Raghad Final.doc


J Bagh College Dentistry                       Vol. 26(2), June 2014                  Dental caries among   
   

 

Orthodontics, Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry 157 
 

Dental caries among a group of boys with β-thalassemia 
major (10-12 years old) in relation to salivary Mutans 

streptococci 
 
Raghad R. Al-Zaidi, B.D.S. (1) 
Sulafa K. El- Samarrai, B.D.S., M.Sc., Ph.D. (2) 
 
ABSTRACT 
Background: Beta thalassemia major is an inherited disorder that may affect general and oral health.The purpose of 
this study was toassess the severity of dental caries in relation to oral cleanliness, mutans streptococciamong a group 
of boys with beta thalassemia majorin comparison with a control group. 
Materials and Methods: The study involved 30 boys with BTM aged 10-12 years compared to 30 healthy boys with the 
same age group. d1-4mfs and D1-4 MFS indices were applied (Muhlemann, 1976), the viable counts of mutans 
streptococci in stimulated saliva were also determined. 
Results: The entire thalassemic group was caries-active. For both dentitions, a higher dmfs/DMFS values were 
recorded for study compared to control group, difference was statistically not significantconcerning dmfs, while it 
was statistically significant concerning DMFS (P<0.05). Salivary bacterial counts of mutans streptococci were found to 
be higher in the study compared to control group and the difference was statistically highly significant (P<0.01).All 
correlations between bacterial counts and dmfs/DMFS indices in study group were statistically not significant. 
Conclusion: Patients with Beta thalasemic major had more caries severity compared to normal subjects.  
Key words: β-thalassemia, mutans streptococci.  (J Bagh Coll Dentistry 2014; 26(2): 157-159). 

  الخالصة
. االضطرابات الوراثیة التي قد تؤدي الى انخفاض في انتاج كریات الدم الحمراء كما یعمل على زیادة تحطیمھا النوع الكبیر أحد أنواع یعتبرفقر دم البحر األبیض المتوسط :المقدمة

  .تصیب الفم واللعاب مما قد یزید من احتمالیة االصابة بتسّوس األسنان یعاني المصابون بھذا المرض من عدة تغیرات جرثومیة التي قد
المكّورات المسبحیة عند مجموعة من األطفال الذكور المصابین بمرض فقر دم البحر األبیض المتوسط , نظافة الفم, تھدف ھذه الدراسة الى حساب حّدة تسّوس األسنان :أھداف الدراسة

  .جموعة ضابطةالنوع الكبیربالمقارنة مع م
تم قیاس حّدة تسّوس األسنان . من األطفال األصّحاء ومن نفس الفئة العمریة 30سنة بالمقارنة مع ) 12- 10(مریض تتراوح أعمارھم مابین  30شملت الدراسة  :المواد وطرق العمل

ّینات الُلعاب المحّفز باالضافة احتساب االعداد الحّیة للمكّورات المسبحّیة في تم جمع ع). 1976(حسب طریقة موھلمان ) D1-4 MFSو d1-4 mfs) (حشوة, قلع, تسّوس(حسب مقیاس 
  .اللعاب
لدى ) dmfs) (حشوة, قلع, تسّوس(أظھرت النتائج وجود قیم عالیة للتسّوس حسب مقیاس , فیما یتعلق باألسنان اللبنیة. أظھرت النتائج اصابة جمیع االطفال بتسّوس األسنان :النتائج

لدى المرضى  ) DMFS) (حشوة, قلع, تسّوس(وجدت قیم عالیة للتسّوس حسب مقیاس , فیما یتعلق باألسنان الدائمیة. قارنة باألطفال األصّحاء مع عدم وجود فروقات معنویةالمرضى م
ند األطفال المصابین بالمرض مقارنة مع المجموعة الضابطة مع النتائج بّینت أن أعداد المكّورات المسبحیة أعلى ع. )P<0.05(مقارنة باألطفال األصّحاء مع وجود فروقات معنویة

  .كل العالقات بین أعداد المكورات المسبحیة في اللعاب مع تسّوس األسنان لألطفال المصابین بالمرض كانت بدون فروقات معنویة.)P<0.01(وجود فرق معنوي عاٍل 
  .مما یعني ضرورة توفیر برنامج وقائي فّعال لھؤالء األطفال المرضى, من أقرانھم من األطفال األصّحاء وجد أن تسّوس األسنان في األطفال المرضى أعلى :األستنتاج

  .المكّورات المسبحیة المیوتانز, فقر دم البحر المتوسط النوع الكبیر: كلمات مفتاحیة
 
INTRODUCTION 

Beta thalassemias are a group of inherited 
blood disorders caused by reduced or absent 
synthesis of the beta chains of hemoglobin (1, 2).  
From the few studies regarding dental caries 
among patients with BTM it was concluded that 
the prevalence and severity of this disease were 
higher in those patient than in normal subjects (3, 
4).  

