Journal of Medical Ethics and History of Medicine Original Article Pediatric residents’ and attending physicians’ perspectives on the ethical challenges of end of life care in children Alireza Ebrahimi1, Sedigheh Ebrahimi2* 1 Student of Medicine, Student Research Committee, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran. 2 Associate Professor, Department of Medical Ethics, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran. Corresponding Author: Sedigheh Ebrahimi Block No.2, Department of Medical Ethics and Philosophy of Health, School of Medicine, Zand Ave., Imam Hosein Sq., Shiraz, Fars, Iran. Email: sedighehebrah@yahoo.com Tel: (+98) 713 2349985 Fax: (+98) 713 2348980 Received: 7 Sep 2018 Accepted: 29 Dec 2018 Published: 30 Dec 2018 J Med Ethics Hist Med, 2018, 11: 16 © 2018 Medical Ethics and History of Medicine Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences. All rights reserved. Abstract One issue that has received less attention in present health care protocols is pediatric palliative care (PPC), which is an approach to care starting with the diagnosis of life-threatening diseases in children. It embraces physical, emotional and spiritual elements. Ethical issues are major concerns in today’s pediatric health care guidelines and must be considered by residents and attending physicians in this field. The present study was conducted in Namazi Teaching Hospital, Shiraz, Iran. Forty-eight out of 92 pediatricians were enrolled in this research, including 8 attendings, 6 fellows, and 34 residents. The study questionnaire consisted of 66 items. It was built based on previous reliable and validated questionnaire; also the calculated Cranach’s alpha was 0.815. Data were analyzed and presented by mean ± SD and percentage. While seventy-five percent of the participants reported involvement in pediatric palliative care, fifty-six percent did not acknowledge any information about the subject. More than half of the participants perceived the pediatric palliative care services in Namazi Hospital as somewhat or completely satisfactory. Furthermore, thirty-five percent of the applicants stated that they encounter an ethical problem with regard to PPC once a week. There are many challenges to providing decent palliative care for children, including symptom controlling, shifting to end of life care, background dissimilarities of patients, financial restrictions, and acceptance of death. Our applicants believed that offering psycho-spiritual support was the most important challenge in PPC. However, further investigations are needed to determine other requirements for providing a comprehensive guideline on PPC. Keywords: Ethics, medical residents, palliative care, pediatrics J Med Ethics Hist Med 11: 16, December, 2018 jmehm.tums.ac.ir Alireza Ebrahimi et al. Introduction Palliative care (PC) has been internationally acknowledged as a human right and a public health issue, since it involves themes such as dignity of individuals, universality and nondiscrimination (1). As announced in article no. 25.1 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, “Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health of himself and his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services….” (2). “Attention and care for chronically and terminally ill persons, sparing them avoidable pain and enabling them to die with dignity” has also been mentioned in General Comment no. 14 (2). World Health Organization (WHO) defines palliative care as active care for patients who have no curative alternative, and the principal points include control of pain and other symptoms such as psychological, social and spiritual breakdowns in order to improve the quality of life (QoL) (3, 4). Pediatric Palliative Care (PPC) could be defined as measures taken to manage children who are suffering from terminal diseases, and it should be applied when cure cannot be achieved by other treatments (5, 6). PPC has physical, emotional, social and spiritual aspects and is aimed at helping patients and their families improve their QoL throughout death and loss (5, 6). Educating the patients and their families, social support, and involving the affected parties in discussions about planning PPC should all be handled in an open and transparent way (5, 7). The emerging paradigm of PPC embraces the concept of applying PPC codes at the primitive stages