








key: cord-002257-30s14h9j
authors: Ratnamohan, Vigneswary M.; Zeng, Frank; Donovan, Linda; MacIntyre, Chandini R.; Kok, Jen; Dwyer, Dominic E.
title: Phylogenetic analysis of human rhinoviruses collected over four successive years in Sydney, Australia
date: 2016-08-09
journal: Influenza Other Respir Viruses
DOI: 10.1111/irv.12404
sha: 
doc_id: 2257
cord_uid: 30s14h9j

BACKGROUND: Human rhinoviruses (HRV) cause a wide spectrum of disease, ranging from a mild influenza‐like illness (ILI) to severe respiratory infection. Molecular epidemiological data are limited for HRV circulating in the Southern Hemisphere. OBJECTIVES: To identify the species and genotypes of HRV from clinical samples collected in Sydney, Australia, from 2006 to 2009. METHODS: Combined nose and throat swabs or nasopharyngeal aspirates collected from individuals with ILI were tested for HRV using real‐time reverse‐transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT‐PCR). Sequencing data of 5′UTR and VP4/VP2 coding regions on RT‐PCR‐positive specimens were analysed. RESULTS: Human rhinoviruses were detected by real‐time PCR in 20.9% (116/555) of samples tested. Phylogenetic analysis of 5′UTR and VP4/VP2 on HRV‐positive samples was concordant in the grouping of HRV A and B species but not HRV C species. Eighty per cent (16/20) of sequences that grouped as HRV C in the VP4/VP2 tree clustered as HRV A, alongside some previously described C strains as subspecies C/A. Discordant branching was seen within HRV A group: two sequences clustering as A in the VP4/VP2 tree branched within the C/A subspecies in the 5′UTR tree, and one sequence showed identity to different HRV A strains in the two genes. The prevalence of HRV C and C/A species was greater in paediatric compared to adult patients (47.9% vs 25.5%, P = .032). CONCLUSION: Human rhinoviruses are a common cause of respiratory infections, and HRV C is present in the Southern Hemisphere. Sequencing of multiple HRV regions may be necessary to determine exact phylogenetic relationships.

Human rhinoviruses (HRV) are a diverse virus group, currently known to contain 167 serotypes. 1 Along with human enteroviruses (HEV), HRV belong to the Picornaviridae family, 2 although they are phylo genetically unrelated to HEV despite similarities in genome organization and structure. Human rhinoviruses are generally associated with the common cold and mild upper respiratory infections, 3 but can also cause severe respiratory infections in immunocompromised hosts (including lung and hematopoietic stem cell transplant recipients) or patients with chronic pulmonary diseases. [4] [5] [6] [7] Unlike respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) and influenza viruses, HRV can cause respiratory illness throughout the year, but peak incidence occurs in early autumn and spring in temperate climates. 6 Early molecular analyses of the HRV capsid protein coding regions clustered different serotypes into two distinct species, HRV A and HRV B. 8 In 2007, a new HRV genetic variant (subsequently designated HRV C) was identified in patients with severe pneumonia from the United States of America (USA), Germany, Hong Kong, Australia and China. [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] Severe respiratory disease and asthma exacerbations in children were observed. 11, 14 HRV C has been further divided into two subspecies, HRV Cc and HRV Ca. 15 HRV C strains are difficult to grow in cell lines known to support the growth of other rhinoviruses, 11 although two HRV C isolates have been propagated in nasal epithelial cell cultures. 16 There are limited molecular epidemiological data on HRV circulating in the Southern Hemisphere, including Australia. This study aimed to identify the species and genotypes of HRV from clinical samples collected in Sydney, Australia, over four consecutive years by analysing the nucleotide homology in the 5′UTR, VP4 and part of the VP2 capsid protein coding regions. 

Primers used to amplify all picornaviruses, 18 the HRV-specific probes 5′UTR and VP4-VP2 gene sequencing primers are listed in Table 1 .

The RT-PCR probe sequences were designed to include most HRV sequences available in GenBank ® in 2007, and sequences generated from the present study.

RNA was prepared directly from combined NTS or NPA using Roche High Pure RNA kits (Roche, Mannheim, Germany).

