Indiana Law Review INDIANA LAW REVIEW VOLUME 30 1996-1997 AUTHOR, TITLE AND CASE EsfDEX The Trustees of Indiana University Copyright © 1997 1997] INDEX i CONTRIBUTOR INDEX ARTICLES Ammeen, Jr., James J., Developments in Appellate Practice in J996 1 165 Baker, Judge John G., The History ofthe Court ofAppeals in Indiana 233 Barteau, Honorable Betty, Thirty Years of the Journey ofIndiana's Women Judges 1964-1994 43 Betz, Kevin W., Deibert, Andrew T., An Examination ofthe Indiana Supreme Court Docket, Dispositions, and Voting in 1996 921 Boshkoff, Douglass G., Bankruptcy in the Seventh Circuit: 1996 937 Brown, Christopher A., Recent Changes in Intellectual Property Law 1213 Browning, Minde C, Humphrey, Richard, Kleinschmidt, Bruce Biographical Sketches ofIndiana Supreme Court Justices 329 Chezem, Honorable Linda L., Nagy, Sarah L., Judicial Abrogation ofa Husband's Paternity: Can a Third Party Seek to Establish Paternity Over a Child Born into a Marriage While That Marriage Remains Intact? 467 Cooper, Jeffrey O., Recent Developments Under the Indiana Rules ofEvidence » 1049 Dickson, Justice Brent E., John, Thomas A., Wyman, Katherine A. Lawyers and Judges as Framers ofIndiana's 1851 Constitution 397 Dillin, Judge S. Hugh, The Origin and Development ofthe Indiana Bar Examination 391 Estes, R. Wayne, Joseph, Andrea E., Missing Analytical Link in Supreme Court's "Salting" Decision Disturbs Balance of Union-Management Rights: A Critical Analysis of NLRB V. Town & Country Electric 445 Evans, Kelly A., Developments in Indiana Employment Law 1037 Funk, David A., Two Lives in Law 643 Galbraith, Brad A., Judicial Developments in Business and Contract Law 941 Greenberg, Harold, Patchel, Kathleen, 1996 Survey ofthe Uniform Commercial Code in Indiana 1359 Grove, Jeffrey W., Remarks Honoring William F. Harvey, Carl M. Gray Professor ofLaw and Advocacy 439 Jegen, III, Lawrence A., Tripp, James S., Murphy, Jr., Stephen P. 1996 Developments in Indiana Taxation 1291 Kidd, Charles M., McKinney, Dennis K., Survey of 1996 Developments in the Law ofProfessional Responsibility 1251 Kinney, Eleanor D., Selby, Justice Myra C, History and Jurisprudence of the Physician-Patient Relationship in Indiana 263 Levinson, Rosalie Berger, State and Federal Constitutional Law Developments 953 Lupton, Suzann Weber, Isaac Blackford: First Man ofthe Court 319 Maley, John R., 1996 Federal Civil Practice and Procedure Update for Seventh Circuit Practitioners 1099 ii INDIANA LAW REVIEW [Vol.30 Maley, John R., Survey ofDevelopments in Indiana Civil Procedure 1121 McGreal, Paul E., Constitutional Illiteracy, Review Essay ofLouis Michael Seidman & Mark V. Tushnet, Remnants of Belief: Constitutional Issues 693 McMains, Michael B., Morrison, Catherine M, The Impact of Technological Advancement on Pharmaceutical Company Liability 487 Meyer, Tammy J., Cox, Dina M., Recent Developments in Indiana Tort Law ... 1317 Miller, Hon. Gary L., Schumm, Joel M., Recent Developments in Indiana Criminal Law and Procedure 1005 Morris, Jennifer Tracie, The End ofan Era 441 Papke, David Ray, The American Legal Faith: Traditions, Contradictions and Possibilities 645 Pippin, Judy Winn, Foote, Daniel G., Recent Cases in Worker's Compensation Law 1389 Render, John C, Health Care Law: A Survey of 1996 Developments 1131 Saxer, Shelley Ross, Local Autonomy or Regionalism?: Sharing the Benefits and Burdens ofSuburban Commercial Development 659 Schaefer, Paula J., Ruppert, Michael G., Survey ofIndiana Family Law in 1996 1073 Shepard, Chief Justice Randall T., On the Retirement ofJustice Roger O. DeBruler 7 Shepard, Chief Justice Randall T., Reflections on a Decade at the Indiana Supreme Court, 1987-1997 921 Shepard, Chief Justice