id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
inlawrev-25097	1	1	developments	development	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	1	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	1	3	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	1	4	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	1	5	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	1	6	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	1	7	october	october	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	1	8	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	1	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	1	10	2017	2017	NUM
inlawrev-25097	1	11	–	–	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	1	12	september	september	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	1	13	30	30	NUM
inlawrev-25097	1	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	1	15	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	1	16	r.	r.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	1	17	trevor	trevor	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	1	18	carter	carter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	1	19	*	*	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	1	20	leslie	leslie	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	1	21	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	1	22	hayden	hayden	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	2	1	*	*	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	2	2	*	*	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	2	3	reid	reid	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	2	4	e.	e.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	2	5	dodge	dodge	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	2	6	*	*	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	2	7	*	*	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	2	8	*	*	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	3	1	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	3	2	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	3	3	addresses	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	3	4	recent	recent	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	3	5	developments	development	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	3	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	3	7	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	3	8	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	3	9	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	3	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	4	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	4	2	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	4	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	4	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	4	5	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	4	6	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	4	7	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	4	8	overview	overview	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	4	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	4	10	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	4	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	4	12	six	six	NUM
inlawrev-25097	4	13	pivotal	pivotal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	4	14	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	4	15	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	4	16	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	4	17	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	4	18	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	4	19	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-25097	4	20	october	october	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	4	21	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	4	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	4	23	2017	2017	NUM
inlawrev-25097	4	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	4	25	september	september	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	4	26	31	31	NUM
inlawrev-25097	4	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	4	28	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	4	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	5	1	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-25097	5	2	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	5	3	these	these	DET
inlawrev-25097	5	4	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	5	5	come	come	VERB
inlawrev-25097	5	6	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	5	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	5	8	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	5	9	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	5	10	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	5	11	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	5	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	5	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	5	14	remaining	remain	VERB
inlawrev-25097	5	15	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-25097	5	16	come	come	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	5	17	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	5	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	5	19	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	5	20	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	5	21	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	5	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	5	23	appeals	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	5	24	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	5	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	5	26	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	5	27	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	5	28	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	5	29	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	5	30	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	5	31	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	5	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	5	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	5	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	6	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	6	2	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	6	3	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	6	4	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	6	5	•	•	NUM
inlawrev-25097	6	6	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	6	7	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	6	8	energy	energy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	6	9	services	services	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	6	10	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	6	11	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	6	12	greene	greene	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	6	13	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	6	14	energy	energy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	6	15	group	group	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	6	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	6	17	llc;1	llc;1	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	6	18	•	•	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	6	19	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	6	20	institute	institute	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	6	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	6	22	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	6	23	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	2	iancu;2	iancu;2	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	3	•	•	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	4	westerngeco	westerngeco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	5	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	6	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	7	ion	ion	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	8	geophysical	geophysical	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	7	9	corp.3	corp.3	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	10	•	•	NUM
inlawrev-25097	7	11	wi	wi	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	7	13	fi	fi	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	14	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	7	15	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	16	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	17	broadcom	broadcom	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	18	corp.;4	corp.;4	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	19	•	•	ADV
inlawrev-25097	7	20	berkheimer	berkheimer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	21	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	22	hp	hp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	23	inc.;5	inc.;5	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	7	25	•	•	NUM
inlawrev-25097	7	26	saint	saint	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	27	regis	regis	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	28	mohawk	mohawk	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	29	tribe	tribe	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	30	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	31	mylan	mylan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	32	pharmaceuticals.6	pharmaceuticals.6	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	33	i.	i.	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	34	constitutionality	constitutionality	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	36	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	37	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	38	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	39	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	7	40	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	41	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	42	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	43	greene	greene	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	44	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	7	45	energy	energy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	46	group	group	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	47	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	7	48	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	49	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	50	april	april	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	51	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	7	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	7	53	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	7	54	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	55	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	56	issued	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	7	57	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	7	58	highly	highly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	7	59	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	7	60	anticipated	anticipate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	7	61	7	7	NUM
inlawrev-25097	7	62	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	7	63	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-25097	7	64	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	65	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	66	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	67	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	68	energy	energy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	69	services	service	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	70	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	71	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	72	greene	greene	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	73	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	7	74	energy	energy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	75	group	group	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	76	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	7	77	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	78	upholding	uphold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	7	79	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	7	80	constitutionality	constitutionality	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	81	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	82	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	7	83	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	84	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	85	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	86	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	87	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	88	patents.7	patents.7	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	89	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	7	90	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	91	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	7	92	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	7	93	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	94	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	95	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	96	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	7	97	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	7	98	violate	violate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	7	99	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	100	iii	iii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	101	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	7	102	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	7	103	seventh	seventh	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	7	104	amendment.8	amendment.8	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	105	a.	a.	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	106	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	107	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	7	108	america	america	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	109	invents	invents	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	110	act	act	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	111	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	112	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-25097	7	113	created	create	VERB
inlawrev-25097	7	114	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	7	115	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	116	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	117	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	118	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	119	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	120	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	7	121	means	mean	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	122	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	123	reexamining	reexamine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	7	124	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	7	125	validity	validity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	126	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	127	previously	previously	ADV
inlawrev-25097	7	128	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	7	129	issued	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	7	130	patents.9	patents.9	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	131	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	7	132	inter	inter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	133	*	*	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	134	r.	r.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	135	trevor	trevor	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	136	carter	carter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	137	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	7	138	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	7	139	partner	partner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	140	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	141	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	7	142	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	143	firm	firm	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	7	144	faegre	faegre	VERB
inlawrev-25097	7	145	baker	baker	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	146	daniels	daniels	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	147	llp	llp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	148	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	7	149	indianapolis	indianapolis	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	150	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	7	151	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	7	152	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	8	1	*	*	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	8	2	*	*	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	8	3	leslie	leslie	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	8	4	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	8	5	hayden	hayden	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	8	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	8	7	ip	ip	PRON
inlawrev-25097	8	8	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	8	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	8	10	macom	macom	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	8	11	technology	technology	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	8	12	solutions	solutions	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	8	13	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	8	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	9	1	*	*	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	9	2	*	*	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	9	3	*	*	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	9	4	reid	reid	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	9	5	e.	e.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	9	6	dodge	dodge	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	9	7	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	9	8	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	9	9	associate	associate	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	9	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	9	11	faegre	faegre	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	9	12	baker	baker	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	9	13	daniels	daniels	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	9	14	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	9	15	indianapolis	indianapolis	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	9	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	9	17	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	9	18	office	office	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	9	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	10	1	1	1	X
inlawrev-25097	10	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-25097	10	3	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	10	4	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	10	5	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	10	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	10	7	1365	1365	NUM
inlawrev-25097	10	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	10	9	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	10	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	10	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	11	1	2	2	X
inlawrev-25097	11	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-25097	11	3	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	11	4	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	11	5	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	11	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	11	7	1348	1348	NUM
inlawrev-25097	11	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	11	9	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	11	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	11	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	12	1	3	3	X
inlawrev-25097	12	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-25097	12	3	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	12	4	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	12	5	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	12	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	12	7	2129	2129	NUM
inlawrev-25097	12	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	12	9	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	12	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	12	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	13	1	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-25097	13	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-25097	13	3	878	878	NUM
inlawrev-25097	13	4	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	13	5	1364	1364	NUM
inlawrev-25097	13	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	13	7	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	13	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	13	9	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	13	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	13	11	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	13	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	13	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	14	1	5	5	X
inlawrev-25097	14	2	.	.	NUM
inlawrev-25097	14	3	881	881	NUM
inlawrev-25097	14	4	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	14	5	1360	1360	NUM
inlawrev-25097	14	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	14	7	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	14	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	14	9	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	14	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	14	11	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	14	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	14	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	15	1	6	6	NUM
inlawrev-25097	15	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-25097	15	3	896	896	NUM
inlawrev-25097	15	4	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	15	5	1322	1322	NUM
inlawrev-25097	15	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	15	7	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	15	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	15	9	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	15	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	15	11	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	15	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	15	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	15	14	cert	cert	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	15	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	16	1	denied	deny	VERB
inlawrev-25097	16	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	16	3	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	16	4	wl	wl	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	16	5	1590253	1590253	NUM
inlawrev-25097	16	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	16	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	16	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	16	9	apr	apr	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	16	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	16	11	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-25097	16	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	16	13	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	16	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	16	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	17	1	7	7	X
inlawrev-25097	17	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-25097	17	3	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	17	4	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	17	5	energy	energy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	17	6	servs	servs	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	17	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	18	1	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	18	2	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	18	3	greene	greene	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	18	4	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	18	5	energy	energy	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	18	6	grp	grp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	18	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	18	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	18	9	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	18	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	18	11	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	18	12	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	18	13	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	18	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	18	15	1365	1365	NUM
inlawrev-25097	18	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	18	17	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	18	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	18	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	19	1	8	8	X
inlawrev-25097	19	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	20	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	20	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	20	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	20	4	1369	1369	NUM
inlawrev-25097	20	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	21	1	9	9	X
inlawrev-25097	21	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-25097	21	3	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-25097	21	4	america	america	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	21	5	invents	invents	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	21	6	act	act	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	21	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	21	8	pub	pub	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	21	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	22	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	22	2	no	no	INTJ
inlawrev-25097	22	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	23	1	112	112	NUM
inlawrev-25097	23	2	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	23	3	29	29	NUM
inlawrev-25097	23	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	23	5	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	23	6	6(a	6(a	NUM
inlawrev-25097	23	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	23	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	23	9	125	125	NUM
inlawrev-25097	23	10	stat	stat	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	23	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	24	1	284	284	NUM
inlawrev-25097	24	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	24	3	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-25097	24	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	24	5	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	24	6	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	24	7	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	24	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	25	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	25	2	311	311	NUM
inlawrev-25097	25	3	et	et	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	25	4	seq	seq	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	25	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	26	1	772	772	NUM
inlawrev-25097	26	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	26	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	26	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	26	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	26	8	52:771	52:771	NUM
inlawrev-25097	26	9	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	10	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	26	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	26	13	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	26	15	like	like	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	26	16	adversarial	adversarial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	26	17	proceeding	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	18	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-25097	26	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	26	20	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	21	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	22	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	26	23	appeals	appeals	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	26	24	board	board	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	25	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	26	26	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	26	27	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	28	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	26	29	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	26	30	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	26	31	board	board	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	26	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	26	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	26	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	26	36	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	26	37	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	26	38	patent	patent	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	26	39	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	26	40	trademark	trademark	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	26	41	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	42	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	26	43	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	26	44	uspto”).10	uspto”).10	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	45	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	26	46	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	26	47	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	26	48	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	49	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	50	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	26	51	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	26	52	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	53	wishing	wish	VERB
inlawrev-25097	26	54	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	26	55	challenge	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	26	56	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	26	57	validity	validity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	58	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	26	59	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	26	60	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	61	files	file	VERB
inlawrev-25097	26	62	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	26	63	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	26	64	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	26	65	cancel	cancel	VERB
inlawrev-25097	26	66	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	26	67	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	26	68	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	26	69	claims.11	claims.11	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	27	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	2	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	3	owner	owner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	27	5	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	6	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	7	opportunity	opportunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	27	9	respond	respond	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	10	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	12	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	27	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	27	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	16	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	17	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	27	18	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	20	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	21	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	22	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	27	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	27	24	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	25	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	26	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	27	27	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	28	review.12	review.12	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	29	unlike	unlike	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	30	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	31	types	type	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	33	post	post	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	34	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	35	grant	grant	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	36	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	37	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	38	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	40	uspto	uspto	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	27	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	43	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	44	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	27	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	46	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	47	owner	owner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	48	both	both	PRON
inlawrev-25097	27	49	participate	participate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	50	throughout	throughout	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	52	process.13	process.13	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	53	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	27	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	55	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	27	56	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	57	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	58	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	27	59	instituted	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	60	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	27	61	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	62	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	63	conduct	conduct	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	64	discovery	discovery	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	65	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	27	66	submit	submit	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	67	briefing	briefing	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	68	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	69	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	70	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	71	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	27	72	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	27	73	participate	participate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	74	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	75	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	76	oral	oral	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	77	hearing.14	hearing.14	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	78	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	79	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	80	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	27	81	issues	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	82	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	83	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	84	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	27	85	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	86	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	87	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	88	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	89	patentability	patentability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	90	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	91	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	92	claims.15	claims.15	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	27	93	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	27	94	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	95	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	96	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	97	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	98	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	27	99	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	100	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	101	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	27	102	unhappy	unhappy	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	103	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	104	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	105	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	106	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	107	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	108	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	27	109	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	27	110	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-25097	27	111	appeal	appeal	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	112	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	113	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	114	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	115	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	116	appeals	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	117	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	118	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	119	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	120	circuit.16	circuit.16	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	27	121	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	122	reviewing	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	123	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	124	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	125	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	126	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	127	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	27	128	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	27	129	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	130	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	131	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	132	assesses	assess	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	133	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	27	134	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	27	135	board	board	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	136	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	27	137	compliance	compliance	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	138	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	139	governing	govern	VERB
inlawrev-25097	27	140	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	141	standards	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	142	de	de	X
inlawrev-25097	27	143	novo	novo	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	144	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	27	145	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	27	146	underlying	underlying	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	147	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	148	determinations	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	149	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	27	150	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	27	151	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	27	152	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	27	153	’”17	’”17	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	28	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	2	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	3	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	28	5	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	6	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	7	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	8	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	28	10	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	11	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	12	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	13	violates	violate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	15	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	17	constitution	constitution	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	18	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	28	19	separation	separation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	21	powers	power	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	22	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	28	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	24	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	28	25	proceeding	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	26	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	28	27	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-25097	28	28	result	result	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	31	revocation	revocation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	33	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	34	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	35	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-25097	28	36	take	take	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	37	place	place	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	38	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	39	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	40	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	41	iii	iii	NUM
inlawrev-25097	28	42	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	43	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	45	jury.18	jury.18	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	46	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	47	procedural	procedural	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	48	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	49	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	50	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	51	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	28	52	greene	greene	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	53	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	28	54	energy	energy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	55	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	28	56	competitors	competitor	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	57	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	58	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	59	oilfield	oilfield	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	60	services	service	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	61	industry.19	industry.19	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	62	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	63	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	64	brought	bring	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	65	suit	suit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	66	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	67	greene	greene	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	68	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	28	69	energy	energy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	70	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	71	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	28	72	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	73	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	74	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	75	allegedly	allegedly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	28	76	infringing	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	77	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	28	78	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	79	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	80	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	81	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	28	82	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	83	relating	relate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	84	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	85	fracking	fracke	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	86	equipment.20	equipment.20	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	87	greene	greene	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	88	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	28	89	energy	energy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	90	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	28	91	filed	file	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	92	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	93	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	94	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	95	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	28	96	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	97	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	98	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	99	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	100	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	101	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	28	102	patent.2	patent.2	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	103	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	28	104	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	105	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	106	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	107	issued	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	108	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	109	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	110	construction	construction	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	111	order	order	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	112	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	28	113	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	28	114	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	115	win	win	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	116	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	117	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	118	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	119	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	28	120	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	28	121	foreclosed	foreclose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	122	greene	greene	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	123	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	28	124	energy	energy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	125	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	28	126	arguments	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	127	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	28	128	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	129	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	130	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	28	131	invalid.22	invalid.22	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	132	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-25097	28	133	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	28	134	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	135	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	136	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	28	137	issued	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	138	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	139	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	140	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	141	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	142	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	143	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	144	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	145	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	28	146	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	147	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	28	148	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	149	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	150	claims	claim	VERB
inlawrev-25097	28	151	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	28	152	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	28	153	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	28	154	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	155	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	28	156	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	28	157	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-25097	28	158	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	29	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-25097	29	2	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	29	3	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	29	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	30	1	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	30	2	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	30	3	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	30	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	30	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	30	6	1371	1371	NUM
inlawrev-25097	30	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	31	1	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-25097	31	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	32	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	32	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	32	3	12	12	NUM
inlawrev-25097	32	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	33	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	33	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	33	3	13	13	NUM
inlawrev-25097	33	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	34	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	34	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	34	3	14	14	NUM
inlawrev-25097	34	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	35	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	35	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	35	3	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-25097	35	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	36	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	36	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	36	3	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	36	4	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	36	5	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	36	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	37	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	37	2	317(a	317(a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	37	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	37	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	37	5	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	37	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	37	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	38	1	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-25097	38	2	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	38	3	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	38	4	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	38	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	39	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	39	2	319	319	NUM
inlawrev-25097	39	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	39	4	17	17	NUM
inlawrev-25097	39	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	40	1	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	40	2	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	40	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	40	4	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	40	5	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	40	6	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	40	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	41	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	41	2	1372	1372	NUM
inlawrev-25097	41	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	41	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	41	5	randall	randall	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	41	6	mfg	mfg	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	41	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	42	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	42	2	rea	rea	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	42	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	42	4	733	733	NUM
inlawrev-25097	42	5	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	42	6	1355	1355	NUM
inlawrev-25097	42	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	42	8	1362	1362	NUM
inlawrev-25097	42	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	42	10	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	42	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	42	12	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	42	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	42	14	2013	2013	NUM
inlawrev-25097	42	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	42	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	42	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	43	1	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-25097	43	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	44	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	44	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	44	3	19	19	NUM
inlawrev-25097	44	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	45	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	45	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	45	3	20	20	NUM
inlawrev-25097	45	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	46	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	46	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	46	3	21	21	NUM
inlawrev-25097	46	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	47	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	47	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	47	3	22	22	NUM
inlawrev-25097	47	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	48	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	48	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	3	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	48	4	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	48	5	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	6	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	7	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	8	773	773	NUM
inlawrev-25097	48	9	unpatentable.23	unpatentable.23	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	10	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	11	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	12	appealed	appeal	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	14	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	15	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	16	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	17	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	20	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	21	circuit.24	circuit.24	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	22	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	48	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	24	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	25	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	26	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	48	27	arguments	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	28	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	30	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	31	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	32	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	48	33	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	48	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	35	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	36	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	37	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	38	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	39	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	48	40	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	41	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	48	42	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	43	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	44	proceeding	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	45	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	48	46	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-25097	48	47	result	result	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	48	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	50	revocation	revocation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	51	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	52	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	53	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	54	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-25097	48	55	take	take	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	56	place	place	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	57	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	58	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	59	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	60	iii	iii	NUM
inlawrev-25097	48	61	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	62	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	63	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	64	jury.25	jury.25	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	65	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	66	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	67	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	68	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	69	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	70	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	71	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	48	72	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	73	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	74	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	75	constitutionality	constitutionality	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	76	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	77	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	78	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	79	review.26	review.26	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	80	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	81	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	82	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	48	83	sought	seek	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	84	certiorari	certiorari	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	85	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	86	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	87	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	88	court.27	court.27	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	89	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	90	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	91	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	92	granted	grant	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	93	certiorari	certiorari	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	94	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	48	95	upheld	uphold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	96	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	97	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	98	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	99	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	48	100	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	101	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	48	102	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	103	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	48	104	inter	inter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	105	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	106	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	107	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	48	108	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	109	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	48	110	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	48	111	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	48	112	violate	violate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	113	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	114	iii	iii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	115	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	48	116	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	117	seventh	seventh	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	118	amendment.28	amendment.28	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	119	c.	c.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	120	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	121	thomas	thomas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	122	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	48	123	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	124	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	125	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	126	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	127	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	128	thomas	thomas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	129	delivered	deliver	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	130	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	131	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	132	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	133	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	134	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	135	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	48	136	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	137	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	138	justices	justices	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	139	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	140	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	48	141	ginsburg	ginsburg	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	142	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	48	143	breyer	breyer	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	144	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	48	145	alito	alito	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	146	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	48	147	sotomayor	sotomayor	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	148	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	48	149	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	48	150	kagan.29	kagan.29	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	151	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	152	thomas	thomas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	153	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	154	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	48	155	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-25097	48	156	analyzing	analyze	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	157	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	158	iii	iii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	159	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	48	160	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	161	seventh	seventh	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	48	162	amendment	amendment	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	163	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	48	164	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	48	165	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	166	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	48	167	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	168	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	169	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	170	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	48	171	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	48	172	violate	violate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	48	173	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	48	174	constitution	constitution	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	48	175	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	49	1	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-25097	49	2	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	49	3	focused	focus	VERB
inlawrev-25097	49	4	largely	largely	ADV
inlawrev-25097	49	5	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	49	6	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	49	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	49	8	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	49	9	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	49	10	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	49	11	applies	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	49	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	49	13	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	49	14	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	49	15	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	49	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	50	1	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	50	2	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	50	3	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	50	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	50	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	50	6	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	50	7	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	50	8	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	50	9	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-25097	50	10	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	50	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	50	12	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	50	13	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	50	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	50	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	50	16	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	50	17	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	50	18	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	50	19	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	50	20	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	50	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	50	22	violate	violate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	50	23	article	article	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	50	24	iii	iii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	50	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	51	1	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	51	2	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	51	3	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	51	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	51	5	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-25097	51	6	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-25097	51	7	no	no	DET
inlawrev-25097	51	8	seventh	seventh	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	51	9	amendment	amendment	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	51	10	violation	violation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	51	11	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	51	12	once	once	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	51	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	51	14	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	51	15	properly	properly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	51	16	assigns	assign	VERB
inlawrev-25097	51	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	51	18	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	51	19	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	51	20	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	51	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	51	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	51	23	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	51	24	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	51	25	article	article	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	51	26	iii	iii	NUM
inlawrev-25097	51	27	tribunal	tribunal	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	51	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	51	29	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-25097	51	30	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-25097	51	31	no	no	DET
inlawrev-25097	51	32	seventh	seventh	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	51	33	amendment	amendment	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	51	34	violation	violation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	51	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	52	1	1	1	X
inlawrev-25097	52	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-25097	52	3	article	article	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	52	4	iii.—article	iii.—article	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	52	5	iii	iii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	52	6	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	52	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	52	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	52	9	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	52	10	powers	power	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	52	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	52	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	52	13	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	52	14	government	government	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	52	15	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	52	16	vested	vest	VERB
inlawrev-25097	52	17	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	52	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	52	19	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	52	20	supreme	supreme	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	52	21	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	52	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	52	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	52	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	52	25	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	52	26	inferior	inferior	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	52	27	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	52	28	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	52	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	52	30	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	52	31	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-25097	52	32	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	52	33	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	52	34	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	52	35	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	52	36	ordain	ordain	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	52	37	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	52	38	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-25097	52	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	53	1	”30	”30	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	53	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	53	3	addressing	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	53	4	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	53	5	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	53	6	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	7	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	8	violates	violate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	53	9	article	article	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	53	10	iii	iii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	53	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	53	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	53	13	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	14	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	53	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	53	16	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	53	17	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	18	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	53	20	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	53	21	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	53	22	covers	cover	VERB
inlawrev-25097	53	23	matters	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	24	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	53	25	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	53	26	arise	arise	VERB
inlawrev-25097	53	27	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-25097	53	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	53	29	government	government	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	30	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	53	31	persons	person	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	32	subject	subject	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	53	33	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	53	34	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	53	35	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	36	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	53	37	connection	connection	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	38	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	53	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	53	40	performance	performance	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	53	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	53	43	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	53	44	functions	function	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	53	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	53	47	executive	executive	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	53	48	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	53	49	legislative	legislative	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	53	50	departments	department	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	53	52	’”31	’”31	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	53	53	stated	state	VERB
inlawrev-25097	53	54	differently	differently	ADV
inlawrev-25097	53	55	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	53	56	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	53	57	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	53	58	applies	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	53	59	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	53	60	matters	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	61	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	53	62	arising	arise	VERB
inlawrev-25097	53	63	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-25097	53	64	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	53	65	government	government	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	66	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	53	67	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	68	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	53	69	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	53	70	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	53	71	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-25097	53	72	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	73	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	53	74	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	53	75	require	require	VERB
inlawrev-25097	53	76	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	53	77	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	53	78	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	53	79	yet	yet	ADV
inlawrev-25097	53	80	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	53	81	susceptible	susceptible	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	53	82	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	53	83	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	53	84	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	53	85	’”32	’”32	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	54	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	54	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	54	3	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	54	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	54	5	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	54	6	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	54	7	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	54	8	involves	involve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	54	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	54	10	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	54	11	right—“reconsideration	right—“reconsideration	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	54	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	54	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	54	14	government	government	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	54	15	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	54	16	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	54	17	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	54	18	grant	grant	VERB
inlawrev-25097	54	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	54	20	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	54	21	23	23	NUM
inlawrev-25097	54	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	55	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	55	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	55	3	24	24	NUM
inlawrev-25097	55	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	56	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	56	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	56	3	25	25	NUM
inlawrev-25097	56	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	57	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	57	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	57	3	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-25097	57	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	58	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	58	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	58	3	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-25097	58	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	59	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	59	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	59	3	28	28	NUM
inlawrev-25097	59	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	60	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	60	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	60	3	29	29	NUM
inlawrev-25097	60	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	61	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	61	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	61	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	61	4	1369	1369	NUM
inlawrev-25097	61	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	62	1	30	30	NUM