The cDNA was reverse-transcribed from 10 μL of specimen RNA using 100 units of SuperScript III reverse transcriptase (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, USA) and 4 μL used for real-time PCR as described previously. 19 Amplification was performed in glass capillaries on 

Human rhinoviruses RT-PCR-positive samples were then tested using UTR primers EV140 and EV170 to amplify a 395-bp product. 20 Where RNA was available, samples were amplified with primers RHI3A and EVP4R, generating a 638-bp fragment that included part of 5′UTR, all of VP4 and part of VP2 regions. 18 

CS07-7-A24 A A A CS09-5-A24 A A A CS09-22-A24 A A A CS09-3-A33 A A A CS09-12-A33 A A A •CS09-2-A67 A branches with HRV89 A- A MS07-20-A57 A A A MS07-21-A57 A A A CS09-6-A21 A A A CS09-17-A21 A A A CS09-21-A21 A A A MS06-4-A61 A A A MS06-6-A61 A A A CS09-15-A41 A A A MS08-8-A55 A A A CS09-11-A58 A A A CS09-26-A58 A A A MS06-2-A89 A A A CS09-28-A8 A A A CS07-9-1B A A A CS07-12-1B A A A CS07-13-1B A A A CS07-14-1B A A A CS07-18-1B A A A MS08-6-A43 A A A CS09-4-A43 A A A MS07-16-A31 A A A CS09-13-A31 A A A CS09-20-A47 A A A CS07-24-A56 A A A CS09-23-A98 A A A MS08-2-A15 A A A MS08-3-A15 A A A CS07-6-A15 A A A CS09-27-A15 A A A CS07-4-A22 A A A CS09-1-A23 A A A CS09-8-A23 A A A (Continues)

Using BLAST ® , nearly all the sequences showed >98% similarity to one or more HRV sequences with partial cds available in GenBank ® .

These were approximately 390-420 bp and did not cover the full sequence from 5′UTR to VP2 of our study samples, and were not included in the construction of the ML tree.

As the data size was large, it was not possible to include each one of the HRV prototype sequences in the tree construction. Figure 1 shows the ML tree for the 5′UTR for all 93 sequences, and Figs 2 and 3 show the ML trees, respectively, of VP4/VP2 and 5′UTR/VP4/VP2 regions of the 65 samples. in group C with VP4/VP2 analysis also clustered in group C in the 5′UTR along with reference strain C-EU840728; 16 of the 20 HRV C samples grouped as HRV A, along with reference strains C-X2-EF077280, C-EU840952, C-DQ875932, C-JQ994498, C-EF077279, C-EF582387 and C-GQ223227. Four clades that grouped as C species in the VP4/VP2 analysis segregated into the A genogroup in the 5′UTR analysis (Figs 1 and 2) .

Discordant branching was seen in the following and indicated by a circle Figure 1 ). Samples with asterisk (*) denote strains that grouped as C in the VP4/VP2 region, but grouped with HRV A species. Samples with only 5′UTR sequences are denoted by ^. Discordant branches in the VP4/VP2 and 5′UTR sequences are indicated by • Sample MS06-3 and HRV A12 (EF173415) clustered in a clade more related to C-DQ875932 (subspecies Ca). The two samples showed between 80% and 82% ID to C-DQ875932 strain and samples in that cluster and similar identity to A15 and its cluster in the UTR tree, but in the VP4/VP2 tree the two samples showed 61% identity to C-DQ875932 and lower to other C strains and 62% and 80% identity to A 15 and 1B, respectively.

Maximum-likelihood tree of the 5′UTR/VP4/VP2 region, showing relationships of clinical strains, newly described strains and prototype strains of HRV (constructed as described for Fig. 1 ). Samples with asterisk (*) denote strains that grouped as C in the VP4/VP2 region, but grouped with HRV A species in 5′UTR analysis. Discordant branches in the VP4/VP2 and 5′UTR sequences are indicated by • 

The 65 sample sequences segregated into three phylogenetically distinct species: 44 (67.7%) HRV A, 20 (30.8%) HRV C and one (1.5%) HRV B. Several clades were represented within HRV A and C (Fig. 2) .

