	9	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	90	10	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	90	11	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	90	12	contained	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	90	13	asbestos.21	asbestos.21	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	90	14	•	•	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	90	15	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	90	16	throughout	throughout	ADP
inlawrev-20850	90	17	life	life	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	90	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	90	19	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	90	20	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	90	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	90	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	90	23	ambient	ambient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	90	24	air	air	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	90	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	90	26	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	90	27	capable	capable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	90	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	90	29	being	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	90	30	linked	link	VERB
inlawrev-20850	90	31	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	90	32	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	90	33	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	90	34	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	90	35	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	90	36	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	90	37	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	90	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	91	1	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	91	2	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	91	3	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	91	4	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	91	5	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	91	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	91	7	universal.22	universal.22	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	91	8	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-20850	91	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	92	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	92	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	4	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	92	5	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	92	6	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	92	7	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	92	8	home	home	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	92	9	improvement	improvement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	92	10	projects	project	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	92	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	92	12	detail	detail	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	92	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	14	including	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	92	15	gaps	gap	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	92	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	92	17	harold	harold	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	92	18	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	92	19	recollection	recollection	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	92	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	21	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	22	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	92	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	24	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	92	25	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	92	26	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	92	27	353	353	NUM
inlawrev-20850	92	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	29	369	369	NUM
inlawrev-20850	92	30	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	31	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	92	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	33	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	92	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	35	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	92	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	37	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	38	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	92	39	harold	harold	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	92	40	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	92	41	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	92	42	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	92	43	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	92	44	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	92	45	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	92	46	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	47	pacific	pacific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	92	48	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	92	49	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	92	50	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	51	98	98	NUM
inlawrev-20850	92	52	percent	percent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	92	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	92	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	92	55	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	92	56	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	57	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	92	58	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	92	59	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	92	60	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	92	61	timothy	timothy	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	92	62	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	92	63	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	92	64	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	92	65	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	66	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	92	67	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	68	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	92	69	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	70	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	92	71	times	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	92	72	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	73	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	92	74	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	93	1	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	93	2	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	93	3	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	93	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	93	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	93	6	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	93	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	93	8	projects	project	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	93	9	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	93	10	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	93	11	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	93	12	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	93	13	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	93	14	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	93	15	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	93	16	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	93	17	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	93	18	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	93	19	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	93	20	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	93	21	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	93	22	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	93	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	93	24	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	93	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	93	26	dispute	dispute	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	93	27	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	93	28	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	93	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	93	30	varying	vary	VERB
inlawrev-20850	93	31	interpretations	interpretation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	93	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	93	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	93	34	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	93	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	94	1	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	94	2	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	94	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	94	4	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	94	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	94	6	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	94	7	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	94	8	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	94	9	able	able	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	94	10	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	94	11	conclude	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	94	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	94	13	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	94	14	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	94	15	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	94	16	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	94	17	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	94	18	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	94	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	94	20	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	94	21	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	94	22	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	94	23	conclude	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	94	24	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	94	25	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	94	26	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	94	27	ever	ever	ADV
inlawrev-20850	94	28	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	94	29	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	94	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	94	31	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	94	32	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	94	33	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	94	34	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	94	35	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	94	36	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	94	37	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	94	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	94	39	dismissing	dismiss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	94	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	94	41	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	94	42	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-20850	94	43	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	94	44	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	94	45	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	94	46	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	94	47	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	94	48	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	94	49	easy	easy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	94	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	95	1	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-20850	95	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	96	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	96	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	96	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	96	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	96	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	96	6	369	369	NUM
inlawrev-20850	96	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	96	8	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	96	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	96	10	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	96	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	96	12	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	96	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	96	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	97	1	17	17	NUM
inlawrev-20850	97	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	98	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	98	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	98	3	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-20850	98	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	99	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	99	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	99	4	354	354	NUM
inlawrev-20850	99	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	6	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	99	7	mention	mention	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	99	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	99	9	frequency	frequency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	99	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	11	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	12	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	99	13	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	99	14	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	99	15	369	369	NUM
inlawrev-20850	99	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	17	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	99	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	19	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	99	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	21	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	99	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	24	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	25	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-20850	99	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	99	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	99	28	pipes	pipe	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	99	29	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	30	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	31	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	32	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	99	33	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	99	34	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	99	35	379	379	NUM
inlawrev-20850	99	36	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	37	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	38	intermittent	intermittent	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	99	39	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	40	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	41	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	42	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	99	43	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	44	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	99	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	46	320	320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	99	47	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	99	48	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	99	49	595	595	NUM
inlawrev-20850	99	50	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	51	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	52	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	99	53	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	99	54	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-20850	99	55	times	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	99	56	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	99	57	week	week	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	99	58	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	59	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	99	60	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	100	1	19	19	NUM
inlawrev-20850	100	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	101	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	101	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	101	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	101	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	101	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	101	6	354	354	NUM
inlawrev-20850	101	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	101	8	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	101	9	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	101	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	101	11	frequency	frequency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	101	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	101	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	102	1	20	20	NUM
inlawrev-20850	102	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	102	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	102	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	102	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	102	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	102	7	320	320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	102	8	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	102	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	102	10	595	595	NUM
inlawrev-20850	102	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	102	12	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	102	13	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	102	14	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	102	15	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	102	16	older	old	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	102	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	102	18	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	102	19	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	102	20	did	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	102	21	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	102	22	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	102	23	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	102	24	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-20850	102	25	brake	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	102	26	jobs	job	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	102	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	102	28	year	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	102	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	102	30	fewer	few	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	102	31	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	102	32	ten	ten	NUM
inlawrev-20850	102	33	clutch	clutch	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	102	34	jobs	job	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	102	35	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	102	36	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	102	37	lifetime	lifetime	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	102	38	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	102	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	103	1	21	21	NUM
inlawrev-20850	103	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	104	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	104	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	104	3	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	105	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	105	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	105	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	105	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	105	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	105	6	354	354	NUM
inlawrev-20850	105	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	105	8	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	105	9	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	105	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	105	11	frequency	frequency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	105	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	105	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	106	1	22	22	NUM
inlawrev-20850	106	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	107	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	107	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	107	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	107	6	339	339	NUM
inlawrev-20850	107	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	8	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	107	9	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	107	10	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	107	11	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	107	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	13	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	107	14	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	107	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	107	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	17	232	232	NUM
inlawrev-20850	107	18	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	107	19	765	765	NUM
inlawrev-20850	107	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	21	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	107	22	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	107	23	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-20850	107	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	25	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	26	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	107	27	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	107	28	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	107	29	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	107	30	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	31	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	32	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	33	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	107	34	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	107	35	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	36	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	107	37	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	107	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	107	39	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	107	40	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	107	41	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	107	42	witnesses	witness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	107	43	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	44	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	45	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	46	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	107	47	w]e	w]e	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	107	48	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	107	49	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	107	50	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	107	51	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	107	52	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	53	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	107	54	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-20850	107	55	lungs	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	107	56	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	57	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	58	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	59	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	107	60	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	107	61	sienkiewicz	sienkiewicz	VERB
inlawrev-20850	107	62	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	107	63	greif	greif	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	107	64	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	65	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	107	66	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	107	67	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	107	68	uksc	uksc	VERB
inlawrev-20850	107	69	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	108	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	108	2	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-20850	108	3	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	108	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	108	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	108	6	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	108	7	]	]	SYM
inlawrev-20850	108	8	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	108	9	a.c	a.c	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	108	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	108	11	229	229	NUM
inlawrev-20850	108	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	108	13	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	108	14	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	108	15	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	108	16	eng	eng	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	108	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	108	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	109	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	109	2	lord	lord	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	109	3	phillips	phillips	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	109	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	109	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	109	6	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	109	7	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	109	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	109	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	109	10	occupational	occupational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	109	11	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	109	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	109	13	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	109	14	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	109	15	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	109	16	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	109	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	109	18	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	109	19	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	109	20	121	121	NUM
inlawrev-20850	109	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	109	22	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	109	23	persuaded	persuade	VERB
inlawrev-20850	109	24	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	109	25	juries	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	109	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	109	27	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	109	28	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	109	29	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	109	30	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	109	31	liable	liable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	109	32	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	109	33	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	109	34	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	109	35	death	death	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	109	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	110	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	110	2	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	110	3	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	110	4	apportioned	apportion	VERB
inlawrev-20850	110	5	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	110	6	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	110	7	georgia	georgia	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	110	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	110	9	pacific23	pacific23	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	110	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	110	11	knox	knox	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	110	12	glass	glass	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	110	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	110	14	assigning	assign	VERB
inlawrev-20850	110	15	seventy	seventy	NUM
inlawrev-20850	110	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	110	17	five	five	NUM
inlawrev-20850	110	18	percent	percent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	110	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	110	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	110	21	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	110	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	110	23	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	110	24	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	110	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	111	1	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	111	2	post	post	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	111	3	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	111	4	trial	trial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	111	5	skirmishing	skirmishing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	111	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	111	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	111	8	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	111	9	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	111	10	entered	enter	VERB
inlawrev-20850	111	11	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	111	12	awarding24	awarding24	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	111	13	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	111	14	nearly	nearly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	111	15	seven	seven	NUM
inlawrev-20850	111	16	million	million	NUM
inlawrev-20850	111	17	dollars	dollar	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	111	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	111	19	compensatory	compensatory	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	111	20	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	111	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	111	22	nearly	nearly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	111	23	five	five	NUM
inlawrev-20850	111	24	million	million	NUM
inlawrev-20850	111	25	dollars	dollar	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	111	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	111	27	punitive	punitive	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	111	28	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	111	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	112	1	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	112	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	112	3	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	112	4	persuaded	persuade	VERB
inlawrev-20850	112	5	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	112	6	appellate25	appellate25	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	7	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	112	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	112	10	reasons	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	11	explained	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	112	12	below	below	ADV
inlawrev-20850	112	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	112	14	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	112	15	reverse	reverse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	112	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	112	17	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	18	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	19	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	20	and26	and26	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	112	21	render	render	VERB
inlawrev-20850	112	22	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	112	24	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	25	take	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	112	26	nothing.27	nothing.27	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	112	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	112	28	above	above	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	112	29	synopsis	synopsis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	112	31	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	112	32	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	112	33	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	34	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	35	immediately	immediately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	112	36	distinguishes	distinguish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	112	37	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	112	38	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	39	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	112	40	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-20850	112	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	112	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	112	43	generation	generation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	112	45	claimants	claimant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	46	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	112	47	preceded	precede	VERB
inlawrev-20850	112	48	him	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	112	49	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	112	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	112	51	boilermakers	boilermaker	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	52	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	112	53	pipefitters	pipefitter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	54	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	112	55	worked	work	VERB
inlawrev-20850	112	56	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	112	57	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	58	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	112	59	decades	decade	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	60	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	112	61	air	air	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	62	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	112	63	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	64	dust	dust	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	65	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	112	66	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	112	67	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-20850	112	68	snow	snow	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	112	69	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	112	70	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	113	1	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	113	2	comparison	comparison	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	113	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	113	4	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	113	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	113	6	overall	overall	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	113	7	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	113	8	to28	to28	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	113	9	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	113	10	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	113	11	identifiable	identifiable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	113	12	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	113	13	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	113	14	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	113	15	low.29	low.29	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	113	16	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	113	17	joseph	joseph	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	113	18	sanders	sanders	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	113	19	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	113	20	observed	observe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	113	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	113	22	mesotheliomas	mesotheliomas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	113	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	113	24	individuals	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	113	25	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	113	26	experienced	experience	VERB
inlawrev-20850	113	27	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	113	28	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	113	29	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	113	30	constitute	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	113	31	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	113	32	increasing	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	113	33	proportion	proportion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	113	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	113	35	newly	newly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	113	36	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	113	37	diagnosed	diagnose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	113	38	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	113	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	113	40	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	113	41	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	113	42	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	113	43	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	113	44	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	113	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	113	46	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	113	47	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	113	48	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	113	49	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	113	50	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	113	51	increasing	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	113	52	proportion	proportion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	113	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	113	54	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	113	55	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	113	56	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	113	57	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	114	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	114	2	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	114	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	114	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	114	5	is30	is30	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	114	6	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	114	7	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	114	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	114	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	114	10	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	114	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	114	12	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	114	13	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	114	14	declined	decline	VERB
inlawrev-20850	114	15	dramatically	dramatically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	114	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	114	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	114	18	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	114	19	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	114	20	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	114	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	114	22	1970s	1970	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	114	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	115	1	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	115	2	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	115	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	115	4	heaviest	heavy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	115	5	occupational	occupational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	115	6	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	115	7	occurred31	occurred31	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	115	8	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	115	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	115	10	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	115	11	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	115	12	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	115	13	worker	worker	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	115	14	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	115	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	115	16	manufacturing	manufacturing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	115	17	facility	facility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	115	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	115	19	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	115	20	shown	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	115	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	115	22	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	115	23	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	115	24	her	her	PRON
inlawrev-20850	115	25	total	total	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	115	26	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	115	27	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	115	28	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	115	29	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-20850	115	30	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	115	31	above	above	ADP
inlawrev-20850	115	32	ambient	ambient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	115	33	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	115	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	115	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	116	1	23	23	NUM
inlawrev-20850	116	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	117	1	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	117	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	117	3	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	117	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	117	5	320	320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	117	6	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	117	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	117	8	590	590	NUM
inlawrev-20850	117	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	117	10	91	91	NUM
inlawrev-20850	117	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	118	1	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	118	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	118	3	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	118	4	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	118	5	verdict	verdict	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	118	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	118	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	118	8	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	118	9	judge	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	118	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	118	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	118	12	reasons	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	118	13	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	118	14	explained	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	118	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	118	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	118	17	appellate	appellate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	118	18	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	118	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	118	20	ordered	order	VERB
inlawrev-20850	118	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	118	22	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	118	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	118	24	agree	agree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	118	25	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	118	26	remit	remit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	118	27	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	118	28	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	118	29	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	118	30	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	118	31	elect	elect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	118	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	118	33	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	118	34	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	118	35	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	118	36	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	118	37	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	118	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	119	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	119	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	119	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	119	4	plaintiffs	plaintiffs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	119	5	chose	choose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	119	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	119	7	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	119	8	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	119	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	119	10	prevailed	prevail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	119	11	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-20850	119	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	120	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	120	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	120	3	24	24	NUM
inlawrev-20850	120	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	121	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	121	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	121	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	121	4	591	591	NUM
inlawrev-20850	121	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	122	1	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	122	2	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	122	3	above	above	ADV
inlawrev-20850	122	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	122	5	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	122	6	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	122	7	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	122	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	122	9	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	122	10	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	122	11	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	122	12	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	122	13	summer	summer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	122	14	employment	employment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	122	15	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	122	16	knox	knox	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	122	17	glass	glass	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	122	18	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	122	19	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	122	20	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	122	21	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	122	22	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	122	23	carried	carry	VERB
inlawrev-20850	122	24	home	home	ADV
inlawrev-20850	122	25	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	122	26	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	122	27	father	father	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	122	28	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	122	29	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	122	30	clothes	clothe	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	122	31	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	122	32	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	122	33	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	122	34	father	father	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	122	35	worked	work	VERB
inlawrev-20850	122	36	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	122	37	knox	knox	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	122	38	glass	glass	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	122	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	123	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	123	2	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	123	3	text	text	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	123	4	accompanying	accompanying	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	123	5	notes	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	123	6	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-20850	123	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	123	8	22	22	NUM
inlawrev-20850	123	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	124	1	25	25	NUM
inlawrev-20850	124	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	124	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	124	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	124	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	124	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	124	7	320	320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	124	8	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	124	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	124	10	591	591	NUM
inlawrev-20850	124	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	125	1	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	125	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	126	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	126	2	infra	infra	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	126	3	part	part	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	126	4	ii	ii	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	126	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	126	6	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	126	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	127	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	127	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	127	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	127	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	127	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	127	6	536	536	NUM
inlawrev-20850	127	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	127	8	affirming	affirm	VERB
inlawrev-20850	127	9	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	127	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	127	11	appeals	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	127	12	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	127	13	rendered	render	VERB
inlawrev-20850	127	14	take	take	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	127	15	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	127	16	nothing	nothing	PRON
inlawrev-20850	127	17	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	127	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	127	19	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	127	20	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	127	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	127	22	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	127	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	127	24	320	320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	127	25	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	127	26	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	127	27	590	590	NUM
inlawrev-20850	127	28	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	127	29	reversing	reverse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	127	30	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	127	31	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	127	32	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	127	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	127	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	128	1	28	28	NUM
inlawrev-20850	128	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	129	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	129	2	instances	instance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	129	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	129	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	129	5	description	description	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	129	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	129	7	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	129	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	129	9	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	129	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	129	11	acands	acands	AUX
inlawrev-20850	129	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	129	13	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	129	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	130	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	130	2	asner	asner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	130	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	130	4	657	657	NUM
inlawrev-20850	130	5	a.2d	a.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	130	6	379	379	NUM
inlawrev-20850	130	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	130	8	384	384	NUM
inlawrev-20850	130	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	130	10	md	md	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	130	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	131	1	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	131	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	131	3	spec	spec	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	131	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	132	1	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	132	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	132	3	1995	1995	NUM
inlawrev-20850	132	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	133	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	133	2	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	133	3	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	133	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	133	5	coworker	coworker	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	133	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	133	7	electrician	electrician	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	133	8	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	133	9	worked	work	VERB
inlawrev-20850	133	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	133	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	133	12	shipyard	shipyard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	133	13	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	133	14	world	world	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	133	15	war	war	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	133	16	ii	ii	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	133	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	133	18	died	die	VERB
inlawrev-20850	133	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	133	20	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	133	21	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	133	22	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	133	23	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	133	24	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	133	25	always	always	ADV
inlawrev-20850	133	26	coming	come	VERB
inlawrev-20850	133	27	down	down	ADP
inlawrev-20850	133	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	134	2	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	134	3	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-20850	134	4	snow	snow	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	134	5	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	8	rev’d	rev’d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	134	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	10	686	686	NUM
inlawrev-20850	134	11	a.2d	a.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	134	12	250	250	NUM
inlawrev-20850	134	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	14	md	md	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	134	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	134	16	1996	1996	NUM
inlawrev-20850	134	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	18	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	19	peek	peek	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	134	20	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	134	21	skw	skw	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	134	22	/	/	SYM
inlawrev-20850	134	23	clinton	clinton	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	134	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	25	855	855	NUM
inlawrev-20850	134	26	p.2d	p.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	134	27	415	415	NUM
inlawrev-20850	134	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	29	419	419	NUM
inlawrev-20850	134	30	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	31	alaska	alaska	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	134	32	1993	1993	NUM
inlawrev-20850	134	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	34	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	35	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	134	36	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	134	37	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	134	38	coworkers	coworker	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	134	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	134	40	pipefitter	pipefitter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	134	41	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	134	42	died	die	VERB
inlawrev-20850	134	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	134	44	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	134	45	testified	testify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	134	46	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	134	47	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	48	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	134	49	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	134	50	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	51	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-20850	134	52	snow	snow	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	134	53	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	54	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	134	55	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	134	56	air	air	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	134	57	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	134	58	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	134	59	jobs	job	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	134	60	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	61	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	62	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	63	wagner	wagner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	134	64	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	134	65	bondex	bondex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	134	66	int’l	int’l	NUM
inlawrev-20850	134	67	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	68	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	134	69	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	134	70	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	71	368	368	NUM
inlawrev-20850	134	72	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	134	73	340	340	NUM
inlawrev-20850	134	74	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	75	354	354	NUM
inlawrev-20850	134	76	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	134	77	mo	mo	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	134	78	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	135	1	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	135	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	136	1	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	136	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	136	3	2012	2012	NUM
inlawrev-20850	136	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	136	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	136	6	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	136	7	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	136	9	carpenter	carpenter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	10	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	136	11	cut	cut	VERB
inlawrev-20850	136	12	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	136	14	ceiling	ceiling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	15	tile	tile	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	16	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	136	17	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	136	18	regularly	regularly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	136	19	subjected	subject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	136	20	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	136	21	clouds	cloud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	136	23	bondex	bondex	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	24	joint	joint	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	25	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	26	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	27	dust	dust	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	28	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	136	29	fell	fall	VERB
inlawrev-20850	136	30	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-20850	136	31	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	136	32	snow	snow	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	33	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	136	34	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-20850	136	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	136	36	period	period	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	136	38	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	136	39	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	136	40	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	136	41	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	136	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	137	1	29	29	NUM
inlawrev-20850	137	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	137	3	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	137	4	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	137	5	bostic	bostic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	137	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	137	7	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	137	8	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	137	9	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	137	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	137	11	30	30	NUM
inlawrev-20850	137	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	138	1	sanders	sander	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	138	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	138	3	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	138	4	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	138	5	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	138	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	138	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	138	8	1182	1182	NUM
inlawrev-20850	138	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	138	10	83	83	NUM
inlawrev-20850	138	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	138	12	31	31	NUM
inlawrev-20850	138	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	139	1	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	139	2	jane	jane	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	139	3	henley	henley	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	139	4	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	140	1	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	140	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	140	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	140	4	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	140	5	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	140	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	140	7	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	140	8	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	140	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	140	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	140	11	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	140	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	140	13	columbia	columbia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	140	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	140	15	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	140	16	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	140	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	140	18	2003	2003	NUM
inlawrev-20850	140	19	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	140	20	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-20850	140	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	140	22	19	19	NUM
inlawrev-20850	140	23	int’l	int’l	NUM
inlawrev-20850	140	24	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	140	25	occupational	occupational	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	140	26	envtl	envtl	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	140	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	141	1	health	health	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	141	2	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	141	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	141	4	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	141	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	141	6	2013	2013	NUM
inlawrev-20850	141	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	141	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	141	9	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	141	10	decline	decline	VERB
inlawrev-20850	141	11	http://dx.doi.org/10.1179/2049396712y.0000000016	http://dx.doi.org/10.1179/2049396712y.0000000016	PRON
inlawrev-20850	141	12	122	122	NUM
inlawrev-20850	141	13	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	141	14	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	141	15	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	142	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	142	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	142	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	143	1	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	143	2	decades	decade	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	143	3	ago	ago	ADV
inlawrev-20850	143	4	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	143	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	143	6	cohort	cohort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	143	7	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	143	8	experienced	experience	VERB
inlawrev-20850	143	9	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	143	10	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	143	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	143	12	dwindling	dwindle	VERB
inlawrev-20850	143	13	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	143	14	age	age	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	143	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	143	16	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	143	17	take	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	143	18	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	143	19	toll	toll	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	143	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	144	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	144	2	lower	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	144	3	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	144	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	144	5	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	144	6	often	often	ADV
inlawrev-20850	144	7	seen	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	144	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	144	9	more3	more3	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	144	10	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	144	11	recent	recent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	144	12	decades	decade	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	144	13	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	144	14	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	144	15	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	144	16	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	144	17	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	144	18	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	144	19	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	144	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	144	21	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	144	22	take	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	144	23	longer33	longer33	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	144	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	144	25	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	144	26	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	144	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	145	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	145	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	145	3	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	145	4	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	145	5	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	145	6	expect	expect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	145	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	145	8	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	145	9	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	145	10	go	go	VERB
inlawrev-20850	145	11	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	145	12	individuals34	individuals34	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	145	13	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	145	14	lesser	less	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	145	15	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	145	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	145	17	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	145	18	dust	dust	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	145	19	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	145	20	comprise	comprise	VERB
inlawrev-20850	145	21	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	145	22	increasingly	increasingly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	145	23	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	145	24	percentage	percentage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	145	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	145	26	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	145	27	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	145	28	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	145	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	146	1	”35	”35	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	2	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	146	3	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	146	4	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	146	5	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	146	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	146	7	overall	overall	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	146	8	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	146	10	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	11	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	146	12	modest	modest	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	146	13	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	146	14	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	146	15	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	146	17	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	18	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	146	19	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	146	20	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	146	21	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	146	22	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	146	23	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	24	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	146	25	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	146	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	146	27	fraction	fraction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	146	29	that.36	that.36	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	30	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	146	31	presented	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	146	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	146	33	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	34	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	146	35	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	146	36	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	146	37	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	146	38	specifically	specifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	146	39	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	146	40	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	41	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	146	42	georgiapacific	georgiapacific	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	43	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	146	44	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	146	45	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	46	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	146	47	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	146	48	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	146	49	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	146	50	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	146	51	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	146	52	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	146	54	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	146	55	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	146	56	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	57	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	146	58	considering	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	146	59	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	146	60	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	146	61	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	146	62	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	146	63	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	146	64	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	146	65	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	146	66	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	67	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	146	68	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	146	69	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	147	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	147	2	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	147	3	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	147	4	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	147	5	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	147	6	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	147	7	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	147	8	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	147	9	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	147	10	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	147	11	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	147	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	148	1	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	148	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	148	3	contrary	contrary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	148	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	148	5	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	148	6	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	148	7	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	148	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	148	9	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	148	10	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	148	11	sold	sell	VERB
inlawrev-20850	148	12	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	148	13	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	148	14	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	148	15	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	148	16	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	148	17	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	148	18	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	148	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	148	20	norm	norm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	148	21	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	148	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	148	23	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	148	24	successful	successful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	148	25	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	148	26	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	148	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	149	1	nor37	nor37	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	149	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	149	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	149	4	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	149	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	149	6	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	149	7	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	149	8	limited	limit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	149	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	149	10	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	149	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	149	12	modest	modest	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	149	13	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	149	14	occasional	occasional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	149	15	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	149	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	150	2	early	early	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	150	3	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	4	brought	bring	VERB
inlawrev-20850	150	5	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	150	6	heavily	heavily	ADV
inlawrev-20850	150	7	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	150	8	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	10	most	most	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	150	11	courts38	courts38	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	150	13	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	150	15	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	17	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	18	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	150	19	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	150	20	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	150	21	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-20850	150	22	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	23	explaining	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	150	24	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	150	25	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	26	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	27	correlates	correlate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	150	28	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	150	29	degree	degree	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	150	31	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	32	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	33	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	150	34	cross	cross	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	150	35	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	150	36	country	country	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	150	37	comparisons	comparison	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	38	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	39	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	40	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	150	41	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	150	42	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	150	43	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	150	44	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	150	45	bans	ban	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	46	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	150	47	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	48	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	49	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	150	50	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	150	51	epa	epa	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	150	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	53	www2.epa.gov/asbestos/us-federal-bans-asbestos	www2.epa.gov/asbestos/us-federal-bans-asbesto	VERB
inlawrev-20850	150	54	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	150	55	http://perma.cc/7n62-8zvb	http://perma.cc/7n62-8zvb	X
inlawrev-20850	150	56	]	]	X
inlawrev-20850	150	57	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	58	last	last	ADV
inlawrev-20850	150	59	visited	visit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	150	60	mar	mar	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	150	61	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	150	62	31	31	NUM
inlawrev-20850	150	63	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	64	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	150	65	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	66	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	67	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	150	68	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	150	69	statutory	statutory	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	150	70	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	150	71	regulatory	regulatory	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	150	72	prohibitions	prohibition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	73	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	150	74	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	150	75	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	76	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	150	77	dating	date	VERB
inlawrev-20850	150	78	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	150	79	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	150	80	early	early	ADV
inlawrev-20850	150	81	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	150	82	1973	1973	NUM
inlawrev-20850	150	83	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	150	84	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	151	1	32	32	NUM
inlawrev-20850	151	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	151	3	henley	henley	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	151	4	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	151	5	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	151	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	151	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	151	8	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	151	9	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	151	10	31	31	NUM
inlawrev-20850	151	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	151	12	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	151	13	6	6	NUM
inlawrev-20850	151	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	151	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	151	16	us	us	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	151	17	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	151	18	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	151	19	rates	rate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	151	20	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	151	21	highest	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	151	22	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	151	23	older	old	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	151	24	men	man	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	151	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	151	26	women	woman	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	151	27	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	151	28	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	151	29	probably	probably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	151	30	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	151	31	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	151	32	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	151	33	before	before	ADV
inlawrev-20850	151	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	151	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	151	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	1	efforts	effort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	152	2	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	152	3	undertaken	undertake	VERB
inlawrev-20850	152	4	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	152	5	limit	limit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	152	6	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	152	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	8	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	10	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	11	sanders	sander	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	152	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	13	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	152	14	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	152	15	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	152	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	17	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	152	18	1182	1182	NUM
inlawrev-20850	152	19	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	152	20	83	83	NUM
inlawrev-20850	152	21	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	22	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	152	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	152	24	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	152	25	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	152	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	27	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	152	28	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	152	29	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	30	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	152	31	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	152	32	navy	navy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	152	33	shipyards	shipyard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	152	34	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	152	35	world	world	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	152	36	war	war	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	152	37	ii	ii	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	152	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	39	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	152	40	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	152	41	long	long	ADV
inlawrev-20850	152	42	ago	ago	ADV
inlawrev-20850	152	43	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	152	44	most	most	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	152	45	people	people	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	152	46	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	152	47	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	152	48	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	152	49	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	152	50	deceased	deceased	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	152	51	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	52	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	53	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	152	54	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	152	55	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	152	56	workers	worker	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	152	57	now	now	ADV
inlawrev-20850	152	58	becoming	become	VERB
inlawrev-20850	152	59	ill	ill	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	152	60	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	152	61	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	152	62	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	152	63	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	152	64	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	152	65	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	152	66	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	67	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	152	68	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	152	69	few	few	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	152	70	nonbankrupt	nonbankrupt	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	152	71	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	152	72	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	152	73	sue	sue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	152	74	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	75	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	152	76	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	153	1	33	33	NUM
inlawrev-20850	153	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	154	1	sanders	sander	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	154	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	154	3	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	154	4	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	154	5	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	154	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	154	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	154	8	1157	1157	NUM
inlawrev-20850	154	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	154	10	58	58	NUM
inlawrev-20850	154	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	154	12	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	154	13	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	154	14	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	154	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	154	16	cumulative	cumulative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	154	17	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	154	18	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	154	19	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	154	20	prolonged	prolonged	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	154	21	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	154	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	154	23	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	154	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	154	25	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	154	26	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	154	27	severe	severe	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	154	28	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	154	29	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	154	30	total	total	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	154	31	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	154	32	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	154	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	155	1	34	34	NUM
inlawrev-20850	155	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	155	3	a.	a.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	155	4	reid	reid	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	155	5	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	155	6	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	155	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	155	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	155	9	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	155	10	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	155	11	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	155	12	40	40	NUM
inlawrev-20850	155	13	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	155	14	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	155	15	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	155	16	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	155	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	155	18	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	155	19	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	155	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	155	21	pooled	pooled	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	155	22	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	155	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	155	24	69	69	NUM
inlawrev-20850	155	25	thorax	thorax	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	155	26	843	843	NUM
inlawrev-20850	155	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	155	28	848	848	NUM
inlawrev-20850	155	29	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	155	30	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	155	31	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	155	32	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	155	33	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	155	34	lower	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	155	35	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	155	36	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	155	37	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	155	38	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	155	39	shown	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	155	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	155	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	155	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	156	1	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	156	2	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	156	3	associated	associate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	156	4	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	156	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	156	6	longer	long	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	156	7	latency	latency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	156	8	period	period	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	156	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	156	10	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	157	1	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	157	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	158	1	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-20850	158	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	159	1	sanders	sander	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	159	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	159	3	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	159	4	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	159	5	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	159	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	159	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	159	8	1155	1155	NUM
inlawrev-20850	159	9	n.16	n.16	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	159	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	159	11	explaining	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	159	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	159	13	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	159	14	expectation	expectation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	159	15	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	159	16	hold	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	159	17	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	159	18	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	159	19	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	159	20	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	159	21	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	159	22	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	159	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	159	24	cease	cease	VERB
inlawrev-20850	159	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	159	26	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	159	27	the	the	PRON
inlawrev-20850	159	28	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	159	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	159	30	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	159	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	159	32	the	the	PRON
inlawrev-20850	159	33	shorter	short	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	159	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	159	35	latency	latency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	159	36	period	period	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	159	37	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	159	38	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	159	39	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	159	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	160	1	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	160	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	160	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	160	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	160	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	160	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	160	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	161	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	161	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	161	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	161	4	320	320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	161	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	161	6	588	588	NUM
inlawrev-20850	161	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	161	8	598	598	NUM
inlawrev-20850	161	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	161	10	602	602	NUM
inlawrev-20850	161	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	161	12	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	161	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	161	14	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	161	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	161	16	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	161	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	161	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	161	19	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	161	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	161	21	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	161	22	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	161	23	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	161	24	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	161	25	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	161	26	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	161	27	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	161	28	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	161	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	162	1	37	37	NUM
inlawrev-20850	162	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	163	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	163	2	borel	borel	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	163	3	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	163	4	fibreboard	fibreboard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	163	5	paper	paper	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	163	6	prods	prod	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	163	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	1	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	164	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	164	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	4	493	493	NUM
inlawrev-20850	164	5	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	6	1076	1076	NUM
inlawrev-20850	164	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	8	1086	1086	NUM
inlawrev-20850	164	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	10	1094	1094	NUM
inlawrev-20850	164	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	12	5th	5th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	164	13	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	164	15	1973	1973	NUM
inlawrev-20850	164	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	18	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	20	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	164	21	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	22	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	164	23	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	164	25	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	26	alleged	allege	VERB
inlawrev-20850	164	27	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	28	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	164	29	eleven	eleven	NUM
inlawrev-20850	164	30	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	31	’	’	PART
inlawrev-20850	164	32	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	33	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	35	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	164	36	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	164	37	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	38	showed	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	164	39	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	164	40	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	41	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	164	42	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	164	43	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	164	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	164	45	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	46	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	164	47	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	48	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	164	50	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	51	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	164	52	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	164	53	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	164	54	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	164	55	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	56	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	164	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	164	58	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	59	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	164	60	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	61	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	164	62	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	164	63	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	64	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	164	65	borel	borel	VERB
inlawrev-20850	164	66	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	67	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	164	68	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	69	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	164	70	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	164	71	impossible	impossible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	164	72	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	73	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	164	74	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	164	75	practical	practical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	164	76	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	77	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	78	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	164	79	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	164	80	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	164	81	absolute	absolute	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	164	82	certainty	certainty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	83	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	164	84	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	164	85	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	86	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	164	87	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	88	dust	dust	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	89	resulted	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	164	90	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	164	91	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	164	92	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	93	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	164	94	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	165	1	38	38	NUM
inlawrev-20850	165	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	166	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	166	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	166	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	166	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	166	5	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	166	6	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	166	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	166	8	1081	1081	NUM
inlawrev-20850	166	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	166	10	plaintiff	plaintiff	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	166	11	borel	borel	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	166	12	worked	work	VERB
inlawrev-20850	166	13	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	166	14	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	166	15	industrial	industrial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	166	16	insulation	insulation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	166	17	worker	worker	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	166	18	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	166	19	thirtythree	thirtythree	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	166	20	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	166	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	166	22	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	166	23	lohrmann	lohrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	166	24	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	166	25	pittsburgh	pittsburgh	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	166	26	corning	corning	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	166	27	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	166	28	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	166	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	166	30	782	782	NUM
inlawrev-20850	166	31	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	166	32	1156	1156	NUM
inlawrev-20850	166	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	166	34	1158	1158	NUM
inlawrev-20850	166	35	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	166	36	4th	4th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	166	37	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	166	38	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	166	39	1986	1986	NUM
inlawrev-20850	166	40	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	167	1	http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/thoraxjnl-2013-204161	http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/thoraxjnl-2013-204161	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	167	2	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	167	3	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	167	4	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	167	5	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	167	6	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	167	7	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	167	8	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	167	9	123	123	NUM
inlawrev-20850	167	10	declined	decline	VERB
inlawrev-20850	167	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	167	12	preclude	preclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	167	13	recovery	recovery	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	167	14	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-20850	167	15	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	167	16	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	167	17	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	167	18	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	167	19	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	167	20	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	167	21	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	167	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	167	23	harmful	harmful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	167	24	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	167	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	167	26	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	167	27	though	though	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	167	28	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	167	29	method	method	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	167	30	exists	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	167	31	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	167	32	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	167	33	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	167	34	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	167	35	initiated	initiate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	167	36	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	167	37	promoted	promote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	167	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	167	39	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	167	40	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	167	41	whence	whence	ADP
inlawrev-20850	167	42	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	167	43	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	167	44	came	come	VERB
inlawrev-20850	167	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	168	1	instead	instead	ADV
inlawrev-20850	168	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	168	3	in39	in39	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	168	4	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	168	5	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	168	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	168	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	168	8	rock	rock	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	168	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	168	10	uncertainty	uncertainty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	168	11	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	168	12	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	168	13	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	168	14	presented	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	168	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	168	16	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	168	17	fashioned	fashion	VERB
inlawrev-20850	168	18	a40	a40	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	168	19	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	168	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	168	21	doctrinal	doctrinal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	168	22	mechanisms	mechanism	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	168	23	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	168	24	allowed	allow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	168	25	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	168	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	168	27	recover	recover	VERB
inlawrev-20850	168	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	168	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	168	30	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	168	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	168	32	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-20850	168	33	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	168	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	168	35	increasingly	increasingly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	168	36	permitted	permit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	168	37	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	168	38	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	168	39	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-20850	168	40	distinctions	distinction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	168	41	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	168	42	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	168	43	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	168	44	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	168	45	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	168	46	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	168	47	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	168	48	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	168	49	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	168	50	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	168	51	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	168	52	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	168	53	deemed	deem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	168	54	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	168	55	causal	causal	ADV
inlawrev-20850	168	56	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	169	1	”41	”41	VERB
inlawrev-20850	169	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	169	3	recent	recent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	169	4	prevalence	prevalence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	169	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	169	6	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	169	7	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	169	8	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	169	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	169	10	coincidence	coincidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	169	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	169	12	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	169	13	overall	overall	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	169	14	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	169	15	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	169	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	169	17	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	169	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	169	19	individually	individually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	169	20	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	169	21	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	169	22	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	169	23	put	put	VERB
inlawrev-20850	169	24	pressure	pressure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	169	25	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	169	26	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	169	27	doctrinal	doctrinal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	169	28	mechanisms	mechanism	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	169	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	169	30	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	169	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	170	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	170	2	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	170	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	170	4	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	170	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	170	6	including	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	170	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	170	8	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	170	9	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	170	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	170	11	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	170	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	170	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	170	14	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-20850	170	15	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	170	16	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	170	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	170	18	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	170	19	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	170	20	plaintiffs’42	plaintiffs’42	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	170	21	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	170	22	theories	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	170	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	170	24	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	170	25	involving	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	170	26	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	170	27	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	170	28	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	170	29	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	170	30	defendantspecific	defendantspecific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	170	31	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	170	32	aggregate	aggregate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	170	33	amounts	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	170	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	170	35	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	170	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	171	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	171	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	171	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	171	4	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	171	5	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	171	6	of43	of43	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	171	7	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	171	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	171	9	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	171	10	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	171	11	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	171	12	trend	trend	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	171	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	171	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	171	15	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	171	16	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	171	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	171	18	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	171	19	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	171	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	171	21	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	171	22	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	171	23	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	171	24	doctrinal	doctrinal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	171	25	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	171	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	172	1	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	172	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	172	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	172	4	my	my	PRON
inlawrev-20850	172	5	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	172	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	172	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	172	8	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	172	9	overall	overall	ADV
inlawrev-20850	172	10	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	172	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	172	12	better	well	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	172	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	172	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	172	15	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	172	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	172	17	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	172	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	172	19	my	my	PRON
inlawrev-20850	172	20	critique	critique	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	172	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	172	22	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	172	23	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	172	24	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	172	25	depend	depend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	172	26	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	172	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	172	28	belief	belief	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	172	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	172	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	172	31	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	172	32	reached	reach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	172	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	172	34	wrong	wrong	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	172	35	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	172	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	173	1	nor	nor	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	173	2	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	173	3	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	173	4	depend	depend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	173	5	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	173	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	173	7	belief	belief	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	173	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	173	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	173	10	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	173	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	173	12	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	173	13	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	173	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	173	15	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	173	16	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	173	17	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	173	18	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	173	19	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	173	20	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	173	21	occupational	occupational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	173	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	173	23	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	173	24	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	173	25	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	173	26	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	173	27	succeed	succeed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	173	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	174	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	174	3	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	174	4	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	174	5	believe	believe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	174	7	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	174	8	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	174	9	better	well	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	174	10	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	174	11	protect	protect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	12	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	13	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	174	14	supplied	supply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	15	consumer	consumer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	16	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	17	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	18	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	19	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	20	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	21	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	174	22	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	174	23	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	174	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	174	25	compensate	compensate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	26	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	27	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	174	28	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	29	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	30	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	174	32	developed	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	33	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	34	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	35	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	174	36	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	174	37	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	174	38	believe	believe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	39	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	174	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	41	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	42	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	174	43	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	44	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	45	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	174	46	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	174	47	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	48	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	49	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	174	50	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	51	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	52	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	53	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	54	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	55	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	174	56	worked	work	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	57	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	58	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	59	pipefitter	pipefitter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	60	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	61	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	62	shipyard	shipyard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	63	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	64	thirty	thirty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	174	65	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	66	nine	nine	NUM
inlawrev-20850	174	67	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	68	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	69	followed	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	70	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	71	usual	usual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	174	72	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	73	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	74	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	75	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	76	attempting	attempt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	77	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	174	78	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	79	contact	contact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	80	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	81	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	82	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	83	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	84	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	85	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	86	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	87	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	174	88	seven	seven	NUM
inlawrev-20850	174	89	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	90	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	91	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	92	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	174	93	went	go	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	94	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	95	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	96	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	97	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	98	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	174	99	nineteen	nineteen	NUM
inlawrev-20850	174	100	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	101	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	102	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	103	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	174	104	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	174	105	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	106	1162	1162	NUM
inlawrev-20850	174	107	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	174	108	63	63	NUM
inlawrev-20850	174	109	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	110	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	111	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	112	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	113	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	114	typical	typical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	174	115	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	116	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	117	pattern	pattern	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	118	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	119	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	174	120	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	121	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	174	122	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	123	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	174	124	t]o	t]o	AUX
inlawrev-20850	174	125	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	126	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	127	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	128	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	129	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	174	130	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	131	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	132	circumstantial	circumstantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	174	133	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	134	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	135	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	174	136	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	174	137	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	174	138	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	139	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	140	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	141	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	142	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	143	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	174	144	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	145	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	146	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	147	regular	regular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	174	148	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	149	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	150	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	151	extended	extended	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	174	152	period	period	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	153	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	154	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	155	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	156	proximity	proximity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	157	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	158	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	174	159	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	160	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	161	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	174	162	worked	work	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	163	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	164	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	165	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	166	rutherford	rutherford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	174	167	v.	v.	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	174	168	owens	owens	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	174	169	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	170	illinois	illinois	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	174	171	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	172	941	941	NUM
inlawrev-20850	174	173	p.2d	p.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	174	174	1203	1203	NUM
inlawrev-20850	174	175	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	176	1207	1207	NUM
inlawrev-20850	174	177	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	174	178	08	08	NUM
inlawrev-20850	174	179	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	180	cal	cal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	174	181	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	182	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	174	183	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	184	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	185	explaining	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	186	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	174	187	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	188	diagnosed	diagnose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	189	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	190	lung	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	191	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	192	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	193	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	174	194	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	195	forty	forty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	174	196	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	197	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	198	occupational	occupational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	174	199	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	200	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	174	201	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	202	sued	sue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	174	203	nineteen	nineteen	NUM
inlawrev-20850	174	204	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	174	205	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	174	206	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	175	1	39	39	NUM
inlawrev-20850	175	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	176	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	176	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	176	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	176	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	176	5	borel	borel	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	176	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	176	7	493	493	NUM
inlawrev-20850	176	8	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	176	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	176	10	1096	1096	NUM
inlawrev-20850	176	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	176	12	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	176	13	manufacturers	manufacturer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	176	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	176	15	insulation	insulation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	176	16	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	176	17	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	176	18	jointly	jointly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	176	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	176	20	severally	severally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	176	21	liable	liable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	176	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	176	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	177	1	40	40	NUM
inlawrev-20850	177	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	178	1	sienkiewicz	sienkiewicz	VERB
inlawrev-20850	178	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	178	3	greif	greif	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	178	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	178	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	178	6	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	178	7	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	178	8	uksc	uksc	VERB
inlawrev-20850	178	9	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	179	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	179	2	7	7	NUM
inlawrev-20850	179	3	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	179	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	179	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	179	6	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	179	7	]	]	SYM
inlawrev-20850	179	8	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	179	9	a.c	a.c	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	179	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	179	11	229	229	NUM
inlawrev-20850	179	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	179	13	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	179	14	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	179	15	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	179	16	eng	eng	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	179	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	179	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	180	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	180	2	lord	lord	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	180	3	bingham	bingham	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	180	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	180	5	cornhill	cornhill	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	180	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	180	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	181	1	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-20850	181	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	182	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	182	3	sanders	sander	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	5	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	6	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	7	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	182	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	182	10	1161	1161	NUM
inlawrev-20850	182	11	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	182	12	66	66	NUM
inlawrev-20850	182	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	14	tracing	trace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	182	15	developments	development	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	16	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	182	17	borel	borel	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	18	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	182	19	individisible	individisible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	182	20	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	21	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	23	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	182	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	182	26	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	27	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	182	28	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	29	approach	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	182	31	lohrmann	lohrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	32	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	182	33	frequency	frequency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	34	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	35	regularityproximity	regularityproximity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	36	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	37	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	182	38	rutherford	rutherford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	39	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	182	40	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	41	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	42	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	43	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	44	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	45	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	46	jane	jane	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	47	stapleton	stapleton	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	48	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	49	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	182	50	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	182	51	fictions	fiction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	52	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	182	53	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	182	54	heart	heart	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	55	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	182	56	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	57	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	58	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	59	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	60	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	61	122	122	NUM
inlawrev-20850	182	62	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	63	quarterly	quarterly	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	64	rev	rev	VERB
inlawrev-20850	182	65	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	66	189	189	NUM
inlawrev-20850	182	67	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	68	191	191	NUM
inlawrev-20850	182	69	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	70	2006	2006	NUM
inlawrev-20850	182	71	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	72	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	73	joseph	joseph	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	74	sanders	sanders	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	75	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	76	risky	risky	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	182	77	business	business	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	78	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	79	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	80	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	182	81	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	82	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	83	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	84	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	85	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	182	86	beyond	beyond	ADP
inlawrev-20850	182	87	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	88	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	89	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	90	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	182	91	perspectives	perspective	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	92	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	182	93	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	94	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	182	95	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	96	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-20850	182	97	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	182	98	30	30	NUM
inlawrev-20850	182	99	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	100	richard	richard	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	101	goldberg	goldberg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	102	ed	ed	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	103	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	104	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	105	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	182	106	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	107	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	108	tracing	trace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	182	109	lineage	lineage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	110	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	182	111	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	182	112	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	182	113	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	114	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	115	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	182	116	united	united	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	182	117	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	182	118	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	182	119	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	183	1	42	42	NUM
inlawrev-20850	183	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	184	1	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	184	2	v.	v.	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	184	3	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	184	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	184	5	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	184	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	184	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	184	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	184	9	232	232	NUM
inlawrev-20850	184	10	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	184	11	765	765	NUM
inlawrev-20850	184	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	184	13	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	184	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	184	15	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-20850	184	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	184	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	185	1	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-20850	185	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	186	1	sanders	sander	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	186	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	186	3	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	186	4	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	186	5	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	186	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	186	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	186	8	1176	1176	NUM
inlawrev-20850	186	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	186	10	82	82	NUM
inlawrev-20850	186	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	186	12	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	186	13	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	186	14	favoring	favor	VERB
inlawrev-20850	186	15	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	186	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	186	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	186	18	absence	absence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	186	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	186	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	186	21	unifying	unifying	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	186	22	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	186	23	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	186	24	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	186	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	186	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	187	1	124	124	NUM
inlawrev-20850	187	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	187	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	187	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	187	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	187	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	187	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	187	8	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	187	9	beyond	beyond	ADP
inlawrev-20850	187	10	salvation	salvation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	187	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	188	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	188	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	188	3	rests	rest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	188	4	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	188	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	188	6	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	188	7	preference	preference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	188	8	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	188	9	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	188	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	188	11	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	188	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	188	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	188	14	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	188	15	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	188	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	188	17	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	188	18	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-20850	188	19	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	188	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	188	21	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	188	22	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	188	23	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	188	24	for	for	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	188	25	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	188	26	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	188	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	188	28	end	end	VERB
inlawrev-20850	188	29	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	188	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	188	31	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	188	32	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	188	33	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	188	34	express	express	VERB
inlawrev-20850	188	35	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	188	36	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	188	37	openly	openly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	188	38	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	188	39	implemented	implement	VERB
inlawrev-20850	188	40	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	188	41	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	188	42	distorting	distort	VERB
inlawrev-20850	188	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	188	44	concept	concept	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	188	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	188	46	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	188	47	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	188	48	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	188	49	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	188	50	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	188	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	189	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	189	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	189	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	189	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	189	5	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	189	6	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	189	7	want	want	VERB
inlawrev-20850	189	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	189	9	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	189	10	such	such	DET
inlawrev-20850	189	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	189	12	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	189	13	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	189	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	189	15	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	189	16	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	189	17	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	189	18	fashion	fashion	VERB
inlawrev-20850	189	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	189	20	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	189	21	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	189	22	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	189	23	truly	truly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	189	24	balances	balance	VERB
inlawrev-20850	189	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	189	26	interest	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	189	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	189	28	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	189	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	189	30	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	189	31	being	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	189	32	liable	liable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	189	33	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	189	34	harms	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	189	35	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	189	36	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	189	37	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	189	38	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	189	39	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	189	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	189	41	interest	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	189	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	189	43	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	189	44	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	189	45	being	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	189	46	compensated	compensate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	189	47	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	189	48	wrongfully	wrongfully	ADV
inlawrev-20850	189	49	inflicted	inflict	VERB
inlawrev-20850	189	50	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	189	51	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	189	52	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	189	53	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	189	54	definitively	definitively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	189	55	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	189	56	linked	link	VERB
inlawrev-20850	189	57	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	189	58	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	189	59	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	189	60	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	189	61	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	190	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	190	2	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	190	3	approach	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	190	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	190	5	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	190	6	replicated	replicate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	190	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	190	8	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	190	9	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	190	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	190	11	extended	extend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	190	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	190	13	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	190	14	contexts	contexts	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	190	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	190	16	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	190	17	wreak	wreak	VERB
inlawrev-20850	190	18	havoc	havoc	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	190	19	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	190	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	190	21	logic	logic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	190	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	190	23	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	190	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	190	25	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	190	26	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	190	27	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	190	28	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	190	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	191	1	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	191	2	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	191	3	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	191	4	biological	biological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	191	5	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	191	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	191	7	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	191	8	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	191	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	192	1	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	192	2	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	192	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	192	4	causation.—the	causation.—the	DET
inlawrev-20850	192	5	familiar	familiar	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	192	6	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	192	7	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	192	8	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	192	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	192	10	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	192	11	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	192	12	asks	ask	VERB
inlawrev-20850	192	13	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	192	14	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	192	15	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	192	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	192	17	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	192	18	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	192	19	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	192	20	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	192	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	192	22	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	192	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	192	24	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	192	25	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	192	26	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	192	27	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	192	28	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	192	29	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	192	30	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	193	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	193	2	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	193	3	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	193	4	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	193	5	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	193	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	193	7	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	193	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	193	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	193	10	appears	appear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	193	11	sufficient,44	sufficient,44	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	193	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	193	13	bring	bring	VERB
inlawrev-20850	193	14	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	193	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	193	16	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	193	17	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	193	18	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	193	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	194	1	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	194	2	course	course	ADV
inlawrev-20850	194	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	194	4	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	194	5	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	194	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	194	7	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	194	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	194	9	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	194	10	obscures	obscure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	194	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	194	12	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	194	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	194	14	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	194	15	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	194	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	194	17	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	194	18	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	194	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	194	20	single	single	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	194	21	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	194	22	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	194	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	194	24	so	so	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	194	25	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	194	26	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	194	27	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	194	28	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	194	29	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	194	30	think	think	VERB
inlawrev-20850	194	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	194	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	194	33	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	194	34	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	194	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	194	36	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	194	37	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	194	38	together	together	ADV
inlawrev-20850	194	39	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	194	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	194	41	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	194	42	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	194	43	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	194	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	195	1	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	195	2	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	195	3	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	195	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	195	5	such	such	DET
inlawrev-20850	195	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	195	7	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	195	8	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	195	9	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	195	10	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	195	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	195	12	innumerable	innumerable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	195	13	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	195	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	195	15	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	195	16	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	195	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	195	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	195	19	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	195	20	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	195	21	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	195	22	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	195	23	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	195	24	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	195	25	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	195	26	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	195	27	contributing	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	195	28	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	195	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	195	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	195	31	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	195	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	196	1	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	196	2	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	196	3	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	196	4	concurring	concurring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	196	5	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	196	6	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	196	7	be45	be45	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	196	8	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	196	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	196	10	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	196	11	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	196	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	196	13	negligently	negligently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	196	14	prescribed	prescribe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	196	15	drug	drug	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	196	16	weakens	weaken	VERB
inlawrev-20850	196	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	196	18	patient	patient	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	196	19	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	196	20	immune	immune	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	196	21	system	system	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	196	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	196	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	196	24	patient	patient	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	196	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	196	26	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	196	27	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	196	28	otherwise	otherwise	ADV
inlawrev-20850	196	29	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	196	30	fought	fight	VERB
inlawrev-20850	196	31	off	off	ADP
inlawrev-20850	196	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	196	33	infection	infection	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	196	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	196	35	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	196	36	overcome	overcome	VERB
inlawrev-20850	196	37	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	196	38	consuming	consume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	196	39	food	food	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	196	40	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	196	41	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	196	42	contaminated	contaminate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	196	43	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	196	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	196	45	pathogen	pathogen	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	196	46	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	196	47	sold	sell	VERB
inlawrev-20850	196	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	197	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	197	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	197	3	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	197	4	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	197	5	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	197	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	197	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	197	8	concurring	concurring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	197	9	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	197	10	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	197	11	accepts	accept	VERB
inlawrev-20850	197	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	197	13	possibility	possibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	197	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	197	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	197	16	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	197	17	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	197	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	197	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	197	20	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	197	21	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	197	22	toxin	toxin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	197	23	combined	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	197	24	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	197	25	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	197	26	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	197	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	197	28	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	197	29	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	197	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	198	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	198	2	concurring	concurring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	3	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	4	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	5	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	198	6	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	198	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	198	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	198	9	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	198	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	198	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	198	13	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	14	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	198	15	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	198	16	susceptibility	susceptibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	198	18	dna	dna	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	198	19	damage	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	198	21	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	198	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	198	24	sun	sun	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	198	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	198	27	wrongful	wrongful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	198	28	dermal	dermal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	198	29	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	198	31	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	198	32	chemical	chemical	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	33	carcinogen	carcinogen	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	34	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	198	35	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	198	36	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	198	37	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	198	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	198	39	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	40	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	198	41	development	development	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	198	43	skin	skin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	44	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	198	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	199	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	199	2	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
inlawrev-20850	199	3	potential	potential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	199	4	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	199	5	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	199	6	mutually	mutually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	199	7	exclusive	exclusive	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	199	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	200	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	200	2	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	200	3	negligent	negligent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	200	4	hunters	hunter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	200	5	simultaneously	simultaneously	ADV
inlawrev-20850	200	6	fire	fire	VERB
inlawrev-20850	200	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	200	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	200	9	direction	direction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	200	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	200	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	200	12	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	200	13	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	200	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	200	15	struck	strike	VERB
inlawrev-20850	200	16	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	200	17	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	200	18	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	200	19	bullet	bullet	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	200	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	200	21	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	200	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	200	23	hunter	hunter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	200	24	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	200	25	fired	fire	VERB
inlawrev-20850	200	26	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	200	27	bullet	bullet	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	200	28	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	200	29	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	200	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	200	31	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	200	32	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	200	33	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	200	34	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	200	35	ballistics	ballistic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	200	36	testing	testing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	200	37	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	200	38	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	200	39	able	able	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	200	40	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	200	41	resolve	resolve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	200	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	200	43	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	200	44	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	200	45	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	200	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	201	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	201	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	201	3	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	201	4	torts	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	201	5	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	201	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	201	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	201	8	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	201	9	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	201	10	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	201	11	posits	posit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	201	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	201	13	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	201	14	of46	of46	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	201	15	44	44	NUM
inlawrev-20850	201	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	201	17	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	201	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	201	19	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	201	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	201	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	201	22	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	201	23	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	201	24	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	201	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	202	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	202	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	202	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	202	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	202	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	202	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	202	7	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	202	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	202	9	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	202	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	202	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	203	1	45	45	NUM
inlawrev-20850	203	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	204	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	204	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	204	3	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	204	4	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	204	5	cmt	cmt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	204	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	205	1	g.	g.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	205	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	205	3	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	205	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	205	5	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	205	6	consistent	consistent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	205	7	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	205	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	205	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	205	10	ness	ness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	205	11	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	205	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	205	13	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	205	14	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	205	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	205	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	205	17	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	205	18	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	205	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	205	20	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	205	21	developed	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	205	22	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	205	23	richard	richard	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	205	24	wright	wright	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	205	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	206	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	206	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	206	3	richard	richard	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	206	4	w.	w.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	206	5	wright	wright	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	206	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	206	7	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	206	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	206	9	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	206	10	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	206	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	206	12	73	73	NUM
inlawrev-20850	206	13	calif	calif	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	206	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	207	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	207	2	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	207	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	207	4	1735	1735	NUM
inlawrev-20850	207	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	207	6	1788	1788	NUM
inlawrev-20850	207	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	207	8	1803	1803	NUM
inlawrev-20850	207	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	207	10	1985	1985	NUM
inlawrev-20850	207	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	207	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	207	13	explaining	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	207	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	207	15	ness	ness	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	207	16	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	207	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	207	18	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	207	19	richard	richard	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	207	20	w.	w.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	207	21	wright	wright	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	207	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	207	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	207	24	ness	ness	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	207	25	account	account	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	207	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	207	27	natural	natural	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	207	28	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	207	29	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	207	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	207	31	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	207	32	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	207	33	criticisms	criticism	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	207	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	207	35	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	207	36	perspectives	perspective	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	207	37	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	207	38	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	207	39	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	207	40	richard	richard	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	207	41	goldberg	goldberg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	207	42	ed	ed	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	207	43	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	207	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	207	45	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	207	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	207	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	208	1	46	46	NUM
inlawrev-20850	208	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	209	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	209	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	209	3	bullet	bullet	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	209	4	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	209	5	source	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	209	6	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	209	7	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	209	8	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	209	9	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	209	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	209	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	209	12	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	209	13	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	209	14	use	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	209	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	209	16	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	209	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	209	18	alternative	alternative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	209	19	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	209	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	209	21	shift	shift	VERB
inlawrev-20850	209	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	209	23	burden	burden	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	209	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	209	25	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	209	26	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	209	27	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	209	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	210	1	summers	summer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	210	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	210	3	tice	tice	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	210	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	210	5	199	199	NUM
inlawrev-20850	210	6	p.2d	p.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	210	7	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	210	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	210	9	cal	cal	NUM
inlawrev-20850	210	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	210	11	1948	1948	NUM
inlawrev-20850	210	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	210	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	211	1	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	211	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	211	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	211	4	bullet	bullet	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	211	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	211	6	source	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	211	7	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	211	8	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	211	9	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	211	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	211	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	211	12	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	211	13	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	211	14	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	211	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	211	16	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	211	17	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	211	18	use	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	211	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	211	20	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	211	21	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	211	22	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	211	23	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	211	24	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	211	25	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	211	26	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	211	27	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	211	28	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	211	29	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	211	30	125	125	NUM
inlawrev-20850	211	31	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	211	32	potential	potential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	211	33	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	211	34	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	211	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	211	36	actual	actual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	211	37	sine	sine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	211	38	qua	qua	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	211	39	non	non	X
inlawrev-20850	211	40	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	211	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	211	42	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	211	43	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	211	44	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	211	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	212	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	212	2	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	212	3	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	4	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	5	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	212	6	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	212	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	212	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	212	9	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	212	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	212	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	212	13	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	14	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	212	15	development	development	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	212	17	skin	skin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	18	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	19	resulted	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	212	20	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	212	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	212	22	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	212	24	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	212	25	predisposition	predisposition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	26	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	212	27	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	28	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	212	29	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	212	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	212	32	sun	sun	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	33	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	212	34	wrongful	wrongful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	212	35	dermal	dermal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	36	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	37	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	212	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	212	39	chemical	chemical	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	40	carcinogen	carcinogen	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	212	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	213	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	213	2	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	213	3	times	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	213	4	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	213	5	causes	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	213	6	overdetermine	overdetermine	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	213	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	213	8	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	213	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	214	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	214	2	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	214	3	negligent	negligent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	214	4	hunters	hunter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	214	5	simultaneously	simultaneously	ADV
inlawrev-20850	214	6	fire	fire	VERB
inlawrev-20850	214	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	214	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	214	9	direction	direction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	214	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	214	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	214	12	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	214	13	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	214	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	214	15	struck	strike	VERB
inlawrev-20850	214	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	214	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	214	18	heart	heart	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	214	19	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	214	20	both	both	DET
inlawrev-20850	214	21	bullets	bullet	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	214	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	214	23	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	214	24	hunter	hunter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	214	25	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	214	26	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	214	27	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	214	28	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	214	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	214	30	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	214	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	214	32	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	214	33	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	214	34	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	214	35	brought	bring	VERB
inlawrev-20850	214	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	214	37	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	214	38	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	214	39	such	such	DET
inlawrev-20850	214	40	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	214	41	fateful	fateful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	214	42	pass	pass	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	214	43	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	214	44	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	214	45	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	214	46	independently	independently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	214	47	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	214	48	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	214	49	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	214	50	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	214	51	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	214	52	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	214	53	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	215	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	215	2	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	215	3	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	215	4	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	215	5	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	215	6	treats	treat	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	215	7	both	both	DET
inlawrev-20850	215	8	hunters	hunter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	215	9	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	215	10	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	215	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	215	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	215	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	215	14	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	215	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	215	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	215	17	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	215	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	216	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	216	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	216	3	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	216	4	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	216	5	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	216	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	216	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	216	8	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	216	9	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	216	10	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	216	11	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	216	12	posits	posit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	216	13	that47	that47	VERB
inlawrev-20850	216	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	216	15	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	216	16	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	216	17	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	216	18	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	216	19	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	216	20	resulted	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	216	21	independently	independently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	216	22	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	216	23	any	any	PRON
inlawrev-20850	216	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	216	25	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	216	26	potential	potential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	216	27	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	216	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	217	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	217	2	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	217	3	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	217	4	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	5	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	6	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	217	7	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	217	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	217	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	217	10	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	217	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	217	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	217	14	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	15	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	217	16	development	development	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	217	18	skin	skin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	19	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	20	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	217	21	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	217	22	resulted	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	217	23	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	217	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	217	25	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	26	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	217	27	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	217	28	predisposition	predisposition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	217	30	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	31	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	217	32	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	217	33	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	217	34	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	217	35	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	36	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	217	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	217	38	sun	sun	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	39	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	217	40	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	217	41	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	217	42	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	217	43	wrongful	wrongful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	217	44	dermal	dermal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	217	45	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	46	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	217	47	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	217	48	chemical	chemical	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	49	carcinogen	carcinogen	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	50	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	217	51	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	217	52	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	217	53	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	217	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	217	55	absence	absence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	56	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	217	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	217	58	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	217	59	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	217	60	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	217	61	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	218	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	218	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	218	3	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	218	4	skin	skin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	218	5	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	218	6	examples	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	218	7	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	218	8	above	above	ADV
inlawrev-20850	218	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	218	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	218	11	chemical	chemical	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	218	12	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	218	13	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	218	14	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	218	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	218	16	carcinogen	carcinogen	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	218	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	219	1	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	219	2	assumption	assumption	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	3	limits	limit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	219	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	219	5	above	above	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	219	6	examples	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	219	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	219	9	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	219	10	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	11	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	219	13	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	219	14	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	15	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	219	16	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	219	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	219	18	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	19	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	219	20	wrongful	wrongful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	219	21	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	219	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	219	24	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	219	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	219	27	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	219	28	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	29	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	219	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	219	31	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	219	32	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	219	34	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	35	afflicting	afflict	VERB
inlawrev-20850	219	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	219	37	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	219	39	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	219	40	light	light	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	219	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	219	43	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	44	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	219	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	219	46	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	219	47	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	48	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	219	49	occur	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	219	50	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	219	51	people	people	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	52	never	never	ADV
inlawrev-20850	219	53	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	219	54	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	219	55	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	219	56	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	219	57	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	220	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	220	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	220	3	carcinogenicity	carcinogenicity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	220	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	220	6	chemical	chemical	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	7	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	220	8	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	220	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	220	10	doubt	doubt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	220	12	the48	the48	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	13	examples	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	14	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	220	15	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	220	16	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	220	17	involved	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	220	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	220	19	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	220	21	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	220	22	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	23	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	220	24	agentdisease	agentdisease	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	220	25	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	26	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	220	27	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	220	28	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	220	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	220	31	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	32	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	220	33	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	34	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	220	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	220	36	biological	biological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	220	37	capacity	capacity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	38	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	220	39	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	220	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	220	41	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	42	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	220	43	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	44	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	220	45	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	220	46	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	220	47	coexistence	coexistence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	48	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	220	49	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	50	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	220	51	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	52	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	220	53	purely	purely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	220	54	coincidental.49	coincidental.49	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	220	55	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	220	56	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	220	57	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	220	58	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	220	59	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	220	60	skin	skin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	61	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	62	examples	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	63	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	220	64	above	above	ADV
inlawrev-20850	220	65	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	220	66	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	220	67	potential	potential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	220	68	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	69	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	220	70	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	220	71	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	72	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	220	73	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	220	74	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	220	75	qualitatively	qualitatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	220	76	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	220	77	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	221	1	genetics	genetic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	221	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	221	3	solar	solar	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	221	4	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	221	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	221	6	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	221	7	chemical	chemical	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	221	8	carcinogen	carcinogen	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	221	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	222	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	222	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	222	3	concurring	concurring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	222	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	222	5	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	222	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	222	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	222	8	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	222	9	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	222	10	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	222	11	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	222	12	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	222	13	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	222	14	potentially	potentially	ADV
inlawrev-20850	222	15	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	222	16	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	222	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	222	18	groups	group	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	222	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	222	20	potential	potential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	222	21	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	222	22	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	222	23	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	222	24	qualitatively	qualitatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	222	25	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	222	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	222	27	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	222	28	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	222	29	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	222	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	222	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	222	32	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	222	33	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	222	34	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	222	35	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	222	36	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	222	37	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	222	38	created	create	VERB
inlawrev-20850	222	39	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	222	40	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	222	41	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	222	42	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	222	43	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	222	44	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	222	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	222	46	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	222	47	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	222	48	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	222	49	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	223	1	evaluating	evaluate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	223	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	223	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	223	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	223	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	223	6	choices	choice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	223	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	223	8	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	223	9	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	223	10	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	223	11	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	223	12	consideration	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	223	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	223	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	223	15	biological	biological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	223	16	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	223	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	223	18	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	223	19	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	223	20	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	223	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	223	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	223	23	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	223	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	224	1	2	2	X
inlawrev-20850	224	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	224	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	224	4	biological	biological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	224	5	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	224	7	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	8	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	9	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	224	10	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	11	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	12	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	224	13	concurrent	concurrent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	224	14	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	15	contribution.—the	contribution.—the	DET
inlawrev-20850	224	16	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	224	18	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	224	19	disputed	dispute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	224	20	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	224	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	224	22	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	224	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	224	24	record	record	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	224	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	224	27	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	224	28	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	224	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	224	30	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	224	31	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	32	reveals	reveal	VERB
inlawrev-20850	224	33	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	224	34	little	little	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	224	35	disagreement	disagreement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	36	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	224	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	224	38	current	current	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	224	39	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	40	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	224	41	biological	biological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	224	42	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	224	44	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	45	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	46	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	224	47	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	48	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	224	49	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	225	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	225	2	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	225	3	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	225	4	purposes	purpose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	225	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	225	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	225	7	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	225	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	225	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	225	10	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	225	11	concert	concert	VERB
inlawrev-20850	225	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	225	13	action	action	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	225	14	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	225	15	hold	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	225	16	both	both	DET
inlawrev-20850	225	17	shooters	shooter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	225	18	liable	liable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	225	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	226	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	226	2	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	226	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	226	4	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	226	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	226	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	226	7	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	226	8	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	226	9	876	876	NUM
inlawrev-20850	226	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	226	11	1966	1966	NUM
inlawrev-20850	226	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	226	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	227	1	47	47	NUM
inlawrev-20850	227	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	227	3	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	227	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	227	5	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	227	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	227	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	227	8	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	227	9	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	227	10	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	227	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	228	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	228	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	228	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	228	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	228	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	228	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	228	7	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	228	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	228	9	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	228	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	228	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	229	1	48	48	NUM
inlawrev-20850	229	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	230	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	230	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	230	3	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	230	4	28	28	NUM
inlawrev-20850	230	5	cmt	cmt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	230	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	231	1	c.	c.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	231	2	49	49	NUM
inlawrev-20850	231	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	232	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	232	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	232	3	126	126	NUM
inlawrev-20850	232	4	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	232	5	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	232	6	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	233	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	233	4	49:117	49:117	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	5	effectively	effectively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	233	6	agreed	agree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	233	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	233	8	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	9	causes	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	233	10	pleural	pleural	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	233	11	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	233	13	caused50	caused50	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	233	14	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	233	15	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	233	16	pleural	pleural	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	233	17	mesothelioma.51	mesothelioma.51	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	18	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	19	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	233	20	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	233	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	233	23	apparently	apparently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	233	24	undisputed	undisputed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	233	25	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	233	27	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	233	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	233	29	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	30	by	by	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	233	31	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	233	32	inhaled	inhale	VERB
inlawrev-20850	233	33	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	34	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	35	reach	reach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	233	36	mesothelial	mesothelial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	233	37	tissue	tissue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	233	39	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	233	40	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	233	41	fiber	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	42	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	233	43	damage	damage	VERB
inlawrev-20850	233	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	233	45	cell	cell	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	46	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	233	47	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	233	48	material	material	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	49	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	233	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	233	51	accumulation	accumulation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	52	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	233	53	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	233	54	damage	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	55	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	233	56	lead	lead	VERB
inlawrev-20850	233	57	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	233	58	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	233	59	cell	cell	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	60	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	233	61	malignant	malignant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	233	62	transformation	transformation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	233	63	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	234	1	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	234	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	234	3	usually	usually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	234	4	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	234	5	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	6	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	234	7	initial52	initial52	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	8	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	234	10	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	234	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	234	13	patient	patient	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	234	15	diagnosed	diagnose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	234	16	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	234	17	malignant	malignant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	234	18	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	234	20	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	234	21	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	234	22	impossible	impossible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	234	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	234	24	identify	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	234	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	234	26	fiber	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	27	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	234	28	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	29	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	234	30	interacted	interact	VERB
inlawrev-20850	234	31	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	234	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	234	33	dna	dna	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	34	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	234	35	any	any	PRON
inlawrev-20850	234	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	234	37	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	234	38	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	234	39	changes	change	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	40	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	234	41	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	234	42	distinguish	distinguish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	234	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	234	44	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	234	46	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	234	48	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	234	49	types53	types53	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	50	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	234	51	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	234	52	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	234	53	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	234	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	234	55	patient	patient	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	56	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	234	57	tissue.54	tissue.54	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	234	58	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	59	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	234	60	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	234	61	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	234	62	inevitable	inevitable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	234	63	consequence	consequence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	64	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	234	65	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	66	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	234	67	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	234	68	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	234	69	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	235	1	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	235	2	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	235	3	creates	create	VERB
inlawrev-20850	235	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	235	5	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	235	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	235	7	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	235	8	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	235	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	235	10	certainty	certainty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	235	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	235	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	235	13	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	235	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	236	1	even55	even55	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	236	2	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	236	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	237	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	237	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	237	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	237	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	237	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	237	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	237	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	237	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	237	9	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	237	10	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	237	11	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	237	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	237	13	336	336	NUM
inlawrev-20850	237	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	237	15	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	237	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	237	17	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	237	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	237	19	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	237	20	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	237	21	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	237	22	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	237	23	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	237	24	dispute	dispute	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	237	25	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	237	26	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	237	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	237	28	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	237	29	breathed	breathe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	237	30	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-20850	237	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	237	32	lungs	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	237	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	237	34	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	237	35	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	237	36	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	237	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	237	38	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	237	39	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	237	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	238	1	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	238	2	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	238	3	uses	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	238	4	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	238	5	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	238	6	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	238	7	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	238	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	238	9	term	term	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	238	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	238	11	convenience	convenience	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	238	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	238	13	glossing	gloss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	238	14	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-20850	238	15	distinctions	distinction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	238	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	238	17	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	238	18	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	238	19	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	238	20	important	important	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	238	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	238	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	238	23	bostic	bostic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	238	24	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	238	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	238	26	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	238	27	various	various	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	238	28	asbestiform	asbestiform	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	238	29	minerals	mineral	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	238	30	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	238	31	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	238	32	chrysotile	chrysotile	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	238	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	238	34	amosite	amosite	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	238	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	238	36	tremolite	tremolite	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	238	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	238	38	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	238	39	crocidolite	crocidolite	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	238	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	239	2	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	3	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	4	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	5	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	7	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	239	8	brief	brief	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	9	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	239	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	239	11	merits	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	12	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	239	13	6	6	NUM
inlawrev-20850	239	14	n.8	n.8	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	16	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	17	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	239	18	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	19	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	20	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	21	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	22	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	24	439	439	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	25	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	239	26	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	239	27	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	28	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	29	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	30	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	239	31	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	32	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	33	no	no	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	239	34	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	35	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	239	36	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	239	37	0775	0775	NUM
inlawrev-20850	239	38	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	39	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	40	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	41	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	42	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	43	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	44	contends	contend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	239	45	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	239	46	chrysotile	chrysotile	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	47	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	48	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	239	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	239	50	type	type	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	51	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	239	52	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	239	53	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	54	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	55	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	56	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	239	57	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	239	58	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	59	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	60	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	239	61	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	239	62	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	239	63	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	64	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	65	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	239	66	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	67	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	239	68	purposes	purpose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	69	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	239	70	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	239	71	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	72	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	73	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	74	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	75	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	239	76	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	239	77	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	239	78	challenge	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	239	79	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	239	80	assumption	assumption	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	81	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	239	82	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	83	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	239	84	chrysotile	chrysotile	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	85	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	239	86	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	239	87	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	239	88	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	89	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	90	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	239	91	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	240	1	51	51	NUM
inlawrev-20850	240	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	240	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	240	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	240	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	240	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	240	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	240	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	240	9	brief	brief	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	240	10	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	240	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	240	12	merits	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	240	13	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	240	14	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-20850	240	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	240	16	supra	supra	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	240	17	note	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	240	18	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	240	19	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	240	20	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	240	21	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	240	22	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	240	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	240	24	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	240	25	rare	rare	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	240	26	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	240	27	whose	whose	DET
inlawrev-20850	240	28	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	240	29	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-20850	240	30	environmental	environmental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	240	31	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	240	32	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	240	33	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	240	34	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	240	35	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	240	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	240	37	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	240	38	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	240	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	241	1	georgiapacific	georgiapacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	241	2	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	241	3	brief	brief	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	241	4	never	never	ADV
inlawrev-20850	241	5	admitted	admit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	241	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	241	7	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	241	8	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	241	9	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	241	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	241	11	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	241	12	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	241	13	never	never	ADV
inlawrev-20850	241	14	contested	contest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	241	15	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	241	16	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	241	17	either	either	ADV
inlawrev-20850	241	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	241	19	instead	instead	ADV
inlawrev-20850	241	20	emphasizing	emphasize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	241	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	241	22	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	241	23	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	241	24	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	241	25	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	241	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	241	27	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	241	28	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	241	29	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	241	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	241	31	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	241	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	242	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	242	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	242	3	52	52	NUM
inlawrev-20850	242	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	243	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	243	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	243	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	243	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	243	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	243	6	368	368	NUM
inlawrev-20850	243	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	243	8	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	243	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	243	10	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	243	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	243	12	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	243	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	243	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	244	1	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	244	2	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	244	3	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	244	4	understanding	understanding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	244	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	244	6	scientists	scientist	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	244	7	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	244	8	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	244	9	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	244	10	know	know	VERB
inlawrev-20850	244	11	precisely	precisely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	244	12	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	244	13	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	244	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	244	15	various	various	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	244	16	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	244	17	disruptions	disruption	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	244	18	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	244	19	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	244	20	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	244	21	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	244	22	causes	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	244	23	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	244	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	245	2	thompson	thompson	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	245	3	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	245	4	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	245	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	245	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	7	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	245	8	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	245	9	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	245	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	11	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	245	12	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	245	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	245	16	molecular	molecular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	245	17	pathogenesis	pathogenesis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	245	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	245	19	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	245	20	malignant	malignant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	245	21	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	245	22	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	23	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	245	24	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-20850	245	25	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	245	26	elusive	elusive	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	245	27	multifactorial	multifactorial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	245	28	event	event	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	245	29	involving	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	245	30	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	245	31	mechanisms	mechanism	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	245	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	33	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	35	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	36	xu	xu	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	245	37	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	245	38	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	245	39	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	245	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	41	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	245	42	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	245	43	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	245	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	45	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	245	46	4388	4388	NUM
inlawrev-20850	245	47	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	48	identifying	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	245	49	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	245	50	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	245	51	changes	change	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	245	52	implicated	implicate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	245	53	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	245	54	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	245	55	tumorigenesis	tumorigenesis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	245	56	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	57	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	245	58	date	date	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	245	59	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	60	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	245	61	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	246	1	53	53	NUM
inlawrev-20850	246	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	247	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	247	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	6	344	344	NUM
inlawrev-20850	247	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	9	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	247	10	e]stablishing	e]stablishing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	11	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	247	12	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	13	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	14	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	247	15	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	16	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	247	17	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	247	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	247	19	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	20	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	247	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	247	22	always	always	ADV
inlawrev-20850	247	23	humanly	humanly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	247	24	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	247	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	26	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	27	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	28	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	29	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	247	30	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	247	31	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	247	32	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	33	368	368	NUM
inlawrev-20850	247	34	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	35	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	247	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	37	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	247	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	39	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	247	40	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	41	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	42	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	247	43	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	44	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	45	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	46	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	47	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	48	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	49	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	50	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	247	51	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	247	52	rutherford	rutherford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	247	53	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	54	owens	owens	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	247	55	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	56	illinois	illinois	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	247	57	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	58	941	941	NUM
inlawrev-20850	247	59	p.2d	p.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	247	60	1203	1203	NUM
inlawrev-20850	247	61	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	62	1219	1219	NUM
inlawrev-20850	247	63	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	64	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	247	65	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	66	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	67	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	247	68	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	69	impossibility	impossibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	70	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	71	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	72	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	247	73	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	74	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	75	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	76	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	247	77	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	247	78	kiyoshi	kiyoshi	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	247	79	sakai	sakai	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	247	80	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	247	81	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	247	82	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	247	83	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	84	trends	trend	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	85	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	86	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	87	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	247	88	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	247	89	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	247	90	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	91	fibre	fibre	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	92	concentrations	concentration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	93	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	94	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	247	95	lung	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	96	tissues	tissue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	97	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	98	japanese	japanese	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	247	99	patients	patient	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	100	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	101	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	102	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	103	58	58	NUM
inlawrev-20850	247	104	annals	annal	VERB
inlawrev-20850	247	105	occupational	occupational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	247	106	hygiene	hygiene	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	107	103	103	NUM
inlawrev-20850	247	108	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	109	103	103	NUM
inlawrev-20850	247	110	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	111	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	247	112	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	113	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	114	reporting	report	VERB
inlawrev-20850	247	115	millions	million	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	116	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	117	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	118	per	per	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	119	gram	gram	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	120	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	121	dry	dry	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	247	122	lung	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	123	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	124	tissue	tissue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	125	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	126	mesothelium	mesothelium	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	127	patients	patient	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	128	occupationally	occupationally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	247	129	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	247	130	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	247	131	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	247	132	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	247	133	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	248	1	54	54	NUM
inlawrev-20850	248	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	248	3	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	248	4	minerals	mineral	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	248	5	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	248	6	contain	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	248	7	distinguishable	distinguishable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	248	8	types	type	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	248	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	248	10	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	248	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	248	12	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	248	13	chrysotile	chrysotile	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	248	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	248	15	amphibole	amphibole	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	248	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	248	17	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	248	18	tremolite	tremolite	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	248	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	248	20	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	248	21	one	one	PRON
inlawrev-20850	248	22	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	248	23	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	248	24	expect	expect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	248	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	248	26	say	say	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	248	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	248	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	248	29	chrysotile	chrysotile	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	248	30	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	248	31	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	248	32	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	248	33	pacific	pacific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	248	34	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	248	35	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	248	36	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	248	37	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	248	38	distinguishable	distinguishable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	248	39	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	248	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	248	41	chrysotile	chrysotile	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	248	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	248	43	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	248	44	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	248	45	company	company	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	248	46	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	248	47	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	248	48	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	248	49	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	249	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	249	2	am	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	249	3	aware	aware	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	249	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	249	5	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	249	6	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	249	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	249	8	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	249	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	249	10	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	249	11	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	249	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	249	13	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	249	14	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	249	15	chemical	chemical	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	249	16	fingerprinting	fingerprinting	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	249	17	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	249	18	rule	rule	VERB
inlawrev-20850	249	19	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-20850	249	20	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	249	21	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	249	22	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	249	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	249	24	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	249	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	249	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	249	27	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	249	28	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	249	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	250	1	55	55	NUM
inlawrev-20850	250	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	251	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	251	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	251	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	251	4	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	251	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	251	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	251	7	374	374	NUM
inlawrev-20850	251	8	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	251	9	75	75	NUM
inlawrev-20850	251	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	251	11	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	251	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	251	13	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	251	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	251	15	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	251	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	251	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	251	18	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	251	19	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	251	20	e]ven	e]ven	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	251	21	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	251	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	251	23	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	251	24	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	251	25	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	251	26	exceeds	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	251	27	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	251	28	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	251	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	251	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	251	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	252	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	252	2	f]ate	f]ate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	3	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	252	4	frown	frown	VERB
inlawrev-20850	252	5	upon	upon	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	252	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	252	7	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	252	9	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	252	10	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	252	11	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	252	12	respect	respect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	13	http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/annhyg/met055	http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/annhyg/met055	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	14	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	252	15	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	252	16	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	17	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	252	19	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	252	20	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	21	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-20850	252	22	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	252	23	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	252	25	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	26	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	27	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	252	28	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	252	29	smaller	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	252	30	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	252	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	252	32	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	33	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	252	34	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	252	35	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	252	36	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	37	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	252	38	increase	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	252	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	252	40	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	252	42	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	252	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	253	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	253	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	253	3	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	253	4	that56	that56	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	253	5	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	253	6	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	253	7	below	below	ADP
inlawrev-20850	253	8	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	253	9	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	253	10	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	253	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	253	12	incapable	incapable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	253	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	253	14	inducing	induce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	253	15	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	253	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	253	17	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	253	18	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	253	19	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	253	20	such	such	DET
inlawrev-20850	253	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	253	22	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	253	23	exists	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	253	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	253	25	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	253	26	one	one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	253	27	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	253	28	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	253	29	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	253	30	able	able	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	253	31	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	253	32	identify	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	253	33	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	253	34	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	253	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	253	36	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-20850	253	37	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	253	38	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	253	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	253	40	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	253	41	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	253	42	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	253	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	253	44	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	253	45	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	253	46	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	253	47	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	253	48	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	253	49	low57	low57	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	253	50	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	253	51	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	253	52	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	253	53	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	253	54	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	253	55	able	able	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	253	56	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	253	57	measure	measure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	253	58	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	253	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	254	1	”58	”58	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	254	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	254	3	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	254	4	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	254	5	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	254	6	agreed	agree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	254	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	254	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	254	9	degree	degree	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	254	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	254	11	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	254	12	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	254	13	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	254	14	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	254	15	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	254	16	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	254	17	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	254	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	254	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	254	20	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	254	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	254	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	254	23	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	254	24	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	254	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	254	26	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	254	27	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	254	28	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	254	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	254	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	254	31	the	the	PRON
inlawrev-20850	254	32	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	254	33	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	254	34	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	254	35	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	254	36	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	254	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	254	38	developing	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	254	39	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	254	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	255	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	255	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	255	3	incremental	incremental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	255	4	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	255	5	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	255	6	add	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	255	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	255	8	a59	a59	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	255	9	before	before	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	255	10	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	255	11	develops	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	255	12	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	255	13	rare	rare	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	255	14	form	form	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	255	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	255	16	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	255	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	255	18	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	255	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	255	20	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	255	21	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	255	22	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	255	23	thompson	thompson	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	255	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	255	25	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	255	26	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	255	27	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	255	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	255	29	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	255	30	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-20850	255	31	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	255	32	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	255	33	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	255	34	about	about	ADV
inlawrev-20850	255	35	5	5	NUM
inlawrev-20850	255	36	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	255	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	255	38	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-20850	255	39	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	255	40	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	255	41	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	255	42	develop	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	255	43	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	255	44	malignant	malignant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	255	45	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	255	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	255	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	256	1	56	56	NUM
inlawrev-20850	256	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	257	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	257	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	6	338	338	NUM
inlawrev-20850	257	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	8	contrasting	contrast	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	9	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	11	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	12	needed	need	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	257	14	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	15	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	257	17	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	19	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	20	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	257	21	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	257	22	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	23	367	367	NUM
inlawrev-20850	257	24	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	25	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	257	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	27	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	257	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	29	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	30	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	31	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	32	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	33	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	35	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	36	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	37	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	38	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	257	39	research	research	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	40	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	257	41	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	42	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	257	43	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	44	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	46	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	47	below	below	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	48	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	257	49	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	50	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	51	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	257	52	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	257	53	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	54	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	55	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	56	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	257	57	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	257	58	demonstrated	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	59	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	257	60	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	257	61	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	62	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	63	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	64	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	65	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	66	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	67	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	257	68	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	69	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	257	70	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	257	71	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	257	72	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	257	73	brief	brief	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	74	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	75	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	257	76	merits	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	77	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	78	30	30	NUM
inlawrev-20850	257	79	n.26	n.26	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	80	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	81	supra	supra	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	82	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	83	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	257	84	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	85	asserting	assert	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	86	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	87	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	88	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	257	89	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	90	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	91	arguing	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	92	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	257	93	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	94	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	257	95	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	96	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	97	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	257	98	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	257	99	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	100	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	257	101	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	102	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	257	103	minimum	minimum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	104	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	105	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	106	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	107	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	108	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	257	109	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	110	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	111	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	112	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	257	113	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	257	114	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	115	minimum	minimum	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	257	116	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	117	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	118	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	119	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	120	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	257	121	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	257	122	lead	lead	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	123	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	124	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	257	125	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	126	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	127	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	128	developing	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	129	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	130	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	257	131	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	132	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	133	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	257	134	minimum	minimum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	135	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	136	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	257	137	higher	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	257	138	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	139	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	257	140	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	141	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	142	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	143	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	144	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	145	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	146	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	257	147	air	air	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	148	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	149	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	150	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	151	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	257	152	xu	xu	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	257	153	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	257	154	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	257	155	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	257	156	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	157	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	257	158	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	257	159	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	257	160	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	161	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	162	4388	4388	NUM
inlawrev-20850	257	163	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	164	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	165	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	257	166	individuals	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	167	develop	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	168	malignant	malignant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	257	169	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	170	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	171	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	172	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	173	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	257	174	amounts	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	175	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	176	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	177	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	178	whereas	whereas	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	257	179	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	180	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	181	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	257	182	heavy	heavy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	257	183	amounts	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	257	184	do	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	257	185	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	257	186	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	187	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	188	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	257	189	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	258	1	57	57	NUM
inlawrev-20850	258	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	259	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	259	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	259	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	259	4	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	259	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	259	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	259	7	357	357	NUM
inlawrev-20850	259	8	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	259	9	58	58	NUM
inlawrev-20850	259	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	259	11	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	259	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	259	13	accepting	accept	VERB
inlawrev-20850	259	14	arguendo	arguendo	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	259	15	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	259	16	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	259	17	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	259	18	witnesses	witness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	259	19	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	259	20	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	259	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	259	22	scientists	scientist	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	259	23	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	259	24	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	259	25	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	259	26	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	259	27	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	259	28	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	259	29	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	259	30	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	259	31	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	259	32	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	259	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	260	1	58	58	NUM
inlawrev-20850	260	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	261	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	261	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	261	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	261	4	368	368	NUM
inlawrev-20850	261	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	261	6	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	261	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	261	8	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	261	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	261	10	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	261	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	261	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	261	13	quotation	quotation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	261	14	marks	mark	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	261	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	261	16	brackets	bracket	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	261	17	omitted	omit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	261	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	261	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	262	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	262	2	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	262	3	briefs	brief	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	262	4	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	262	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	262	6	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	262	7	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	262	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	262	9	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	262	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	262	11	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	262	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	262	13	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	262	14	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	262	15	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	262	16	contest	contest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	262	17	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	262	18	description	description	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	262	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	262	20	despite	despite	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	262	21	arguing	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	262	22	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	262	23	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	262	24	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	262	25	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	262	26	prevail	prevail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	262	27	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	262	28	establishing	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	262	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	262	30	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	262	31	dose	dose	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	262	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	263	1	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	263	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	263	3	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	263	4	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	263	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	263	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	263	7	brief	brief	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	263	8	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	263	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	263	10	merits	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	264	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	264	2	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	264	3	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	264	4	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	264	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	264	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	264	7	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	264	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	264	9	29	29	NUM
inlawrev-20850	264	10	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	264	11	30	30	NUM
inlawrev-20850	264	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	265	1	59	59	NUM
inlawrev-20850	265	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	266	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	266	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	4	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	266	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	266	7	339	339	NUM
inlawrev-20850	266	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	10	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	11	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	12	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	13	consistently	consistently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	266	14	testified	testify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	266	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	266	16	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	266	17	asbestosrelated	asbestosrelate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	266	18	diseases	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	19	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	266	20	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	22	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	266	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	24	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	266	26	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	266	27	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	266	28	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	266	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	266	30	report	report	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	31	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	266	32	stated	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	266	33	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	34	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	266	35	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	266	36	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	37	environmental	environmental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	266	38	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	39	carry	carry	VERB
inlawrev-20850	266	40	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	266	41	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	266	42	extremely	extremely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	266	43	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	266	44	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	45	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	47	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	48	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	266	49	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	50	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	266	51	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	266	52	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	266	53	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	266	54	brief	brief	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	55	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	266	56	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	266	57	merits	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	58	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	59	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	266	60	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	61	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	266	62	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	63	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	266	64	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-20850	266	65	n.4	n.4	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	66	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	67	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	68	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	69	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	266	70	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	266	71	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	72	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	73	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	74	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	75	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	76	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	77	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	78	meaning	mean	VERB
inlawrev-20850	266	79	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	266	80	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	266	81	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	82	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	266	83	developing	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	266	84	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	266	85	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	86	increases	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	266	87	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	266	88	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	266	89	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	90	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	266	91	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	92	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	266	93	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	94	increases	increase	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	266	95	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	96	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	266	97	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	267	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	267	2	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	267	3	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	267	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	267	5	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	267	6	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	267	7	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	267	8	brief	brief	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	267	9	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	267	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	267	11	merits	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	267	12	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	267	13	6	6	NUM