Randall T., The Importance ofLegal History for Modern Lawyering 1 Shoultz, Richard K., Survey ofRecent Developments in Insurance Law 1191 Staton, Judge Robert H., Hicklin, Gina M., The History ofthe Court ofAppeals ofIndiana 203 Stommel, R. Robert, Cox, Dina M., Recent Developments in the Indiana Law ofProduct Liability 1227 Stroud, Kenneth M., Justice DeBruler and the Dissenting Opinion 15 Sullivan, Jr., Justice Frank, A Tribute to Justice Roger O. DeBruler 11 Sullivan, Jr., Justice Frank, Indiana as a Forerunner in the Juvenile Court Movement 279 Wilkins, Lawrence P., Tribute to Professor Debra A. Falender 917 Williams, Sandra Boyd, The Indiana Supreme Court and the Struggle Against Slavery 305 Wright, Danaya C, Captive Gas and Condemned Trash: Highs and Lows of Indiana Property Law in 1996 1269 Wright, Danaya C, Private Rights and Public Ways: Property Disputes and Rails-to-Trails in Indiana 723 NOTES Blaiklock, A. Richard M., Fiduciary Duties Owed by Frozen-Out Minority Shareholders in Close Corporations 763 Bowman III, Ray F., English Common Law and Indiana Jurisprudence 409 1997] INDEX iii Church, Steven A., The Weakening ofthe Presumption of Validityfor Design Patents: Continued Confusion Under the Functionality and Matter of Concern Doctrines 499 Donahue, Robert J., Racial Diversity as a Compelling Governmental Interest 523 Johnson, Brian J., The Response to Payne v. Tennessee; Giving the Victim 's Family a Voice in the Capital Sentencing Process 795 McCauley, John F., CipoUone & Myrick; Deflating the Airbag Preemption Defense 827 Murphy-Farmer, Candice M., Mandatory Appointment of Guardians Ad Litemfor Children in Dissolution Proceedings: An Important Step Towards Low-Impact Divorce 551 Ross, Jacqueline, Will States Protect Us, Equally, from Damage Caps in Medical Malpractice Legislation? 575 Ster, Brian T., Photocopying and Fair Use: Exploring the Marketfor Scientific Journal Articles 607 Strain, Jana Schrink, Medicaid vs. The Tobacco Industry: A Reasonable Legislative Solution to a State's Financial Woes? 851 Troyer, Matthew T., Mail Order Retailers and Commerce Clause Nexus: A Bright Line Rule or an Opaque Standard 881 iv INDIANA LAW REVffiW [Vol.30 TITLE INDEX ARTICLES 1996 Developments in Indiana Taxation Lawrence A. Jegen, III James S. Tripp Stephen P. Murphy, Jr. 1291 1996 Federal Civil Practice and Procedure Update for Seventh Circuit Practitioners John R. Maley 1099 1996 Survey of the Uniform Commercial Code in Indiana Harold Greenberg Kathleen Patchel 1359 A Tribute to Justice Roger O. DeBruler Justice Frank Sullivan, Jr. 1 1 An Examination of the Indiana Supreme Court Docket, Dispositions, and Voting in 1996 Kevin W. Betz Andrew T. Deibert 933 Bankruptcy in the Seventh Circuit: 1996 Douglass G. Boshkojf 949 Biographical Sketches of Indiana Supreme Court Justices Minde C. Browning Richard Humphrey Bruce Kleinschmidt 329 Captive Gas and Condemned Trash: Highs and Lows of Indiana Property Law in 1996 Danaya C. Wright 1269 Constitutional Illiteracy Review Essay of Louis Michael Seidman & Mark V. Tushnet, Remnants ofBelief: Constitutional Issues Developments in Appellate Practice in 1996 Developments in Indiana Employment Law Health Care Law: A Survey of 1996 Developments History and Jurisprudence of the Physician-Patient Relationship in Indiana Paul E. McGreal 693 James J. Ammeen, Jr. 1 165 Kelly A. Evans 1037 John C. Render 1131 Eleanor D. Kinney Justice Myra C. Selby 263 Indiana as a Forerunner in the Juvenile Court Movement Justice Frank Sullivan, Jr. 279 1997] INDEX Isaac Blackford: First Man of the Court Suzann Weber Lupton 319 Judicial Abrogation of a Husband's Paternity: Can a Third Party Seek to Establish Paternity Over a Child Born