inlawrev-25097	62	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	63	1	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	63	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	63	3	const	const	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	63	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	63	5	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	63	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	64	1	iii	iii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	64	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	64	3	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	64	4	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	64	5	.	.	SYM
inlawrev-25097	64	6	31	31	NUM
inlawrev-25097	64	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	65	1	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	65	2	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	65	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	65	4	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	65	5	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	65	6	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	65	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	66	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	66	2	1373	1373	NUM
inlawrev-25097	66	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	66	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	66	5	crowell	crowell	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	66	6	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	66	7	benson	benson	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	66	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	66	9	285	285	NUM
inlawrev-25097	66	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	66	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	66	12	22	22	NUM
inlawrev-25097	66	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	66	14	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-25097	66	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	66	16	1932	1932	NUM
inlawrev-25097	66	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	66	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	66	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	67	1	32	32	NUM
inlawrev-25097	67	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	68	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	68	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	68	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	68	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	68	5	crowell	crowell	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	68	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	68	7	285	285	NUM
inlawrev-25097	68	8	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	68	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	68	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	68	11	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-25097	68	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	68	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	69	1	774	774	NUM
inlawrev-25097	69	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	69	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	69	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	69	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	69	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	69	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	69	8	52:771	52:771	NUM
inlawrev-25097	69	9	franchise	franchise	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	69	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	70	1	”33	”33	VERB
inlawrev-25097	70	2	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	70	3	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	70	4	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	70	5	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	70	6	involves	involve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	70	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	70	8	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	70	9	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	70	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	70	11	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	70	12	falls	fall	VERB
inlawrev-25097	70	13	within	within	ADP
inlawrev-25097	70	14	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-25097	70	15	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	70	16	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-25097	70	17	precedents	precedent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	70	18	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	70	19	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	70	20	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	70	21	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-25097	70	22	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	70	23	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	70	24	latitude	latitude	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	70	25	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	70	26	assign	assign	VERB
inlawrev-25097	70	27	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	70	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	70	29	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	70	30	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	70	31	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	70	32	entities	entity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	70	33	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	70	34	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-25097	70	35	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	70	36	iii	iii	NUM
inlawrev-25097	70	37	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	70	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	71	1	”34	”34	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	72	1	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-25097	72	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	72	3	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	72	4	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	72	5	delegation	delegation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	7	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	72	8	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	9	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	10	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	13	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	72	15	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	72	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	17	violation	violation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	19	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	20	iii.35	iii.35	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	22	concluding	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	72	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	25	reconsideration	reconsideration	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	28	grant	grant	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	31	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	32	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	72	33	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	34	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	72	35	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	72	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	38	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	39	pointed	point	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	40	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	41	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	72	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	43	grant	grant	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	45	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	46	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	47	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	72	48	long	long	ADV
inlawrev-25097	72	49	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	72	50	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	51	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	52	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	53	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	54	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	55	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	72	56	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	57	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	72	58	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	72	59	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	72	60	need	need	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	61	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	72	62	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	72	63	adjudicated	adjudicate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	64	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	65	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	66	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	67	iii	iii	NUM
inlawrev-25097	72	68	court.36	court.36	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	69	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	70	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	71	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	72	72	characterized	characterize	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	73	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	72	74	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	75	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	76	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	77	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	78	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	79	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	80	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	81	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	82	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	72	83	grant	grant	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	84	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	85	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	86	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	72	87	concluding	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	88	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	72	89	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	72	90	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	91	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	92	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	72	93	involves	involve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	94	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	95	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	72	96	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	72	97	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	72	98	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	72	99	interests	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	100	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	101	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	102	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	103	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	72	104	grant	grant	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	105	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	106	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	107	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	108	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	109	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	72	110	instance	instance	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	111	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	72	112	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	72	113	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	72	114	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-25097	72	115	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	72	116	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	72	117	falls	fall	VERB
inlawrev-25097	72	118	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	119	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	120	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	72	121	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	122	side	side	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	123	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	72	124	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	72	125	line	line	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	72	126	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	73	1	”37	”37	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	73	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	73	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	4	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-25097	73	5	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	73	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	73	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	73	8	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	9	adjudicated	adjudicate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	73	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	73	11	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	73	12	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	73	13	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	14	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	15	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	73	16	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	73	17	need	need	VERB
inlawrev-25097	73	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	73	19	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	73	20	resolved	resolve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	73	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	73	22	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	73	23	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	24	iii	iii	NUM
inlawrev-25097	73	25	court.38	court.38	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	73	26	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-25097	73	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	73	28	seventh	seventh	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	73	29	amendment.—the	amendment.—the	DET
inlawrev-25097	73	30	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	31	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	73	32	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	73	33	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	73	34	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	73	35	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	36	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	37	violates	violate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	73	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	73	39	seventh	seventh	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	73	40	amendment	amendment	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	73	42	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	73	43	protects	protect	VERB
inlawrev-25097	73	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	73	45	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	73	46	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	73	48	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	49	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	73	50	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	51	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	73	52	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	73	53	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	73	54	suits	suit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	55	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	73	56	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	73	57	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	58	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	73	59	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	73	60	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	73	61	value	value	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	62	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	73	63	controversy	controversy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	64	shall	shall	AUX
inlawrev-25097	73	65	exceed	exceed	VERB
inlawrev-25097	73	66	twenty	twenty	NUM
inlawrev-25097	73	67	dollars	dollar	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	73	68	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	74	1	”39	”39	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	74	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	74	3	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	74	4	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	74	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	8	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	74	10	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	74	11	precedents	precedent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	12	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	74	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	74	15	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	74	16	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	74	17	properly	properly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	74	18	assigns	assign	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	20	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	74	22	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	74	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	25	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	74	26	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	74	27	article	article	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	74	28	iii	iii	NUM
inlawrev-25097	74	29	tribunal	tribunal	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	74	31	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	74	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	33	seventh	seventh	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	74	34	amendment	amendment	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	35	poses	pose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	36	no	no	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	37	independent	independent	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	74	38	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	39	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	74	40	adjudication	adjudication	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	74	42	that	that	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	43	action	action	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	44	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	74	45	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	46	nonjury	nonjury	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	47	factfinder	factfinder	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	74	49	”4	”4	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	74	50	0	0	NUM
inlawrev-25097	74	51	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	74	52	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	53	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	74	54	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	55	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	56	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	57	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	74	58	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	74	59	violate	violate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	60	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	61	iii	iii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	74	62	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	74	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	64	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	65	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	66	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	74	67	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	74	68	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	74	69	properly	properly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	74	70	assigned	assign	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	71	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	74	72	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	74	73	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	74	74	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	75	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	76	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	74	77	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-25097	74	78	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	74	79	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	74	80	violate	violate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	81	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	82	seventh	seventh	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	74	83	amendment.41	amendment.41	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	74	84	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	74	85	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	74	86	breyer	breyer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	74	87	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	74	88	concurrence	concurrence	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	89	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	90	breyer	breyer	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	91	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	92	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	93	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	94	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	95	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	74	96	full	full	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	74	97	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	74	98	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	74	99	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	100	separately	separately	ADV
inlawrev-25097	74	101	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	74	102	point	point	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	103	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-25097	74	104	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	74	105	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	74	106	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	107	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	108	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	74	109	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	110	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-25097	74	111	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	74	112	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	74	113	read	read	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	114	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	74	115	say	say	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	116	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	74	117	matters	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	118	involving	involve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	119	private	private	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	74	120	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	121	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-25097	74	122	never	never	ADV
inlawrev-25097	74	123	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	74	124	adjudicated	adjudicate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	74	125	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	74	126	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-25097	74	127	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	74	128	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	129	iii	iii	NUM
inlawrev-25097	74	130	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	131	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	74	132	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	74	133	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	74	134	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	74	135	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	74	136	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	74	137	precedent	precedent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	138	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	74	139	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	74	140	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	74	141	contrary	contrary	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	74	142	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	75	1	”42	”42	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	75	2	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	75	3	ginsburg	ginsburg	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	75	4	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	75	5	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	75	6	sotomayor	sotomayor	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	75	7	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-25097	75	8	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	75	9	breyer	breyer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	75	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	75	11	concurrence.43	concurrence.43	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	75	12	33	33	NUM
inlawrev-25097	75	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	76	1	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	76	2	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	76	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	76	4	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	76	5	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	76	6	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	76	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	77	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	77	2	1373	1373	NUM
inlawrev-25097	77	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	78	1	34	34	NUM
inlawrev-25097	78	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	79	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	79	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	79	3	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	79	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	80	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	80	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	80	3	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-25097	80	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	81	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	81	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	81	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	81	4	1374	1374	NUM
inlawrev-25097	81	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	82	1	37	37	NUM
inlawrev-25097	82	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	83	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	83	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	83	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	83	4	1374	1374	NUM
inlawrev-25097	83	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	83	6	75	75	NUM
inlawrev-25097	83	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	84	1	38	38	NUM
inlawrev-25097	84	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	85	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	85	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	85	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	85	4	1375	1375	NUM
inlawrev-25097	85	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	86	1	39	39	NUM
inlawrev-25097	86	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	87	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	87	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	87	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	87	4	1379	1379	NUM
inlawrev-25097	87	5	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	87	6	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	87	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	87	8	const	const	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	87	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	88	1	amend	amend	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	88	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	89	1	vii	vii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	89	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	89	3	40	40	NUM
inlawrev-25097	89	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	90	1	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	90	2	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	90	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	90	4	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	90	5	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	90	6	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	90	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	91	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	91	2	1379	1379	NUM
inlawrev-25097	91	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	91	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	91	5	granfinanciera	granfinanciera	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	91	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	91	7	s.a	s.a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	91	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	92	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	92	2	nordberg	nordberg	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	92	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	92	4	492	492	NUM
inlawrev-25097	92	5	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	92	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	92	7	33	33	NUM
inlawrev-25097	92	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	92	9	53	53	NUM
inlawrev-25097	92	10	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	92	11	54	54	NUM
inlawrev-25097	92	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	92	13	1989	1989	NUM
inlawrev-25097	92	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	92	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	92	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	93	1	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-25097	93	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	94	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	94	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	94	3	42	42	NUM
inlawrev-25097	94	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	95	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	95	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	95	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	95	4	1379	1379	NUM
inlawrev-25097	95	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	95	6	80	80	NUM
inlawrev-25097	95	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	95	8	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-25097	95	9	stern	stern	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	95	10	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	95	11	marshall	marshall	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	95	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	95	13	564	564	NUM
inlawrev-25097	95	14	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	95	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	95	16	462	462	NUM
inlawrev-25097	95	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	95	18	494	494	NUM
inlawrev-25097	95	19	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	95	20	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-25097	95	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	95	22	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	95	23	commodity	commodity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	95	24	futures	future	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	95	25	trading	trading	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	95	26	comm’n	comm’n	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	95	27	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	95	28	schor	schor	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	95	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	95	30	478	478	NUM
inlawrev-25097	95	31	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	95	32	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	95	33	833	833	NUM
inlawrev-25097	95	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	95	35	853	853	NUM
inlawrev-25097	95	36	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	95	37	856	856	NUM
inlawrev-25097	95	38	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	95	39	1986	1986	NUM
inlawrev-25097	95	40	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	95	41	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	95	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	96	1	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-25097	96	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	97	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	97	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	97	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	97	4	1379	1379	NUM
inlawrev-25097	97	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	1	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	98	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	3	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	98	4	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	5	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	98	6	775	775	NUM
inlawrev-25097	98	7	e.	e.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	98	8	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	98	9	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	98	10	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	98	11	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	12	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	13	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	98	14	dissented	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	98	16	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	17	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	18	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	19	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	98	20	chief	chief	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	98	21	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	22	roberts.44	roberts.44	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	23	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	24	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	98	25	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	98	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	28	concern	concern	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	98	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	31	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	98	32	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	33	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	34	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	35	gives	give	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	36	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	37	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	38	political	political	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	98	39	appointee	appointee	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	40	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	98	41	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-25097	98	42	administrative	administrative	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	98	43	agents	agent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	45	instead	instead	ADV
inlawrev-25097	98	46	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	98	47	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	48	independent	independent	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	98	49	judge	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	50	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	51	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	52	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	53	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	54	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	98	55	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	56	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	57	validity	validity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	58	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	98	59	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	60	patent.45	patent.45	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	61	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-25097	98	62	describing	describe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	64	dangers	danger	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	65	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	98	66	having	have	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	67	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	68	political	political	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	98	69	appointee	appointee	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	70	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	98	71	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-25097	98	72	employees	employee	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	73	adjudicate	adjudicate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	74	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	75	validity	validity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	76	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	98	77	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	78	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	79	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	80	gorsuch	gorsuch	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	98	81	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	82	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-25097	98	83	own	own	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	98	84	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	85	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	98	86	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	87	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	98	88	cases	case	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	89	independent	independent	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	98	90	judges	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	91	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-25097	98	92	hear	hear	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	93	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	94	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	95	referring	refer	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	96	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	98	97	article	article	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	98	98	iii	iii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	98	99	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	98	100	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	101	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	102	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	98	103	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	98	104	]	]	X
inlawrev-25097	98	105	understanding	understanding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	106	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	107	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	98	108	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	109	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	110	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	98	111	power	power	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	112	extended	extend	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	113	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	98	114	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	115	suit[s	suit[s	VERB
inlawrev-25097	98	116	]	]	X
inlawrev-25097	98	117	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	98	118	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	98	119	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	98	120	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	121	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	122	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	98	123	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	98	124	equity	equity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	125	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	126	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	98	127	admiralty	admiralty	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	98	128	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	98	129	”4	”4	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	99	1	6	6	NUM
inlawrev-25097	99	2	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	99	3	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-25097	99	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	99	5	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	99	6	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	99	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	99	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	99	9	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	99	10	follows	follow	VERB
inlawrev-25097	99	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	99	12	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	99	13	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	99	14	w]hen	w]hen	ADV
inlawrev-25097	99	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	99	16	suit	suit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	99	17	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	99	18	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	99	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	99	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	99	21	stuff	stuff	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	99	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	99	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	99	24	traditional	traditional	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	99	25	actions	action	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	99	26	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	99	27	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	99	28	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	99	29	tried	try	VERB
inlawrev-25097	99	30	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	99	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	99	32	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	99	33	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	99	34	westminster	westminster	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	99	35	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	99	36	1789	1789	NUM
inlawrev-25097	99	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	99	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	99	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	100	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	100	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	100	3	brought	bring	VERB
inlawrev-25097	100	4	within	within	ADP
inlawrev-25097	100	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	100	6	bounds	bound	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	100	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	100	8	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	100	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	100	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	100	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	100	12	responsibility	responsibility	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	100	13	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	100	14	deciding	decide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	100	15	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	100	16	suit	suit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	100	17	rests	rest	VERB
inlawrev-25097	100	18	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	100	19	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	100	20	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	100	21	iii	iii	NUM
inlawrev-25097	100	22	judges	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	100	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	101	1	”47	”47	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	101	2	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	101	3	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	101	4	agreed	agree	VERB
inlawrev-25097	101	5	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	101	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	101	7	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	8	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	101	9	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	101	10	premise	premise	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	101	12	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	101	13	disagreed	disagree	VERB
inlawrev-25097	101	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	101	15	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	101	16	application.48	application.48	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	101	18	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	19	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	101	20	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	101	21	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	101	23	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	24	shows	show	VERB
inlawrev-25097	101	25	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	101	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	101	27	england	england	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	101	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	101	29	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	101	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	101	31	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	101	33	founding	founding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	101	35	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-25097	101	36	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	37	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-25097	101	38	hear	hear	VERB
inlawrev-25097	101	39	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	40	challenges	challenge	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	101	42	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	101	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	101	44	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	45	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	101	46	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	47	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	101	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	101	49	forum	forum	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	50	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	101	51	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	101	52	disputes	dispute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	101	53	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-25097	101	54	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	55	validity	validity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	56	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-25097	101	57	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	101	58	heard	hear	VERB
inlawrev-25097	101	59	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	101	60	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	101	61	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	101	62	firm	firm	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	63	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	101	64	most	most	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	101	65	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	101	66	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-25097	101	67	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	101	68	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	102	1	”49	”49	ADP
inlawrev-25097	102	2	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	3	gorsuch	gorsuch	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	4	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	102	5	disagreed	disagree	VERB
inlawrev-25097	102	6	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	102	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	102	8	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	102	10	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	11	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	102	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	102	13	revocation	revocation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	102	15	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	16	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	102	17	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-25097	102	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	102	19	reversal	reversal	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	102	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	102	22	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	23	grant.50	grant.50	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	24	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-25097	102	25	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	102	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	102	27	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	28	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	29	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-25097	102	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	102	31	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	32	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	102	33	grant	grant	VERB
inlawrev-25097	102	34	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	102	35	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	102	37	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	102	38	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	39	gorsuch	gorsuch	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	40	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	102	41	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	102	43	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	102	44	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	102	45	mean	mean	VERB
inlawrev-25097	102	46	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	102	47	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	102	48	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	102	49	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-25097	102	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	102	51	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	52	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	102	53	take	take	VERB
inlawrev-25097	102	54	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	102	55	away.51	away.51	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	56	historically	historically	ADV
inlawrev-25097	102	57	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	102	58	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	59	holders	holder	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	60	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	102	61	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-25097	102	62	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	102	63	proven	prove	VERB
inlawrev-25097	102	64	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	102	65	social	social	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	102	66	utility	utility	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	67	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	102	68	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-25097	102	69	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	70	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	102	71	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	102	72	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	102	73	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	102	74	protection	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	75	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-25097	102	76	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-25097	102	77	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	78	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	79	being	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	102	80	revoked	revoke	VERB
inlawrev-25097	102	81	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	102	82	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	102	83	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	84	gorsuch	gorsuch	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	85	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	102	86	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	102	87	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	102	88	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	102	89	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	90	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-25097	102	91	us	we	PRON
inlawrev-25097	102	92	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	102	93	honor	honor	VERB
inlawrev-25097	102	94	those	those	DET
inlawrev-25097	102	95	historical	historical	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	102	96	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	102	97	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	102	98	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	102	99	diminish	diminish	VERB
inlawrev-25097	102	100	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-25097	102	101	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	103	1	”52	”52	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	103	2	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	3	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	103	4	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	103	5	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-25097	103	6	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	7	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	103	8	emphasizing	emphasize	VERB
inlawrev-25097	103	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	103	10	importance	importance	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	103	12	protecting	protect	VERB
inlawrev-25097	103	13	article	article	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	103	14	iii	iii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	103	15	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	103	16	guarantees.53	guarantees.53	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	17	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	103	18	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	103	19	considering	consider	VERB
inlawrev-25097	103	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	103	21	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	22	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	103	23	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	103	25	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	103	26	rout	rout	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	27	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	103	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	103	29	article	article	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	103	30	iii	iii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	103	31	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	103	32	guarantees	guarantee	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	103	34	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	35	gorsuch	gorsuch	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	36	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
inlawrev-25097	103	37	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	103	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	103	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	103	40	importance	importance	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	103	42	preserving	preserve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	103	43	article	article	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	44	iii	iii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	103	45	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	103	46	protections	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	47	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	103	48	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	103	49	ensur[e	ensur[e	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	103	50	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	103	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	103	52	people	people	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	53	today	today	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	54	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	103	55	tomorrow	tomorrow	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	56	enjoy	enjoy	VERB
inlawrev-25097	103	57	no	no	DET
inlawrev-25097	103	58	fewer	few	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	103	59	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	60	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-25097	103	61	governmental	governmental	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	103	62	intrusion	intrusion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	103	63	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-25097	103	64	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-25097	103	65	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-25097	103	66	came	come	VERB
inlawrev-25097	103	67	before	before	ADV
inlawrev-25097	103	68	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	104	1	”54	”54	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	105	1	44	44	NUM
inlawrev-25097	105	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	106	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	106	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	106	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	106	4	1380	1380	NUM
inlawrev-25097	106	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	107	1	45	45	NUM
inlawrev-25097	107	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	108	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	108	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	108	3	46	46	NUM
inlawrev-25097	108	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	109	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	109	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	109	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	109	4	1381	1381	NUM
inlawrev-25097	109	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	109	6	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-25097	109	7	murray	murray	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	109	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	109	9	lessee	lessee	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	109	10	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	109	11	hoboken	hoboken	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	109	12	land	land	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	109	13	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	109	14	improvement	improvement	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	109	15	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	109	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	109	17	59	59	NUM
inlawrev-25097	109	18	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	109	19	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	109	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	109	21	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-25097	109	22	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	109	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	109	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	110	1	272	272	NUM
inlawrev-25097	110	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	110	3	284	284	NUM
inlawrev-25097	110	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	110	5	1856	1856	NUM
inlawrev-25097	110	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	110	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	110	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	111	1	47	47	NUM
inlawrev-25097	111	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	112	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	112	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	112	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	112	4	alteration	alteration	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	112	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	112	6	omission	omission	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	112	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	112	8	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	112	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	112	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	112	11	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	112	12	stern	stern	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	112	13	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	112	14	marshall	marshall	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	112	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	112	16	564	564	NUM
inlawrev-25097	112	17	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	112	18	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	112	19	462	462	NUM
inlawrev-25097	112	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	112	21	484	484	NUM
inlawrev-25097	112	22	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	112	23	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-25097	112	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	112	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	112	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	113	1	48	48	NUM
inlawrev-25097	113	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	114	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	114	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	114	3	49	49	NUM
inlawrev-25097	114	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	115	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	115	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	115	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	115	4	1384	1384	NUM
inlawrev-25097	115	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	116	1	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-25097	116	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	117	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	117	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	117	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	117	4	1385	1385	NUM
inlawrev-25097	117	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	118	1	51	51	NUM
inlawrev-25097	118	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	119	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	119	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	119	3	52	52	NUM
inlawrev-25097	119	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	120	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	120	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	120	3	53	53	NUM
inlawrev-25097	120	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	121	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	121	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	121	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	121	4	1386	1386	NUM
inlawrev-25097	121	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	122	1	54	54	NUM
inlawrev-25097	122	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	123	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	123	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	123	3	776	776	NUM
inlawrev-25097	123	4	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	123	5	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	123	6	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	123	7	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	123	8	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	123	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	123	10	52:771	52:771	NUM
inlawrev-25097	123	11	ii	ii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	123	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	124	1	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	124	2	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	124	3	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	124	4	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	124	5	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	124	6	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	124	7	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	124	8	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	124	9	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	124	10	inst	inst	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	124	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	124	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	124	13	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	124	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	125	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	125	2	iancu	iancu	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	125	3	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	125	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	125	5	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	125	6	day	day	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	125	7	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	125	8	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	125	9	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	125	10	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	125	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	125	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	125	13	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	125	14	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	125	15	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	125	16	issued	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	125	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	125	18	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	125	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	125	20	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	125	21	inst	inst	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	125	22	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	125	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	125	24	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	125	25	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	126	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	126	2	iancu	iancu	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	127	1	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	127	2	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	3	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	127	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	127	5	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	6	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	7	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	127	8	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	9	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	10	proceeding	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	127	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	13	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	16	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	127	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	127	18	patent	patent	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	127	19	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	127	20	trademark	trademark	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	127	21	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	22	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-25097	127	23	issue	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	25	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	127	26	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	27	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	28	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	29	all	all	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	30	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	31	raised	raise	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	32	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	34	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	35	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	127	36	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	127	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	38	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	39	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	41	discretion	discretion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	42	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	127	43	issue	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	45	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	127	46	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	47	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	48	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	49	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-25097	127	50	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	51	smaller	small	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	127	52	set	set	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	54	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	55	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	56	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	127	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	58	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	127	59	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	60	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	61	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	127	62	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-25097	127	63	instituted.55	instituted.55	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	64	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	65	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	66	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	67	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	68	authored	author	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	69	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	70	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	71	gorsuch	gorsuch	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	72	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	127	73	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	74	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	75	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	76	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	127	77	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	78	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	79	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	80	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-25097	127	81	decide	decide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	82	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	127	83	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	127	84	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	85	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	86	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	127	87	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	88	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	89	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	127	90	issue	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	91	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	92	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	127	93	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	94	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	95	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	96	all	all	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	97	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	98	challenged	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	99	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	100	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	101	petitioner.56	petitioner.56	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	127	102	prior	prior	ADV
inlawrev-25097	127	103	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	104	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	105	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	106	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	127	107	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	108	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	109	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	110	followed	follow	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	111	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	112	procedure	procedure	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	113	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	114	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	127	115	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	116	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	117	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	118	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	119	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	127	120	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	121	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	122	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-25097	127	123	identify	identify	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	124	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	125	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	127	126	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	127	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-25097	127	128	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	129	claims	claim	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	130	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	127	131	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	127	132	challenging	challenging	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	127	133	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	127	134	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	135	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	136	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	137	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-25097	127	138	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	139	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	140	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	141	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	142	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	143	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	127	144	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	127	145	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	127	146	any	any	PRON
inlawrev-25097	127	147	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	127	148	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	149	those	those	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	150	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	151	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	127	152	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-25097	127	153	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	154	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	127	155	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	127	156	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	127	157	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	158	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	159	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	160	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-25097	127	161	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-25097	127	162	issue	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	163	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	164	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	127	165	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	166	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	167	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	168	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	127	169	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	127	170	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-25097	127	171	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	127	172	instituted	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	127	173	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	127	174	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	128	1	a.	a.	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	128	2	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	128	3	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	128	4	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	128	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	128	6	section	section	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	128	7	i.a	i.a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	128	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	128	9	above	above	ADV
inlawrev-25097	128	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	128	11	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	128	12	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	128	13	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	128	14	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	128	15	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	128	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	128	17	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	128	18	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	128	19	like	like	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	128	20	adversarial	adversarial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	128	21	proceeding	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	128	22	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-25097	128	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	128	24	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	128	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	128	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	128	27	uspto.57	uspto.57	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	128	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	128	29	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	128	30	requests	request	VERB
inlawrev-25097	128	31	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	128	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	128	33	ptab	ptab	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	128	34	institute	institute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	128	35	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	128	36	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	128	37	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	128	38	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	128	39	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	128	40	cancel	cancel	VERB
