Indiana Law Review INDIANA LAW REVIEW VOLUME 21 1988 INDEX & TABLE OF CASES The Trustees of Indiana University Copyright © 1989 Indiana Lavk^ Reviei^ Volume 21 1988 Editor-in-Chief Ellen M. White Executive Editors Articles and Production Notes and Topics Kristin A. Mulholland John R. Maley Articles Editors Margo Eckard Scott Bruning Stahi Marcia K. Icenogle Ron Weisenberger Michael D. Wright Business Editor D. Michael Young Note and Development Editors Leslie Cracraft Stephen C. Hombach Michael P. Dugan Kevin R. Kaster David H. Eyke John G. Shubat Associate Editors Jay D. Benjamin Mary Jane Harmon Lyn K. Berkebile Amy Link Karozos David Berry Michael McNelis Duane R. Denton Patrick D. Murphy Richard R. Dykhouse Fran Quigley Teresa Eppley Clifford T. Rubenstein Robert C. Feightner James Schrier Edwin W. Free III Douglas Taylor Ronald Gorsline Jeffrey Townsend Kathryn S. Hall James Waanders Rebecca Wehling Editorial Assistant Amy Morrison Grubbs Faculty Advisor Paul J. Galanti Vol. 21] INDEX iii ARTICLES An Essay: The Competing Currents of Rule lOb-5 Jurisprudence David M. Phillips 625 Developments in Business Association Law: CTS Corporation v. Dynamics Corporation of America Paul J. Galanti 1 Donald L. Jackson 291 Theodore F. Smith, Jr. 367 James A. Reed 159 Developments in Professional Responsibility Developments in Social Security Law Family Law Survey Hansen v. Von Duprin: Have the Floodgates Opened to Workmen's Com- pensation Claims? Carolyn W. Spengler 453 The Indiana Insurance Guaranty Association Act: More Problems Than Protection James W. Hehner Mark R. Smith 11^ The Indiana Judicial System: An Analysis of Change John L. Kellam 213 Indiana Rules of Professional Conduct: A Comparison with the Old Code Danielle Oates Sheff Fran Quigley 307 Indiana's New Health Care Consent Act: A Guiding Light for the Health Care Provider William H. Thompson 181 Loan Receipt Agreements Revisited: Recognizing Substance Over Form Robert W. Strohmeyer, Jr. 439 Market Philosophy in the Legal Tension Between Children's Autonomy and Parental Authority Robin Paul Malloy 889 Nonparty Tortfeasors in Indiana: The Early Cases Leonard E. Eilbacher 413 Pre-trial Discovery of Trial Preparation Materials Prepared, and Non- testifying Experts Retained, in Anticipation of Prior Litigation Andrew W. Hull 57 Property Survey 1987 Walter W. Krieger 343 The Rationale of Personal Admissions Roger Park 509 The ''Savings" Clause of Trial Rule 60(B): Muddy Waters? Scott A. Weathers 73 iv INDIANA LAW REVIEW [Vol.21] Significant Developments in Indiana Taxation Francina A. Dlouhy J.B. King 383 The Supreme Court, Title VII and "Voluntary" Affirmative Action— A Critique Paul N. Cox 767 Toward True and Plain Dealing: A Theory of Fraudulent Transfers In- volving Unreasonably Small Capital Bruce A. Markell 469 Underinsurance in Indiana: An Illusion of Coverage? Mary A. Findling Barbara J. Germano 205 Vertical Privity and Damages for Breach of Implied Warranty Under the U.C.C.: It's Time for Indiana to Abandon the Citadel Harold Greenburg 23 White V. State: And Now for Something Different Susan Stuart Richard Pitts 85 Who Pays for Environmental Damage: Recent Developments in CERCLA Liability and Insurance Coverage Litigation George Pendygraft George M. Plews James W. Clark Peter C. Wright 117 BOOK REVIEW Applications of Political Science to the Analysis and Practice of Law David A. Funk 617 NOTES Apportionment of Harm to Causes: Asbestosis and the Smoking Plaintiff 523 Disclaimer of Joint Tenancy Interest—When Does