id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
inlawrev-3967	1	1	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	1	2	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	1	3	review	review	VERB
inlawrev-3967	1	4	developments	development	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	1	6	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	1	7	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	8	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	9	christopher	christopher	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	1	10	a.	a.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	1	11	brown	brown	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	1	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	1	13	reviewing	review	VERB
inlawrev-3967	1	14	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	1	15	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	16	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	17	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	1	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	1	19	survey	survey	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	20	period	period	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	1	22	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	1	23	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	24	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	1	25	instructive	instructive	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	1	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	1	27	interpreting	interpreting	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	1	29	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	1	30	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-3967	1	31	aspects	aspect	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	1	33	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	1	35	trademark	trademark	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	36	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	1	37	copyright	copyright	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	1	39	trade	trade	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	40	secret	secret	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	1	42	right	right	ADV
inlawrev-3967	1	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	1	44	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	1	46	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	1	47	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	1	48	laws	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	1	49	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	2	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	2	2	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	2	3	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	2	4	represent	represent	VERB
inlawrev-3967	2	5	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	2	6	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	2	7	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	2	8	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	2	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	2	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	2	11	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	2	12	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	2	13	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	2	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	2	15	greatest	great	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	2	16	impact	impact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	2	17	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	2	18	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	2	19	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	2	20	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	2	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	2	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	2	23	past	past	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	2	24	year	year	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	2	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	3	1	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-3967	3	2	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	3	3	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	3	4	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	3	5	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	3	6	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	3	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	3	8	concerning	concern	VERB
inlawrev-3967	3	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	3	10	overhaul	overhaul	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	3	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	3	12	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	3	13	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	3	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	3	15	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	3	16	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	3	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	3	18	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	3	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	3	20	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	3	21	implementation	implementation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	3	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	3	23	previously	previously	ADV
inlawrev-3967	3	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	3	25	announced	announce	VERB
inlawrev-3967	3	26	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	3	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	4	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	4	2	fourth	fourth	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	4	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	4	4	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	4	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	4	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	4	7	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	4	8	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	4	9	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	4	10	address	address	VERB
inlawrev-3967	4	11	head	head	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	4	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	4	13	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	4	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	4	15	reach	reach	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	4	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	4	17	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	4	18	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	4	19	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	4	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	4	21	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	4	22	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	4	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	5	1	i.	i.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	5	2	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	5	3	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	5	4	revision	revision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	5	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	5	6	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	5	7	standards	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	5	8	arguably	arguably	ADV
inlawrev-3967	5	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	5	10	most	most	ADV
inlawrev-3967	5	11	anticipated	anticipate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	5	12	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	5	13	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	5	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	5	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	5	16	year	year	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	5	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	5	18	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	5	19	international	international	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	5	20	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	5	21	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	5	22	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	5	23	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	5	24	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	6	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	6	2	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	6	3	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	6	4	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	6	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	6	6	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	6	7	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	6	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	6	9	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	6	10	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	6	11	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	6	12	foray	foray	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	6	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	6	14	decades	decade	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	6	15	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-3967	6	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	6	17	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	6	18	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	6	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	6	20	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	6	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	6	22	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	6	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	6	24	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	6	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	6	26	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	6	27	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	6	28	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	6	29	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	6	30	performed	perform	VERB
inlawrev-3967	6	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	7	1	starting	start	VERB
inlawrev-3967	7	2	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	7	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	7	4	seminal	seminal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	7	5	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	7	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	7	7	graham	graham	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	7	8	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	7	9	john	john	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	7	10	deere	deere	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	7	11	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	7	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	7	13	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-3967	7	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	7	15	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	7	16	stopped	stop	VERB
inlawrev-3967	7	17	briefly	briefly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	7	18	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	7	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	7	20	few	few	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	7	21	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	7	22	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	7	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	7	24	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	7	25	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	7	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	7	27	precedent	precedent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	7	28	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-3967	7	29	making	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	7	30	sweeping	sweeping	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	7	31	pronouncements	pronouncement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	7	32	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	7	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	7	34	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	7	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	7	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	7	37	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	7	38	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	7	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	8	1	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	8	2	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-3967	8	3	detailed	detailed	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	8	4	below	below	ADV
inlawrev-3967	8	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	8	6	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	8	7	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	8	8	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	8	9	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	8	10	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	8	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	8	12	sea	sea	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	8	13	change	change	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	8	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	8	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	8	16	consideration	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	8	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	8	18	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	8	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	8	20	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	8	21	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	8	22	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	8	23	turn	turn	VERB
inlawrev-3967	8	24	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-3967	8	25	merely	merely	ADV
inlawrev-3967	8	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	8	27	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	8	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	8	29	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	8	30	righting	righting	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	8	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	8	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	8	33	ship	ship	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	8	34	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	8	35	toward	toward	ADP
inlawrev-3967	8	36	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	8	37	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-3967	8	38	practical	practical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	8	39	analytical	analytical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	8	40	framework	framework	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	8	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	9	1	a.	a.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	9	2	obviousness	obviousness	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	9	3	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	9	4	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	9	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	9	6	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	9	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	9	8	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	9	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	9	10	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-3967	9	11	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	9	12	criteria	criterion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	9	13	concerning	concern	VERB
inlawrev-3967	9	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	9	15	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	9	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	9	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	9	18	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	9	19	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	9	20	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	9	21	met	meet	VERB
inlawrev-3967	9	22	before	before	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	9	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	9	24	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	9	25	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	9	26	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	9	27	granted	grant	VERB
inlawrev-3967	9	28	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	9	29	useful	useful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	9	30	inventive	inventive	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	9	31	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	9	32	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	9	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	10	1	first	first	ADV
inlawrev-3967	10	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	10	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	10	4	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	10	5	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	10	6	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	10	7	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	10	8	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	10	9	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	10	10	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	10	11	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	10	12	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	10	13	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	10	14	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	10	15	anticipated	anticipated	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	10	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	10	17	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	11	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	11	2	exactly	exactly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	11	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	11	4	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	11	5	machine	machine	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	11	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	11	7	composition	composition	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	11	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	11	9	method	method	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	11	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	11	11	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	11	12	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	11	13	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	11	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	11	15	being	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	11	16	claimed	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	11	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	11	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	11	19	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	11	20	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	11	21	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	11	22	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	11	23	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	11	24	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	11	25	sale	sale	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	11	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	11	27	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-3967	11	28	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	11	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	11	30	printed	print	VERB
inlawrev-3967	11	31	publication	publication	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	11	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	11	33	patented	patent	VERB
inlawrev-3967	11	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	11	35	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	11	36	otherwise	otherwise	ADV
inlawrev-3967	11	37	within	within	ADP
inlawrev-3967	11	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	11	39	applicable	applicable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	11	40	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	11	41	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	11	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	11	43	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-3967	11	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	11	45	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	11	46	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	11	47	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	11	48	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	11	49	anticipated	anticipate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	11	50	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	11	51	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	11	52	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	11	53	no	no	DET
inlawrev-3967	11	54	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	11	55	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	11	56	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	11	57	granted	grant	VERB
inlawrev-3967	11	58	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	11	59	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	11	60	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	12	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	12	2	criteria	criterion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	12	3	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	12	4	anticipation	anticipation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	12	5	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	12	6	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	12	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	12	8	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-3967	12	9	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	12	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	13	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	13	2	102	102	NUM
inlawrev-3967	13	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	13	4	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-3967	13	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	13	6	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	13	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	13	8	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	13	9	shall	shall	AUX
inlawrev-3967	13	10	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	13	11	entitled	entitle	VERB
inlawrev-3967	13	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	13	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	13	14	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	13	15	unless	unless	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	13	16	...	...	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	13	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	13	18	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	13	19	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	13	20	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	13	21	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	13	22	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-3967	13	23	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	13	24	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	13	25	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	13	26	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	13	27	country	country	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	13	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	13	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	14	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	15	1	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-3967	15	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	15	3	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	15	4	thereof	thereof	ADV
inlawrev-3967	15	5	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	15	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	15	7	applicant	applicant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	15	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	15	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	15	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	15	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	16	1	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	16	2	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	16	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	17	1	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-3967	17	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	17	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	17	4	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	17	5	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	17	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	17	7	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	17	8	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	17	9	exactly	exactly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	17	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	17	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	17	12	applicable	applicable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	17	13	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	17	14	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	17	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	17	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	17	17	applicant	applicant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	17	18	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	17	19	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	17	20	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-3967	17	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	17	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	17	23	woods	wood	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	17	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	18	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	18	2	concept	concept	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	18	3	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	18	4	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	18	5	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	18	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	18	7	hurdle	hurdle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	18	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	18	9	overcome	overcome	VERB
inlawrev-3967	18	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	18	11	obtaining	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	18	12	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	18	13	protection	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	18	14	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-3967	18	15	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	18	16	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	18	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	18	18	embryonic	embryonic	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	18	19	form	form	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	18	20	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	18	21	early	early	ADV
inlawrev-3967	18	22	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	18	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	18	24	beginning	beginning	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	18	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	18	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	18	27	republic	republic	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	18	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	18	29	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-3967	18	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	18	31	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	18	32	commentators	commentator	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	18	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	19	1	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-3967	19	2	*	*	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	19	3	partner	partner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	19	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	19	5	woodard	woodard	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	19	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	19	7	emhardt	emhardt	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	19	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	19	9	moriarty	moriarty	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	19	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	19	11	mcnett	mcnett	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	19	12	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	19	13	henry	henry	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	19	14	llp	llp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	19	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	19	16	indianapolis	indianapolis	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	19	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	20	1	j.d	j.d	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	20	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	20	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	20	4	summa	summa	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	20	5	cum	cum	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	20	6	laude	laude	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	20	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	20	8	1996	1996	NUM
inlawrev-3967	20	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	20	10	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	20	11	university	university	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	20	12	school	school	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	20	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	20	14	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	20	15	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	20	16	indianapolis	indianapolis	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	20	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	21	1	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	21	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-3967	21	3	127s.q	127s.q	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	21	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	22	1	1727	1727	NUM
inlawrev-3967	22	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	22	3	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	22	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	23	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	23	2	rev	rev	VERB
inlawrev-3967	23	3	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	23	4	g	g	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	23	5	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	23	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	23	7	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	23	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	24	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	24	2	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	24	3	int'l	int'l	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	24	4	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	24	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	24	6	119f	119f	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	24	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	24	8	app'x282(fed.cir	app'x282(fed.cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	24	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	24	10	2005	2005	NUM
inlawrev-3967	24	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	24	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	25	1	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-3967	25	2	.	.	SYM
inlawrev-3967	25	3	383	383	NUM
inlawrev-3967	25	4	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	25	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	25	6	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	25	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	25	8	1966	1966	NUM
inlawrev-3967	25	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	25	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	26	1	3	3	X
inlawrev-3967	26	2	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	26	3	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-3967	26	4	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	26	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	27	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	27	2	102(a	102(a	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	27	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	27	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	27	5	2000	2000	NUM
inlawrev-3967	27	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	27	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	28	1	4	4	X
inlawrev-3967	28	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-3967	28	3	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	28	4	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-3967	28	5	john	john	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	28	6	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	28	7	duffy	duffy	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	28	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	28	9	inventing	invent	VERB
inlawrev-3967	28	10	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	28	11	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	28	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	28	13	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	28	14	study	study	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	28	15	oflegal	oflegal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	28	16	innovation	innovation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	28	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	28	18	86	86	NUM
inlawrev-3967	28	19	1140	1140	NUM
inlawrev-3967	28	20	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	28	21	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	28	22	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	29	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	29	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	29	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	30	1	41:1139	41:1139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	30	2	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-3967	30	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	30	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	30	5	solidification	solidification	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	30	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	30	7	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	30	8	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	30	9	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	30	10	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	30	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	30	12	patentability	patentability	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	30	13	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	30	14	began	begin	VERB
inlawrev-3967	30	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	30	16	earnest	earnest	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	30	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	30	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	30	19	1850s	1850	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	30	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	30	21	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	30	22	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	30	23	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-3967	30	24	hotchkiss	hotchkiss	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	30	25	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	30	26	greenwood	greenwood	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	30	27	?	?	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	31	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	31	2	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	31	3	demand	demand	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	31	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	31	5	patentable	patentable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	31	6	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	31	7	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	31	8	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	31	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	31	10	quality	quality	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	31	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	31	12	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	31	13	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	31	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	32	1	"6	"6	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	32	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	32	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	32	4	words	word	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	32	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	32	6	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	32	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	32	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	32	9	unless	unless	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	32	10	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	32	11	ingenuity	ingenuity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	32	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	32	13	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	32	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	32	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	33	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	33	2	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	33	3	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-3967	33	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	33	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	34	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	35	1	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	35	2	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	35	3	possessed	possess	VERB
inlawrev-3967	35	4	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	35	5	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	35	6	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	35	7	mechanic	mechanic	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	35	8	acquainted	acquaint	VERB
inlawrev-3967	35	9	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	35	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	35	11	business	business	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	35	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	35	13	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-3967	35	14	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-3967	35	15	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	35	16	absence	absence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	35	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	35	18	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	35	19	degree	degree	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	35	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	35	21	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	35	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	35	23	ingenuity	ingenuity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	35	24	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	35	25	constitute	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-3967	35	26	essential	essential	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	35	27	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	35	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	35	29	every	every	DET
inlawrev-3967	35	30	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	35	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	36	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	36	2	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	36	3	words	word	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	36	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	36	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	36	6	improvement	improvement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	36	7	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	36	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	36	9	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	36	10	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	36	11	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	36	12	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	36	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	36	14	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	36	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	36	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	36	17	skilful	skilful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	36	18	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	36	19	sic	sic	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	36	20	]	]	X
inlawrev-3967	36	21	mechanic	mechanic	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	36	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	36	23	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	36	24	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	36	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	36	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	36	27	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	36	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	36	29	7	7	NUM
inlawrev-3967	36	30	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-3967	36	31	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	36	32	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	36	33	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	36	34	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	36	35	something	something	PRON
inlawrev-3967	36	36	beyond	beyond	ADP
inlawrev-3967	36	37	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-3967	36	38	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-3967	36	39	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	36	40	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	36	41	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	36	42	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	36	43	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	36	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	36	45	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	36	46	field	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	36	47	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	36	48	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	36	49	protection	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	36	50	arise	arise	VERB
inlawrev-3967	36	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	37	1	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-3967	37	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	37	3	century	century	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	37	4	ofjudicial	ofjudicial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	37	5	treatment	treatment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	37	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	37	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	37	8	codification	codification	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	37	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	37	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	37	11	1952	1952	NUM
inlawrev-3967	37	12	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	37	13	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	37	14	included	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	37	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	37	16	statutory	statutory	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	37	17	statement	statement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	37	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	37	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	37	20	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	37	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	37	22	nonobviousness	nonobviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	37	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	38	1	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	38	2	103(a	103(a	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	38	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	38	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	38	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	38	6	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	38	7	reads	read	VERB
inlawrev-3967	38	8	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	38	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	38	10	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	38	11	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	38	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	38	13	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	38	14	obtained	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	38	15	though	though	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	38	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	38	17	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	38	18	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	38	19	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	38	20	identically	identically	ADV
inlawrev-3967	38	21	disclosed	disclose	VERB
inlawrev-3967	38	22	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	38	23	described	describe	VERB
inlawrev-3967	38	24	...	...	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	39	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	39	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	39	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	39	4	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	39	5	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	6	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	39	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	39	8	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	39	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	39	10	differences	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	11	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-3967	39	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	39	13	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	14	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	15	sought	seek	VERB
inlawrev-3967	39	16	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	39	17	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	39	18	patented	patent	VERB
inlawrev-3967	39	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	39	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	39	21	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	39	22	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	23	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	39	24	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	39	25	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	39	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	39	27	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	28	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	29	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	39	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	39	31	whole	whole	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	32	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	39	33	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	39	34	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	39	35	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	39	36	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	39	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	39	38	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	39	40	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	41	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	39	42	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	39	43	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	39	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	39	45	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	46	having	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	39	47	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	39	48	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	49	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	39	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	39	51	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	52	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	39	53	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	39	54	said	say	VERB
inlawrev-3967	39	55	subject	subject	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	39	56	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	39	57	pertains	pertain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	39	58	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	40	1	8	8	NUM
inlawrev-3967	40	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	40	3	language	language	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	40	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	40	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	40	6	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	40	7	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	40	8	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	40	9	concepts	concept	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	40	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	41	1	first	first	ADV
inlawrev-3967	41	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	41	3	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-3967	41	4	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	41	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	41	6	differences	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	41	7	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-3967	41	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	41	9	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	41	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	41	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	41	12	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	41	13	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	41	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	41	15	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	41	16	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	41	17	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	41	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	41	19	such	such	DET
inlawrev-3967	41	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	41	21	character	character	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	41	22	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	41	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	41	24	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	41	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	41	26	whole	whole	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	41	27	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	41	28	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	41	29	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	41	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	42	1	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	42	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	42	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	42	4	eyes	eye	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	42	5	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-3967	42	6	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	42	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	42	8	assessment	assessment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	42	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	42	10	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	42	11	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	42	12	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	42	13	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	42	14	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	42	15	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	42	16	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	42	17	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	42	18	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-3967	42	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	42	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	42	21	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	42	22	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	42	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	42	24	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	42	25	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	42	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	42	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	42	28	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	42	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	43	1	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	43	2	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	43	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	43	4	deemed	deem	VERB
inlawrev-3967	43	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	43	6	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	43	7	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-3967	43	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	43	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	43	10	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	43	11	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	43	12	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	43	13	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-3967	43	14	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	43	15	her	her	PRON
inlawrev-3967	43	16	fingertips	fingertip	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	43	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	43	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	43	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	43	20	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	43	21	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	43	22	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	43	23	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	43	24	experience	experience	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	43	25	and/or	and/or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	43	26	training	training	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	43	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	43	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	43	29	field	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	43	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	43	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	43	32	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	43	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	44	1	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	44	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	44	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	44	4	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	44	5	considers	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	44	6	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-3967	44	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	44	8	conditions	condition	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	44	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	44	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	44	11	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	44	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	44	13	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	44	14	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	44	15	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	44	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	45	1	later	late	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	45	2	discoveries	discovery	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	45	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	45	4	techniques	technique	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	45	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	45	6	experience	experience	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	45	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	45	8	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	45	9	training	training	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	45	10	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	45	11	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	45	12	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	45	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	45	14	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	45	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	46	1	once	once	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	46	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	46	3	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	46	4	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	46	5	enacted	enact	VERB
inlawrev-3967	46	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	46	7	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-3967	46	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	46	9	another	another	DET
inlawrev-3967	46	10	fifteen	fifteen	NUM
inlawrev-3967	46	11	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	46	12	passed	pass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	46	13	before	before	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	46	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	46	15	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	46	16	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	46	17	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	46	18	graham9	graham9	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	46	19	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	46	20	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	46	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	46	22	framework	framework	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	46	23	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	46	24	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	46	25	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	46	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	47	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	47	2	graham	graham	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	47	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	47	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	47	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	47	6	set	set	VERB
inlawrev-3967	47	7	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-3967	47	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	47	9	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-3967	47	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	47	11	pronged	pronged	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	47	12	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	47	13	analytical	analytical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	47	14	structure	structure	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	47	15	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	47	16	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	47	17	questions	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	47	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	48	1	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-3967	48	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	48	3	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	48	4	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	48	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	48	6	content	content	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	48	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	48	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	48	9	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	48	10	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	48	11	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	48	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	48	13	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	48	14	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	48	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	48	16	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	48	17	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	48	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	48	19	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	48	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	48	21	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	48	22	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	48	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	48	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	48	25	pertinent	pertinent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	48	26	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	48	27	resolved	resolve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	48	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	48	29	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	48	30	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	48	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	48	32	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	48	33	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	48	34	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	48	35	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	48	36	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	48	37	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	48	38	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	48	39	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	48	40	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	48	41	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	48	42	jessica	jessica	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	48	43	silbey	silbey	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	48	44	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	48	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	48	46	mythical	mythical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	48	47	beginnings	beginning	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	48	48	ofintellectual	ofintellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	48	49	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	48	50	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	48	51	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-3967	48	52	geo	geo	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	48	53	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	48	54	mason	mason	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	48	55	l.	l.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	48	56	rev	rev	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	48	57	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	49	1	319	319	NUM
inlawrev-3967	49	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	49	3	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-3967	49	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	49	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	50	1	5	5	NUM
inlawrev-3967	50	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-3967	50	3	52	52	NUM
inlawrev-3967	50	4	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	50	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	50	6	248(1851	248(1851	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	50	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	50	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	51	1	6	6	X
inlawrev-3967	51	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-3967	52	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	52	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	52	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	52	4	267	267	NUM
inlawrev-3967	52	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	53	1	7	7	X
inlawrev-3967	53	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-3967	54	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	54	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	54	3	8	8	NUM
inlawrev-3967	54	4	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	54	5	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-3967	54	6	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	54	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	55	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	55	2	103(a	103(a	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	55	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	55	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	55	5	2000	2000	NUM
inlawrev-3967	55	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	55	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	56	1	9	9	X
inlawrev-3967	56	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-3967	56	3	graham	graham	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	56	4	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	56	5	john	john	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	56	6	deere	deere	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	56	7	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	56	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	56	9	383	383	NUM
inlawrev-3967	56	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	56	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	56	12	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	56	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	56	14	1966	1966	NUM
inlawrev-3967	56	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	56	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	57	1	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-3967	57	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	58	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	58	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	58	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	58	4	17	17	NUM
inlawrev-3967	58	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	58	6	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-3967	58	7	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	58	8	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	58	9	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	58	10	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	58	11	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	58	12	141	141	NUM
inlawrev-3967	58	13	differences	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	58	14	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-3967	58	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	58	16	claimed	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	58	17	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	58	18	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	58	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	58	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	58	21	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	58	22	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	58	23	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	58	24	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	58	25	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-3967	58	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	59	1	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-3967	60	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	60	2	fourth	fourth	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	60	3	prong	prong	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	4	reviews	review	VERB
inlawrev-3967	60	5	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	60	6	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	60	7	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	8	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	60	9	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	60	10	commercial	commercial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	60	11	success	success	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	60	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	60	14	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	60	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	60	17	long	long	ADV
inlawrev-3967	60	18	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	60	19	felt	feel	VERB
inlawrev-3967	60	20	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	60	21	unsolved	unsolved	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	60	22	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	60	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	60	25	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	60	27	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	60	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	60	29	failure	failure	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	60	31	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	32	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	60	33	reach	reach	VERB
inlawrev-3967	60	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	60	35	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	36	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	60	37	solution	solution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	60	39	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	60	40	mixes	mix	VERB
inlawrev-3967	60	41	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	60	42	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	43	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-3967	60	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	60	45	overall	overall	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	60	46	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	60	48	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	60	49	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	60	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	60	51	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	60	52	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	53	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	60	54	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	60	55	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	60	56	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	60	57	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	60	58	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	61	1	12	12	NUM
inlawrev-3967	61	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	61	3	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	61	4	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	61	5	repeated	repeat	VERB
inlawrev-3967	61	6	graham	graham	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	61	7	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	61	8	goal	goal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	61	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	61	10	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	61	11	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	61	12	uniformity	uniformity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	61	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	61	14	definiteness	definiteness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	61	15	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	61	16	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	61	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	61	18	analyzing	analyze	VERB
inlawrev-3967	61	19	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	61	20	questions	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	61	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	61	22	saw	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	61	23	graham	graham	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	61	24	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	61	25	confirming	confirm	VERB
inlawrev-3967	61	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	61	27	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	61	28	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	61	29	functional	functional	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	61	30	approach	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	61	31	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	61	32	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	61	33	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	61	34	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	61	35	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-3967	61	36	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	61	37	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	61	38	broad	broad	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	61	39	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	61	40	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	61	41	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-3967	61	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	61	43	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-3967	61	44	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	61	45	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	61	46	above	above	ADV
inlawrev-3967	61	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	62	1	13	13	NUM
inlawrev-3967	62	2	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	3	presents	present	VERB
inlawrev-3967	62	4	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	62	5	variety	variety	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	62	7	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	62	9	including	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	62	10	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-3967	62	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	62	12	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	62	13	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	14	shows	show	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	62	16	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-3967	62	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	62	18	differences	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	19	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-3967	62	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	62	21	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	62	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	62	24	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	62	25	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	26	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	62	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	62	28	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-3967	62	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	62	30	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	62	32	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	62	33	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	34	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	62	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	62	36	field	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	37	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	62	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	62	39	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	62	40	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	62	41	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	62	43	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	62	44	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-3967	62	45	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	62	46	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	62	47	primary	primary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	62	48	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	49	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	62	50	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	51	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	52	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	62	53	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-3967	62	54	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	62	55	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	62	56	prosecution	prosecution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	57	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	62	58	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	59	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	62	60	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	62	61	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	62	62	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	62	63	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	64	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	62	65	trademark	trademark	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	66	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	62	67	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	63	1	certainly	certainly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	63	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	63	3	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	63	4	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	63	5	said	say	VERB
inlawrev-3967	63	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	63	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	63	8	approximately	approximately	ADV
inlawrev-3967	63	9	fifty	fifty	NUM
inlawrev-3967	63	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	63	11	five	five	NUM
inlawrev-3967	63	12	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	63	13	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	63	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	63	15	enactment	enactment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	63	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	63	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	63	18	1952	1952	NUM
inlawrev-3967	63	19	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	63	20	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	63	21	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	63	22	seen	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	63	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	63	24	wealth	wealth	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	63	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	63	26	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	63	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	63	28	various	various	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	63	29	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	63	30	interpreting	interpret	VERB
inlawrev-3967	63	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	63	32	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	63	33	provision	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	63	34	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	63	35	fleshing	flesh	VERB
inlawrev-3967	63	36	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-3967	63	37	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	63	38	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	63	39	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	63	40	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	63	41	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	63	42	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-3967	63	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	64	1	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	64	2	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	64	3	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	64	4	ofksr	ofksr	VERB
inlawrev-3967	64	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	64	6	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	64	7	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	64	8	arose	arise	VERB
inlawrev-3967	64	9	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-3967	64	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	64	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	64	12	dispute	dispute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	64	13	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-3967	64	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	64	15	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	64	16	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	64	17	automobile	automobile	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	64	18	pedal	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	64	19	systems	system	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	64	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	65	1	14	14	NUM
inlawrev-3967	65	2	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	65	3	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	65	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	65	5	sued	sue	VERB
inlawrev-3967	65	6	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	65	7	international	international	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	65	8	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	65	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	65	10	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	65	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	65	12	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	65	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	65	14	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	65	15	no	no	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	65	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	65	17	6,237,565	6,237,565	NUM
inlawrev-3967	65	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	65	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	65	20	engelgau	engelgau	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	65	21	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	65	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	65	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	65	24	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	65	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	65	26	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	65	27	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	65	28	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-3967	65	29	directed	direct	VERB
inlawrev-3967	65	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	65	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	65	32	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	65	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	65	34	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	65	35	adjustable	adjustable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	65	36	automobile	automobile	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	65	37	pedal	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	65	38	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	65	39	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	65	40	electronic	electronic	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	65	41	sensor	sensor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	65	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	66	1	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-3967	66	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	66	3	sensor	sensor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	66	4	sends	send	VERB
inlawrev-3967	66	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	66	6	signal	signal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	66	7	indicating	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	66	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	66	9	pedal	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	66	10	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	66	11	position	position	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	66	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	66	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	66	14	computer	computer	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	66	15	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	66	16	controls	control	VERB
inlawrev-3967	66	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	66	18	throttle	throttle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	66	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	66	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	66	21	automobile	automobile	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	66	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	67	1	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-3967	68	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	68	2	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	3	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	68	4	trademark	trademark	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	5	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	68	7	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	68	8	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	68	9	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	68	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	68	11	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	68	12	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	68	13	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	68	14	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	15	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	16	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-3967	68	17	prosecution	prosecution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	68	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	68	20	engelgau	engelgau	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	21	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	68	23	including	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	68	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	68	25	redding	redd	VERB
inlawrev-3967	68	26	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	27	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	68	28	showed	show	VERB
inlawrev-3967	68	29	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	68	30	adjustable	adjustable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	68	31	pedal	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	32	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	68	33	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	68	34	smith	smith	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	68	35	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	36	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	68	37	showed	show	VERB
inlawrev-3967	68	38	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	68	39	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	68	40	mount	mount	VERB
inlawrev-3967	68	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	68	42	sensor	sensor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	43	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	68	44	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	68	45	pedal	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	46	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	68	47	structure	structure	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	68	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	69	1	17	17	NUM
inlawrev-3967	69	2	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-3967	69	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	69	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	69	5	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	69	6	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	69	7	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	69	8	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	69	9	another	another	DET
inlawrev-3967	69	10	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	69	11	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-3967	69	12	prosecution	prosecution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	69	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	69	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	69	15	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	69	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	69	17	asano	asano	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	69	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	69	19	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	69	20	showed	show	VERB
inlawrev-3967	69	21	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	69	22	housing	housing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	69	23	structure	structure	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	69	24	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	69	25	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	69	26	adjustable	adjustable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	69	27	automobile	automobile	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	69	28	pedal	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	69	29	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	69	30	allowed	allow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	69	31	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	69	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	69	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	69	34	pedal	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	69	35	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	69	36	pivot	pivot	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	69	37	points	point	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	69	38	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	69	39	remain	remain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	69	40	fixed	fix	VERB
inlawrev-3967	69	41	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	69	42	adjustments	adjustment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	69	43	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	69	44	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	69	45	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	69	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	69	47	pedal	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	69	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	70	1	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-3967	70	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	70	3	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	70	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	70	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	70	6	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	70	7	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	70	8	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	70	9	motion	motion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	70	10	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	70	11	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	70	12	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	70	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	70	14	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-3967	70	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	70	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	70	17	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	70	18	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	70	19	ofteleflex	ofteleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	70	20	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	70	21	s	s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	70	22	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	70	23	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	70	24	invalid	invalid	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	70	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	71	1	19	19	NUM
inlawrev-3967	71	2	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	71	3	graham	graham	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	71	4	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	71	5	analytical	analytical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	71	6	guidance	guidance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	71	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	71	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	71	9	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	71	10	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	71	11	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	71	12	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	71	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	71	14	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	71	15	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	71	16	record	record	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	71	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	71	18	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	71	19	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-3967	71	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	72	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	72	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	72	3	12	12	NUM
inlawrev-3967	72	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	73	1	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	73	2	int'l	int'l	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	73	3	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	73	4	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	73	5	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	73	6	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	73	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	73	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	73	9	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	73	10	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	73	11	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	73	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	73	13	1727	1727	NUM
inlawrev-3967	73	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	73	15	1730	1730	NUM
inlawrev-3967	73	16	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	73	17	31	31	NUM
inlawrev-3967	73	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	73	19	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	73	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	73	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	74	1	13	13	NUM
inlawrev-3967	74	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	75	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	75	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	75	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	75	4	1739	1739	NUM
inlawrev-3967	75	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	75	6	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-3967	75	7	graham	graham	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	75	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	75	9	383	383	NUM
inlawrev-3967	75	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	75	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	75	12	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	75	13	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-3967	75	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	75	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	76	1	14	14	NUM
inlawrev-3967	76	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	77	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	77	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	77	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	77	4	1734	1734	NUM
inlawrev-3967	77	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	78	1	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-3967	78	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	79	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	79	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	79	3	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-3967	79	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	79	5	mat	mat	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	79	6	1735	1735	NUM
inlawrev-3967	79	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	80	1	17	17	NUM
inlawrev-3967	80	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	81	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	81	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	81	3	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-3967	81	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	82	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	82	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	82	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	82	4	1737	1737	NUM
inlawrev-3967	82	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	83	1	19	19	NUM
inlawrev-3967	83	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	84	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	84	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	84	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	84	4	1737	1737	NUM
inlawrev-3967	84	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	84	6	38	38	NUM
inlawrev-3967	84	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	85	1	1142	1142	NUM
inlawrev-3967	85	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	85	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	85	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	85	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	85	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	85	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	86	1	41:1139	41:1139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	86	2	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	86	3	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	86	4	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	86	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	86	6	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	86	7	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	87	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	88	1	reviewed	review	VERB
inlawrev-3967	88	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	88	3	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	88	4	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	88	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	88	6	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	88	7	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	88	8	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	88	9	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	88	10	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	88	11	little	little	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	88	12	difference	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	88	13	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	88	14	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-3967	88	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	88	16	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	88	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	88	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	88	19	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	88	20	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	88	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	89	1	20	20	NUM
inlawrev-3967	89	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	89	3	features	feature	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	89	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	89	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	89	6	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	89	7	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	89	8	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	89	9	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	89	10	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	89	11	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-3967	89	12	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	89	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	89	14	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	89	15	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	89	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	89	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	89	18	asano	asano	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	89	19	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	89	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	89	21	except	except	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	89	22	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	89	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	89	24	sensor	sensor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	89	25	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	89	26	detects	detect	VERB
inlawrev-3967	89	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	89	28	pedal	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	89	29	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	89	30	position	position	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	89	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	89	32	sends	send	VERB
inlawrev-3967	89	33	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	89	34	information	information	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	89	35	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	89	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	89	37	vehicle	vehicle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	89	38	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	89	39	throttle	throttle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	89	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	90	1	21	21	NUM
inlawrev-3967	90	2	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	90	3	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	90	4	included	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	90	5	such	such	DET
inlawrev-3967	90	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	90	7	sensor	sensor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	90	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	90	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	90	10	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-3967	90	11	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-3967	90	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	90	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	90	14	features	feature	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	90	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	90	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	90	17	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	90	18	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	90	19	present	present	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	90	20	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	90	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	90	22	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	90	23	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	90	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	91	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	91	2	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	91	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	91	4	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	91	5	followed	follow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	91	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	91	7	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	91	8	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	91	9	'	'	PART
inlawrev-3967	91	10	s	s	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	91	11	precedent	precedent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	91	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	91	13	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-3967	91	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	91	15	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	91	16	teaching	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	91	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	91	18	suggestion	suggestion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	91	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	91	20	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	91	21	motivation	motivation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	91	22	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	91	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	91	24	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	91	25	tsm	tsm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	91	26	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	91	27	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	91	28	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	91	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	91	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	91	31	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	91	32	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-3967	91	33	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	91	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	92	1	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-3967	92	2	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	92	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	92	4	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	92	5	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	92	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	92	7	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	92	8	i]t	i]t	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	92	9	reasoned	reason	VERB
inlawrev-3967	92	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	92	11	1	1	X
inlawrev-3967	92	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	92	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	92	14	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	92	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	92	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	92	17	industry	industry	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	92	18	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	92	19	lead	lead	VERB
inlawrev-3967	92	20	inevitably	inevitably	ADV
inlawrev-3967	92	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	92	22	combinations	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	92	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	92	24	electronic	electronic	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	92	25	sensors	sensor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	92	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	92	27	adjustable	adjustable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	92	28	pedals	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	92	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	92	30	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	92	31	2	2	X