of life threatening diseases and creating a multidisciplinary system of support around the children and their families, and can be provided in different settings such as the hospital or hospice care unit, school and home (8, 9). Usually, children - especially young children - cannot engage in the decision-making process; however, they often know they are dying and they may have treatment preferences (10 - 17). An additional aspect of PPC involves families as they are the ones who see the child’s discomfort and distress before death, must make difficult choices near and after the point of death, and lose a child and have to experience the sort of grief that is considered the most intense bereavement (18, 19). Reports demonstrate that the incidence of emotional disturbances is high in these families (about 50% in at least one family member). Moreover, parental grief has been reported to last deeply for 4 years. Thoughts of suicide, self-accusation and social withdrawal have also been observed in parents who have lost a child (20 - 24). Previous investigations have shown that families of dying children need respect and a true relationship provided by the nursing team; in addition, they expect health care providers to treat their children as individual patients with explicit diagnoses, relieve their distress, and give them sufficient care (25). Determining the suitable time to open a conversation about a child’s death is challenging, as the beliefs and situations of parents must be well understood. Alleviating the families’ feeling of bereavement after the loss could be achieved by multiple means available through palliative care, including psychologists and psychiatrists, clergymen and spiritual aids, and support groups (26 - 29). Former studies also indicate that health-care providers’ writing condolence messages and attending the memorial service could help families cope with the grief (26 - 29). Students and residents normally feel awkward in their confrontations with dying patients. They see death as a medical failure and generally do not perceive palliative care as an obvious component of medicine (30, 31). However, educationalists and legislators are paying more attention to the issue of palliative care in order to develop knowledge and investigation in this field (30, 31). The present study examined pediatricians’ perspectives on ethical subjects related to this field to improve the agenda of palliative care by using a questionnaire covering issues such as pediatricians’ uncluttered explanations, decision-making and psycho/spiritual support. The study targeted residents and attendings to find out if they had established maladaptive attitudes or practices. Method Population and Data Collection The present study was performed on 48 of the 92 pediatric residents, fellows and attendings of Namazi Teaching Hospital in Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran between December 21, 2016 and May 21, 2017. The population consisted of 8 attendings, 6 fellows and 34 residents (54.2% male and 45.8% female), including 12 first-year, 13 second-year, and 9 third-year residents. The questionnaire was designed based on previously published surveys and consultations with experts in the field of medical ethics (32 - 34). In order to evaluate its validity and reliability, the questionnaire was given to 20 residents who were selected randomly. After a month, the questionnaire was given to the same people, and the outcome was evaluated by using Spearman correlation test. Using Cronbach’s alpha (< 0.7), the questions that were found to create a significant bias were omitted Page 2 of 13 J Med Ethics Hist Med 11: 16, December, 2018 jmehm.tums.ac.ir Alireza Ebrahimi et al. (Appendix 1); moreover, Cronbach’s alpha was calculated for all questions jointly to estimate the consistency of the questionnaire, which was 0.815, and thus the questionnaire was finalized (Appendix 2). The questionnaire consisted of 3 sections. The first section contained the basic demographic data. The second section included queries designed in 5-point Likert-scale questions to assess the level of satisfaction with palliative care services (5 = completely satisfactory to 1 = completely unsatisfactory). The third section was based on Likert-scale responses to assess the participants’ general opinion about the topic and ethical challenges to implementation