the Nine-Month Time Limit in LR.C. Section 2518 Begin to Run? 669 Dissenting Shareholders' Rights Under the New Indiana Business Cor- poration Act: Jurisprudential Interpretations of the Exclusivity Provision 93 1 First Church Decides Compensation is Remedy for Temporary Regulatory Takings—Local Governments are "Singing the Blues" 901 The Institutionalized Wolf: An Analysis of the Unconstitutionality of the Independent Counsel Provisions of the Ethics in Government Act of 1978 955 Vol. 21] INDEX \ The Limitations Period for Title I of the LMRDA: Protection of the Union Member's Civil Rights 587 Medicare Provider Reimbursement Disputes: Mapping the Contorted Bor- ders of Administrative and Judicial Review 705 Remedies for Employer's Wrongful Discharge of an Employee Subject to Employment of Indefinite Duration 547 The Superfund Insurance Dilemma: Defining the Super Risks and Rights of Comprehensive General Liability Policies 735 VI INDIANA LAW REVIEW [Vol. 21] TABLE OF CASES Aaron v. SEC 631, 641-43, 660 Aetna Casualty and Surety Co. V. Hanna 759 Affiliated Ute Citizens v. United States 630 Agins V. City of Tiburon 912, 919 Albemarle Paper Co. v. Moody 871 Allied Products Corp. v. Arrow Freightways, Inc. 489-90 Alpert V. 28 Williams St. Corp. 945 American Buildings Co. v. Kokomo Grain Co. 57, 59, 67, 71 Arnone v. Murphy 267-68 Ashland Pipeline Co. v. Indiana Bell Telephone Co. 357 Athens Community Hospital v. Schweiker 714 Austin V. State 85, 89, 92, 94-97, 99, 107, 111-12, 114-15 Auto Workers v. Hoosier Cardinal Corp. 596, 601, 613 B Bachran v. Morishige 530 Baeder v. Heckler 374 Ball Stores, Inc. v. State Board of Tax Commissioners 386-88 Barker v. Wingo 101 Barmet of Indiana, Inc. v. Security Insurance Group 156-57 Barnes v. MacBrown & Co. 34, 35, 49, 50 Bateman Eichler, Hill Richards, Inc. V. Berner 627, 632-35 Bell V. Bingham 177-78 Berard v. General Motors Corp. 593 Bethesda Hospital v. Bowen 714-16, 733 Blue Chip Stamps v. Manor Drug Stores 639, 643 Bowen v. Michigan Academy of Family Physicians 731, 733 Bowen v. Yuckert 367, 380 Boykin v. Alabama 91, 97, 99-102, 115 Brady v. United States 101 Brisboy v. Fibreboard Paper Products Corp. 537, 539 Bryant v. State 110 Buian v. J. L. Jacobs & Co. 552 Burnett v. Grattan 614 Caley v. Lung 81, 83 Cahfornia Union Insurance Co. v. Central National Insurance Co. of Omaha 240 Candlelight Homes, Inc. v. Zomes 32-33, 42-43, 53 Carpenter v. United States 625-26, 628-29, 635, 637, 648, 652-53, 655-56, 659, 661, 665 Carpenter v. Wisniewski 352-53 Carrousel Concessions, Inc. v. Florida Insurance Guaranty Association 270 Carvey v. Indiana National Bank 79-80 Case V. Nebraska 86 Case V. Phelps 476, 478 Centennial Insurance Co. v. Lumbermens Mutual Casualty Co. 762-63 Chapman v. California 107-08 Chermak v. Chermak 80-81 Chiarella v. United States 631, 645, 647, 649, 653, 655-56, 661, 663 Chicago, Burhngton & Quincy R.R. Co. V. Chicago 904 City Investing v. Simcox 3, 4 City of Lafayette v. Louisiana Power & Light Co. 927 City of Los Angeles Dep't of Water & Power V. Manhart 773-74, 827 Cleary v. American Airhnes, Inc. 564-65 demons v. Metropolitan Trucking, Inc. 420 Continental Insurance Cos. v. North- eastern Pharmaceutical & Chemical Co. 741, 748 Continental Insurance v. Northeastern Pharmaceutical Chemical Co. 149 Copitas V. Retail Clerks International Association 594 Cort V. Ash 638-39, 645 County of Los Angeles v. Davis 725 Vol. 21] INDEX vn Credit Managers Associations of Southern California v. Federal Co. 489-90, 502-03, 505, 508 