Indiana Law Review


. CI
y ^7

Indiana
„law
Review
VOLUME 15 • 1982 • NUMBER 1

Periodical

Collection

1981 Survey of Recent Developments in Indiana Law

I. Administrative Law— H^ai/ne K. Lewis
n. Business Associations—PauZ «/. Galanti

HL Civil Procedure and Jurisdiction— William F. Harvey
IV. Commercial LtLW — Gerald L. Bepko
V. Constitutional Law—J?. Matthew Neff
VL Criminal Law and Procedure—Lt/nne D. Lidke

VII. Decedents' Estates and Trusts—Dcfera A. Falender

VIII. Domestic Relations—PameZai?/ime <fe Anne H. Weinheimer

IX. Evidence—/fenry C. Karlson

X. Insurance —G. Kent Frandsen
XI. Labor La,w—Edward P. Archer

XII. Products Liability—JoAn Vargo

XIII. Professional Responsibility—Damd A. Funk
XIV. Property -iV. Kent Smith & Mark R. Wenzel
XV. Secured Transactions and Creditors' Rights—i?. Bruce Townsend •

XVI. Taxation -J.B. King

XVII. ToHLtiw—DanielJ. Harrigan

XVIII. Workers* Compensation—Jordan H. Leibman



Registered Professional

Reporters

JOHN E. CONNOR & Associates

(317) 632-5533

204 UNION FEDERAL BUILDING

Indianapolis, Ind. 46204

Reference: MARTINDALE-HUBBELL

INDIANA LAW REVIEW

We are pleased to announce that Volume 15, Number 2 will feature a
Symposium on:

SECURED CREDITORS'
RIGHTS IN BANKRUPTCY

Subscription Rates: one year, $15.00; foreign, $18.50; student, $13.00

PUBLISHED FOUR TIMES YEARLY

Send Orders to: Business Manager
Indiana Law Review

Indiana University School of Law, Indianapolis

735 W. New York Street, Indianapolis, Indiana 46202



Indiana Lai^ Revieiv
Volume 15 1982 Number 1

Copyright (fj 1982 by the Trustees of Indiana University

1981 Survey of Recent Developments in Indiana Law

Table of Cases ix

I. Administrative Law Wayne K. Lewis 1
A. Procedural Due Process 1
B. Scope of Judicial Review 11

C. The Requirement of Findings 15

D. Reviewability of Agency Decisions 22

E. Exhaustion 23

F. Timely Appeals 25

II. Business Associations Paul J. Galanti 31

A. In Pari Delicto Defense 31

B. Securities Fraud 34

C. Indiana Business Takeover Act 39

D. Definition of Security 47

E. Rights and Liability of a Promoter 51

F. Retaliatory Discharge 54

G. Intercorporate Relations 57

H. Statutory Developments 58

III. Civil Procedure and Jurisdiction William F. Harvey 69

A. Introduction 69

B. Jurisdiction, Process, Venue, Standing and Claims in General 69

C The 1981 Original Action Rule 77
D. Pleadings and Pre-Trial Motions 80

E. Parties and Discovery 83

F. Trial and Judgments 95

G. Appeals 99

IV. Commercial Law Gerald L. Bepko 109
A. Dishonored Checks 109

B. Treble Damages and Deceptive Advertising 112
C. Banks as Holders In Due Course 114

Volume 15 Winter 1982 Number 1

The INDIANA LAW REVIEW (ISSN 0090-4198) is the property of Indiana University and is published four
times yearly, January, March, April, and June, by the Indiana University School of Law — Indianapolis, which assumes
complete editorial responsibility therefor. Subscription rates: one year $15.00; foreign $18.50. Single copies: annual

Survey issue, $9.00; other issues, $4.50. Back issues, volume 1 through volume 13, are available from Fred B. Rothman
& Co., 10368 W. Centennial Rd., Littleton, Co. 80123. Please notify us one month in advance of any change of address
and include both old and new addresses with zip codes to ensure delivery of all issues. Send all correspondence to
Editorial Assistant, Indiana Law Review, Indiana University School of Law — Indianapolis, 735 West New York Street,
Indianapolis, Indiana 46202. Publication office: 735 West New York Street, Indianapolis, Indiana 46202. Second class
postage paid at Indianapolis, Indiana 46201.