Within HRV A, identity at > 86% was seen with known HRV reference strains as shown in Table 2 

The grouping of samples as C and CA in the 5′UTR/VP4/VP2 analysis was very similar to that seen in the 5′UTR analysis. The discordant branching pattern seen with samples MS06-3 and HRV A12

(EF173415), MS07-18 and MS08-7 and CS09-2 (indicated with •) in the 5′UTR ML tree was not seen; it was in agreement with that seen in the VP4/VP2 ML tree.

In The distribution of the different HRV subtypes is shown in Table 3 .

Both HRV A and C or C/A variant were detected in higher numbers than HRV B. Human rhinoviruses C or C/A variant was detected more In our study, the sequences grouped into three phylogenetically distinct species: A (52.6%), C/CA (37.6%) and B (9.6%). However, there was discordance between proposed phylogeny groups when sequences from the 5′UTR and VP4/VP2 coding regions were analysed. Sixteen of the 20 samples that clustered as HRV C in the VP4/ VP2 ML tree segregated as A in the 5′UTR analysis, as did some of the early, well-characterized HRV C strains from New York (EU840952 and DQ875932), 23, 26 San Francisco (EF077279 and EF077280), 25 Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (EF582387) 11 and China (GQ223227). 15 Twelve of 28 sequences with only UTR sequences also segregated along with the above-mentioned reference C strains, branching in two major subgroups within HRV A. These have been labelled in this study as C/A, clustering with C strains, but grouping as A in the 5′UTR region: these formed 30% of the clinical sequences. Huang et al. 15 reported similar clustering of field strains in their study and designated the above C strains (EU840952, DQ875932, EF077279, EF077280, GQ223227 and EF582387) as Ca, a subspecies of HRV C that clustered differently to HRV A, HRV B and HRV C in the UTR. They further showed that HRV Ca subspecies were formed from interspecies recombination in the 5′UTR region. Similar inconsistent clustering of field strains as compared to VP4/VP2 was also reported in the 3D polymerase-coding region as well as 5′UTR region. 30 Three discordant branching events were seen in our analyses. MS07-18

(identity to A65) in one branch and MS06-3 along with HRV A12 in another branch segregated as A in the VP4/VP2 analysis, but localized within the Ca subspecies in the 5′UTR analysis. Sample CS09-2 clustered with HRV A89 with 96% relatedness in the UTR region but differed in the VP4/VP2 region. These three samples may represent recombinants as reported by Palmenberg et al. and Kim et al. 31, 32 There is no designated region within the HRV genome that is 26, 34 The clustering of HRV C as C and C/A when 5′UTR region was included in the analysis (Figs 1 and 3 ) in our study may suggest that they are true C species that showed recombination with A in the 5′UTR.

In this study, the 5′UTR primers and the primers chosen to amplify the entire VP4 and partial VP2 region produced amplicons with overlapping sequences that resulted in an approximately 900bp continuous sequence. We used a single set of primers for each of the two PCR assays but did not use cloning, which has been used in other studies. 24 were collected from patients with respiratory illness who were sick enough to warrant testing or in many cases hospitalization, but our data are insufficient to attribute clinical severity to any of the HRV

It is possible that HRV C or the C/A variants may cause exacerbation of respiratory infections in infants that require presentation to ED compared to HRV A or B, and this may contribute to the higher percentage of HRV C or C/A infection in the paediatric population. One of the early reports of HRV C-QPM variant severity was from Australian samples collected in 2003 from children with lower respiratory infection. 37 Other reports have observed the association between HRV C variants and asthmatic wheeze and severe lower respiratory infections. 10, 11, 23, 27, 38 Xiang et al. 35 reported that the clinical manifestations of HRV A and C are similar, and co-infection with RSV and HRV in infants increases the severity of infection. Both

HRV A and C are more virulent than HRV B in infants and HRV virulence is greater in winter, although peak infection rates occur in spring and fall. 9

In conclusion, the present study shows that sequencing of one region alone is insufficient for determining the lineage of the HRV variants. The presence of many diverse strains has become apparent, and it is likely that more will emerge.

Genotypic assignment and identification of HRV types will facilitate monitoring of emerging novel variants, and investigations into type-associated differences in disease epidemiology, transmission and outcomes.

