Omar Final.doc J Bagh College Dentistry Vol. 26(2), June 2014 The benefit of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery and Periodontics 122 The benefit of Ramfjord teeth to represent the full-mouth clinical attachment level in epidemiological study Omar Husham Ali, B.D.S., M.Sc. (1) Hadeel Mazin, B.D.S., M.Sc. (1) ABSTRACT Background: Since the periodontal disease Index of Ramfjord (Ramfjord index) can potentially shorten the examination time by almost half, many studies evaluated Ramfjord teeth in predicting full-mouth periodontal status of an adult population. The aim of this study was to evaluate the benefit of Ramfjord teeth in predicting the full- mouth clinical attachment level of an adult population in patients attending the college of dentistry- Baghdad University. Materials and methods: The study participants were 100 patients with age range from 30-60 years old which represent group zero. The patients were divided into three main groups according to the age of the patients. Group I and group II each of them composed of 30 patients while group III composed of 40 patients. In the first time clinical attachment level (CAL) was measured from the full mouth (FM) and then from the Ramfjord teeth (RT) (teeth number: 16, 21, 24, 36, 41, 44) in all groups. Clinical attachment level (CAL) was measured in millimeters using periodontal probe. Results: The difference in the mean clinical attachment level measured from the full mouth (FM) and Ramfjord teeth (RT) by using paired t - test was non significant in all the groups. Also in all groups the correlation coefficient as well as beta coefficient was high. Conclusion: The high agreement between Ramfjord teeth and full mouth CAL confirm the epidemiological validity of Ramfjord teeth to represent the full mouth. Key words: Ramfjord teeth, Clinical attachment level, full-mouth examination. (J Bagh Coll Dentistry 2014; 26(2): 122- 124). الخالصة .لثة لكامل الفم في السكان البالغینمفورد المراض اللثة یمكن ان یقلل وقت الفحص الى النصف تقریبا، لذا الكثیر من الدراسات قیمت اسنان رامفورد في توقع الحالة الصحیة لمؤشر را .جامعة بغداد -الغیین من المرضى الذین یراجعون كلیة طب االسنانھدف ھذه الدراسة كان لتقییم اسنان رامفورد في توقع مستوى االنسجة الرابطة لكامل الفم لدى السكان الب . تم تقسیم المشاركین في ھذه الدراسة الى ثالث مجموعات رئیسیة وفقا للعمر. سنة ویمثلون مجموعة الصفر 60-30المشاركین في ھذه الدراسة كانوا مائة مریض، تتراوح اعمارھم من .مشارك 40مشارك بینما المجموعة الرابعة تتكون من 30منھما من المجموعة االولى والثانیة تتكون كل في كل ) 16،21،24،36،41،44: اسنان رامفورد( (RF)ومن ثم قیاس مستوى االنسجة الرابطة السنان رامفورد (FM)تم اوال قیاس مستوى االنسجة الرابطة لجمیع االسنان في الفم .طة باستخدام مسبار اللثةتم قیاس مستوى االنسجة الراب. المجموعات كان غیر مھم في كل المجموعات، قیاسات معامل t باختبار (RF)ومستوى االنسجة الرابطة السنان رامفورد (FM)الفرق بین معدل مستوى االنسجة الرابطة المقاس لكامل الفم .االرتباط ومعامل بیتا في كل المجموعات كانت عالیة ولكامل الفم یؤكد صحة استخدام اسنان رامفورد لتمثیل كامل الفم في الدراسات الوبائیة وى االنسجة الرابطة السنان رامفوردالموافقة العالیة بین مست INTRODUCTION Most survey methods use full-mouth assessment of periodontal diseases, which involves the examination of 4 sites on all present teeth. Data from full-mouth examination are the gold standard for accurate assessment of periodontal disease. However, because of the restraints in time, logistic, and cost of full-mouth assessment, this clinical assessment of periodontal diseases is impractical in epidemiological surveys involving large population samples (1). Therefore, the programs to examine part of teeth are proposed (2). Since the Ramfjord index can potentially shorten the examination time by almost half, Mumghamba et al evaluated Ramfjord teeth in predicting full-mouth periodontal status of an adult population (3). Partial recording of Indices of periodontitis have long been used in clinical and epidemiological studies to predict full-mouth situation (4). (1)Assistant lecturer, Department of Periodontics, College of Dentistry, University of Baghdad Ramfjord index had a strong correlation with the full-mouth index in recording plaque, gingivitis, and other periodontal indicators like the probing pocket depth but due to