D. Implied Warranties by Non-'Merchants 115

E. Privity Requirements 116

F. Express Warranties 118

G. Statute ofLimitations: Sales of Goods 121

H. Warranty by Endorsement .' 122

V. Comtitutional Law R. Matthew Neff 125

I
A. Introduction 125

fj
B. Due Process ofLaw 125
C. Equal Protection of the Law 136
D. Specific Constitutional Rights and Duties 142

ij E. Conclusion 157

^ VI. Criminml Law and Procedure Lynne D. Lidke 159
A. Death Penalty 159

B. Plea Bargain Agreements and "Shock Probation" 163

C. "Allen Charges" 165

D. The Insanity Defense and Psychiatric Testimony 166

E. Lesser Included Offenses and Double Jeopardy 167

F. Collateral Estoppel and the Habitual Offender Law 171
G. Standards of Care: Neglect ofa Dependent 172

VIL Decedents* Estates and Trusts DebraA. Falender 175
A. Malpractice Statute of Limitations 177

B. Equitable Election 179

C. The Kingseed Saga: Estate Administration Issues 180

D. Other Decedents' Estates Developments 187

E. Trust Developments 198

VIIL Domestic Relations Pamela Rhine 203
Anne H. Weinheimer

A. Adoption 203

3 B. Child Custody 207

C Child Support 213
' D. Dissolution 215

E. Paternity 222

IX. Evidence Henry C Karlson 227
A. Hearsay 227

B. Best Evidence Rule 232

C. Impeachment 234
D. Competency 236

E. Informant 's Privilege 238

F. Opening the Door 240
G. Opinion Testimony 242

X. Insurance G. Kent Frandsen 247

A. Exclusions for Intentional Acts 247

B. Cumulative Coverage Clauses 252

C. Uninsured Motorist Coverage 257

D. Omnibus Clause 260
E. Insurer's Subrogation Rights Prejudiced 264

F. Limitations of Coverage of Comprehensive General Liability Policy . . . 265

XI. Labor Law Edward P. Archer 269
A. Teacher Bargaining 269

B. Bargaining for Other Public Employees 273
C. Arbitration Appeals 280

I



D. Unemployment Compensation 285

E. Strike Injunction Enforcement 287

XII. Products Liability John Vargo 289

A. Introduction . 289

B. The Dague Case 290

C. Defenses and Bars to Recovery 293

D. Foreseeahility and Component Parts 296

E. Failure to Warn 299
F. Distinctions Among Theories 302
G. Conclusion 303

XIII. Professional Responsibility David A. Funk 305

A. Introduction 305

B. "Statutory" Developments 306

C. Indiana Court Cases 307

D. Federal Cases 313

E. Ethics Committee Opinions 315

F. Indiana Supreme Court Disciplinary Commission 315

G. Conclusion 316

XIV. Property A^. Kent Smith 319

Mark R. Wenzel
A. Bailments 320

B. Easements and Restrictive Covenants 322

C. Joint Ownership 325

D. Landlord and Tenant Relations 328

E. Land Ownership in General 341
F. Lateral and Subjacent Support 343

G. Water Law 346
H. Real Estate Transactions 351

XV. Secured Transactions and Creditors' Rights R. Bruce Townsend 367
A. Secured Transactions 368

B. Creditors' Rights 389

C Miscellaneous Cases and Legislation 405

XVI. Taxation JB. King 409

A. Introduction 409

B. The Supreme Court's Kimberly-Clark Decision 410
C Calcar v. Cave Stone—^ Continuing Sales Tax Dilemma 413
D. The 1980-1981 Gross Income Tax Decisions 415

E. The Tax Situs of Intangibles— Mercantile Mortgage 419

F. Judicial Review ofState Tax BoardAssessments— Uhlir v. Ritz Revisited 421
G. Some Inheritance Tax Decisions 422
H. 1981 Tax Legislation 423

XVII. Torts Daniel J. Harrigan 425

A. Introduction 425

B. Medical Malpractice 425

C. Attorney Malpractice 432

D. Director Misconduct 433

E. Landowners, Farm Animals and Duty Issues 433
F. Landlord and Tenant 435

G. Premises Liability and Landlord Invitees 436

H. Vendor-Purchaser and Unknown Defects 437
/. Slander of Title and Punitive Damages 437



J. Duty, Discretionary Functions, and the Tort Claims Act 438

K. School Officials 442

L. Defamation 443

M. Retaliatory Discharge 446

N. Personal Service Contracts and Punitive Damages 447
0. Explosives, Proximate Cause, and Damages 448
P. Wrongful Death 449

XVIII. Workers' Compensation Jordan H. Leibman 453
A. Permanent Total Disability 453
B. Exclusiveness of Remedy 458
C. Progressive and Recurrent Injuries 470

D. Arising Out Of and In The Course of Employment 473
E. Statutory Discrepancy in Benefit Schedules 474

F. Statutory Development 475



TABLE OF CASES

Aaron v. Review Board of Indiana

Employment Security Division, 13

Abell V. Clark County Department of Pub-

lic Welfare, 74

Adams v. Luros, 80, 430
Addison v. Review Board of Indiana Em-

ployment Security Division, 10

American Automobile Insurance Co. v.

Spieker, 265

American Fletcher Mortgage Co. v. U.S.

Steel Credit Corp., 47

American Leasing, Inc. v. Maple, 110

Amermac, Inc. v. Gordon, 291

Anderson Federation of Teachers v.