inlawrev-25097	128	41	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	128	42	claims.58	claims.58	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	2	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	3	owner	owner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	4	responds	respond	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	129	6	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	129	7	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	129	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	9	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	10	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	12	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	13	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	129	14	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	129	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	129	16	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	18	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	129	19	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	20	review.59	review.59	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	21	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	129	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	23	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	129	24	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	25	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	26	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	129	27	instituted	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	129	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	30	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	31	conduct	conduct	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	32	discovery	discovery	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	129	34	submit	submit	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	35	briefing	briefing	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	36	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	129	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	38	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	39	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	129	40	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	129	41	participate	participate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	129	43	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	44	oral	oral	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	129	45	hearing.60	hearing.60	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	47	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	48	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	129	49	issues	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	50	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	51	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	129	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	129	53	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	54	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	55	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	129	56	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	57	patentability	patentability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	58	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	129	59	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	60	claims.61	claims.61	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	61	prior	prior	ADV
inlawrev-25097	129	62	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	129	63	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	129	64	institute	institute	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	129	65	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	129	66	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	67	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	68	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	129	69	practice	practice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	70	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	129	71	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	129	72	decide	decide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	73	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	129	74	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	129	75	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	76	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	77	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	129	78	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	79	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	80	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	129	81	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-25097	129	82	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	129	83	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-25097	129	84	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-25097	129	85	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	129	86	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	129	87	none	none	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	88	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	129	89	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	90	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	91	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	92	challenged	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	129	93	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	129	94	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	129	95	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	129	96	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	130	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	130	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	130	3	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	130	4	instituted	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	130	5	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	130	6	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	130	7	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-25097	130	8	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-25097	130	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	130	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	130	11	challenged	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	130	12	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	130	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	130	14	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	130	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	130	16	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	130	17	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	130	18	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	130	19	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-25097	130	20	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-25097	130	21	address	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	130	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	130	23	instituted	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	130	24	claims.62	claims.62	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	130	25	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	130	26	procedural	procedural	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	130	27	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	130	28	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	130	29	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	130	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	130	31	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	130	32	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	130	33	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	130	34	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	130	35	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	130	36	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	130	37	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	130	38	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	130	39	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	130	40	sought	seek	VERB
inlawrev-25097	130	41	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	130	42	cancel	cancel	VERB
inlawrev-25097	130	43	55	55	NUM
inlawrev-25097	130	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	131	1	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	131	2	inst	inst	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	131	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	131	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	131	5	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	131	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	132	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	132	2	iancu	iancu	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	132	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	132	4	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	132	5	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	132	6	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	132	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	132	8	1348	1348	NUM
inlawrev-25097	132	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	132	10	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	132	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	132	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	133	1	56	56	NUM
inlawrev-25097	133	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	134	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	134	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	134	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	134	4	1353	1353	NUM
inlawrev-25097	134	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	134	6	54	54	NUM
inlawrev-25097	134	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	135	1	57	57	NUM
inlawrev-25097	135	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	136	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	136	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	136	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	136	4	1353	1353	NUM
inlawrev-25097	136	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	137	1	58	58	NUM
inlawrev-25097	137	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	138	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	138	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	138	3	59	59	NUM
inlawrev-25097	138	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	139	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	139	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	139	3	60	60	NUM
inlawrev-25097	139	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	140	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	140	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	140	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	140	4	1354	1354	NUM
inlawrev-25097	140	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	141	1	61	61	NUM
inlawrev-25097	141	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	142	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	142	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	142	3	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	142	4	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	142	5	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	142	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	143	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	143	2	318(a	318(a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	143	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	143	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	143	5	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	143	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	143	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	144	1	62	62	NUM
inlawrev-25097	144	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	145	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-25097	145	2	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	145	3	inst	inst	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	145	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	145	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	146	1	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	146	2	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	146	3	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	146	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	147	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	147	2	1354	1354	NUM
inlawrev-25097	147	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	148	1	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	148	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	148	3	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	148	4	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	5	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	6	777	777	NUM
inlawrev-25097	148	7	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-25097	148	8	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	148	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	148	11	software	software	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	12	patent.63	patent.63	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	148	13	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	148	14	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	148	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	148	16	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	148	17	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	148	19	all	all	DET
inlawrev-25097	148	20	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-25097	148	21	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	22	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	148	23	invalid	invalid	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	148	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	148	25	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	148	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	148	27	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	28	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-25097	148	29	instituted	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	148	30	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	148	32	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	33	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	148	34	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	148	35	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-25097	148	36	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	148	37	10.64	10.64	NUM
inlawrev-25097	148	38	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	148	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	148	40	end	end	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	148	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	148	43	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	148	44	partes	partes	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	148	45	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	148	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	148	48	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	49	issued	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	148	50	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	148	51	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	148	52	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	148	53	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	54	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	148	55	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	148	56	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	148	57	instituted	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	148	58	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	59	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	148	60	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	148	61	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-25097	148	62	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	148	63	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-25097	148	64	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	148	65	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	148	66	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	148	67	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	148	68	address	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	148	69	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	148	70	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	148	71	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	148	72	instituted	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	148	73	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	74	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	148	75	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	148	76	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	148	77	challenged	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	148	78	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	148	79	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	148	80	petition.65	petition.65	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	81	sas	sa	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	82	appealed	appeal	VERB
inlawrev-25097	148	83	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	148	84	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	148	85	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	148	86	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	87	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	148	88	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	148	89	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	148	90	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	91	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	148	92	arguing	argue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	148	93	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	148	94	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	148	95	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	148	96	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	149	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	2	318(a	318(a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	149	4	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-25097	149	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	149	6	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	149	8	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	149	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	149	10	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	11	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	149	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	149	13	patentability	patentability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	149	15	each	each	DET
inlawrev-25097	149	16	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	17	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	149	18	sas	sa	VERB
inlawrev-25097	149	19	raised	raise	VERB
inlawrev-25097	149	20	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	149	21	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	149	22	petition.66	petition.66	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	149	24	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	149	25	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	26	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-25097	149	27	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	28	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	149	29	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	149	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	149	32	sas	sa	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	33	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	149	34	petitioned	petition	VERB
inlawrev-25097	149	35	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	149	36	certiorari	certiorari	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	37	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	149	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	149	39	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	40	court.67	court.67	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	41	c.	c.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	42	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	43	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	44	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	149	45	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	46	opinion	opinion	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	47	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	48	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	49	delivered	deliver	VERB
inlawrev-25097	149	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	149	51	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	52	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	149	53	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	149	54	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	55	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	149	56	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-25097	149	57	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	149	58	justices	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	59	roberts	roberts	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	60	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	149	61	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	62	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	149	63	thomas	thomas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	149	64	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	149	65	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	149	66	alito.68	alito.68	VERB
inlawrev-25097	149	67	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	149	68	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	69	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	149	70	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	71	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	149	72	reaching	reach	VERB
inlawrev-25097	149	73	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	149	74	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	75	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	149	76	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-25097	149	77	largely	largely	ADV
inlawrev-25097	149	78	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	149	79	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	149	80	language	language	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	149	81	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	149	82	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	149	83	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	149	84	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	150	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	150	2	318(a	318(a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	150	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	150	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	150	5	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	150	6	states	state	VERB
inlawrev-25097	150	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	150	8	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	150	9	i]f	i]f	ADP
inlawrev-25097	150	10	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	150	11	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	150	12	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	150	13	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	150	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	150	15	instituted	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	150	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	150	17	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	150	18	dismissed	dismiss	VERB
inlawrev-25097	150	19	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	150	20	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	150	21	chapter	chapter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	150	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	150	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	150	24	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	150	25	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	150	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	150	27	appeal	appeal	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	150	28	board	board	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	150	29	shall	shall	AUX
inlawrev-25097	150	30	issue	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	150	31	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	150	32	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	150	33	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	150	34	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	150	35	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	150	36	respect	respect	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	150	37	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	150	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	150	39	patentability	patentability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	150	40	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	150	41	any	any	DET
inlawrev-25097	150	42	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	150	43	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	150	44	challenged	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	150	45	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	150	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	150	47	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	150	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	151	1	”69	”69	VERB
inlawrev-25097	151	2	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	151	3	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	151	4	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	151	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	151	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	151	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	151	8	directive	directive	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	151	9	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	151	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	151	11	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	151	12	statutory	statutory	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	151	13	provision	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	151	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	151	15	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	151	16	both	both	PRON
inlawrev-25097	151	17	mandatory	mandatory	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	151	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	151	19	comprehensive	comprehensive	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	151	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	151	21	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	151	22	meaning	mean	VERB
inlawrev-25097	151	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	151	24	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	151	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	151	26	board	board	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	151	27	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-25097	151	28	address	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	151	29	every	every	DET
inlawrev-25097	151	30	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	151	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	151	32	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	151	33	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	151	34	challenged	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	151	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	151	36	”70	”70	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	152	1	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-25097	152	2	concluding	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	152	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	152	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	5	plain	plain	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	152	6	meaning	meaning	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	152	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	9	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	10	answered	answer	VERB
inlawrev-25097	152	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	12	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	13	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-25097	152	14	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	152	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	152	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	17	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	18	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	19	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	152	20	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	152	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	152	22	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-25097	152	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	24	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	152	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	27	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	28	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	29	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	152	30	arguments	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	31	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	152	32	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	152	33	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	152	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	35	discretion	discretion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	36	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	152	37	decide	decide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	152	38	which	which	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	39	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	40	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	152	41	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	152	42	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	152	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	44	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	45	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-25097	152	46	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	47	actual	actual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	152	48	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	152	49	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	50	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	51	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	152	52	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-25097	152	53	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	152	54	claims	claim	VERB
inlawrev-25097	152	55	merit	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	56	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	57	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	152	58	written	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	152	59	decision.71	decision.71	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	60	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	61	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	152	62	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	152	63	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	152	64	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	152	65	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	152	66	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	67	outset	outset	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	68	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	152	69	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	70	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	152	71	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	72	review	review	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	152	73	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	74	gives	give	VERB
inlawrev-25097	152	75	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	76	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	77	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	152	78	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	152	79	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	80	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	81	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	152	82	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	83	ability	ability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	84	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	152	85	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	152	86	define	define	VERB
inlawrev-25097	152	87	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	88	contours	contours	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	89	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	152	90	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	152	91	proceeding	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	152	92	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	153	1	”72	”72	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	153	2	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	153	3	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	153	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	153	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	153	6	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	153	8	pursue	pursue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	153	9	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	153	10	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	153	11	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	12	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	153	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	153	15	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	16	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-25097	153	17	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-25097	153	18	claims	claim	VERB
inlawrev-25097	153	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	153	20	include	include	VERB
inlawrev-25097	153	21	rest	rest	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	22	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	153	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	153	24	petitioner.73	petitioner.73	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	153	26	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	153	27	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	28	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	29	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	153	30	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	153	31	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	153	32	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-25097	153	33	previous	previous	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	153	34	processes	process	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	153	36	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	153	37	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	153	38	ex	ex	X
inlawrev-25097	153	39	parte	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	40	reexamination	reexamination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	153	42	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	153	43	gave	give	VERB
inlawrev-25097	153	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	153	45	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	153	47	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	48	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	153	49	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	153	50	reexamination	reexamination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	51	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	153	52	any	any	DET
inlawrev-25097	153	53	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	54	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	153	55	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-25097	153	56	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	153	57	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	58	gorsuch	gorsuch	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	153	59	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	153	60	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	153	61	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	153	62	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	153	63	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	153	64	wished	wish	VERB
inlawrev-25097	153	65	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	153	66	grant	grant	VERB
inlawrev-25097	153	67	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	153	68	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	69	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	153	70	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	71	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	153	72	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	153	73	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	74	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	153	75	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	153	76	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	153	77	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	153	78	63	63	NUM
inlawrev-25097	153	79	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	154	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	154	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	154	3	64	64	NUM
inlawrev-25097	154	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	155	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	155	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	155	3	65	65	NUM
inlawrev-25097	155	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	156	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	156	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	156	3	66	66	NUM
inlawrev-25097	156	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	157	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	157	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	157	3	67	67	NUM
inlawrev-25097	157	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	158	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	158	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	158	3	68	68	NUM
inlawrev-25097	158	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	159	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	159	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	159	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	159	4	1352	1352	NUM
inlawrev-25097	159	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	160	1	69	69	NUM
inlawrev-25097	160	2	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	160	3	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	160	4	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	160	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	161	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	161	2	318(a	318(a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	161	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	161	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	161	5	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	161	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	161	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	162	1	70	70	NUM
inlawrev-25097	162	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-25097	162	3	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	162	4	inst	inst	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	162	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	162	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	162	7	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	162	8	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	162	9	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	162	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	163	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	163	2	1354	1354	NUM
inlawrev-25097	163	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	163	4	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	163	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	163	6	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	163	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	163	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	164	1	71	71	NUM
inlawrev-25097	164	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	165	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	165	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	165	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	165	4	1355	1355	NUM
inlawrev-25097	165	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	166	1	72	72	NUM
inlawrev-25097	166	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	167	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	167	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	167	3	73	73	NUM
inlawrev-25097	167	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	168	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	168	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	168	3	778	778	NUM
inlawrev-25097	168	4	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	168	5	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	168	6	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	168	7	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	168	8	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	168	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	168	10	52:771	52:771	NUM
inlawrev-25097	168	11	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	168	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	168	13	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	168	14	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	168	15	knew	know	VERB
inlawrev-25097	168	16	exactly	exactly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	168	17	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	168	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	168	19	do	do	VERB
inlawrev-25097	168	20	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-25097	168	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	169	1	”74	”74	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	169	2	moving	move	VERB
inlawrev-25097	169	3	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	169	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	169	5	actual	actual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	169	6	institution	institution	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	169	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	169	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	169	9	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	169	10	partes	partes	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	169	11	review	review	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	169	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	169	13	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	169	14	gorsuch	gorsuch	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	169	15	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	169	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	169	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	169	18	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	169	19	gives	give	VERB
inlawrev-25097	169	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	169	21	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	169	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	169	23	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	169	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	169	25	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	169	26	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	169	27	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	169	28	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	169	29	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	169	30	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	169	31	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	169	32	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	169	33	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	169	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	169	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	169	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	170	1	pursuant	pursuant	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	170	2	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	170	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	4	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	170	6	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	170	7	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	170	8	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	170	9	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	170	10	grant	grant	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	12	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	14	discretion	discretion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	170	16	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	17	which	which	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	18	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	170	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	21	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	170	23	include.75	include.75	ADV
inlawrev-25097	170	24	nor	nor	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	170	25	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	170	26	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	27	314(a)—which	314(a)—which	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	170	28	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	30	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	31	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	170	32	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	33	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	170	34	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	170	35	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-25097	170	36	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	37	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	38	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	170	39	likelihood	likelihood	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	40	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	170	41	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	170	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	43	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	44	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-25097	170	45	succeed	succeed	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	46	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	170	47	invalidating	invalidate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	48	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-25097	170	49	least	least	ADV
inlawrev-25097	170	50	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	170	51	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	52	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	170	53	give	give	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	55	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	56	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	57	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	58	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	170	59	pick	pick	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	60	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	170	61	choose	choose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	62	which	which	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	63	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	64	actually	actually	ADV
inlawrev-25097	170	65	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	170	66	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	170	67	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	68	instituted	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	69	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	170	70	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	71	review.76	review.76	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	170	72	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	73	gorsuch	gorsuch	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	74	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	170	75	dismissed	dismiss	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	76	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	77	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	78	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	170	79	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	80	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	81	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	170	82	partial	partial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	170	83	institution	institution	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	84	increases	increase	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	85	efficiency	efficiency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	86	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	170	87	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	170	88	allows	allow	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	89	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	90	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	91	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	92	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	170	93	allocate	allocate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	94	resources	resource	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	95	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	170	96	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	170	97	focus	focus	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	98	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	170	99	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	170	100	most	most	ADV
inlawrev-25097	170	101	promising	promising	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	170	102	challenges	challenge	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	103	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	170	104	avoid	avoid	VERB
inlawrev-25097	170	105	spending	spending	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	106	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	107	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	170	108	resources	resource	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	109	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	170	110	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	170	111	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	170	112	”7	”7	X
inlawrev-25097	171	1	7	7	NUM
inlawrev-25097	171	2	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	171	3	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	171	4	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	171	5	plausible	plausible	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	171	6	reasons	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	7	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	171	8	why	why	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	171	9	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	171	10	efficiency	efficiency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	11	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	12	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	171	13	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	171	15	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	171	16	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
inlawrev-25097	171	17	deferred	defer	VERB
inlawrev-25097	171	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	171	19	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	171	20	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	171	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	171	22	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	171	23	body	body	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	171	25	prescribe	prescribe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	171	26	policies	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	171	28	create	create	VERB
inlawrev-25097	171	29	efficiencies	efficiency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	30	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	171	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	171	32	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	33	office.78	office.78	VERB
inlawrev-25097	171	34	next	next	ADV
inlawrev-25097	171	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	171	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	171	37	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	38	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	171	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	171	40	impact	impact	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	171	42	chevron	chevron	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	171	43	u.s.a	u.s.a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	171	44	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	171	45	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	171	46	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	171	47	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	171	48	natural	natural	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	171	49	resources	resource	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	50	defense	defense	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	171	51	council	council	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	171	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	171	53	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	171	54	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	171	55	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	171	56	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	171	57	decision.79	decision.79	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	58	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	171	59	chevron	chevron	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	60	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	171	61	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	171	62	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	171	63	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	171	64	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	171	65	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	171	66	left	leave	VERB
inlawrev-25097	171	67	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	171	68	gap	gap	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	69	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	171	70	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	171	71	agency	agency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	72	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	171	73	fill	fill	VERB
inlawrev-25097	171	74	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	171	75	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-25097	171	76	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-25097	171	77	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	171	78	express	express	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	171	79	delegation	delegation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	80	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	171	81	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	82	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	171	83	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	171	84	agency	agency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	85	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	171	86	elucidate	elucidate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	171	87	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	171	88	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	171	89	provision	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	90	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	171	91	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	171	92	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	93	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	171	94	regulation	regulation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	171	95	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	171	96	”8	”8	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	171	97	0	0	NUM
inlawrev-25097	172	1	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	172	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	172	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	172	4	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	172	5	le[ft	le[ft	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	172	6	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	172	7	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	172	8	another	another	DET
inlawrev-25097	172	9	day	day	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	172	10	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	172	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	172	12	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	172	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	172	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	172	15	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	172	16	chevron	chevron	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	172	17	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-25097	172	18	remain	remain	VERB
inlawrev-25097	172	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	173	1	”81	”81	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	173	2	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-25097	173	3	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	173	4	chevron	chevron	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	173	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	173	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	173	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	173	8	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	173	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	173	10	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	173	11	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-25097	173	12	owe	owe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	173	13	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	173	14	agency	agency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	173	15	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	173	16	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	173	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	173	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	173	19	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	173	20	no	no	DET
inlawrev-25097	173	21	deference	deference	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	173	22	unless	unless	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	173	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	173	24	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-25097	173	25	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	173	26	employing	employ	VERB
inlawrev-25097	173	27	traditional	traditional	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	173	28	tools	tool	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	173	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	173	30	statutory	statutory	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	173	31	construction	construction	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	173	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	173	33	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	173	34	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-25097	173	35	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	173	36	ourselves	ourselves	PRON
inlawrev-25097	173	37	unable	unable	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	173	38	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	173	39	discern	discern	VERB
inlawrev-25097	173	40	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	173	41	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	173	42	meaning	meaning	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	173	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	174	1	”82	”82	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	174	2	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	174	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	174	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	5	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	174	6	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	174	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	174	8	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	174	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	174	10	meaning	meaning	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	11	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	174	12	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	174	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	174	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	174	15	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	174	16	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	17	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	18	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	19	focuses	focus	VERB
inlawrev-25097	174	20	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	174	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	174	22	contents	content	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	174	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	174	25	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	26	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	174	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	174	28	centerpiece	centerpiece	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	174	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	174	31	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	174	33	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	174	34	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-25097	174	35	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-25097	174	36	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	174	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	174	38	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	39	issue	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	174	40	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	174	41	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	42	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-25097	174	43	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	174	44	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-25097	174	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	174	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	174	47	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	48	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	174	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	174	50	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	51	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	174	52	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	174	53	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	54	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	174	55	chevron	chevron	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	56	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	174	57	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	174	58	inapplicable.83	inapplicable.83	ADV
inlawrev-25097	174	59	finally	finally	ADV
inlawrev-25097	174	60	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	174	61	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	174	62	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	63	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	174	64	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	174	65	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	66	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	174	67	cuozzo	cuozzo	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	68	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	174	69	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	174	70	language	language	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	174	71	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	174	72	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	174	73	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	174	74	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	175	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	175	2	314(d	314(d	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	175	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	175	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	176	1	section	section	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	176	2	314(d	314(d	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	176	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	176	4	states	state	VERB
inlawrev-25097	176	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	176	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	176	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	176	8	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	176	9	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	176	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	176	11	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	176	12	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	176	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	176	14	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	176	15	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	176	16	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	176	17	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	176	18	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	176	19	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	176	20	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	176	21	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	176	22	shall	shall	AUX
inlawrev-25097	176	23	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	176	24	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	176	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	176	26	nonappealable	nonappealable	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	176	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	177	1	”84	”84	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	177	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	177	3	cuozzo	cuozzo	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	177	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	177	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	177	6	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	177	7	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	177	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	177	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	177	10	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	177	11	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	177	12	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	177	13	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	177	14	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	177	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	177	16	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	177	17	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	177	18	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	177	19	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	177	20	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	177	21	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	177	22	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	177	23	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	177	24	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	177	25	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	177	26	non74	non74	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	177	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	178	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	178	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	178	3	75	75	NUM
inlawrev-25097	178	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	179	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	179	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	179	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	179	4	1355	1355	NUM
inlawrev-25097	179	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	179	6	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	179	7	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	179	8	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	179	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	180	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	180	2	314(b	314(b	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	180	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	180	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	180	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	181	1	76	76	NUM
inlawrev-25097	181	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	182	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	182	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	182	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	182	4	1356	1356	NUM
inlawrev-25097	182	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	182	6	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	182	7	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	182	8	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	182	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	183	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	183	2	314(a	314(a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	183	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	183	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	183	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	184	1	77	77	NUM
inlawrev-25097	184	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	185	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	185	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	185	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	185	4	1357	1357	NUM
inlawrev-25097	185	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	186	1	78	78	NUM
inlawrev-25097	186	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	187	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	187	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	187	3	79	79	NUM
inlawrev-25097	187	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	188	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	188	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	188	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	188	4	1358	1358	NUM
inlawrev-25097	188	5	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	188	6	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-25097	188	7	chevron	chevron	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	188	8	u.s.a	u.s.a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	188	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	188	10	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	188	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	189	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	189	2	nat	nat	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	189	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	190	1	res	re	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	190	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	191	1	def	def	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	191	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	191	3	council	council	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	191	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	191	5	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	191	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	191	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	191	8	467	467	NUM
inlawrev-25097	191	9	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	191	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	191	11	837	837	NUM
inlawrev-25097	191	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	191	13	1984	1984	NUM
inlawrev-25097	191	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	191	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	192	1	80	80	NUM
inlawrev-25097	192	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	193	1	chevron	chevron	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	193	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	193	3	467	467	NUM
inlawrev-25097	193	4	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	193	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	193	6	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	193	7	843	843	NUM
inlawrev-25097	193	8	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	193	9	44	44	NUM
inlawrev-25097	193	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	193	11	81	81	NUM
inlawrev-25097	193	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	193	13	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	193	14	inst	inst	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	193	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	193	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	193	17	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	193	18	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	193	19	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	193	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	194	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	194	2	1358	1358	NUM
inlawrev-25097	194	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	195	1	82	82	NUM
inlawrev-25097	195	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	196	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	196	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	196	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	196	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	196	5	chevron	chevron	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	196	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	196	7	467	467	NUM
inlawrev-25097	196	8	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	196	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	196	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	196	11	843	843	NUM
inlawrev-25097	196	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	196	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	197	1	83	83	NUM
inlawrev-25097	197	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	198	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	198	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	198	3	84	84	NUM
inlawrev-25097	198	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	198	5	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	198	6	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	198	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	199	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	199	2	314(d	314(d	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	199	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	199	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	199	5	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	199	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	199	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	1	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	200	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	3	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	200	4	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	5	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	6	779	779	NUM
inlawrev-25097	200	7	appealable.85	appealable.85	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	8	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	200	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	200	10	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	200	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	200	13	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	14	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	200	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	200	16	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	17	314(d	314(d	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	200	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	200	20	cuozzo	cuozzo	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	200	21	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	200	22	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	200	23	change	change	VERB
inlawrev-25097	200	24	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	200	25	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	26	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	27	relying	rely	VERB
inlawrev-25097	200	28	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	200	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	200	30	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	31	strong	strong	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	200	32	presumption	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	33	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	200	35	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	200	36	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	38	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-25097	200	39	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-25097	200	40	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	200	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	200	42	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	43	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	200	44	text	text	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	200	47	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	48	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	200	49	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	200	50	cuozzo	cuozzo	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	51	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	200	52	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	53	314(d	314(d	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	200	54	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	55	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-25097	200	56	preclude	preclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	200	57	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	200	58	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	59	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	200	60	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	200	61	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	62	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	200	63	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	64	initial	initial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	200	65	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	66	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	67	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	200	68	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	200	69	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	200	70	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	200	71	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	200	72	review.86	review.86	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	73	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	200	74	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	200	75	ginsburg	ginsburg	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	200	76	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	200	77	dissent	dissent	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	200	78	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	200	79	ginsburg	ginsburg	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	200	80	authored	author	VERB