inlawrev-20850	267	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	267	15	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	267	16	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	267	17	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	267	18	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	267	19	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	267	20	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	267	21	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	267	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	267	23	439	439	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	267	24	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	267	25	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	267	26	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	267	27	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	267	28	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	267	29	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	267	30	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	268	1	no	no	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	268	2	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	269	1	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	269	2	-	-	NUM
inlawrev-20850	269	3	0775	0775	NUM
inlawrev-20850	269	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	269	5	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	269	6	proposed	propose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	269	7	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	269	8	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	269	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	269	10	consumer	consumer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	269	11	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	269	12	safety	safety	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	269	13	commission	commission	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	269	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	269	15	introduced	introduce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	269	16	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	269	17	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	269	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	269	19	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	269	20	stated	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	269	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	269	22	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	269	23	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	269	24	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	269	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	269	26	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	269	27	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	269	28	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	269	29	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	269	30	increase	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	269	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	269	32	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	269	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	269	34	developing	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	269	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	269	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	269	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	270	1	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	270	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	270	3	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	270	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	270	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	271	1	higher	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	271	2	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	271	3	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	271	4	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	271	5	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	271	6	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	271	7	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	271	8	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	271	9	severe	severe	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	271	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	271	11	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	271	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	271	13	unlike	unlike	ADP
inlawrev-20850	271	14	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	271	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	272	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	272	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	4	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	272	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	272	7	338	338	NUM
inlawrev-20850	272	8	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	272	9	39	39	NUM
inlawrev-20850	272	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	11	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	272	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	272	13	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	15	appears	appear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	272	16	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	272	17	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	272	18	dose	dose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	272	19	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	20	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	272	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	22	so	so	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	272	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	272	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	272	25	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	272	26	one	one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	27	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	272	28	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	272	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	30	the	the	PRON
inlawrev-20850	272	31	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	272	32	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	272	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	272	34	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	35	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	272	36	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	272	37	occur	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	272	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	39	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	272	40	the	the	PRON
inlawrev-20850	272	41	higher	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	272	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	272	43	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	44	the	the	PRON
inlawrev-20850	272	45	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	272	46	severe	severe	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	272	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	272	48	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	49	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	272	50	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	272	51	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	272	52	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	272	53	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	54	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	272	55	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	56	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	57	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	272	58	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	59	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	272	60	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	61	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	62	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	63	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	272	64	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	65	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	272	66	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	272	67	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	68	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	272	69	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	70	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	272	71	developing	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	272	72	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	73	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	272	74	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	75	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	76	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	272	77	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	272	78	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	272	79	total	total	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	272	80	occupational	occupational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	272	81	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	82	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	272	83	inhaled	inhaled	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	272	84	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	85	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	86	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	272	87	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	88	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	89	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	90	internal	internal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	272	91	citations	citation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	92	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	272	93	quotation	quotation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	94	marks	mark	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	95	omitted	omit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	272	96	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	97	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	98	michael	michael	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	272	99	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	272	100	green	green	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	272	101	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	102	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	272	103	thoughts	thought	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	104	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	272	105	apportionment	apportionment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	106	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	272	107	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	108	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	109	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	272	110	37	37	NUM
inlawrev-20850	272	111	sw	sw	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	272	112	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	273	1	u.	u.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	273	2	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	273	3	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	273	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	273	5	531	531	NUM
inlawrev-20850	273	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	273	7	533	533	NUM
inlawrev-20850	273	8	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	273	9	34	34	NUM
inlawrev-20850	273	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	273	11	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-20850	273	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	273	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	274	1	128	128	NUM
inlawrev-20850	274	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	274	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	274	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	275	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	275	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	275	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	275	4	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	276	1	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	276	2	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	276	3	aggregate	aggregate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	276	4	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	276	5	add	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	276	6	incrementally	incrementally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	276	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	276	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	276	9	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	276	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	276	11	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	276	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	277	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	277	2	bostic60	bostic60	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	277	3	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	277	4	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	277	5	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	277	6	disagreed	disagree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	277	7	fundamentally	fundamentally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	277	8	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	277	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	277	10	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	277	11	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	277	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	277	13	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	277	14	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	277	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	278	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	278	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	278	3	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	278	4	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	278	5	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	278	6	dispute	dispute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	278	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	278	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	278	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	278	10	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	278	11	above	above	ADP
inlawrev-20850	278	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	278	13	presumed61	presumed61	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	278	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	278	15	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	278	16	unidentified	unidentified	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	278	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	278	18	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	278	19	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	278	20	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	278	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	278	22	additional	additional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	278	23	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	278	24	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	278	25	add	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	278	26	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	278	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	278	28	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	278	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	278	30	developing	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	278	31	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	278	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	279	1	nor	nor	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	279	2	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	279	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	279	4	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	279	5	dispute	dispute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	279	6	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	279	7	each62	each62	VERB
inlawrev-20850	279	8	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	279	9	prior	prior	ADV
inlawrev-20850	279	10	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	279	11	reaching	reach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	279	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	279	13	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	279	14	contributes	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	279	15	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	279	16	reaching	reach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	279	17	it.63	it.63	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	279	18	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	279	19	account	account	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	279	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	279	21	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	279	22	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	279	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	279	24	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	279	25	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	279	26	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	279	27	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	279	28	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	279	29	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	279	30	comfortably	comfortably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	279	31	fit	fit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	279	32	traditional	traditional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	279	33	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	279	34	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	279	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	279	36	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	279	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	280	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	280	2	science	science	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	280	3	suggests	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	280	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	280	5	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	280	6	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	280	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	280	8	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	280	9	necessarily	necessarily	ADV
inlawrev-20850	280	10	inhaled	inhale	VERB
inlawrev-20850	280	11	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	280	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	280	13	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	280	14	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	280	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	280	16	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	280	17	necessarily	necessarily	ADV
inlawrev-20850	280	18	contributed	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	280	19	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	280	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	280	21	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	280	22	source	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	280	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	280	24	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	280	25	participate	participate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	280	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	280	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	280	28	series	series	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	280	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	280	30	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	280	31	changes	change	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	280	32	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	280	33	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	280	34	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	280	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	280	36	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	280	37	cellular	cellular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	280	38	transformation	transformation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	280	39	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	280	40	eventually	eventually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	280	41	produces	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	280	42	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	280	43	fatal	fatal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	280	44	tumor	tumor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	280	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	281	1	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	281	2	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	281	3	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	281	4	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	281	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	281	6	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	281	7	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	281	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	281	9	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	281	10	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	281	11	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	281	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	281	13	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	281	14	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	281	15	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	281	16	contributed	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	281	17	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	281	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	281	19	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	281	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	281	21	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	281	22	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	281	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	281	24	concurring	concurring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	281	25	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	281	26	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	281	27	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	281	28	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	281	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	281	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	281	31	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	281	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	282	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	282	2	any	any	PRON
inlawrev-20850	282	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	282	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	282	5	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	282	6	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	282	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	282	8	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	282	9	inhaled	inhale	VERB
inlawrev-20850	282	10	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	282	11	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	282	12	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	282	13	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	282	14	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	282	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	282	16	actual	actual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	282	17	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	282	18	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	282	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	283	1	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	283	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	283	3	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	283	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	283	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	283	6	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	283	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	283	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	283	9	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	283	10	respective	respective	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	283	11	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	283	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	283	13	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	283	14	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	283	15	viewed	view	VERB
inlawrev-20850	283	16	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	283	17	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	283	18	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	283	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	284	1	discriminating	discriminate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	284	2	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	284	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	284	4	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	284	5	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	284	6	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	284	7	identify	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	284	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	284	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	284	10	actual	actual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	284	11	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	284	12	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	284	13	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	284	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	284	15	impossible	impossible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	284	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	284	17	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	284	18	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	284	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	284	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	284	21	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	284	22	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	284	23	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	284	24	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	284	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	284	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	284	27	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	284	28	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	284	29	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	284	30	concurrent	concurrent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	284	31	contributors	contributor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	284	32	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	284	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	284	34	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	284	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	284	36	developing	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	284	37	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	284	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	285	1	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	285	2	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	285	3	tried	try	VERB
inlawrev-20850	285	4	various	various	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	285	5	approaches	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	285	6	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	285	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	285	8	disconnection	disconnection	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	285	9	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	285	10	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	285	11	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	285	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	285	13	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	285	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	285	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	285	16	biological	biological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	285	17	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	285	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	285	19	concurrent	concurrent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	285	20	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	285	21	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	285	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	286	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	286	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	286	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	286	4	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	286	5	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	286	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	286	7	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	286	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	286	9	effort	effort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	286	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	287	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	287	2	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	287	3	spectacularly.64	spectacularly.64	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	287	4	ii	ii	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	287	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	288	1	understanding	understand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	288	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	288	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	288	4	misunderstandings	misunderstanding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	288	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	288	6	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	288	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	288	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	288	9	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	288	10	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	288	11	appealing	appeal	VERB
inlawrev-20850	288	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	288	13	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	288	14	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	288	15	verdict	verdict	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	288	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	288	17	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	288	18	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	288	19	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	288	20	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	288	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	288	22	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	288	23	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	288	24	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	288	25	legally	legally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	288	26	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	288	27	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	288	28	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	288	29	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	288	30	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	288	31	pacific	pacific	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	288	32	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	288	33	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	288	34	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	288	35	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	288	36	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	288	37	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	288	38	timothy	timothy	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	288	39	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	288	40	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	288	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	288	42	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	289	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	289	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	289	4	appeals	appeals	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	289	6	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	7	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	289	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	289	9	the65	the65	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	289	10	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	11	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	289	12	produced	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	289	13	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	289	14	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	289	16	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	289	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	289	18	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	19	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	289	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	289	21	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	22	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	289	23	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	289	24	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	289	25	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	26	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	289	27	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	28	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	289	29	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	30	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	289	31	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	289	32	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	289	34	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	289	35	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	289	36	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	37	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	289	38	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	289	39	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	40	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	289	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	289	42	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	289	43	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	289	44	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	289	45	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	289	46	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	289	48	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	49	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	289	50	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	51	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	289	52	death.66	death.66	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	53	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	289	54	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	289	55	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	56	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	289	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	289	58	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	59	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	289	60	appeals	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	61	attempted	attempt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	289	62	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	289	63	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	289	64	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	289	65	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	66	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	67	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	289	68	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	69	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	289	70	precedent	precedent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	71	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	289	72	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	289	73	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	74	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	289	75	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	289	76	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	77	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	289	78	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	79	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	80	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	81	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	82	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	289	83	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	290	1	the67	the67	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	290	2	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	290	3	understood	understand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	290	4	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	290	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	290	6	require	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	290	7	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	290	8	components	component	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	290	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	290	10	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	290	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	290	12	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	290	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	290	14	60	60	NUM
inlawrev-20850	290	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	291	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	291	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	291	3	green	green	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	291	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	291	5	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	291	6	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	291	7	59	59	NUM
inlawrev-20850	291	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	291	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	291	10	538	538	NUM
inlawrev-20850	291	11	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	291	12	39	39	NUM
inlawrev-20850	291	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	291	14	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	291	15	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	291	16	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	291	17	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	291	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	291	19	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	291	20	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	291	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	291	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	292	1	61	61	NUM
inlawrev-20850	292	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	293	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	293	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	293	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	293	4	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	293	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	293	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	293	7	337	337	NUM
inlawrev-20850	293	8	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	293	9	39	39	NUM
inlawrev-20850	293	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	294	1	62	62	NUM
inlawrev-20850	294	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	295	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	295	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	295	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	295	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	295	5	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	295	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	295	7	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	295	8	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	295	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	295	10	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	295	11	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	295	12	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	295	13	suggestion	suggestion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	295	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	295	15	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	295	16	adduced	adduce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	295	17	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	295	18	contradicting	contradict	VERB
inlawrev-20850	295	19	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	295	20	incremental	incremental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	295	21	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	295	22	add	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	295	23	incremental	incremental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	295	24	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	295	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	295	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	296	1	63	63	NUM
inlawrev-20850	296	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	297	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	297	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	297	3	64	64	NUM
inlawrev-20850	297	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	297	5	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	297	6	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	297	7	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	297	8	65	65	NUM
inlawrev-20850	297	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	298	1	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	298	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	298	3	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	298	4	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	299	1	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	299	2	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	299	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	299	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	299	5	320	320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	299	6	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	299	7	588	588	NUM
inlawrev-20850	299	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	299	9	591	591	NUM
inlawrev-20850	299	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	299	11	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	299	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	299	13	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	299	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	299	15	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	299	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	299	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	299	18	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	299	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	299	20	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	299	21	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	299	22	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	299	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	299	24	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	299	25	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	299	26	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	299	27	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	299	28	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	299	29	footnote	footnote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	299	30	omitted	omit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	299	31	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	299	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	300	1	66	66	NUM
inlawrev-20850	300	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	301	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	301	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	301	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	301	4	602	602	NUM
inlawrev-20850	301	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	301	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	301	7	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	301	8	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	301	9	legally	legally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	301	10	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	301	11	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	301	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	301	13	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	301	14	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	301	15	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	301	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	301	17	verdict	verdict	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	301	18	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-20850	301	19	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	301	20	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	301	21	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	301	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	301	23	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	301	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	301	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	302	1	67	67	NUM
inlawrev-20850	302	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	303	1	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	303	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	303	3	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	303	4	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	303	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	304	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	304	2	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	304	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	304	4	232	232	NUM
inlawrev-20850	304	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	304	6	765	765	NUM
inlawrev-20850	304	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	304	8	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	304	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	304	10	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-20850	304	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	304	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	305	1	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	305	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	305	3	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	4	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	305	6	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	305	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	8	129	129	NUM
inlawrev-20850	305	9	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	305	11	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	305	12	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	305	14	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	15	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	305	16	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	305	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	305	18	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	19	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	305	20	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	305	21	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	305	22	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	305	23	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	305	24	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	305	26	defendant	defendant	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	305	27	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	305	28	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	29	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	30	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	31	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	305	32	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	305	33	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	305	34	become	become	VERB
inlawrev-20850	305	35	ill	ill	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	305	36	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	305	37	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	305	38	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	305	39	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	40	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	305	41	defendant	defendant	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	305	42	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	305	43	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	44	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	45	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	305	46	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	305	47	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	305	48	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	49	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	305	50	producing	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	305	51	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	52	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	305	53	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	305	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	306	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	306	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	306	3	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	306	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	306	5	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	306	6	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	306	7	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	306	8	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	306	9	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	306	10	both68	both68	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	306	11	scores	score	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	306	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	306	13	reversed	reverse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	306	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	306	15	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	306	16	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	306	17	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	306	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	306	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	306	20	rendered	render	VERB
inlawrev-20850	306	21	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	306	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	306	23	favor	favor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	306	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	306	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	306	26	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	306	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	307	1	69	69	NUM
inlawrev-20850	307	2	first	first	ADV
inlawrev-20850	307	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	307	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	307	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	307	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	307	7	appeals	appeals	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	307	8	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	307	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	307	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	307	11	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	307	12	’	’	PART
inlawrev-20850	307	13	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	307	14	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	307	15	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	307	16	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	307	17	declined	decline	VERB
inlawrev-20850	307	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	307	19	opine	opine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	307	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	307	21	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	307	22	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	307	23	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	307	24	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	307	25	developed	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	307	26	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	307	27	absent	absent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	307	28	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	307	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	307	30	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	307	31	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	307	32	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	307	33	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	307	34	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	307	35	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	307	36	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	307	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	308	1	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	308	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	308	3	the7	the7	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	308	4	0	0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	308	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	308	6	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	308	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	308	8	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	308	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	308	10	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	308	11	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	308	12	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	308	13	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	308	14	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	308	15	b]ecause	b]ecause	ADP
inlawrev-20850	308	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	308	17	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	308	18	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	308	19	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	308	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	308	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	308	22	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	308	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	308	24	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	308	25	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	308	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	308	27	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	308	28	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	308	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	308	30	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	308	31	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	308	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	308	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	308	34	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	308	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	309	1	”71	”71	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	309	2	second	second	ADV
inlawrev-20850	309	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	309	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	309	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	309	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	309	7	appeals	appeals	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	309	8	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	309	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	309	10	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	309	11	lacked	lack	VERB
inlawrev-20850	309	12	both	both	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	309	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	309	14	qualitative	qualitative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	309	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	309	16	quantitative	quantitative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	309	17	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	309	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	309	19	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	309	20	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	309	21	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	309	22	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	309	23	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	309	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	309	25	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	309	26	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	309	27	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	309	28	flores	flores	AUX
inlawrev-20850	309	29	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	309	30	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	309	31	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	309	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	309	33	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	309	34	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	309	35	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	309	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	310	1	because72	because72	VERB
inlawrev-20850	310	2	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	310	3	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	310	4	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	310	5	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	310	6	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	310	8	timothy	timothy	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	310	10	frequent	frequent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	310	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	310	12	regular	regular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	310	13	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	14	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	310	15	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	310	17	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	18	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	310	19	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	20	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	310	21	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	310	22	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	310	23	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	24	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	310	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	310	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	310	27	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	310	28	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	29	is73	is73	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	30	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	310	31	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	310	32	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	310	33	quantitative	quantitative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	310	34	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	310	36	timothy	timothy	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	37	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	310	38	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	39	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	310	40	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	41	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	42	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	310	43	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	44	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	310	45	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	46	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	310	47	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	48	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	310	49	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	310	50	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	310	51	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	310	53	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	310	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	310	55	court74	court74	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	56	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	310	57	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	310	58	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	59	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	310	60	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	310	61	produced	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	310	62	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	310	63	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	64	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	310	65	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	310	66	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	310	67	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	68	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	310	69	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	70	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	310	71	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	72	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	310	73	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	74	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	310	75	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	310	76	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	310	77	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	78	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	310	79	producing	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	310	80	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	81	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	310	82	disease.75	disease.75	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	83	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	310	84	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	85	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	86	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	310	87	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	88	affirmed	affirm	VERB
inlawrev-20850	310	89	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	310	90	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	91	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	310	92	appeals	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	93	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	310	94	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	95	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	310	96	speaking	speak	VERB
inlawrev-20850	310	97	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	310	98	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	310	99	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	100	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-20850	310	101	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	310	102	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	103	don	don	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	104	r.	r.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	105	willett	willett	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	310	106	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	310	107	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-20850	310	108	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	310	109	five	five	NUM
inlawrev-20850	310	110	justices	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	310	111	in	in	ADV
inlawrev-20850	310	112	all	all	ADV
inlawrev-20850	310	113	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	311	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	311	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	311	3	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	311	4	stated	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	311	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	311	6	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	311	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	311	8	lower	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	311	9	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	311	10	was76	was76	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	311	11	wrong	wrong	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	311	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	311	13	insist	insist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	311	14	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	311	15	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	311	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	311	17	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	311	18	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	311	19	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	311	20	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	311	21	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	311	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	311	23	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	311	24	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	311	25	right	right	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	311	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	311	27	require	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	311	28	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	311	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	311	30	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	311	31	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	311	32	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	311	33	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	311	34	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	311	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	312	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	312	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	312	3	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	312	4	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	312	5	prescribed	prescribe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	312	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	312	7	detailed77	detailed77	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	312	8	set	set	VERB
inlawrev-20850	312	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	312	10	requirements	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	312	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	312	12	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	312	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	312	14	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	312	15	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	312	16	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	312	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	312	18	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	312	19	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	312	20	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	312	21	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	312	22	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	312	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	312	24	finally	finally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	312	25	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	312	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	312	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	312	28	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	312	29	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	312	30	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	312	31	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	312	32	presented	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	312	33	proof78	proof78	VERB
inlawrev-20850	312	34	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	312	35	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	312	36	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	312	37	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	312	38	requirements	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	312	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	313	1	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	313	2	eva	eva	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	313	3	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	313	4	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-20850	313	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	313	6	concurring79	concurring79	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	313	7	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	313	8	arguing	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	313	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	313	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	313	11	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	313	12	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	313	13	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	313	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	313	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	313	16	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	313	17	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	313	18	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	313	19	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	313	20	too	too	ADV
inlawrev-20850	313	21	68	68	NUM
inlawrev-20850	313	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	1	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	314	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	3	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	314	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	5	320	320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	314	6	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	314	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	314	8	596	596	NUM
inlawrev-20850	314	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	10	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	11	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	12	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	314	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	314	14	both	both	PRON
inlawrev-20850	314	15	proximate	proximate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	314	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	314	17	producing	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	314	18	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	314	19	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	314	20	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	314	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	314	22	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	314	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	24	including	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	314	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	314	26	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	314	27	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	314	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	314	29	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	314	30	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	314	31	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	314	32	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	314	33	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	314	34	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	314	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	314	36	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	314	37	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	314	38	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	314	39	bringing	bring	VERB
inlawrev-20850	314	40	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	314	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	314	42	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	314	43	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	314	44	injuries	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	314	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	46	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	47	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	48	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	49	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	50	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	314	51	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	314	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	53	232	232	NUM
inlawrev-20850	314	54	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	314	55	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	314	56	770	770	NUM
inlawrev-20850	314	57	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	314	58	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	314	59	union	union	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	314	60	pump	pump	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	314	61	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	315	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	315	2	allbritton	allbritton	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	315	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	315	4	898	898	NUM
inlawrev-20850	315	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	315	6	773	773	NUM
inlawrev-20850	315	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	315	8	775	775	NUM
inlawrev-20850	315	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	315	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	315	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	315	12	1995	1995	NUM
inlawrev-20850	315	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	315	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	315	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	315	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	315	17	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	315	18	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	315	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	315	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	316	1	69	69	NUM
inlawrev-20850	316	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	317	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	317	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	317	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	317	4	590	590	NUM
inlawrev-20850	317	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	318	1	70	70	NUM
inlawrev-20850	318	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	319	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	319	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	319	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	319	4	596	596	NUM
inlawrev-20850	319	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	320	1	71	71	NUM
inlawrev-20850	320	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	321	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	321	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	321	3	72	72	NUM
inlawrev-20850	321	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	322	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	322	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	322	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	322	4	602	602	NUM
inlawrev-20850	322	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	323	1	73	73	NUM
inlawrev-20850	323	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	324	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	324	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	324	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	324	4	599	599	NUM
inlawrev-20850	324	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	325	1	74	74	NUM
inlawrev-20850	325	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	326	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	326	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	326	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	326	4	601	601	NUM
inlawrev-20850	326	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	327	1	75	75	NUM
inlawrev-20850	327	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	328	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	328	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	328	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	328	4	602	602	NUM
inlawrev-20850	328	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	329	1	76	76	NUM
inlawrev-20850	329	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	330	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	330	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	330	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	330	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	330	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	330	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	330	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	330	8	439	439	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	330	9	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	330	10	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	330	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	330	12	336	336	NUM
inlawrev-20850	330	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	330	14	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	330	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	330	16	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	330	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	330	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	331	1	77	77	NUM
inlawrev-20850	331	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	332	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	332	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	332	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	332	4	344	344	NUM
inlawrev-20850	332	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	333	1	78	78	NUM
inlawrev-20850	333	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	334	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	334	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	334	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	334	4	346	346	NUM
inlawrev-20850	334	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	334	6	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	334	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	334	8	79	79	NUM
inlawrev-20850	334	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	335	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	335	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	335	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	335	4	353	353	NUM
inlawrev-20850	335	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	335	6	60	60	NUM
inlawrev-20850	335	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	335	8	130	130	NUM
inlawrev-20850	335	9	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	335	10	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	335	11	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	335	12	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	335	13	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	335	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	335	15	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	335	16	stringent	stringent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	335	17	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	335	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	335	19	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	335	20	’s	’	VERB
inlawrev-20850	335	21	too	too	ADV
inlawrev-20850	335	22	lax	lax	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	335	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	336	1	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	336	2	justices	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	336	3	dissented	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	336	4	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	336	5	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	336	6	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	336	7	written80	written80	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	336	8	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	336	9	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	336	10	debra	debra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	336	11	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	336	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	337	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	337	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	337	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	337	4	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	337	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	337	6	best	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	337	7	understood	understand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	337	8	by81	by81	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	337	9	considering	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	337	10	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	337	11	components	component	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	337	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	337	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	337	14	sequence	sequence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	337	15	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	337	16	above	above	ADV
inlawrev-20850	337	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	337	18	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	337	19	though	though	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	337	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	337	21	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	337	22	presented	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	337	23	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	337	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	337	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	337	26	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	337	27	order	order	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	337	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	338	1	a.	a.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	339	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	339	2	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	339	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	339	4	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	339	5	need	need	AUX
inlawrev-20850	339	6	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	339	7	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	339	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	339	9	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	339	10	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	339	11	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	339	12	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	339	13	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	339	14	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	339	15	war	war	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	339	16	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	339	17	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	339	18	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	339	19	nine	nine	NUM
inlawrev-20850	339	20	justices	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	339	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	339	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	339	23	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	339	24	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	339	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	339	26	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	339	27	agreed	agree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	339	28	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	339	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	339	30	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	339	31	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	339	32	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	339	33	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	339	34	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	339	35	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	339	36	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	339	37	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	339	38	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	339	39	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	339	40	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	339	41	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	339	42	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	339	43	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	339	44	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	339	45	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	339	46	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	339	47	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	339	48	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	339	49	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	339	50	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	339	51	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	339	52	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	339	53	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	339	54	contracted	contract	VERB
inlawrev-20850	339	55	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	339	56	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	339	57	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	340	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	340	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	340	3	initially82	initially82	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	340	4	justified	justify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	340	5	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	340	6	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	340	7	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	340	8	grounds	ground	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	340	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	340	10	impossibility	impossibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	340	11	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	340	12	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	340	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	340	14	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	340	15	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	340	16	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	340	17	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	340	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	340	19	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	340	20	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	340	21	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	340	22	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	340	23	impossible	impossible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	340	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	340	25	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	340	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	340	27	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	340	28	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	340	29	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	340	30	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	340	31	become	become	VERB
inlawrev-20850	340	32	ill	ill	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	340	33	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	340	34	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	340	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	340	36	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	340	37	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	340	38	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	340	39	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	340	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	341	1	”83	”83	VERB
inlawrev-20850	341	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	341	3	only	only	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	341	4	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	341	5	quibble	quibble	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	341	6	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	341	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	341	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	341	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	341	10	statement	statement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	341	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	341	12	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	341	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	341	14	word	word	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	341	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	341	16	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	341	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	341	18	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	342	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	342	2	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	342	3	causative	causative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	342	4	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	342	5	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	342	6	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	342	7	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	342	8	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	342	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	342	10	traced	trace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	342	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	342	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	342	13	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	342	14	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	342	15	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	342	16	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	342	17	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	342	18	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	342	19	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	342	20	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	342	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	342	22	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	342	23	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-20850	342	24	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	342	25	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	342	26	follow	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	342	27	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	342	28	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	342	29	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	342	30	exposure84	exposure84	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	342	31	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	342	32	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	342	33	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	342	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	342	35	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	342	36	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	342	37	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	342	38	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	342	39	developed	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	342	40	mesothelioma.85	mesothelioma.85	PRON
inlawrev-20850	342	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	342	42	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	342	43	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	342	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	342	45	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	342	46	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	342	47	hardly	hardly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	342	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	342	49	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	342	50	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	342	51	recognize	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	342	52	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	342	53	impossibility	impossibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	342	54	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	342	55	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	342	56	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	342	57	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	342	58	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	342	59	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	342	60	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	342	61	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	342	62	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	342	63	injustice	injustice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	342	64	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	342	65	allowing	allow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	342	66	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	342	67	impossibility	impossibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	342	68	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	342	69	preclude	preclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	342	70	recovery	recovery	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	342	71	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	342	72	every	every	DET
inlawrev-20850	342	73	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	342	74	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	342	75	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	342	76	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	342	77	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	343	1	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	343	2	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	343	3	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	343	4	wrestling	wrestle	VERB
inlawrev-20850	343	5	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	343	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	343	7	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	343	8	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	343	9	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	343	10	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	343	11	alternatives	alternative	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	343	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	343	13	the	the	PRON
inlawrev-20850	343	14	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	343	15	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	343	16	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	343	17	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	343	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	344	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	344	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	344	3	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	344	4	quoted	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	344	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	344	6	california	california	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	344	7	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	344	8	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	344	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	344	10	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	344	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	344	12	a86	a86	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	344	13	80	80	NUM
inlawrev-20850	344	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	345	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	345	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	345	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	345	4	362	362	NUM
inlawrev-20850	345	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	345	6	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	345	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	345	8	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	345	9	concurring	concurring	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	345	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	345	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	346	1	81	81	NUM
inlawrev-20850	346	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	347	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	347	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	347	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	347	4	366	366	NUM
inlawrev-20850	347	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	347	6	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	347	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	347	8	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	347	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	347	10	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	347	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	347	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	348	1	82	82	NUM
inlawrev-20850	348	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	349	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	349	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	349	4	346	346	NUM
inlawrev-20850	349	5	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	6	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	349	7	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	349	8	i	i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	349	9	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	349	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	349	11	361	361	NUM
inlawrev-20850	349	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	13	guzman	guzman	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	349	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	15	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	349	16	concurring	concurring	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	349	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	19	joining	join	VERB
inlawrev-20850	349	20	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	349	21	ii.a.2	ii.a.2	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	349	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	349	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	349	24	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	349	25	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	349	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	27	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	349	28	discussed	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	349	29	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	30	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	349	31	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	349	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	33	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	349	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	35	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	36	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	349	37	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	349	38	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	349	39	377	377	NUM
inlawrev-20850	349	40	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	349	41	79	79	NUM
inlawrev-20850	349	42	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	43	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	349	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	45	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	349	46	dissenting	dissenting	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	349	47	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	48	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	49	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	349	50	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	349	51	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	349	52	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	349	53	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	349	54	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	349	55	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	349	56	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	57	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	349	58	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	349	59	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	60	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	349	61	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	350	1	83	83	NUM
inlawrev-20850	350	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	351	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	351	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	351	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	351	4	344	344	NUM
inlawrev-20850	351	5	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	351	6	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	351	7	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	351	8	i	i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	351	9	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	351	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	351	11	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	351	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	351	13	long	long	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	351	14	latency	latency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	351	15	period	period	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	351	16	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	351	17	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	351	18	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	351	19	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	351	20	diseases	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	351	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	351	22	coupled	couple	VERB
inlawrev-20850	351	23	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	351	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	351	25	inability	inability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	351	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	351	27	trace	trace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	351	28	precisely	precisely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	351	29	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	351	30	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	351	31	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	351	32	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	351	33	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	351	34	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	351	35	whose	whose	DET
inlawrev-20850	351	36	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	351	37	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	351	38	emanated	emanate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	351	39	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	351	40	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	351	41	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	351	42	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	351	43	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	351	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	351	45	proving	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	351	46	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	351	47	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	351	48	inexact	inexact	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	351	49	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	351	50	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	351	51	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	351	52	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	351	53	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	351	54	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	351	55	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	351	56	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	351	57	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	351	58	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	352	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	352	2	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	352	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	352	4	232	232	NUM
inlawrev-20850	352	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	352	6	765	765	NUM
inlawrev-20850	352	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	352	8	772	772	NUM
inlawrev-20850	352	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	352	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	352	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	352	12	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-20850	352	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	352	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	352	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	353	1	84	84	NUM
inlawrev-20850	353	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	354	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	354	2	text	text	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	354	3	accompanying	accompany	VERB
inlawrev-20850	354	4	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	354	5	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	354	6	49	49	NUM
inlawrev-20850	354	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	354	8	85	85	NUM
inlawrev-20850	354	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	355	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	355	2	steve	steve	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	355	3	c.	c.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	355	4	gold	gold	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	355	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	355	6	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	355	7	certainty	certainty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	355	8	dissolves	dissolve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	355	9	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-20850	355	10	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	355	11	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	355	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	355	13	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	355	14	vision	vision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	355	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	355	16	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	355	17	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	355	18	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	355	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	355	20	post	post	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	355	21	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	355	22	genomic	genomic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	355	23	era	era	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	355	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	355	25	70	70	NUM
inlawrev-20850	355	26	wash	wash	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	355	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	356	1	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	356	2	lee	lee	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	356	3	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	356	4	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	356	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	356	6	237	237	NUM
inlawrev-20850	356	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	356	8	288	288	NUM
inlawrev-20850	356	9	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	356	10	n.211	n.211	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	356	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	356	12	302	302	NUM
inlawrev-20850	356	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	356	14	2013	2013	NUM
inlawrev-20850	356	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	356	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	356	17	discussing	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	356	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	356	19	possibility	possibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	356	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	356	21	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	356	22	absent	absent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	356	23	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	356	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	356	25	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	356	26	causative	causative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	356	27	fiber	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	356	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	356	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	356	30	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	356	31	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	356	32	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	356	33	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	356	34	cell	cell	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	356	35	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	356	36	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	356	37	become	become	VERB
inlawrev-20850	356	38	malignant	malignant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	356	39	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	356	40	action	action	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	356	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	356	42	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	356	43	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	356	44	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	356	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	357	1	86	86	NUM
inlawrev-20850	357	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	358	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	358	2	sienkiewicz	sienkiewicz	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	358	3	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	358	4	greif	greif	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	358	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	358	6	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	358	7	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	358	8	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	358	9	uksc	uksc	VERB
inlawrev-20850	358	10	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	359	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	359	2	107	107	NUM
inlawrev-20850	359	3	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	359	4	08	08	NUM
inlawrev-20850	359	5	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	359	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	359	7	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	359	8	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	359	9	]	]	SYM
inlawrev-20850	359	10	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	359	11	wlr	wlr	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	359	12	523	523	NUM
inlawrev-20850	359	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	359	14	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	359	15	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	359	16	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	359	17	eng	eng	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	359	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	359	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	2	lord	lord	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	3	phillips	phillips	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	6	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	360	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	360	8	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	9	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	10	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	360	11	material	material	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	360	12	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	360	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	360	15	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	16	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	360	17	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	360	19	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	21	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	22	rutherford	rutherford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	23	v.	v.	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	360	24	owens	owens	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	26	illinois	illinois	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	28	941	941	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	29	p.2d	p.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	360	30	1203	1203	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	32	1220	1220	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	33	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	360	34	21	21	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	36	1223	1223	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	37	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	38	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	39	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	40	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	41	treating	treat	VERB
inlawrev-20850	360	42	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	360	43	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	44	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	360	45	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	360	46	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	360	48	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	49	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	360	50	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	360	51	contributed	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	360	52	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	360	53	risk	risk	VERB
inlawrev-20850	360	54	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	55	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	56	lohrmann	lohrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	57	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	58	pittsburgh	pittsburgh	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	59	corning	corning	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	60	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	61	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	62	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	63	728	728	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	64	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	65	1156	1156	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	66	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	67	1163	1163	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	68	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	69	4th	4th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	360	70	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	71	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	72	1986	1986	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	73	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	74	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	75	adopting	adopt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	360	76	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	77	frequency	frequency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	78	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	79	regularity	regularity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	80	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	360	81	proximity	proximity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	82	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	83	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	84	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	360	85	distinguish	distinguish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	360	86	causal	causal	ADV
inlawrev-20850	360	87	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	360	88	de	de	X
inlawrev-20850	360	89	minimis	minimis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	90	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	91	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	92	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	93	ford	ford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	94	motor	motor	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	95	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	96	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	360	97	boomer	boomer	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	98	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	99	736	736	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	100	s.e.2d	s.e.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	101	724	724	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	102	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	103	732	732	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	104	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	360	105	33	33	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	106	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	107	va	va	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	108	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	109	2013	2013	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	110	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	111	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	112	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	360	113	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	360	114	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	360	115	lieu	lieu	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	116	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	360	117	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	360	118	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	119	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	360	120	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	121	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	122	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	360	123	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	124	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	360	125	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	126	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	127	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	360	128	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	360	129	deemed	deem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	360	130	causal	causal	ADV
inlawrev-20850	360	131	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	360	132	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	360	133	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	360	134	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	360	135	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	360	136	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	360	137	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	138	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	139	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	140	stapleton	stapleton	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	360	141	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	142	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	143	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	360	144	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	145	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	360	146	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	360	147	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	361	1	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	361	2	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	361	3	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	361	4	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	361	5	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	361	6	131	131	NUM
inlawrev-20850	361	7	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	361	8	alleging	allege	VERB
inlawrev-20850	361	9	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	361	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	361	11	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	361	12	lung	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	361	13	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	361	14	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	362	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	362	2	p]laintiffs	p]laintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	362	3	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	362	4	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	362	5	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	362	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	362	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	362	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	363	1	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	363	2	demonstrating	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	363	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	363	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	363	5	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	363	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	363	7	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	363	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	363	9	defendant	defendant	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	363	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	363	11	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	363	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	363	13	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	363	14	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	363	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	363	16	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	363	17	medical	medical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	363	18	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	363	19	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	363	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	363	21	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	363	22	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	363	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	363	24	contributing	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	363	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	363	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	363	27	aggregate	aggregate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	363	28	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	363	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	363	30	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	363	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	363	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	363	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	364	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	364	2	hence	hence	ADV
inlawrev-20850	364	3	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	364	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	364	5	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	364	7	developing	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	364	8	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	9	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	364	10	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	364	11	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	364	13	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	364	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	364	15	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	16	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	364	17	demonstrate	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	364	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	364	19	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	20	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	364	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	364	22	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	364	24	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	364	25	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	26	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	364	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	364	28	ones	one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	364	30	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	364	31	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	364	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	364	33	ones	one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	364	35	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	364	36	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	364	37	produced	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	364	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	364	39	malignant	malignant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	40	growth.87	growth.87	VERB
inlawrev-20850	364	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	364	42	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	364	43	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	364	45	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	364	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	364	47	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	364	48	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	364	49	adopt	adopt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	364	50	california	california	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	364	51	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	364	52	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	53	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	54	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	364	55	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	364	56	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	364	57	favorably	favorably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	364	58	quoted	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	364	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	365	1	instead	instead	ADV
inlawrev-20850	365	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	365	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	365	4	took	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	365	5	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	365	6	end	end	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	365	7	run	run	VERB
inlawrev-20850	365	8	around	around	ADP
inlawrev-20850	365	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	365	10	stone	stone	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	365	11	wall	wall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	365	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	365	13	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	365	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	365	15	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	365	16	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	365	17	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	365	18	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	365	19	end	end	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	365	20	run	run	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	365	21	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	365	22	led	lead	VERB
inlawrev-20850	365	23	down	down	ADP
inlawrev-20850	365	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	365	25	dead	dead	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	365	26	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	365	27	end	end	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	365	28	street	street	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	365	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	366	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	366	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	366	3	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	366	4	eliminated	eliminate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	366	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	366	6	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	366	7	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	366	8	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	366	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	366	10	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	366	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	366	12	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	366	13	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	366	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	366	15	except	except	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	366	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	366	17	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	366	18	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	366	19	n’t	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	366	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	367	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	367	2	retrenchment	retrenchment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	367	3	began	begin	VERB
inlawrev-20850	367	4	immediately	immediately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	367	5	after	after	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	367	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	367	7	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	367	8	abjured	abjure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	367	9	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	367	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	367	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	367	12	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	367	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	367	14	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	367	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	367	16	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	367	17	chose	choose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	367	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	367	19	fight	fight	VERB
inlawrev-20850	367	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	367	21	battle	battle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	367	22	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	367	23	enemy	enemy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	367	24	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	367	25	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-20850	367	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	368	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	368	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	368	4	nod	nod	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	5	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	368	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	368	7	realities	reality	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	368	9	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	368	11	induced	induce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	368	12	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	13	carcinogenesis	carcinogenesis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	14	amply	amply	ADV
inlawrev-20850	368	15	justified	justify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	368	16	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	368	17	alteration	alteration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	368	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	368	20	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	21	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	368	22	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	368	23	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	368	24	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	368	26	infact	infact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	27	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	368	28	neither	neither	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	368	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	368	30	concurrence	concurrence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	31	nor	nor	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	368	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	368	33	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	34	questioned	question	VERB
inlawrev-20850	368	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	368	36	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	368	37	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	38	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	368	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	369	1	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
inlawrev-20850	369	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	369	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	369	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	369	5	went	go	VERB
inlawrev-20850	369	6	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	369	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	369	8	defend	defend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	369	9	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	369	10	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	369	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	369	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	369	13	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	369	14	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	369	15	formulation	formulation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	369	16	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	369	17	consistent	consistent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	369	18	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	369	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	369	20	restatements	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	369	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	369	22	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	369	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	370	1	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	370	2	defense88	defense88	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	370	3	pulled	pull	VERB
inlawrev-20850	370	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	370	5	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	370	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	370	7	train	train	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	370	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	370	9	reasoning	reason	VERB
inlawrev-20850	370	10	far	far	ADV
inlawrev-20850	370	11	off	off	ADP
inlawrev-20850	370	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	370	13	rails	rail	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	370	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	3	observed	observe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	371	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	371	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	6	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	371	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	9	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	10	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	11	yields	yield	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	14	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	371	15	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	16	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	17	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	18	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	20	situations	situation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	21	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	371	22	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	24	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	371	25	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	26	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	27	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	371	28	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	371	29	practically	practically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	371	30	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	31	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	371	32	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	33	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	34	otherwise	otherwise	ADV
inlawrev-20850	371	35	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	371	36	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	371	37	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	371	38	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	371	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	40	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	41	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	42	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	371	43	face89	face89	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	44	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	45	formulation	formulation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	46	seems	seem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	371	47	susceptible	susceptible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	48	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	50	understanding	understanding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	51	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	371	52	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	371	53	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	371	54	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	371	55	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	56	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	371	57	practically	practically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	371	58	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	59	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	60	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	371	61	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	371	62	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	63	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	64	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	65	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	66	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	371	67	essential	essential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	68	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	69	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	70	creation	creation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	71	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	72	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	371	73	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	371	74	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	75	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	76	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	77	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	371	78	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	371	79	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	80	alternative	alternative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	81	method	method	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	82	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	83	determining	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	371	84	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	85	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	86	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	87	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	88	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	89	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	90	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	91	model.90	model.90	ADV
inlawrev-20850	371	92	instead	instead	ADV
inlawrev-20850	371	93	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	94	acknowledging	acknowledge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	371	95	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	96	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	97	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	371	98	reconceptualize	reconceptualize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	371	99	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	100	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	101	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	102	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	103	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	371	104	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	105	reached	reach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	371	106	back	back	ADV
inlawrev-20850	371	107	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	108	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	109	earliest	early	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	110	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	111	uses	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	112	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	113	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	114	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	115	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	116	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	117	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	371	118	led	lead	VERB
inlawrev-20850	371	119	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	120	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	121	phrase	phrase	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	122	being	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	371	123	enshrined	enshrine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	371	124	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	125	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	126	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	127	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	128	torts	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	129	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	130	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	371	131	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	132	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	133	191	191	NUM
inlawrev-20850	371	134	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	371	135	93	93	NUM
inlawrev-20850	371	136	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	137	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	371	138	various	various	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	139	uses	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	140	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	141	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	371	142	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	143	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	144	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	371	145	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	146	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	371	147	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	371	148	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	372	1	87	87	NUM
inlawrev-20850	372	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	373	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	373	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	373	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	373	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	373	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	373	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	373	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	373	8	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	373	9	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	373	10	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	373	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	373	12	344	344	NUM
inlawrev-20850	373	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	373	14	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	373	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	373	16	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	373	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	373	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	373	19	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	373	20	rutherford	rutherford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	373	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	373	22	941	941	NUM
inlawrev-20850	373	23	p.2d	p.2d	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	373	24	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	373	25	1219	1219	NUM
inlawrev-20850	373	26	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	373	27	footnote	footnote	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	373	28	omitted	omit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	373	29	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	373	30	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	373	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	374	1	88	88	NUM
inlawrev-20850	374	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	375	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	375	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	375	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	375	4	344	344	NUM
inlawrev-20850	375	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	375	6	46	46	NUM
inlawrev-20850	375	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	375	8	89	89	NUM
inlawrev-20850	375	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	376	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	376	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	376	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	376	4	344	344	NUM
inlawrev-20850	376	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	376	6	90	90	NUM
inlawrev-20850	376	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	377	1	see	see	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	377	2	rutherford	rutherford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	377	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	377	4	941	941	NUM
inlawrev-20850	377	5	p.2d	p.2d	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	377	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	377	7	1203	1203	NUM
inlawrev-20850	377	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	377	9	quoted	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	377	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	377	11	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	377	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	377	13	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	377	14	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	377	15	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	377	16	344	344	NUM
inlawrev-20850	377	17	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	377	18	45	45	NUM
inlawrev-20850	377	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	378	1	rutherford	rutherford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	378	2	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	378	3	alternatively	alternatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	378	4	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	378	5	viewed	view	VERB
inlawrev-20850	378	6	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	378	7	re	re	VERB
inlawrev-20850	378	8	-	-	VERB
inlawrev-20850	378	9	conceptualizing	conceptualize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	378	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	378	11	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	378	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	378	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	378	14	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	378	15	inflicted	inflict	VERB
inlawrev-20850	378	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	378	17	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	378	18	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	378	19	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	378	20	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	378	21	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	378	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	378	23	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	378	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	378	25	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	378	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	379	1	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	379	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	379	3	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	379	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	379	5	rutherford	rutherford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	379	6	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	379	7	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	379	8	perfectly	perfectly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	379	9	consistent	consistent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	379	10	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	379	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	379	12	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	379	13	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	379	14	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	379	15	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	379	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	379	17	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	379	18	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	379	19	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	379	20	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	379	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	380	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	380	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	380	3	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	380	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	380	5	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	380	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	380	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	380	8	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	380	9	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	380	10	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	380	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	381	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	381	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	381	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	381	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	381	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	381	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	381	7	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	381	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	381	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	382	1	f	f	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	382	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	382	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	382	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	382	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	382	6	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	382	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	382	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	382	9	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	382	10	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	382	11	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	382	12	defining	define	VERB
inlawrev-20850	382	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	382	14	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	382	15	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	382	16	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	382	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	382	18	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	382	19	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	382	20	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	382	21	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	382	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	382	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	382	24	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
inlawrev-20850	382	25	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	382	26	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	382	27	recognize	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	382	28	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	382	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	382	30	unusual	unusual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	382	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	382	32	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	382	33	reconceptualized	reconceptualize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	382	34	harms	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	382	35	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	382	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	382	37	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	383	1	i	i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	383	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	383	3	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	383	4	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	383	5	cmt	cmt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	383	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	384	1	j	j	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	384	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	384	3	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	384	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	384	5	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	384	6	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	384	7	reasons	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	384	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	384	9	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	384	10	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	384	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	384	12	unavailable	unavailable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	384	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	384	14	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	384	15	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	384	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	384	17	permit	permit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	384	18	recovery	recovery	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	384	19	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	384	20	unconventional	unconventional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	384	21	types	type	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	384	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	384	23	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	384	24	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	384	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	384	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	385	1	132	132	NUM
inlawrev-20850	385	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	385	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	385	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	385	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	385	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	385	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	385	8	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	385	9	place	place	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	385	10	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	385	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	385	12	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	385	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	385	14	overdetermined	overdetermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	385	15	outcomes	outcome	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	385	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	386	1	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	386	2	situation	situation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	386	4	exemplified	exemplify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	386	5	by91	by91	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	386	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	386	7	classic	classic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	386	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	386	9	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	386	10	fires	fire	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	11	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	386	12	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	386	14	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	386	15	neither	neither	DET
inlawrev-20850	386	16	fire	fire	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	17	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	386	18	literally	literally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	386	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	386	20	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	386	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	386	22	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	386	23	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	386	25	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	26	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	386	27	absent	absent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	386	28	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	386	29	fire	fire	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	386	31	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	32	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	386	33	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	386	34	resulted	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	386	35	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	386	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	386	37	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	386	38	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	386	39	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	386	40	fire	fire	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	41	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	386	42	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	386	43	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	386	44	bring	bring	VERB
inlawrev-20850	386	45	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	386	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	386	47	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	48	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	386	49	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	386	50	neither	neither	PRON
inlawrev-20850	386	51	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	386	52	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	386	53	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	386	54	do	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	386	55	so.92	so.92	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	56	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	386	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	386	58	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	386	59	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	60	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	386	61	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	386	62	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	386	63	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	64	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	386	65	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	386	66	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-20850	386	67	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	386	68	predecessors	predecessor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	69	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	386	70	posits	posit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	71	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	386	72	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	386	73	independently	independently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	386	74	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	386	75	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	76	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	386	77	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	386	78	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	386	79	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	386	80	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	81	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	386	82	infact	infact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	83	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	386	84	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	386	85	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	386	86	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	387	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	387	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	387	3	called	call	VERB
inlawrev-20850	387	4	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	387	5	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	387	6	exception	exception	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	387	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	387	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	387	9	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	387	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	387	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	387	12	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	387	13	in93	in93	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	387	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	387	15	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	387	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	387	17	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	387	18	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	387	19	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	387	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	387	21	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	387	22	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	387	23	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	387	24	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	387	25	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	387	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	387	27	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	387	28	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	387	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	387	30	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-20850	387	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	387	32	earlier	early	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	387	33	restatements	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	387	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	387	35	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	387	36	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	387	37	require	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	387	38	strict	strict	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	387	39	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	387	40	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	387	41	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	387	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	387	43	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	387	44	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	387	45	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	387	46	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	387	47	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	387	48	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	387	49	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	387	50	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-20850	387	51	today	today	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	387	52	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	387	53	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	387	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	387	55	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	388	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	388	2	leaping	leap	VERB
inlawrev-20850	388	3	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	388	4	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	5	contribution94	contribution94	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	6	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	388	7	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	388	8	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	388	9	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	388	11	equating	equate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	388	12	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	388	13	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	14	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	388	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	388	16	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	388	17	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	388	19	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	388	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	388	21	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	22	silently	silently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	388	23	switched	switch	VERB
inlawrev-20850	388	24	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	388	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	388	26	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	388	28	contributing	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	388	29	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	388	31	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	388	32	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	388	34	independently	independently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	388	35	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	388	36	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	388	37	possibly	possibly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	388	38	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	388	39	causes.95	causes.95	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	388	41	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	42	quoted	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	388	43	comments	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	44	f	f	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	388	45	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	388	46	g	g	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	388	47	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	388	48	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	49	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	388	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	388	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	388	52	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	388	53	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	388	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	389	1	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	389	2	f	f	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	389	3	explains	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	389	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	389	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	389	6	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	389	7	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	389	8	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	389	9	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	389	10	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	389	11	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	389	12	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	389	13	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	389	14	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	389	15	actor	actor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	389	16	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	389	17	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	389	18	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	389	19	combine	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	389	20	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	389	21	another	another	PRON
inlawrev-20850	389	22	’s	’s	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	389	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	389	24	bring	bring	VERB
inlawrev-20850	389	25	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	389	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	389	27	harm.9	harm.9	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	389	28	6	6	NUM
inlawrev-20850	389	29	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	389	30	g	g	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	389	31	notes	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	389	32	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	389	33	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	389	34	situation	situation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	389	35	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	389	36	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	389	37	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	389	38	most	most	ADV
inlawrev-20850	389	39	frequently	frequently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	389	40	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	389	41	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	389	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	389	43	91	91	NUM
inlawrev-20850	389	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	390	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	390	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	390	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	390	6	345	345	NUM
inlawrev-20850	390	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	8	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	390	9	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	390	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	11	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	390	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	390	14	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	390	15	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	390	16	432(2	432(2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	390	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	19	1966	1966	NUM
inlawrev-20850	390	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	22	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	23	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	390	24	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	390	25	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	390	26	346	346	NUM
inlawrev-20850	390	27	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	28	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	390	29	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	390	30	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	31	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	390	32	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	390	34	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	390	35	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	390	36	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	390	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	391	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	391	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	391	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	391	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	391	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	391	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	391	7	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	391	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	391	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	392	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	392	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	392	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	392	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	392	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	392	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	393	1	92	92	NUM
inlawrev-20850	393	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	394	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	394	2	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	394	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	394	4	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	394	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	394	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	394	7	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	394	8	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	394	9	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	394	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	395	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	395	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	395	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	395	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	395	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	395	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	395	7	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	395	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	395	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	396	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	396	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	396	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	396	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	396	5	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	396	6	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	396	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	396	8	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	396	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	396	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	396	11	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	396	12	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	396	13	432(2	432(2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	396	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	396	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	396	16	1966	1966	NUM
inlawrev-20850	396	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	396	18	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	396	19	anderson	anderson	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	396	20	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	396	21	minneapolis	minneapolis	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	396	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	396	23	st	st	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	396	24	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	396	25	paul	paul	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	396	26	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	396	27	sault	sault	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	396	28	ste	ste	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	396	29	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	397	1	marie	marie	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	397	2	ry	ry	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	397	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	397	4	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	397	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	397	6	179	179	NUM
inlawrev-20850	397	7	n.w	n.w	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	397	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	397	9	45	45	NUM
inlawrev-20850	397	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	397	11	49	49	NUM
inlawrev-20850	397	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	397	13	minn	minn	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	397	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	397	15	1920	1920	NUM
inlawrev-20850	397	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	397	17	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	397	18	see	see	AUX
inlawrev-20850	397	19	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	397	20	text	text	VERB
inlawrev-20850	397	21	accompanying	accompanying	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	397	22	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	397	23	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	397	24	45	45	NUM
inlawrev-20850	397	25	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	397	26	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	397	27	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	397	28	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	397	29	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	397	30	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	397	31	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	397	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	398	1	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	398	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	398	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	398	4	only	only	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	398	5	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	398	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	398	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	398	8	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	398	9	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	398	10	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	398	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	398	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	398	13	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	398	14	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	398	15	deems	deem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	398	16	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	398	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	399	1	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	399	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	399	3	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	399	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	399	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	399	6	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	399	7	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	399	8	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	399	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	400	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	400	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	400	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	400	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	400	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	400	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	400	7	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	400	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	400	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	401	1	j	j	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	401	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	401	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	401	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	401	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	401	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	401	7	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	401	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	401	9	sole	sole	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	401	10	exception	exception	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	401	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	401	12	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	401	13	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	401	14	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	401	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	401	16	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	401	17	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	401	18	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	401	19	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	401	20	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	401	21	nothing	nothing	PRON
inlawrev-20850	401	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	401	23	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	401	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	401	25	determining	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	401	26	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	401	27	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	401	28	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	401	29	exists	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	401	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	401	31	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	401	32	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	401	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	402	1	93	93	NUM
inlawrev-20850	402	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	403	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	403	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	403	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	403	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	403	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	403	6	346	346	NUM
inlawrev-20850	403	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	403	8	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	403	9	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	403	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	403	11	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	403	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	403	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	403	14	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	403	15	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	403	16	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	403	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	404	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	404	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	404	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	404	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	404	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	404	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	404	7	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	404	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	404	9	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	404	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	404	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	404	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	405	1	94	94	X
inlawrev-20850	405	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	406	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	406	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	406	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	406	4	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	406	5	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	406	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	406	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	407	1	95	95	NUM
inlawrev-20850	407	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	408	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	408	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	408	3	accomplished	accomplish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	408	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	408	5	feat	feat	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	408	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	408	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	408	8	span	span	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	408	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	408	10	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	408	11	sentences	sentence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	408	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	409	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	409	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	409	3	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	409	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	409	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	409	6	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	409	7	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	409	8	presents	present	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	409	9	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	409	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	409	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	409	12	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	409	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	409	14	basic	basic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	409	15	definition	definition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	409	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	409	17	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	409	18	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	409	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	410	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	410	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	410	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	410	4	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	410	5	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	410	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	410	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	410	8	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	410	9	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	410	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	410	11	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	410	12	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	410	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	410	14	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	410	15	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	410	16	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	410	17	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	410	18	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	410	19	absent	absent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	410	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	410	21	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	410	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	410	23	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	410	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	411	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	411	2	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	411	3	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	411	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	411	5	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	411	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	411	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	411	8	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	411	9	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	411	10	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	411	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	412	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	412	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	412	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	412	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	412	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	412	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	412	7	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	412	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	412	9	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	412	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	412	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	412	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	413	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	413	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	413	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	413	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	413	5	stated	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	413	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	413	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	413	8	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	413	9	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	413	10	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	413	11	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	413	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	413	13	require	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	413	14	strict	strict	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	413	15	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	413	16	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	413	17	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	413	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	413	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	413	20	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	413	21	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	413	22	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	413	23	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	413	24	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	413	25	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	413	26	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-20850	413	27	today	today	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	413	28	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	413	29	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	413	30	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	413	31	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	413	32	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	413	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	413	34	exception	exception	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	413	35	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	413	36	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	413	37	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	413	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	413	39	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	413	40	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	413	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	413	42	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	414	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	414	2	d	d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	414	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	414	4	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	414	5	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	414	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	414	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	415	1	cf	cf	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	415	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	415	3	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	415	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	415	5	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	415	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	415	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	415	8	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	415	9	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	415	10	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	415	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	416	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	416	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	416	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	416	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	416	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	416	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	416	7	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	416	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	416	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	417	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	417	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	417	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	417	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	417	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	417	6	cautioning	caution	VERB
inlawrev-20850	417	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	417	8	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	417	9	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	417	10	distinguish	distinguish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	417	11	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	417	12	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	417	13	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	417	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	417	15	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	417	16	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	417	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	417	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	417	19	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	417	20	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	417	21	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	417	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	417	23	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	417	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	417	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	418	1	96	96	NUM
inlawrev-20850	418	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	419	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	419	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	419	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	419	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	419	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	419	6	346	346	NUM
inlawrev-20850	419	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	419	8	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	419	9	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	419	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	419	11	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	419	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	419	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	419	14	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	419	15	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	419	16	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	419	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	420	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	420	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	420	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	420	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	420	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	420	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	420	7	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	420	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	420	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	421	1	f	f	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	421	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	421	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	421	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	421	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	421	6	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	421	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	421	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	421	9	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	421	10	applies	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	421	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	421	12	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	421	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	421	14	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	421	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	421	16	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	421	17	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	421	18	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	421	19	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	421	20	actor	actor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	421	21	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	421	22	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	421	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	421	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	421	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	422	1	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	422	2	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	422	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	422	4	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	422	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	422	6	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	422	7	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	422	8	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	422	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	422	10	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	422	11	combined	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	422	12	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	422	13	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	422	14	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	422	15	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	422	16	persons	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	422	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	422	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	422	19	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	422	20	overdetermines	overdetermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	422	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	422	22	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	422	23	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	422	24	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	422	25	though	though	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	422	26	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	422	27	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	422	28	actor	actor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	422	29	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	422	30	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	422	31	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	422	32	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	422	33	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	422	34	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	422	35	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	422	36	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	422	37	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	422	38	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	422	39	another	another	DET
inlawrev-20850	422	40	’s	’s	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	422	41	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	422	42	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	422	43	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	422	44	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	422	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	423	1	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	423	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	423	3	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	4	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	423	6	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	423	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	8	133	133	NUM
inlawrev-20850	423	9	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	423	10	persons	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	11	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	423	12	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	423	13	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	423	14	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	423	15	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	423	16	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	423	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	423	19	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	423	20	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	423	22	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	423	23	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	423	24	the97	the97	VERB
inlawrev-20850	423	25	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	26	called	call	VERB
inlawrev-20850	423	27	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	423	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	423	29	scenario	scenario	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	30	closest	close	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	423	31	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	423	32	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-20850	423	33	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	34	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	423	35	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	423	36	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	423	37	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	423	38	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	39	contracts	contract	VERB
inlawrev-20850	423	40	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	423	41	disease9	disease9	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	42	8	8	NUM
inlawrev-20850	423	43	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	423	44	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	423	45	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	423	47	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	423	48	sues	sue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	423	49	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	423	50	actors	actor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	51	claiming	claim	VERB
inlawrev-20850	423	52	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	423	53	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	423	54	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	423	55	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	423	56	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	57	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	423	58	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	423	59	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	423	60	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	61	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	423	62	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	423	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	423	64	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	423	65	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	423	66	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	424	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	424	2	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	424	3	assumes	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	424	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	424	5	a99	a99	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	424	6	threshold	threshold	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	424	7	dose	dose	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	424	8	exists	exist	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	424	9	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	424	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	424	11	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	424	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	424	13	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	424	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	424	15	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	424	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	424	17	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	424	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	424	19	sick	sick	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	424	20	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	424	21	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	424	22	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	424	23	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	424	24	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	424	25	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	424	26	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	424	27	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	424	28	amount	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	424	29	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-20850	424	30	getting	get	VERB
inlawrev-20850	424	31	sick	sick	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	424	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	425	1	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	425	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	425	3	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	425	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	425	5	exceeded	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	425	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	425	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	425	8	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	425	9	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	425	10	overdetermined	overdetermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	425	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	425	12	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	425	13	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-20850	425	14	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	425	15	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	425	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	425	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	425	18	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	425	19	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	425	20	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	425	21	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	425	22	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	425	23	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	425	24	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	425	25	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	425	26	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	425	27	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	425	28	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	425	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	425	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	425	31	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	425	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	425	33	”100	”100	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	426	1	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	426	2	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
inlawrev-20850	426	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	426	4	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	426	5	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	426	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	426	7	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	426	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	426	9	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	426	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	426	11	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	426	12	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	426	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	426	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	426	15	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	426	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	426	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	426	18	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	426	19	prior	prior	ADV
inlawrev-20850	426	20	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	426	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	426	22	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	426	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	426	24	contracting	contract	VERB
inlawrev-20850	426	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	426	26	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	426	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	426	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	427	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	428	1	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	428	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	428	3	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	428	4	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	428	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	428	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	428	7	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	428	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	428	9	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	428	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	429	1	”101	”101	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	429	2	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	429	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	429	4	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	429	5	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	429	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	429	7	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	429	8	majority	majority	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	429	9	understood	understand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	429	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	429	11	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	429	12	g	g	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	429	13	seems	seem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	429	14	closely	closely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	429	15	analogous	analogous	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	429	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	429	17	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	429	18	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	429	19	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	429	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	430	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	430	2	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	430	3	disagreed	disagree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	430	4	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	430	5	whether102	whether102	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	430	6	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	430	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	430	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	430	9	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	430	10	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	430	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	430	12	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	430	13	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	430	14	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	430	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	430	16	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	430	17	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	430	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	430	19	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	430	20	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	430	21	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	430	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	430	23	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	430	24	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	430	25	correct	correct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	430	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	430	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	430	28	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	430	29	exists	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	430	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	430	31	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	430	32	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	430	33	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	430	34	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	430	35	tautological	tautological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	430	36	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	430	37	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	430	38	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	430	39	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	430	40	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	430	41	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	430	42	reached	reach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	430	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	430	44	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	430	45	presumably	presumably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	430	46	exceeded	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	430	47	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	430	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	430	49	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	430	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	431	1	straightforward	straightforward	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	431	2	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	431	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	431	4	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	431	5	g	g	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	431	6	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	431	7	suggest	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	431	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	431	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	431	10	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	431	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	431	12	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	431	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	431	14	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	431	15	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	431	16	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	431	17	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	431	18	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	431	19	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	431	20	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	431	21	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	431	22	along	along	ADP
inlawrev-20850	431	23	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	431	24	every	every	DET
inlawrev-20850	431	25	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	431	26	pre	pre	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	431	27	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	431	28	disease	disease	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	431	29	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	431	30	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	431	31	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	431	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	431	33	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	431	34	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	431	35	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	431	36	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	431	37	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	431	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	431	39	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	431	40	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	431	41	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	431	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	432	1	yet	yet	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	432	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	432	3	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	432	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	432	5	despite	despite	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	432	6	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	432	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	432	8	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	432	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	432	10	reached	reach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	432	11	exactly	exactly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	432	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	432	13	opposite	opposite	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	432	14	conclusion.103	conclusion.103	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	432	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	432	16	unacknowledged	unacknowledged	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	432	17	shift	shift	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	432	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	432	19	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	432	20	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	432	21	mattered	matter	VERB
inlawrev-20850	432	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	433	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	433	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	3	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	433	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	433	5	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	433	6	complexities	complexity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	433	8	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	433	9	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	433	10	scenarios	scenario	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	11	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	433	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	433	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	433	14	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	433	15	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	433	16	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	17	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	433	19	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	433	20	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	433	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	433	22	appreciate	appreciate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	433	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	433	24	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	433	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	433	26	comments	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	27	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	433	28	quoted.104	quoted.104	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	433	29	comments	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	30	f	f	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	433	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	433	32	g	g	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	433	33	treat	treat	VERB
inlawrev-20850	433	34	every	every	DET
inlawrev-20850	433	35	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	36	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	433	37	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	433	38	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	433	39	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	40	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	433	41	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	433	42	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	433	43	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	44	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	433	46	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	47	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	433	48	per	per	ADP
inlawrev-20850	433	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	433	50	comments	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	433	52	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	53	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	433	54	overdetermined	overdetermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	433	55	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	433	56	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	433	57	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	433	58	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	433	59	sets	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	433	60	exist	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	433	61	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	434	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	434	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	434	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	434	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	434	5	focused	focus	VERB
inlawrev-20850	434	6	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	434	7	the1	the1	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	434	8	0	0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	434	9	5	5	NUM
inlawrev-20850	434	10	relation	relation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	434	11	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	434	12	individually	individually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	434	13	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	434	14	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	434	15	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	434	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	435	1	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	435	2	relying	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	435	3	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	435	4	multiple106	multiple106	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	435	5	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	435	6	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	435	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	435	8	justify	justify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	435	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	435	10	abandonment	abandonment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	435	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	435	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	435	13	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	435	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	435	15	for	for	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	435	16	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	435	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	435	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	435	19	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	435	20	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	435	21	eased	ease	VERB
inlawrev-20850	435	22	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	435	23	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	435	24	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-20850	435	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	435	26	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	435	27	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	435	28	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	435	29	effectively	effectively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	435	30	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	435	31	every	every	DET
inlawrev-20850	435	32	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	435	33	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	435	34	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	435	35	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	435	36	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	435	37	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	435	38	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	435	39	overall	overall	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	435	40	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	435	41	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	435	42	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	435	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	435	44	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	435	45	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	435	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	435	47	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	435	48	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	435	49	97	97	NUM
inlawrev-20850	435	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	436	1	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	436	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	436	3	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	436	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	436	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	436	6	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	436	7	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	436	8	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	436	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	437	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	437	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	437	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	437	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	437	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	437	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	437	7	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	437	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	437	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	438	1	g	g	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	438	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	438	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	438	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	438	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	439	1	98	98	NUM
inlawrev-20850	439	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	440	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	440	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	440	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	440	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	440	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	440	6	346	346	NUM
inlawrev-20850	440	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	441	1	99	99	NUM
inlawrev-20850	441	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	441	3	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	441	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	441	5	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	441	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	441	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	441	8	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	441	9	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	441	10	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	441	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	442	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	442	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	442	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	442	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	442	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	442	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	442	7	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	442	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	442	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	443	1	g	g	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	443	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	443	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	443	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	443	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	444	1	100	100	NUM
inlawrev-20850	444	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	445	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	445	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	445	3	101	101	NUM
inlawrev-20850	445	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	446	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	446	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	446	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	446	4	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	446	5	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	446	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	446	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	447	1	102	102	NUM
inlawrev-20850	447	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	448	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	448	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	448	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	448	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	448	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	448	6	346	346	NUM
inlawrev-20850	448	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	448	8	103	103	NUM
inlawrev-20850	448	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	449	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	449	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	449	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	449	4	360	360	NUM
inlawrev-20850	449	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	450	1	104	104	NUM
inlawrev-20850	450	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	451	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	451	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	451	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	451	4	346	346	NUM
inlawrev-20850	451	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	452	1	105	105	NUM
inlawrev-20850	452	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	452	3	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	452	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	452	5	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	452	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	452	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	452	8	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	452	9	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	452	10	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	452	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	453	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	453	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	453	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	453	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	453	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	453	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	453	7	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	453	8	cmts	cmts	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	453	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	454	1	f	f	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	454	2	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	454	3	g	g	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	454	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	454	5	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	454	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	454	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	455	1	106	106	NUM
inlawrev-20850	455	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	456	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	456	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	456	3	bostic	bostic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	456	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	456	5	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	456	6	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	456	7	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	456	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	456	9	134	134	NUM
inlawrev-20850	456	10	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	456	11	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	456	12	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	457	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	457	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	457	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	457	4	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	457	5	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	457	6	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	457	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	458	1	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	ADP
inlawrev-20850	458	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	458	3	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	458	4	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	458	5	obligation	obligation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	458	6	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	458	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	458	8	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	458	9	substantial107	substantial107	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	458	10	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	458	11	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	458	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	458	13	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	458	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	458	15	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	458	16	insisted	insist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	458	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	458	18	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	458	19	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	458	20	hold	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	458	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	458	22	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	458	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	458	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	459	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	460	1	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	460	2	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	460	3	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	460	4	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	460	5	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	460	6	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	460	7	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	460	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	460	9	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	460	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	460	11	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	460	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	460	13	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	460	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	460	15	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	460	16	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	460	17	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	460	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	460	19	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	460	20	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	460	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	460	22	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	460	23	contracted	contract	VERB
inlawrev-20850	460	24	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	460	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	460	26	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	461	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	461	2	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	461	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	461	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	461	5	proceeded108	proceeded108	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	461	6	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	461	7	analyze	analyze	VERB
inlawrev-20850	461	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	461	9	meaning	meaning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	461	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	461	11	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	461	12	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	461	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	461	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	461	15	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	461	16	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	461	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	461	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	461	19	essence	essence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	461	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	461	21	demanded	demand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	461	22	exactly	exactly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	461	23	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	461	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	462	1	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	462	2	holdings	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	3	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	462	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	462	5	meaning	meaning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	462	7	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	462	8	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	9	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	462	10	mixing	mixing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	462	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	462	13	matching	match	VERB
inlawrev-20850	462	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	462	15	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	462	16	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	17	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	18	seeking	seek	VERB
inlawrev-20850	462	19	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	462	20	alternative	alternative	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	462	22	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	462	23	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	462	24	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	462	25	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	462	27	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	462	28	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	462	29	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	30	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	31	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	462	32	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	462	33	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	462	34	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	462	35	takes	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	462	36	considerable	considerable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	462	37	thought	thought	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	38	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	462	39	explain	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	462	40	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	462	41	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	462	42	distinguish	distinguish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	462	43	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	462	44	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	462	46	insubstantial	insubstantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	462	47	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	48	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	462	49	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	462	50	non	non	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	51	-	-	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	52	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	53	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	462	54	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	462	55	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	462	56	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	57	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	462	58	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	462	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	463	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	463	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	463	3	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	463	4	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	463	5	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	463	6	exception	exception	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	463	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	464	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	464	2	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	464	3	thinking	thinking	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	464	4	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	464	5	fuzzy	fuzzy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	464	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	465	1	in109	in109	VERB
inlawrev-20850	465	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	465	3	end	end	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	465	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	465	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	465	6	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	465	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	465	8	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	465	9	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	465	10	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	465	11	imposed	impose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	465	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	465	13	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	465	14	inappropriately	inappropriately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	465	15	stiffened	stiffen	VERB
inlawrev-20850	465	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	465	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	465	18	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	465	19	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	465	20	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	465	21	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	465	22	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	465	23	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	465	24	purported	purport	VERB
inlawrev-20850	465	25	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	465	26	relax	relax	VERB
inlawrev-20850	465	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	466	1	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	466	2	achieve	achieve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	466	3	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	466	4	outcome	outcome	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	466	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	466	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	466	7	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	466	8	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	466	9	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	466	10	invoked	invoke	VERB
inlawrev-20850	466	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	466	12	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	466	13	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	466	14	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	466	15	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	466	16	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	466	17	stage	stage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	466	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	466	19	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	466	20	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	466	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	467	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	467	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	3	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	467	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	467	5	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	467	6	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	467	7	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	8	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	9	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	467	10	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	467	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	467	12	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	467	13	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	467	14	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	467	15	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	467	17	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	467	18	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	467	19	minimum	minimum	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	467	20	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	467	22	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	23	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	467	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	467	25	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	467	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	467	27	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	467	28	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	29	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	467	31	effectively	effectively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	467	32	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	467	33	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	467	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	467	35	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	36	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	467	37	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	467	38	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	467	39	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	40	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	467	41	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	467	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	467	43	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	467	44	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	467	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	467	46	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	467	47	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	467	48	disease.110	disease.110	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	467	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	467	50	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	51	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	467	52	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	467	53	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	467	54	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	55	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	56	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	467	57	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	467	58	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	467	59	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	60	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	467	61	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	467	62	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	63	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	467	64	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	467	65	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	467	66	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	467	67	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	467	68	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	467	69	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	467	70	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	467	71	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	72	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	467	73	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	467	74	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	468	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	468	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	3	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	468	4	a111	a111	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	468	5	concurring	concurring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	6	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	7	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	468	9	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	468	10	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	468	11	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	468	12	mixed	mixed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	468	13	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	14	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	15	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	468	16	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	468	17	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	468	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	468	20	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	468	21	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	468	22	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	468	24	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	468	25	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	468	26	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	27	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	468	28	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	468	29	independently	independently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	468	30	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	468	31	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	468	32	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	468	33	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	34	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	468	35	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	468	36	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	468	37	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	468	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	468	39	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	40	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	468	41	infact.112	infact.112	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	42	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	468	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	468	44	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	468	45	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	468	46	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	468	47	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	468	48	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	468	49	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	50	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	468	51	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	468	52	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	468	53	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	468	54	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	55	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	56	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	468	57	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	468	58	causes.—the	causes.—the	DET
inlawrev-20850	468	59	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	468	60	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	61	announced	announce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	468	62	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	468	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	468	64	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	65	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	468	66	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	468	67	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	468	68	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	468	69	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	70	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	71	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	468	72	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	73	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	74	need	need	AUX
inlawrev-20850	468	75	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	468	76	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	468	77	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	468	78	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	79	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	468	80	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	468	81	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	468	82	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	83	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	468	84	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	85	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	468	86	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	468	87	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	468	88	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	468	89	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	468	90	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	91	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	468	92	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	468	93	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	94	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	468	95	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	468	96	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	468	97	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	468	98	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	468	99	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	100	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	468	101	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	468	102	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	468	103	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	104	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	468	105	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	106	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	468	107	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	468	108	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	468	109	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	110	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	468	111	producing	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	468	112	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	468	113	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	468	114	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	469	1	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	469	2	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	469	3	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	469	4	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	469	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	469	6	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	469	7	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	469	8	test?113	test?113	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	469	9	taking	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	469	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	469	11	page	page	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	469	12	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	469	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	469	14	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	469	15	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	469	16	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	469	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	469	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	469	19	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	469	20	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	469	21	equated	equate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	469	22	107	107	NUM
inlawrev-20850	469	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	470	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	470	2	infra	infra	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	470	3	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	470	4	iii.b.1	iii.b.1	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	470	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	471	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	471	2	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	471	3	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	471	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	471	5	virginia	virginia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	471	6	did	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	471	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	471	8	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	471	9	thing	thing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	471	10	via	via	ADP
inlawrev-20850	471	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	471	12	slightly	slightly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	471	13	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	471	14	pathway	pathway	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	471	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	472	1	ford	ford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	472	2	motor	motor	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	472	3	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	472	4	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	472	5	boomer	boomer	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	472	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	472	7	736	736	NUM
inlawrev-20850	472	8	s.e.2d	s.e.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	472	9	724	724	NUM
inlawrev-20850	472	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	472	11	va	va	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	472	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	472	13	2013	2013	NUM
inlawrev-20850	472	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	472	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	473	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	473	2	infra	infra	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	473	3	note	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	473	4	135	135	NUM
inlawrev-20850	473	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	473	6	108	108	NUM
inlawrev-20850	473	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	474	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	474	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	474	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	474	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	474	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	474	6	346	346	NUM
inlawrev-20850	474	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	475	1	109	109	NUM
inlawrev-20850	475	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	476	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	476	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	476	3	sienkiewicz	sienkiewicz	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	476	4	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	476	5	greif	greif	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	476	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	476	7	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	476	8	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	476	9	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	476	10	uksc	uksc	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	476	11	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	476	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	476	13	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	476	14	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	476	15	]	]	SYM
inlawrev-20850	476	16	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	476	17	wlr	wlr	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	476	18	523	523	NUM
inlawrev-20850	476	19	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	476	20	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	476	21	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	476	22	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	476	23	eng	eng	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	476	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	476	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	1	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	2	rutherford	rutherford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	3	v.	v.	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	477	4	owens	owens	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	6	illinois	illinois	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	8	941	941	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	9	p.2d	p.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	477	10	1203	1203	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	12	1220	1220	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	13	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	477	14	21	21	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	16	1223	1223	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	18	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	20	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	21	lohrmann	lohrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	22	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	23	pittsburgh	pittsburgh	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	24	corning	corning	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	25	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	26	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	28	728	728	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	29	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	477	30	1156	1156	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	32	1163	1163	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	33	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	34	4th	4th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	477	35	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	477	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	37	1986	1986	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	38	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	39	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	40	ford	ford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	41	motor	motor	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	42	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	44	736	736	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	45	s.e.2d	s.e.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	477	46	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	477	47	732	732	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	48	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	477	49	33	33	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	50	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	51	allen	allen	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	52	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	53	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	54	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	55	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	477	56	588	588	NUM
inlawrev-20850	477	57	f.	f.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	477	58	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	477	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	478	1	247	247	NUM
inlawrev-20850	478	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	478	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	478	4	utah	utah	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	478	5	1984	1984	NUM
inlawrev-20850	478	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	478	7	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	479	1	elam	elam	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	479	2	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	479	3	alcolac	alcolac	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	479	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	479	5	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	479	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	479	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	479	8	765	765	NUM
inlawrev-20850	479	9	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	479	10	42	42	NUM
inlawrev-20850	479	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	479	12	mo	mo	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	479	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	480	1	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	480	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	481	1	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	481	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	481	3	1988	1988	NUM
inlawrev-20850	481	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	481	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	482	1	110	110	NUM
inlawrev-20850	482	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	483	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	483	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	483	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	483	4	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	483	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	483	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	483	7	350	350	NUM
inlawrev-20850	483	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	483	9	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	483	10	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	483	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	483	12	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	483	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	483	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	484	1	111	111	NUM
inlawrev-20850	484	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	484	3	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	484	4	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	484	5	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	484	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	484	7	350	350	NUM
inlawrev-20850	484	8	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	484	9	51	51	NUM
inlawrev-20850	484	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	484	11	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	484	12	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	484	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	484	14	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	484	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	484	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	485	1	112	112	NUM
inlawrev-20850	485	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	486	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	486	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	486	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	486	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	486	5	351	351	NUM
inlawrev-20850	486	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	486	7	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	486	8	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	486	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	486	10	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	486	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	486	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	487	1	113	113	NUM
inlawrev-20850	487	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	488	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	488	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	488	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	488	4	346	346	NUM
inlawrev-20850	488	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	489	1	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	489	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	489	3	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	489	4	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	489	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	489	6	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	489	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	489	8	135	135	NUM
inlawrev-20850	489	9	substantiality	substantiality	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	489	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	489	11	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	489	12	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	489	13	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	489	14	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	489	15	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	489	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	490	1	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	490	2	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	490	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	490	4	an114	an114	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	490	5	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	490	6	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	490	7	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	490	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	490	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	490	10	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	490	11	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	490	12	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	490	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	490	14	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	490	15	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	490	16	quantify	quantify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	490	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	490	18	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	490	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	490	20	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	490	21	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	490	22	received	receive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	490	23	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	490	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	490	25	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	490	26	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	490	27	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	490	28	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	490	29	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	490	30	activity	activity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	490	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	491	1	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	491	2	reviewing	review	VERB
inlawrev-20850	491	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	491	4	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	491	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	491	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	491	7	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	491	8	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	491	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	491	10	plaintiffs115	plaintiffs115	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	491	11	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	491	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	491	13	introduce	introduce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	491	14	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	491	15	quantitative	quantitative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	491	16	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	491	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	491	18	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	491	19	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	491	20	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	491	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	491	22	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	491	23	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	491	24	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	491	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	491	26	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	491	27	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	491	28	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	491	29	mud.116	mud.116	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	491	30	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	491	31	holdings	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	491	32	alone	alone	ADV
inlawrev-20850	491	33	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	491	34	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	491	35	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	491	36	adequate	adequate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	491	37	for	for	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	491	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	491	39	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	491	40	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	491	41	dispose	dispose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	491	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	491	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	491	44	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	491	45	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	491	46	render	render	VERB
inlawrev-20850	491	47	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	491	48	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	491	49	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	491	50	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	491	51	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	491	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	492	1	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	492	2	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	492	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	492	4	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	492	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	492	6	said	say	VERB
inlawrev-20850	492	7	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	492	8	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	492	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	493	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	493	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	493	3	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	493	4	willett	willett	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	493	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	493	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	493	7	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-20850	493	8	justices	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	493	9	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	493	10	fully	fully	ADV
inlawrev-20850	493	11	joined117	joined117	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	493	12	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	493	13	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	493	14	chose	choose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	493	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	493	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	493	17	write	write	VERB
inlawrev-20850	493	18	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-20850	493	19	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	493	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	493	21	meaning	meaning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	493	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	493	23	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	493	24	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	493	25	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	493	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	493	27	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	493	28	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	493	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	493	30	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	494	1	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	494	2	answered	answer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	494	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	494	4	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	494	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	494	7	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	494	8	incipient	incipient	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	494	10	their118	their118	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	494	11	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	494	13	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	494	14	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	494	15	essential	essential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	494	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	494	17	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	494	18	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	19	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	494	20	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	494	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	494	22	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	23	did	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	494	24	present	present	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	494	25	satisfactory	satisfactory	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	494	26	quantitative	quantitative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	494	27	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	494	29	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	494	31	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	494	32	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	494	33	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	34	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	494	35	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	36	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	494	37	containing	contain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	494	38	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	39	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	494	40	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	494	41	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	494	42	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	43	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	494	44	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	494	45	enough	enough	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	494	46	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	494	47	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	494	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	494	49	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	494	50	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	494	51	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	52	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	494	53	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	54	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	494	55	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	56	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	494	57	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	494	58	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	494	59	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	494	60	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	495	1	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	495	2	answer	answer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	495	3	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	495	4	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	495	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	495	6	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	495	7	looked	look	VERB
inlawrev-20850	495	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	495	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	495	10	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	495	11	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	495	12	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	495	13	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	495	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	495	15	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	495	16	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	495	17	pharmaceuticals	pharmaceuticals	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	495	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	495	19	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	495	20	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	496	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	496	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	496	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	497	1	adapting	adapt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	497	2	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	497	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	497	4	havner’s119	havner’s119	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	497	5	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	497	6	insights	insight	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	7	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	497	8	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	497	9	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	497	10	integrated	integrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	497	11	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	497	12	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-20850	497	13	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	14	here	here	ADV
inlawrev-20850	497	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	497	16	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	497	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	497	18	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	19	held120	held120	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	497	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	497	21	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	497	22	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	497	23	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	497	24	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	497	25	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	26	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	497	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	497	29	absence	absence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	497	31	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	497	32	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	497	34	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	497	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	497	37	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	38	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	497	39	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	497	40	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	497	41	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	497	42	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	497	43	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	497	44	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	45	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	497	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	497	47	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	48	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	497	49	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	50	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	497	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	497	52	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	53	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	497	54	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	55	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	497	56	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	497	57	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	497	58	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	497	59	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	60	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	497	61	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	62	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	497	63	contracting	contract	VERB
inlawrev-20850	497	64	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	497	65	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	497	66	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	498	1	”121	”121	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	498	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	498	3	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	498	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	498	5	breathtakingly	breathtakingly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	498	6	inconsistent	inconsistent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	498	7	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	498	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	498	9	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	498	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	498	11	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	498	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	498	13	infact	infact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	498	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	498	15	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	498	16	sound	sound	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	498	17	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	498	18	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	498	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	499	1	once	once	ADV
inlawrev-20850	499	2	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-20850	499	3	shifting	shift	VERB
inlawrev-20850	499	4	sub	sub	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	499	5	silentio	silentio	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	499	6	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	499	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	499	8	paradigm	paradigm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	499	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	499	10	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	499	11	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	499	12	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	499	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	499	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	499	15	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	499	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	499	17	immediately	immediately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	499	18	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	499	19	announcing	announce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	499	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	499	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	499	22	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	499	23	need	need	AUX
inlawrev-20850	499	24	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	499	25	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	499	26	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	499	27	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	499	28	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	499	29	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	499	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	499	31	imposed	impose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	499	32	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	499	33	evidentiary	evidentiary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	499	34	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	499	35	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	499	36	most	most	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	499	37	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	499	38	recognize	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	499	39	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	499	40	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	499	41	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	499	42	for	for	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	499	43	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	499	44	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	499	45	equivalent	equivalent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	499	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	500	1	understanding	understand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	500	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	500	3	shift	shift	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	500	4	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	500	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	500	6	basic	basic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	500	7	understanding	understanding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	500	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	500	9	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	500	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	500	11	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	500	12	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	500	13	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	500	14	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	500	15	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	500	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	500	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	500	18	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	500	19	central	central	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	500	20	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	500	21	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	500	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	500	23	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	500	24	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	500	25	borrowed	borrow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	500	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	501	1	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-20850	501	2	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	501	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	501	4	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	501	5	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	501	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	501	7	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	501	8	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	501	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	501	10	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	501	11	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	501	12	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	501	13	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	501	14	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	501	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	501	16	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	501	17	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	501	18	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	501	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	501	20	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	501	21	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	501	22	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	501	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	501	24	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	501	25	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	501	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	501	27	maternal	maternal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	501	28	ingestion	ingestion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	501	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	501	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	501	31	anti	anti	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	501	32	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	501	33	nausea	nausea	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	501	34	drug	drug	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	501	35	bendectin	bendectin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	501	36	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	501	37	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	501	38	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	501	39	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	501	40	114	114	NUM
inlawrev-20850	501	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	502	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	502	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	502	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	502	4	349	349	NUM
inlawrev-20850	502	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	502	6	51	51	NUM
inlawrev-20850	502	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	502	8	115	115	NUM
inlawrev-20850	502	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	503	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	503	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	503	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	503	4	353	353	NUM
inlawrev-20850	503	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	503	6	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	503	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	503	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	503	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	503	10	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	503	11	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	503	12	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	503	13	quantified	quantify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	503	14	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	503	15	need	need	AUX
inlawrev-20850	503	16	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	503	17	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	503	18	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	503	19	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	503	20	mathematical	mathematical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	503	21	precision	precision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	503	22	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	503	23	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	503	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	504	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	504	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	504	3	explained	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	504	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	504	5	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	504	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	504	7	extend[ed	extend[ed	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	504	8	]	]	X
inlawrev-20850	504	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	504	10	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	504	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	504	12	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	504	13	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	504	14	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	504	15	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	504	16	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	504	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	504	18	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	504	19	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	504	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	505	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	505	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	505	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	505	4	342	342	NUM
inlawrev-20850	505	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	506	1	116	116	NUM
inlawrev-20850	506	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	507	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	507	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	507	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	507	4	356	356	NUM
inlawrev-20850	507	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	507	6	359	359	NUM
inlawrev-20850	507	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	507	8	60	60	NUM
inlawrev-20850	507	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	507	10	117	117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	507	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	508	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	508	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	508	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	508	4	364	364	NUM
inlawrev-20850	508	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	508	6	guzman	guzman	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	508	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	508	8	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	508	9	concurring	concurring	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	508	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	508	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	508	12	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	508	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	508	14	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	508	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	508	16	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	508	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	508	18	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	508	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	508	20	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	508	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	508	22	needed	need	VERB