Alexander, 269

Andrus v. P-Burg Coal Co., 145

Argyelan v. Haviland, 346

Arnold v. Dirrim, 38

Atkinson v. City of Marion, 136

Atwood v. Davis, 429

B

Bailey v. State, 133

Baker v. Chambers, 368, 369

Ball Stores, Inc. v. State Board of Tax

Commissioners, 75

Baumholser v. Amax Coal Co., 449
Bemis Co. v. Rubush, 302

Berman v. City Products Corp., 34

Blake v. Dunn Farms, Inc., 341, 342, 343,

433

Board of Commissioners v. Joeckel, 324

Board of Regents v. Roth, 131

Bogdon V. Ramada Inn, Inc., 470
Boland v. Greer, 449

Bolen V. Mid-Continent Refrigerator Co.,

376, 378

Bottoms V. B & M Coal Corp., 98, 287
Bowen v. Sonnenburg, 23, 84
Bowling v. Holdeman, 92

Brames v. State, 148

Breezewood Management Co. v. Maltbie,

329, 330, 331

Brewer v. Brewer, 83

Brewer v. State, 161

Bridges v. Kentucky Stone Co., 448

Briggs & Stratton Corp. v. Commission,
411

Brown V. Union Oil Co., 92

Budnick v. Budnick, 396

Bunker v. National Gypsum Co., 466

Burd V. Sussex Mutual Insurance Co., 251

Burks V. Bolerjack, 442

Burnett v. State, 165

Burton v. L.O. Smith Foundry Products

Co., 299

c
California v. Green, 229

Campbell v. Eli Lilly & Co., 54, 446
Candlelight Homes, Inc. v. Zornes, 117

Cargill, Inc. v. Perlich, 375

Carrow v. Streeter, 430

Carter v. State, 227

Chauffeurs, Teamsters, Warehousmen and
Helpers Local 135 v. Jefferson Trucking

Co., 283

Chavis V. Rowe, 151

Cherry v. State, 236

Chrysler Corp. v. Reeves, 94

Citizens Energy Coalition, Inc. v. Sendak,
133

Citizens Energy Coalition, Inc. v. Indiana

& Michigan Electric Company, 11
Citizens National Bank v. Stasell, 179, 180

Citizens National Bank v. Harvey, 395

City Investing Co. v. Simcox, 39

City of Evansville v. Miller, 101

City of Hammond v. Red Top Trucking
Company, Inc., 126

City of Hammond v. State ex rei Jeffer-
son, 8

City of Indianapolis v. Sherman, 4

City of South Bend v. Brooksfield Farm, 28

Claise v. Bernardi, 382

Clark County State Bank v. Bennett, 97

Clark v. Clark, 397

Clark V. Lee, 137

Colorado River Water Conservation

District v. United States, 41

Colton V. Commonwealth of Kentucky, 133
Commission on General Education v.

Union Township School of Fulton

County, 134

Cook V. Loftus, 187

IX



INDIANA LAW REVIEW [Vol. 15:ix

County Department of Public Welfare v.

AFSCME, 273
Craven v. Niagara Machine & Tool Works,

Inc., 301

Crestwood Park, Inc. v. Apostal, 406

Criss V. Bitzegaio, 175

Crouch V. Hall, 439

Cua V. Ramos, 443

Cunningham v. Aluminum Co. of America,
458

D
D.H. V. J.H., 210

Dague V. Piper Aircraft Corp., 289, 291
Dan Purvis Drugs, Inc. v. Aetna Life

Insurance Co., 31

Davis V. B.C.L. Enterprises, Inc., 403

Deetz V. McGowan, 102
Department of Treasury v. Allied Mills,

Inc., 416

Department of Treasury v. International

Harvester Co., 416

Diaz V. Duncan, 191

Dodd V. Kiefer, 293

Doe V. Renfrow, 148, 443

Donahue v. Watson, 201, 103

Dorsey v. Dorsey, 213, 225

Dortch V. Lugar, 130

Douglas V. Warner Gear Division of Borg

Warner Corp., 473

Duke Power Co. v. Carolina Environ-
mental Study Group, Inc., 139

Duncan v. George Moser Leather Co., 244

E
E.F.P. Corp. V. Pendill, 472

East Chicago Teachers Union Local 511 v.

Board of Trustees, 274

Eberbach v. McNabney, 80, 399
Ebersold v. Wise, 371, 373

Elliott V. Roach, 77, 83, 444

Elmore v. State, 170

Eisen IV, Eisen v. Carlisle & Jacquelin, 85
Erdman v. White, 96
Estate of Gillilan v. Estate of Gillilan, 187,