Samples used in this study were not collected for this study per se, but as part of a study assessing the use of face mask in controlling respiratory virus transmission in households following approval by the local institutional review board or for laboratory diagnosis of patients with an influenza-like illness. The present study does not involve the reporting of patient data, and no patient intervention occurred with the obtained results.

Virus Taxonomy: Classification and Nomenclature of Viruses: Ninth Report of the International Committee on Taxonomy of Viruses

A collaborative report: rhinoviruses-extension of the numbering system from 89 to 100

Viruses and bacteria in the etiology of the common cold

Rhinovirus infections in hematopoietic stem cell transplant recipients with pneumonia

Detection of human rhinoviruses in the lower respiratory tract of lung transplant recipients

Human rhinoviruses

Human rhinovirus C in adult hematopoietic stem cell transplant recipients with respiratory illness

Genetic clustering of all 102 human rhinovirus prototype strains: serotype 87 is close to human enterovirus 70

Human rhinovirus species and season of infection determine illness severity

A recently identified rhinovirus genotype is associated with severe respiratory-tract infection in children in Germany

Clinical features and complete genome characterization of a distinct human rhinovirus (HRV) genetic cluster, probably representing a previously undetected HRV species, HRV-C, associated with acute respiratory illness in children

Distinguishing molecular features and clinical characteristics of a putative new rhinovirus species, human rhinovirus C (HRV C)

Human rhinovirus group C infection in children with lower respiratory tract infection

Assay for 5′ noncoding region analysis of all human rhinovirus prototype strains

Evidence of recombination and genetic diversity in human rhinoviruses in children with acute respiratory infection

Molecular modeling, organ culture and reverse genetics for a newly identified human rhinovirus C

Face mask use and control of respiratory virus transmission in households

Detection of human picornaviruses by multiplex reverse transcription-PCR and liquid hybridization

Pandemic clinical case definitions are non-specific: multiple respiratory viruses circulating in the early phases of the 2009 influenza pandemic in New South Wales

Enterovirus 68 is associated with respiratory illness and shares biological features with both the enteroviruses and the rhinoviruses

Detection and differentiation of picornaviruses in clinical samples following genomic amplification

A simple, fast, and accurate algorithm to estimate large phylogenies by maximum likelihood

MassTag polymerase-chainreaction detection of respiratory pathogens, including a new rhinovirus genotype, that caused influenza-like illness in New York State during

A diverse group of previously unrecognized human rhinoviruses are common causes of respiratory illnesses in infants

Pan-viral screening of respiratory tract infections in adults with and without asthma reveals unexpected human coronavirus and human rhinovirus diversity

New respiratory enterovirus and recombinant rhinoviruses among circulating picornaviruses

Human rhinovirus C: age, season, and lower respiratory illness over the past 3 decades

Proposals for the classification of human rhinovirus species A, B and C into genotypically assigned types

Analysis of complete genome sequences of human rhinovirus

Molecular characterization of human rhinovirus field strains isolated during surveillance of enteroviruses

Sequencing and analyses of all known human rhinovirus genomes reveal structure and evolution

Identification of recombinant human rhinovirus A and C in circulating strains from upper and lower respiratory infections

Clinical and molecular features of human rhinovirus C

Analysis of genetic diversity and sites of recombination in human rhinovirus species C

Human rhinovirus C infections mirror those of human rhinovirus A in children with community-acquired pneumonia

Phylogenetic analysis of rhinovirus isolates collected during successive epidemic seasons

Molecular characterization and distinguishing features of a novel human rhinovirus (HRV) C, HRVC-QCE, detected in children with fever, cough and wheeze during

A novel group of rhinoviruses is associated with asthma hospitalizations

We thank Ms. Gordana Nedeljkovic for compiling patient information from the laboratory information system network. Funding: None.Competing intesrests: None declared.

VMR participated in the study design, analysed the results and drafted the manuscript. FZ and LD performed nucleic acid testing. CRM was the chief investigator of the study on the use of face masks to reduce household transmission of respiratory viruses. JK had input in the preparation and editing of the manuscript. DED participated in the design of the study and was involved in manuscript editing. All authors have read and accepted the manuscript. 

Additional Supporting Information may be found online in the supporting information tab for this article.