inlawrev-20850	508	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	508	24	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	508	25	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	508	26	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	508	27	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	508	28	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	508	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	508	30	approximate	approximate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	508	31	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	508	32	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	508	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	508	34	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	508	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	508	36	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	508	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	508	38	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	508	39	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	508	40	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	508	41	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	508	42	do	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	508	43	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	508	44	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	508	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	509	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	509	2	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	509	3	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	509	4	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	509	5	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	509	6	presented	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	509	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	509	8	support	support	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	509	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	509	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	509	11	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	509	12	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	509	13	discussed	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	509	14	infra	infra	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	509	15	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	509	16	331	331	NUM
inlawrev-20850	509	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	510	1	118	118	NUM
inlawrev-20850	510	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	511	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	511	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	511	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	511	4	346	346	NUM
inlawrev-20850	511	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	512	1	119	119	NUM
inlawrev-20850	512	2	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	512	3	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	512	4	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	512	5	706	706	NUM
inlawrev-20850	512	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	512	7	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	512	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	512	9	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	512	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	512	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	513	1	120	120	NUM
inlawrev-20850	513	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	514	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	514	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	514	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	514	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	514	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	514	6	347	347	NUM
inlawrev-20850	514	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	515	1	121	121	NUM
inlawrev-20850	515	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	516	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	516	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	516	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	516	4	353	353	NUM
inlawrev-20850	516	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	516	6	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	516	7	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	516	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	516	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	517	1	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-20850	517	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	517	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	517	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	518	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	518	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	518	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	518	4	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	518	5	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	518	6	defect	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	518	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	519	1	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	519	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	519	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	519	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	519	5	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	519	6	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	519	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	519	8	key	key	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	519	9	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	519	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	519	11	both	both	DET
inlawrev-20850	519	12	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	519	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	519	14	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	519	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	519	16	causal122	causal122	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	519	17	arguments	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	519	18	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	519	19	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	519	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	520	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	520	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	520	3	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	520	4	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	520	5	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	520	6	dispute	dispute	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	520	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	520	8	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	520	9	causes	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	520	10	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	520	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	520	12	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	520	13	serious	serious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	520	14	dispute	dispute	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	520	15	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	520	16	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	520	17	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	520	18	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	520	19	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	520	20	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	520	21	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	520	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	520	23	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	520	24	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	520	25	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	520	26	exposure(s	exposure(s	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	520	27	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	520	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	520	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	520	30	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	520	31	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	520	32	defendant(s	defendant(s	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	520	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	520	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	520	35	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	520	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	520	37	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	520	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	521	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	521	2	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	521	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	521	4	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	521	5	bendectin	bendectin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	521	6	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	521	7	kelly	kelly	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	521	8	havner123	havner123	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	521	9	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	521	10	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	521	11	born	bear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	521	12	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	521	13	missing	miss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	521	14	fingers	finger	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	521	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	521	16	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	521	17	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	521	18	indisputably	indisputably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	521	19	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	521	20	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	521	21	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	521	22	bendectin;124	bendectin;124	ADP
inlawrev-20850	521	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	521	24	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	521	25	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	521	26	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	521	27	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	521	28	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	521	29	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	521	30	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	521	31	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	521	32	all	all	ADV
inlawrev-20850	521	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	521	34	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	521	35	less	less	ADV
inlawrev-20850	521	36	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	521	37	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	521	38	limb	limb	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	521	39	reduction	reduction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	521	40	specifically	specifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	521	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	522	1	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	522	2	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	522	3	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	522	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	522	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	522	6	scientific1	scientific1	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	522	7	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	522	8	5	5	NUM
inlawrev-20850	522	9	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	522	10	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	522	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	522	12	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	522	13	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	522	14	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	522	15	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	522	16	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	522	17	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	522	18	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	522	19	unreliable	unreliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	522	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	522	21	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	522	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	522	23	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	522	24	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	522	25	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	522	26	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	522	27	constitute	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	522	28	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	522	29	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	522	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	522	31	causation.126	causation.126	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	522	32	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	522	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	522	34	havners	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	522	35	rel[ied	rel[ie	VERB
inlawrev-20850	522	36	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	522	37	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	522	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	522	39	considerable	considerable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	522	40	extent	extent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	522	41	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	522	42	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	522	43	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	522	44	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	522	45	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	522	46	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	522	47	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	522	48	bendectin	bendectin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	522	49	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	522	50	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	522	51	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	522	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	523	1	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	523	2	definition	definition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	523	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	523	4	epidemiology127	epidemiology127	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	523	5	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	523	6	groups	group	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	523	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	523	8	people	people	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	523	9	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	523	10	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	523	11	individuals	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	523	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	523	13	seeking	seek	VERB
inlawrev-20850	523	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	523	15	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	523	16	pertinent	pertinent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	523	17	here	here	ADV
inlawrev-20850	523	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	523	19	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	523	20	122	122	NUM
inlawrev-20850	523	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	524	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	524	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	524	3	gerald	gerald	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	524	4	w.	w.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	524	5	boston	boston	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	524	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	524	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	524	8	mass	mass	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	524	9	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	524	10	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	524	11	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	524	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	524	13	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	524	14	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	524	15	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	524	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	524	17	content	content	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	524	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	524	19	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	524	20	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	524	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	524	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	524	23	regulatory	regulatory	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	524	24	experience	experience	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	524	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	524	26	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-20850	524	27	colum	colum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	524	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	525	1	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	525	2	envtl	envtl	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	525	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	526	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	526	2	181	181	NUM
inlawrev-20850	526	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	526	4	195	195	NUM
inlawrev-20850	526	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	526	6	201	201	NUM
inlawrev-20850	526	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	526	8	1993	1993	NUM
inlawrev-20850	526	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	527	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	527	2	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	527	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	527	4	mass	mass	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	527	5	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	527	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	527	7	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	527	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	527	9	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	527	10	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	527	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	527	12	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	527	13	marc	marc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	527	14	galanter	galanter	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	527	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	527	16	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	527	17	congregations	congregation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	527	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	527	19	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	527	20	careers	career	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	527	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	527	22	24	24	NUM
inlawrev-20850	527	23	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	527	24	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	527	25	soc’y	soc’y	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	527	26	rev	rev	VERB
inlawrev-20850	527	27	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	527	28	371	371	NUM
inlawrev-20850	527	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	527	30	372	372	NUM
inlawrev-20850	527	31	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	527	32	1990	1990	NUM
inlawrev-20850	527	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	527	34	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	527	35	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	527	36	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	527	37	features	feature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	527	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	527	39	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	527	40	congregations	congregation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	527	41	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	527	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	528	1	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	528	2	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	528	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	528	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	528	5	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	528	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	528	7	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	528	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	528	9	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	528	10	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	528	11	dwarfs	dwarf	VERB
inlawrev-20850	528	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	528	13	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	528	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	528	15	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	528	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	528	17	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	528	18	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	528	19	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	528	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	529	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	529	2	joseph	joseph	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	529	3	sanders	sanders	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	529	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	529	5	bendectin	bendectin	ADV
inlawrev-20850	529	6	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	529	7	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	529	8	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	529	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	529	10	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	529	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	529	12	mass	mass	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	529	13	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	529	14	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	529	15	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-20850	529	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	529	17	1998	1998	NUM
inlawrev-20850	529	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	529	19	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	529	20	explaining	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	529	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	529	22	fifty	fifty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	529	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	529	24	100	100	NUM
inlawrev-20850	529	25	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	529	26	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	529	27	filed	file	VERB
inlawrev-20850	529	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	529	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	529	30	potential	potential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	529	31	universe	universe	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	529	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	529	33	6,000	6,000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	529	34	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	529	35	16,000	16,000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	529	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	529	37	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	529	38	sanders	sander	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	529	39	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	529	40	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	529	41	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	529	42	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	529	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	529	44	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	529	45	1154	1154	NUM
inlawrev-20850	529	46	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	529	47	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	529	48	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	529	49	hundreds	hundred	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	529	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	529	51	thousands	thousand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	529	52	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	529	53	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	529	54	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	529	55	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	529	56	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	529	57	filed	file	VERB
inlawrev-20850	529	58	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	529	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	530	1	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	530	2	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	530	3	reasons	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	4	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	530	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	530	6	difference	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	7	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	530	8	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	530	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	530	10	vast	vast	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	530	11	difference	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	530	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	530	14	quality	quality	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	530	16	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	530	18	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	19	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	530	20	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	21	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	530	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	530	24	difference	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	25	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	530	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	530	27	extent	extent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	530	29	duration	duration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	530	31	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	32	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	530	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	530	34	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	530	36	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	530	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	530	39	alleged	allege	VERB
inlawrev-20850	530	40	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	530	42	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	530	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	530	44	difference	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	45	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	530	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	530	47	availability	availability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	48	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	530	49	financially	financially	ADV
inlawrev-20850	530	50	viable	viable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	530	51	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	530	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	531	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	531	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	531	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	531	4	1154	1154	NUM
inlawrev-20850	531	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	531	6	55	55	NUM
inlawrev-20850	531	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	531	8	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	531	9	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	531	10	accounting	account	VERB
inlawrev-20850	531	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	531	12	longevity	longevity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	531	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	531	14	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	531	15	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	531	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	531	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	532	1	123	123	NUM
inlawrev-20850	532	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	533	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	533	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	533	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	533	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	533	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	533	6	341	341	NUM
inlawrev-20850	533	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	533	8	124	124	NUM
inlawrev-20850	533	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	534	2	michael	michael	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	534	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	534	4	green	green	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	534	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	6	bendectin	bendectin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	534	8	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	9	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	10	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	534	12	challenges	challenge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	534	14	mass	mass	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	534	15	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	534	16	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	17	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	18	90	90	NUM
inlawrev-20850	534	19	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	20	1996	1996	NUM
inlawrev-20850	534	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	22	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	23	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	534	24	development	development	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	26	approval	approval	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	534	29	marketing	marketing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	534	31	bendectin	bendectin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	32	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	33	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	34	sanders	sander	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	36	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	534	37	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	534	38	122	122	NUM
inlawrev-20850	534	39	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	40	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	534	41	214	214	NUM
inlawrev-20850	534	42	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	43	identifying	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	534	44	various	various	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	534	45	iterations	iteration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	46	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	534	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	534	48	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	534	49	corporation	corporation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	50	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	534	51	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	52	bendectin	bendectin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	534	53	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	534	54	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	534	55	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	56	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	534	57	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	535	1	125	125	NUM
inlawrev-20850	535	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	536	1	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	536	2	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	536	3	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	536	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	536	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	536	6	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	536	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	537	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	537	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	537	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	537	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	537	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	537	6	706	706	NUM
inlawrev-20850	537	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	537	8	708	708	NUM
inlawrev-20850	537	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	537	10	09	09	NUM
inlawrev-20850	537	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	537	12	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	537	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	537	14	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	537	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	537	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	538	1	126	126	X
inlawrev-20850	538	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	539	1	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	539	2	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	539	3	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	539	4	both	both	PRON
inlawrev-20850	539	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	539	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	7	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	539	8	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	539	9	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	10	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	539	11	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	539	12	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	539	13	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	539	14	admitted	admit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	539	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	539	16	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	539	17	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	539	18	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	539	19	709	709	NUM
inlawrev-20850	539	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	539	21	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	539	22	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	539	24	motion	motion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	25	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	539	26	limine	limine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	539	28	exclude	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	539	29	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	30	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	539	31	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	539	32	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	33	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	539	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	539	36	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	539	37	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	539	38	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	539	39	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	539	40	admissible	admissible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	539	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	539	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	539	43	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	44	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	539	45	too	too	ADV
inlawrev-20850	539	46	unreliable	unreliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	539	47	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	539	48	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	539	49	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	539	50	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	539	51	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	52	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	539	53	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	54	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	539	55	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	539	56	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	539	57	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	539	58	711	711	NUM
inlawrev-20850	539	59	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	539	60	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	539	61	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	62	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	539	63	motion	motion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	64	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	539	65	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	66	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	539	67	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	539	68	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	540	1	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	540	2	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	540	3	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	540	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	540	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	540	6	daubert	daubert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	540	7	reliability	reliability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	540	8	/	/	SYM
inlawrev-20850	540	9	fit	fit	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	540	10	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	540	11	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	540	12	admissibility	admissibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	540	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	540	14	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	540	15	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	540	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	541	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	541	2	e.i	e.i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	541	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	541	4	du	du	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	541	5	pont	pont	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	541	6	de	de	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	541	7	nemours	nemours	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	541	8	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	541	9	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	542	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	542	2	robinson	robinson	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	542	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	4	923	923	NUM
inlawrev-20850	542	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	542	6	549	549	NUM
inlawrev-20850	542	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	8	556	556	NUM
inlawrev-20850	542	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	542	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	542	12	1995	1995	NUM
inlawrev-20850	542	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	15	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	542	16	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	542	17	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	542	18	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	542	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	542	20	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	542	21	702	702	NUM
inlawrev-20850	542	22	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	23	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	542	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	542	25	proponent	proponent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	542	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	542	27	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	542	28	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	542	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	542	30	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	542	31	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	542	32	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	542	33	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	542	34	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	542	35	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	542	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	542	37	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	542	38	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	542	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	542	40	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	542	41	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	542	42	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	542	43	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	542	44	upon	upon	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	542	45	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	542	46	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	542	47	foundation	foundation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	542	48	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	49	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	50	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	51	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	542	52	daubert	daubert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	542	53	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	542	54	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	542	55	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	542	56	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	542	57	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	58	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	59	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	542	60	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	542	61	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	62	509	509	NUM
inlawrev-20850	542	63	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	542	64	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	542	65	579	579	NUM
inlawrev-20850	542	66	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	67	1993	1993	NUM
inlawrev-20850	542	68	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	69	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	542	70	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	543	1	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	543	2	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	543	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	543	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	543	5	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	543	6	verdict	verdict	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	543	7	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	543	8	grounds	ground	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	543	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	543	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	543	11	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	543	12	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	543	13	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	543	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	543	15	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	543	16	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	543	17	specified	specify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	543	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	543	19	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	543	20	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	543	21	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	543	22	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	543	23	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	543	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	543	25	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	543	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	544	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	544	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	544	3	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	544	4	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	544	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	544	6	711	711	NUM
inlawrev-20850	544	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	544	8	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	544	9	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	544	10	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	544	11	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	544	12	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	544	13	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	544	14	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	544	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	544	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	544	17	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	544	18	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	544	19	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	544	20	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	544	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	544	22	probative	probative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	544	23	force	force	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	544	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	544	25	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	544	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	544	27	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	544	28	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	544	29	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	544	30	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	544	31	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	544	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	545	1	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-20850	545	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	546	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	546	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	546	3	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	546	4	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	546	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	546	6	715	715	NUM
inlawrev-20850	546	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	547	1	http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/3053686	http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/3053686	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	547	2	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	547	3	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	547	4	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	5	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	6	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	547	7	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	547	8	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	9	137	137	NUM
inlawrev-20850	547	10	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	11	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	547	12	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	14	suspected	suspect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	15	toxins	toxin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	547	17	associated	associate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	18	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	19	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	20	occurrence	occurrence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	22	diseases	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	23	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	547	24	conditions	condition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	25	suspected	suspect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	547	27	result	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	28	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	29	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	547	30	exposure.128	exposure.128	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	31	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	547	32	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	547	33	diseases	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	35	interest	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	36	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	547	37	occur	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	38	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	547	39	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	40	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	547	41	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	42	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	547	44	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	547	45	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	547	46	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	48	interest	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	49	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	547	50	occur	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	51	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	547	52	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	53	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	547	54	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	55	resulting	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	56	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	57	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	547	58	often	often	ADV
inlawrev-20850	547	59	epidemiology	epidemiology	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	60	fundamentally	fundamentally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	547	61	measures	measure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	62	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	63	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	547	64	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	547	65	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	547	66	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	67	exists	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	68	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	547	69	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	547	70	deemed	deem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	71	causal	causal	ADV
inlawrev-20850	547	72	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	547	73	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	547	74	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	75	yield	yield	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	76	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	547	77	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	78	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	547	79	statistical129	statistical129	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	547	80	measures	measure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	81	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	547	82	quantify	quantify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	83	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	547	84	subject	subject	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	547	85	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	86	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	547	87	vagaries	vagary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	88	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	89	sampling	sample	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	90	error	error	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	91	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	547	92	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	547	93	extent130	extent130	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	547	94	131	131	NUM
inlawrev-20850	547	95	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	547	96	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	547	97	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	98	increases	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	99	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	547	100	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	101	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	102	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	103	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	547	104	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	105	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	547	106	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	107	faced	face	VERB
inlawrev-20850	547	108	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	547	109	unexposed	unexposed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	547	110	people	people	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	547	111	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	548	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	548	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	548	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	548	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	548	5	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	548	6	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	548	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	548	8	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	548	9	spent	spend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	548	10	considerable	considerable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	548	11	energy	energy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	548	12	grappling	grappling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	548	13	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	548	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	548	15	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	548	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	548	17	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	548	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	548	19	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	548	20	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	548	21	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	548	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	548	23	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	548	24	group	group	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	548	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	548	26	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	548	27	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	548	28	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	548	29	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	548	30	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	548	31	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	548	32	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	548	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	548	34	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	548	35	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	548	36	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	548	37	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	548	38	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	548	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	549	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	549	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	549	3	framed	frame	VERB
inlawrev-20850	549	4	the132	the132	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	549	5	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	549	6	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	549	7	follows	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	549	8	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	549	9	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	549	10	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	549	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	549	12	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	549	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	549	14	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	549	15	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	549	16	capable	capable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	549	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	549	18	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	549	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	549	20	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	549	21	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	549	22	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	549	23	condition	condition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	549	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	549	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	549	26	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	549	27	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	549	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	549	29	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	549	30	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	549	31	128	128	NUM
inlawrev-20850	549	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	550	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	550	2	gary	gary	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	550	3	h.	h.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	550	4	spivey	spivey	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	550	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	550	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	550	7	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	550	8	method	method	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	550	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	550	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	550	11	environmental	environmental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	550	12	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	550	13	9	9	NUM
inlawrev-20850	550	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	550	15	14	14	NUM
inlawrev-20850	550	16	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	550	17	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-20850	550	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	550	19	william	william	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	550	20	m.	m.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	550	21	draper	draper	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	550	22	ed	ed	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	550	23	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	550	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	550	25	1994	1994	NUM
inlawrev-20850	550	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	550	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	551	1	129	129	NUM
inlawrev-20850	551	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	552	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	552	2	mere	mere	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	552	3	existence	existence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	552	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	552	5	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	552	6	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	552	7	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	552	8	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	552	9	necessarily	necessarily	ADV
inlawrev-20850	552	10	mean	mean	VERB
inlawrev-20850	552	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	552	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	552	13	observed	observed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	552	14	increase	increase	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	552	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	552	16	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	552	17	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	552	18	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	552	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	553	1	epidemiologists	epidemiologist	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	553	2	typically	typically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	553	3	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	553	4	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	553	5	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	553	6	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	553	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	553	8	suite	suite	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	553	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	553	10	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	553	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	553	12	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	553	13	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	553	14	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	553	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	553	16	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	553	17	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	553	18	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	553	19	observed	observed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	553	20	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	553	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	554	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	554	2	austin	austin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	554	3	bradford	bradford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	554	4	hill	hill	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	554	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	554	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	554	7	environment	environment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	554	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	554	9	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	554	10	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	554	11	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	554	12	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	554	13	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	554	14	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	554	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	554	16	58	58	NUM
inlawrev-20850	554	17	proc	proc	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	554	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	555	1	royal	royal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	555	2	soc’y	soc’y	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	555	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	555	4	med	med	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	555	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	555	6	295	295	NUM
inlawrev-20850	555	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	555	8	1965	1965	NUM
inlawrev-20850	555	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	555	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	556	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	556	2	purposes	purpose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	556	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	556	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	556	5	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	556	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	556	7	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	556	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	556	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	556	10	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	556	11	role	role	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	556	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	556	13	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	556	14	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	556	15	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	556	16	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	556	17	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	556	18	prescribed	prescribe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	556	19	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	556	20	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	556	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	556	22	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	556	23	assume	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	556	24	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	556	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	556	26	observed	observe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	556	27	increases	increase	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	556	28	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	556	29	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	556	30	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	556	31	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	556	32	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	556	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	557	1	130	130	NUM
inlawrev-20850	557	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	558	1	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	558	2	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	558	3	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	558	4	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	558	5	reported	report	VERB
inlawrev-20850	558	6	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	558	7	any	any	PRON
inlawrev-20850	558	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	558	9	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	558	10	values	value	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	558	11	depending	depend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	558	12	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	558	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	558	14	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	558	15	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	558	16	design	design	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	558	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	559	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	559	2	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	559	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	559	4	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	559	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	559	6	cohort	cohort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	559	7	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	559	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	559	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	559	10	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	559	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	559	12	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	559	13	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	559	14	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	559	15	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	559	16	sample	sample	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	559	17	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	559	18	compared	compare	VERB
inlawrev-20850	559	19	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	559	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	559	21	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	559	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	559	23	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	559	24	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	559	25	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	559	26	unexposed	unexposed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	559	27	sample	sample	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	559	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	559	29	reported	report	VERB
inlawrev-20850	559	30	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	559	31	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	559	32	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	559	33	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	559	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	559	35	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	560	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	560	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	560	3	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	560	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	560	5	control	control	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	560	6	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	560	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	560	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	560	9	likelihood	likelihood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	560	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	560	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	560	12	sick	sick	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	560	13	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	560	14	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	560	15	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	560	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	560	17	compared	compare	VERB
inlawrev-20850	560	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	560	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	560	20	likelihood	likelihood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	560	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	560	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	560	23	healthy	healthy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	560	24	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	560	25	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	560	26	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	560	27	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	560	28	reported	report	VERB
inlawrev-20850	560	29	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	560	30	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	560	31	odds	odd	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	560	32	ratio	ratio	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	560	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	560	34	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	561	1	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	561	2	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	561	3	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	561	4	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	561	5	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	561	6	reported	report	VERB
inlawrev-20850	561	7	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	561	8	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	561	9	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	561	10	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	561	11	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	561	12	fraction	fraction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	561	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	561	14	standardized	standardize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	561	15	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	561	16	ratio	ratio	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	561	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	561	18	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	561	19	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	561	20	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	561	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	561	22	studied	study	VERB
inlawrev-20850	561	23	outcome	outcome	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	561	24	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	561	25	death	death	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	561	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	561	27	standardized	standardize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	561	28	mortality	mortality	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	561	29	ratio	ratio	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	561	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	562	1	conceptually	conceptually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	562	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	562	3	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	562	4	measures	measure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	562	5	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	562	6	describe	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	562	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	562	8	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	562	9	thing	thing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	562	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	563	2	green	green	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	563	3	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	563	4	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	563	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	563	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	7	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	563	8	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	9	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-20850	563	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	11	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	563	12	348	348	NUM
inlawrev-20850	563	13	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	563	14	52	52	NUM
inlawrev-20850	563	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	16	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	563	17	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	563	18	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	20	odds	odd	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	21	ratio	ratio	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	563	24	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	563	25	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	27	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	28	maryfran	maryfran	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	29	sowers	sower	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	31	design	design	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	32	methods	method	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	33	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	563	34	occupational	occupational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	563	35	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	563	36	environmental	environmental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	563	37	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	39	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	563	40	environmental	environmental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	563	41	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	43	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	563	44	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	563	45	128	128	NUM
inlawrev-20850	563	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	47	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	563	48	21	21	NUM
inlawrev-20850	563	49	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	50	25	25	NUM
inlawrev-20850	563	51	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	52	explaining	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	563	53	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	563	54	odds	odd	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	55	ratio	ratio	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	56	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	57	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	563	58	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	563	59	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	563	60	surrogate	surrogate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	563	61	estimate	estimate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	62	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	563	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	563	64	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	563	65	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	563	66	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	67	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	68	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	563	69	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	564	1	131	131	X
inlawrev-20850	564	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	565	1	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	565	2	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	565	3	holds	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	565	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	565	5	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	565	6	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	565	7	measuring	measure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	565	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	565	9	characteristic	characteristic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	565	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	565	11	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	565	12	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	565	13	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	565	14	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	565	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	565	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	565	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	565	18	sample	sample	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	565	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	565	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	565	21	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	565	22	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	565	23	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	565	24	approximate	approximate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	565	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	565	26	value	value	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	565	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	565	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	565	29	measurement	measurement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	565	30	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	565	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	565	32	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	565	33	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	565	34	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	565	35	whole	whole	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	565	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	566	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	566	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	566	3	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	566	4	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	566	5	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	566	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	566	7	reported	report	VERB
inlawrev-20850	566	8	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	566	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	566	10	single	single	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	566	11	calculated	calculate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	566	12	value	value	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	566	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	566	14	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	566	15	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	566	16	always	always	ADV
inlawrev-20850	566	17	subject	subject	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	566	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	566	19	sampling	sample	VERB
inlawrev-20850	566	20	error	error	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	566	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	566	22	unlikely	unlikely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	566	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	566	24	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	566	25	replicated	replicate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	566	26	exactly	exactly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	566	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	566	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	566	29	subsequent	subsequent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	566	30	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	566	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	567	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	567	2	robert	robert	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	567	3	r.	r.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	567	4	sokal	sokal	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	567	5	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	567	6	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	567	7	james	james	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	567	8	rohlf	rohlf	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	567	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	567	10	biometry	biometry	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	567	11	158	158	NUM
inlawrev-20850	567	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	567	13	4th	4th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	567	14	ed	ed	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	567	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	567	16	2012	2012	NUM
inlawrev-20850	567	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	567	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	567	19	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	567	20	confidence	confidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	567	21	intervals	interval	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	567	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	567	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	568	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	568	2	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	568	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	568	4	sampling	sample	VERB
inlawrev-20850	568	5	error	error	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	568	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	568	7	unavoidable	unavoidable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	568	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	568	9	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	568	10	conventionally	conventionally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	568	11	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-20850	568	12	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	568	13	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	568	14	techniques	technique	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	568	15	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	568	16	estimate	estimate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	568	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	568	18	likelihood	likelihood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	568	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	568	20	incorrectly	incorrectly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	568	21	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	568	22	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	568	23	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	568	24	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	568	25	random	random	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	568	26	chance	chance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	568	27	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	568	28	type	type	VERB
inlawrev-20850	568	29	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	568	30	error	error	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	568	31	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	568	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	569	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	569	2	green	green	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	569	3	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	569	4	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	569	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	569	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	569	7	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	569	8	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	569	9	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-20850	569	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	569	11	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	569	12	575	575	NUM
inlawrev-20850	569	13	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	569	14	78	78	NUM
inlawrev-20850	569	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	570	1	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	570	2	research	research	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	570	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	570	4	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	570	5	potentially	potentially	ADV
inlawrev-20850	570	6	subject	subject	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	570	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	570	8	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	570	9	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	570	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	570	11	error	error	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	570	12	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	570	13	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	570	14	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
inlawrev-20850	570	15	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	570	16	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-20850	570	17	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	570	18	careful	careful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	570	19	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	570	20	design	design	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	570	21	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	570	22	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	570	23	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	570	24	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	570	25	subjected	subject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	570	26	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	570	27	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	570	28	testing	testing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	570	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	571	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	571	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	571	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	571	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	571	5	583	583	NUM
inlawrev-20850	571	6	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	571	7	97	97	NUM
inlawrev-20850	571	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	572	1	132	132	NUM
inlawrev-20850	572	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	573	1	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	573	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	573	3	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	573	4	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	573	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	573	6	714	714	NUM
inlawrev-20850	573	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	573	8	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-20850	573	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	574	1	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-20850	574	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	574	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	574	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	575	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	575	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	575	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	576	1	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	576	2	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	576	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	576	4	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	576	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	576	6	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	576	7	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	576	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	576	9	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	576	10	individual	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	576	11	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	576	12	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	576	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	577	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	577	2	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	577	3	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	577	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	577	5	controlled	control	VERB
inlawrev-20850	577	6	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	577	7	experiments	experiment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	577	8	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	577	9	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	577	10	carried	carry	VERB
inlawrev-20850	577	11	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-20850	577	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	577	13	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	577	14	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	577	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	577	16	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	577	17	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	577	18	capable	capable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	577	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	577	20	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	577	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	577	22	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	577	23	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	577	24	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	577	25	condition	condition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	577	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	577	27	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	577	28	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	577	29	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	577	30	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	577	31	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	577	32	criteria	criterion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	577	33	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	577	34	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	577	35	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	577	36	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	577	37	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	577	38	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	577	39	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	577	40	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	577	41	certainty	certainty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	577	42	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	577	43	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	577	44	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	577	45	individual	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	577	46	's	's	PART
inlawrev-20850	577	47	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	577	48	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	577	49	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	577	50	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	577	51	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	577	52	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	577	53	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	577	54	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	577	55	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	577	56	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	578	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	578	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	578	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	578	4	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	578	5	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	578	6	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	578	7	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	578	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	578	9	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	578	10	experimentation	experimentation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	578	11	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	578	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	578	13	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	578	14	done	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	578	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	578	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	578	17	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	578	18	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	578	19	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	578	20	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	578	21	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	578	22	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	578	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	578	24	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	578	25	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	578	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	579	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	579	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	579	3	absence	absence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	579	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	579	5	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	579	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	579	7	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	579	8	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	579	9	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	579	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	579	11	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	579	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	579	13	claimants	claimant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	579	14	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	579	15	attempt	attempt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	579	16	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	579	17	demonstrate	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	579	18	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	579	19	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	579	20	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	579	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	579	22	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	579	23	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	579	24	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	579	25	increases	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	579	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	579	27	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	579	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	579	29	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	579	30	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	579	31	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	579	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	580	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	580	2	finder	finder	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	580	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	580	4	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	580	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	580	6	asked	ask	VERB
inlawrev-20850	580	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	580	8	infer	infer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	580	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	580	10	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	580	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	580	12	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	580	13	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	580	14	demonstrably	demonstrably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	580	15	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	580	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	580	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	580	18	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	580	19	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	580	20	due	due	ADP
inlawrev-20850	580	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	580	22	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	580	23	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	580	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	580	25	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	580	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	580	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	580	28	claimant	claimant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	580	29	's	's	PART
inlawrev-20850	580	30	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	580	31	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	580	32	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	580	33	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	580	34	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	580	35	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	580	36	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	580	37	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	580	38	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	580	39	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	580	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	581	1	such	such	DET
inlawrev-20850	581	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	581	3	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	581	4	concedes	concede	VERB
inlawrev-20850	581	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	581	6	science	science	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	581	7	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	581	8	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	581	9	tell	tell	VERB
inlawrev-20850	581	10	us	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	581	11	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	581	12	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	581	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	581	14	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	581	15	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	581	16	's	's	PART
inlawrev-20850	581	17	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	581	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	582	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	582	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	582	3	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	582	4	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	582	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	582	6	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	7	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	582	9	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	582	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	582	11	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	582	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	582	14	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	15	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	582	16	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	17	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	582	18	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	582	19	elevated	elevate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	582	20	due	due	ADP
inlawrev-20850	582	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	582	22	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	23	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	582	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	582	25	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	582	27	someone	someone	PRON
inlawrev-20850	582	28	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	582	29	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	582	30	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	582	31	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	582	32	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	582	33	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	34	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	582	35	exhibits	exhibit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	582	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	582	37	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	38	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	582	39	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	40	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	582	41	raise	raise	VERB
inlawrev-20850	582	42	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	582	43	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	44	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	45	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	582	46	causation.133	causation.133	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	47	despite	despite	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	582	48	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	582	49	uneasiness	uneasiness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	50	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	582	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	582	52	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	53	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	54	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	582	55	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	582	56	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	582	57	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	58	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
inlawrev-20850	582	59	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	582	60	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	582	61	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	582	62	impossibility	impossibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	63	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	582	64	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	582	65	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	582	66	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	582	67	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	68	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	582	69	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	70	justified	justify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	582	71	allowing	allow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	582	72	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	73	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	582	74	rely	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	582	75	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	582	76	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	582	77	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	582	78	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	582	79	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	582	80	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	582	81	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	582	82	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	583	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	583	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	583	3	set	set	VERB
inlawrev-20850	583	4	strict	strict	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	583	5	methodologic	methodologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	583	6	standards	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	583	7	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	583	8	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	583	9	reliability134	reliability134	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	583	10	135	135	NUM
inlawrev-20850	583	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	583	12	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	583	13	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	583	14	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	583	15	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	583	16	additional	additional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	583	17	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	583	18	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	583	19	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	583	20	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	583	21	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	583	22	elevated	elevate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	583	23	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	583	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	583	25	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	583	26	raise	raise	VERB
inlawrev-20850	583	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	583	28	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	583	29	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	583	30	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	583	31	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	583	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	583	33	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	584	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	584	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	584	3	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	584	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	584	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	584	6	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	584	7	data136	data136	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	584	8	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	584	9	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	584	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	584	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	584	12	studied	study	VERB
inlawrev-20850	584	13	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	584	14	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	584	15	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	584	16	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	584	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	584	18	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	584	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	584	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	584	21	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	584	22	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	584	23	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	584	24	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	584	25	condition	condition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	584	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	585	1	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	585	2	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	585	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	585	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	585	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	585	6	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	585	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	585	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	585	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	585	10	rational	rational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	585	11	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	585	12	for137	for137	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	585	13	133	133	NUM
inlawrev-20850	585	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	586	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	586	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	586	3	134	134	NUM
inlawrev-20850	586	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	587	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	587	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	587	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	587	4	718	718	NUM
inlawrev-20850	587	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	587	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	587	7	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	587	8	recognize	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	587	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	587	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	587	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	588	1	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	588	2	frequency	frequency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	588	3	data	datum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	588	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	588	5	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	588	6	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	588	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	588	8	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	588	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	588	10	adverse	adverse	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	588	11	effects	effect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	588	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	588	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	588	14	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	588	15	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	588	16	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	588	17	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	588	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	588	19	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	588	20	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	588	21	indicate	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	588	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	588	23	actual	actual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	588	24	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	588	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	588	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	588	27	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	588	28	individual	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	588	29	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	588	30	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	588	31	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	588	32	condition	condition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	588	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	589	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	589	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	589	3	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	589	4	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	589	5	balance	balance	VERB
inlawrev-20850	589	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	589	7	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	589	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	589	9	compensate	compensate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	589	10	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-20850	589	11	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	589	12	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	589	13	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	589	14	injured	injure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	589	15	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	589	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	589	17	wrongful	wrongful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	589	18	actions	action	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	589	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	589	20	another	another	PRON
inlawrev-20850	589	21	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	589	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	589	23	concept	concept	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	589	24	deeply	deeply	ADV
inlawrev-20850	589	25	imbedded	imbed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	589	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	589	27	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-20850	589	28	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	589	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	589	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	589	31	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	589	32	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	589	33	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	589	34	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	589	35	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	589	36	liable	liable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	589	37	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	589	38	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	589	39	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	589	40	unless	unless	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	589	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	589	42	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	589	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	589	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	589	45	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	589	46	supports	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	589	47	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	589	48	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	589	49	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	589	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	589	51	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	589	52	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	590	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	590	2	citations	citation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	590	3	omitted	omit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	590	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	590	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	591	1	135	135	NUM
inlawrev-20850	591	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	592	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	592	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	592	3	imposed	impose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	592	4	standards	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	592	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	592	6	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	592	7	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	592	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	592	9	replication	replication	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	592	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	592	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	592	12	similarity	similarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	592	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	592	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	592	15	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	592	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	592	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	592	18	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	592	19	subjects	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	592	20	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	592	21	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	592	22	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	592	23	satisfied	satisfied	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	592	24	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	592	25	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	592	26	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	592	27	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	592	28	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	592	29	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	592	30	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	592	31	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	592	32	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	592	33	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	592	34	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	592	35	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	592	36	deemed	deem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	592	37	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	592	38	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	592	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	592	40	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	593	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	593	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	593	3	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	593	4	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	593	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	593	6	721	721	NUM
inlawrev-20850	593	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	593	8	25	25	NUM
inlawrev-20850	593	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	593	10	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	593	11	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	593	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	593	13	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	593	14	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	593	15	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	593	16	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	593	17	727	727	NUM
inlawrev-20850	593	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	593	19	replication	replication	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	593	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	593	21	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	593	22	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	593	23	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	593	24	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	593	25	720	720	NUM
inlawrev-20850	593	26	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	593	27	21	21	NUM
inlawrev-20850	593	28	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	593	29	similarity	similarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	593	30	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	593	31	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	593	32	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	593	33	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	593	34	merck	merck	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	593	35	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	593	36	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	594	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	594	2	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	594	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	594	4	347	347	NUM
inlawrev-20850	594	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	594	6	256	256	NUM
inlawrev-20850	594	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	594	8	265	265	NUM
inlawrev-20850	594	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	594	10	66	66	NUM
inlawrev-20850	594	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	594	12	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	594	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	594	14	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	594	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	594	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	594	17	emphasizing	emphasize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	594	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	594	19	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	594	20	requirements	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	594	21	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	594	22	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	594	23	strictly	strictly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	594	24	observed	observe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	594	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	594	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	595	1	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-20850	595	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	596	1	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	596	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	596	3	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	596	4	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	596	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	596	6	715	715	NUM
inlawrev-20850	596	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	597	1	137	137	NUM
inlawrev-20850	597	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	598	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	598	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	598	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	598	5	717	717	NUM
inlawrev-20850	598	6	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	598	7	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-20850	598	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	9	adopting	adopt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	598	10	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	11	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	598	12	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	598	13	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	598	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	598	15	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	16	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	17	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	18	despite	despite	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	598	19	arguments	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	598	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	598	22	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	23	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	598	24	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	598	25	too	too	ADV
inlawrev-20850	598	26	stringent	stringent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	598	27	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	598	28	too	too	ADV
inlawrev-20850	598	29	lenient	lenient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	598	30	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	31	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	32	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	598	33	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	598	34	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	598	35	725	725	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	598	36	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	37	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	598	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	39	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	598	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	598	41	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	598	43	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	598	44	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	45	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	46	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	47	’	’	PART
inlawrev-20850	598	48	reliance	reliance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	49	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	598	50	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	598	51	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	53	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	598	54	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	55	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	598	56	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	598	57	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	58	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	598	59	need	need	VERB
inlawrev-20850	598	60	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	598	61	exceed	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	598	62	2.0	2.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	598	63	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	64	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	598	65	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	598	66	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	67	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	68	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	69	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	598	70	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	598	71	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	72	139	139	NUM
inlawrev-20850	598	73	relating	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	598	74	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	598	75	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	76	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	598	77	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	598	78	be	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	598	79	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	598	80	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	598	81	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	598	82	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	83	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	84	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	598	85	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	598	86	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	87	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	598	88	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	598	89	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-20850	598	90	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	598	91	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	92	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	93	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	598	94	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	95	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	598	96	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	598	97	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	598	98	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	598	99	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	598	100	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	598	101	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	598	102	burden	burden	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	103	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	598	104	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	598	105	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	599	1	”138	”138	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	599	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	599	3	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	599	4	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	599	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	599	6	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	599	7	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	599	8	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	9	neatly	neatly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	599	10	disposed	dispose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	599	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	599	12	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	599	14	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	599	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	599	16	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	17	presented	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	599	18	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	599	19	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	599	20	data	datum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	21	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	599	22	satisfied	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	599	23	both	both	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	599	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	599	25	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	26	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	599	27	methodologic	methodologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	599	28	requirements	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	599	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	599	31	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	32	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	599	33	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	599	34	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	599	35	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	599	36	requirement.139	requirement.139	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	599	37	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	38	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	599	39	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	599	40	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	599	41	hint	hint	VERB
inlawrev-20850	599	42	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	599	43	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	599	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	599	45	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	599	46	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	599	47	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	599	48	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	49	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	599	50	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	599	51	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	599	52	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	599	53	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	599	54	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	599	55	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	56	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	599	57	source	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	58	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	599	59	responsible	responsible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	599	60	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	599	61	exposing	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	599	62	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	599	63	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	64	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	599	65	separate	separate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	599	66	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	67	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	599	68	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	599	69	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	599	70	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	599	71	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	599	72	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	600	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	600	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	600	3	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	600	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	600	5	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	600	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	600	7	borrowed	borrow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	600	8	the140	the140	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	600	9	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	600	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	600	11	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	600	12	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	600	13	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	600	14	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	600	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	600	16	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	600	17	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	600	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	600	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	600	20	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	600	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	600	22	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	600	23	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	600	24	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	600	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	600	26	brisk	brisk	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	600	27	elision	elision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	600	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	600	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	600	30	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	600	31	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	600	32	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	600	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	600	34	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	600	35	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	600	36	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	600	37	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	600	38	enunciated	enunciate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	600	39	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	600	40	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	600	41	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	600	42	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	600	43	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	600	44	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	600	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	600	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	600	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	601	1	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	601	2	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	601	3	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	601	5	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	601	7	lacking	lack	VERB
inlawrev-20850	601	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	601	9	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	601	10	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	601	11	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	601	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	601	14	form	form	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	601	16	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	601	17	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	18	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	601	19	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	601	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	601	21	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	22	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	601	23	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	24	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	601	25	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	601	26	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	601	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	601	28	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	29	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	601	30	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	601	32	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	33	appropriately	appropriately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	601	34	corresponds	correspond	VERB
inlawrev-20850	601	35	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	601	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	601	37	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	601	38	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	601	40	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	41	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	601	42	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	601	43	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	601	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	601	46	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	601	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	602	1	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	602	2	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	602	3	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	602	4	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	602	5	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	602	6	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	602	7	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	602	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	602	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	602	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	603	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	604	1	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	604	2	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	604	3	conclude	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	604	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	604	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	604	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	604	7	absence	absence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	604	9	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	604	10	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	604	12	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	604	14	establishing	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	604	15	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	604	17	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	18	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-20850	604	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	604	20	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	604	22	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	604	23	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	604	25	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	604	26	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	27	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	28	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	604	29	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	604	30	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	604	31	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	32	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	604	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	604	34	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	35	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	604	36	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	37	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	604	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	604	39	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	40	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	604	41	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	42	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	604	43	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	604	44	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	604	45	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	604	46	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	604	48	contracting	contract	VERB
inlawrev-20850	604	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	604	50	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	604	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	605	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	605	2	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	605	3	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	605	4	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	605	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	605	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	605	7	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	8	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	605	9	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	605	10	shown	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	605	11	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	605	12	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	605	13	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	14	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	15	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	605	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	605	17	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	605	18	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	605	19	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	605	20	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	21	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	605	22	similarly	similarly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	605	23	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	605	24	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	605	25	testimony.141	testimony.141	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	605	27	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	605	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	605	30	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	605	31	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	605	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	605	33	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	34	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	605	35	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	36	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	605	37	meant	mean	VERB
inlawrev-20850	605	38	bendectin	bendectin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	605	39	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	605	40	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	605	41	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	605	42	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	605	43	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	605	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	605	45	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	46	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	605	47	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	48	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	605	49	meant	mean	VERB
inlawrev-20850	605	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	605	51	quantity	quantity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	52	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	605	53	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	54	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	605	55	georgiapacific	georgiapacific	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	56	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	605	57	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	605	58	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	59	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	605	60	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	605	61	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	605	62	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	605	63	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	605	64	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	605	65	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	605	66	father	father	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	67	did	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	605	68	home	home	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	69	renovation	renovation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	70	projects.142	projects.142	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	71	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	605	72	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	605	73	justices	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	74	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	605	75	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	605	76	complained	complain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	605	77	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	605	78	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	605	79	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	605	80	t]he	t]he	ADV
inlawrev-20850	605	81	framework	framework	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	605	82	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	605	83	approved	approve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	605	84	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	605	85	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	605	86	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	605	87	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	606	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	607	1	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	607	2	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	607	3	contemplate	contemplate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	607	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	607	5	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	607	6	scenario	scenario	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	7	involving	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	607	8	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	607	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	607	10	confidence	confidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	11	interval	interval	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	12	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	607	13	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	607	14	include	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	607	15	1.0	1.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	607	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	607	17	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	607	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	607	19	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	607	21	indicate	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	607	22	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	607	23	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	607	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	607	25	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	607	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	607	28	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	607	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	607	31	statistically	statistically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	607	32	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	607	33	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	34	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	607	35	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	607	36	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	607	37	limb	limb	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	38	reduction	reduction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	39	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	40	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	41	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	607	42	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	607	43	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	607	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	607	45	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	607	46	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	47	possibly	possibly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	607	48	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	607	49	great	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	607	50	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	607	51	1.8	1.8	NUM
inlawrev-20850	607	52	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	607	53	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	607	54	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	607	55	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	607	56	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	57	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	607	58	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	607	59	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	60	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	607	61	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	607	62	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	607	63	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	607	64	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	607	65	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	66	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	607	67	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	607	68	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	607	69	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	607	70	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	607	71	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	607	72	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	607	73	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	74	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	607	75	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	607	76	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	607	77	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	607	78	probable	probable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	607	79	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	607	80	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	607	81	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	607	82	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	607	83	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	607	84	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	607	85	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	86	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	607	87	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	607	88	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	607	89	limb	limb	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	90	reduction	reduction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	91	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	92	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	607	93	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	607	94	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	607	95	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	607	96	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	607	97	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	607	98	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	608	1	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-20850	608	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	609	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	609	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	609	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	609	4	717	717	NUM
inlawrev-20850	609	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	610	1	139	139	NUM
inlawrev-20850	610	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	611	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	611	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	611	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	611	4	724	724	NUM
inlawrev-20850	611	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	611	6	28	28	NUM
inlawrev-20850	611	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	611	8	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	611	9	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	611	10	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	611	11	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	611	12	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	611	13	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	611	14	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	611	15	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	611	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	611	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	612	1	140	140	X
inlawrev-20850	612	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	613	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	613	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	613	3	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	613	4	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	613	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	613	6	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	613	7	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	613	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	613	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	613	10	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	613	11	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	613	12	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	613	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	613	14	371	371	NUM
inlawrev-20850	613	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	613	16	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	613	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	613	18	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	613	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	613	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	613	21	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	613	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	613	23	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	613	24	dissenting	dissenting	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	613	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	613	26	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	613	27	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	613	28	havner	havner	X
inlawrev-20850	613	29	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	613	30	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	613	31	address	address	VERB
inlawrev-20850	613	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	613	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	613	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	614	1	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	614	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	614	3	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	614	4	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	614	5	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	614	6	contribute	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	614	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	614	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	614	9	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	614	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	614	11	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	614	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	614	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	614	14	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	614	15	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	614	16	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	614	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	614	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	614	19	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	614	20	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	614	21	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	614	22	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	614	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	614	24	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	614	25	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	614	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	614	27	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	614	28	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	614	29	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	614	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	615	1	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	615	2	stands	stand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	615	3	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	615	4	reason	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	615	5	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	615	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	615	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	615	8	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	615	9	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	615	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	615	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	615	12	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	615	13	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	615	14	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	615	15	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	615	16	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	615	17	to	to	AUX
inlawrev-20850	615	18	bendectin	bendectin	VERB
inlawrev-20850	615	19	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	615	20	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	615	21	source	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	615	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	615	23	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	615	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	615	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	616	1	141	141	NUM
inlawrev-20850	616	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	617	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	617	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	617	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	617	4	349	349	NUM
inlawrev-20850	617	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	617	6	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	617	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	617	8	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	617	9	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	617	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	617	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	618	1	142	142	NUM
inlawrev-20850	618	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	619	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	619	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	619	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	619	4	337	337	NUM
inlawrev-20850	619	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	620	1	140	140	NUM
inlawrev-20850	620	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	620	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	620	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	621	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	621	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	621	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	621	4	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	621	5	manufacturers	manufacturer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	621	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	621	7	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	622	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	622	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	622	3	responded	respond	VERB
inlawrev-20850	622	4	dismissively	dismissively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	622	5	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	622	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	622	7	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	622	8	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	622	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	622	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	622	11	loss	loss	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	622	12	to143	to143	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	622	13	understand	understand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	622	14	why	why	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	622	15	[	[	AUX
inlawrev-20850	622	16	]	]	X
inlawrev-20850	622	17	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	622	18	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	622	19	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	622	20	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	622	21	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	622	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	622	23	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	622	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	622	25	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	622	26	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	622	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	623	1	the144	the144	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	623	2	explanation	explanation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	623	3	lies	lie	VERB
inlawrev-20850	623	4	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	623	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	623	6	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	623	7	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	623	8	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	623	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	623	10	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	623	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	623	12	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	623	13	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	623	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	623	15	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	623	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	623	17	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	623	18	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	623	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	623	20	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	623	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	624	1	consequently	consequently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	624	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	624	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	624	4	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	624	5	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	624	6	switched	switch	VERB
inlawrev-20850	624	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	624	8	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	624	9	inapposite	inapposite	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	624	10	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	624	11	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	624	12	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	624	13	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	624	14	noticing	notice	VERB
inlawrev-20850	624	15	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	624	16	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	624	17	admitting	admit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	624	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	624	19	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	624	20	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	624	21	doing	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	624	22	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	624	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	625	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	625	2	central	central	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	625	3	justification	justification	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	625	4	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	625	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	625	6	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	625	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	625	8	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	625	9	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	625	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	625	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	625	12	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	625	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	625	14	elsewhere	elsewhere	ADV
inlawrev-20850	625	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	625	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	625	17	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	625	18	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	625	19	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	625	20	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	625	21	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	625	22	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	625	23	doubles	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	625	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	625	25	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	625	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	625	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	625	28	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	625	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	625	30	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	625	31	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	625	32	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	625	33	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	625	34	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	625	35	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	625	36	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	625	37	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	625	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	625	39	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	625	40	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	625	41	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	625	42	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	625	43	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	625	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	625	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	625	46	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	625	47	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	625	48	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	625	49	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	625	50	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	625	51	suffered	suffer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	625	52	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	625	53	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	625	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	626	1	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	626	2	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	626	3	above	above	ADV
inlawrev-20850	626	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	626	5	epidemiologists	epidemiologist	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	626	6	compare	compare	VERB
inlawrev-20850	626	7	the145	the145	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	626	8	estimated	estimate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	626	9	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	626	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	626	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	626	12	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	626	13	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	626	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	626	15	unexposed	unexposed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	626	16	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	626	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	626	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	626	19	estimated	estimate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	626	20	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	626	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	626	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	626	23	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	626	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	626	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	626	26	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	626	27	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	626	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	626	29	assuming	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	626	30	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	626	31	absent	absent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	626	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	626	33	effects	effect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	626	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	626	35	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	626	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	626	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	626	38	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	626	39	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	626	40	rates	rate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	626	41	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	626	42	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	626	43	equal	equal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	626	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	627	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	627	2	researchers	researcher	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	627	3	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	627	4	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	627	5	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	627	6	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	627	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	627	8	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	627	9	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	627	10	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	627	11	individuals	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	627	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	627	13	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	627	14	themselves	themselves	PRON
inlawrev-20850	627	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	627	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	627	17	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	627	18	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	627	19	neither	neither	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	627	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	627	21	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	627	22	sampling	sampling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	627	23	fluke	fluke	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	627	24	nor	nor	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	627	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	627	26	mere	mere	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	627	27	coincidence	coincidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	627	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	627	29	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	627	30	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	627	31	attribute	attribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	627	32	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	627	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	627	34	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	627	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	627	36	excess	excess	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	627	37	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	627	38	above	above	ADP
inlawrev-20850	627	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	627	40	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	627	41	observed	observe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	627	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	627	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	627	44	unexposed	unexposed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	627	45	sample	sample	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	627	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	628	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	628	2	fraction	fraction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	628	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	628	4	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	628	5	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	628	6	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	628	7	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	628	8	follows	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	628	9	directly	directly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	628	10	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	628	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	628	12	amount	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	628	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	628	14	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	628	15	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	628	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	629	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	629	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	629	3	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	629	4	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	629	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	629	6	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	629	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	629	8	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	629	9	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	629	10	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	629	11	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	629	12	observed	observe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	629	13	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	629	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	629	15	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	629	16	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	629	17	one	one	PRON
inlawrev-20850	629	18	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	629	19	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	629	20	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	629	21	expected	expect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	629	22	absent	absent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	629	23	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	629	24	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	629	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	629	26	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	629	27	fraction	fraction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	629	28	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	629	29	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	629	30	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-20850	629	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	629	32	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	629	33	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	629	34	fifty	fifty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	629	35	percent	percent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	629	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	630	1	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	630	2	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	630	3	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	4	above	above	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	5	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	630	6	implies	imply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	630	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	630	8	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	630	9	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	10	half	half	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	630	13	cases146	cases146	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	630	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	15	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	630	18	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	630	19	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	20	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	630	21	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	630	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	630	24	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	630	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	27	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	630	28	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	630	30	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	630	31	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	630	32	sick	sick	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	630	33	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	34	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	630	35	chosen	choose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	630	36	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	37	random	random	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	630	38	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	39	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	630	41	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	630	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	630	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	630	44	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	45	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	630	46	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	630	47	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	48	fifty	fifty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	630	49	percent	percent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	50	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	630	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	630	52	randomly	randomly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	630	53	selected	select	VERB
inlawrev-20850	630	54	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	55	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	630	56	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	630	57	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	630	58	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	630	59	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	630	60	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	630	61	attributed	attribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	630	62	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	630	64	exposure.147	exposure.147	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	65	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	66	conventionally	conventionally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	630	67	express	express	VERB
inlawrev-20850	630	68	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	630	69	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	70	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	71	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	630	72	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	73	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	74	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	75	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	76	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	630	77	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	78	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	630	79	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	630	80	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	630	81	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	630	82	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	630	83	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	630	84	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	630	85	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	630	86	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	630	87	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	630	88	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	630	89	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	630	90	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	630	91	true	true	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	630	92	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	631	1	the148	the148	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	631	2	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	631	3	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	631	4	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	631	5	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	631	6	depends	depend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	631	7	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	631	8	equating	equate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	631	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	631	10	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	631	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	631	12	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	631	13	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	631	14	derived	derive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	631	15	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	631	16	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	631	17	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	631	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	631	19	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	631	20	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	631	21	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	631	22	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	631	23	demanded	demand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	631	24	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	631	25	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	631	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	632	1	this149	this149	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	632	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	632	3	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	632	4	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	632	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	632	6	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	632	7	supposedly	supposedly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	632	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	632	9	corresponds	correspond	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	632	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	632	11	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	632	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	632	13	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	632	14	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	632	15	term	term	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	632	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	632	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	632	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	632	19	143	143	NUM
inlawrev-20850	632	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	633	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	633	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	633	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	633	4	371	371	NUM
inlawrev-20850	633	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	633	6	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	633	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	633	8	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	633	9	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	633	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	633	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	634	1	144	144	NUM
inlawrev-20850	634	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	635	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	635	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	635	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	635	4	352	352	NUM
inlawrev-20850	635	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	635	6	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-20850	635	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	636	1	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	636	2	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	636	3	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	636	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	636	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	636	6	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	636	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	637	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	637	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	637	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	637	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	637	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	637	6	706	706	NUM
inlawrev-20850	637	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	637	8	717	717	NUM
inlawrev-20850	637	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	637	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	637	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	637	12	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	637	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	637	14	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	637	15	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	637	16	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	637	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	637	18	re	re	VERB
inlawrev-20850	637	19	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	637	20	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	637	21	orange	orange	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	637	22	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	637	23	prod	prod	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	637	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	638	1	liab	liab	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	638	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	639	1	litig	litig	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	639	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	640	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	640	2	597	597	NUM
inlawrev-20850	640	3	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	640	4	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	640	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	641	1	740	740	NUM
inlawrev-20850	641	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	641	3	e.d.n.y	e.d.n.y	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	641	4	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	641	5	1984	1984	NUM
inlawrev-20850	641	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	641	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	641	8	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	641	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	641	10	818	818	NUM
inlawrev-20850	641	11	f.2d	f.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	641	12	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-20850	641	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	641	14	2d	2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	641	15	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	641	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	641	17	1987	1987	NUM
inlawrev-20850	641	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	641	19	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	641	20	cook	cook	VERB
inlawrev-20850	641	21	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	641	22	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	641	23	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	641	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	641	25	545	545	NUM
inlawrev-20850	641	26	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	641	27	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	641	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	642	1	306	306	NUM
inlawrev-20850	642	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	642	3	n.d	n.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	642	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	642	5	cal	cal	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	642	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	642	7	1982	1982	NUM
inlawrev-20850	642	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	642	9	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	642	10	estate	estate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	642	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	642	12	george	george	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	642	13	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	642	14	vt	vt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	642	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	642	16	league	league	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	642	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	642	18	cities	city	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	642	19	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	642	20	towns	town	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	642	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	642	22	993	993	NUM
inlawrev-20850	642	23	a.2d	a.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	642	24	367	367	NUM
inlawrev-20850	642	25	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	642	26	vt	vt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	642	27	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	642	28	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	642	29	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	642	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	643	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	643	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	643	3	canvass	canvass	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	643	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	643	5	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	643	6	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	643	7	early	early	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	643	8	1999	1999	NUM
inlawrev-20850	643	9	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	643	10	discuss	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	643	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	643	12	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	643	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	643	14	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	643	15	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	643	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	643	17	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	643	18	russelyn	russelyn	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	643	19	carruth	carruth	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	643	20	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	643	21	bernard	bernard	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	643	22	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	643	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	643	24	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	643	25	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	643	26	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	643	27	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	643	28	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	643	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	643	30	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	643	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	643	32	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	643	33	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	643	34	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	643	35	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	643	36	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	643	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	643	38	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-20850	643	39	jurimetrics	jurimetric	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	643	40	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	643	41	195	195	NUM
inlawrev-20850	643	42	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	643	43	2001	2001	NUM
inlawrev-20850	643	44	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	643	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	644	1	146	146	NUM
inlawrev-20850	644	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	645	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	645	2	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	645	3	notes	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	645	4	128	128	NUM
inlawrev-20850	645	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	645	6	31	31	NUM
inlawrev-20850	645	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	645	8	accompanying	accompany	VERB
inlawrev-20850	645	9	text	text	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	645	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	646	1	147	147	NUM
inlawrev-20850	646	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	646	3	treating	treat	VERB
inlawrev-20850	646	4	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	646	5	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	646	6	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	646	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	646	8	single	single	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	646	9	fixed	fix	VERB
inlawrev-20850	646	10	value	value	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	646	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	646	12	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	646	13	oversimplification	oversimplification	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	646	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	647	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	647	2	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	647	3	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	647	4	131	131	NUM
inlawrev-20850	647	5	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	647	6	148	148	NUM
inlawrev-20850	647	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	648	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	648	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	648	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	648	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	648	5	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	648	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	648	7	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	648	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	648	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	648	10	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	648	11	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	648	12	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	648	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	649	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	649	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	649	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	649	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	649	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	649	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	649	7	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	649	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	649	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	650	1	l	l	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	650	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	650	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	650	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	650	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	651	1	149	149	NUM
inlawrev-20850	651	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	652	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	652	2	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	652	3	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	652	4	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	652	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	652	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	652	7	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	652	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	653	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	653	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	653	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	653	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	653	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	653	6	706	706	NUM
inlawrev-20850	653	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	653	8	717	717	NUM
inlawrev-20850	653	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	653	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	653	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	653	12	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	653	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	653	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	653	15	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	653	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	653	17	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	653	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	653	19	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	653	20	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	653	21	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	653	22	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	653	23	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	653	24	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	653	25	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	653	26	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	653	27	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	653	28	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	653	29	statistically	statistically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	653	30	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	653	31	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	653	32	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	653	33	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	653	34	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	653	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	653	36	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	653	37	individual	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	653	38	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	653	39	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	653	40	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	653	41	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	653	42	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	653	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	653	44	drug	drug	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	653	45	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	653	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	653	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	654	1	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	654	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	654	3	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	654	4	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	654	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	654	6	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	654	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	654	8	141	141	NUM
inlawrev-20850	654	9	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	654	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	654	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	654	12	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	654	13	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	654	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	655	1	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	655	2	commentators	commentator	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	655	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	655	4	myself150	myself150	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	655	5	included	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	655	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	655	7	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	655	8	criticized	criticize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	655	9	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	655	10	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	655	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	655	12	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	655	13	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	655	14	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	655	15	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	655	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	655	17	accepted	accept	VERB
inlawrev-20850	655	18	for1	for1	VERB
inlawrev-20850	655	19	5	5	NUM
inlawrev-20850	655	20	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	655	21	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	655	22	purposes	purpose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	655	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	655	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	655	25	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	655	26	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	655	27	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	655	28	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	655	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	655	30	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	655	31	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	655	32	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	655	33	logic	logic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	655	34	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	655	35	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	655	36	withstand	withstand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	655	37	scrutiny	scrutiny	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	655	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	656	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	656	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	656	3	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	656	4	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	656	5	inheres	inhere	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	656	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	656	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	656	8	logic	logic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	656	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	656	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	656	11	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	656	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	656	13	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	656	14	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	656	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	657	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	657	2	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	657	3	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	657	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	657	5	rooted	root	VERB
inlawrev-20850	657	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	657	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	657	8	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	657	9	concept	concept	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	657	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	657	11	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	657	12	fraction	fraction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	657	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	657	14	implies	imply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	657	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	657	16	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	657	17	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	657	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	657	19	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	657	20	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	657	21	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	657	22	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	657	23	really	really	ADV
inlawrev-20850	657	24	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	657	25	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	657	26	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	657	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	657	28	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	657	29	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	657	30	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	657	31	really	really	ADV
inlawrev-20850	657	32	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	657	33	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	657	34	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	657	35	something	something	PRON
inlawrev-20850	657	36	else	else	ADV
inlawrev-20850	657	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	657	38	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	657	39	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	657	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	657	41	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	657	42	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	657	43	tells	tell	VERB
inlawrev-20850	657	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	657	45	factfinder	factfinder	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	657	46	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	657	47	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	657	48	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	657	49	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	657	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	658	1	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	658	2	say	say	VERB
inlawrev-20850	658	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	658	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	658	5	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	658	6	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	658	7	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	658	8	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	658	9	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	658	10	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	658	11	leads	lead	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	658	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	658	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	658	14	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	658	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	658	16	something	something	PRON
inlawrev-20850	658	17	else	else	ADV
inlawrev-20850	658	18	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	658	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	658	20	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	658	21	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	658	22	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	658	23	illness	illness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	658	24	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	658	25	no	no	ADV
inlawrev-20850	658	26	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	658	27	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	658	28	saying	say	VERB
inlawrev-20850	658	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	658	30	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	658	31	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	658	32	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	658	33	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	658	34	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	658	35	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	658	36	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	658	37	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	658	38	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	658	39	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	658	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	658	41	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	658	42	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	658	43	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	658	44	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	658	45	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	658	46	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	658	47	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	658	48	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	658	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	658	50	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	658	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	659	1	conversely	conversely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	659	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	659	3	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	659	4	say	say	VERB
inlawrev-20850	659	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	659	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	659	7	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	659	8	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	659	9	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	659	10	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	659	11	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	659	12	leads	lead	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	659	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	659	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	659	15	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	659	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	659	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	659	18	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	659	19	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	659	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	659	21	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	659	22	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	659	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	659	24	illness	illness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	659	25	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	659	26	no	no	ADV
inlawrev-20850	659	27	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	659	28	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	659	29	saying	say	VERB
inlawrev-20850	659	30	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	659	31	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	659	32	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	659	33	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	659	34	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	659	35	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	659	36	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	659	37	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	659	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	659	39	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	659	40	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	659	41	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	659	42	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	659	43	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	659	44	sick	sick	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	659	45	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	659	46	she	she	PRON
inlawrev-20850	659	47	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	659	48	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	659	49	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	659	50	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	659	51	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	659	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	660	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	660	2	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	660	3	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	660	4	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	660	5	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	660	6	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	660	7	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	660	8	replace	replace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	660	9	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	660	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	660	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	660	12	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	660	13	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	660	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	660	15	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	660	16	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	660	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	660	18	contributing	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	660	19	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	660	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	660	21	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	660	22	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	660	23	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	660	24	concept	concept	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	660	25	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	660	26	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	660	27	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-20850	660	28	creates	create	VERB
inlawrev-20850	660	29	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	660	30	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	660	31	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	660	32	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	660	33	determining	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	660	34	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	660	35	but	but	ADV
inlawrev-20850	660	36	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	660	37	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	660	38	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	660	39	exists	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	660	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	661	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	661	2	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	661	3	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	661	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	661	5	evident	evident	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	661	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	662	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	662	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	662	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	4	pointed	point	VERB
inlawrev-20850	662	5	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-20850	662	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	662	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	662	8	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	662	9	limb	limb	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	10	reduction	reduction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	11	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	12	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	662	13	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	662	14	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	662	15	]	]	X
inlawrev-20850	662	16	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	662	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	662	18	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	662	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	662	20	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	662	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	662	23	large	large	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	662	24	percentage	percentage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	662	26	limb	limb	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	27	reduction	reduction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	28	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	29	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	30	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	662	31	unknown	unknown	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	662	32	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	662	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	662	34	]	]	X
inlawrev-20850	662	35	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	662	36	raising	raise	VERB
inlawrev-20850	662	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	662	38	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	39	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	662	40	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	662	41	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	662	42	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	662	43	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	44	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	662	45	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	662	46	raise	raise	VERB
inlawrev-20850	662	47	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	662	48	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	49	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	50	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	662	51	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	662	52	bendectin	bendectin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	662	53	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	662	54	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	662	55	individual	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	56	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	662	57	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	58	defect	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	59	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	662	60	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	662	61	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	662	62	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	662	63	framing	framing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	64	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	662	65	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	662	66	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	67	set	set	VERB
inlawrev-20850	662	68	up	up	ADP
inlawrev-20850	662	69	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	662	70	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	662	71	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	662	72	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	662	73	bendectin152	bendectin152	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	662	74	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	662	75	something	something	PRON
inlawrev-20850	662	76	else	else	ADV
inlawrev-20850	662	77	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	662	78	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	662	79	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	662	80	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	663	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	663	2	phrase	phrase	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	663	3	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	663	4	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	663	5	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	663	6	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	663	7	never	never	ADV
inlawrev-20850	663	8	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	663	9	appeared	appear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	663	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	663	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	663	12	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	663	13	opinion.153	opinion.153	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	663	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	663	15	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	663	16	logic	logic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	663	17	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	663	18	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	663	19	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	663	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	663	21	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	663	22	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	663	23	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	663	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	663	25	vary	vary	VERB
inlawrev-20850	663	26	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	663	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	663	28	amount	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	663	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	663	30	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	663	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	664	1	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	664	2	information	information	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	664	3	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	664	4	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	664	5	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	664	6	risks	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	664	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	664	8	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	664	9	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	664	10	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	664	11	available	available	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	664	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	664	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	664	14	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	664	15	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	664	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	664	17	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	664	18	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	664	19	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	664	20	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	664	21	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	664	22	divide	divide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	664	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	664	24	world	world	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	664	25	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-20850	664	26	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	664	27	categories	category	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	664	28	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	664	29	unexposed	unexposed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	664	30	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	664	31	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	664	32	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	664	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	664	34	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	664	35	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	664	36	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	664	37	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	664	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	664	39	150	150	NUM
inlawrev-20850	664	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	665	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	665	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	665	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	665	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	665	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	665	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	665	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	665	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	665	9	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	665	10	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	665	11	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	665	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	665	13	349	349	NUM
inlawrev-20850	665	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	665	15	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	665	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	665	17	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	665	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	665	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	666	1	151	151	NUM
inlawrev-20850	666	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	667	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	667	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	5	sander	sander	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	6	greenland	greenland	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	7	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	667	8	james	james	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	9	m.	m.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	10	robins	robins	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	12	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	14	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	667	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	667	18	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	667	20	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	22	40	40	NUM
inlawrev-20850	667	23	jurimetrics	jurimetric	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	24	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	25	321	321	NUM
inlawrev-20850	667	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	27	322	322	NUM
inlawrev-20850	667	28	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	29	2000	2000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	667	30	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	31	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	32	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	667	33	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	667	34	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	35	equating	equate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	667	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	667	37	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	667	39	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	40	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	667	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	667	42	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	667	43	fraction	fraction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	44	leads	lead	VERB
inlawrev-20850	667	45	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	667	46	systematic	systematic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	667	47	underestimation	underestimation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	48	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	49	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	667	50	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	51	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	667	52	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	53	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	54	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	55	bernard	bernard	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	56	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	57	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	58	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	59	toxic	toxic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	60	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	61	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	62	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	667	63	devil	devil	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	64	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	667	65	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	667	66	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	667	67	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	68	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	69	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-20850	667	70	j.l	j.l	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	71	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	72	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	667	73	pol’y	pol’y	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	74	551	551	NUM
inlawrev-20850	667	75	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	76	57177	57177	NUM
inlawrev-20850	667	77	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	78	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-20850	667	79	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	80	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	81	criticizing	criticize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	667	82	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	667	83	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	667	84	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	667	85	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	86	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	667	87	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	667	88	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	667	89	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	668	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	668	2	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	668	3	cited	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	668	4	numerous	numerous	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	668	5	critics	critic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	668	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	668	7	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	668	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	668	9	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	668	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	669	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	669	2	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	669	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	669	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	669	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	669	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	669	7	716	716	NUM
inlawrev-20850	669	8	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	669	9	17	17	NUM
inlawrev-20850	669	10	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	669	11	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	669	12	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	669	13	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	669	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	669	15	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	669	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	669	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	669	18	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	669	19	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	669	20	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	669	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	670	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	670	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	670	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	670	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	670	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	670	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	670	7	28	28	NUM
inlawrev-20850	670	8	cmt	cmt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	670	9	c.	c.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	670	10	reporters	reporters	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	670	11	’	’	PART
inlawrev-20850	670	12	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	670	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	670	14	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	670	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	670	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	670	17	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	670	18	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	670	19	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	670	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	670	21	scholarly	scholarly	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	670	22	literature	literature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	670	23	discussing	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	670	24	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	670	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	670	26	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	670	27	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	670	28	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	670	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	671	1	152	152	NUM
inlawrev-20850	671	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	672	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	672	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	672	3	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	672	4	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	672	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	672	6	714	714	NUM
inlawrev-20850	672	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	673	1	153	153	NUM
inlawrev-20850	673	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	673	3	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	673	4	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	673	5	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	673	6	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	673	7	mention	mention	VERB
inlawrev-20850	673	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	673	9	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	673	10	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	673	11	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	673	12	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	673	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	673	14	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	673	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	673	16	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	673	17	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	673	18	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	673	19	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	673	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	673	21	articulate	articulate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	673	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	673	23	traditional	traditional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	673	24	conception	conception	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	673	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	673	26	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	673	27	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	673	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	673	29	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	673	30	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	673	31	clearly	clearly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	673	32	employed	employ	VERB
inlawrev-20850	673	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	674	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	674	2	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	674	3	sole	sole	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	674	4	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	674	5	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	674	6	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	674	7	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	674	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	674	9	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	674	10	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	674	11	within	within	ADP
inlawrev-20850	674	12	citations	citation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	674	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	674	14	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	674	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	674	16	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	674	17	concept	concept	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	674	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	674	19	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	674	20	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	674	21	proportion	proportion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	674	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	674	23	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	674	24	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	674	25	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	674	26	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	674	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	674	28	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	674	29	proportion	proportion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	674	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	674	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	674	32	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	674	33	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	674	34	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	674	35	individuals	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	674	36	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	674	37	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	674	38	associated	associate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	674	39	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	674	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	674	41	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	674	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	674	43	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	674	44	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	675	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	675	2	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	675	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	675	4	721	721	NUM
inlawrev-20850	675	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	675	6	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	675	7	linda	linda	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	675	8	a.	a.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	675	9	bailey	bailey	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	675	10	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	675	11	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	675	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	675	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	675	14	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	675	15	guide	guide	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	675	16	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	675	17	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	675	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	675	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	675	20	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	675	21	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	675	22	center	center	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	675	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	675	24	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	675	25	manual	manual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	675	26	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	675	27	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	675	28	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	675	29	169	169	NUM
inlawrev-20850	675	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	675	31	149	149	NUM
inlawrev-20850	675	32	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	675	33	1994	1994	NUM
inlawrev-20850	675	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	675	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	675	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	676	1	142	142	NUM
inlawrev-20850	676	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	676	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	676	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	676	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	676	8	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	676	9	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	676	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	676	12	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	676	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	676	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	676	15	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	16	no	no	ADV
inlawrev-20850	676	17	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	676	18	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	676	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	676	20	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	21	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	676	22	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	676	23	double	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	676	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	676	25	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	26	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	676	27	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	676	28	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	29	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	676	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	676	31	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	32	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	676	33	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	676	34	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	676	35	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	36	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	676	37	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	676	38	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	676	39	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	676	40	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	676	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	676	42	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	43	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	676	44	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	45	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	676	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	676	47	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	676	48	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	676	49	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	676	50	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	676	51	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	52	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	676	53	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	676	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	676	55	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	676	56	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	57	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	676	58	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	676	59	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	60	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	676	61	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	676	62	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	63	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	676	64	reach	reach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	676	65	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	676	66	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	676	67	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	676	68	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	677	1	regardless	regardless	ADV
inlawrev-20850	677	2	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	677	3	the154	the154	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	677	4	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	677	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	677	6	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	677	7	categories	category	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	677	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	677	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	677	10	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	677	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	677	12	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	677	13	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	677	14	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-20850	677	15	equates	equate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	677	16	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	677	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	677	18	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	677	19	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	677	20	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	677	21	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	677	22	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	677	23	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	677	24	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	677	25	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	677	26	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	677	27	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	677	28	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	677	29	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	677	30	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	677	31	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	677	32	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	677	33	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	677	34	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	677	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	678	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	678	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	678	3	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	678	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	678	5	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	678	6	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	678	7	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	678	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	678	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	678	10	havner	havner	X
inlawrev-20850	678	11	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	678	12	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	678	13	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	678	14	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	678	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	678	16	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	678	17	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	678	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	678	19	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	678	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	678	21	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	678	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	678	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	678	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	679	1	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	679	2	premised	premise	VERB
inlawrev-20850	679	3	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	679	4	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	679	5	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	679	7	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	8	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	9	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	679	10	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	679	11	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	12	here	here	ADV
inlawrev-20850	679	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	679	14	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	679	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	679	16	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	679	17	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	679	19	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	679	20	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	679	21	referred	refer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	679	22	included	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	679	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	679	24	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	679	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	679	26	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	679	27	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	28	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	679	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	679	31	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	32	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	679	33	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	679	34	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	679	35	few	few	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	679	36	paragraphs	paragraph	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	37	earlier	early	ADV
inlawrev-20850	679	38	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	679	39	despite	despite	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	679	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	679	41	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	42	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	679	43	characterization	characterization	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	679	45	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	679	46	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	679	47	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	679	48	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	679	49	requisite	requisite	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	50	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	679	51	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	679	52	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	53	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	679	54	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	679	55	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	679	56	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	679	57	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	58	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	679	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	679	60	”155	”155	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	680	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	680	2	problems	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	680	3	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	680	4	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	680	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	680	6	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	680	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	680	8	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	680	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	680	10	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	680	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	680	12	go	go	VERB
inlawrev-20850	680	13	far	far	ADV
inlawrev-20850	680	14	beyond	beyond	ADP
inlawrev-20850	680	15	inconsistency	inconsistency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	680	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	681	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	681	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	681	3	name	name	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	681	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	681	5	defending	defend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	681	6	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	681	7	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	681	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	681	9	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	681	10	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	681	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	681	12	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	681	13	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	681	14	did	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	681	15	violence	violence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	681	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	681	17	elementary	elementary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	681	18	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	681	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	681	20	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	681	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	681	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	681	23	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	681	24	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	681	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	682	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	682	2	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	682	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	682	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	682	5	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	682	6	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	682	7	works	work	VERB
inlawrev-20850	682	8	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-20850	682	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	682	10	something	something	PRON
inlawrev-20850	682	11	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-20850	682	12	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	682	13	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	682	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	682	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	682	16	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	682	17	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	682	18	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	682	19	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	682	20	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	682	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	682	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	682	23	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	682	24	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	682	25	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	682	26	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	682	27	inappropriate	inappropriate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	682	28	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	682	29	science	science	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	682	30	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	682	31	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	682	32	tell	tell	VERB
inlawrev-20850	682	33	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	682	34	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	682	35	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	682	36	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	682	37	defendant(s	defendant(s	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	682	38	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	682	39	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	682	40	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	682	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	682	42	cellular	cellular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	682	43	alterations	alteration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	682	44	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	682	45	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	682	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	682	47	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	682	48	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	682	49	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	682	50	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	682	51	developed	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	682	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	683	1	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	683	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	683	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	683	4	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	683	5	need	need	AUX
inlawrev-20850	683	6	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	683	7	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	683	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	683	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	683	10	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	683	11	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	683	12	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	683	13	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	683	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	683	15	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	683	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	683	17	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	683	18	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	683	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	683	20	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	683	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	684	1	science	science	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	684	2	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	684	3	say	say	VERB
inlawrev-20850	684	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	684	5	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	684	6	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	684	7	contributed	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	684	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	684	9	risk	risk	VERB
inlawrev-20850	684	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	684	11	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	684	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	684	13	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	684	14	fits	fit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	684	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	684	16	contributing	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	684	17	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	684	18	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	684	19	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	684	20	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	684	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	685	1	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	685	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	685	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	685	4	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	685	5	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	685	6	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	685	7	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	685	8	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	685	9	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	685	10	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	685	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	685	12	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	685	13	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	685	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	686	1	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	686	2	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	686	3	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	686	4	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	686	5	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	686	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	686	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	686	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	686	9	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	686	10	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	686	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	686	12	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	686	13	derived	derive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	686	14	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	686	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	686	16	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	686	17	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	686	18	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	686	19	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	686	20	proving	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	686	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	686	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	686	23	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	686	24	contributed	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	686	25	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	686	26	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	686	27	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	686	28	individually	individually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	686	29	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	686	30	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	686	31	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	686	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	686	33	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	686	34	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	686	35	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	686	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	687	1	per	per	ADP
inlawrev-20850	687	2	the156	the156	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	687	3	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	687	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	687	5	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	687	6	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	687	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	687	8	such	such	DET
inlawrev-20850	687	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	687	10	showing	showing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	687	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	687	12	tantamount	tantamount	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	687	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	687	14	proving	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	687	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	687	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	687	17	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	687	18	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	687	19	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	687	20	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	687	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	687	22	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	687	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	687	24	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	687	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	687	26	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	687	27	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	687	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	687	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	687	30	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	687	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	688	1	tautologically	tautologically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	688	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	688	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	688	4	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	688	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	688	6	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	688	7	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	688	8	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	688	9	both	both	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	688	10	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	688	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	688	12	independently	independently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	688	13	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	688	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	688	15	together	together	ADV
inlawrev-20850	688	16	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	688	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	688	18	154	154	NUM
inlawrev-20850	688	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	689	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	689	2	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	689	3	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	689	4	extent	extent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	689	5	foreshadowed	foreshadow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	689	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	689	7	possibility	possibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	689	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	689	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	689	10	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	689	11	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	689	12	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	689	13	able	able	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	689	14	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	689	15	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	689	16	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	689	17	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	689	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	689	19	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	689	20	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	689	21	enough	enough	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	689	22	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	689	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	689	24	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	689	25	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	689	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	689	27	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	689	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	690	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	690	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	690	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	690	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	690	5	720	720	NUM
inlawrev-20850	690	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	690	7	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	690	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	690	9	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	690	10	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	690	11	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	690	12	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	690	13	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	690	14	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	690	15	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	690	16	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	690	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	690	18	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	690	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	690	20	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	690	21	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	690	22	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	690	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	690	24	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	690	25	received	receive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	690	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	690	27	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	690	28	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	690	29	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	690	30	equal	equal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	690	31	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	690	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	690	33	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	690	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	690	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	690	36	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	690	37	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	690	38	subjects	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	690	39	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	690	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	691	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	691	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	691	3	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	691	4	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	691	5	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	691	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	691	7	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	691	8	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	691	9	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	691	10	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	691	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	691	12	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	691	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	691	14	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	691	15	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	691	16	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	691	17	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	691	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	691	19	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	691	20	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	691	21	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	691	22	contexts	contexts	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	691	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	692	1	155	155	NUM
inlawrev-20850	692	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	693	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	693	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	693	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	693	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	693	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	693	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	693	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	693	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	693	9	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	693	10	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	693	11	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	693	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	693	13	348	348	NUM
inlawrev-20850	693	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	693	15	353	353	NUM
inlawrev-20850	693	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	693	17	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	693	18	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	693	19	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	693	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	693	21	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	693	22	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	693	23	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	693	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	693	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	694	1	156	156	NUM
inlawrev-20850	694	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	695	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	695	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	695	3	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	695	4	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	695	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	695	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	695	7	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	695	8	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	695	9	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	695	10	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	695	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	695	12	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	695	13	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	695	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	695	15	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	695	16	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	695	17	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	695	18	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	695	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	695	20	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	695	21	reliance	reliance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	695	22	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	695	23	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	695	24	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	695	25	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	695	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	695	27	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	695	28	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	695	29	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	695	30	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	695	31	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	695	32	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	695	33	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	695	34	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	695	35	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	695	36	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	695	37	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	695	38	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	695	39	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	695	40	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	695	41	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	695	42	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	695	43	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	695	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	695	45	contracting	contracting	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	695	46	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	695	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	695	48	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	696	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	696	2	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	696	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	696	4	359	359	NUM
inlawrev-20850	696	5	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	696	6	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	696	7	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	696	8	i	i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	696	9	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	696	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	696	11	353	353	NUM
inlawrev-20850	696	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	696	13	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	696	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	696	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	696	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	696	17	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	696	18	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	696	19	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	696	20	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	696	21	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	696	22	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	696	23	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	696	24	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	696	25	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	696	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	696	27	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	696	28	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	696	29	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	696	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	696	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	696	32	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	696	33	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	696	34	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	696	35	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	696	36	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	696	37	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	696	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	696	39	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	696	40	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	696	41	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	696	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	696	43	contracting	contract	VERB
inlawrev-20850	696	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	696	45	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	696	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	696	47	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	696	48	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	697	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	697	2	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	697	3	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	697	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	697	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	698	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	698	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	698	3	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	698	4	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	698	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	698	6	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	698	7	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	698	8	entails	entail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	698	9	quantitative	quantitative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	698	10	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	698	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	698	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	698	13	amount	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	698	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	698	15	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	698	16	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	698	17	resulted	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	698	18	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	698	19	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	698	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	698	21	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	698	22	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	698	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	698	24	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	698	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	698	26	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	698	27	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	698	28	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	698	29	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	698	30	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	698	31	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	698	32	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	698	33	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	698	34	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	698	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	698	36	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	698	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	699	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	699	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	699	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	699	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	699	5	353	353	NUM
inlawrev-20850	699	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	699	7	356	356	NUM
inlawrev-20850	699	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	699	9	358	358	NUM
inlawrev-20850	699	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	699	11	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	699	12	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	699	13	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	699	14	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	699	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	699	16	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	699	17	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	700	1	143	143	PRON
inlawrev-20850	700	2	universe	universe	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	700	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	700	4	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	700	5	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	700	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	700	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	700	8	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	700	9	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	700	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	700	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	700	12	bring	bring	VERB
inlawrev-20850	700	13	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	700	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	700	15	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	700	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	701	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	701	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	701	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	701	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	701	5	invented	invent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	701	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	701	7	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	701	8	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	701	9	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	701	10	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	701	11	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	701	12	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	701	13	for	for	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	701	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	701	15	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	701	16	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	701	17	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	701	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	701	19	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	701	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	701	21	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	701	22	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	701	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	701	24	bringing	bring	VERB
inlawrev-20850	701	25	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	701	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	701	27	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	701	28	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	701	29	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	701	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	701	31	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	701	32	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	701	33	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	701	34	independently	independently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	701	35	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	701	36	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	701	37	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	701	38	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	701	39	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	701	40	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	701	41	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	701	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	701	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	701	44	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	701	45	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	701	46	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	701	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	702	1	conversely	conversely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	702	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	702	3	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-20850	702	4	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	702	5	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	702	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	702	7	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	702	8	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	702	9	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	702	10	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	702	11	be157	be157	VERB
inlawrev-20850	702	12	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	702	13	factors.158	factors.158	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	702	14	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	702	15	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	702	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	702	17	inconsistent	inconsistent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	702	18	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	702	19	elementary	elementary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	702	20	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	702	21	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	702	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	703	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	703	2	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	703	3	various	various	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	703	4	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	703	5	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	703	6	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	703	7	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	703	8	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	703	9	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	703	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	703	11	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	703	12	elevated	elevated	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	703	13	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	703	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	703	15	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	703	16	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	703	17	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	703	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	703	19	function	function	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	703	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	703	21	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	703	22	aggregate	aggregate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	703	23	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	703	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	703	25	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	703	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	703	27	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	703	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	703	29	separate	separate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	703	30	functions	function	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	703	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	703	32	discrete	discrete	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	703	33	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	703	34	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	703	35	separate	separate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	703	36	contributors	contributor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	703	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	704	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	704	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	704	3	majority	majority	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	704	4	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	704	5	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	704	6	illogically	illogically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	704	7	implies	imply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	704	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	704	9	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	704	10	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	704	11	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	704	12	tortiously	tortiously	ADV
inlawrev-20850	704	13	contribute	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	704	14	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	704	15	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	704	16	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	704	17	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	704	18	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	704	19	cumulatively	cumulatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	704	20	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	704	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	704	22	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	704	23	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	704	24	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	704	25	i.e.	i.e.	X
inlawrev-20850	704	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	704	27	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	704	28	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	704	29	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	704	30	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	704	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	704	32	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	704	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	704	34	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	704	35	none	none	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	704	36	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	704	37	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	704	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	704	39	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	704	40	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	704	41	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	704	42	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	704	43	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	704	44	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	704	45	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	704	46	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	704	47	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	704	48	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	704	49	every	every	DET
inlawrev-20850	704	50	separate	separate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	704	51	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	704	52	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	704	53	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	704	54	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	704	55	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	704	56	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	704	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	704	58	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	704	59	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	704	60	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	704	61	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	704	62	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	704	63	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	704	64	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	705	1	imagine	imagine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	705	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	705	3	poison	poison	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	705	4	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	705	5	causes	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	705	6	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	705	7	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	705	8	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	705	9	all	all	ADV
inlawrev-20850	705	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	705	11	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	705	12	less	less	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	705	13	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	705	14	100	100	NUM
inlawrev-20850	705	15	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	705	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	705	17	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	705	18	157	157	NUM
inlawrev-20850	705	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	706	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	706	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	706	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	706	4	373	373	NUM
inlawrev-20850	706	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	706	6	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	706	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	706	8	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	706	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	706	10	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	706	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	706	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	707	1	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	707	2	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	707	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	707	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	707	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	707	6	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	707	7	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	707	8	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	707	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	707	10	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	707	11	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	707	12	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	707	13	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	707	14	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	707	15	exceeded	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	707	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	707	17	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	707	18	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	707	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	707	20	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	707	21	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	707	22	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	707	23	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	707	24	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	707	25	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	707	26	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	707	27	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	707	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	707	29	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	707	30	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	707	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	707	32	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	707	33	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	707	34	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	707	35	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	707	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	707	37	classic	classic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	707	38	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	707	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	707	40	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	707	41	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	707	42	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	707	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	708	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	708	2	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	708	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	708	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	708	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	708	6	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	708	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	708	8	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	708	9	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	708	10	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	708	11	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	708	12	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	708	13	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	708	14	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	708	15	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	708	16	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	708	17	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	708	18	own	own	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	708	19	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	708	20	combined	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	708	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	708	22	bring	bring	VERB