188

Evans v. Huss, 90

Exxon Corporation v. FTC, 149

F.J. v. State, 134

Featherston v. Stanton, 8

First Federal Savings & Loan Association
V. Arena, 355, 381, 403

Fleetwood Corp. v. Mirich, 433

Flipside, Hoffman Estates, Inc. v. Village

of Hoffman Estates, 135

Foremost Life Insurance Co. v. Depart-

ment of Insurance, 399

Fort Wayne Patrolman's Benevolent
Association, Inc. v. City of Fort Wayne,

275, 277

Forth V. Forth, 200

Foster v. New, 444
Foster v. Review Board of Indiana Employ-

ment Security Division, 6, 18, 127

Frampton v. Central Indiana Gas Co., 55,

463

Froberg v. Northern Indiana Construction,

Inc., 391

G
Gannett Co. v. DePasquale, 144

Garvey Grain Co. v. Director, Office of

Workers' Compensation Programs, 469

Gary Teachers Union Local 4 v. School

City of Gary, 274

Gary-Northwest Indiana Women's Ser-
vices V. Bowen, 156

General Motors Corp. v. Arnett, 81, 389,

451

Gerhardt v. City of Evansville, 2, 129

Gilliam v. State, 241

Glasgo V. Glasgo, 219

Good V. Crowel, 98

Graham v. Starr, 206
Grayned v. Rockford, 135

Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co. v. Wilson,
339, 436

Gregg V. Georgia, 160

Gross Income Tax Division v. Owens-

Corning Fiberglass Corp., 416

Grueninger Travel Service, Inc. v. Lake

County Trust Co., 335, 336

H
Hall V. State, 171

Hanchar Industrial Waste Management,

Inc. V. Wayne Reclamation & Recycling,
Inc., 93

Harper v. Goodin, 390, 437

Harrington v. State, 234

Harris v. Rainsoft of Allen County, Inc.,

473

Haynes v. State, 240

Hedges v. Rawley, 441



1982] TABLE OF CASES XI

Henderlong Lumber Co. v. Zinn, 390
Hensley v. Hensley, 194

Herff Jones Co. v. State Tax Commission,

411

Herman v. Arnold, 204
Hervey v. AMF Beaird, Inc., 411
Heshelman v. Nationwide Mutual Fire

Insurance Co., 249

Hewitt V. Hewitt, 220

Hiatt V. Yergin, 96

Hickman v. Taylor, 86

Hidden Valley Lake Property Owners

Association v. HVL Utilities, 19
Hills V. Area Plan Commission, 16

Hinds V. McNair, 198

Hockelberg v. Farm Bureau Insurance

Co., 264

Hodel V. Indiana, 155

Holdbrook v. Pitt, 132

Home Insurance Co. v. Neilsen, 248
Home Mutual Insurance Co. v. Automobile

Underwriters, Inc., 262

Hornbrook-Price Co. v. Stewart, 472

Huggins V. State, 308

I

In re Bruce E. Bloom, 309

In re C. Keith Pettigrew

In re City Investing Co., 43, 67

In re Estate of Baird, 192, 194

In re Estate of Compton, 423

In re Estate of Garwood, 195

In re Estate of Jackson, 97

In re Estate of Kingseed, 181-186, 400

In re Estate of Newell, 422

In re Estate of Sandefur, 192

In re Estate of Wisely, 422

In re George A. Purvis, 309

In re Hugh V. Banta, 308
In re John M. Rhame III, 308
In re Joseph, 211

In re Leckrone, 206

In re Lemond, 207

In re M. Daniel Friedland, 309, 310

In re Marriage of Dreflak, 216, 217

In re Miedl, 204

In re Preston M. Thomas, 311
In re Snyder, 90

In re William R. McCain, 310, 311

Indiana Alcoholic Beverage Commission v.

Gault, 4, 131

Indiana Bankers Association v. First

Federal Savings & Loan Association, 85
Indiana Department of Public Welfare v.

Rynard, 102

Indiana Department of Revenue v.

Kimberly-Clark Corp., 409, 411

Indiana Department of State Revenue v.

American Dairy of Evansville, 415

Indiana Department of State Revenue v.

Cave Stone, Inc., 413

Indiana Department of State Revenue v.

Commercial Towel & Uniform Serv.,
418

Indiana Department of State Revenue v.

Continental Steel Corp., 412

Indiana Department of State Revenue v.

Convenient Industries of America, 417

Indiana Department of State Revenue v.

Lyall Electric, Inc., 419

Indiana Department of State Revenue v.

Marsh Supermarkets, Inc., 417

Indiana Department of State Revenue v.

Mercantile Mortgage Co., 409, 419, 420

Indiana Department of State Revenue v.

RCA Corp., 414
Indiana Education Employment Relations

Bd. V. Benton Community School, 273
Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance Co. v,

Speer, 257

Indiana Insurance Co. v. American Under-

writers, Inc., 253

Indiana Insurance Co. v. DeZutti, 265

Indiana Insurance Co. v. Federated Mutual

Insurance Co., 253

Indiana Insurance Co. v. Pettigrew, 69

Indiana Lumbermen's Mutual Insurance

Co. V. Brandum, 247

Indiana State Board of Embalmers &
Funeral Directors v. Keller, 18

Indiana State Department of Welfare,

Medicaid Division v. Stagner, 24

Indiana State Highway Commission v.

Rickert, 438

Indiana University v. Indiana Bonding &
Surety Company, 403

Indianapolis Public Transit Corp. v.