inlawrev-25097	200	81	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	200	82	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	200	83	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	84	paragraph	paragraph	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	85	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	86	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	87	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-25097	200	88	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	200	89	justices	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	90	breyer	breyer	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	91	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	92	sotomayor	sotomayor	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	93	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	94	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	200	95	kagan,87	kagan,87	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	96	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	200	97	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	200	98	she	she	PRON
inlawrev-25097	200	99	criticized	criticize	VERB
inlawrev-25097	200	100	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	200	101	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	102	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	200	103	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	104	wooden	wooden	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	200	105	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	200	106	reading	reading	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	200	107	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	200	108	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	200	109	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	200	110	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	201	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	201	2	318(a	318(a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	201	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	202	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	202	2	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	202	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	202	4	she	she	PRON
inlawrev-25097	202	5	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-25097	202	6	instead	instead	ADV
inlawrev-25097	202	7	read	read	VERB
inlawrev-25097	202	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	202	9	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	202	10	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	202	11	allowing	allow	VERB
inlawrev-25097	202	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	202	13	board	board	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	202	14	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	202	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	202	16	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-25097	202	17	rational	rational	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	202	18	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	202	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	202	20	weed	weed	VERB
inlawrev-25097	202	21	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-25097	202	22	insubstantial	insubstantial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	202	23	challenges	challenge	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	202	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	203	1	”88	”88	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	203	2	e.	e.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	203	3	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	203	4	breyer	breyer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	203	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	203	6	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	7	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	8	breyer	breyer	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	9	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	203	10	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	203	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	203	12	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	13	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-25097	203	14	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	203	15	justices	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	16	ginsburg	ginsburg	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	203	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	203	18	sotomayor.89	sotomayor.89	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	203	19	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	203	20	kagan	kagan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	203	21	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	203	22	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-25097	203	23	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	24	breyer	breyer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	203	25	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	203	26	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	203	28	except	except	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	203	29	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	203	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	203	31	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	203	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	203	34	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	35	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	203	36	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	203	37	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	38	breyer	breyer	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	39	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	203	40	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-25097	203	41	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-25097	203	42	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	203	44	chevron	chevron	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	203	46	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	203	47	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	203	48	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	203	49	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	203	50	rigid	rigid	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	203	51	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	203	52	black	black	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	203	53	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	203	54	letter	letter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	55	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	56	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	203	57	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	58	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	203	59	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	203	60	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	203	61	instead	instead	ADV
inlawrev-25097	203	62	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	203	63	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	203	64	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	203	65	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	66	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	203	67	thumb	thumb	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	68	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	203	69	guiding	guide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	203	70	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	71	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	203	72	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	203	73	effort	effort	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	74	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	203	75	respect	respect	VERB
inlawrev-25097	203	76	that	that	DET
inlawrev-25097	203	77	leeway	leeway	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	78	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	203	79	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	203	80	intended	intend	VERB
inlawrev-25097	203	81	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	203	82	agencies	agency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	203	83	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	203	84	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-25097	203	85	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	204	1	”90	”90	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	204	2	iii	iii	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	204	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	204	4	recovery	recovery	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	204	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	204	6	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	204	7	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	204	8	profits	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	204	9	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	204	10	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	204	11	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	204	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	205	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	205	2	284	284	NUM
inlawrev-25097	205	3	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	205	4	westerngeco	westerngeco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	205	5	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	205	6	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	205	7	ion	ion	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	205	8	geophysical	geophysical	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	205	9	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	205	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	205	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	205	12	june	june	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	205	13	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	205	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	205	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	205	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	205	17	7	7	NUM
inlawrev-25097	205	18	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	205	19	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-25097	205	20	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	205	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	205	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	205	23	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	205	24	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	205	25	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	205	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	205	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	205	28	successful	successful	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	205	29	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	205	30	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-25097	205	31	recover	recover	VERB
inlawrev-25097	205	32	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	205	33	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	205	34	profits	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	205	35	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	205	36	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	205	37	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	205	38	permissible	permissible	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	205	39	domestic	domestic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	205	40	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	205	41	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	205	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	205	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	205	44	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	205	45	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	205	46	provision	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	205	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	205	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	205	49	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	205	50	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	205	51	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	205	52	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	205	53	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	205	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	206	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	206	2	284.91	284.91	NUM
inlawrev-25097	206	3	a.	a.	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	4	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	206	6	patentee	patentee	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	7	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-25097	206	8	proves	prove	VERB
inlawrev-25097	206	9	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	10	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	11	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	206	12	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	206	13	271	271	NUM
inlawrev-25097	206	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	206	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	206	16	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	17	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	18	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-25097	206	19	recover	recover	VERB
inlawrev-25097	206	20	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	21	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	206	22	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	206	23	284	284	NUM
inlawrev-25097	206	24	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	206	25	adequate	adequate	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	206	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	206	27	compensate	compensate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	206	28	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	206	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	206	30	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	206	32	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	206	33	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	206	34	no	no	DET
inlawrev-25097	206	35	event	event	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	36	less	less	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	206	37	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-25097	206	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	206	39	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	206	40	royalty	royalty	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	206	42	”9	”9	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	43	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-25097	206	44	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	45	271	271	NUM
inlawrev-25097	206	46	describes	describe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	206	47	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	206	48	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	206	49	ways	way	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	50	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	206	51	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	206	52	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	206	53	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	54	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-25097	206	55	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	206	56	infringed.9	infringed.9	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	206	57	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-25097	206	58	particularly	particularly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	206	59	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	206	60	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	206	61	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	206	62	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	63	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	206	64	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	206	65	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	206	66	271(f	271(f	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	206	67	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	206	68	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	206	69	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	206	70	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	206	71	company	company	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	72	ships	ship	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	73	components	component	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	74	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	206	75	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	206	76	patented	patented	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	206	77	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	206	78	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	206	79	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	206	80	85	85	NUM
inlawrev-25097	206	81	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	207	1	cuozzo	cuozzo	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	207	2	speed	speed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	207	3	techs	tech	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	207	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	207	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	207	6	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	207	7	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	207	8	lee	lee	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	207	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	207	10	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	207	11	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	207	12	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	207	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	207	14	2131	2131	NUM
inlawrev-25097	207	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	207	16	2151	2151	NUM
inlawrev-25097	207	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	207	18	2016	2016	NUM
inlawrev-25097	207	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	207	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	208	1	86	86	NUM
inlawrev-25097	208	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	208	3	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	208	4	inst	inst	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	208	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	208	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	208	7	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	208	8	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	208	9	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	208	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	209	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	209	2	1359	1359	NUM
inlawrev-25097	209	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	209	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	209	5	cuozzo	cuozzo	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	209	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	209	7	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	209	8	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	209	9	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	209	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	210	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	210	2	2134	2134	NUM
inlawrev-25097	210	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	210	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	211	1	87	87	NUM
inlawrev-25097	211	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	212	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	212	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	212	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	212	4	1360	1360	NUM
inlawrev-25097	212	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	213	1	88	88	NUM
inlawrev-25097	213	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	214	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	214	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	214	3	89	89	NUM
inlawrev-25097	214	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	215	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	215	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	215	3	90	90	NUM
inlawrev-25097	215	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	216	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	216	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	4	sotomayor	sotomayor	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	216	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	6	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	216	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	8	joining	join	VERB
inlawrev-25097	216	9	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	216	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	11	except	except	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	216	12	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	216	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	216	14	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	216	15	iii.a	iii.a	NUM
inlawrev-25097	216	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	17	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	18	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	216	19	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	216	20	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	216	21	1364	1364	NUM
inlawrev-25097	216	22	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	23	breyer	breyer	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	216	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	25	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	216	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	27	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	216	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	29	pt	pt	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	216	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	31	iii.a	iii.a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	216	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	216	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	217	1	91	91	NUM
inlawrev-25097	217	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	218	1	westerngeco	westerngeco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	218	2	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	218	3	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	218	4	ion	ion	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	218	5	geophysical	geophysical	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	218	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	218	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	218	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	218	9	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	218	10	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	218	11	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	218	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	218	13	2129	2129	NUM
inlawrev-25097	218	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	218	15	2139	2139	NUM
inlawrev-25097	218	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	218	17	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	218	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	218	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	219	1	92	92	NUM
inlawrev-25097	219	2	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	219	3	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	219	4	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	219	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	220	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	220	2	284	284	NUM
inlawrev-25097	220	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	220	4	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	220	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	220	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	221	1	93	93	NUM
inlawrev-25097	221	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	222	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-25097	222	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	222	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	222	4	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	222	5	271	271	NUM
inlawrev-25097	222	6	.	.	X
inlawrev-25097	222	7	780	780	NUM
inlawrev-25097	222	8	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	222	9	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	222	10	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	223	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	4	52:771	52:771	NUM
inlawrev-25097	223	5	assembled	assemble	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	6	abroad	abroad	ADV
inlawrev-25097	223	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	8	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-25097	223	9	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-25097	223	10	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	223	11	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	12	liable	liable	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	13	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	14	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	15	infringement.94	infringement.94	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	16	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	17	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	223	18	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	223	19	undisputed	undisputed	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	21	these	these	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	22	statutes	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	23	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	24	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	25	recovery	recovery	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	26	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	27	acts	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	29	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	30	occurring	occur	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	31	within	within	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	33	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	34	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	37	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	38	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	39	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	40	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	41	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	223	42	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	43	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	44	domestic	domestic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	45	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	46	owner	owner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	47	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-25097	223	48	recover	recover	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	49	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	50	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	51	profits	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	52	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	53	these	these	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	54	provisions	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	55	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	56	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	57	well.95	well.95	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	58	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	59	procedural	procedural	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	60	history	history	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	61	westerngeco	westerngeco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	62	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	63	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	64	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	65	westerngeco	westerngeco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	66	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	67	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	68	owns	own	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	69	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-25097	223	70	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	71	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	72	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	73	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	74	system	system	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	75	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	223	76	uses	use	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	77	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	78	lateral	lateral	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	79	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	80	steering	steering	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	81	technology	technology	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	82	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	83	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	84	surveying	survey	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	85	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	86	ocean	ocean	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	87	floor.96	floor.96	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	88	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	89	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-25097	223	90	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	91	ion	ion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	92	geophysical	geophysical	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	93	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	94	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	95	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	96	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	97	ion	ion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	98	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	99	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	100	began	begin	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	101	manufacturing	manufacture	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	102	components	component	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	103	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	104	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	105	competing	compete	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	106	system	system	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	107	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	108	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	109	shipped	ship	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	110	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	111	components	component	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	112	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	113	overseas	overseas	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	114	companies	company	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	115	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-25097	223	116	assembled	assemble	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	117	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	118	components	component	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	119	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	223	120	create	create	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	121	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	122	system	system	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	123	identical	identical	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	124	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	125	westerngeco’s.97	westerngeco’s.97	PRON
inlawrev-25097	223	126	these	these	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	127	overseas	overseas	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	128	companies	company	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	129	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	223	130	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	131	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	132	system	system	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	133	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	223	134	directly	directly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	223	135	compete	compete	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	136	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	137	westerngeco	westerngeco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	138	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	223	139	services.98	services.98	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	140	westerngeco	westerngeco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	141	subsequently	subsequently	ADV
inlawrev-25097	223	142	sued	sue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	143	ion	ion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	144	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	145	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	146	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	147	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	148	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	149	§	§	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	150	271(f)(1	271(f)(1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	223	151	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	152	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	153	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	154	f)(2	f)(2	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	155	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	156	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	157	proved	prove	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	158	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	159	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	160	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	161	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	162	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	163	awarded	award	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	164	$	$	SYM
inlawrev-25097	223	165	12.5	12.5	NUM
inlawrev-25097	223	166	million	million	NUM
inlawrev-25097	223	167	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	168	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	169	royalties	royalty	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	170	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	171	$	$	SYM
inlawrev-25097	223	172	93.4	93.4	NUM
inlawrev-25097	223	173	million	million	NUM
inlawrev-25097	223	174	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	175	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	176	profits.99	profits.99	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	177	ion	ion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	178	filed	file	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	179	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	180	post	post	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	181	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	182	trial	trial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	183	motion	motion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	184	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	223	185	set	set	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	186	aside	aside	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	187	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	188	$	$	SYM
inlawrev-25097	223	189	93.4	93.4	NUM
inlawrev-25097	223	190	million	million	NUM
inlawrev-25097	223	191	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	192	arguing	argue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	193	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	194	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	195	271(f	271(f	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	196	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	197	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	223	198	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	223	199	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	200	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	201	extraterritorially	extraterritorially	ADV
inlawrev-25097	223	202	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	203	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	204	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	205	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-25097	223	206	westerngeco	westerngeco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	207	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-25097	223	208	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	223	209	recover	recover	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	210	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	211	profits.100	profits.100	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	212	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	213	motion	motion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	214	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	223	215	denied	deny	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	216	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	217	ion	ion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	218	filed	file	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	219	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	220	appeal.101	appeal.101	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	221	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	222	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	223	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	224	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	225	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	226	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	227	reversed	reverse	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	228	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	229	award	award	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	230	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	231	lost	lost	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	232	profits	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	233	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	234	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	235	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	223	236	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	237	precedent,102	precedent,102	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	238	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	239	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	240	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	241	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	242	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	243	provision	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	244	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	245	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	246	271(a	271(a	NUM
inlawrev-25097	223	247	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	248	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	249	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	223	250	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	223	251	allow	allow	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	252	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	253	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	254	owner	owner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	255	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	223	256	recover	recover	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	257	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	258	profits	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	259	off	off	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	260	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	261	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	262	sales	sale	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	263	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	264	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	265	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	266	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	267	271(f	271(f	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	268	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	269	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-25097	223	270	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	223	271	interpreted	interpret	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	272	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	273	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	274	way.103	way.103	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	275	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	276	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	277	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	278	granted	grant	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	279	certiorari	certiorari	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	280	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	281	vacated	vacate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	282	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	283	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	284	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	285	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	223	286	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	287	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	288	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	289	remanded	remand	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	290	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	291	further	further	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	292	consideration	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	293	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	294	light	light	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	295	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	296	halo	halo	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	297	electronics	electronic	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	298	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	299	pulse	pulse	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	300	electronics.104	electronics.104	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	301	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	302	remand	remand	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	303	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	304	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	305	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	223	306	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	307	once	once	ADV
inlawrev-25097	223	308	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-25097	223	309	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	310	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	311	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	312	271(f	271(f	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	313	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	314	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	223	315	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	223	316	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	317	extraterritorially	extraterritorially	ADV
inlawrev-25097	223	318	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	319	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	223	320	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	321	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	322	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	323	granted	grant	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	324	certiorari	certiorari	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	325	again.105	again.105	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	326	c.	c.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	327	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	328	thomas	thomas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	329	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	223	330	majority	majority	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	331	opinion	opinion	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	332	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	333	thomas	thomas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	223	334	delivered	deliver	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	335	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	336	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	337	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	338	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	223	339	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	340	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	223	341	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-25097	223	342	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	223	343	justices	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	223	344	94	94	NUM
inlawrev-25097	223	345	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	224	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	224	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	224	3	95	95	NUM
inlawrev-25097	224	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	225	1	westerngeco	westerngeco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	225	2	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	225	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	225	4	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	225	5	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	225	6	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	225	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	226	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	226	2	2134	2134	NUM
inlawrev-25097	226	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	227	1	96	96	NUM
inlawrev-25097	227	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	228	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	228	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	228	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	228	4	2135	2135	NUM
inlawrev-25097	228	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	229	1	97	97	NUM
inlawrev-25097	229	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	230	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	230	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	230	3	98	98	NUM
inlawrev-25097	230	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	231	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	231	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	231	3	99	99	NUM
inlawrev-25097	231	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	232	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	232	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	232	3	100	100	NUM
inlawrev-25097	232	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	233	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	233	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	233	3	101	101	NUM
inlawrev-25097	233	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	234	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	234	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	234	3	102	102	NUM
inlawrev-25097	234	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	235	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-25097	235	2	power	power	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	235	3	integrations	integration	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	235	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	235	5	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	235	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	236	1	v.	v.	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	236	2	fairchild	fairchild	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	236	3	semiconductor	semiconductor	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	236	4	int’l	int’l	NUM
inlawrev-25097	236	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	236	6	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	236	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	236	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	236	9	711	711	NUM
inlawrev-25097	236	10	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	236	11	1348	1348	NUM
inlawrev-25097	236	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	236	13	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	236	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	236	15	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	236	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	236	17	2013	2013	NUM
inlawrev-25097	236	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	236	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	237	1	103	103	NUM
inlawrev-25097	237	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	238	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	238	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	238	3	104	104	NUM
inlawrev-25097	238	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	239	1	westerngeco	westerngeco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	239	2	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	239	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	239	4	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	239	5	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	239	6	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	239	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	240	2	2136	2136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	240	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	4	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-25097	240	5	halo	halo	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	240	6	elecs	elec	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	240	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	9	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	240	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	240	11	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	240	12	pulse	pulse	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	240	13	elecs	elec	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	240	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	16	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	240	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	240	18	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	240	19	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	240	20	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	240	21	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	240	22	1923	1923	NUM
inlawrev-25097	240	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	24	2016	2016	NUM
inlawrev-25097	240	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	26	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	27	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	240	28	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	240	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	240	30	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	240	31	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	240	32	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	240	33	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-25097	240	34	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	35	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	240	36	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	240	37	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	240	38	enhanced	enhanced	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	240	39	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	240	40	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	240	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	240	42	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	240	43	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	240	44	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	240	46	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	47	seagate	seagate	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	240	48	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	240	49	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	50	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	51	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	240	52	inconsistent	inconsistent	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	240	53	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	240	54	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	240	55	284	284	NUM
inlawrev-25097	240	56	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	57	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	240	58	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	241	1	105	105	NUM
inlawrev-25097	241	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	242	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	242	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	242	3	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	242	4	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	242	5	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	242	6	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	242	7	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	242	8	781	781	NUM
inlawrev-25097	242	9	kennedy	kennedy	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	242	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	242	11	ginsburg	ginsburg	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	242	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	242	13	alito	alito	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	242	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	242	15	sotomayor	sotomayor	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	242	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	242	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	242	18	kagan	kagan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	242	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	243	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	243	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	243	3	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-25097	243	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	243	5	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	243	6	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-25097	243	7	recognize	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-25097	243	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	243	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	243	10	presumption	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	243	11	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-25097	243	12	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	243	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	243	14	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	243	15	referring	refer	VERB
inlawrev-25097	243	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	243	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	243	18	principal	principal	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	243	19	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	243	20	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	243	21	statutes	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	243	22	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	243	23	meant	mean	VERB
inlawrev-25097	243	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	243	25	govern	govern	VERB
inlawrev-25097	243	26	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-25097	243	27	domestically	domestically	ADV
inlawrev-25097	243	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	243	29	necessarily	necessarily	ADV
inlawrev-25097	243	30	avoiding	avoid	VERB
inlawrev-25097	243	31	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	243	32	clashes	clash	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	243	33	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	243	34	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	243	35	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	243	36	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-25097	243	37	result	result	VERB
inlawrev-25097	243	38	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	243	39	international	international	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	243	40	discord	discord	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	243	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	244	1	”106	”106	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	244	2	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-25097	244	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	244	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	244	5	presumption	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	244	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	244	7	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	244	8	absolute	absolute	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	244	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	245	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	245	2	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	245	3	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	245	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	245	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	245	6	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	245	7	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	245	8	reiterated	reiterate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	245	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	245	10	twostep	twostep	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	245	11	framework	framework	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	245	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	245	13	decide	decide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	245	14	questions	question	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	245	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	245	16	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	245	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	246	1	first	first	ADV
inlawrev-25097	246	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	246	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	246	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	246	5	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-25097	246	6	ask	ask	VERB
inlawrev-25097	246	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	246	8	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	246	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	246	10	presumption	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	246	11	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-25097	246	12	extraterritoriality	extraterritoriality	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	246	13	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	246	14	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	246	15	rebutted,”1	rebutted,”1	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	246	16	07	07	NUM
inlawrev-25097	246	17	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	246	18	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-25097	246	19	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-25097	246	20	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	246	21	done	do	VERB
inlawrev-25097	246	22	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	246	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	246	24	text	text	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	246	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	246	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	246	27	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	246	28	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	246	29	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	246	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	246	31	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	246	32	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	246	33	indication	indication	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	246	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	246	35	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	246	36	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	246	37	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	246	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	246	39	’”108	’”108	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	247	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	247	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	247	3	presumption	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	4	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	247	5	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	247	6	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	247	7	rebutted	rebut	VERB
inlawrev-25097	247	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	247	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	247	10	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	247	11	step	step	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	247	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	247	14	framework	framework	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	15	asks	ask	VERB
inlawrev-25097	247	16	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	247	17	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	247	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	247	19	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	20	involves	involve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	247	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	247	22	domestic	domestic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	247	23	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	247	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	247	26	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	247	28	”109	”109	VERB
inlawrev-25097	247	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	247	30	answer	answer	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	31	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	247	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	247	33	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	247	34	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	35	hinges	hinge	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	36	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	247	37	determining	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	247	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	247	39	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	40	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	247	41	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	247	42	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	43	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	247	44	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	247	45	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	247	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	247	47	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	247	48	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	49	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	247	50	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	247	51	that	that	DET
inlawrev-25097	247	52	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	53	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-25097	247	54	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	247	55	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	247	56	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	247	57	territory	territory	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	247	58	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	247	59	”110	”110	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	248	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	248	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	3	exercised	exercise	VERB
inlawrev-25097	248	4	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	248	5	discretion	discretion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	6	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	248	7	begin	begin	VERB
inlawrev-25097	248	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	248	9	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	248	11	step	step	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	12	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-25097	248	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	248	14	sought	seek	VERB
inlawrev-25097	248	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	248	16	identify	identify	VERB
inlawrev-25097	248	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	248	18	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	19	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	248	20	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	248	21	focus	focus	VERB
inlawrev-25097	248	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	248	23	”111	”111	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	248	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	248	25	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	248	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	248	27	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	248	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	248	30	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	31	honed	hone	VERB
inlawrev-25097	248	32	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	248	33	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	248	34	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	248	35	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	248	36	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	37	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	248	38	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-25097	248	39	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	248	40	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	248	41	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	248	42	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	248	43	i]f	i]f	ADP
inlawrev-25097	248	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	248	45	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	46	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	248	47	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	248	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	248	49	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	50	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	248	51	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	52	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-25097	248	53	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	248	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	248	55	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	248	56	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	248	57	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	248	58	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	248	59	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	248	60	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	61	involves	involve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	248	62	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	248	63	permissible	permissible	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	248	64	domestic	domestic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	248	65	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	66	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	248	67	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	248	68	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	248	69	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	70	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	248	71	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	248	72	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-25097	248	73	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	248	74	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	248	75	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	248	76	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-25097	248	77	abroad	abroad	ADV
inlawrev-25097	248	78	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	249	1	’”112	’”112	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	249	2	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-25097	249	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	249	4	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	249	5	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	249	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	249	7	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	249	8	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	249	9	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-25097	249	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	249	11	another	another	DET
inlawrev-25097	249	12	country	country	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	249	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	249	14	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	249	15	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	249	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	249	17	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	249	18	involves	involve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	249	19	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	249	20	impermissible	impermissible	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	249	21	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	249	22	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	249	23	regardless	regardless	ADV
inlawrev-25097	249	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	249	25	any	any	DET
inlawrev-25097	249	26	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	249	27	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	249	28	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	249	29	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-25097	249	30	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	249	31	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	249	32	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	249	33	territory	territory	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	249	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	250	1	’”113	’”113	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	250	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	250	3	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	250	4	these	these	DET
inlawrev-25097	250	5	principals	principal	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	250	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	250	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	9	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	250	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	250	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	250	12	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	13	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	250	14	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	250	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	250	16	statutory	statutory	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	250	17	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	250	19	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	250	20	284	284	NUM
inlawrev-25097	250	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	250	22	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	250	23	271(f)(2	271(f)(2	NUM
inlawrev-25097	250	24	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	250	25	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	250	26	domestic.114	domestic.114	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	250	28	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	29	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	250	30	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	250	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	250	32	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	250	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	250	35	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	250	36	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	37	provision	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	250	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	250	40	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	41	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	42	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	250	43	adequately	adequately	ADV
inlawrev-25097	250	44	compensating	compensate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	250	45	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	250	46	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	47	owner	owner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	48	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	250	49	acts	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	250	51	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	250	53	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	250	54	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	250	55	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	250	56	a]ccordingly	a]ccordingly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	250	57	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	250	58	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	250	59	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	60	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	250	61	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	250	62	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	250	63	plainly	plainly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	250	64	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	250	65	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	66	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	250	67	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	250	68	284.”115	284.”115	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	250	69	subsequently	subsequently	ADV
inlawrev-25097	250	70	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	250	71	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	250	72	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	73	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	250	74	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	250	75	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	250	76	271(f)(2)—the	271(f)(2)—the	NUM
inlawrev-25097	250	77	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	78	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	250	79	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	250	80	acts	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	81	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	250	82	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	83	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	250	84	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	250	85	focused	focus	VERB
inlawrev-25097	250	86	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	250	87	domestic	domestic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	250	88	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	250	89	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	251	2	coming	come	VERB
inlawrev-25097	251	3	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	251	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	251	5	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	251	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	9	reasoned	reason	VERB
inlawrev-25097	251	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	251	11	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	251	13	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	251	14	271(f)(2	271(f)(2	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	16	regulated	regulate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	251	17	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	18	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	251	19	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	20	focus”—was	focus”—wa	VERB
inlawrev-25097	251	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	251	22	domestic	domestic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	251	23	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	251	25	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	26	supply[ing	supply[e	VERB
inlawrev-25097	251	27	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	28	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	29	components	component	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	251	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	251	32	patented	patented	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	251	33	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	34	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	35	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	251	36	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	251	37	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	251	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	251	39	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	251	40	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	251	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	42	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	43	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	251	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	251	45	overseas	overseas	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	251	46	assembly	assembly	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	251	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	251	49	patented	patented	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	251	50	invention.116	invention.116	PRON
inlawrev-25097	251	51	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-25097	251	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	53	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	251	54	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	55	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	251	56	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	57	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	251	58	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	251	59	284	284	NUM
inlawrev-25097	251	60	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	61	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	251	62	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	251	63	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	64	involving	involve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	251	65	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	66	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	251	67	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	251	68	271(f)(2	271(f)(2	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	69	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	70	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	71	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	251	72	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	251	73	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	74	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	251	75	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	251	76	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	77	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	251	78	exporting	export	VERB