Crowley v. Local No. 82, Furniture and Piano Moving, Furniture Store Drivers, Helpers, Warehousemen, and Packers 593 CTS Corp. V. Dynamics Corporations of America 8, 10, 12, 14, 16-20 D Davis V. UAW 598, 606-07 DelCostello v. International Brother- hood of Teamsters 588-89, 595, 597-603, 606, 609-11, 613-16 Diller v. Irving Trust Co. (In re CoUege Chemist, Inc.) 488-91, 494 Dirks V. SEC 631-32, 634, 645, 647, 651, 663 Doty V. Sewall 599, 601-03, 606 Dutton V. International Harvester Co. 34 E Edgar v. MITE Corp. 2, 4, 9-10, 16, 18 Eli Lilly and Co. v. Home Insurance Co. 147 Ernst & Ernst v. Hochfelder 639, 641, 643 Estran v. Heckler 374 Evans v. Yankeetown Dock Corporation 453, 455-59, 462, 464-65 Ex parte Hennen 969-70 Ex parte Siebold 969-70, 972, 978 F.W. Woolworth Co. v. Plaza North, Inc 346 Paris Mailing, Inc. v. Indiana Department of State Revenue 397 Ferguson v. United States 688-91 Ferrari v. Toto 266-68 Fidehty Trust Co. v. Union National Bank 500 Fireman's Fund Insurance Cos. V. Ex-Cell-O Corp. 743 First English Evangelical Lutheran Church of Glendale v. County of Los Angeles 901-02, 904, 909, 911, 913-14, 916-17, 919-23, 926, 928-30 Florida Insurance Guaranty Association v. Dolan 265-66 Frampton v. Central Indiana Gas Co. 557, 567-68 Franklin Bank and Trust Co. V. Reed 175, 177-79 Frankhn v. White 361 Gabhart v. Gabhart 938-39 German v. State 85, 89, 92, 94-95, 99, 109-12, 114-15 Gideon v. Johns-Manville Sales Corp. 540 Globe Indemnity Co. v. People 754-55 Goldblatt V. Town of Hempstead 908, 915 Gould V. Ruefenacht 653, 655 Great W. United Corp. v. Kidwell (see n.7) 4 Greenco, Inc. v. May 355 Griggs V. Duke Power Co. 838, 857-59, 871-72 Gwinn v. Commissioner 680-81 H Hadacheck v. Sebastian 915 Hagerman v. Buchanan 478-80 Haines v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co. 760 Hansen v. Von Duprin 453-54, 456, 458-59, 461-62, 464, 467 Harless v. First National Bank in Fairmont 569, 578 Harrison v. American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations 594 Haskell & Barker Car Co. V. Brown 460 Hazel-Atlas Glass Co. v. Hartford Empire Co. 76, 78, 81, 83 Hazelwood School District v. United States 796-98 Henderson v. Morgan 101, 115 Vlll INDIANA LA W REVIEW [Vol. 21] Henninger v. Riley 253 Henningsen v. Bloomfield Motors, Inc. 29-31, 39 Herff Jones, Inc. v. State Board of Tax Commissioners 389, 391, 394-95 Herman & MacLean v. Huddleston 632-33 Hickerson v. Protective National Insurance Co. 254-55 Hickman v. Taylor 65-66, 70 Hill V. Metropolitan Trucking, Inc. 420-21, 429, 435, 437 Hill V. United States 92 Hirsch v. Merchants National Bank and Trust Co. 350 Hobbs V. State 283 Hobson V. Hansen 970-71, 978-79 Hoffman v. United States 689-91 Home Insurance Co. v. Neilsen 144 Howard v. Reeck 171 Huber v. Henley 427-29 Hughes V. Great American Indemnity Co. 529-30 Humphrey's Executor v. United States 974-76 Indiana Insurance Guaranty Association v. Kiner 223, 226-27, 249, 264 Indiana Lumberman's Mutual Insurance Co. v. Brandum 145 Interstate Commerce Commission V. Brimson 979 J.I. Case Co. v. Borak 630, 634 J.I. Case Co. v. Sandefur 34 Jackson Township Municipal Utility Authority v. Hartford Accident and Indemnity Co. 153-54 Jackson v. Russell 300-04 Jacobson v. First State Bank (In re Jacobson) 504 Jenkins v. Halstead Industries 534-35 Jenney v. Vining 505 Jewett V. Commissioner 691-95, 700-01 Johnson v. Johnson 174 Johnson v. Transportation Agency 792-94, 796, 798-99, 802-03, 805-07, 811-12, 818, 848 Judy V. State 104-06 In re Agent Orange Product