inlawrev-20850	708	23	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	708	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	708	25	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	708	26	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	708	27	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	708	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	708	29	none	none	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	708	30	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	708	31	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	708	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	708	33	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	708	34	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	708	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	709	1	158	158	NUM
inlawrev-20850	709	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	710	1	remarkably	remarkably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	710	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	710	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	710	4	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	710	5	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	710	6	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	710	7	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	710	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	710	9	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	710	10	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	710	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	710	12	issue	issue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	710	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	710	14	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	710	15	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	710	16	such	such	DET
inlawrev-20850	710	17	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	710	18	effect	effect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	710	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	711	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	711	2	ford	ford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	711	3	motor	motor	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	711	4	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	711	5	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	711	6	boomer	boomer	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	711	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	711	8	736	736	NUM
inlawrev-20850	711	9	s.e.2d	s.e.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	711	10	724	724	NUM
inlawrev-20850	711	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	711	12	va	va	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	711	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	711	14	2013	2013	NUM
inlawrev-20850	711	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	711	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	711	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	711	18	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	711	19	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	711	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	711	21	virginia	virginia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	711	22	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	711	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	711	24	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	711	25	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	711	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	711	27	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	711	28	trooper	trooper	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	711	29	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	711	30	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	711	31	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	711	32	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	711	33	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	711	34	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	711	35	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	711	36	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	711	37	ford	ford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	711	38	brakes	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	711	39	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	711	40	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	711	41	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	711	42	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	711	43	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	711	44	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	711	45	along	along	ADP
inlawrev-20850	711	46	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	711	47	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	711	48	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	711	49	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	711	50	brands	brand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	711	51	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	711	52	brakes	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	711	53	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	711	54	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	711	55	vehicle	vehicle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	711	56	inspections	inspection	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	711	57	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	712	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	712	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	712	3	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	712	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	712	5	difficulty	difficulty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	712	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	712	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	712	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	712	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	712	10	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	712	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	712	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	712	13	lifetime	lifetime	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	712	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	712	15	potential	potential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	712	16	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	712	17	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	712	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	712	19	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	712	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	712	21	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	712	22	designating	designate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	712	23	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	712	24	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	712	25	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	712	26	causative	causative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	712	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	712	28	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	713	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	713	2	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	713	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	713	4	729	729	NUM
inlawrev-20850	713	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	714	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	714	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	714	3	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	714	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	714	5	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	714	6	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	714	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	714	8	traditional	traditional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	714	9	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	714	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	714	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	714	12	definition	definition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	714	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	714	14	proximate	proximate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	714	15	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	714	16	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	714	17	invoked	invoke	VERB
inlawrev-20850	714	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	714	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	714	20	injured	injure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	714	21	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	714	22	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	714	23	virtually	virtually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	714	24	never	never	ADV
inlawrev-20850	714	25	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	714	26	able	able	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	714	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	714	28	recover	recover	VERB
inlawrev-20850	714	29	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	714	30	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	714	31	arising	arise	VERB
inlawrev-20850	714	32	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	714	33	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	714	34	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	714	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	714	36	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	714	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	714	38	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	714	39	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	714	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	714	41	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	715	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	715	2	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	715	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	715	4	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	715	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	715	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	715	7	recognizing	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	715	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	715	9	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	715	10	thing	thing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	715	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	715	12	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	715	13	instructed	instruct	VERB
inlawrev-20850	715	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	715	15	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	715	16	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	715	17	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	715	18	causationin	causationin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	715	19	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	715	20	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	715	21	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	715	22	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	715	23	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	715	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	715	25	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	715	26	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	715	27	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	715	28	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	715	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	715	30	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	715	31	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	715	32	contributing	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	715	33	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	715	34	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	715	35	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	715	36	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	715	37	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	715	38	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	715	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	715	40	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	716	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	716	2	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	716	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	716	4	153	153	NUM
inlawrev-20850	716	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	716	6	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	716	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	716	8	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	716	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	716	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	717	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	717	2	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	717	3	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	717	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	717	5	virginia	virginia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	717	6	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	717	7	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	717	8	instruction	instruction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	717	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	717	10	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	717	11	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	717	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	717	13	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-20850	717	14	misreading	misreading	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	717	15	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	717	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	717	17	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	717	18	third	third	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	717	19	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	717	20	renunciation	renunciation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	717	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	717	22	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	717	23	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	717	24	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	717	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	717	26	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	718	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	718	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	718	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	718	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	718	5	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	718	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	718	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	718	8	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	718	9	third	third	ADV
inlawrev-20850	718	10	asserted	assert	VERB
inlawrev-20850	718	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	718	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	718	13	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	718	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	718	15	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	718	16	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	718	17	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	718	18	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	718	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	718	20	only	only	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	718	21	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	718	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	718	23	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	718	24	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	718	25	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	718	26	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	718	27	utility	utility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	718	28	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	718	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	718	30	substitute	substitute	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	718	31	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	718	32	strict	strict	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	718	33	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	718	34	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	718	35	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	718	36	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	718	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	719	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	719	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	719	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	719	4	731	731	NUM
inlawrev-20850	719	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	720	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	3	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	720	4	reasoned	reason	VERB
inlawrev-20850	720	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	720	6	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	720	7	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	720	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	720	10	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	11	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	720	12	impossible	impossible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	720	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	720	14	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	720	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	720	16	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	720	17	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	18	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	19	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	20	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	22	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	720	23	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	24	for	for	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	25	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	720	26	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	720	27	replaced	replace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	720	28	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	720	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	720	30	only	only	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	720	31	available	available	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	720	32	option	option	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	33	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	34	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	720	35	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	36	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	720	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	720	38	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	39	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	40	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	720	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	720	42	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	43	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	720	44	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	46	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	720	47	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	720	48	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	720	49	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	720	50	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	720	51	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	52	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	720	53	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	54	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	55	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	720	56	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	720	57	treated	treat	VERB
inlawrev-20850	720	58	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	720	59	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	720	60	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	61	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	62	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	720	63	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	64	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	65	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	720	66	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	720	67	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	720	68	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	720	69	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	720	70	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	71	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	72	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	720	73	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	720	74	]	]	X
inlawrev-20850	720	75	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	720	76	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	720	77	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	720	78	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	79	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	720	80	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	720	81	prior	prior	ADV
inlawrev-20850	720	82	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	720	83	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	720	84	development	development	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	85	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	720	86	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	720	87	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	88	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	720	89	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	90	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	720	91	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	92	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	720	93	constitute	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	720	94	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	720	95	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	720	96	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	720	97	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	720	98	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	99	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	720	100	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	720	101	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	102	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	720	103	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	720	104	concurring	concurring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	105	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	720	106	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	720	107	virginia	virginia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	720	108	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	720	109	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	721	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	721	2	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	721	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	721	4	732	732	NUM
inlawrev-20850	721	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	722	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	722	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	722	3	boomer	boomer	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	722	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	722	5	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	722	6	seemed	seem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	722	7	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-20850	722	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	722	9	misunderstand	misunderstand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	722	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	722	11	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	722	12	third	third	ADV
inlawrev-20850	722	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	722	14	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	722	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	722	16	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	722	17	mistake	mistake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	722	18	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	722	19	bostic	bostic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	722	20	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	722	21	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	722	22	every	every	DET
inlawrev-20850	722	23	concurring	concurring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	722	24	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	722	25	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	722	26	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	722	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	722	28	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	722	29	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	722	30	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	722	31	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	722	32	recognizing	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	722	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	722	34	possibility	possibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	722	35	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	722	36	individually	individually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	722	37	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	722	38	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	722	39	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	722	40	combine	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	722	41	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	722	42	create	create	VERB
inlawrev-20850	722	43	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	722	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	723	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	723	2	boomer	boomer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	723	3	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	723	4	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	723	5	open	open	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	723	6	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	723	7	honest	honest	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	723	8	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	723	9	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	723	10	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	723	11	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	723	12	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	723	13	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	723	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	723	15	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	723	16	shrouded	shroud	VERB
inlawrev-20850	723	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	723	18	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	723	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	723	20	hidden	hidden	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	723	21	changes	change	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	723	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	723	23	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	723	24	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	723	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	723	26	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	723	27	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	723	28	created	create	VERB
inlawrev-20850	723	29	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	723	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	723	31	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	723	32	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	723	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	724	1	144	144	NUM
inlawrev-20850	724	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	724	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	724	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	724	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	724	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	724	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	725	1	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	725	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	725	3	invariably	invariably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	725	4	lethal	lethal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	725	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	725	6	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	725	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	725	8	100	100	NUM
inlawrev-20850	725	9	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	725	10	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	725	11	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	725	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	726	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	726	2	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	726	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	726	4	ten	ten	NUM
inlawrev-20850	726	5	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	726	6	exposes	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	726	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	726	8	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	726	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	726	10	ten	ten	NUM
inlawrev-20850	726	11	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	726	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	726	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	726	14	poison	poison	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	726	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	726	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	726	17	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	726	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	726	19	every	every	DET
inlawrev-20850	726	20	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	726	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	726	22	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	726	23	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	726	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	726	25	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	726	26	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	726	27	infact	infact	VERB
inlawrev-20850	726	28	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	726	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	726	30	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	726	31	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	726	32	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	726	33	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	726	34	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	726	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	726	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	726	37	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	726	38	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	726	39	death	death	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	726	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	726	41	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	726	42	though	though	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	726	43	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	726	44	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	726	45	contributed	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	726	46	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	726	47	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	726	48	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	726	49	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	726	50	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	726	51	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	726	52	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	726	53	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	727	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	2	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	3	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	727	5	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	727	6	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	727	7	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	8	exposes	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	727	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	10	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	12	ninety	ninety	NUM
inlawrev-20850	727	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	727	14	nine	nine	NUM
inlawrev-20850	727	15	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	727	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	18	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	727	19	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	20	exposes	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	727	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	22	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	23	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	24	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	727	25	unit	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	727	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	28	acts	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	30	both	both	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	31	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	32	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	727	33	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	727	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	35	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	727	36	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	727	37	unit	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	38	contributor	contributor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	39	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	727	40	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	727	41	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	727	42	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	727	43	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	44	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	47	death.159	death.159	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	727	48	now	now	ADV
inlawrev-20850	727	49	suppose	suppose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	727	50	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	727	51	instead	instead	ADV
inlawrev-20850	727	52	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	53	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	54	sharp	sharp	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	727	55	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	56	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	57	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	58	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	727	59	never	never	ADV
inlawrev-20850	727	60	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	727	61	always	always	ADV
inlawrev-20850	727	62	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	727	63	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	64	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	727	65	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	66	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	67	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	68	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	69	gradually	gradually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	727	70	increases	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	727	71	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	72	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	73	amount	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	74	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	75	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	76	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	727	77	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	727	78	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	727	79	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	80	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	81	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	82	100	100	NUM
inlawrev-20850	727	83	confers	confer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	84	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-20850	727	85	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	727	86	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	87	double	double	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	88	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	89	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	90	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	91	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	92	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	93	compared	compare	VERB
inlawrev-20850	727	94	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	95	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	727	96	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	97	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	98	zero	zero	NUM
inlawrev-20850	727	99	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	727	100	unexposed	unexposed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	727	101	people	people	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	727	102	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	728	1	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	728	2	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	728	3	increase	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	728	4	above	above	ADP
inlawrev-20850	728	5	100	100	NUM
inlawrev-20850	728	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	728	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	728	8	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	728	9	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	728	10	increases	increase	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	728	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	728	12	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	728	13	always	always	ADV
inlawrev-20850	728	14	exceeds	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	728	15	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	728	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	729	1	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	729	2	smaller	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	729	3	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	729	4	100	100	NUM
inlawrev-20850	729	5	increase	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	729	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	729	7	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	729	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	729	9	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	729	10	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	729	11	less	less	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	729	12	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	729	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	729	14	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	729	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	729	16	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	729	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	730	1	assume	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	730	2	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	730	3	a160	a160	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	730	4	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	730	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	730	6	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	730	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	730	8	100	100	NUM
inlawrev-20850	730	9	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	730	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	730	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	730	12	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	730	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	731	1	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	731	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	731	3	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	731	4	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	731	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	731	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	731	7	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	731	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	731	9	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	731	10	exceeded	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	731	11	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	731	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	731	13	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	731	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	731	15	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	731	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	731	17	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	731	18	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	731	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	731	20	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	731	21	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	731	22	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	731	23	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	731	24	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	731	25	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	731	26	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	731	27	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	731	28	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	731	29	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	731	30	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	731	31	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	731	32	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	731	33	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	731	34	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	731	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	731	36	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	731	37	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	731	38	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	731	39	opposed	oppose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	731	40	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	731	41	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	731	42	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	731	43	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	731	44	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	731	45	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	731	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	731	47	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	731	48	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	731	49	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	731	50	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	731	51	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	731	52	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	731	53	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	731	54	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	731	55	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	731	56	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	731	57	illness	illness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	731	58	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	732	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	732	2	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	732	3	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	732	4	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	732	5	tortiously	tortiously	ADV
inlawrev-20850	732	6	responsible	responsible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	732	7	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	732	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	732	9	entire	entire	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	732	10	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	732	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	732	12	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	732	13	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	732	14	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	732	15	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	732	16	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	732	17	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	732	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	732	19	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	732	20	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	732	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	732	22	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	732	23	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	732	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	732	25	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	732	26	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	732	27	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	732	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	733	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	733	2	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	733	3	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	733	4	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	733	5	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	733	6	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	733	7	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	733	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	733	9	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	733	10	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	733	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	733	12	fifty	fifty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	733	13	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	733	14	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	733	15	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	733	16	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	733	17	tortfeasors	tortfeasor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	733	18	acting	act	VERB
inlawrev-20850	733	19	independently	independently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	733	20	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	734	1	once	once	ADV
inlawrev-20850	734	2	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-20850	734	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	734	4	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	734	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	734	6	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	734	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	734	8	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	734	9	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	734	10	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	734	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	734	12	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	734	13	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	734	14	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	734	15	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	734	16	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	734	17	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	734	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	734	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	734	20	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	734	21	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	734	22	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	734	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	734	24	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	734	25	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	734	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	734	27	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	734	28	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	734	29	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	734	30	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	734	31	exceeded	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	734	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	735	1	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	735	2	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	735	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	735	4	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	735	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	735	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	735	7	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	735	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	735	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	735	10	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	735	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	735	12	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	735	13	exceedance	exceedance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	735	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	736	1	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	736	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	736	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	736	4	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	736	5	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	736	6	either	either	DET
inlawrev-20850	736	7	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	736	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	736	9	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	736	10	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	736	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	736	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	736	13	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	736	14	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	736	15	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	736	16	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	736	17	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	736	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	736	19	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	736	20	fifty	fifty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	736	21	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	736	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	736	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	736	24	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	736	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	736	26	making	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	736	27	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	736	28	less	less	ADV
inlawrev-20850	736	29	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	736	30	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	736	31	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	736	32	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	736	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	736	34	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	736	35	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	736	36	illness	illness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	736	37	resulted	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	736	38	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	736	39	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	736	40	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	736	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	736	42	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	736	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	737	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	737	2	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	737	3	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	737	4	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	737	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	737	6	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	737	7	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	737	8	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	737	9	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	737	10	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	737	11	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	737	12	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	737	13	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	737	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	737	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	737	16	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	737	17	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	737	18	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	737	19	resulted	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	737	20	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	737	21	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	737	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	737	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	737	24	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	737	25	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	737	26	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	737	27	opposed	oppose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	737	28	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	737	29	being	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	737	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	737	31	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	737	32	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	737	33	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	737	34	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	737	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	737	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	738	1	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	738	2	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	738	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	738	4	neither	neither	DET
inlawrev-20850	738	5	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	738	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	738	7	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	738	8	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	738	9	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	738	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	738	11	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	738	12	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	738	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	738	14	bringing	bring	VERB
inlawrev-20850	738	15	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	738	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	738	17	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	738	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	738	19	neither	neither	DET
inlawrev-20850	738	20	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	738	21	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	738	22	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	738	23	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	738	24	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	738	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	738	26	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	738	27	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	738	28	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	738	29	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	738	30	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	738	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	739	1	next	next	ADV
inlawrev-20850	739	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	739	3	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	739	4	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	739	5	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	739	6	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	739	7	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	739	8	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	739	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	739	10	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	739	11	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	739	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	739	13	ninety	ninety	NUM
inlawrev-20850	739	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	739	15	nine	nine	NUM
inlawrev-20850	739	16	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	739	17	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	739	18	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	739	19	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	739	20	tortfeasors	tortfeasor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	739	21	acting	act	VERB
inlawrev-20850	739	22	independently	independently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	739	23	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	740	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	740	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	740	3	sake	sake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	740	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	740	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	740	6	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	740	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	740	8	assume	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	740	9	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-20850	740	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	740	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	740	12	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	740	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	740	14	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	740	15	curve	curve	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	740	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	740	17	linear	linear	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	740	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	740	19	so	so	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	740	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	740	21	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	740	22	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	740	23	cumulative	cumulative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	740	24	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	740	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	740	26	297	297	NUM
inlawrev-20850	740	27	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	740	28	confers	confer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	740	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	740	30	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	740	31	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	740	32	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	740	33	close	close	ADV
inlawrev-20850	740	34	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	740	35	six	six	NUM
inlawrev-20850	740	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	741	1	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	741	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	741	3	logic	logic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	741	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	741	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	741	6	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	741	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	741	8	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	741	9	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	741	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	741	11	one	one	PRON
inlawrev-20850	741	12	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	741	13	infer	infer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	741	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	741	15	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	741	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	741	17	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	741	18	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	741	19	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	741	20	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	741	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	741	22	159	159	NUM
inlawrev-20850	741	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	742	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	742	2	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	742	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	742	4	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	742	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	742	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	742	7	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	742	8	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	742	9	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	742	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	743	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	743	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	743	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	743	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	743	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	743	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	743	7	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	743	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	743	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	744	1	b	b	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	744	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	744	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	744	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	745	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	745	2	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	745	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	745	4	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	745	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	745	6	absence	absence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	745	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	745	8	overdetermined	overdetermined	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	745	9	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	745	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	745	11	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	745	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	745	13	actor	actor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	745	14	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	745	15	negligently	negligently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	745	16	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	745	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	745	18	straw	straw	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	745	19	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	745	20	breaks	break	VERB
inlawrev-20850	745	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	745	22	camel	camel	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	745	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	745	24	back	back	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	745	25	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	745	26	subject	subject	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	745	27	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	745	28	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	745	29	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	745	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	745	31	broken	broken	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	745	32	back	back	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	745	33	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	745	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	745	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	746	1	160	160	NUM
inlawrev-20850	746	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	747	1	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	747	2	long	long	ADV
inlawrev-20850	747	3	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	747	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	747	5	relationship	relationship	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	747	6	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	747	7	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	747	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	747	9	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	747	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	747	11	monotonic	monotonic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	747	12	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	747	13	that	that	ADV
inlawrev-20850	747	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	747	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	747	16	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	747	17	long	long	ADV
inlawrev-20850	747	18	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	747	19	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	747	20	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	747	21	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	747	22	always	always	ADV
inlawrev-20850	747	23	confers	confer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	747	24	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	747	25	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	747	26	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	747	27	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	747	28	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	747	29	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	747	30	smaller	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	747	31	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	747	32	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	747	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	747	34	exact	exact	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	747	35	shape	shape	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	747	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	747	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	747	38	doseresponse	doseresponse	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	747	39	curve	curve	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	747	40	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	747	41	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	747	42	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	747	43	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	747	44	unimportant	unimportant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	747	45	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	747	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	747	47	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	747	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	748	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	748	2	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	748	3	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	748	4	linear	linear	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	748	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	748	6	logarithmic	logarithmic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	748	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	748	8	exponential	exponential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	748	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	748	10	logistic	logistic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	748	11	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	748	12	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	748	13	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	748	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	749	1	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	749	2	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	749	3	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	749	4	seen	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	749	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	749	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	749	7	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	749	8	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	749	9	remains	remain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	749	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	749	11	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	749	12	regardless	regardless	ADV
inlawrev-20850	749	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	749	14	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	749	15	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	749	16	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	749	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	749	18	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	749	19	dose	dose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	749	20	below	below	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	749	21	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	749	22	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	749	23	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	749	24	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	749	25	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	749	26	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	749	27	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	749	28	all	all	ADV
inlawrev-20850	749	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	750	1	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	750	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	750	3	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	750	4	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	750	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	750	6	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	750	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	750	8	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-20850	750	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	750	10	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	750	11	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	750	12	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	750	13	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	750	14	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	750	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	751	1	yet	yet	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	751	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	751	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	751	4	majority	majority	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	751	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	751	6	holding161	holding161	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	751	7	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	751	8	compel	compel	VERB
inlawrev-20850	751	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	751	10	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	751	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	751	12	none	none	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	751	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	751	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	751	15	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	751	16	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	751	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	751	18	illness	illness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	751	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	752	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	752	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	752	3	immediately	immediately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	752	4	preceding	precede	VERB
inlawrev-20850	752	5	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	752	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	752	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	752	8	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	752	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	752	10	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	752	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	752	12	overdetermined	overdetermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	752	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	753	1	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	753	2	single	single	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	753	3	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	753	4	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	753	5	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	753	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	753	7	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	753	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	754	1	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	754	2	single	single	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	754	3	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	754	4	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	754	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	754	6	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	754	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	754	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	754	9	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	754	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	754	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	754	12	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	754	13	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	754	14	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	754	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	754	16	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	754	17	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	754	18	absent	absent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	754	19	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	754	20	one	one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	754	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	754	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	754	23	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	754	24	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	754	25	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	754	26	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-20850	754	27	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	754	28	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	754	29	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	754	30	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	754	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	754	32	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	754	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	755	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	755	2	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	755	3	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	755	4	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	755	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	755	6	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	755	7	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	755	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	755	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	755	10	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	755	11	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	755	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	755	13	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	755	14	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	755	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	755	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	755	17	together	together	ADV
inlawrev-20850	755	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	755	19	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	755	20	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	755	21	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	755	22	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	755	23	nearly	nearly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	755	24	quadrupled	quadruple	VERB
inlawrev-20850	755	25	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	755	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	755	27	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	755	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	755	29	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	755	30	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	755	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	755	32	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	755	33	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	755	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	756	1	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	756	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	756	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	756	4	dissenters	dissenter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	756	5	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	756	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	756	7	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	756	8	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	756	9	closely	closely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	756	10	parallels	parallel	VERB
inlawrev-20850	756	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	756	12	illustration	illustration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	756	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	756	14	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	756	15	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	756	16	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	756	17	sets	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	756	18	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	756	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	756	20	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	756	21	third	third	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	756	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	757	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	757	2	illustration162	illustration162	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	757	3	explains	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	757	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	757	5	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	757	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	757	7	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	757	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	757	9	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	757	10	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	757	11	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	757	12	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	757	13	sets	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	757	14	exist	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	757	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	757	16	every	every	DET
inlawrev-20850	757	17	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	757	18	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	757	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	757	20	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	757	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	757	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	757	23	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	757	24	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	757	25	sets	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	757	26	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	757	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	757	28	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	757	29	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	757	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	757	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	757	32	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	757	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	758	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	758	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	758	3	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	758	4	quoted	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	758	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	758	6	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	758	7	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	758	8	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	758	9	ignored	ignore	VERB
inlawrev-20850	758	10	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	758	11	teaching	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	758	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	758	13	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	758	14	instead	instead	ADV
inlawrev-20850	758	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	758	16	none	none	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	758	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	758	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	758	19	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	758	20	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	758	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	758	22	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	758	23	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	758	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	759	1	finally	finally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	759	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	759	3	return	return	VERB
inlawrev-20850	759	4	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	759	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	759	6	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	759	7	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	759	8	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	759	9	received	receive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	759	10	ten	ten	NUM
inlawrev-20850	759	11	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	759	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	759	13	ten	ten	NUM
inlawrev-20850	759	14	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	759	15	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	759	16	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	759	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	759	18	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	759	19	acts	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	759	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	759	21	ten	ten	NUM
inlawrev-20850	759	22	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	759	23	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	759	24	acting	act	VERB
inlawrev-20850	759	25	independently	independently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	759	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	760	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	760	2	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	760	3	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	760	4	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	760	5	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	760	6	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-20850	760	7	posits	posit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	760	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	760	9	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	760	10	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	760	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	760	12	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	760	13	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	760	14	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	760	15	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	760	16	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	760	17	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	760	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	760	19	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	760	20	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	760	21	illness	illness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	760	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	761	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	761	2	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-20850	761	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	761	4	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	761	5	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	761	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	761	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	761	8	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	761	9	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	761	10	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	761	11	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	761	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	761	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	761	14	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	761	15	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	761	16	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	761	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	761	18	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	761	19	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	761	20	absent	absent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	761	21	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	761	22	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	761	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	761	24	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	761	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	761	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	761	27	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	761	28	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	761	29	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	761	30	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	761	31	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	761	32	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	761	33	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	761	34	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	761	35	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	761	36	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	761	37	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	761	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	761	39	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	761	40	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	761	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	762	1	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	762	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	762	3	true	true	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	762	4	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	762	5	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	762	6	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	762	7	ten	ten	NUM
inlawrev-20850	762	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	762	9	unit	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	762	10	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	762	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	762	12	below	below	ADP
inlawrev-20850	762	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	762	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	762	15	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	762	16	effect	effect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	762	17	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	762	18	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	762	19	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	762	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	762	21	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	762	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	763	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	763	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	763	3	scenario	scenario	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	763	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	763	5	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	763	6	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	763	7	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	763	8	act	act	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	763	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	763	10	alone	alone	ADV
inlawrev-20850	763	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	763	12	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	763	13	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	763	14	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	763	15	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	763	16	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	763	17	all	all	ADV
inlawrev-20850	763	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	764	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	764	2	combined	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	764	3	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	764	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	764	5	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	764	6	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	764	7	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	764	8	acts	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	764	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	764	10	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	764	11	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	764	12	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	764	13	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	764	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	764	15	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	764	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	764	17	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	764	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	764	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	764	20	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	764	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	764	22	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	764	23	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	764	24	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	764	25	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	764	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	764	27	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	764	28	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	764	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	764	30	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	764	31	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	764	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	764	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	764	34	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	764	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	765	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	765	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	765	3	majority	majority	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	765	4	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	765	5	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	765	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	765	7	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	765	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	765	9	once	once	ADV
inlawrev-20850	765	10	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-20850	765	11	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	765	12	compel	compel	VERB
inlawrev-20850	765	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	765	14	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	765	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	765	16	none	none	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	765	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	765	18	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	765	19	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	765	20	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	765	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	765	22	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	765	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	765	24	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	765	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	766	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	766	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	766	3	sub	sub	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	766	4	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	766	5	threshold	threshold	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	766	6	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	766	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	766	8	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	766	9	ten	ten	NUM
inlawrev-20850	766	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	766	11	unit	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	766	12	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	766	13	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	766	14	analogous	analogous	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	766	15	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	766	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	766	17	driver	driver	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	766	18	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	766	19	speeds	speed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	766	20	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	766	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	766	22	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-20850	766	23	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	766	24	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	766	25	stop	stop	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	766	26	past	past	ADP
inlawrev-20850	766	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	766	28	pedestrian	pedestrian	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	766	29	standing	stand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	766	30	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	766	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	766	32	sidewalk	sidewalk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	766	33	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	766	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	766	35	corner	corner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	766	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	767	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	767	2	driver	driver	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	767	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	767	4	negligent	negligent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	767	5	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	767	6	causes	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	767	7	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	767	8	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	767	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	767	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	767	11	pedestrian	pedestrian	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	767	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	768	1	another	another	DET
inlawrev-20850	768	2	driver	driver	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	768	3	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	768	4	run	run	VERB
inlawrev-20850	768	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	768	6	stop	stop	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	768	7	sign	sign	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	768	8	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	768	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	768	10	crossing	crossing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	768	11	street	street	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	768	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	768	13	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-20850	768	14	with	with	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	768	15	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	768	16	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	768	17	done	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	768	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	769	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	769	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	769	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	4	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	769	5	drivers	driver	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	6	happen	happen	VERB
inlawrev-20850	769	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	769	8	run	run	VERB
inlawrev-20850	769	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	10	stop	stop	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	11	sign	sign	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	12	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	769	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	14	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	769	15	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	769	17	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	769	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	19	collision	collision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	20	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	769	21	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	769	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	23	pedestrian	pedestrian	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	24	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	769	25	injured	injure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	769	26	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	769	27	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	769	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	769	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	30	ricocheting	ricocheting	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	769	31	vehicles	vehicle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	769	33	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	34	driver	driver	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	35	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	769	36	negligence	negligence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	37	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	769	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	39	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	769	40	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	769	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	43	pedestrian	pedestrian	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	44	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	769	45	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	46	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	769	47	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	769	48	though	though	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	769	49	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	50	driver	driver	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	51	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	769	52	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	53	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	769	54	independently	independently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	769	55	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	769	56	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	769	57	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	769	58	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	769	59	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	769	60	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	61	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	62	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	769	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	64	pedestrian	pedestrian	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	65	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	769	66	all.163	all.163	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	67	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	769	68	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	69	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	769	70	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	769	71	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	769	72	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	73	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	769	74	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	75	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	769	76	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	769	77	seriously	seriously	ADV
inlawrev-20850	769	78	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	769	79	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	769	80	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	81	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	769	82	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	83	unquestionably	unquestionably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	769	84	took	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	769	85	havner	havner	ADV
inlawrev-20850	769	86	seriously	seriously	ADV
inlawrev-20850	769	87	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	769	88	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	769	89	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	90	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	769	91	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	769	92	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	769	93	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	769	94	161	161	NUM
inlawrev-20850	769	95	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	770	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	770	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	770	3	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	770	4	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	770	5	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	770	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	770	7	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	770	8	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	770	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	770	10	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	770	11	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	770	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	770	13	six	six	NUM
inlawrev-20850	770	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	770	15	five	five	NUM
inlawrev-20850	770	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	770	17	every	every	DET
inlawrev-20850	770	18	six	six	NUM
inlawrev-20850	770	19	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	770	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	770	21	83.3	83.3	NUM
inlawrev-20850	770	22	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	770	23	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	770	24	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	770	25	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	770	26	attributed	attribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	770	27	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	770	28	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	770	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	771	1	162	162	NUM
inlawrev-20850	771	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	772	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	772	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	772	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	772	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	772	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	772	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	9	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	772	10	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	772	11	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	772	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	13	373	373	NUM
inlawrev-20850	772	14	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	772	15	74	74	NUM
inlawrev-20850	772	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	17	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	772	18	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	772	19	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	772	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	21	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	22	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	772	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	24	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	772	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	26	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	772	27	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	28	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	29	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	772	30	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	772	31	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	32	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	772	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	772	35	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	772	36	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	772	37	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	772	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	773	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	773	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	773	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	773	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	773	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	773	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	773	7	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	773	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	773	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	774	1	f	f	X
inlawrev-20850	774	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	774	3	illus	illus	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	774	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	775	1	b	b	X
inlawrev-20850	775	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	775	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	775	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	775	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	775	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	776	1	163	163	NUM
inlawrev-20850	776	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	777	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	777	2	thank	thank	VERB
inlawrev-20850	777	3	michael	michael	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	777	4	green	green	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	777	5	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	777	6	reminding	remind	VERB
inlawrev-20850	777	7	me	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	777	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	777	9	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	777	10	analogous	analogous	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	777	11	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	777	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	778	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	778	2	marc	marc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	778	3	a.	a.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	778	4	franklin	franklin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	778	5	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	778	6	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	778	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	778	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	778	9	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	778	10	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	778	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	778	12	alternatives	alternative	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	778	13	364	364	NUM
inlawrev-20850	778	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	778	15	9th	9th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	778	16	ed	ed	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	778	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	778	18	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	778	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	778	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	779	1	146	146	NUM
inlawrev-20850	779	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	779	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	779	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	779	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	779	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	779	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	779	8	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	780	1	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	780	2	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	780	3	doubles	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	780	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	780	5	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	780	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	780	7	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	780	8	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	780	9	equivalent	equivalent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	780	10	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	780	11	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	780	12	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	780	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	780	14	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	780	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	780	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	780	17	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	780	18	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	780	19	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	780	20	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	780	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	780	22	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	780	23	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	780	24	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	780	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	780	26	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	780	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	780	28	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	780	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	780	30	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	780	31	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	780	32	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	780	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	781	1	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	781	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	781	3	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	781	4	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	781	5	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	781	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	781	7	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	781	8	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	781	9	combine	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	781	10	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	781	11	exceed	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	781	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	781	13	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	781	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	781	15	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	781	16	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	781	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	781	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	781	19	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	781	20	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	781	21	effectively	effectively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	781	22	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	781	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	781	24	none	none	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	781	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	781	26	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	781	27	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	781	28	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	781	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	781	30	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	781	31	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	781	32	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	781	33	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	781	34	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	781	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	782	1	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	782	2	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	782	3	contradicts	contradict	VERB
inlawrev-20850	782	4	basic	basic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	782	5	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	782	6	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	782	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	782	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	782	9	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	782	10	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	782	11	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	782	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	782	13	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	782	14	purported	purport	VERB
inlawrev-20850	782	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	782	16	rely	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	782	17	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	782	18	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	782	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	782	20	dissenters	dissenter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	782	21	stated	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	782	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	782	23	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	782	24	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	782	25	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	782	26	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	782	27	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-20850	782	28	offend	offend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	782	29	logic	logic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	782	30	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	782	31	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	782	32	offends	offend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	782	33	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	782	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	783	1	”164	”164	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	783	2	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	783	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	784	1	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	784	2	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	784	3	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	784	4	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	5	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	784	6	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	784	7	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	784	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	784	9	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	784	10	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	11	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	784	13	risk	risk	VERB
inlawrev-20850	784	14	contribution.—the	contribution.—the	DET
inlawrev-20850	784	15	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	784	16	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	17	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	784	18	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-20850	784	19	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	784	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	784	21	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	784	22	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	784	23	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	784	24	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	784	26	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	784	27	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	784	28	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	784	29	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	784	30	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	784	31	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	32	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	784	33	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	784	34	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	784	35	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	36	exposure.165	exposure.165	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	37	instead	instead	ADV
inlawrev-20850	784	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	784	39	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	784	40	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	784	41	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	784	42	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	784	43	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	784	44	proven	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	784	45	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	784	46	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	784	47	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	784	48	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	49	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	784	50	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	51	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	784	52	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	784	53	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	784	54	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	784	55	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	784	56	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	57	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	58	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	784	59	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	784	60	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	784	61	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	784	62	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	784	63	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	784	64	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	65	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	784	66	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	784	67	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	784	68	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	784	69	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	784	70	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	785	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	785	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	785	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	785	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	785	5	disagreed	disagree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	785	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	785	7	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	785	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	785	9	plaintiffs166	plaintiffs166	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	785	10	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	785	11	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	785	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	785	13	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	785	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	785	15	extent	extent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	785	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	785	17	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	785	18	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	785	19	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	785	20	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	785	21	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	785	22	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	785	23	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	785	24	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	785	25	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	785	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	786	1	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	786	2	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	786	3	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	4	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	786	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	786	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	7	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	786	8	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	9	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	786	10	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	786	12	all167	all167	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	786	13	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	14	above	above	ADP
inlawrev-20850	786	15	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	16	contributed	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	786	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	786	18	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	786	19	elevated	elevated	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	786	20	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	786	22	mesothelioma,168	mesothelioma,168	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	786	24	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	25	inferred	infer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	786	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	786	27	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	28	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	786	29	prevail	prevail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	786	30	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	786	31	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	786	32	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	786	33	every	every	PRON
inlawrev-20850	786	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	786	35	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	786	36	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	786	37	any	any	PRON
inlawrev-20850	786	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	786	39	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	786	40	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	786	41	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	786	42	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	786	43	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	786	44	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	45	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	786	46	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	47	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	786	48	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	49	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	786	50	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	51	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	786	52	proven	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	786	53	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	786	54	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	786	55	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	786	56	causein	causein	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	57	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	786	58	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	59	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	786	60	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	786	61	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	786	62	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	786	63	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	787	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	787	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	787	3	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	787	4	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	787	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	787	6	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	787	7	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	787	8	could169	could169	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	787	9	never	never	ADV
inlawrev-20850	787	10	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	787	11	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	787	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	787	13	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	787	14	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	787	15	causation.170	causation.170	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	787	16	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	787	17	explain	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	787	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	787	19	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	787	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	787	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	787	22	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	787	23	began	begin	VERB
inlawrev-20850	787	24	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	787	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	787	26	observation	observation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	787	27	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	787	28	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	787	29	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	787	30	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	787	31	amounts	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	787	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	787	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	787	34	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	787	35	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	787	36	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	787	37	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	787	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	788	1	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	788	2	seems	seem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	788	3	incongruous:171	incongruous:171	PRON
inlawrev-20850	788	4	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	788	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	788	6	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	788	7	amount	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	788	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	788	9	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	788	10	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	788	11	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	788	12	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	788	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	788	14	why	why	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	788	15	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	788	16	n’t	n’t	VERB
inlawrev-20850	788	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	788	18	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	788	19	164	164	NUM
inlawrev-20850	788	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	789	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	789	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	789	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	789	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	789	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	789	6	374	374	NUM
inlawrev-20850	789	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	789	8	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	789	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	789	10	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	789	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	789	12	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	789	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	789	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	790	1	165	165	NUM
inlawrev-20850	790	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	790	3	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	790	4	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	790	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	790	6	brief	brief	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	790	7	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	790	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	790	9	merits	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	790	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	790	11	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	790	12	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	790	13	59	59	NUM
inlawrev-20850	790	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	790	15	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	790	16	32	32	NUM
inlawrev-20850	790	17	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	790	18	33	33	NUM
inlawrev-20850	790	19	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	790	20	contrasting	contrast	VERB
inlawrev-20850	790	21	individually	individually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	790	22	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	790	23	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	790	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	790	25	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	790	26	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	790	27	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	790	28	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	790	29	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	790	30	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	790	31	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	790	32	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	790	33	contributing	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	790	34	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	790	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	790	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	791	1	166	166	NUM
inlawrev-20850	791	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	792	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	792	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	792	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	792	4	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-20850	792	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	792	6	19	19	NUM
inlawrev-20850	792	7	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	792	8	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	792	9	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	792	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	792	11	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	792	12	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	792	13	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	792	14	375	375	NUM
inlawrev-20850	792	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	792	16	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	792	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	792	18	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	792	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	792	20	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	792	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	792	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	793	1	167	167	NUM
inlawrev-20850	793	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	794	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	794	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	794	6	338	338	NUM
inlawrev-20850	794	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	8	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	9	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	794	10	quantification	quantification	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	794	12	dose	dose	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	794	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	14	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	15	i	i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	794	16	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	794	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	18	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	19	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	794	20	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	794	21	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	794	22	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	794	23	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	25	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	26	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	794	27	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	794	28	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	794	29	353	353	NUM
inlawrev-20850	794	30	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	31	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	32	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	794	33	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	794	34	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	794	35	quantify	quantify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	794	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	794	37	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	38	received	receive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	794	39	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	794	40	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	794	41	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	42	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	794	43	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	45	though	though	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	794	46	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	794	47	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	794	48	mathematical	mathematical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	794	49	precision	precision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	50	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	51	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	52	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	794	53	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	794	54	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	794	55	353	353	NUM
inlawrev-20850	794	56	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	794	57	54	54	NUM
inlawrev-20850	794	58	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	59	highlighting	highlight	VERB
inlawrev-20850	794	60	heuristic	heuristic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	794	61	uncertainties	uncertainty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	62	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	794	63	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	794	64	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	794	65	dose	dose	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	794	66	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	794	67	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	794	68	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	69	pacific	pacific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	794	70	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	71	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	72	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	73	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	794	74	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	794	75	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	794	76	355	355	NUM
inlawrev-20850	794	77	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	78	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	79	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	80	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	794	81	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	794	82	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	794	83	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	794	84	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	794	85	approximate	approximate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	794	86	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	794	87	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	88	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	89	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	794	90	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	795	1	168	168	NUM
inlawrev-20850	795	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	796	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	796	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	796	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	796	5	356	356	NUM
inlawrev-20850	796	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	8	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	796	9	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	796	10	attempting	attempt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	796	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	796	12	quantify	quantify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	796	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	796	14	aggregate	aggregate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	796	15	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	796	17	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	18	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	796	19	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	796	20	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	796	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	22	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	796	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	796	24	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	26	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	27	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	28	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	29	expressly	expressly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	796	30	eschewed	eschew	VERB
inlawrev-20850	796	31	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	796	32	approach	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	33	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	796	34	favor	favor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	796	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	796	37	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	38	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	796	39	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	796	40	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	41	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	796	42	all	all	ADV
inlawrev-20850	796	43	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	796	44	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	796	45	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	796	46	constitute	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	796	47	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	796	48	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	49	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	796	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	796	51	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	53	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	55	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	56	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	57	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	58	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	59	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	796	60	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	796	61	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	796	62	338	338	NUM
inlawrev-20850	796	63	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	796	64	39	39	NUM
inlawrev-20850	796	65	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	66	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	796	67	invitation	invitation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	68	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	796	69	distinguish	distinguish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	796	70	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	71	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	72	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	796	73	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	74	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	75	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	796	76	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	77	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	796	78	minute	minute	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	796	79	quantities	quantity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	80	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	796	81	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	82	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	796	83	result	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	796	84	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	796	85	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	86	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	87	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	796	88	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	89	development	development	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	90	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	796	91	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	92	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	796	93	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	796	94	heavy	heavy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	796	95	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	796	96	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	97	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	796	98	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	797	1	169	169	NUM
inlawrev-20850	797	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	798	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	798	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	798	4	338	338	NUM
inlawrev-20850	798	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	6	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	798	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	798	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	9	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	798	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	798	11	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	12	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	13	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	798	15	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	16	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	798	17	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	18	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	19	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	798	20	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	21	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	798	22	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	23	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	24	alone	alone	ADV
inlawrev-20850	798	25	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	798	26	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	798	27	suffice	suffice	VERB
inlawrev-20850	798	28	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	798	29	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	798	30	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	33	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	798	34	though	though	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	798	35	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	36	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	798	37	amounts	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	798	39	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	40	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	41	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	798	42	result	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	798	43	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	798	44	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	45	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	47	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	48	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	798	49	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	798	50	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	798	51	354	354	NUM
inlawrev-20850	798	52	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	798	53	55	55	NUM
inlawrev-20850	798	54	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	55	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	798	56	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	798	57	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	58	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	59	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	60	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	61	repeatedly	repeatedly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	798	62	testified	testify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	798	63	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	798	64	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	65	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	798	66	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	798	67	every	every	PRON
inlawrev-20850	798	68	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	69	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	70	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	798	71	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	72	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	798	73	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	798	74	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	75	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	798	76	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	798	77	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	798	78	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	79	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	80	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	798	81	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	798	82	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	798	83	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	798	84	legally	legally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	798	85	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	798	86	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	798	87	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	799	1	170	170	NUM
inlawrev-20850	799	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	800	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	800	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	800	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	800	4	355	355	NUM
inlawrev-20850	800	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	801	1	171	171	NUM
inlawrev-20850	801	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	802	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	802	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	802	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	802	4	338	338	NUM
inlawrev-20850	802	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	803	1	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	803	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	803	3	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	803	4	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	803	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	803	6	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	803	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	803	8	147	147	NUM
inlawrev-20850	803	9	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	803	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	803	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	803	12	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	803	13	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	803	14	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	803	15	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	803	16	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	803	17	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	803	18	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	803	19	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	803	20	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	803	21	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	803	22	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	803	23	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	803	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	803	25	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	803	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	803	27	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	803	28	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	803	29	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	803	30	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	804	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	804	2	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	804	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	804	4	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-20850	804	5	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	804	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	804	7	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	804	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	804	9	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	804	10	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	804	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	804	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	804	13	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	804	14	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	804	15	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	804	16	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	804	17	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	804	18	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	804	19	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	804	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	804	21	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	804	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	804	23	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	804	24	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	804	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	804	26	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	804	27	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	804	28	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	804	29	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	804	30	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	804	31	implies	imply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	804	32	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	804	33	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	804	34	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	804	35	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	804	36	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	804	37	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	804	38	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	804	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	805	1	after172	after172	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	805	2	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	805	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	805	4	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	805	5	everyone	everyone	PRON
inlawrev-20850	805	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	805	7	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	805	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	805	9	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	805	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	805	12	ambient	ambient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	805	13	air	air	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	805	15	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	805	16	so:173	so:173	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	17	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	805	18	fail	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	805	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	805	20	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	805	21	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	805	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	805	23	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	24	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	805	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	805	26	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	805	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	805	28	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	805	30	logic	logic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	805	32	exclude	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	805	33	higher	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	805	34	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	805	35	normal	normal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	805	36	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	37	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	38	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	805	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	805	40	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	805	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	805	43	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	44	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	805	45	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	805	47	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	805	48	accept	accept	VERB
inlawrev-20850	805	49	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	805	50	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	805	51	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	52	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	805	53	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	805	54	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	805	55	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	56	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	805	57	no	no	ADV
inlawrev-20850	805	58	matter	matter	ADV
inlawrev-20850	805	59	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	805	60	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	805	61	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	805	62	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	805	63	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	805	64	accepted	accept	VERB
inlawrev-20850	805	65	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	805	66	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	805	67	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	68	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	805	69	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	70	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	805	71	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	805	72	disease.174	disease.174	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	805	73	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	805	74	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	75	complained	complain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	805	76	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	805	77	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	805	78	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	805	79	a]cceptance	a]cceptance	ADP
inlawrev-20850	805	80	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	805	81	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	805	82	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	805	83	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	84	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	805	85	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	805	86	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	805	87	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	805	88	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	806	1	impose	impose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	806	2	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	806	3	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	806	4	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	806	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	806	6	for	for	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	806	7	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	806	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	806	9	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	806	10	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	806	11	tell	tell	VERB
inlawrev-20850	806	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	806	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	806	14	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	806	15	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	806	16	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	806	17	become	become	VERB
inlawrev-20850	806	18	ill	ill	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	806	19	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	806	20	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	806	21	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	806	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	806	23	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	806	24	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	806	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	806	26	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	806	27	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	806	28	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	806	29	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	806	30	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	806	31	reason	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	806	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	806	33	”175	”175	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	807	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	807	2	above	above	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	807	3	quotations	quotation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	807	4	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	807	5	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	807	6	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	807	7	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	807	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	807	9	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	807	10	possibilities	possibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	807	11	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	807	12	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	807	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	808	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	808	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	808	3	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	808	4	assumed	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	808	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	808	6	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	808	7	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	808	8	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	808	9	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	808	10	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	808	11	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	808	12	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	808	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	808	14	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	808	15	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	808	16	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	808	17	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	808	18	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	808	19	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	808	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	808	21	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	808	22	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	808	23	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	808	24	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	808	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	808	26	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	808	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	808	28	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	808	29	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	808	30	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	808	31	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	808	32	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	808	33	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	808	34	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	808	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	808	36	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	808	37	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	808	38	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	808	39	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	808	40	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	808	41	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	808	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	808	43	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	808	44	acting176	acting176	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	808	45	independently	independently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	808	46	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	808	47	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	808	48	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	808	49	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	808	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	808	51	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	808	52	acting	act	VERB
inlawrev-20850	808	53	together	together	ADV
inlawrev-20850	808	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	809	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	809	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	809	4	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	809	6	indistinguishable	indistinguishable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	809	7	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	809	8	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	809	10	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	809	11	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	809	12	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	13	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	14	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	809	15	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	809	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	809	17	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	809	18	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	809	20	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	809	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	809	22	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	809	23	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	809	25	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	26	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	809	27	asking	ask	VERB
inlawrev-20850	809	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	809	29	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	809	30	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	809	32	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	809	33	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	34	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	809	35	uranium	uranium	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	36	mining	mining	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	37	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	809	38	milling	milling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	39	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	809	40	opposed	oppose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	809	41	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	809	42	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	809	43	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	44	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	809	45	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	46	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	809	47	cancers	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	48	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	809	49	thyroid	thyroid	VERB
inlawrev-20850	809	50	disease.177	disease.177	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	809	51	172	172	NUM
inlawrev-20850	809	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	810	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	810	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	810	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	810	4	339	339	NUM
inlawrev-20850	810	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	810	6	173	173	NUM
inlawrev-20850	810	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	811	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	811	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	811	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	811	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	811	5	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	811	6	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	811	7	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	811	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	811	9	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	811	10	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	811	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	811	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	811	13	232	232	NUM
inlawrev-20850	811	14	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	811	15	765	765	NUM
inlawrev-20850	811	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	811	17	767	767	NUM
inlawrev-20850	811	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	811	19	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	811	20	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	811	21	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-20850	811	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	811	23	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	811	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	812	1	174	174	NUM
inlawrev-20850	812	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	813	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	813	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	813	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	813	4	341	341	NUM
inlawrev-20850	813	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	814	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	814	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	814	3	worth	worth	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	814	4	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	814	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	814	6	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	814	7	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	814	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	814	9	higher	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	814	10	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	814	11	normal	normal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	814	12	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	814	13	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	814	14	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	814	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	814	16	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	814	17	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	814	18	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	814	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	814	20	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	814	21	places	place	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	814	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	814	23	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	814	24	associated	associate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	814	25	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	814	26	elevated	elevated	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	814	27	risks	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	814	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	814	29	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	814	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	814	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	814	32	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	814	33	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	814	34	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	814	35	say	say	VERB
inlawrev-20850	814	36	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	814	37	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	814	38	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	814	39	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	814	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	814	41	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	814	42	record	record	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	814	43	suggested	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	814	44	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	814	45	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	814	46	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	814	47	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	814	48	experienced	experience	VERB
inlawrev-20850	814	49	unusually	unusually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	814	50	great	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	814	51	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	814	52	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	814	53	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	815	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	815	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	815	3	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	815	4	left	leave	VERB
inlawrev-20850	815	5	unclear	unclear	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	815	6	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	815	7	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	815	8	bear	bear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	815	9	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	815	10	obligation	obligation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	815	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	815	12	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	815	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	815	14	extent	extent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	815	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	815	16	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	815	17	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	815	18	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	815	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	815	20	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	815	21	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	815	22	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	815	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	816	1	175	175	NUM
inlawrev-20850	816	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	817	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	817	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	817	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	817	4	339	339	NUM
inlawrev-20850	817	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	817	6	176	176	NUM
inlawrev-20850	817	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	818	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	818	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	818	3	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	818	4	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	818	5	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	818	6	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	818	7	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	818	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	818	9	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	818	10	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	818	11	reason	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	818	12	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	818	13	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	818	14	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	818	15	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	818	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	818	17	real	real	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	818	18	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	818	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	818	20	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	818	21	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	818	22	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	818	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	819	1	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	819	2	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	819	3	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	819	4	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	819	5	real	real	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	819	6	dispute	dispute	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	819	7	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	819	8	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	819	9	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	819	10	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	819	11	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	819	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	819	13	presumably	presumably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	819	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	819	15	potential	potential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	819	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	819	17	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	819	18	reason[s	reason[	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	819	19	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	819	20	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	819	21	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	819	22	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	819	23	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	819	24	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	819	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	819	26	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	819	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	820	1	177	177	NUM
inlawrev-20850	820	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	821	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	821	2	wilcox	wilcox	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	821	3	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	821	4	homestake	homestake	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	821	5	mining	mining	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	821	6	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	821	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	821	8	619	619	NUM
inlawrev-20850	821	9	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	821	10	1165	1165	NUM
inlawrev-20850	821	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	821	12	10th	10th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	821	13	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	821	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	821	15	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	821	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	2	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	822	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	822	4	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	822	5	new	new	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	822	6	mexico	mexico	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	822	7	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	9	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	822	10	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	11	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	12	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	822	13	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	822	14	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	822	15	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	822	16	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	17	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	18	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	20	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	822	21	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	822	22	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	822	23	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	24	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	25	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	26	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	822	27	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	822	28	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	822	29	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	822	30	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	822	31	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	32	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	822	33	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	35	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	36	june	june	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	822	37	v.	v.	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	822	38	union	union	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	822	39	carbide	carbide	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	822	40	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	822	41	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	822	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	43	577	577	NUM
inlawrev-20850	822	44	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	822	45	1234	1234	NUM
inlawrev-20850	822	46	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	47	10th	10th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	822	48	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	49	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	822	50	2009	2009	NUM
inlawrev-20850	822	51	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	52	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	53	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	822	54	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	822	55	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	822	56	colorado	colorado	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	822	57	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	58	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	59	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	60	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	61	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	822	62	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	63	opining	opine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	822	64	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	822	65	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	822	66	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	67	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	822	68	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	69	dose	dose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	822	70	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	822	71	mine	mine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	72	tailings	tailing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	73	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	822	74	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	822	75	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	822	76	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	77	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	822	78	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	822	79	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	80	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	822	81	legally	legally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	822	82	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	822	83	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	822	84	failing	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	822	85	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	822	86	state	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	822	87	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	822	88	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	89	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	90	illnesses	illness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	91	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	822	92	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	822	93	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	822	94	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	822	95	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	822	96	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	822	97	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	822	98	tailings	tailing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	99	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	822	100	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	822	101	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	823	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	823	2	comparable	comparable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	823	3	examples	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	823	4	involving	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	823	5	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	823	6	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	823	7	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	823	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	823	9	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	823	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	823	11	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	823	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	823	13	baker	baker	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	823	14	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	823	15	chevron	chevron	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	823	16	usa	usa	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	823	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	823	18	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	823	19	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	823	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	823	21	680	680	NUM
inlawrev-20850	823	22	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	823	23	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	823	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	1	2d	2d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	824	2	865	865	NUM
inlawrev-20850	824	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	4	878	878	NUM
inlawrev-20850	824	5	n.9	n.9	SYM
inlawrev-20850	824	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	7	s.d	s.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	824	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	824	9	ohio	ohio	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	824	10	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	824	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	13	cited	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	824	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	824	15	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	824	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	17	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	824	18	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	824	19	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	824	20	339	339	NUM
inlawrev-20850	824	21	n.24	n.24	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	824	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	24	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	824	25	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	824	26	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	824	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	824	28	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	824	29	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	30	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	824	31	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	824	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	824	33	carcinogenesis	carcinogenesis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	824	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	35	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	36	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	824	37	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	824	38	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	824	39	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-20850	824	40	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	824	41	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	824	42	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	824	43	ambient	ambient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	824	44	benzene	benzene	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	824	45	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	46	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	824	47	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	824	48	benzene	benzene	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	824	49	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	824	50	refinery	refinery	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	824	51	emissions	emission	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	824	52	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	824	53	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	824	54	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	55	blood	blood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	824	56	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	824	57	lymph	lymph	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	824	58	cancers	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	824	59	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	60	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	61	henricksen	henricksen	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	824	62	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	824	63	conocophillips	conocophillips	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	824	64	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	824	65	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	824	66	605	605	NUM
inlawrev-20850	824	67	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	824	68	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	824	69	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	825	1	2d	2d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	825	2	1142	1142	NUM
inlawrev-20850	825	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	825	4	148	148	NUM
inlawrev-20850	825	5	indiana	indiana	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	825	6	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	825	7	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	826	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	826	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	826	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	826	4	49:117	49:117	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	827	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	827	2	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	827	3	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	827	4	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	827	5	goes	go	VERB
inlawrev-20850	827	6	hand	hand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	827	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	827	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	827	9	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	827	10	hand	hand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	827	11	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	827	12	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	827	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	827	14	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	827	15	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	827	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	828	1	why	why	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	828	2	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	828	3	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	828	4	matter	matter	VERB
inlawrev-20850	828	5	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	828	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	828	7	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	828	8	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	828	9	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	828	10	exclude	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	828	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	828	12	say	say	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	828	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	828	14	ambient	ambient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	828	15	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	828	16	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	828	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	828	18	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	828	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	828	20	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	828	21	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	829	1	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	829	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	829	3	ambient	ambient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	829	4	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	829	5	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	829	6	really	really	ADV
inlawrev-20850	829	7	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	829	8	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	829	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	829	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	829	11	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	829	12	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	829	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	829	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	829	15	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	829	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	829	17	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	829	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	829	19	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	829	20	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	829	21	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	829	22	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	829	23	sick	sick	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	829	24	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	829	25	absent	absent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	829	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	829	27	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	829	28	for	for	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	829	29	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	829	30	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	829	31	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	829	32	responsible	responsible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	829	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	830	1	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	830	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	830	3	invoked	invoke	VERB
inlawrev-20850	830	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	830	5	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	830	6	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	830	7	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	830	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	830	9	reject	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	830	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	830	11	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	830	12	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	830	13	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	830	14	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	830	15	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	830	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	830	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	830	18	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	830	19	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	830	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	830	21	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	830	22	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	830	23	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	830	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	830	25	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	830	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	830	27	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	830	28	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	830	29	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	830	30	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	830	31	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	830	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	830	33	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	830	34	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	830	35	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	830	36	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	830	37	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	830	38	next	next	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	830	39	breath.178	breath.178	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	830	40	comparing	compare	VERB
inlawrev-20850	830	41	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	830	42	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	830	43	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	830	44	tenth	tenth	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	830	45	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	830	46	uranium	uranium	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	830	47	mining	mining	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	830	48	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	830	49	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	830	50	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	830	51	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	830	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	831	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	831	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	831	3	mining	mining	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	4	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	831	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	831	7	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	8	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	831	9	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	10	attempted	attempt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	831	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	831	12	quantify	quantify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	831	13	the179	the179	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	831	14	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	15	dose	dose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	831	16	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	831	17	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	18	received	receive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	831	19	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	831	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	831	21	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	22	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	831	23	operations	operation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	831	25	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	831	26	attribute	attribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	831	27	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	831	28	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	831	29	dose	dose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	831	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	831	31	fraction	fraction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	831	33	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	831	34	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	35	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	831	36	overall	overall	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	831	37	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	38	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	39	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	831	40	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	831	41	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	831	42	opine	opine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	831	43	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	831	44	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	831	45	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	831	46	fraction	fraction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	47	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	831	48	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	831	49	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	831	50	contributing	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	831	51	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	52	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	831	53	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	831	54	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	55	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	831	56	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	831	57	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	832	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	832	2	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	832	3	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	832	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	832	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	832	6	expressly	expressly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	832	7	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	832	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	832	9	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	832	10	testimony180	testimony180	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	832	11	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	832	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	832	13	suffice	suffice	VERB
inlawrev-20850	832	14	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	832	15	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	832	16	witness	witness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	832	17	testified	testify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	832	18	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	832	19	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	832	20	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	832	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	832	22	mining	mining	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	832	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	832	24	milling	mill	VERB
inlawrev-20850	832	25	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	832	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	832	27	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	832	28	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	832	29	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	832	30	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	832	31	become	become	VERB
inlawrev-20850	832	32	ill	ill	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	832	33	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	832	34	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	832	35	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	832	36	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	832	37	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	832	38	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	832	39	displace	displace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	832	40	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	832	41	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	832	42	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	832	43	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	832	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	833	1	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	833	2	contrast	contrast	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	833	4	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	833	5	purported	purport	VERB
inlawrev-20850	833	6	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	833	7	accept181	accept181	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	833	8	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	833	9	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	10	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	11	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	833	12	using	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	833	13	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	833	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	833	15	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	833	16	logic.182	logic.182	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	17	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	833	18	bolster	bolster	VERB
inlawrev-20850	833	19	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	833	20	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	833	22	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	833	23	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	24	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	25	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	833	26	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	833	27	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	833	28	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	833	29	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	833	31	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	833	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	833	34	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	833	35	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	36	emphasized	emphasize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	833	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	833	38	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	39	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	833	40	dependence	dependence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	833	42	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	43	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	833	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	1	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	2	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	3	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	4	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	834	5	agreed	agree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	834	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	834	7	the	the	PRON
inlawrev-20850	834	8	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	834	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	834	10	cumulative183	cumulative183	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	834	11	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	13	the	the	PRON
inlawrev-20850	834	14	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	834	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	834	16	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	18	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	834	19	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	834	20	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	834	21	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	834	22	agreed	agree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	834	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	834	24	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	834	25	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	834	26	1162	1162	NUM
inlawrev-20850	834	27	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	834	28	63	63	NUM
inlawrev-20850	834	29	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	30	e.d	e.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	834	31	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	834	32	wash	wash	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	34	2009	2009	NUM
inlawrev-20850	834	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	36	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	37	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	834	38	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	834	39	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	40	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	834	41	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	834	42	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	834	43	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	834	44	[	[	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	45	leukemia	leukemia	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	46	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	47	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	834	48	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	834	49	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	834	50	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	51	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	834	52	benzene	benzene	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	53	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	834	54	gasoline	gasoline	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	55	fumes	fume	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	56	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	834	57	opposed	oppose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	834	58	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	834	59	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	60	idiopathic	idiopathic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	834	61	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	62	origin	origin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	63	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	64	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	65	tompkin	tompkin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	66	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	834	67	philip	philip	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	834	68	morris	morris	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	834	69	usa	usa	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	834	70	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	71	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	834	72	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	834	73	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	74	362	362	NUM
inlawrev-20850	834	75	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	834	76	882	882	NUM
inlawrev-20850	834	77	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	78	894	894	NUM
inlawrev-20850	834	79	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	80	6th	6th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	834	81	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	82	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	83	2004	2004	NUM
inlawrev-20850	834	84	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	85	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	86	explaining	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	834	87	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	834	88	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	89	apparently	apparently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	834	90	believed	believe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	834	91	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	834	92	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	93	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	94	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	834	95	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	834	96	cigarette	cigarette	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	97	smoking	smoking	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	98	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	834	99	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	100	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	834	101	lung	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	102	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	834	103	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	834	104	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	835	1	178	178	NUM
inlawrev-20850	835	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	836	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	836	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	4	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	836	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	836	7	342	342	NUM
inlawrev-20850	836	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	10	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	836	11	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	836	12	reasons	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	14	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	836	15	extend	extend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	836	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	836	17	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	836	19	holdings	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	836	21	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	836	23	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	24	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	26	including	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	836	27	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-20850	836	28	rejection	rejection	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	836	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	836	31	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	32	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	836	33	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	34	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	35	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	836	37	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	39	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	836	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	836	41	clarifications	clarification	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	42	discussed	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	836	43	below	below	ADV
inlawrev-20850	836	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	45	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	836	48	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	836	49	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	50	clarification	clarification	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	51	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	52	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	53	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	836	54	followed	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	836	55	immediately	immediately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	836	56	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	836	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	836	58	sentence	sentence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	59	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-20850	836	60	quoted	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	836	61	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	62	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	836	63	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	836	64	reject	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	836	65	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	836	66	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	67	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	836	68	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	69	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	836	70	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	836	71	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	836	72	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	836	73	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	836	74	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	837	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	837	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	837	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	837	4	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	837	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	837	6	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	837	7	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	837	8	concern	concern	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	837	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	837	10	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	837	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	837	12	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	837	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	837	14	appeals	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	837	15	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	837	16	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	837	17	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	837	18	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	837	19	read	read	VERB
inlawrev-20850	837	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	837	21	require	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	837	22	satisfying	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	837	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	837	24	proof	proof	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	837	25	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	837	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	837	27	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	837	28	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	837	29	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	837	30	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	837	31	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	837	32	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	837	33	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	837	34	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	837	35	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	837	36	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	837	37	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	837	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	837	39	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	837	40	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	837	41	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	837	42	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	837	43	contracted	contract	VERB
inlawrev-20850	837	44	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	837	45	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	837	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	837	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	838	1	179	179	NUM
inlawrev-20850	838	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	839	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	839	2	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	839	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	839	4	wilcox	wilcox	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	839	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	839	6	619	619	NUM
inlawrev-20850	839	7	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	839	8	1165	1165	NUM
inlawrev-20850	839	9	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	839	10	june	june	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	839	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	839	12	577	577	NUM
inlawrev-20850	839	13	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	839	14	1234	1234	NUM
inlawrev-20850	839	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	840	1	180	180	NUM
inlawrev-20850	840	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	840	3	wilcox	wilcox	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	840	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	840	5	619	619	NUM
inlawrev-20850	840	6	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	840	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	840	8	1170	1170	NUM
inlawrev-20850	840	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	840	10	71	71	NUM
inlawrev-20850	840	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	840	12	lucero	lucero	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	840	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	840	14	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	840	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	840	16	concurring	concurring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	840	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	840	18	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	840	19	june	june	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	840	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	840	21	577	577	NUM
inlawrev-20850	840	22	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	840	23	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	840	24	1237	1237	NUM
inlawrev-20850	840	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	841	1	181	181	NUM
inlawrev-20850	841	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	842	1	wilcox	wilcox	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	842	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	842	3	619	619	NUM
inlawrev-20850	842	4	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	842	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	842	6	1168	1168	NUM
inlawrev-20850	842	7	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	842	8	june	june	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	842	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	842	10	577	577	NUM
inlawrev-20850	842	11	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	842	12	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	842	13	1245	1245	NUM
inlawrev-20850	842	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	843	1	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	843	2	focusing	focus	VERB
inlawrev-20850	843	3	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	843	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	843	5	tenth	tenth	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	843	6	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	843	7	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	843	8	clarity	clarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	843	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	843	10	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	843	11	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	843	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	843	13	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	843	14	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	843	15	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	843	16	mean	mean	VERB
inlawrev-20850	843	17	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	843	18	imply	imply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	843	19	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	843	20	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	843	21	think	think	VERB
inlawrev-20850	843	22	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	843	23	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	843	24	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	843	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	843	26	best	good	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	843	27	choice	choice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	843	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	844	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	844	2	gold	gold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	844	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	844	4	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	844	5	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	844	6	85	85	NUM
inlawrev-20850	844	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	844	8	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	844	9	250	250	NUM
inlawrev-20850	844	10	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	844	11	52	52	NUM
inlawrev-20850	844	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	844	13	criticizing	criticize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	844	14	wilcox	wilcox	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	844	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	844	16	june	june	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	844	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	844	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	845	1	182	182	NUM
inlawrev-20850	845	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	846	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	846	2	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	846	3	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	846	4	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	846	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	846	6	distinguish	distinguish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	846	7	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	846	8	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	846	9	wilcox	wilcox	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	846	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	846	11	june	june	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	846	12	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	846	13	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	846	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	846	15	quantum	quantum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	846	17	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	846	19	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	20	adduced	adduce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	846	21	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	846	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	846	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	846	24	uranium	uranium	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	25	mine	mine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	26	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	846	28	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	29	attempted	attempt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	846	30	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	846	31	quantify	quantify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	846	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	846	33	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	34	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	846	35	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	36	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	846	37	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	38	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	846	39	operations	operation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	846	41	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	846	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	846	43	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	846	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	846	45	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	46	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	846	47	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	846	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	846	49	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	50	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	846	51	utterly	utterly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	846	52	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	846	53	quantify	quantify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	846	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	846	55	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	846	56	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	847	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	847	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	847	3	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	847	4	distinction	distinction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	847	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	847	6	beside	beside	ADP
inlawrev-20850	847	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	847	8	point	point	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	847	9	here	here	ADV
inlawrev-20850	847	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	848	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	848	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	848	3	no	no	ADV
inlawrev-20850	848	4	less	less	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	848	5	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	848	6	wilcox	wilcox	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	848	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	848	8	june	june	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	848	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	848	10	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	848	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	848	12	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	848	13	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	848	14	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	848	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	849	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	849	2	implies	imply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	849	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	849	4	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	849	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	849	6	quantified	quantified	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	849	7	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	849	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	849	9	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	849	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	849	11	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	849	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	849	13	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	849	14	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	849	15	enough	enough	ADV
inlawrev-20850	849	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	849	17	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	849	18	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	849	19	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	849	20	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	849	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	849	22	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	849	23	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	849	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	849	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	849	26	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	849	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	850	1	183	183	NUM
inlawrev-20850	850	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	851	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	851	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	851	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	851	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	851	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	851	6	338	338	NUM
inlawrev-20850	851	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	851	8	39	39	NUM
inlawrev-20850	851	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	852	1	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	852	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	852	3	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	852	4	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	852	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	852	6	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	852	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	852	8	149	149	NUM
inlawrev-20850	852	9	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	852	10	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	852	11	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	852	12	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	852	13	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	852	14	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	852	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	853	1	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	853	2	went	go	VERB
inlawrev-20850	853	3	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	853	4	far	far	ADV
inlawrev-20850	853	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	853	6	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	853	7	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	853	8	by184	by184	VERB
inlawrev-20850	853	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	853	10	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	853	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	853	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	853	13	testify	testify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	853	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	853	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	853	16	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	853	17	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	853	18	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	853	19	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	853	20	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	853	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	853	22	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	853	23	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	853	24	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	853	25	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	853	26	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	853	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	853	28	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	854	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	854	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	854	3	saw	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	854	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	854	5	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	854	6	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	854	7	fatally	fatally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	854	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	854	9	conflict	conflict	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	854	10	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	854	11	the185	the185	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	854	12	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	854	13	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	854	14	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	854	15	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	854	16	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	854	17	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	854	18	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	854	19	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	854	20	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	854	21	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	854	22	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	854	23	all	all	ADV
inlawrev-20850	854	24	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	854	25	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	854	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	854	27	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	854	28	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	854	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	854	30	everyone	everyone	PRON
inlawrev-20850	854	31	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	854	32	suffer	suffer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	854	33	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	854	34	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	854	35	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	854	36	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	854	37	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	854	38	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	854	39	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	854	40	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	854	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	854	42	contracting	contract	VERB
inlawrev-20850	854	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	854	44	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	854	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	855	1	”186	”186	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	855	2	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	855	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	855	4	dissenters	dissenter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	855	5	pointed	point	VERB
inlawrev-20850	855	6	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-20850	855	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	855	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	855	9	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	855	10	t]his	t]his	DET
inlawrev-20850	855	11	statement	statement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	855	12	misunderstands	misunderstand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	855	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	855	14	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	855	15	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	855	16	regarding	regard	VERB
inlawrev-20850	855	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	855	18	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	855	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	855	20	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	855	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	855	22	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	856	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	856	2	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	856	3	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	856	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	856	5	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	856	6	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	856	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	856	8	if187	if187	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	856	9	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	856	10	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	856	11	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	856	12	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	856	13	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	856	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	856	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	856	16	everyone	everyone	PRON
inlawrev-20850	856	17	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	856	18	suffer	suffer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	856	19	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	856	20	it”—is	it”—is	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	856	21	utter	utter	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	856	22	nonsense	nonsense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	856	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	857	1	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	857	2	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	857	3	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	857	4	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	857	5	thankful	thankful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	857	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	857	7	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	857	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	857	9	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	857	10	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	857	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	857	12	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	857	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	857	14	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	857	15	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	857	16	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	857	17	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	857	18	always	always	ADV
inlawrev-20850	857	19	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	857	20	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	857	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	858	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	858	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	858	3	did	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	858	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	858	5	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	858	6	horrific	horrific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	858	7	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	858	8	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	858	9	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	858	10	vastly	vastly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	858	11	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	858	12	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	858	13	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	858	14	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	858	15	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	858	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	859	1	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	859	2	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	859	3	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-20850	859	4	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	859	5	heavy	heavy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	859	6	occupational	occupational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	859	7	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	859	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	859	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	859	10	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	859	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	859	12	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	859	13	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	859	14	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	859	15	modest.188	modest.188	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	859	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	859	17	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	859	18	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	859	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	859	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	859	21	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	859	22	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	859	23	statement	statement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	859	24	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	859	25	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	859	26	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	859	27	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	859	28	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	859	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	859	30	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	859	31	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	859	32	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	859	33	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	859	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	859	35	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	859	36	everyone	everyone	PRON
inlawrev-20850	859	37	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	859	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	859	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	859	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	860	1	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	860	2	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	860	3	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	860	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	860	5	contracting	contract	VERB
inlawrev-20850	860	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	860	7	disease”—is	disease”—is	ADV
inlawrev-20850	860	8	perfectly	perfectly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	860	9	consistent	consistent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	860	10	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	860	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	860	12	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	860	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	860	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	860	15	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	860	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	861	1	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	861	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	861	3	court1	court1	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	861	4	8	8	NUM
inlawrev-20850	861	5	9	9	NUM
inlawrev-20850	861	6	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	861	7	immediately	immediately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	861	8	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-20850	861	9	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	861	10	sentence	sentence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	861	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	861	12	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	861	13	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	861	14	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	861	15	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	861	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	861	17	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	861	18	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	861	19	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	861	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	861	21	report	report	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	861	22	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	861	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	861	24	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	861	25	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	861	26	m]esothelioma	m]esothelioma	VERB
inlawrev-20850	861	27	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	861	28	occur	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	861	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	861	30	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	861	31	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	861	32	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	861	33	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	861	34	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	861	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	862	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	862	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	862	3	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	862	4	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	862	5	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	862	6	environmental	environmental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	862	7	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	862	8	carry	carry	VERB
inlawrev-20850	862	9	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	862	10	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	862	11	extremely	extremely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	862	12	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	862	13	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	862	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	862	15	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	862	16	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	863	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	863	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	863	3	everyone	everyone	PRON
inlawrev-20850	863	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	863	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	863	6	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	863	7	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	863	8	less	less	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	863	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	863	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	863	11	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	863	12	of190	of190	VERB
inlawrev-20850	863	13	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	863	14	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	863	15	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	863	16	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	863	17	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	863	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	864	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	864	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	864	3	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-20850	864	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	864	5	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	864	6	risks	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	864	7	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	864	8	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	864	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	864	10	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	864	11	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	864	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	865	1	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	865	2	reason	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	865	3	offered	offer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	865	4	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	865	5	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	865	6	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	865	7	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	865	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	865	9	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	865	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	865	11	that191	that191	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	865	12	184	184	NUM
inlawrev-20850	865	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	866	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	866	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	866	3	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	866	4	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	866	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	866	6	356	356	NUM
inlawrev-20850	866	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	866	8	58	58	NUM
inlawrev-20850	866	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	866	10	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	866	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	866	12	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	866	13	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	866	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	866	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	867	1	185	185	NUM
inlawrev-20850	867	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	868	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	868	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	868	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	868	4	339	339	NUM
inlawrev-20850	868	5	n.22	n.22	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	868	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	868	7	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	868	8	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	868	9	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	868	10	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	868	11	witness	witness	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	868	12	dr	dr	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	868	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	868	14	brody	brody	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	868	15	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	868	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	868	17	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	868	18	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	868	19	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	868	20	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	868	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	868	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	868	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	869	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	869	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	869	3	amount	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	869	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	869	5	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	869	6	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	869	7	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	869	8	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	869	9	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	869	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	869	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	869	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	870	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	870	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	870	3	lung	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	870	4	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	870	5	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	870	6	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	870	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	870	8	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	870	9	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	870	10	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	870	11	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	870	12	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	870	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	871	1	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	871	2	’s	’	VERB
inlawrev-20850	871	3	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	871	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	871	5	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	871	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	871	7	anyone	anyone	PRON
inlawrev-20850	871	8	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	871	9	measure	measure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	871	10	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	871	11	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	871	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	871	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	872	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	872	2	plausible	plausible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	872	3	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	872	5	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	872	6	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	7	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	872	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	872	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	872	10	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	872	11	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	12	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	872	13	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	872	14	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	15	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	872	17	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	872	18	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	872	19	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	872	20	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	872	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	872	22	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	872	23	detected	detect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	872	24	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	872	25	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	872	26	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	27	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	872	28	moreover	moreover	ADV
inlawrev-20850	872	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	872	30	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	872	31	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	872	32	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	872	33	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	872	34	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	872	35	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	872	36	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	37	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	872	39	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	40	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	872	41	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-20850	872	42	lungs	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	872	44	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	872	45	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	872	46	unexposed	unexposed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	872	47	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	872	48	control	control	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	49	group	group	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	50	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	872	51	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	872	52	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	872	53	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-20850	872	54	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	872	55	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	872	56	measure	measure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	872	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	872	58	effect	effect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	59	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	872	60	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	872	61	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	62	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	872	63	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	872	64	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	873	1	186	186	NUM
inlawrev-20850	873	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	874	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	874	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	874	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	874	4	339	339	NUM
inlawrev-20850	874	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	875	1	187	187	NUM
inlawrev-20850	875	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	876	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	876	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	876	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	876	4	374	374	NUM
inlawrev-20850	876	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	876	6	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	876	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	876	8	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	876	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	876	10	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	876	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	876	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	877	1	188	188	NUM
inlawrev-20850	877	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	878	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	878	2	osteen	osteen	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	878	3	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	878	4	a.c	a.c	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	878	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	878	6	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	878	7	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	878	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	878	9	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	878	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	878	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	878	12	307	307	NUM
inlawrev-20850	878	13	n.w.2d	n.w.2d	ADP
inlawrev-20850	878	14	514	514	NUM
inlawrev-20850	878	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	878	16	518	518	NUM
inlawrev-20850	878	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	878	18	neb	neb	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	878	19	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	878	20	1981	1981	NUM
inlawrev-20850	878	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	2	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	879	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	879	4	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	879	5	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	6	workers	worker	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	8	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	879	10	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	879	12	approximately	approximately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	879	13	seven	seven	NUM
inlawrev-20850	879	14	percent	percent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	16	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	17	thompson	thompson	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	19	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	20	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	21	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	879	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	23	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	879	24	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-20850	879	25	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	26	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	879	27	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	879	28	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	29	affects	affect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	879	30	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	31	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	879	32	about	about	ADV
inlawrev-20850	879	33	5	5	NUM
inlawrev-20850	879	34	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	35	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	879	37	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	879	38	people	people	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	39	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	40	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	41	tod	tod	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	42	zuckerman	zuckerman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	43	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	879	44	mark	mark	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	45	raskoff	raskoff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	47	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-20850	879	48	environmental	environmental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	879	49	insurance	insurance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	50	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	51	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	52	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	53	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	879	54	practice	practice	VERB
inlawrev-20850	879	55	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	56	26:5	26:5	NUM
inlawrev-20850	879	57	n.5	n.5	X
inlawrev-20850	879	58	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	59	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	879	60	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	61	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	62	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	879	63	mark	mark	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	64	h.	h.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	65	beers	beers	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	66	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	67	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	68	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	69	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	70	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	879	71	merck	merck	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	72	manual	manual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	73	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	879	74	diagnosis	diagnosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	75	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	879	76	therapy	therapy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	77	472	472	NUM
inlawrev-20850	879	78	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	79	robert	robert	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	80	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	81	porter	porter	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	82	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	879	83	thomas	thomas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	84	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	85	jones	jones	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	86	eds	eds	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	87	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	879	88	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	89	18th	18th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	879	90	ed	ed	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	91	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	92	2006	2006	NUM
inlawrev-20850	879	93	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	94	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	95	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	96	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	879	97	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	879	98	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	99	workers	worker	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	100	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	879	101	up	up	ADP
inlawrev-20850	879	102	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	879	103	ten	ten	NUM
inlawrev-20850	879	104	percent	percent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	105	lifetime	lifetime	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	106	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	107	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	879	108	developing	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	879	109	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	879	110	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	879	111	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	880	1	189	189	NUM
inlawrev-20850	880	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	881	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	881	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	881	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	881	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	881	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	881	6	339	339	NUM
inlawrev-20850	881	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	882	1	190	190	NUM
inlawrev-20850	882	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	883	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	883	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	883	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	883	4	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	883	5	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	883	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	883	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	884	1	191	191	X
inlawrev-20850	884	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	885	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	885	2	re	re	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	885	3	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	885	4	litig	litig	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	885	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	886	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	886	2	900	900	NUM
inlawrev-20850	886	3	a.2d	a.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	886	4	120	120	NUM
inlawrev-20850	886	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	886	6	132	132	NUM
inlawrev-20850	886	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	886	8	del	del	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	886	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	886	10	super	super	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	886	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	887	1	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	887	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	887	3	2006	2006	NUM
inlawrev-20850	887	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	888	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	888	2	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	888	3	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	888	4	b]ackground	b]ackground	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	888	5	incidence	incidence	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	888	6	rate	rate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	888	7	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	888	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	888	9	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	888	10	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	888	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	888	12	basically	basically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	888	13	zero	zero	NUM
inlawrev-20850	888	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	888	15	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	888	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	888	17	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	888	18	boston	boston	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	888	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	888	20	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	888	21	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	888	22	122	122	NUM
inlawrev-20850	888	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	888	24	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	888	25	294	294	NUM
inlawrev-20850	888	26	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	888	27	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	888	28	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	888	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	888	30	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	888	31	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	888	32	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	888	33	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	888	34	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	888	35	approximately	approximately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	888	36	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	888	37	per	per	ADP
inlawrev-20850	888	38	million	million	NUM
inlawrev-20850	888	39	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	888	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	889	1	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	889	2	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	889	3	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	889	4	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	889	5	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	889	6	150	150	NUM
inlawrev-20850	889	7	indiana	indiana	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	889	8	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	889	9	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	890	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	890	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	890	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	890	4	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	891	1	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	891	2	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	891	3	w]hen	w]hen	ADV
inlawrev-20850	891	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	891	5	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	891	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	891	7	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	891	8	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	891	9	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	891	10	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	891	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	891	12	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	891	13	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	891	14	tend	tend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	891	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	891	16	keep	keep	VERB
inlawrev-20850	891	17	up	up	ADP
inlawrev-20850	891	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	891	19	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	891	20	’s	’	VERB
inlawrev-20850	891	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	891	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	891	23	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	891	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	891	25	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	891	26	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	892	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	892	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	892	3	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	892	5	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-20850	892	6	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	892	7	zero	zero	NUM
inlawrev-20850	892	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	892	9	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-20850	892	10	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	892	11	certain192	certain192	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	892	12	individuals	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	13	bear	bear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	892	14	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	892	15	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	892	16	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	892	17	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	892	18	mutations	mutation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	19	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	892	20	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	892	21	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	892	22	less	less	ADV
inlawrev-20850	892	23	able	able	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	892	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	892	25	resist	resist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	892	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	892	27	repair	repair	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	892	29	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	892	30	root	root	VERB
inlawrev-20850	892	31	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-20850	892	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	892	33	dna	dna	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	892	34	damage	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	35	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	892	36	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	37	wreaks	wreak	VERB
inlawrev-20850	892	38	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	892	39	lead	lead	VERB
inlawrev-20850	892	40	mesothelium	mesothelium	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	41	cells	cell	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	42	down	down	ADP
inlawrev-20850	892	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	892	44	path	path	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	45	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	892	46	malignant	malignant	VERB
inlawrev-20850	892	47	transformation.193	transformation.193	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	892	48	similarly	similarly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	892	49	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	892	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	892	51	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	52	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	892	53	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	892	54	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	892	55	e]xposure	e]xposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	56	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	892	57	asbestos	asbestos	VERB
inlawrev-20850	892	58	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	892	59	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	892	60	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-20850	892	61	carcinogen	carcinogen	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	62	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	892	63	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	892	64	never	never	ADV
inlawrev-20850	892	65	healthy	healthy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	892	66	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	892	67	fortunately	fortunately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	892	68	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	892	69	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	892	70	always	always	ADV
inlawrev-20850	892	71	result	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	892	72	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	892	73	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	74	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	892	75	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	892	76	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	892	77	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	892	78	mean194	mean194	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	892	79	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	892	80	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	892	81	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	82	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	892	83	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	84	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	892	85	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	892	86	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	892	87	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	892	88	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	893	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	893	2	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	893	3	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	893	4	matter195	matter195	VERB
inlawrev-20850	893	5	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	893	6	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	893	7	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	893	8	inevitable	inevitable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	893	9	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	893	10	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	893	11	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	893	12	aggregate	aggregate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	893	13	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	893	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	893	15	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	893	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	894	1	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-20850	894	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	894	3	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-20850	894	4	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	894	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	894	6	people	people	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	894	7	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	894	8	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	894	9	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	894	10	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	894	11	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	894	12	develop	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	894	13	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	894	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	894	15	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	894	16	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	894	17	did	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	894	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	895	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	895	2	implying	imply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	895	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	895	4	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	895	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	895	6	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	895	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	895	8	georgia-196	georgia-196	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	895	9	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	895	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	895	11	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	895	12	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	895	13	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	895	14	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	895	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	895	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	895	17	times	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	895	18	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	895	19	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	895	20	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	895	21	does	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	895	22	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	895	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	895	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	895	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	896	1	result	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	896	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	896	3	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	896	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	896	5	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	896	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	896	7	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	896	8	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-20850	896	9	functionally	functionally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	896	10	framed	frame	VERB
inlawrev-20850	896	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	896	12	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	896	13	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	896	14	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	896	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	896	16	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	896	17	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	896	18	quantify	quantify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	896	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	896	20	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	896	21	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	896	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	896	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	896	24	assess	assess	VERB
inlawrev-20850	896	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	896	26	incremental	incremental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	896	27	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	896	28	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	896	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	896	30	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	896	31	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	896	32	above	above	ADP
inlawrev-20850	896	33	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	896	34	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	896	35	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	896	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	897	1	sienkiewicz	sienkiewicz	VERB
inlawrev-20850	897	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	897	3	greif	greif	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	897	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	897	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	897	6	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	897	7	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	897	8	uksc	uksc	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	897	9	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	897	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	897	11	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	897	12	107	107	NUM
inlawrev-20850	897	13	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	897	14	12	12	NUM
inlawrev-20850	897	15	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	897	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	897	17	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	897	18	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	897	19	]	]	SYM
inlawrev-20850	897	20	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	897	21	wlr	wlr	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	897	22	523	523	NUM
inlawrev-20850	897	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	897	24	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	897	25	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	897	26	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	897	27	eng	eng	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	897	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	897	29	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	898	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	898	2	lord	lord	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	898	3	phillips	phillips	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	898	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	898	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	898	6	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	898	7	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	898	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	898	9	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	898	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	898	11	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	898	12	occupational	occupational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	898	13	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	898	14	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	898	15	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	898	16	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	898	17	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	898	18	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-20850	898	19	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	898	20	above	above	ADP
inlawrev-20850	898	21	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	898	22	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	898	23	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	898	24	secretary	secretary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	898	25	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	898	26	worked	work	VERB
inlawrev-20850	898	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	898	28	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	898	29	portion	portion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	898	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	898	31	factory	factory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	898	32	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	898	33	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	898	34	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	898	35	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	898	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	898	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	899	1	192	192	NUM
inlawrev-20850	899	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	900	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	900	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	900	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	900	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	900	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	900	6	374	374	NUM
inlawrev-20850	900	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	900	8	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	900	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	900	10	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	900	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	900	12	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	900	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	900	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	900	15	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	900	16	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	900	17	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	900	18	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	900	19	witness	witness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	900	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	900	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	901	1	193	193	NUM
inlawrev-20850	901	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	902	1	r.m	r.m	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	902	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	902	3	rudd	rudd	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	902	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	902	5	malignant	malignant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	902	6	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	902	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	902	8	93	93	NUM
inlawrev-20850	902	9	brit	brit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	902	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	903	1	med	med	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	903	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	903	3	bull	bull	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	903	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	904	1	105	105	NUM
inlawrev-20850	904	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	904	3	108	108	NUM
inlawrev-20850	904	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	904	5	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	904	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	904	7	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	904	8	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	904	9	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	904	10	jennifer	jennifer	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	904	11	e.	e.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	904	12	below	below	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	904	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	904	14	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	904	15	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	904	16	impact	impact	VERB
inlawrev-20850	904	17	susceptibility	susceptibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	904	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	904	19	fiber	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	904	20	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	904	21	induced	induce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	904	22	health	health	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	904	23	effects	effect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	904	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	904	25	14	14	NUM
inlawrev-20850	904	26	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	904	27	toxicology	toxicology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	904	28	envtl	envtl	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	904	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	905	1	health	health	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	905	2	246	246	NUM
inlawrev-20850	905	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	905	4	254	254	NUM
inlawrev-20850	905	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	905	6	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	905	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	905	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	905	9	suggesting	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	905	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	905	11	genome	genome	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	905	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	905	13	wide	wide	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	905	14	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	905	15	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	905	16	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	905	17	likely	likely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	905	18	reveal	reveal	VERB
inlawrev-20850	905	19	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	905	20	susceptibility	susceptibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	905	21	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	905	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	905	23	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	905	24	aki	aki	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	905	25	murakami	murakami	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	905	26	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	905	27	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	905	28	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	905	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	905	30	heme	heme	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	905	31	oxygenase-1	oxygenase-1	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	905	32	promoter	promoter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	905	33	polymorphism	polymorphism	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	905	34	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	905	35	associated	associate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	905	36	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	905	37	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	905	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	905	39	malignant	malignant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	905	40	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	905	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	905	42	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	905	43	lung	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	905	44	333	333	NUM
inlawrev-20850	905	45	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	905	46	2012	2012	NUM
inlawrev-20850	905	47	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	905	48	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	1	xu	xu	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	2	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	3	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	6	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	7	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	8	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	906	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	11	4389	4389	NUM
inlawrev-20850	906	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	13	4395	4395	NUM
inlawrev-20850	906	14	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	906	15	96	96	NUM
inlawrev-20850	906	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	17	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	906	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	19	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	20	reporting	report	VERB
inlawrev-20850	906	21	experimental	experimental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	906	22	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	23	consistent	consistent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	906	24	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	906	26	hypothesis	hypothesis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	27	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	906	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	906	29	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	906	30	mutation	mutation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	31	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	906	32	individuals	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	33	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	906	34	susceptible	susceptible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	906	35	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	36	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	37	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	38	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	906	39	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	906	40	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	42	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	43	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	45	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	906	46	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	906	48	hypothesis	hypothesis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	49	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	906	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	906	51	mutation	mutation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	52	causes	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	906	53	individuals	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	54	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	906	55	develop	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	906	56	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	57	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	906	58	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	59	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	60	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	61	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	62	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	63	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	64	joseph	joseph	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	65	r.	r.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	66	testa	testa	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	67	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	68	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	69	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	70	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	71	germline	germline	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	72	bap1	bap1	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	906	73	mutations	mutation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	74	predispose	predispose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	906	75	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	76	malignant	malignant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	906	77	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	78	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	79	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-20850	906	80	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	81	genetics	genetic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	82	1022	1022	NUM
inlawrev-20850	906	83	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	84	1022	1022	NUM
inlawrev-20850	906	85	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	86	1025	1025	NUM
inlawrev-20850	906	87	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	88	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	906	89	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	90	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	91	reporting	report	VERB