inlawrev-3967	92	32	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	93	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	93	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	93	3	rixon	rixon	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	93	4	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	93	5	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	93	6	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	93	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	93	8	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	93	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	93	10	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	93	11	developments	development	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	93	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	93	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	93	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	93	15	3	3	X
inlawrev-3967	93	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	94	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	94	2	another	another	DET
inlawrev-3967	94	3	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	94	4	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	94	5	taught	teach	VERB
inlawrev-3967	94	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	94	7	solution	solution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	94	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	94	9	wire	wire	VERB
inlawrev-3967	94	10	chafing	chafing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	94	11	problems	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	94	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	94	13	rixon	rixon	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	94	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	94	15	namely	namely	ADV
inlawrev-3967	94	16	locating	locate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	94	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	94	18	sensor	sensor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	94	19	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	94	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	94	21	fixed	fix	VERB
inlawrev-3967	94	22	structure	structure	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	94	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	94	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	94	25	pedal	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	94	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	95	1	22	22	NUM
inlawrev-3967	95	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	95	3	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	95	4	words	word	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	96	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	3	judge	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	4	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	96	5	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	96	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	7	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	8	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	9	record	record	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	96	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	12	automotive	automotive	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	96	13	field	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	14	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	96	15	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	96	16	inevitably	inevitably	ADV
inlawrev-3967	96	17	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	96	18	get	get	VERB
inlawrev-3967	96	19	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	96	20	adjustable	adjustable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	96	21	pedal	pedal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	96	22	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	96	23	sensor	sensor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	24	combinations	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	96	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	27	rixon	rixon	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	96	28	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	29	supported	support	VERB
inlawrev-3967	96	30	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	31	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	96	33	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	96	34	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	35	further	further	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	96	36	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	37	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	96	38	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	39	instruction	instruction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	40	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	96	41	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-3967	96	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	96	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	44	field	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	45	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	96	46	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-3967	96	47	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-3967	96	48	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	49	reason	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	50	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	96	51	benefit	benefit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	96	52	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	96	53	placing	place	VERB
inlawrev-3967	96	54	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	55	sensor	sensor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	56	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	96	57	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	58	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	96	59	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	60	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	96	61	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	96	62	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	63	pedal.23	pedal.23	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	96	64	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	65	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	66	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	96	67	direct	direct	VERB
inlawrev-3967	96	68	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	69	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	70	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	96	71	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	96	72	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	73	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	96	74	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	75	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	76	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	96	77	combine	combine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	96	78	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	79	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	96	80	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	81	sensor	sensor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	82	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	96	83	adjustable	adjustable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	96	84	pedal	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	85	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	96	86	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	96	87	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	88	engelgau	engelgau	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	89	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	90	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	96	91	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	96	92	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	96	93	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	94	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	95	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	96	96	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	96	97	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	97	1	24	24	NUM
inlawrev-3967	97	2	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	97	3	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	97	4	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	97	5	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	97	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	97	7	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	97	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	97	9	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	97	10	bolstered	bolster	VERB
inlawrev-3967	97	11	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	97	12	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	97	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	97	14	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	97	15	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	97	16	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	97	17	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	97	18	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	97	19	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	97	20	shake	shake	VERB
inlawrev-3967	97	21	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	97	22	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	97	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	98	1	25	25	NUM
inlawrev-3967	98	2	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	98	3	appealed	appeal	VERB
inlawrev-3967	98	4	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	98	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	98	6	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	98	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	98	8	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	98	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	98	10	appeals	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	98	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	98	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	98	13	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	98	14	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	98	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	99	1	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-3967	99	2	hearing	hear	VERB
inlawrev-3967	99	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	4	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	99	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	7	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	99	8	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	9	reversed	reverse	VERB
inlawrev-3967	99	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	99	11	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	99	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	13	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	99	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	16	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	17	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	18	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	99	19	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	99	21	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	22	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	99	23	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	99	24	rely	rely	VERB
inlawrev-3967	99	25	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	99	26	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	99	27	precedent	precedent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	28	concerning	concern	VERB
inlawrev-3967	99	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	30	proper	proper	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	99	31	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	32	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	99	33	combine	combine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	99	34	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	35	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	99	36	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	37	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	38	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	99	39	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	40	claim.26	claim.26	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	41	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	99	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	43	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	99	44	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	99	45	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	99	46	words	word	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	47	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	99	48	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	49	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	99	50	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	51	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	52	centered	center	VERB
inlawrev-3967	99	53	around	around	ADP
inlawrev-3967	99	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	55	tsm	tsm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	56	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	57	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	99	58	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	99	59	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	99	60	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	99	61	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	62	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	63	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	64	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	99	65	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-3967	99	66	proved	prove	VERB
inlawrev-3967	99	67	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	99	68	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	99	69	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	99	70	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	71	motivation	motivation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	72	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	99	73	suggestion	suggestion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	74	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	99	75	combine	combine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	99	76	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	77	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	99	78	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	79	teachings	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	80	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	99	81	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	99	82	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	99	83	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	99	84	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	99	85	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	86	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	99	87	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	88	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	99	89	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	90	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	91	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	99	92	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	93	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	94	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	99	95	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	99	96	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	97	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	98	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	99	99	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	100	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	101	having	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	99	102	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	99	103	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	104	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	99	105	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	99	106	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	99	107	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	99	108	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	100	1	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-3967	100	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	100	3	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	100	4	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	100	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	100	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	100	7	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	100	8	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	100	9	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	100	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	100	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	100	12	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	100	13	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	100	14	20	20	NUM
inlawrev-3967	100	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	101	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	101	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	101	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	101	4	1738	1738	NUM
inlawrev-3967	101	5	21	21	NUM
inlawrev-3967	101	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	102	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	102	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	102	3	22	22	NUM
inlawrev-3967	102	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	103	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	103	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	103	3	23	23	NUM
inlawrev-3967	103	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	104	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	104	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	104	3	24	24	NUM
inlawrev-3967	104	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	105	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	105	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	105	3	25	25	NUM
inlawrev-3967	105	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	106	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	106	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	106	3	26	26	NUM
inlawrev-3967	106	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	107	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	107	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	107	3	27	27	NUM
inlawrev-3967	107	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	108	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	108	4	1734	1734	NUM
inlawrev-3967	108	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	6	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	108	7	al	al	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	9	site	site	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	10	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	12	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	13	vsi	vsi	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	14	int'l	int'l	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	16	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	19	174	174	NUM
inlawrev-3967	108	20	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	108	21	1308	1308	NUM
inlawrev-3967	108	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	23	1323	1323	NUM
inlawrev-3967	108	24	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	108	25	24	24	NUM
inlawrev-3967	108	26	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	27	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	29	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	30	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	31	1999	1999	NUM
inlawrev-3967	108	32	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	33	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	34	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	108	35	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	108	36	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	37	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	38	patent	patent	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	39	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	108	40	trademark	trademark	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	41	office	office	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	108	42	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	43	manualofpatent	manualofpatent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	108	44	examining	examine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	108	45	procedure	procedure	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	108	46	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	47	mpep	mpep	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	48	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	49	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	50	2141.03	2141.03	NUM
inlawrev-3967	108	51	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	52	8th	8th	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	108	53	ed	ed	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	108	54	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	55	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	56	6	6	NUM
inlawrev-3967	108	57	rev	rev	VERB
inlawrev-3967	108	58	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	108	59	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	108	60	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	61	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	62	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	108	64	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	108	65	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	108	66	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	108	67	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	108	68	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	108	69	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	108	70	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	108	71	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	108	72	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	108	73	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	108	74	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	108	75	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-3967	108	76	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	108	77	presumed	presume	VERB
inlawrev-3967	108	78	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	108	79	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	108	80	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	108	81	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	108	82	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	108	83	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	108	84	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	108	85	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	108	86	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	108	87	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	108	88	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	108	89	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	108	90	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	108	91	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	2	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	109	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	109	4	re	re	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	5	gpac,57f.3d	gpac,57f.3d	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	6	1573	1573	NUM
inlawrev-3967	109	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	8	1579	1579	NUM
inlawrev-3967	109	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	10	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	12	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	14	1995	1995	NUM
inlawrev-3967	109	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	16	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	17	custom	custom	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	109	18	accessories	accessories	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	20	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	21	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	22	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	109	23	jeffrey	jeffrey	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	25	allan	allan	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	26	indus	indus	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	27	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	29	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	30	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	109	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	32	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-3967	109	33	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	34	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	109	35	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	109	36	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	109	37	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	109	38	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	109	39	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-3967	109	40	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	109	41	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	109	42	followed	follow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	109	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	109	44	tsm	tsm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	109	45	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	109	46	properly	properly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	109	47	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	109	48	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	109	49	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	109	50	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	109	51	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	109	52	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	109	53	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	109	54	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	109	55	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	109	56	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	109	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	109	58	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	59	understanding	understanding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	109	60	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	109	61	principle	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	109	62	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	109	63	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	109	64	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	109	65	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	109	66	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	109	67	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	109	68	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	109	69	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	109	70	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	109	71	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	109	72	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	109	73	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	109	74	motivated	motivate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	109	75	him	he	PRON
inlawrev-3967	109	76	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	109	77	her	she	PRON
inlawrev-3967	109	78	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	109	79	combine	combine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	109	80	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	109	81	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	109	82	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	110	1	28	28	NUM
inlawrev-3967	111	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	111	2	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	111	3	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	111	4	characterized	characterize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	111	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	111	6	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	111	7	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	111	8	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	111	9	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	111	10	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	111	11	holding	hold	VERB
inlawrev-3967	111	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	111	13	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	111	14	motivation	motivation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	111	15	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	111	16	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	111	17	lacking	lack	VERB
inlawrev-3967	111	18	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	111	19	unless	unless	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	111	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	111	21	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	111	22	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	111	23	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	111	24	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	111	25	address[ed	address[ed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	111	26	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	111	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	111	28	precise	precise	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	111	29	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	111	30	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	111	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	111	32	patentee	patentee	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	111	33	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	111	34	trying	try	VERB
inlawrev-3967	111	35	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	111	36	solve	solve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	111	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	111	38	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	111	39	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	112	1	29	29	NUM
inlawrev-3967	112	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	112	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	112	4	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	112	5	recitation	recitation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	112	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	112	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	112	8	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	112	9	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	112	10	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	112	11	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	112	12	went	go	VERB
inlawrev-3967	112	13	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-3967	112	14	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-3967	112	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	113	1	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-3967	113	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	113	3	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	113	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	113	6	lower	low	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	113	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	8	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	113	9	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	113	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	113	12	problems	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	113	14	solutions	solution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	15	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	113	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	113	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	113	18	asano	asano	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	113	19	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	113	21	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	113	22	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	113	23	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	24	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	113	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	113	27	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	28	saw	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	113	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	113	30	appellate	appellate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	113	31	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	32	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	113	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	113	34	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	113	36	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	113	37	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	38	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	113	39	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	113	40	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	113	41	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	113	42	led	lead	VERB
inlawrev-3967	113	43	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	113	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	113	45	patentee	patentee	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	46	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	113	47	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	48	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	113	49	having	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	113	50	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	113	51	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	52	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	113	53	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	113	54	appellate	appellate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	113	55	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	56	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	113	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	113	58	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	113	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	114	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	114	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	114	3	specifically	specifically	ADV
inlawrev-3967	114	4	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	114	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	114	6	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	114	7	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	114	8	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	114	9	dismissal	dismissal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	114	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	114	11	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	114	12	supposition	supposition	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	114	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	114	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	114	15	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	114	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	114	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	114	18	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	114	19	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-3967	114	20	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	114	21	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	114	22	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	114	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	114	24	try	try	VERB
inlawrev-3967	114	25	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	114	26	irrelevant	irrelevant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	114	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	114	28	light	light	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	114	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	114	30	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	114	31	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	114	32	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	114	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	115	1	30	30	NUM
inlawrev-3967	115	2	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	115	3	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	115	4	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	115	5	seen	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	115	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	115	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	115	8	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	115	9	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	115	10	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-3967	115	11	practically	practically	ADV
inlawrev-3967	115	12	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-3967	115	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	115	14	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	115	15	ideas	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	115	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	115	17	reinstating	reinstate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	115	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	115	19	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	115	20	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	115	21	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	115	22	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	115	23	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	115	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	115	25	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	115	26	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	115	27	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	115	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	116	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	116	2	doing	do	VERB
inlawrev-3967	116	3	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-3967	116	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	116	5	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	116	6	portions	portion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	116	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	116	8	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	116	9	circuitjurisprudence	circuitjurisprudence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	116	10	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	116	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	116	12	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	116	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	116	14	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	116	15	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	116	16	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-3967	116	17	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	116	18	revised	revise	VERB
inlawrev-3967	116	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	116	20	reinterpreted	reinterpret	VERB
inlawrev-3967	116	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	117	1	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	117	2	revisions	revision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	3	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	117	4	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	117	5	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	117	6	indeed	indeed	ADV
inlawrev-3967	117	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	117	8	already	already	ADV
inlawrev-3967	117	9	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	117	10	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	117	11	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	117	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	117	13	marked	marked	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	117	14	effect	effect	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	15	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	117	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	117	17	judgments	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	117	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	117	20	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	117	21	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	117	22	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	23	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-3967	117	24	prosecution	prosecution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	117	26	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	27	applications	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	117	29	related	related	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	117	30	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	117	32	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	117	33	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-3967	117	34	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	117	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	117	36	analyses	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	37	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	117	38	breadth	breadth	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	117	40	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	41	available	available	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	117	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	117	43	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	117	44	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	45	challenges	challenge	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	46	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	117	47	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	48	validity	validity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	117	49	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	118	1	c.	c.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	119	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	119	2	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	119	3	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	119	4	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	119	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	119	6	major	major	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	119	7	point	point	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	119	8	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	119	9	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	119	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	119	11	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	119	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	119	13	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	119	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	119	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	119	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	119	17	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	119	18	analytical	analytical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	119	19	framework	framework	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	119	20	set	set	VERB
inlawrev-3967	119	21	forth	forth	ADP
inlawrev-3967	119	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	119	23	graham	graham	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	119	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	119	25	wielded	wield	VERB
inlawrev-3967	119	26	flexibly	flexibly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	119	27	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	119	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	119	29	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	119	30	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	119	31	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	119	32	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	119	33	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	119	34	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	119	35	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	119	36	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	119	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	119	38	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	119	39	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-3967	119	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	119	41	elemental	elemental	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	119	42	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	119	43	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	119	44	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	119	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	120	1	31	31	NUM
inlawrev-3967	120	2	rigid	rigid	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	120	3	tests	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	120	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	120	5	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	120	6	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	120	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	120	8	additional	additional	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	120	9	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	120	10	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	120	11	analyses	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	120	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	120	13	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	120	14	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	120	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	120	16	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	120	17	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-3967	120	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	121	1	32	32	NUM
inlawrev-3967	122	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	122	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	122	3	proceeded	proceed	VERB
inlawrev-3967	122	4	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	122	5	note	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	122	6	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-3967	122	7	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	122	8	viewed	view	VERB
inlawrev-3967	122	9	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	122	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	122	11	series	series	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	122	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	122	13	errors	error	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	122	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	122	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	122	16	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	122	17	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	122	18	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	122	19	approaches	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	122	20	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	122	21	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	122	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	122	23	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	122	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	122	25	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	122	26	treatment	treatment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	122	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	122	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	122	29	underlying	underlie	VERB
inlawrev-3967	122	30	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	122	31	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	122	32	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	122	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	123	1	33	33	NUM
inlawrev-3967	123	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	123	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	123	4	began	begin	VERB
inlawrev-3967	123	5	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	123	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	123	7	recitation	recitation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	123	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	123	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	123	10	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	123	11	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	123	12	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	123	13	caution	caution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	123	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	123	15	granting	grant	VERB
inlawrev-3967	123	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	123	17	807	807	NUM
inlawrev-3967	123	18	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	123	19	955	955	NUM
inlawrev-3967	123	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	123	21	962	962	NUM
inlawrev-3967	123	22	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	123	23	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	123	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	123	25	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	123	26	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	123	27	1986	1986	NUM
inlawrev-3967	123	28	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	123	29	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	124	1	envtl	envtl	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	124	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	125	1	designs	design	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	125	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	125	3	ltd	ltd	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	125	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	125	5	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	125	6	union	union	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	125	7	oil	oil	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	125	8	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	125	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	125	10	713	713	NUM
inlawrev-3967	125	11	f.2d	f.2d	ADP
inlawrev-3967	125	12	693	693	NUM
inlawrev-3967	125	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	125	14	696	696	NUM
inlawrev-3967	125	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	125	16	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	125	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	125	18	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	125	19	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	125	20	1983	1983	NUM
inlawrev-3967	125	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	125	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	125	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	126	1	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	126	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	126	3	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	126	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	126	5	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	126	6	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	126	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	126	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	126	9	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	126	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	126	11	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	126	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	126	13	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	126	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	126	15	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	126	16	creativity	creativity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	126	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	126	18	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	126	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	126	20	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	126	21	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	126	22	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	126	23	able	able	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	126	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	126	25	fit	fit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	126	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	126	27	teachings	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	126	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	126	29	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	126	30	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	126	31	together	together	ADV
inlawrev-3967	126	32	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-3967	126	33	pieces	piece	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	126	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	126	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	126	36	puzzle	puzzle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	126	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	126	38	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	127	1	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	127	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	127	3	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	127	4	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	127	5	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	127	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	128	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	128	2	1742	1742	NUM
inlawrev-3967	128	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	129	1	28	28	NUM
inlawrev-3967	129	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	130	1	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	130	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	130	3	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	130	4	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	130	5	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	130	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	131	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	131	2	1738	1738	NUM
inlawrev-3967	131	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	132	1	29	29	NUM
inlawrev-3967	132	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	133	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	133	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	133	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	133	4	1738	1738	NUM
inlawrev-3967	133	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	133	6	39	39	NUM
inlawrev-3967	133	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	133	8	alteration	alteration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	133	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	133	10	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	133	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	133	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	133	13	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	133	14	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	133	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	133	16	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	133	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	134	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	134	2	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	134	3	int'l	int'l	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	134	4	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	134	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	134	6	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	134	7	19	19	NUM
inlawrev-3967	134	8	f.app'x	f.app'x	NUM
inlawrev-3967	134	9	282	282	NUM
inlawrev-3967	134	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	134	11	288	288	NUM
inlawrev-3967	134	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	134	13	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	134	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	134	15	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	134	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	134	17	2005	2005	NUM
inlawrev-3967	134	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	134	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	134	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	135	1	30	30	NUM
inlawrev-3967	135	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	136	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	136	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	136	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	136	4	1739	1739	NUM
inlawrev-3967	136	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	136	6	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	136	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	136	8	re	re	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	136	9	deuel	deuel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	136	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	136	11	51	51	NUM
inlawrev-3967	136	12	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	136	13	1552	1552	NUM
inlawrev-3967	136	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	136	15	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	136	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	136	17	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	136	18	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	136	19	1995	1995	NUM
inlawrev-3967	136	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	136	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	136	22	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	136	23	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	136	24	infra	infra	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	136	25	note	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	136	26	34	34	NUM
inlawrev-3967	136	27	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	136	28	regarding	regard	VERB
inlawrev-3967	136	29	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	136	30	ban	ban	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	136	31	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	136	32	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	136	33	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	136	34	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	136	35	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	136	36	try	try	VERB
inlawrev-3967	136	37	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	136	38	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	136	39	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	136	40	evaluating	evaluate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	136	41	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	136	42	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	136	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	137	1	31	31	NUM
inlawrev-3967	137	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	138	1	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	138	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	138	3	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	138	4	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	138	5	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	138	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	139	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	139	2	1739	1739	NUM
inlawrev-3967	139	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	140	1	32	32	NUM
inlawrev-3967	140	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	141	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	141	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	141	3	33	33	NUM
inlawrev-3967	141	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	142	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	142	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	142	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	142	4	1741	1741	NUM
inlawrev-3967	142	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	142	6	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-3967	142	7	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	142	8	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	142	9	144	144	NUM
inlawrev-3967	142	10	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	142	11	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	142	12	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	142	13	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	142	14	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	142	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	143	1	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-3967	143	2	:	:	SYM
inlawrev-3967	143	3	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	143	4	139	139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	143	5	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	143	6	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-3967	143	7	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	143	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	143	9	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	143	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	143	11	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	143	12	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	143	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	143	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	143	15	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	143	16	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	143	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	143	18	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	144	1	34	34	NUM
inlawrev-3967	144	2	certainly	certainly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	144	3	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	144	4	beginning	beginning	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	144	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	144	6	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	144	7	suggestion	suggestion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	144	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	144	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	144	10	desire	desire	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	144	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	144	12	emphasize	emphasize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	144	13	vigorous	vigorous	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	144	14	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	144	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	144	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	144	17	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	144	18	provisions	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	144	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	144	20	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	144	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	144	22	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	144	23	draw	draw	VERB
inlawrev-3967	144	24	inward	inward	ADV
inlawrev-3967	144	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	144	26	limits	limit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	144	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	144	28	patentability	patentability	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	144	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	144	30	leave	leave	VERB
inlawrev-3967	144	31	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	144	32	developments	development	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	144	33	outside	outside	ADV
inlawrev-3967	144	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	144	35	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	144	36	limits	limit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	144	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	145	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	145	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	145	3	went	go	VERB
inlawrev-3967	145	4	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	145	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	145	6	cite	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	145	7	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-3967	145	8	post	post	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	145	9	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	145	10	graham	graham	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	145	11	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	145	12	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	145	13	approval	approval	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	145	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	146	1	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-3967	146	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	146	3	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	146	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	146	5	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	146	6	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	146	7	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	146	8	adams,36	adams,36	ADP
inlawrev-3967	146	9	concerned	concerned	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	146	10	battery	battery	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	146	11	technology	technology	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	146	12	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	146	13	differed	differ	VERB
inlawrev-3967	146	14	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	146	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	146	16	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	146	17	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	146	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	146	19	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-3967	146	20	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	146	21	ways	way	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	146	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	147	1	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-3967	147	2	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	147	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	147	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	147	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	147	6	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	147	7	adams	adams	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	147	8	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	147	9	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	147	10	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	147	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	147	12	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	147	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	147	14	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	147	15	claims	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	147	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	147	17	structure	structure	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	147	18	already	already	ADV
inlawrev-3967	147	19	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	147	20	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	147	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	147	22	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	147	23	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	147	24	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	147	25	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	147	26	altered	alter	VERB
inlawrev-3967	147	27	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	147	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	147	29	mere	mere	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	147	30	substitution	substitution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	147	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	147	32	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	147	33	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	147	34	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	147	35	another	another	PRON
inlawrev-3967	147	36	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	147	37	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	147	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	147	39	field	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	147	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	147	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	147	42	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	147	43	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	147	44	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	147	45	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	147	46	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-3967	147	47	yield	yield	VERB
inlawrev-3967	147	48	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	147	49	predictable	predictable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	147	50	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	147	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	147	52	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	148	1	37	37	NUM
inlawrev-3967	148	2	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
inlawrev-3967	148	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	148	4	adams	adams	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	148	5	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	148	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	148	7	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	148	8	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	148	9	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	148	10	nonobvious	nonobvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	148	11	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	148	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	148	13	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	148	14	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	148	15	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	148	16	directed	direct	VERB
inlawrev-3967	148	17	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-3967	148	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	148	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	148	20	field	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	148	21	away	away	ADV
inlawrev-3967	148	22	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	148	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	148	24	solution	solution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	148	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	148	26	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	148	27	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	148	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	149	1	38	38	NUM
inlawrev-3967	150	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	150	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	150	3	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	150	4	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	150	5	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	150	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	150	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	150	8	'	'	PART
inlawrev-3967	150	9	s	s	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	150	10	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	150	11	ofadams	ofadam	VERB
inlawrev-3967	150	12	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	150	13	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	150	14	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	150	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	150	16	teachings	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	150	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	150	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	150	19	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	150	20	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	150	21	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	150	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	150	23	unexpected	unexpected	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	150	24	success	success	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	150	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	150	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	150	27	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	150	28	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	150	29	solution	solution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	150	30	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	150	31	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	150	32	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	150	33	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	150	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	150	35	both	both	PRON
inlawrev-3967	150	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	150	37	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	150	38	tipped	tip	VERB
inlawrev-3967	150	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	150	40	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	150	41	balance	balance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	150	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	150	43	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-3967	150	44	favor	favor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	150	45	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	151	1	next	next	ADV
inlawrev-3967	151	2	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	151	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	151	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	151	5	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	151	6	list	list	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	151	7	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	151	8	anderson's	anderson's	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	151	9	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	151	10	black	black	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	151	11	rock	rock	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	151	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	151	13	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	151	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	152	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	152	2	pavement	pavement	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	152	3	salvage	salvage	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	152	4	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	152	5	39	39	NUM
inlawrev-3967	152	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	152	7	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	8	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	152	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	11	patented	patented	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	152	12	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	13	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	14	combined	combine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	152	15	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-3967	152	16	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	152	17	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	18	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	152	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	152	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	22	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	23	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	152	24	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	25	decided	decide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	152	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	152	27	such	such	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	29	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	30	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	152	31	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	152	32	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	152	33	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-3967	152	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	35	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	152	36	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	37	called	call	VERB
inlawrev-3967	152	38	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	152	39	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	40	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	152	41	synergy	synergy	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	42	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	152	43	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	152	44	unexpected	unexpected	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	152	45	benefit.40	benefit.40	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	47	lesson	lesson	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	48	drawn	draw	VERB
inlawrev-3967	152	49	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	152	50	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	51	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	52	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	152	53	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	152	54	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	55	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	56	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	152	57	old	old	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	152	58	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	59	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	152	60	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	152	61	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	152	62	add[s	add[s	VERB
inlawrev-3967	152	63	]	]	X
inlawrev-3967	152	64	nothing	nothing	PRON
inlawrev-3967	152	65	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	152	66	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	67	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	68	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	152	69	quality	quality	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	70	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	152	71	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	152	72	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	152	73	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	74	items	item	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	75	previously	previously	ADV
inlawrev-3967	152	76	patented	patent	VERB
inlawrev-3967	152	77	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	152	78	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	152	79	patentable	patentable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	152	80	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	152	81	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-3967	152	82	though	though	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	152	83	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	84	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	85	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	152	86	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	152	87	performed	perform	VERB
inlawrev-3967	152	88	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	152	89	useful	useful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	152	90	34	34	NUM
inlawrev-3967	152	91	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	153	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	153	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	153	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	153	4	1739	1739	NUM
inlawrev-3967	153	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	154	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	154	2	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-3967	154	3	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	154	4	statement	statement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	154	5	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	154	6	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	154	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	154	8	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	154	9	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	154	10	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	154	11	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	154	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	154	13	great	great	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	154	14	atlantic	atlantic	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	154	15	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	154	16	pacific	pacific	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	154	17	tea	tea	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	154	18	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	154	19	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	154	20	supermarket	supermarket	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	154	21	equipment	equipment	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	154	22	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	154	23	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	154	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	154	25	340	340	NUM
inlawrev-3967	154	26	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	154	27	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	154	28	147	147	NUM
inlawrev-3967	154	29	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	154	30	1950	1950	NUM
inlawrev-3967	154	31	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	154	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	154	33	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	154	34	came	come	VERB
inlawrev-3967	154	35	prior	prior	ADV
inlawrev-3967	154	36	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	154	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	154	38	1952	1952	NUM
inlawrev-3967	154	39	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	154	40	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	154	41	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	154	42	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	154	43	codification	codification	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	154	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	154	45	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	154	46	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	154	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	154	48	provisions	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	154	49	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	154	50	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-3967	154	51	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	154	52	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	155	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	155	2	103	103	NUM
inlawrev-3967	155	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	155	4	2000	2000	NUM
inlawrev-3967	155	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	155	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	156	1	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	156	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	156	3	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	156	4	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	156	5	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	156	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	157	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	157	2	1739	1739	NUM
inlawrev-3967	157	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	158	1	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-3967	158	2	recognizing	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	158	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	158	4	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	158	5	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	158	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	158	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	158	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	158	9	brushed	brush	VERB
inlawrev-3967	158	10	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	158	11	aside	aside	ADV
inlawrev-3967	158	12	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	158	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	158	14	statement	statement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	158	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	158	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	158	17	enactment	enactment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	158	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	158	19	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	158	20	103	103	NUM
inlawrev-3967	158	21	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	158	22	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	158	23	disturb	disturb	VERB
inlawrev-3967	158	24	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	158	25	earlier	early	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	158	26	instructions	instruction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	158	27	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	158	28	concerning	concern	VERB
inlawrev-3967	158	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	158	30	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	158	31	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	158	32	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	158	33	caution	caution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	158	34	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	158	35	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	158	36	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	158	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	158	38	text	text	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	158	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	159	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	159	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	159	3	notably	notably	ADV
inlawrev-3967	159	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	159	5	p.j	p.j	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	159	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	159	7	federico	federico	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	159	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	159	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	159	10	primary	primary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	159	11	author	author	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	159	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	159	14	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	15	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	16	believed	believe	VERB
inlawrev-3967	159	17	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	159	18	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	159	19	congress	congress	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	159	20	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	159	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	159	22	intend	intend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	159	23	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	159	24	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	159	25	radical	radical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	159	26	change	change	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	159	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	159	29	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	159	31	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	159	33	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	159	34	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-3967	159	35	thought	think	VERB
inlawrev-3967	159	36	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	159	37	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	159	38	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	159	39	modification	modification	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	40	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	159	41	intended	intend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	159	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	159	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	159	44	direction	direction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	159	46	moderating	moderate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	159	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	159	48	extreme	extreme	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	159	49	degrees	degree	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	159	51	strictness	strictness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	52	exhibited	exhibit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	159	53	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	159	54	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	159	55	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	56	ofjudicial	ofjudicial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	159	57	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	58	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-3967	159	59	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	159	60	past	past	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	159	61	dozen	dozen	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	62	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	159	63	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	159	64	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	65	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	159	66	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	159	67	is	is	ADV
inlawrev-3967	159	68	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	159	69	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	159	70	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	159	71	change	change	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	72	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	159	73	attitude	attitude	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	74	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-3967	159	75	favorable	favorable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	159	76	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	159	77	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	159	78	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	159	79	hoped	hope	VERB
inlawrev-3967	159	80	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	159	81	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	159	82	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	160	1	p.j	p.j	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	160	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	160	3	federico	federico	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	160	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	160	5	commentary	commentary	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	160	6	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	160	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	160	8	new	new	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	160	9	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	160	10	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	160	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	160	12	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-3967	160	13	u.s.c.a	u.s.c.a	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	160	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	161	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	161	2	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	161	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	161	4	west	west	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	161	5	1954	1954	NUM
inlawrev-3967	161	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	161	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	161	8	reprinted	reprint	VERB
inlawrev-3967	161	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	161	10	75	75	NUM
inlawrev-3967	161	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	162	1	j.	j.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	162	2	pat	pat	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	162	3	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	162	4	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	162	5	trademark	trademark	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	162	6	off	off	ADP
inlawrev-3967	162	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	163	1	socy	socy	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	163	2	161	161	NUM
inlawrev-3967	163	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	163	4	183(1993	183(1993	NUM
inlawrev-3967	163	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	163	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	164	1	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-3967	164	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	165	1	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	165	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	165	3	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	165	4	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	165	5	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	165	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	165	7	1739	1739	NUM
inlawrev-3967	165	8	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	165	9	40	40	NUM
inlawrev-3967	165	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	166	1	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-3967	166	2	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	166	3	383	383	NUM
inlawrev-3967	166	4	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	166	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	166	6	39(1966	39(1966	NUM
inlawrev-3967	166	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	166	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	167	1	37	37	NUM
inlawrev-3967	167	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	168	1	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	168	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	168	3	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	168	4	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	168	5	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	168	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	169	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	169	2	1740	1740	NUM
inlawrev-3967	169	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	169	4	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	169	5	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	169	6	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	169	7	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	169	8	adams	adams	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	169	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	169	10	383	383	NUM
inlawrev-3967	169	11	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	169	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	169	13	39	39	NUM
inlawrev-3967	169	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	169	15	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-3967	169	16	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	169	17	51	51	NUM
inlawrev-3967	169	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	169	19	1966	1966	NUM
inlawrev-3967	169	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	169	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	169	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	170	1	38	38	NUM
inlawrev-3967	170	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	171	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	171	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	171	3	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	171	4	circumstance	circumstance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	171	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	171	6	commonly	commonly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	171	7	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	171	8	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	171	9	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	171	10	teaching	teach	VERB
inlawrev-3967	171	11	away	away	ADV
inlawrev-3967	171	12	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	171	13	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	171	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	171	15	claimed	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	171	16	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	171	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	172	1	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	172	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	172	3	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	4	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	172	5	lead	lead	VERB
inlawrev-3967	172	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	172	7	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	172	9	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	172	10	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	172	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	172	13	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	172	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	172	16	technological	technological	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	172	17	direction	direction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	18	away	away	ADV
inlawrev-3967	172	19	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	172	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	172	21	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	22	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	172	23	ideas	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	24	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	172	25	suggests	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-3967	172	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	172	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	172	28	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	29	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	172	30	ideas	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	31	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	172	32	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	172	33	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	172	34	successful	successful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	172	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	172	36	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	172	37	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	172	38	said	say	VERB
inlawrev-3967	172	39	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	172	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	172	41	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	42	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	172	43	teaches	teach	VERB
inlawrev-3967	172	44	away	away	ADV
inlawrev-3967	172	45	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	172	46	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	172	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	172	48	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	49	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	172	50	making	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	172	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	172	52	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	53	nonobvious	nonobvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	172	54	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	172	55	light	light	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	56	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	172	57	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	172	58	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	172	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	173	1	39	39	NUM
inlawrev-3967	173	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-3967	173	3	396	396	NUM
inlawrev-3967	174	1	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	174	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	174	3	57(1969	57(1969	NUM
inlawrev-3967	174	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	174	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	175	1	40	40	NUM
inlawrev-3967	175	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	176	1	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	176	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	176	3	127s.ct.at	127s.ct.at	NUM
inlawrev-3967	176	4	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	176	5	740	740	NUM
inlawrev-3967	176	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	176	7	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	176	8	anderson	anderson	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	176	9	'	'	PART
inlawrev-3967	176	10	s	s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	176	11	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	176	12	black	black	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	176	13	rock	rock	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	176	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	176	15	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	176	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	177	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	177	2	payment	payment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	177	3	salvage	salvage	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	177	4	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	177	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	177	6	396	396	NUM
inlawrev-3967	177	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	177	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	177	9	57	57	NUM
inlawrev-3967	177	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	177	11	62	62	NUM
inlawrev-3967	177	12	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	177	13	63	63	NUM
inlawrev-3967	177	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	177	15	1969	1969	NUM
inlawrev-3967	177	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	177	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	177	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	178	1	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-3967	178	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	178	3	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	178	4	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	178	5	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	178	6	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	178	7	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-3967	178	8	function	function	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	178	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	179	1	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-3967	179	2	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	179	3	summarize	summarize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	179	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	179	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	179	6	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	179	7	cited	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	179	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	179	9	sakraida	sakraida	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	179	10	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	179	11	ag	ag	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	179	12	pro	pro	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	179	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	179	14	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	179	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	179	16	42	42	NUM
inlawrev-3967	179	17	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	179	18	say	say	VERB
inlawrev-3967	179	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	179	20	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	179	21	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	179	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	179	23	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	179	24	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	179	25	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-3967	179	26	arranges	arrange	VERB
inlawrev-3967	179	27	old	old	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	179	28	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	179	29	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	179	30	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-3967	179	31	performing	perform	VERB
inlawrev-3967	179	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	179	33	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	179	34	function	function	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	179	35	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	179	36	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	179	37	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	179	38	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	179	39	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	179	40	perform	perform	VERB
inlawrev-3967	179	41	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	179	42	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	179	43	yields	yield	VERB
inlawrev-3967	179	44	no	no	PRON
inlawrev-3967	179	45	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	179	46	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-3967	179	47	one	one	PRON
inlawrev-3967	179	48	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	179	49	expect	expect	VERB
inlawrev-3967	179	50	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	179	51	such	such	DET