into a Marriage While That Marriage Remains Intact? Honorable Linda L. Chezem Sarah L Nagy 467 Judicial Developments in Business and Contract Law Brad A. Galbraith Timothy D. Freeman 953 Justice DeBruler and the Dissenting Opinion Kenneth M. Stroud 15 Lawyers and Judges as Framers of Indiana's 1851 Constitution Justice Brent E. Dickson Thomas A. John Katherine A. Wyman 397 Local Autonomy or Regionalism?: Sharing the Benefits and Burdens of Suburban Commercial Development Shelley Ross Saxer 659 Missing Analytical Link in Supreme Court's "Salting" Decision Disturbs Balance of Union-Management Rights: A Critical Analysis of NLRB V. Town & Country Electric R. Wayne Estes Andrea E. Joseph 445 On the Retirement of Justice Roger O. DeBruler ChiefJustice Randall T. Shepard 1 Private Rights and Public Ways: Property Disputes and Rails-to-Trails in Indiana Danaya C. Wright 723 Recent Cases in Worker's Compensation Law Judy Winn Pippin Daniel G. Foote 1389 Recent Changes in Intellectual Property Law Christopher A. Brown 1213 Recent Developments in Indiana Criminal Law and Procedure Hon. Gary L. Miller Joel M. Schumm 1005 Recent Developments in Indiana Tort Law Tammy J. Meyer DinaM. Cox 1317 Recent Developments in the Indiana Law of Product Liability R. Robert Stommel DinaM. Cox 1227 vi INDIANA LAW REVIEW [Vol.30 Recent Developments Under the Indiana Rules of Evidence Jeffrey O. Cooper 1049 Reflections on a Decade at the Indiana Supreme Court, 1987-1997 ChiefJustice Randall T. Shepard 921 Remaiks Honoring William F. Harvey, Carl M. Gray Professor of Law and Advocacy Jeffrey W. Grove 439 Richard M. Givan: Justice, Indiana Supreme Court, 1969-1994 Chief Justice of Indiana, 1974-1987 Jerome L. Withered 35 State and Federal Constitutional Law Developments Rosalie Berger Levinson 965 Survey of 1996 Developments in the Law of Professional Responsibility Charles M. Kidd Dennis K. McKinney 1251 Survey of Developments in Indiana Civil Procedure JohnR.Maley 1121 Survey of Indiana Family Law in 1996 Paula J. Schaefer Michael G. Ruppert 1073 Survey of Recent Developments in Insurance Law Richard K. Shoultz 1191 The American Legal Faith: Traditions, Contradictions and Possibilities David Ray Papke 645 The End of an Era Jennifer Trade Morris 441 The History of the Court of Appeals of Indiana Judge Robert H. Staton 203 Gina M. Hicklin The History of the Indiana Trial Court System and Attempts at Renovation Judge John G. Baker 233 The Impact of Technological Advancement on Pharmaceutical Company Liability Michael B. McMains Catherine M. Morrison 487 The Importance of Legal History for Modem Lawyering ChiefJustice Randall T. Shepard 1 The Indiana Supreme Court and the Struggle Against Slavery Sandra Boyd Williams 305 The Origin and Development of the Indiana Bar Examination Judge S. Hugh Dillin 391 Thirty Years of the Journey of Indiana's Women Judges 1964-1994 Honorable Betty Barteau 43 Two Lives in Law David A. Funk 643 Tribute to Professor Debra A. Falender Lawrence P. Wilkins 917 1997] INDEX vii NOTES Cipollone 8l Myrick: Deflating the Airbag Preemption Defense John F. McCauley 827 English Common Law and Indiana Jurisprudence Ray F. Bowman III 409 Fiduciary Duties Owed by Frozen-Out Minority Shareholders in Close Corporations A. Richard M. Blaiklock 763 Mail Order Retailers and Commerce Clause Nexus: A Bright Line Rule or an Opaque Standard? Matthew T. Troyer 88 1 Mandatory Appointment of Guardians Ad Litem for Children in Dissolution Proceedings: An Important Step Towards Low-Impact Divorce Candice M. Murphy-Farmer 55 1 Medicaid vs. The Tobacco Industry: A Reasonable Legislative Solution to a State's Financial Woes? Jana Schrink Strain 85 1 Photocopying and Fair Use: Exploring the