of pediatric palliative care. The second and third section of the questionnaire consisted of 66 items and were given to participants who were gathered in a conference room on the same day. The data were extracted by a trained person who was unaware of the names and degrees of the people who filled the forms. After analysis of the data, questions that had a significant bias according to the correlation test were omitted. The finalized data were sent for statistical evaluations, and the study protocol was approved by the Medical Ethics Committee of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran. Participation in this research was voluntary, and participants were assured that their information would be kept confidential. Data Management and Statistical Analysis The collected data were reviewed for accuracy and verified by two independent experts. Descriptive statistics were analyzed by mean ± SD and percentage calculations. The discrete and ordinal data were compared using student’s t-test, and Spearman’s correlation and Pearson’s correlation tests were applied. The differences with a P-value ≤ 0.05 were regarded as statistically significant. Statistical analyses were performed using SPSS version 19.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL). Results The data are presented in Tables 1 to 5 below. Table 1 shows the demographic data of the participants. The participants’ experiences (both as contributors and as observers) regarding working hours, knowledge and their exposure to palliative care are demonstrated in Table 2. Table 1- Demographic data of the study participants Gender Percent Male Female 54.2 45.8 Marital Status Single Married 70.8 29.2 Age 20-29 30-39 40-49 50-60 27.1 50 18.8 4.2 Position Attending 1st year resident 2nd year resident 3rd year resident Fellow 16.7 25 27.1 18.8 12.5 Table 2- Participants’ experiences of palliative care Months of working in pediatrics ward 53.88± 70.58 Months of working in pediatrics ICU 14.31± 20.42 Practicing hours per week 64.64± 30.50 Practicing palliative care Yes No 75 22.9 Information about palliative care Yes No 56.3 43.8 Source of information Medical education resources Internet and journals Methodological education 37.5 12.5 >6 hours <6 hours 10.4 52.1 Number of participants patients who needed palliative care 1-5 6-10 11-15 16-20 >20 29.2 14.6 8.3 8.3 37.5 Number of the participants patients who died 1-5 6-10 11-15 16-20 >20 35.4 16.7 10.4 2.1 31.3 Page 3 of 13 J Med Ethics Hist Med 11: 16, December, 2018 jmehm.tums.ac.ir Alireza Ebrahimi et al. Seventy-five percent of the participants reported involvement in pediatric palliative care, and 38% of the residents, fellows and attendings had had over 20 patients in need of palliative care. An additional 31% had observed more than 20 patients expiring, while 56% of the participants did not acknowledge any information about palliative care. Table 3 presents participants’ responses to the questions designed to assess the level of satisfaction with palliative care services. More than half of the participants (84.5% of all medical service providers and 68.9% of those in the ICU) perceived the pediatric palliative care services in Namazi Hospital, Shiraz, Iran as somewhat or completely satisfactory. Table 3- Participant’s satisfaction with palliative care services Questionnaire Item N Minimum Maximum Mean SD How do you evaluate the facilities prepared by all medical provider sections for dying patients? 45 1.00 4.00 3.0889 .76343 How do you evaluate the appreciation of medical services by families of dying patients? 45 1.00 4.00 2.8222 .77720 How do you evaluate the pediatric palliative care in Intensive Care Units? 45 2.00 5.00 3.4444 .78496 How do you evaluate your own implementation of pediatric palliative care? 44 1.00 4.00 2.9318 1.02066 Values based on Likert-scale responses (1= Completely unsatisfactory, 2= Unsatisfactory, 3= Somewhat satisfactory, 4= Satisfactory, 5= Completely satisfactory) Table 4- General comments on implementation of pediatric palliative care Questionnaire Item N Minimum Maximum Mean SD The lack of education in physicians about pediatric palliative care limits appropriate services. 