inlawrev-20850	906	92	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	906	93	mutations	mutation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	94	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	95	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	906	96	gene	gene	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	97	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	906	98	codes	code	VERB
inlawrev-20850	906	99	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	100	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	906	101	tumor	tumor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	102	suppressor	suppressor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	103	protein	protein	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	104	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	906	105	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	906	106	associated	associate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	906	107	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	108	heightened	heightened	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	906	109	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	110	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	111	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	906	112	cancers	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	113	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	906	114	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	906	115	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	116	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	117	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	118	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	906	119	predominantly	predominantly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	906	120	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	121	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	906	122	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	123	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	906	124	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	906	125	present	present	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	906	126	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	906	127	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	907	1	194	194	NUM
inlawrev-20850	907	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	908	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	908	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	908	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	908	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	908	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	908	6	339	339	NUM
inlawrev-20850	908	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	908	8	40	40	NUM
inlawrev-20850	908	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	908	10	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	908	11	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	908	12	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	908	13	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	908	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	908	15	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	908	16	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	908	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	908	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	908	19	232	232	NUM
inlawrev-20850	908	20	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	908	21	765	765	NUM
inlawrev-20850	908	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	908	23	770	770	NUM
inlawrev-20850	908	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	908	25	71(tex	71(tex	NUM
inlawrev-20850	908	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	908	27	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-20850	908	28	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	908	29	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	908	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	909	1	195	195	X
inlawrev-20850	909	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	909	3	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	909	4	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	909	5	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	909	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	909	7	375	375	NUM
inlawrev-20850	909	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	909	9	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	909	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	909	11	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	909	12	dissenting	dissenting	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	909	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	909	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	909	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	909	16	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	909	17	state	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	909	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	909	19	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	909	20	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	909	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	909	22	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	909	23	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	909	24	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	909	25	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	909	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	909	27	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	909	28	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	909	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	909	30	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-20850	909	31	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	909	32	every	every	DET
inlawrev-20850	909	33	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	909	34	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	909	35	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	909	36	developed	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	909	37	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	909	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	909	39	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	909	40	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	909	41	ignore	ignore	VERB
inlawrev-20850	909	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	909	43	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	909	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	909	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	909	46	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	909	47	witnesses	witness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	909	48	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	909	49	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	909	50	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	909	51	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	909	52	misunderstand	misunderstand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	909	53	fundamentally	fundamentally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	909	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	909	55	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	909	56	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	909	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	909	58	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	909	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	909	60	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	909	61	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	909	62	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	910	1	196	196	NUM
inlawrev-20850	910	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	911	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	911	2	overall	overall	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	911	3	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	911	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	911	5	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	911	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	911	7	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	911	8	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	911	9	occupationally	occupationally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	911	10	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	911	11	workers	worker	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	911	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	911	13	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	911	14	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	911	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	912	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	912	2	supra	supra	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	912	3	text	text	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	912	4	accompanying	accompanying	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	912	5	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	912	6	191	191	NUM
inlawrev-20850	912	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	913	1	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	913	2	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	913	3	above	above	ADV
inlawrev-20850	913	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	913	5	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	913	6	supra	supra	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	913	7	text	text	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	913	8	accompanying	accompanying	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	913	9	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	913	10	193	193	NUM
inlawrev-20850	913	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	913	12	research	research	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	913	13	increasingly	increasingly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	913	14	supports	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	913	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	913	16	hypothesis	hypothesis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	913	17	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	913	18	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	913	19	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	913	20	variations	variation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	913	21	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	913	22	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	913	23	individuals	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	913	24	particularly	particularly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	913	25	susceptible	susceptible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	913	26	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	913	27	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	913	28	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	913	29	induced	induce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	913	30	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	913	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	913	32	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	913	33	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	913	34	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	913	35	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	913	36	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	913	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	914	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	914	2	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	914	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	914	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	914	5	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	914	6	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	914	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	914	8	375	375	NUM
inlawrev-20850	914	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	914	10	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	914	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	914	12	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	914	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	914	14	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	914	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	914	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	914	17	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	914	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	914	19	development	development	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	914	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	914	21	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	914	22	after	after	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	914	23	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	914	24	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	914	25	depends	depend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	914	26	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	914	27	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	914	28	least	least	ADV
inlawrev-20850	914	29	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	914	30	stochastic	stochastic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	914	31	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	914	32	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	914	33	transport	transport	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	914	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	914	35	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	914	36	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	914	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	914	38	pleura	pleura	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	914	39	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	914	40	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	914	41	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	914	42	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	914	43	affect	affect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	914	44	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	914	45	susceptibility	susceptibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	914	46	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	914	47	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	914	48	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	914	49	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	915	1	http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/bmb/ldp047	http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/bmb/ldp047	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	915	2	http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10937404.2011.556052	http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10937404.2011.556052	PRON
inlawrev-20850	915	3	http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00408-012-9371-2	http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00408-012-9371-2	VERB
inlawrev-20850	915	4	http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/ng.912	http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/ng.912	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	915	5	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	915	6	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	915	7	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	8	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	915	10	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	915	11	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	12	151	151	NUM
inlawrev-20850	915	13	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	14	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	915	15	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	915	16	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	915	17	avoided	avoid	VERB
inlawrev-20850	915	18	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	915	19	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	915	20	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	915	21	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	915	22	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	23	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	915	24	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	915	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	915	26	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	915	27	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	915	28	products.197	products.197	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	915	30	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	915	31	effort	effort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	32	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	915	33	avoid	avoid	VERB
inlawrev-20850	915	34	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	915	35	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	915	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	915	38	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	39	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	915	40	assumed	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	915	41	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	915	42	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	915	43	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	915	44	true	true	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	915	45	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	915	46	science	science	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	47	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	915	48	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	915	49	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	915	50	demonstrated	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	915	51	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	915	52	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	915	53	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	915	54	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	915	55	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	915	56	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	57	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	915	58	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	59	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	915	60	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	61	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	915	62	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	915	63	incapable	incapable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	915	64	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	915	65	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	915	66	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	67	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	915	68	hence	hence	ADV
inlawrev-20850	915	69	the198	the198	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	915	70	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	71	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	915	72	insistence	insistence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	73	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	915	74	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	915	75	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	915	76	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	915	77	called	call	VERB
inlawrev-20850	915	78	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	915	79	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	80	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	81	contradicts	contradict	VERB
inlawrev-20850	915	82	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	915	83	asserted	asserted	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	915	84	inability	inability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	85	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	915	86	ambient	ambient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	915	87	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	88	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	89	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	915	90	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	91	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	92	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	915	93	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	915	94	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	915	95	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	915	96	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	916	1	ironically	ironically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	916	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	916	3	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	916	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	916	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	916	6	existence	existence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	916	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	916	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	916	9	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	916	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	916	11	effect	effect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	916	12	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	916	13	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	916	14	tend199	tend199	VERB
inlawrev-20850	916	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	916	16	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	916	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	916	18	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	916	19	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	916	20	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	916	21	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	916	22	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	916	23	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	916	24	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	916	25	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	916	26	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	916	27	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	916	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	916	29	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	916	30	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	916	31	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	916	32	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	916	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	916	34	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	916	35	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	916	36	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	916	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	917	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	917	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	917	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	917	4	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	917	5	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	917	6	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	917	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	917	8	pacific’s200	pacific’s200	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	917	9	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	917	10	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	917	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	917	12	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	917	13	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	917	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	917	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	917	16	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	917	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	917	18	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	917	19	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	917	20	collectively	collectively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	917	21	exceeded	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	917	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	917	23	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	917	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	917	25	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	917	26	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	917	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	917	28	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	917	29	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	917	30	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	917	31	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	917	32	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	917	33	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	917	34	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	917	35	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	917	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	917	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	917	38	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	917	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	918	1	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	918	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	918	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	918	4	aggregate	aggregate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	918	5	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	918	6	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	918	7	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	918	8	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	918	9	exceeded	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	918	10	the201	the201	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	918	11	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	918	12	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	918	13	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	918	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	918	15	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	918	16	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	918	17	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	918	18	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	918	19	meaning	mean	VERB
inlawrev-20850	918	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	918	21	georgiapacific	georgiapacific	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	918	22	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	918	23	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	918	24	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	918	25	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	918	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	918	27	strictly	strictly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	918	28	speaking	speak	VERB
inlawrev-20850	918	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	918	30	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	918	31	for	for	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	918	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	918	33	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	918	34	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	918	35	occur	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	918	36	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	918	37	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	918	38	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	918	39	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	918	40	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	918	41	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	918	42	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	918	43	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-20850	918	44	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	918	45	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	918	46	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	918	47	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	918	48	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	918	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	918	50	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	918	51	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	918	52	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	918	53	rule.202	rule.202	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	918	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	918	55	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	918	56	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	918	57	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	918	58	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	918	59	embrace	embrace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	918	60	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	918	61	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	918	62	articulate	articulate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	918	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	918	64	above	above	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	918	65	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	918	66	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	919	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	919	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	919	3	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	919	4	attempt	attempt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	919	5	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	919	6	alternative	alternative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	919	7	justification	justification	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	919	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	919	9	insulating	insulate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	919	10	contributors	contributor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	919	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	919	12	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	919	13	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	919	14	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	919	15	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	919	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	919	17	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	919	18	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	919	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	920	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	920	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	920	3	move	move	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	920	4	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	920	5	proved	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	920	6	too	too	ADV
inlawrev-20850	920	7	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	920	8	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	920	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	920	10	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	920	11	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	920	12	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	920	13	concurred	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	920	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	920	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	920	16	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	920	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	920	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	920	19	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	920	20	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	920	21	another	another	DET
inlawrev-20850	920	22	shift	shift	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	920	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	920	24	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	920	25	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	920	26	paradigm	paradigm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	920	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	920	28	ensure	ensure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	920	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	920	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	920	31	contributing	contributing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	920	32	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	920	33	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	920	34	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	920	35	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	920	36	unavailable	unavailable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	920	37	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	920	38	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	920	39	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	920	40	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	920	41	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	920	42	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	920	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	921	1	3	3	X
inlawrev-20850	921	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	921	3	comparing	compare	VERB
inlawrev-20850	921	4	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	5	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	921	6	mixing	mix	VERB
inlawrev-20850	921	7	norm	norm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	921	9	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	921	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	921	12	concurring	concurring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	13	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	14	model.—in	model.—in	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	921	15	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	921	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	921	17	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	921	18	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	921	19	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	20	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	921	21	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	921	23	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	921	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	921	26	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	921	27	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	28	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	921	29	principally	principally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	921	30	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	921	31	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	921	32	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	921	33	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	34	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	921	36	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	921	37	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	921	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	921	39	idea	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	40	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	921	41	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	921	42	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	921	44	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	921	45	contributing	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	921	46	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	921	47	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	48	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	921	49	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	921	50	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	921	51	combine	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	921	52	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	921	53	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	921	54	197	197	NUM
inlawrev-20850	921	55	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	922	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	922	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	922	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	922	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	922	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	922	6	339	339	NUM
inlawrev-20850	922	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	922	8	40	40	NUM
inlawrev-20850	922	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	923	1	198	198	NUM
inlawrev-20850	923	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	924	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	924	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	924	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	924	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	924	5	340	340	NUM
inlawrev-20850	924	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	924	7	characterizing	characterize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	924	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	924	9	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	924	10	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	924	11	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	924	12	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	924	13	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	924	14	premised	premise	VERB
inlawrev-20850	924	15	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	924	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	924	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	924	18	failure	failure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	924	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	924	20	science	science	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	924	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	924	22	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	924	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	924	24	maximum	maximum	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	924	25	safe	safe	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	924	26	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	924	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	924	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	924	29	toxin	toxin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	924	30	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	924	31	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	924	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	925	1	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	925	2	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	925	3	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	925	4	witnesses	witness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	925	5	accepted	accept	VERB
inlawrev-20850	925	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	925	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	925	8	noeffect	noeffect	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	925	9	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	925	10	theoretically	theoretically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	925	11	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	925	12	exist	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	925	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	925	14	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	925	15	testified	testify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	925	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	925	17	such	such	DET
inlawrev-20850	925	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	925	19	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	925	20	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	925	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	925	22	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	925	23	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	925	24	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	925	25	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	925	26	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	925	27	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	925	28	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	925	29	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	925	30	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	925	31	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	925	32	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	925	33	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	925	34	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	925	35	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	925	36	able	able	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	925	37	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	925	38	measure	measure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	925	39	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	925	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	925	41	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	926	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	926	2	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	926	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	926	4	368	368	NUM
inlawrev-20850	926	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	926	6	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	926	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	926	8	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	926	9	dissenting	dissenting	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	926	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	926	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	926	12	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	926	13	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	926	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	926	15	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	926	16	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	926	17	witness	witness	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	926	18	dr	dr	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	926	19	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	926	20	lemen	lemen	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	926	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	926	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	927	1	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	927	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	927	3	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	927	4	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	927	5	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	927	6	dispute	dispute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	927	7	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	927	8	assertion	assertion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	927	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	927	10	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	927	11	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	927	12	embraced	embrace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	927	13	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	927	14	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	927	15	grounds	ground	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	927	16	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	927	17	affirmance	affirmance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	927	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	928	2	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	928	3	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	4	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	928	5	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	928	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	928	7	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	928	8	brief	brief	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	9	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	928	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	928	11	merits	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	13	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	928	14	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	15	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	928	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	17	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	928	18	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	928	19	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	20	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	928	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	928	22	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	23	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	24	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	25	admitted	admit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	928	26	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	928	27	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	928	28	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	928	29	identify	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	928	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	928	31	minimum	minimum	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	928	32	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	928	34	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	35	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	928	36	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	928	37	lead	lead	VERB
inlawrev-20850	928	38	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	928	39	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	40	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	41	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	42	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	928	43	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	928	44	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	928	45	29	29	NUM
inlawrev-20850	928	46	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	928	47	n.26	n.26	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	928	48	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	49	arguing	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	928	50	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	51	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	928	52	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	928	53	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	928	54	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	55	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	928	56	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	57	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	928	58	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	59	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	928	60	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	928	61	minimum	minimum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	62	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	63	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	928	64	higher	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	928	65	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	928	66	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	928	67	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	68	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	69	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	928	70	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	928	71	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	72	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	73	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	928	74	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	929	1	199	199	NUM
inlawrev-20850	929	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	930	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	930	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	930	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	930	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	930	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	930	6	339	339	NUM
inlawrev-20850	930	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	931	1	200	200	NUM
inlawrev-20850	931	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	932	1	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	932	2	assumes	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	932	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	932	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	932	5	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	932	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	932	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	932	8	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	932	9	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	932	10	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	932	11	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	932	12	for	for	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	932	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	932	14	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	932	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	932	16	conclude	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	932	17	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	932	18	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	932	19	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	932	20	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	932	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	932	22	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	932	23	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	932	24	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-20850	932	25	amount	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	932	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	932	27	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	932	28	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	932	29	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	932	30	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	932	31	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	932	32	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	932	33	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	932	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	933	1	201	201	NUM
inlawrev-20850	933	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	933	3	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	933	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	933	5	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	933	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	933	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	933	8	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	933	9	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	933	10	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	933	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	934	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	934	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	934	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	934	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	934	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	934	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	934	7	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	934	8	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	934	9	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	934	10	cmt	cmt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	934	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	935	1	c	c	X
inlawrev-20850	935	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	935	3	28	28	NUM
inlawrev-20850	935	4	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	935	5	cmt	cmt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	935	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	936	1	c	c	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	936	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	936	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	936	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	936	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	937	1	202	202	NUM
inlawrev-20850	937	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	938	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	938	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	938	3	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	938	4	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	938	5	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	938	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	939	1	f	f	X
inlawrev-20850	939	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	939	3	g.	g.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	939	4	152	152	NUM
inlawrev-20850	939	5	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	939	6	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	939	7	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	940	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	940	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	940	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	940	4	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	941	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	941	2	large	large	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	941	3	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	941	4	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	941	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	941	6	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	941	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	941	8	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	941	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	941	10	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	941	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	942	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	942	2	providing	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	942	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	942	4	further	further	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	942	5	rationale203	rationale203	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	942	6	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	942	7	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	942	8	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	942	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	942	10	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	942	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	942	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	942	13	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	942	14	switched	switch	VERB
inlawrev-20850	942	15	gears	gear	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	942	16	once	once	ADV
inlawrev-20850	942	17	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-20850	942	18	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	942	19	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-20850	942	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	942	21	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	942	22	are	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	942	23	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	942	24	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	942	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	942	26	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	942	27	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	942	28	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	942	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	942	30	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	942	31	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	942	32	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	942	33	tied	tie	VERB
inlawrev-20850	942	34	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	942	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	942	36	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	942	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	942	38	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	942	39	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	942	40	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	942	41	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	942	42	minuscule	minuscule	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	942	43	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	942	44	compared	compare	VERB
inlawrev-20850	942	45	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	942	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	942	47	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	942	48	resulting	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	942	49	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	942	50	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	942	51	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	942	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	942	53	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	942	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	942	55	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	943	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	943	2	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	943	3	third	third	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	943	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	943	5	torts	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	943	6	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	943	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	943	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	943	9	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	943	10	w]hen	w]hen	ADV
inlawrev-20850	943	11	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	943	12	actor	actor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	943	13	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	943	14	negligent	negligent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	943	15	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	943	16	constitutes	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	943	17	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	943	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	943	19	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	943	20	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	943	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	943	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	943	23	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	943	24	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	943	25	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	943	26	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	943	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	943	28	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	943	29	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	943	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	943	31	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	943	32	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	943	33	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	943	34	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	944	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	944	2	addressing	address	VERB
inlawrev-20850	944	3	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	944	4	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	944	5	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	6	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	944	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	944	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	944	9	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	944	11	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	944	12	within	within	ADP
inlawrev-20850	944	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	944	14	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	944	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	944	17	actor	actor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	18	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	944	19	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	944	21	”204	”204	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	944	22	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	944	23	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	944	24	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	944	25	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	26	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	944	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	944	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	944	29	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	30	third	third	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	944	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	944	33	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	34	betrayed	betray	VERB
inlawrev-20850	944	35	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	944	36	another	another	DET
inlawrev-20850	944	37	switch	switch	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	38	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	944	39	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	40	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	41	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	944	42	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	944	43	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	944	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	944	45	move	move	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	46	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	944	47	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	944	48	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	944	49	normative	normative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	944	50	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	944	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	945	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	945	2	quoted	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	945	3	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	945	4	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	945	5	applies	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	945	6	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	945	7	conduct	conduct	VERB
inlawrev-20850	945	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	945	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	945	10	constitutes	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	945	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	945	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	945	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	946	1	a	a	PRON
inlawrev-20850	946	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	946	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	946	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	947	1	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	947	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	947	3	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	947	4	albeit	albeit	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	947	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	947	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	947	7	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	947	8	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	947	9	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	947	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	947	11	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	947	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	947	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	947	14	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	947	15	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	947	16	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	947	17	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	947	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	947	19	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	947	20	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	947	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	947	22	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	947	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	947	24	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	948	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	948	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	948	3	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	948	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	948	5	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	948	6	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	7	contended	contend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	948	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	948	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	948	10	immediately	immediately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	948	11	adjacent205	adjacent205	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	948	12	paragraphs	paragraph	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	948	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	948	15	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	948	16	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	948	18	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	19	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	948	20	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	948	21	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	948	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	948	23	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	948	24	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	948	26	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	948	28	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	948	29	invoking	invoke	VERB
inlawrev-20850	948	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	948	31	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	948	32	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	948	33	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	34	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	948	35	rule	rule	VERB
inlawrev-20850	948	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	948	37	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	38	shifted206	shifted206	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	948	39	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	948	40	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	948	41	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	948	43	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	948	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	948	45	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	948	46	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	47	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	948	48	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	948	49	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	948	50	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	51	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	948	52	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	948	53	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	948	54	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	948	55	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	56	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	948	57	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	948	58	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	59	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	948	60	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	948	61	classic	classic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	948	62	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	63	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	948	64	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	948	65	causes.207	causes.207	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	66	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	948	67	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	68	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	948	69	combine	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	948	70	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	948	71	bring	bring	VERB
inlawrev-20850	948	72	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	948	73	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	74	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	948	75	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	948	76	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	948	77	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	78	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	948	79	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	948	80	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	948	81	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	949	1	yet	yet	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	949	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	949	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	949	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	949	5	ignored	ignore	VERB
inlawrev-20850	949	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	949	7	concurring	concurring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	949	8	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	949	9	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	949	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	949	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	949	12	rest208	rest208	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	949	13	203	203	NUM
inlawrev-20850	949	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	950	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	950	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	950	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	950	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	950	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	950	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	950	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	950	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	950	9	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	950	10	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	950	11	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	950	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	950	13	338	338	NUM
inlawrev-20850	950	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	950	15	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	950	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	950	17	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	950	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	950	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	951	1	204	204	NUM
inlawrev-20850	951	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	952	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	952	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	952	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	952	4	341	341	NUM
inlawrev-20850	952	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	952	6	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	952	7	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	952	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	952	9	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	952	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	952	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	952	12	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	952	13	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	952	14	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	952	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	953	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	953	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	953	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	953	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	953	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	953	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	953	7	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	953	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	953	9	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	953	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	953	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	953	12	ellipsis	ellipsis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	953	13	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	953	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	953	15	footnote	footnote	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	953	16	omitted	omit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	953	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	953	18	bracketed	bracketed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	953	19	material	material	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	953	20	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	953	21	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	953	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	953	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	954	1	205	205	NUM
inlawrev-20850	954	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	955	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	955	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	955	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	955	4	345	345	NUM
inlawrev-20850	955	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	955	6	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	955	7	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	955	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	955	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	956	1	206	206	NUM
inlawrev-20850	956	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	957	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	957	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	957	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	957	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	957	5	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	957	6	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	957	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	957	8	340	340	NUM
inlawrev-20850	957	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	957	10	arguing	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	957	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	957	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	957	13	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	957	14	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	957	15	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	16	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	957	17	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	18	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	957	19	negates	negate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	957	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	957	21	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	22	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	957	23	burden	burden	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	957	25	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	957	26	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	27	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	957	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	957	29	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	957	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	957	32	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	33	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	957	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	957	35	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	957	36	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	957	37	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	957	38	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	957	39	341	341	NUM
inlawrev-20850	957	40	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	957	41	arguing	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	957	42	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	957	43	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	957	44	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	957	45	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	46	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	47	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	957	48	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	957	49	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	957	50	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	51	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	957	52	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	53	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	957	54	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	957	55	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	957	56	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	57	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	957	58	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	59	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	957	60	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	957	61	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	62	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	957	63	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	957	64	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	957	65	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	957	66	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	957	67	either	either	ADV
inlawrev-20850	957	68	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	957	69	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	958	1	207	207	NUM
inlawrev-20850	958	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	959	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	959	2	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	959	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	959	4	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	959	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	959	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	959	7	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	959	8	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	959	9	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	959	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	960	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	960	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	960	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	960	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	960	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	960	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	960	7	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	960	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	960	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	961	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	961	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	961	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	961	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	961	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	961	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	961	7	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	961	8	t]he	t]he	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	961	9	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	961	10	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-20850	961	11	constitutes	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	961	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	961	13	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	961	14	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	961	15	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	961	16	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	961	17	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	961	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	961	19	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	961	20	f	f	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	961	21	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	961	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	961	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	962	1	208	208	NUM
inlawrev-20850	962	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	962	3	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	962	4	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	962	5	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	962	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	962	7	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	962	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	962	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	963	1	c	c	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	963	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	963	3	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	963	4	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	963	5	actor	actor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	963	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	963	7	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	963	8	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	963	9	need	need	AUX
inlawrev-20850	963	10	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	963	11	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	963	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	963	13	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	963	14	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	963	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	963	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	963	17	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	963	18	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	963	19	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	963	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	964	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	964	2	existence	existence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	964	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	964	4	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	964	5	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	964	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	964	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	964	8	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	964	9	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	964	10	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	964	11	affect	affect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	964	12	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	964	13	specified	specify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	964	14	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	964	15	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	964	16	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	964	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	964	18	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	964	19	condition	condition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	964	20	for	for	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	964	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	964	22	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	964	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	964	24	occur	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	964	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	964	26	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	964	27	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	965	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	965	2	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	965	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	965	4	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	965	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	965	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	966	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	966	2	complication	complication	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	966	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	966	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	966	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	966	6	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	966	7	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	966	8	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	966	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	966	10	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	966	11	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	966	12	applies	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	966	13	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	966	14	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	966	15	overdetermined	overdetermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	966	16	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	966	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	967	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	967	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	967	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	967	4	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	967	5	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	967	6	cmt	cmt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	967	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	968	1	b	b	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	968	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	968	3	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	968	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	968	5	exception	exception	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	968	6	applies	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	968	7	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	968	8	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	968	9	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	968	10	are	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	968	11	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	968	12	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	968	13	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	968	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	968	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	968	16	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	968	17	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	968	18	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	968	19	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	968	20	constitutes	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	968	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	968	22	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	968	23	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	968	24	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	968	25	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	968	26	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	968	27	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	968	28	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	968	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	968	30	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	968	31	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	968	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	969	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	969	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	969	3	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	969	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	969	5	sections	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	969	6	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	969	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	969	8	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	969	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	969	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	969	11	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	969	12	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	969	13	works	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	969	14	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	969	15	follows	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	969	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	970	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	970	2	1	1	X
inlawrev-20850	970	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	970	4	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	970	5	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	970	6	says	say	VERB
inlawrev-20850	970	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	970	8	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	970	9	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	970	10	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	970	11	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	970	12	exist	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	970	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	970	14	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	970	15	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	970	16	treated	treat	VERB
inlawrev-20850	970	17	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	970	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	970	19	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	970	20	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	970	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	970	22	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	970	23	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	970	24	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	970	25	though	though	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	970	26	none	none	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	970	27	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	970	28	literally	literally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	970	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	970	30	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	970	31	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	970	32	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	970	33	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	970	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	971	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	971	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	971	3	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	971	4	takes	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	971	5	1000	1000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	971	6	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	971	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	971	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	971	9	poison	poison	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	971	10	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	971	11	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	971	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	971	13	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	971	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	971	15	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	971	16	tortfeasors	tortfeasor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	971	17	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	971	18	administer	administer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	971	19	1000	1000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	971	20	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	971	21	before	before	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	971	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	971	23	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	971	24	develops	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	971	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	971	26	both	both	DET
inlawrev-20850	971	27	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	971	28	acts	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	971	29	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	971	30	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	971	31	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	971	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	971	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	971	34	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	971	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	972	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	972	2	2	2	X
inlawrev-20850	972	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	972	4	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	972	5	f	f	X
inlawrev-20850	972	6	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	972	7	section	section	VERB
inlawrev-20850	972	8	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	972	9	explains	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	972	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	972	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	972	12	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	972	13	applies	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	972	14	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	972	15	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	972	16	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	972	17	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	972	18	sets	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	972	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	972	20	so	so	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	972	21	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	972	22	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	972	23	need	need	AUX
inlawrev-20850	972	24	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	972	25	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	972	26	entirely	entirely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	972	27	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	972	28	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	972	29	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	972	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	973	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	973	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	973	3	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	973	4	tortfeasors	tortfeasor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	973	5	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	973	6	administer	administer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	973	7	667	667	NUM
inlawrev-20850	973	8	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	973	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	973	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	973	11	poison	poison	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	973	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	973	13	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	973	14	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	973	15	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	973	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	973	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	973	18	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	973	19	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	973	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	973	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	973	22	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	973	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	974	1	cf	cf	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	974	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	975	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	975	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	975	3	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	975	4	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	975	5	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	975	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	976	1	f	f	X
inlawrev-20850	976	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	976	3	illus	illus	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	976	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	977	1	3	3	X
inlawrev-20850	977	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	977	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	977	4	3	3	X
inlawrev-20850	977	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	977	6	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	7	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	977	8	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	977	9	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	10	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	977	12	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	977	13	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	14	153	153	NUM
inlawrev-20850	977	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	977	16	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	977	17	opinion.209	opinion.209	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	18	moreover	moreover	ADV
inlawrev-20850	977	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	977	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	977	21	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	22	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	23	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	977	24	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	977	25	say	say	VERB
inlawrev-20850	977	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	977	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	977	28	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	977	29	contributor	contributor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	977	31	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	977	32	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	977	33	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	34	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	35	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	977	36	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	977	37	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	977	38	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	977	39	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	40	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	977	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	977	42	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	43	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	977	44	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	977	46	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	977	47	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	977	48	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	977	49	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	977	50	actors	actor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	51	responsible	responsible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	977	52	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	977	53	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	977	54	contributions	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	55	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	977	56	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	977	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	977	58	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	59	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	977	60	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	977	61	within	within	ADP
inlawrev-20850	977	62	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	977	63	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	64	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	977	65	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	977	66	actor	actor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	67	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	977	68	liability”—an	liability”—an	VERB
inlawrev-20850	977	69	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	977	70	normative	normative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	977	71	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	977	72	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	978	1	the210	the210	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	978	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	978	3	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	978	4	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	978	5	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-20850	978	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	978	7	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	978	8	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	978	9	invoking	invoke	VERB
inlawrev-20850	978	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	978	11	normative	normative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	978	12	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	978	13	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	978	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	978	15	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	978	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	978	17	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	978	18	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	978	19	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	978	20	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	978	21	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	978	22	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	978	23	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	978	24	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	978	25	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	978	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	978	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	978	28	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	978	29	cited	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	978	30	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	978	31	g	g	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	978	32	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	978	33	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	978	34	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	978	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	978	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	978	37	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	978	38	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	978	39	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	978	40	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	978	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	978	42	scenario	scenario	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	978	43	closest	close	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	978	44	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	978	45	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-20850	978	46	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	978	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	979	1	”211	”211	PRON
inlawrev-20850	979	2	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	3	g	g	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	979	4	instructs	instruct	VERB
inlawrev-20850	979	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	979	6	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	979	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	979	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	9	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	979	10	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	979	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	979	12	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	979	13	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	979	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	979	16	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	979	17	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	979	19	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	979	20	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	21	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	979	22	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	979	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	979	24	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	979	25	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	979	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	979	28	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	29	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	979	30	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	31	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	979	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	979	33	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	979	34	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	979	35	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	979	36	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	37	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	979	38	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	979	40	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	979	41	section”—even	section”—even	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	42	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	979	43	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	979	44	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	45	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	979	46	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	979	47	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	979	48	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	979	49	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	979	50	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	979	51	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	979	52	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	53	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	979	54	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	979	55	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	979	56	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	57	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	979	58	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	979	59	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	979	60	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	979	61	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	979	62	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	63	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	979	64	excess	excess	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	65	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	979	66	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	979	67	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	68	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	979	69	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	979	70	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	979	71	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	979	72	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	979	73	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	980	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	980	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	980	3	ignored	ignore	VERB
inlawrev-20850	980	4	that212	that212	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	980	5	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	980	6	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	980	7	preferring	prefer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	980	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	980	9	hold	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	980	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	980	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	980	12	contributing	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	980	13	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	980	14	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	980	15	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	980	16	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	980	17	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	980	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	980	19	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	980	20	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	980	21	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	980	22	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	980	23	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	980	24	alone	alone	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	980	25	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	980	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	980	27	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	980	28	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	980	29	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	980	30	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	980	31	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	980	32	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	980	33	logic	logic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	980	34	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	980	35	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	980	36	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
inlawrev-20850	980	37	quoted	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	980	38	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	980	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	981	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	981	2	quotation	quotation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	981	4	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	981	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	981	6	left	leave	VERB
inlawrev-20850	981	7	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-20850	981	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	981	9	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	981	11	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	981	12	sentence	sentence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	13	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	981	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	981	15	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	981	16	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	981	17	are	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	981	18	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	981	19	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	20	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	981	21	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	981	22	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	981	23	de	de	X
inlawrev-20850	981	24	minimis	minimis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	25	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	981	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	981	27	actor	actor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	28	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	981	29	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	981	30	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	981	31	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	981	32	liable	liable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	981	33	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	981	34	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	981	35	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	36	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	981	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	981	38	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	981	39	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	981	41	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	981	42	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	981	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	981	44	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	981	46	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	981	47	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	981	48	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-20850	981	49	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	981	50	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	981	51	36.”213	36.”213	NUM
inlawrev-20850	981	52	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	981	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	981	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	981	55	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	56	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	981	57	holdings	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	58	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	981	59	appear	appear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	981	60	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	981	61	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	981	62	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-20850	981	63	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	981	64	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	981	65	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	981	66	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	67	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	981	68	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	981	69	understood	understand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	981	70	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	981	71	normative	normative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	981	72	judgments	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	73	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	981	74	seen	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	981	75	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	981	76	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	981	77	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	981	78	applies	applie	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	79	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	981	80	protect	protect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	981	81	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-20850	981	82	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	981	83	contribute	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	981	84	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	981	85	trivially	trivially	ADV
inlawrev-20850	981	86	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	981	87	any	any	PRON
inlawrev-20850	981	88	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	981	89	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	981	90	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	981	91	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	981	92	sets	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	93	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	981	94	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	981	95	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	982	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	982	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	982	3	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	982	4	tortfeasors	tortfeasor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	982	5	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	982	6	administer	administer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	982	7	999	999	NUM
inlawrev-20850	982	8	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	982	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	982	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	982	11	poison	poison	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	982	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	982	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	982	14	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	982	15	tortfeasor	tortfeasor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	982	16	administers	administer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	982	17	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	982	18	unit	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	982	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	982	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	982	21	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	982	22	tortfeasor	tortfeasor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	982	23	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	982	24	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	982	25	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	982	26	liable	liable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	982	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	983	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	983	2	third	third	ADV
inlawrev-20850	983	3	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	983	4	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	983	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	983	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	983	7	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	983	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	983	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	983	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	983	11	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	983	12	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	983	13	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	983	14	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	983	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	983	16	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	983	17	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	983	18	exist	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	983	19	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	983	20	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	983	21	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	983	22	sets	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	983	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	983	24	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	983	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	983	26	999	999	NUM
inlawrev-20850	983	27	+	+	SYM
inlawrev-20850	983	28	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	983	29	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	983	30	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	983	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	983	32	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	983	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	983	34	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	983	35	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	983	36	unit	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	983	37	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	983	38	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	983	39	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	983	40	essential	essential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	983	41	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	983	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	984	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	984	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	984	3	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	984	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	984	5	overdetermined	overdetermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	984	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	984	7	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	984	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	984	9	total	total	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	984	10	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	984	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	984	12	1999	1999	NUM
inlawrev-20850	984	13	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	984	14	exceeds	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	984	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	984	16	1000	1000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	984	17	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	984	18	unit	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	984	19	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	984	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	985	1	moreover	moreover	ADV
inlawrev-20850	985	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	985	3	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	985	4	exists	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	985	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	985	6	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	985	7	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	985	8	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	985	9	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	985	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	985	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	985	12	999	999	NUM
inlawrev-20850	985	13	+	+	SYM
inlawrev-20850	985	14	999	999	NUM
inlawrev-20850	985	15	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	985	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	985	17	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	985	18	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	985	19	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	985	20	include	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	985	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	985	22	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	985	23	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	985	24	unit	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	985	25	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	985	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	986	1	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	986	2	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	986	3	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	986	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	986	5	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	986	6	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	986	7	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	986	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	986	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	986	10	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	986	11	reasons	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	986	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	986	13	factfinder	factfinder	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	986	14	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	986	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	986	16	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	986	17	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	986	18	excuse	excuse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	986	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	986	20	tortfeasor	tortfeasor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	986	21	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	986	22	administered	administer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	986	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	986	24	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	986	25	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	986	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	987	1	209	209	NUM
inlawrev-20850	987	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	988	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	988	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	988	3	supra	supra	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	988	4	parts	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	988	5	ii.a	ii.a	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	988	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	988	7	ii.b.1	ii.b.1	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	988	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	988	9	ii.b.2	ii.b.2	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	988	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	989	1	210	210	NUM
inlawrev-20850	989	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	990	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	990	2	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	990	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	990	4	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	990	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	990	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	990	7	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	990	8	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	990	9	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	990	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	991	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	991	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	991	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	991	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	991	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	991	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	991	7	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	991	8	cmt	cmt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	991	9	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	991	10	reporters	reporters	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	991	11	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	991	12	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	991	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	991	14	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	991	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	991	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	991	17	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	991	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	991	19	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	991	20	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	991	21	limitation	limitation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	991	22	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	991	23	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	991	24	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	991	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	991	26	normative	normative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	991	27	one	one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	991	28	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	991	29	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	991	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	991	31	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	991	32	one	one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	991	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	991	34	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	991	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	991	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	992	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	992	2	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	3	third	third	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	4	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	992	5	positions	position	VERB
inlawrev-20850	992	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	992	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	992	8	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	992	9	contributions	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	10	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	992	11	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	12	amid	amid	ADP
inlawrev-20850	992	13	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	992	14	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	992	15	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	16	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	992	17	withhold	withhold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	992	18	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	19	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	992	20	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	992	21	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	992	22	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	23	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	992	24	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	992	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	992	26	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	992	27	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	992	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	992	30	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	31	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	992	32	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	992	34	denominated	denominate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	992	35	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	992	36	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	992	38	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	39	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	992	40	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	992	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	992	42	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	43	third	third	ADV
inlawrev-20850	992	44	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	992	45	often	often	ADV
inlawrev-20850	992	46	called	call	VERB
inlawrev-20850	992	47	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	992	48	proximate	proximate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	49	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	992	50	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	992	51	elsewhere	elsewhere	ADV
inlawrev-20850	992	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	993	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	993	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	993	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	993	4	ch	ch	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	993	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	993	6	6	6	NUM
inlawrev-20850	993	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	993	8	special	special	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	993	9	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	993	10	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	993	11	proximate	proximate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	993	12	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	993	13	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	993	14	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	993	15	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	993	16	i	i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	993	17	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	993	18	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	993	19	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	993	20	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	993	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	994	1	g	g	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	994	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	994	3	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	994	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	994	5	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	994	6	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	994	7	treats	treat	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	994	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	994	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	994	10	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	994	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	994	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	994	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	994	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	995	1	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	995	2	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	995	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	995	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	996	1	211	211	NUM
inlawrev-20850	996	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	997	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	997	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	997	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	997	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	997	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	997	6	346	346	NUM
inlawrev-20850	997	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	998	1	212	212	NUM
inlawrev-20850	998	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	998	3	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	998	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	998	5	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	998	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	998	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	998	8	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	998	9	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	998	10	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	998	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	999	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	999	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	999	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	999	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	999	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	999	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	999	7	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	999	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	999	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1000	1	g	g	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1000	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1000	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1000	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1000	5	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1000	6	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1000	7	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1000	8	i	i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1000	9	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1000	10	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1000	11	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1000	12	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1000	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1001	1	f	f	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1001	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1001	3	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1001	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1001	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1001	6	overdetermined	overdetermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1001	7	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1001	8	situations	situation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1001	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1001	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1001	11	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1001	12	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1001	13	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1001	14	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1001	15	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1001	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1001	17	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1001	18	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1001	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1001	20	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1001	21	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1001	22	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1001	23	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1001	24	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1001	25	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1001	26	actor	actor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1001	27	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1001	28	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1001	29	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1001	30	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1001	31	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1001	32	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1001	33	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1001	34	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1001	35	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1001	36	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1001	37	another	another	DET
inlawrev-20850	1001	38	’s	’s	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1001	39	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1001	40	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1001	41	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1001	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1002	1	213	213	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1002	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1003	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1003	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1003	3	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1003	4	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1003	5	cmt	cmt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1003	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1004	1	g.	g.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1004	2	154	154	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1004	3	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1004	4	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1004	5	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1005	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1005	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1005	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1005	4	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1005	5	lens	lens	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1005	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1005	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1005	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1005	9	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1005	10	contributions	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1005	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1005	12	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1005	13	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1005	14	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1005	15	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1005	16	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1005	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1006	1	first	first	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1006	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1006	3	the214	the214	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1006	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1006	5	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1006	6	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1006	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1006	8	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1006	9	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1006	10	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1006	11	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1006	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1006	13	comment	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1006	14	g	g	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1006	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1006	16	restatement	restatement	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1006	17	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1006	18	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1006	19	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1006	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1006	21	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1006	22	are	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1006	23	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1006	24	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1006	25	sufficiently	sufficiently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1006	26	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1006	27	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1006	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1006	29	actors	actor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1006	30	responsible	responsible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1006	31	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1006	32	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1006	33	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1006	34	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1006	35	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1006	36	liable	liable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1006	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1007	1	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1007	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1007	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1007	4	majority215	majority215	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1007	5	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1007	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1007	7	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1007	8	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1007	9	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1007	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1007	11	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1007	12	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1007	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1007	14	avoid	avoid	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1007	15	having	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1007	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1007	17	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1007	18	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1007	19	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1007	20	treated	treat	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1007	21	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1007	22	de	de	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1007	23	minimis	minimis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1007	24	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1007	25	quantifying	quantify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1007	26	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1007	27	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1007	28	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1007	29	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1007	30	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1007	31	mathematical	mathematical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1007	32	precision	precision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1007	33	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1007	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1007	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1007	36	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1007	37	contributed	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1007	38	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1007	39	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	1007	40	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1007	41	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1007	42	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1007	43	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1007	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1007	45	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1007	46	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1007	47	total	total	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1007	48	dose	dose	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1007	49	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1008	1	third	third	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1008	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1008	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1008	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	5	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1008	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1008	7	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	8	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	9	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1008	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1008	11	minimum	minimum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	12	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	13	that216	that216	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1008	14	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1008	15	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1008	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1008	17	substantial”—hence	substantial”—hence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1008	19	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1008	20	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1008	21	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1008	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1008	23	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1008	25	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1008	26	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	27	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1008	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1008	29	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1008	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1008	31	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1008	32	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1008	33	double	double	DET
inlawrev-20850	1008	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1008	35	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1008	37	disease.217	disease.217	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1008	39	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	40	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1008	41	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1008	42	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	43	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1008	44	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1008	45	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1008	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1008	48	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	49	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1008	50	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1008	51	utterly	utterly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1008	52	inconsistent	inconsistent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1008	53	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1008	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1008	55	concurring	concurring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	56	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	57	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	58	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1008	59	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1008	60	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1008	61	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1008	62	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	63	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1008	64	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1008	65	derived	derive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1008	66	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1009	1	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1009	2	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1009	3	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1009	4	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1009	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1009	6	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1009	7	ruling	ruling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1009	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1009	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1009	10	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1009	11	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1009	12	invoked	invoke	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1009	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1009	14	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1009	15	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1009	16	rule	rule	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1009	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1009	18	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1009	19	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1009	20	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1010	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1010	2	w]hen	w]hen	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1010	3	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1010	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1010	5	introduced	introduce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1010	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1010	7	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1010	8	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1010	9	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1010	10	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1010	11	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1010	12	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1010	13	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1010	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1010	15	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1010	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1010	17	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1010	18	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1010	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1010	20	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1010	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1010	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1010	23	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1010	24	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1010	25	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1010	26	suffice	suffice	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1010	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1010	28	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1010	29	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1010	30	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1010	31	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1010	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1011	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1011	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1011	3	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1011	4	second	second	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1011	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1011	6	torts	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1011	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1011	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1011	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1011	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1012	1	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1012	2	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1012	3	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1012	4	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1012	5	denote[s	denote[s	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1012	6	]	]	X
inlawrev-20850	1012	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1012	8	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1012	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1012	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1012	11	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1012	12	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1012	13	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1012	14	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1012	15	such	such	DET
inlawrev-20850	1012	16	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1012	17	effect	effect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1012	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1012	19	producing	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1012	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1012	21	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1012	22	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1012	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1012	24	lead	lead	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1012	25	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1012	26	men	man	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1012	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1012	28	regard	regard	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1012	29	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1012	30	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1012	31	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1012	32	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1012	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1012	34	using	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1012	35	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1012	36	word	word	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1012	37	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1012	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1012	39	popular	popular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1012	40	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1012	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1012	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1012	43	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1012	44	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1012	45	always	always	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1012	46	lurks	lurk	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1012	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1012	48	idea	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1012	49	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1012	50	responsibility	responsibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1012	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1012	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1012	53	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1012	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1013	1	along	along	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1013	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1013	3	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1013	4	lines	line	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1013	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1013	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1013	7	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1013	8	third	third	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1013	9	recognizes	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1013	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1013	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1013	12	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1013	13	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1013	14	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1013	15	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1013	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1013	17	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1013	18	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1013	19	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1013	20	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1013	21	result	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1013	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1013	23	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1013	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1014	1	suppose	suppose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1014	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1014	3	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1014	4	shows	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1014	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1014	6	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1014	7	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1014	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1014	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1014	10	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1014	11	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1014	12	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1014	13	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1014	14	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1014	15	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1014	16	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1014	17	chances	chance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1014	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1014	19	contracting	contract	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1014	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1014	21	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1014	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1014	23	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1014	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1014	25	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1014	26	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1014	27	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1014	28	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1014	29	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1014	30	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1014	31	another	another	DET
inlawrev-20850	1014	32	source	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1014	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1014	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1014	35	toxin	toxin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1014	36	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1014	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1014	38	chances	chance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1014	39	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1014	40	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1014	41	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1014	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1014	43	10,000	10,000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1014	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1015	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1015	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1015	3	circumstance	circumstance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1015	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1015	6	trier	trier	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1015	8	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	9	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1015	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1015	11	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	12	reviewing	review	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1015	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1015	14	sufficiency	sufficiency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1015	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1015	17	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	18	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1015	19	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1015	20	allowed	allow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1015	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1015	22	conclude	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1015	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1015	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1015	25	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	26	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1015	27	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	28	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1015	29	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1015	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1015	31	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1015	32	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	33	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1015	34	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1015	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1015	36	disease.218	disease.218	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	37	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1015	38	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1015	39	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1015	40	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1015	41	intuitive	intuitive	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1015	42	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	43	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1015	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1015	45	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1015	46	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	47	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1015	48	contributions	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	49	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1015	50	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1015	51	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1015	52	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1015	53	assumed	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1015	54	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1015	55	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1015	56	additive	additive	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1015	57	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1016	1	examination	examination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1016	2	reveals	reveal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1016	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1016	4	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1016	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1016	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1016	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1016	8	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1016	9	behind	behind	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1016	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1016	11	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1016	12	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1016	13	neither	neither	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1016	14	consistent	consistent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1016	15	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1016	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1016	17	rest	rest	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1016	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1016	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1016	20	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1016	21	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1016	22	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1016	23	nor	nor	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1016	24	compelled	compel	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1016	25	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1016	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1016	27	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1016	28	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1016	29	provision	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1016	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1016	31	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1016	32	cited	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1016	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1017	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1017	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1017	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1017	4	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1017	5	treated	treat	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1017	6	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1017	7	independent	independent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1017	8	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1017	9	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1017	10	together	together	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1017	11	constituting	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1017	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1017	13	one	one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1017	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1017	15	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1017	16	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1017	17	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1017	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1017	19	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1017	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1018	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1018	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1018	3	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1018	4	214	214	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1018	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1019	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1019	2	brevity	brevity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1019	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1019	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1019	5	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1019	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1019	7	hereinafter	hereinafter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1019	8	referred	refer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1019	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1019	10	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1019	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1019	12	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1019	13	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1019	14	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1019	15	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1019	16	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1019	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1019	18	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1019	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1019	20	qualifier	qualifier	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1019	21	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1019	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1019	23	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1019	24	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1019	25	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1019	26	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1019	27	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1019	28	important	important	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1019	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1020	1	215	215	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1020	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1021	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1021	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1021	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1021	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1021	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1021	6	338	338	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1021	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1022	1	216	216	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1022	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1023	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1023	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1023	3	217	217	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1023	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1024	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1024	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1024	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1024	4	356	356	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1024	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1025	1	218	218	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1025	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1026	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1026	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1026	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1026	4	350	350	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1026	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1026	6	51	51	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1026	7	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	8	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1026	9	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1026	10	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	11	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1026	13	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1026	14	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	15	155	155	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1026	16	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1026	17	embraced	embrace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1026	18	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1026	19	distinct	distinct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1026	20	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1026	21	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	22	sets	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	23	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1026	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1026	25	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	26	consisting	consisting	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1026	28	both	both	DET
inlawrev-20850	1026	29	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	30	combined	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1026	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1026	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1026	33	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	34	consisting	consist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1026	35	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1026	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1026	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1026	38	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1026	39	giant	giant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1026	40	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1026	41	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	42	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1026	43	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1026	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1026	45	10,000	10,000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1026	46	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1026	47	fold	fold	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1026	48	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1026	49	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	50	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1026	51	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1026	52	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1026	53	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	54	consisting	consist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1026	55	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1026	56	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1026	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1026	58	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1026	59	challenged	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1026	60	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1026	61	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	62	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1026	63	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1026	64	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1026	65	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1026	66	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1026	67	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1026	68	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1026	69	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1027	1	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1027	2	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1027	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1027	4	challenged	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1027	5	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1027	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1027	7	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1027	8	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1027	9	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1027	10	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1027	11	compared	compare	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1027	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1027	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1027	14	giant	giant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1027	15	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1027	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1027	17	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1027	18	constitute	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1027	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1027	20	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1027	21	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1027	22	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1027	23	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1028	1	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1028	2	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1028	3	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1028	4	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1028	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1028	6	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1028	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1029	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1029	2	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1029	3	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1029	4	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1029	5	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1029	6	logically	logically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1029	7	implies	imply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1029	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1029	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1029	10	challenged	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1029	11	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1029	12	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1029	13	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1029	14	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1029	15	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1029	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1029	17	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1029	18	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1029	19	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1029	20	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1029	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1029	22	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1029	23	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1029	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1029	25	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1029	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1029	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1029	28	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1029	29	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1029	30	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1029	31	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1029	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1029	33	absence	absence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1029	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1029	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1029	36	giant	giant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1029	37	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1029	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1030	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1030	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1030	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1030	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1030	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1030	6	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1030	7	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1030	8	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1030	9	involve	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1030	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1030	11	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1030	12	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1030	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1030	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1030	15	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1030	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1030	17	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1030	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1030	19	together	together	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1030	20	overdetermine	overdetermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1030	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1030	22	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1030	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1031	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1031	2	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1031	3	involves	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1031	4	two219	two219	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1031	5	independent	independent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1031	6	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1031	7	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1031	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1031	9	analogous	analogous	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1031	10	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1031	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1031	12	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1031	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1031	14	fire	fire	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1031	15	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1031	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1031	17	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1031	18	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1031	19	fire	fire	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1031	20	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1031	21	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1031	22	bigger	big	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1031	23	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1031	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1031	25	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1031	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1031	27	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1031	28	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1031	29	alone	alone	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1031	30	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1031	31	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1031	32	burn	burn	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1031	33	down	down	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1031	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1031	35	house	house	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1031	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1032	1	another	another	DET
inlawrev-20850	1032	2	analogy	analogy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1032	3	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1032	4	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1032	5	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1032	6	negligent	negligent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1032	7	shooters	shooter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1032	8	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1032	9	simultaneously	simultaneously	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1032	10	fire	fire	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1032	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1032	12	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1032	13	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1032	14	direction	direction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1032	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1033	1	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1033	2	fires	fire	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1033	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1033	4	single	single	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1033	5	rifle	rifle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1033	6	shot	shoot	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1033	7	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1033	8	pierces	pierce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1033	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1033	10	victim	victim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1033	11	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1033	12	heart	heart	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1033	13	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1033	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1033	15	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1033	16	empties	empty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1033	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1033	18	machine	machine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1033	19	gun	gun	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1033	20	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1033	21	ammunition	ammunition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1033	22	belt	belt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1033	23	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1033	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1033	25	victim	victim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1033	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1034	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1034	2	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1034	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1034	4	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	1034	5	analogous	analogous	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1034	6	situations	situation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1034	8	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1034	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1034	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1034	11	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1034	12	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1034	13	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1034	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1034	16	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1034	17	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1034	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1034	19	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1034	20	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1034	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1034	23	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	24	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1034	25	occurs.220	occurs.220	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1034	26	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1034	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1034	28	intuition	intuition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	29	rebels	rebel	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	30	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1034	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1034	32	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1034	33	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	34	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1034	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1034	36	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1034	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1034	38	enormity	enormity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1034	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1034	41	giant	giant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1034	42	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	43	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1034	44	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1034	45	seem	seem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1034	46	seems	seem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1034	47	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1034	48	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1034	49	probable	probable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1034	50	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1034	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1034	52	giant	giant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1034	53	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	54	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1034	55	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1034	56	source	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	57	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1034	58	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1034	59	molecules	molecule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	60	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1034	61	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1034	62	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	63	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1034	64	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1034	65	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1034	66	interacted	interact	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1034	67	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1034	68	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1034	69	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	70	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1034	71	cells	cell	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	72	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1034	73	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1034	74	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1034	75	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1035	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1035	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1035	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1035	4	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1035	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1035	6	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1035	7	rule221	rule221	X
inlawrev-20850	1035	8	219	219	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1035	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1036	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1036	2	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1036	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1036	4	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1036	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1036	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1036	7	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1036	8	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1036	9	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1036	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1037	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1037	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1037	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1037	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1037	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1037	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1037	7	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1037	8	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1037	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1038	1	b	b	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1038	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1038	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1038	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1038	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1038	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1038	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1038	8	exception	exception	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1038	9	applies	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1038	10	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1038	11	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1038	12	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1038	13	are	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1038	14	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1038	15	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1038	16	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1038	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1038	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1038	19	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1038	20	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1038	21	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1038	22	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1038	23	constitutes	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1038	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1038	25	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1038	26	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1038	27	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1038	28	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1038	29	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1038	30	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1038	31	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1038	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1038	33	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1038	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1039	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1039	2	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1039	3	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1039	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1039	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1040	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1040	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1040	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1040	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1040	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1040	6	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1040	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1040	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1040	9	challenged	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1040	10	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1040	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1040	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1040	13	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1040	14	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1040	15	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1040	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1040	17	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1040	18	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1040	19	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1040	20	includes	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1040	21	both	both	DET
inlawrev-20850	1040	22	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1040	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1040	24	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1040	25	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1040	26	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1040	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1040	28	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1040	29	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1040	30	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1040	31	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1040	32	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1040	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1040	34	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1040	35	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1040	36	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1040	37	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1040	38	includes	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1040	39	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1040	40	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1040	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1041	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1041	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1041	3	respect	respect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1041	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1041	5	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1041	6	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1041	7	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1041	8	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1041	9	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1041	10	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1041	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1041	12	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1041	13	third	third	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1041	14	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1041	15	illustration	illustration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1041	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1041	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1041	18	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1041	19	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1041	20	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1041	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1042	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1042	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1042	3	illustration	illustration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1042	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1042	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1042	6	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1042	7	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1042	8	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1042	9	worked	work	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1042	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1042	11	construction	construction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1042	12	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1042	13	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1042	14	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1042	15	eleven	eleven	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1042	16	manufacturers	manufacturer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1042	17	’	’	PART
inlawrev-20850	1042	18	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1042	19	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1042	20	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1042	21	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1042	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1042	23	daily	daily	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1042	24	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1042	25	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1042	26	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1042	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1042	28	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1042	29	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1042	30	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1042	31	overall	overall	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1042	32	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1042	33	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1042	34	forty	forty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1042	35	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1042	36	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1042	37	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1042	38	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1042	39	considerably	considerably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1042	40	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1042	41	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1042	42	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1042	43	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1042	44	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1042	45	jerry	jerry	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1042	46	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1042	47	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1042	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1042	49	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1043	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1043	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1043	3	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1043	4	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1043	5	cmt	cmt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1043	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1044	1	b	b	X
inlawrev-20850	1044	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1044	3	illus	illus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1044	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1045	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1045	2	twelfth	twelfth	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1045	3	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1045	4	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1045	5	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1045	6	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1045	7	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1045	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1045	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1045	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1045	11	single	single	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1045	12	day	day	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1045	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1045	14	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1045	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1045	16	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1045	17	floor	floor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1045	18	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1045	19	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1045	20	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1045	21	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1045	22	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1045	23	site	site	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1045	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1046	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1046	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1046	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1046	4	illustration	illustration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1046	5	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1046	6	assumes	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1046	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1046	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1046	9	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1046	10	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1046	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1046	12	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1046	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1046	14	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1046	15	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1046	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1046	17	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1046	18	assumes	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1046	19	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1046	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1046	21	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1046	22	single	single	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1046	23	day	day	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1046	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1046	25	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1046	26	floor	floor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1046	27	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1046	28	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1046	29	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1046	30	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1046	31	exceed	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1046	32	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1046	33	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1046	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1047	1	220	220	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1047	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1048	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1048	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1048	3	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1048	4	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1048	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1048	6	221	221	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1048	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1049	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1049	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1049	3	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1049	4	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1049	5	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1049	6	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1049	7	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1049	8	distinguished	distinguish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1049	9	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1049	10	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1049	11	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1049	12	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1049	13	s]pecial	s]pecial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1049	14	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1049	15	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1049	16	discussed	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1049	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1049	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1049	19	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1049	20	third	third	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1049	21	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1049	22	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1049	23	involve	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1049	24	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1049	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1049	26	dramatically	dramatically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1049	27	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1049	28	magnitude	magnitude	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1049	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1050	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1050	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1050	3	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1050	4	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1050	5	cmt	cmt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1050	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1051	1	i.	i.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1051	2	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	1051	3	special	special	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1051	4	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1051	5	involve	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1051	6	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1051	7	contributions	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1051	8	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1051	9	become	become	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1051	10	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1051	11	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1051	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1051	13	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1051	14	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1051	15	sets	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1051	16	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1051	17	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1051	18	disaggregating	disaggregate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1051	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1051	20	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1051	21	larger	large	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1051	22	contributions	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1051	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1051	24	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1051	25	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1051	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1052	1	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1052	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1052	3	easiest	easy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1052	4	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1052	5	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1052	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1052	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1052	8	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1052	9	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1052	10	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1052	11	enormous	enormous	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1052	12	unforeseeable	unforeseeable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1052	13	flood	flood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1052	14	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1052	15	breaches	breach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1052	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1052	17	negligently	negligently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1052	18	constructed	construct	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1052	19	dam	dam	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1052	20	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1052	21	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1052	22	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1052	23	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1052	24	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1052	25	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1052	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1052	27	normal	normal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1052	28	flood	flood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1052	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1053	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1053	2	bad	bad	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1053	3	dam	dam	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1053	4	becomes	become	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1053	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1053	6	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1053	7	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1053	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1053	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1053	10	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1053	11	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1053	12	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1053	13	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1053	14	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1053	15	hypothesizing	hypothesize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1053	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1053	17	flood	flood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1053	18	smaller	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1053	19	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1053	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1053	21	one	one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1053	22	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1053	23	took	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1053	24	place	place	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1053	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1054	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1054	2	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1054	3	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1054	4	analogous	analogous	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1054	5	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1054	6	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1054	7	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1054	8	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1054	9	involve	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1054	10	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1054	11	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1054	12	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1054	13	contribute	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1054	14	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1054	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1054	16	1500	1500	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1054	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1054	18	500	500	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1054	19	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1054	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1054	21	respectively	respectively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1054	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1054	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1054	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1054	25	toxin	toxin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1054	26	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1054	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1054	28	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1054	29	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1054	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1054	31	1000	1000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1054	32	units	unit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1054	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1055	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1055	2	smaller	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1055	3	156	156	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1055	4	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1055	5	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1055	6	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1055	7	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1055	8	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1055	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1055	10	49:117	49:117	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1055	11	acknowledges	acknowledge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1055	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1055	13	determining	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1055	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1055	15	actual	actual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1055	16	culprit	culprit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1055	17	molecules	molecule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1055	18	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1055	19	impossible	impossible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1055	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1055	21	uses	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1055	22	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1055	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1055	24	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1055	25	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1055	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1055	27	proxy	proxy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1055	28	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1055	29	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1055	30	sufficiency	sufficiency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1055	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1056	1	one	one	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1056	2	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1056	3	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1056	4	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1056	5	ask	ask	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1056	6	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	1056	7	fire	fire	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1056	8	supplied	supply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1056	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1056	10	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1056	11	flames	flame	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1056	12	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1056	13	consumed	consume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1056	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1056	15	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1056	16	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1056	17	house	house	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1056	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1057	1	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1057	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1057	3	seem	seem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1057	4	unfair	unfair	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1057	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1057	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1057	7	source	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1057	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1057	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1057	10	challenged	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1057	11	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1057	12	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1057	13	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1057	14	liable	liable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1057	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1057	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1057	17	face	face	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1057	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1057	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1057	20	existence	existence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1057	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1057	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1057	23	giant	giant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1057	24	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1057	25	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1058	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1058	2	partial	partial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1058	3	answer	answer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1058	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1058	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1058	6	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1058	7	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1058	8	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1058	9	unfair	unfair	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1058	10	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1058	11	absolve	absolve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1058	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1058	13	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1058	14	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1058	15	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1058	16	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1058	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1058	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1058	19	happenstance	happenstance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1058	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1058	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1058	22	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1058	23	worse	bad	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1058	24	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1058	25	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1058	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1058	27	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1058	28	larger	large	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1058	29	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1058	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1059	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1059	2	better	well	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1059	3	answer	answer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1059	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1059	5	supplied	supply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1059	6	in222	in222	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1059	7	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1059	8	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1059	9	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1059	10	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1059	11	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1059	12	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1059	13	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1059	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1059	15	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1059	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1059	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1059	18	most	most	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1059	19	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1059	20	comparative	comparative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1059	21	responsibility	responsibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1059	22	doctrines	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1059	23	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1059	24	adjust	adjust	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1059	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1059	26	shares	share	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1059	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1059	28	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1059	29	borne	bear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1059	30	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1059	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1059	32	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1059	33	causes.223	causes.223	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1059	34	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1059	35	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1059	36	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1059	37	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1059	38	argue	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1059	39	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1059	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1059	41	trivial	trivial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1059	42	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1059	43	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1059	44	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1059	45	never	never	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1059	46	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1059	47	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1059	48	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1059	49	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1059	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1059	51	overdetermined	overdetermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1059	52	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1059	53	involving	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1059	54	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1059	55	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1059	56	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1059	57	sets	set	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1059	58	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1060	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1060	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1060	3	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1060	4	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1060	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1060	6	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1060	7	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1060	8	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1060	9	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1060	10	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1060	11	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1060	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1060	13	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1060	14	choice	choice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1060	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1061	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1061	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1061	3	majority	majority	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1061	4	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1061	5	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1061	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1061	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1061	8	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1061	9	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1061	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1061	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1061	12	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1061	13	contributions	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1061	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1061	15	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1061	16	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1061	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1061	18	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1061	19	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1061	20	invoked	invoke	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1061	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1061	22	normative	normative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1061	23	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1061	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1061	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1061	26	guise	guise	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1061	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1061	28	providing	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1061	29	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1061	30	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1061	31	standards	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1061	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1062	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1062	2	implied	imply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1062	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1062	4	concurring	concurring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1062	5	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1062	6	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1062	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1062	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1062	9	remainder	remainder	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1062	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1062	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1062	12	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1062	13	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1062	14	eschewed	eschew	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1062	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1063	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1063	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1063	3	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1063	4	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1063	5	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1063	6	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1063	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1063	8	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1063	9	situation	situation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1063	10	outside	outside	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1063	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1063	12	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1063	13	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1063	14	literal	literal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1063	15	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1063	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1064	1	4	4	X
inlawrev-20850	1064	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1064	3	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1064	4	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1064	5	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1064	6	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1064	7	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1064	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1064	9	alternative	alternative	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1064	10	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1064	11	isn’t.—according	isn’t.—accorde	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1064	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1064	13	both	both	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1064	14	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1064	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1064	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1064	17	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1064	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1064	19	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	1064	20	nine	nine	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1064	21	justices	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1064	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1064	23	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1064	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1064	25	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1064	26	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1064	27	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1064	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1064	29	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1064	30	functions	function	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1064	31	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1064	32	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1064	33	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1064	34	alternative	alternative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1064	35	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1064	36	method	method	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1064	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1064	38	proving	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1064	39	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1064	40	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1064	41	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1064	42	i]n	i]n	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1064	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1064	44	absence	absence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1064	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1064	46	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1064	47	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1064	48	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1064	49	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1064	50	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1064	51	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1064	52	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1064	53	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1064	54	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1065	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1065	2	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1065	3	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1065	4	constitute2	constitute2	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1065	5	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1065	6	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1065	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1065	8	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1065	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1065	10	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1065	11	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1065	12	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1065	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1065	14	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1065	15	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1065	16	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1066	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1066	2	hinted	hint	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1066	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1066	4	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1066	5	controlled	control	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1066	6	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1066	7	experiments	experiment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1066	8	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1066	9	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1066	10	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1066	11	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1066	12	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1066	13	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1066	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1066	15	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1066	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1066	17	capable	capable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1066	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1066	19	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1066	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1066	21	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1066	22	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1066	23	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1066	24	condition	condition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1066	25	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1066	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1066	27	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1066	28	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1066	29	criteria	criterion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1066	30	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1066	31	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1066	32	help	help	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1066	33	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1066	34	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1066	35	[	[	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1066	36	]	]	X
inlawrev-20850	1066	37	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1066	38	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1066	39	certainty	certainty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1066	40	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1066	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1066	42	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1066	43	individual	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1066	44	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1066	45	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1066	46	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1066	47	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1066	48	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1066	49	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1066	50	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1066	51	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1066	52	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1066	53	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1066	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1066	55	”225	”225	X
inlawrev-20850	1067	1	animal	animal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1067	2	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1067	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1067	4	vitro	vitro	X
inlawrev-20850	1067	5	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1067	6	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1067	7	controlled	control	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1067	8	experiments	experiment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1067	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1067	10	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1067	11	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1067	12	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1067	13	demonstrated	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1067	14	reluctance	reluctance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1067	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1067	16	infer	infer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1067	17	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1067	18	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1067	19	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1067	20	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1067	21	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1067	22	absent	absent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1067	23	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1067	24	support	support	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1067	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1068	1	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1068	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1068	3	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1068	4	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1068	5	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1068	6	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1068	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1068	8	researchers	researcher	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1068	9	generally226	generally226	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1068	10	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1068	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1068	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1068	13	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1068	14	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1068	15	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1068	16	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1068	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1068	18	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1068	19	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1068	20	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1068	21	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1068	22	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1068	23	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1068	24	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1068	25	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1068	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1068	27	larger	large	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1068	28	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1068	29	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1068	30	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1068	31	below	below	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1068	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1068	33	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1068	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1069	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1069	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1069	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1069	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1069	5	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1069	6	majority	majority	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1069	7	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1069	8	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1069	9	assumes	assume	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1069	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1069	11	both	both	DET
inlawrev-20850	1069	12	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1069	13	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1069	14	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1069	15	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1069	16	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1069	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1069	18	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1069	19	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1069	20	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1069	21	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1069	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1070	1	moreover	moreover	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1070	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1070	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1070	4	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1070	5	notes	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1070	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1070	7	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	1070	8	special	special	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1070	9	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1070	10	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1070	11	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1070	12	difficult	difficult	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1070	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1070	14	explain	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1070	15	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1070	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1070	17	specifically	specifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1070	18	questions	question	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1070	19	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1070	20	appropriateness	appropriateness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1070	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1070	22	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1070	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1070	24	overdetermined	overdetermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1070	25	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1070	26	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1070	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1071	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1071	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1071	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1071	4	222	222	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1071	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1072	1	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1072	2	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1072	3	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1072	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1072	5	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1072	6	important	important	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1072	7	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1072	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1072	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1072	10	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1072	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1072	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1072	13	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1072	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1072	15	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1072	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1072	17	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1072	18	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1072	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1072	20	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1072	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1073	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1073	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1073	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1073	4	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1073	5	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1073	6	cmt	cmt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1073	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1074	1	c	c	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1074	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1074	3	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1074	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1074	5	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1074	6	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1074	7	pointing	point	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1074	8	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1074	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1074	10	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1074	11	fortuity	fortuity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1074	12	often	often	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1074	13	allows	allow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1074	14	persons	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1074	15	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1074	16	commit	commit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1074	17	otherwise	otherwise	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1074	18	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1074	19	acts	act	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1074	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1074	21	avoid	avoid	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1074	22	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1074	23	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1074	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1075	1	223	223	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1075	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1076	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1076	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1076	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1076	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1076	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1076	6	365	365	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1076	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1076	8	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1076	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1076	10	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1076	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1076	12	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1076	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1076	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1077	1	224	224	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1077	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1078	1	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1078	2	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1078	3	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1078	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1078	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1078	6	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1078	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1079	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1079	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1079	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1079	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1079	6	706	706	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1079	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	8	715	715	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1079	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1079	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1079	12	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1079	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	14	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	15	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1079	16	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1079	17	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1079	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	19	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1079	20	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1079	21	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1079	22	348	348	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1079	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	24	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1079	25	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1079	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	27	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	28	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1079	29	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1079	30	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1079	31	360	360	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1079	32	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	33	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1079	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	35	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1079	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	37	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1079	38	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	39	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	40	havner	havner	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1079	41	allowed	allow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1079	42	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1079	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1079	44	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	45	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1079	46	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1079	47	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1079	48	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1079	49	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1079	50	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	51	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	52	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	53	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1079	54	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1079	55	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1079	56	371	371	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1079	57	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	58	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1079	59	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	60	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1079	61	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	62	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1079	63	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	64	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	65	agreeing	agree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1079	66	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1079	67	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1079	68	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1079	69	distinction	distinction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1079	70	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1079	71	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1079	72	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1079	73	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1079	74	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1079	75	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1079	76	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1080	1	225	225	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1080	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1081	1	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1081	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1081	3	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1081	4	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1081	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1081	6	714	714	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1081	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1081	8	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1081	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1082	1	226	226	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1082	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1083	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1083	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1083	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1083	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1083	5	728	728	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1083	6	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1083	7	29	29	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1083	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1083	9	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1083	10	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1083	11	animal	animal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1083	12	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1083	13	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1083	14	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1083	15	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1083	16	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1083	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1083	18	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1083	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1083	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1084	1	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1084	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1084	3	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1084	4	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1084	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1084	6	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1084	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1084	8	157	157	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1084	9	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1084	10	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1084	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1084	12	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1084	13	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1084	14	expose	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1084	15	human	human	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1084	16	beings	being	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1084	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1084	18	controlled	control	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1084	19	experiments	experiment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1084	20	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1084	21	suspected	suspect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1084	22	toxins	toxin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1084	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1085	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1085	2	notable	notable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1085	3	exception	exception	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1085	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1085	5	drug	drug	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1085	6	clinical	clinical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1085	7	trials	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1085	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1085	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1085	10	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1085	11	the227	the227	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1085	12	potential	potential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1085	13	benefit	benefit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1085	14	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1085	15	justify	justify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1085	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1085	17	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1085	18	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1085	19	informed	informed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1085	20	consent	consent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1085	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1086	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1086	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1086	3	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1086	4	clinical	clinical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1086	5	trials	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1086	6	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1086	7	experimental	experimental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1086	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1086	9	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1086	10	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1086	11	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1086	12	fundamentally	fundamentally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1086	13	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1086	14	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1086	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1086	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1086	17	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1086	18	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1086	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1086	20	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1086	21	treats	treat	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1086	22	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1086	23	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1086	24	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1086	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1087	1	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1087	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1087	3	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1087	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1087	5	hard	hard	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1087	6	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1087	7	see228	see228	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1087	8	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1087	9	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1087	10	qualify	qualify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1087	11	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1087	12	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1087	13	controlled	control	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1087	14	experimentation	experimentation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1087	15	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1087	16	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1087	17	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1087	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1087	19	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1087	20	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1087	21	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1087	22	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1087	23	alternative	alternative	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1087	24	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1087	25	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1087	26	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1087	27	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1087	28	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1087	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1087	30	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1087	31	causation.229	causation.229	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1087	32	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1087	33	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1087	34	equally	equally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1087	35	hard	hard	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1087	36	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1087	37	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1087	38	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1087	39	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1087	40	qualify	qualify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1087	41	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1087	42	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1087	43	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1087	44	criteria	criterion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1087	45	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1087	46	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1087	47	serve	serve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1087	48	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1087	49	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1087	50	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1087	51	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1087	52	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1087	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1087	54	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1087	55	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1087	56	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1087	57	except	except	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1087	58	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1087	59	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1087	60	unusual	unusual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1087	61	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1087	62	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1087	63	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1087	64	signature	signature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1087	65	disease.230	disease.230	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1087	66	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1087	67	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1087	68	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1087	69	seemed	seem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1087	70	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1087	71	admit	admit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1087	72	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1087	73	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	3	responded	respond	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	4	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	5	follows	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	6	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1088	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	8	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1088	10	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	13	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1088	14	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	15	proved	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	16	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	17	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1088	18	direct231	direct231	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1088	19	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	22	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1088	23	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1088	24	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1088	25	need	need	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1088	27	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	28	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	29	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	30	satisfying	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	32	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	33	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	34	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	35	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	36	):	):	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	37	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	39	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	40	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1088	41	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	42	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1088	43	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	44	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	45	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	46	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	47	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	48	1	1	X
inlawrev-20850	1088	49	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	50	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1088	51	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	52	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1088	53	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	54	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	55	toxin	toxin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	56	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1088	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	58	only	only	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	59	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	60	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	61	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1088	62	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1088	63	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	64	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	65	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	66	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	67	2	2	X
inlawrev-20850	1088	68	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	69	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	70	only	only	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	71	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	72	source	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	73	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1088	74	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	75	toxin	toxin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	76	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1088	77	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	78	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	79	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1088	80	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	81	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	82	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	83	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	84	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1088	85	another	another	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1088	86	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1088	87	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	88	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	89	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1088	90	hypotheticals	hypothetical	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	91	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	92	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	93	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	94	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1088	95	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1088	96	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	97	whose	whose	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	98	combined	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	99	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	100	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	101	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	102	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	103	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	104	dose	dose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	105	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1088	106	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	107	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	108	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	109	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1088	110	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	111	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	112	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1088	113	amount	amount	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	114	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1088	115	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	116	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	117	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1088	118	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	119	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	120	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1088	121	alternative	alternative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1088	122	approach	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1088	123	embraced	embrace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1088	124	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1088	125	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1088	126	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1088	127	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1088	128	227	227	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1088	129	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1089	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1089	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1089	3	228	228	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1089	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1089	5	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1089	6	merck	merck	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1089	7	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1089	8	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1090	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1090	2	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1090	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1090	4	347	347	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1090	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1090	6	256	256	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1090	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1090	8	260	260	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1090	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1090	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1090	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1090	12	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1090	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1090	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1090	15	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1090	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1090	17	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1090	18	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1090	19	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1090	20	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1090	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1090	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1090	23	clinical	clinical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1090	24	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1090	25	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1090	26	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1090	27	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1090	28	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1090	29	satisfied	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1090	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1090	31	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1090	32	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1090	33	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1090	34	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1090	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1090	36	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1090	37	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1090	38	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1090	39	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1090	40	263	263	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1090	41	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1090	42	64	64	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1090	43	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1090	44	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1090	45	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1090	46	clinical	clinical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1090	47	trials	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1090	48	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1090	49	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1090	50	methods	method	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1090	51	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1090	52	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1090	53	experimental	experimental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1090	54	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1090	55	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1090	56	observational	observational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1090	57	setting	setting	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1090	58	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1090	59	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1090	60	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1090	61	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1090	62	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1090	63	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1090	64	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1090	65	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1090	66	applies	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1090	67	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1090	68	clinical	clinical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1090	69	trials	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1090	70	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1090	71	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1091	1	229	229	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1091	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1092	1	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1092	2	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1092	3	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1092	4	modes	mode	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1092	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1092	6	action	action	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1092	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1092	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1092	9	subcellular	subcellular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1092	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1092	11	molecular	molecular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1092	12	scale	scale	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1092	13	offer	offer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1092	14	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1092	15	potential	potential	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1092	16	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1092	17	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1092	18	experimental	experimental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1092	19	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1092	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1092	21	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1092	22	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1092	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1093	1	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1093	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1093	3	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1093	4	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1093	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1093	6	advances	advance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1093	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1093	8	toxicogenomics	toxicogenomic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1093	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1093	10	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1093	11	fields	field	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1093	12	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1093	13	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1093	14	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1093	15	increasingly	increasingly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1093	16	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1093	17	for	for	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1093	18	researchers	researcher	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1093	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1093	20	detect	detect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1093	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1093	22	ways	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1093	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1093	24	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1093	25	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1093	26	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1093	27	various	various	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1093	28	substances	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1093	29	affect	affect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1093	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1093	31	structure	structure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1093	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1093	33	dna	dna	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1093	34	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1093	35	chromosomes	chromosome	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1093	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1093	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1093	38	expression	expression	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1093	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1093	40	genes	gene	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1093	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1093	42	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1093	43	epigenetic	epigenetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1093	44	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1093	45	associated	associate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1093	46	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1093	47	dna	dna	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1093	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1094	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1094	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1094	3	steve	steve	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1094	4	c.	c.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1094	5	gold	gold	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1094	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1094	7	the	the	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1094	8	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1094	9	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1094	10	know	know	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1094	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1094	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1094	13	less	less	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1094	14	intelligent	intelligent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1094	15	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1094	16	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1094	17	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1095	1	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1095	2	genomic	genomic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1095	3	information	information	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1095	4	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1095	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1095	6	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1095	7	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1095	8	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1095	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1095	10	change	change	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1095	11	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1095	12	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1095	13	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1095	14	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1095	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1095	16	34	34	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1095	17	harv	harv	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1095	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1096	1	envtl	envtl	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1096	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1097	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1097	2	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1097	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1097	4	369	369	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1097	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1097	6	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1097	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1097	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1098	1	often	often	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1098	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1098	3	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1098	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1098	5	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1098	6	mechanistic	mechanistic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1098	7	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1098	8	confirms	confirm	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1098	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1098	10	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1098	11	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1098	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1098	13	observed	observed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1098	14	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1098	15	associations	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1098	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1099	1	mechanistic	mechanistic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1099	2	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1099	3	standing	stand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1099	4	alone	alone	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1099	5	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1099	6	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1099	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1099	8	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1099	9	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1099	10	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1099	11	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1099	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1099	13	attain	attain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1099	14	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1099	15	acceptance	acceptance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1099	16	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1099	17	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1099	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1100	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1100	2	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1100	3	milward	milward	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1100	4	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1100	5	acuity	acuity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1100	6	specialty	specialty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1100	7	prod	prod	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1100	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1101	1	grp	grp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1101	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1101	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1101	4	639	639	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1101	5	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1101	6	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1101	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1101	8	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1101	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1101	10	1st	1st	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1101	11	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1101	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1101	13	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1101	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1101	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1101	16	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1101	17	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1101	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1101	19	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1101	20	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1101	21	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1101	22	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1101	23	admitted	admit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1101	24	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1101	25	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1101	26	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1101	27	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1101	28	weight	weight	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1101	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1101	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1101	31	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1101	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1101	33	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1101	34	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1101	35	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1101	36	primarily	primarily	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1101	37	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1101	38	mechanistic	mechanistic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1101	39	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1101	40	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1101	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1102	1	230	230	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1102	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1103	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1103	2	development	development	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1103	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1103	4	valid	valid	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1103	5	biomarkers	biomarker	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1103	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1103	7	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1103	8	sensitivity	sensitivity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1103	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1103	10	specificity	specificity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1103	11	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1103	12	someday	someday	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1103	13	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1103	14	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1103	15	definitive	definitive	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1103	16	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1103	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1103	18	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1103	19	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1103	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1103	21	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1103	22	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1103	23	far	far	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1103	24	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1103	25	potential	potential	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1103	26	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1103	27	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1103	28	little	little	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1103	29	realized	realize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1103	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1103	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1103	32	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1103	33	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1103	34	unclear	unclear	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1103	35	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1103	36	fully	fully	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1103	37	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1103	38	ever	ever	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1103	39	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1103	40	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1103	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1104	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1104	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1104	3	gold	gold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1104	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1104	5	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1104	6	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1104	7	229	229	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1104	8	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1104	9	gold	gold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1104	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1104	11	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1104	12	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1104	13	85	85	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1104	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1104	15	231	231	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1104	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1105	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1105	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1105	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1105	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1105	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1105	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1105	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1105	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1105	9	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1105	10	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1105	11	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1105	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1105	13	367	367	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1105	14	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1105	15	68	68	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1105	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1105	17	376	376	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1105	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1105	19	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1105	20	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1105	21	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1105	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1105	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1105	24	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1105	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1105	26	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1105	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1105	28	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1105	29	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1105	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1106	1	158	158	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1106	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1106	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1106	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1106	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1106	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1106	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1106	8	49:117	49:117	X