Transit Local 1070, 284

Industrial Disposal Corp. v. City of East

Chicago, 325, 369

Irwin V. Irwin, 217

Jackson v. Gibson, 462

Jackson v. Review Board, 287

Jackson v. State, 232

Jaymar-Ruby, Inc. v. FTC, 22, 149
Johnson v. Capps, 206

Johnson v. Robinson, 139

Johnson v. Ross, 213



Xll INDIANA LAW REVIEW [Vol. 15:ix

Johnson v. St. Vincent Hospital, Inc., 135

138, 425

Jones V. Review Board of the Indiana

Employment Security Division, 18

Jones V. State, 312

Judy V. State, 159

K
Keiling v. Mclntire, 72

Kelsey v. Nagy, 34

Key V. Sneed, 190, 400
Kincaid v. Lazar, 57

King Pin Motor Lodge, Inc. v. D.J. Con-

struction Co., 394

Kiyose v. Trustees of Indiana University,

49

Kottis V. United States Steel Corp., 462

Krieg v. Glassburn, 212

Krueger v. Bailey, 95

Kuchler v. Mark II Homeowners Associa-
tion, Inc., 322, 369

Lafayette Tennis Club, Inc. v. C.W. Ellison

Builders, Inc., 394

Lane v. Barringer, 294

Lantis v. Astec Industries, Inc., 298

Lawrence County Commissioners v.

Chorley, 242

Lee V. Weston, 242

Leon-Roche v. Review Board of the Indiana

Employment Security Division, 7
Lewis V. State, 165, 166

Lincoln Nebraska Bank v. Herber, 51
Lockett V. Ohio, 162

Lukowski V. Vecta Education Corp., 298

Lustic V. Hall, 449

M
Maher v. Gagne, 72

Mailand v. Burckle, 33

Maine v. Thiboutot, 72

Manning v. Allgood, 92

Marcovich Land Corp. v. J.J. Newberry

Co., 340

Marich v. Kragulac, 142, 143

Marotta v. Iroquois Realty Co., 366

Martin v. Piatt, 55

Martincich v. City of Hammond, 150

Martinez v. California, 72

Marvin v. Marvin, 219

Masson Cheese Corp. v. Valley Lea

Dairies, Inc., 377

Mathews v. Eldridge, 5

McCall V. State, 166, 242

McCormick Piano and Organ Co. v. Geiger,

112

McDonnell v. Flaharty, 450

McGairk v. State, 168

McMahon Food Co. v. Call, 110
Melnik v. Melnik, 216

Michelson v. United States, 241

Mid-America Marketing v. Falender

Development Corp., 350, 351

Midway Ford Truck Center, Inc. v.
Gilmore, 81, 302

Midwest Mutual Insurance Co. v. Indiana

Insurance Co., 256

Miles Homes of Indiana, Inc. v. Harrah
Plumbing & Heating, 371, 392, 393

Miles Laboratories, Inc. v. Department of

Revenue, 411

Mills V. American Playground Device Co.,

80

Mite Corp. v. Dixon, 39

Modlin V. Paulson, 76

Moore v. Barrett Co., 32

Morris v. State, 307

Mother Goose Nursery Schools v. Sendak,

132

Mueller Brass Co. v. Gross Income Tax
Division, 416

Mullane v. Central Hanover Bank & Trust
Co., 126, 133

Murphy v. State, 168

N
Nate v. Galloway, 332

National League of Cities v. Usery, 153,

156

Neal V. Neal, 219

Needham v. Fred's Frozen Foods, Inc., 462
Needham v. Needham, 211
Nelson v. O'Neil, 229, 230

Nimel Industries, Inc. v. Joy Manufactur-

ing Co., 320, 321

North V. Newlin, 370

Northeast Marine Terminal Co. v. Caputo,

469

Nova Records, Inc., v. Sendak, 134

o
O'Donaghue v. Review Board of the

Indiana Employment Security Division,

27

Office of the Public Counselor v. Indiana-

polis Power & Light Co., 15
Orto v. Jackson, 353



1982] TABLE OF CASES Xlll

Pain V. Packard, 404

Palmer v. State, 312

Pardue v. Seven-Up Bottling Co. of In-

diana, 295

Parrett v. Lebamoff, 450

Pearson v. First National Bank, 356, 387

Pennycuff v. Fetter, 352, 437

Perez v. United States Steel Corp., 20, 453

Perma Life Mufflers, Inc. v. International
Parts Corp., 32

Peterson v. Culver Educational Founda-

tion, 447

Pillars V. State, 170

Piskorowski v. Shell Oil Co., 83

Piwowar v. Washington Lumber & Coal
Co., 77

Powers V. Ford, 372

Presbyterian Church v. Hall Church, 142

Profitt V. Florida, 160

Purcell V. English, 435

R
Railroad Commission v. Pullman, 40
Ralston v. State, 99

Reed v. Reed, 139

Rees V. Heyser, 82

Reliance Insurance Co. v. Al E. & C. Ltd.,
299

Rhodes v. Chapman, 151, 152
Riner v. Raines, 128

Riverside Insurance Company of America
V. Smith, 261

Roadway Express, Inc. v. Piper, 94, 314
Roberts v. Casting Service Corp., 474

Roberts v. Wabash Life Insurance Co., 196
Robertson v. Mattingly, 389

Roe V. Wade, 156, 157
Rohn V. Thuma, 213, 396
Rohrabaugh v. Wagoner, 138, 431
Ross V. Heyne, 314