There are a limited number of studies 
concerning counts of mutans streptococci in 
relation to dental caries in BTM (5). This study 
was designed to correlate dental caries severity to 
salivary mutans streptococci among of β-
thalassemia major patients. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
(1)Master student. Department of Pedodontics and Preventive 
Dentistry, College of Dentistry, University of Baghdad 
(2)Professor. Department of Pedodontics and Preventive 
Dentistry, College of Dentistry, University of Baghdad 

MATERIALS AND METHODS 
The study group included 30 boys, with an age 

range of 10-12 years according to the last birth 
day (6); they were already diagnosed with β-
thalassemia major, attending the thalassemic 
center in Ibn Al-Baladi Hospital for their regular 
checkup and blood transfusion. The control group 
included 30 boys matching in age and genders 
with the study group; they were examined in their 
primary school nearby the hospital. Prior to 
clinical examination, collection of stimulated 
salivary samples from both study and control 
groups was done (7).  

Each individual was asked to chew a piece of 
Arabic gum for one minute then to remove all 
saliva by expectoration, chewing was then 
continued for ten minutes  with the same piece of 
gum and saliva collected in a sterile screw-capped 
bottles. After collection and disappearance of 
salivary foams, 0.1 ml of saliva wastransferred to 
0.9 ml of sterile phosphate buffer saline (pH 7.0) 
for microbiological analysis. 

Dental caries was diagnosed by clinical 
examination; using dental mirror and sharp dental 



J Bagh College Dentistry                       Vol. 26(2), June 2014                  Dental caries among   
   

 

Orthodontics, Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry 158 
 

explorer. Assessment and recording of caries 
experience was by the application of (d1-4 mfs/D1-4 
MFS). The selective media for the cultivation of 
mutans streptococci was Mitis Salivarius 
Bacitracin Agar. Isolation and identification of 
bacteria were done according to Holbrook and 
Beighton(8). Statistical Analyses were achievedby 
using SPSS version 20 (Statistical Package for 
Social Sciences). Descriptive measurement (mean 
and standard deviation) and interferential statistic 
involved (Student's t-test, Paired t-test, Person's 
correlation coefficient, and multiple liner 
regression) were applied. The level of confidence 
was 95%. 
 
RESULTS 

Clinical examination showed that all subjects 
were affected by dental caries. Decayed, missed 
and filled teeth surfaces of boys by fractions of d1-
4mfs/D1-4 MFS index are represented by their 
means and standard deviations (SD) in Tables (1) 
and (2).  

Salivary bacterial counts of mutans 
streptococci were found to be higher in study 
group (3.63±1.650)CFU/ml×104 compared to 
control group (1.93±0.907)CFU/ml×104 and the 
difference was statistically highly significant 
(P<0.01). All correlations between bacterial 
counts and dmfs/DMFS were statistically not 
significant Table (3).  

Tables (4) and (5) illustrate results of single 
linear regressions of dmfs and DMFS indices as a 
(dependent variable) in both study and control 
groups explained by mutans streptococci count 
(independent variables). The recorded correlation 
coefficient (r) between dmfs and bacterial count 
was 0.242 in study group and 0.320 in control 
group, the R2 value was lower in the study 
compared to the control group. For DMFS, the 
correlation coefficient (r) with bacterial count was 
0.041 in study group and 0.252 in control group; 
the R2 value was also lower in the study compared 
to the control group. 

 
Table 1: Caries-experience of primary teeth (dmfs) among study and control groups 

Parameters No. Study Control Mean ±SD Mean ±SD 
ds 30 6.100 5.797 4.400 4.966 
ms 30 0.330 1.269 0.630 2.684 
fs 30 - - - - 

dmfs 30 6.430 6.185 5.030 5.468 
 

Table 2: Caries-experience of permanent teeth (DMFS) in study and control groups 
Parameters No. Study Control t-value P-value Mean ±SD Mean ±SD 

DS 30 6.500 4.297 4.230 2.029 2.613* 0.011 
MS 30 - - - - - - 
FS 30 - - - - - - 

DMFS 30 6.500 4.297 4.230 2.029 2.613* 0.011 
*significant at the level P<0.05,df=29 

 
Table 3: Correlation coefficients between mutans streptococci counts in saliva and caries-

experience (primary and permanent teeth) in study and control groups 
Caries-Experience Study Control r P r P 

dmfs 0.242 0.198 0.320 0.084 
DMFS -0.041 0.831 0.252 0.179 

 
Table 4: Single linear regression of caries-experience (dmfs) with mutans streptococci counts in 

study and control groups 

Group 
Coefficients 

t-value P-value 
B S.E 

Study 
R2=5.8% 1.168 0.886 1.318 0.198 

Control 
R2=10.3% 1.930 1.079 1.789 0.084 

 



J Bagh College Dentistry                       Vol. 26(2), June 2014                  Dental caries among   
   

 