inlawrev-25097	251	79	components	component	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	80	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	251	81	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	251	82	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	251	83	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	251	84	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	85	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	251	86	i.e.	i.e.	X
inlawrev-25097	251	87	ion	ion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	88	’s	’s	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	251	89	106	106	NUM
inlawrev-25097	251	90	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	252	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	252	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	252	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	252	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	252	5	eeoc	eeoc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	252	6	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	252	7	arabian	arabian	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	252	8	am	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	252	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	252	10	oil	oil	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	252	11	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	252	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	252	13	499	499	NUM
inlawrev-25097	253	1	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	253	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	253	3	244	244	NUM
inlawrev-25097	253	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	253	5	248	248	NUM
inlawrev-25097	253	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	253	7	1991	1991	NUM
inlawrev-25097	253	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	253	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	253	10	internal	internal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	253	11	quotation	quotation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	253	12	marks	mark	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	253	13	omitted	omit	VERB
inlawrev-25097	253	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	253	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	253	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	254	1	107	107	NUM
inlawrev-25097	254	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	255	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	255	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	255	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	255	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	255	5	rjr	rjr	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	255	6	nabisco	nabisco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	255	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	255	8	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	255	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	256	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	256	2	european	european	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	256	3	cmty	cmty	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	256	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	257	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	257	2	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	257	3	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	257	4	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	257	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	257	6	2090	2090	NUM
inlawrev-25097	257	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	257	8	2101	2101	NUM
inlawrev-25097	257	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	257	10	2016	2016	NUM
inlawrev-25097	257	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	257	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	257	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	258	1	108	108	NUM
inlawrev-25097	258	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	259	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	259	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	259	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	259	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	259	5	morrison	morrison	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	259	6	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	259	7	nat’l	nat’l	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	259	8	austl	austl	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	259	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	260	1	bank	bank	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	260	2	ltd	ltd	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	260	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	260	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	260	5	561	561	NUM
inlawrev-25097	260	6	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	260	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	260	8	247	247	NUM
inlawrev-25097	260	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	260	10	255	255	NUM
inlawrev-25097	260	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	260	12	2010	2010	NUM
inlawrev-25097	260	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	260	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	260	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	261	1	109	109	NUM
inlawrev-25097	261	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	262	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	262	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	262	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	262	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	262	5	rjr	rjr	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	262	6	nabisco	nabisco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	262	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	262	8	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	262	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	262	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	262	11	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	262	12	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	262	13	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	262	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	263	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	263	2	2101	2101	NUM
inlawrev-25097	263	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	263	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	264	1	110	110	NUM
inlawrev-25097	264	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	265	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	265	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	265	3	111	111	NUM
inlawrev-25097	265	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	266	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	266	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	266	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	266	4	2136	2136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	266	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	266	6	37	37	NUM
inlawrev-25097	266	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	266	8	112	112	NUM
inlawrev-25097	266	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	267	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	267	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	267	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	267	4	2137	2137	NUM
inlawrev-25097	267	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	267	6	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	267	7	rjr	rjr	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	267	8	nabisco	nabisco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	267	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	267	10	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	267	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	267	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	267	13	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	267	14	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	267	15	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	267	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	268	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	268	2	2101	2101	NUM
inlawrev-25097	268	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	268	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	269	1	113	113	NUM
inlawrev-25097	269	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	270	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	270	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	270	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	270	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	270	5	rjr	rjr	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	270	6	nabisco	nabisco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	270	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	270	8	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	270	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	270	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	270	11	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	270	12	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	270	13	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	270	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	271	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	271	2	2101	2101	NUM
inlawrev-25097	271	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	271	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	272	1	114	114	NUM
inlawrev-25097	272	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	273	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	273	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	273	3	115	115	NUM
inlawrev-25097	273	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	274	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	274	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	274	3	116	116	NUM
inlawrev-25097	274	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	275	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	275	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	275	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	275	4	2137	2137	NUM
inlawrev-25097	275	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	275	6	38	38	NUM
inlawrev-25097	275	7	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	275	8	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	275	9	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	275	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	276	1	§	§	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	276	2	271(f)(2	271(f)(2	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	276	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	276	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	276	5	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	276	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	276	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	277	1	782	782	NUM
inlawrev-25097	277	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	277	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	277	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	278	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	278	4	52:771	52:771	NUM
inlawrev-25097	278	5	domestic	domestic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	278	6	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	278	8	shipping	shipping	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	9	components	component	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	10	overseas	overseas	ADV
inlawrev-25097	278	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	278	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	278	13	westerngeco	westerngeco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	278	14	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	278	15	entitled	entitle	VERB
inlawrev-25097	278	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	278	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	278	18	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	278	19	profits	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	20	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	278	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	278	22	domestic	domestic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	278	23	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	278	25	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	278	26	284.117	284.117	NUM
inlawrev-25097	278	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	278	28	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	29	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-25097	278	30	ion	ion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	31	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	278	32	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	33	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	278	34	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	278	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	278	36	loss	loss	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	278	38	profits	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	39	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-25097	278	40	extraterritorially	extraterritorially	ADV
inlawrev-25097	278	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	278	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	278	43	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	44	involved	involve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	278	45	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	278	46	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	278	47	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	48	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	278	49	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	278	50	284.118	284.118	NUM
inlawrev-25097	278	51	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-25097	278	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	278	53	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	278	54	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	55	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-25097	278	56	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	278	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	278	58	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	278	59	overseas	overseas	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	278	60	events	event	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	61	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	278	62	merely	merely	ADV
inlawrev-25097	278	63	incidental	incidental	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	278	64	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	278	65	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	278	66	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	278	67	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	278	68	”1	”1	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	279	1	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	279	2	9	9	NUM
inlawrev-25097	279	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	279	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	279	5	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	279	6	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-25097	279	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	279	8	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	279	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	279	10	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	279	11	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	279	12	awards	award	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	279	13	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	279	14	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	279	15	injuries	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	279	16	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	279	17	always	always	ADV
inlawrev-25097	279	18	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	279	19	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	279	20	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	279	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	279	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	279	23	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	279	24	provision	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	279	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	279	26	”1	”1	VERB
inlawrev-25097	280	1	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-25097	280	2	0	0	NUM
inlawrev-25097	280	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	280	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	280	5	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-25097	280	6	refuted	refute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	280	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	280	8	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	280	9	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	280	10	position	position	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	280	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	280	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	280	13	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	280	14	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	280	15	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	280	16	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	280	17	permit	permit	VERB
inlawrev-25097	280	18	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	280	19	awards	award	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	280	20	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	280	21	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	280	22	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	280	23	profits	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	280	24	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	280	25	suggesting	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-25097	280	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	280	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	280	28	dissenters	dissenter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	280	29	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	280	30	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	280	31	conflat[ing	conflat[e	VERB
inlawrev-25097	280	32	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	280	33	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	280	34	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	280	35	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	280	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	280	37	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	280	38	arising	arise	VERB
inlawrev-25097	280	39	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	280	40	that	that	DET
inlawrev-25097	280	41	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	280	42	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	280	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	1	”121	”121	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	2	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
inlawrev-25097	281	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	6	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	8	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	9	awarded	award	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	10	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	11	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	12	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	13	profits	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	14	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	281	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	16	permissible	permissible	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	17	domestic	domestic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	18	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	20	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	21	284	284	NUM
inlawrev-25097	281	22	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	23	acts	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	25	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	26	occurring	occur	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	27	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	28	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	29	271(f)(2).122	271(f)(2).122	NUM
inlawrev-25097	281	30	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	31	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	32	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	33	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	281	34	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	35	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	36	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	37	dissented	dissent	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	38	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	39	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	40	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	42	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	43	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	44	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	45	breyer.123	breyer.123	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	46	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	47	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-25097	281	48	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	49	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	50	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	51	gorsuch	gorsuch	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	52	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	53	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	54	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	281	55	agreed	agree	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	56	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	58	award	award	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	59	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	60	lost	lost	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	61	profits	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	62	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	63	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	281	64	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	281	65	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	66	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	281	67	offend	offend	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	68	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	69	judicially	judicially	ADV
inlawrev-25097	281	70	created	create	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	71	presumption	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	72	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	73	extraterritorial	extraterritorial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	74	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	75	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	76	statutes	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	77	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	78	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	79	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-25097	281	80	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	81	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	281	82	submitted	submit	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	83	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	84	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	85	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	86	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	87	came	come	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	88	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	89	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	90	right	right	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	91	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	92	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	93	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	281	94	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	95	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	96	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	97	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	98	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	99	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	100	foreclose[d	foreclose[d	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	101	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	102	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	103	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	104	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	105	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	106	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	107	profits.124	profits.124	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	108	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	109	reason	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	110	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	111	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	112	gorsuch	gorsuch	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	113	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	114	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	115	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	281	116	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	117	straightforward”—a	straightforward”—a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	118	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	119	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	120	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	121	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	122	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	123	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	124	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	125	monopoly	monopoly	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	126	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	127	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	128	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	129	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	130	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-25097	281	131	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	132	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	133	allowing	allow	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	134	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	135	monopoly	monopoly	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	136	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	281	137	extend	extend	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	138	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	139	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	140	territories	territory	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	141	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-25097	281	142	invite	invite	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	143	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	144	countries	country	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	145	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	281	146	similarly	similarly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	281	147	infiltrate	infiltrate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	148	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	149	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	150	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	151	economy	economy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	152	via	via	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	153	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-25097	281	154	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	155	laws.125	laws.125	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	156	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	281	157	reiterated	reiterate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	158	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	159	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	160	acts	act	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	161	outside	outside	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	162	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	163	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	164	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	165	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	281	166	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	281	167	infringe	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	168	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	169	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	170	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	171	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	172	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	173	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	174	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	175	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	176	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	177	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	178	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-25097	281	179	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-25097	281	180	occur	occur	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	181	within	within	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	182	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	183	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	184	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	185	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	186	order	order	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	187	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	188	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	189	patentee	patentee	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	190	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	281	191	claim	claim	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	192	damages.1	damages.1	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	193	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-25097	281	194	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	195	gorsuch	gorsuch	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	196	articulated	articulate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	197	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	198	westerngeco	westerngeco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	199	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	281	200	entitled	entitle	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	201	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	202	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	203	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	204	royalty	royalty	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	205	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	206	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	207	infringing	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	208	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	209	ion	ion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	210	produced	produce	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	211	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	212	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	213	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	214	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	215	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	216	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	217	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	281	218	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	281	219	owed	owe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	220	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	221	profits	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	222	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	223	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	224	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	281	225	the	the	X
inlawrev-25097	281	226	]	]	X
inlawrev-25097	281	227	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	228	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	229	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	281	230	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	281	231	n’t	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	281	232	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	233	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	234	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	235	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	236	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	237	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	238	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-25097	281	239	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	240	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	241	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	281	242	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	281	243	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	244	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	245	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	246	compensation	compensation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	247	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	248	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	249	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	250	plain	plain	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	251	terms	term	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	252	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	253	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	254	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	255	284.127	284.127	NUM
inlawrev-25097	281	256	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	281	257	illustrate	illustrate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	258	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-25097	281	259	point	point	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	260	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	261	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	262	gorsuch	gorsuch	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	263	pointed	point	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	264	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	265	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-25097	281	266	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	267	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	268	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	269	1	1	X
inlawrev-25097	281	270	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	271	brown	brown	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	272	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	273	duchesne	duchesne	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	281	274	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	281	275	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	281	276	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	281	277	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	278	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	279	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	280	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	281	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	282	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	281	283	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	281	284	high	high	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	281	285	seas	sea	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	281	286	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	281	287	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	281	288	117	117	NUM
inlawrev-25097	281	289	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	282	1	westerngeco	westerngeco	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	282	2	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	282	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	282	4	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	282	5	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	282	6	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	282	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	283	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	283	2	2138	2138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	283	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	284	1	118	118	NUM
inlawrev-25097	284	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	285	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	285	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	285	3	119	119	NUM
inlawrev-25097	285	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	286	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	286	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	286	3	120	120	NUM
inlawrev-25097	286	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	287	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	287	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	287	3	121	121	NUM
inlawrev-25097	287	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	288	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	288	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	288	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	288	4	2138	2138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	288	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	289	1	122	122	NUM
inlawrev-25097	289	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	290	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	290	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	290	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	290	4	2139	2139	NUM
inlawrev-25097	290	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	291	1	123	123	NUM
inlawrev-25097	291	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	292	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	292	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	292	3	124	124	NUM
inlawrev-25097	292	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	293	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	293	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	293	3	125	125	NUM
inlawrev-25097	293	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	294	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	294	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	294	3	126	126	NUM
inlawrev-25097	294	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	295	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	295	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	295	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	295	4	2139	2139	NUM
inlawrev-25097	295	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	295	6	40	40	NUM
inlawrev-25097	295	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	295	8	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	295	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	295	10	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	295	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	295	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	296	1	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-25097	296	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	297	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	297	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	297	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	297	4	2140	2140	NUM
inlawrev-25097	297	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	1	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	298	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	3	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	298	4	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	5	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	6	783	783	NUM
inlawrev-25097	298	7	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	8	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	298	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	11	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	298	13	[	[	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	14	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	15	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	16	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	17	outside	outside	ADP
inlawrev-25097	298	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	298	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	22	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	298	23	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	298	24	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	298	25	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	298	26	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	298	28	[	[	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	30	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	31	owner	owner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	32	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	298	33	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	34	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	35	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	36	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	298	37	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-25097	298	38	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-25097	298	39	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-25097	298	40	no	no	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	41	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	42	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	298	43	compensation;128	compensation;128	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	44	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	45	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-25097	298	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	47	birdsall	birdsall	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	298	48	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	298	49	coolidge	coolidge	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	298	50	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	51	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	298	52	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	298	53	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	54	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	298	55	supposed	suppose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	298	56	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	298	57	compensate	compensate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	298	58	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	59	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	60	owner	owner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	61	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	298	62	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	63	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	64	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	65	unlawful	unlawful	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	298	66	acts	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	67	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	298	68	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	69	defendant”;129	defendant”;129	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	298	70	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	298	71	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	72	3	3	X
inlawrev-25097	298	73	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	74	yale	yale	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	75	lock	lock	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	298	76	manufacturing	manufacturing	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	298	77	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	298	78	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	298	79	sargent	sargent	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	298	80	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	81	which	which	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	82	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	83	gorsuch	gorsuch	ADV
inlawrev-25097	298	84	dubbed	dub	VERB
inlawrev-25097	298	85	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	86	[	[	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	87	t]his	t]his	ADP
inlawrev-25097	298	88	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	89	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	298	90	leading	lead	VERB
inlawrev-25097	298	91	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	92	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	298	93	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	298	94	profit	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	95	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	96	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	97	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	98	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	298	99	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	100	difference	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	101	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	298	102	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	103	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	104	holder	holder	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	105	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	298	106	economic	economic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	298	107	position	position	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	108	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-25097	298	109	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	110	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	298	111	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	298	112	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-25097	298	113	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	114	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	115	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	298	116	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	298	117	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	298	118	measured	measure	VERB
inlawrev-25097	298	119	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	298	120	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	298	121	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	298	122	additional	additional	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	298	123	profits	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	299	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	299	2	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	299	3	owner	owner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	299	4	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	299	5	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-25097	299	6	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	299	7	realized	realize	VERB
inlawrev-25097	299	8	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	299	9	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	299	10	sales	sale	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	299	11	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	299	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	299	13	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	299	14	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	299	15	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	299	16	interfered	interfere	VERB
inlawrev-25097	299	17	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	299	18	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	299	19	monopoly	monopoly	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	299	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	300	1	’”130	’”130	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	300	2	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	3	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	300	4	proposed	propose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	300	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	300	6	all	all	DET
inlawrev-25097	300	7	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-25097	300	8	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	9	taught	teach	VERB
inlawrev-25097	300	10	us	we	PRON
inlawrev-25097	300	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	300	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	300	13	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	14	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	15	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	300	16	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	300	17	warrant	warrant	VERB
inlawrev-25097	300	18	compensation	compensation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	19	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	300	20	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	300	21	uses	use	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	300	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	300	24	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	300	25	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	300	26	patent.131	patent.131	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	27	furthermore	furthermore	ADV
inlawrev-25097	300	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	300	29	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	30	gorsuch	gorsuch	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	300	31	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	300	32	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	300	33	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-25097	300	34	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	300	35	271(f)(2	271(f)(2	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	300	37	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	300	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	300	39	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	300	40	special	special	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	300	41	exception	exception	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	42	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	300	43	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	300	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	300	45	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	300	46	bedrock	bedrock	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	47	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	48	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	300	49	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	300	50	uses	use	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	51	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	300	52	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	300	53	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	54	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	300	55	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-25097	300	56	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	300	57	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	58	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	300	59	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	300	60	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	300	61	country	country	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	62	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	300	63	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	300	64	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	300	65	infringe	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	300	66	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	300	67	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	300	68	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	300	69	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	300	70	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	300	71	”1	”1	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	301	1	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-25097	301	2	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-25097	301	3	instead	instead	ADV
inlawrev-25097	301	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	301	5	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	301	6	gorsuch	gorsuch	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	301	7	opined	opine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	301	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	301	9	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	301	10	271(f)(2	271(f)(2	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	301	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	301	12	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-25097	301	13	extended	extend	VERB
inlawrev-25097	301	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	301	15	domestic	domestic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	301	16	protections	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	301	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	301	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	301	19	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	301	20	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	301	21	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	301	22	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	301	23	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	301	24	making	making	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	301	25	]	]	X
inlawrev-25097	301	26	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	301	27	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	301	28	someone	someone	PRON
inlawrev-25097	301	29	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-25097	301	30	almost	almost	ADV
inlawrev-25097	301	31	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	301	32	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	301	33	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	301	34	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	301	35	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	301	36	country	country	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	301	37	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-25097	301	38	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	301	39	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	301	40	liable	liable	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	301	41	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	301	42	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	301	43	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	301	44	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	301	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	301	46	complete	complete	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	301	47	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	301	48	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	301	49	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	301	50	country	country	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	301	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	302	1	”133	”133	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	302	2	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	302	3	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	302	4	warned	warn	VERB
inlawrev-25097	302	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	302	6	allowing	allow	VERB
inlawrev-25097	302	7	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	302	8	protection	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	302	9	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-25097	302	10	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	302	11	uses	use	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	302	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	302	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	302	14	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	302	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	302	16	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-25097	302	17	lead	lead	VERB
inlawrev-25097	302	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	302	19	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	302	20	anomalous	anomalous	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	302	21	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	302	22	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	302	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	302	24	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	302	25	threaten	threaten	VERB
inlawrev-25097	302	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	302	27	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	302	28	conver[t	conver[t	VERB
inlawrev-25097	302	29	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	302	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	302	31	single	single	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	302	32	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	302	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	302	34	supply	supply	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	302	35	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	302	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	302	37	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	302	38	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	302	39	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-25097	302	40	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	302	41	springboard	springboard	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	302	42	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	302	43	liability	liability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	302	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	303	1	’”134	’”134	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	303	2	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	3	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	303	4	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	303	5	presented	present	VERB
inlawrev-25097	303	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	303	7	situation	situation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	8	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	303	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	303	10	microchip	microchip	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	11	developer	developer	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	12	created	create	VERB
inlawrev-25097	303	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	303	14	microchip	microchip	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	303	16	infringed	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	303	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	303	18	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	303	19	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	303	20	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	303	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	303	23	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	303	25	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	303	26	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	303	27	competed	compete	VERB
inlawrev-25097	303	28	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	303	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	303	30	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	31	owner	owner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	32	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	303	33	microchip	microchip	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	34	strictly	strictly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	303	35	overseas.135	overseas.135	VERB
inlawrev-25097	303	36	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-25097	303	37	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	303	38	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	39	gorsuch	gorsuch	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	303	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	303	41	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	303	42	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	303	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	303	44	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	45	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	303	46	approach	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	47	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	303	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	303	49	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	50	owner	owner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	51	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-25097	303	52	recover	recover	VERB
inlawrev-25097	303	53	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	303	54	profits	profit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	55	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	303	56	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-25097	303	57	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	303	58	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	303	59	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	303	60	sales	sale	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	61	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	303	62	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	303	63	infringing	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	303	64	microchip	microchip	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	65	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	303	66	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	303	67	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-25097	303	68	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	303	69	effectively	effectively	ADV
inlawrev-25097	303	70	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	303	71	give	give	VERB
inlawrev-25097	303	72	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	303	73	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	303	74	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	75	owner	owner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	76	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	303	77	monopoly	monopoly	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	78	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-25097	303	79	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	303	80	markets	market	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	81	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-25097	303	82	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	303	83	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	303	84	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	303	85	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	303	86	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	303	87	”136	”136	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	304	1	justice	justice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	304	2	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	304	3	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	304	4	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-25097	304	5	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	6	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	304	7	further	further	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	304	8	warning	warning	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	304	10	overstepping	overstep	VERB
inlawrev-25097	304	11	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	304	12	extending	extend	VERB
inlawrev-25097	304	13	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	14	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	304	16	beyond	beyond	ADP
inlawrev-25097	304	17	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-25097	304	18	borders	border	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	19	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	304	20	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-25097	304	21	invite	invite	VERB
inlawrev-25097	304	22	reciprocal	reciprocal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	304	23	actions	action	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	24	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	304	25	foreign	foreign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	304	26	patentees.137	patentees.137	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	27	finally	finally	ADV
inlawrev-25097	304	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	304	29	justice	justice	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	30	gorsuch	gorsuch	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	304	31	heeded	heed	VERB
inlawrev-25097	304	32	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	304	33	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	304	34	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	304	36	comity	comity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	37	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	38	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-25097	304	39	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	304	40	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	304	42	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-25097	304	43	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	44	laws	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	45	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	304	46	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-25097	304	47	interfere	interfere	VERB
inlawrev-25097	304	48	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-25097	304	49	dramatically	dramatically	ADV
inlawrev-25097	304	50	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	304	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	304	52	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	304	54	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	304	55	nations	nation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	56	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	304	57	regulate	regulate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	304	58	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-25097	304	59	own	own	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	304	60	economies	economy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	304	61	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	305	1	”138	”138	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	305	2	128	128	NUM
inlawrev-25097	305	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	306	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	306	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	306	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	306	4	alterations	alteration	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	306	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	306	6	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	306	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	306	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	306	9	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	306	10	brown	brown	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	306	11	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	306	12	duchesne	duchesne	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	306	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	306	14	60	60	NUM
inlawrev-25097	306	15	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	306	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	306	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	306	18	19	19	NUM
inlawrev-25097	306	19	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	306	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	306	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	307	1	183	183	NUM
inlawrev-25097	307	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	307	3	195	195	NUM
inlawrev-25097	307	4	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	307	5	96	96	NUM
inlawrev-25097	307	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	307	7	1857	1857	NUM
inlawrev-25097	307	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	307	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	307	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	308	1	129	129	NUM
inlawrev-25097	308	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	309	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	309	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	309	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	309	4	2140	2140	NUM
inlawrev-25097	309	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	309	6	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	309	7	birdsall	birdsall	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	309	8	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	309	9	coolidge	coolidge	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	309	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	309	11	93	93	NUM
inlawrev-25097	309	12	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	309	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	309	14	64	64	NUM
inlawrev-25097	309	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	309	16	1876	1876	NUM
inlawrev-25097	309	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	309	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	309	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	310	1	130	130	NUM
inlawrev-25097	310	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	311	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	311	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	311	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	311	4	2141	2141	NUM
inlawrev-25097	311	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	311	6	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	311	7	yale	yale	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	311	8	lock	lock	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	311	9	mfg	mfg	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	311	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	311	11	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	312	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	312	2	sargent	sargent	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	312	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	312	4	117	117	NUM
inlawrev-25097	312	5	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	312	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	312	7	536	536	NUM
inlawrev-25097	312	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	312	9	552	552	NUM
inlawrev-25097	312	10	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	312	11	53	53	NUM
inlawrev-25097	312	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	312	13	1886	1886	NUM
inlawrev-25097	312	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	312	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	312	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	313	1	131	131	X
inlawrev-25097	313	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	314	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	314	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	314	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	314	4	2140	2140	NUM
inlawrev-25097	314	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	314	6	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-25097	314	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	315	1	132	132	NUM
inlawrev-25097	315	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	316	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	316	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	316	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	316	4	2141	2141	NUM
inlawrev-25097	316	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	316	6	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	316	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	316	8	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	316	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	316	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	317	1	133	133	NUM
inlawrev-25097	317	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	318	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	318	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	318	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	318	4	2142	2142	NUM
inlawrev-25097	318	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	318	6	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	318	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	318	8	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	318	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	318	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	319	1	134	134	NUM
inlawrev-25097	319	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	320	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	320	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	320	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	320	4	alteration	alteration	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	320	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	320	6	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	320	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	320	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	320	9	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	320	10	microsoft	microsoft	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	320	11	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	320	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	321	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	321	2	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	321	3	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	321	4	t	t	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	321	5	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	321	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	321	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	321	8	550	550	NUM
inlawrev-25097	321	9	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	321	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	321	11	437	437	NUM
inlawrev-25097	321	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	321	13	456	456	NUM
inlawrev-25097	321	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	321	15	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-25097	321	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	321	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	321	18	internal	internal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	321	19	quotations	quotation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	321	20	omitted	omit	VERB
inlawrev-25097	321	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	321	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	321	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	322	1	135	135	NUM
inlawrev-25097	322	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	323	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	323	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	323	3	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	323	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	324	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	324	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	324	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	324	4	2142	2142	NUM
inlawrev-25097	324	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	324	6	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-25097	324	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	324	8	137	137	NUM
inlawrev-25097	324	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	325	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	325	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	325	3	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	325	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	326	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	326	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	326	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	326	4	2143	2143	NUM
inlawrev-25097	326	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	327	1	784	784	NUM
inlawrev-25097	327	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	327	3	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	327	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	327	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	327	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	327	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	327	8	52:771	52:771	NUM
inlawrev-25097	327	9	iv	iv	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	327	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	328	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	328	2	appealability	appealability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	328	4	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	328	6	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	7	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	328	8	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	9	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	328	10	institution	institution	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	11	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	12	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	328	13	wi	wi	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	328	15	fi	fi	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	16	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	328	17	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	18	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	19	broadcom	broadcom	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	20	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	21	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	328	23	january	january	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	24	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	328	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	328	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	328	27	en	en	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	28	banc	banc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	29	federal	federal	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	30	circuit	circuit	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	31	revisited	revisit	VERB
inlawrev-25097	328	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	328	33	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	328	35	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	328	36	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	328	38	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	39	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	328	40	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	41	determinations	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	42	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	328	43	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	328	44	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	45	315(b).139	315(b).139	NUM
inlawrev-25097	328	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	328	47	panel	panel	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	48	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	328	49	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	50	overruled	overrule	VERB