inlawrev-3967	179	52	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	179	53	arrangement	arrangement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	179	54	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	179	55	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	179	56	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	179	57	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	179	58	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	179	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	179	60	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	180	1	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-3967	180	2	clearly	clearly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	180	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	180	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	180	5	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	180	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	180	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	180	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	180	9	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	180	10	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	180	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	180	12	pertinent	pertinent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	180	13	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	180	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	180	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	180	16	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	180	17	-	-	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	180	18	patentability	patentability	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	180	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	180	20	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	180	21	inventive	inventive	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	180	22	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	180	23	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	180	24	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	180	25	uses	use	VERB
inlawrev-3967	180	26	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-3967	180	27	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	180	28	old	old	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	180	29	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	180	30	items	item	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	180	31	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	180	32	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-3967	180	33	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	180	34	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	180	35	accustomed	accustomed	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	180	36	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	180	37	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	180	38	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	180	39	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	180	40	nothing	nothing	PRON
inlawrev-3967	180	41	unexpected	unexpected	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	180	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	180	43	return	return	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	180	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	181	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	181	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	181	3	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	181	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	181	5	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	181	6	most	most	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	181	7	inventions	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	181	8	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	181	9	fashioned	fashion	VERB
inlawrev-3967	181	10	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	181	11	already	already	ADV
inlawrev-3967	181	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	181	13	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	181	14	parts	part	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	181	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	181	16	44	44	NUM
inlawrev-3967	181	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	181	18	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	181	19	appears	appear	VERB
inlawrev-3967	181	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	181	21	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	181	22	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-3967	181	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	181	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	181	25	whole	whole	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	181	26	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	181	27	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	181	28	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	181	29	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-3967	181	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	181	31	sum	sum	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	181	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	181	33	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	181	34	parts	part	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	181	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	182	1	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	182	2	use	use	VERB
inlawrev-3967	182	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	182	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	182	5	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	182	6	own	own	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	182	7	words	word	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	182	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	182	9	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	182	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	182	11	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	182	12	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	182	13	ask	ask	VERB
inlawrev-3967	182	14	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	182	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	182	16	improvement	improvement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	182	17	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	182	18	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	182	19	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-3967	182	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	182	21	predictable	predictable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	182	22	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	182	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	182	24	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	182	25	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	182	26	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	182	27	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-3967	182	28	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	182	29	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-3967	182	30	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-3967	182	31	functions	function	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	182	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	182	33	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	183	1	45	45	NUM
inlawrev-3967	183	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	183	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	4	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	183	5	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	183	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	183	7	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	183	8	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	9	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	183	10	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	183	11	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-3967	183	12	difficult	difficult	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	183	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	183	14	analyze	analyze	VERB
inlawrev-3967	183	15	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-3967	183	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	183	17	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	18	presented	present	VERB
inlawrev-3967	183	19	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	183	20	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	183	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	183	22	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	183	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	183	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	183	25	gave	give	VERB
inlawrev-3967	183	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	183	27	presumably	presumably	ADV
inlawrev-3967	183	28	exemplary	exemplary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	183	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	183	30	non	non	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	183	31	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	183	32	limiting	limiting	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	183	33	list	list	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	183	35	information	information	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	36	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	183	37	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	183	38	go	go	VERB
inlawrev-3967	183	39	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-3967	183	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	183	41	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	183	42	analysis.46	analysis.46	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	183	43	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-3967	183	44	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	183	45	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	183	46	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	183	47	interrelated	interrelated	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	183	48	teachings	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	49	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	183	50	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	183	51	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	183	53	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	183	54	demands	demand	VERB
inlawrev-3967	183	55	present	present	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	183	56	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	183	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	183	58	marketplace	marketplace	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	59	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	183	60	otherwise	otherwise	ADV
inlawrev-3967	183	61	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	183	62	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	183	63	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	64	designers	designer	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	65	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	183	66	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	183	67	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	183	68	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	69	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	70	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	183	71	entailed	entail	VERB
inlawrev-3967	183	72	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	183	73	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	183	74	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	183	75	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	76	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	183	77	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	183	78	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-3967	183	79	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	183	80	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	1	47	47	NUM
inlawrev-3967	184	2	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	3	data	datum	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	4	points	point	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	6	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	184	7	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	9	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	184	10	gathered	gather	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	11	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	13	order	order	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	14	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	184	15	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	16	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	184	17	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-3967	184	18	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	19	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	20	apparent	apparent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	21	reason	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	22	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	184	23	combine	combine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	25	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	26	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	29	fashion	fashion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	30	claimed	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	31	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	32	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	34	inventor.48	inventor.48	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	184	35	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	184	36	errors	error	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	37	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	39	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	40	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	42	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	43	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	44	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	184	45	principal	principal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	46	error	error	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	47	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	48	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	49	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	51	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	53	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	184	54	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	184	55	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	56	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	57	fashioning	fashioning	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	58	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	59	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	60	tsm	tsm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	61	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	62	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-3967	184	63	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	64	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	184	65	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	184	66	implied	imply	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	67	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	184	68	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	69	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	70	helpful	helpful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	71	insight	insight	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	72	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	73	toward	toward	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	74	identifying	identify	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	75	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	76	reasons	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	77	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	78	combining	combine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	79	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	80	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	184	81	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	82	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	83	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	84	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	85	49	49	NUM
inlawrev-3967	184	86	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	184	87	inventions	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	88	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	89	rely	rely	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	90	upon	upon	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	184	91	building	build	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	92	blocks	block	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	93	long	long	ADV
inlawrev-3967	184	94	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	184	95	uncovered	uncover	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	96	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	97	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	184	98	claimed	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	99	discoveries	discovery	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	100	almost	almost	ADV
inlawrev-3967	184	101	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	102	necessity	necessity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	103	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	184	104	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	184	105	combinations	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	106	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	107	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-3967	184	108	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	109	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	110	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	111	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	112	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	113	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	184	114	already	already	ADV
inlawrev-3967	184	115	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	116	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	117	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	118	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	119	showing	showing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	120	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	121	why	why	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	184	122	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	123	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	124	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	125	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	126	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	127	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	184	128	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	129	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	184	130	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	131	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	132	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	133	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	134	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	135	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	184	136	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	137	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	138	claimed	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	139	combination.50	combination.50	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	184	140	no	no	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	141	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	142	necessary	necessary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	143	inconsistency	inconsistency	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	144	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	145	exists	exist	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	146	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	147	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	148	tsm	tsm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	149	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	150	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	151	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	184	152	looks	look	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	153	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	154	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	155	cited	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	156	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	157	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	158	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	159	teaching	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	160	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	161	suggestion	suggestion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	162	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	163	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	184	164	motivation	motivation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	165	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	166	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-3967	184	167	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	168	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	184	169	modification	modification	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	170	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	171	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	184	172	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	173	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	174	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	175	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	176	graham	graham	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	184	177	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	184	178	later	later	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	179	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	180	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	181	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	184	182	reviewed	review	VERB
inlawrev-3967	184	183	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	184	184	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	184	185	current	current	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	184	186	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	184	187	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	184	188	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	185	1	51	51	NUM
inlawrev-3967	185	2	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-3967	185	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	185	4	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-3967	185	5	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	185	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	185	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	185	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	185	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	185	10	fault	fault	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	185	11	lies	lie	VERB
inlawrev-3967	185	12	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-3967	185	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	186	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	186	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	186	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	186	4	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-3967	186	5	anderson's	anderson's	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	186	6	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	186	7	black	black	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	186	8	rock	rock	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	186	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	186	10	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	186	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	186	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	186	13	396	396	NUM
inlawrev-3967	186	14	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	186	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	186	16	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	186	17	62	62	NUM
inlawrev-3967	186	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	186	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	187	1	42	42	NUM
inlawrev-3967	187	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-3967	187	3	425	425	NUM
inlawrev-3967	187	4	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	187	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	187	6	273	273	NUM
inlawrev-3967	187	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	187	8	1976	1976	NUM
inlawrev-3967	187	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	187	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	188	1	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-3967	188	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	189	1	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	189	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	189	3	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	189	4	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	189	5	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	189	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	190	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	190	2	1740	1740	NUM
inlawrev-3967	190	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	190	4	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	190	5	sakraida	sakraida	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	190	6	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	190	7	ag	ag	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	190	8	pro	pro	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	190	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	190	10	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	190	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	190	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	190	13	425	425	NUM
inlawrev-3967	190	14	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	190	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	190	16	273	273	NUM
inlawrev-3967	190	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	190	18	282	282	NUM
inlawrev-3967	190	19	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	190	20	1976	1976	NUM
inlawrev-3967	190	21	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	190	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	190	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	191	1	44	44	NUM
inlawrev-3967	191	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	192	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	192	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	192	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	192	4	1741	1741	NUM
inlawrev-3967	192	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	193	1	45	45	NUM
inlawrev-3967	193	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	194	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	194	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	194	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	194	4	1740	1740	NUM
inlawrev-3967	194	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	195	1	46	46	NUM
inlawrev-3967	195	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	196	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	196	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	196	3	47	47	NUM
inlawrev-3967	196	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	197	1	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	197	2	1740	1740	NUM
inlawrev-3967	197	3	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	197	4	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-3967	197	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	198	1	48	48	NUM
inlawrev-3967	198	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	199	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	199	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	199	3	49	49	NUM
inlawrev-3967	199	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	200	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	200	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	200	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	200	4	1741	1741	NUM
inlawrev-3967	200	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	201	1	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-3967	201	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	202	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	202	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	202	3	51	51	NUM
inlawrev-3967	202	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	203	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	203	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	203	3	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	203	4	146	146	NUM
inlawrev-3967	203	5	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	203	6	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	203	7	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	204	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	204	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	204	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	205	1	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-3967	205	2	:	:	SYM
inlawrev-3967	205	3	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	205	4	139	139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	205	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	205	6	rigid	rigid	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	205	7	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	205	8	formalistic	formalistic	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	205	9	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	205	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	205	12	tsm	tsm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	13	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	205	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	205	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	205	17	limiting	limiting	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	205	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	205	20	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	205	21	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	22	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	205	23	disregarding	disregarding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	205	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	205	26	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	205	27	diversity	diversity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	205	29	inventive	inventive	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	205	30	pursuits	pursuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	205	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	205	33	modern	modern	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	205	34	technology	technology	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	35	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	205	36	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	205	37	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	205	38	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	39	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	205	40	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	205	41	result.52	result.52	VERB
inlawrev-3967	205	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	205	43	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	44	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-3967	205	45	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-3967	205	46	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	205	47	manifestations	manifestation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	48	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	205	49	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	205	50	principal	principal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	205	51	error	error	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	52	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	205	53	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-3967	205	54	arising	arise	VERB
inlawrev-3967	205	55	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	205	56	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	205	57	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	205	58	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	59	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	205	60	narrow	narrow	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	205	61	interpretation	interpretation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	62	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	205	63	obviousness.53	obviousness.53	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	64	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	205	65	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	205	66	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	205	67	these	these	PRON
inlawrev-3967	205	68	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	205	69	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	205	70	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	71	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	205	72	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	205	73	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	74	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	205	75	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	205	76	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	205	77	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	78	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	205	79	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	205	80	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	81	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	205	82	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	205	83	sought	seek	VERB
inlawrev-3967	205	84	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	205	85	solve	solve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	205	86	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	206	1	54	54	NUM
inlawrev-3967	206	2	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-3967	206	3	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	206	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	206	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	206	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	206	7	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	206	8	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	206	9	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	206	10	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	206	11	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	206	12	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	206	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	206	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	206	15	field	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	206	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	206	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	206	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	207	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	207	2	addressed	address	VERB
inlawrev-3967	207	3	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	207	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	207	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	207	6	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	207	7	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	207	8	]	]	X
inlawrev-3967	207	9	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	207	10	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	207	11	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	207	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	207	13	reason	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	207	14	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	207	15	combining	combine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	207	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	207	17	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	207	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	207	19	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	208	1	55	55	NUM
inlawrev-3967	208	2	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-3967	208	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	208	4	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	208	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	208	6	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	208	8	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	208	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	208	10	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	11	wanted	want	VERB
inlawrev-3967	208	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	208	13	solve	solve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	208	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	208	15	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	208	16	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	17	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	208	18	putting	put	VERB
inlawrev-3967	208	19	together	together	ADP
inlawrev-3967	208	20	items	item	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	21	a	a	PRON
inlawrev-3967	208	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	208	23	b.	b.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	208	24	regardless	regardless	ADV
inlawrev-3967	208	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	208	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	208	27	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	28	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	208	29	resolved	resolved	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	208	30	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	208	32	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	208	33	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	208	34	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	208	35	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	208	36	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	208	37	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	208	38	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	208	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	208	40	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	208	41	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	208	43	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	208	44	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	45	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	208	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	208	47	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	208	48	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	49	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	208	50	putting	put	VERB
inlawrev-3967	208	51	together	together	ADP
inlawrev-3967	208	52	items	item	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	53	a	a	PRON
inlawrev-3967	208	54	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	208	55	b	b	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	56	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	208	57	solve	solve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	208	58	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	208	59	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	208	60	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	61	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	208	62	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	208	63	condition	condition	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	64	appears	appear	VERB
inlawrev-3967	208	65	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	208	66	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	208	67	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	208	68	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	208	69	initial	initial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	208	70	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	71	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	208	72	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	208	73	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	209	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	209	2	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	209	3	error	error	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	209	4	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	209	5	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	209	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	209	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	209	8	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	209	9	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	209	10	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	209	11	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	209	12	assumption	assumption	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	209	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	209	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	209	15	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	209	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	209	17	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	209	18	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	209	19	attempting	attempt	VERB
inlawrev-3967	209	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	209	21	solve	solve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	209	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	209	23	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	209	24	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	209	25	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	209	26	led	lead	VERB
inlawrev-3967	209	27	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-3967	209	28	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	209	29	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	209	30	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	209	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	209	32	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	209	33	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	209	34	designed	design	VERB
inlawrev-3967	209	35	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	209	36	solve	solve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	209	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	209	38	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	209	39	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	209	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	209	41	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	210	1	56	56	NUM
inlawrev-3967	210	2	instead	instead	ADV
inlawrev-3967	210	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	210	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	210	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	6	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-3967	210	7	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	210	8	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	210	9	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	210	10	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	11	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	210	12	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	210	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	210	14	broader	broad	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	210	15	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	210	17	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	210	18	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	210	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	210	21	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	210	23	obviousness.57	obviousness.57	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	210	24	items	item	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	25	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	210	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	210	27	piece	piece	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	210	29	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	210	30	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	31	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	210	32	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	210	33	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	210	34	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	210	35	primary	primary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	210	36	purposes	purpose	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	210	38	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	210	39	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	210	40	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	210	41	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	210	42	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	210	43	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	210	44	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	210	45	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	210	46	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	210	47	uses	use	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	48	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	210	49	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	210	50	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	210	51	enable	enable	VERB
inlawrev-3967	210	52	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	210	53	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	54	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	210	55	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	210	56	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	57	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	210	58	fit	fit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	210	59	together	together	ADV
inlawrev-3967	210	60	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	210	61	teachings	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	62	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	210	63	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	210	64	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	210	65	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	211	1	58	58	NUM
inlawrev-3967	211	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	211	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	211	4	present	present	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	211	5	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	211	7	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-3967	211	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	211	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	211	10	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	211	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	211	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	211	14	asano	asano	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	211	15	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	16	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	211	17	primary	primary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	211	18	solution	solution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	19	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	211	20	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	211	21	directed	direct	VERB
inlawrev-3967	211	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	211	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	211	24	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	25	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	211	26	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	27	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	211	28	immaterial.59	immaterial.59	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	211	29	asano	asano	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	211	30	taught	teach	VERB
inlawrev-3967	211	31	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	211	32	example	example	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	211	34	technology	technology	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	35	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	211	36	here	here	ADV
inlawrev-3967	211	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	211	38	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	211	39	adjustable	adjustable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	211	40	pedal	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	41	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	211	42	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	211	43	fixed	fix	VERB
inlawrev-3967	211	44	pivot	pivot	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	45	point	point	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	46	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	211	47	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	211	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	211	49	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	50	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	211	51	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	211	52	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	53	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	211	54	link	link	VERB
inlawrev-3967	211	55	together	together	ADV
inlawrev-3967	211	56	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	211	57	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	211	58	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	59	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	211	60	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	211	61	taught	teach	VERB
inlawrev-3967	211	62	placing	place	VERB
inlawrev-3967	211	63	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	211	64	sensor	sensor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	65	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	211	66	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	211	67	fixed	fix	VERB
inlawrev-3967	211	68	pivot	pivot	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	69	point	point	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	70	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	211	71	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	211	72	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	211	73	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	211	74	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	75	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	211	76	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	211	77	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	211	78	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	211	79	lead	lead	VERB
inlawrev-3967	211	80	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	211	81	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	211	82	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	212	1	60	60	NUM
inlawrev-3967	212	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	212	3	last	last	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	212	4	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	212	5	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	212	6	error	error	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	212	7	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	212	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	212	9	incorrect	incorrect	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	212	10	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	212	11	drawn	draw	VERB
inlawrev-3967	212	12	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	212	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	212	14	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	212	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	212	16	combating	combat	VERB
inlawrev-3967	212	17	hindsight	hindsight	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	212	18	bias	bias	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	212	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	212	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	212	21	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	212	22	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	212	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	213	1	61	61	NUM
inlawrev-3967	213	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	213	3	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	213	4	long	long	ADV
inlawrev-3967	213	5	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	213	6	axiomatic	axiomatic	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	213	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	213	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	213	9	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	213	10	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	213	11	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	213	12	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	213	13	looked	look	VERB
inlawrev-3967	213	14	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	213	15	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	213	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	213	17	point	point	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	213	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	213	19	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	213	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	213	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	213	22	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	213	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	213	24	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	213	25	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	213	26	without	without	ADP
inlawrev-3967	213	27	reliance	reliance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	213	28	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	213	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	213	30	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	213	31	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	213	32	own	own	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	213	33	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	213	34	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	213	35	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	213	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	214	1	62	62	NUM
inlawrev-3967	214	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	214	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	214	4	spoke	speak	VERB
inlawrev-3967	214	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	214	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	214	7	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	214	8	distortion	distortion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	214	9	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	214	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	214	11	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	214	12	hindsight	hindsight	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	214	13	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	214	14	cause	cause	VERB
inlawrev-3967	214	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	214	16	being	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	214	17	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	214	18	cautious	cautious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	214	19	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	214	20	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-3967	214	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	214	22	reasoning	reasoning	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	214	23	drawn	draw	VERB
inlawrev-3967	214	24	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	214	25	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	214	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	214	27	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	214	28	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	214	29	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	214	30	come	come	VERB
inlawrev-3967	214	31	down	down	ADV
inlawrev-3967	214	32	52	52	NUM
inlawrev-3967	214	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	215	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	215	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	215	3	53	53	NUM
inlawrev-3967	215	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	216	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	216	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	216	3	54	54	NUM
inlawrev-3967	216	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	217	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	217	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	217	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	217	4	1742	1742	NUM
inlawrev-3967	217	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	217	6	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	217	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	217	8	lower	low	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	217	9	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	217	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	217	11	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	217	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	217	13	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	217	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	217	15	v.ksrint'lco	v.ksrint'lco	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	217	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	217	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	217	18	119	119	NUM
inlawrev-3967	217	19	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	217	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	218	1	app'x282,288	app'x282,288	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	218	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	218	3	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	218	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	218	5	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	218	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	218	7	2005	2005	NUM
inlawrev-3967	218	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	218	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	218	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	219	1	55	55	NUM
inlawrev-3967	219	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	220	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	220	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	220	3	56	56	NUM
inlawrev-3967	220	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	221	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	221	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	221	3	57	57	NUM
inlawrev-3967	221	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	222	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	222	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	222	3	58	58	NUM
inlawrev-3967	222	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	223	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	223	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	223	3	59	59	NUM
inlawrev-3967	223	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	224	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	224	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	224	3	60	60	NUM
inlawrev-3967	224	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	225	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	225	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	225	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	225	4	1742	1742	NUM
inlawrev-3967	225	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	225	6	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-3967	225	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	225	8	61	61	NUM
inlawrev-3967	225	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	226	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	226	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	226	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	226	4	1742	1742	NUM
inlawrev-3967	226	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	227	1	62	62	NUM
inlawrev-3967	227	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	228	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	228	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	228	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	228	4	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	228	5	graham	graham	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	228	6	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	228	7	john	john	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	228	8	deere	deere	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	228	9	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	228	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	228	11	383	383	NUM
inlawrev-3967	228	12	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	228	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	228	14	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	228	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	228	16	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-3967	228	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	228	18	1966	1966	NUM
inlawrev-3967	228	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	228	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	228	21	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	228	22	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	228	23	caution	caution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	228	24	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	228	25	using	use	VERB
inlawrev-3967	228	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	228	27	teachings	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	228	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	228	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	228	30	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	228	31	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	228	32	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-3967	228	33	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	228	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	228	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	229	1	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-3967	229	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	229	3	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	229	4	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	229	5	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	229	6	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	229	7	147	147	NUM
inlawrev-3967	229	8	entirely	entirely	ADV
inlawrev-3967	229	9	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	229	10	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	229	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	230	1	63	63	NUM
inlawrev-3967	230	2	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-3967	230	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	230	4	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	230	5	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-3967	230	6	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	230	7	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	230	8	r]igid	r]igid	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	230	9	preventative	preventative	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	230	10	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	230	11	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	230	12	deny	deny	VERB
inlawrev-3967	230	13	factfinders	factfinder	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	230	14	recourse	recourse	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	230	15	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	230	16	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	230	17	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	230	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	231	1	"64	"64	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	232	1	apparently	apparently	ADV
inlawrev-3967	232	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	232	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	232	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	232	5	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	232	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	232	7	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	232	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	232	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	232	10	tsm	tsm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	232	11	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	232	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	232	13	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	232	14	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	232	15	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	232	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	232	17	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	232	18	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	232	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	232	20	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	232	21	violated	violate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	232	22	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	232	23	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	232	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	232	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	232	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	232	27	legitimate	legitimate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	232	28	concern	concern	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	232	29	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	232	30	preventing	prevent	VERB
inlawrev-3967	232	31	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	232	32	ex	ex	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	232	33	post	post	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	232	34	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	232	35	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	232	36	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	232	37	justify	justify	VERB
inlawrev-3967	232	38	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	232	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	233	1	notably	notably	ADV
inlawrev-3967	233	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	233	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	233	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	5	indicated	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	233	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	233	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	233	8	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	233	9	broader	broad	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	233	10	conception	conception	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	233	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	233	13	tsm	tsm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	14	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	15	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	233	16	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	233	17	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	233	18	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	233	19	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	233	20	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	21	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	233	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	233	23	implicit	implicit	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	233	24	motivations	motivation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	25	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	233	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	233	27	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	233	28	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	29	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	233	30	pass	pass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	233	31	muster.65	muster.65	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	233	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	233	33	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	34	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	233	35	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	233	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	233	37	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	233	38	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	39	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	233	40	tsm	tsm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	41	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	42	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	233	43	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-3967	233	44	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	233	45	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	233	46	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	47	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	233	48	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	233	49	consistent	consistent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	233	50	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	233	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	233	52	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	53	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	233	54	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	55	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	56	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	233	57	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	233	58	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	233	59	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	60	essentially	essentially	ADV
inlawrev-3967	233	61	reverted	revert	VERB
inlawrev-3967	233	62	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	233	63	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	233	64	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	65	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	233	66	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	233	67	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	68	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	233	69	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	234	1	66	66	NUM
inlawrev-3967	235	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	235	2	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	235	3	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	235	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	235	5	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	235	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	235	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	235	8	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	235	9	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	235	10	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	235	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	235	12	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	235	13	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	235	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	236	1	67	67	NUM
inlawrev-3967	236	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	236	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	236	4	led	lead	VERB
inlawrev-3967	236	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	236	6	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	236	7	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	236	8	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	236	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	236	10	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	236	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	236	12	desirability	desirability	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	236	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	236	14	electronic	electronic	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	236	15	pedals	pedal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	236	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	236	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	236	18	marketplace	marketplace	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	236	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	236	20	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	236	21	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	236	22	indicating	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	236	23	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	236	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	236	25	do	do	VERB
inlawrev-3967	236	26	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	236	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	236	28	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-3967	236	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	236	30	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	236	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	236	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	236	33	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	236	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	236	35	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	236	36	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	236	37	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	236	38	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-3967	236	39	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	236	40	she	she	PRON
inlawrev-3967	236	41	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	236	42	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	236	43	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	236	44	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	236	45	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	236	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	237	1	68	68	NUM
inlawrev-3967	237	2	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	237	3	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	237	4	position	position	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	237	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	237	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	237	7	references	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	237	8	taught	teach	VERB
inlawrev-3967	237	9	away	away	ADV
inlawrev-3967	237	10	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	237	11	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-3967	237	12	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	237	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	237	14	resulting	result	VERB
inlawrev-3967	237	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	237	16	unobviousness	unobviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	237	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	237	18	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	237	19	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-3967	237	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	237	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	237	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	237	23	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	237	24	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	237	25	no	no	DET
inlawrev-3967	237	26	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	237	27	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	237	28	secondary	secondary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	237	29	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	237	30	indicating	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	237	31	unobviousness	unobviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	237	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	238	1	69	69	NUM
inlawrev-3967	238	2	e.	e.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	238	3	comments	comment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	238	4	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	238	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	238	6	author	author	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	238	7	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	238	8	discussions	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	238	9	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	238	10	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	238	11	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	238	12	practitioners	practitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	238	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	238	14	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	238	15	regard	regard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	238	16	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	238	17	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	238	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	238	19	sea	sea	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	238	20	change	change	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	238	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	238	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	238	23	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	238	24	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	238	25	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	238	26	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	238	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	238	28	both	both	PRON
inlawrev-3967	238	29	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	238	30	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	238	31	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	238	32	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	238	33	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	238	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	238	35	examining	examine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	238	36	corps	corps	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	238	37	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	238	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	238	39	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	238	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	239	1	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	239	2	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	239	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	239	4	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	239	5	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	239	6	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	239	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	239	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	239	9	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	239	10	righting	righting	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	239	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	239	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	239	13	ship	ship	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	239	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	239	15	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	239	16	bringing	bring	VERB
inlawrev-3967	239	17	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	239	18	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	239	19	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	239	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	239	21	patentability	patentability	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	239	22	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-3967	239	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	239	24	line	line	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	239	25	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	239	26	practical	practical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	239	27	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	239	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	239	29	basic	basic	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	239	30	theory	theory	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	239	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	239	32	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	239	33	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	239	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	240	1	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	240	2	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-3967	240	3	dicta	dicta	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	240	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	240	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	240	6	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	240	7	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	240	8	closing	closing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	240	9	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	240	10	suggestive	suggestive	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	240	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	240	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	240	13	ideas	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	240	14	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	240	15	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	240	16	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	240	17	intended	intend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	240	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	240	19	foster	foster	VERB
inlawrev-3967	240	20	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	240	21	we	we	PRON
inlawrev-3967	240	22	build	build	VERB
inlawrev-3967	240	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	240	24	create	create	VERB
inlawrev-3967	240	25	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	240	26	bringing	bring	VERB
inlawrev-3967	240	27	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	240	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	240	29	tangible	tangible	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	240	30	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	240	31	palpable	palpable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	240	32	reality	reality	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	240	33	around	around	ADP
inlawrev-3967	240	34	us	we	PRON
inlawrev-3967	240	35	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	240	36	works	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	240	37	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-3967	240	38	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	240	39	instinct	instinct	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	240	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	240	41	simple	simple	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	240	42	logic	logic	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	240	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	240	44	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	240	45	inferences	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	240	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	240	47	extraordinary	extraordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	240	48	ideas	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	240	49	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	240	50	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	240	51	sometimes	sometimes	ADV
inlawrev-3967	240	52	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-3967	240	53	genius	genius	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	240	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	241	1	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	241	2	advances	advance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	241	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	241	4	once	once	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	241	5	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	241	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	241	7	our	our	PRON
inlawrev-3967	241	8	shared	shared	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	241	9	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	241	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	241	11	define	define	VERB
inlawrev-3967	241	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	241	13	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	241	14	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	241	15	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	241	16	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	241	17	innovation	innovation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	241	18	starts	start	VERB
inlawrev-3967	241	19	once	once	ADV
inlawrev-3967	241	20	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	241	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	242	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	242	2	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	242	3	progress	progress	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	242	4	beginning	begin	VERB
inlawrev-3967	242	5	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	242	6	higher	high	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	242	7	levels	level	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	242	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	242	9	achievement	achievement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	242	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	242	11	expected	expect	VERB
inlawrev-3967	242	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	242	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	242	14	normal	normal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	242	15	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	242	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	242	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	242	18	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	242	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	242	20	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	242	21	innovation	innovation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	242	22	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	242	23	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	242	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	242	25	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	242	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	242	27	exclusive	exclusive	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	242	28	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	242	29	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	242	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	242	31	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	242	32	laws	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	242	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	243	1	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	243	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	243	3	otherwise	otherwise	ADV
inlawrev-3967	243	4	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	243	5	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-3967	243	6	stifle	stifle	VERB
inlawrev-3967	243	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	243	8	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-3967	243	9	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-3967	243	10	promote	promote	VERB
inlawrev-3967	243	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	243	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	243	13	progress	progress	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	243	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	243	15	useful	useful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	243	16	arts	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	243	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	244	1	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	244	2	premises	premise	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	244	3	led	lead	VERB
inlawrev-3967	244	4	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	244	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	244	6	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	244	7	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	244	8	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	244	9	claiming	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	244	10	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	244	11	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	244	12	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	244	13	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-3967	244	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	244	15	hotchkiss	hotchkiss	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	244	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	244	17	codified	codify	VERB
inlawrev-3967	244	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	244	19	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	244	20	103	103	NUM
inlawrev-3967	244	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	245	1	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	245	2	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	245	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	245	4	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	245	5	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	245	6	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	245	7	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	245	8	confined	confine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	245	9	within	within	ADP
inlawrev-3967	245	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	245	11	63	63	NUM
inlawrev-3967	245	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	246	1	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	246	2	1742	1742	NUM
inlawrev-3967	246	3	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	246	4	43	43	NUM
inlawrev-3967	246	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	247	1	64	64	NUM
inlawrev-3967	247	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	248	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	248	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	248	3	65	65	NUM
inlawrev-3967	248	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	249	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	249	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	249	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	249	4	1743	1743	NUM
inlawrev-3967	249	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	250	1	66	66	NUM
inlawrev-3967	250	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	251	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	251	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	251	3	67	67	NUM
inlawrev-3967	251	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	252	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	252	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	252	3	68	68	NUM
inlawrev-3967	252	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	253	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	253	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	253	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	253	4	1744	1744	NUM
inlawrev-3967	253	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	254	1	69	69	NUM
inlawrev-3967	254	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	255	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	255	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	255	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	255	4	1745	1745	NUM
inlawrev-3967	255	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	256	1	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	256	2	148	148	NUM
inlawrev-3967	256	3	indiana	indiana	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	256	4	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	256	5	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	256	6	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	256	7	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	256	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	257	1	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-3967	257	2	:	:	SYM
inlawrev-3967	257	3	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	257	4	139	139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	257	5	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	6	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	257	7	formulation	formulation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	8	too	too	ADV
inlawrev-3967	257	9	constrained	constrain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	257	10	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	257	11	serve	serve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	257	12	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	257	13	purpose	purpose	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	14	70	70	NUM
inlawrev-3967	257	15	some	some	PRON
inlawrev-3967	257	16	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	257	17	say	say	VERB
inlawrev-3967	257	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	257	19	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	257	20	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	21	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	257	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	257	23	progress	progress	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	257	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	257	26	useful	useful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	257	27	arts	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	257	29	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	257	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	257	31	reward	reward	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	32	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	257	33	excellence	excellence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	34	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	257	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	257	36	reflection	reflection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	257	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	257	39	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-3967	257	40	subtle	subtle	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	257	41	change	change	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	257	43	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	44	intended	intend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	257	45	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	257	46	move	move	VERB
inlawrev-3967	257	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	257	48	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	257	49	factfinders	factfinder	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	50	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	257	51	toward	toward	ADP
inlawrev-3967	257	52	sharper	sharp	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	257	53	scrutiny	scrutiny	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	54	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	257	55	inventions	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	257	56	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	257	57	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	257	58	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	257	59	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	257	60	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	257	61	correct	correct	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	257	62	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	258	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-3967	258	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	258	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	258	4	phrase	phrase	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	5	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	258	6	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	258	7	innovation	innovation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	8	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	258	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	258	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	258	11	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	12	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	258	13	rejection	rejection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	258	15	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	16	protection	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	17	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	258	18	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	258	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	258	20	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	258	21	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-3967	258	22	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	258	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	258	24	concern	concern	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	25	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-3967	258	26	stifling	stifle	VERB
inlawrev-3967	258	27	progress	progress	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	258	29	suggests	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-3967	258	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	258	31	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	258	32	author	author	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	33	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	258	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	258	35	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	36	views	view	VERB
inlawrev-3967	258	37	patentable	patentable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	258	38	subject	subject	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	258	39	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	40	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	258	41	inventions	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	42	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	258	43	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	258	44	closer	close	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	258	45	toward	toward	ADP
inlawrev-3967	258	46	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	258	47	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	258	48	flash	flash	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	49	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	258	50	genius	genius	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	51	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	258	52	end	end	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	53	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	258	54	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	258	55	inventive	inventive	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	258	56	spectrum	spectrum	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	258	57	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	259	1	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	259	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	259	3	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	259	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	259	5	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	259	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	259	7	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	259	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	259	9	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	259	10	fewer	few	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	259	11	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	259	12	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	259	13	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	259	14	granted	grant	VERB
inlawrev-3967	259	15	and/or	and/or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	259	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	259	17	granted	grant	VERB
inlawrev-3967	259	18	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	259	19	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	259	20	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	259	21	somewhat	somewhat	ADV
inlawrev-3967	259	22	narrower	narrow	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	259	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	259	24	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	259	25	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	259	26	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	259	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	259	28	extent	extent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	259	29	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	259	30	comparisons	comparison	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	259	31	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	259	32	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	259	33	meaningfully	meaningfully	ADV
inlawrev-3967	259	34	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	259	35	within	within	ADP
inlawrev-3967	259	36	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	259	37	across	across	ADP
inlawrev-3967	259	38	technological	technological	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	259	39	fields	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	259	40	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	259	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	260	1	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	260	2	change	change	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	260	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	260	4	already	already	ADV
inlawrev-3967	260	5	being	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	260	6	seen	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	260	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	260	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	260	9	examination	examination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	260	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	260	11	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	260	12	applications	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	260	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	261	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	261	2	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	261	3	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	261	4	prepared	prepare	VERB
inlawrev-3967	261	5	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	261	6	examination	examination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	261	7	guidelines	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	261	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	261	9	response	response	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	261	10	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	261	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	261	12	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	261	13	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	261	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	261	15	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	261	16	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	261	17	published	publish	VERB
inlawrev-3967	261	18	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-3967	261	19	outside	outside	ADV
inlawrev-3967	261	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	261	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	261	22	survey	survey	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	261	23	period	period	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	261	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	262	1	71	71	NUM
inlawrev-3967	262	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	262	3	guidelines	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	262	4	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	262	5	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	262	6	overview	overview	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	262	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	262	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	262	9	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	262	10	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	262	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	262	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	262	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	262	14	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	262	15	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	262	16	inquiries	inquiry	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	262	17	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-3967	262	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	262	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	262	20	graham	graham	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	262	21	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	262	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	262	23	reaffirmed	reaffirm	VERB
inlawrev-3967	262	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	262	25	ksr.12	ksr.12	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	262	26	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	262	27	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	262	28	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	262	29	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	262	30	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	262	31	hand	hand	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	262	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	262	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	262	34	examiner	examiner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	262	35	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	262	36	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-3967	262	37	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	262	38	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	262	39	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	262	40	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	262	41	exists	exist	VERB