Market for Scientific Journal Articles Brian T. Ster 607 Racial Diversity as a Compelling Governmental Interest Robert J. Donahue 523 The Response to Payne v. Tennessee: Giving the Victim's Family a Voice in the Capital Sentencing Process Brian J. Johnson 795 The Weakening of the Presumption of Validity for Design Patents: Continued Confusion Under the Functionality and Matter of Concern Doctrines Steven A. Church 499 Will States Protect Us, Equally, from Damage Caps in Medical Malpractice Legislation? Jacqueline Ross 575 1997] INDEX IX TABLE OF CASES* A Women's Choice-East Side Women's Clinic v. Newman 1 154 Adams v. Children's Mercy Hosp. 597 Adams v. State 32 Adarand Constructors, Inc. v. Pena 525, 527, 537, 541,543,717 Alabama V. White 1012 Allstate Ins. Co, v. Smith 1 197 American States Ins. Co. v. Kiger 1207 Americanos v. Carter 998 Anderson v. P.A. Radocy & Sons, Inc. 1236 Arneson v. Olson 599, 603 Atchley v. Heritage Cable Vision Assocs. 1114 Atkins V. Niermeier 1271 Avia Group Intn'l, Inc. v. L.A. Gear Cal. 506-07 -B- Bamberger & Feibleman V. IPL 1227 Bankmark of Fla., Inc. v. Star Fin. Card Servs. 1126 Basko V. Sterling Drug, Inc. 495 Batson v. Kentucky 1023 Bell V. Clark 960 Benante v. United Pac. Life Ins. Co. 1210 Bennis v. Michigan 984 Best Lock Corp. v. Ilco Unican Corp. 513,520 Biel, Inc. v. Kirsch 1196 Bivins v. State 806 Blackwell v. Bornstein 963 BMWofN.Am.,Inc. V. Gore 982 Board of City Comm'rs v. Umbehr 999 Board of Trustees of Clark Mem'l Hosp. V. Collins 1191 Boggs V. Blue Diamond Coal Co. 1402 Bohacv.West 1112 Bonaventura v. Leach 1 101, 1 141 Booth V. Maryland 795-96 Borgman v. Aikens 1 129 Bowers v. Hardwick 991 Bowman v. Bowman 1086 Braden Corp. v. Citizens Nat'l Bank 1378 Branti v. Finkel 998 Bratcher V, State 1013 Bridwell V. State 1018 Brown v. Penn Cent. Corp. 738, 742 Brown v. State 1067 Brown v. St. Joseph County 1 106 Brown's Furniture, Inc. v. Wagner 906 Bruch V. Centerview Comm. Church, Inc. 736 Bryan v. Rectors & Visitors of the Univ. of Va. 1152-53 Bryant v. Mutual Hosp. Servs. 1 146 Buck V. Banks 1285 Buckner v. Sam's Club, Inc. 1112 Budget Car Sales v. Stott 1 35 1 Bullitt V. Scribner 419 Bussell V. Minix 1 106 Buzzard V. State 1063 * The cases listed here are those cases that were discussed in the text of an Article or Note. If a case was only mentioned in footnotes, it does not appear in the Table of Cases. INDIANA LAW REVIEW [Vol. 30 -C- C & M Fiberglass Septic Tanks, Inc. v. T & N Fiberglass Mfg. Co. 519 Cage V. Louisiana 1033 Cain V. Cain 773 Camp V. Gregory 987 Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music, Inc. 632 Campbell v. Criterion Group 423,1177 Campbell v. Eckman/Freeman Assocs. 1319, 1393 Canterbury v. Spence 271-72 Cargle v. State 820 Carson v. Maurer 595 Caruso v. DeLuca 999 Cason V. State 1060 Central States, S.E. & S.W. Pension Fund v. Central Cartage Co. 1118-19 Channell v. Citicorp Nat'l Servs., Inc. 1103 Chestnut v. Roof 1232 Cipollone v. Liggett Group, Inc. 828, 841 City of Minot v. Freelander 1279 City of Richmond v. J.A. Croson Co. 540, 546 C.J.C. V. C.B.J. 1096 Claridge v. Phelps 735 Clark V. Donahue 987 Clark V. State 1018 Clifft V. Indiana Dep't of State Revenue 979 Cobbs V.Grant 271 Collins V. Day 583, 603, 966, 1026 Comer v.Gohil 1137 Commercial Union Ins. Co. v. Moore 1198 Compassion in Dying v. State 987 Complete Auto Transit v. Brady 893 Computers Unlimited, Inc. v. Midwest Data Sys., Inc. 1 350 Conner v. Conner 1083 Connick v. Myers 996 Conrail v. Lewellen 746 Contel of Indiana, Inc. v. Coulson 1273 Cox V. American Aggregates Corp. 1398 Craft Prods., Inc. v. Hartford Fire Ins. Co. 1387 Craig V. Bennett 227-28 Cruzan v. Missouri Dep't of Health 988 Culbertson v. Memitz 267, 269, 27 1 Cummins v. Lyle Indus. 