inlawrev-20850	1107	1	unnecessary.232	unnecessary.232	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	1107	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1107	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1107	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1107	5	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1107	6	squeezed	squeeze	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1107	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1107	8	possibility	possibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1107	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1107	10	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1107	11	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1107	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1107	13	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1107	14	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1107	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1107	16	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1107	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1107	18	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1107	19	space	space	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1107	20	indeed	indeed	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1107	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1108	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1108	2	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1108	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1108	4	doing	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1108	5	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1108	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1108	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1108	8	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1108	9	reasoned	reason	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1108	10	inconsistently	inconsistently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1108	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1109	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1109	2	responding	respond	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1109	3	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1109	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1109	5	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1109	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1109	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1109	8	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1109	9	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1109	10	asserted	assert	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1109	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1109	12	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1109	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1109	14	signature	signature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1109	15	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1109	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1109	17	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1109	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1109	19	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1109	20	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1109	21	contributed	contribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1109	22	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1109	23	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1109	24	combined	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1109	25	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1109	26	reach	reach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1109	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1109	28	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1109	29	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1109	30	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1109	31	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1109	32	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1109	33	constitute	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1109	34	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1109	35	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1109	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1109	37	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1109	38	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1109	39	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	1109	40	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1109	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1110	1	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1110	2	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1110	3	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1110	4	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1110	5	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1110	6	reconciled	reconcile	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1110	7	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1110	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1110	9	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1110	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1110	11	insistence	insistence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1110	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1110	13	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	1110	14	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1110	15	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1110	16	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1110	17	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1110	18	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1110	19	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1110	20	double	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1110	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1110	22	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1110	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1110	24	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1110	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1110	26	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1110	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1111	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1111	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1111	3	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1111	4	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1111	5	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1111	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1111	7	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1111	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1111	9	complaint	complaint	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1111	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1111	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1111	12	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1111	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1111	14	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1111	15	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1111	16	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1111	17	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1111	18	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1111	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1111	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1111	21	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1111	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1111	23	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1111	24	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1111	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1111	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1111	27	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1111	28	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1111	29	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1111	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1112	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1112	2	doing	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1112	3	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1112	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1112	5	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	6	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1112	7	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1112	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1112	9	burden	burden	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	10	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1112	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1112	12	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1112	13	court,233	court,233	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	14	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1112	15	scant	scant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1112	16	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1112	18	put	put	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1112	19	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1112	20	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	21	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1112	22	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1112	23	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1112	24	producing	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1112	25	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1112	26	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1112	27	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	28	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1112	29	statistically	statistically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1112	30	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1112	31	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	32	satisfying	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1112	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1112	34	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1112	35	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1112	36	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1112	37	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1112	39	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1112	40	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1112	41	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1112	42	are	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1112	43	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1112	44	plausible	plausible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1112	45	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	46	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1112	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1112	48	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	49	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1112	50	condition	condition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	51	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1112	52	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1112	53	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1112	54	negated	negate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1112	55	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1112	56	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1112	57	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	58	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1112	59	offer	offer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1112	60	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	61	excluding	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1112	62	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	1112	63	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	64	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1112	65	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1112	66	certainty	certainty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1112	67	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1112	68	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1113	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1113	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1113	3	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1113	4	reasoned:234	reasoned:234	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1113	5	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1113	6	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1113	7	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1113	8	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1113	9	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1113	10	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1113	11	irrelevant	irrelevant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1113	12	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1113	13	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1113	14	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1113	15	havner	havner	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1113	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1113	17	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1113	18	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1113	19	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1113	20	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1113	21	stated	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1113	22	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1113	23	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1113	24	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1113	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1113	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1113	27	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1113	28	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1113	29	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1113	30	excluded	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1113	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1113	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1113	33	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1113	34	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1113	35	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1113	36	relax	relax	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1113	37	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1113	38	today	today	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1113	39	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1113	40	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1113	41	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1113	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1113	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1113	44	special	special	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1113	45	difficulties	difficulty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1113	46	encountered	encounter	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1113	47	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1113	48	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1113	49	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1113	50	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1113	51	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1113	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1113	53	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1113	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1113	55	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1114	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1114	2	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1114	3	think	think	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1114	4	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1114	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1114	6	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1114	8	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1114	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1114	11	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1114	12	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1114	13	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1114	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1114	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1114	16	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	17	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1114	18	particularly	particularly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1114	19	useful	useful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1114	20	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1114	21	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1114	22	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1114	23	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	24	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	25	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1114	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1114	27	alternative	alternative	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	28	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1114	29	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1114	30	abdicate	abdicate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1114	31	resort	resort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	32	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1114	33	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1114	34	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1114	35	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	36	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1114	37	accept	accept	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1114	38	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1114	39	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1114	40	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	41	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1114	42	suffice.235	suffice.235	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1114	43	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1114	44	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1114	45	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1114	46	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1114	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1114	48	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1114	49	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	50	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	51	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1114	52	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1114	53	above	above	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1114	54	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	55	confused	confuse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1114	56	distinct	distinct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1114	57	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	58	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1114	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1115	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1115	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1115	3	besides	besides	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1115	4	turning	turn	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1115	5	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1115	6	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1115	7	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1115	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1115	9	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1115	10	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1115	11	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1115	12	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1115	13	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1115	14	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1115	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1115	16	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1115	17	involved	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1115	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1115	19	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1115	20	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1115	21	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1115	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1116	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1116	2	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1116	3	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1116	4	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1116	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1116	6	treat	treat	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1116	7	separate	separate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1116	8	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1116	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1116	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1116	11	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1116	12	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1116	13	as236	as236	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1116	14	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1116	15	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1116	16	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1116	17	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1116	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1116	19	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1116	20	positing	posit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1116	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1116	22	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1116	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1116	24	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1116	25	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1116	26	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1116	27	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1116	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1116	29	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1116	30	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1116	31	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1116	32	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1116	33	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1116	34	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1116	35	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1116	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1116	37	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1116	38	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1116	39	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1116	40	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1116	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1116	42	one	one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1116	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1116	44	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1117	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1117	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1117	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1117	4	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1117	5	disavowed	disavow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1117	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1117	7	approach	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1117	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1117	9	favor	favor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1117	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1117	11	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1117	12	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1117	13	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1117	14	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1117	15	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1117	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1117	17	why	why	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1117	18	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1117	19	relaxed	relax	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1117	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1117	21	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1117	22	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1117	23	exclude	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1117	24	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1117	25	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1117	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1118	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1118	2	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1118	3	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1118	4	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1118	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1118	6	require	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1118	7	exclusion	exclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1118	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1118	9	supposedly	supposedly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1118	10	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1118	11	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1118	12	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1118	13	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1118	14	really	really	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1118	15	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1118	16	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1118	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1118	18	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1118	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1118	20	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1118	21	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1118	22	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1118	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1118	24	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1118	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1118	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1118	27	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1118	28	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1118	29	causal	causal	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1118	30	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1118	31	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1118	32	contributors	contributor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1118	33	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1118	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1118	35	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1118	36	risk.237	risk.237	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1118	37	232	232	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1118	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1119	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1119	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1119	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1119	4	352	352	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1119	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1119	6	233	233	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1119	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1120	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1120	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1120	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1120	4	352	352	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1120	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1120	6	353	353	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1120	7	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1120	8	234	234	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1120	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1121	1	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1121	2	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1121	3	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1121	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1121	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1121	6	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1121	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1122	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1122	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1122	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1122	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1122	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1122	6	706	706	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1122	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1122	8	720	720	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1122	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1122	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1122	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1122	12	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1122	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1122	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1123	1	235	235	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1123	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1124	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1124	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1124	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1124	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1124	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1124	6	352	352	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1124	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1124	8	236	236	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1124	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1125	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1125	2	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1125	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1125	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1125	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1125	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1125	7	352	352	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1125	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1125	9	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1125	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1125	11	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1125	12	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1125	13	both	both	DET
inlawrev-20850	1125	14	sides	side	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1125	15	agreed	agree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1125	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1125	17	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1125	18	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1125	19	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1125	20	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1125	21	genetically	genetically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1125	22	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1125	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1125	24	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1125	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1125	26	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1125	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1125	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1125	29	large	large	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1125	30	percentage	percentage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1125	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1125	32	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1125	33	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1125	34	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1125	35	unknown	unknown	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1125	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1125	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1126	1	237	237	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1126	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1127	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1127	2	sienkiewicz	sienkiewicz	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1127	3	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1127	4	greif	greif	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1127	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1127	6	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1127	7	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1127	8	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1127	9	uksc	uksc	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1127	10	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1128	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1128	2	93	93	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1128	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1128	4	104	104	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1128	5	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1129	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1129	2	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1129	3	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1129	4	]	]	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1129	5	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1129	6	a.c	a.c	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1129	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1129	8	229	229	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1129	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1129	10	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1129	11	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1129	12	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1129	13	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1129	14	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1129	15	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1129	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1129	17	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1129	18	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1129	19	159	159	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1129	20	iii	iii	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1129	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1130	1	further	further	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1130	2	reflections	reflection	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1130	3	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1130	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1130	5	strange	strange	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1130	6	career	career	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1130	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1130	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1130	9	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1130	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1130	11	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1130	12	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1130	13	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1130	14	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1130	15	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1130	16	largely	largely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1130	17	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1130	18	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1130	19	driven	drive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1130	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1130	21	holdings	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1130	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1130	23	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1130	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1130	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1130	26	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1130	27	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1130	28	confusion	confusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1130	29	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1130	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1130	31	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1130	32	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1130	33	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1130	34	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1130	35	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1130	36	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1130	37	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1130	38	traced	trace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1130	39	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1130	40	doctrinal	doctrinal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1130	41	confusion	confusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1130	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1130	43	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1130	44	toxic	toxic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1130	45	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1130	46	precedent	precedent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1130	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1131	1	reviewing	review	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1131	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1131	3	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1131	4	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1131	5	led	lead	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1131	6	up	up	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1131	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1131	8	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1131	9	offers	offer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1131	10	lessons	lesson	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1131	11	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1131	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1131	13	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1131	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1131	15	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1131	16	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1131	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1131	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1131	19	evolution	evolution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1131	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1131	21	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1131	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1131	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1131	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1131	25	dialogue	dialogue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1131	26	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1131	27	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1131	28	scholarship	scholarship	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1131	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1131	30	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1131	31	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1131	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1132	1	a.	a.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1133	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	2	brief	brief	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1133	3	early	early	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1133	4	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	7	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1133	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1133	9	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1133	10	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1133	12	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	13	havner	havner	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1133	14	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1133	15	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	18	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1133	19	half	half	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	22	twentieth	twentieth	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1133	23	century	century	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	24	occasionally	occasionally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1133	25	encountered	encounter	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1133	26	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	27	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1133	28	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1133	29	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1133	30	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	31	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	33	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	35	disease,238	disease,238	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	37	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1133	38	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1133	39	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1133	40	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	41	first	first	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1133	42	appeared	appear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1133	43	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	45	published	publish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1133	46	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1133	47	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	48	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	49	1982.239	1982.239	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1133	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	51	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1133	53	cook	cook	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1133	54	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1133	55	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1133	56	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1133	57	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1133	58	involved	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1133	59	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	60	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1133	61	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	62	swine	swine	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1133	63	flu	flu	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	64	vaccine	vaccine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	65	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1133	66	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	67	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	68	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1133	69	guillain	guillain	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	70	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1133	71	barré	barré	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1133	72	syndrome	syndrome	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1133	73	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1133	74	gbs).240	gbs).240	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	75	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	76	retrospect	retrospect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	77	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1133	78	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	79	light	light	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	80	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	81	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1133	82	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1133	83	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1133	84	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1133	85	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1133	86	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	87	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	88	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1133	89	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1133	90	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1133	91	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	92	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1133	93	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	94	most	most	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1133	95	remarkable	remarkable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1133	96	thing	thing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	97	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	98	cook	cook	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	99	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1133	100	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	101	casualness	casualness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	102	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1133	103	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1133	104	the241	the241	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1133	105	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	106	announced	announce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1133	107	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1133	108	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1133	109	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1134	1	having	having	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1134	2	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1134	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1134	4	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1134	5	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1134	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1134	7	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	1134	8	actions	action	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1134	9	turns	turn	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1134	10	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1134	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1134	12	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1134	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1134	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1134	15	cdc	cdc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1134	16	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1134	17	data	datum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1134	18	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1134	19	measuring	measure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1134	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1134	21	rate	rate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1134	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1134	23	gbs	gbs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1134	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1134	25	vaccinated	vaccinated	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1134	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1134	27	unvaccinated	unvaccinated	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1134	28	populations	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1134	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1134	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1134	31	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1134	32	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1134	33	observed	observe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1134	34	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1134	35	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1134	36	eng	eng	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1134	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1134	38	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1135	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1135	2	lord	lord	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1135	3	phillips	phillips	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1135	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1135	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1135	6	contrasting	contrast	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1135	7	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1135	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1135	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1135	10	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1135	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1135	12	plus	plus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1135	13	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1135	14	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1135	15	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1135	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1135	17	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1135	18	opposed	oppose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1135	19	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1135	20	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1135	21	cumulative	cumulative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1135	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1135	23	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1135	24	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1135	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1135	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1136	1	238	238	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1136	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1137	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1137	2	earliest	early	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1137	3	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1137	4	involved	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1137	5	environmental	environmental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1137	6	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1137	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1137	8	typhoid	typhoid	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1137	9	bacteria	bacteria	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1137	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1137	11	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1137	12	water	water	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1137	13	supplies	supply	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1137	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1138	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1138	2	martin	martin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1138	3	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1138	4	springfield	springfield	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1138	5	water	water	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1138	6	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1138	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1138	8	128	128	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1138	9	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1138	10	674	674	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1138	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1138	12	678	678	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1138	13	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1138	14	79	79	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1138	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1138	16	mo	mo	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1138	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1138	18	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1138	19	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1138	20	1939	1939	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1138	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1139	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1139	2	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1139	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1139	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1139	5	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	6	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	7	properly	properly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1139	8	admitted	admit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1139	9	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1139	10	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	11	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1139	12	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	13	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1139	14	objection	objection	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1139	16	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	17	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1139	18	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1139	19	qualified	qualified	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1139	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1139	21	give	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1139	22	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1139	23	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	24	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1139	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1139	26	witness	witness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	27	opined	opine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1139	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1139	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1139	30	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	31	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1139	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1139	33	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1139	34	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	35	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1139	36	included	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1139	37	assumptions	assumption	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	38	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1139	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1139	40	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1139	42	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1139	44	typhoid	typhoid	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	45	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1139	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1139	47	community	community	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	48	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1139	49	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1139	50	contaminated	contaminate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1139	51	water	water	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	52	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1139	53	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	54	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1139	55	typhoid	typhoid	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1139	56	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1139	57	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1140	1	safransky	safransky	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1140	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1140	3	city	city	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1140	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1140	5	helena	helena	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1140	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1140	7	39	39	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1140	8	p.2d	p.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1140	9	644	644	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1140	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1140	11	mont	mont	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1140	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1141	1	1935	1935	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1141	2	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1142	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1142	2	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1142	3	epidemiologist	epidemiologist	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	4	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1142	5	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1142	8	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	10	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	12	typhoid	typhoid	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	14	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	15	before	before	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1142	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1142	17	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1142	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1142	20	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1142	22	period	period	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	24	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1142	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1142	26	water	water	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	27	supply	supply	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	28	pipe	pipe	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	29	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1142	30	subject	subject	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1142	31	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	32	contamination	contamination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	33	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	34	sewage	sewage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	35	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1142	36	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	37	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	38	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1142	39	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1142	41	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	42	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1142	43	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1142	44	lovich	lovich	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	45	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1142	46	salvation	salvation	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1142	47	army	army	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1142	48	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1142	49	75	75	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1142	50	n.e.2d	n.e.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	51	459	459	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1142	52	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1142	53	ohio	ohio	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1142	54	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1142	55	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1142	56	1947	1947	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1142	57	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1142	58	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1142	59	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1142	60	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1142	61	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1142	62	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	63	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	64	incorrectly	incorrectly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1142	65	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1142	66	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1142	67	epidemiologist	epidemiologist	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	68	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1142	69	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	70	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1142	71	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	72	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1142	73	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	74	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	75	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	76	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1142	77	food	food	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	78	preparation	preparation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	79	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	80	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1142	81	infected	infected	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1142	82	individual	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	83	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1142	84	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1142	85	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	86	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1142	87	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	88	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1142	89	typhoid	typhoid	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1142	90	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1142	91	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1143	1	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1143	2	earlier	early	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1143	3	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1143	4	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1143	5	typhoid	typhoid	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1143	6	involved	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1143	7	rudimentary	rudimentary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1143	8	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1143	9	ideas	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1143	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1143	11	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1143	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1143	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1143	14	term	term	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1143	15	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1143	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1144	2	missouri	missouri	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	3	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	4	illinois	illinois	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	6	200	200	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1144	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	9	496	496	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1144	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	11	1906	1906	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1144	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	14	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1144	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1144	17	dismissing	dismiss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1144	18	missouri	missouri	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	19	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1144	20	nuisance	nuisance	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1144	21	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	22	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1144	23	alleged	allege	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1144	24	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1144	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1144	26	canal	canal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	27	carrying	carry	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1144	28	sewage	sewage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	29	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1144	30	chicago	chicago	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	31	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1144	32	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1144	33	observed	observed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1144	34	increase	increase	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	35	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1144	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1144	37	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1144	39	typhoid	typhoid	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	40	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	41	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1144	42	saint	saint	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	43	louis	louis	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	45	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1144	46	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1144	47	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	48	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1144	49	typhoid	typhoid	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	50	bacteria	bacteria	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	51	existed	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1144	52	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	53	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	54	stubbs	stubbs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	55	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	56	city	city	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	57	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1144	58	rochester	rochester	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	59	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	60	124	124	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1144	61	n.e	n.e	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	62	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	63	137	137	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1144	64	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	65	n.y	n.y	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	66	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1144	67	1919	1919	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1144	68	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	69	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	70	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1144	71	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1144	72	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	73	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1144	74	proved	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1144	75	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	76	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1144	77	contaminated	contaminate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1144	78	drinking	drinking	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	79	water	water	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	80	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1144	81	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1144	82	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1144	83	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1144	84	rule	rule	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1144	85	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1144	86	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	1144	87	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1144	88	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1144	89	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	90	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1144	91	typhoid	typhoid	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1144	92	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1144	93	recover	recover	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1144	94	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1144	95	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1145	1	239	239	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1145	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1146	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1146	2	carruth	carruth	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1146	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1146	4	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1146	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1146	6	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1146	7	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1146	8	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1146	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1146	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1146	11	199	199	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1146	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1147	1	240	240	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1147	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1148	1	cook	cook	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1148	2	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1148	3	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1148	4	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1148	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1148	6	545	545	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1148	7	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1148	8	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1148	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1149	1	306	306	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1149	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1149	3	n.d	n.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1149	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1149	5	cal	cal	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1149	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1149	7	1982	1982	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1149	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1149	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1150	1	241	241	X
inlawrev-20850	1150	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1151	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1151	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1151	3	sampling	sampling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1151	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1151	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1151	6	scholarly	scholarly	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1151	7	commentary	commentary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1151	8	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1151	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1151	10	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1151	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1151	12	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1151	13	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1151	14	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1151	15	up	up	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1151	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1151	17	2000	2000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1151	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1151	19	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1151	20	carruth	carruth	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1151	21	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1151	22	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1151	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1151	24	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1151	25	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1151	26	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1151	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1151	28	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1151	29	196	196	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1151	30	n.4	n.4	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1151	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1152	1	160	160	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1152	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1152	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1152	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1152	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1152	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1152	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1152	8	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1153	1	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1153	2	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1153	3	w]henever	w]henever	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1153	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1153	5	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1153	6	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1153	8	vaccinated	vaccinated	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1153	9	persons	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1153	11	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1153	12	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1153	13	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1153	14	times	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1153	16	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1153	18	unvaccinated	unvaccinate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1153	19	persons	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1153	21	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1153	22	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1153	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1153	24	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1153	25	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1153	26	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1153	27	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	28	chance	chance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1153	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1153	31	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1153	32	gbs	gbs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1153	33	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	34	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1153	35	vaccinees	vaccinee	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1153	37	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1153	38	latency	latency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	39	period	period	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	40	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1153	41	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1153	42	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1153	43	vaccination	vaccination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1153	45	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1153	46	sustaining	sustain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1153	47	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	48	's	's	PART
inlawrev-20850	1153	49	burden	burden	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1153	51	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	52	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1153	53	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1153	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1153	55	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1154	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1154	2	few	few	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1154	3	months	month	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	4	later,242	later,242	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1154	5	another	another	DET
inlawrev-20850	1154	6	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1154	7	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	9	deciding	decide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1154	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1154	11	swine	swine	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1154	12	flu	flu	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	13	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	14	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1154	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1154	16	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1154	17	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1154	18	plus	plus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	19	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	20	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1154	21	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1154	22	slightly	slightly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1154	23	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1154	24	explication.243	explication.243	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1154	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1154	26	numerous	numerous	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1154	27	swine	swine	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1154	28	flu	flu	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	29	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1154	31	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1154	32	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1154	33	happened	happen	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1154	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1154	35	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1154	36	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1154	37	ideal	ideal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1154	38	environment	environment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	39	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1154	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1154	41	uncontested	uncontested	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1154	42	adoption	adoption	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1154	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1154	45	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	46	equating	equate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1154	47	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1154	48	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1154	49	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1154	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1154	51	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	52	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1154	53	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	54	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1154	55	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1154	56	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1154	57	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1154	58	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1154	59	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1154	60	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1154	61	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1154	62	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1155	1	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1155	2	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1155	3	virtually	virtually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1155	4	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1155	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1155	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1155	7	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1155	8	connecting	connect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1155	9	swine	swine	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1155	10	flu	flu	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1155	11	vaccine	vaccine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1155	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1155	13	gbs	gbs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1155	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1156	1	the244	the244	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1156	2	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1156	3	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1156	4	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1156	5	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1156	6	high	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1156	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1156	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1156	9	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1156	10	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1156	11	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1156	12	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1156	13	strong	strong	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1156	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1156	15	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1156	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1156	17	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1156	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1156	19	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1156	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1156	21	gbs	gbs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1156	22	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1156	23	central	central	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1156	24	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1156	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1156	26	government	government	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1156	27	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1156	28	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1156	29	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1156	30	end	end	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1156	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1156	32	nationwide	nationwide	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1156	33	swine	swine	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1156	34	flu	flu	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1156	35	vaccination	vaccination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1156	36	program	program	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1156	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1157	1	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1157	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1157	3	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1157	4	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1157	5	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1157	6	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1157	7	hard245	hard245	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1157	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1157	9	defense	defense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1157	10	attorneys	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1157	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1157	12	argue	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1157	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1157	14	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1157	15	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1157	16	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1157	17	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1157	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1157	19	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1157	20	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1157	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1158	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1158	2	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1158	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1158	4	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1158	5	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1158	6	peaked	peak	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1158	7	soon	soon	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1158	8	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1158	9	vaccination	vaccination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1158	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1158	11	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1158	12	declined	decline	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1158	13	toward	toward	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1158	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1158	15	baseline	baseline	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1158	16	rate	rate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1158	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1158	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1158	19	unvaccinated	unvaccinated	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1158	20	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1158	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1158	22	specific246	specific246	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1158	23	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1158	24	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1158	25	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1158	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1158	27	doubt	doubt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1158	28	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1158	29	gbs	gbs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1158	30	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1158	31	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1158	32	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1158	33	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1158	34	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1158	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1158	36	few	few	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1158	37	weeks	week	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1158	38	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1158	39	vaccination	vaccination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1158	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1159	1	eventually	eventually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1159	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1159	3	government	government	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1159	4	stipulated	stipulate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1159	5	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1159	6	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1159	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1159	8	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1159	9	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1159	10	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1159	11	onset	onset	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1159	12	earlier	early	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1159	13	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1159	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1159	15	cut	cut	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1159	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1159	17	off	off	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1159	18	point	point	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1159	19	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1159	20	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1159	21	risks	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1159	22	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1159	23	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1159	24	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1159	25	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1159	26	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1159	27	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1159	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1159	29	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1159	30	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1159	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1159	32	government	government	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1159	33	accepted	accept	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1159	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1159	35	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1159	36	contested	contest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1159	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1159	38	largely	largely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1159	39	successfully	successfully	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1159	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1159	41	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1159	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1159	43	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1159	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1159	45	gbs	gbs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1159	46	appeared	appear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1159	47	later	later	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1159	48	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1159	49	that.247	that.247	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1159	50	allen	allen	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1159	51	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1159	52	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1159	53	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1159	54	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1159	55	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1159	56	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1159	57	1984	1984	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1159	58	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1159	59	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1159	60	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1159	61	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1159	62	complicated	complicated	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1159	63	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1160	1	the248	the248	DET
inlawrev-20850	1160	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1160	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1160	4	allen	allen	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1160	5	alleged	allege	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1160	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1160	7	above	above	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1160	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1160	9	ground	ground	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1160	10	nuclear	nuclear	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1160	11	weapons	weapon	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1160	12	tests	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1160	13	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1160	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1160	15	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1160	16	242	242	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1160	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1161	1	cook	cook	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1161	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1161	3	545	545	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1161	4	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1161	5	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1161	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1162	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1162	2	308	308	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1162	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1162	4	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1162	5	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1162	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1162	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1163	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1163	2	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1163	3	agreed	agree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1163	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1163	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1163	6	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1163	7	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1163	8	value	value	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1163	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1163	10	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1163	11	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1163	12	sharply	sharply	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1163	13	divide	divide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1163	14	successful	successful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1163	15	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1163	16	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1163	17	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1163	18	unsuccessful	unsuccessful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1163	19	ones	one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1163	20	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1163	21	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1163	22	disagreed	disagree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1163	23	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1163	24	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1163	25	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1163	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1163	27	compute	compute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1163	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1163	29	applicable	applicable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1163	30	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1163	31	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1163	32	value	value	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1163	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1164	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1164	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1164	3	243	243	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1164	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1165	1	padgett	padgett	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1165	2	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1165	3	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1165	4	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1165	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1165	6	553	553	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1165	7	f.	f.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1165	8	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1165	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1166	1	794	794	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1166	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1166	3	800	800	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1166	4	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1166	5	01	01	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1166	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1166	7	w.d	w.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1166	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1166	9	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1166	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1166	11	1982	1982	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1166	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1166	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1166	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1166	15	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1166	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1166	17	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1166	18	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1166	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1166	20	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1166	21	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1166	22	calculate	calculate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1166	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1166	24	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1166	25	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1166	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1166	27	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1166	28	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1166	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1166	30	gbs	gbs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1166	31	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1166	32	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1166	33	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1166	34	vaccination	vaccination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1166	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1166	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1166	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1167	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1167	2	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1167	3	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1167	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1167	5	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1167	6	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1167	7	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1167	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1167	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1168	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1168	2	means	mean	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1168	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1168	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1168	5	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1168	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1168	7	vaccination	vaccination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1168	8	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1168	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1168	10	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1168	11	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1168	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1168	13	gbs	gbs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1168	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1168	15	better	well	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1168	16	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1168	17	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1168	18	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1168	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1169	1	hence	hence	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1169	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1169	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1169	4	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1169	5	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1169	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1169	7	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1169	8	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1169	9	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1169	10	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1169	11	indicate	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1169	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1169	13	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1169	14	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1169	15	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1169	16	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1169	17	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1169	18	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1169	19	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1169	20	vaccination	vaccination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1169	21	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1169	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1169	23	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1169	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1169	25	gbs	gbs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1169	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1169	27	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1169	28	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1169	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1169	30	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1169	31	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1169	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1169	33	slight	slight	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1169	34	error	error	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1169	35	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1169	36	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1169	37	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1169	38	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1169	39	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1169	40	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1169	41	exactly	exactly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1169	42	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1169	43	implies	imply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1169	44	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1169	45	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1169	46	fraction	fraction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1169	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1169	48	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1169	49	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1169	50	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1169	51	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1169	52	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1169	53	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1169	54	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1169	55	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1169	56	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1170	1	244	244	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1170	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1171	1	david	david	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1171	2	a.	a.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1171	3	freedman	freedman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1171	4	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1171	5	philip	philip	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1171	6	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1171	7	stark	stark	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1171	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1171	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1171	10	swine	swine	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1171	11	flu	flu	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1171	12	vaccine	vaccine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1171	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1171	14	guillain	guillain	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1171	15	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1171	16	barre	barre	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1171	17	syndrome	syndrome	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1171	18	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1171	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1171	20	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1171	21	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1171	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1171	23	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1171	24	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1171	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1171	26	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1171	27	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1171	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1171	29	64	64	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1171	30	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1171	31	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1171	32	contemp	contemp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1171	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1172	1	probs	prob	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1172	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1173	1	49	49	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1173	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1173	3	2001	2001	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1173	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1174	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1174	2	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1174	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1174	4	twenty	twenty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1174	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1174	6	five	five	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1174	7	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1174	8	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1174	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1174	10	swine	swine	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1174	11	flu	flu	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1174	12	vaccine	vaccine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1174	13	program	program	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1174	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1174	15	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1174	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1174	17	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1174	18	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1174	19	causal	causal	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1174	20	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1174	21	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1174	22	controversial	controversial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1174	23	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1174	24	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1174	25	arnold	arnold	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1174	26	w.	w.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1174	27	reitze	reitze	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1174	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1174	29	jr	jr	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1174	30	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1174	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1174	32	federal	federal	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1174	33	compensation	compensation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1174	34	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1174	35	vaccination	vaccination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1174	36	induced	induce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1174	37	injuries	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1174	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1174	39	13	13	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1174	40	b.c	b.c	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1174	41	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1174	42	envtl	envtl	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1174	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1175	1	aff	aff	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1175	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1176	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1176	2	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1176	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1176	4	169	169	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1176	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1176	6	182	182	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1176	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1176	8	1986	1986	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1176	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1176	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1176	11	etiology	etiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1176	12	unknown	unknown	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1176	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1176	14	1970s	1970s	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1176	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1176	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1177	1	245	245	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1177	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	1177	3	reitze	reitze	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1177	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1177	5	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1177	6	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1177	7	244	244	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1177	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1177	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1177	10	180	180	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1177	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1177	12	246	246	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1177	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1178	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1178	2	freedman	freedman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1178	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1178	4	stark	stark	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1178	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1178	6	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1178	7	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1178	8	244	244	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1178	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1178	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1178	11	53	53	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1178	12	.	.	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1178	13	247	247	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1178	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1179	1	cook	cook	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1179	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1179	3	545	545	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1179	4	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1179	5	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1179	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1180	2	307	307	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1180	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	4	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1180	5	stipulation	stipulation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1180	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	7	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	8	bert	bert	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1180	9	black	black	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1180	10	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1180	11	david	david	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1180	12	e.	e.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1180	13	lilienfeld	lilienfeld	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1180	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	15	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1180	16	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1180	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1180	18	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1180	19	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1180	20	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1180	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	22	52	52	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1180	23	fordham	fordham	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1180	24	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1180	25	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1180	26	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1180	27	732	732	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1180	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	29	774	774	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1180	30	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	31	1984	1984	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1180	32	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	33	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	34	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1180	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1180	36	importance	importance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1180	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1180	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1180	39	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1180	40	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1180	41	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	42	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	43	reitze	reitze	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1180	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	45	supra	supra	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1180	46	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1180	47	244	244	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1180	48	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	49	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1180	50	186	186	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1180	51	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	52	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1180	53	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1180	54	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1180	55	prevailed	prevail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1180	56	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1180	57	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1180	58	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1180	59	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1180	60	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1180	61	contested	contest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1180	62	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1180	63	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1180	64	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1181	1	248	248	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1181	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	1182	1	588	588	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1182	2	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1182	3	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1182	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1183	1	247	247	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1183	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1183	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1183	4	utah	utah	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1183	5	1984	1984	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1183	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1183	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1183	8	rev’d	rev’d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1183	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1183	10	816	816	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1183	11	f.2d	f.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1183	12	1417	1417	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1183	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1183	14	10th	10th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1183	15	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1183	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1183	17	1987	1987	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1183	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1183	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1184	1	http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1192290	http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1192290	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1184	2	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1184	3	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1184	4	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1184	5	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1184	6	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1184	7	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1184	8	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1184	9	161	161	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1184	10	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1184	11	government	government	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1184	12	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1184	13	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1184	14	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1184	15	develop	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1184	16	various	various	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1184	17	types	type	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1184	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1184	19	cancers	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1184	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1185	1	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1185	2	a249	a249	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1185	3	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1185	4	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1185	5	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1185	6	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1185	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1185	8	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1185	9	bruce	bruce	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1185	10	jenkins	jenkins	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1185	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1185	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1185	13	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1185	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1185	15	utah	utah	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1185	16	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1185	17	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1185	18	trouble	trouble	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1185	19	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1185	20	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1185	21	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1185	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1186	1	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	2	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1186	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1186	4	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1186	5	contrast	contrast	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1186	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1186	7	presented	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1186	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1186	9	usual250	usual250	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1186	10	problems	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1186	11	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1186	12	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1186	14	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1186	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	16	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	1186	17	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1186	18	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1186	19	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1186	20	resulted	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1186	21	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1186	22	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1186	23	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1186	24	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1186	25	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	26	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1186	27	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	28	unknown	unknown	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	29	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1186	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1186	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	32	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	33	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1186	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1186	35	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	36	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1186	37	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1186	38	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1186	40	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	41	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1186	42	came	come	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1186	43	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1186	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1186	45	nuclear	nuclear	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	46	tests	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1186	47	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	48	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1186	49	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1186	50	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1186	51	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1186	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1187	1	judge251	judge251	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1187	2	jenkins	jenkins	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1187	3	formulated	formulate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1187	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1187	5	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1187	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1187	7	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1187	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1187	9	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1187	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1187	11	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1187	12	terms	term	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1187	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1187	14	solved	solve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1187	15	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1187	16	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1187	17	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1187	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1187	19	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1187	20	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1187	21	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1187	22	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1187	23	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1187	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1187	25	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1187	26	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1187	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1187	28	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1187	29	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1187	30	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1187	31	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1187	32	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1187	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1187	34	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1187	35	lieu	lieu	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1187	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1187	37	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1187	38	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1187	39	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1187	40	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1187	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1188	1	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1188	2	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1188	3	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1188	4	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1188	5	equating252	equating252	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1188	6	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1188	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1188	8	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1188	9	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1188	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1188	11	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1188	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1188	13	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1188	14	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1188	15	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1188	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1188	17	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1188	18	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1188	19	causation.253	causation.253	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1189	1	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1189	2	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1189	3	months	month	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1189	4	after	after	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1189	5	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1189	6	jenkins	jenkins	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1189	7	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1189	8	allen	allen	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1189	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1189	10	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1189	11	jack	jack	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1189	12	weinstein	weinstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1189	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1189	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1189	15	eastern	eastern	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1189	16	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1189	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1189	18	new	new	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1189	19	york	york	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1189	20	elaborated	elaborate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1189	21	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1189	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1189	23	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1189	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1189	25	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1189	26	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1189	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1190	1	judge254	judge254	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1190	2	weinstein	weinstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1190	3	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1190	4	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1190	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1190	6	approve	approve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1190	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1190	8	tentative	tentative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1190	9	settlement	settlement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1190	10	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1190	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1190	12	class	class	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1190	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1190	14	veterans	veteran	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1190	15	alleging	allege	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1190	16	injuries	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1190	17	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1190	18	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1190	19	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1190	20	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1190	21	orange	orange	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1190	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1190	23	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1190	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1190	25	major	major	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1190	26	portion	portion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1190	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1190	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1190	29	chemical	chemical	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1190	30	industry	industry	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1190	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1190	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1191	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1191	2	compromise	compromise	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1191	3	settlement	settlement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1191	4	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1191	5	justified	justify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1191	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1191	7	judge255	judge255	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1191	8	weinstein	weinstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1191	9	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1191	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1191	11	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1191	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1191	13	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1191	14	risks	risk	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1191	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1191	16	class	class	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1191	17	faced.256	faced.256	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1191	18	chief	chief	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1191	19	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1191	20	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	1191	21	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1191	22	risks	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1191	23	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1191	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1191	25	difficulty	difficulty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1191	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1191	27	proving	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1191	28	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1191	29	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1191	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1191	31	agent	agent	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1191	32	orange	orange	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1191	33	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1191	34	any	any	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1191	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1191	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1191	37	disparate	disparate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1191	38	injuries	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1191	39	suffered	suffer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1191	40	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1191	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1191	42	class	class	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1191	43	members	member	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1191	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1192	1	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1192	2	weinstein	weinstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1192	3	explained	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1192	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1192	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1192	6	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1192	7	orange	orange	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1192	8	plaintiffs	plaintiffs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1192	9	faced	face	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1192	10	all257	all257	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1192	11	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1192	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1192	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1192	14	classic	classic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1192	15	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1192	16	problems	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1192	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1192	18	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1192	19	torts	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1192	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1193	1	first	first	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1193	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1193	3	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1193	4	largely	largely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1193	5	on258	on258	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1193	6	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1193	7	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1193	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1193	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1193	10	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1193	11	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1193	12	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1193	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1193	14	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1193	15	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1193	16	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1193	17	gravely	gravely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1193	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1193	19	doubt	doubt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1193	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1194	1	second	second	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1194	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1194	3	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1194	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1194	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1194	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1194	7	faced	face	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1194	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1194	9	version	version	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1194	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1194	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1194	12	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1194	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1194	14	exposure259	exposure259	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1194	15	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1194	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1194	17	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1194	18	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1194	19	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1194	20	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1194	21	virtually	virtually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1194	22	impossible	impossible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1194	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1194	24	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1194	25	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	1194	26	manufacturers	manufacturer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1194	27	’	’	PART
inlawrev-20850	1194	28	249	249	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1194	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1195	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1195	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1195	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1195	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1195	5	258	258	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1195	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1196	1	250	250	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1196	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1197	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1197	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1197	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1197	4	405	405	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1197	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1197	6	recognizing	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1197	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1197	8	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1197	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1197	10	appears	appear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1197	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1197	12	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1197	13	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1197	14	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1197	15	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1197	16	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1197	17	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1197	18	ionizing	ionize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1197	19	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1197	20	causes	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1197	21	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1197	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1197	23	leukemia	leukemia	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1197	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1198	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1198	2	does	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1198	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1198	4	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1198	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1198	6	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1198	7	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1198	8	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1198	9	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1198	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1198	11	258	258	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1198	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1198	13	explaining	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1198	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1198	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1198	16	judge	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1198	17	acted	act	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1198	18	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1198	19	factfinder	factfinder	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1198	20	pursuant	pursuant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1198	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1198	22	28	28	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1198	23	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1198	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1199	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1199	2	2402	2402	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1199	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1199	4	1976	1976	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1199	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1199	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1199	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1200	1	251	251	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1200	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1201	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1201	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1201	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1201	4	405	405	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1201	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1201	6	06	06	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1201	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1202	1	252	252	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1202	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1203	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1203	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1203	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1203	4	428	428	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1203	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1203	6	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1203	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1203	8	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1203	9	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1203	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1203	11	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1203	12	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1203	13	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1203	14	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1203	15	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1203	16	drawn	draw	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1203	17	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1203	18	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1203	19	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1203	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1203	21	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1203	22	increase	increase	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1203	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1203	24	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1203	25	resulting	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1203	26	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1203	27	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1203	28	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1203	29	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1203	30	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1203	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1204	1	253	253	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1204	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1205	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1205	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1205	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1205	4	416	416	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1205	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1205	6	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1205	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1206	1	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1206	2	jenkins	jenkins	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1206	3	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1206	4	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1206	5	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1206	6	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1206	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1206	8	closely	closely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1206	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1206	10	though	though	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1206	11	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1206	12	perfectly	perfectly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1206	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1206	14	tracked	track	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1206	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1206	16	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1206	17	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1206	18	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1206	19	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1206	20	followed	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1206	21	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1206	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1206	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1206	24	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1206	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1206	26	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1206	27	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1206	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1207	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1207	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1207	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1207	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1207	5	429	429	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1207	6	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1207	7	40	40	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1207	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1207	9	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1207	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1207	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1207	12	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	1207	13	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1207	14	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1207	15	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1207	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1207	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1207	18	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1207	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1207	20	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1207	21	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1207	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1207	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1207	24	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1207	25	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1207	26	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1207	27	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1207	28	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1207	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1208	1	254	254	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1208	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1209	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1209	2	re	re	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1209	3	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1209	4	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1209	5	orange	orange	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1209	6	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1209	7	prod	prod	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1209	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1210	1	liab	liab	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1210	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1211	1	litig	litig	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1211	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1212	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1212	2	597	597	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1212	3	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1212	4	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1212	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1213	1	740	740	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1213	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1213	3	746	746	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1213	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1213	5	e.d.n.y	e.d.n.y	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1213	6	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1213	7	1984	1984	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1213	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1213	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1213	10	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1213	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1213	12	818	818	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1213	13	f.2d	f.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1213	14	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1213	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1213	16	2d	2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1213	17	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1213	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1214	1	1987	1987	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1214	2	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1214	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1215	1	255	255	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1215	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1216	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1216	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1216	3	256	256	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1216	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1217	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1217	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	4	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1217	5	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1217	6	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1217	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	8	weighing	weigh	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1217	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1217	10	uncertainties	uncertainty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1217	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1217	12	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1217	13	obstacles	obstacle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1217	14	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1217	15	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1217	16	accompany	accompany	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1217	17	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1217	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1217	19	protracted	protract	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1217	20	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1217	21	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1217	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1217	23	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1217	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1217	25	go	go	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1217	26	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1217	27	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1217	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1217	30	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1217	31	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1217	32	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1217	33	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1217	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1217	35	settlement	settlement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1217	36	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1217	37	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1217	38	approved	approve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1217	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	40	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	41	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	42	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	43	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1217	44	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1217	45	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1217	46	757	757	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1217	47	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	48	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	49	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1217	50	settlement	settlement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1217	51	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	52	gives	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1217	53	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1217	54	class	class	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1217	55	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1217	56	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1217	57	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1217	58	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1217	59	likely	likely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1217	60	achieve	achieve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1217	61	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1217	62	attempting	attempt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1217	63	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1217	64	litigate	litigate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1217	65	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1217	66	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1217	67	death	death	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1217	68	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	69	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	70	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1217	71	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1218	1	257	257	X
inlawrev-20850	1218	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1219	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1219	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1219	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1219	4	782	782	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1219	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1220	1	258	258	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1220	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1221	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1221	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1221	3	259	259	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1221	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1222	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1222	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1222	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1222	4	782	782	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1222	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1222	6	95	95	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1222	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1223	1	162	162	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1223	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1223	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1223	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1224	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1224	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1224	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1224	4	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1224	5	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1224	6	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1224	7	service	service	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1224	8	member	member	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1224	9	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1224	10	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1224	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1224	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1225	1	third	third	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1225	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1225	3	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1225	4	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1225	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1225	6	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	7	class260	class260	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	8	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1225	9	overcome	overcome	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1225	10	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	1225	11	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1225	12	problems	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1225	14	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1225	15	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	16	remained	remain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1225	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1225	18	near	near	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1225	19	insuperable	insuperable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1225	20	obstacle	obstacle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	21	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1225	22	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1225	23	traditional	traditional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1225	24	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	25	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1225	27	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1225	28	relying	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1225	29	heavily	heavily	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1225	30	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1225	31	a261	a261	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1225	32	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1225	33	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1225	34	recently	recently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1225	35	published	publish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1225	36	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	37	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1225	38	professor	professor	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1225	39	david	david	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1225	40	rosenberg	rosenberg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1225	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1225	42	judge	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	43	weinstein262	weinstein262	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1225	44	explained	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1225	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1225	46	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1225	47	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1225	48	plus	plus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	49	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	50	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1225	51	comporting	comport	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1225	52	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1225	53	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1225	54	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1225	55	weak	weak	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1225	56	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1225	57	version	version	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	58	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1225	59	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1225	60	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	61	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	62	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1225	63	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1225	64	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1225	65	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1225	66	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1225	67	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1225	68	unjust	unjust	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1225	69	and263	and263	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1225	70	economically	economically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1225	71	inefficient	inefficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1225	72	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	73	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1225	74	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1225	75	mass	mass	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1225	76	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	77	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	78	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1225	79	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1225	80	advocated	advocate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1225	81	proportional	proportional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1225	82	recovery	recovery	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	83	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1225	84	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1225	85	solution	solution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1225	86	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1226	1	foreshadowing	foreshadow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1226	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1226	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1226	4	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1226	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1226	6	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1226	8	the264	the264	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	9	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	10	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1226	11	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1226	12	complicate	complicate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1226	13	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1226	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1226	15	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1226	16	weinstein	weinstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1226	17	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1226	18	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1226	19	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1226	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1226	21	existence	existence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1226	23	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1226	24	tortfeasors	tortfeasor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	25	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1226	26	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1226	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1226	28	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	29	class	class	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1226	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1226	32	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1226	33	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	34	exacerbated	exacerbate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1226	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1226	36	problems	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1226	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1226	39	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1226	40	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1226	41	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1226	42	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	43	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1226	44	making	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1226	45	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1226	46	proportionately	proportionately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1226	47	less	less	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1226	48	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1226	49	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1226	50	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1226	51	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1226	52	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	53	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1226	54	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	55	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1226	56	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1226	57	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1226	58	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	59	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1226	60	harm.265	harm.265	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	61	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1226	62	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1226	63	1990s	1990	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	64	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1226	65	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	66	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	67	adopting	adopt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1226	68	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1226	69	form	form	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	70	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1226	71	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1226	72	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1226	73	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1226	74	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1226	75	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1226	76	proliferated	proliferate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1226	77	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1227	1	bendectin	bendectin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1227	2	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1227	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1227	4	major	major	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1227	5	reason	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1227	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1228	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1228	2	bendectin	bendectin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1228	3	produced266	produced266	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1228	4	267	267	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1228	5	260	260	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1228	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1229	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1229	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1229	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1229	4	819	819	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1229	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1229	6	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1229	7	weinstein	weinstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1229	8	assumed	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1229	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1229	10	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1229	11	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1229	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1229	13	burden	burden	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1229	14	shifting	shift	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1229	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1229	16	alternative	alternative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1229	17	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1229	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1229	19	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1229	20	enterprise	enterprise	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1229	21	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1229	22	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1229	23	overcome	overcome	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1229	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1229	25	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1229	26	indeterminate	indeterminate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1229	27	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1229	28	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1229	29	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1229	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1230	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1230	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1230	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1230	4	81933	81933	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1230	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1231	1	261	261	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1231	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1232	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1232	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1232	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1232	4	835	835	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1232	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1233	1	262	262	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1233	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1234	1	david	david	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1234	2	rosenberg	rosenberg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1234	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1234	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1234	5	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1234	6	connection	connection	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1234	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1234	8	mass	mass	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1234	9	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1234	10	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1234	11	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1234	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1234	13	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1234	14	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1234	15	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1234	16	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1234	17	vision	vision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1234	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1234	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1234	20	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1234	21	system	system	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1234	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1234	23	97	97	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1234	24	harv	harv	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1234	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1235	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1235	2	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1235	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1235	4	849	849	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1235	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1235	6	1984	1984	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1235	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1235	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1236	1	263	263	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1236	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1237	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1237	2	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1237	3	weak	weak	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1237	4	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1237	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1237	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1237	7	strong	strong	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1237	8	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1237	9	versions	version	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1237	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1237	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1237	12	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1237	13	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1237	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1237	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1237	16	rosenberg	rosenberg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1237	17	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1237	18	language	language	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1237	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1237	20	differ	differ	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1237	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1237	22	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1237	23	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1237	24	particularistic	particularistic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1237	25	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1237	26	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1237	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1237	28	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1237	29	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1237	30	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1237	31	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1237	32	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1237	33	addition	addition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1237	34	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1237	35	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1237	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1237	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1237	38	magnitude	magnitude	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1237	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1237	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1237	41	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1237	42	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1237	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1238	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1238	2	strong	strong	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1238	3	version	version	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1238	4	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1238	5	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1238	6	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1238	7	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1238	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1238	9	weak	weak	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1238	10	version	version	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1238	11	allows	allow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1238	12	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1238	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1238	14	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1238	15	inferred	infer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1238	16	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1238	17	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1238	18	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1238	19	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1238	20	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1238	21	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1238	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1238	23	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1238	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1239	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1239	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1239	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1239	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1239	5	857	857	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1239	6	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1239	7	58	58	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1239	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1240	1	264	264	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1240	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1241	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1241	2	re	re	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1241	3	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1241	4	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1241	5	orange	orange	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1241	6	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1241	7	prod	prod	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1241	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1242	1	liab	liab	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1242	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1243	1	litig	litig	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1243	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1244	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1244	2	597	597	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1244	3	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1244	4	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1244	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1245	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1245	2	824	824	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1245	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1246	1	265	265	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1246	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1247	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1247	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1247	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1247	4	837	837	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1247	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1248	1	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1248	2	weinstein	weinstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1248	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1248	4	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1248	5	illustration	illustration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1248	6	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1248	7	assumed	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1248	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1248	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1248	10	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1248	11	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1248	12	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1248	13	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1248	14	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1248	15	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1248	16	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1248	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1248	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1248	19	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	1248	20	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1248	21	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1248	22	identical	identical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1248	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1249	1	266	266	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1249	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1250	1	carruth	carruth	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1250	2	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1250	3	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1250	4	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1250	5	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1250	6	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1250	7	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1250	8	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1250	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1250	10	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1250	11	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1250	12	orange	orange	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1250	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1250	14	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1250	15	referred	refer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1250	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1250	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1250	18	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1250	19	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1250	20	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1250	21	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1250	22	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1250	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1250	24	rest	rest	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1250	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1250	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1250	27	1980s	1980s	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1250	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1251	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1251	2	carruth	carruth	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1251	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1251	4	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1251	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1251	6	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1251	7	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1251	8	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1251	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1251	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1251	11	197	197	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1251	12	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1251	13	99	99	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1251	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1251	15	199	199	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1251	16	n.9	n.9	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1251	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1251	18	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1251	19	manko	manko	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1251	20	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1251	21	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1251	22	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1251	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1251	24	636	636	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1251	25	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1251	26	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1251	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1252	1	1419	1419	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1252	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1252	3	w.d	w.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1252	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1252	5	mo	mo	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1252	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1252	7	1986	1986	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1252	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1252	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1252	10	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1252	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1252	12	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1252	13	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1252	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1252	15	830	830	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1252	16	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1252	17	831	831	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1252	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1252	19	8th	8th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1252	20	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1252	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1252	22	1987	1987	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1252	23	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1252	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1252	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1253	1	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1253	2	contrast	contrast	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1253	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1253	4	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1253	5	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1253	6	twenty	twenty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1253	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1253	8	six	six	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1253	9	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1253	10	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1253	11	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1253	12	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1253	13	1990	1990	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1253	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1253	15	early	early	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1253	16	1999	1999	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1253	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1254	1	carruth	carruth	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1254	2	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1254	3	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1254	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1254	5	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1254	6	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1254	7	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1254	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1254	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1254	10	197	197	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1254	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1255	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1255	2	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1255	3	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1255	4	additional	additional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1255	5	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1255	6	issued	issue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1255	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1255	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1255	9	1990s	1990	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1255	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1255	11	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1255	12	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1255	13	obliquely	obliquely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1255	14	discussed	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1255	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1255	16	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1255	17	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1255	18	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1255	19	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1255	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1256	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1256	2	wade	wade	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1256	3	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1256	4	greaux	greaux	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1256	5	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1256	6	whitehall	whitehall	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1256	7	labs	labs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1256	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1256	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1256	10	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1256	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1256	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1256	13	874	874	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1256	14	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1256	15	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1256	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1257	1	1441	1441	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1257	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1257	3	1452	1452	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1257	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1257	5	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1257	6	v.i	v.i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1257	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1257	8	1994	1994	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1257	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1258	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1258	2	equating	equate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1258	3	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1258	4	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1258	5	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1258	6	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1258	7	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1258	8	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1258	9	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1258	10	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1258	11	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1258	12	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1258	13	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1258	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1258	15	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1258	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1258	17	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1258	18	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1258	19	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1258	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1258	21	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1258	22	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1258	23	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1258	24	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1258	25	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1258	26	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1258	27	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1258	28	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1258	29	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1258	30	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1258	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1258	32	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1258	33	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1258	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1258	35	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1258	36	hand	hand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1258	37	v.	v.	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1258	38	norfolk	norfolk	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1258	39	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1258	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1259	1	ry	ry	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1259	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1259	3	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1259	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1259	5	no	no	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	1259	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1259	7	03a01	03a01	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1259	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1259	9	9704cv-00123	9704cv-00123	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1259	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1259	11	1998	1998	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1259	12	wl	wl	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1259	13	281946	281946	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1259	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1259	15	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1259	16	*	*	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1259	17	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1259	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1259	19	tenn	tenn	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1259	20	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1259	21	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1259	22	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1259	23	1998	1998	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1259	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1259	25	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1259	26	agreeing	agree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1259	27	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1259	28	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1259	29	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1259	30	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1259	31	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1259	32	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1259	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1259	34	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1259	35	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1259	36	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1259	37	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1259	38	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1259	39	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1259	40	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1259	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1259	42	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1259	43	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1259	44	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1259	45	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1259	46	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1259	47	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1259	48	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1259	49	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1259	50	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1259	51	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1259	52	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1259	53	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1259	54	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1259	55	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1260	1	267	267	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1260	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	1260	3	five	five	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1260	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1260	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1260	6	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1260	7	carruth	carruth	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1260	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1260	9	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1260	10	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1260	11	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1260	12	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1260	13	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1260	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1261	1	carruth	carruth	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1261	2	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1261	3	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1261	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1261	5	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1261	6	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1261	7	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1261	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1261	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1261	10	199	199	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1261	11	n.9	n.9	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1261	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1262	1	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1262	2	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1262	3	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1262	4	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1262	5	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1262	6	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1262	7	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1262	8	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1262	9	except	except	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1262	10	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1262	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1262	12	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1262	13	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1262	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1262	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1262	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1262	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1262	18	nine	nine	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1262	19	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1262	20	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1262	21	listed	list	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1262	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1262	23	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1262	24	emerged	emerge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1262	25	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1262	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1262	27	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1262	28	civil	civil	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1262	29	action	action	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1262	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1263	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1263	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1263	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1263	4	197	197	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1263	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1263	6	99	99	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1263	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1263	8	listing	list	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1263	9	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1263	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1263	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1264	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1264	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1264	3	noteworthy	noteworthy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1264	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1264	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1264	6	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	7	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	8	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1264	9	elicited	elicit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1264	10	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1264	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1264	13	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1264	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1264	15	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1264	16	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	17	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1264	18	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1264	19	involve	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1264	20	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	21	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1264	22	signature	signature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	23	diseases	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1264	25	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1264	27	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1264	29	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1264	30	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1264	31	lung	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	32	http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1341021	http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1341021	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	33	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1264	34	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1264	35	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	36	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	37	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1264	38	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1264	39	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	40	163	163	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1264	41	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1264	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1265	1	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1265	2	bendectin	bendectin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1265	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1265	4	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1265	6	plus	plus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1265	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	9	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1265	10	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1265	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1265	12	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	13	/	/	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1265	14	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	15	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	16	muddle	muddle	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1265	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1265	18	saga	saga	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1265	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1265	21	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	22	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	23	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1265	24	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1265	25	amply	amply	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1265	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	27	ably	ably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1265	28	told	tell	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1265	29	elsewhere.268	elsewhere.268	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1265	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1265	31	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	32	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1265	33	eventually	eventually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1265	34	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1265	35	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1265	37	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1265	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1265	39	face	face	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	40	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1265	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1265	42	large	large	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	43	body	body	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1265	45	powerful	powerful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	46	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	47	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	48	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1265	49	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1265	50	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1265	51	detect	detect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1265	52	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1265	53	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	54	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	55	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1265	56	bendectin	bendectin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	57	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	58	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1265	59	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	60	type	type	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	61	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1265	62	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	63	defect	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	64	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1265	65	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1265	66	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	67	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1265	68	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	69	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1265	70	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	71	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	72	inadmissible	inadmissible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	73	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1265	74	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	75	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1265	76	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1265	77	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	78	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1265	79	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	80	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1265	81	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	82	both.269	both.269	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	83	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1265	84	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1265	85	pertinent	pertinent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	86	here	here	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1265	87	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1265	88	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	89	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1265	90	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1265	91	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1265	92	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	93	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	94	crept	creep	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1265	95	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1265	96	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1265	97	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	98	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1265	99	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1265	100	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1265	101	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1266	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1266	2	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1266	3	appearance	appearance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1266	4	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1266	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1266	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1266	7	1990	1990	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1266	8	deluca	deluca	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1266	9	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1266	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1266	11	ironically	ironically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1266	12	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1266	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1266	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1266	15	few	few	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1266	16	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1266	17	appeals	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1266	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1266	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1266	20	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1266	21	won	win	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1266	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1267	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1267	2	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1267	3	judge270	judge270	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1267	4	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1267	5	excluded	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1267	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1267	7	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1267	8	proffered	proffer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1267	9	expert	expert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1267	10	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1267	11	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1267	12	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1267	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1267	14	granted	grant	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1267	15	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1267	16	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1267	17	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1267	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1267	19	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1267	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1268	1	ruling	rule	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1268	2	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1268	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1268	4	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1268	5	court’s271	court’s271	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1268	6	daubert	daubert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1268	7	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1268	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1268	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1268	10	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1268	11	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1268	12	reversed	reverse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1268	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1269	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1269	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1269	3	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1269	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1269	5	explaining272	explaining272	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1269	6	273	273	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1269	7	why	why	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1269	8	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1269	9	felt	feel	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1269	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1269	11	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1269	12	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1269	13	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1269	14	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1269	15	admitted	admit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1269	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1269	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1269	18	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1269	19	correctly	correctly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1269	20	observed	observe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1269	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1269	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1269	23	statistically	statistically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1269	24	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1269	25	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1269	26	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1269	27	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1269	28	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1269	29	1.0	1.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1269	30	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1269	31	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1269	32	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1269	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1269	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1269	35	support	support	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1269	36	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1269	37	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1269	38	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1269	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1269	40	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1269	41	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1269	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1270	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1270	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1270	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1270	4	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1270	6	inviting	invite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1270	7	the274	the274	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	8	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	9	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1270	10	renew	renew	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1270	11	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1270	12	motion	motion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	13	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1270	14	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	15	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	16	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1270	17	remand	remand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1270	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1270	20	court275	court275	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1270	21	stated	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1270	22	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1270	23	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1270	24	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1270	25	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	26	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1270	27	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1270	28	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	29	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1270	30	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1270	31	admissible	admissible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1270	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1270	33	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1270	34	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1270	35	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1270	36	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1270	37	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1270	38	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1270	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1270	40	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1270	41	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1270	42	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1270	43	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	44	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1270	45	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1270	46	new	new	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1270	47	jersey	jersey	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1270	48	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	49	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1270	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1270	51	delucas	deluca	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	52	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1270	53	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1270	54	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1270	55	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1270	56	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1270	57	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1270	58	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1270	59	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1270	60	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1270	61	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1270	62	bendectin	bendectin	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1270	63	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1270	64	amy	amy	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1270	65	deluca	deluca	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1270	66	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1270	67	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	68	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1270	69	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1270	70	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1270	71	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1270	72	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1270	73	forced	force	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1270	74	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1270	75	rely	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1270	76	solely	solely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1270	77	on	on	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1270	78	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1270	79	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1270	80	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1271	1	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1271	2	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1271	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1271	4	order	order	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1271	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1271	6	avoid	avoid	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1271	7	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1271	8	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1271	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1271	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1271	11	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1271	12	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1271	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1271	14	limb	limb	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1271	15	reduction	reduction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1271	16	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1271	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1271	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1271	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1272	1	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1272	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1272	3	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1272	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1272	5	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1272	6	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1272	7	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1272	8	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1272	9	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1272	10	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1272	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1272	12	widely	widely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1272	13	accepted	accept	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1272	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1272	15	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1272	16	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1272	17	cancers	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1272	18	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1272	19	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1272	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1272	21	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1272	22	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1272	23	link	link	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1272	24	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1272	25	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1272	26	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1272	27	disputed	dispute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1272	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1273	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1273	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1273	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1273	4	listing	list	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1273	5	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1273	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1273	7	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1273	8	involving	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1273	9	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1273	10	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1273	11	colon	colon	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1273	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1273	13	larynx	larynx	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1273	14	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1273	15	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1273	16	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1273	17	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1273	18	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1273	19	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1273	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1273	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1274	1	268	268	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1274	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1275	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1275	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1275	3	green	green	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1275	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1275	5	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1275	6	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1275	7	124	124	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1275	8	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1275	9	sanders	sander	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1275	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1275	11	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1275	12	note	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1275	13	122	122	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1275	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1275	15	269	269	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1275	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1276	1	sanders	sanders	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1276	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1276	3	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1276	4	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1276	5	122	122	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1276	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1276	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1276	8	146	146	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1276	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1276	10	49	49	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1276	11	tbl	tbl	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1276	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1277	1	14	14	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1277	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1277	3	156	156	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1277	4	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1277	5	57	57	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1277	6	tbl	tbl	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1277	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1278	1	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1278	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1278	3	listing	list	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1278	4	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1278	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1278	6	appellate	appellate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1278	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1278	8	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1278	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1278	10	respectively	respectively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1278	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1278	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1278	13	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1278	14	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1278	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1278	16	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1278	17	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1278	18	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1278	19	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1278	20	190	190	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1278	21	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1278	22	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1278	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1278	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1278	25	judiciary	judiciary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1278	26	became	become	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1278	27	convinced	convinced	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1278	28	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1278	29	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1278	30	verdict	verdict	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1278	31	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1278	32	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1278	33	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1278	34	wrong	wrong	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1278	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1278	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1279	1	270	270	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1279	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1280	1	deluca	deluca	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1280	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1280	3	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1280	4	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1280	5	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1280	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1280	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1280	8	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1280	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1280	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1280	11	911	911	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1280	12	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1280	13	941	941	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1280	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1280	15	959	959	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1280	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1280	17	3d	3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1280	18	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1280	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1280	20	1990	1990	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1280	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1280	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1281	1	271	271	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1281	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1282	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1282	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1282	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1282	4	943	943	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1282	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1282	6	272	272	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1282	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1283	1	daubert	daubert	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1283	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1283	3	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1283	4	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1283	5	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1283	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1283	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1283	8	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1283	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1283	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1283	11	509	509	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1283	12	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1283	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1283	14	579	579	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1283	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1283	16	1993	1993	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1283	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1283	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1283	19	establishing	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1283	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1283	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1283	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1283	23	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1283	24	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1283	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1283	26	standards	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1283	27	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1283	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1283	29	admissibility	admissibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1283	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1283	31	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1283	32	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1283	33	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1283	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1283	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1284	1	273	273	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1284	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1285	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1285	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1285	3	274	274	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1285	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1286	1	deluca	deluca	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1286	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1286	3	911	911	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1286	4	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1286	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1286	6	947	947	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1286	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1286	8	48	48	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1286	9	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1286	10	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1286	11	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1286	12	i	i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1286	13	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1286	14	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1286	15	958	958	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1286	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1286	17	explaining	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1286	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1286	19	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1286	20	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1286	21	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1286	22	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1286	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1286	24	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1286	25	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1286	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1286	27	25	25	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1286	28	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1286	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1286	30	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1286	31	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1286	32	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1286	33	attributed	attribute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1286	34	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1286	35	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1286	36	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1286	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1286	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1286	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1287	1	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1287	2	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1287	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1287	4	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1287	5	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1287	6	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1287	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1287	8	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1287	9	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1287	10	rationally	rationally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1287	11	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1287	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1287	13	bendectin	bendectin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1287	14	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1287	15	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1287	16	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1287	17	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1287	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1287	19	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1287	20	child	child	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1287	21	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1287	22	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1287	23	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1287	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1287	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1288	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1288	2	record	record	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1288	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1288	4	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1288	5	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1288	6	gave	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1288	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1288	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1288	9	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1288	10	occasion	occasion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1288	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1288	12	discuss	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1288	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1288	14	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1288	15	epidemiologists	epidemiologist	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1288	16	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1288	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1288	18	assessing	assess	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1288	19	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1288	20	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1288	21	observed	observed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1288	22	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1288	23	demonstrates	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1288	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1288	25	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1288	26	relation	relation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1288	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1289	1	275	275	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1289	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1290	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1290	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1290	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1290	4	955	955	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1290	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1291	1	164	164	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1291	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1291	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1291	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1292	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1292	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1292	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1292	4	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1292	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1292	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1292	7	minimum	minimum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1292	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1292	9	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1292	10	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1292	11	exceed	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1292	12	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1292	13	2[.]”276	2[.]”276	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1292	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1292	15	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1292	16	statement	statement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1292	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1292	18	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1292	19	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1292	20	shifted	shift	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1292	21	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1292	22	discussing	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1292	23	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1292	24	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1292	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1292	26	discussing	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1292	27	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1292	28	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1292	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1293	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1293	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1293	3	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1293	4	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1293	5	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1293	6	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1293	7	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1293	8	shift	shift	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1293	9	explicit	explicit	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1293	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1294	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1294	2	ninth	ninth	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1294	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1294	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1294	5	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1294	6	remand	remand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1294	7	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1294	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1294	9	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1294	10	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1294	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1294	12	daubert	daubert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1294	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1294	14	picked	pick	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1294	15	up	up	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1294	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1294	17	ran	run	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1294	18	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1294	19	deluca	deluca	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1294	20	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1294	21	dictum	dictum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1294	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1295	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1295	2	ninth	ninth	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1295	3	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1295	4	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1295	5	initially	initially	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1295	6	affirmed	affirm	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1295	7	the277	the277	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1295	8	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1295	9	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1295	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1295	11	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1295	12	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1295	13	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1295	14	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1295	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1295	16	lack	lack	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1295	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1295	18	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1295	19	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1295	20	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1295	21	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1295	22	bendectin	bendectin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1295	23	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1295	24	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1295	25	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1295	26	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1295	27	all	all	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1295	28	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1295	29	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1295	30	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1295	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1295	32	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1295	33	failure	failure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1295	34	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1295	35	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1295	36	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1295	37	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1295	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1296	1	after	after	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1296	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1296	3	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1296	4	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1296	5	reversed	reverse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1296	6	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1296	7	remanded	remand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1296	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1296	9	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	10	of278	of278	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1296	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1296	12	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1296	13	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	14	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1296	15	admissibility	admissibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1296	17	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	18	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1296	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1296	21	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1296	22	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1296	23	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1296	24	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	25	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1296	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1296	27	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	28	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	29	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1296	30	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	31	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1296	32	upholding	uphold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1296	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1296	34	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	35	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	36	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1296	37	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1296	38	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	39	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1296	40	raise	raise	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1296	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1296	42	material	material	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	43	dispute	dispute	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1296	45	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	46	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1296	47	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1296	48	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1296	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1296	50	negative	negative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1296	51	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1296	52	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1296	53	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1297	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1297	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	3	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1297	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1297	5	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	6	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1297	7	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1297	9	testif[ied]279	testif[ied]279	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1297	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1297	11	bendectin	bendectin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1297	12	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1297	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1297	14	teratogen	teratogen	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	15	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1297	16	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1297	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1297	18	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	19	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1297	20	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1297	21	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1297	22	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	23	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1297	24	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1297	25	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1297	26	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1297	27	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1297	28	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1297	29	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	30	increases	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1297	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1297	32	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1297	34	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	35	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1297	37	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1297	38	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1297	39	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1297	40	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1297	41	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1297	42	n]one	n]one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1297	44	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	45	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1297	46	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1297	47	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	48	claim[ed	claim[ed	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1297	49	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1297	50	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1297	51	ingestion	ingestion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	52	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1297	53	bendectin	bendectin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	54	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1297	55	pregnancy	pregnancy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	56	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1297	57	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1297	58	doubl[ed	doubl[ed	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1297	59	]	]	X
inlawrev-20850	1297	60	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1297	61	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	62	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1297	63	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	64	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1297	65	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1297	66	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1298	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1298	2	latter	latter	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1298	3	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1298	4	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1298	5	necessary,280	necessary,280	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1298	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1298	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1298	8	reasoned	reason	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1298	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1298	10	for	for	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1298	11	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1298	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1298	13	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1298	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1298	15	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1298	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1298	17	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1298	18	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1298	19	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1298	20	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1298	21	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1298	22	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1298	23	injuries	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1298	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1298	25	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1299	1	justifying	justify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1299	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1299	3	exclusion	exclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1299	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1299	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1299	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1299	7	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1299	8	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1299	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1299	10	the281	the281	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1299	11	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1299	12	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1299	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1299	14	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1299	15	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1299	16	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1299	17	elevated	elevated	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1299	18	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1299	19	less	less	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1299	20	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1299	21	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1299	22	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1299	23	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1299	24	confuse	confuse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1299	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1299	26	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1299	27	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1299	28	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1299	29	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1299	30	a	a	X
inlawrev-20850	1299	31	]	]	X
inlawrev-20850	1299	32	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1299	33	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1299	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1299	35	less	less	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1299	36	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1299	37	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1299	38	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1299	39	suggest	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1299	40	teratogenicity	teratogenicity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1299	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1299	42	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1299	43	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1299	44	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1299	45	tends	tend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1299	46	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1299	47	disprove	disprove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1299	48	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1299	49	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1299	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1299	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1299	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1299	53	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1299	54	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1300	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1300	2	court282	court282	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1300	3	unquestionably	unquestionably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1300	4	understood	understand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1300	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1300	6	difference	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1300	7	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1300	8	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1300	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1300	10	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1300	11	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1300	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1300	13	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1300	14	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1300	15	distinction	distinction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1300	16	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1300	17	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1300	18	teratogenicity	teratogenicity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1300	19	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1300	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1300	21	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1300	22	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1300	23	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1300	24	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1300	25	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1300	26	unfortunately	unfortunately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1300	27	obscure	obscure	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1300	28	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1300	29	such	such	DET
inlawrev-20850	1300	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1300	31	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1300	32	high	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1300	33	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1300	34	profile	profile	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1300	35	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1300	36	opinion.283	opinion.283	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1300	37	276	276	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1300	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1301	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1301	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1301	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1301	4	958	958	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1301	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1301	6	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1301	7	manko	manko	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1301	8	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1301	9	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1301	10	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1301	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1301	12	636	636	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1301	13	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1301	14	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1301	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1302	1	1419	1419	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1302	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1302	3	1434	1434	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1302	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1302	5	w.d	w.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1302	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1302	7	mo	mo	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1302	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1302	9	1986	1986	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1302	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1302	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1302	12	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1302	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1302	14	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1302	15	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1302	16	plus	plus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1302	17	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1302	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1302	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1302	20	swine	swine	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1302	21	flu	flu	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1302	22	vaccine	vaccine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1302	23	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1302	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1302	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1302	26	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1302	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1302	28	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1302	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1302	30	830	830	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1302	31	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1302	32	831	831	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1302	33	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1302	34	8th	8th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1302	35	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1302	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1302	37	1987	1987	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1302	38	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1302	39	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1302	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1303	1	277	277	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1303	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1304	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1304	2	daubert	daubert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1304	3	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1304	4	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1304	5	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1304	6	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1304	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1304	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1304	9	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1304	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1304	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1304	12	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1304	13	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1304	14	1311	1311	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1304	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1304	16	9th	9th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1304	17	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1304	18	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1304	19	1995	1995	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1304	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1305	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1305	2	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1305	3	remand	remand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1305	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1305	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1306	1	278	278	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1306	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	1	daubert	daubert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1307	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1307	3	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1307	4	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1307	5	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1307	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	8	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1307	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1307	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	11	951	951	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1307	12	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	13	1128	1128	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1307	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	15	1129	1129	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1307	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	17	9th	9th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1307	18	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	19	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1307	20	1991	1991	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1307	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	23	vacated	vacate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1307	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	25	509	509	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1307	26	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1307	27	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1307	28	579	579	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1307	29	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	30	1993	1993	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1307	31	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	32	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	33	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1307	34	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1307	35	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	36	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1307	37	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1307	38	unpublished	unpublished	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1307	39	reanalyses	reanalyse	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	40	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1307	41	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1307	42	data	datum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	43	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1307	44	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1307	45	admissible	admissible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1307	46	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1307	47	light	light	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	48	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1307	49	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	50	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1307	51	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1307	52	30	30	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1307	53	published	publish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1307	54	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1307	55	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	56	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	57	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	58	involving	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1307	59	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1307	60	130,000	130,000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1307	61	patients	patient	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	62	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	63	none	none	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	64	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1307	65	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1307	66	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	67	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1307	68	demonstrated	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1307	69	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1307	70	statistically	statistically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1307	71	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1307	72	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	73	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1307	74	bendectin	bendectin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	75	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1307	76	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	77	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1307	78	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	79	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1307	80	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1308	1	279	279	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1308	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1309	1	daubert	daubert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1309	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1309	3	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1309	4	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1309	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1309	6	1320	1320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1309	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1309	8	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1309	9	remand	remand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1309	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1309	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1310	1	280	280	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1310	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1311	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1311	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1311	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1311	4	1320	1320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1311	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1311	6	21	21	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1311	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1311	8	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1311	9	deluca	deluca	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1311	10	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1311	11	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1311	12	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1311	13	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1311	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1311	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1311	16	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1311	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1311	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1311	19	911	911	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1311	20	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1311	21	941	941	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1311	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1311	23	959	959	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1311	24	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1311	25	3d	3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1311	26	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1311	27	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1311	28	1990	1990	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1311	29	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1311	30	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1311	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1312	1	281	281	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1312	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1313	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1313	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1313	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1313	4	1320	1320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1313	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1314	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1314	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1314	3	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1314	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1314	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1314	6	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1314	7	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1314	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1314	9	less	less	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1314	10	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1314	11	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1314	12	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1314	13	suffice	suffice	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1314	14	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1314	15	accompanied	accompany	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1314	16	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1314	17	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1314	18	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1314	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1314	20	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1314	21	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1314	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1314	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1314	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1314	25	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1314	26	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1314	27	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1314	28	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1314	29	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1314	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1314	31	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1314	32	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1314	33	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1314	34	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1314	35	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1314	36	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1314	37	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1314	38	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1314	39	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1314	40	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1314	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1315	1	282	282	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1315	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1316	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1316	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1316	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1316	4	1321	1321	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1316	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1317	1	283	283	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1317	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1318	1	andrew	andrew	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1318	2	jurs	jurs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1318	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1318	4	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1318	5	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1318	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1318	7	complex	complex	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1318	8	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1318	9	cutting	cutting	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1318	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1318	11	edge	edge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1318	12	science	science	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1318	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1318	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1318	15	daubert	daubert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1318	16	era	era	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1318	17	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1318	18	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1318	19	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1318	20	assessment	assessment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1318	21	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1318	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1318	23	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1318	24	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1318	25	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1318	26	reform	reform	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1318	27	strategies	strategy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1318	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1318	29	42	42	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1318	30	conn	conn	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1318	31	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1319	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1319	2	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1319	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1319	4	49	49	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1319	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1319	6	55	55	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1319	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1319	8	2009	2009	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1319	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1319	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1320	1	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1320	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1320	3	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1320	4	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1320	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1320	6	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1320	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1320	8	165	165	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1320	9	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1320	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1320	11	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1320	12	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1320	13	later	later	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1320	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1320	15	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1320	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1320	17	next	next	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1320	18	major	major	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1320	19	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1320	20	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1320	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1321	1	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	2	the284	the284	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1321	3	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1321	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	5	stated	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1321	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	7	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	8	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1321	9	rely	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1321	10	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	11	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	12	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1321	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1321	15	absence	absence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	17	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1321	19	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1321	20	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	21	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	23	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1321	25	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1321	26	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1321	27	conflated	conflate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1321	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1321	29	concepts	concept	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	30	of285	of285	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1321	31	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	32	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	33	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	34	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	35	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	36	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1321	37	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1321	38	distinguished	distinguish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1321	39	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1321	40	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	41	before.286	before.286	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	42	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1321	43	conflation	conflation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	44	produced	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1321	45	theoretical	theoretical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	46	incoherence	incoherence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	47	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1321	49	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	50	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1321	51	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	52	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	53	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1321	54	proceeded	proceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1321	55	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1321	56	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1321	57	methodological	methodological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	58	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	59	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	60	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1321	61	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	62	associations	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	63	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1321	64	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	65	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	66	testing	testing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	67	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	68	type	type	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	69	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1321	70	error	error	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	71	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	72	associations	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	73	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1321	74	criteria	criterion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	75	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	76	determining	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1321	77	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	78	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1321	79	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	80	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1321	81	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	82	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1321	83	external	external	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	84	validity	validity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	85	standards	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	86	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	87	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	88	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	89	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	90	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	91	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	92	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	93	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	94	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1321	95	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	96	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1321	97	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1321	98	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1321	99	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	100	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	101	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1321	102	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1321	103	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	104	ever	ever	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1321	105	making	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1321	106	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	107	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	108	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1321	109	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	110	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	111	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	112	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	1321	113	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	114	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1321	115	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1321	116	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	117	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	118	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1321	119	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1321	120	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1322	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1322	2	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1322	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1322	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1322	5	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1322	6	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1322	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1322	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1322	9	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1322	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1322	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1322	12	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1322	13	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1322	14	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1322	15	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1322	16	foundered	founder	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1322	17	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1322	18	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1322	19	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1322	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1322	21	failing	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1322	22	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1322	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1322	24	lack	lack	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1322	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1322	26	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1322	27	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1322	28	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1322	29	bendectin	bendectin	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1322	30	causes	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1322	31	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1322	32	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1322	33	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1322	34	humans	human	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1322	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1323	1	”287	”287	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1323	2	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1323	3	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1323	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1323	5	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1323	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1323	7	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1323	8	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1323	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1323	10	havner	havner	X
inlawrev-20850	1323	11	repeatedly	repeatedly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1323	12	framed	frame	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1323	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1323	14	doublingplus	doublingplus	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1323	15	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1323	16	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1323	17	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1323	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1323	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1323	20	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1323	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1323	22	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1323	23	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1323	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1324	1	introducing	introduce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1324	2	its288	its288	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1324	3	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1324	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1324	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1324	6	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1324	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1324	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1324	9	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1324	10	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1324	11	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1324	12	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1324	13	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1324	14	t]he	t]he	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1324	15	havners	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1324	16	rely	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1324	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1324	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1324	19	considerable	considerable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1324	20	extent	extent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1324	21	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1324	22	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1324	23	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1324	24	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1324	25	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1324	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1324	27	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1324	28	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1324	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1325	1	accordingly	accordingly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1325	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1325	3	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1325	4	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1325	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1325	6	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1325	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1325	8	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1325	9	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1325	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1325	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1325	12	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1325	13	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1325	14	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1325	15	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1325	16	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1325	17	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1325	18	burden	burden	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1325	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1325	20	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1325	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1325	22	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1326	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1326	2	concluding	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1326	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1326	4	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1326	5	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1326	6	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1326	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1326	8	rational	rational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1326	9	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1326	10	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1326	11	relating	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1326	12	the289	the289	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1326	13	284	284	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1326	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1327	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1327	2	sanders	sanders	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1327	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1327	4	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1327	5	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1327	6	122	122	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1327	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1327	8	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1327	9	146	146	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1327	10	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1327	11	49	49	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1327	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1327	13	157	157	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1327	14	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1327	15	59	59	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1327	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1327	17	listing	list	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1327	18	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1327	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1327	20	appellate	appellate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1327	21	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1327	22	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1327	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1327	24	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1327	25	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1327	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1327	27	chronological	chronological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1327	28	order	order	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1327	29	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1327	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1328	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1328	2	only	only	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1328	3	appellate	appellate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1328	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1328	5	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1328	6	listed	list	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1328	7	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1328	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1328	9	daubert	daubert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1328	10	remand	remand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1328	11	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1328	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1328	13	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1328	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1328	15	raynor	raynor	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1328	16	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1328	17	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1328	18	pharmaceuticals	pharmaceuticals	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1328	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1328	20	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1328	21	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1328	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1328	23	104	104	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1328	24	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1328	25	1371	1371	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1328	26	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1328	27	d.c	d.c	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1328	28	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1328	29	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1328	30	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1328	31	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1328	32	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1328	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1328	34	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1328	35	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1328	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1328	37	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1328	38	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1328	39	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1328	40	daubert	daubert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1328	41	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1328	42	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1328	43	existing	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1328	44	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1328	45	precedent	precedent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1328	46	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1328	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1328	48	admissibility	admissibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1328	49	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1328	50	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1328	51	’	’	PART
inlawrev-20850	1328	52	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1328	53	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1328	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1329	1	285	285	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1329	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1330	1	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1330	2	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1330	3	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1330	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1330	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1330	6	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1330	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1331	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1331	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1331	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1331	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1331	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1331	6	706	706	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1331	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1331	8	715	715	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1331	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1331	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1331	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1331	12	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1331	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1331	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1332	1	286	286	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1332	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1333	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1333	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1333	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1333	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1333	5	714	714	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1333	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1333	7	defining	define	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1333	8	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1333	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1333	10	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1333	11	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1333	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1333	13	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1333	14	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1333	15	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1333	16	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1333	17	714	714	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1333	18	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1333	19	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1333	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1333	21	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1333	22	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1333	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1333	24	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1333	25	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1333	26	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1333	27	controlled	control	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1333	28	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1333	29	experiments	experiment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1333	30	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1333	31	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1333	32	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1333	33	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1333	34	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1333	35	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1333	36	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1333	37	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1333	38	criteria	criterion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1333	39	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1333	40	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1333	41	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1333	42	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1333	43	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1333	44	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1333	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1334	1	287	287	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1334	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1335	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1335	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1335	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1335	4	730	730	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1335	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1335	6	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1335	7	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1335	9	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1335	10	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	11	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1335	12	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	13	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1335	14	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1335	15	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1335	16	animal	animal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1335	18	vitro	vitro	X
inlawrev-20850	1335	19	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1335	21	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1335	22	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1335	23	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1335	24	i	i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1335	25	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1335	26	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1335	27	729	729	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1335	28	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1335	29	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1335	30	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1335	32	another	another	DET