the site-specificity of periodontal diseases, a part of the teeth does not fully reflect the status of full-mouth teeth (5). So that different index teeth be selected depending on the purpose of survey so as to not only assesses both the incidence and severity of the disease correctly, but also improve the sensitivity and reduce the bias (6). MATERIALS AND METHODS The patients participated in this study were referred to the department of Periodontics in college of dentistry Baghdad University. The patients include 100 male which represented by group (0). All the patients were suffered from chronic periodontitis which affect people mostly after the age of 30; the samples were divided into three main groups according to the age of the patients in which group (I) include 30 patients with an age range of (30-40) years, group (II) J Bagh College Dentistry Vol. 26(2), June 2014 The benefit of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery and Periodontics 123 include 30 patients with an age of (>40-50) years while group (III) include 40 patients with an age more than 50 years. Clinical attachment level (CAL) was measured in millimeters using William periodontal probe with Williams's markings from the cemento- enamel junction to the bottom of the pocket/sulcus. The measurements were made at four surfaces of each tooth. The distance was measured indirectly by subtracting the distance from the gingival margin to the cemento-enamel junction from probing pocket depth. In some cases when there was gingival recession, loss attachment was measured by adding the distance from the gingival margin to the cemento-enamel junction to the probing pocket depth. The level of the cemento-enamel junction could be determined by feeling it with probe. In some situation were the cemento-enamel junction was totally obliterated by:- 1. Full crown coverage. 2. Disto- occlusal, mesio-occlusal or MOD fillings were extended below cemento- enamel junction. 3. Badly carious tooth, were extending mesially or distally below the cemento- enamel junction. 4. Heavy calculus covers the teeth. In these situations the tooth was excluded. If the patient had a Ramfjord tooth/teeth missing, he was excluded from the study. In the first time clinical attachment level (CAL) was measured from the full mouth (FM) and then from the Ramfjord teeth (RT) in all groups. The mean CAL per tooth was calculated by summing the measurements per tooth and dividing by the number of measurements. Mean CAL for full mouth was calculated by summing the mean CAL per tooth and dividing by the number of the teeth. While the mean CAL for Ramfjord teeth was calculated by summing the mean CAL per tooth for the Ramfjord teeth (teeth number: 16, 21, 24, 36, 41, 44) and dividing them by the number of the Ramfjord teeth, if the Ramfjord tooth was missing the case was ignored. The statistical analyses used in this study were a paired t-test to compare the difference in the mean CAL measured from the full mouth (FM) versus Ramfjord teeth (RT). In addition to that Pearson correlation coefficients between the mean CAL calculated from the full mouth measurement and from the Ramfjord teeth were conducted and then a linear regression analysis (β coefficient) with the full mouth mean CAL as the outcome variable and the Ramfjord teeth mean CAL as independent variable were conducted . RESULTS Descriptive statistics which include mean and standard deviation of CAL for each group were shown in table (1). The difference in the mean of CAL measured from the full mouth (FM) and Ramfjord teeth (RT) by using paired t-test were non significant in all the groups as shown in table (2) the p>0.05 non significant. The correlation between the mean CAL calculated from the full mouth and Ramfjord teeth was 0.75 in the 1st age group and was 0.92 in the 2nd age group, while it was 0.86 in the 3rd age group, in the all previous groups the correlation coefficient were strong (+)ve, as shown in the table (3). We then conducted a linear regression analysis with the full mouth mean CAL as the outcome variable and the Ramfjord teeth mean CAL as the independents variable in each group, the β coefficient for the mean CAL measured by Ramfjord teeth