1239 Curless v . Watson 214 Currin v. State 1023 -D- Dale Elecs., Inc. v. R.C.L. Elecs., Inc. 512 Dandridge v. Williams 603 D'Archangel v. Allstate Ins. Co. 1 197 Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharm.,Inc. 1110-11 Davis V. Central Rent-a-Crane, Inc. 1404 Demoulas v. Demoulas Super Mkts., Inc. 773 Design, Inc. v. Emerson Co. 519 Dickson v. State 29 Dishnow v. School Dist. of Rib Lake 997 Doe V. Hersemann 1 108 Donahue v. Rodd Electrotype Co. 769, 774, 779 Donnell V. State 311 Doty V. Ford Motor Co. 839 E- Eckles V. Consolidated Rail Corp. 1045 Egan V. Burkhart 1270 Eldon Indus., Inc. v. Vanier Mfg., Inc. 512 Elrod V. Burns 998 Encyclopaedia Brittanica, Inc. v. State Bd. of Tax Comm'rs 1 309 1996] INDEX XI Erie Ins. Co. v. George 1 196 Erie Ins. Group v. Alliance Envtl., Inc. Estate of Cole v. Fromm Estate of Meyer v. Meyer Evans v. Schenk Cattle Co. Evans v. Yankeetown Dock Corp. Ex parte France Ex parte Sweeney -F- Falkenburgh v. Jones Farrington v. Allsop Faulkner v. Markkay, Inc. Fein v. Permanente Med. Group Fifer v. Soretore-Dodds Firefighters Local Union No. 1784 V. Stotts First Source Bank v. First Resource Fed'l Credit Union Fleck V. Hann Fleischmann v. Wausau Bus. Ins. Co. 1396 Folsom V. Marsh 609 Foreman v. State 1016 44 Liquormart, Inc. v. Rhode Island 994 Foshee v. Shoney's, Inc. 1391 Freeman V. Robinson 312,314 Freeman v . State 1010 Freightliner Corp. v. Myrick 828,841 Fresh Cut, Inc. v. Fazli 959 Fritsch v. ICC 729 Frye v. Trustees of Rumbletown Free Methodist Church 1331 FTC V. Compagnie De Saint- Gobain-Pont-A-Mousson 1108 FTC V. Freeman Hosp. 1 157 Fullilove V. Klutznick 53 1 , 539 Furman v. Georgia 32, 800 G- 1204 Garret v. Ford Motor Co. 840 985 G.B. Lewis Co. v. Gould 1282 Prods., Inc. 512 1330 General Accident Ins. Co. \r Gonzales 1194 1390 Gideon v. Wainwright 922 214 Gilpin v. Gilpin 1090 211 Gleason v. Bush 1139 Gnerlich v. Gnerlich 1075 Gonzalez v. Clinton 1394 Gorham Co. v. White 510, 515, 517 403 Gorka v. Sullivan 1277 1353 Graham Farms, Inc. v. IPL 1289 1064 Graves v. State 310,315 Greco v. Ford Motor Co. 1233, 1250 596 Greencastle Twp. v. Black 404 1123 Greer v. State 1049 Gregg V. Georgia 32-33, 800 540 Griswold v. Connecticut 30, 704, 714 Grody v. State 12 1109 Gross V. Gross 1073 1274 Grund v. State 1066 H- H.B. Zachry Co. v. NLRB 449 Haas V. Chater 993 Hacker v. Hacker 1084 Hale v. Kemp 1405 Hammond v. Clayton 1 105 Hancock v. Indiana Sch. for the Blind 1401 Hanlester Network v. Shalala 1 144 Hanson v. Von Duprin 1392 Hardsaw V. Courtney 1345 Harper & Row Pubs., Inc. v. Nation Enter. 63 1 Hart V. Steel Prods., Inc. 1352 Hastins Mut. Ins. Co. v. Webb 1201 Hayworth v. Schilli Leasing, Inc. 1246 Xll INDIANA LAW REVIEW [Vol. 30 HCC Credit Corp. v. Springs Valley Bank & Trust Co. 1 384 Heck V. Robey 1324 Hefty V. All Other Members of the Certified Settlement Class 742,1128 Helm V. Resolution Trust Corp. 1118 Helms V. Am. Sec. Co. 410-11 Hendricks County Bd. of Zoning Appeals V. Barlow 1288 Heoneger v. Lomas 417 Hicks V. State 819 Hill V. Rieth-Riley Constr. Co. 1230, 1317 Hill V. Gateway 2000, Inc. 1370 Hoffman v. United States 597 Hooks V. State 972 Hopwood V. Texas 525, 545 Hosts, Inc. V. Wells 424 Hottinger v. Trugreen Corp. 1062, 1241 Howell V. Indiana-American Water Co. 1288 Hughes V. Glaese 1355 Humbert v. Smith 1094 Hupp V. Canal Ins. Co. 1 199 Hurd V. Monsanto Co. 1392 Hurley v. Eddingfield 267-69, 278 -I- IDS Property Cas. Ins. Co. v. Kalberer 1200 IHSAA V. Cariberg 968 IHSAA V. Avant 968 IHSAA V. Reyes 967 In re Anonymous 1256, 1261, 1406 /n re Baby K 1153-54 In re Carletti 507 //I re Carousel Intern' 1 Corp. 949 //ireC.D.T. 1013 M re Clark 308,315 /nreComstock 1260 /« re Duke 951 In re Fletcher 1258 In re Garbo 507 In re Horine 1256 In re Kelly 1254 In re Koehring 515 In re Koors 1209 In re Lawrance 267, 272, 274 In re Marriage of Coyle 1081 In re Marriage of Lang 1092 In re Marriage of M.E. 474 In re Marriage of Tearman 1091 In re Marriage of Vucic 554 In re Midway Airlines, Inc. 950 In re Myers 1260 In re Nathurst 1109 In re P.L.M. 1093 In re Rimsat, Ltd. 952 In re Shur 1108 In re Tolona Pizza 950 In re Train Collision at Gary 976 In re Vicars Ins. Agency, Inc. 952 In re Webb 516 In re Weybright 1252 Indiana Gaming Conmi'n v. Moseley 975 Indiana Hi-Rail Corp. v. State Bd. of Tax Comm'rs 1311 Indiana Farm Gas Prods. Co. v. Southern Ind. Gas & Elec. Co. 1283 Indiana Ins. Co. v. North Vermillion Conamunity Sch. Corp. 1206 Interman v. Baker 1133 Intermatic Inc. v. Toeppen 1215 International Paper Co. v. Ouellette 839 -J- J Bar H, Inc. v. Johnson 764, 776 Jackson v. Indiana 1 2 Jackson v. State 25, 1020 Jefferson v. Ambroz 997 Jendreas v. Jendreas 1075 J.I. Chase Credit Corp. v. First Nat'l Bank of Madison County 1385 JKB, Sr. V. Armour Pharm. Co. 1231 Joe V. Lebow 1087 1996] INDEX xiu Johnson v. General Motors Corp. 840 Johnson v. St. Vincent Hosp., Inc. 265 Johnson v. State 1012, 1015 1028, 1057 Johnson v. University of Wisconsin-Equ Claire 996 Jones V. City of Gary 98 1 Jones V. State Bd. of Med. 600 Jones-Bey v. Wright 1 1 09 Judy V. State 33, 1168 Justus V. Justus 1073 Keilbach v. McCullough Keith V. Van Hoy, Inc. Kerlin v. State Kevorkian v. Amett Kimble v. State 1271 1334 11,20 1152 1054 Kohler v. Leslie Hindman, Inc. 1 107 Kohlman v. Indiana Univ. 1399 Kottlowski V. Bridgestone/Firestone, Inc. 1280 Kovenock v. Mallus 1093 Koziol V. Vojvoda 1061 Krouse v. Krouse 421 K.S.V.R.S. 467,469,471-79, 481-85, 1095-96 K.T.H. V. M.K.B. 1096 -L- Lake County Trust Co. v. Lane 737 Lalli V. Lalli 993 Lane v. Brown 424 Langdon v. Applegate 403 Lannan v. State 11,20 Lashbrook v. Oerkfitz 978-79, 996 Lasselle v. State 305,317 Lay V. State 1056 Lechmere, Inc. v. NLRB 459 Lee V. Dayton-Hudson Corp. 508 Lee V. Weisman 1002 Leisure v. Leisure 1075 Lemon v. Kurtzman 1003 Leon V. Caterpillar Indus., Inc. 1237 Leslie v. State 1068 Lewis V. State 12 L.K.I. Holdings, Inc. v. Tyner 1328, 1340 Liberty Mut. Ins. Co. v. Connecticut Indem. Co. 1 195 Lim V. White 1208 Lincoln Utils., Inc. v. Office of Util. Consumer Counselor 1277 Linville v. Hoosier Trim Products 1410 Lochner v. New York 696 Logansport State Hosp. v. W.S. 977 Lucas V. South Carolina Coastal Council 758 Lucas V. United States 601 -M- MacDonald v. Maxwell Maddry v. NBD Bank Marshall v. Reeves Martin v. Richey Martinez Chavez v. State 1356 1104 1172 971 1029 Maxon v. Tyler Pipe Indus. 1362 McClain v. State 1064, 1070 Mclntyre v. Baker 1275 McQuade v. Draw Tite, Inc. 1401 Mead Data Cent., Inc. v. Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc. 1219 Medical Dev. Network Inc. v. Professional Resp. Care/Home Med. Equip Servs., Inc. 1 145 Medley v.Frey 1192 Meridian Mutual Ins. Co. v. Auto- Owners Ins. Co. 1 193 Meridian Mutual Ins. Co. v. Harter 1121 Metro Broad., Inc. v. FCC 525-26,531 Meyer v. Biedron 1 175 Meyer v. Robinson 1117 Meyers v. Furrow Bldg. Materials 1234 XIV INDIANA LAW REVIEW [Vol. 30 Michael H. v. Gerald D. Mid-West Fed' ISavs. Bank v. Kerlin Miller v. Johnson Miller v. Schoene Minnesota v. Dickerson Minton v. Sackett Missouri v. Jenkins 467 1287 541,544 695, 709 1012 1344 543 Mitchell V. Collagen Corp. 1244 Mitchell V. State 979, 985 Modesitt V. State 12, 18 Moll V. South Cent. Solar Sys., Inc. 954 Moran v. State 966 Morton V. Merrillville Toyota, Inc. 412 Motorists Mut. Ins. Co. v. Morris 1202 Mukhtar v. Castleton Serv. Corp. 1161 Murzyn v. Amoco Co. Metro. 