Orthodontics, Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry 159 
 

Table 5: Single linear regression of caries-experience (DMFS) with mutans streptococci counts 
in study and control Groups 

Group 
Coefficients 

t-value P-value 
B S.E 

Study 
R2=0.2% -0.137 0.634 -0.216 0.831 

Control 
R2=6.4% 0.564 0.409 1.380 0.179 

 
DISCUSSION 

Data of the present study showed that all 
children in both study and control groups had 
dental caries, i.e. a 100% of occurrence of the 
disease;    this may indicate that both groups may 
have the same susceptibility to dental caries.  
However, data revealed that there is a variation in 
the severity of caries-experience between the 
groups; this was true for primary and permanent 
teeth. For both dentitions, caries-experience as 
measured by dmfs/DMFS index was higher in the 
study group compared to the control and 
differences were statistically significant for 
DMFS and not significant for dmfs. This may 
indicate a higher severity of dental caries among 
study group compared to control; the same results 
were recorded by others (9, 10).  

In thalassemic patient, the DMFS index was 
composed of decay surface only, as no case was 
seen with either missing or filling surfaces. This is 
an indication of the increased need for dental 
treatment. The increased severity of dental caries 
among thalassemic children may be attributed to 
poor oral cleanliness, related to certain oral 
structural changes that take place in thalassemic 
patient due to maxillary enlargement result in 
protrusion of anterior teeth, increase space 
between teeth, over-bite or open-bite and varying 
degrees of malocclusion, aid in more plaque 
accumulation (11). Another explanation for the 
increase severity of dental caries in the study 
group is the higher counts of mutans streptococci 
in the thalassemic group; as found by this study 
with a statistically high significant difference, the 
same result was reported by other (5).The higher 
counts of salivary mutans streptococci may be 
related to the lower IgA level in saliva of 
thalassemic patients that may lead to increased 
microbial proliferation (12).  

Results of multiple linear regressions revealed 
a more impact of mutans streptococci on dental 
caries of the control group compared to study 
group. Studying bacterial count in dental plaque 
may give more obvious picture regarding the 
correlation between count of this cariogenic 

bacteria and dental caries. The increased 
cariesseverity among thalassemic patients may 
indicate the increase need for special care and 
preventive programs for this special group. 
 
REFERENCES 
1. Tefferi A.Primary hematology, 10th ed.USA, 2001. 
2. Greer J, Rodgers G, Foerster J, Glader B, Arber D, 

Means R. Wintrobe's clinical hematology.12thed. 
chain, 2009. 

3. Al-Raheem Y, Abdul Hussein M, Al-Ani R, Al-
Rubayee M. The Impact of Thalassemia Major on 
Dental Integrity and Development. MDJ 2009; 6: 4. 

4. KatariaSushla A, Arora M, Dadhich A, KatariaKushal 
R. Orodental complication and orofacial manifestation 
in children and adolescents with thalassemia major of 
western Rajasthan population: a comparative study. Int 
J Biol Med Res 2012; 3(2):1816-9. 

5. Lugliè PF, Campus G, Deiola C, Mela MG, Gallisai 
D. Oral condition, chemistry of saliva chemistry of 
saliva and salivary levels of streptococcus mutans in 
thalassemic patients. Clin Oral Inves 2002; 6(4): 223-
6. 

6. WHO: Oral health surveys. Basic methods. 4th ed. 
Geneva. 1997. 

7. Tenovou J, Lagerlöf F. Saliva. In: Thylstrup and 
Fejerscov O. Textbook of Clinical Cariology. 2nd ed. 
Copenhagen: Munksgaard; 1996. p. 17-43. 

8. Holbrook W, Beighton D. Streptococcus mutans levels 
in saliva and distribution of serotypes among 9-year-
old Icelandic children. Scan J Dent Res 1986; 95:37-
42. 

9. Mohammed I.  Oral  Health  Status , Treatment Needs  
and  Dentofacial  Anomalies  among  (5-14)  Years 
Patients  with  β–  Thalassemia  Major  Syndrome  in 
Comparison  to  School  Children  in  Baghdad  
Province. A master thesis, College of Dentistry, 
University of Baghdad, 2004. 

10. Noori M. Orofacial, salivary and radiographic changes 
in major thalassemic patients in Mousl. A master 
thesis, College of Dentistry, University of Baghdad, 
2004. 

11. Al-Wahadni AM, Tami DQ, AlOmari MO.  Dental 
disease in subjects with beta-thalassaemia major.  
Comm Dent Oral Epidem 2002; 30(6): 418-22. 

12. Siamopoulou  MA,  Mavridou A,  Galanakis  E, 
Vasako  S,  Fatourou  H,  Lapatsanis  P.  Flow  rate  
and chemistry  of  parotid  saliva  related  to  dental  
caries  and gingivitis  in  patients  with  thalassemia  
major.  Int J Pediatr Dent 1992; 2(2): 93-7.