inlawrev-3967	262	42	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	262	43	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-3967	262	44	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	262	45	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	262	46	rejection	rejection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	262	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	263	1	73	73	NUM
inlawrev-3967	264	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	264	2	guidelines	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	264	3	supply	supply	VERB
inlawrev-3967	264	4	seven	seven	NUM
inlawrev-3967	264	5	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	264	6	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	264	7	rationales	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	264	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	264	9	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	264	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	264	11	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	264	12	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-3967	264	13	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	264	14	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	264	15	explanation	explanation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	264	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	264	17	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-3967	264	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	264	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	264	20	context	context	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	264	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	264	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	264	23	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	264	24	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	264	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	265	1	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-3967	265	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	265	3	discussed	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-3967	265	4	briefly	briefly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	265	5	below	below	ADV
inlawrev-3967	265	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	266	1	74	74	NUM
inlawrev-3967	266	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	266	3	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	266	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	266	5	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	266	6	combining	combine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	266	7	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	266	8	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	266	9	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	266	10	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-3967	266	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	266	12	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	266	13	methods	method	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	266	14	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	266	15	yield	yield	VERB
inlawrev-3967	266	16	predictable	predictable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	266	17	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	266	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	266	19	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	267	1	75	75	NUM
inlawrev-3967	267	2	once	once	ADV
inlawrev-3967	267	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	267	4	graham	graham	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	267	5	inquiries	inquiry	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	267	6	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	267	7	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	267	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	267	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	267	10	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	267	11	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	267	12	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	267	13	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	267	14	ruled	rule	VERB
inlawrev-3967	267	15	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	267	16	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	267	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	267	18	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	267	19	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	267	20	shows	show	VERB
inlawrev-3967	267	21	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-3967	267	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	267	23	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	267	24	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	267	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	267	26	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	267	27	further	further	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	267	28	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	267	29	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	267	30	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	267	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	268	1	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	268	2	further	further	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	268	3	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	268	4	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	268	5	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	268	6	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	268	7	1	1	X
inlawrev-3967	268	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	268	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	268	10	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	268	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	268	12	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	268	13	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	268	14	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	268	15	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	268	16	combined	combine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	268	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	268	18	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	268	19	via	via	ADP
inlawrev-3967	268	20	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	268	21	methods	method	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	268	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	268	23	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	268	24	each	each	DET
inlawrev-3967	268	25	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	268	26	merely	merely	ADV
inlawrev-3967	268	27	performing	perform	VERB
inlawrev-3967	268	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	268	29	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	268	30	function	function	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	268	31	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	268	32	did	do	VERB
inlawrev-3967	268	33	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	268	34	separate	separate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	268	35	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	268	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	268	37	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	268	38	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	268	39	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	268	40	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-3967	268	41	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	268	42	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	268	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	268	44	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	268	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	268	46	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	268	47	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	268	48	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	268	49	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	268	50	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	268	51	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	268	52	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	268	53	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	268	54	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	268	55	result(s	result(s	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	268	56	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	268	57	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	268	58	predictable	predictable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	268	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	269	1	76	76	NUM
inlawrev-3967	270	1	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	270	2	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	270	3	appears	appear	VERB
inlawrev-3967	270	4	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	270	5	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	270	6	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	270	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	270	8	previous	previous	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	270	9	bases	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	270	10	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	270	11	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	270	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	271	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	271	2	2	2	X
inlawrev-3967	271	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	271	4	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	271	5	simple	simple	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	271	6	substitution	substitution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	271	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	271	8	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	271	9	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	271	10	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	271	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	271	12	another	another	PRON
inlawrev-3967	271	13	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	271	14	obtain	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	271	15	predictable	predictable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	271	16	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	271	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	271	18	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	272	1	77	77	NUM
inlawrev-3967	272	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	272	3	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	272	4	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-3967	272	5	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-3967	272	6	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	272	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	273	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	273	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	273	3	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	273	4	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	273	5	includes	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	273	6	subject	subject	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	273	7	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	273	8	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	273	9	differs	differ	VERB
inlawrev-3967	273	10	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	273	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	273	12	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	273	13	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	273	14	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-3967	273	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	273	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	273	17	substitution	substitution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	273	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	273	19	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	273	20	components	component	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	273	21	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	273	22	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	273	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	273	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	273	25	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	273	26	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	273	27	substituted	substitute	VERB
inlawrev-3967	273	28	components	component	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	273	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	273	30	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-3967	273	31	70	70	NUM
inlawrev-3967	273	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	274	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	274	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	274	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	274	4	1746	1746	NUM
inlawrev-3967	274	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	274	6	citations	citation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	274	7	omitted	omit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	274	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	274	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	275	1	71	71	NUM
inlawrev-3967	275	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	275	3	examination	examination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	275	4	guidelines	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	275	5	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	275	6	determining	determine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	275	7	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	275	8	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	275	9	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-3967	275	10	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	275	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	275	12	103	103	NUM
inlawrev-3967	275	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	275	14	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	275	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	275	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	275	17	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	275	18	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	275	19	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	275	20	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	275	21	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	275	22	international	international	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	275	23	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	275	24	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	275	25	teleflexlnc	teleflexlnc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	275	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	275	27	72	72	NUM
inlawrev-3967	275	28	fed	feed	VERB
inlawrev-3967	275	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	276	1	reg	reg	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	276	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	277	1	57,526	57,526	NUM
inlawrev-3967	277	2	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	277	3	oct	oct	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	277	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	277	5	10	10	NUM
inlawrev-3967	277	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	277	7	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	277	8	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	278	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	278	2	hereinafter	hereinafter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	278	3	guidelines	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	278	4	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	278	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	279	1	72	72	NUM
inlawrev-3967	279	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	280	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	280	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	280	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	280	4	57,526	57,526	NUM
inlawrev-3967	280	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	280	6	28	28	NUM
inlawrev-3967	280	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	281	1	73	73	NUM
inlawrev-3967	281	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	282	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	282	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	282	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	282	4	57,528	57,528	NUM
inlawrev-3967	282	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	282	6	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	282	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	282	8	key	key	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	282	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	282	10	supporting	support	VERB
inlawrev-3967	282	11	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	282	12	rejection	rejection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	282	13	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	282	14	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-3967	282	15	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	282	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	282	17	103	103	NUM
inlawrev-3967	282	18	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	282	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	282	20	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	282	21	articulation	articulation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	282	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	282	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	282	24	reason(s	reason(s	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	282	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	282	26	why	why	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	282	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	282	28	claimed	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	282	29	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	282	30	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	282	31	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	282	32	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	282	33	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	282	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	282	35	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	282	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	282	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	283	1	74	74	NUM
inlawrev-3967	283	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	284	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	284	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	284	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	284	4	57,529	57,529	NUM
inlawrev-3967	284	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	285	1	75	75	NUM
inlawrev-3967	285	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	286	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	286	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	286	3	76	76	NUM
inlawrev-3967	286	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	287	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	287	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	287	3	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-3967	287	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	288	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	288	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	288	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	288	4	57,530	57,530	NUM
inlawrev-3967	288	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	289	1	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-3967	289	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	289	3	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	289	4	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	289	5	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	289	6	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	289	7	149	149	NUM
inlawrev-3967	289	8	functions	function	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	289	9	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	289	10	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	289	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	289	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	289	13	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	289	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	289	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	289	16	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	289	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	289	18	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	289	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	289	20	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	289	21	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	289	22	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	289	23	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	289	24	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	289	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	289	26	substitution	substitution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	289	27	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	289	28	predictable	predictable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	289	29	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	289	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	289	31	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-3967	289	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	289	33	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	289	34	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	289	35	satisfied	satisfied	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	289	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	290	1	78	78	NUM
inlawrev-3967	290	2	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-3967	290	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	290	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	290	5	analytical	analytical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	290	6	path	path	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	290	7	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	290	8	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	290	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	290	10	existing	exist	VERB
inlawrev-3967	290	11	ideas	idea	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	290	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	290	13	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	290	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	291	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	291	2	3	3	X
inlawrev-3967	291	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	291	4	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	291	5	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	291	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	291	7	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	291	8	technique	technique	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	291	9	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	291	10	improve	improve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	291	11	similar	similar	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	291	12	devices	device	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	291	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	291	14	methods	method	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	291	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	291	16	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	291	17	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	291	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	291	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	291	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	291	21	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	291	22	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	291	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	291	24	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	292	1	79	79	NUM
inlawrev-3967	292	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	292	3	examiner	examiner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	292	4	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	292	5	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	292	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	292	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	292	8	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	292	9	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	292	10	includes	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	292	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	292	12	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	292	13	base	base	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	292	14	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	292	15	device	device	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	292	16	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	292	17	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	292	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	292	19	claimed	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	292	20	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	292	21	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	292	22	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	292	23	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	292	24	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	292	25	improvement	improvement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	292	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	292	27	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	293	1	80	80	NUM
inlawrev-3967	293	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	293	3	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-3967	293	4	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-3967	293	5	something	something	PRON
inlawrev-3967	293	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	293	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	293	8	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	293	9	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	293	10	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	293	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	293	12	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	293	13	comparable	comparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	293	14	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	293	15	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	293	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	293	17	base	base	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	293	18	device	device	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	293	19	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	293	20	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	293	21	improved	improve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	293	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	293	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	293	24	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	293	25	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	293	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	293	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	293	28	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	293	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	293	30	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	293	31	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	293	32	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	293	33	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	293	34	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-3967	293	35	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	293	36	improvement	improvement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	293	37	technique	technique	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	293	38	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	293	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	293	40	base	base	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	293	41	device	device	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	293	42	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	293	43	predictable	predictable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	293	44	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	293	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	293	46	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-3967	293	47	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	293	48	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	293	49	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	293	50	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	293	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	294	1	81	81	NUM
inlawrev-3967	294	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	294	3	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	4	adds	add	VERB
inlawrev-3967	294	5	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	294	6	breadth	breadth	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	294	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	294	9	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	294	10	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	294	12	insofar	insofar	ADV
inlawrev-3967	294	13	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	294	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	294	15	addition	addition	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	294	17	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	294	18	item	item	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	19	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	294	20	comparable	comparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	294	21	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	294	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	294	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	294	24	principal	principal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	25	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	294	26	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	27	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	294	28	improvements	improvement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	294	30	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	294	31	item	item	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	32	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	294	33	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	294	34	step	step	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	35	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-3967	294	36	away	away	ADV
inlawrev-3967	294	37	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	294	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	294	39	evaluation	evaluation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	40	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	294	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	294	42	claimed	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	294	43	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	44	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	45	vis	vis	X
inlawrev-3967	294	46	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	294	47	a	a	X
inlawrev-3967	294	48	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	294	49	vis	vis	X
inlawrev-3967	294	50	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	294	51	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	294	52	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	294	53	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	295	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	295	2	4	4	X
inlawrev-3967	295	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	295	4	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	295	5	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-3967	295	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	295	7	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	295	8	technique	technique	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	295	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	295	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	295	11	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	295	12	device	device	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	295	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	295	14	method	method	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	295	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	295	16	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	295	17	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	295	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	295	19	ready	ready	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	295	20	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	295	21	improvement	improvement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	295	22	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	295	23	yield	yield	VERB
inlawrev-3967	295	24	predictable	predictable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	295	25	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	295	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	295	27	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	296	1	82	82	NUM
inlawrev-3967	296	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	296	3	examiner	examiner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	296	4	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	296	5	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	296	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	296	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	296	8	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	296	9	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	296	10	shows	show	VERB
inlawrev-3967	296	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	296	12	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	296	13	base	base	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	296	14	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	296	15	device	device	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	296	16	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	296	17	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	296	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	296	19	claimed	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	296	20	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	296	21	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	296	22	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	296	23	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	296	24	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	296	25	improvement	improvement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	296	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	296	27	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	297	1	83	83	NUM
inlawrev-3967	297	2	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-3967	297	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	297	4	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	297	5	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-3967	297	6	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-3967	297	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	297	8	technique	technique	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	297	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	297	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	297	11	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	297	12	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	297	13	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	297	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	297	15	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	297	16	applicable	applicable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	297	17	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	297	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	297	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	297	20	base	base	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	297	21	device	device	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	297	22	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	297	23	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	297	24	predictable	predictable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	297	25	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	297	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	297	27	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	297	28	improved	improved	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	297	29	system	system	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	297	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	297	31	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	297	32	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	297	33	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	297	34	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	297	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	298	1	84	84	NUM
inlawrev-3967	298	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	298	3	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	298	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	298	5	closely	closely	ADV
inlawrev-3967	298	6	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	298	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	298	8	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	298	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	298	10	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-3967	298	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	298	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	298	13	above	above	ADV
inlawrev-3967	298	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	298	15	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	298	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	298	17	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	298	18	clearly	clearly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	298	19	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	298	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	298	21	principal	principal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	298	22	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	298	23	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	298	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	298	25	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	298	26	relationship	relationship	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	298	27	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	298	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	298	29	claimed	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	298	30	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	298	31	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	298	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	299	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	299	2	5	5	NUM
inlawrev-3967	299	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	299	4	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	299	5	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	299	6	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	299	7	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	299	8	try'—choosing	try'—choose	VERB
inlawrev-3967	299	9	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	299	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	299	11	finite	finite	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	299	12	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	299	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	299	14	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-3967	299	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	299	16	predictable	predictable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	299	17	solutions	solution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	299	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	299	19	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	299	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	299	21	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	299	22	expectation	expectation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	299	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	299	24	success	success	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	299	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	299	26	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	300	1	85	85	NUM
inlawrev-3967	300	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	300	3	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	300	4	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-3967	300	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	300	6	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	300	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	300	8	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-3967	300	9	was	be	VERB
inlawrev-3967	300	10	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	300	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	300	12	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	300	13	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	300	14	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	300	15	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	300	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	300	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	300	18	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	300	19	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	300	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	300	21	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	300	22	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	300	23	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	300	24	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	300	25	design	design	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	300	26	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	300	27	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	300	28	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	300	29	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	300	30	market	market	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	300	31	pressure	pressure	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	300	32	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	300	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	300	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	301	1	86	86	NUM
inlawrev-3967	301	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	301	3	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-3967	301	4	are	be	VERB
inlawrev-3967	301	5	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	301	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	301	7	finite	finite	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	301	8	number	number	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	301	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	301	10	identified	identify	VERB
inlawrev-3967	301	11	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	301	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	301	13	]	]	X
inlawrev-3967	301	14	predictable	predictable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	301	15	solutions	solution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	301	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	301	17	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	301	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	301	19	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	301	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	301	21	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	301	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	301	23	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	301	24	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	301	25	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	301	26	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	301	27	tried	try	VERB
inlawrev-3967	301	28	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	301	29	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	301	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	301	31	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	301	32	expectation	expectation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	301	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	301	34	success	success	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	301	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	301	36	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-3967	301	37	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	301	38	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	301	39	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	301	40	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	301	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	302	1	87	87	NUM
inlawrev-3967	302	2	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-3967	302	3	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	302	4	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-3967	302	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	302	6	most	most	ADV
inlawrev-3967	302	7	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	302	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	302	9	broadening	broaden	VERB
inlawrev-3967	302	10	change	change	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	302	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	302	12	examination	examination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	302	13	practice	practice	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	302	14	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	302	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	302	16	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	302	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	302	18	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	302	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	302	20	allegation	allegation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	302	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	302	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	302	23	solution	solution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	302	24	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	302	25	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	302	26	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	302	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	302	28	try	try	VERB
inlawrev-3967	302	29	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	302	30	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	302	31	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	302	32	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	302	33	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	302	34	proper	proper	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	302	35	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	302	36	criterion	criterion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	302	37	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	302	38	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	302	39	78	78	NUM
inlawrev-3967	302	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	303	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	303	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	303	3	79	79	NUM
inlawrev-3967	303	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	304	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	304	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	304	3	80	80	NUM
inlawrev-3967	304	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	305	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	305	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	305	3	81	81	NUM
inlawrev-3967	305	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	306	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	306	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	306	3	82	82	NUM
inlawrev-3967	306	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	307	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	307	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	307	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	307	4	57,531	57,531	NUM
inlawrev-3967	307	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	308	1	83	83	NUM
inlawrev-3967	308	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	309	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	309	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	309	3	84	84	NUM
inlawrev-3967	309	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	310	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	310	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	310	3	85	85	NUM
inlawrev-3967	310	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	311	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	311	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	311	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	311	4	57,532	57,532	NUM
inlawrev-3967	311	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	312	1	86	86	NUM
inlawrev-3967	312	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	313	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	313	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	313	3	87	87	NUM
inlawrev-3967	313	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	314	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	314	2	d.	d.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	314	3	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	314	4	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	314	5	50	50	NUM
inlawrev-3967	314	6	indiana	indiana	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	314	7	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	314	8	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	315	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	315	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	315	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	316	1	41:1139	41:1139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	316	2	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	316	3	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	316	4	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	316	5	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-3967	316	6	least	least	ADV
inlawrev-3967	316	7	twenty	twenty	NUM
inlawrev-3967	316	8	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	316	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	317	1	88	88	NUM
inlawrev-3967	317	2	now	now	ADV
inlawrev-3967	317	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	317	4	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-3967	317	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	317	6	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	317	7	ksr*9	ksr*9	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	317	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	317	9	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	317	10	guidelines	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	317	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	317	12	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	317	13	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	317	14	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	317	15	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	317	16	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	317	17	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	317	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	317	19	try	try	VERB
inlawrev-3967	317	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	317	21	patentee	patentee	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	317	22	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	317	23	solution	solution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	317	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	317	25	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	317	26	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	317	27	sufficient	sufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	317	28	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	317	29	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	317	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	318	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	318	2	6	6	NUM
inlawrev-3967	318	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	318	4	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	318	5	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	318	6	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	318	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	318	8	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	318	9	field	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	318	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	318	11	endeavor	endeavor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	318	12	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	318	13	prompt	prompt	VERB
inlawrev-3967	318	14	variations	variation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	318	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	318	16	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	318	17	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	318	18	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	318	19	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	318	20	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	318	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	318	22	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	318	23	field	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	318	24	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	318	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	318	26	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	318	27	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	318	28	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-3967	318	29	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	318	30	design	design	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	318	31	incentives	incentive	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	318	32	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	318	33	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	318	34	market	market	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	318	35	forces	force	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	318	36	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	318	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	318	38	variations	variation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	318	39	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	318	40	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	318	41	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	318	42	predictable	predictable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	318	43	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	318	44	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	318	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	318	46	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	318	47	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	318	48	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	318	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	318	50	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	318	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	318	52	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	319	1	90	90	NUM
inlawrev-3967	319	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	319	3	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	319	4	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	319	5	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	319	6	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-3967	319	7	something	something	PRON
inlawrev-3967	319	8	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	319	9	analogous	analogous	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	319	10	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	319	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	319	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	319	13	applicant	applicant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	319	14	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	319	15	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	319	16	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	319	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	319	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	319	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	319	20	examiner	examiner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	319	21	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	319	22	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	319	23	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	319	24	design	design	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	319	25	incentives	incentive	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	319	26	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	319	27	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	319	28	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	319	29	market	market	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	319	30	forces	force	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	319	31	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	319	32	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	319	33	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	319	34	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	319	35	encouraged	encourage	VERB
inlawrev-3967	319	36	changing	change	VERB
inlawrev-3967	319	37	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	319	38	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	319	39	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	319	40	item	item	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	319	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	320	1	91	91	NUM
inlawrev-3967	321	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	321	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	321	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	321	4	addition	addition	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	321	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	321	7	examiner	examiner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	8	finds	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	321	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	321	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	321	11	differences	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	12	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-3967	321	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	321	14	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	321	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	321	17	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	321	18	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	19	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	321	20	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	321	21	variations	variation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	22	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	321	23	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	321	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	321	26	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	321	27	principle	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	28	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	321	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	321	30	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	321	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	321	32	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	321	34	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	321	35	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	36	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	321	37	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	321	38	such	such	DET
inlawrev-3967	321	39	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	321	40	predictable	predictable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	321	41	variation	variation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	321	43	light	light	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	321	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	321	46	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	321	47	incentives	incentive	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	48	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	321	49	forces	force	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	50	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	321	51	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-3967	321	52	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	321	53	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	321	54	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	321	55	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	321	56	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	322	1	92	92	NUM
inlawrev-3967	322	2	until	until	ADP
inlawrev-3967	322	3	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	322	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	322	5	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	322	6	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	322	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	322	8	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	322	9	technical	technical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	322	10	field	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	322	11	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	322	12	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-3967	322	13	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	322	14	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-3967	322	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	322	16	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	322	17	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	322	18	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	322	19	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	322	20	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	322	21	concerned	concern	VERB
inlawrev-3967	322	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	322	23	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	322	24	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	322	25	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	322	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	322	27	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	322	28	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	322	29	concerned	concern	VERB
inlawrev-3967	322	30	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	322	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	322	32	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	322	33	analogous	analogous	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	322	34	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	322	35	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	322	36	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	322	37	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	322	38	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	323	1	93	93	NUM
inlawrev-3967	323	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	323	3	traditional	traditional	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	323	4	approach	approach	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	323	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	323	6	recognizing	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	323	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	323	8	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-3967	323	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	323	10	hypothetical	hypothetical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	323	11	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	323	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	323	13	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	323	14	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	323	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	323	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	323	17	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	323	18	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	323	19	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	323	20	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	323	21	charged	charge	VERB
inlawrev-3967	323	22	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	323	23	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	323	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	323	25	all	all	DET
inlawrev-3967	323	26	fields	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	323	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	323	28	appears	appear	VERB
inlawrev-3967	323	29	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	323	30	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	323	31	severely	severely	ADV
inlawrev-3967	323	32	weakened	weaken	VERB
inlawrev-3967	323	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	323	34	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	323	35	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	323	36	eliminated	eliminate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	323	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	323	38	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	323	39	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	323	40	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	323	41	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	323	42	examination	examination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	323	43	guidelines	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	323	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	324	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	324	2	7	7	NUM
inlawrev-3967	324	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	324	4	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	324	5	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	324	6	teaching	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	324	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	324	8	suggestion	suggestion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	324	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	324	10	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	324	11	motivation	motivation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	324	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	324	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	324	14	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	324	15	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	324	16	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	324	17	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	324	18	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	324	19	led	lead	VERB
inlawrev-3967	324	20	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	324	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	324	22	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	324	23	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	324	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	324	25	modify	modify	VERB
inlawrev-3967	324	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	324	27	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	324	28	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	324	29	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	324	30	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	324	31	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	324	32	combine	combine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	324	33	prior	prior	ADV
inlawrev-3967	324	34	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	324	35	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	324	36	teachings	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	324	37	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	324	38	arrive	arrive	VERB
inlawrev-3967	324	39	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	324	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	324	41	claimed	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	324	42	invention	invention	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	324	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	324	44	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	325	1	94	94	NUM
inlawrev-3967	325	2	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	325	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	325	4	examiner	examiner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	5	finds	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	325	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	325	7	teaching	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	325	9	suggestion	suggestion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	325	11	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	325	12	motivation	motivation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	13	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	325	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	325	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	325	16	cited	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	325	17	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	325	18	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	19	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	325	20	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	21	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-3967	325	22	available	available	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	325	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	325	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	325	25	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	26	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	325	27	modify	modify	VERB
inlawrev-3967	325	28	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	325	29	combine	combine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	325	30	reference	reference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	31	teachings	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	325	33	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	325	34	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-3967	325	35	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	325	36	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	325	37	reasonable	reasonable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	325	38	expectation	expectation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	325	40	success	success	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	325	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	325	43	modification	modification	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	44	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	325	45	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	325	47	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	325	48	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	49	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	325	50	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	325	51	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	325	52	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	325	53	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	325	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	326	1	95	95	NUM
inlawrev-3967	327	1	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-3967	327	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	327	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	327	4	pre	pre	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	327	5	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	327	6	ksr	ksr	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	327	7	tsm	tsm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	327	8	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	327	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	327	10	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	327	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	327	12	familiar	familiar	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	327	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	327	14	all	all	DET
inlawrev-3967	327	15	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	327	16	practitioners	practitioner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	327	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	327	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	327	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	327	20	rigid	rigid	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	327	21	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	327	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	327	23	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	327	24	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	327	25	struck	strike	VERB
inlawrev-3967	327	26	down	down	ADP
inlawrev-3967	327	27	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	327	28	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	327	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	328	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	328	2	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	328	3	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	328	4	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	328	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	328	6	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	328	7	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	328	8	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	328	9	foreclose	foreclose	VERB
inlawrev-3967	328	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	328	11	flexible	flexible	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	328	12	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	328	13	open	open	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	328	14	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	328	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	328	16	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	328	17	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	328	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	329	1	96	96	NUM
inlawrev-3967	329	2	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	329	3	inclusion	inclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	329	4	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	329	5	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	329	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	329	7	seven	seven	NUM
inlawrev-3967	329	8	rationales	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	329	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	329	10	88	88	NUM
inlawrev-3967	329	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	330	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	330	2	2	2	NUM
inlawrev-3967	330	3	donald	donald	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	330	4	s.chisum	s.chisum	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	330	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	330	6	chisum	chisum	VERB
inlawrev-3967	330	7	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	330	8	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	330	9	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	330	10	5.04[l][f][i]-[iv	5.04[l][f][i]-[iv	NUM
inlawrev-3967	330	11	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	330	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	330	13	1998	1998	NUM
inlawrev-3967	330	14	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	330	15	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	330	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	1	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	331	2	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	4	discussing	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-3967	331	5	and/or	and/or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	331	6	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	331	7	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	331	8	alia	alia	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	331	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	331	10	re	re	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	11	o'farrell	o'farrell	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	13	853	853	NUM
inlawrev-3967	331	14	f.2d	f.2d	SYM
inlawrev-3967	331	15	894	894	NUM
inlawrev-3967	331	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	17	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	19	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	20	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	21	1988	1988	NUM
inlawrev-3967	331	22	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	23	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	331	25	re	re	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	26	yates	yates	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	28	663	663	NUM
inlawrev-3967	331	29	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	331	30	1054	1054	NUM
inlawrev-3967	331	31	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	32	c.c.p.a	c.c.p.a	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	33	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	34	1981	1981	NUM
inlawrev-3967	331	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	36	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	37	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	331	38	re	re	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	331	39	lindel	lindel	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	41	385	385	NUM
inlawrev-3967	331	42	f.2d	f.2d	ADP
inlawrev-3967	331	43	453	453	NUM
inlawrev-3967	331	44	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	45	c.c.p.a	c.c.p.a	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	46	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	47	1967	1967	NUM
inlawrev-3967	331	48	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	49	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	50	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	331	51	re	re	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	331	52	huellmantel	huellmantel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	331	53	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	54	324	324	NUM
inlawrev-3967	331	55	f.2d	f.2d	ADP
inlawrev-3967	331	56	998	998	NUM
inlawrev-3967	331	57	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	58	c.c.p.a	c.c.p.a	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	59	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	331	60	1963	1963	NUM
inlawrev-3967	331	61	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	331	62	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	332	1	89	89	NUM
inlawrev-3967	332	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	333	1	ksrint'lco	ksrint'lco	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	333	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	334	1	v.teleflexinc	v.teleflexinc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	334	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	334	3	127s.q	127s.q	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	334	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	335	1	1727	1727	NUM
inlawrev-3967	335	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	335	3	1742	1742	NUM
inlawrev-3967	335	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	335	5	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	335	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	335	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	335	8	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	335	9	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	335	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	335	11	person	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	335	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	335	13	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	335	14	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	335	15	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	335	16	good	good	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	335	17	reason	reason	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	335	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	335	19	pursue	pursue	VERB
inlawrev-3967	335	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	335	21	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	335	22	options	option	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	335	23	within	within	ADP
inlawrev-3967	335	24	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-3967	335	25	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	335	26	her	her	PRON
inlawrev-3967	335	27	technical	technical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	335	28	grasp	grasp	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	335	29	...	...	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	335	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	335	31	anticipated	anticipated	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	335	32	success	success	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	335	33	...	...	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	335	34	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	335	35	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	335	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	335	37	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	335	38	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	335	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	335	40	innovation	innovation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	335	41	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	335	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	335	43	ordinary	ordinary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	335	44	skill	skill	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	335	45	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	335	46	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	335	47	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	335	48	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	336	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	336	2	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	336	3	instance	instance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	336	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	336	5	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	336	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	336	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	336	8	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	336	9	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	336	10	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	336	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	336	12	try	try	VERB
inlawrev-3967	336	13	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-3967	336	14	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-3967	336	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	336	16	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	336	17	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	336	18	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	336	19	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	336	20	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	336	21	103	103	NUM
inlawrev-3967	336	22	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	336	23	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	336	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	337	1	90	90	NUM
inlawrev-3967	337	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	337	3	guidelines	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	337	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	337	5	72	72	NUM
inlawrev-3967	337	6	fed	feed	VERB
inlawrev-3967	337	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	338	1	reg	reg	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	338	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	339	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	339	2	57,533	57,533	NUM
inlawrev-3967	339	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	339	4	91	91	NUM
inlawrev-3967	339	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	340	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	340	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	340	3	92	92	NUM
inlawrev-3967	340	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	341	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	341	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	341	3	93	93	NUM
inlawrev-3967	341	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	342	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	342	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	342	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-3967	342	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	342	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	342	6	re	re	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	342	7	oetiker	oetiker	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	342	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	342	9	977	977	NUM
inlawrev-3967	342	10	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	342	11	1443	1443	NUM
inlawrev-3967	342	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	342	13	1446	1446	NUM
inlawrev-3967	342	14	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	342	15	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	342	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	342	17	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	342	18	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	342	19	1992	1992	NUM
inlawrev-3967	342	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	342	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	343	1	94	94	NUM
inlawrev-3967	343	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	344	1	guidelines	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	344	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	344	3	72	72	NUM
inlawrev-3967	344	4	fed	feed	VERB
inlawrev-3967	344	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	345	1	reg	reg	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	345	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	346	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	346	2	57,534	57,534	NUM
inlawrev-3967	346	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	346	4	95	95	NUM
inlawrev-3967	346	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	347	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	347	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	347	3	96	96	NUM
inlawrev-3967	347	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	348	1	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	348	2	int'l	int'l	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	348	3	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	348	4	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	348	5	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	348	6	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	348	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	348	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	348	9	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	348	10	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	348	11	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	348	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	348	13	1727	1727	NUM
inlawrev-3967	348	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	348	15	1743	1743	NUM
inlawrev-3967	348	16	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	348	17	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	348	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	348	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	349	1	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-3967	349	2	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	349	3	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	349	4	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	349	5	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	349	6	1151	1151	NUM
inlawrev-3967	349	7	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	349	8	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	349	9	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-3967	349	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	349	11	starkest	stark	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	349	12	indication	indication	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	349	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	349	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	349	15	broad	broad	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	349	16	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	349	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	349	18	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	349	19	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	349	20	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	349	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	349	22	offing	offing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	349	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	349	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	349	25	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	349	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	350	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	350	2	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	350	3	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	350	4	examination	examination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	350	5	guidelines	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	350	6	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	350	7	briefly	briefly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	350	8	discuss	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-3967	350	9	rebuttal	rebuttal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	350	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	350	11	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	350	12	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	350	13	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	350	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	350	15	focusing	focus	VERB
inlawrev-3967	350	16	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	350	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	350	18	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	350	19	applicants	applicant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	350	20	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	350	21	offer	offer	VERB
inlawrev-3967	350	22	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	350	23	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	350	24	regard	regard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	350	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	351	1	97	97	NUM
inlawrev-3967	351	2	notably	notably	ADV
inlawrev-3967	351	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	351	4	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	351	5	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	351	6	focuses	focus	VERB
inlawrev-3967	351	7	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	351	8	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	351	9	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	351	10	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	351	11	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	351	12	rebut	rebut	VERB
inlawrev-3967	351	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	351	14	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	351	15	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	351	16	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	351	17	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	351	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	351	19	examiner	examiner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	351	20	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	351	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	351	22	graham	graham	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	351	23	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	351	24	inquiries	inquiry	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	351	25	and/or	and/or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	351	26	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	351	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	351	28	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	351	29	needed	need	VERB
inlawrev-3967	351	30	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	351	31	establish	establish	VERB
inlawrev-3967	351	32	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	351	33	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	351	34	rationale	rationale	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	351	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	352	1	98	98	NUM
inlawrev-3967	352	2	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	352	3	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	352	4	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	352	5	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	352	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	352	7	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	352	8	secondary	secondary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	352	9	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	352	10	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	352	11	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	352	12	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	352	13	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	352	14	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	352	15	like	like	ADP
inlawrev-3967	352	16	commercial	commercial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	352	17	success	success	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	352	18	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	352	19	failure	failure	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	352	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	352	21	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	352	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	353	1	99	99	NUM
inlawrev-3967	353	2	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-3967	353	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	353	4	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	353	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	353	6	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	353	7	showing	show	VERB
inlawrev-3967	353	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	353	9	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	353	10	methods	method	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	353	11	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	353	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	353	13	achieve	achieve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	353	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	353	15	proposed	propose	VERB
inlawrev-3967	353	16	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	353	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	353	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	353	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	353	20	combined	combined	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	353	21	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	353	22	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	353	23	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	353	24	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	353	25	merely	merely	ADV
inlawrev-3967	353	26	perform	perform	VERB
inlawrev-3967	353	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	353	28	function	function	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	353	29	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	353	30	each	each	DET
inlawrev-3967	353	31	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	353	32	performs	perform	VERB
inlawrev-3967	353	33	separately	separately	ADV
inlawrev-3967	353	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	353	35	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	353	36	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	353	37	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	353	38	unexpected	unexpected	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	353	39	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	353	40	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	353	41	obtained	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	353	42	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	353	43	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	353	44	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	353	45	offered	offer	VERB
inlawrev-3967	353	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	354	1	100	100	NUM
inlawrev-3967	354	2	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-3967	354	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	354	4	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	354	5	a	a	X
inlawrev-3967	354	6	]	]	X
inlawrev-3967	354	7	mere	mere	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	354	8	statement	statement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	354	9	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	354	10	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	354	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	354	12	the	the	PRON
inlawrev-3967	354	13	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	354	14	pto	pto	X
inlawrev-3967	354	15	]	]	X
inlawrev-3967	354	16	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	354	17	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	354	18	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-3967	354	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	354	20	prima	prima	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	354	21	facie	facie	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	354	22	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	354	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	354	24	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	354	25	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	354	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	354	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	354	28	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	354	29	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	354	30	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	354	31	]	]	X
inlawrev-3967	354	32	reliance	reliance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	354	33	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	354	34	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	354	35	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	354	36	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	354	37	unsupported	unsupported	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	354	38	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	354	39	documentary	documentary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	354	40	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	354	41	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	354	42	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	354	43	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	354	44	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	354	45	substantively	substantively	ADV
inlawrev-3967	354	46	adequate	adequate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	354	47	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	354	48	rebut	rebut	VERB
inlawrev-3967	354	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	354	50	rejection	rejection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	354	51	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	354	52	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	354	53	effective	effective	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	354	54	traverse	traverse	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	354	55	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	354	56	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	354	57	rejection	rejection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	354	58	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	354	59	37	37	NUM
inlawrev-3967	354	60	cfr	cfr	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	354	61	1.1	1.1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	354	62	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	354	63	1(b	1(b	NUM
inlawrev-3967	354	64	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	354	65	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	355	1	101	101	NUM
inlawrev-3967	355	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	355	3	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	355	4	guideline	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	355	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	355	6	interpreted	interpret	VERB
inlawrev-3967	355	7	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-3967	355	8	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	355	9	mean	mean	VERB
inlawrev-3967	355	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	355	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	355	12	mere	mere	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	355	13	allegation	allegation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	355	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	355	15	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	355	16	failures	failure	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	355	17	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	355	18	insufficient	insufficient	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	355	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	355	20	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-3967	355	21	no	no	DET
inlawrev-3967	355	22	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	355	23	change	change	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	355	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	355	25	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	355	26	appears	appear	VERB
inlawrev-3967	355	27	indicated	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	355	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	356	1	102	102	NUM
inlawrev-3967	356	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	356	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	356	4	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	356	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	356	6	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	356	7	hand	hand	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	356	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	356	9	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	356	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	356	11	strictly	strictly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	356	12	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	356	13	severely	severely	ADV
inlawrev-3967	356	14	interpreted	interpret	VERB
inlawrev-3967	356	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	356	16	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	356	17	appears	appear	VERB
inlawrev-3967	356	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	356	19	declaration	declaration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	356	20	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	356	21	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	356	22	documentary	documentary	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	356	23	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	356	24	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	356	25	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	356	26	required	require	VERB
inlawrev-3967	356	27	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	356	28	most	most	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	356	29	responses	response	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	356	30	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	356	31	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	356	32	rejections	rejection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	356	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	357	1	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	357	2	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	357	3	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	357	4	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	357	5	guidelines	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	357	6	indicate	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	357	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	357	8	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-3967	357	9	broader	broad	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	357	10	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	357	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	357	12	obviousness	obviousness	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	357	13	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	357	14	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	357	15	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	357	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	357	17	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	357	18	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	357	19	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-3967	357	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	357	21	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	357	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	357	23	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	357	24	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	357	25	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	357	26	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-3967	357	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	357	28	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	357	29	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	357	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	358	1	examiners	examiner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	358	2	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	358	3	continue	continue	VERB