1208 Myrick v. Freuhauf Corp. 843 -N- National Ass'n of Miniature Enthusiasts v. State Bd. of TaxComm'rs 1315 National Bellas Hess, Inc. v. Department of Revenue 884 National Eng'g & Contracting Co. V. C&P Eng*g & Mfg. Co. 1124 National Steel Erection v. Hinkle 1335 Nelson v. Parker 1272 Nill V. Martin 1090 NLRB V. Elias Bros. Big Boy 448 NLRB V. Henlopen Mfg. Co. 449 NLRB V. Town & Country Elec, Inc. 447, 456 Nobles V. Cartwright 1348 Norco Prods., Inc. v. Mecca Dev., Inc. 516 O- Ogle V. Barker 1272 O'Hare Truck Serv. v. City of Northlake 1001 Oklahoma Tax Comm'n v. Jefferson Lines, Inc. 904 Ooms V. USX Corp. 1332 Orr V. Westminster Village North, Inc. 1041 Orvis Co. V. Tax Appeals Tribunal 883 Owen V. Kroger Co. 1 105, 1 1 1 3 -P- Pacific & Southern Co. v. Duncan 634 Pacific Employer's Ins. Co. v. Austgen's Elec, Inc. 1321 Panaras v. Liquid Carbonic Indus. Corp. 1100 Parke State Bank v. Akers 1281 Parker V. State 1011 Paternity of S.R.I. 474 Patterson V. State 11, 18 Payne v. State 1050 Payne v. Tennessee 795, 817 Pena v. Mattox 985 People V. Raley 804 Person v. State 969, 1024 Petroski v. Northern Ind. Pub. Serv. Co. 1228 Pfenninger v. Pfenninger 1086 Phelps Dodge Corp. v. NLRB 447 Piatt v.Eads 419 Piatt V. State 993 Plumlee v. Monroe Guar. Ins. Co. 1211 Podberesky v. Kirwan 548 Polly (a woman of colour) v. Lasselle 305 Poorev. State 1021 Posadas de Puerto Rico Assocs. v. Tourism Co. of Puerto Rico 995 Power Controls Corp. v. Hybrinetics 508 Prenatt v. Stevens 1077 1996] INDEX XV Preseault v. ICC 729, 757 Price V. State 971 Prigg V. Pennsylvania 310 Princeton Univ. Press v. Michigan Document Servs. 633 Pro-Eco, Inc. v. Board of Comm'rs 984-85 ProCD, Inc. v. Zeidenberg 1364 Proffitt V. Proffitt 473 Protective Ins. Co. v. Cody 141 1 -Q- Quackenbush Ins. Co. v. Allstate 1104 Quill Corp. V. North Dakota 883 Quill V. Vacco 987 Quillen v. Quillen 1078, 1083 Quinton v. Edison Park Dev. Corp. 665 -R- Raberv. State 1018 Raintree Friends Housing, Inc. v. Indiana Dep't of State Revenue 1313 Rayford v. Lumberman's Mut. Cas. Co. 1396 R.D.S. V. S.L.S. 473,481 Reboy v. Cozzi Iron & Metal 1402 Reese v. Reese 1076, 1078-79 Regents of the Univ. of Cal. V. Bakke 524-25, 528, 546 Reiddle v. Buckner 127 1 Reilly v. Daly 980 Reilly v. Robinson 12 Reinking v. Metropolitan Bd. of Zoning Appeals 1 279 Resnover v. State 34 Rexford Rand, Hagshenas v. Gaylord 781 Rexford Rand Corp. v. Ancel 764, 778 Rice V. Strunk 960 Richard S. Brunt Trust v. Plantz 737 Richmond v. J.A. Croson Co. 526 Riddle v. Newton Crane Serv., Inc. 961 Rider v. Rider 1073 Rieheman v. Cornerstone Seeds, Inc. 1408 Riley at Jackson Remonstrance Group V. State Bd. of Tax Comm'rs 1308 Ringling Bros.-Barnum & Bailey Combined Shows Inc. v. B.E. Windows Corp. 1217 Ritz V. Indiana & Ohio R.R. 737 Roark v. State 1029 Robbins v. IHSAA 969 Roberts v. Roberts 1077, 1083 Roe V. Wade 704,714 Rogers v. Ford Motor Co. 1248 Rollins Burdick Hunter, Inc. v. Board of Trustees 1210 Romack v. Public Serv. Co. 1038 Romer v. Evans 991 Rose V. Locke 29 Ross, Inc. V. Legler 739 Russell V. Russell 474, 479 Rutan V. Republican Party 998, 1002 Rynerson v. City of Franklin 981 -S- San Antonio Indep. Sch. Dist. v. Rodriguez 580 Sapp V. Morton Bldgs., Inc. 1230 Schiro V. State 1028 Scott V. Scott 1092 Sebring Homes Corp. v. T.R. Arnold & Assocs., Inc. 1 103 Seymour Mfg. Co. v. Commercial Ins. Co. 1207 Shand Mining, Inc. v. Clay County Bd. of Comm'rs 1326 Shinauh V. State 1014 Short V. Stotts 416 Short V. Stotts 418 Shots V. CSX Transp., Inc. 1 106 Shrock V. United States 1117 Sidel V. Majors 603 Sills V. Irelan 1089 Sloan V. Metro Health Council 1 133 Smith V. Atlantic Props., Inc. 772 XVI INDIANA LAW REVIEW [Vol. 30 Smith V. Ford Motor Co. 1 