inlawrev-20850	1335	33	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	34	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1335	35	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	36	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1335	37	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1335	38	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1335	39	animal	animal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	40	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	41	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1335	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1335	43	doubts	doubt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	44	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1335	45	extrapolation	extrapolation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	46	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1335	47	humans	human	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	48	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1335	49	light	light	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1335	51	large	large	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1335	52	body	body	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1335	54	negative	negative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1335	55	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1335	56	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1335	57	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1335	58	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1336	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1336	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1336	3	reached	reach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1336	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1336	5	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1336	6	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1336	7	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1336	8	respect	respect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1336	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1336	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1336	11	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1336	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1336	13	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1336	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1336	15	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1336	16	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1336	17	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1336	18	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1336	19	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1336	20	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1336	21	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1336	22	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1336	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1337	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1337	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1337	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1337	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	5	725	725	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1337	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1337	7	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1337	8	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	10	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1337	11	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	12	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1337	13	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	14	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1337	15	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1337	16	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	17	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	18	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	19	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	20	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1337	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1337	22	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1337	23	statistically	statistically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1337	24	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	25	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	26	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	27	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	29	limb	limb	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	30	reductions	reduction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	31	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1337	32	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1337	33	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1337	34	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1337	35	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	36	726	726	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1337	37	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1337	38	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1337	39	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1337	40	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1337	41	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	43	another	another	DET
inlawrev-20850	1337	44	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	45	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1337	46	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	47	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1337	48	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1337	49	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	50	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	51	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	52	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	53	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1337	54	large	large	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	55	body	body	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	56	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	57	negative	negative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	58	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	59	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	60	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	61	lack	lack	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	62	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	63	publication	publication	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	64	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	65	replication	replication	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	66	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1337	67	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1337	68	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1337	69	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1337	70	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	71	730	730	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1337	72	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1337	73	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1337	74	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	75	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	76	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1337	77	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	78	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1337	79	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	80	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1337	81	opined	opine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1337	82	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	83	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	84	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	85	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	86	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	87	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1337	88	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1337	89	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1337	90	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	91	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	92	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1337	93	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1337	94	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1337	95	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1337	96	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1337	97	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1337	98	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1337	99	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1338	1	joseph	joseph	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1338	2	sanders	sanders	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1338	3	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1338	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1338	5	reasons	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1338	6	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1338	7	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1338	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1338	9	win	win	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1338	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1338	11	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1338	12	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1338	13	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1338	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1338	15	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1338	16	f]ailure	f]ailure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1338	17	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1338	18	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1338	19	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1338	20	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1338	21	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1338	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1338	23	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1338	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1338	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1338	26	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1338	27	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1338	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1338	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1338	30	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1338	31	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1338	32	f]ailure	f]ailure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1338	33	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1338	34	present	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1338	35	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1338	36	qualified	qualified	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1338	37	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1338	38	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1338	39	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1338	40	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1338	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1338	42	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1338	43	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1338	44	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1338	45	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1338	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1338	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1339	1	sanders	sander	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1339	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1339	3	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1339	4	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1339	5	122	122	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1339	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1339	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1339	8	158	158	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1339	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1340	1	288	288	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1340	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1341	1	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1341	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1341	3	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1341	4	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1341	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1341	6	715	715	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1341	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1342	1	289	289	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1342	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1343	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1343	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1343	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1343	4	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1343	5	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1343	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1343	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1344	1	166	166	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1344	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1344	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1344	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1345	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1345	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1345	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1345	4	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1345	5	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1345	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1345	7	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1345	8	be	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1345	9	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1345	10	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1345	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1345	12	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1345	13	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1345	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1345	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1345	16	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1345	17	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1345	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1345	19	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1345	20	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1345	21	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1345	22	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1345	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1345	24	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1345	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1345	26	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1345	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1345	28	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1345	29	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1345	30	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1345	31	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1345	32	burden	burden	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1345	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1345	34	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1345	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1345	36	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1345	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1345	38	court290	court290	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1345	39	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1345	40	referred	refer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1345	41	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1345	42	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1345	43	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1345	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1345	45	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1346	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1346	2	next	next	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1346	3	explained	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1346	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1346	5	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1346	6	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1346	7	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1346	8	logic	logic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1346	9	with291	with291	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1346	10	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1346	11	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1346	12	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1346	13	seemed	seem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1346	14	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1346	15	refer	refer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1346	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1346	17	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1346	18	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1346	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1346	20	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1346	21	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1346	22	immediately292	immediately292	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1346	23	summed	sum	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1346	24	up	up	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1346	25	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1346	26	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1346	27	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1346	28	t]his	t]his	X
inlawrev-20850	1346	29	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1346	30	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1346	31	oversimplification	oversimplification	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1346	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1346	33	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1346	34	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1346	35	relating	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1346	36	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1346	37	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1346	38	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1346	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1346	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1346	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1347	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1347	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1347	3	illustrates	illustrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1347	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1347	5	thinking	thinking	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1347	6	behind	behind	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1347	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1347	8	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1347	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1347	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1347	11	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1347	12	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1347	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1347	14	”293	”293	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1348	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1348	2	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1348	3	thinking	thinking	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1348	4	behind	behind	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1348	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1348	6	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1348	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1348	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1348	9	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1348	10	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1348	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1348	12	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1348	13	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1348	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1348	15	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1348	16	nothing	nothing	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1348	17	whatever	whatever	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1348	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1348	19	do	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1348	20	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1348	21	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1348	22	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1348	23	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1348	24	relating	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1348	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1348	26	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1348	27	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1348	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1348	29	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1349	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1349	2	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1349	3	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1349	4	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1349	5	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1349	6	depends	depend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1349	7	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1349	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1349	9	presumed	presume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1349	10	congruence	congruence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1349	11	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1349	12	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1349	13	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1349	14	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1349	15	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1349	16	attributable	attributable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1349	17	fraction	fraction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1349	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1349	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1349	20	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1349	21	sample	sample	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1349	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1349	23	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1349	24	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1349	25	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1349	26	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1349	27	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1349	28	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1349	29	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1349	30	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1349	31	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1349	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1350	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1350	2	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1350	3	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1350	4	commentators	commentator	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1350	5	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1350	6	accept	accept	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1350	7	it,294	it,294	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1350	8	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1350	9	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1350	10	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1350	11	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1350	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1350	13	technique	technique	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1350	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1350	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1350	16	theoretical	theoretical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1350	17	justification	justification	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1350	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1350	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1350	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1350	21	substantive	substantive	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1350	22	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1350	23	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1350	24	making	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1350	25	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1350	26	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1350	27	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1350	28	group	group	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1350	29	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1350	30	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1350	31	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1350	32	supporting	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1350	33	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1350	34	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1350	35	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1350	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1350	37	otherwise	otherwise	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1350	38	irresolvable	irresolvable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1350	39	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1350	40	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1350	41	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1350	42	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1350	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1351	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1351	2	reasoned	reason	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1351	3	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1351	4	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1351	5	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1351	6	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1351	7	talking	talk	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1351	8	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1351	9	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1351	10	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1351	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1352	1	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1352	2	wonder	wonder	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1352	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1352	4	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1352	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1352	6	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1352	7	russelyn	russelyn	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1352	8	carruth	carruth	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1352	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1352	10	bernard	bernard	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1352	11	goldstein295	goldstein295	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1352	12	290	290	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1352	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1353	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1353	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1353	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1353	4	717	717	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1353	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1353	6	291	291	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1353	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1354	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1354	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1354	3	292	292	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1354	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1355	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1355	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1355	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1355	4	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1355	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1355	6	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1355	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1355	8	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1355	9	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1355	10	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1355	11	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1355	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1355	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1355	14	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1355	15	means	mean	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1355	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1355	17	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1355	18	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1355	19	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1355	20	statistically	statistically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1355	21	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1355	22	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1355	23	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1355	24	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1355	25	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1355	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1355	27	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1355	28	individual	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1355	29	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1355	30	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1355	31	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1355	32	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1355	33	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1355	34	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1355	35	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1355	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1355	37	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1355	38	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1355	39	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1355	40	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1355	41	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1355	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1355	43	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1355	44	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1355	45	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1355	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1355	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1356	1	293	293	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1356	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1357	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1357	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1357	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1357	4	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1357	5	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1357	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1357	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1358	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1358	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	3	continued	continue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1358	4	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1358	5	describe	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1358	6	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1358	7	commentators	commentator	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	8	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1358	9	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1358	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1358	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1358	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1358	14	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	15	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1358	16	words	word	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1358	18	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1358	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1358	20	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1358	22	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1358	23	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	24	changes	change	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1358	25	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1358	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1358	27	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1358	29	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1358	30	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	31	changes	change	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1358	33	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1358	34	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1358	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1358	36	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1358	37	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1358	39	2.75	2.75	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1358	40	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1358	41	result	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1358	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1358	43	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1358	44	little	little	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1358	45	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1358	46	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1358	47	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	48	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1358	49	52	52	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1358	50	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	51	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	52	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1358	53	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1358	54	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1358	55	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	56	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1358	57	depending	depend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1358	58	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1358	59	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1358	60	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	61	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1358	62	chosen	choose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1358	63	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1359	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1359	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1359	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1359	4	718	718	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1359	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1360	1	294	294	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1360	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1361	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1361	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1361	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1361	4	715	715	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1361	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1361	6	295	295	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1361	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1362	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1362	2	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1362	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1362	4	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1362	5	havner	havner	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1362	6	linked	link	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1362	7	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1362	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1362	9	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1362	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1362	11	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1362	12	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1362	13	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1362	14	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1362	15	distinguished	distinguish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1362	16	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1362	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1362	18	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1362	19	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1362	20	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1362	21	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1362	22	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1362	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1362	24	probative	probative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1362	25	value	value	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1362	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1362	27	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1362	28	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1362	29	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1362	30	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1362	31	values	value	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1362	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1363	1	strength	strength	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1363	2	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1363	3	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1363	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1363	5	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1363	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1363	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1363	8	criteria	criterion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1363	9	epidemiologists	epidemiologist	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1363	10	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1363	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1363	12	assessing	assess	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1363	13	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1363	14	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1363	15	observed	observed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1363	16	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1363	17	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1363	18	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1363	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1364	1	hill	hill	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1364	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1364	3	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1364	4	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1364	5	129	129	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1364	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1364	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1364	8	295	295	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1364	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1365	1	methodological	methodological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1365	2	difficulties	difficulty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1365	3	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1365	4	bias	bias	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1365	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1365	6	confounding	confound	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1365	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1365	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1365	9	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1365	10	variability	variability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1365	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1365	12	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1365	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1365	14	susceptibility	susceptibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1365	15	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1365	16	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1365	17	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1365	18	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1365	19	difficult	difficult	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1365	20	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1365	21	observational	observational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1365	22	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1365	23	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1365	24	reliably	reliably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1365	25	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1365	26	detect	detect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1365	27	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1365	28	assess	assess	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1365	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1365	30	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1365	31	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1365	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1365	33	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1365	34	measured	measure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1365	35	increases	increase	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1365	36	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1365	37	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1365	38	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1365	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1366	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1366	2	michael	michael	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1366	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1366	4	green	green	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1366	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1366	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1366	7	future	future	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1366	9	proportional	proportional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1366	10	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	11	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1366	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1366	13	lessons	lesson	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1366	15	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1366	16	substances	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	17	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1366	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1366	20	exploring	explore	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1366	21	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	22	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	23	352	352	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1366	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1366	25	357	357	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1366	26	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1366	27	70	70	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1366	28	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1366	29	m.	m.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	30	stuart	stuart	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1366	31	madden	madden	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1366	32	ed	ed	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1366	33	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1366	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1366	35	2005	2005	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1366	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1366	37	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1366	38	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1366	39	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1366	40	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1366	42	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1366	43	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1366	44	m]any	m]any	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	45	scientists	scientist	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	46	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1366	47	leery	leery	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1366	48	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1366	49	accepting	accept	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1366	50	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1366	51	group	group	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	52	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	53	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1366	54	finds	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1366	55	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1366	56	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1366	57	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	58	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1366	59	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	60	below	below	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1366	61	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1366	62	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1366	63	magnitude	magnitude	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	64	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1366	65	demonstrating	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1366	66	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1366	67	true	true	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1366	68	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1366	69	relationship	relationship	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1366	70	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1366	71	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1367	1	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1367	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1367	3	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1367	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1367	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1367	6	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1367	7	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1367	8	liab	liab	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1367	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1368	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1368	2	physical	physical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1368	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1368	4	emotional	emotional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1368	5	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1368	6	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1368	7	28	28	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1368	8	cmt	cmt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1368	9	c.	c.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1368	10	reporters	reporters	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1368	11	’	’	PART
inlawrev-20850	1368	12	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1368	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1368	14	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1368	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1368	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1369	1	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	1369	2	arguments	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1369	3	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1369	4	purely	purely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1369	5	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1369	6	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1369	7	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1369	8	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1369	9	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1369	10	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1369	11	inferred	infer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1369	12	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1369	13	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1369	14	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1369	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1370	1	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1370	2	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1370	3	nothing	nothing	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1370	4	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1370	5	do	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1370	6	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1370	7	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1370	8	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1370	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1371	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1371	2	connection	connection	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1371	3	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1371	4	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1371	5	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1371	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1371	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1371	8	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1371	9	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1371	10	2.0	2.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1371	11	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1371	12	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1371	13	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1371	14	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1371	15	magical	magical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1371	16	meaning	meaning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1371	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1372	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1372	2	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1372	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1372	4	methodologically	methodologically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1372	5	challenged	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1372	6	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1372	7	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1372	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1372	9	statistically	statistically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1372	10	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1372	11	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1372	12	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1372	13	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1372	14	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1372	15	2.0	2.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1372	16	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1372	17	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1372	18	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1372	19	weak	weak	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1372	20	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1372	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1372	22	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1372	23	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1372	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1373	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1373	2	large	large	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1373	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1373	4	powerful	powerful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1373	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1373	6	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1373	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1373	8	designed	design	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1373	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1373	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1373	11	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1373	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1373	13	controlled	control	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1373	14	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1373	15	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1373	16	high	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1373	17	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1373	18	quality	quality	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1373	19	data	datum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1373	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1373	21	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1373	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1373	23	randomized	randomized	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1373	24	clinical	clinical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1373	25	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1373	26	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1373	27	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1373	28	observational	observational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1373	29	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1373	30	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1373	31	does	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1373	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1373	33	good	good	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1373	34	job	job	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1373	35	accounting	accounting	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1373	36	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1373	37	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1373	38	confounders	confounder	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1373	39	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1373	40	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1373	41	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1373	42	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1373	43	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1373	44	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1373	45	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1373	46	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1373	47	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1373	48	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1373	49	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1373	50	167	167	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1373	51	assessed	assess	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1373	52	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1373	53	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1373	54	meaning	meaning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1373	55	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1373	56	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1373	57	unclear	unclear	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1373	58	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1373	59	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1374	1	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1374	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1374	3	settled	settle	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1374	4	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1374	5	its296	its296	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1374	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1374	7	foundational	foundational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1374	8	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1374	9	place	place	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1374	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1374	11	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1374	12	toxic	toxic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1374	13	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1374	14	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1374	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1374	16	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1374	17	lack	lack	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1374	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1374	19	clarity	clarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1374	20	began	begin	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1374	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1374	22	have297	have297	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1374	23	consequences	consequence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1374	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1375	1	c.	c.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1375	2	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1375	3	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1375	4	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1375	5	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1375	6	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1375	7	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1375	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1375	9	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1375	10	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1375	11	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1375	12	muddying	muddy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1375	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1375	14	muddle	muddle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1375	15	lower	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1375	16	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1375	17	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1375	18	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1375	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1375	20	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1375	21	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1375	22	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1375	23	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1375	24	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1375	25	naturally	naturally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1375	26	began	begin	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1375	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1375	28	follow	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1375	29	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1375	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1376	1	unsurprisingly	unsurprisingly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1376	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1376	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1376	4	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1376	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1376	6	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1376	7	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1376	8	appeared	appear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1376	9	in298	in298	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1376	10	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1376	11	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1376	12	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1376	13	involving	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1376	14	substances	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1376	15	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1376	16	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1376	17	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1376	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1377	1	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1377	2	sometimes299	sometimes299	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1377	3	disagreed	disagree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1377	4	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1377	5	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1377	6	literally	literally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1377	7	havner	havner	X
inlawrev-20850	1377	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1377	9	requirements	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1377	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1377	11	including	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1377	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1377	13	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1377	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1377	15	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1377	16	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1377	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1377	18	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1377	19	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1377	20	interpreted.300	interpreted.300	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1377	21	strong	strong	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1377	22	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1377	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1377	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1377	25	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1377	26	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1377	27	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1377	28	less	less	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1377	29	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1377	30	doubles	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1377	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1377	32	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1377	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1378	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1378	2	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1378	3	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1378	4	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	1378	5	points	point	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1378	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1378	7	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1378	8	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1378	9	after	after	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1378	10	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1378	11	announced	announce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1378	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1378	13	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1378	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1378	15	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1378	16	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1378	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1378	18	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1378	19	retreated	retreat	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1378	20	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1378	21	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1378	22	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1378	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1378	24	showing	showing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1378	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1378	26	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1378	27	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1378	28	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1378	29	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1378	30	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1378	31	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1378	32	alone	alone	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1378	33	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1378	34	for	for	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1378	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1378	36	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1378	37	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1378	38	reach	reach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1378	39	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1378	40	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1378	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1379	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1379	2	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1379	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1379	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1379	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1379	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1379	7	718	718	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1379	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1379	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1379	10	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1379	11	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1379	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1379	13	hold	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1379	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1379	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1379	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1380	1	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1380	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1380	3	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1380	4	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1380	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1380	6	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1380	7	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1380	8	2.0	2.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1380	9	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1380	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1380	11	litmus	litmus	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1380	12	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1380	13	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1380	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1380	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1380	16	single	single	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1380	17	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1380	18	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1380	19	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1380	20	legally	legally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1380	21	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1380	22	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1380	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1380	24	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1380	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1380	26	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1380	27	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1380	28	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1380	29	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1380	30	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1380	31	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1380	32	719	719	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1380	33	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1380	34	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1380	35	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1380	36	s]ome	s]ome	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1380	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1380	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1380	39	literature	literature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1380	40	indicates	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1380	41	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1380	42	epidemiologists	epidemiologist	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1380	43	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1380	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1380	45	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1380	46	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1380	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1380	48	less	less	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1380	49	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1380	50	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1380	51	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1380	52	indicate	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1380	53	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1380	54	weak	weak	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1380	55	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1380	56	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1380	57	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1380	58	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1381	1	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1381	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1381	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1381	4	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1381	5	shows	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1381	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1381	7	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1381	8	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1381	9	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1381	10	utterly	utterly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1381	11	unmoored	unmoored	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1381	12	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1381	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1381	14	supposed	suppose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1381	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1381	16	rational	rational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1381	17	connection	connection	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1381	18	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1381	19	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1381	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1381	21	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1381	22	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1381	23	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1381	24	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1381	25	2.0	2.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1381	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1381	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1381	28	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1381	29	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1381	30	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1381	31	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1381	32	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1381	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1381	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1381	35	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1381	36	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1381	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1382	1	296	296	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1382	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1383	1	carruth	carruth	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1383	2	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1383	3	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1383	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1383	5	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1383	6	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1383	7	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1383	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1383	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1383	10	204	204	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1383	11	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1383	12	n.32	n.32	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1383	13	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1383	14	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1383	15	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1383	16	tumlinson	tumlinson	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1383	17	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1383	18	advanced	advanced	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1383	19	micro	micro	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1383	20	devices	devices	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1383	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1383	22	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1383	23	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1383	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1383	25	no	no	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	1383	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1384	1	08c–07–106	08c–07–106	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1384	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1384	3	2013	2013	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1384	4	wl	wl	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1384	5	7084888	7084888	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1384	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1384	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1384	8	*	*	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1384	9	5	5	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1384	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1384	11	del	del	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1384	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1384	13	super	super	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1384	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1384	15	oct	oct	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1384	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1384	17	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1384	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1384	19	2013	2013	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1384	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1385	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1385	2	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1385	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1385	4	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1385	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1385	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1385	7	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1385	8	muddles	muddle	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1385	9	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1385	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1385	11	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1385	12	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1385	13	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1385	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1385	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1385	16	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1385	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1385	18	81	81	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1385	19	a.3d	a.3d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1385	20	1264	1264	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1385	21	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1385	22	del	del	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1385	23	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1385	24	2013	2013	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1385	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1385	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1386	1	297	297	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1386	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1387	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1387	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1387	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1387	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1387	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1387	6	347	347	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1387	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1387	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1387	9	havner	havner	X
inlawrev-20850	1387	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1387	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1387	12	foundational	foundational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1387	13	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1387	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1387	15	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1387	16	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1387	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1387	18	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1387	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1387	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1388	1	298	298	X
inlawrev-20850	1388	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1389	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1389	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1389	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1389	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1389	5	cano	cano	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1389	6	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1389	7	everest	everest	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1389	8	minerals	minerals	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1389	9	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1389	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1389	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1389	12	362	362	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1389	13	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1389	14	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1389	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1390	1	2d	2d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1390	2	814	814	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1390	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1390	4	w.d	w.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1390	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1391	1	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1392	1	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1392	2	2005	2005	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1392	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1392	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1393	1	299	299	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1393	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1393	3	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1393	4	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1393	5	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1393	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1393	7	822	822	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1393	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1393	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1393	10	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1393	11	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1393	12	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1393	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1393	14	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1393	15	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1393	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1393	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1393	18	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1393	19	spoke	speak	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1393	20	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1393	21	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1393	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1393	23	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1393	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1393	25	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1393	26	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1393	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1393	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1394	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1395	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1395	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1395	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1395	4	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1395	5	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1395	6	read	read	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1395	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1395	8	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1395	9	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1395	10	limit	limit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1395	11	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	1395	12	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1395	13	solely	solely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1395	14	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1395	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1395	16	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1395	17	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1395	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1395	19	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1395	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1395	21	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1395	22	matt	matt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1395	23	dietz	dietz	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1395	24	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1395	25	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	1	v.	v.	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1396	2	torres	torres	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1396	4	198	198	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1396	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1396	6	798	798	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1396	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1396	8	804	804	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1396	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1396	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	12	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	14	2006	2006	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1396	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1396	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1396	17	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1396	18	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1396	19	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1396	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1396	21	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1396	22	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1396	23	requirements	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1396	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1396	25	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1396	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1396	27	pesticide	pesticide	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1396	28	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1396	29	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1396	30	laryngeal	laryngeal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1396	31	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1396	32	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1396	33	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1396	34	daniels	daniels	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	35	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1396	36	lyondell	lyondell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	37	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1396	38	citgo	citgo	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	39	refining	refining	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	40	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1396	42	99	99	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1396	43	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	44	722	722	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1396	45	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1396	46	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	47	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	48	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	49	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1396	50	2003	2003	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1396	51	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1396	52	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1396	53	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1396	54	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1396	55	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1396	56	cited	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1396	57	infra	infra	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1396	58	note	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1396	59	308	308	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1396	60	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1397	1	300	300	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1397	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1398	1	compare	compare	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1398	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1398	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1398	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1398	5	exxon	exxon	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1398	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1398	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1399	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1399	2	makofski	makofski	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1399	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1399	4	116	116	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1399	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1399	6	176	176	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1399	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1399	8	182	182	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1399	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1399	10	83	83	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1399	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1399	12	188	188	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1399	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1399	14	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1399	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1399	16	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1399	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1399	18	2003	2003	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1399	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1399	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1399	21	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1399	22	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1399	23	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1399	24	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1399	25	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1399	26	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1399	27	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1399	28	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1399	29	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1399	30	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1399	31	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1399	32	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1400	1	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	1	wells	wells	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	2	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	3	smithkline	smithkline	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	4	beecham	beecham	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	5	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	8	no	no	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	1401	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	10	a-06	a-06	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	12	ca-126	ca-126	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	14	ly	ly	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	16	2009	2009	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1401	17	wl	wl	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	18	564303	564303	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1401	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	20	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1401	21	*	*	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	22	8	8	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1401	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	24	w.d	w.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	26	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	27	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	28	feb	feb	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	29	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	30	19	19	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1401	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	32	2009	2009	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1401	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	34	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	35	concluding	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1401	36	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1401	37	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	38	havner	havner	X
inlawrev-20850	1401	39	establishes	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1401	40	substantive	substantive	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1401	41	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	42	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	43	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1401	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1401	45	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	46	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1401	47	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	48	burden	burden	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	49	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1401	50	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	51	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	52	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	53	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1401	54	proffered	proffered	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1401	55	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	56	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1401	57	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	58	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	59	daniels	daniels	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	60	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	61	99	99	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1401	62	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1401	63	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1401	64	728	728	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1401	65	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1401	66	29	29	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1401	67	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	68	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1401	69	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	70	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1401	71	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1401	72	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1401	73	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1401	74	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1401	75	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	76	reporting	report	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1401	77	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1401	78	risks	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1401	79	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1401	80	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1401	81	1.0	1.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1401	82	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1401	83	less	less	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1401	84	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1401	85	2.0	2.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1401	86	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	87	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	88	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1401	89	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	90	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1401	91	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1401	92	cotroneo	cotroneo	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1401	93	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	94	shaw	shaw	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	95	envtl	envtl	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1401	96	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1402	1	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1402	2	infrastructure	infrastructure	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1402	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1402	4	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1402	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1402	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1402	7	no	no	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	1402	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1403	1	h-05	h-05	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1403	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1403	3	1250	1250	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1403	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1403	5	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1403	6	wl	wl	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1403	7	3145791	3145791	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1403	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1403	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1403	10	*	*	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1403	11	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1403	12	n.5	n.5	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1403	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1403	14	s.d	s.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1403	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	1	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1404	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1404	3	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1404	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	6	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1404	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1404	8	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1404	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	10	hedges	hedge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1404	11	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1404	12	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1404	13	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1404	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	15	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1404	16	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	17	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1404	18	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1404	19	qualifiers	qualifier	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1404	20	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	23	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1404	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1404	25	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1404	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	27	vacated	vacate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1404	28	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1404	29	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1404	30	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1404	31	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1404	32	grounds	ground	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1404	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	34	639	639	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1404	35	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1404	36	186	186	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1404	37	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	38	5th	5th	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1404	39	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1404	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	41	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1404	42	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	43	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1404	44	merck	merck	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1404	45	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1404	46	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1405	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1405	2	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1405	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1405	4	277	277	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1405	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1405	6	430	430	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1405	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1405	8	435	435	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1405	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1405	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1405	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1405	12	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1405	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1405	14	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1405	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1405	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1405	17	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1405	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1405	19	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1405	20	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1405	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1405	22	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1405	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1405	24	bright	bright	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1405	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1405	26	line	line	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1405	27	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1405	28	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1405	29	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1405	30	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1405	31	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1405	32	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1405	33	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1405	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1405	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1405	36	rev’d	rev’d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1405	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1405	38	347	347	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1405	39	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1405	40	256	256	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1405	41	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1405	42	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1405	43	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1405	44	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1405	45	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1405	46	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1406	1	minn	minn	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1406	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1406	3	mining	mining	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1406	4	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1406	5	mfg	mfg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1406	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1406	7	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1407	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1407	2	atterbury	atterbury	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1407	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1407	4	978	978	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1407	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1407	6	183	183	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1407	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1407	8	198	198	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1407	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1407	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1407	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1407	12	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1407	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1407	14	1998	1998	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1407	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1407	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1407	17	interpreting	interpret	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1407	18	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1407	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1407	20	allow	allow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1407	21	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1407	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1407	23	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1407	24	risks	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1407	25	less	less	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1407	26	168	168	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1407	27	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1407	28	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1407	29	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1407	30	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1407	31	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1407	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1407	33	49:117	49:117	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1408	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1408	2	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1408	3	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1408	4	reflected	reflect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1408	5	confusion	confusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1408	6	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1408	7	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1408	8	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1408	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1408	10	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1408	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1408	12	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1408	13	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1408	14	fit	fit	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1408	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1408	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1408	17	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1408	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1408	19	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1408	20	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1408	21	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1408	22	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1408	23	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1408	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1408	25	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1408	26	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1408	27	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1408	28	unsurprising	unsurprising	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1408	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1408	30	light	light	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1408	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1408	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1408	33	confusion	confusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1408	34	evident	evident	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1408	35	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1408	36	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1408	37	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1408	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1409	1	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1409	2	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1409	3	saw	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1409	4	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1409	5	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1409	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1409	7	language	language	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1409	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1409	9	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1409	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1409	11	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1409	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1409	13	plus	plus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1409	14	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1409	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1409	16	evaluating	evaluate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1409	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1409	18	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1409	19	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1409	20	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1409	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1409	22	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1409	23	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1409	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1410	1	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1410	2	often	often	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1410	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1410	4	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1410	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1410	6	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1410	7	followed301	followed301	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1410	8	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1410	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1410	10	structure	structure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1410	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1410	12	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1410	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1410	14	statistically	statistically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1410	15	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1410	16	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1410	17	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1410	18	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1410	19	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1410	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1410	21	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1410	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1410	23	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1410	24	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1410	25	essential	essential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1410	26	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1410	27	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1410	28	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1410	29	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1410	30	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1410	31	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1410	32	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1410	33	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1410	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1410	35	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1410	36	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1410	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1411	1	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1411	2	least	least	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1411	3	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1411	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1411	5	conflated	conflate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1411	6	statistical302	statistical302	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1411	7	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1411	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1411	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1411	10	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1411	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1411	12	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1411	13	rule.303	rule.303	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1411	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1411	15	decade	decade	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1411	16	passed	pass	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1411	17	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1411	18	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1411	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1411	20	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1411	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1411	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1411	23	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1411	24	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1411	25	of304	of304	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1411	26	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1411	27	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1411	28	next	next	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1411	29	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1411	30	ruling	ruling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1411	31	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1411	32	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1411	33	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1411	34	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1411	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1412	1	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1412	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1412	3	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1412	4	auto	auto	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1412	5	mechanic	mechanic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1412	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1412	7	alleged	allege	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1412	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1412	9	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1412	10	developed	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1412	11	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1412	12	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1412	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1412	14	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1412	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1412	16	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1412	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1412	18	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1412	19	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1412	20	thousands	thousand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1412	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1412	22	brake	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1412	23	installation	installation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1412	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1412	25	repair	repair	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1412	26	jobs	job	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1412	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1413	1	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1413	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1413	3	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1413	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1413	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1413	6	only	only	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1413	7	non-305	non-305	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1413	8	settling	settle	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1413	9	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1413	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1413	11	manufactured	manufacture	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1413	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1413	13	brakes	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1413	14	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1413	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1413	16	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1413	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1413	18	fraction	fraction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1413	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1413	20	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	1413	21	jobs.306	jobs.306	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1413	22	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1413	23	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1413	24	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1413	25	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1413	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1413	27	follow	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1413	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1413	29	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1413	30	involved	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1413	31	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1413	32	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1413	33	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1413	34	smaller	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1413	35	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1413	36	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1413	37	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1413	38	occupations	occupation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1413	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1414	1	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1414	2	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1414	3	mr	mr	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1414	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1414	5	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1414	6	suffered	suffer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1414	7	from307	from307	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1414	8	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1414	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1414	10	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1414	11	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1414	12	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1414	13	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1414	14	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1414	15	concerning	concern	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1414	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1414	17	sufficiency	sufficiency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1414	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1414	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1414	20	plaintiff’s308	plaintiff’s308	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1414	21	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1414	22	2.0	2.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1414	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1414	24	suffice	suffice	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1414	25	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1414	26	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1414	27	supported	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1414	28	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1414	29	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1414	30	credible	credible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1414	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1414	32	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1414	33	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1414	34	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1414	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1414	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1415	1	301	301	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1415	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1416	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1416	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1416	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1416	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1416	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1416	6	re	re	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1416	7	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1416	8	prod	prod	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1416	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1417	1	liab	liab	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1417	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1418	1	litig	litig	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1418	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1419	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1419	2	no	no	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	1419	3	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1419	4	vi	vi	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1419	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1419	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1419	7	no	no	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	1419	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1420	1	mdl–875	mdl–875	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1420	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1420	3	2012	2012	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1420	4	wl	wl	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1420	5	760739	760739	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1420	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1420	7	e.d	e.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1420	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1420	9	pa	pa	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1420	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1421	1	feb	feb	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1421	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1421	3	17	17	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1421	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1421	5	2012	2012	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1421	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1421	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1422	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1422	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1422	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1422	4	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1422	5	got	get	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1422	6	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1422	7	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1422	8	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1422	9	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1422	10	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1422	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1422	12	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1422	13	sedgwick	sedgwick	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1422	14	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1422	15	bp	bp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1422	16	products	products	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1422	17	northern	northern	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1422	18	america	america	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1422	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1422	20	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1422	21	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1422	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1422	23	no	no	INTJ
inlawrev-20850	1422	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1423	1	g-13	g-13	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1423	2	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1423	3	188	188	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1423	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1423	5	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1423	6	wl	wl	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1423	7	6911543	6911543	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1423	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1423	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1423	10	*	*	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1423	11	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1423	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1423	13	s.d	s.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1423	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1423	15	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1423	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1423	17	nov	nov	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1423	18	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1423	19	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1423	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1423	21	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1423	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1423	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1424	1	302	302	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1424	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1425	1	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1425	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1425	3	lofton	lofton	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1425	4	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1425	5	mcneil	mcneil	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1425	6	consumer	consumer	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1425	7	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1425	8	specialty	specialty	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1425	9	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1425	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1425	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1425	12	682	682	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1425	13	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1425	14	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1425	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1426	1	2d	2d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1426	2	662	662	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1426	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1426	4	668	668	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1426	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1426	6	n.d	n.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1426	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1426	8	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1426	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1426	10	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1426	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1427	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1427	2	listing	list	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1427	3	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1427	4	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	5	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1427	6	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1427	7	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1427	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1427	9	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1427	10	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	11	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1427	12	95	95	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1427	13	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	14	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	15	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1427	16	requirements	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	17	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1427	18	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	19	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1427	20	meet	meet	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1427	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1427	22	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1427	23	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1427	24	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1427	26	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1427	27	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	28	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1427	29	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1427	30	wells	well	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1427	32	2009	2009	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1427	33	wl	wl	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	34	564303	564303	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1427	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1427	36	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1427	37	*	*	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1427	38	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1427	39	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1427	40	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1427	41	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1427	42	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1427	43	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1427	44	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	45	compliant	compliant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	46	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1427	47	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1427	48	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1427	49	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1427	50	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1427	51	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1427	52	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	53	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1427	54	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1427	55	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1427	56	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1427	57	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	58	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1427	59	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	60	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1427	61	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1427	62	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1427	63	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	64	satisfied	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1427	65	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1427	66	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	67	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1427	68	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1427	69	burton	burton	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1427	70	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1427	71	wyeth	wyeth	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1427	72	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1427	73	ayerst	ayerst	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1427	74	labs	lab	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1427	75	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1428	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1428	2	513	513	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1428	3	f.	f.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1428	4	supp.2	supp.2	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1428	5	d	d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1428	6	719	719	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1428	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1428	8	730	730	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1428	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1428	10	n.d	n.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1428	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1428	12	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1428	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1428	14	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1428	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1428	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1428	17	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1428	18	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1428	19	lofton	lofton	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1428	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1428	21	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1429	1	faust	faust	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1429	2	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1429	3	bnsf	bnsf	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1429	4	ry	ry	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1429	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1429	6	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1429	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1429	8	337	337	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1429	9	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1429	10	325	325	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1429	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1429	12	337	337	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1429	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1429	14	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1429	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1429	16	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1429	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1429	18	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1429	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1429	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1429	21	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1429	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1429	23	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1429	24	matt	matt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1429	25	dietz	dietz	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1429	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1429	27	198	198	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1429	28	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1429	29	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1429	30	805	805	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1429	31	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1429	32	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1429	33	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1429	34	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1429	35	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1429	36	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1429	37	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1429	38	requirements	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1429	39	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1429	40	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1429	41	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1429	42	pesticide	pesticide	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1429	43	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1429	44	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1429	45	laryngeal	laryngeal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1429	46	cancer	cancer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1429	47	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1429	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1430	1	303	303	X
inlawrev-20850	1430	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1431	1	daniels	daniels	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1431	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1431	3	99	99	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1431	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1431	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1431	6	730	730	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1431	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1431	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1431	9	none	none	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1431	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1431	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1431	12	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1431	13	[	[	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1431	14	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1431	15	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1431	16	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1431	17	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1431	18	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1431	19	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1431	20	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1431	21	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1431	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1431	23	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1431	24	requisite	requisite	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1431	25	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1431	26	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1431	27	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1431	28	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1431	29	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1431	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1431	31	none	none	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1431	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1431	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1431	34	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1431	35	reaches	reach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1431	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1431	37	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1431	38	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1431	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1431	40	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1431	41	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1431	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1432	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1432	2	daniels	daniels	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1432	3	family	family	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1432	4	presented	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1432	5	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1432	6	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1432	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1432	8	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1432	9	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1432	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1432	11	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1432	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1432	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1433	1	304	304	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1433	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1434	1	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1434	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1434	3	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1434	4	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1434	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1434	6	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1434	7	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1434	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1434	9	232	232	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1434	10	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1434	11	765	765	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1434	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1434	13	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1434	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1434	15	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1434	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1434	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1435	1	305	305	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1435	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1435	3	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1435	4	testified	testify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1435	5	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1435	6	did	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1435	7	roughly	roughly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1435	8	twenty	twenty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1435	9	brake	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1435	10	jobs	job	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1435	11	per	per	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1435	12	week	week	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1435	13	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1435	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1435	15	thirty	thirty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1435	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1435	17	five	five	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1435	18	year	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1435	19	career	career	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1435	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1436	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1436	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1436	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1436	4	866	866	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1436	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1437	1	assuming	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1437	2	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	1437	3	figures	figure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1437	4	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1437	5	accurate	accurate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1437	6	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1437	7	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1437	8	worked	work	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1437	9	fifty	fifty	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1437	10	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1437	11	weeks	week	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1437	12	per	per	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1437	13	year	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1437	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1437	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1437	16	total	total	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1437	17	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1437	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1437	19	brake	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1437	20	jobs	job	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1437	21	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1437	22	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1437	23	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1437	24	approximately	approximately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1437	25	35,000	35,000	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1437	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1438	1	306	306	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1438	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1439	1	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1439	2	testified	testify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1439	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1439	4	five	five	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1439	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1439	6	seven	seven	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1439	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1439	8	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	1439	9	week	week	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1439	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1439	11	jobs	job	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1439	12	involved	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1439	13	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1439	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1439	15	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1439	16	brakes	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1439	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1440	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1440	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1440	3	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1440	4	works	work	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1440	5	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1440	6	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1440	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1440	8	total	total	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1440	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1440	10	approximately	approximately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1440	11	8,750	8,750	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1440	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1440	13	12,250	12,250	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1440	14	jobs	job	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1440	15	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1440	16	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1440	17	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1440	18	involved	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1440	19	borgwarner	borgwarner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1440	20	brakes	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1440	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1441	1	307	307	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1441	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1442	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1442	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1442	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1442	4	774	774	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1442	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1443	1	308	308	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1443	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1444	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1444	2	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1444	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1444	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1444	5	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1444	6	contended	contend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1444	7	otherwise	otherwise	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1444	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1445	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1445	2	defense	defense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1445	3	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1445	4	testified	testify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1445	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1445	6	mr	mr	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1445	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1445	8	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1445	9	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1445	10	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1445	11	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1445	12	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1445	13	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1445	14	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1445	15	another	another	DET
inlawrev-20850	1445	16	form	form	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1445	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1445	18	interstitial	interstitial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1445	19	lung	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1445	20	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1445	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1446	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1446	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1446	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1446	4	768	768	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1446	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1447	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1447	2	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1447	3	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1447	4	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1447	5	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1447	6	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1447	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1447	8	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1447	9	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1447	10	169	169	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1447	11	total	total	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1447	12	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1447	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1447	14	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1447	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1447	16	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1447	17	received	receive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1447	18	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1447	19	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1447	20	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1447	21	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1447	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1447	23	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1448	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1448	2	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1448	3	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1448	4	of309	of309	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1448	5	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1448	6	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1448	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1448	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1448	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1448	10	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1448	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1448	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1448	13	amount	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1448	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1448	15	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1448	16	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1448	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1448	18	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1448	19	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1448	20	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1448	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1448	22	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1448	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1448	24	brake	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1448	25	pads	pad	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1448	26	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1448	27	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1448	28	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1448	29	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1448	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1448	31	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1448	32	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1448	33	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1448	34	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1448	35	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1448	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1449	1	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1449	2	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1449	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1449	4	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1449	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1449	6	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1449	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1449	8	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1449	9	causal	causal	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1449	10	link	link	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1449	11	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1449	12	plaintiff’s310	plaintiff’s310	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1449	13	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1449	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1449	15	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1449	16	aggregate	aggregate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1449	17	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1449	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1449	19	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1449	20	seemed	seem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1449	21	apparent	apparent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1449	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1449	23	questions	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1449	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1449	25	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1449	26	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1449	27	troubled	trouble	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1449	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1449	29	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1449	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1450	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1450	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1450	3	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1450	4	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1450	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1450	6	asbestosis311	asbestosis311	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1450	7	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1450	8	resulted	result	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1450	9	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1450	10	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1450	11	long	long	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1450	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1450	13	term	term	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1450	14	heavy	heavy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1450	15	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1450	16	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1450	17	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1450	18	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1450	19	shortterm	shortterm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1450	20	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1450	21	extremely	extremely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1450	22	heavy	heavy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1450	23	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1450	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1451	1	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1451	2	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	3	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1451	4	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1451	5	quantify	quantify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1451	6	the312	the312	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1451	7	aggregate	aggregate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1451	8	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1451	10	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	11	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1451	12	received	receive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1451	13	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1451	14	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1451	15	brake	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	16	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1451	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1451	19	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	20	reasoned	reason	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1451	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1451	22	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1451	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1451	24	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	25	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1451	26	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1451	27	evaluate	evaluate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1451	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1451	29	quantity	quantity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1451	31	respirable	respirable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1451	32	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	33	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1451	34	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1451	35	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	36	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1451	37	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1451	38	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1451	39	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1451	40	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1451	41	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1451	42	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	1451	43	amounts	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	44	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1451	45	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1451	46	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1451	47	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1451	48	asbestosis”—a	asbestosis”—a	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	49	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1451	51	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1451	52	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1451	53	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1452	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1452	2	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1452	3	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1452	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1452	6	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	7	invoked313	invoked313	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1452	8	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1452	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1452	10	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1452	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1452	12	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1452	13	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	14	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1452	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1452	16	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1452	17	were	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1452	18	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1452	19	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1452	20	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	21	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1452	22	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1452	23	brake	brake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	24	mechanics	mechanic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	25	face	face	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1452	26	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1452	27	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1452	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1452	29	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1452	30	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1452	32	asbestosis	asbestosis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1452	34	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1452	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1452	36	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	37	observed.314	observed.314	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	38	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1452	39	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	40	later	later	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1452	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1452	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1452	43	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1452	44	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1452	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1452	46	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1452	47	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1452	48	merck	merck	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1452	49	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1452	50	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1452	51	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1452	52	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1452	53	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1452	54	locked	lock	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1452	55	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1452	56	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1452	57	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	58	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1452	59	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1452	60	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1452	61	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1452	62	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1452	63	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1452	64	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	65	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1452	66	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1452	67	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1452	68	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1453	1	the315	the315	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1453	2	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1453	3	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1453	4	alleged	allege	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1453	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1453	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1453	7	prescription	prescription	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1453	8	drug	drug	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1453	9	vioxx	vioxx	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1453	10	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1453	11	leonel	leonel	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1453	12	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1453	13	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1453	14	fatal	fatal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1453	15	heart	heart	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1453	16	attack	attack	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1453	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1454	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1454	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	3	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1454	4	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1454	5	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1454	6	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1454	7	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1454	8	clinical	clinical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1454	9	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1454	11	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1454	12	well316	well316	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1454	13	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1454	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1454	15	meta	meta	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1454	17	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1454	19	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1454	20	trials	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1454	22	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1454	23	statistically	statistically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1454	24	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1454	25	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	26	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1454	27	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1454	28	vioxx	vioxx	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	29	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1454	30	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1454	31	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1454	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1454	33	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1454	35	heart	heart	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	36	attacks.317	attacks.317	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1454	37	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1454	38	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1454	39	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1454	40	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1454	41	plenty	plenty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1454	43	reason	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	44	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1454	45	question	question	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1454	46	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1454	47	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	48	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1454	49	garza	garza	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	50	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1454	51	particularly	particularly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1454	52	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1454	53	the	the	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1454	54	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1454	55	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1454	56	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1454	57	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1454	58	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1455	1	leonel	leonel	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1455	2	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1455	3	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1455	4	pre	pre	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1455	5	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1455	6	existing	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1455	7	heart	heart	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1455	8	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1455	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1455	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1455	11	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1455	12	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1455	13	easily	easily	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1455	14	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1455	15	viewed	view	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1455	16	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1455	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1455	18	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1455	19	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1455	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1455	21	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1455	22	a318	a318	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1455	23	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1455	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1455	25	concurrent	concurrent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1455	26	contributing	contributing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1455	27	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1455	28	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1455	29	vioxx	vioxx	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1455	30	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1455	31	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1455	32	necessarily	necessarily	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1455	33	showed	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1455	34	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1455	35	smoking	smoking	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1455	36	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1455	37	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1455	38	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1455	39	interstitial	interstitial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1455	40	lung	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1455	41	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1455	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1455	43	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1455	44	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1455	45	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1455	46	766	766	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1455	47	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1455	48	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1455	49	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1455	50	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1455	51	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1455	52	smoked	smoke	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1455	53	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1455	54	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1455	55	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1455	56	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1455	57	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1455	58	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1455	59	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1455	60	768	768	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1455	61	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1456	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1456	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1456	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1456	4	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1456	5	record	record	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1456	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1456	7	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1456	8	suggested	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1456	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1456	10	possibility	possibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1456	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1456	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1456	13	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1456	14	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1456	15	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1456	16	explained	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1456	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1456	18	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1456	19	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1456	20	symptoms	symptom	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1456	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1457	1	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1457	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1457	3	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1457	4	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1457	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1457	6	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1457	7	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1457	8	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1457	9	rely	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1457	10	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1457	11	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1457	12	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1457	13	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1457	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1457	15	reaching	reach	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1457	16	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1457	17	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1457	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1457	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1457	20	possibility	possibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1457	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1457	22	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1457	23	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1457	24	smoking	smoking	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1457	25	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1457	26	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1457	27	encouraged	encourage	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1457	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1457	29	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1457	30	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1457	31	set	set	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1457	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1457	33	high	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1457	34	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1457	35	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1457	36	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1457	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1457	38	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1457	39	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1457	40	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1457	41	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1457	42	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1457	43	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1457	44	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1457	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1458	1	309	309	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1458	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1459	1	sanders	sander	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1459	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1459	3	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1459	4	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1459	5	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1459	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1459	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1459	8	1168	1168	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1459	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1460	1	310	310	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1460	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	1460	3	flores	flores	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1460	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1460	5	232	232	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1460	6	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1460	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1460	8	771	771	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1460	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1460	10	72	72	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1460	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1460	12	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1460	13	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1460	14	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1460	15	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1460	16	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1460	17	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1460	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1460	19	record	record	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1460	20	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1460	21	reveals	reveal	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1460	22	nothing	nothing	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1460	23	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1460	24	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1460	25	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1460	26	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1460	27	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1460	28	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1460	29	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1460	30	inhaled	inhale	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1460	31	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1460	32	nor	nor	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1460	33	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1460	34	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1460	35	what	what	DET
inlawrev-20850	1460	36	percentage	percentage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1460	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1460	38	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1460	39	indeterminate	indeterminate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1460	40	amount	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1460	41	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1460	42	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1460	43	originated	originate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1460	44	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1460	45	borg	borg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1460	46	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1460	47	warner	warner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1460	48	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1460	49	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1460	50	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1460	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1461	1	311	311	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1461	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1462	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1462	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1462	3	312	312	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1462	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1463	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1463	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1463	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1463	4	771	771	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1463	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1464	1	313	313	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1464	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1465	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1465	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1465	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1465	4	771	771	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1465	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1465	6	72	72	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1465	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1465	8	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1465	9	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1465	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1465	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1466	1	314	314	X
inlawrev-20850	1466	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1467	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1467	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1467	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1467	4	772	772	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1467	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1467	6	footnote	footnote	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1467	7	omitted	omit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1467	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1467	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1468	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1468	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1468	3	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1468	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1468	5	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1468	6	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1468	7	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1468	8	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1468	9	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1468	10	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1468	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1468	12	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1468	13	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1468	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1468	15	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1468	16	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1468	17	emphasized	emphasize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1468	18	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1468	19	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1468	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1468	21	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1468	22	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1468	23	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1468	24	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1468	25	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1468	26	strikes	strike	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1468	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1468	28	balance	balance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1468	29	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1468	30	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1468	31	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1468	32	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1468	33	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1468	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1469	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1469	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1469	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1469	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1469	5	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1469	6	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1469	7	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1469	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1469	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1469	10	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1469	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1470	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1470	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1470	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1470	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1470	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1470	6	706	706	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1470	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1470	8	715	715	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1470	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1470	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1470	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1470	12	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1470	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1470	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1470	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1471	1	315	315	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1471	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	1472	1	347	347	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1472	2	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1472	3	256	256	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1472	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1472	5	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1472	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1472	7	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1472	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1472	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1473	1	316	316	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1473	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1474	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1474	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1474	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1474	4	259	259	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1474	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1474	6	60	60	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1474	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1474	8	317	317	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1474	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1475	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1475	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1475	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1475	4	266	266	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1475	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1475	6	67	67	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1475	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1475	8	318	318	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1475	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1476	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1476	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1476	3	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1476	4	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1476	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1476	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1476	7	long	long	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1476	8	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1476	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1476	10	heart	heart	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1476	11	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1476	12	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1476	13	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1476	14	length	length	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1476	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1477	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1477	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1477	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1477	4	259	259	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1477	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1477	6	60	60	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1477	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1478	1	170	170	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1478	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1478	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1478	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1479	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1479	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1479	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1480	1	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1480	2	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1480	3	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1480	4	absurd	absurd	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1480	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1481	1	faced	face	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1481	2	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1481	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1481	4	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1481	5	verdict	verdict	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1481	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1481	7	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1481	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1481	9	favor	favor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1481	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1481	11	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1481	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1481	13	the319	the319	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1481	14	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1481	15	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1481	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1481	17	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1481	18	unanimously	unanimously	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1481	19	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1481	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1481	21	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1481	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1481	23	garzas	garzas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1481	24	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1481	25	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1481	26	present	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1481	27	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1481	28	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1481	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1481	30	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1481	31	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1481	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1481	33	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1481	34	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1481	35	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1481	36	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1481	37	present	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1481	38	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1481	39	than320	than320	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1481	40	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1481	41	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1481	42	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1481	43	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1481	44	statistically	statistically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1481	45	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1481	46	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1481	47	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1481	48	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1481	49	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1481	50	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1481	51	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1481	52	subjects	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1481	53	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1481	54	took	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1481	55	vioxx	vioxx	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1481	56	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1481	57	smaller	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1481	58	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1481	59	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1481	60	equal	equal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1481	61	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1481	62	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1481	63	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1481	64	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1481	65	consumed.321	consumed.321	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1481	66	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1481	67	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1481	68	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1481	69	framing	frame	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1481	70	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1481	71	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1481	72	appear	appear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1481	73	inadvertent	inadvertent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1481	74	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1482	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1482	2	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1482	3	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1482	4	carefully	carefully	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1482	5	defined	define	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1482	6	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	7	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	8	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1482	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1482	10	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1482	12	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	13	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1482	14	capable	capable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1482	16	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1482	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1482	18	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	19	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	20	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	21	condition	condition	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1482	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1482	24	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	25	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	26	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1482	27	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1482	28	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1482	29	that322	that322	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1482	30	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1482	31	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	32	holds	hold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1482	34	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	35	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1482	36	reiterate	reiterate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1482	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1482	38	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	39	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	40	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	41	attempt	attempt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1482	42	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1482	43	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1482	44	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	45	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	46	using	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1482	47	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	48	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	49	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1482	50	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1482	51	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	52	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1482	54	reliability	reliability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	55	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1482	56	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1482	58	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	59	demonstrate	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1482	60	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1482	61	statistically	statistically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1482	62	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1482	63	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	64	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1482	65	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1482	66	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1482	67	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1482	68	”323	”323	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1483	1	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1483	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1483	3	authors	author	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1483	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1483	5	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1483	6	treatise	treatise	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1483	7	stated	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1483	8	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1483	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1483	10	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1483	11	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1483	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1483	13	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1483	14	correct	correct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1483	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1483	16	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1484	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1484	2	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1484	3	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1484	4	was324	was324	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1484	5	repeated	repeat	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1484	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1484	7	bostic.325	bostic.325	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1484	8	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1484	9	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1484	10	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1484	11	confusion	confusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1484	12	reigns	reign	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1484	13	one	one	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1484	14	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1484	15	argue	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1484	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1484	17	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1484	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1484	19	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1484	20	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1484	21	insist	insist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1484	22	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1484	23	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1484	24	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1484	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1484	26	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1484	27	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1484	28	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1484	29	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1484	30	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1484	31	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1484	32	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1484	33	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1484	34	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1484	35	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1484	36	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1484	37	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1484	38	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1484	39	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1484	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1484	41	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1484	42	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1484	43	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1484	44	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1484	45	matter	matter	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1484	46	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1484	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1484	48	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1484	49	labels	label	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1484	50	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1484	51	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1484	52	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1484	53	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1484	54	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1484	55	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1484	56	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1484	57	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1484	58	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1484	59	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1484	60	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1484	61	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1484	62	neither	neither	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1484	63	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1485	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1485	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1485	3	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1485	4	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1485	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1486	1	first	first	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1486	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1486	3	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1486	4	matters	matter	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1486	5	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1486	6	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1486	7	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1486	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1486	9	making	making	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1486	10	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1486	11	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1486	12	coherent	coherent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1486	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1486	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1486	15	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1486	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1486	17	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1486	18	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1486	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1486	20	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1486	21	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1486	22	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1486	23	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1486	24	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1486	25	all	all	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1486	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1486	27	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1486	28	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1486	29	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1486	30	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1486	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1486	32	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1486	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1486	34	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1486	35	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1486	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1487	1	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1487	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1487	3	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1487	4	matters	matter	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1487	5	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1487	6	confusion	confusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1487	7	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1487	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1487	9	role	role	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1487	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1487	11	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1487	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1487	13	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1487	14	facilitated	facilitate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1487	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1487	16	shifts	shift	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1487	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1487	18	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1487	19	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1487	20	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1487	21	led	lead	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1487	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1487	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1487	24	internally	internally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1487	25	inconsistent	inconsistent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1487	26	holdings	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1487	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1487	28	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1487	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1488	1	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1488	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1488	3	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1488	4	matters	matter	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1488	5	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1488	6	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1488	7	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1488	8	treat	treat	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1488	9	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1488	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1488	11	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1488	12	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1488	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1488	14	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1488	15	of326	of326	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1488	16	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1488	17	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1488	18	inevitably	inevitably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1488	19	founder	founder	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1488	20	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1488	21	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1488	22	try	try	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1488	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1488	24	articulate	articulate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1488	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1488	26	meaning	meaning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1488	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1488	28	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1488	29	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1488	30	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1488	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1488	32	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1488	33	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1488	34	try	try	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1488	35	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1488	36	understand	understand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1488	37	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1488	38	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1488	39	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1488	40	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1488	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1489	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1489	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1489	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1489	4	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1489	5	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1489	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1489	7	disconnect	disconnect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1489	8	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1489	9	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1489	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1489	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1489	12	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1489	13	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1489	14	turned	turn	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1489	15	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1489	16	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1489	17	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1489	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1489	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1489	20	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1489	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1489	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1489	23	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1489	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1489	25	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1489	26	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1489	27	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1489	28	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1489	29	319	319	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1489	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1490	1	merck	merck	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1490	2	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1490	3	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1490	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1490	5	vioxx	vioxx	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1490	6	revealed	reveal	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1490	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1490	8	higher	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1490	9	incidence	incidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1490	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1490	11	adverse	adverse	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1490	12	cardiovascular	cardiovascular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1490	13	events	event	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1490	14	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1490	15	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1490	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1490	17	patients	patient	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1490	18	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1490	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1490	20	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1490	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1490	22	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1490	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1490	24	atherosclerotic	atherosclerotic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1490	25	cardiovascular	cardiovascular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1490	26	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1490	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1490	28	’’	’'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1491	1	mcdarby	mcdarby	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1491	2	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1491	3	merck	merck	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1491	4	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1491	5	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1491	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1491	7	949	949	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1491	8	a.2d	a.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1491	9	223	223	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1491	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1491	11	234	234	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1491	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1491	13	n.j	n.j	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1491	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1491	15	super	super	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1491	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1491	17	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1491	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1491	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1492	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1492	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1492	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1492	4	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1492	5	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1492	6	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1492	7	chosen	choose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1492	8	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1492	9	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1492	10	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1492	11	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1492	12	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1492	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1492	14	1	1	X
inlawrev-20850	1492	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1492	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1492	17	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1492	18	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1492	19	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1492	20	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1492	21	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1492	22	heart	heart	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1492	23	attack	attack	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1492	24	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1492	25	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1492	26	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1492	27	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1492	28	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1492	29	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1492	30	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1492	31	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1492	32	vioxx	vioxx	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1492	33	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1492	34	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1492	35	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1492	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1492	37	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1493	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1493	2	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1493	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1493	4	vioxx	vioxx	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1493	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1493	6	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1493	7	acting	act	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1493	8	alone	alone	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1493	9	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1493	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1493	11	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1493	12	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1493	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1493	14	heart	heart	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1493	15	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1493	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1493	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1493	18	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1493	19	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1493	20	heart	heart	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1493	21	attack	attack	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1493	22	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1493	23	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1493	24	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1493	25	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1493	26	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1493	27	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1493	28	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1493	29	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1493	30	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1493	31	did	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1493	32	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1493	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1494	1	320	320	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1494	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1494	3	garza	garza	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1494	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1494	5	347	347	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1494	6	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1494	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1494	8	268	268	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1494	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1494	10	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1494	11	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1494	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1494	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1495	1	321	321	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1495	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1496	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1496	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1496	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1496	4	266	266	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1496	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1496	6	67	67	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1496	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1496	8	discussing	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1496	9	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1496	10	upon	upon	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1496	11	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1496	12	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1496	13	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1496	14	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1496	15	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1496	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1496	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1497	1	322	322	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1497	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1498	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1498	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1498	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1498	4	262	262	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1498	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1498	6	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1498	7	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1498	8	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1498	9	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1498	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1498	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1498	12	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1498	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1499	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1499	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1499	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1499	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1499	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1499	6	706	706	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1499	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1499	8	714	714	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1499	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1499	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1499	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1499	12	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1499	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1499	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1499	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1500	1	323	323	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1500	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1501	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1501	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1501	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1501	4	265	265	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1501	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1502	1	324	324	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1502	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1503	1	david	david	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1503	2	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1503	3	faigman	faigman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1503	4	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1503	5	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1503	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1503	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1503	8	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1503	9	modern	modern	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1503	10	sci	sci	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1503	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1503	12	evid	evid	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1503	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1504	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1504	2	23:27	23:27	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1504	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1504	4	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1504	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1504	6	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1504	7	ed	ed	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1504	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1504	9	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1504	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1504	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1505	1	325	325	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1505	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1506	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1506	3	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1506	4	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1506	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	6	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1506	7	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1506	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1506	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	10	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1506	11	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1506	12	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1506	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	14	349	349	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1506	15	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1506	16	n.74	n.74	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1506	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	18	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1506	19	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1506	20	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1506	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	22	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	23	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1506	24	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1506	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	26	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1506	27	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1506	28	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1506	29	715	715	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1506	30	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1506	31	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1506	32	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	33	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	34	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1506	35	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1506	36	i	i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1506	37	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1506	38	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1506	39	362	362	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1506	40	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	41	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1506	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	43	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1506	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	45	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1506	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	47	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	48	nothing	nothing	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1506	49	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1506	50	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1506	51	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1506	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	53	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1506	54	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1506	55	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1506	56	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1506	57	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1506	58	satisfying	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1506	59	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1506	60	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1506	61	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	62	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1506	63	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1506	64	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1506	65	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1507	1	326	326	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1507	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1507	3	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1507	4	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1507	5	part	part	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1507	6	ii.b	ii.b	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1507	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1508	1	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1508	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1508	3	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1508	4	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1508	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1508	6	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1508	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1508	8	171	171	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1508	9	conceded	concede	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1508	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1508	11	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1508	12	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1508	13	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1508	14	327	327	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1508	15	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1508	16	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1508	17	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1508	18	concerned	concerned	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1508	19	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1508	20	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1508	21	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1508	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1509	1	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1509	2	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1509	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1509	4	never	never	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1509	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1509	6	ultimate	ultimate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1509	7	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1509	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1509	9	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1509	10	tried	try	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1509	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1509	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1509	13	finder	finder	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1509	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1509	15	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1509	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1509	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1509	18	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1509	19	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1509	20	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1509	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1510	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1510	2	ultimate	ultimate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1510	3	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1510	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1510	5	always	always	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1510	6	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1510	7	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1510	8	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1510	9	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1510	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1510	11	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1510	12	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1510	13	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1510	14	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1510	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1510	16	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1510	17	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1510	18	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1510	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1510	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1510	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1511	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1512	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1512	2	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1512	4	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1512	5	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1512	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	7	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	8	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	9	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1512	11	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	12	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	13	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1512	14	unavailable	unavailable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1512	16	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	17	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	18	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1512	19	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1512	20	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1512	21	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1512	22	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1512	23	alternative	alternative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	24	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1512	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1512	26	step	step	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	27	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	28	whereby	whereby	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1512	30	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	31	establishes	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1512	32	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	33	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	34	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1512	35	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	36	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1512	38	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	39	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1512	40	demonstrates	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1512	41	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	42	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1512	43	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	44	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1512	45	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	46	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1512	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1512	48	subjects	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	49	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1512	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1512	51	studies.328	studies.328	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1512	52	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1512	53	bifurcation	bifurcation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	54	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1512	55	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1512	56	mimicked	mimic	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1512	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1512	58	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1512	59	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1512	60	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1512	61	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1512	62	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1512	63	separation	separation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	64	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1512	65	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1512	66	reliability	reliability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	67	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1512	68	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	69	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1512	70	fit	fit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	71	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1512	72	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1512	73	criteria	criterion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	74	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1512	75	admissibility	admissibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	76	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1512	77	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	78	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	79	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1512	80	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	81	treated	treat	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1512	82	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1512	83	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1512	84	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1512	85	boundary	boundary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	86	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1512	87	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	88	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	89	specific329	specific329	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1512	90	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1512	91	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1513	1	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1513	2	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1513	3	own	own	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1513	4	terms	term	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1513	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1513	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1513	7	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1513	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1513	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1513	10	description	description	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1513	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1513	12	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1513	13	unquestionably	unquestionably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1513	14	included	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1513	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1513	16	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1513	17	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1513	18	plus	plus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1513	19	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1513	20	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1513	21	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1513	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1513	23	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1513	24	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1513	25	criteria	criterion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1513	26	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1513	27	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1513	28	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1513	29	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1513	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1513	31	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1514	1	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1514	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1514	3	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1514	4	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1514	5	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1514	6	justices	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1514	7	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1514	8	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1514	9	rejected330	rejected330	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1514	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1514	11	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1514	12	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1514	13	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1514	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1514	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1514	16	larger	large	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1514	17	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1514	18	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1514	19	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1514	20	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1514	21	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	1514	22	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1514	23	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1514	24	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1514	25	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1514	26	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1514	27	adopted	adopt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1514	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1514	29	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1514	30	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1514	31	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1514	32	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1514	33	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1514	34	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1514	35	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1514	36	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1514	37	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1514	38	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1514	39	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1514	40	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1514	41	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1514	42	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1514	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1515	1	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	1515	2	nine	nine	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1515	3	justices	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1515	4	agreed	agree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1515	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1515	6	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1515	7	a331	a331	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1515	8	327	327	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1515	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1516	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1516	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1516	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1516	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1516	6	348	348	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1516	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1516	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1516	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1516	10	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1516	11	extent	extent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	12	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	13	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1516	14	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1516	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1516	17	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1516	19	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1516	20	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	21	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1516	22	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1516	23	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	1516	24	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	25	supported	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1516	26	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1516	27	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	28	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1516	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1516	30	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1516	32	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1516	33	bendectin	bendectin	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1516	34	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1516	35	capable	capable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1516	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1516	37	causing	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1516	38	birth	birth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	39	defects	defect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1516	41	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1516	42	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1516	43	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1516	44	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1516	45	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1516	46	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1516	47	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1516	48	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1516	49	today	today	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	50	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1516	51	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1516	53	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1516	54	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	55	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1516	56	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1516	57	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1516	58	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1516	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	1	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1517	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	3	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1517	4	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1517	5	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1517	6	dispute	dispute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1517	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1517	9	purposes	purpose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1517	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1517	11	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1517	12	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1517	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	14	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1517	15	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1517	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1517	17	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1517	18	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1517	19	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1517	20	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1517	21	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1517	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	23	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	25	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	26	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1517	27	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1517	28	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1517	29	351	351	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1517	30	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	31	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	32	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1517	33	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1517	34	above	above	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1517	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	36	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1517	37	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1517	38	concerned	concern	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1517	39	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1517	40	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1517	41	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1517	42	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1517	43	today	today	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1517	44	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1517	45	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1517	46	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1517	47	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1517	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	49	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	50	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1517	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1518	1	328	328	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1518	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1519	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1519	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1519	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1519	4	351	351	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1519	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1519	6	329	329	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1519	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1520	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1520	2	daubert	daubert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1520	3	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1520	4	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1520	5	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1520	6	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1520	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1520	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1520	9	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1520	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1520	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1520	12	509	509	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1520	13	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1520	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1520	15	579	579	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1520	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1520	17	590	590	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1520	18	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1520	19	91	91	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1520	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1520	21	1993	1993	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1520	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1520	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1520	24	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1520	25	reliability	reliability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1520	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1520	27	fit	fit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1520	28	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1520	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1521	1	330	330	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1521	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	1522	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	2	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1522	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	7	717	717	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1522	8	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1522	9	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1522	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	11	adopting	adopt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1522	13	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	15	plus	plus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	16	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	17	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	18	rationally	rationally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1522	19	connected	connect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	20	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1522	22	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	23	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	25	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	26	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1522	27	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1522	28	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	29	718	718	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1522	30	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1522	31	19	19	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1522	32	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	33	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	34	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	35	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1522	36	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	37	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	38	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	39	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	40	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	41	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	43	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	44	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1522	45	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1522	46	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1522	47	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	48	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	49	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	50	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	51	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	52	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	53	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	54	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1522	55	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1522	56	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	57	721	721	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1522	58	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1522	59	24	24	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1522	60	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	61	establishing	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	62	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	63	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	64	standards	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	65	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	66	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	67	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	68	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	69	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	70	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1522	71	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1522	72	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	73	720	720	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1522	74	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1522	75	21	21	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1522	76	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	77	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	78	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1522	79	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1522	80	survive	survive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	81	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	82	sufficiency	sufficiency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	83	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	84	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1522	85	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	86	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1522	87	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	88	do	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	89	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	90	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	91	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	92	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	93	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	94	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	95	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	96	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	97	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	98	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	99	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1522	100	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	101	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	102	proving	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	103	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1522	104	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	105	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1522	106	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	107	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	108	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1522	109	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	110	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1522	111	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	112	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1522	113	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1522	114	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	115	ruling	rule	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1522	116	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1522	117	plausible	plausible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	118	alternative	alternative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1522	119	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1522	120	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1522	121	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1523	1	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1523	2	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1523	3	else	else	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1523	4	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1523	5	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1523	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1523	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1523	8	line	line	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1523	9	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1523	10	reliability	reliability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1523	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1523	12	sufficiency	sufficiency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1523	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1523	14	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1523	15	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1523	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1523	17	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1523	18	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1523	19	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1523	20	times	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1523	21	blurry	blurry	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1523	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1524	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1524	2	framed	frame	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1524	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1524	4	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1524	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1524	6	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1524	7	similarity	similarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1524	8	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1524	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1524	10	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1524	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1524	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1524	13	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1524	14	subjects	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1524	15	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1524	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1524	17	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1524	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1524	19	sufficiency	sufficiency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1524	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1524	21	presumably	presumably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1524	22	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1524	23	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1524	24	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1524	25	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1524	26	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1524	27	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1524	28	introduced	introduce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1524	29	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1524	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1524	31	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1524	32	immediately	immediately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1524	33	afterward	afterward	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1524	34	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1524	35	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1524	36	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1524	37	emphasize	emphasize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1524	38	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1524	39	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1524	40	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1524	41	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1524	42	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1524	43	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1524	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1524	45	reliability	reliability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1524	46	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1524	47	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	1524	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1524	49	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1524	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1524	51	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1525	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1525	2	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1525	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1525	4	720	720	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1525	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1525	6	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1525	7	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1525	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1525	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1526	1	331	331	X
inlawrev-20850	1526	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1527	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1527	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1527	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1527	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1527	6	362	362	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1527	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1527	8	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1527	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1527	10	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1527	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1527	12	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1527	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1527	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1527	15	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1527	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1527	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1527	18	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	19	using	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1527	20	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1527	21	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	22	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1527	23	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1527	24	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1527	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1527	27	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	28	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1527	29	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1527	30	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1527	31	doubles	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1527	32	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	33	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1527	34	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1527	35	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1527	36	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	37	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1527	38	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1527	39	i	i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1527	40	d	d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1527	41	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1527	42	370	370	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1527	43	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1527	44	explaining	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1527	45	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1527	46	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1527	47	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1527	48	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1527	49	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1527	50	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	51	shows	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1527	52	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1527	53	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	54	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1527	55	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1527	56	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1527	57	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1527	58	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1527	59	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1527	60	population	population	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	61	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1527	62	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1527	63	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1527	64	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1527	65	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	66	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1527	67	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1527	68	toxin	toxin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	69	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1527	70	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1527	71	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	1527	72	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	73	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1527	74	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1527	75	demands	demand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1527	76	172	172	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1527	77	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1527	78	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1527	79	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1528	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1528	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1528	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1529	1	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1530	1	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	2	relies	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1530	3	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1530	4	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1530	5	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1530	7	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	8	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1530	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1530	10	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1530	11	get	get	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1530	12	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1530	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1530	14	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1530	15	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1530	16	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1530	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1530	18	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1530	19	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1530	20	reliability	reliability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	21	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1530	22	hurdles	hurdle	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	23	listed	list	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1530	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1530	25	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1530	26	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1530	27	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1530	28	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1530	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1530	31	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	32	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1530	33	similarity	similarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	34	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1530	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1530	36	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	37	subjects	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	38	constitutes	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1530	39	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	40	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1530	41	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1530	42	causation.332	causation.332	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	43	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1530	44	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1530	45	face	face	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1530	47	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1530	48	formulation	formulation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	49	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1530	50	appear	appear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1530	51	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1530	52	adopt	adopt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1530	53	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1530	54	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1530	55	weak	weak	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1530	56	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1530	57	version	version	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	58	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1530	59	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1530	60	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	61	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	62	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1530	63	freeing	free	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1530	64	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	65	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1530	66	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1530	67	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1530	68	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1530	69	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1530	70	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1530	71	plus	plus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	72	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	73	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1530	74	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1530	75	almost	almost	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1530	76	always	always	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1530	77	impossible	impossible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1530	78	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1530	79	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1530	80	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1530	81	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1530	82	demand	demand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	83	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1530	84	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1530	85	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1530	86	particularistic	particularistic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1530	87	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	88	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1530	89	support	support	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	90	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1530	91	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1530	92	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1530	93	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1531	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1531	2	strictness	strictness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1531	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1531	4	the333	the333	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1531	5	similarity	similarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1531	6	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1531	7	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1531	8	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1531	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1531	10	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1531	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1531	12	undermines	undermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1531	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1531	14	notion	notion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1531	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1531	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1531	17	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1531	18	version	version	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1531	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1531	20	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1531	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1531	22	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1531	23	conceded	concede	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1531	24	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1531	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1531	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1531	27	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1531	28	indeterminacy	indeterminacy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1531	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1531	30	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1531	31	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1531	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1532	1	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1532	2	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1532	3	similarity	similarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1532	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1532	5	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1532	6	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1532	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1532	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1532	9	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1532	10	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1532	11	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1532	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1532	13	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1532	14	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1532	15	she	she	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1532	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1532	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1533	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1534	1	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1534	2	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1534	3	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1534	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1534	5	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1534	6	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1534	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1534	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1534	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1535	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1535	2	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1535	3	]	]	X