inlawrev-25097	328	51	achates	achate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	328	52	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	53	publishing	publishing	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	328	54	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	328	55	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	56	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	57	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	58	apple	apple	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	59	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	60	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	328	61	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	328	62	803	803	NUM
inlawrev-25097	328	63	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	328	64	652	652	NUM
inlawrev-25097	328	65	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	328	66	658	658	NUM
inlawrev-25097	329	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	2	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	4	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	6	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-25097	329	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	329	10	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	329	12	determinations	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	13	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	14	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	16	ptab	ptab	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	17	regarding	regard	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	19	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	329	20	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	21	year	year	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	22	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	23	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	329	25	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	329	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	329	27	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	28	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	29	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	30	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	31	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	329	32	appealable.140	appealable.140	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	329	33	a.	a.	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	34	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	35	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	37	passage	passage	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	40	leahy	leahy	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	41	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	42	smith	smith	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	43	america	america	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	44	invents	invents	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	45	act	act	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	46	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	47	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	48	aia	aia	X
inlawrev-25097	329	49	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	50	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	51	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	52	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-25097	329	53	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	54	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	55	created	create	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	56	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	329	57	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	58	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	59	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	329	60	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	329	61	post	post	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	329	62	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	329	63	grant	grant	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	329	64	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	65	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	66	order	order	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	67	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	329	68	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	69	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	70	efficient	efficient	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	329	71	alternative	alternative	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	72	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	73	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	74	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	75	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	329	76	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	77	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	329	78	challenge	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	79	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	80	patentability	patentability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	81	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	82	issued	issue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	83	claims.141	claims.141	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	84	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	85	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-25097	329	86	most	most	ADV
inlawrev-25097	329	87	pertinent	pertinent	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	329	88	provisions	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	89	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	90	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	91	aia	aia	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	92	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	93	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	94	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	95	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	329	96	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	97	314(d	314(d	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	98	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	99	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	100	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	329	101	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	102	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	329	103	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	104	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	329	105	t]he	t]he	ADV
inlawrev-25097	329	106	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	107	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	108	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	109	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	110	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	329	111	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	329	112	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	113	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	114	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	115	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	116	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	117	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	118	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	119	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	120	shall	shall	AUX
inlawrev-25097	329	121	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	329	122	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	329	123	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	329	124	nonappealable,”142	nonappealable,”142	PRON
inlawrev-25097	329	125	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	329	126	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	127	315(b	315(b	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	128	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	129	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	130	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	329	131	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	132	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	329	133	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	134	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	329	135	a]n	a]n	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	329	136	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	329	137	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	138	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	139	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-25097	329	140	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	329	141	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	329	142	instituted	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	143	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	329	144	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	145	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	146	requesting	request	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	147	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	148	proceeding	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	149	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	329	150	filed	file	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	151	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	329	152	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	153	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	329	154	year	year	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	155	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	156	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	157	date	date	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	158	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	159	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	329	160	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	161	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	162	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	163	real	real	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	329	164	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	165	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	166	interest	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	167	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	168	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	329	169	privy	privy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	170	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	171	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	172	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	173	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	329	174	served	serve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	175	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	176	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	177	complaint	complaint	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	178	alleging	allege	VERB
inlawrev-25097	329	179	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	180	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	329	181	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	329	182	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	329	183	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	329	184	”143	”143	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	330	2	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	330	4	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	330	5	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	6	314(d	314(d	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	8	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	330	9	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	10	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	330	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	330	12	nonappealable	nonappealable	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	330	13	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	14	language	language	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	15	applies	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	17	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	18	315(b	315(b	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	20	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	330	21	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	22	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	23	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	24	determinations.144	determinations.144	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	25	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	26	procedural	procedural	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	27	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	28	prior	prior	ADV
inlawrev-25097	330	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	30	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	330	31	rehearing	rehear	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	32	en	en	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	33	banc	banc	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	330	36	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	330	37	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	38	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	330	39	already	already	ADV
inlawrev-25097	330	40	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	330	42	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	43	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	44	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	330	45	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	46	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	47	achates.145	achates.145	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	48	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	49	achates	achate	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	50	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	330	52	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	330	53	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	54	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	55	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	330	56	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	57	314(d	314(d	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	58	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	59	precluded	preclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	60	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	330	61	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	330	62	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	63	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	64	reviewing	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	65	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	330	66	board	board	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	67	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	330	68	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	69	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	330	70	initiate	initiate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	71	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	330	72	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	73	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	74	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	75	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	76	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	77	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	330	78	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	79	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	80	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	81	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	82	§	§	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	83	315(b).146	315(b).146	NUM
inlawrev-25097	330	84	subsequently	subsequently	ADV
inlawrev-25097	330	85	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	86	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	330	87	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	88	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	89	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	90	cuozzo	cuozzo	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	91	speed	speed	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	92	technologies	technology	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	93	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	94	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	95	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	96	lee	lee	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	97	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	98	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	99	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	330	100	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-25097	330	101	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	102	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	330	103	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	104	314(d	314(d	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	105	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	106	bars	bar	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	107	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	330	108	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	109	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	110	determinations	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	111	regarding	regard	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	112	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	330	113	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	330	114	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	115	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	330	116	pleaded	plead	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	117	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	118	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	330	119	particularity	particularity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	120	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	121	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	122	312(a)(3).147	312(a)(3).147	NUM
inlawrev-25097	330	123	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	330	124	cuozzo	cuozzo	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	330	125	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	330	126	despite	despite	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	330	127	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
inlawrev-25097	330	128	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	330	129	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	330	130	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	330	131	139	139	NUM
inlawrev-25097	330	132	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	331	1	wi	wi	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	331	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	331	3	fi	fi	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	331	4	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	331	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	331	6	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	331	7	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	331	8	broadcom	broadcom	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	331	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	331	10	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	331	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	331	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	331	13	878	878	NUM
inlawrev-25097	331	14	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	331	15	1364	1364	NUM
inlawrev-25097	331	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	331	17	1365	1365	NUM
inlawrev-25097	332	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	332	2	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	332	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	332	4	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	332	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	332	6	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	332	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	332	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	333	1	140	140	NUM
inlawrev-25097	333	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	334	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	334	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	334	3	141	141	NUM
inlawrev-25097	334	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	335	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-25097	335	2	pub	pub	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	335	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	336	1	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	336	2	no	no	INTJ
inlawrev-25097	336	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	337	1	112	112	NUM
inlawrev-25097	337	2	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	337	3	29	29	NUM
inlawrev-25097	337	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	337	5	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	337	6	6(a)-(c	6(a)-(c	NUM
inlawrev-25097	337	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	337	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	337	9	125	125	NUM
inlawrev-25097	337	10	stat	stat	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	337	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	338	1	284	284	NUM
inlawrev-25097	338	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	338	3	299–305	299–305	NUM
inlawrev-25097	338	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	338	5	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-25097	338	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	338	7	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	338	8	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	338	9	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	338	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	339	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	339	2	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	339	3	311	311	NUM
inlawrev-25097	339	4	-	-	NUM
inlawrev-25097	339	5	319	319	NUM
inlawrev-25097	339	6	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	339	7	h.r	h.r	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	339	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	339	9	rep	rep	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	339	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	339	11	no	no	INTJ
inlawrev-25097	339	12	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	340	1	112	112	NUM
inlawrev-25097	340	2	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	340	3	98	98	NUM
inlawrev-25097	340	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	340	5	pt	pt	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	340	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	340	7	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	340	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	340	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	340	10	48	48	NUM
inlawrev-25097	340	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	340	12	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-25097	340	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	340	14	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	340	15	157	157	NUM
inlawrev-25097	340	16	cong	cong	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	340	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	341	1	rec	rec	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	341	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	342	1	2,710	2,710	NUM
inlawrev-25097	342	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	342	3	2011	2011	NUM
inlawrev-25097	342	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	342	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	342	6	statement	statement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	342	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	342	8	sen	sen	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	342	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	342	10	grassley	grassley	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	342	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	342	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	343	1	142	142	NUM
inlawrev-25097	343	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-25097	343	3	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	343	4	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	343	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	344	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	344	2	314(d	314(d	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	344	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	344	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	344	5	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	344	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	344	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	345	1	143	143	X
inlawrev-25097	345	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	346	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	346	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	346	3	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	346	4	315(b	315(b	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	346	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	346	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	347	1	144	144	NUM
inlawrev-25097	347	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	348	1	wi	wi	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	348	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	348	3	fi	fi	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	348	4	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	348	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	348	6	878	878	NUM
inlawrev-25097	348	7	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	348	8	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	348	9	1368	1368	NUM
inlawrev-25097	348	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	349	1	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-25097	349	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	350	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	350	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	350	3	146	146	NUM
inlawrev-25097	350	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	351	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	351	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	351	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	351	4	1369	1369	NUM
inlawrev-25097	351	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	352	1	147	147	NUM
inlawrev-25097	352	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	353	1	cuozzo	cuozzo	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	353	2	speed	speed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	353	3	techs	tech	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	353	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	353	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	353	6	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	353	7	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	353	8	lee	lee	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	353	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	353	10	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	353	11	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	353	12	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	353	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	354	1	2131	2131	NUM
inlawrev-25097	354	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	354	3	2016	2016	NUM
inlawrev-25097	354	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	354	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	355	1	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	355	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	355	3	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	355	4	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	5	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	6	785	785	NUM
inlawrev-25097	355	7	314(d	314(d	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	355	9	precluded	preclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	355	10	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	355	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	355	13	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	355	14	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	355	15	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-25097	355	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	355	17	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-25097	355	18	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-25097	355	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	355	20	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	355	21	strong	strong	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	355	22	presumption	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	355	24	favor	favor	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	355	26	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	355	27	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	28	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	355	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	355	30	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-25097	355	31	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	355	32	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	355	33	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	34	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	355	35	limited	limited	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	355	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	355	37	expressly	expressly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	355	38	opening	open	VERB
inlawrev-25097	355	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	355	40	door	door	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	41	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	355	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	355	43	potential	potential	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	44	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	355	45	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	46	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	355	47	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	48	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	355	49	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	355	50	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	355	51	partes	part	VERB
inlawrev-25097	355	52	review.148	review.148	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	53	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	355	54	that	that	DET
inlawrev-25097	355	55	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	56	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	355	57	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	355	58	backdrop	backdrop	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	59	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	355	60	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	355	61	present	present	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	355	62	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	63	came	come	VERB
inlawrev-25097	355	64	about	about	ADV
inlawrev-25097	355	65	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-25097	355	66	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	355	67	period	period	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	68	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	355	69	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	355	70	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	71	involving	involve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	355	72	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	355	73	convoluted	convoluted	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	355	74	mixture	mixture	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	75	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	355	76	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	355	77	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	356	1	ericsson	ericsson	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	356	2	initially	initially	ADV
inlawrev-25097	356	3	owned	own	VERB
inlawrev-25097	356	4	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-25097	356	5	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	356	6	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	356	7	sued	sue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	356	8	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	356	9	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	356	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	356	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	356	12	eastern	eastern	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	356	13	district	district	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	356	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	356	15	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	356	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	356	17	2010.149	2010.149	NUM
inlawrev-25097	356	18	that	that	DET
inlawrev-25097	356	19	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	356	20	progressed	progress	VERB
inlawrev-25097	356	21	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-25097	356	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	356	23	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	356	24	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	356	25	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	356	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	356	27	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	356	28	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	356	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	356	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	356	31	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	356	32	infringed	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	356	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	356	34	asserted	assert	VERB
inlawrev-25097	356	35	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	356	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	2	2013	2013	NUM
inlawrev-25097	357	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	4	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-25097	357	5	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	7	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	357	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	9	year	year	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	10	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	12	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	13	315(b	315(b	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	16	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	18	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	21	jury	jury	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	22	verdict	verdict	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	24	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	357	25	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	357	26	eventually	eventually	ADV
inlawrev-25097	357	27	affirmed	affirm	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	29	broadcom	broadcom	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	30	corporation	corporation	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	31	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	32	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	33	broadcom	broadcom	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	34	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	37	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-25097	357	38	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	357	39	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	357	40	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	41	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	44	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	46	filed	file	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	47	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-25097	357	48	petitions	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	49	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	50	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	51	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	52	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	53	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	55	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-25097	357	56	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	57	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	58	insuit.150	insuit.150	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	59	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	60	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	61	pendency	pendency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	62	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	64	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	65	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	66	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	67	petitions	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	68	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	69	ericsson	ericsson	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	70	transferred	transfer	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	71	ownership	ownership	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	72	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	73	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	74	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-25097	357	75	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	76	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	77	wi	wi	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	78	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	79	fi	fi	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	80	one	one	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	81	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	82	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	83	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	84	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	85	wi	wi	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	86	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	87	fi”).151	fi”).151	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	88	wi	wi	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	89	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	90	fi	fi	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	91	initially	initially	ADV
inlawrev-25097	357	92	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	93	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	94	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	95	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	96	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	357	97	prohibited	prohibit	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	98	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	99	instituting	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	100	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	101	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	102	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	103	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-25097	357	104	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	105	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	106	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	107	315(b	315(b	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	108	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	109	’s	’	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	110	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	357	111	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	112	year	year	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	113	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	114	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	115	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	116	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	117	broadcom	broadcom	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	118	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	357	119	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	120	privity	privity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	121	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	122	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	123	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	124	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	357	125	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	357	126	served	serve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	127	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	128	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	129	complaint	complaint	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	130	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	131	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	132	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	133	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	134	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	135	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	136	2010.152	2010.152	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	137	throughout	throughout	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	138	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	139	board	board	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	140	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	141	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	142	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	143	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	144	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	145	wi	wi	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	146	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	147	fi	fi	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	148	maintained	maintain	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	149	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	150	position.153	position.153	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	151	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	152	losing	lose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	153	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	154	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	155	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	156	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	157	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	158	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	159	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	160	wi	wi	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	161	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	162	fi	fi	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	163	petitioned	petition	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	164	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	165	rehearing	rehear	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	166	en	en	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	167	banc	banc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	168	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	169	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	357	170	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	357	171	granted.154	granted.154	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	172	c.	c.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	173	federal	federal	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	174	circuit	circuit	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	175	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	357	176	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	177	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	178	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	179	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	180	began	begin	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	181	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	182	reiterating	reiterate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	183	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	184	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-25097	357	185	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	186	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	187	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	188	strong	strong	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	189	presumption	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	190	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	191	favoring	favor	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	192	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	193	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	194	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	195	administrative	administrative	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	196	actions	action	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	197	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	198	including	include	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	199	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	200	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	201	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	357	202	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	203	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	204	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	205	institution	institution	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	206	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	207	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	208	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	209	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	210	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	211	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-25097	357	212	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	357	213	abdicated	abdicate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	214	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-25097	357	215	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	216	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	217	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	218	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	219	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	220	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	221	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	222	convincing	convincing	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	223	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	224	indications	indication	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	225	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	226	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	357	227	intends	intend	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	228	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	357	229	prohibit	prohibit	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	230	review.155	review.155	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	231	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	232	noting	note	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	233	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-25097	357	234	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	235	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	236	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	237	announced	announce	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	238	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	239	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-25097	357	240	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	241	no	no	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	242	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	243	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	244	convincing	convincing	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	245	indication	indication	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	246	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	247	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	248	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	249	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	250	statutory	statutory	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	251	language	language	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	252	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	253	legislative	legislative	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	254	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	255	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	256	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	257	statutory	statutory	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	258	scheme	scheme	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	259	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	260	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	261	whole	whole	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	262	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	357	263	demonstrates	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	264	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	265	intent	intent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	266	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	357	267	bar	bar	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	268	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	269	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	270	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	271	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	272	315(b	315(b	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	273	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	274	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	275	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	276	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	277	determinations.156	determinations.156	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	278	turning	turn	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	279	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	280	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	281	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	282	statutory	statutory	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	283	language	language	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	284	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	285	statutory	statutory	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	286	scheme	scheme	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	287	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	288	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	289	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	290	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	291	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	292	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	293	314(d	314(d	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	294	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	295	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	357	296	states	state	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	297	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	298	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	357	299	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	357	300	t]he	t]he	ADV
inlawrev-25097	357	301	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	302	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	303	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	304	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	305	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	306	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	357	307	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	357	308	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	309	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	357	310	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	311	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	312	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	357	313	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	357	314	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	315	shall	shall	AUX
inlawrev-25097	357	316	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	357	317	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	357	318	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	357	319	nonappealable	nonappealable	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	357	320	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	358	1	”157	”157	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	359	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	359	2	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	359	3	reasoned	reason	VERB
inlawrev-25097	359	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	359	5	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	359	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	359	7	statutory	statutory	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	359	8	language	language	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	359	9	148	148	NUM
inlawrev-25097	359	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	360	1	wi	wi	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	360	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	360	3	fi	fi	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	360	4	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	360	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	360	6	878	878	NUM
inlawrev-25097	360	7	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	360	8	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	360	9	1369	1369	NUM
inlawrev-25097	360	10	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	360	11	70	70	NUM
inlawrev-25097	360	12	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	360	13	149	149	NUM
inlawrev-25097	360	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	361	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	361	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	361	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	361	4	1370	1370	NUM
inlawrev-25097	361	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	362	1	150	150	NUM
inlawrev-25097	362	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	363	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	363	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	363	3	151	151	NUM
inlawrev-25097	363	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	364	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	364	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	364	3	152	152	NUM
inlawrev-25097	364	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	365	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	365	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	365	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	365	4	1370	1370	NUM
inlawrev-25097	365	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	365	6	71	71	NUM
inlawrev-25097	365	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	365	8	153	153	NUM
inlawrev-25097	365	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	366	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	366	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	366	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	366	4	1371	1371	NUM
inlawrev-25097	366	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	367	1	154	154	NUM
inlawrev-25097	367	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	368	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	368	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	368	3	155	155	NUM
inlawrev-25097	368	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	369	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	369	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	369	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	369	4	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-25097	369	5	cuozzo	cuozzo	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	369	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	369	7	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	369	8	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	369	9	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	369	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	370	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	370	2	2140	2140	NUM
inlawrev-25097	370	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	370	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	371	1	156	156	NUM
inlawrev-25097	371	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	372	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	372	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	372	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	372	4	1372	1372	NUM
inlawrev-25097	372	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	373	1	157	157	NUM
inlawrev-25097	373	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	374	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	374	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	374	3	786	786	NUM
inlawrev-25097	374	4	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	374	5	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	374	6	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	375	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	375	4	52:771	52:771	NUM
inlawrev-25097	375	5	limits	limit	VERB
inlawrev-25097	375	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	375	7	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	375	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	375	10	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	375	12	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	375	13	own	own	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	375	14	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	375	15	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	375	17	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	375	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	375	19	only	only	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	375	20	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	21	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	375	22	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	375	23	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	375	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	375	25	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	375	26	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	375	27	appealable	appealable	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	375	28	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	375	29	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-25097	375	30	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	375	31	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	375	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	375	33	substantive	substantive	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	375	34	provisions	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	375	36	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	375	37	314(a).158	314(a).158	NUM
inlawrev-25097	375	38	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	39	314	314	NUM
inlawrev-25097	375	40	addresses	address	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	375	42	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	375	44	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	375	46	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	375	47	discretion	discretion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	48	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	375	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	375	50	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	51	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	375	52	preliminarily	preliminarily	ADV
inlawrev-25097	375	53	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	375	54	patentability	patentability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	375	55	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	376	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	376	2	contrast	contrast	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	376	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	376	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	376	5	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	376	6	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	376	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	376	8	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	376	9	315(b	315(b	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	376	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	376	11	addresses	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	376	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	376	13	discrete	discrete	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	376	14	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	376	15	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	376	16	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	376	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	376	18	service	service	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	376	19	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	376	20	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	376	21	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	376	22	wholly	wholly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	376	23	outside	outside	ADP
inlawrev-25097	376	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	376	25	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	376	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	376	27	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	376	28	314(a	314(a	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	376	29	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	376	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	377	1	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	377	2	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	377	3	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-25097	377	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	377	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	377	6	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	7	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	377	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	377	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	377	10	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	377	12	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	13	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	377	15	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	377	16	akin	akin	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	377	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	377	18	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	377	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	377	20	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	377	21	-	-	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	22	initiation	initiation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	23	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	377	24	preliminary	preliminary	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	377	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	377	26	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-25097	377	27	merits	merit	VERB
inlawrev-25097	377	28	determinations	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	29	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	377	30	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	377	31	unreviewability	unreviewability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	32	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	377	33	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	377	34	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	377	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	377	36	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	37	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	377	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	377	39	timebar	timebar	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	40	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-25097	377	41	nothing	nothing	PRON
inlawrev-25097	377	42	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	377	43	do	do	VERB
inlawrev-25097	377	44	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	377	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	377	46	patentability	patentability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	47	merits	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	48	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	377	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	377	50	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	51	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	377	52	discretion	discretion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	53	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	377	54	to	to	AUX
inlawrev-25097	377	55	institute.159	institute.159	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	377	56	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	377	57	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	377	58	hughes	hughes	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	377	59	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	377	60	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	61	judge	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	62	hughes	hughes	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	377	63	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	377	64	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	65	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	377	66	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-25097	377	67	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	377	68	judges	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	377	69	lourie	lourie	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	377	70	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	377	71	bryson	bryson	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	377	72	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	377	73	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	377	74	dyk	dyk	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	377	75	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	2	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	3	focused	focus	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	4	largely	largely	ADV
inlawrev-25097	378	5	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	7	plain	plain	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	8	language	language	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	10	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	11	314(d	314(d	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	13	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	378	14	explicitly	explicitly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	378	15	states	state	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	17	unreviewability	unreviewability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	20	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	21	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	22	institution	institution	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	23	decision.160	decision.160	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	24	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	27	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	28	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	31	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	32	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	33	heavily	heavily	ADV
inlawrev-25097	378	34	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	36	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	37	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	38	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	39	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	40	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	41	cuozzo.161	cuozzo.161	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	42	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-25097	378	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	45	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	46	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	47	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-25097	378	48	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	49	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	51	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	52	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	53	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	54	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	55	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	56	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-25097	378	57	were	be	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	58	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	59	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	60	convincing	convincing	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	61	indications	indication	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	62	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	63	overcome	overcome	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	64	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	65	presumption	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	66	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	67	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	68	reviewability	reviewability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	69	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	70	respect	respect	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	71	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	72	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	73	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	74	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	75	institution	institution	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	76	decisions.162	decisions.162	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	77	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	78	dissent	dissent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	79	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	378	80	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	81	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	82	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	83	petitions	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	84	timeliness	timeliness	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	85	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	86	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	87	315(b	315(b	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	88	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	89	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	378	90	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	91	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	92	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	93	board	board	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	94	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	95	institution	institution	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	96	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	97	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	98	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-25097	378	99	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	100	therefore	therefore	ADV
inlawrev-25097	378	101	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	102	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	378	103	barred	bar	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	104	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	105	judicial	judicial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	106	review.163	review.163	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	107	e.	e.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	108	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	109	o’malley	o’malley	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	110	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	111	concurrence	concurrence	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	112	judge	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	113	o’malley	o’malley	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	114	concurred	concur	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	115	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	116	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	117	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	118	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	119	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	120	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	121	separately	separately	ADV
inlawrev-25097	378	122	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	123	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	124	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	125	point	point	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	126	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	127	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	378	128	believed	believe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	129	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	130	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	131	before	before	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	132	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	133	en	en	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	134	banc	banc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	135	panel	panel	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	136	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	378	137	simpler	simple	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	138	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	139	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	140	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	141	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	142	implies	imply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	143	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	144	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	145	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	146	turns	turn	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	147	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	148	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	149	distinction	distinction	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	150	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	151	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	152	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	153	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	154	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	155	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	156	exercise	exercise	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	157	discretion	discretion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	158	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	159	reviewing	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	160	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	161	adequacy	adequacy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	162	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	163	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	164	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	165	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	166	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	167	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	168	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	169	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	170	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	171	proceeding	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	172	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	173	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	174	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	175	undertake	undertake	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	176	such	such	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	177	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	178	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	179	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	180	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	181	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	182	instance.164	instance.164	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	183	judge	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	184	o’malley	o’malley	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	185	stated	state	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	186	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	187	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	188	315(b	315(b	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	189	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	190	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	191	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	378	192	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	193	contemplate	contemplate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	194	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	195	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	196	uspto	uspto	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	197	render	render	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	198	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	199	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	200	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	201	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	202	patentability	patentability	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	203	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	204	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	378	205	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-25097	378	206	places	place	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	207	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	208	limit	limit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	209	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	210	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	211	uspto	uspto	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	212	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	213	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	214	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	215	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	216	[	[	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	217	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	218	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	219	reviews	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	220	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	221	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	378	222	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	378	223	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	224	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	225	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	226	comparison	comparison	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	227	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	228	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-25097	378	229	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	230	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	231	dates	date	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	232	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	233	”165	”165	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	234	finally	finally	ADV