Ross V. Tavel, 57

Rossow V. Jones, 435
Royal Business Machines, Inc. v. Lorraine

Corp., 118

Rufer V. State, 308

Russell V. Review Board of the Indiana
Employment Security Division, 12

S & F Supply Co. V. Hunter, 37
Sanders v. Kerwin, 73

Sandlin v. Review Board of the Indina
Employment Security Division, 5, 127

Sandock v. Taylor Construction Corp., 102
Sandoval v. Hammersly, 223
Schenkel v. Allen County Plan Commis-

sion, 16

Scherer v. Scherer, 218

Schleiffer v. Meyers, 209

Schoolcraft v. Ross, 357

Scott V. Union Tank Car Co., 447, 464
Shane Quadri v. Goodyear Service Stores,
404

Shanks v. A.F.E. Industries, Inc., 296, 297
Sherbert v. Verner, 285

Shideler v. Dwyer, 177, 432
Short V. Texaco, Inc., 133

Sidle V. Majors, 139

Sigsbee v. Swathwood, 333
Silva V. State, 238

Siskind v. Siskind, 395, 396

Skendzel v. Marshall, 367, 372

Slebodnik v. City of Indianapolis, 125

Smith V. State, 172
Snodgrass v. Baize, 250, 398

Snyder v, Shelby County Department of
Public Welfare, 203

Snyder v. Tell City Clinic, 97

Solar Sources v. Air Pollution Control

Board, 27, 74

South Bend Osteopathic Hospital, Inc. v.
Phillips, 432

Southern, School Buildings, Inc. v. Loew
Electric, Inc., 390

Spall V. Janota, 344, 345

Speiser v. Addis, 338

Spencer v. Glover, 321, 322

St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co. v.
State Bank of Salem, 114

Stanley v. Kelley, 100

Stanton v. Godfrey, 71

State Board of Tax Commissioners v.
Catling Gun Club, Inc., 410, 421

State Department of Administration v.

Sightes, 282

State Department of Revenue v. Calcar
Quarries, Inc., 413

State ex rel. Dunlap v. Cross, 1, 129

State ex rel. Goldsmith v. Marion County

Superior Court, 163

State ex rel. Long v. Marion County
Superior Court, 71

State ex rel. Newton v. Board of School
Trustees, 15

State ex rel. Shaunki v. Endsley, 219

State ex rel The Post-Tribune Pubhshing
Co. V. Porter Superior Court, 143

State of Indiana v. Andrus, 1.^)2



XIV INDIANA LAW REVIEW [Vol. 15:ix

State V. Kuespert, 93

State V. Mason, 348

State V. Normandy Farms, 97
State V. Tharp, 169

State, Indiana State Highway Commission

V. Speidel, 82

Steup V. Indiana Housing Finance Author-

ity, 137

Stokely-Van Camp, Inc. v. State Board of

Tax Commissioners, 422

Stoneburner v. Fletcher, 360, 361

Stotts V. State, 133

Stumler v. Ferry-Morse Seed Co., 121

Suburban Electric Co. v. Lake County

Trust Co., 391

Sui Yee Lee v. Lafayette Home Hospital,
Inc., 429

Summerlot v. Summerlot, 195, 399

Sutton V. Roth, Wehrly, Heiny, Inc., 366

Taber v. Hutson, 110

Talas V. Correct Piping Co., 11, 455

Tauteris v. Review Board of Indiana

Security Division, 10

Temple v. Temple, 216

Theobald v. Chumley, 359

Thomas v. Review Board, 285
Thompson v. Lee, 434
Tipton County Abstract Co. v. Heritage

Federal Savings & Loan, 363
Toller V. Toller, 225

Tucker v. Marion County Department of

Public Welfare, 126

U
U.S. Aircraft Financing, Inc. v. Jankovich,

371, 383

Uhlir V. Ritz, 421

United Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co.
V. Wampler, 398

United Services Automobile Association v.

American Interinsurance Exchange, 255

United States Housing Foundation v.