inlawrev-20850	1535	4	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1535	5	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1535	6	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1535	7	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1535	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1535	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1535	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1536	1	comparable	comparable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1536	2	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1536	3	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1536	4	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1536	5	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1536	6	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1536	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1536	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1536	9	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1536	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1536	11	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1537	1	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1537	2	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1537	3	latency	latency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1537	4	and334	and334	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1537	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1537	6	observational	observational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1537	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1537	8	often	often	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1537	9	retrospective	retrospective	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1537	10	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1537	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1537	12	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1537	13	investigation	investigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1537	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1537	15	proving	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1537	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1537	17	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1537	18	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1537	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1537	20	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1537	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1537	22	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1537	23	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1537	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1537	25	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1537	26	subjects	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1537	27	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1537	28	apt	apt	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1537	29	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1537	30	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1537	31	difficult	difficult	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1537	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1538	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1538	2	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1538	3	assuming	assume	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1538	4	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1538	5	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1538	6	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1538	7	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1538	8	compared	compare	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1538	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1538	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1538	11	havner335	havner335	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1538	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1538	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1538	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1538	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1539	1	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1539	2	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1539	3	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1539	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1539	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1540	1	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1540	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1541	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1541	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	4	351	351	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1541	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	6	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1541	7	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	9	similarity	similarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	10	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1541	12	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	13	step	step	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1541	16	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1541	17	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	18	step	step	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	19	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	20	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	21	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1541	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1541	23	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	24	step	step	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	25	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1541	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1541	27	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1541	28	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	29	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	30	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	31	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	32	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	33	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1541	34	satisfy	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1541	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1541	36	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1541	37	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	38	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	39	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	40	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	41	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	42	requirements	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	43	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	44	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	45	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1541	46	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1541	47	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	48	362	362	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1541	49	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	50	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1541	51	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	52	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1541	53	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	54	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1541	55	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	56	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	57	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	58	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	59	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1541	60	wake	wake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	61	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	62	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	63	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	64	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	65	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	66	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	67	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1541	68	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	69	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1541	70	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1541	71	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	72	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	73	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1541	74	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	75	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1541	76	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	77	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	78	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1541	79	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	80	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1541	81	toxin	toxin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	82	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1541	83	comparable	comparable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	84	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	85	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	86	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	87	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	88	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1541	89	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	90	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	91	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1541	92	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	93	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1541	94	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	95	dose	dose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1541	96	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	97	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1541	98	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	99	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	100	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1541	101	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	102	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	103	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	104	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	105	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	106	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	107	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1541	108	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1541	109	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	110	371	371	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1541	111	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	112	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1541	113	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	114	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1541	115	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	116	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1541	117	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	118	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	119	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	120	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	121	respect	respect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1541	122	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1541	123	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	124	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1541	125	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1542	1	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1542	2	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1542	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1542	4	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1542	5	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1542	6	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1542	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1542	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1542	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1543	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1543	2	t]he	t]he	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1543	3	claimant	claimant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1543	4	must	must	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1543	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1543	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1543	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1544	1	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1544	2	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1544	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1544	4	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1544	5	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1544	6	she	she	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1544	7	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1544	8	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1544	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1544	10	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1544	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1544	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1544	13	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1544	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1544	15	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1544	16	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1544	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1544	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1544	19	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1544	20	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1544	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1544	22	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1544	23	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1544	24	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1544	25	720	720	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1544	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1544	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1545	1	333	333	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1545	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1546	1	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1546	2	least	least	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1546	3	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1546	4	lower	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1546	5	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1546	6	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1546	7	seems	seem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1546	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1546	9	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1546	10	understood	understand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1546	11	havner	havner	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1546	12	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1546	13	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1546	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1547	1	coastal	coastal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1547	2	tankships	tankship	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1547	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1547	4	u.s.a	u.s.a	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1547	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1547	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1547	7	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1547	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1548	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1548	2	anderson	anderson	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1548	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1548	4	87	87	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1548	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1548	6	591	591	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1548	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1548	8	602	602	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1548	9	n.21	n.21	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1548	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1548	11	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1548	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1548	13	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1548	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1548	15	2002	2002	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1548	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1548	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1548	18	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1548	19	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1548	20	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1548	21	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1548	22	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1548	23	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1548	24	circumstantially	circumstantially	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1548	25	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1548	26	taking	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1548	27	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1548	28	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1548	29	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1548	30	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1548	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1548	32	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1548	33	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1548	34	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1548	35	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1548	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1548	37	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1548	38	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1548	39	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1548	40	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1548	41	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1548	42	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1548	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1548	44	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1548	45	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1548	46	subjects	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1548	47	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1548	48	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1548	49	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1548	50	allowing	allow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1548	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1548	52	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1548	53	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1548	54	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1548	55	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1548	56	both	both	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1548	57	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1548	58	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1548	59	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1548	60	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1548	61	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1548	62	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1549	1	another	another	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1549	2	understood	understand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1549	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1549	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1549	5	logic	logic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1549	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1549	7	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1549	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1549	9	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1549	10	inherently	inherently	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1549	11	applies	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1549	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1549	13	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1549	14	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1549	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1550	1	mo	mo	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1550	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1551	1	pac	pac	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1551	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1552	1	r.r	r.r	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1552	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1552	3	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1552	4	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1552	5	navarro	navarro	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1552	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1552	7	90	90	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1552	8	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1552	9	747	747	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1552	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1552	11	758	758	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1552	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1552	13	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1552	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1552	15	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1552	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1552	17	2002	2002	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1552	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1553	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1553	2	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1553	3	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1553	4	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1553	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1553	6	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1553	7	shown	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1553	8	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1553	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1553	10	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1553	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1553	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1553	13	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1553	14	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1553	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1553	16	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1553	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1553	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1554	1	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1554	2	typically	typically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1554	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1554	4	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1554	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1554	6	lower	lower	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1554	7	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1554	8	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1554	9	expressed	express	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1554	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1554	11	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1554	12	distinction	distinction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1554	13	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1554	14	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1554	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1554	16	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1554	17	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1554	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1554	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1554	20	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1554	21	terms	term	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1554	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1554	23	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1554	24	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1554	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1554	26	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1554	27	adopted	adopt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1554	28	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1554	29	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1554	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1555	1	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1555	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1555	3	lofton	lofton	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1555	4	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1555	5	mcneil	mcneil	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1555	6	consumer	consumer	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1555	7	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1555	8	specialty	specialty	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1555	9	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1555	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1555	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1555	12	682	682	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1555	13	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1555	14	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1555	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1556	1	2d	2d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1556	2	662	662	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1556	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1556	4	668	668	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1556	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1556	6	w.d	w.d	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1556	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1557	1	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1557	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1557	3	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1557	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1557	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1557	6	listing	list	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1557	7	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1557	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1557	9	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1557	10	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1557	11	component	component	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1557	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1557	13	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1557	14	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1557	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1557	16	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1558	1	faust	faust	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1558	2	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1558	3	bnsf	bnsf	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1558	4	ry	ry	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1558	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1558	6	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1558	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1558	8	337	337	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1558	9	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1558	10	325	325	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1558	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1558	12	337	337	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1558	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1558	14	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1558	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1558	16	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1558	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1558	18	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1558	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1558	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1558	21	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1558	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1558	23	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1558	24	matt	matt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1558	25	dietz	dietz	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1558	26	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1559	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1559	2	torres	torres	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1559	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1559	4	198	198	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1559	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1559	6	798	798	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1559	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1559	8	804	804	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1559	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1559	10	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1559	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1559	12	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1559	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1559	14	2006	2006	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1559	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1560	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1560	2	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1560	3	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1560	4	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1560	5	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1560	6	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1560	7	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1560	8	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1560	9	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1560	10	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1560	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1560	12	only	only	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1560	13	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1560	14	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1560	15	reported	report	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1560	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1560	17	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1560	18	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1560	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1560	20	1.5	1.5	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1560	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1560	22	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1560	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1560	24	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1560	25	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1560	26	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1560	27	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1560	28	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1560	29	establishing	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1560	30	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1560	31	similarity	similarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1560	32	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1560	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1560	34	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1560	35	subjects	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1560	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1560	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1561	1	334	334	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1561	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1562	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1562	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1562	3	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1562	4	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1562	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1562	6	720	720	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1562	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1562	8	335	335	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1562	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1563	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1563	2	holcomb	holcomb	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1563	3	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1563	4	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1563	5	pac	pac	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1563	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1563	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1563	8	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1563	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1563	10	289	289	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1563	11	p.3d	p.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1563	12	188	188	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1563	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1563	14	195	195	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1563	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1563	16	nev	nev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1563	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1563	18	2012	2012	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1563	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1563	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1563	21	concluding	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1563	22	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1563	23	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1563	24	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1563	25	swings	swing	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1563	26	too	too	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1563	27	far	far	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1563	28	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1563	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1563	30	favor	favor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1563	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1563	32	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1563	33	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1563	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1563	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1563	36	difficulty	difficulty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1563	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1563	38	quantifying	quantify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1563	39	defendantspecific	defendantspecific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1563	40	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1563	41	cumulative	cumulative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1563	42	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1563	43	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1563	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1564	1	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1564	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1564	3	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1564	4	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1564	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1564	6	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1564	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1564	8	173	173	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1564	9	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1564	10	eliminates	eliminate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1564	11	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1564	12	possibility	possibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1564	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1564	14	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1564	15	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1564	16	lower	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1564	17	doses	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1564	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1564	19	regardless	regardless	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1564	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1564	21	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1564	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1564	23	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1564	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1564	25	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1564	26	relationship	relationship	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1564	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1565	1	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1565	2	take	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1565	3	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1565	4	oversimplified	oversimplified	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1565	5	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1565	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1565	7	imagine	imagine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1565	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1565	9	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1565	10	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1565	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1565	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1565	13	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1565	14	measure	measure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1565	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1565	16	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1565	17	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1565	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1565	19	8.0	8.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1565	20	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1565	21	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1565	22	x	x	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1565	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1565	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1565	25	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1565	26	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1565	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1565	28	1.0	1.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1565	29	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1565	30	dose	dose	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1565	31	x/4	x/4	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1565	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1566	1	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1566	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1566	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1566	4	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1566	5	shows	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1566	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1566	7	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1566	8	received	receive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1566	9	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1566	10	x/2	x/2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1566	11	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1567	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1567	2	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1567	3	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1567	4	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1567	5	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1567	6	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1567	7	attempt	attempt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1567	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1567	9	interpolate	interpolate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1567	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1567	11	testify	testify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1567	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1567	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1567	14	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1567	15	received	receive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1567	16	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1567	17	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1567	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1567	19	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1567	20	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1567	21	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1567	22	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1567	23	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1567	24	unreliable	unreliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1567	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1567	26	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1567	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1567	28	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1567	29	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1567	30	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1567	31	interpolation	interpolation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1567	32	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1567	33	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1567	34	widely	widely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1567	35	accepted	accept	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1567	36	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1567	37	scientists	scientist	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1567	38	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1567	39	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1567	40	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1567	41	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1567	42	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1567	43	subject	subject	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1567	44	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1567	45	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1567	46	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1567	47	disagreement	disagreement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1567	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1568	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1568	2	decreed	decreed	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1568	3	such336	such336	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1568	4	interpolation	interpolation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1568	5	impermissible	impermissible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1568	6	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1568	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1568	8	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1568	9	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1568	10	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1568	11	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1568	12	both	both	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1568	13	inadmissible	inadmissible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1568	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1568	15	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1568	16	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1568	17	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1568	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1568	19	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1568	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1568	21	law.337	law.337	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1568	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1568	23	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1568	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1568	25	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1568	26	extended	extend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1568	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1568	28	rigidity	rigidity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1568	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1568	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1568	31	similarity	similarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1568	32	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1568	33	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1568	34	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1568	35	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1568	36	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1568	37	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	1568	38	source	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1568	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1568	40	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1568	41	individually	individually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1568	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1569	1	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1569	2	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1569	3	extent	extent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1569	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1569	5	would338	would338	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1569	6	seem	seem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1569	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1569	8	follow	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1569	9	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1569	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1569	11	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1569	12	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1569	13	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1569	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1569	15	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1569	16	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1569	17	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1569	18	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1569	19	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1569	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1569	21	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1569	22	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1569	23	entirely	entirely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1569	24	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1569	25	one	one	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1569	26	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1569	27	imagine	imagine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1569	28	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1569	29	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1569	30	testifying	testify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1569	31	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1569	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1569	33	smaller	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1569	34	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1569	35	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1569	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1569	37	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1569	38	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1569	39	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1569	40	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1569	41	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1569	42	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1569	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1569	44	larger	large	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1569	45	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1569	46	associated	associate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1569	47	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1569	48	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1569	49	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1569	50	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1569	51	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1569	52	doubled	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1569	53	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1569	54	risks	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1569	55	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1570	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1570	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1570	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	4	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1570	5	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	6	left	leave	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	7	no339	no339	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1570	8	ambiguity	ambiguity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	9	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	10	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	11	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1570	12	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1570	13	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	14	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1570	15	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1570	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1570	17	called	call	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	18	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	19	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	20	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	22	similarity	similarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	23	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1570	24	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1570	25	far	far	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1570	26	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	27	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1570	28	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1570	29	tell	tell	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1570	31	none	none	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	34	peer	peer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	35	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1570	36	reviewed	review	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	37	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	38	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	39	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	40	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1570	41	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	42	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1570	43	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	44	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	45	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	46	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	47	statistically	statistically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1570	48	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	49	link	link	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	50	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	51	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	52	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	53	occasional	occasional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	54	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	55	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	56	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	57	compounds	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	58	comparable	comparable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	59	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	60	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1570	61	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1570	62	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	63	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1570	64	namely	namely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1570	65	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	66	occasional	occasional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	67	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	68	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	69	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	70	son	son	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	71	helping	help	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	72	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1570	73	father	father	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	74	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	75	building	build	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	76	renovation	renovation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	77	projects	project	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	78	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1570	79	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1570	80	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1570	81	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	82	primary	primary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	83	occupation	occupation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	84	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	85	either	either	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	86	father	father	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	87	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	88	son	son	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	89	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1570	90	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	91	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1570	92	included	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	93	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	94	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	95	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1570	96	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1570	97	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	98	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	99	construction	construction	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	100	activities.340	activities.340	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1570	101	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1570	102	state	state	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	103	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	104	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	105	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	106	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	107	terms	term	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	108	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1570	109	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1570	110	explain	explain	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	111	why	why	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	112	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	113	one	one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	114	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1570	115	studied	study	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	116	such	such	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	117	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	118	meticulously	meticulously	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1570	119	constructed	construct	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1570	120	sample	sample	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	121	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1570	122	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	123	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	124	majority’s341	majority’s341	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	125	sanctimonious	sanctimonious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	126	observations	observation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	127	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	128	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1570	129	thoroughly	thoroughly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1570	130	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1570	131	health	health	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	132	effects	effect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	133	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1570	134	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1570	135	336	336	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1570	136	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1571	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1571	2	carruth	carruth	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1571	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1571	4	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1571	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1571	6	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1571	7	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1571	8	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1571	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1571	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1571	11	209	209	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1571	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1571	13	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1571	14	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1571	15	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1571	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1571	17	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1571	18	effect	effect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1571	19	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1571	20	affect	affect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1571	21	attempts	attempt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1571	22	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1571	23	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1571	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1571	25	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1571	26	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1571	27	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1571	28	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1571	29	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1571	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1572	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1572	2	illustrative	illustrative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1572	3	purposes	purpose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1572	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1572	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1572	6	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1572	7	considers	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1572	8	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1572	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1572	10	point	point	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1572	11	estimates	estimate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1572	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1572	13	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1572	14	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1572	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1572	16	takes	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1572	17	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1572	18	account	account	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1572	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1572	20	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1572	21	confidence	confidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1572	22	intervals	interval	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1572	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1573	1	337	337	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1573	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1574	1	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1574	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1574	3	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1574	4	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1574	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1574	6	720	720	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1574	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1575	1	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1575	2	reiterated	reiterate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1575	3	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1575	4	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1575	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1576	1	merck	merck	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1576	2	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1576	3	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1577	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1577	2	garza	garza	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1577	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1577	4	347	347	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1577	5	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1577	6	256	256	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1577	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1577	8	266	266	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1577	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1577	10	67	67	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1577	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1577	12	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1577	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1577	14	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1577	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1577	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1578	1	338	338	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1578	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1579	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1579	2	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1579	3	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1579	4	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1579	5	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1579	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1579	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1579	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1579	9	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1579	10	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1579	11	332	332	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1579	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1579	13	358	358	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1579	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1579	15	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1579	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1579	17	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1579	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1579	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1580	1	339	339	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1580	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1581	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1581	2	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1581	3	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1581	4	surely	surely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1581	5	argue	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1581	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1581	7	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1581	8	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1581	9	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1581	10	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1581	11	excluded	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1581	12	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1581	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1581	14	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1581	15	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1581	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1581	17	unreliable	unreliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1581	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1581	19	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1582	1	failing	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1582	2	exclusion	exclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1582	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1582	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1582	5	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1582	6	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1582	7	surely	surely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1582	8	argue	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1582	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1582	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1582	11	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1582	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1582	13	finder	finder	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1582	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1582	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1582	16	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1582	17	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1582	18	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1582	19	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1582	20	believed	believe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1582	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1583	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1583	2	merits	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1583	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1583	4	either	either	DET
inlawrev-20850	1583	5	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1583	6	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1583	7	depend	depend	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1583	8	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1583	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1583	10	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1583	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1583	12	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1583	13	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1583	14	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1583	15	debating	debate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1583	16	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	1583	17	merits	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1583	18	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1583	19	beyond	beyond	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1583	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1583	21	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1583	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1583	23	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1583	24	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1583	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1584	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1584	2	important	important	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1584	3	point	point	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1584	4	here	here	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1584	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1584	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1584	7	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1584	8	reason	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1584	9	exists	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1584	10	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1584	11	believe	believe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1584	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1584	13	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1584	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1584	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1584	16	every	every	DET
inlawrev-20850	1584	17	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1584	18	impossible	impossible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1584	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1584	20	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1584	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1584	22	scientifically	scientifically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1584	23	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1584	24	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1584	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1584	26	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1584	27	sort	sort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1584	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1585	1	340	340	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1585	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1586	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1586	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1586	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1586	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1586	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1586	6	358	358	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1586	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1587	1	341	341	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1587	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1587	3	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1587	4	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1587	5	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1587	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1587	7	364	364	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1587	8	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1587	9	65	65	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1587	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1587	11	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1587	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1587	13	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1587	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1587	15	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1587	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1587	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1587	18	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1587	19	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1587	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1587	21	practical	practical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1587	22	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1587	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1587	24	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1587	25	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1587	26	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1587	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1587	28	exactitude	exactitude	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1587	29	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1587	30	imply	imply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1587	31	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1587	32	hardly	hardly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1587	33	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1587	34	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1587	35	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1587	36	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1587	37	recover	recover	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1587	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1587	39	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1587	40	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1587	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1588	1	174	174	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1588	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1588	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1588	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1588	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1588	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1588	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1589	1	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1589	2	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1589	3	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1589	4	researched	research	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1589	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1590	1	moreover	moreover	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1590	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1590	3	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1590	4	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1590	5	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1590	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1590	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1590	8	function	function	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1590	9	of342	of342	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1590	10	cumulative	cumulative	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1590	11	dose	dose	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1590	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1590	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1590	14	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1590	15	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1590	16	desired	desire	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1590	17	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1590	18	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1590	19	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1590	20	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1590	21	biologically	biologically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1590	22	meaningful	meaningful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1590	23	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1590	24	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1590	25	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1590	26	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1590	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1591	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1591	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1591	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1591	4	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1591	5	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1591	6	too	too	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1591	7	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1591	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1591	9	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1591	10	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1591	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1591	12	whose	whose	DET
inlawrev-20850	1591	13	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1591	14	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1591	15	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1591	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1591	17	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1591	18	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1591	19	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1591	20	extrapolation	extrapolation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1591	21	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1591	22	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1591	23	permitted	permit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1591	24	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1591	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1591	26	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1591	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1591	28	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1591	29	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1591	30	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1591	31	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1591	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1591	33	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1591	34	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1591	35	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1591	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1591	37	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1591	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1591	39	supported	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1591	40	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1591	41	reliable	reliable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1591	42	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1591	43	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1591	44	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1591	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1592	1	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1592	2	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1592	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1592	4	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	5	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1592	6	merit	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1592	8	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1592	9	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1592	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1592	11	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1592	12	mistaken	mistaken	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1592	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1592	14	tying	tie	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1592	15	even343	even343	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1592	16	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1592	17	extrapolated	extrapolated	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1592	18	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	19	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	20	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1592	21	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1592	22	causation.344	causation.344	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1592	24	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1592	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1592	26	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1592	27	rigid	rigid	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1592	28	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1592	30	similarity	similarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	31	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1592	32	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	33	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1592	34	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	35	subjects	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	36	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1592	37	denies	deny	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1592	38	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1592	40	ability	ability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	41	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1592	42	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1592	43	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1592	44	characteristics	characteristic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1592	46	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1592	47	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	48	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1592	49	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1592	50	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1592	51	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1592	52	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1592	54	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1592	55	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1592	56	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1593	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1593	2	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1593	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1593	4	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1593	5	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1593	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1593	7	occupational	occupational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1593	8	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1593	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1593	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1593	11	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1593	12	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1593	13	subjects	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1593	14	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1593	15	typically	typically	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1593	16	adults	adult	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1593	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1594	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1594	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1594	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1594	4	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1594	5	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1594	6	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1594	7	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1594	8	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1594	9	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1594	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1594	11	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1594	12	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1594	13	joint	joint	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1594	14	342	342	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1594	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1595	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1595	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1595	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1595	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1595	5	350	350	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1595	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1595	7	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1595	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1595	9	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1595	10	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1595	11	witness	witness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1595	12	testified	testify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1595	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1595	14	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1595	15	association	association	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1595	16	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1595	17	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1595	18	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1595	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1595	20	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1595	21	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1595	22	documented	document	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1595	23	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1595	24	1963	1963	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1595	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1595	26	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1595	27	1965	1965	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1595	28	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1595	29	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1595	30	thousand	thousand	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1595	31	publications	publication	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1595	32	discussed	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1595	33	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1595	34	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1595	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1595	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1596	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1596	2	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1596	3	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1596	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1596	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1596	6	imagined	imagine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1596	7	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1596	8	require	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1596	9	comparison	comparison	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1596	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1596	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1596	12	sample	sample	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1596	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1596	14	people	people	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1596	15	whose	whose	DET
inlawrev-20850	1596	16	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1596	17	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1596	18	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1596	19	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1596	20	background	background	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1596	21	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1596	22	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1596	23	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1596	24	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1596	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1596	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1596	27	sample	sample	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1596	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1596	29	people	people	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1596	30	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1596	31	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1596	32	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1596	33	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1596	34	background	background	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1596	35	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1596	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1597	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1597	2	moment	moment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1597	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1597	4	reflection	reflection	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1597	5	conjures	conjure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1597	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1597	7	methodological	methodological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1597	8	problems	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1597	9	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1597	10	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1597	11	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1597	12	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1597	13	face	face	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1597	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1597	15	identifying	identify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1597	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1597	17	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1597	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1597	19	potential	potential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1597	20	subjects	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1597	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1597	22	either	either	DET
inlawrev-20850	1597	23	category	category	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1597	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1598	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1598	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1598	3	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1598	4	easy	easy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1598	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1598	6	imagine	imagine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1598	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1598	8	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1598	9	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1598	10	such	such	DET
inlawrev-20850	1598	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1598	12	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1598	13	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1598	14	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1598	15	conducted	conduct	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1598	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1598	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1598	18	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1598	19	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1598	20	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1598	21	sample	sample	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1598	22	inevitably	inevitably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1598	23	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1598	24	include	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1598	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1598	26	range	range	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1598	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1598	28	actual	actual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1598	29	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1598	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1598	31	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1598	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1598	33	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1598	34	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1598	35	likely	likely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1598	36	exceed	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1598	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1598	38	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1598	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1598	40	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1598	41	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1598	42	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1598	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1598	44	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1598	45	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1598	46	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1598	47	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1598	48	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1598	49	subject	subject	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1598	50	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1598	51	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1598	52	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1598	53	similarity	similarity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1598	54	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1598	55	challenge	challenge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1598	56	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1598	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1598	58	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1598	59	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1598	60	standards	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1598	61	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1599	1	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	1599	2	methodological	methodological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1599	3	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1599	4	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1599	5	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1599	6	answered	answer	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1599	7	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1599	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1599	9	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1599	10	majority	majority	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1599	11	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1599	12	assurance	assurance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1599	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1599	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1599	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1599	16	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1599	17	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1599	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1599	19	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1599	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1599	21	the	the	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1599	22	easier	easy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1599	23	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1599	24	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1599	25	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1599	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1599	27	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1599	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1599	29	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1599	30	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1599	31	compliant	compliant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1599	32	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1599	33	link	link	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1599	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1599	35	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1600	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1600	2	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1600	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1600	4	358	358	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1600	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1601	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1601	2	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1601	3	goldstein	goldstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1601	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1601	5	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1601	6	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1601	7	151	151	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1601	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1601	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1601	10	572	572	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1601	11	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1601	12	77	77	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1601	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1601	14	exploring	explore	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1601	15	problems	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1601	16	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1601	17	arise	arise	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1601	18	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1601	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1601	20	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1601	21	group	group	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1601	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1601	23	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1601	24	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1601	25	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1601	26	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1601	27	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1601	28	experienced	experience	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1601	29	heterogeneous	heterogeneous	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1601	30	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1601	31	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1601	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1602	1	343	343	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1602	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1603	1	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1603	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1603	3	439	439	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1603	4	s.w.3d	s.w.3d	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1603	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1603	6	361	361	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1603	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1603	8	64	64	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1603	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1603	10	guzman	guzman	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1603	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1603	12	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1603	13	concurring	concurring	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1603	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1603	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1603	16	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1603	17	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1603	18	lack	lack	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1603	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1603	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1603	21	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1603	22	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1603	23	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1603	24	extrapolation	extrapolation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1603	25	left	leave	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1603	26	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1603	27	analytical	analytical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1603	28	gap	gap	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1603	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1603	30	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1603	31	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1603	32	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1603	33	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1603	34	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1603	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1603	36	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1603	37	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1603	38	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1603	39	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1603	40	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1603	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1604	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1604	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1604	3	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1604	4	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1604	5	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1604	6	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1604	7	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1604	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1604	9	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1604	10	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1604	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1604	12	government	government	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1604	13	document	document	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1604	14	making	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1604	15	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1604	16	calculations	calculation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1604	17	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1604	18	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1604	19	extrapolations	extrapolation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1604	20	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1604	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1604	22	published	publish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1604	23	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1604	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1604	25	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1604	26	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1604	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1605	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1605	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1605	3	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1605	4	guzman	guzman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1605	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1605	6	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1605	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1605	8	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1605	9	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1605	10	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1605	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1605	12	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1605	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1605	14	introduce	introduce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1605	15	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1605	16	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1605	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1605	18	government	government	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1605	19	document	document	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1605	20	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1605	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1605	22	underlying	underlie	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1605	23	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1605	24	literature	literature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1605	25	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1605	26	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1605	27	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1605	28	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1605	29	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1605	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1606	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1606	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1606	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1606	4	364	364	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1606	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1607	1	344	344	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1607	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1608	1	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1608	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1608	3	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1608	4	embraced	embrace	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1608	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1608	6	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1608	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1608	8	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1608	9	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1608	10	rely	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1608	11	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1608	12	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1608	13	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1608	14	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1608	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1608	16	per	per	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1608	17	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1608	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1608	19	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1608	20	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1608	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1608	22	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1608	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1608	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1608	25	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1608	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1608	27	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1608	28	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1608	29	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1608	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1609	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1609	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1609	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1609	4	376	376	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1609	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1609	6	lehrmann	lehrmann	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1609	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1609	8	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1609	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1609	10	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1609	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1609	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1610	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1610	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1610	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1610	4	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1610	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1610	6	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1610	7	evaded	evade	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1610	8	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1610	9	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1610	10	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1610	11	arguing	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1610	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1610	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1610	14	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1610	15	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1610	16	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1610	17	both	both	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1610	18	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1610	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1610	20	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1610	21	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1610	22	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1610	23	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1610	24	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1610	25	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1610	26	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1610	27	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1610	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1610	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1610	30	contrast	contrast	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1610	31	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1610	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1610	33	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1610	34	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1610	35	alternative	alternative	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1610	36	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1610	37	authorized	authorize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1610	38	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1610	39	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1610	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1611	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1611	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1611	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1611	4	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1611	5	recapitulated	recapitulate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1611	6	testimony	testimony	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1611	7	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1611	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1611	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1611	10	biological	biological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1611	11	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1611	12	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1611	13	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1611	14	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1611	15	fibers	fiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1611	16	migrate	migrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1611	17	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1611	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1611	19	lung	lung	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1611	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1611	21	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1611	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1611	23	pleura	pleura	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1611	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1611	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1611	26	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1611	27	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1611	28	errors	error	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1611	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1611	30	mesothelial	mesothelial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1611	31	cells	cell	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1611	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1611	33	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1611	34	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1611	35	arguably	arguably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1611	36	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1611	37	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1611	38	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1611	39	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1611	40	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1611	41	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1611	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1611	43	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1611	44	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1611	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1612	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1612	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1612	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1612	4	367	367	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1612	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1612	6	68	68	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1612	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1612	8	376	376	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1612	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1613	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1613	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1613	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1613	4	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1613	5	direct	direct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1613	6	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1613	7	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1613	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1613	9	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1613	10	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1613	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1613	12	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1613	13	cited	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1613	14	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1613	15	mostly	mostly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1613	16	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1613	17	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1613	18	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1613	19	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1613	20	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1613	21	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1613	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1614	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1614	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1614	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1614	4	377	377	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1614	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1615	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1615	2	dissenters	dissenter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1615	3	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1615	4	willing	willing	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1615	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1615	6	accept	accept	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1615	7	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1615	8	qualitative	qualitative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1615	9	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1615	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1615	11	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1615	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1615	13	unlike	unlike	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1615	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1615	15	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1615	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1615	17	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1615	18	demanded	demand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1615	19	quantitative	quantitative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1615	20	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1615	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1615	22	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1615	23	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1615	24	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1615	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1615	26	proven	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1615	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1615	28	quantified	quantified	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1615	29	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1615	30	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1615	31	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1615	32	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1615	33	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1615	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1615	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1616	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1616	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1616	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1616	4	379	379	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1616	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1617	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1617	2	all	all	DET
inlawrev-20850	1617	3	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1617	4	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1617	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1617	6	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1617	7	focused	focus	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1617	8	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1617	9	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1617	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1617	11	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1617	12	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1617	13	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1617	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1617	15	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1617	16	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1617	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1618	1	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1618	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1618	3	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1618	4	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1618	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1618	6	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1618	7	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1618	8	175	175	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1618	9	compound	compound	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1618	10	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1618	11	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1618	12	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1618	13	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1618	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1618	15	child	child	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1618	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1619	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1619	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1619	3	majority345	majority345	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1619	4	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1619	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1619	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1619	7	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1619	8	experts	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1619	9	agreed	agree	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1619	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1619	11	children	child	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1619	12	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1619	13	especially	especially	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1619	14	vulnerable	vulnerable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1619	15	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1619	16	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1619	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1619	18	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1619	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1619	20	carcinogens	carcinogen	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1619	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1619	22	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1619	23	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1619	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1619	25	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1619	26	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1619	27	suggest	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1619	28	that346	that346	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1619	29	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1619	30	expert	expert	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1619	31	disputed	dispute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1619	32	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1619	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1620	1	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1620	2	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1620	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1620	4	childhood	childhood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	5	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	6	creates	create	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1620	7	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1620	8	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	9	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1620	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1620	11	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1620	12	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	13	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1620	14	adulthood	adulthood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1620	16	one	one	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1620	17	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1620	18	expect	expect	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1620	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1620	20	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1620	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1620	23	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	24	vigorously	vigorously	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1620	25	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1620	26	contest	contest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1620	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1620	28	extent	extent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	29	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1620	30	which	which	DET
inlawrev-20850	1620	31	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1620	33	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1620	34	childhood	childhood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	35	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	36	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1620	37	additional	additional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1620	38	support	support	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	39	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1620	40	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1620	41	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1620	43	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1620	44	causation.347	causation.347	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	45	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1620	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1620	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1620	48	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1620	49	majority	majority	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1620	50	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1620	51	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	52	entirely	entirely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1620	53	precluded	preclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1620	54	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1620	55	debate	debate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1620	56	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1621	1	under348	under348	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1622	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1622	2	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1622	3	majority	majority	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1622	4	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1622	5	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1623	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1623	3	childhood	childhood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	4	timing	timing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1623	6	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1623	7	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	8	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1623	9	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1623	10	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1623	11	significance	significance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	12	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1623	13	all	all	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1623	14	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1623	15	unless	unless	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1623	17	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	18	finds	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1623	19	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1623	20	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	21	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	22	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1623	23	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	24	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1623	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1623	26	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1623	28	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	29	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1623	30	children	child	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	31	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1623	32	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1623	33	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1623	34	equal	equal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	35	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	36	smaller	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	37	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	38	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1623	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1623	40	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	41	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1623	42	dose.349	dose.349	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1623	43	e.	e.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1623	44	judges	judges	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1623	45	reading	read	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1623	46	scholars	scholar	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	47	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	48	vice	vice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	49	versa	versa	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1623	50	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1623	51	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1623	52	failure	failure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	53	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1623	54	communicate	communicate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1623	55	judges	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	56	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	57	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	58	observers	observer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	59	often	often	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1623	60	lament	lament	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1623	61	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	62	contemporary	contemporary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	63	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	64	scholarship	scholarship	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	65	lacks	lack	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1623	66	relevance	relevance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	67	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1623	68	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1623	69	daily	daily	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	70	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	71	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1623	72	resolving	resolve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1623	73	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1623	74	disputes	dispute	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1623	75	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1624	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1624	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1624	3	toxic350	toxic350	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1624	4	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1624	5	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1624	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1624	7	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1624	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1624	9	great	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1624	10	academic	academic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1624	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1624	12	philosophical	philosophical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1624	13	interest	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1624	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1624	15	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1624	16	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1624	17	vitally	vitally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1624	18	important	important	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1624	19	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1624	20	litigants	litigant	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1624	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1624	22	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1624	23	judges	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1624	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1624	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1624	26	appellate	appellate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1624	27	judges	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1624	28	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1624	29	countless	countless	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1624	30	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1624	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1625	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1625	2	topic	topic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1625	3	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1625	4	presents	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1625	5	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1625	6	excellent	excellent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1625	7	opportunity	opportunity	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1625	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1625	9	academic	academic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1625	10	commentators	commentator	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1625	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1625	12	345	345	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1625	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1626	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1626	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1626	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1626	4	353	353	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1626	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1627	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1627	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1627	3	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1627	4	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1627	5	hold	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1627	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1627	7	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1627	8	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1627	9	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1627	10	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1627	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1627	12	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1627	13	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1627	14	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1627	15	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1627	16	georgia	georgia	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1627	17	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1627	18	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1627	19	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1627	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1627	21	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1627	22	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1627	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1627	24	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1627	25	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1627	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1627	27	quantify	quantify	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1627	28	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1627	29	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1627	30	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1627	31	compare	compare	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1627	32	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1627	33	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1627	34	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1627	35	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1627	36	dose	dose	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1627	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1628	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1628	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1628	3	346	346	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1628	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1629	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1629	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1629	3	347	347	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1629	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1630	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1630	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1630	3	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1630	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1630	5	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1630	6	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1630	7	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1630	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1630	9	childhood	childhood	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1630	10	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1630	11	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1630	12	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1630	13	particularly	particularly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1630	14	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1630	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1630	16	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1631	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1631	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1631	3	348	348	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1631	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1632	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1632	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1632	3	349	349	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1632	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1633	1	similarly	similarly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1633	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1633	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1633	4	logic	logic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1633	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1633	6	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1633	7	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1633	8	preclude	preclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1633	9	consideration	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1633	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1633	11	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1633	12	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1633	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1633	14	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1633	15	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1633	16	genetic	genetic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1633	17	susceptibility	susceptibility	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1633	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1633	19	carcinogens	carcinogen	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1633	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1633	21	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1633	22	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1633	23	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1633	24	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1633	25	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1633	26	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1633	27	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1633	28	individual	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1633	29	experienced	experience	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1633	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1633	31	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1633	32	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1633	33	increment	increment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1633	34	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1633	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1633	36	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1633	37	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1633	38	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1633	39	did	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1633	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1633	41	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1633	42	average	average	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1633	43	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1633	44	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1633	45	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1633	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1634	1	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1634	2	contrast	contrast	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1634	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1634	4	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1634	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1634	6	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1634	7	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1634	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1634	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1634	10	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1634	11	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1634	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1634	13	rule	rule	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1634	14	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1634	15	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1634	16	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1634	17	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1634	18	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1634	19	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1634	20	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1634	21	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1634	22	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1634	23	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1634	24	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1634	25	individual	individual	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1634	26	experienced	experience	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1634	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1634	28	smaller	small	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1634	29	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1634	30	increment	increment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1634	31	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1634	32	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1634	33	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1634	34	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1634	35	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1634	36	did	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1634	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1634	38	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1634	39	average	average	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1634	40	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1634	41	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1634	42	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1634	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1635	1	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1635	2	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1635	3	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1635	4	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1635	5	adopted	adopt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1635	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1635	7	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1635	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1635	9	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1635	10	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1635	11	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1635	12	done	do	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1635	13	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1635	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1635	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1635	16	similarly	similarly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1635	17	asymmetrical	asymmetrical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1635	18	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1635	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1636	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1636	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1636	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1636	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1636	5	estate	estate	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1636	7	george	george	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1636	8	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1636	9	vt	vt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1636	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1636	11	league	league	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1636	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1636	13	cities	city	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	14	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1636	15	towns	town	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1636	17	993	993	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1636	18	a.2d	a.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1636	19	367	367	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1636	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1636	21	384	384	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1636	22	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1636	23	vt	vt	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1636	24	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1636	25	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1636	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1636	27	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1636	28	reiber	reiber	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1636	30	c.j	c.j	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1636	31	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1636	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1636	33	dissenting	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1636	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1636	35	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1636	36	arguing	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1636	37	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1636	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1636	39	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	40	judge	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	41	sitting	sit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1636	42	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1636	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1636	44	factfinder	factfinder	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	45	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1636	46	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1636	47	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1636	48	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	49	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1636	50	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	51	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1636	52	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1636	53	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1636	54	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1636	55	faced	face	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1636	56	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1636	57	risks	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	58	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1636	59	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1636	60	average	average	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1636	61	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	62	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	63	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1636	64	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1636	65	relying	rely	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1636	66	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1636	67	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	68	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1636	69	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1636	70	average	average	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1636	71	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1636	72	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	73	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1636	74	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1636	75	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1636	76	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1636	77	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1636	78	less	less	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1636	79	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1636	80	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1636	81	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1636	82	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1637	1	350	350	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1637	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	1	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1638	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	3	adam	adam	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	4	liptak	liptak	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1638	7	lackluster	lackluster	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1638	8	reviews	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	9	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1638	10	lawyers	lawyer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	11	love	love	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1638	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1638	13	hate	hate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1638	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	15	n.y	n.y	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	17	times	times	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	19	oct	oct	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	20	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	21	22	22	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1638	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	23	2013	2013	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1638	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	25	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1638	26	a15	a15	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	28	available	available	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1638	29	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1638	30	http://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/22/us/law-scholarships-lacklusterreviews.html?_r=0	http://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/22/us/law-scholarships-lacklusterreviews.html?_r=0	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1638	31	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1638	32	http://perma.cc/kkp6-ty6n	http://perma.cc/kkp6-ty6n	X
inlawrev-20850	1638	33	]	]	X
inlawrev-20850	1638	34	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	35	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1638	36	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1638	37	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	38	judge	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	39	dennis	dennis	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	40	g.	g.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	41	jacobs	jacobs	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	42	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	43	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	44	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1638	45	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1638	46	n’t	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1638	47	opened	open	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1638	48	up	up	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1638	49	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1638	50	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	51	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	52	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1638	53	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	54	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	55	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	56	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	57	leonard	leonard	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	58	hoffman	hoffman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	59	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	60	lord	lord	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	61	hoffman	hoffman	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	62	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	63	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	64	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	65	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1638	66	perspectives	perspective	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	67	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1638	68	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	69	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	70	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1638	71	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	72	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1638	73	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	74	richard	richard	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	75	goldberg	goldberg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	76	ed	ed	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	77	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1638	78	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	79	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1638	80	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	81	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	82	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1638	83	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1638	84	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1638	85	british	british	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1638	86	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	87	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	88	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	89	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	90	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1638	91	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1638	92	notable	notable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1638	93	exception	exception	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	94	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1638	95	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1638	96	trend	trend	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	97	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1638	98	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	99	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1638	100	academic	academic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1638	101	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	102	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1638	103	often	often	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1638	104	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	105	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1638	106	concluding	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1638	107	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1638	108	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1638	109	judges	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	110	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1638	111	scholars	scholar	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1638	112	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	113	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1638	114	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1638	115	missing	miss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1638	116	something	something	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1638	117	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	118	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1638	119	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1639	1	176	176	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1639	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1639	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1639	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1639	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1639	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1639	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1640	1	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1640	2	engage	engage	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1640	3	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1640	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1640	5	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1640	6	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1640	7	craft	craft	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1640	8	evolving	evolve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1640	9	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1640	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1640	11	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1640	12	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1640	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1640	14	vice	vice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1640	15	versa.351	versa.351	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1640	16	meaningful	meaningful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1640	17	engagement	engagement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1640	18	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1640	19	careful	careful	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1640	20	reading	reading	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1640	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1640	22	understanding	understanding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1640	23	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1640	24	both	both	DET
inlawrev-20850	1640	25	sides	side	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1640	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1640	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1640	28	dialogue	dialogue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1640	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1641	1	unfortunately	unfortunately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1641	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1641	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1641	4	evolution	evolution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1641	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1641	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1641	7	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1641	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1641	9	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1641	10	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1641	11	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1641	12	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1641	13	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1641	14	origins	origin	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1641	15	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1641	16	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1641	17	adoption	adoption	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1641	18	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1641	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1641	20	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1641	21	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1641	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1641	23	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1641	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1641	25	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1641	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1641	27	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1641	28	subsequent	subsequent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1641	29	articulations	articulation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1641	30	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1641	31	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1641	32	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1641	33	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1641	34	suggests	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1641	35	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1641	36	judges	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1641	37	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1641	38	scholars	scholar	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1641	39	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1641	40	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1641	41	failed	fail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1641	42	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1641	43	receive	receive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1641	44	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	1641	45	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1641	46	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1641	47	meaning	meaning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1641	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1642	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1642	2	earliest	early	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1642	3	articulation	articulation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1642	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1642	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1642	6	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1642	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1642	8	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1642	9	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1642	10	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1642	11	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1642	12	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1642	13	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1642	14	able	able	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1642	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1642	16	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1642	17	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1642	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1642	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1642	20	1960	1960	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1642	21	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1642	22	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1642	23	samuel	samuel	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1642	24	estep	estep	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1642	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1643	1	early	early	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1643	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1643	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1643	4	atomic	atomic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1643	5	age	age	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1643	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1643	7	estep	estep	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1643	8	considered352	considered352	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1643	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1643	10	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1643	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1643	12	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1643	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1643	14	induced	induce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1643	15	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1643	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1643	17	anticipated	anticipate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1643	18	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1643	19	problems	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1643	20	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1643	21	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1643	22	come	come	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1643	23	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1643	24	prominence	prominence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1643	25	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1643	26	future	future	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1643	27	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1643	28	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1643	29	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1643	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1644	1	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1644	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1644	3	impossibility353	impossibility353	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1644	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1644	5	proving	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1644	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1644	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1644	8	biological	biological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1644	9	connection	connection	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1644	11	irradiation	irradiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	12	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1644	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1644	14	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1644	15	nonspecific	nonspecific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1644	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1644	17	latent	latent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1644	18	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	19	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1644	20	existing	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1644	21	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1644	22	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	23	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1644	24	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1644	26	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1644	27	estep	estep	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	28	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1644	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1644	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1644	31	doublingplus	doublingplus	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1644	32	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	33	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1644	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1644	35	only	only	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1644	36	approach	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	37	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1644	38	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1644	39	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	40	concordant	concordant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1644	41	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1644	42	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1644	44	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1644	45	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1644	46	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1644	47	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	48	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1644	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1644	50	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	51	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1644	52	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1644	53	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	54	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1644	55	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1645	1	estep	estep	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1645	2	clearly3	clearly3	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1645	3	5	5	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1645	4	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1645	5	understood	understand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1645	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1645	7	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1645	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1645	9	plus	plus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1645	10	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1645	11	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1645	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1645	13	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1645	14	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1645	15	albeit	albeit	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1645	16	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1645	17	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1645	18	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1645	19	inadequate	inadequate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1645	20	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1645	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1645	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1645	23	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1645	24	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1645	25	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1645	26	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1645	27	become	become	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1645	28	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1645	29	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1645	30	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1645	31	specific355	specific355	X
inlawrev-20850	1645	32	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1645	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1646	1	”356	”356	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1646	2	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1646	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1646	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1646	5	type	type	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1646	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1646	7	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1646	8	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1646	9	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1646	10	estep	estep	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1646	11	anticipated	anticipate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1646	12	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1646	13	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1646	14	become	become	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1646	15	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1646	16	until	until	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1646	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1646	18	1980s	1980	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1646	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1646	20	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1646	21	mostly	mostly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1646	22	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1646	23	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1646	24	involve	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1646	25	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1646	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1646	27	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1646	28	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1646	29	induced	induce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1646	30	illness	illness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1646	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1647	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1647	2	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1647	3	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1647	4	adoptions	adoption	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1647	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1647	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1647	7	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1647	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1647	9	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1647	10	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1647	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1647	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1647	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1647	14	early	early	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1647	15	swine357	swine357	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1647	16	flu	flu	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1647	17	vaccine	vaccine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1647	18	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1647	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1647	20	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1647	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1647	22	cite	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1647	23	estep	estep	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1647	24	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1647	25	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1647	26	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1647	27	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1647	28	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1647	29	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1647	30	scholarship.358	scholarship.358	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1647	31	351	351	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1647	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1648	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1648	2	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1648	3	seems	seem	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1648	4	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1648	5	understand	understand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1648	6	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1648	7	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1648	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1648	9	fair	fair	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1648	10	amount	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1648	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1648	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1648	13	recent	recent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1648	14	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1648	15	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1648	16	literature	literature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1648	17	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1648	18	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1648	19	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1648	20	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1648	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1648	22	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1648	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1648	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1648	25	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1648	26	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1648	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1648	28	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1648	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1648	30	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1648	31	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1648	32	authored	author	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1648	33	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1648	34	practicing	practice	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1648	35	attorneys	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1648	36	whose	whose	DET
inlawrev-20850	1648	37	clients	client	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1648	38	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1648	39	dogs	dog	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1648	40	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1648	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1648	42	fight	fight	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1648	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1649	1	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1649	2	richard	richard	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1649	3	o.	o.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1649	4	faulk	faulk	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1649	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1649	6	dispelling	dispel	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1649	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1649	8	myths	myth	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1649	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1649	10	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1649	11	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1649	12	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1649	13	solutions	solution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1649	14	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1649	15	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1649	16	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1649	17	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1649	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1649	19	44	44	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1649	20	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1649	21	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1649	22	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1649	23	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1649	24	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1649	25	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1650	1	945	945	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1650	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	3	2003	2003	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1650	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	6	defense	defense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1650	7	attorney	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1650	8	favorably	favorably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1650	9	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1650	10	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1650	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	12	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	13	andrew	andrew	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1650	14	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1650	15	lipton	lipton	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1650	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	17	proving	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1650	18	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1650	19	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1650	20	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	21	getting	get	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1650	22	past	past	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1650	23	slice	slice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1650	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1650	25	dice	dice	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1650	26	tactics	tactic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1650	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	28	45	45	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1650	29	mcgeorge	mcgeorge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1650	30	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1650	31	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1650	32	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1650	33	707	707	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1650	34	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	35	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1650	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	37	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	38	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1650	39	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	40	attorney	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1650	41	criticizing	criticize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1650	42	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1650	43	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	44	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1650	45	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1650	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1650	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1651	1	352	352	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1651	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1652	1	samuel	samuel	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1652	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1652	3	estep	estep	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1652	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1652	5	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1652	6	injuries	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1652	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1652	8	statistics	statistic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1652	9	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1652	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1652	11	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1652	12	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1652	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1652	14	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1652	15	approach	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1652	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1652	17	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1652	18	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1652	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1652	20	59	59	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1652	21	mich	mich	X
inlawrev-20850	1652	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1653	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1653	2	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1653	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1654	1	259	259	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1654	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1654	3	1960	1960	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1654	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1654	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1655	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1655	2	am	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1655	3	indebted	indebted	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1655	4	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1655	5	michael	michael	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1655	6	green	green	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1655	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1655	8	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1655	9	first	first	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1655	10	called	call	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1655	11	my	my	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1655	12	attention	attention	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1655	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1655	14	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1655	15	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1655	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1656	1	353	353	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1656	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1657	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1657	2	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1657	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1657	4	estep	estep	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1657	5	anticipated	anticipate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1657	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1657	7	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1657	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1657	9	reform	reform	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1657	10	statutes	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1657	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1657	12	limitations	limitation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1657	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1657	14	take	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1657	15	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1657	16	account	account	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1657	17	long	long	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1657	18	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1657	19	latency	latency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1657	20	periods	period	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1657	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1658	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1658	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1658	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1658	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1658	5	262	262	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1658	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1658	7	354	354	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1658	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1659	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1659	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1659	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1659	4	274	274	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1659	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1659	6	355	355	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1659	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1660	1	using	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1660	2	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1660	3	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1660	4	induced	induce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1660	5	leukemia	leukemia	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1660	6	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1660	7	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1660	8	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1660	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1660	10	estep	estep	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1660	11	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1660	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1660	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1660	14	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1660	15	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1660	16	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1660	17	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1660	18	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1660	19	lead	lead	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1660	20	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1660	21	undercompensation	undercompensation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1660	22	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1660	23	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1660	24	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1660	25	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1660	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1660	27	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1660	28	brought	bring	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1660	29	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1660	30	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1660	31	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1660	32	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1660	33	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1660	34	manifestation	manifestation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1660	35	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1660	36	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1660	37	overcompensation	overcompensation	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1660	38	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1660	39	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1660	40	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1660	41	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1660	42	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1660	43	brought	bring	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1660	44	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1660	45	manifestation	manifestation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1660	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1661	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1661	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1661	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1661	4	275	275	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1661	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1661	6	80	80	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1661	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1662	1	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1662	2	proposed	propose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1662	3	creating	create	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1662	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1662	5	fund	fund	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1662	6	upon	upon	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1662	7	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1662	8	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1662	9	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1662	10	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1662	11	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1662	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1662	13	compensate	compensate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1662	14	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1662	15	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1662	16	developed	develop	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1662	17	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1662	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1662	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1662	20	future	future	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1662	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1663	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1663	2	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1663	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1663	4	281	281	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1663	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1663	6	88	88	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1663	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1663	8	356	356	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1663	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1664	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1664	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1664	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1664	4	279	279	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1664	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1664	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1664	7	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1664	8	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1664	9	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1664	10	purely	purely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1664	11	statistical	statistical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1664	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1664	13	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1664	14	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1664	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1664	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1664	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1665	1	assignment	assignment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1665	2	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1665	3	natural	natural	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1665	4	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1665	5	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1665	6	causes	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1665	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1665	8	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1665	9	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1665	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1665	11	impossible	impossible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1665	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1665	13	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1665	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1665	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1666	1	357	357	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1666	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1667	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1667	2	notable	notable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1667	3	radiation	radiation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1667	4	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1667	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1667	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1667	7	1980s	1980	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1667	8	involved	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1667	9	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1667	10	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1667	11	persons	person	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1667	12	exposed	expose	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1667	13	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1667	14	nuclear	nuclear	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1667	15	weapons	weapon	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1667	16	tests	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1667	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1668	1	allen	allen	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1668	2	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1668	3	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1668	4	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1668	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1668	6	588	588	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1668	7	f.	f.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1668	8	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1668	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1669	1	247	247	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1669	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1669	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1669	4	utah	utah	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1669	5	1984	1984	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1669	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1669	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1670	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1670	2	supra	supra	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1670	3	text	text	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1670	4	accompanying	accompany	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1670	5	notes	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1670	6	248	248	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1670	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1670	8	53	53	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1670	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1671	1	358	358	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1671	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1672	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1672	2	supra	supra	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1672	3	text	text	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1672	4	accompanying	accompanying	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1672	5	notes	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1672	6	240	240	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1672	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1672	8	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1672	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1673	1	http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1286328	http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1286328	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	2	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1673	3	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1673	4	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	5	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	6	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1673	7	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1673	8	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	9	177	177	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1673	10	soon	soon	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1673	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1673	12	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1673	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1673	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1673	15	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	16	reviews	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	17	began	begin	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1673	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1673	19	fill	fill	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1673	20	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1673	21	discussions	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1673	23	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1673	24	epidemiologic	epidemiologic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1673	25	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	26	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1673	27	bear	bear	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1673	28	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1673	29	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1673	30	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1673	31	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1673	32	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1673	34	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1673	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1673	36	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1673	37	rehearsed	rehearse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1673	38	estep	estep	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	39	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1673	40	concerns	concern	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	41	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1673	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1673	43	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1673	44	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1673	45	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1673	46	rule.359	rule.359	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1673	47	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1673	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1673	49	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1673	51	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1673	52	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1673	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1673	54	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1673	55	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1673	56	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	57	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1673	58	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1673	59	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1673	60	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1673	61	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1673	62	body	body	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	63	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1673	64	literature	literature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	65	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1673	66	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1673	67	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1673	68	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1673	69	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1673	70	body	body	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	71	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1673	72	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	73	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1673	74	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1673	75	built	build	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1673	76	up	up	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1673	77	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1674	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1674	2	terms	term	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1674	3	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1674	4	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1674	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1674	6	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1674	7	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1674	8	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1674	9	become	become	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1674	10	widely	widely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1674	11	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1674	12	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1674	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1674	14	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1674	15	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1674	16	adopted	adopt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1674	17	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1674	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1674	19	defined	define	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1674	20	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1674	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1674	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1674	23	conventional	conventional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1674	24	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1674	25	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1674	26	addressing	address	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1674	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1674	28	role	role	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1674	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1674	30	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1674	31	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1674	32	proving	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1674	33	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1674	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1675	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1675	2	havner	havn	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1675	3	court360	court360	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1675	4	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1675	5	embarked	embark	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1675	6	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1675	7	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1675	8	unusually	unusually	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1675	9	wide	wide	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1675	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1675	11	ranging	range	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1675	12	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1675	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1675	14	both	both	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1675	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1675	16	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1675	17	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1675	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1675	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1675	20	literature	literature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1675	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1676	1	unfortunately	unfortunately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1676	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1676	3	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1676	4	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	5	blurred	blur	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1676	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1676	7	difference	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	8	between361	between361	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1676	9	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1676	10	distinct	distinct	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1676	11	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	12	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1676	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1676	14	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1676	15	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1676	16	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1676	18	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1676	19	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	20	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1676	21	ever	ever	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1676	22	suffice	suffice	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1676	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1676	24	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1676	25	any	any	DET
inlawrev-20850	1676	26	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1676	28	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1676	29	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	30	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1676	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1676	32	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1676	33	precise	precise	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1676	34	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1676	36	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1676	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1676	38	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1676	39	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1676	40	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1676	41	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	42	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1676	43	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1676	44	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1676	45	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1676	46	correspond	correspond	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1676	47	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1676	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1676	49	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	50	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	51	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1676	52	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1676	54	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1676	55	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	56	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1676	57	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1676	58	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1676	59	ever	ever	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1676	60	making	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1676	61	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1676	62	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1676	63	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1676	64	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	65	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1676	66	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1676	67	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	68	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1676	69	hand	hand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1676	70	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1677	1	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1677	2	allowed	allow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1677	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1677	4	havner362	havner362	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1677	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1677	6	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1677	7	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1677	8	cast	cast	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1677	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1677	10	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1677	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1677	12	plus	plus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1677	13	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1677	14	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1677	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1677	16	compromise	compromise	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1677	17	position	position	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1677	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1677	19	mistakenly	mistakenly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1677	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1677	21	label	label	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1677	22	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1677	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1677	24	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1677	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1677	26	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1677	27	causation.363	causation.363	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1677	28	359	359	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1677	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1678	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1678	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	5	rosenberg	rosenberg	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1678	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	7	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1678	8	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1678	9	262	262	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1678	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	11	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1678	12	859	859	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1678	13	n.43	n.43	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	15	recognizing	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1678	16	estep	estep	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	17	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1678	18	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	19	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1678	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1678	21	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	22	pioneer	pioneer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	23	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	25	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	26	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1678	27	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1678	28	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1678	29	863	863	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1678	30	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	31	arguing	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1678	32	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1678	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1678	34	strong	strong	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1678	35	version	version	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1678	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1678	38	preponderance	preponderance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	39	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	41	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1678	42	particularistic	particularistic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1678	43	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	45	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	46	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1678	47	aggregate	aggregate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1678	48	underdeterrence	underdeterrence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	49	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1678	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1678	51	weak	weak	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1678	52	version	version	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	53	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	54	allowing	allow	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1678	55	recovery	recovery	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	56	whenever	whenever	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1678	57	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1678	58	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	59	exceeds	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1678	60	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1678	61	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	62	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	63	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1678	64	aggregate	aggregate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1678	65	overdeterrence	overdeterrence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1678	66	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1678	67	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1679	2	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1679	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	4	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1679	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	6	black	black	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1679	7	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1679	8	lilienfeld	lilienfeld	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	10	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	11	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	12	247	247	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1679	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	14	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1679	15	767	767	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1679	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	17	advocating	advocate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1679	18	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1679	19	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1679	20	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	21	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1679	22	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	23	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	24	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	25	colin	colin	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	26	hugh	hugh	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	27	buckley	buckley	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1679	30	suggested	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1679	31	remedy	remedy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	32	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1679	33	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1679	34	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	35	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	36	class	class	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	37	actions	action	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	39	epidemiology	epidemiology	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	41	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1679	42	economic	economic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1679	43	efficiency	efficiency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	45	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1679	46	wm	wm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	47	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	48	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1679	49	mary	mary	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	50	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	51	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	52	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	53	497	497	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1679	54	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	55	528	528	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1679	56	n.190	n.190	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	57	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	58	1985	1985	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1679	59	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	60	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	61	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1679	62	underterrence/	underterrence/	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1679	63	overdeterrence	overdeterrence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	64	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	65	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	66	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	67	palma	palma	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	68	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	69	strand	strand	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1679	70	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	71	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1679	72	inapplicability	inapplicability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	73	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1679	74	traditional	traditional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1679	75	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	76	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	77	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1679	78	environmental	environmental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1679	79	risks	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	80	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	81	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1679	82	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	83	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1679	84	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1679	85	waste	waste	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	86	pollution	pollution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	87	victim	victim	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	88	compensation	compensation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	89	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1679	90	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1679	91	stan	stan	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1679	92	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1680	2	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1680	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1680	4	575	575	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1680	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	6	583	583	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1680	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1680	8	04	04	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1680	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	10	603	603	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1680	11	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1680	12	04	04	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1680	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	14	1983	1983	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1680	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	17	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1680	18	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1680	19	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1680	20	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1680	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	22	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1680	23	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1680	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1680	25	discussing	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1680	26	problems	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1680	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1680	28	both	both	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1680	29	all	all	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1680	30	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	31	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1680	32	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	33	nothing	nothing	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1680	34	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1680	35	proportional	proportional	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1680	36	recovery	recovery	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1680	37	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1680	38	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	39	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	40	mario	mario	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1680	41	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1680	42	rizzo	rizzo	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1680	43	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1680	44	frank	frank	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1680	45	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1680	46	arnold	arnold	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1680	47	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	48	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1680	49	apportionment	apportionment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1680	50	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1680	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1680	52	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1680	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1680	54	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1680	55	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	56	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1680	57	economic	economic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1680	58	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1680	59	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1680	60	80	80	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1680	61	colum	colum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1680	62	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1681	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1681	2	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1681	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1681	4	1399	1399	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1681	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1681	6	1402	1402	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1681	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1681	8	1980	1980	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1681	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1681	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1681	11	advocating	advocate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1681	12	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1681	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1681	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1681	15	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1681	16	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1681	17	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1681	18	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1681	19	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1681	20	apportionment	apportionment	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1681	21	tool	tool	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1681	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1681	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1682	1	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1682	2	weinstein	weinstein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1682	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1682	4	fairness	fairness	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1682	5	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1682	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1682	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1682	8	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1682	9	orange	orange	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1682	10	litigation	litigation	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1682	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1682	12	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1682	13	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1682	14	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1682	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1682	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1682	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1683	1	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1683	2	masqueraded	masquerade	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1683	3	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1683	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1683	5	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1683	6	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1683	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1683	8	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1683	9	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1683	10	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1683	11	included	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1683	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1683	13	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1683	14	group	group	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1683	15	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1683	16	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1683	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1684	1	green	green	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1684	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1684	3	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1684	4	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1684	5	295	295	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1684	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1684	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1684	8	360	360	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1684	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1684	10	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1684	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1684	12	re	re	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1684	13	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1684	14	agent	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1684	15	orange	orange	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1684	16	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1684	17	prod	prod	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1684	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1685	1	liab	liab	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1685	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1686	1	litig	litig	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1686	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1687	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1687	2	597	597	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1687	3	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1687	4	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1687	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1688	1	740	740	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1688	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1688	3	e.d.n.y	e.d.n.y	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1688	4	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1688	5	1984	1984	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1688	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1688	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1688	8	aff’d	aff’d	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1688	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1688	10	818	818	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1688	11	f.2d	f.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1688	12	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1688	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1688	14	2d	2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1688	15	cir	cir	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1688	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1688	17	1987	1987	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1688	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1688	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1688	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1689	1	360	360	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1689	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1690	1	merrell	merrell	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1690	2	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1690	3	pharm	pharm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1690	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1690	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1690	6	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1690	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1691	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1691	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1691	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1691	4	953	953	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1691	5	s.w.2d	s.w.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1691	6	706	706	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1691	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1691	8	714	714	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1691	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1691	10	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1691	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1691	12	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1691	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1691	14	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1691	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1691	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1692	1	361	361	X
inlawrev-20850	1692	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1693	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1693	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1693	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1693	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1693	5	715	715	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1693	6	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1693	7	17	17	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1693	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1694	1	362	362	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1694	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	1	compare	compare	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1695	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1695	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	5	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1695	6	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1695	8	715	715	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1695	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	10	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	11	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	12	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1695	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	15	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1695	16	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	17	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	18	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1695	19	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	20	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	21	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1695	22	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1695	24	recovery	recovery	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	25	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	27	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1695	28	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1695	29	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1695	30	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1695	31	716	716	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1695	32	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	33	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	34	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1695	35	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1695	36	commentators	commentator	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	37	argue	argue	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	38	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	39	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1695	40	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	41	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1695	42	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1695	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	44	standing	stand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	45	alone	alone	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1695	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	47	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	48	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	49	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	50	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	51	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	52	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1695	53	i	i	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1695	54	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1695	55	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	56	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	57	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	58	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	59	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1695	60	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1695	61	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	62	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1695	63	exceed	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	64	2.0	2.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1695	65	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1695	66	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	67	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	68	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1695	69	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	70	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	71	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	72	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1695	73	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1695	74	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1695	75	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1695	76	717	717	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1695	77	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	78	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	79	academic	academic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1695	80	criticism	criticism	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	81	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1695	82	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	83	attempts	attempt	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	84	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1695	85	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1695	86	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	87	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1695	88	meld	meld	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	89	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1695	90	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1695	91	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1695	92	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1695	93	%	%	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	94	probability	probability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	95	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	96	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1695	97	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1695	98	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1695	99	risks	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	100	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1695	101	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1695	102	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1695	103	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1695	104	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	105	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1695	106	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1696	1	363	363	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1696	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1697	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1697	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1697	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1697	4	717	717	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1697	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1697	6	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1697	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1697	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1697	9	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1697	10	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1697	11	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1697	12	persuaded	persuade	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1697	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1697	14	properly	properly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1697	15	designed	design	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1697	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1697	17	executed	execute	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1697	18	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1697	19	studies	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1697	20	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1697	21	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1697	22	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1697	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1697	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1697	25	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1697	26	supporting	support	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1697	27	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1697	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1697	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1697	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1698	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1698	2	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1698	3	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1698	4	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1698	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1698	6	rational	rational	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1698	7	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1698	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1698	9	relating	relate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1698	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1698	11	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1698	12	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1698	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1698	14	]	]	X
inlawrev-20850	1698	15	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1698	16	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1698	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1698	18	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1698	19	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1698	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1698	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1698	22	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1698	23	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1698	24	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1698	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1698	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1699	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1700	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1700	2	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1700	3	http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1228596	http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1228596	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1700	4	http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1122170	http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1122170	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1701	1	178	178	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1701	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1701	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1701	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1701	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1701	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1701	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1702	1	49:117	49:117	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1702	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1702	3	elicited	elicit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1702	4	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1702	5	academic	academic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1702	6	commentary	commentary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1702	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1702	8	including	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1702	9	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1702	10	criticism	criticism	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1702	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1703	1	but364	but364	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1703	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1703	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1703	4	misapplication	misapplication	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1703	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1703	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1703	7	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1703	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1703	9	plus	plus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1703	10	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1703	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1703	12	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1703	13	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1703	14	garnered	garner	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1703	15	little	little	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1703	16	attention	attention	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1703	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1704	1	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1704	2	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1704	3	entirely	entirely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1704	4	understandable	understandable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1704	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1705	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1705	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1705	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1705	4	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1705	5	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1705	6	express	express	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1705	7	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1705	8	clearly	clearly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1705	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1706	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1706	2	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1706	3	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1706	4	illustration	illustration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1706	5	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1706	6	fit	fit	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1706	7	perfectly	perfectly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1706	8	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1706	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1706	10	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1706	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1706	12	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1706	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1706	14	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1706	15	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1706	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1706	17	proxy	proxy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1706	18	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1706	19	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1706	20	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1706	21	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1706	22	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1706	23	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1706	24	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1706	25	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1706	26	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1706	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1707	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1707	3	most	most	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	4	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1707	6	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1707	8	community	community	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	10	scholars	scholar	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	11	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1707	12	thinks	think	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1707	13	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	14	these	these	DET
inlawrev-20850	1707	15	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1707	17	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1707	18	stood	stand	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1707	19	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	20	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1707	21	another	another	DET
inlawrev-20850	1707	22	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	23	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1707	24	albeit	albeit	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	25	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	26	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1707	27	ways	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	28	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1707	29	extreme	extreme	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	30	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	31	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1707	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	33	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1707	34	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	35	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	36	using	use	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1707	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1707	38	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1707	39	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1707	40	plus	plus	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	41	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	43	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1707	44	familiar	familiar	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	45	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	46	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1707	47	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1707	48	address	address	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1707	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1707	50	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	51	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	52	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	53	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	54	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	55	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	56	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	57	signature	signature	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	58	diseases	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	59	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1707	60	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1707	61	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1707	62	caused	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1707	63	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	64	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	65	exposures.365	exposures.365	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	66	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	67	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1707	68	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1707	69	unremarked	unremarked	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	70	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	71	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	72	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	73	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	74	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	75	havner	havner	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	76	reverberated	reverberate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1707	77	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1707	78	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	79	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1707	80	above	above	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1707	81	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1707	82	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1707	83	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1707	84	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	85	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1707	86	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	87	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1707	88	evolved	evolve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1707	89	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1708	1	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1708	2	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1708	3	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1708	4	seen	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1708	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1708	6	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1708	7	undermined	undermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1708	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1708	9	coherence	coherence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1708	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1708	11	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1708	12	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1708	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1708	14	left	leave	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1708	15	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1708	16	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1708	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1708	18	including	include	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1708	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1708	20	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1708	21	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1708	22	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1708	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1708	24	confused	confuse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1708	25	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1708	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1708	27	meaning	meaning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1708	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1708	29	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1708	30	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1708	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1708	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1708	33	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1708	34	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1708	35	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1708	36	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1708	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1709	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1709	2	facilitated	facilitate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1709	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1709	4	shifts	shift	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1709	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1709	6	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1709	7	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1709	8	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1709	9	led	lead	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1709	10	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1709	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1709	12	internally	internally	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1709	13	inconsistent	inconsistent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1709	14	holdings	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1709	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1709	16	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1709	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1710	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1710	2	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1710	3	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1710	4	led	lead	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1710	5	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1710	6	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1710	7	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1710	8	most	most	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1710	9	egregious	egregious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1710	10	error	error	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1710	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1710	12	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1710	13	independent	independent	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1710	14	causal	causal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1710	15	sufficiency	sufficiency	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1710	16	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1710	17	each	each	DET
inlawrev-20850	1710	18	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1710	19	source	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1710	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1710	21	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1710	22	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1710	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1711	1	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1711	2	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1711	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1711	4	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1711	5	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1711	6	no	no	DET
inlawrev-20850	1711	7	telling	tell	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1711	8	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1711	9	academic	academic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1711	10	commentary	commentary	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1711	11	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1711	12	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1711	13	changed	change	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1711	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1711	15	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1711	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1711	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1711	18	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1711	19	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1711	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1711	21	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1711	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1712	1	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1712	2	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1712	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1712	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1712	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1712	6	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1712	7	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1712	8	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1712	9	conducted	conduct	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1712	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1712	11	canvass	canvass	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1712	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1712	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1712	14	scholarly	scholarly	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1712	15	literature	literature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1712	16	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1712	17	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1712	18	torts	torts	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1712	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1713	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1713	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1713	3	cited	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1713	4	few	few	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1713	5	sources	source	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1713	6	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1713	7	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1713	8	literature	literature	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1713	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1713	10	flores	flore	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1713	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1713	12	none	none	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1713	13	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1713	14	all	all	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1713	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1713	16	garza	garza	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1713	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1713	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1713	19	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1713	20	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1713	21	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1713	22	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1713	23	counting	count	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1713	24	restatement	restatement	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1713	25	sections	section	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1713	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1713	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1713	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1713	29	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1713	30	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1713	31	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1713	32	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1713	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1714	1	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1714	2	one	one	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1714	3	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1714	4	hope	hope	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1714	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1714	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1714	7	scholarly	scholarly	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1714	8	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1714	9	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1714	10	prompt	prompt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1714	11	rethinking	rethinking	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1714	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1714	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1714	14	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1714	15	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1714	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1714	17	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1714	18	elsewhere	elsewhere	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1714	19	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1714	20	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1714	21	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1714	22	tempted	tempt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1714	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1714	24	emulate	emulate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1714	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1714	26	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1714	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1714	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1714	29	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1714	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1714	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1714	32	highest	high	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1714	33	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1714	34	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1714	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1714	36	nation	nation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1714	37	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1714	38	second	second	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1714	39	most	most	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1714	40	populous	populous	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1714	41	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1714	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1715	1	this366	this366	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1715	2	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1715	3	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1715	4	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1715	5	burden	burden	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1715	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1715	7	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1715	8	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1715	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1715	10	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1715	11	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1715	12	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1715	13	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1715	14	718	718	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1715	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1715	16	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1715	17	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1715	18	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1715	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1715	20	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1715	21	balance	balance	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1715	22	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1715	23	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1715	24	conflicting	conflict	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1715	25	norms	norm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1715	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1715	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1716	1	364	364	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1716	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	1717	1	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1717	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1717	3	finley	finley	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1717	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1717	5	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1717	6	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1717	7	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1717	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1717	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1717	10	362	362	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1717	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1717	12	criticizing	criticize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1717	13	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1717	14	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1717	15	making	make	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1717	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1717	17	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1717	18	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1717	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1717	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1717	21	guise	guise	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1717	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1717	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1717	24	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1717	25	reliability	reliability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1717	26	ruling	ruling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1717	27	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1717	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1718	1	365	365	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1718	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-20850	1719	1	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1719	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1719	3	danielle	danielle	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1719	4	conway	conway	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1719	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1719	6	jones	jones	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1719	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1719	8	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1719	9	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1719	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1719	11	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1719	12	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1719	13	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1719	14	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1719	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1719	16	philosophical	philosophical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1719	17	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1719	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1719	19	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1719	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1719	21	certainty	certainty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1719	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1719	23	uncertain	uncertain	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1719	24	disciplines	discipline	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1719	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1719	26	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1719	27	u.	u.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1719	28	rich	rich	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1719	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1720	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1720	2	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1720	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1720	4	875	875	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1720	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1720	6	905	905	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1720	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1720	8	2002	2002	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1720	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1720	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1720	11	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1720	12	havner	havner	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1720	13	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1720	14	embodying	embody	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1720	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1720	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1720	17	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1720	18	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1720	19	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1720	20	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1720	21	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1720	22	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1720	23	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1720	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1720	25	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1721	1	andrew	andrew	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1721	2	r.	r.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1721	3	klein	klein	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1721	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1721	5	rethinking	rethink	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1721	6	medical	medical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1721	7	monitoring	monitoring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1721	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1721	9	64	64	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1721	10	brook	brook	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1721	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1722	2	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1722	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1722	4	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1722	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	6	20	20	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1722	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1722	8	21	21	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1722	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	10	1998	1998	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1722	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	13	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1722	14	havner	havner	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1722	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	16	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1722	17	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1722	18	examples	example	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	20	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1722	21	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1722	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1722	24	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1722	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	26	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1722	27	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	28	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1722	29	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1722	30	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	32	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1722	33	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1722	34	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	35	advocating	advocate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1722	36	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1722	37	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	38	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1722	39	receive	receive	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1722	40	medical	medical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1722	41	monitoring	monitoring	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	42	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	43	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1722	44	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1722	45	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1722	46	tortious	tortious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1722	47	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	48	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1722	49	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1722	50	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1722	51	doubles	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1722	52	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1722	53	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	54	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1722	55	disease	disease	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	56	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	57	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	58	vern	vern	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1722	59	r.	r.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1722	60	walker	walker	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1722	61	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	62	restoring	restore	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1722	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1722	64	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1722	65	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	66	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1722	67	tort	tort	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1722	68	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	69	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1722	70	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1722	71	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	72	junk	junk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	73	logic	logic	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	74	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	75	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1722	76	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1722	77	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	78	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1722	79	56	56	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1722	80	ala	ala	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1722	81	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1723	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1723	2	rev	rev	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1723	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1723	4	381	381	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1723	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1723	6	472	472	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1723	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1723	8	73	73	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1723	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1723	10	2004	2004	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1723	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1723	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1723	13	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1723	14	havner	havner	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1723	15	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-20850	1723	16	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1723	17	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1723	18	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1723	19	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1723	20	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1723	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1723	22	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1723	23	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1723	24	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1723	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1723	26	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1723	27	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1723	28	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1723	29	thomas	thomas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1723	30	o.	o.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1723	31	mcgarity	mcgarity	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1723	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1723	33	proposal	proposal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1723	34	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1723	35	linking	link	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1723	36	culpability	culpability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1723	37	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1723	38	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1723	39	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1723	40	ensure	ensure	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1723	41	corporate	corporate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1723	42	accountability	accountability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1723	43	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1723	44	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1723	45	risks	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1723	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1723	47	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1723	48	wm	wm	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1723	49	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1723	50	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1723	51	mary	mary	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1723	52	envtl	envtl	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1723	53	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1724	1	l	l	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1724	2	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1724	3	pol’y	pol’y	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1724	4	rev	rev	X
inlawrev-20850	1724	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1724	6	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1724	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1724	8	24	24	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1724	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1724	10	2001	2001	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1724	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1724	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1724	13	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1724	14	havner	havner	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1724	15	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1724	16	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1724	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1724	18	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1724	19	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1724	20	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1724	21	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1724	22	read	read	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1724	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1724	24	daubert	daubert	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1724	25	remand	remand	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1724	26	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1724	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1724	28	conclude	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1724	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1724	30	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1724	31	epidemiological	epidemiological	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1724	32	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1724	33	demonstrating	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1724	34	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1724	35	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1724	36	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1724	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1724	38	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1724	39	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1724	40	2.0	2.0	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1724	41	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1724	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1724	43	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1724	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1724	45	minimum	minimum	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1724	46	showing	showing	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1724	47	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1724	48	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1724	49	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1724	50	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1724	51	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1724	52	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1724	53	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1724	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1725	1	366	366	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1725	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1726	1	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1726	2	date	date	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1726	3	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1726	4	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1726	5	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1726	6	little	little	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1726	7	cited	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1726	8	outside	outside	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1726	9	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1726	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1726	11	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1726	12	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1726	13	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1726	14	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1726	15	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1726	16	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1726	17	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1726	18	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1726	19	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1726	20	drywall	drywall	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1726	21	mud	mud	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1726	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1726	23	muddy	muddy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1726	24	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1726	25	179	179	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1726	26	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1726	27	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1726	28	prompt	prompt	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1726	29	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1726	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1726	31	that	that	DET
inlawrev-20850	1726	32	thought	thought	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1726	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1727	1	conclusion	conclusion	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1727	2	toxic	toxic	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1727	3	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1727	4	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1727	5	involving	involve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1727	6	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1727	7	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1727	8	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1727	9	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1727	10	easy	easy	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1727	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1728	1	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1728	2	present	present	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1728	3	challenging	challenging	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1728	4	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1728	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1728	6	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1728	7	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1728	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1728	9	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1728	10	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1728	11	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1728	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1729	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1729	2	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1729	3	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1729	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1729	5	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1729	6	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1729	7	largely	largely	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1729	8	beyond	beyond	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1729	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1729	10	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1729	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1729	12	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1729	13	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1729	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1729	15	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1729	16	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1729	17	particularly	particularly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1729	18	acute	acute	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1729	19	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1729	20	carcinogens	carcinogen	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1729	21	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1729	22	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1729	23	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1729	24	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1729	25	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1729	26	serious	serious	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1729	27	illness	illness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1729	28	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1729	29	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1729	30	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1729	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1729	32	exposure	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1729	33	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1729	34	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1729	35	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1729	36	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1729	37	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1729	38	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1729	39	ubiquitous	ubiquitous	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1729	40	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1729	41	workplace	workplace	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1729	42	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1729	43	consumer	consumer	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1729	44	settings	setting	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1729	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1730	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1730	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1730	3	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1730	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1730	5	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1730	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1730	7	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1730	8	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1730	9	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1730	10	judgments	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1730	11	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1730	12	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1730	13	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1730	14	influenced	influence	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1730	15	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1730	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1730	17	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1730	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1730	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1730	20	most	most	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1730	21	culpable	culpable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1730	22	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1730	23	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1730	24	long	long	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1730	25	since	since	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1730	26	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1730	27	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1730	28	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1730	29	proof	proof	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1730	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1731	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1731	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1731	3	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1731	4	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	5	concerns	concern	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	6	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1731	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1731	8	drive367	drive367	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1731	9	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	10	’	’	PART
inlawrev-20850	1731	11	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1731	13	making	making	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1731	15	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1731	16	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1731	18	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	19	ought	ought	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1731	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1731	21	express	express	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1731	22	openly	openly	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1731	23	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1731	24	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	25	judgments	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1731	27	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1731	28	rationales	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1731	30	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1731	31	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1731	32	casting	cast	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1731	33	those	those	DET
inlawrev-20850	1731	34	judgments	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	35	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1731	36	matters	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1731	38	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	39	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1731	40	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1731	41	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1731	42	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1731	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1732	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1732	2	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1732	3	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1732	4	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1732	5	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1732	6	difficult	difficult	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1732	7	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1732	8	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1732	9	intractable	intractable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1732	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1733	1	some	some	DET
inlawrev-20850	1733	2	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1733	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1733	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1733	5	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1733	6	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1733	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1733	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1733	9	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1733	10	kingdom	kingdom	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1733	11	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1733	12	successfully	successfully	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1733	13	turned	turn	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1733	14	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1733	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1733	16	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1733	17	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1733	18	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1733	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1733	20	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1733	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1733	22	eschewing	eschew	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1733	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1733	24	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1733	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1733	26	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1733	27	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1733	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1734	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1734	2	risk368	risk368	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1734	3	369	369	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1734	4	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1734	5	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1734	6	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1734	7	not	not	PART
inlawrev-20850	1734	8	necessarily	necessarily	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1734	9	mean	mean	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1734	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1734	11	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1734	12	always	always	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1734	13	prevail	prevail	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1734	14	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1734	15	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1734	16	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1734	17	leave	leave	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1734	18	room	room	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1734	19	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1734	20	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1734	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1734	22	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1734	23	exceptions	exception	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1734	24	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1734	25	de	de	X
inlawrev-20850	1734	26	minimis	minimis	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1734	27	contributions	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1734	28	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1734	29	overdetermined	overdetermine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1734	30	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1734	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1734	32	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1734	33	apportionment	apportionment	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1734	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1734	35	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1734	36	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1734	37	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1734	38	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1734	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1735	1	this	this	DET
inlawrev-20850	1735	2	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1735	4	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1735	5	imperfect	imperfect	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1735	7	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1735	8	considerable	considerable	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1735	9	merit	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1735	11	comports	comport	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1735	12	reasonably	reasonably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1735	13	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1735	14	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1735	15	existing	exist	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1735	16	scientific	scientific	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1735	17	understanding	understanding	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1735	19	mesothelioma	mesothelioma	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	20	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	21	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1735	22	asbestos.370	asbestos.370	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1735	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1735	24	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1735	25	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	26	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1735	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1735	28	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	29	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	30	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1735	31	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1735	32	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1735	33	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1735	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1735	35	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	36	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1735	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1735	38	appropriateness	appropriateness	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1735	40	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1735	41	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	42	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	43	model	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1735	44	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1735	45	refused	refuse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1735	46	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1735	47	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1735	48	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1735	49	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1736	1	instead	instead	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1736	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1736	3	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1736	4	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1736	5	serve	serve	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1736	6	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1736	7	objectives	objective	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1736	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1736	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1736	10	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1736	11	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1736	12	misused	misuse	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1736	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1736	14	hodgepodge	hodgepodge	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1736	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1736	16	causal	causal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1736	17	models	model	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1736	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1736	19	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1736	20	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1736	21	causation	causation	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1736	22	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1736	23	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1736	24	odds	odd	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1736	25	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1736	26	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1736	27	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1736	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1736	29	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1736	30	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1736	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1737	1	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1737	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1737	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1737	4	mistake	mistake	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1737	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1737	6	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1737	7	scholars	scholar	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1737	8	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1737	9	note	note	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1737	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1737	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1737	12	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1737	13	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1737	14	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1737	15	decline	decline	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1737	16	to	to	PART
inlawrev-20850	1737	17	replicate	replicate	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1737	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1738	1	note	note	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1738	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1739	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1739	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1739	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1739	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1739	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1739	6	re	re	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1739	7	n.y	n.y	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1739	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1739	9	city	city	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1739	10	asbestos	asbestos	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1739	11	litig	litig	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1739	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1740	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1740	2	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1740	3	wl	wl	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1740	4	1840006	1840006	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1740	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1740	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1740	7	21	21	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1740	8	n.1	n.1	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1740	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1740	10	n.y	n.y	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1740	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1740	12	sup	sup	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1740	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1741	1	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1741	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1742	1	apr	apr	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1742	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1742	3	13	13	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1742	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1742	5	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1742	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1742	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1742	8	favorably	favorably	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1742	9	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1742	10	bostic	bostic	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1742	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1742	12	ford	ford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1742	13	motor	motor	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1742	14	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1742	15	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1742	16	boomer	boomer	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1742	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1742	18	736	736	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1742	19	s.e.2d	s.e.2d	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1742	20	724	724	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1742	21	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1742	22	va	va	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1742	23	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1742	24	2013	2013	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1742	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1742	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1742	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1743	1	367	367	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1743	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1744	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1744	2	sanders	sanders	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1744	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1744	4	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1744	5	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1744	6	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1744	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1744	8	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1744	9	1156	1156	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1744	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1745	1	368	368	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1745	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	1	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1746	2	sienkiewicz	sienkiewicz	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1746	3	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1746	4	greif	greif	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1746	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	6	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1746	7	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1746	8	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	9	uksc	uksc	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1746	10	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1746	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	12	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1746	13	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1746	14	]	]	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1746	15	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1746	16	wlr	wlr	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1746	17	523	523	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1746	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	19	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1746	20	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1746	21	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1746	22	eng	eng	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1746	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	25	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	26	rutherford	rutherford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1746	27	v.	v.	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1746	28	owens	owens	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1746	29	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	30	illinois	illinois	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1746	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	32	941	941	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1746	33	p.2d	p.2d	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1746	34	1203	1203	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1746	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	36	1220	1220	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1746	37	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1746	38	21	21	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1746	39	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	40	1223	1223	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1746	41	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	42	1997	1997	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1746	43	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1746	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1747	1	369	369	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1747	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1748	1	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1748	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1748	3	sienkiewicz	sienkiewicz	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1748	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1748	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1748	6	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1748	7	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1748	8	uksc	uksc	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1748	9	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1749	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1749	2	105	105	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1749	3	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1749	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1750	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-20850	1750	2	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1750	3	]	]	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1750	4	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1750	5	wlr	wlr	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1750	6	523	523	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1750	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1750	8	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1750	9	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1750	10	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1750	11	eng	eng	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1750	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1750	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1751	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1751	2	lord	lord	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1751	3	phillips	phillips	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1751	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1751	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1751	6	giving	give	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1751	7	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1751	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1751	9	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1751	10	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1751	11	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1751	12	combine	combine	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1751	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1751	14	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1751	15	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1751	16	double	double	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1751	17	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1751	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1751	19	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1751	20	doubling	double	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1751	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1751	22	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1751	23	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1751	24	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1751	25	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1751	26	exposures	exposure	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1751	27	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1751	28	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1751	29	allen	allen	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1751	30	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1751	31	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1751	32	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1751	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1751	34	588	588	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1751	35	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1751	36	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1751	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1752	1	247	247	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1752	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1752	3	416	416	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1752	4	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1752	5	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1752	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1752	7	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1752	8	utah	utah	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1752	9	1984	1984	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1752	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1752	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1752	12	rejecting	reject	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1752	13	doubling	doubling	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1752	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1752	15	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1752	16	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1752	17	minimum	minimum	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1752	18	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1752	19	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1752	20	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1752	21	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1752	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1752	23	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1752	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1752	25	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1753	1	rutherford	rutherford	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1753	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1753	3	941	941	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1753	4	p.2d	p.2d	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1753	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1753	6	1220	1220	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1753	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1753	8	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1753	9	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-20850	1753	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1753	11	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1753	12	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1753	13	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1753	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1753	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1753	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1753	17	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1753	18	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1753	19	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1753	20	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1753	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-20850	1753	22	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1753	23	broad	broad	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1753	24	one	one	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1753	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1753	26	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1753	27	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-20850	1753	28	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1753	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1753	30	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1753	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1753	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1753	33	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1753	34	cause	cause	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1753	35	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-20850	1753	36	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1753	37	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1753	38	negligible	negligible	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1753	39	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-20850	1753	40	theoretical	theoretical	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1753	41	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1753	42	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1753	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1754	1	370	370	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1754	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1755	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1755	2	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1755	3	exploration	exploration	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1755	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1755	5	potential	potential	ADJ
inlawrev-20850	1755	6	difficulties	difficulty	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1755	7	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1755	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1755	9	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1755	10	contribution	contribution	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1755	11	approach	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1755	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1755	13	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1755	14	sanders	sander	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1755	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1755	16	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1755	17	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1755	18	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1755	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1755	20	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1755	21	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1755	22	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1755	23	40	40	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1755	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1756	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1756	2	an	an	DET
inlawrev-20850	1756	3	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1756	4	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1756	5	favor	favor	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1756	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1756	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-20850	1756	8	approach	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1756	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1756	10	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-20850	1756	11	gold	gold	NOUN
inlawrev-20850	1756	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1756	13	supra	supra	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1756	14	note	note	PROPN
inlawrev-20850	1756	15	85	85	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1756	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-20850	1756	17	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-20850	1756	18	322	322	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1756	19	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-20850	1756	20	38	38	NUM
inlawrev-20850	1756	21	.	.	PUNCT