inlawrev-25097	378	235	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	236	judge	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	237	o’malley	o’malley	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	238	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	239	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	240	point	point	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	241	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	242	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	243	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	244	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	245	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	246	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	247	uspto	uspto	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	248	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	249	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	250	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	378	251	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	252	partes	partes	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	253	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	254	]	]	X
inlawrev-25097	378	255	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	256	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	378	257	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	258	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	259	barred	bar	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	260	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	261	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	262	315(b	315(b	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	378	263	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	264	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	378	265	entirely	entirely	ADV
inlawrev-25097	378	266	unrelated	unrelated	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	267	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	268	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	378	269	agency	agency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	270	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	271	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	272	core	core	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	273	statutory	statutory	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	378	274	function	function	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	275	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	378	276	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	378	277	determining	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	378	278	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	279	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	378	280	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	378	281	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	378	282	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	378	283	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	378	284	158	158	NUM
inlawrev-25097	378	285	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	379	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	379	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	379	3	159	159	NUM
inlawrev-25097	379	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	380	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	380	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	380	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	380	4	1373	1373	NUM
inlawrev-25097	380	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	380	6	74	74	NUM
inlawrev-25097	380	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	381	1	160	160	NUM
inlawrev-25097	381	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	382	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	382	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	382	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	382	4	1378	1378	NUM
inlawrev-25097	382	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	383	1	161	161	NUM
inlawrev-25097	383	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	384	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	384	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	384	3	162	162	NUM
inlawrev-25097	384	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	385	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	385	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	385	3	163	163	NUM
inlawrev-25097	385	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	386	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	386	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	386	3	164	164	NUM
inlawrev-25097	386	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	387	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	387	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	387	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	387	4	1375	1375	NUM
inlawrev-25097	387	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	388	1	165	165	NUM
inlawrev-25097	388	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	389	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	389	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	389	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	389	4	1377	1377	NUM
inlawrev-25097	389	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	390	1	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	390	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	390	3	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	390	4	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	390	5	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	390	6	787	787	NUM
inlawrev-25097	390	7	patentable	patentable	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	390	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	391	1	”166	”166	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	392	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	392	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	392	3	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	392	4	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	392	5	underlying	underlie	VERB
inlawrev-25097	392	6	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	392	7	eligible	eligible	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	392	8	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	392	9	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	392	10	inquiries	inquiry	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	392	11	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	392	12	berkheimer	berkheimer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	392	13	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	392	14	hp	hp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	392	15	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	392	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	393	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	393	2	february	february	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	393	3	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	393	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	393	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	393	6	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	393	7	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	393	8	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	393	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	393	10	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	393	11	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	393	12	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	393	13	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	393	14	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	393	15	invalidating	invalidate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	393	16	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	393	17	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	393	18	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	393	19	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	393	20	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	393	21	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	393	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	393	23	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-25097	393	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	393	25	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	393	26	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	393	27	eligibility	eligibility	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	393	28	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	393	29	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	393	30	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	393	31	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	393	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	394	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	394	2	101.167	101.167	NUM
inlawrev-25097	394	3	a.	a.	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	394	4	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	394	5	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	394	6	eligibility	eligibility	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	394	7	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	394	8	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	394	9	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	394	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	395	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	395	2	101	101	NUM
inlawrev-25097	395	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	395	4	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
inlawrev-25097	395	5	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	395	6	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	395	8	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	395	10	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	395	11	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-25097	395	12	contain	contain	VERB
inlawrev-25097	395	13	underlying	underlying	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	395	14	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	395	16	fact.168	fact.168	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	395	18	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	395	19	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	395	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	395	22	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	395	23	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	24	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	395	25	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-25097	395	26	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	27	regarding	regard	VERB
inlawrev-25097	395	28	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	395	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	395	30	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	31	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	32	appropriately	appropriately	ADV
inlawrev-25097	395	33	awarded	award	VERB
inlawrev-25097	395	34	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	35	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	395	37	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	38	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	395	39	all	all	DET
inlawrev-25097	395	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	395	41	challenged	challenge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	395	42	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	43	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	395	44	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	395	45	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	395	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	396	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	396	2	101.169	101.169	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	396	3	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	396	4	procedural	procedural	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	396	5	history	history	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	396	6	steven	steven	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	396	7	e.	e.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	396	8	berkheimer	berkheimer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	396	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	396	10	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	396	11	berkheimer	berkheimer	X
inlawrev-25097	396	12	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	396	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	396	14	owns	own	VERB
inlawrev-25097	396	15	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	396	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	396	17	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	396	18	no	no	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	396	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	397	1	7,447,713	7,447,713	NUM
inlawrev-25097	397	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	397	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	397	4	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	397	5	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	397	6	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	397	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	397	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	397	9	suit	suit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	397	10	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	397	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	397	12	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	397	13	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	397	14	relates	relate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	397	15	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	397	16	digitally	digitally	ADV
inlawrev-25097	397	17	processing	process	VERB
inlawrev-25097	397	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	397	19	archiving	archive	VERB
inlawrev-25097	397	20	files	file	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	397	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	397	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	397	23	digital	digital	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	397	24	asset	asset	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	397	25	management	management	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	397	26	system	system	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	397	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	397	28	”170	”170	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	1	berkheimer	berkheimer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	2	sued	sue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	3	hp	hp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	5	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	9	hp	hp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	10	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	14	northern	northern	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	398	15	district	district	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	17	illinois	illinois	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	19	alleging	allege	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	20	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	22	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	23	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	398	24	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	398	25	7	7	NUM
inlawrev-25097	398	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	398	27	9	9	NUM
inlawrev-25097	398	28	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	398	29	19	19	NUM
inlawrev-25097	398	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	32	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	33	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	34	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	35	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	36	suit.171	suit.171	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	37	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	39	markman	markman	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	40	hearing	hearing	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	43	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	44	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	45	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	46	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	398	47	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	398	48	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	49	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	51	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	52	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	53	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	54	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	55	suit	suit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	56	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	398	57	directed	direct	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	58	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	59	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	60	ineligible	ineligible	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	398	61	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	62	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	63	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	398	64	granted	grant	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	65	hp	hp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	66	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	398	67	motion	motion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	68	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	69	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	70	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	71	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	72	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	73	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	74	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	75	101	101	NUM
inlawrev-25097	398	76	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	77	berkheimer	berkheimer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	78	appealed.172	appealed.172	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	79	c.	c.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	80	federal	federal	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	81	circuit	circuit	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	82	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	398	83	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	84	opinion	opinion	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	85	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	86	moore	moore	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	87	authored	author	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	88	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	89	unanimous	unanimous	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	398	90	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	91	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	92	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	93	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	398	94	circuit.173	circuit.173	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	95	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	96	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	398	97	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	98	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	99	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	100	101	101	NUM
inlawrev-25097	398	101	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	102	eligibility	eligibility	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	103	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	104	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	105	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-25097	398	106	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	107	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	108	alice	alice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	109	framework.174	framework.174	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	110	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	111	alice	alice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	112	step	step	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	398	113	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	398	114	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	115	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	116	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	398	117	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	118	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	119	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	398	120	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	121	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	122	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	398	123	directed	direct	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	124	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	125	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	126	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	127	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	128	ineligible	ineligible	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	398	129	concept.175	concept.175	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	130	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	131	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	398	132	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	133	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	134	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	135	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	398	136	claims	claim	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	137	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	398	138	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	398	139	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-25097	398	140	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	398	141	9	9	NUM
inlawrev-25097	398	142	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	398	143	directed	direct	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	144	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	145	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	146	abstract	abstract	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	398	147	idea	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	148	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	149	parsing	parse	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	150	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	398	151	comparing	compare	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	152	data	datum	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	153	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	154	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	155	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-25097	398	156	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	398	157	directed	direct	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	158	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	159	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	398	160	abstract	abstract	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	398	161	idea	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	162	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	398	163	parsing	parsing	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	164	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	165	comparing	comparing	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	166	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	167	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	398	168	storing	store	VERB
inlawrev-25097	398	169	data	datum	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	398	170	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	398	171	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	398	172	166	166	NUM
inlawrev-25097	398	173	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	399	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	399	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	399	3	167	167	NUM
inlawrev-25097	399	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	400	1	berkheimer	berkheimer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	400	2	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	400	3	hp	hp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	400	4	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	400	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	400	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	401	1	881	881	NUM
inlawrev-25097	401	2	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	401	3	1360	1360	NUM
inlawrev-25097	401	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	401	5	1370	1370	NUM
inlawrev-25097	402	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	402	2	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	402	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	402	4	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	402	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	402	6	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	402	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	402	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	403	1	168	168	NUM
inlawrev-25097	403	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	404	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	404	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	404	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	404	4	1365	1365	NUM
inlawrev-25097	404	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	405	1	169	169	NUM
inlawrev-25097	405	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	406	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	406	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	406	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	406	4	1364	1364	NUM
inlawrev-25097	406	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	406	6	65	65	NUM
inlawrev-25097	406	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	406	8	170	170	NUM
inlawrev-25097	406	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	407	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	407	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	407	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	407	4	1362	1362	NUM
inlawrev-25097	407	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	408	1	171	171	NUM
inlawrev-25097	408	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	409	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	409	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	409	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	409	4	1363	1363	NUM
inlawrev-25097	409	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	410	1	172	172	NUM
inlawrev-25097	410	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	411	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	411	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	411	3	173	173	NUM
inlawrev-25097	411	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	412	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	412	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	412	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	412	4	1362	1362	NUM
inlawrev-25097	412	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	413	1	174	174	NUM
inlawrev-25097	413	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	414	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	414	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	414	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	414	4	1364	1364	NUM
inlawrev-25097	414	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	414	6	1365	1365	NUM
inlawrev-25097	414	7	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	414	8	alice	alice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	414	9	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	414	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	415	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	415	2	cls	cls	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	415	3	bank	bank	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	415	4	int’l	int’l	NUM
inlawrev-25097	415	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	415	6	573	573	NUM
inlawrev-25097	415	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	415	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	415	9	208	208	NUM
inlawrev-25097	415	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	415	11	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-25097	415	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	415	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	416	1	175	175	NUM
inlawrev-25097	416	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	417	1	berkheimer	berkheimer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	417	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	417	3	881	881	NUM
inlawrev-25097	417	4	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	417	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	417	6	1366	1366	NUM
inlawrev-25097	417	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	417	8	67	67	NUM
inlawrev-25097	417	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	418	1	788	788	NUM
inlawrev-25097	418	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	418	3	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	418	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	419	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	419	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	419	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	419	4	52:771	52:771	NUM
inlawrev-25097	419	5	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	419	6	5	5	NUM
inlawrev-25097	419	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	419	8	7	7	NUM
inlawrev-25097	419	9	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	419	10	directed	direct	VERB
inlawrev-25097	419	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	419	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	419	13	abstract	abstract	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	419	14	idea	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	419	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	419	16	parsing	parsing	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	419	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	419	18	comparing	comparing	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	419	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	419	20	storing	storing	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	419	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	419	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	419	23	editing	edit	VERB
inlawrev-25097	419	24	data	datum	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	419	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	420	1	”176	”176	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	420	2	these	these	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	3	abstract	abstract	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	420	4	ideas	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	5	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	420	6	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-25097	420	7	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	420	8	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-25097	420	9	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	11	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	420	12	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	14	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	420	15	cases.177	cases.177	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	16	despite	despite	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	420	17	berkheimer	berkheimer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	420	18	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	420	19	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	20	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	22	contrary	contrary	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	420	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	25	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	420	26	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	27	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	420	28	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	420	29	parsers	parser	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	30	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	420	31	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-25097	420	32	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	420	33	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-25097	420	34	prior	prior	ADV
inlawrev-25097	420	35	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	37	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	38	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	420	39	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	420	40	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-25097	420	41	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	420	42	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	420	43	improve	improve	VERB
inlawrev-25097	420	44	computer	computer	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	45	functionality.178	functionality.178	ADV
inlawrev-25097	420	46	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	47	alice	alice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	420	48	step	step	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	420	49	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-25097	420	50	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	420	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	52	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	420	53	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	54	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-25097	420	55	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	56	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	57	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	58	each	each	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	59	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	60	individually	individually	ADV
inlawrev-25097	420	61	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	420	62	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	63	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	64	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	420	65	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	420	66	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	420	67	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	68	additional	additional	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	420	69	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	70	transform	transform	VERB
inlawrev-25097	420	71	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	72	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	73	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	74	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	75	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	76	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	77	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	78	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	79	eligible	eligible	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	420	80	application.179	application.179	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	81	here	here	ADV
inlawrev-25097	420	82	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	420	83	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	84	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	420	85	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	86	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	420	87	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	88	interesting	interesting	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	420	89	observation	observation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	90	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	420	91	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	92	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	93	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	94	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	420	95	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	96	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	97	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	98	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	420	99	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	100	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	101	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	102	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	420	103	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-25097	420	104	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	420	105	understood	understand	VERB
inlawrev-25097	420	106	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	420	107	routine	routine	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	420	108	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	420	109	conventional	conventional	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	420	110	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	111	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	112	skilled	skilled	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	420	113	artisan	artisan	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	114	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	115	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	116	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	420	117	field	field	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	118	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	420	119	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	420	120	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	121	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	420	122	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	420	123	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	421	1	any	any	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	2	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	421	4	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	5	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	421	6	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	7	one	one	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	421	9	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	421	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	421	11	pertinent	pertinent	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	421	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	14	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	15	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	16	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-25097	421	17	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	421	18	proven	prove	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	19	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	421	20	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	421	22	convincing	convincing	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	23	evidence.180	evidence.180	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	25	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	26	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	27	likened	liken	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	29	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	30	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	421	31	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	32	step	step	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	33	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	421	34	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	421	35	done	do	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	36	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	421	37	indefiniteness	indefiniteness	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	421	39	enablement	enablement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	421	41	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	421	42	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	43	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	421	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	45	overall	overall	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	46	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	47	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	421	48	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-25097	421	49	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	421	50	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	51	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	421	52	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	421	53	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	421	54	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	421	55	contains	contain	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	56	underlying	underlie	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	57	facts.181	facts.181	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	58	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	421	59	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	60	precedential	precedential	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	61	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	62	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	421	63	affirmed	affirm	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	64	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	65	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	66	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	421	67	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	68	ineligibility	ineligibility	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	69	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	421	70	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	71	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	72	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	73	carefully	carefully	ADV
inlawrev-25097	421	74	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	75	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	76	distinction	distinction	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	77	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-25097	421	78	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	79	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	421	80	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	81	no	no	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	82	genuine	genuine	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	83	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	84	disputes	dispute	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	85	underlying	underlie	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	86	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	87	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	88	eligibility	eligibility	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	89	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	90	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	421	91	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-25097	421	92	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	421	93	do.182	do.182	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	94	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	95	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	96	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	97	set	set	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	98	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	99	record	record	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	100	straight	straight	ADV
inlawrev-25097	421	101	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	421	102	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	103	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	104	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	105	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	421	106	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	421	107	acknowledge	acknowledge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	108	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	109	underlying	underlie	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	110	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	111	questions	question	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	112	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	421	113	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	114	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	421	115	101	101	NUM
inlawrev-25097	421	116	inquiry.183	inquiry.183	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	117	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
inlawrev-25097	421	118	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	421	119	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	120	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	121	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	122	concluded	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	123	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	421	124	claims	claim	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	125	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	421	126	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	421	127	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-25097	421	128	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	421	129	9	9	NUM
inlawrev-25097	421	130	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	421	131	ineligible	ineligible	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	132	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	421	133	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-25097	421	134	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	421	135	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	421	136	possess	possess	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	137	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	138	inventive	inventive	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	139	concept.184	concept.184	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	140	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-25097	421	141	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	421	142	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	143	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	144	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	145	vacated	vacate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	146	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	147	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	148	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	149	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	150	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	421	151	claims	claim	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	152	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-25097	421	153	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	421	154	7	7	NUM
inlawrev-25097	421	155	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	421	156	ineligible	ineligible	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	157	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	421	158	remanded	remand	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	159	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	421	160	further	further	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	421	161	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	162	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	163	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	421	164	berkheimer	berkheimer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	421	165	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	421	166	meaningfully	meaningfully	ADV
inlawrev-25097	421	167	argued	argue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	168	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	421	169	those	those	DET
inlawrev-25097	421	170	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	171	contained	contain	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	172	limitations	limitation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	421	173	directed	direct	VERB
inlawrev-25097	421	174	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	421	175	176	176	NUM
inlawrev-25097	421	176	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	422	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	422	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	422	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	422	4	1366	1366	NUM
inlawrev-25097	422	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	423	1	177	177	NUM
inlawrev-25097	423	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	424	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-25097	424	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	424	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-25097	424	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	424	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	424	6	re	re	PRON
inlawrev-25097	424	7	tli	tli	X
inlawrev-25097	424	8	commc’ns	commc’ns	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	424	9	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	424	10	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	424	11	litig	litig	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	424	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	425	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	425	2	823	823	NUM
inlawrev-25097	425	3	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	425	4	607	607	NUM
inlawrev-25097	425	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	425	6	613	613	NUM
inlawrev-25097	425	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	425	8	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	425	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	425	10	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	425	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	426	1	2016	2016	NUM
inlawrev-25097	426	2	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	426	3	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	426	4	content	content	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	426	5	extraction	extraction	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	426	6	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	426	7	transmission	transmission	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	426	8	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	426	9	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	426	10	wells	wells	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	426	11	fargo	fargo	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	426	12	bank	bank	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	426	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	426	14	nat’l	nat’l	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	426	15	ass’n	ass’n	NUM
inlawrev-25097	426	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	426	17	776	776	NUM
inlawrev-25097	426	18	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	426	19	1343	1343	NUM
inlawrev-25097	426	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	426	21	1347	1347	NUM
inlawrev-25097	426	22	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	426	23	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	426	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	426	25	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	426	26	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	426	27	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-25097	426	28	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	426	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	427	1	178	178	NUM
inlawrev-25097	427	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	428	1	berkheimer	berkheim	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	428	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	428	3	881	881	NUM
inlawrev-25097	428	4	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	428	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	428	6	1367	1367	NUM
inlawrev-25097	428	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	429	1	179	179	NUM
inlawrev-25097	429	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	430	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	430	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	430	3	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	430	4	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-25097	430	5	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	430	6	alice	alice	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	430	7	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	430	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	430	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	430	10	573	573	NUM
inlawrev-25097	430	11	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	430	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	430	13	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	430	14	217	217	NUM
inlawrev-25097	430	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	431	1	180	180	NUM
inlawrev-25097	431	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	432	1	berkheimer	berkheimer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	432	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	432	3	881	881	NUM
inlawrev-25097	432	4	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	432	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	432	6	1368	1368	NUM
inlawrev-25097	432	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	433	1	181	181	NUM
inlawrev-25097	433	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	434	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	434	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	434	3	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	434	4	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-25097	434	5	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	434	6	apple	apple	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	434	7	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	434	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	435	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	435	2	samsung	samsung	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	435	3	elecs	elecs	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	435	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	1	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	436	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	3	839	839	NUM
inlawrev-25097	436	4	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	436	5	1034	1034	NUM
inlawrev-25097	436	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	7	1047	1047	NUM
inlawrev-25097	436	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	9	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	436	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	11	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	436	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	436	13	2016	2016	NUM
inlawrev-25097	436	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	16	en	en	X
inlawrev-25097	436	17	banc	banc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	436	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	19	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	20	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	21	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	436	22	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	436	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	436	24	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	436	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	436	26	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	436	27	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-25097	436	28	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	436	29	underlying	underlying	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	436	30	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	436	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	34	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	35	akzo	akzo	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	436	36	nobel	nobel	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	436	37	coatings	coatings	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	436	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	436	39	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	436	40	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	436	41	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	436	42	dow	dow	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	436	43	chem	chem	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	436	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	1	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	437	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	3	811	811	NUM
inlawrev-25097	437	4	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	437	5	1334	1334	NUM
inlawrev-25097	437	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	7	1343	1343	NUM
inlawrev-25097	437	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	9	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	437	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	11	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	437	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	437	13	2016	2016	NUM
inlawrev-25097	437	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	16	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	17	indefiniteness	indefiniteness	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	437	18	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	437	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	437	20	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	437	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	437	22	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	437	23	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	437	24	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-25097	437	25	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	437	26	de	de	ADV
inlawrev-25097	437	27	novo	novo	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	437	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	29	[	[	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	30	]	]	X
inlawrev-25097	437	31	subject	subject	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	437	32	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	437	33	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	437	34	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	437	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	437	36	underlying	underlie	VERB
inlawrev-25097	437	37	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	437	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	39	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	40	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	41	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	437	42	alcon	alcon	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	437	43	research	research	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	437	44	ltd	ltd	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	437	45	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	438	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	438	2	barr	barr	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	438	3	labs	labs	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	438	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	438	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	438	6	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	438	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	438	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	438	9	745	745	NUM
inlawrev-25097	438	10	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	438	11	1180	1180	NUM
inlawrev-25097	438	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	438	13	1188	1188	NUM
inlawrev-25097	438	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	438	15	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	438	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	438	17	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	438	18	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	438	19	2014	2014	NUM
inlawrev-25097	438	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	439	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	439	2	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	439	3	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	439	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	439	5	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	439	6	satisfies	satisfy	VERB
inlawrev-25097	439	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	439	8	enablement	enablement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	439	9	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	439	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	439	11	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	439	12	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	439	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	440	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	440	2	112	112	NUM
inlawrev-25097	440	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	440	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	440	5	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	440	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	440	7	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	440	8	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	440	9	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-25097	440	10	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	440	11	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-25097	440	12	deference	deference	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	440	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	440	14	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	440	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	440	16	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	440	17	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-25097	440	18	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	440	19	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-25097	440	20	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	440	21	underlying	underlie	VERB
inlawrev-25097	440	22	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	440	23	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	440	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	440	25	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	440	26	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-25097	440	27	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	440	28	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	440	29	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	440	30	error	error	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	440	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	440	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	440	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	440	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	441	1	182	182	NUM
inlawrev-25097	441	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	442	1	berkheimer	berkheimer	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	442	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	442	3	881	881	NUM
inlawrev-25097	442	4	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	442	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	442	6	1368	1368	NUM
inlawrev-25097	442	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	443	1	183	183	NUM
inlawrev-25097	443	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	444	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	444	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	444	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	444	4	1369	1369	NUM
inlawrev-25097	444	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	445	1	184	184	NUM
inlawrev-25097	445	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	446	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	446	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	446	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	446	4	1370	1370	NUM
inlawrev-25097	446	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	447	1	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	447	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	447	3	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	4	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	5	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	6	789	789	NUM
inlawrev-25097	447	7	unconventional	unconventional	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	8	inventive	inventive	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	9	concepts	concept	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	10	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	447	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	447	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	447	13	specification.185	specification.185	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	14	vi	vi	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	447	16	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	17	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	447	19	inter	inter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	20	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	21	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	22	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	447	23	saint	saint	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	24	regis	regis	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	25	mohawk	mohawk	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	26	tribe	tribe	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	27	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	28	mylan	mylan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	29	pharmaceuticals	pharmaceuticals	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	30	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	31	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	32	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	447	33	july	july	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	34	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	447	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	447	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	447	37	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	38	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	39	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	447	40	saint	saint	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	41	regis	regis	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	42	mohawk	mohawk	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	43	tribe	tribe	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	44	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	45	mylan	mylan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	46	pharmaceuticals	pharmaceuticals	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	47	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	48	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	49	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	447	50	answered	answer	VERB
inlawrev-25097	447	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	447	52	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	447	54	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	447	55	tribal	tribal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	56	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	57	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	58	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-25097	447	59	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	447	60	asserted	assert	VERB
inlawrev-25097	447	61	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	447	62	terminate	terminate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	447	63	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	64	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	65	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	66	proceedings.186	proceedings.186	VERB
inlawrev-25097	447	67	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	447	68	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	69	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	70	affirmed	affirm	VERB
inlawrev-25097	447	71	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	447	72	board	board	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	73	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	447	74	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	75	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	447	76	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	447	77	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	447	78	tribal	tribal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	79	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	80	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	81	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-25097	447	82	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	447	83	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	447	84	asserted	assert	VERB
inlawrev-25097	447	85	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	447	86	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	447	87	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	88	reviews.187	reviews.187	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	89	a.	a.	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	90	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	91	derived	derive	VERB
inlawrev-25097	447	92	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	447	93	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	94	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	95	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	447	96	indian	indian	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	97	tribes	tribe	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	98	possess	possess	VERB
inlawrev-25097	447	99	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	447	100	inherent	inherent	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	101	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	102	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	103	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	447	104	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	447	105	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-25097	447	106	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	447	107	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	447	108	sued	sue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	447	109	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	447	110	absent	absent	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	111	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	447	112	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	113	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	114	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	447	115	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	447	116	tribe	tribe	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	117	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	447	118	congressional	congressional	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	447	119	abrogation	abrogation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	447	120	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	448	1	”188	”188	VERB
inlawrev-25097	448	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-25097	448	3	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	448	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	448	5	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-25097	448	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	448	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	448	8	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	448	9	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	448	10	extend	extend	VERB
inlawrev-25097	448	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	448	12	actions	action	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	448	13	brought	bring	VERB
inlawrev-25097	448	14	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	448	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	448	16	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	448	17	government	government	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	448	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	448	19	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	448	20	nor	nor	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	448	21	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	448	22	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	448	23	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-25097	448	24	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	448	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	448	26	investigations	investigation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	448	27	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	448	28	adjudications	adjudication	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	448	29	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	448	30	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	448	31	administrative	administrative	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	448	32	agency.189	agency.189	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	448	33	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
inlawrev-25097	448	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	448	35	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-25097	448	36	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-25097	448	37	no	no	DET
inlawrev-25097	448	38	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	448	39	blanket	blanket	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	448	40	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	448	41	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	448	42	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	448	43	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	448	44	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	448	45	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	448	46	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	448	47	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	448	48	agency	agency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	448	49	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	448	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	1	”190	”190	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	2	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	3	procedural	procedural	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	4	history	history	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	5	allergan	allergan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	7	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	10	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	11	allergan	allergan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	12	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	449	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	449	16	pharmaceutical	pharmaceutical	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	449	17	company	company	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	18	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	449	19	owns	own	VERB
inlawrev-25097	449	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	449	21	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	449	24	name	name	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	25	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	26	brand	brand	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	27	dry	dry	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	449	28	eye	eye	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	29	medication	medication	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	30	called	call	VERB
inlawrev-25097	449	31	restasis.191	restasis.191	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	32	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	33	2015	2015	NUM
inlawrev-25097	449	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	35	allergan	allergan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	36	sued	sue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	449	37	mylan	mylan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	38	pharmaceuticals	pharmaceuticals	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	39	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	40	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	41	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	42	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	43	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	44	mylan	mylan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	45	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	47	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	48	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	449	49	generic	generic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	449	50	drug	drug	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	51	manufacturer	manufacturer	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	53	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	54	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	55	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	56	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	57	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	449	58	restasis	restasis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	59	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	60	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-25097	449	61	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	62	mylan	mylan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	63	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	449	64	filing	filing	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	65	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	66	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	449	67	abbreviated	abbreviate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	449	68	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	449	69	drug	drug	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	70	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	71	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	72	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	73	anda	anda	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	74	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	75	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	76	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	77	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	449	78	generic	generic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	449	79	dry	dry	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	449	80	eye	eye	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	81	treatment.192	treatment.192	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	82	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	83	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	84	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	85	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	86	june	june	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	87	2016	2016	NUM