Liability Litigation 70 In re City Investing Co. 4 In re Marriage of Davis 174 In re Marriage of Osborne 161-62 In re Marriage of Patus 166-69 In re Murphy 67 In re Olson 961 In re Reed 305-06 In re Sealed Case 979 In re Stanton I (Stanton II) 291-94, 299-300 In re Yussman 293 Independent Petrochemical Corp. v. Aetna Casualty and Surety 745 Indiana Department of State Revenue V. Best Ever Companies 383, 398, 400 Indiana Department of State Revenue V. Food Marketing Corp. 400 Indiana Department of State Revenue V. Stark-Wetzel 400 K Keene Corp v. Insurance Co. of North America 146 Kelsay v. Motorola, Inc. 579 Kennedy v. Commissioner 669-71, 673, 679-80, 685, 688-89, 693-95, 697-703 Kentucky Insurance Guaranty Association Mutual v. State Farm Automobile Insurance Co. 252 Keystone Bituminous Coal Association V. DeBenedictis 915, 920, 929 Kilbourn v, Thompson 963 Kipin Industries, Inc. v. American Universal Insurance Co. 155 Landreth Timber Co. v. Landreth 627, 653-57 Vol. 21] INDEX IX Lane v. Barringer 32-34, 45 Lansco, Inc. v. Department of Environmental Protection 148-49, 153 LeSea Broadcasting Corp. v. State Board of Tax Commissioners 384-85, 388 Linda R. S. v. Richard D. 965 Local Union 1397, United Steelworkers V. United Steelworkers 598, 606-07 Lofton V. Schweiker 372 Luedke v. Luedke 159-60, 162-66, 168-70, 178 Lyons v. McDonald 361 M MacDonald, Sommer, & Frates v. Yolo County 918, 922 Mackay v. Douglas 478-80 MacPherson v. Buick Motor Co. 29-30 Magnuson v. Blickenstaff 75, 78-82 Margrat, Inc., v. Indiana State Board of Tax Commissioners 385-88 Marshall v. Holmes 77-78, 81-82 Martin v. Johns-Manville Corp. 526-28, 541, 543 Martin v. Martin 170, 174, 179 Martin v. State 109, 112 Maryland Casualty Co. v. Armco, Inc. 150, 151, 741, 743, 745, 750, 752, 756-57, 761, 763-64 McBride v. Bertsch 500-01 McCarthy v. United States 93-95, 106-08 McClanahan v. Remington Freight Lines, Inc. 570 McDonald v. Commissioner 670, 700-01, 703 Michaels v. Michaels 953 Mills V. Electric Auto-Lite Co. 630, 644 Monell V. New York City Department of Social Services 927 Mooney v. Holohan 86 Moore v. Johns-Manville Sales Corp. 543 Morrison v. Olson 976, 979-80 Mraz v. Canadian Universal Insurance Co. 150-51, 753-54 Mugler V. Kansas 907, 915, 919-20 Myers v. United States 974, 976, 979, 981 N National Standard Insurance Co. V. Continental Insurance Co. 146-47 National Surety Co. of New York V. State Bank of Humboldt 75 Nectow V. City of Cambridge 925 Neeley v. State 85, 88-89 Nees V. Hocks 568, 579 New Castle County v. Hartford Accident and Indemnity Co. 755, 762-63 Niagara County v. Utica Mutual Insurance Co. 155-56 Null V. WiUiamson 356 Pacific Indemnity Co. V. Bunker Hill Co. 146 Patton V. State 109, 111 Pearson v. Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. 556 Penn Central Transportation Co. V. New York City 921 Pennsylvania Coal Co. v. Mahon 908, 918-20 Persinger v. Lucas 432 Petermann v. International Brother- hood of Teamsters, Local 396 557 Pine River State Bank v. Mettille 562-63 Plant V. Howard Johnson's Motor Lodge 360 Port of Portland v. Water Quality Insurance Syndicate 755 Prairie Production, Inc. v. Agchem Div.