233 Smith V. Midland Brake, Inc. 1 108 Smith V.Moody 31-17 Smith V. Schulte 600 Sneed v. Associated Group Ins. 1181,1400 Sony Corp. of Amer. v. Universal City Studios, Inc. 630 South Carolina v. Gathers 797 Southern Burlington County NAACP V. Township of Mount Laurel 666 Southern Pac. Co. v. Bogert 773 Spears v. Blackwell 1333 St. Mary's Med. Ctr. v. Warrick County 1 145 Staggs v. Chrysler Corp. 839 Starzenski v. City of Elkhart 1 279 State V. Atwood 806 State V. Basile 819 State V. Clark 583 State V.Eaton 1342 State V. Gentry 813 State V. Metz 804 State V. Muhammad 823 State V. Swift 392, 405 State V. Tucker 819 State ex rel. ANR Pipeline Co. v. Indiana Dep't of State Revenue 1307 State ex rel. Rondon v. Lake Superior Court 12 State ex rel. Shortridge v. Court of Appeals 226 State ex rel. Whitehead v. Madison County Circuit Ct. 12 Steward V. State 1061 Stewart v. Abend 632 Storm, Inc. v. Indiana Dep't of State Revenue 1306 Strodtman v. Integrity Builders 1285 Stultz V. Stultz 1092 Stump V. Commercial Union 1394-95 Sturrup V. Mahan 968 Superior Steel Sys., Inc. v. Nature's Nuggets, Inc. 963 Sword V. NKC Hosps., Inc. 1 131 T- Tacket v. General Motors Corp. 1390 Tanford v. Brand 1003 Teegarden v. Teegarden 1090 Templeton v. City of Hammond 1127 Terry V.Ohio 1011,1016 Thiele v. Norfolk & W. Ry.Co. 1327 Thomas v. State 1070 Thomas v. Review Bd. of Ind. Emp. Sec. Div. 12, 28 Tompkins v. State 1052 Town of Highland v. Zerkel 1 34 1 Town of St. John v. State Bd. ofTaxComm'rs 974 Township of River Vale v. Town of Orangetown 667 Transamerica Ins. Servs. v. Kopko 1207 Tri-Prof 1 Realty v. Hillenburg 1270 Trimble Prods., Inc. v. W.T. Grant Co. 511 Trojnar v. Trojnar 1 123 Tucker v. Nike, Inc. 1111 Twin Peaks Prods., Inc. v. Publications Intern' 1, Ltd. 633 TXO Prod. Corp. v. Alliance Resources Corp. 982 -U- UACC Midwest, Inc. v. Indiana Dep' t of State Revenue 1 304 Ultrasystems Western Constructors, Inc. V. NLRB 450 Union Auto. Indem. Ass'n v. Shields 1198 United Capitol Ins. Co. v. Special Trucks, Inc. 1205 United Farm Bureau Mut. Ins. Co. v. Blossom Chevrolet 1357 United Farm Bureau Mut. Ins. Co. v. Owen 1203 1996] INDEX xvu United Services Auto. Ass'n v. Caplin 1206 United States v. Byrum 773 United States v. Greber 1 144 United States v. Mercy Health Servs. 1157 United States v. Neufeld 1 144 United States v. Paradise 540 United States v. Virginia 990 United States Dep't of Agric. v. Moreno 873 United Steelworkers v. Weber 539 Utley V. Healy 1329 -V- Vacco V. Quill 988 Van Schoyck v. Van Schoyck 1088 Vega V. State 1062 Verhaar v. Consumers Power Co. 1402 Victor V. Nebraska 1032 Village of Barrington Hills v. Village of Hoffman Estates Voigt V. Voigt Vonnegut v. State Bd. of Tax Comm'rs Vore V. McFarland W- W & W Equip. Co. v. Mink 954-56 Walker v. State 1014, 1026 Wallace v. Benware 998 Walsh V. McCain Foods Ltd. 1107, 1110 Warren v. Indiana Telephone Co. 215 Warth V. Seldin 662 Warzon v. Drew 997-98 Washington v. Glucksberg 987 Waukesha Foundry, Inc. v. Industrial Eng'g Inc. 1362 Webster v. Reproductive Health Servs. 701 Weida v. Dowden 1337 Weiser v. Godby Bros., Inc. 1042 Wells V. Hickman 1339 White V. White 1085 Whittington v. State Williams v. State Williams & Wilkins Co. v. United States Williamson County Reg'l Planning Comm'n v. Hamilton Bank Willmar Elec. Serv., Inc. v NLRB Willoughby v. State Wilson V. Pleasant Wilson Fertilizer & Grain, ADM Milling Co. Winegeart v. State Wior V. Anchor Indus., Inc. Wolvos V. Meyer Woodward v. State Wright v. Pennamped Wygant v. Jackson Bd. of Educ. 972 1023, 1057 611,617-18 1277 450 1068 1242 1359 1031 Inc. V. 1038, 1043 1283 315 1354 540 664 -X- 1085 -Y- 1312 1091 Y.A, V. Bayh 976 Yin V. Society Nat'l Bank Ind. 1373 -z-