inlawrev-3967	358	4	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	358	5	rely	rely	VERB
inlawrev-3967	358	6	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	358	7	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-3967	358	8	own	own	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	358	9	assessment	assessment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	358	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	358	11	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	358	12	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	358	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	358	14	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	358	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	358	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	358	17	wide	wide	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	358	18	field	field	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	358	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	358	20	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	358	21	art	art	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	358	22	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	358	23	attack	attack	VERB
inlawrev-3967	358	24	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	358	25	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	358	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	359	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	359	2	examiner	examiner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	359	3	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	359	4	job	job	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	359	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	359	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	359	7	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	359	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	359	9	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	359	10	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	359	11	allow	allow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	359	12	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	359	13	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	359	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	359	15	patentable	patentable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	359	16	merit	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	359	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	359	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	359	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	359	20	reject	reject	VERB
inlawrev-3967	359	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	359	22	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	359	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	360	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	360	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	360	3	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	360	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	360	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	360	6	obviousness	obviousness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	360	7	hurdle	hurdle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	360	8	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	360	9	now	now	ADV
inlawrev-3967	360	10	significantly	significantly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	360	11	higher	high	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	360	12	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	360	13	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	360	14	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	360	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	360	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	360	17	applicants	applicant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	360	18	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	360	19	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	360	20	substantially	substantially	ADV
inlawrev-3967	360	21	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-3967	360	22	difficult	difficult	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	360	23	tasks	task	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	360	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	360	25	terms	term	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	360	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	360	27	preparing	prepare	VERB
inlawrev-3967	360	28	applications	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	360	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	360	30	offering	offer	VERB
inlawrev-3967	360	31	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	360	32	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	360	33	arguments	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	360	34	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	360	35	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	360	36	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	360	37	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-3967	360	38	prosecution	prosecution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	360	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	361	1	97	97	NUM
inlawrev-3967	361	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	361	3	guidelines	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	361	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	361	5	72	72	NUM
inlawrev-3967	361	6	fed	feed	VERB
inlawrev-3967	361	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	362	1	reg	reg	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	362	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	363	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	363	2	57,534	57,534	NUM
inlawrev-3967	363	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	363	4	98	98	NUM
inlawrev-3967	363	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	364	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	364	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	364	3	99	99	NUM
inlawrev-3967	364	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	365	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	365	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	365	3	100	100	NUM
inlawrev-3967	365	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	366	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	366	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	366	3	101	101	NUM
inlawrev-3967	366	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	367	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	367	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	367	3	102	102	NUM
inlawrev-3967	367	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	368	1	note	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	368	2	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	368	3	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	368	4	guidelines	guideline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	368	5	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	368	6	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	368	7	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	368	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	368	9	harmony	harmony	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	368	10	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	368	11	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	368	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	368	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	368	14	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	368	15	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	368	16	require	require	VERB
inlawrev-3967	368	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	368	18	examiner	examiner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	368	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	368	20	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	368	21	documentation	documentation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	368	22	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	368	23	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-3967	368	24	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	368	25	her	her	PRON
inlawrev-3967	368	26	views	view	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	368	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	369	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	369	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	369	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-3967	369	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	369	5	37	37	NUM
inlawrev-3967	369	6	c.f.r	c.f.r	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	369	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	370	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	370	2	1.104(d)(2	1.104(d)(2	NUM
inlawrev-3967	370	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	370	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	370	5	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	370	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	370	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	370	8	requiring	require	VERB
inlawrev-3967	370	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	370	10	examiner	examiner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	370	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	370	12	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	370	13	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	370	14	affidavit	affidavit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	370	15	concerning	concern	VERB
inlawrev-3967	370	16	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	370	17	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	370	18	information	information	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	370	19	within	within	ADP
inlawrev-3967	370	20	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-3967	370	21	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	370	22	her	her	PRON
inlawrev-3967	370	23	own	own	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	370	24	knowledge	knowledge	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	370	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	370	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	371	1	1152	1152	NUM
inlawrev-3967	371	2	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	371	3	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	371	4	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	371	5	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	371	6	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	371	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	372	1	41:1139	41:1139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	372	2	n.	n.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	3	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	4	standards	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	5	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	372	6	inre	inre	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	372	7	seagate	seagate	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	372	8	technology	technology	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	372	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	372	10	llcm	llcm	VERB
inlawrev-3967	372	11	another	another	DET
inlawrev-3967	372	12	long	long	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	372	13	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	372	14	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	15	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	372	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	372	18	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	19	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	20	reviewed	review	VERB
inlawrev-3967	372	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	372	22	overhauled	overhaul	VERB
inlawrev-3967	372	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	372	24	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	372	25	concerns	concern	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	372	27	standards	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	28	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	372	29	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	372	30	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	372	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	372	33	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	34	willful	willful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	372	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	372	36	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	372	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	372	38	accompanying	accompanying	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	372	39	potential	potential	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	40	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	372	41	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	372	42	award	award	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	372	44	increased	increase	VERB
inlawrev-3967	372	45	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	46	and/or	and/or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	372	47	attorney	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	48	fees	fee	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	372	49	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	373	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	373	2	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	373	3	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	373	4	permits	permit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	373	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	373	6	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	373	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	373	8	increase	increase	VERB
inlawrev-3967	373	9	actual	actual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	373	10	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	373	11	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	373	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	373	13	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	373	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	373	15	up	up	ADP
inlawrev-3967	373	16	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	373	17	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-3967	373	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	373	19	104	104	NUM
inlawrev-3967	373	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	373	21	although	although	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	373	22	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	373	23	specified	specify	VERB
inlawrev-3967	373	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	373	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	373	26	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	373	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	373	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	373	29	existence	existence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	373	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	373	31	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	373	32	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	373	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	373	34	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	373	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	373	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	373	37	infringer	infringer	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	373	38	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	373	39	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	373	40	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-3967	373	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	373	42	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	373	43	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	373	44	invocation	invocation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	373	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	373	46	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	373	47	enhanced	enhanced	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	373	48	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	373	49	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	374	1	105	105	NUM
inlawrev-3967	374	2	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-3967	374	3	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	374	4	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	374	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	374	6	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	374	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	374	8	enhanced	enhance	VERB
inlawrev-3967	374	9	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	374	10	need	need	AUX
inlawrev-3967	374	11	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	374	12	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	374	13	awarded	award	VERB
inlawrev-3967	374	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	374	15	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	374	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	374	17	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	374	18	uses	use	VERB
inlawrev-3967	374	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	374	20	permissive	permissive	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	374	21	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	374	22	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	374	23	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	374	24	concerning	concern	VERB
inlawrev-3967	374	25	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	374	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	375	1	106	106	NUM
inlawrev-3967	376	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	376	2	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	376	3	act	act	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	376	4	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	376	5	permits	permit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	376	6	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	376	7	award	award	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	376	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	376	9	attorney	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	376	10	fees	fee	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	376	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	376	12	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	376	13	exceptional	exceptional	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	376	14	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	376	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	376	16	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	376	17	107	107	NUM
inlawrev-3967	376	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	376	19	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	376	20	exceptional	exceptional	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	376	21	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	376	22	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	376	23	include	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	376	24	situations	situation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	376	25	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	376	26	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	376	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	376	28	infringer	infringer	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	376	29	exhibited	exhibit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	376	30	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	376	31	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	376	32	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-3967	376	33	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	376	34	her	her	PRON
inlawrev-3967	376	35	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	376	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	377	1	a.	a.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	378	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	378	2	underwater	underwater	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	378	3	devices	device	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	378	4	rule	rule	VERB
inlawrev-3967	378	5	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	378	6	almost	almost	ADV
inlawrev-3967	378	7	twenty	twenty	NUM
inlawrev-3967	378	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	378	9	five	five	NUM
inlawrev-3967	378	10	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	378	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	378	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	378	13	baseline	baseline	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	378	14	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	378	15	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	378	16	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	378	17	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	378	18	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	378	19	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-3967	378	20	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	378	21	underwater	underwater	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	378	22	devices	devices	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	378	23	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	378	24	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	378	25	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	378	26	morrison	morrison	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	378	27	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	378	28	knudsen	knudsen	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	378	29	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	378	30	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	378	31	108	108	NUM
inlawrev-3967	378	32	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	378	33	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	378	34	...	...	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	378	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	378	36	potential	potential	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	378	37	infringer	infringer	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	378	38	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	378	39	actual	actual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	378	40	notice	notice	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	378	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	378	42	another	another	PRON
inlawrev-3967	378	43	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	378	44	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	378	45	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	378	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	378	47	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-3967	378	48	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	378	49	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	378	50	affirmative	affirmative	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	378	51	duty	duty	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	378	52	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	378	53	exercise	exercise	VERB
inlawrev-3967	378	54	due	due	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	378	55	care	care	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	378	56	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	378	57	determine	determine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	378	58	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	378	59	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	378	60	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	378	61	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-3967	378	62	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	378	63	infringing	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-3967	378	64	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	379	1	such	such	DET
inlawrev-3967	379	2	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	379	3	affirmative	affirmative	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	379	4	duty	duty	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	379	5	includes	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	379	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	379	7	inter	inter	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	379	8	alia	alia	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	379	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	379	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	379	11	duty	duty	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	379	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	379	13	seek	seek	VERB
inlawrev-3967	379	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	379	15	obtain	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	379	16	competent	competent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	379	17	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	379	18	advice	advice	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	379	19	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	379	20	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	379	21	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-3967	379	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	379	23	initiation	initiation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	379	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	379	25	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	379	26	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	379	27	infringing	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-3967	379	28	activity	activity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	379	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	379	30	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	380	1	109	109	NUM
inlawrev-3967	380	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	380	3	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	380	4	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-3967	380	5	actual	actual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	380	6	notice	notice	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	380	7	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	380	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	380	9	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	380	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	380	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	380	12	putative	putative	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	380	13	infringer	infringer	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	380	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	380	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	380	16	charges	charge	VERB
inlawrev-3967	380	17	him	he	PRON
inlawrev-3967	380	18	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	380	19	her	she	PRON
inlawrev-3967	380	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	380	21	take	take	VERB
inlawrev-3967	380	22	steps	step	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	380	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	380	24	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	380	25	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	380	26	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-3967	380	27	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	380	28	she	she	PRON
inlawrev-3967	380	29	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	380	30	infringing	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-3967	380	31	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	380	32	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	380	33	infringe	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-3967	380	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	380	35	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	380	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	381	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	381	2	requirement	requirement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	381	3	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	381	4	obtain	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	381	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	381	6	proper	proper	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	381	7	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	381	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	381	9	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	381	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	381	11	included	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	381	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	381	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	381	14	duty	duty	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	381	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	381	16	care	care	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	381	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	381	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	381	19	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	381	20	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	381	21	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	381	22	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	381	23	prior	prior	ADV
inlawrev-3967	381	24	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	381	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	381	26	beginning	beginning	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	381	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	381	28	potentially	potentially	ADV
inlawrev-3967	381	29	infringing	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-3967	381	30	actions	action	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	381	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	381	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	381	33	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	381	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	381	35	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	381	36	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	381	37	due	due	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	381	38	ahead	ahead	ADV
inlawrev-3967	381	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	381	40	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	381	41	actions	action	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	381	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	382	1	110	110	NUM
inlawrev-3967	382	2	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	382	3	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	382	4	became	become	VERB
inlawrev-3967	382	5	aware	aware	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	382	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	382	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	382	8	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	382	9	after	after	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	382	10	activity	activity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	382	11	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	382	12	begun	begin	VERB
inlawrev-3967	382	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	382	14	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	382	15	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	382	16	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-3967	382	17	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	382	18	obtained	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	382	19	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	382	20	soon	soon	ADV
inlawrev-3967	382	21	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	382	22	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	382	23	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-3967	382	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	382	25	discovery	discovery	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	382	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	382	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	382	28	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	382	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	383	1	x	x	SYM
inlawrev-3967	383	2	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	383	3	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	383	4	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	383	5	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	383	6	underwater	underwater	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	383	7	devices	device	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	383	8	evolved	evolve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	383	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	383	10	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	383	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	383	12	view	view	VERB
inlawrev-3967	383	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	383	14	duty	duty	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	383	15	103	103	NUM
inlawrev-3967	383	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	384	1	497	497	NUM
inlawrev-3967	384	2	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	384	3	1360	1360	NUM
inlawrev-3967	384	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	384	5	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	384	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	384	7	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	384	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	384	9	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	384	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	384	11	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	384	12	en	en	X
inlawrev-3967	384	13	banc	banc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	384	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	384	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	385	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	385	2	author	author	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	385	3	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	385	4	like	like	VERB
inlawrev-3967	385	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	385	6	acknowledge	acknowledge	VERB
inlawrev-3967	385	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	385	8	thank	thank	VERB
inlawrev-3967	385	9	holiday	holiday	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	385	10	w.	w.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	385	11	banta	banta	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	385	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	385	13	partner	partner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	385	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	385	15	woodard	woodard	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	385	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	385	17	emhardt	emhardt	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	385	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	385	19	moriarty	moriarty	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	385	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	385	21	mcnett	mcnett	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	385	22	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	385	23	henry	henry	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	385	24	llp	llp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	385	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	385	26	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	385	27	information	information	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	385	28	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	385	29	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	385	30	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	385	31	provided	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	385	32	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	385	33	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	385	34	meeting	meeting	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	385	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	385	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	385	37	firm	firm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	385	38	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	385	39	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	385	40	practice	practice	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	385	41	group	group	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	385	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	386	1	104	104	NUM
inlawrev-3967	386	2	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	386	3	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-3967	386	4	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	386	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	387	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	387	2	284	284	NUM
inlawrev-3967	387	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	387	4	2000	2000	NUM
inlawrev-3967	387	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	387	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	388	1	105	105	NUM
inlawrev-3967	388	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	389	1	seagate	seagate	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	389	2	tech	tech	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	389	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	389	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	389	5	497	497	NUM
inlawrev-3967	389	6	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	389	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	389	8	1368	1368	NUM
inlawrev-3967	389	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	389	10	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	389	11	beatrice	beatrice	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	389	12	foods	foods	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	389	13	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	389	14	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	389	15	new	new	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	389	16	england	england	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	389	17	printing	printing	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	389	18	&	&	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	389	19	lithographing	lithographing	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	389	20	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	389	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	389	22	923	923	NUM
inlawrev-3967	389	23	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	389	24	1576	1576	NUM
inlawrev-3967	389	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	389	26	1578	1578	NUM
inlawrev-3967	389	27	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	389	28	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	389	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	389	30	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	389	31	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	389	32	1991	1991	NUM
inlawrev-3967	389	33	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	389	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	389	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	390	1	106	106	NUM
inlawrev-3967	390	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	391	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	391	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	391	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	391	4	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	391	5	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-3967	391	6	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	391	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	392	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	392	2	284	284	NUM
inlawrev-3967	392	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	392	4	2000	2000	NUM
inlawrev-3967	392	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	392	6	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	392	7	odetics	odetic	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	392	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	392	9	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	392	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	393	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	393	2	storage	storage	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	393	3	tech	tech	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	393	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	1	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	394	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	3	185	185	NUM
inlawrev-3967	394	4	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	394	5	1259	1259	NUM
inlawrev-3967	394	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	7	1274	1274	NUM
inlawrev-3967	394	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	9	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	394	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	11	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	394	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	394	13	1999	1999	NUM
inlawrev-3967	394	14	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	15	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	16	jurgens	jurgens	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	394	17	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	394	18	cbk	cbk	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	394	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	20	ltd	ltd	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	394	21	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	394	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	23	80	80	NUM
inlawrev-3967	394	24	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	394	25	1566	1566	NUM
inlawrev-3967	394	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	27	1570	1570	NUM
inlawrev-3967	394	28	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	29	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	394	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	31	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	394	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	33	1996	1996	NUM
inlawrev-3967	394	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	394	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	395	1	107	107	NUM
inlawrev-3967	395	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-3967	395	3	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-3967	395	4	u.s.c	u.s.c	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	395	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	396	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	396	2	285	285	NUM
inlawrev-3967	396	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	396	4	2000	2000	NUM
inlawrev-3967	396	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	396	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	397	1	108	108	NUM
inlawrev-3967	397	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-3967	398	1	717	717	NUM
inlawrev-3967	398	2	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	398	3	1380	1380	NUM
inlawrev-3967	398	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	398	5	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	398	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	398	7	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	398	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	398	9	1983	1983	NUM
inlawrev-3967	398	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	398	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	398	12	overruled	overrule	VERB
inlawrev-3967	398	13	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	398	14	seagate	seagate	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	398	15	tech	tech	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	398	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	398	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	399	1	497	497	NUM
inlawrev-3967	399	2	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	399	3	1360	1360	NUM
inlawrev-3967	399	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	400	1	109	109	NUM
inlawrev-3967	400	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	400	3	seagate	seagate	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	400	4	tech	tech	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	400	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	400	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	400	7	491	491	NUM
inlawrev-3967	400	8	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	400	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	400	10	1368	1368	NUM
inlawrev-3967	400	11	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	400	12	69	69	NUM
inlawrev-3967	400	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	400	14	omission	omission	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	400	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	400	16	original	original	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	400	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	400	18	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	400	19	quoting	quote	VERB
inlawrev-3967	400	20	underwater	underwater	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	400	21	devices	device	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	400	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	400	23	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	400	24	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	400	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	400	26	717	717	NUM
inlawrev-3967	400	27	f.2d	f.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	400	28	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	400	29	1389	1389	NUM
inlawrev-3967	400	30	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	400	31	90	90	NUM
inlawrev-3967	400	32	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	400	33	citations	citation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	400	34	omitted	omit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	400	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	400	36	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	400	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	401	1	110	110	NUM
inlawrev-3967	401	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	402	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	402	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	402	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	402	4	1369	1369	NUM
inlawrev-3967	402	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	403	1	111	111	NUM
inlawrev-3967	403	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	404	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	404	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	404	3	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-3967	404	4	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	404	5	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	404	6	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	404	7	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	404	8	1153	1153	NUM
inlawrev-3967	404	9	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	404	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	404	11	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	404	12	totality	totality	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	404	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	404	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	404	15	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	404	16	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	404	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	404	18	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	404	19	enumerated	enumerate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	404	20	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	404	21	informing	inform	VERB
inlawrev-3967	404	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	404	23	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	404	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	404	25	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	405	1	112	112	NUM
inlawrev-3967	405	2	b.	b.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	405	3	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	405	4	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	405	5	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	405	6	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	405	7	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-3967	405	8	being	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	405	9	sued	sue	VERB
inlawrev-3967	405	10	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	405	11	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	405	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	405	13	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-3967	405	14	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	405	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	405	16	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	405	17	seagate	seagate	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	405	18	technology	technology	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	405	19	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	405	20	sought	seek	VERB
inlawrev-3967	405	21	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	405	22	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	405	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	405	24	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	405	25	concerning	concern	VERB
inlawrev-3967	405	26	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	405	27	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	405	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	406	1	113	113	NUM
inlawrev-3967	406	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	406	3	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	406	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	406	5	received	receive	VERB
inlawrev-3967	406	6	shortly	shortly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	406	7	after	after	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	406	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	406	9	complaint	complaint	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	406	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	406	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	406	12	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	406	13	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	406	14	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	406	15	filed	file	VERB
inlawrev-3967	406	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	406	17	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	406	18	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	406	19	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	406	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	406	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	406	22	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	406	23	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	406	24	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	406	25	invalid	invalid	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	406	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	406	27	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	406	28	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	406	29	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	406	30	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	406	31	infringed	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-3967	406	32	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	406	33	seagate	seagate	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	406	34	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	406	35	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	406	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	407	1	114	114	NUM
inlawrev-3967	407	2	additional	additional	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	407	3	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	407	4	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	407	5	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	407	6	obtained	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	407	7	later	later	ADV
inlawrev-3967	407	8	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	407	9	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	407	10	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	407	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	408	1	115	115	NUM
inlawrev-3967	408	2	after	after	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	408	3	seagate	seagate	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	4	notified	notify	VERB
inlawrev-3967	408	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	408	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	408	8	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	408	9	intended	intend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	408	10	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	408	11	rely	rely	VERB
inlawrev-3967	408	12	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	408	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	408	14	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	408	16	defend	defend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	408	17	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	408	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	408	19	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	408	21	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	408	23	permitted	permit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	408	24	discovery	discovery	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	408	26	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	408	27	attorney	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	28	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	408	29	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-3967	408	30	documents	document	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	31	relating	relate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	408	32	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	408	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	408	34	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	408	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	408	37	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	38	moved	move	VERB
inlawrev-3967	408	39	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	408	40	compel	compel	VERB
inlawrev-3967	408	41	production	production	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	42	ofcommunications	ofcommunication	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	43	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	408	44	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	45	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	46	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	408	47	seagate	seagate	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	408	48	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	408	49	s	s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	408	50	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	51	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	408	52	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	408	53	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	408	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	409	1	116	116	NUM
inlawrev-3967	410	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	410	2	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	410	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	410	4	ruled	rule	VERB
inlawrev-3967	410	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	410	6	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	410	7	broad	broad	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	410	8	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	410	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	410	10	privilege	privilege	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	410	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	410	12	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	410	13	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	410	14	immunity	immunity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	410	15	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	410	16	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-3967	410	17	place	place	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	410	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	410	19	ordered	order	VERB
inlawrev-3967	410	20	disclosure	disclosure	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	410	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	411	1	117	117	NUM
inlawrev-3967	411	2	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	411	3	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	4	'	'	PART
inlawrev-3967	411	5	request	request	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	6	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	411	7	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	8	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	9	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	411	11	notices	notice	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	411	13	deposition	deposition	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	411	15	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	16	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	411	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	411	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	411	20	denial	denial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	411	22	seagate	seagate	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	411	23	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	411	24	motions	motion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	25	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	411	26	stay	stay	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	27	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	411	28	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	411	29	certification	certification	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	411	31	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	411	32	interlocutory	interlocutory	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	33	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	34	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	411	35	seagate	seagate	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	411	36	petitioned	petition	VERB
inlawrev-3967	411	37	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	411	38	mandamus	mandamus	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	39	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	411	40	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	411	41	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	411	42	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	411	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	412	1	118	118	NUM
inlawrev-3967	412	2	recognizing	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	412	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	412	4	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	412	5	practical	practical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	412	6	dilemmas	dilemma	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	412	7	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	412	8	arising	arise	VERB
inlawrev-3967	412	9	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-3967	412	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	412	11	desire	desire	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	412	12	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	412	13	protection	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	412	14	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	412	15	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	412	16	determinations	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	412	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	412	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	412	19	potential	potential	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	412	20	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	412	21	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	412	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	412	23	privilege	privilege	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	412	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	412	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	412	26	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	412	27	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	412	28	granted	grant	VERB
inlawrev-3967	412	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	412	30	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	412	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	413	1	119	119	NUM
inlawrev-3967	413	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	413	3	traced	trace	VERB
inlawrev-3967	413	4	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	413	5	consideration	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	413	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	413	7	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	413	8	dilemmas	dilemma	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	413	9	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-3967	413	10	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	413	11	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	413	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	414	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	414	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	414	3	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	414	4	recommended	recommend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	414	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	414	6	camera	camera	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	414	7	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	414	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	414	9	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	414	10	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	414	11	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	414	12	privileged	privileged	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	414	13	materials	material	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	414	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	414	15	bifurcated	bifurcated	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	414	16	trials	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	414	17	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	414	18	employ	employ	VERB
inlawrev-3967	414	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	414	20	right	right	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	414	21	balance	balance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	414	22	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-3967	414	23	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	414	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	414	25	privilege	privilege	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	414	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	415	1	12	12	NUM
inlawrev-3967	415	2	°	°	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	3	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-3967	415	4	recently	recently	ADV
inlawrev-3967	415	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	415	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	415	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	8	moved	move	VERB
inlawrev-3967	415	9	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-3967	415	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	415	11	favor	favor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	415	13	protecting	protect	VERB
inlawrev-3967	415	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	415	15	attorney	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	415	17	client	client	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	18	relationship	relationship	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	19	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	415	20	refusing	refuse	VERB
inlawrev-3967	415	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	415	22	give	give	VERB
inlawrev-3967	415	23	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	415	24	adverse	adverse	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	415	25	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	26	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	415	27	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	415	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	415	29	substance	substance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	415	31	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	415	32	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	415	34	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	35	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	415	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	415	37	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	38	asserted	assert	VERB
inlawrev-3967	415	39	attorney	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	40	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	415	41	client	client	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	42	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	415	43	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	44	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	45	privilege	privilege	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	415	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	416	1	121	121	NUM
inlawrev-3967	416	2	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	416	3	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	416	4	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	416	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	416	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	8	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	416	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	416	10	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	416	11	reliance	reliance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	12	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	416	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	416	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	416	15	house	house	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	16	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	17	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	416	18	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	19	waives	waive	VERB
inlawrev-3967	416	20	attorney	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	416	22	client	client	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	23	privilege	privilege	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	416	25	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	416	26	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-3967	416	27	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	416	28	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	29	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	30	protection	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	31	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	416	32	communications	communication	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	33	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	416	34	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	416	35	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	416	36	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	37	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	416	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	416	40	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	41	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	416	42	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	416	43	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	416	44	extend	extend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	416	45	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	416	46	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	47	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	48	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	416	49	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	416	50	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	416	51	communicated	communicate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	416	52	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	416	53	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	416	54	accused	accuse	VERB
inlawrev-3967	416	55	infringer	infringer	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	416	56	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	416	57	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	417	1	122	122	NUM
inlawrev-3967	417	2	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	417	3	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	417	4	112	112	NUM
inlawrev-3967	417	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	418	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	418	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	418	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	418	4	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	418	5	read	read	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	418	6	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	418	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	419	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	419	2	portec	portec	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	419	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	419	4	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	419	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	419	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	419	7	970	970	NUM
inlawrev-3967	419	8	f.2d	f.2d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	419	9	816	816	NUM
inlawrev-3967	419	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	419	11	826	826	NUM
inlawrev-3967	419	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	419	13	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	419	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	419	15	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	419	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	419	17	1992	1992	NUM
inlawrev-3967	419	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	420	1	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	420	2	rolls	rolls	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	420	3	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	420	4	royce	royce	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	420	5	ltd	ltd	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	420	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	421	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	421	2	gte	gte	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	421	3	valeton	valeton	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	421	4	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	421	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	421	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	421	7	800	800	NUM
inlawrev-3967	421	8	f.2d	f.2d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	421	9	1101,1110	1101,1110	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	421	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	421	11	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	421	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	421	13	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	421	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	421	15	1986	1986	NUM
inlawrev-3967	421	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	421	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	421	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	422	1	113	113	NUM
inlawrev-3967	422	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	423	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	423	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	423	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	423	4	1366	1366	NUM
inlawrev-3967	423	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	424	1	114	114	NUM
inlawrev-3967	424	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	425	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	425	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	425	3	115	115	NUM
inlawrev-3967	425	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	426	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	426	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	426	3	116	116	NUM
inlawrev-3967	426	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	427	1	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	427	2	1366	1366	NUM
inlawrev-3967	427	3	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	427	4	67	67	NUM
inlawrev-3967	427	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	427	6	117	117	NUM
inlawrev-3967	427	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	428	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	428	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	428	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	428	4	1367	1367	NUM
inlawrev-3967	428	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	429	1	118	118	NUM
inlawrev-3967	429	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	430	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	430	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	430	3	119	119	NUM
inlawrev-3967	430	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	431	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	431	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	431	3	120	120	NUM
inlawrev-3967	431	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	432	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	432	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	432	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	432	4	1369	1369	NUM
inlawrev-3967	432	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	432	6	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	432	7	quantum	quantum	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	432	8	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	432	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	432	10	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	432	11	tandon	tandon	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	432	12	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	432	13	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	432	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	432	15	940	940	NUM
inlawrev-3967	432	16	f.2d	f.2d	ADP
inlawrev-3967	432	17	642	642	NUM
inlawrev-3967	432	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	432	19	643	643	NUM
inlawrev-3967	432	20	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	432	21	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	432	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	432	23	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	432	24	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	432	25	1991	1991	NUM
inlawrev-3967	432	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	432	27	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	432	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	433	1	121	121	NUM
inlawrev-3967	433	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	434	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	434	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	434	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	434	4	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	434	5	369	369	NUM
inlawrev-3967	434	6	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	434	7	70	70	NUM
inlawrev-3967	434	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	434	9	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	434	10	knorr	knorr	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	434	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	434	12	bremse	bremse	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	434	13	systeme	systeme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	434	14	fuer	fuer	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	434	15	nutzfahrzeuge	nutzfahrzeuge	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	434	16	gmbh	gmbh	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	434	17	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	434	18	dana	dana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	434	19	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	434	20	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	434	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	434	22	383	383	NUM
inlawrev-3967	434	23	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	434	24	1337	1337	NUM
inlawrev-3967	434	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	434	26	1344	1344	NUM
inlawrev-3967	434	27	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	434	28	45	45	NUM
inlawrev-3967	434	29	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	434	30	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	434	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	434	32	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	434	33	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	434	34	2004	2004	NUM
inlawrev-3967	434	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	435	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	435	2	en	en	X
inlawrev-3967	435	3	banc	banc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	435	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	435	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	435	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	436	1	122	122	NUM
inlawrev-3967	436	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	437	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	437	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	437	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	437	4	1370	1370	NUM
inlawrev-3967	437	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	437	6	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	437	7	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	437	8	re	re	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	437	9	echostar	echostar	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	437	10	commc'ns	commc'ns	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	437	11	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	437	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	437	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	437	14	448	448	NUM
inlawrev-3967	437	15	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	437	16	1294	1294	NUM
inlawrev-3967	437	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	437	18	1303	1303	NUM
inlawrev-3967	437	19	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	437	20	04	04	NUM
inlawrev-3967	437	21	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	437	22	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	437	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	437	24	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	437	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	437	26	1154	1154	NUM
inlawrev-3967	437	27	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	437	28	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	437	29	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	438	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	438	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	438	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	439	1	41:1139	41:1139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	439	2	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	439	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	439	4	hand	hand	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	439	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	439	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	439	7	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	439	8	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	439	9	turned	turn	VERB
inlawrev-3967	439	10	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	439	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	439	12	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	439	13	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	439	14	hand	hand	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	439	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	439	16	namely	namely	ADV
inlawrev-3967	439	17	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	439	18	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	439	19	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	439	20	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	439	21	resulting	result	VERB
inlawrev-3967	439	22	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	439	23	advice	advice	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	439	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	439	25	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	439	26	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	439	27	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	439	28	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	439	29	defenses	defense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	439	30	extend	extend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	439	31	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	439	32	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	439	33	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	439	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	439	35	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	440	1	123	123	NUM
inlawrev-3967	440	2	c.	c.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	440	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	440	4	underwater	underwater	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	440	5	devices	device	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	440	6	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	440	7	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	440	8	overruled	overrule	VERB
inlawrev-3967	440	9	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-3967	440	10	reviewing	review	VERB
inlawrev-3967	440	11	briefly	briefly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	440	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	440	13	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	440	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	440	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	440	16	term	term	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	440	17	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	440	18	willful	willful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	440	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	440	20	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	440	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	440	22	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	440	23	declared	declare	VERB
inlawrev-3967	440	24	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	440	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	440	26	underwater	underwater	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	440	27	devices	device	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	440	28	duty	duty	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	440	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	440	30	care	care	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	440	31	set	set	VERB
inlawrev-3967	440	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	440	33	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	440	34	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	440	35	willful	willful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	440	36	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	440	37	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	440	38	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	440	39	too	too	ADV
inlawrev-3967	440	40	low	low	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	440	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	441	1	124	124	NUM
inlawrev-3967	441	2	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-3967	441	3	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-3967	441	4	using	use	VERB
inlawrev-3967	441	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	441	6	recklessness	recklessness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	441	7	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	441	8	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	441	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	441	10	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	441	11	areas	area	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	441	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	441	13	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	441	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	441	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	441	16	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	441	17	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	441	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	441	19	existing	exist	VERB
inlawrev-3967	441	20	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	441	21	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	441	22	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	441	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	441	24	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	441	25	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-3967	441	26	akin	akin	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	441	27	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	441	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	441	29	negligence	negligence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	441	30	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	441	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	441	32	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	441	33	allow[ed	allow[ed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	441	34	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	441	35	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	441	36	punitive	punitive	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	441	37	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	441	38	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	441	39	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	441	40	manner	manner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	441	41	inconsistent	inconsistent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	441	42	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	441	43	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	441	44	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	441	45	precedent	precedent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	441	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	441	47	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	442	1	125	125	NUM
inlawrev-3967	442	2	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-3967	442	3	though	though	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	442	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	442	5	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	442	6	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	442	7	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	442	8	discovery	discovery	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	442	9	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	442	10	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-3967	442	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	442	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	442	13	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	442	14	saw	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	442	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	442	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	442	17	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	442	18	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	442	19	clearly	clearly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	442	20	affects	affect	VERB
inlawrev-3967	442	21	what	what	DET
inlawrev-3967	442	22	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	442	23	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	442	24	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	442	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	442	26	likewise	likewise	ADV
inlawrev-3967	442	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	442	28	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	442	29	range	range	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	442	30	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	442	31	discovery	discovery	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	442	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	443	1	126	126	NUM
inlawrev-3967	443	2	consequently	consequently	ADV
inlawrev-3967	443	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	443	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	443	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	443	6	took	take	VERB
inlawrev-3967	443	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	443	8	opportunity	opportunity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	443	9	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	443	10	rework	rework	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	443	11	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	443	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	443	13	analytical	analytical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	443	14	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	443	15	surrounding	surround	VERB
inlawrev-3967	443	16	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	443	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	443	18	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	443	19	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	443	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	443	21	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	443	22	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	443	23	defenses	defense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	443	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	443	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	443	26	concentrated	concentrate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	443	27	heavily	heavily	ADV
inlawrev-3967	443	28	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	443	29	objectivity	objectivity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	443	30	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	443	31	doing	do	VERB
inlawrev-3967	443	32	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-3967	443	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	444	1	derived	derive	VERB
inlawrev-3967	444	2	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	444	3	definitions	definition	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	444	4	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	444	5	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	444	6	areas	area	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	444	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	444	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	444	9	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	444	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	444	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	444	12	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	444	13	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	444	14	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	444	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	444	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	444	17	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	444	18	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	444	19	now	now	ADV
inlawrev-3967	444	20	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	444	21	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	444	22	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	444	23	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	444	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	444	25	showing	showing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	444	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	444	27	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	444	28	recklessness	recklessness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	444	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	444	30	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	445	1	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	445	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	445	3	explaining	explain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	445	4	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	445	5	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	445	6	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-3967	445	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	445	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	445	9	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	445	10	stated	state	VERB
inlawrev-3967	445	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	445	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	445	13	successful	successful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	445	14	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	445	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	445	16	willful	willful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	445	17	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	445	18	requires	require	VERB
inlawrev-3967	445	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	445	20	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	445	21	show[ing	show[ing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	445	22	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	445	23	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	445	24	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	445	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	445	26	convincing	convincing	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	445	27	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	445	28	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	445	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	445	30	infringer	infringer	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	445	31	acted	act	VERB
inlawrev-3967	445	32	despite	despite	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	445	33	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	445	34	objectively	objectively	ADV
inlawrev-3967	445	35	high	high	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	445	36	likelihood	likelihood	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	445	37	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	445	38	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	445	39	actions	action	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	445	40	constituted	constitute	VERB
inlawrev-3967	445	41	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	445	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	445	43	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	445	44	valid	valid	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	445	45	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	445	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	445	47	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	446	1	128	128	NUM
inlawrev-3967	446	2	apparently	apparently	ADV
inlawrev-3967	446	3	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	446	4	underscore	underscore	VERB
inlawrev-3967	446	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	446	6	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-3967	446	7	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	446	8	fold	fold	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	446	9	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	446	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	446	11	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	446	12	objectiveness	objectiveness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	446	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	446	14	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	446	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	446	16	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	446	17	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-3967	446	18	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	446	19	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	446	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	446	21	putative	putative	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	446	22	infringer	infringer	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	446	23	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	446	24	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	446	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	446	26	mind	mind	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	446	27	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	446	28	irrelevant	irrelevant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	446	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	446	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	446	31	assessment	assessment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	446	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	446	33	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	446	34	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	446	35	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	446	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	447	1	129	129	NUM
inlawrev-3967	448	1	once	once	ADV
inlawrev-3967	448	2	such	such	DET
inlawrev-3967	448	3	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	448	4	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	448	5	likelihood	likelihood	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	448	6	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	448	7	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-3967	448	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	448	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	448	10	patentee	patentee	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	448	11	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	448	12	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-3967	448	13	demonstrate	demonstrate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	448	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	448	15	mental	mental	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	448	16	element	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	448	17	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	448	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	448	19	infringer	infringer	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	448	20	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	448	21	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	448	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	449	1	130	130	NUM
inlawrev-3967	449	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	449	3	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	449	4	risk	risk	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	449	5	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	449	6	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	449	7	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	449	8	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	449	9	known	known	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	449	10	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	449	11	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-3967	449	12	obvious	obvious	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	449	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	449	14	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	449	15	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-3967	449	16	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	449	17	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	449	18	known	know	VERB
inlawrev-3967	449	19	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	449	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	449	21	accused	accuse	VERB
inlawrev-3967	449	22	infringer	infringer	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	449	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	449	24	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	450	1	131	131	NUM
inlawrev-3967	450	2	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-3967	450	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	450	4	this	this	PRON
inlawrev-3967	450	5	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	450	6	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	450	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	450	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	450	9	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	450	10	guidance	guidance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	450	11	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	450	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	450	13	topic	topic	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	450	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	450	15	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	450	16	ends	end	VERB
inlawrev-3967	450	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	450	18	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	450	19	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	450	20	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	450	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	450	22	present	present	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	450	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	451	1	having	having	AUX
inlawrev-3967	451	2	appropriately	appropriately	ADV
inlawrev-3967	451	3	explained	explain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	451	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	451	5	jump	jump	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	451	6	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	451	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	451	8	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	451	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	451	10	mandamus	mandamus	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	451	11	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	451	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	451	13	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	451	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	451	15	discovery	discovery	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	451	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	451	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	451	18	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	451	19	questions	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	451	20	involved	involve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	451	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	451	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	451	23	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	451	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	451	25	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	451	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	451	27	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	451	28	having	having	AUX
inlawrev-3967	451	29	offered	offer	VERB
inlawrev-3967	451	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	451	31	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-3967	451	32	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	451	33	step	step	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	451	34	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	451	35	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	451	36	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	451	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	451	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	451	39	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	451	40	stopped	stop	VERB
inlawrev-3967	451	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	452	1	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-3967	452	2	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	452	3	offer	offer	VERB
inlawrev-3967	452	4	further	further	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	452	5	teaching	teaching	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	452	6	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	452	7	examples	example	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	452	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	452	9	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-3967	452	10	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	452	11	past	past	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	452	12	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	452	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	452	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	452	15	judges	judge	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	452	16	preferred	prefer	VERB