48 1.00 5.00 3.6875 1.15143 I have difficulty understanding the principles of palliative care. 43 1.00 5.00 3.5814 1.00552 There is a lack of information and resources in the field of palliative care. 44 1.00 5.00 3.4091 1.08517 More studies and investigations must be conducted in this field in order to enhance the application of suitable palliative care. 44 2.00 5.00 4.2273 .91152 I believe authorized education must be promoted in this field, and I will participate in this education. 43 2.00 5.00 4.2791 .90831 We must actively participate in the field of palliative care during our education. 46 2.00 5.00 3.8043 .93380 I control the expiring patients’ symptoms (such as nausea, vomiting, constipation) sufficiently. 46 1.00 5.00 4.2391 1.03676 I can identify the poor-prognosis symptoms in dying patients. 45 1.00 5.00 3.6000 1.09545 Due to lack of time and workforce, it is not possible to provide patients and their families with psychological support. 46 1.00 5.00 2.6522 1.47900 Due to cultural differences between families and healthcare providers, psychological support is unachievable. 46 1.00 5.00 3.1957 1.27575 Lessening the dying patients’ physical symptoms is the most important challenge in palliative care. 46 1.00 5.00 3.1739 .90196 Providing the physiological needs of terminal patients must be the first priority in palliative care. 45 2.00 5.00 3.7111 1.01404 Palliative care should be practiced by anesthesiologists. 44 1.00 5.00 2.2955 1.15294 Palliative care should be practiced by oncologists. 44 1.00 5.00 2.1364 1.11211 Specialists should be trained in the field of palliative care. 44 1.00 5.00 3.5000 1.19105 Palliative care should be provided in primary care facilities. 43 1.00 5.00 2.4884 1.26061 There should be units that are specialized in palliative care. 25 2.00 5.00 4.0400 .97809 Palliative care must be provided in patients’ homes. 26 2.00 5.00 3.6538 1.01754 Page 4 of 13 J Med Ethics Hist Med 11: 16, December, 2018 jmehm.tums.ac.ir Alireza Ebrahimi et al. Questionnaire Item N Minimum Maximum Mean SD The best way to train in this field is to capture the attendings’ experiences and bedside teachings. 44 1.00 5.00 3.5682 1.08687 The best way to train in this field is to experience the situation individually. 44 1.00 5.00 2.6591 1.19967 The best way to train in this field is to participate in related conferences. 44 1.00 5.00 3.2273 .91152 Interdisciplinary groups must be appointed between different factions of the health-care system to improve palliative care. 44 3.00 5.00 4.2045 .76492 Educating patients and their families is necessary for the improvement of palliative care. 44 2.00 5.00 4.0682 .89955 Values based on Likert-scale responses (1= Disagree, 2= Unsure, 3= Somewhat agree, 4= Mostly agree, 5= Totally agree) Table 5-General topics in PPC Questionnaire Item N Minimum Maximum Mean SD Patients’ relatives obtain information from unauthorized individuals instead of their cognizant healthcare providers. 46 1.00 5.00 4.4130 .97925 Families have difficulty deciding on continuation of invasive treatments. 47 1.00 5.00 2.9787 1.34309 The lack of suitable facilities and plots limits dying patients and their families’ privacy. 47 1.00 5.00 3.9787 1.29362 The nursing team’s lack of education about pediatric palliative care limits provision of appropriate services. 46 1.00 5.00 3.5652 1.55852 The lack of applicable guidelines about approaching dying children limits proper pediatric palliative care. 44 1.00 5.00 3.6818 1.44307 Values based on Likert-scale responses (1= Disagree, 2= Unsure, 3= Somewhat agree, 4= Mostly agree, 5= Totally agree) Table 6- Ethical challenges of pediatric palliative care Questionnaire Item N Minimum Maximum Mean SD It is very difficult for me to discuss palliative care with patients and their families. 28 1.00 5.00 3.5714 1.31736 I provide the information to dying patients and their families about altering curative treatments to palliative therapy. 47 1.00 5.00 3.5106 1.26615 I announce the diagnosis of the life-threatening disease to patients’ families in a meeting. 47 1.00 5.00 3.9149 1.21279 I ask the dying children to participate in these meetings. 47 1.00 4.00 1.6170 .89814 I explain the DNR1 protocol to patients’ families. 47 1.00 5.00 2.5319 1.48691 Families have difficulty deciding on the DNR protocol or termination of mechanical ventilation. 47 1.00 5.00 4.0213 1.15136 Patients’ families are not prepared to accept that their child’s disease is incurable. 47 1.00 5.00 3.6596 1.08901 I am afraid of discussing the cessation of curative treatments. 