Forman, 50

United States Steel Corp. v. Dykes, 473

United States of America v. Board of

School Commissioners, 139, 140

United States v. Harris, 235

United States v. Sims, 245

Universal Camera v. NLRB, 12
Upjohn Co. V. United States, 86, 313

Van Bibber v. Norris, 367, 379, 383, 384,
386

Vetor V. Shockey, 115, 351

w

Wagner v. Kendall, 281
Wagoner Construction Co. v. Noonan, 354
Wakschlag v. Review Board of Indiana

Employment Security Division, 11
Walker v. Review Board of Indiana

Employment, 6

Walton V. Ramp, 440
Warner Press, Inc. v. Review Board, 286
Warram v. Stanton, 26
Warren v. Indiana Telephone, 2, 130
Washington County Department of Public

Welfare v. Konar, 205

Watt V. State, 230
Weedo v. Stone-E-Brick, Inc., 267
Welborn v. Society for Propagation of

Faith, 331

Whispering Pines Home for Senior Citi-
zens V. Nicalek, 21

White Truck Sales, Inc. v. Shelby National

Bank, 122

Whitman v. Whitman, 210, 215
Wienke v. Lynch, 325, 368
William S. Deckelbaum Co. v. Equitable

Life Assurance Society, 365

Williams v. State, 173

Wilson V. Health and Hospital Corp., 146

Wilson V. Review Board of the Indiana

Employment Security Division, 25
Wilson V. Wilson, 216, 397

Witherspoon v. Salm, 462

Wood V. Strickland, 149, 442
Wright V. Doe d. Tatharti, 231

Young V. Taylor, 39

Zurich General Accident & Liability Insur-
ance Co. V. Clamor, 252



Indiana Laiiv Revieir
Volume 15 1981

R. George Wright
Editor-in-Chief

JupiTH A. Stewart
Executive Editor

S. Andrew Bowman
Catherine Chambers

William M. Thompson
Merlin P. Whiteman

Articles Editors

WILLIAM J. HANCOCK JOAN M. SAYLOR
Managing Editors

MICHAEL J. GRISHAM DAVID W. STEED
LYNNE D. LIDKE RAYMOND R. STOMMEL, JR.
Alan K. Mills Susan P, Stuart

Anne H. Weinheimer
Note and Development Editors

Mark Ahearn
BARRY Beldin
Mark Boyll
Cheryl Danberry
James Deal
Paul Gerhardt
Thomas Grabb
Victor Indiano

Jay Kennedy
Sharon Murphy

John polivick
PAMELA Rhine
John Schneider
Carol Shosid
lana swingler
John Christopher Wall
Ardeth Wilson
Terrance woolston
Gerald Wunsch
Beth Young

Associate Editors

PAUL J. GALANTI
Faculty Advisor

GwEN I. Wilson
Editorial Assistant



Indiana University School of Law— Indianapolis

1981-1982 ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICERS AND FACULTY

Administrative Officers

John W. Ryan, Ph.D., President of the University
Glenn W. Irwin, Jr., M.D., Vice-President
Gerald L. Bepko, LL.M., Acting Dean
G. Kent Frandsen, J.D., Associate Dean for Student Affairs
Jeffrey W. Grove, J.D., Acting Associate Dean for Academic Affairs

Fftculty

Thomas B. Allington, Professor. B.S., University of Nebraska, 1964; J.D., 1966; LL.M.,
New York University, 1971.

Edward P. Archer, Professor. B.M.E., Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, 1958; J.D.,
Georgetown University, 1962; LL.M., 1964.

James F. Bailey, III., Associate Professor and Director of Law Library. A.B., Univer-
sity of Michigan, 1961; J.D., 1964; M.A.L.S., 1970.

Gerald L. Bepko, Acting Dean and Professor. B.S., Northern Illinois University, 1962;
J.D., IIT/Chicago-Kent College of Law, 1965; LL.M., Yale University 1972.

Clyde Harrison Crockett, Professor. A.B., University of Texas, 1962; J.D., 1965;

LL.M., University of London (The London School of Economics and Political

Science}, 1972.

Debra a. Falender, Associate Professor. A.B., Mount Holyoke College, 1970; J.D., In-
diana University, 1975.

G. Kent Frandsen, Associate Dean for Student Affairs and Associate Professor. B.S.,
Bradley University, 1950; J.D., Indiana University, 1965.

David A. Funk, Professor. A.B., College of Wooster, 1949; J.D., Case Western Reserve
University, 1951; M.A., The Ohio State University, 1968; LL.M., Ca^e Western
Reserve University, 1972; LL.M., Columbia University, 1973.

Paul J. Galanti, Professor. A.B., Bowdoin College, 1960; J.D., University of Chicago,
1963.

Helen P. Garfield, Professor (on leave first semester, 1981-82). B.S.J., Northwestern
University, 1945; J.D., University of Colorado, 1967.

Harold Greenberg, Associate Professor. A.B., Temple University, 1959; J.D., Univer-
sity of Pennsylvania, 1962.

Jeffrey W. Grove, Acting Associate Dean for Academic Affairs and Professor. A.B.,
Juniata College, 1965; J.D., George Washington University, 1969.

William F. Harvey, CarlM. Gray Professor ofLaw. A.B., University of Missouri 1954;
J.D., Georgetown University, 1959; LL.M., 1961.