inlawrev-25097	449	88	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	89	mylan	mylan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	90	petitioned	petition	VERB
inlawrev-25097	449	91	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	92	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	449	93	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	94	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	95	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	96	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	449	97	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	98	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	449	99	restasis	restasis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	100	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	101	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	102	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	103	teva	teva	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	104	pharmaceuticals	pharmaceuticals	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	105	usa	usa	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	106	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	107	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	108	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	109	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	449	110	akorn	akorn	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	111	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	112	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	113	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	114	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	115	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-25097	449	116	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	449	117	generic	generic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	449	118	drug	drug	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	119	manufacturers	manufacturer	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	120	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	121	joining.193	joining.193	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	122	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	449	123	board	board	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	124	instituted	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	449	125	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	449	126	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	127	review.194	review.194	VERB
inlawrev-25097	449	128	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	449	129	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	449	130	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	131	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	132	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	133	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	449	134	pending	pende	VERB
inlawrev-25097	449	135	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	136	allergan	allergan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	137	transferred	transfer	VERB
inlawrev-25097	449	138	title	title	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	139	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	140	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	449	141	restasis	restasis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	142	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	143	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	144	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	449	145	saint	saint	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	146	regis	regis	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	147	mohawk	mohawk	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	449	148	tribe	tribe	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	149	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	150	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	151	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	449	152	tribe	tribe	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	449	153	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	154	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	449	155	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-25097	449	156	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	449	157	185	185	NUM
inlawrev-25097	449	158	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	450	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	450	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	450	3	186	186	NUM
inlawrev-25097	450	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	450	5	896	896	NUM
inlawrev-25097	450	6	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	450	7	1322	1322	NUM
inlawrev-25097	450	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	450	9	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	450	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	450	11	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	450	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	450	13	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	450	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	450	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	450	16	cert	cert	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	450	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	451	1	denied	deny	VERB
inlawrev-25097	451	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	451	3	139	139	NUM
inlawrev-25097	451	4	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	451	5	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	451	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	451	7	1547	1547	NUM
inlawrev-25097	451	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	451	9	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	451	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	451	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	452	1	187	187	NUM
inlawrev-25097	452	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	453	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	453	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	453	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	453	4	1326	1326	NUM
inlawrev-25097	453	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	454	1	188	188	NUM
inlawrev-25097	454	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	455	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	455	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	455	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	455	4	1325	1325	NUM
inlawrev-25097	455	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	455	6	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	455	7	okla	okla	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	455	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	456	1	tax	tax	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	456	2	comm’n	comm’n	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	456	3	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	456	4	citizen	citizen	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	456	5	band	band	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	456	6	potawatomi	potawatomi	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	456	7	indian	indian	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	456	8	tribe	tribe	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	456	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	456	10	okla	okla	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	456	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	457	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	457	2	498	498	NUM
inlawrev-25097	457	3	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	457	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	457	5	505	505	NUM
inlawrev-25097	457	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	457	7	509	509	NUM
inlawrev-25097	457	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	457	9	1991	1991	NUM
inlawrev-25097	457	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	457	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	457	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	458	1	189	189	NUM
inlawrev-25097	458	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	459	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	459	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	459	3	190	190	NUM
inlawrev-25097	459	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	460	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	460	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	460	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	460	4	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-25097	460	5	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	460	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	461	1	mar	mar	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	461	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	461	3	comm’n	comm’n	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	462	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	462	2	s.c	s.c	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	462	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	462	4	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	462	5	ports	port	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	462	6	auth	auth	ADV
inlawrev-25097	462	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	463	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	463	2	fmc	fmc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	463	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	463	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	463	5	535	535	NUM
inlawrev-25097	463	6	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	463	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	463	8	743	743	NUM
inlawrev-25097	463	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	463	10	754	754	NUM
inlawrev-25097	463	11	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	463	12	56	56	NUM
inlawrev-25097	463	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	463	14	2002	2002	NUM
inlawrev-25097	463	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	463	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	463	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	464	1	191	191	X
inlawrev-25097	464	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	465	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	465	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	465	3	192	192	NUM
inlawrev-25097	465	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	466	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	466	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	466	3	193	193	NUM
inlawrev-25097	466	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	467	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	467	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	467	3	194	194	NUM
inlawrev-25097	467	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	468	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	468	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	468	3	790	790	NUM
inlawrev-25097	468	4	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	468	5	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	468	6	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	7	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	468	8	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	468	10	52:771	52:771	NUM
inlawrev-25097	468	11	recorded	record	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	12	assignment	assignment	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	13	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	468	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	15	uspto.195	uspto.195	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	17	tribe	tribe	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	18	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-25097	468	19	moved	move	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	468	21	terminate	terminate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	23	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	468	24	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	25	reviews	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	468	27	asserting	assert	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	28	tribal	tribal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	468	29	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	468	30	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	468	32	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	468	33	allergan	allergan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	468	34	moved	move	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	35	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	468	36	withdraw.196	withdraw.196	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	38	board	board	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	39	denied	deny	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	40	both	both	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	41	motions	motion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	468	43	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	468	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	45	tribe	tribe	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	46	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	468	47	allergan	allergan	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	468	48	appealed.197	appealed.197	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	468	49	c.	c.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	468	50	federal	federal	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	468	51	circuit	circuit	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	468	52	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	468	53	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	54	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	55	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	56	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	468	57	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	58	began	begin	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	59	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	468	60	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	61	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	468	62	evaluating	evaluate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	64	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	468	65	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	468	66	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	468	67	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	68	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	468	69	fmc,198	fmc,198	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	468	70	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	468	71	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	72	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	73	assessed	assess	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	74	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	468	75	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	76	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	468	77	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	78	barred	bar	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	79	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	80	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	468	81	maritime	maritime	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	468	82	commission	commission	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	83	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	468	84	adjudicating	adjudicate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	85	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	86	private	private	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	468	87	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	88	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	468	89	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	90	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-25097	468	91	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	92	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	93	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	468	94	run	run	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	95	port.199	port.199	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	96	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	97	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	98	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	99	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	468	100	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	101	determinative	determinative	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	468	102	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	103	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	468	104	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	468	105	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	468	106	commission	commission	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	107	adjudications	adjudication	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	108	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	468	109	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	468	110	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	111	type	type	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	112	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	468	113	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	114	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	468	115	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	468	116	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	117	framers	framer	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	118	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-25097	468	119	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	468	120	thought	think	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	121	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	122	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	123	possessed	possess	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	124	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	125	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	468	126	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-25097	468	127	agreed	agree	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	128	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	468	129	enter	enter	VERB
inlawrev-25097	468	130	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	468	131	union	union	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	468	132	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	469	1	’”200	’”200	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	469	2	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	469	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	469	4	commissioner	commissioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	5	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	469	6	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	7	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	469	8	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	469	9	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	469	10	overhelming[ly	overhelming[ly	X
inlawrev-25097	469	11	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	469	12	’	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	469	13	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	469	14	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	469	15	]	]	X
inlawrev-25097	469	16	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	469	17	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	469	18	civil	civil	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	469	19	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	20	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	469	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	469	23	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	24	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	469	25	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	469	26	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	27	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	469	28	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	29	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	469	30	shield	shield	VERB
inlawrev-25097	469	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	469	32	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	33	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	469	34	adjudicatory	adjudicatory	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	469	35	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	36	brought	bring	VERB
inlawrev-25097	469	37	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	469	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	469	39	private	private	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	469	40	party.201	party.201	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	41	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-25097	469	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	469	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	469	44	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	45	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-25097	469	46	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-25097	469	47	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	469	48	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-25097	469	49	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-25097	469	50	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	469	51	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	469	52	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	469	53	distinction	distinction	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	54	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-25097	469	55	adjudicative	adjudicative	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	469	56	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	57	brought	bring	VERB
inlawrev-25097	469	58	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-25097	469	59	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	469	60	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	61	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	469	62	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	469	63	private	private	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	469	64	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	65	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	469	66	agency	agency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	67	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	469	68	initiated	initiate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	469	69	enforcement	enforcement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	70	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	469	71	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	470	1	”202	”202	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	2	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-25097	470	3	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	470	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	5	tribe	tribe	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	470	7	tribal	tribal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	470	8	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	470	9	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	10	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	470	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	470	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	13	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	470	14	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	15	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	470	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	470	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	18	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	470	19	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	21	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	470	22	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	23	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	470	24	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	470	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	26	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	470	28	fmc	fmc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	470	29	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	470	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	31	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	470	32	private	private	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	470	33	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	34	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	470	35	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	470	36	i.e.	i.e.	X
inlawrev-25097	470	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	38	generic	generic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	470	39	drug	drug	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	40	manufacturers	manufacturer	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	41	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	470	42	initiated	initiate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	470	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	44	proceeding.203	proceeding.203	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	46	appellees	appellee	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	47	countered	counter	VERB
inlawrev-25097	470	48	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	470	49	arguing	argue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	470	50	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	470	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	52	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	470	53	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	54	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	55	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	470	56	brought	bring	VERB
inlawrev-25097	470	57	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	470	58	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	59	agency	agency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	60	action	action	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	61	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	470	62	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	470	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	64	tribe	tribe	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	65	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-25097	470	66	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	470	67	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-25097	470	68	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	470	69	assert	assert	VERB
inlawrev-25097	470	70	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	71	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	470	72	defend	defend	VERB
inlawrev-25097	470	73	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	74	sham	sham	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	470	75	assignment.204	assignment.204	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	470	76	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
inlawrev-25097	470	77	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	470	78	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	79	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	470	80	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	81	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	470	82	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	470	83	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	470	84	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	470	85	a]lthough	a]lthough	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	470	86	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	470	87	precise	precise	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	470	88	contours	contours	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	89	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	470	90	tribal	tribal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	470	91	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	470	92	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	93	differ	differ	VERB
inlawrev-25097	470	94	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	470	95	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-25097	470	96	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	470	97	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	98	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	470	99	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	470	100	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	470	101	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	470	102	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	471	1	tribal	tribal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	471	2	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	471	3	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	471	4	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-25097	471	5	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	471	6	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	471	7	asserted	assert	VERB
inlawrev-25097	471	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	471	9	[	[	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	471	10	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	471	11	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	471	12	reviews].”205	reviews].”205	X
inlawrev-25097	471	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	471	14	coming	come	VERB
inlawrev-25097	471	15	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	471	16	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	471	17	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	471	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	471	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	471	20	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	471	21	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	471	22	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	471	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	471	24	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	471	25	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	471	26	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	471	27	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	471	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	471	29	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	471	30	hybrid	hybrid	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	471	31	proceeding	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	471	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	471	33	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	471	34	characteristics	characteristic	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	471	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	471	36	both	both	DET
inlawrev-25097	471	37	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	471	38	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	471	39	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	471	40	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	471	41	specialized	specialized	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	471	42	agency	agency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	471	43	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	471	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	472	1	”206	”206	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	472	2	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-25097	472	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	472	4	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-25097	472	5	were	be	VERB
inlawrev-25097	472	6	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	472	7	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	472	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	472	9	195	195	X
inlawrev-25097	472	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	473	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	473	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	473	3	196	196	NUM
inlawrev-25097	473	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	474	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	474	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	474	3	197	197	NUM
inlawrev-25097	474	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	475	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	475	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	475	3	198	198	NUM
inlawrev-25097	475	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	476	1	fmc	fmc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	476	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	476	3	535	535	NUM
inlawrev-25097	476	4	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	476	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	476	6	743	743	NUM
inlawrev-25097	476	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	476	8	2002	2002	NUM
inlawrev-25097	476	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	476	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	477	1	199	199	NUM
inlawrev-25097	477	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	477	3	saint	saint	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	477	4	regis	regis	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	477	5	mohawk	mohawk	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	477	6	tribe	tribe	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	477	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	477	8	896	896	NUM
inlawrev-25097	477	9	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	477	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	477	11	1326	1326	NUM
inlawrev-25097	477	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	478	1	200	200	NUM
inlawrev-25097	478	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	479	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	479	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	479	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	479	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	479	5	fmc	fmc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	479	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	479	7	535	535	NUM
inlawrev-25097	479	8	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	479	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	479	10	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	479	11	756	756	NUM
inlawrev-25097	479	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	479	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	480	1	201	201	NUM
inlawrev-25097	480	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	481	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	481	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	481	3	202	202	NUM
inlawrev-25097	481	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	482	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	482	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	482	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	482	4	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	482	5	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-25097	482	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	482	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	483	1	203	203	NUM
inlawrev-25097	483	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	484	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	484	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	484	3	204	204	NUM
inlawrev-25097	484	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	485	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	485	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	485	3	205	205	NUM
inlawrev-25097	485	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	486	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	486	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	486	3	206	206	NUM
inlawrev-25097	486	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	487	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	487	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	487	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	487	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	487	5	cuozzo	cuozzo	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	487	6	speed	speed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	487	7	techs	tech	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	487	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	487	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	487	10	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	487	11	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	487	12	lee	lee	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	487	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	487	14	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	487	15	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	487	16	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	487	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	487	18	2131	2131	NUM
inlawrev-25097	487	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	487	20	2143	2143	NUM
inlawrev-25097	487	21	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	487	22	44	44	NUM
inlawrev-25097	487	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	487	24	2016	2016	NUM
inlawrev-25097	487	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	487	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	487	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	488	1	compare	compare	VERB
inlawrev-25097	488	2	oil	oil	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	488	3	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	488	4	energy	energy	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	488	5	servs	servs	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	488	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	489	2	greene	greene	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	3	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	489	4	energy	energy	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	5	grp	grp	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	8	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	10	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	489	11	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	12	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	14	1365	1365	NUM
inlawrev-25097	489	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	16	1373	1373	NUM
inlawrev-25097	489	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	18	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	489	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	21	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	22	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	24	goal	goal	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	489	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	27	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	28	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	29	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	30	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	489	31	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	489	32	protect	protect	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	34	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	35	interest	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	36	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	37	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	38	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	39	inter	inter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	40	2019	2019	NUM
inlawrev-25097	489	41	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	42	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	43	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	44	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	45	791	791	NUM
inlawrev-25097	489	46	persuaded	persuade	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	48	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	49	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	489	50	conclude	conclude	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	51	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	52	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	53	[	[	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	54	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	55	partes	partes	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	56	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	57	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	58	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	489	59	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-25097	489	60	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-25097	489	61	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	62	agency	agency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	63	enforcement	enforcement	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	64	action	action	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	65	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-25097	489	66	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	67	civil	civil	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	68	suit	suit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	69	brought	bring	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	70	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	489	71	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	72	private	private	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	73	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	74	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	75	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	76	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-25097	489	77	avoiding	avoid	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	78	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	79	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	80	implication	implication	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	81	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	489	82	tribal	tribal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	83	immunity.207	immunity.207	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	84	first	first	ADV
inlawrev-25097	489	85	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	86	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	87	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	88	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	89	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	90	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	91	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	92	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	93	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	94	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	489	95	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	96	constrained	constrain	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	97	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	98	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-25097	489	99	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	100	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	489	101	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-25097	489	102	conduct	conduct	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	103	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	104	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	105	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	106	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	107	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-25097	489	108	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	109	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	110	broad	broad	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	111	discretion	discretion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	112	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	113	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-25097	489	114	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	115	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	489	116	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-25097	489	117	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	118	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	119	partes	partes	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	120	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	121	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	122	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	123	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	489	124	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	125	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	126	agency	agency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	127	chooses	choose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	128	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	129	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	130	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	489	131	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	489	132	institute	institute	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	133	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	134	proceeding.208	proceeding.208	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	135	second	second	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	136	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	137	once	once	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	138	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	139	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	140	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	141	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	489	142	initiated	initiate	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	143	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	144	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	145	board	board	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	146	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-25097	489	147	continue	continue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	148	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	149	regardless	regardless	ADV
inlawrev-25097	489	150	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	489	151	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	152	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	153	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	489	154	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	155	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	156	chooses	choose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	157	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	489	158	continue	continue	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	159	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	489	160	participate.209	participate.209	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	161	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-25097	489	162	supports	support	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	163	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	164	idea	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	165	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	489	166	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	167	[	[	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	168	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	169	partes	partes	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	170	review	review	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	489	171	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	489	172	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	489	173	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	174	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	175	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-25097	489	176	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	177	agency	agency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	178	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	489	179	reconsidering	reconsider	VERB
inlawrev-25097	489	180	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	489	181	own	own	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	182	grant	grant	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	183	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	489	184	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	489	185	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	489	186	franchise	franchise	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	489	187	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	490	1	”2	”2	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	491	1	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-25097	491	2	0	0	NUM
inlawrev-25097	491	3	third	third	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	491	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	491	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	491	6	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	491	7	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-25097	491	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	491	9	uspto	uspto	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	491	10	procedures	procedure	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	491	11	vary	vary	VERB
inlawrev-25097	491	12	significantly	significantly	ADV
inlawrev-25097	491	13	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	491	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	491	15	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	491	16	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	491	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	491	18	civil	civil	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	491	19	procedure	procedure	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	491	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	491	21	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	491	22	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	491	23	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	491	24	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	491	25	both	both	PRON
inlawrev-25097	491	26	functionally	functionally	ADV
inlawrev-25097	491	27	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	491	28	procedurally	procedurally	ADV
inlawrev-25097	491	29	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	491	30	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-25097	491	31	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	491	32	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	491	33	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	491	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	491	35	”211	”211	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	492	1	finally	finally	ADV
inlawrev-25097	492	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	492	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	492	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	5	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-25097	492	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	492	7	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	492	8	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	492	9	t]he	t]he	ADV
inlawrev-25097	492	10	tribe	tribe	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	11	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
inlawrev-25097	492	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	492	13	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	492	14	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	15	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-25097	492	16	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	492	17	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	492	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	492	19	ex	ex	X
inlawrev-25097	492	20	parte	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	21	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	492	22	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	492	23	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	24	reexamination	reexamination	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	492	25	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	26	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	492	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	492	28	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-25097	492	29	inquisitorial	inquisitorial	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	492	30	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	492	32	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	492	33	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	492	34	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	492	35	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	492	36	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	492	37	understood	understand	VERB
inlawrev-25097	492	38	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	492	39	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	492	40	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	41	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	42	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	492	43	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	492	44	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-25097	492	45	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	492	46	inquisitive	inquisitive	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	492	47	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	492	48	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	492	49	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	50	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-25097	492	51	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-25097	492	52	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-25097	492	53	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	492	54	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	492	55	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	56	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	57	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	492	58	reexamination	reexamination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	59	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-25097	492	60	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	492	61	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	492	62	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	492	63	‘	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	492	64	basic	basic	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	492	65	purposes	purpose	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	66	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	492	67	namely	namely	ADV
inlawrev-25097	492	68	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	492	69	reexamine	reexamine	VERB
inlawrev-25097	492	70	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	492	71	agency	agency	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	72	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	492	73	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	493	1	’”212	’”212	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	493	2	notably	notably	ADV
inlawrev-25097	493	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	493	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	493	5	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	493	6	circuit	circuit	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	493	7	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	493	8	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	9	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	493	10	limited	limit	VERB
inlawrev-25097	493	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	493	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	493	13	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	493	15	tribal	tribal	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	493	16	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	493	17	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	493	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	493	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	493	21	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	22	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	493	23	le[ft	le[ft	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	493	24	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	493	25	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-25097	493	26	another	another	DET
inlawrev-25097	493	27	day	day	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	28	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	493	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	493	30	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	493	32	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	493	33	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	34	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-25097	493	35	assert	assert	VERB
inlawrev-25097	493	36	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-25097	493	37	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	38	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	493	39	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	40	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-25097	493	41	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	493	42	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	43	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	493	44	proceedings.213	proceedings.213	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	493	45	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	493	46	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	493	47	dyk	dyk	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	493	48	’s	’s	PART
inlawrev-25097	493	49	concurrence	concurrence	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	50	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	493	51	dyk	dyk	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	493	52	fully	fully	ADV
inlawrev-25097	493	53	joined	join	VERB
inlawrev-25097	493	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	493	55	panel	panel	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	56	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	57	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	493	58	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	493	59	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	493	60	separately	separately	ADV
inlawrev-25097	493	61	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	493	62	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	493	63	describe	describe	VERB
inlawrev-25097	493	64	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	493	65	greater	great	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	493	66	detail	detail	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	67	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	493	68	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	69	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	493	70	inter	inter	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	493	71	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	72	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	73	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	74	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	493	75	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	76	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-25097	493	77	confirms	confirm	VERB
inlawrev-25097	493	78	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	493	79	those	those	DET
inlawrev-25097	493	80	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	81	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	493	82	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	493	83	adjudications	adjudication	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	84	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-25097	493	85	private	private	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	493	86	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	493	87	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	493	88	”214	”214	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	494	1	judge	judge	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	494	2	dyk	dyk	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	494	3	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	494	4	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	494	5	extensive	extensive	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	494	6	overview	overview	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	494	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	494	9	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	494	11	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	494	12	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	13	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	14	partes	part	VERB
inlawrev-25097	494	15	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	494	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	494	18	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	19	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	494	20	which	which	DET
inlawrev-25097	494	21	arise[s	arise[s	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	22	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	494	23	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-25097	494	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	494	25	government	government	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	494	27	persons	person	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	28	subject	subject	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	494	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-25097	494	30	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	494	31	authority	authority	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	32	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	494	33	connection	connection	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	34	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	494	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	494	36	performance	performance	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	494	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	494	39	constitutional	constitutional	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	494	40	functions	function	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	494	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	494	43	executive	executive	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	494	44	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	494	45	legislative	legislative	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	494	46	departments	department	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	494	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	494	48	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	494	49	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	495	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	495	2	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	495	3	cromwell	cromwell	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	495	4	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-25097	495	5	benson	benson	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	495	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	495	7	285	285	NUM
inlawrev-25097	495	8	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	495	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	495	10	22	22	NUM
inlawrev-25097	495	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	495	12	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-25097	495	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	495	14	1932	1932	NUM
inlawrev-25097	495	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	495	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	495	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	495	18	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-25097	495	19	sas	sas	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	495	20	inst	inst	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	495	21	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	495	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	495	23	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	495	24	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	496	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	496	2	iancu	iancu	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	496	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	496	4	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-25097	496	5	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	496	6	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	496	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	496	8	1348	1348	NUM
inlawrev-25097	496	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	496	10	1355	1355	NUM
inlawrev-25097	496	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	496	12	2018	2018	NUM
inlawrev-25097	496	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	496	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	496	15	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	496	16	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-25097	496	17	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-25097	496	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	496	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	496	20	civil	civil	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	496	21	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	496	22	system	system	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	496	23	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	496	24	mimics	mimic	VERB
inlawrev-25097	496	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	496	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	496	27	an	an	DET
inlawrev-25097	496	28	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	496	29	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	496	30	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-25097	496	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	496	32	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	496	33	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	496	34	master	master	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	496	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	496	36	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	496	37	complaint	complaint	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	496	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	496	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	496	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	496	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	497	1	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	497	2	chose	choose	VERB
inlawrev-25097	497	3	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	497	4	structure	structure	VERB
inlawrev-25097	497	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	497	6	process	process	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	497	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-25097	497	8	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	497	9	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	497	10	’s	’	VERB
inlawrev-25097	497	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	497	12	petitioner	petitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	497	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	497	14	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	497	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	497	16	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	497	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	497	18	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-25097	497	19	gets	get	VERB
inlawrev-25097	497	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	497	21	define	define	VERB
inlawrev-25097	497	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	497	23	contours	contours	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	497	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	497	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	497	26	proceeding	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	497	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	497	28	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	497	29	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	497	30	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	497	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	498	1	207	207	NUM
inlawrev-25097	498	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	499	1	saint	saint	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	499	2	regis	regis	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	499	3	mohawk	mohawk	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	499	4	tribe	tribe	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	499	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	499	6	896	896	NUM
inlawrev-25097	499	7	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-25097	499	8	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	499	9	1327	1327	NUM
inlawrev-25097	499	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	500	1	208	208	NUM
inlawrev-25097	500	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	501	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	501	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	501	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	501	4	1328	1328	NUM
inlawrev-25097	501	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	501	6	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	501	7	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-25097	501	8	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-25097	501	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	501	10	director	director	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	501	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	501	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	501	13	politically	politically	ADV
inlawrev-25097	501	14	appointed	appoint	VERB
inlawrev-25097	501	15	executive	executive	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	501	16	branch	branch	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	501	17	official	official	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	501	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	501	19	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	501	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	501	21	private	private	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	501	22	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	501	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	501	24	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-25097	501	25	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
inlawrev-25097	501	26	decides	decide	VERB
inlawrev-25097	501	27	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	501	28	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	501	29	proceed	proceed	VERB
inlawrev-25097	501	30	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-25097	501	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	501	32	sovereign	sovereign	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	501	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	501	34	”	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	501	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	501	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	502	1	209	209	NUM
inlawrev-25097	502	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	503	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	503	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	503	3	210	210	NUM
inlawrev-25097	503	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	504	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	504	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	504	3	211	211	NUM
inlawrev-25097	504	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	505	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	505	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	505	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	505	4	1329	1329	NUM
inlawrev-25097	505	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	506	1	212	212	NUM
inlawrev-25097	506	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	507	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	507	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	507	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	507	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-25097	507	5	cuozzo	cuozzo	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	507	6	speed	speed	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	507	7	techs	tech	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	507	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	507	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	507	10	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	507	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	507	12	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-25097	507	13	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	507	14	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	507	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	508	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	508	2	2144	2144	NUM
inlawrev-25097	508	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	508	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	509	1	213	213	NUM
inlawrev-25097	509	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	510	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	510	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	510	3	214	214	NUM
inlawrev-25097	510	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	511	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	511	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	511	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	511	4	dyk	dyk	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	511	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	511	6	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	511	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	511	8	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-25097	511	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	511	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	512	1	792	792	NUM
inlawrev-25097	512	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	512	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	512	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	512	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	512	8	52:771	52:771	NUM
inlawrev-25097	512	9	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	512	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	512	12	wrote	write	VERB
inlawrev-25097	512	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	512	14	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-25097	512	15	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	512	16	partes	parte	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	17	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	512	19	civil	civil	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	512	20	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	21	share	share	VERB
inlawrev-25097	512	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-25097	512	23	few	few	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	512	24	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-25097	512	25	similarities	similarity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	512	27	“	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	512	28	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	512	29	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	512	30	core	core	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	512	32	[	[	X
inlawrev-25097	512	33	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	512	34	partes	partes	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	512	35	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	36	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	512	37	retains	retain	VERB
inlawrev-25097	512	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	512	39	purpose	purpose	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	40	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-25097	512	41	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	512	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	512	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-25097	512	44	procedures	procedure	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-25097	512	46	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-25097	512	47	reexamination	reexamination	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	48	ancestors	ancestor	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	49	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	512	50	to	to	PART
inlawrev-25097	512	51	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-25097	512	52	everybody	everybody	PRON
inlawrev-25097	512	53	agrees	agree	VERB
inlawrev-25097	512	54	sovereign	sovereign	ADJ
inlawrev-25097	512	55	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-25097	512	56	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-25097	512	57	not	not	PART
inlawrev-25097	512	58	apply	apply	VERB
inlawrev-25097	512	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	513	1	”215	”215	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	513	2	215	215	NUM
inlawrev-25097	513	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	514	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-25097	514	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	514	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-25097	514	4	1330	1330	NUM
inlawrev-25097	514	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-25097	514	6	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-25097	514	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	514	8	dyk	dyk	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	514	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	514	10	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-25097	514	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	514	12	concurring	concur	VERB
inlawrev-25097	514	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-25097	514	14	.	.	PUNCT