to predict the full mouth was ranged between 0.70 and 1.06, the result were positive for the all groups which mean it is a significant result, as shown in table (4). Table 1: Descriptive statistics of CAL for each group Descriptive statistics Group 0 No=100 Group I Group II Group III 30-40 40-50 >50 F.M R.T F.M R.T F.M R.T F.M R.T Mean 2.88 2.82 2.54 2.48 2.62 2.54 3.34 3.28 +SD 0.076 0.079 0.11 0.099 0.099 0.11 0.126 0.133 Table 2: t-test and significant difference of mean CAL for each group Groups t-test P-value Sig Group 0 1.81 0.073 NS Group I 0.816 0.42 NS Group II 1.789 0.084 NS Group III 0.93 0.355 NS J Bagh College Dentistry Vol. 26(2), June 2014 The benefit of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery and Periodontics 124 Table 3: Correlation Coefficient between F.M and R.T of mean CAL for each group Groups r Group 0 0.888 Group I 0.755 Group II 0.925 Group III 0.865 Table 4: Linear regression of F.M and R.T for mean CAL at each group Groups slope B Linear regression equation Group 0 0.923 y=0.154+0.924x Group I 0.701 y=0.699+0.701x Group II 1.06 y=-0.256+1.07x Group III 0.916 y=0.217+0.916x DISCUSSION The study based on CAL measurement in patients have chronic periodontitis of different age groups, the results show non significant differences between Ramfjord teeth and full mouth at different age groups using paired t- test. The other results show strong (+ve) correlation between Ramfjord teeth and full mouth at different age groups. The beta coefficient which was used to assess prediction of the full-mouth mean CAL by Ramfjord teeth mean CAL was high. The high agreement between Ramfjord teeth and full mouth mean CAL proves the epidemiological validity of Ramfjord teeth to represent the full mouth. This was disagree with Fleiss et al, who found that the Ramfjord teeth are inadequate alternatives of the rest of the mouth for epidemiologic studies of periodontitis (7), so that the assessment of Ramfjord teeth was not as suitable for evaluation of either disease extent or prevalence (2). But this study was in agreement with Mumghamba et al, Silness and Røynstrand, and Najah et al (3,5,8). They concluded that there is high agreement between Ramfjord teeth and full mouth. Partial-mouth examinations with appropriate adjustment of Ramfjord index teeth data may be useful for assessing periodontal disease progression in longitudinal population studies of human periodontitis (9). So these results support the use of Ramfjord teeth procedure to conserve time, limit cost and reduce patient and examiner fatigue, while providing maximal clinical information (2). REFERENCES 1. Kingman A, Albandar JM. Methodological aspects of epidemiological studies of periodontal diseases. Periodontol 2000; 29:11-30. 2. Dowsett SA, Eckert GJ, Kowolik MJ. The applicability of half mouth examination to periodontal disease assessment in untreated adult populations. J Periodontology 2002; 73(9): 975-81. 3. Mumghamba EG, PitiPhat W, Matee MI, Simon E, Merchant AT. The use fullness of using Ramfjord teeth in predicting periodontal status of a Tanzanian adult population. J Clin Peiodontol 2004; 31:16-8. 4. Hunt RJ. The efficiency of half mouth examination in estimating the prevalence of periodontal disease. Journal of dental research 1987; 66: 1044-8. 5. Silness J, Røynstrand T. Partial mouth recording of plaque, gingivitis and probing depth in adolescents. J Clin Periodontol 1988; 15:189-92. 6. Zhang J. Applicability of community periodontal index teeth and random half-mouth examination to gingival bleeding assessment in untreated adult population in Beijing. Chin Med Sci J 2012; 27: 41-5. 7. Fleiss JL, Park MH, Chilton NW, Alman JE, Feldman RS, Chauncey HH. Representativeness of the Ramfjord teeth for epidemiologic studies of gingivitis and periodontitis. Commun Dent and Oral Epidemiol 1987; 15(4): 221-4. 8. Najah A, Seham S, Fadhil R. The usefulness of Ramfjord teeth to represent the full-mouth pocket depth in epidemiological study. J Baghdad Coll Dent 2010; 22(2): 272-5. 9. Rams TE, Oler J, Listgarten MA, Slots J. Utility of Ramfjord index teeth to assess periodontal disease progression in longitudinal studies. J Clinical Periodontology 1993; 20(2):147-50.