inlawrev-3967	452	17	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	452	18	allow	allow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	452	19	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	452	20	future	future	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	452	21	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	452	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	452	23	further	further	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	452	24	2006	2006	NUM
inlawrev-3967	452	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	452	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	452	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	453	1	123	123	NUM
inlawrev-3967	453	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	454	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	454	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	454	3	124	124	NUM
inlawrev-3967	454	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	454	5	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	454	6	1371	1371	NUM
inlawrev-3967	454	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	455	1	125	125	NUM
inlawrev-3967	455	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	456	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	456	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	456	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	456	4	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	456	5	safeco	safeco	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	456	6	ins	ins	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	456	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	456	8	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	457	2	geico	geico	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	3	gen	gen	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	5	ins	ins	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	457	7	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	457	9	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	457	10	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	11	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	12	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	13	2201	2201	NUM
inlawrev-3967	457	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	457	15	2209	2209	NUM
inlawrev-3967	457	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	457	17	2214	2214	NUM
inlawrev-3967	457	18	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	457	19	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-3967	457	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	457	21	2216	2216	NUM
inlawrev-3967	457	22	n.20	n.20	X
inlawrev-3967	457	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	457	24	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	457	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	457	26	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	457	27	smith	smith	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	28	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	29	wade	wade	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	457	31	461	461	NUM
inlawrev-3967	457	32	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	33	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	457	34	30	30	NUM
inlawrev-3967	457	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	457	36	39	39	NUM
inlawrev-3967	457	37	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	457	38	49	49	NUM
inlawrev-3967	457	39	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	457	40	1983	1983	NUM
inlawrev-3967	457	41	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	457	42	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	457	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	458	1	126	126	NUM
inlawrev-3967	458	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	459	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	459	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	459	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	459	4	1371	1371	NUM
inlawrev-3967	459	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	459	6	72	72	NUM
inlawrev-3967	459	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	460	1	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	460	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	461	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	461	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	461	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	461	4	1371	1371	NUM
inlawrev-3967	461	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	462	1	128	128	NUM
inlawrev-3967	462	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	463	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	463	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	463	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	463	4	emphasis	emphasis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	463	5	added	add	VERB
inlawrev-3967	463	6	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	463	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	463	8	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	463	9	safeco	safeco	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	463	10	ins	ins	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	463	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	463	12	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	463	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	464	1	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	464	2	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	464	3	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	464	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	465	1	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	465	2	2215	2215	NUM
inlawrev-3967	465	3	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	465	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	466	1	129	129	NUM
inlawrev-3967	466	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	467	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	467	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	467	3	130	130	NUM
inlawrev-3967	467	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	468	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	468	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	468	3	131	131	NUM
inlawrev-3967	468	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	469	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	469	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	469	3	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-3967	469	4	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	469	5	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	469	6	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	469	7	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	469	8	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	469	9	155	155	NUM
inlawrev-3967	469	10	develop	develop	VERB
inlawrev-3967	469	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	469	12	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	469	13	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	469	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	469	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	469	16	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	469	17	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	469	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	470	1	132	132	NUM
inlawrev-3967	470	2	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
inlawrev-3967	470	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	470	4	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	470	5	oblique	oblique	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	470	6	expectation	expectation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	470	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	470	8	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	470	9	standards	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	470	10	ofcommerce	ofcommerce	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	470	11	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	470	12	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	470	13	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-3967	470	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	470	15	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	470	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	470	17	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	470	18	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-3967	470	19	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	470	20	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	470	21	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	470	22	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	470	23	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	470	24	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-3967	470	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	470	26	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	470	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	471	1	133	133	NUM
inlawrev-3967	471	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	471	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	4	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	471	5	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	471	6	offer	offer	VERB
inlawrev-3967	471	7	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	471	8	solutions	solution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	471	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	471	11	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	12	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	471	13	bar	bar	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	471	15	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	471	16	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	471	17	disposition	disposition	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	18	being	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	471	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	471	20	grant	grant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	21	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	471	22	mandamus	mandamus	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	471	24	remand	remand	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	471	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	471	27	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	28	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	29	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	471	30	reconsideration	reconsideration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	471	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	471	33	discovery	discovery	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	34	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	35	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	471	36	fomented	foment	VERB
inlawrev-3967	471	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	471	38	petition	petition	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	471	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	472	1	134	134	NUM
inlawrev-3967	472	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	472	3	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	472	4	facet	facet	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	472	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	472	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	472	7	seagate	seagate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	472	8	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	472	9	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	472	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	472	11	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	472	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	472	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	472	14	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	472	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	472	16	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	472	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	472	18	privilege	privilege	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	472	19	when	when	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	472	20	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	472	21	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	472	22	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	472	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	472	24	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	472	25	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	472	26	defense	defense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	472	27	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	472	28	asserted	assert	VERB
inlawrev-3967	472	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	473	1	135	135	NUM
inlawrev-3967	473	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	473	3	point	point	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	473	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	473	5	clearly	clearly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	473	6	centrally	centrally	ADV
inlawrev-3967	473	7	related	relate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	473	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	473	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	473	10	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	473	11	'	'	PART
inlawrev-3967	473	12	conflict	conflict	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	473	13	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	473	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	473	15	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	473	16	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	473	17	level	level	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	473	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	473	19	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	473	20	split	split	VERB
inlawrev-3967	473	21	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-3967	473	22	separate	separate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	473	23	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	473	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	473	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	473	26	attorney	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	473	27	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	473	28	client	client	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	473	29	privilege	privilege	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	473	30	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-3967	473	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	473	32	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	473	33	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	473	34	protection	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	473	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	474	1	137	137	NUM
inlawrev-3967	474	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	474	3	both	both	DET
inlawrev-3967	474	4	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	475	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	475	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	475	3	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	475	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	475	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	475	6	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	475	7	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	475	8	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	475	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	475	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	475	11	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	475	12	defense	defense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	475	13	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-3967	475	14	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	475	15	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	475	16	work	work	VERB
inlawrev-3967	475	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	475	18	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	475	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	475	20	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	475	21	valuable	valuable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	475	22	protections	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	475	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	476	1	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-3967	476	2	taking	take	VERB
inlawrev-3967	476	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	476	4	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	476	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	476	6	attorney	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	476	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	476	8	client	client	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	476	9	privilege	privilege	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	476	10	first	first	ADV
inlawrev-3967	476	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	476	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	476	13	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	476	14	expressed	express	VERB
inlawrev-3967	476	15	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	476	16	veneration	veneration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	476	17	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	476	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	476	19	privilege	privilege	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	476	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	476	21	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	476	22	value	value	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	476	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	476	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	476	25	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	476	26	system	system	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	476	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	477	1	139	139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	477	2	recognizing	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	477	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	477	4	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	477	5	principle	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	477	7	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	477	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	477	9	client	client	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	10	waives	waive	VERB
inlawrev-3967	477	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	477	12	privilege	privilege	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	477	14	protection	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	15	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	477	16	lost	lose	VERB
inlawrev-3967	477	17	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	477	18	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	477	19	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	477	20	all	all	DET
inlawrev-3967	477	21	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	477	22	communications	communication	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	23	relating	relate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	477	24	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	477	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	477	26	same	same	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	477	27	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	28	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	477	30	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	477	31	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	477	32	140	140	NUM
inlawrev-3967	477	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	477	34	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	35	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	477	36	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	477	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	477	38	lack	lack	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	477	40	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	477	41	bright	bright	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	477	42	line	line	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	43	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	44	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	477	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	477	46	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	47	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	477	48	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	49	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	477	50	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	477	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	477	52	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	53	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	477	54	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	55	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	477	56	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	477	57	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	477	58	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	59	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-3967	477	60	establishing	establish	VERB
inlawrev-3967	477	61	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	477	62	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	477	63	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	478	1	141	141	NUM
inlawrev-3967	478	2	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	478	3	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	5	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	6	espousing	espouse	VERB
inlawrev-3967	478	7	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-3967	478	8	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	478	9	general	general	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	478	10	positions	position	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	11	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	478	12	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	13	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-3967	478	14	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	478	15	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	478	17	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	478	18	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	478	19	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	20	defense	defense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	21	extends	extend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	478	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	478	23	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	24	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	478	26	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	27	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	478	28	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	478	29	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-3967	478	30	extend	extend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	478	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	478	32	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	478	33	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	478	34	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	478	35	middle	middle	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	478	36	ground	ground	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	37	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	478	38	applying	apply	VERB
inlawrev-3967	478	39	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-3967	478	40	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	478	41	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	478	42	communications	communication	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	43	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	478	44	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	478	45	appellate	appellate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	478	46	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	47	chose	choose	VERB
inlawrev-3967	478	48	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	478	49	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	478	50	position	position	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	478	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	479	1	142	142	NUM
inlawrev-3967	479	2	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	479	3	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	479	4	t]he	t]he	ADV
inlawrev-3967	479	5	significantly	significantly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	479	6	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	479	7	functions	function	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	479	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	479	9	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	479	10	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	479	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	479	12	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	479	13	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	479	14	advise	advise	VERB
inlawrev-3967	479	15	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	479	16	extending	extend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	479	17	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	479	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	479	19	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	479	20	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	479	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	479	22	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	480	1	143	143	NUM
inlawrev-3967	480	2	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	480	3	functions	function	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	480	5	viewed	view	VERB
inlawrev-3967	480	6	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	480	7	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	480	8	assessment	assessment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	9	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	480	10	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	11	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	12	versus	versus	ADP
inlawrev-3967	480	13	adversarial	adversarial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	480	14	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	15	strategy	strategy	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	480	17	presentation	presentation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	18	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	480	19	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	20	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	480	22	144	144	NUM
inlawrev-3967	480	23	plus	plus	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	480	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	480	25	long	long	ADV
inlawrev-3967	480	26	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	480	27	standing	stand	VERB
inlawrev-3967	480	28	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	480	29	compelling	compelling	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	480	30	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	480	31	interests	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	32	contrary	contrary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	480	33	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	480	34	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	480	36	privilege	privilege	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	37	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	480	38	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	39	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	40	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-3967	480	41	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	480	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	480	43	focus	focus	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	480	45	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	480	46	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	47	inquiry	inquiry	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	48	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	480	49	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	50	prior	prior	ADV
inlawrev-3967	480	51	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	480	52	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	53	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	480	54	146	146	NUM
inlawrev-3967	480	55	led	lead	VERB
inlawrev-3967	480	56	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	480	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	480	58	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	480	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	481	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	481	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	481	3	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	481	4	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	481	5	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	481	6	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	481	7	rule	rule	VERB
inlawrev-3967	481	8	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	481	9	absolute	absolute	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	481	10	imperative	imperative	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	481	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	481	12	giving	give	VERB
inlawrev-3967	481	13	lower	low	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	481	14	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	481	15	discretion	discretion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	481	16	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	481	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	481	18	unique	unique	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	481	19	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	481	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	481	21	extend	extend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	481	22	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	481	23	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	481	24	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	481	25	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	481	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	481	27	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	481	28	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	481	29	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	481	30	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	481	31	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	481	32	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	481	33	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	481	34	engages	engage	VERB
inlawrev-3967	481	35	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	481	36	132	132	NUM
inlawrev-3967	481	37	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	482	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	482	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	482	3	133	133	NUM
inlawrev-3967	482	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	483	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	483	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	483	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	483	4	1371	1371	NUM
inlawrev-3967	483	5	n.5	n.5	SYM
inlawrev-3967	483	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	483	7	134	134	NUM
inlawrev-3967	483	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	484	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	484	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	484	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	484	4	1376	1376	NUM
inlawrev-3967	484	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	485	1	135	135	NUM
inlawrev-3967	485	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	486	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	486	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	486	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	486	4	1375	1375	NUM
inlawrev-3967	486	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	487	1	136	136	NUM
inlawrev-3967	487	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	488	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	488	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	488	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	488	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	488	5	1372	1372	NUM
inlawrev-3967	488	6	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	488	7	75	75	NUM
inlawrev-3967	488	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	489	1	137	137	NUM
inlawrev-3967	489	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	490	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	490	2	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	490	3	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	490	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	490	5	1375	1375	NUM
inlawrev-3967	490	6	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	490	7	76	76	NUM
inlawrev-3967	490	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	491	1	138	138	NUM
inlawrev-3967	491	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	492	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	492	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	492	3	139	139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	492	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	493	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	493	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	493	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	493	4	1372	1372	NUM
inlawrev-3967	493	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	494	1	140	140	NUM
inlawrev-3967	494	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	495	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	495	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	495	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	495	4	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	495	5	fort	fort	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	495	6	james	james	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	495	7	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	495	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	495	9	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	495	10	solo	solo	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	495	11	cup	cup	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	495	12	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	495	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	495	14	412	412	NUM
inlawrev-3967	495	15	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	495	16	1340	1340	NUM
inlawrev-3967	495	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	495	18	1349	1349	NUM
inlawrev-3967	495	19	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	495	20	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	495	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	495	22	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	495	23	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	495	24	2005	2005	NUM
inlawrev-3967	495	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	495	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	495	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	496	1	141	141	NUM
inlawrev-3967	496	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	497	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	497	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	497	3	142	142	NUM
inlawrev-3967	497	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	498	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	498	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	498	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	498	4	1373	1373	NUM
inlawrev-3967	498	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	499	1	143	143	NUM
inlawrev-3967	499	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	500	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	500	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	500	3	144	144	NUM
inlawrev-3967	500	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	501	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	501	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	501	3	145	145	NUM
inlawrev-3967	501	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	502	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	502	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	502	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	502	4	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	502	5	hickman	hickman	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	502	6	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	502	7	taylor	taylor	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	502	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	502	9	329	329	NUM
inlawrev-3967	502	10	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	502	11	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	502	12	495	495	NUM
inlawrev-3967	502	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	502	14	510	510	NUM
inlawrev-3967	502	15	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	502	16	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-3967	502	17	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	502	18	1947	1947	NUM
inlawrev-3967	502	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	502	20	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	502	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	503	1	146	146	NUM
inlawrev-3967	503	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	504	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	504	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	504	3	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	504	4	156	156	NUM
inlawrev-3967	504	5	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	504	6	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	504	7	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	505	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	505	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	505	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	506	1	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-3967	506	2	:	:	SYM
inlawrev-3967	506	3	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	506	4	139	139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	506	5	chicanery	chicanery	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	506	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	506	7	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	507	1	147	147	NUM
inlawrev-3967	507	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	507	3	section	section	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	507	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	507	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	507	6	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	507	7	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	507	8	included	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	507	9	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	507	10	interesting	interesting	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	507	11	passage	passage	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	507	12	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	507	13	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-3967	507	14	give	give	VERB
inlawrev-3967	507	15	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	507	16	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	507	17	food	food	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	507	18	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	507	19	thought	thought	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	507	20	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	507	21	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	507	22	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	507	23	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	507	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	507	25	request	request	VERB
inlawrev-3967	507	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	507	27	preliminary	preliminary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	507	28	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	507	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	508	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	508	2	preliminary	preliminary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	508	3	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	508	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	508	5	avoided	avoid	VERB
inlawrev-3967	508	6	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-3967	508	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	508	8	showing	showing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	508	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	508	10	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	508	11	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-3967	508	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	508	13	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	508	14	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	508	15	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	508	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	508	17	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	508	18	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	508	19	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	508	20	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	508	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	509	1	148	148	NUM
inlawrev-3967	509	2	correlating	correlate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	509	3	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	509	4	principle	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	509	5	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	509	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	509	7	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	509	8	recklessness	recklessness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	509	9	threshold	threshold	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	509	10	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	509	11	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	509	12	pronounced	pronounce	VERB
inlawrev-3967	509	13	earlier	early	ADV
inlawrev-3967	509	14	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	509	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	509	16	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	510	1	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	510	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	510	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	510	4	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	510	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	510	6	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	510	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	510	8	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	510	9	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	510	10	shown	show	VERB
inlawrev-3967	510	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	510	12	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	510	13	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	510	14	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	510	15	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	510	16	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	510	17	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	510	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	510	19	such	such	DET
inlawrev-3967	510	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	510	21	showing	showing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	510	22	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	510	23	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	510	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	510	25	avoid	avoid	VERB
inlawrev-3967	510	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	510	27	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	510	28	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	510	29	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-3967	510	30	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	510	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	510	32	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	510	33	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	510	34	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	510	35	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-3967	510	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	510	37	filing	filing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	510	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	510	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	510	40	complaint	complaint	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	510	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	511	1	149	149	NUM
inlawrev-3967	511	2	where	where	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	511	3	previously	previously	ADV
inlawrev-3967	511	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	511	5	denial	denial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	511	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	511	7	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	511	8	preliminary	preliminary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	511	9	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	511	10	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	511	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	511	12	setback	setback	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	511	13	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	511	14	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	511	15	fatal	fatal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	511	16	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	511	17	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	511	18	portion	portion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	511	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	511	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	511	21	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	511	22	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	511	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	511	24	now	now	ADV
inlawrev-3967	511	25	such	such	DET
inlawrev-3967	511	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	511	27	denial	denial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	511	28	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	511	29	results	result	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	511	30	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	511	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	511	32	denial	denial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	511	33	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	511	34	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	511	35	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	511	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	511	37	chance	chance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	511	38	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	511	39	obtain	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	511	40	enhanced	enhanced	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	511	41	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	511	42	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	511	43	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	511	44	post	post	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	511	45	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	511	46	complaint	complaint	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	511	47	infringing	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-3967	511	48	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	511	49	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	512	1	150	150	NUM
inlawrev-3967	512	2	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	512	3	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	512	4	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	512	5	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	512	6	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	512	7	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	512	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	512	9	invalidity	invalidity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	512	10	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	512	11	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	512	12	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	512	13	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	512	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	512	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	512	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	512	17	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	512	18	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	512	19	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	512	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	512	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	512	22	show	show	VERB
inlawrev-3967	512	23	objectively	objectively	ADV
inlawrev-3967	512	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	512	25	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	512	26	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	512	27	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	512	28	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-3967	512	29	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	512	30	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	512	31	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	512	32	nonreckless	nonreckless	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	512	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	513	1	151	151	NUM
inlawrev-3967	513	2	similarly	similarly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	513	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	513	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	513	5	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	513	6	occasioned	occasion	VERB
inlawrev-3967	513	7	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	513	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	513	9	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	513	10	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	513	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	513	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	513	13	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	513	14	defense	defense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	513	15	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	513	16	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-3967	513	17	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	513	18	extendable	extendable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	513	19	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	513	20	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	513	21	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	513	22	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	513	23	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	513	24	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	513	25	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	513	26	absent	absent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	513	27	exceptional	exceptional	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	513	28	circumstances	circumstance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	513	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	513	30	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	514	1	152	152	NUM
inlawrev-3967	514	2	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-3967	514	3	recognizing	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	514	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	514	5	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	514	6	place	place	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	7	ofthe	ofthe	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	514	8	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	9	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	10	doctrine	doctrine	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	514	12	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	514	13	adversarial	adversarial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	514	14	system	system	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	514	16	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	514	17	opinions	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	18	concerning	concern	VERB
inlawrev-3967	514	19	scope	scope	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	514	21	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	514	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	514	24	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	25	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-3967	514	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	514	27	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	514	28	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	29	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	30	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	514	31	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	32	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	33	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	514	34	available	available	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	514	35	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	514	36	discovery	discovery	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	37	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	514	38	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	39	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	514	40	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	514	41	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	514	42	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	514	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	515	1	153	153	NUM
inlawrev-3967	515	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	515	3	possibility	possibility	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	515	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	515	5	extending	extend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	515	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	515	7	waiver	waiver	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	515	8	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	515	9	special	special	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	515	10	problem	problem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	515	11	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	515	12	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	515	13	left	leave	VERB
inlawrev-3967	515	14	open	open	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	515	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	515	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	515	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	515	18	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	515	19	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	515	20	acknowledged	acknowledge	VERB
inlawrev-3967	515	21	existing	exist	VERB
inlawrev-3967	515	22	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	515	23	allowing	allow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	515	24	discovery	discovery	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	515	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	515	26	work	work	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	515	27	product	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	515	28	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	515	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	515	30	proper	proper	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	515	31	showing	showing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	515	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	515	33	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	515	34	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	515	35	hardship	hardship	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	515	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	516	1	154	154	NUM
inlawrev-3967	516	2	seagate	seagate	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	516	3	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	516	4	appear	appear	VERB
inlawrev-3967	516	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	516	6	make	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	516	7	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	516	8	significantly	significantly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	516	9	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-3967	516	10	difficult	difficult	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	516	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	516	12	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-3967	516	13	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	516	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	516	15	obtain	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	516	16	enhanced	enhanced	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	516	17	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	516	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	517	1	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	517	2	paper	paper	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	517	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	517	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	517	5	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	517	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	517	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	517	8	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	517	9	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	517	10	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	517	11	characterized	characterize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	517	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	517	13	underwater	underwater	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	517	14	devices	device	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	517	15	rule	rule	VERB
inlawrev-3967	517	16	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	517	17	approving	approve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	517	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	517	19	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	517	20	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	517	21	akin	akin	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	517	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	517	23	negligence	negligence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	517	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	517	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	517	26	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	517	27	moved	move	VERB
inlawrev-3967	517	28	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	517	29	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	517	30	to	to	AUX
inlawrev-3967	517	31	objective	objective	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	517	32	recklessness	recklessness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	517	33	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	517	34	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	517	35	minimum	minimum	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	517	36	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	517	37	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	517	38	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	517	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	518	1	155	155	NUM
inlawrev-3967	518	2	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	518	3	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	518	4	basis	basis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	518	5	alone	alone	ADV
inlawrev-3967	518	6	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	518	7	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	518	8	seem	seem	VERB
inlawrev-3967	518	9	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	518	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	518	11	lower	low	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	518	12	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	518	13	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	518	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	518	15	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	518	16	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	518	17	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	518	18	scrutinize	scrutinize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	518	19	allegations	allegation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	518	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	518	21	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	518	22	much	much	ADV
inlawrev-3967	518	23	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-3967	518	24	carefully	carefully	ADV
inlawrev-3967	518	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	518	26	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	518	27	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	518	28	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	518	29	reject	reject	VERB
inlawrev-3967	518	30	more	more	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	518	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	518	32	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	518	33	allegations	allegation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	518	34	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	518	35	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	518	36	occurred	occur	VERB
inlawrev-3967	518	37	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	518	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	518	39	past	past	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	518	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	519	1	combined	combine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	519	2	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	519	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	519	4	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	519	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	519	6	knorr	knorr	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	519	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	519	8	bremse	bremse	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	519	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	519	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	519	11	failure	failure	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	519	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	519	13	produce	produce	VERB
inlawrev-3967	519	14	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	519	15	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	519	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	519	17	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	519	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	519	19	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	519	20	failure	failure	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	519	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	519	22	obtain	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	519	23	legal	legal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	519	24	advice	advice	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	519	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	519	26	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	519	27	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	519	28	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	519	29	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	519	30	adverse	adverse	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	519	31	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	519	32	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	519	33	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	519	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	519	35	contents	content	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	519	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	519	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	519	38	147	147	NUM
inlawrev-3967	519	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	520	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	520	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	520	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	520	4	1374	1374	NUM
inlawrev-3967	520	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	520	6	75	75	NUM
inlawrev-3967	520	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	520	8	148	148	NUM
inlawrev-3967	520	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	521	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	521	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	521	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	521	4	1374	1374	NUM
inlawrev-3967	521	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	521	6	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	521	7	amazon.com	amazon.com	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	521	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	521	9	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	521	10	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	522	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	522	2	barnesandnoble.com	barnesandnoble.com	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	522	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	522	4	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	522	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	522	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	522	7	239	239	NUM
inlawrev-3967	522	8	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	522	9	1343	1343	NUM
inlawrev-3967	522	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	522	11	1359	1359	NUM
inlawrev-3967	522	12	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	522	13	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	522	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	522	15	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	522	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	522	17	2001	2001	NUM
inlawrev-3967	522	18	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	522	19	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	522	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	523	1	149	149	NUM
inlawrev-3967	523	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	524	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	524	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	524	3	150	150	NUM
inlawrev-3967	524	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	525	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	525	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	525	3	151	151	NUM
inlawrev-3967	525	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	526	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	526	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	526	3	152	152	NUM
inlawrev-3967	526	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	527	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	527	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	527	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	527	4	1375	1375	NUM
inlawrev-3967	527	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	528	1	153	153	NUM
inlawrev-3967	528	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	529	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	529	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	529	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	529	4	1375	1375	NUM
inlawrev-3967	529	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	529	6	76	76	NUM
inlawrev-3967	529	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	529	8	154	154	NUM
inlawrev-3967	529	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	530	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	530	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	530	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	530	4	1376	1376	NUM
inlawrev-3967	530	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	531	1	155	155	NUM
inlawrev-3967	531	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	532	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	532	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	532	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	532	4	1368	1368	NUM
inlawrev-3967	532	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	532	6	73	73	NUM
inlawrev-3967	532	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	532	8	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-3967	532	9	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	532	10	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	532	11	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	532	12	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	532	13	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	532	14	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	532	15	57	57	NUM
inlawrev-3967	532	16	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	532	17	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	532	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	532	19	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	532	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	532	21	156	156	NUM
inlawrev-3967	532	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	532	23	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	532	24	asserting	assert	VERB
inlawrev-3967	532	25	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	532	26	has	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	532	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	532	28	heavier	heavy	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	532	29	burden	burden	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	532	30	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	532	31	proving	prove	VERB
inlawrev-3967	532	32	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	532	33	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	532	34	than	than	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	532	35	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	532	36	true	true	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	532	37	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-3967	532	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	532	39	few	few	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	532	40	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	532	41	ago	ago	ADV
inlawrev-3967	532	42	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	533	1	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	533	2	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	533	3	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	533	4	wish	wish	VERB
inlawrev-3967	533	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	533	6	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	533	7	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-3967	533	8	more	more	ADV
inlawrev-3967	533	9	careful	careful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	533	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	533	11	alleging	allege	VERB
inlawrev-3967	533	12	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	533	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	533	14	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-3967	533	15	complaints	complaint	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	533	16	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-3967	533	17	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	533	18	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	533	19	standards	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	533	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	534	1	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	534	2	changes	change	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	534	3	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	534	4	focused	focus	VERB
inlawrev-3967	534	5	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	534	6	preserving	preserve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	534	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	534	8	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	534	9	surrounding	surround	VERB
inlawrev-3967	534	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	534	11	attorney	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	534	12	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	534	13	client	client	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	534	14	relationship	relationship	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	534	15	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	534	16	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	534	17	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	534	18	developed	develop	VERB
inlawrev-3967	534	19	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-3967	534	20	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	534	21	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	534	22	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	534	23	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-3967	534	24	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	534	25	every	every	DET
inlawrev-3967	534	26	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	534	27	area	area	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	534	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	534	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	534	30	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	534	31	157	157	NUM
inlawrev-3967	534	32	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	534	33	appropriately	appropriately	ADV
inlawrev-3967	534	34	shift	shift	VERB
inlawrev-3967	534	35	burdens	burden	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	534	36	concerning	concern	VERB
inlawrev-3967	534	37	willfulness	willfulness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	534	38	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	534	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	534	40	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	534	41	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	534	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	534	43	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	534	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	535	1	hi	hi	INTJ
inlawrev-3967	535	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	535	3	update	update	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	535	4	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	535	5	ebay	ebay	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	535	6	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	535	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	536	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	536	2	mercexchange	mercexchange	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	536	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	536	4	l.l.c	l.l.c	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	536	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	536	6	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-3967	536	7	*	*	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	536	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	536	9	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	536	10	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	536	11	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	536	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	536	13	eastern	eastern	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	536	14	district	district	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	536	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	536	16	virginia	virginia	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	536	17	issued	issue	VERB
inlawrev-3967	536	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	536	19	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	536	20	ruling	ruling	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	536	21	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	536	22	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	536	23	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	536	24	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	536	25	remand	remand	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	536	26	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	536	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	536	28	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	536	29	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	536	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	537	1	159	159	NUM
inlawrev-3967	537	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	537	3	history	history	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	537	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	537	5	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	537	6	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	537	7	includes	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	537	8	ajury	ajury	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	537	9	verdict	verdict	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	537	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	537	11	willful	willful	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	537	12	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	537	13	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	537	14	defendants	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	537	15	ebay	ebay	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	537	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	537	17	half.com	half.com	X
inlawrev-3967	537	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	537	19	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	537	20	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	537	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	537	22	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	537	23	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	537	24	denied	deny	VERB
inlawrev-3967	537	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	537	26	motion	motion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	537	27	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	537	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	537	29	permanent	permanent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	537	30	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	537	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	538	1	160	160	NUM
inlawrev-3967	538	2	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-3967	538	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	538	4	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	538	5	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	6	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	538	7	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	8	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	538	9	appeal	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	10	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	538	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	538	12	reversal	reversal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	538	14	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	538	15	denial	denial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	16	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	538	17	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	538	18	indication	indication	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	19	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	538	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	538	21	injunctions	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	22	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-3967	538	23	essentially	essentially	ADV
inlawrev-3967	538	24	issue	issue	VERB
inlawrev-3967	538	25	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	538	26	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	538	27	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	538	29	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	30	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	538	31	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	32	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	33	actions	action	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	34	upon	upon	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	538	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	538	36	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	37	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	538	38	validity	validity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	39	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	538	40	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	538	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	538	42	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	539	1	161	161	NUM
inlawrev-3967	539	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	539	3	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	539	4	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	539	5	granted	grant	VERB
inlawrev-3967	539	6	certiorari	certiorari	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	539	7	solely	solely	ADV
inlawrev-3967	539	8	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	539	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	539	10	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	539	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	539	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	539	13	permanent	permanent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	539	14	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	539	15	standard	standard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	539	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	539	17	vacated	vacate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	539	18	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	539	19	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	539	20	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	539	21	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	539	22	ruling	ruling	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	539	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	540	1	162	162	NUM
inlawrev-3967	540	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	540	3	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	540	4	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	540	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	540	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	8	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	540	9	ebay	ebay	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	540	10	ruling	ruling	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	11	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	540	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	540	13	precursor	precursor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	14	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	540	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	540	16	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	540	17	ruling	ruling	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	18	discussed	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-3967	540	19	above	above	ADP
inlawrev-3967	540	20	insofar	insofar	ADV
inlawrev-3967	540	21	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	540	22	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	540	23	demonstrates	demonstrate	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	24	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	540	25	current	current	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	540	26	relative	relative	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	540	27	high	high	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	540	28	interest	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	29	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	540	30	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	31	matters	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	32	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	540	33	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	540	34	desire	desire	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	35	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	540	36	correct	correct	VERB
inlawrev-3967	540	37	what	what	PRON
inlawrev-3967	540	38	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	540	39	views	view	VERB
inlawrev-3967	540	40	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	540	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	540	42	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	540	43	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	44	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	540	45	deviation	deviation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	46	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	540	47	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-3967	540	48	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	49	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	540	50	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	540	51	efforts	effort	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	52	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	540	53	create	create	VERB
inlawrev-3967	540	54	uniformity	uniformity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	55	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	540	56	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	540	57	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	58	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	540	59	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	541	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	541	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	3	relied	rely	VERB
inlawrev-3967	541	4	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	541	5	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	541	6	earlier	early	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	541	7	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	8	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	541	9	injunctions	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	10	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-3967	541	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	541	12	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	541	13	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	14	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	15	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	541	16	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	541	17	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	541	18	copyright	copyright	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	19	decisions	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	541	21	163	163	NUM
inlawrev-3967	541	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	541	23	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-3967	541	24	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	541	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	541	26	familiar	familiar	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	541	27	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-3967	541	28	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	541	29	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	30	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	31	relating	relate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	541	32	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	541	33	injunctions	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	34	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	541	35	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	541	36	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-3967	541	37	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	541	38	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	39	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	40	164	164	NUM
inlawrev-3967	541	41	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	541	42	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	541	43	injunctions	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	44	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	541	45	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	541	46	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	541	47	allowed	allow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	541	48	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	541	49	issue	issue	VERB
inlawrev-3967	541	50	simply	simply	ADV
inlawrev-3967	541	51	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	541	52	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	541	53	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	54	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	541	55	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	541	56	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	542	1	165	165	NUM
inlawrev-3967	542	2	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	542	3	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	542	4	direction	direction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	542	5	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	542	6	mind	mind	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	542	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	542	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	542	9	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	542	10	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	542	11	revisited	revisit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	542	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	542	13	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	542	14	question	question	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	542	15	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	543	1	166	166	NUM
inlawrev-3967	543	2	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-3967	543	3	reviewing	review	VERB
inlawrev-3967	543	4	post	post	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	543	5	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	543	6	remand	remand	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	543	7	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	543	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	543	9	post	post	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	543	10	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	543	11	trial	trial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	543	12	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	543	13	156	156	NUM
inlawrev-3967	543	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	544	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	544	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	544	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	544	4	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	544	5	369	369	NUM
inlawrev-3967	544	6	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	544	7	70	70	NUM
inlawrev-3967	544	8	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	544	9	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	544	10	knorr	knorr	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	544	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	544	12	bremse	bremse	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	544	13	systeme	systeme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	544	14	fuer	fuer	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	544	15	nutzfahrzeuge	nutzfahrzeuge	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	544	16	gmbh	gmbh	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	544	17	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	544	18	dana	dana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	544	19	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	544	20	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	544	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	544	22	383	383	NUM
inlawrev-3967	544	23	f.3d	f.3d	NUM
inlawrev-3967	544	24	1337	1337	NUM
inlawrev-3967	544	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	544	26	1344	1344	NUM
inlawrev-3967	544	27	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	544	28	45	45	NUM
inlawrev-3967	544	29	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	544	30	fed	fed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	544	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	544	32	cir	cir	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	544	33	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	544	34	2004	2004	NUM
inlawrev-3967	544	35	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	545	1	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	545	2	en	en	X
inlawrev-3967	545	3	banc	banc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	545	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	545	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	545	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	546	1	157	157	NUM
inlawrev-3967	546	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	547	1	note	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	547	2	ebay	ebay	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	547	3	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	547	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	548	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	548	2	mercexchange	mercexchange	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	548	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	548	4	l.l.c	l.l.c	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	548	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	548	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	548	7	547	547	NUM
inlawrev-3967	548	8	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	548	9	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	548	10	388	388	NUM
inlawrev-3967	548	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	548	12	391	391	NUM
inlawrev-3967	548	13	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	548	14	92	92	NUM
inlawrev-3967	548	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	548	16	2006	2006	NUM
inlawrev-3967	548	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	548	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	548	19	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	548	20	similarly	similarly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	548	21	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	548	22	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	548	23	tests	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	548	24	available	available	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	548	25	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	548	26	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	548	27	areas	area	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	548	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	548	29	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	548	30	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	548	31	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-3967	548	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	548	33	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-3967	548	34	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	548	35	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	548	36	test	test	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	548	37	employed	employ	VERB
inlawrev-3967	548	38	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	548	39	equity	equity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	548	40	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	548	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	548	42	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	548	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	548	44	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	548	45	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	548	46	grant	grant	VERB
inlawrev-3967	548	47	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	548	48	permanent	permanent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	548	49	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	548	50	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	548	51	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-3967	548	52	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	548	53	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	548	54	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	548	55	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	549	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	549	2	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	549	3	seem	seem	VERB
inlawrev-3967	549	4	likely	likely	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	549	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	549	6	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	549	7	situations	situation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	549	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	549	9	which	which	DET
inlawrev-3967	549	10	practice	practice	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	549	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	549	12	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	549	13	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	549	14	varies	vary	VERB
inlawrev-3967	549	15	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	549	16	practice	practice	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	549	17	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	549	18	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	549	19	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	549	20	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	549	21	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	549	22	likewise	likewise	ADV
inlawrev-3967	549	23	harmonized	harmonize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	549	24	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	549	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	549	26	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	549	27	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	549	28	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	549	29	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	549	30	circuit	circuit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	549	31	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	549	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	549	33	future	future	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	549	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	550	1	158	158	NUM
inlawrev-3967	550	2	.	.	X
inlawrev-3967	550	3	547	547	NUM
inlawrev-3967	551	1	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	551	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	551	3	388	388	NUM
inlawrev-3967	551	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	551	5	159	159	NUM
inlawrev-3967	551	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	552	1	mercexchange	mercexchange	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	552	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	552	3	l.l.c	l.l.c	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	552	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	553	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	553	2	ebay	ebay	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	553	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	553	4	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	553	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	553	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	553	7	500	500	NUM
inlawrev-3967	553	8	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	553	9	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	553	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	554	1	2d	2d	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	554	2	556	556	NUM
inlawrev-3967	554	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	554	4	e.d	e.d	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	554	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	554	6	va	va	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	554	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	554	8	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	554	9	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	554	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	555	1	160	160	NUM
inlawrev-3967	555	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	556	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	556	2	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-3967	556	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	556	4	559	559	NUM
inlawrev-3967	556	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	556	6	61	61	NUM
inlawrev-3967	556	7	.	.	X
inlawrev-3967	556	8	161	161	NUM
inlawrev-3967	556	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	557	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	557	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	557	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	557	4	559	559	NUM
inlawrev-3967	557	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	557	6	60	60	NUM
inlawrev-3967	557	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	558	1	162	162	NUM
inlawrev-3967	558	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	559	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	559	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	559	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	559	4	560	560	NUM
inlawrev-3967	559	5	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	559	6	163	163	NUM
inlawrev-3967	559	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	560	1	ebay	ebay	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	560	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	560	3	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	560	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	560	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	560	6	547	547	NUM
inlawrev-3967	560	7	u.s	u.s	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	560	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	560	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	560	10	390	390	NUM
inlawrev-3967	560	11	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	560	12	164	164	NUM
inlawrev-3967	560	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	561	1	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	561	2	391	391	NUM
inlawrev-3967	561	3	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	561	4	92	92	NUM
inlawrev-3967	561	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	561	6	165	165	NUM
inlawrev-3967	561	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	562	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	562	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	562	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	562	4	394	394	NUM
inlawrev-3967	562	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	562	6	166	166	NUM
inlawrev-3967	562	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	563	1	mercexchange	mercexchange	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	563	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	563	3	l.l.c	l.l.c	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	563	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	563	5	500	500	NUM
inlawrev-3967	563	6	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	563	7	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	563	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	564	1	2d	2d	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	564	2	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	564	3	568	568	NUM
inlawrev-3967	564	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	564	5	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	564	6	158	158	NUM
inlawrev-3967	564	7	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	564	8	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	564	9	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	565	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	565	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	565	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	566	1	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-3967	566	2	:	:	SYM
inlawrev-3967	566	3	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	566	4	139	139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	566	5	developments	development	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	566	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	566	7	167	167	NUM
inlawrev-3967	566	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	566	9	considering	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	566	10	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	566	11	motion	motion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	566	12	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	566	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	566	14	stay	stay	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	566	15	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-3967	566	16	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	566	17	proceedings	proceeding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	566	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	566	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	566	20	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	566	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	566	22	168	168	NUM