-Pennwalt Corp. 31, 36-37 Prutzman v. Armstrong 253-54 Pugh V. See's Candies, Inc. 564-65 R R.H. MarHn v. Indiana Department of Revenue 395-97 INDIANA LAW REVIEW [Vol. 21] Rabkin v. Philip A. Hunt Chemical Corp. 944 Railroad Commission v. Pullman 3 Raley v. DarHng Shop of Greenville, Inc. 556-57 Randall v. Loftsgaarden 657, 659-60 Randy Knitwear, Inc. v. American Cyanamid Co. 31, 37 Ray-Ron Corp. v. DMY Realty Co. 344 Rector v. Local Union No. 10, International Union of Elevator Constructors 599, 602, 607 Regal Construction Co. v. West Lanham Hills Citizen's Association 763 Rice V. Olson 101 Richards v. Goerg Boat & Motors, Inc. 37-38, 53 Riner v. Raines 105 Romack v. Pubhc Service Co. of Indiana 562, 569-70, 574 Ross v. Canadian Indemnity Insurance Co. 251 San Diego Gas & Electric Co. v. City of San Diego 909, 911, 914, 920, 922 Sanders v. Cole Municipal Finance 441-43, 445, 451 Sandor Development Co. v. Reitmeyer 351 Sands v. Pennsylvania Insurance Guaranty Association 256-57 Sante Fe Industries, Inc. v. Green 640, 642, 648 Scruggs V. Schweiker 372 SEC V. Texas Gulf Sulpher Co. 629, 647 Sewell V. Grand Lodge of the International Association of Machin- ists and Aerospace Workers 593 Shaw V. S.S. Kresge Co. 554-55 Shearson/American Express, Inc. V. McMahon 658-61 Singer v. Magnavox Co. 938-39 Smith V. Atlas Off-Shore Boat Service, Inc. 577 Smith V. O'Grady 101 Solvents Recovery Service of New England v. Midland Insurance Co. 756 Springdale Memorial Hospital v. Bowen 717-18 St. Joseph's Hospital v. Heckler 712-13 State V. Bunker Hill 129 State V. Schuetter 424-26 State V. Shore Realty Corp. 129 Steph V. Branch 502-03 Superintendent of Insurance v. Bankers Life and Casualty Co. 640 Tallahassee Memorial Regional Medical Center v. Bowen 724 Tameny v. Atlantic Richfield Co. 570 Temple v. Temple 165-69 Thompson Farms, Inc. v. Corno Feed Products 37 Toscano v. Commissioner 83 Toussaint v. Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Michigan 558, 560, 562-64 Townsend & Freeman Co. v, Taggart 460 Township of Gloucester v. Maryland Casualty Co. 761, 763 Transamerica Insurance Group v. Osborn 220 Tri-Continental Corp. v. Battye 943 TSC Industries v. Northway, Inc. 643-45 U U.S. Steel Corporation v. Multistate Tax Commission 408-09 United Pacific Insurance Company v. Van's Westlake Union, Inc. 156 United States Aviex Co. v. Travelers Insurance Co. 149, 752, 762 United States Steel Corporation V. Dykes 460-61 United States v. Causby 909 United States v. Conservation Chemical Co. 128, 756, 763 United States v. Cox 967 Vol. 21] INDEX XI United States v. General Motors Corp. 918 United States v. Jacobs 681 United States v. Maryland Bank & Trust Co. 133-35 United States v. Mechanik 93-94 United States v. Mirabile 132-35 United States v. Northeastern Pharmaceutical & Chemical Co. 126 United States v. Perkins 977 United States v. Shaw 967 United States v. Solomon 971-72 United States v. Thompson 966 United States v. Throckmorton 77-78, 80-81 United States v. Timmreck 93-94 United States v. Wetterlin 92 United Steelworkers v. Weber 791-95, 798, 802, 871 Weinberger v, U.O.P., Inc. 939, 942 44 Weiner v. McGraw-Hill, Inc. 561-63, 574 Wells Fargo Bank v. Desert View Building Supphes, Inc. 501-02 Western Medical Enterprises, Inc. V. Heckler 712-13 White V. State 85-86, 90-97, 99-104, 107-15 Wiener v. United States 975 Wilks V. First National Bank of Mishawaka 387-88 Wilson V. Garcia 599, 609-10, 612-16 Wilson V. Wilson 174 Winterbottom v. Wright 25, 29, 39-40, 48, 50 Wiskotoni v. Michigan National Bank-West 578 Wygant v. Jackson Board of Education 792-98 Vetor V. Shockey 361 Video Tape Exchange Coop of America v. Indiana Department of State Revenue 398 Vigil V. Arzola 578 Young V. Ragen 86 Young V. United States ex. rel. Vuitton et File S. A. 967-68 W Walters v. Dean 432-34 Weatherhead Co. v. State Board of Tax Commissioners 386-87 Zuk V. Hale 502-03