W. William Hodes, Assistant Professor. A.B., Harvard College, 1966; J.D., Rutgers,
Newark, 1969.

Lawrence A. Jegen, III., Professor. A.B., Beloit College, 1956; J.D., The University of
Michigan, 1959; M.B.A., 1960; LL.M., New York University, 1963.

Henry C. Karlson, Associate Professor. A.B., University of Illinois, 1965; J.D., 1968;
LL.M., 1977.

William Andrew Kerr. Professor (on leave, 1981-82). A.B., West Virginia University,
1955; J.D., 1957; LL.M., Harvard University, 1958; B.D., Duke University, 1968.

Walter W. Krieger, Associate Professor. A.B., Bellarmine College, 1959; J.D., Univer-
sity of Louisville, 1962; LL.M., George Washington University, 1969.

David P. Leonard, Assistant Professor. B.A., University of California at San Diego,
1974; J.D., UCLA School of Law, 1977

Wayne K. Lewis, Assistant Professor. B.A., Rutgers University, 1970; J.D., Cornell
Law School, 1973.

William E. Marsh, Associate Professor. B.S., University of Nebraska, 1965; J.D., 1968.
Susanah M. Mead, Assistant Professor. B.A., Smith College, 1969; J.D., Indiana Univer-

sity, 1976.

Mary H. Mitchell, Assistant Professor. A.B., Butler University, 1975; J.D., Cornell
Law School 1978.



Rita M. Novak, Assistant Professor. B.A., Albion College, 1972; J.D., De Paul Univer-
sity, 1978; LL.M., Columbia University, 1981.

Melvin C. Poland, Professor. B.S., Kansas State University, 1940; LL.B., Washburn
University, 1949; LL.M., The University of Michigan, 1950.

Ronald W. Polston, Professor. B.S., Eastern Illinois University, 1953; LL.B., Univer-
sity of Illinois, 1958.

Gary A. Ratner, Associate Professor. B.S., California Institute of Technology, 1966;
M.S., Purdue University, 1969; J.D., University of Connecticut, 1973, LL.M, Yale
University, 1974.

Bryan M. Schneider, Assistant Professor. B.A., Amherst College, 1973; J.D., Univer-
sity of South Carolina School of Law, 1976; LL.M., Yale Law School, 1980.

Marshall J. Seidman, Professor (on leave, 1981-82). B.S., University of Pennsylvania^
1947; J.D., Harvard University, 1950; LL.M., 1970.

Kenneth M. Stroud, Professor. A.B., Indiana University, 1958; J.D., 1961.
Bradley J. Toben, Assistant Professor. B.A., University of Missouri, 1974; J.D., Baylor

University School ofLaw, 1977; LL.M., Harvard Law School 1981.
R. Bruqe Townsend, Cleon H Foust Professor of Law. A.B., Coe College, 1938; J.D.,

University of Iowa, 1940.

James Patrick White, Professor Ion special assignment). A.B., University oflowa^ 1953;
J.D., 1956; LL.M., George Washington University, 1959.

Lawrence P. Wilkins. Associate Professor. B.A., The Ohio State University, 1968; J.D.,
Capital University Law School, 1973; LL.M., University of Texas School of Law,
1974.

Harold R. Woodard, Professorial Lecturer. B.S., Harvard University, 1933; J.D., 1936.
William J. Woodward, Assistant Professor. B.A., University of Pennsylvania^ 1968;

J.D., Rutgers-Camden, 1975.

Emeriti
Agnes P. Barrett, Associate Professor Emeritus. B.S., Indiana University, 1942;

J.D., 1964.

Cleon H. Foust, Professor Emeritus. A.B., Wabash College, 1928; J.D., University of
Arizona^ 1933.

John S. Grimes, Professor Jurisprudence Emeritus. A.B., Indiana University, 1929;
J.D., 1931.

Legal Writing Instructors
Patricia Seasor Bailey, Lecturer. B.A., Anderson College, 1978; J.D., Indiana Univer-

sity, 1981.

Clark Robinson, Lecturer. A.B., Earlham College, 1966; M.A., Southern Illinois Univer-
sity-Carbondale, 1968; J.D., Indiana University, 1981.

Joan Ruhtenberg, Lecturer. B.A., Mississippi Universityfor Women, 1959; J.D., Indiana
University, 1980.

Law Library Staff
Wendell E. Johnting, Technical Services Librarian. A.B., Taylor University, 1974;

M.L.S., Indiana University, 1975.

Laura Kimberly, Acquisitions/Serials Librarian. B.A., Florida State University, 1977;
M.S., 1980.

Christine L. Stevens, Reference Librarian. A.B., Western Michigan University, 1970;
M.L.S., Indiana University, 1971.

Kathy J. Welker, Assistant Director. A.B., Huntington College, 1969; M.L.S., Indiana
University, 1972.

Merlin P. Whiteman, Reader's Service Librarian. A.B., Hope College, 1973; M.L.S.,
Indiana University, 1974.