inlawrev-3967	566	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	566	24	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	566	25	turned	turn	VERB
inlawrev-3967	566	26	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	566	27	mercexchange	mercexchange	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	566	28	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	566	29	renewed	renew	VERB
inlawrev-3967	566	30	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	566	31	request	request	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	566	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	567	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	567	2	reviewing	review	VERB
inlawrev-3967	567	3	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	567	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	567	5	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	567	6	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	567	7	shown	show	VERB
inlawrev-3967	567	8	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	567	9	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	567	10	injury	injury	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	567	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	567	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	567	13	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	567	14	ran	run	VERB
inlawrev-3967	567	15	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-3967	567	16	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	567	17	immediate	immediate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	567	18	hurdle	hurdle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	567	19	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	567	20	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	567	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	567	22	oft	oft	ADV
inlawrev-3967	567	23	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	567	24	cited	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	567	25	presumption	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	567	26	ofirreparable	ofirreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	567	27	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	567	28	arising	arise	VERB
inlawrev-3967	567	29	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	567	30	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	567	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	567	32	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	567	33	valid	valid	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	567	34	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	567	35	survived	survive	VERB
inlawrev-3967	567	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	567	37	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	567	38	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	567	39	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	567	40	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	567	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	568	1	169	169	NUM
inlawrev-3967	568	2	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	568	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	568	4	import	import	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	568	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	568	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	568	7	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	568	8	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	568	9	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	568	10	language	language	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	568	11	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	568	12	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-3967	568	13	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	568	14	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	568	15	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	568	16	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	568	17	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	568	18	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	568	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	568	20	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	568	21	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	568	22	came	come	VERB
inlawrev-3967	568	23	down	down	ADP
inlawrev-3967	568	24	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	568	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	568	26	presumption	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	568	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	568	28	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	568	29	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	568	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	569	1	170	170	NUM
inlawrev-3967	569	2	nonetheless	nonetheless	ADV
inlawrev-3967	569	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	569	4	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	569	5	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	569	6	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	569	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	569	8	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	569	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	569	10	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	569	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	569	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	569	13	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	569	14	protected	protect	VERB
inlawrev-3967	569	15	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	569	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	569	17	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	569	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	569	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	569	20	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	569	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	569	22	exclude	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-3967	569	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	569	24	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	569	25	frequently	frequently	ADV
inlawrev-3967	569	26	result	result	VERB
inlawrev-3967	569	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	569	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	569	29	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	569	30	successfully	successfully	ADV
inlawrev-3967	569	31	establishing	establish	VERB
inlawrev-3967	569	32	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	569	33	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	569	34	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	569	35	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	569	36	validity	validity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	569	37	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	569	38	infringement	infringement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	569	39	findings	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	569	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	570	1	171	171	NUM
inlawrev-3967	570	2	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-3967	570	3	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-3967	570	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	570	5	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	570	6	remains	remain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	570	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	570	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	570	9	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	570	10	responsibility	responsibility	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	570	11	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	570	12	affirmatively	affirmatively	ADV
inlawrev-3967	570	13	prove	prove	VERB
inlawrev-3967	570	14	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	570	15	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	570	16	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	570	17	exists	exist	VERB
inlawrev-3967	570	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	570	19	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-3967	570	20	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	570	21	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	570	22	numerous	numerous	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	570	23	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	570	24	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	570	25	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	570	26	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	570	27	weigh	weigh	VERB
inlawrev-3967	570	28	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	570	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	570	30	issuance	issuance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	570	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	570	32	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	570	33	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	570	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	570	35	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	571	1	172	172	NUM
inlawrev-3967	571	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	571	3	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	571	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	571	5	then	then	ADV
inlawrev-3967	571	6	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	571	7	each	each	PRON
inlawrev-3967	571	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	571	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	571	10	traditional	traditional	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	571	11	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-3967	571	12	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	571	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	572	1	173	173	NUM
inlawrev-3967	572	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	572	3	first	first	ADV
inlawrev-3967	572	4	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	572	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	572	6	mercexchange	mercexchange	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	572	7	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	572	8	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	572	9	established	establish	VERB
inlawrev-3967	572	10	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	572	11	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	572	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	573	1	174	174	NUM
inlawrev-3967	573	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	573	3	thorough	thorough	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	573	4	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	5	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	573	6	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	573	7	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	8	covered	cover	VERB
inlawrev-3967	573	9	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	573	10	range	range	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	573	12	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	13	concerning	concern	VERB
inlawrev-3967	573	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	573	15	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	573	17	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-3967	573	18	business	business	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	19	activities	activity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	573	21	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	573	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	573	23	ultimate	ultimate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	573	24	conclusion	conclusion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	25	centered	center	VERB
inlawrev-3967	573	26	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	573	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	573	28	most	most	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	573	29	part	part	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	30	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	573	31	mercexhange	mercexhange	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	32	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	573	33	willingness	willingness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	34	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	573	35	license	license	VERB
inlawrev-3967	573	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	573	37	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	38	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	573	39	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	40	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	573	41	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	573	42	own	own	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	573	43	lack	lack	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	573	45	commercial	commercial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	573	46	activity	activity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	573	47	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	573	48	practicing	practice	VERB
inlawrev-3967	573	49	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	573	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	574	1	175	175	NUM
inlawrev-3967	574	2	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	574	3	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	574	4	preventing	prevent	VERB
inlawrev-3967	574	5	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	574	6	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	574	7	obtaining	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	574	8	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	574	9	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	574	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	574	11	mercexchange	mercexchange	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	574	12	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	574	13	efforts	effort	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	574	14	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	574	15	viewed	view	VERB
inlawrev-3967	574	16	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	574	17	evidencing	evidence	VERB
inlawrev-3967	574	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	574	19	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	574	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	574	21	maximizing	maximize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	574	22	revenue	revenue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	574	23	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	574	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	574	25	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	574	26	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	574	27	having	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	574	28	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	574	29	practice	practice	VERB
inlawrev-3967	574	30	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	574	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	574	32	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	574	33	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	574	34	award	award	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	574	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	574	36	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	574	37	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	574	38	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	574	39	compatible	compatible	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	574	40	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	574	41	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	574	42	policy	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	574	43	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	575	1	176	176	NUM
inlawrev-3967	575	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	575	3	practicality	practicality	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	575	4	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	575	5	suitability	suitability	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	575	6	ofmoney	ofmoney	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	575	7	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	575	8	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	575	9	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	575	10	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	575	11	indicated	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	575	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	575	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	575	14	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	575	15	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	575	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	575	17	plaintiff	plaintiff	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	575	18	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	575	19	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	575	20	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	575	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	576	1	177	177	NUM
inlawrev-3967	576	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	576	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	576	4	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	576	5	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	576	6	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	576	7	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-3967	576	8	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-3967	576	9	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	576	10	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	576	11	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	576	12	sub	sub	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	576	13	-	-	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	576	14	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	576	15	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	576	16	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	576	17	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-3967	576	18	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	576	19	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	576	20	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	576	21	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	576	22	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	576	23	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	576	24	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	576	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	577	1	178	178	NUM
inlawrev-3967	577	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	577	3	first	first	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	577	4	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	577	5	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	577	6	potential	potential	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	577	7	distinction	distinction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	577	8	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	577	9	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-3967	577	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	577	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	577	12	sense	sense	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	577	13	excuse	excuse	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	577	14	mercexchange	mercexchange	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	577	15	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	577	16	licensing	licensing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	577	17	program	program	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	577	18	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	577	19	permit	permit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	577	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	577	21	inference	inference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	577	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	577	23	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	577	24	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	577	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	578	1	179	179	NUM
inlawrev-3967	578	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	578	3	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	578	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	578	5	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	578	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	578	7	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	578	8	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	578	9	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	578	10	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	578	11	seek	seek	VERB
inlawrev-3967	578	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	578	13	license	license	VERB
inlawrev-3967	578	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	578	15	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	578	16	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	578	17	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	578	18	alternative	alternative	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	578	19	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	578	20	raising	raise	VERB
inlawrev-3967	578	21	167	167	NUM
inlawrev-3967	578	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	579	1	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	579	2	559	559	NUM
inlawrev-3967	579	3	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	579	4	62	62	NUM
inlawrev-3967	579	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	580	1	168	168	NUM
inlawrev-3967	580	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	581	1	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	581	2	562	562	NUM
inlawrev-3967	581	3	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	581	4	67	67	NUM
inlawrev-3967	581	5	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	581	6	169	169	NUM
inlawrev-3967	581	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	582	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	582	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	582	3	170	170	NUM
inlawrev-3967	582	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	583	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	583	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	583	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	583	4	568	568	NUM
inlawrev-3967	583	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	583	6	69	69	NUM
inlawrev-3967	583	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	583	8	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	583	9	24	24	NUM
inlawrev-3967	583	10	techs	tech	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	583	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	583	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	583	13	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	583	14	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	584	1	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	584	2	microsoft	microsoft	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	584	3	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	584	4	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	584	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	584	6	434	434	NUM
inlawrev-3967	584	7	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	584	8	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	584	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	585	1	437	437	NUM
inlawrev-3967	585	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	585	3	440	440	NUM
inlawrev-3967	585	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	585	5	e.d	e.d	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	585	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	585	7	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	585	8	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	585	9	2006	2006	NUM
inlawrev-3967	585	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	585	11	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	585	12	paice	paice	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	585	13	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	585	14	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	585	15	toyota	toyota	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	585	16	motor	motor	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	585	17	corp	corp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	585	18	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	585	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	585	20	no	no	INTJ
inlawrev-3967	585	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	586	1	2:04	2:04	NUM
inlawrev-3967	586	2	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	586	3	cv-21	cv-21	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	586	4	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	586	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	586	6	df	df	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	586	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	586	8	2006	2006	NUM
inlawrev-3967	586	9	wl	wl	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	586	10	2385139	2385139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	586	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	586	12	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	586	13	*	*	NUM
inlawrev-3967	586	14	4	4	NUM
inlawrev-3967	586	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	586	16	e.d	e.d	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	586	17	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	586	18	tex	tex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	586	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	586	20	aug	aug	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	586	21	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	586	22	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-3967	586	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	586	24	2006	2006	NUM
inlawrev-3967	586	25	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	586	26	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	586	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	587	1	171	171	NUM
inlawrev-3967	587	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	588	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	588	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	588	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	588	4	569	569	NUM
inlawrev-3967	588	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	589	1	172	172	NUM
inlawrev-3967	589	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	590	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	590	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	590	3	173	173	NUM
inlawrev-3967	590	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	591	1	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	591	2	569	569	NUM
inlawrev-3967	591	3	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	591	4	90	90	NUM
inlawrev-3967	591	5	.	.	NUM
inlawrev-3967	591	6	174	174	NUM
inlawrev-3967	591	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	592	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	592	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	592	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	592	4	569	569	NUM
inlawrev-3967	592	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	592	6	70	70	NUM
inlawrev-3967	592	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	593	1	175	175	NUM
inlawrev-3967	593	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	593	3	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	593	4	569	569	NUM
inlawrev-3967	593	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	593	6	71	71	NUM
inlawrev-3967	593	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	594	1	176	176	NUM
inlawrev-3967	594	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	595	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	595	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	595	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	595	4	569	569	NUM
inlawrev-3967	595	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	595	6	70	70	NUM
inlawrev-3967	595	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	595	8	177	177	NUM
inlawrev-3967	595	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	596	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	596	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	596	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	596	4	571	571	NUM
inlawrev-3967	596	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	596	6	178	178	NUM
inlawrev-3967	596	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	597	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	597	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	597	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	597	4	571	571	NUM
inlawrev-3967	597	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	597	6	75	75	NUM
inlawrev-3967	597	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	598	1	179	179	NUM
inlawrev-3967	598	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	599	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	599	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	599	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	599	4	571	571	NUM
inlawrev-3967	599	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	599	6	72	72	NUM
inlawrev-3967	599	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	599	8	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-3967	599	9	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	599	10	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	599	11	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	599	12	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	599	13	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	599	14	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	599	15	59	59	NUM
inlawrev-3967	599	16	capital	capital	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	599	17	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	599	18	develop	develop	VERB
inlawrev-3967	599	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	599	20	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	599	21	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	599	22	himself	himself	PRON
inlawrev-3967	599	23	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	599	24	herself	herself	PRON
inlawrev-3967	599	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	600	1	180	180	NUM
inlawrev-3967	600	2	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	600	3	scenario	scenario	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	600	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	600	5	distinguishable	distinguishable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	600	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	600	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	600	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	600	9	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	600	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	600	11	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	600	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	600	13	individual	individual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	600	14	inventor	inventor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	600	15	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	600	16	still	still	ADV
inlawrev-3967	600	17	seeking	seek	VERB
inlawrev-3967	600	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	600	19	develop	develop	VERB
inlawrev-3967	600	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	600	21	patented	patent	VERB
inlawrev-3967	600	22	item	item	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	600	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	600	24	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	600	25	mercexchange	mercexchange	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	600	26	sought	seek	VERB
inlawrev-3967	600	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	600	28	license	license	VERB
inlawrev-3967	600	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	600	30	companies	company	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	600	31	already	already	ADV
inlawrev-3967	600	32	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	600	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	600	34	market	market	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	600	35	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	600	36	potentially	potentially	ADV
inlawrev-3967	600	37	infringing	infringe	VERB
inlawrev-3967	600	38	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	600	39	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	600	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	601	1	181	181	NUM
inlawrev-3967	601	2	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	601	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	601	4	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	601	5	opposed	oppose	VERB
inlawrev-3967	601	6	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	601	7	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	601	8	owners	owner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	601	9	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	601	10	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-3967	601	11	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	601	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	601	13	practice	practice	VERB
inlawrev-3967	601	14	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-3967	601	15	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	601	16	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	601	17	nonetheless	nonetheless	ADV
inlawrev-3967	601	18	seek	seek	VERB
inlawrev-3967	601	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	601	20	defend	defend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	601	21	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-3967	601	22	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	601	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	601	24	exclude	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-3967	601	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	601	26	mercexchange	mercexchange	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	601	27	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	601	28	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	601	29	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	601	30	private	private	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	601	31	actions	action	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	601	32	indicate	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	601	33	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	601	34	desire	desire	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	601	35	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	601	36	obtain	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	601	37	royalties	royalty	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	601	38	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	601	39	ebay	ebay	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	601	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	601	41	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	602	1	182	182	NUM
inlawrev-3967	602	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	602	3	record	record	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	602	4	showed	show	VERB
inlawrev-3967	602	5	published	publish	VERB
inlawrev-3967	602	6	statements	statement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	602	7	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	602	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	602	9	mercexchange	mercexchange	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	602	10	officer	officer	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	602	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	602	12	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	602	13	attorney	attorney	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	602	14	suggesting	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-3967	602	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	602	16	ebay	ebay	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	602	17	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-3967	602	18	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	602	19	allowed	allow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	602	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	602	21	use	use	VERB
inlawrev-3967	602	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	602	23	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	602	24	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	602	25	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	602	26	royalty	royalty	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	602	27	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	602	28	bearing	bear	VERB
inlawrev-3967	602	29	arrangement	arrangement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	602	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	602	31	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	602	32	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-3967	602	33	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	602	34	private	private	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	602	35	efforts	effort	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	602	36	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-3967	602	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	602	38	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	602	39	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	602	40	enter	enter	VERB
inlawrev-3967	602	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	602	42	license	license	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	602	43	before	before	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	602	44	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	602	45	began	begin	VERB
inlawrev-3967	602	46	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	603	1	183	183	NUM
inlawrev-3967	603	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	603	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	603	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	603	5	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	603	6	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	603	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	603	8	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	603	9	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	603	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	603	11	light	light	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	603	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	603	13	prior	prior	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	603	14	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	603	15	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	603	16	weighed	weigh	VERB
inlawrev-3967	603	17	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	603	18	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	603	19	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	603	20	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	603	21	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	603	22	indication	indication	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	603	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	603	24	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	603	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	603	26	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	603	27	holder	holder	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	603	28	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	603	29	willingness	willingness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	603	30	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	603	31	forgo	forgo	VERB
inlawrev-3967	603	32	his	his	PRON
inlawrev-3967	603	33	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	603	34	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	603	35	exclude	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-3967	603	36	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	603	37	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	604	1	184	184	NUM
inlawrev-3967	604	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	604	3	third	third	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	604	4	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	604	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	604	6	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	604	7	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	604	8	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	604	9	mercexchange	mercexchange	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	604	10	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	604	11	s	s	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	604	12	lack	lack	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	604	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	604	14	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	604	15	attempt	attempt	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	604	16	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	604	17	obtain	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	604	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	604	19	preliminary	preliminary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	604	20	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	604	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	605	1	185	185	NUM
inlawrev-3967	605	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	605	3	opined	opine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	605	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	605	5	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-3967	605	6	are	be	VERB
inlawrev-3967	605	7	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	605	8	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	605	9	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	605	10	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	605	11	go	go	VERB
inlawrev-3967	605	12	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-3967	605	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	605	14	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	605	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	605	16	seek	seek	VERB
inlawrev-3967	605	17	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	605	18	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	605	19	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	605	20	seek	seek	VERB
inlawrev-3967	605	21	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	605	22	preliminary	preliminary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	605	23	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	605	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	605	25	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	605	26	preliminary	preliminary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	605	27	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	605	28	permanent	permanent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	605	29	injunctions	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	605	30	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	605	31	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	605	32	differences	difference	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	605	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	606	1	186	186	NUM
inlawrev-3967	606	2	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-3967	606	3	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-3967	606	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	606	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	606	6	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	7	believed	believe	VERB
inlawrev-3967	606	8	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	606	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	606	10	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	11	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	606	12	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	606	13	seek	seek	VERB
inlawrev-3967	606	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	606	15	preliminary	preliminary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	606	16	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	17	weighed	weigh	VERB
inlawrev-3967	606	18	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	606	19	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	606	20	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	21	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	606	22	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	606	23	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	606	24	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	606	25	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	606	26	consistent	consistent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	606	27	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	606	28	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	606	29	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	606	30	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	31	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	606	32	record	record	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	33	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	606	34	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	606	35	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	606	36	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	606	37	licensing	licensing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	38	efforts	effort	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	39	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	606	40	defendant	defendant	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	41	ebay	ebay	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	606	42	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	606	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	606	44	reduction	reduction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	45	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	606	46	available	available	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	606	47	royalties	royalty	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	48	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	606	49	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	606	50	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	51	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	606	52	issued	issue	VERB
inlawrev-3967	606	53	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	606	54	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	606	55	indicated	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	606	56	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	606	57	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	606	58	true	true	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	606	59	goal	goal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	60	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	606	61	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	606	62	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	606	63	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	606	64	defend	defend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	606	65	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	606	66	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	606	67	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	606	68	exclude	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-3967	606	69	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	607	1	187	187	NUM
inlawrev-3967	607	2	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	607	3	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	607	4	wanted	want	VERB
inlawrev-3967	607	5	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	607	6	defend	defend	VERB
inlawrev-3967	607	7	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	607	8	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	607	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	607	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	607	11	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	607	12	thought	think	VERB
inlawrev-3967	607	13	mercexchange	mercexchange	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	607	14	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	607	15	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	607	16	likely	likely	ADV
inlawrev-3967	607	17	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	607	18	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-3967	607	19	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	607	20	attempted	attempt	VERB
inlawrev-3967	607	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	607	22	stop	stop	VERB
inlawrev-3967	607	23	ebay	ebay	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	607	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	607	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	607	26	purported	purport	VERB
inlawrev-3967	607	27	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	607	28	market	market	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	607	29	monopolist	monopolist	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	607	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	607	31	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	607	32	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	607	33	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-3967	607	34	improving	improve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	607	35	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	607	36	foothold	foothold	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	607	37	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	607	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	607	39	market	market	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	607	40	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	607	41	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	607	42	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	607	43	continued	continue	VERB
inlawrev-3967	607	44	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	608	1	188	188	NUM
inlawrev-3967	608	2	fourth	fourth	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	608	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	608	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	608	5	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	608	6	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	608	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	608	8	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	608	9	ofthe	ofthe	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	608	10	business	business	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	608	11	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	608	12	method	method	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	608	13	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	608	14	matter	matter	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	608	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	608	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	608	17	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	608	18	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	608	19	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	608	20	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	608	21	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	608	22	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	608	23	appears	appear	VERB
inlawrev-3967	608	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	608	25	rely	rely	VERB
inlawrev-3967	608	26	upon	upon	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	608	27	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	608	28	unique	unique	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	608	29	combination	combination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	608	30	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	608	31	nonunique	nonunique	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	608	32	elements	element	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	608	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	608	34	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	609	1	189	189	NUM
inlawrev-3967	609	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	609	3	agreed	agree	VERB
inlawrev-3967	609	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	609	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	609	6	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	609	7	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	609	8	valid	valid	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	609	9	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	609	10	enforceable	enforceable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	609	11	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	609	12	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	609	13	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	609	14	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	609	15	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	609	16	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	609	17	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	609	18	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	609	19	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-3967	609	20	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	609	21	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	609	22	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-3967	609	23	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	609	24	much	much	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	609	25	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	609	26	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	609	27	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	609	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	610	1	190	190	NUM
inlawrev-3967	610	2	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-3967	610	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	610	4	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	610	5	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	610	6	observed	observe	VERB
inlawrev-3967	610	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	610	8	need	need	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	610	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	610	10	caution	caution	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	610	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	610	12	granting	grant	VERB
inlawrev-3967	610	13	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	610	14	patents	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	610	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	610	16	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	610	17	expressed	express	VERB
inlawrev-3967	610	18	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	610	19	supreme	supreme	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	610	20	court	court	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	610	21	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	610	22	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	610	23	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	610	24	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	610	25	international	international	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	610	26	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	610	27	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	610	28	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	610	29	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	610	30	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	611	1	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	611	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	611	3	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	611	4	remanding	remand	VERB
inlawrev-3967	611	5	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	611	6	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	611	7	back	back	ADV
inlawrev-3967	611	8	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	611	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	611	10	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	611	11	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	611	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	611	13	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	611	14	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-3967	611	15	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	611	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	611	17	multiple	multiple	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	611	18	rejections	rejection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	611	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	611	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	611	21	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	611	22	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	611	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	611	24	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	611	25	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	611	26	191	191	NUM
inlawrev-3967	611	27	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	611	28	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	611	29	light	light	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	611	30	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	611	31	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	611	32	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	611	33	suggested	suggest	VERB
inlawrev-3967	611	34	180	180	NUM
inlawrev-3967	611	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	612	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	612	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	612	3	181	181	NUM
inlawrev-3967	612	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	613	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	613	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	613	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	613	4	572	572	NUM
inlawrev-3967	613	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	613	6	182	182	NUM
inlawrev-3967	613	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	614	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	614	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	614	3	183	183	NUM
inlawrev-3967	614	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	615	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	615	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	615	3	184	184	NUM
inlawrev-3967	615	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	616	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	616	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	616	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	616	4	573	573	NUM
inlawrev-3967	616	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	616	6	185	185	NUM
inlawrev-3967	616	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	617	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	617	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	617	3	186	186	NUM
inlawrev-3967	617	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	618	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	618	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	618	3	187	187	NUM
inlawrev-3967	618	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	619	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	619	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	619	3	188	188	NUM
inlawrev-3967	619	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	620	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	620	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	620	3	189	189	NUM
inlawrev-3967	620	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	621	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	621	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	621	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	621	4	574	574	NUM
inlawrev-3967	621	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	622	1	190	190	NUM
inlawrev-3967	622	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	623	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	623	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	623	3	191	191	NUM
inlawrev-3967	623	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	624	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	624	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	624	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	624	4	574	574	NUM
inlawrev-3967	624	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	624	6	75	75	NUM
inlawrev-3967	624	7	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	624	8	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	624	9	ksr	ksr	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	624	10	int'l	int'l	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	624	11	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	624	12	v.	v.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	624	13	teleflex	teleflex	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	624	14	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	624	15	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	624	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	624	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	624	18	127	127	NUM
inlawrev-3967	624	19	s.	s.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	624	20	ct	ct	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	624	21	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	624	22	1727	1727	NUM
inlawrev-3967	624	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	624	24	1739	1739	NUM
inlawrev-3967	624	25	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	624	26	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	624	27	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	624	28	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	624	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	625	1	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	625	2	160	160	NUM
inlawrev-3967	625	3	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	625	4	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	625	5	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	625	6	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	625	7	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	625	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	625	9	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-3967	625	10	:	:	SYM
inlawrev-3967	625	11	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	625	12	139	139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	625	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	625	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	625	15	nature	nature	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	625	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	625	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	625	18	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	625	19	weighed	weigh	VERB
inlawrev-3967	625	20	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	625	21	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	625	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	625	23	finding	finding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	625	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	625	25	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	625	26	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	625	27	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	625	28	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	625	29	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	625	30	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	625	31	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	625	32	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	625	33	improvidently	improvidently	ADV
inlawrev-3967	625	34	granted	grant	VERB
inlawrev-3967	625	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	625	36	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	626	1	192	192	NUM
inlawrev-3967	626	2	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	626	3	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	626	4	four	four	NUM
inlawrev-3967	626	5	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	626	6	sub	sub	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	626	7	-	-	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	626	8	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	626	9	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	626	10	weighed	weigh	VERB
inlawrev-3967	626	11	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	626	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	626	13	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	626	14	ofirreparable	ofirreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	626	15	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	626	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	626	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	626	18	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	626	19	saw	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	626	20	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	626	21	surrounding	surround	VERB
inlawrev-3967	626	22	mercexchange	mercexchange	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	626	23	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	626	24	relationship	relationship	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	626	25	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	626	26	another	another	DET
inlawrev-3967	626	27	licensor	licensor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	626	28	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	626	29	having	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	626	30	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	626	31	potential	potential	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	626	32	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	626	33	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	626	34	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	626	35	significant	significant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	626	36	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	626	37	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	626	38	favoring	favor	VERB
inlawrev-3967	626	39	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	626	40	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	626	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	627	1	193	193	NUM
inlawrev-3967	627	2	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	627	3	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	627	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	627	5	discussed	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-3967	627	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	627	7	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	627	8	detail	detail	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	627	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	627	10	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	627	11	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	627	12	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	627	13	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	627	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	627	15	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	627	16	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	627	17	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	627	18	pointed	point	VERB
inlawrev-3967	627	19	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	627	20	mercexchange	mercexchange	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	627	21	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	627	22	desire	desire	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	627	23	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	627	24	revenue	revenue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	627	25	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-3967	627	26	licensing	licensing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	627	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	627	28	rather	rather	ADV
inlawrev-3967	627	29	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-3967	627	30	assisting	assist	VERB
inlawrev-3967	627	31	itself	itself	PRON
inlawrev-3967	627	32	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	627	33	another	another	PRON
inlawrev-3967	627	34	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	627	35	exclude	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-3967	627	36	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	627	37	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	627	38	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	627	39	market	market	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	627	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	628	1	194	194	NUM
inlawrev-3967	629	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	629	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	629	3	likewise	likewise	ADV
inlawrev-3967	629	4	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	629	5	additional	additional	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	629	6	arguments	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	629	7	frommercexchange	frommercexchange	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	629	8	offered	offer	VERB
inlawrev-3967	629	9	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	629	10	new	new	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	629	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	629	12	previously	previously	ADV
inlawrev-3967	629	13	obtained	obtain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	629	14	evidence	evidence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	629	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	629	16	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	629	17	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	629	18	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	629	19	either	either	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	629	20	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	629	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	629	22	indicators	indicator	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	629	23	ofirreparable	ofirreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	629	24	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	629	25	and/or	and/or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	629	26	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	629	27	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	629	28	overcome	overcome	VERB
inlawrev-3967	629	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	629	30	considerations	consideration	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	629	31	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	629	32	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	629	33	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	629	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	630	1	195	195	NUM
inlawrev-3967	630	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	630	3	ultimately	ultimately	ADV
inlawrev-3967	630	4	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	630	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	630	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	630	7	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	630	8	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	630	9	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	630	10	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	630	11	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	630	12	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-3967	630	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	630	14	entry	entry	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	630	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	630	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	630	17	permanent	permanent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	630	18	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	630	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	631	1	196	196	NUM
inlawrev-3967	631	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	631	3	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	631	4	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	631	5	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	631	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	631	7	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	631	8	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-3967	631	9	is	be	VERB
inlawrev-3967	631	10	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	631	11	adequate	adequate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	631	12	remedy	remedy	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	631	13	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	631	14	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	631	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	631	16	overlaps	overlap	VERB
inlawrev-3967	631	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	631	18	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	631	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	631	20	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	631	21	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	631	22	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	631	23	exists	exist	VERB
inlawrev-3967	631	24	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	632	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	632	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	632	3	summarized	summarize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	632	4	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	632	5	points	point	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	632	6	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	632	7	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	632	8	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	632	9	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	632	10	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	632	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	632	12	determined	determine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	632	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	632	14	money	money	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	632	15	damages	damage	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	632	16	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	632	17	adequately	adequately	ADV
inlawrev-3967	632	18	compensate	compensate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	632	19	mercexchange	mercexchange	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	632	20	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	632	21	light	light	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	632	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	632	23	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	632	24	licensing	licensing	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	632	25	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	632	26	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	632	27	policies	policy	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	632	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	633	1	197	197	NUM
inlawrev-3967	633	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	633	3	determination	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	633	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	633	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	633	6	second	second	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	633	7	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	633	8	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	633	9	weighed	weigh	VERB
inlawrev-3967	633	10	•	•	NUM
inlawrev-3967	633	11	•	•	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	633	12	•	•	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	633	13	•	•	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	633	14	108	108	NUM
inlawrev-3967	633	15	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	633	16	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	633	17	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	633	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	634	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	634	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	634	3	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-3967	634	4	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	634	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	634	6	final	final	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	634	7	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-3967	634	8	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	634	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	634	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	634	11	balance	balance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	634	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	634	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	634	14	hardships	hardship	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	634	15	between	between	ADP
inlawrev-3967	634	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	634	17	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	634	18	199	199	NUM
inlawrev-3967	634	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	634	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	634	21	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	634	22	interest	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	634	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	635	1	200	200	NUM
inlawrev-3967	635	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	635	3	former	former	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	635	4	favored	favor	VERB
inlawrev-3967	635	5	neither	neither	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	635	6	party	party	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	635	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	635	8	according	accord	VERB
inlawrev-3967	635	9	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	635	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	635	11	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	635	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	635	13	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-3967	635	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	635	15	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	635	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	635	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	635	18	relevant	relevant	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	635	19	information	information	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	635	20	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	635	21	record	record	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	635	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	636	1	201	201	NUM
inlawrev-3967	636	2	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	636	3	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	636	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	636	5	latter	latter	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	636	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	636	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	636	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	636	9	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	636	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	636	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	636	12	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	636	13	interest	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	636	14	slightly	slightly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	636	15	weighed	weigh	VERB
inlawrev-3967	636	16	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	636	17	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	636	18	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	636	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	637	1	202	202	NUM
inlawrev-3967	637	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	637	3	started	start	VERB
inlawrev-3967	637	4	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	637	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	637	6	premise	premise	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	637	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	637	9	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	637	10	interest	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	11	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	637	12	maintaining	maintain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	637	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	637	14	strong	strong	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	637	15	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	16	system	system	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	17	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	637	18	favor	favor	VERB
inlawrev-3967	637	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	637	20	patentee	patentee	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	637	22	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	637	23	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	637	24	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	637	25	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	637	26	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	637	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	637	28	type	type	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	29	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	637	30	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	31	involved	involve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	637	32	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	637	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	637	34	impact	impact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	35	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	637	36	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	637	37	market	market	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	637	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	637	40	impact	impact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	41	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	637	42	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	637	43	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	44	system	system	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	637	46	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	637	47	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	637	48	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	637	49	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	50	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	637	51	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	637	52	impact	impact	VERB
inlawrev-3967	637	53	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	637	54	public	public	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	637	55	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	637	56	large	large	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	637	57	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	638	1	"203	"203	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	639	1	192	192	NUM
inlawrev-3967	639	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	640	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	640	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	640	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	640	4	575	575	NUM
inlawrev-3967	640	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	641	1	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	641	2	35	35	NUM
inlawrev-3967	641	3	u.s.c	u.s.c	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	641	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	642	1	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	642	2	282	282	NUM
inlawrev-3967	642	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	642	4	2000	2000	NUM
inlawrev-3967	642	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	642	6	unequivocally	unequivocally	ADV
inlawrev-3967	642	7	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	642	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	642	9	presumption	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	642	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	642	11	validity	validity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	642	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	642	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	642	14	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	642	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	642	16	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	642	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	642	18	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	642	19	survived	survive	VERB
inlawrev-3967	642	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	642	21	underlying	underlie	VERB
inlawrev-3967	642	22	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	642	23	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	642	24	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	642	25	mercexchange	mercexchange	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	642	26	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	642	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	642	28	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	642	29	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-3967	642	30	appear	appear	VERB
inlawrev-3967	642	31	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	642	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	642	33	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	642	34	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	642	35	recital	recital	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	642	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	642	37	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	642	38	improvidently	improvidently	ADV
inlawrev-3967	642	39	granted	grant	VERB
inlawrev-3967	642	40	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	642	41	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	642	42	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	642	43	factor	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	642	44	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	642	45	irreparable	irreparable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	642	46	harm	harm	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	642	47	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	642	48	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	642	49	supportable	supportable	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	642	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	643	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-3967	643	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	643	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	643	4	record	record	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	643	5	indicated	indicate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	643	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	643	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	643	8	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	643	9	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	643	10	issue	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	643	11	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	643	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	643	13	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-3967	643	14	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	643	15	reexamination	reexamination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	643	16	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	643	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	643	18	pto	pto	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	643	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	643	20	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	643	21	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	643	22	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	643	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	643	24	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	643	25	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	643	26	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	643	27	initially	initially	ADV
inlawrev-3967	643	28	rejected	reject	VERB
inlawrev-3967	643	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	644	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	644	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	644	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	644	4	574	574	NUM
inlawrev-3967	644	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	645	1	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	645	2	fact	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	645	3	apparently	apparently	ADV
inlawrev-3967	645	4	allowed	allow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	645	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	645	6	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	645	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	645	8	get	get	VERB
inlawrev-3967	645	9	past	past	ADP
inlawrev-3967	645	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	645	11	validity	validity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	645	12	presumption	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	645	13	and/or	and/or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	645	14	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	645	15	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	645	16	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	645	17	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	645	18	validity	validity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	645	19	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	645	20	existed	exist	VERB
inlawrev-3967	645	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	646	1	193	193	NUM
inlawrev-3967	646	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	647	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	647	2	d	d	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	647	3	:	:	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	647	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	647	5	575	575	NUM
inlawrev-3967	647	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	648	1	194	194	NUM
inlawrev-3967	648	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	649	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	649	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	649	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	649	4	575	575	NUM
inlawrev-3967	649	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	649	6	76	76	NUM
inlawrev-3967	649	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	650	1	195	195	NUM
inlawrev-3967	650	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	651	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	651	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	651	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	651	4	575	575	NUM
inlawrev-3967	651	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	651	6	80	80	NUM
inlawrev-3967	651	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	652	1	196	196	NUM
inlawrev-3967	652	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	653	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	653	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	653	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	653	4	580	580	NUM
inlawrev-3967	653	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	653	6	81	81	NUM
inlawrev-3967	653	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	653	8	197	197	NUM
inlawrev-3967	653	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	654	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	654	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	654	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	654	4	582	582	NUM
inlawrev-3967	654	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	654	6	83	83	NUM
inlawrev-3967	654	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	654	8	198	198	NUM
inlawrev-3967	654	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	655	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	655	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	655	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	655	4	583	583	NUM
inlawrev-3967	655	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	655	6	199	199	NUM
inlawrev-3967	655	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	656	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	656	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	656	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	656	4	583	583	NUM
inlawrev-3967	656	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	656	6	86	86	NUM
inlawrev-3967	656	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	657	1	200	200	NUM
inlawrev-3967	657	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	658	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	658	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	658	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	658	4	586	586	NUM
inlawrev-3967	658	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	658	6	90	90	NUM
inlawrev-3967	658	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	658	8	201	201	NUM
inlawrev-3967	658	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	659	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	659	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	659	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	659	4	585	585	NUM
inlawrev-3967	659	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	659	6	86	86	NUM
inlawrev-3967	659	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	660	1	202	202	NUM
inlawrev-3967	660	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	661	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	661	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	661	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	661	4	586	586	NUM
inlawrev-3967	661	5	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	661	6	203	203	NUM
inlawrev-3967	661	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	662	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	662	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	662	3	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-3967	662	4	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	662	5	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	662	6	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	7	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	8	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	662	9	161	161	NUM
inlawrev-3967	662	10	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-3967	662	11	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	662	12	discussion	discussion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	662	14	these	these	DET
inlawrev-3967	662	15	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	662	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	662	18	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	19	came	come	VERB
inlawrev-3967	662	20	back	back	ADV
inlawrev-3967	662	21	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	662	22	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	662	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	662	24	seemed	seem	VERB
inlawrev-3967	662	25	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	662	26	emphasize	emphasize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	662	27	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	662	28	mercexchange	mercexchange	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	662	29	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	662	30	s	s	PART
inlawrev-3967	662	31	litigation	litigation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	32	position	position	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	33	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	662	34	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	662	35	statements	statement	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	36	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	662	37	apparent	apparent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	662	38	disregard	disregard	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	39	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	662	40	minimization	minimization	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	662	42	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	662	43	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	44	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	662	45	exclude	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-3967	662	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	662	47	finding	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	662	48	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	662	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	662	50	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	662	51	public	public	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	662	52	interest	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	53	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	662	54	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	662	55	disserved	disserve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	662	56	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	662	57	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	662	58	allowing	allow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	662	59	mercexchange	mercexchange	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	60	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	662	61	assert	assert	VERB
inlawrev-3967	662	62	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	662	63	alternative	alternative	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	662	64	reality	reality	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	65	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	662	66	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	662	67	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	68	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	662	69	trial	trial	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	662	70	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	663	1	204	204	NUM
inlawrev-3967	663	2	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	663	3	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-3967	663	4	factors	factor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	663	5	pointing	point	VERB
inlawrev-3967	663	6	away	away	ADV
inlawrev-3967	663	7	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	663	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	663	9	permanent	permanent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	663	10	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	663	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	663	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	663	13	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	663	14	refused	refuse	VERB
inlawrev-3967	663	15	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	663	16	enter	enter	VERB
inlawrev-3967	663	17	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	663	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	664	1	205	205	NUM
inlawrev-3967	664	2	certainly	certainly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	664	3	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	664	4	permanent	permanent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	664	5	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	664	6	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	664	7	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	664	8	necessarily	necessarily	ADV
inlawrev-3967	664	9	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	664	10	focused	focus	VERB
inlawrev-3967	664	11	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	664	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	664	13	particular	particular	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	664	14	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	664	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	664	16	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	664	17	given	give	VERB
inlawrev-3967	664	18	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	664	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	664	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	664	21	so	so	ADV
inlawrev-3967	664	22	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	664	23	value	value	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	664	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	664	25	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	664	26	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	664	27	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	664	28	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	664	29	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	664	30	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	664	31	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	664	32	predicting	predict	VERB
inlawrev-3967	664	33	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	664	34	outcome	outcome	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	664	35	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	664	36	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	664	37	persuading	persuade	VERB
inlawrev-3967	664	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	664	39	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	664	40	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	664	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	664	42	later	later	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	664	43	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	664	44	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	664	45	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	664	46	small	small	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	664	47	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	664	48	negligible	negligible	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	664	49	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	665	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	665	2	mercexchange	mercexchange	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	665	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	665	4	went	go	VERB
inlawrev-3967	665	5	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-3967	665	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	665	7	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	665	8	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	665	9	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	665	10	express	express	VERB
inlawrev-3967	665	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	665	12	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	665	13	analysis	analysis	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	665	14	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	665	15	dependent	dependent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	665	16	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	665	17	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	665	18	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	665	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	665	20	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	665	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	665	22	represent	represent	VERB
inlawrev-3967	665	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	665	24	use	use	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	665	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	665	26	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	665	27	presumptions	presumption	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	665	28	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	665	29	bright	bright	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	665	30	line	line	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	665	31	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	665	32	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	666	1	206	206	NUM
inlawrev-3967	666	2	nevertheless	nevertheless	ADV
inlawrev-3967	666	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	666	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	666	5	variety	variety	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	666	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	666	7	issues	issue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	666	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	666	9	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	666	10	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	666	11	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	666	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	666	13	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	666	14	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	666	15	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	666	16	them	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	666	17	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	666	18	quite	quite	ADV
inlawrev-3967	666	19	instructive	instructive	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	666	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	667	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	667	2	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	667	3	possible	possible	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	667	4	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	667	5	course	course	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	667	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	667	7	further	further	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	667	8	appeals	appeal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	667	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	667	10	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	667	11	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	667	12	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	667	13	affect	affect	VERB
inlawrev-3967	667	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	667	15	merit	merit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	667	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	667	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	667	18	analytical	analytical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	667	19	framework	framework	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	667	20	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	667	21	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	667	22	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	667	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	668	1	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	668	2	now	now	ADV
inlawrev-3967	668	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	668	4	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	668	5	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-3967	668	6	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	668	7	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	668	8	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	668	9	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	668	10	come	come	VERB
inlawrev-3967	668	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	668	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	668	13	decision	decision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	668	14	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	668	15	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	668	16	guidance	guidance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	668	17	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	668	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	668	19	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	668	20	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	668	21	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	668	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	668	23	permanent	permanent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	668	24	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	668	25	request	request	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	668	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	669	1	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	669	2	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	669	3	provides	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	669	4	clear	clear	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	669	5	clues	clue	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	669	6	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	669	7	counsel	counsel	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	669	8	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	669	9	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	669	10	businesspeople	businesspeople	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	669	11	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	669	12	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	669	13	what	what	DET
inlawrev-3967	669	14	conduct	conduct	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	669	15	should	should	AUX
inlawrev-3967	669	16	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	669	17	avoided	avoid	VERB
inlawrev-3967	669	18	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	669	19	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	669	20	patent	patent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	669	21	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	669	22	inherent	inherent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	669	23	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	669	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	669	25	exclude	exclude	VERB
inlawrev-3967	669	26	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	669	27	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	669	28	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	669	29	preserved	preserve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	669	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	670	1	iv	iv	X
inlawrev-3967	670	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	670	3	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	670	4	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	670	5	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	670	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	670	7	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	670	8	—	—	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	670	9	shaw	shaw	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	670	10	familyarchives	familyarchives	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	670	11	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	670	12	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	670	13	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	670	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	670	15	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	670	16	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	670	17	207	207	NUM
inlawrev-3967	670	18	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	670	19	enjoyed	enjoy	VERB
inlawrev-3967	670	20	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	670	21	certain	certain	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	670	22	amount	amount	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	670	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	670	24	fanfare	fanfare	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	670	25	centering	center	VERB
inlawrev-3967	670	26	around	around	ADP
inlawrev-3967	670	27	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	670	28	comparatively	comparatively	ADV
inlawrev-3967	670	29	broad	broad	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	670	30	protections	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	670	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	670	32	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	670	33	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	670	34	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	670	35	hundred	hundred	NUM
inlawrev-3967	670	36	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	670	37	year	year	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	670	38	term	term	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	670	39	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	670	40	protection	protection	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	670	41	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	670	42	208	208	NUM
inlawrev-3967	670	43	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	670	44	longest	long	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	670	45	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	670	46	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	670	47	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	670	48	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	670	49	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	670	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	671	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-3967	671	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	671	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	671	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	671	5	relatively	relatively	ADV
inlawrev-3967	671	6	few	few	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	671	7	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	671	8	since	since	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	671	9	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	671	10	enactment	enactment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	671	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	671	12	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	671	13	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	671	14	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	671	15	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	671	16	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	671	17	subject	subject	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	671	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	671	19	very	very	ADV
inlawrev-3967	671	20	few	few	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	671	21	reported	report	VERB
inlawrev-3967	671	22	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	671	23	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	672	1	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	672	2	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	672	3	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	672	4	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	672	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	672	6	united	united	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	672	7	states	states	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	672	8	district	district	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	672	9	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	672	10	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	672	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	672	12	southern	southern	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	672	13	district	district	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	672	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	672	15	new	new	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	672	16	york	york	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	672	17	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	672	18	opened	open	VERB
inlawrev-3967	672	19	up	up	ADP
inlawrev-3967	672	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	672	21	possibility	possibility	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	672	22	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	672	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	672	24	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	672	25	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	672	26	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	672	27	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	672	28	far	far	ADV
inlawrev-3967	672	29	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	672	30	reaching	reach	VERB
inlawrev-3967	672	31	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	672	32	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	672	33	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	672	34	thought	think	VERB
inlawrev-3967	672	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	673	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	673	2	shaw	shaw	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	673	3	family	family	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	673	4	archives	archives	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	673	5	ltd	ltd	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	673	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	674	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	674	2	cmg	cmg	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	674	3	worldwide	worldwide	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	674	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	674	5	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	674	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	674	7	,209	,209	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	675	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	675	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	675	3	considered	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	675	4	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	675	5	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-3967	675	6	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	675	7	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	675	8	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	675	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	675	10	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	675	11	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	675	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	675	13	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	675	14	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	675	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	675	16	laws	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	675	17	ofnew	ofnew	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	675	18	york	york	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	675	19	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	675	20	california	california	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	675	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	675	22	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	675	23	how	how	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	675	24	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	675	25	affected	affect	VERB
inlawrev-3967	675	26	photographs	photograph	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	675	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	675	28	marilyn	marilyn	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	675	29	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	675	30	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	676	1	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	676	2	2005	2005	NUM
inlawrev-3967	676	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	676	4	indianapolis	indianapolis	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	676	5	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	676	6	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-3967	676	7	cmg	cmg	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	676	8	worldwide	worldwide	ADV
inlawrev-3967	676	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	676	10	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	676	11	cmg	cmg	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	676	12	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	676	13	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	676	14	along	along	ADP
inlawrev-3967	676	15	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	676	16	marilyn	marilyn	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	676	17	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	676	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	676	19	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	676	20	filed	file	VERB
inlawrev-3967	676	21	suit	suit	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	676	22	against	against	ADP
inlawrev-3967	676	23	shaw	shaw	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	676	24	family	family	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	676	25	archives	archive	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	676	26	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	676	27	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	676	28	sfa	sfa	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	676	29	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	676	30	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	676	31	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	676	32	others	other	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	676	33	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	676	34	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	676	35	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	676	36	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	676	37	indianapolis	indianapolis	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	676	38	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	676	39	alleging	allege	VERB
inlawrev-3967	676	40	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	676	41	violation	violation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	676	42	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	676	43	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	676	44	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	676	45	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	676	46	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	676	47	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	676	48	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	676	49	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	676	50	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	676	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	677	1	210	210	NUM
inlawrev-3967	677	2	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-3967	677	3	being	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	677	4	served	serve	VERB
inlawrev-3967	677	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	677	6	sfa	sfa	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	677	7	filed	file	VERB
inlawrev-3967	677	8	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	677	9	action	action	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	677	10	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	677	11	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	677	12	claims	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	677	13	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	677	14	including	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	677	15	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	677	16	request	request	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	677	17	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	677	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	677	19	declaratory	declaratory	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	677	20	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	677	21	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	677	22	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	677	23	whether	whether	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	677	24	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	677	25	post204	post204	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	677	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	678	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	678	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	678	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	678	4	586	586	NUM
inlawrev-3967	678	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	678	6	90	90	NUM
inlawrev-3967	678	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	678	8	205	205	NUM
inlawrev-3967	678	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	678	10	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	678	11	591	591	NUM
inlawrev-3967	678	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	678	13	206	206	NUM
inlawrev-3967	678	14	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	679	1	see	see	VERB
inlawrev-3967	679	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	679	3	e.g.	e.g.	ADV
inlawrev-3967	679	4	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	679	5	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	679	6	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-3967	679	7	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	679	8	569	569	NUM
inlawrev-3967	679	9	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	679	10	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-3967	679	11	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	679	12	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	679	13	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	679	14	permanent	permanent	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	679	15	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	679	16	shall	shall	AUX
inlawrev-3967	679	17	only	only	ADV
inlawrev-3967	679	18	issue	issue	VERB
inlawrev-3967	679	19	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	679	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	679	21	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	679	22	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	680	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	680	2	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	680	3	specific	specific	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	680	4	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	680	5	warrant	warrant	VERB
inlawrev-3967	680	6	entry	entry	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	680	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	680	8	an	an	DET
inlawrev-3967	680	9	injunction	injunction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	680	10	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	680	11	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	680	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	681	1	207	207	NUM
inlawrev-3967	681	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	682	1	ind	ind	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	682	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	682	3	code	code	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	682	4	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	682	5	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	682	6	32	32	NUM
inlawrev-3967	682	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	682	8	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-3967	682	9	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	682	10	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	682	11	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	682	12	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	682	13	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	682	14	-20	-20	NUM
inlawrev-3967	682	15	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	682	16	2004	2004	NUM
inlawrev-3967	682	17	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	682	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	683	1	208	208	NUM
inlawrev-3967	683	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	684	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	684	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	684	3	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	684	4	32	32	NUM
inlawrev-3967	684	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	684	6	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-3967	684	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	684	8	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	684	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	684	10	8	8	NUM
inlawrev-3967	684	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	684	12	209	209	NUM
inlawrev-3967	684	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	685	1	486	486	NUM
inlawrev-3967	685	2	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	685	3	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	685	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	686	1	2d	2d	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	686	2	309	309	NUM
inlawrev-3967	686	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	686	4	s.d.n.y	s.d.n.y	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	686	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	686	6	2007	2007	NUM
inlawrev-3967	686	7	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	686	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	687	1	210	210	NUM
inlawrev-3967	687	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	688	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	688	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	688	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	688	4	310	310	NUM
inlawrev-3967	688	5	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	688	6	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	688	7	162	162	NUM
inlawrev-3967	688	8	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	688	9	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	688	10	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	689	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	689	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	689	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	690	1	41	41	NUM
inlawrev-3967	690	2	:	:	SYM
inlawrev-3967	690	3	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	690	4	139	139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	690	5	mortem	mortem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	690	6	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	690	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	690	8	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	690	9	existed	exist	VERB
inlawrev-3967	690	10	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	690	11	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	690	12	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	690	13	name	name	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	690	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	690	15	likeness	likeness	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	690	16	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	690	17	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	690	18	image	image	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	690	19	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	691	1	2u	2u	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	691	2	following	follow	VERB
inlawrev-3967	691	3	motions	motion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	691	4	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	691	5	each	each	DET
inlawrev-3967	691	6	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	691	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	691	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	691	9	cases	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	691	10	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	691	11	consolidated	consolidate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	691	12	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	691	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	691	14	new	new	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	691	15	york	york	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	691	16	federal	federal	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	691	17	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	691	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	691	19	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	691	20	ruled	rule	VERB
inlawrev-3967	691	21	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	691	22	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	691	23	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	691	24	choice	choice	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	691	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	691	26	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	691	27	principles	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	691	28	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	691	29	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	691	30	used	use	VERB
inlawrev-3967	691	31	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	691	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	691	33	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	691	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	692	1	212	212	NUM
inlawrev-3967	692	2	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	692	3	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	692	4	dealt	deal	VERB
inlawrev-3967	692	5	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	692	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	692	7	parties	party	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	692	8	'	'	PART
inlawrev-3967	692	9	cross	cros	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	692	10	-	-	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	692	11	motions	motion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	692	12	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	692	13	summary	summary	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	692	14	judgment	judgment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	692	15	focused	focus	VERB
inlawrev-3967	692	16	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	692	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	692	18	application	application	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	692	19	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	692	20	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	692	21	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	692	22	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	692	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	692	24	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	692	25	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	692	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	693	1	213	213	NUM
inlawrev-3967	693	2	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	693	3	factual	factual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	693	4	background	background	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	693	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	693	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	693	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	693	8	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	693	9	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	693	10	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	693	11	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	693	12	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	693	13	included	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	693	14	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	693	15	residuary	residuary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	693	16	clause	clause	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	693	17	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	693	18	bequeathed	bequeath	VERB
inlawrev-3967	693	19	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	693	20	lee	lee	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	693	21	strasberg	strasberg	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	693	22	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	693	23	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	693	24	entire	entire	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	693	25	remaining	remain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	693	26	balance	balance	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	693	27	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	693	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	693	29	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	693	30	estate	estate	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	693	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	694	1	214	214	NUM
inlawrev-3967	694	2	eventually	eventually	ADV
inlawrev-3967	694	3	marilyn	marilyn	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	694	4	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	694	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	694	6	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	694	7	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	694	8	formed	form	VERB
inlawrev-3967	694	9	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	694	10	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	694	11	hold	hold	VERB
inlawrev-3967	694	12	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	694	13	manage	manage	VERB
inlawrev-3967	694	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	694	15	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	694	16	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	694	17	assets	asset	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	694	18	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	694	19	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	694	20	residuary	residuary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	694	21	beneficiaries	beneficiary	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	694	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	694	23	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	694	24	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	694	25	will	will	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	694	26	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	694	27	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	695	1	215	215	NUM
inlawrev-3967	695	2	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	695	3	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	695	4	sfa	sfa	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	695	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	695	6	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	695	7	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	695	8	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	695	9	company	company	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	695	10	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	695	11	owns	own	VERB
inlawrev-3967	695	12	photographs	photograph	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	695	13	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	695	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	695	15	late	late	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	695	16	sam	sam	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	695	17	shaw	shaw	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	695	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	695	19	among	among	ADP
inlawrev-3967	695	20	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	695	21	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	695	22	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	695	23	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	695	24	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	695	25	canonical	canonical	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	695	26	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	695	27	marilyn	marilyn	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	695	28	images	image	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	695	29	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	696	1	"216	"216	AUX
inlawrev-3967	696	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	696	3	complaint	complaint	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	696	4	alleged	allege	VERB
inlawrev-3967	696	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	696	6	sfa	sfa	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	696	7	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	696	8	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	696	9	selling	sell	VERB
inlawrev-3967	696	10	shirts	shirt	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	696	11	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	696	12	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	696	13	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	696	14	picture	picture	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	696	15	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	696	16	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	696	17	maintained	maintain	VERB
inlawrev-3967	696	18	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	696	19	website	website	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	696	20	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-3967	696	21	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	696	22	licenses	license	VERB
inlawrev-3967	696	23	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	696	24	use	use	VERB
inlawrev-3967	696	25	pictures	picture	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	696	26	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	696	27	images	image	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	696	28	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	696	29	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	696	30	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	696	31	products	product	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	696	32	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	696	33	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	696	34	purchased	purchase	VERB
inlawrev-3967	696	35	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	697	1	217	217	NUM
inlawrev-3967	697	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	697	3	further	far	ADV
inlawrev-3967	697	4	alleged	allege	VERB
inlawrev-3967	697	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	697	6	marilyn	marilyn	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	697	7	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	697	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	697	9	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	697	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	697	11	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	697	12	proper	proper	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	697	13	successor	successor	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	697	14	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	697	15	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	697	16	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	697	17	interest	interest	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	697	18	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	697	19	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	697	20	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	697	21	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	697	22	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	697	23	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	697	24	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	697	25	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	697	26	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	697	27	claimed	claim	VERB
inlawrev-3967	697	28	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	697	29	passed	pass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	697	30	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-3967	697	31	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	697	32	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	697	33	will	will	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	697	34	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	697	35	strasberg	strasberg	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	697	36	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	697	37	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	697	38	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	697	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	697	40	company	company	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	697	41	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	698	1	218	218	NUM
inlawrev-3967	698	2	sfa	sfa	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	698	3	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	698	4	actions	action	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	698	5	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	698	6	alleged	allege	VERB
inlawrev-3967	698	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	698	8	violate	violate	VERB
inlawrev-3967	698	9	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	698	10	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	698	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	698	12	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	698	13	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	698	14	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	698	15	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	698	16	]	]	X
inlawrev-3967	698	17	passed	pass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	698	18	over	over	ADP
inlawrev-3967	698	19	three	three	NUM
inlawrev-3967	698	20	decades	decade	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	698	21	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-3967	698	22	ms	ms	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	698	23	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	698	24	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	698	25	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	698	26	death	death	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	698	27	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	698	28	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	698	29	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	698	30	state	state	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	698	31	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	698	32	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	698	33	she	she	PRON
inlawrev-3967	698	34	had	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	698	35	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	698	36	as	as	ADV
inlawrev-3967	698	37	far	far	ADV
inlawrev-3967	698	38	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	698	39	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	698	40	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	698	41	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	698	42	aware	aware	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	698	43	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	698	44	absolutely	absolutely	ADV
inlawrev-3967	698	45	no	no	PRON
inlawrev-3967	698	46	contact	contact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	698	47	during	during	ADP
inlawrev-3967	698	48	her	her	PRON
inlawrev-3967	698	49	life	life	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	698	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	698	51	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	699	1	219	219	NUM
inlawrev-3967	699	2	while	while	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	699	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	699	4	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	699	5	deals	deal	VERB
inlawrev-3967	699	6	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	699	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	699	8	main	main	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	699	9	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	699	10	aspects	aspect	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	699	11	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	699	12	probate	probate	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	699	13	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	699	14	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	699	15	insofar	insofar	ADV
inlawrev-3967	699	16	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	699	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	699	18	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	699	19	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	699	20	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	699	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	699	22	vehicle	vehicle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	699	23	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-3967	699	24	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	699	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	699	26	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	699	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	699	28	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	699	29	passed	pass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	699	30	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	699	31	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	699	32	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-3967	699	33	all	all	ADV
inlawrev-3967	699	34	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	699	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	699	36	220	220	NUM
inlawrev-3967	699	37	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	699	38	also	also	ADV
inlawrev-3967	699	39	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	699	40	some	some	DET
inlawrev-3967	699	41	fundamental	fundamental	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	699	42	determinations	determination	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	699	43	about	about	ADP
inlawrev-3967	699	44	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	699	45	reach	reach	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	699	46	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	699	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	699	48	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	699	49	statutory	statutory	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	699	50	provisions	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	699	51	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	700	1	221	221	NUM
inlawrev-3967	700	2	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-3967	700	3	stating	state	VERB
inlawrev-3967	700	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	700	5	principle	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	700	6	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	700	7	one	one	PRON
inlawrev-3967	700	8	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	700	9	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	700	10	devise	devise	VERB
inlawrev-3967	700	11	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	700	12	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	700	13	property	property	VERB
inlawrev-3967	700	14	he	he	PRON
inlawrev-3967	700	15	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	700	16	she	she	PRON
inlawrev-3967	700	17	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	700	18	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	700	19	own	own	VERB
inlawrev-3967	700	20	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	700	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	700	22	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	700	23	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	700	24	death	death	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	700	25	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	700	26	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	700	27	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	700	28	found	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	700	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	700	30	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	700	31	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	700	32	descendible	descendible	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	700	33	postmortem	postmortem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	700	34	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	700	35	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	700	36	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	700	37	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	700	38	recognized	recognize	VERB
inlawrev-3967	700	39	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	700	40	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	700	41	new	new	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	700	42	york	york	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	700	43	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	700	44	california	california	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	700	45	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	700	46	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	700	47	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	700	48	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	700	49	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	700	50	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	700	51	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	700	52	ms	ms	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	700	53	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	700	54	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	700	55	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	700	56	death	death	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	700	57	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	700	58	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	701	1	222	222	NUM
inlawrev-3967	701	2	focusing	focus	VERB
inlawrev-3967	701	3	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	701	4	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	701	5	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	701	6	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	701	7	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	701	8	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	701	9	opined	opine	VERB
inlawrev-3967	701	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	701	11	until	until	ADP
inlawrev-3967	701	12	passage	passage	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	701	13	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	701	14	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	701	15	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	701	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	701	17	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	701	18	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	701	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	701	20	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	701	21	only	only	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	701	22	way	way	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	701	23	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	701	24	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	701	25	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	701	26	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	701	27	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	701	28	asserted	assert	VERB
inlawrev-3967	701	29	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	701	30	via	via	ADP
inlawrev-3967	701	31	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	701	32	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	701	33	personal	personal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	701	34	tort	tort	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	701	35	action	action	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	701	36	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	701	37	invasion	invasion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	701	38	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	701	39	privacy	privacy	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	701	40	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	701	41	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	702	1	223	223	NUM
inlawrev-3967	702	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	702	3	result	result	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	702	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	702	5	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	702	6	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	702	7	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	702	8	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	702	9	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	702	10	she	she	PRON
inlawrev-3967	702	11	enjoyed	enjoy	VERB
inlawrev-3967	702	12	211	211	NUM
inlawrev-3967	702	13	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	703	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	703	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	703	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	703	4	310	310	NUM
inlawrev-3967	703	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	703	6	11	11	NUM
inlawrev-3967	703	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	703	8	212	212	NUM
inlawrev-3967	703	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	704	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	704	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	704	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	704	4	311	311	NUM
inlawrev-3967	704	5	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	704	6	213	213	NUM
inlawrev-3967	704	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	705	1	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	705	2	312	312	NUM
inlawrev-3967	705	3	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	705	4	13	13	NUM
inlawrev-3967	705	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	706	1	214	214	NUM
inlawrev-3967	706	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	707	1	mat	mat	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	707	2	312	312	NUM
inlawrev-3967	707	3	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	707	4	215	215	NUM
inlawrev-3967	707	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	708	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	708	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	708	3	216	216	NUM
inlawrev-3967	708	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	708	5	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	708	6	312	312	NUM
inlawrev-3967	708	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	708	8	13	13	NUM
inlawrev-3967	708	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	709	1	217	217	NUM
inlawrev-3967	709	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	710	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	710	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	710	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	710	4	313	313	NUM
inlawrev-3967	710	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	710	6	218	218	NUM
inlawrev-3967	710	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	711	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	711	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	711	3	219	219	NUM
inlawrev-3967	711	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	712	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	712	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	712	3	220	220	NUM
inlawrev-3967	712	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	712	5	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	712	6	314	314	NUM
inlawrev-3967	712	7	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	712	8	19	19	NUM
inlawrev-3967	712	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	712	10	221	221	NUM
inlawrev-3967	712	11	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	713	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	713	2	d.	d.	VERB
inlawrev-3967	713	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	713	4	319	319	NUM
inlawrev-3967	713	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	713	6	20	20	NUM
inlawrev-3967	713	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	714	1	222	222	NUM
inlawrev-3967	714	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	715	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	715	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	715	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	715	4	314	314	NUM
inlawrev-3967	715	5	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	715	6	223	223	NUM
inlawrev-3967	715	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	716	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	716	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	716	3	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	716	4	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	716	5	ind	ind	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	716	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	717	1	code	code	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	717	2	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	717	3	34	34	NUM
inlawrev-3967	717	4	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	717	5	9	9	NUM
inlawrev-3967	717	6	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	717	7	3	3	NUM
inlawrev-3967	717	8	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	717	9	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	717	10	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	717	11	2004	2004	NUM
inlawrev-3967	717	12	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	717	13	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	717	14	time	time	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	717	15	inc	inc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	717	16	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	718	1	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	718	2	sand	sand	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	718	3	creek	creek	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	718	4	partners	partner	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	718	5	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	718	6	l.p	l.p	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	718	7	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	718	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	718	9	825	825	NUM
inlawrev-3967	718	10	f.	f.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	718	11	supp	supp	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	718	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	719	1	210	210	NUM
inlawrev-3967	719	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	719	3	212	212	NUM
inlawrev-3967	719	4	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	719	5	s.d	s.d	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	719	6	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	719	7	ind	ind	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	719	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	719	9	1993	1993	NUM
inlawrev-3967	719	10	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	719	11	;	;	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	719	12	cont'l	cont'l	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	719	13	optic	optic	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	719	14	co.	co.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	719	15	v.	v.	ADP
inlawrev-3967	719	16	reed	reed	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	719	17	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	719	18	86	86	NUM
inlawrev-3967	719	19	n.e.2d	n.e.2d	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	719	20	306	306	NUM
inlawrev-3967	719	21	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	719	22	309	309	NUM
inlawrev-3967	719	23	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	719	24	ind	ind	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	719	25	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	720	1	app	app	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	720	2	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	720	3	1949	1949	NUM
inlawrev-3967	720	4	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	720	5	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	720	6	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	721	1	note	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	721	2	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	721	3	commentators	commentator	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	721	4	generally	generally	ADV
inlawrev-3967	721	5	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	721	6	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	721	7	origin	origin	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	721	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	721	9	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	721	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	721	11	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	721	12	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	721	13	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	721	14	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	721	15	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	721	16	privacy	privacy	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	721	17	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	721	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	721	19	2008	2008	NUM
inlawrev-3967	721	20	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	721	21	intellectual	intellectual	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	721	22	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	721	23	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	721	24	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	721	25	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	721	26	63	63	NUM
inlawrev-3967	721	27	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	721	28	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	722	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	723	1	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	723	2	extinguished	extinguish	VERB
inlawrev-3967	723	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	723	4	her	her	PRON
inlawrev-3967	723	5	death	death	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	723	6	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	723	7	operation	operation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	723	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	723	9	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	723	10	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	723	11	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	724	1	224	224	NUM
inlawrev-3967	724	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	724	3	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	4	dismissed	dismiss	VERB
inlawrev-3967	724	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	724	6	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	7	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	724	8	marilyn	marilyn	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	724	9	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	724	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	724	11	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	724	12	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	724	13	her	she	PRON
inlawrev-3967	724	14	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	724	15	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	724	16	pass	pass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	724	17	postmortem	postmortem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	18	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	19	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	20	later	later	ADV
inlawrev-3967	724	21	conferred	confer	VERB
inlawrev-3967	724	22	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	724	23	her	she	PRON
inlawrev-3967	724	24	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	724	25	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	26	.	.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	724	27	225	225	NUM
inlawrev-3967	724	28	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	724	29	previously	previously	ADV
inlawrev-3967	724	30	noted	note	VERB
inlawrev-3967	724	31	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	724	32	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	724	33	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	34	discussed	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-3967	724	35	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	724	36	length	length	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	37	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	724	38	new	new	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	724	39	york	york	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	724	40	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	724	41	california	california	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	724	42	probate	probate	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	43	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	44	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	724	45	their	their	PRON
inlawrev-3967	724	46	insistence	insistence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	47	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	724	48	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	724	49	will	will	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	50	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	724	51	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	724	52	pass	pass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	724	53	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	54	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	724	55	owned	own	VERB
inlawrev-3967	724	56	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	724	57	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	724	58	decedent	decedent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	59	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	724	60	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	724	61	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	62	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	724	63	death	death	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	724	64	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	725	1	226	226	NUM
inlawrev-3967	725	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	725	3	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	725	4	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	725	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	725	6	contrary	contrary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	725	7	intent	intent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	725	8	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	725	9	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	725	10	decedent	decedent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	725	11	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	725	12	change	change	VERB
inlawrev-3967	725	13	that	that	DET
inlawrev-3967	725	14	rule	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	725	15	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	725	16	quickly	quickly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	725	17	dispatched	dispatch	VERB
inlawrev-3967	725	18	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	725	19	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	725	20	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	725	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	725	22	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	725	23	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	725	24	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	725	25	provisions	provision	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	725	26	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	725	27	new	new	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	725	28	york	york	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	725	29	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	725	30	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	725	31	california	california	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	725	32	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	725	33	probate	probate	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	725	34	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	725	35	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	725	36	support	support	VERB
inlawrev-3967	725	37	its	its	PRON
inlawrev-3967	725	38	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	725	39	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	726	1	227	227	NUM
inlawrev-3967	726	2	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	726	3	further	further	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	726	4	argument	argument	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	5	based	base	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	6	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	726	7	texas	texas	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	726	8	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	726	10	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	726	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	726	12	residuary	residuary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	726	13	clause	clause	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	14	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	726	15	pass	pass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	16	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	726	18	decedent	decedent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	19	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	726	20	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	726	21	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	726	22	overlooked	overlook	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	23	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	726	24	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	726	25	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	726	26	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	726	27	persuasive	persuasive	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	726	28	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	726	29	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	726	30	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	726	31	out	out	ADP
inlawrev-3967	726	32	ofjurisdiction	ofjurisdiction	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	33	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	726	34	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	726	35	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	726	36	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	726	37	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	726	38	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	726	39	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	726	40	overlooked	overlook	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	41	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	726	42	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	43	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	726	44	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	726	45	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	726	46	come	come	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	47	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-3967	726	48	being	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	726	49	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	726	50	until	until	ADP
inlawrev-3967	726	51	many	many	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	726	52	years	year	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	53	after	after	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	726	54	she	she	PRON
inlawrev-3967	726	55	died	die	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	56	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	726	57	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	726	58	because	because	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	726	59	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	726	60	affirmed	affirm	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	61	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	726	62	principle	principle	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	63	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	726	64	property	property	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	65	owned	own	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	66	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	726	67	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	726	68	decedent	decedent	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	69	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	726	70	all	all	PRON
inlawrev-3967	726	71	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	726	72	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	726	73	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	726	74	devised	devise	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	75	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	726	76	will.228	will.228	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	726	77	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	726	78	last	last	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	726	79	point	point	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	80	made	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	81	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	726	82	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	726	83	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	84	focuses	focus	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	85	on	on	ADP
inlawrev-3967	726	86	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	726	87	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	726	88	statute	statute	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	726	89	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	726	90	interprets	interpret	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	91	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	726	92	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	726	93	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	726	94	permitting	permit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	95	transfer	transfer	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	96	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	726	97	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	98	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	726	99	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	100	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	726	101	persons	person	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	102	already	already	ADV
inlawrev-3967	726	103	deceased	decease	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	104	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	726	105	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	726	106	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	726	107	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	726	108	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	726	109	enacted	enact	VERB
inlawrev-3967	726	110	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	727	1	229	229	NUM
inlawrev-3967	727	2	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	727	3	pointed	point	VERB
inlawrev-3967	727	4	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	727	5	sections	section	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	727	6	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-3967	727	7	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	727	8	18	18	NUM
inlawrev-3967	727	9	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	727	10	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	727	11	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	727	12	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	727	13	which	which	PRON
inlawrev-3967	727	14	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	727	15	several	several	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	727	16	ways	way	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	727	17	including	include	VERB
inlawrev-3967	727	18	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	727	19	testamentary	testamentary	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	727	20	document	document	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	727	21	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	727	22	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	727	23	transferring	transfer	VERB
inlawrev-3967	727	24	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	727	25	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	727	26	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	727	27	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	727	28	provide	provide	VERB
inlawrev-3967	727	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	727	30	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	727	31	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	727	32	pass	pass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	727	33	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	727	34	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	727	35	rules	rule	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	727	36	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	727	37	intestate	intestate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	727	38	succession	succession	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	727	39	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	727	40	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	727	41	transferred	transfer	VERB
inlawrev-3967	727	42	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	727	43	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	727	44	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	727	45	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	727	46	ways	way	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	727	47	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	728	1	230	230	NUM
inlawrev-3967	728	2	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	728	3	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	728	4	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	728	5	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	728	6	words	word	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	728	7	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	728	8	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	728	9	even	even	ADV
inlawrev-3967	728	10	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	728	11	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	728	12	postmortem	postmortem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	728	13	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	728	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	728	15	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	728	16	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	728	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	728	18	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	729	1	could	could	AUX
inlawrev-3967	729	2	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	729	3	been	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	729	4	created	create	VERB
inlawrev-3967	729	5	after	after	ADP
inlawrev-3967	729	6	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	729	7	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	729	8	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	729	9	]	]	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	729	10	death	death	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	729	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	729	12	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	729	13	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	729	14	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	729	15	statute	statute	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	729	16	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	729	17	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	729	18	permit	permit	VERB
inlawrev-3967	729	19	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	729	20	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	729	21	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	729	22	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	729	23	transferred	transfer	VERB
inlawrev-3967	729	24	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-3967	729	25	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	729	26	will	will	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	729	27	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	729	28	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	729	29	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	729	30	personality	personality	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	729	31	'	'	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	729	32	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-3967	729	33	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	729	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	730	1	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	731	1	was	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	731	2	already	already	ADV
inlawrev-3967	731	3	deceased	deceased	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	731	4	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	731	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	731	6	time	time	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	731	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	731	8	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	731	9	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	731	10	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	731	11	enactment	enactment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	731	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	731	13	"	"	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	732	1	231	231	NUM
inlawrev-3967	732	2	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	732	3	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	732	4	postmortem	postmortem	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	732	5	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	732	6	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	732	7	available	available	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	732	8	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	732	9	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	732	10	clearly	clearly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	732	11	were	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	732	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	732	13	passed	pass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	732	14	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	732	15	any	any	PRON
inlawrev-3967	732	16	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	732	17	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	732	18	methods	method	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	732	19	listed	list	VERB
inlawrev-3967	732	20	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	732	21	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	732	22	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	732	23	statute	statute	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	732	24	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	732	25	thus	thus	ADV
inlawrev-3967	732	26	must	must	AUX
inlawrev-3967	732	27	have	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	732	28	passed	pass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	732	29	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	732	30	heirs	heir	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	732	31	via	via	ADP
inlawrev-3967	732	32	intestate	intestate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	732	33	succession	succession	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	732	34	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	733	1	232	232	NUM
inlawrev-3967	734	1	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	734	2	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	734	3	did	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	734	4	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	734	5	discuss	discuss	VERB
inlawrev-3967	734	6	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-3967	734	7	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	734	8	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-3967	734	9	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	734	10	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	734	11	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	734	12	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	734	13	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	734	14	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	734	15	supposed	suppose	VERB
inlawrev-3967	734	16	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	734	17	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-3967	734	18	were	be	VERB
inlawrev-3967	734	19	no	no	DET
inlawrev-3967	734	20	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	734	21	heirs	heir	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	734	22	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	734	23	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	734	24	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	734	25	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	734	26	certainly	certainly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	734	27	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	734	28	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	734	29	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	734	30	neither	neither	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	734	31	cmg	cmg	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	734	32	nor	nor	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	734	33	marilyn	marilyn	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	734	34	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	734	35	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	734	36	llc	llc	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	734	37	had	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	734	38	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	734	39	claim	claim	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	734	40	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	734	41	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	734	42	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	734	43	through	through	ADP
inlawrev-3967	734	44	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	734	45	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	734	46	heirs	heir	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	734	47	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	734	48	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-3967	734	49	exist	exist	VERB
inlawrev-3967	734	50	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	735	1	once	once	ADV
inlawrev-3967	735	2	again	again	ADV
inlawrev-3967	735	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	735	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	735	5	great	great	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	735	6	majority	majority	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	735	7	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	735	8	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	735	9	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	735	10	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	735	11	concerned	concern	VERB
inlawrev-3967	735	12	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	735	13	interpretations	interpretation	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	735	14	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	735	15	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	735	16	will	will	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	735	17	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	735	18	appropriate	appropriate	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	735	19	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	735	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	736	1	nonetheless	nonetheless	ADV
inlawrev-3967	736	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	736	3	two	two	NUM
inlawrev-3967	736	4	important	important	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	736	5	points	point	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	736	6	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	736	7	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	736	8	drawn	draw	VERB
inlawrev-3967	736	9	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	736	10	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	736	11	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	736	12	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	737	1	first	first	ADV
inlawrev-3967	737	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	737	3	at	at	ADV
inlawrev-3967	737	4	least	least	ADV
inlawrev-3967	737	5	one	one	NUM
inlawrev-3967	737	6	federal	federal	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	737	7	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	8	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	737	9	least	least	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	737	10	implicitly	implicitly	ADV
inlawrev-3967	737	11	has	have	AUX
inlawrev-3967	737	12	held	hold	VERB
inlawrev-3967	737	13	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	737	14	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	737	15	'	'	PART
inlawrev-3967	737	16	s	s	PART
inlawrev-3967	737	17	right	right	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	737	18	ofpublicity	ofpublicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	19	statutes	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	20	does	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	737	21	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	737	22	create	create	VERB
inlawrev-3967	737	23	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	24	nuncpro	nuncpro	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	737	25	tunc	tunc	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	26	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	737	27	as	as	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	737	28	though	though	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	737	29	they	they	PRON
inlawrev-3967	737	30	came	come	VERB
inlawrev-3967	737	31	into	into	ADP
inlawrev-3967	737	32	existence	existence	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	33	prior	prior	ADV
inlawrev-3967	737	34	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	737	35	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	737	36	personality	personality	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	37	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	737	38	death.233	death.233	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	39	applied	apply	VERB
inlawrev-3967	737	40	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	737	41	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	737	42	facts	fact	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	43	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	737	44	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	737	45	case	case	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	46	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	737	47	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	737	48	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	49	created	create	VERB
inlawrev-3967	737	50	with	with	ADP
inlawrev-3967	737	51	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	737	52	1994	1994	NUM
inlawrev-3967	737	53	enactment	enactment	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	54	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	737	55	those	those	DET
inlawrev-3967	737	56	statutes	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	57	but	but	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	737	58	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	737	59	early	early	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	737	60	common	common	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	737	61	law	law	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	62	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	63	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	737	64	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	65	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	737	66	quite	quite	DET
inlawrev-3967	737	67	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	737	68	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	737	69	species	specie	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	70	from	from	ADP
inlawrev-3967	737	71	later	later	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	737	72	statutory	statutory	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	737	73	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	737	74	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	738	1	224	224	NUM
inlawrev-3967	738	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	739	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	739	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	739	3	225	225	NUM
inlawrev-3967	739	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	740	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	740	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	740	3	226	226	NUM
inlawrev-3967	740	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	741	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	741	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	741	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	741	4	314	314	NUM
inlawrev-3967	741	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	741	6	17	17	NUM
inlawrev-3967	741	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	742	1	227	227	NUM
inlawrev-3967	742	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	742	3	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	742	4	314	314	NUM
inlawrev-3967	742	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	742	6	15	15	NUM
inlawrev-3967	742	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	743	1	228	228	NUM
inlawrev-3967	743	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	744	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	744	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	744	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	744	4	316	316	NUM
inlawrev-3967	744	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	744	6	17	17	NUM
inlawrev-3967	744	7	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	744	8	229	229	NUM
inlawrev-3967	744	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	745	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	745	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	745	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	745	4	318	318	NUM
inlawrev-3967	745	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	745	6	19	19	NUM
inlawrev-3967	745	7	.	.	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	745	8	230	230	NUM
inlawrev-3967	745	9	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	746	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	746	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	746	3	at	at	ADP
inlawrev-3967	746	4	319	319	NUM
inlawrev-3967	746	5	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	746	6	citing	cite	VERB
inlawrev-3967	746	7	ind	ind	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	746	8	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	747	1	code	code	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	747	2	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	747	3	§	§	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	747	4	32	32	NUM
inlawrev-3967	747	5	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	747	6	36	36	NUM
inlawrev-3967	747	7	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	747	8	1	1	NUM
inlawrev-3967	747	9	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	747	10	16	16	NUM
inlawrev-3967	747	11	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	747	12	-18	-18	SYM
inlawrev-3967	747	13	(	(	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	747	14	2004	2004	NUM
inlawrev-3967	747	15	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	747	16	)	)	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	747	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	748	1	231	231	NUM
inlawrev-3967	748	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	749	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	749	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	749	3	232	232	NUM
inlawrev-3967	749	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	750	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	750	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	750	3	233	233	NUM
inlawrev-3967	750	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	751	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	751	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	751	3	1164	1164	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	751	4	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	751	5	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	751	6	review	review	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	752	1	[	[	X
inlawrev-3967	752	2	vol	vol	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	752	3	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	753	1	41:1139	41:1139	NUM
inlawrev-3967	753	2	do	do	AUX
inlawrev-3967	753	3	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	753	4	act	act	VERB
inlawrev-3967	753	5	retroactively	retroactively	ADV
inlawrev-3967	753	6	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	753	7	create	create	VERB
inlawrev-3967	753	8	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	753	9	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	753	10	1962	1962	NUM
inlawrev-3967	753	11	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	753	12	just	just	ADV
inlawrev-3967	753	13	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-3967	753	14	monroe	monroe	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	753	15	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	753	16	death	death	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	753	17	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	754	1	234	234	NUM
inlawrev-3967	754	2	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	754	3	second	second	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	754	4	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	754	5	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	754	6	holding	holding	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	754	7	that	that	PRON
inlawrev-3967	754	8	any	any	DET
inlawrev-3967	754	9	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	754	10	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	754	11	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	754	12	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	754	13	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	754	14	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	754	15	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	754	16	personalities	personality	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	754	17	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-3967	754	18	died	die	VERB
inlawrev-3967	754	19	before	before	ADP
inlawrev-3967	754	20	1994	1994	NUM
inlawrev-3967	754	21	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	754	22	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	754	23	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	754	24	passed	pass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	754	25	by	by	ADP
inlawrev-3967	754	26	will.235	will.235	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	754	27	taken	take	VERB
inlawrev-3967	754	28	together	together	ADV
inlawrev-3967	754	29	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	754	30	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	754	31	court	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	754	32	would	would	AUX
inlawrev-3967	754	33	seem	seem	VERB
inlawrev-3967	754	34	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	754	35	mean	mean	VERB
inlawrev-3967	754	36	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	754	37	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-3967	754	38	are	be	VERB
inlawrev-3967	754	39	no	no	DET
inlawrev-3967	754	40	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	754	41	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	754	42	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	754	43	under	under	ADP
inlawrev-3967	754	44	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	754	45	law	law	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	754	46	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	754	47	personalities	personality	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	754	48	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-3967	754	49	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	754	50	deceased	decease	VERB
inlawrev-3967	754	51	earlier	early	ADV
inlawrev-3967	754	52	than	than	ADP
inlawrev-3967	754	53	1994	1994	NUM
inlawrev-3967	754	54	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	755	1	if	if	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	755	2	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	755	3	are	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	755	4	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	755	5	retroactively	retroactively	ADV
inlawrev-3967	755	6	created	create	VERB
inlawrev-3967	755	7	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	755	8	whatever	whatever	PRON
inlawrev-3967	755	9	might	might	AUX
inlawrev-3967	755	10	exist	exist	VERB
inlawrev-3967	755	11	can	can	AUX
inlawrev-3967	755	12	not	not	PART
inlawrev-3967	755	13	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	755	14	devised	devise	VERB
inlawrev-3967	755	15	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	755	16	there	there	PRON
inlawrev-3967	755	17	seems	seem	VERB
inlawrev-3967	755	18	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	755	19	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	755	20	little	little	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	755	21	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	755	22	no	no	PRON
inlawrev-3967	755	23	room	room	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	755	24	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	755	25	find	find	VERB
inlawrev-3967	755	26	rights	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	755	27	for	for	ADP
inlawrev-3967	755	28	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	755	29	predeceased	predecease	VERB
inlawrev-3967	755	30	people	people	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	755	31	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	756	1	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	756	2	course	course	ADV
inlawrev-3967	756	3	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	756	4	it	it	PRON
inlawrev-3967	756	5	may	may	AUX
inlawrev-3967	756	6	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	756	7	that	that	SCONJ
inlawrev-3967	756	8	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	756	9	courts	court	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	756	10	or	or	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	756	11	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-3967	756	12	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	756	13	other	other	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	756	14	states	state	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	756	15	will	will	AUX
inlawrev-3967	756	16	have	have	VERB
inlawrev-3967	756	17	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	756	18	different	different	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	756	19	view	view	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	756	20	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	757	1	however	however	ADV
inlawrev-3967	757	2	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	757	3	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	757	4	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	757	5	opinion	opinion	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	757	6	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	757	7	this	this	DET
inlawrev-3967	757	8	author	author	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	757	9	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	757	10	shaw	shaw	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	757	11	family	family	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	757	12	archives	archive	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	757	13	is	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	757	14	well	well	ADV
inlawrev-3967	757	15	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	757	16	reasoned	reason	VERB
inlawrev-3967	757	17	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	757	18	persuasive	persuasive	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	757	19	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	757	20	and	and	CCONJ
inlawrev-3967	757	21	makes	make	VERB
inlawrev-3967	757	22	a	a	DET
inlawrev-3967	757	23	substantial	substantial	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	757	24	rebuttal	rebuttal	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	757	25	to	to	ADP
inlawrev-3967	757	26	those	those	PRON
inlawrev-3967	757	27	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-3967	757	28	consider	consider	VERB
inlawrev-3967	757	29	indiana	indiana	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	757	30	's	's	PART
inlawrev-3967	757	31	right	right	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	757	32	of	of	ADP
inlawrev-3967	757	33	publicity	publicity	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	757	34	statute	statute	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	757	35	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	757	36	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	757	37	far	far	ADV
inlawrev-3967	757	38	-	-	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	757	39	reaching	reach	VERB
inlawrev-3967	757	40	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	757	41	perhaps	perhaps	ADV
inlawrev-3967	757	42	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	757	43	be	be	AUX
inlawrev-3967	757	44	able	able	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	757	45	to	to	PART
inlawrev-3967	757	46	encompass	encompass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	757	47	personalities	personality	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	757	48	who	who	PRON
inlawrev-3967	757	49	passed	pass	VERB
inlawrev-3967	757	50	away	away	ADP
inlawrev-3967	757	51	early	early	ADV
inlawrev-3967	757	52	in	in	ADP
inlawrev-3967	757	53	the	the	DET
inlawrev-3967	757	54	twentieth	twentieth	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	757	55	century	century	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	757	56	,	,	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	757	57	such	such	ADJ
inlawrev-3967	757	58	as	as	ADP
inlawrev-3967	757	59	mark	mark	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	757	60	twain	twain	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	757	61	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	758	1	234	234	NUM
inlawrev-3967	758	2	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	759	1	i	i	PRON
inlawrev-3967	759	2	d.	d.	PROPN
inlawrev-3967	759	3	235	235	NUM
inlawrev-3967	759	4	.	.	PUNCT
inlawrev-3967	760	1	mat	mat	NOUN
inlawrev-3967	760	2	319	319	NUM
inlawrev-3967	760	3	-	-	SYM
inlawrev-3967	760	4	20	20	NUM
inlawrev-3967	760	5	.	.	PUNCT