46 1.00 5.00 2.6522 1.32023 It is very challenging for me to discuss altering curative treatments to palliative therapy with patients and their families. 47 1.00 5.00 3.6809 1.14410 I feel awkward facing the families’ reactions, and I do not know what to tell them. 46 1.00 5.00 3.5000 1.11056 Patients’ families do not understand the terminal nature of the disease, so I do not explain the situation to them. 47 1.00 5.00 1.8723 1.22682 Altering curative treatments to palliative care could hurt the families’ trust in the health-care system that did not cure their child’s disease. 47 1.00 5.00 2.7660 1.25478 Page 5 of 13 J Med Ethics Hist Med 11: 16, December, 2018 jmehm.tums.ac.ir Alireza Ebrahimi et al. Questionnaire Item N Minimum Maximum Mean SD Patients’ families must decide whether to start palliative care or not. 47 1.00 5.00 4.0638 1.05097 Patients’ families must be informed after the decision has been made to start palliative care. 46 1.00 5.00 3.2609 1.59770 I assist the patients and their families with spiritual and psychological support. 47 1.00 5.00 4.4043 .87625 Initiation of palliative care resembles doing nothing for the patients. 46 1.00 4.00 2.0000 1.15470 Palliative care has been designed to decrease the economic burden of dying patients. 45 1.00 5.00 1.9778 1.19637 Continuation of curative treatment in dying patients sometimes seems illogical. 45 1.00 5.00 3.1111 1.30074 In patients with life-threatening conditions, early initiation of palliative care could be more beneficial. 46 1.00 5.00 3.4565 1.14904 Even if there is no hope for treatment of the disease, we must continue the curative and invasive therapies. 45 1.00 5.00 2.0222 1.17722 We must continue invasive treatments for dying patients because we could be sued by their families. 45 1.00 5.00 3.0889 1.44320 Doctors do not accept their patients are dying. 46 1.00 5.00 2.0000 1.21106 We must discuss the situation of every expiring patient uniquely, considering their conditions. 42 1.00 5.00 4.3333 1.00406 No matter how long I have practiced in the field of pediatric palliative care, encountering children who are suffering from end of life conditions is difficult for me. 46 1.00 5.00 3.1522 1.42933 Doctors have a significant role in supporting the patients and their families through psychological and spiritual help. 46 1.00 5.00 4.4130 .83203 Psychological and spiritual support must be provided by other groups such as psychologists and nurses. 46 1.00 5.00 2.9783 1.34146 Providing the patients and their families with appropriate information is the greatest challenge. 45 2.00 5.00 3.9111 1.04059 Providing psychological and spiritual support is the most important challenge in this field. 46 2.00 5.00 4.0217 .95427 Palliative care services are important in dealing with patients. 44 2.00 5.00 4.2273 .96119 How often do you encounter ethical issues with regard to pediatric palliative care? 45 1.00 5.00 3.8444 1.14724 Values are based on Likert-scale responses (1= Disagree, 2= Unsure, 3= Somewhat agree, 4= Mostly agree, 5= Totally agree); 1= Never, 2= 1 time until now, 3= 2-3 times until now, 4= Once a week, 5= Always Discussion There are many challenges to providing decent palliative care for children such as symptom controlling problems in terms of scheduling, sufficiency, and competency of management. Some of these challenges could be due to fear of speeding the child’s death, difficulties associated with management of neonates, the shift from curative care to end of life care, noticing the issue of PPC at a national level, personal differences among different patients, background dissimilarities of patients, lack of time, financial restrictions, dealing with patients’ apprehensions, and acceptance of death by patients, families and health-care providers (5, 6, 35 - 38). On the other hand, there is inadequate literature on the essentials and effectiveness of many PPC interventions which could be due to absence of study cases, unavailability of a baseline score for assessment of pain and QoL in pediatrics, and the fact that PPC is a novel subject (39). Moreover, there is no evidence-based tool to determine which patients would benefit from palliative care, and therefore initiation of palliative care should be personalized (38). Previous studies have suggested policies with regard to PC for various psychosomatic symptoms such as Page 6 of 13 J Med Ethics Hist Med 11: 16, December, 2018 jmehm.tums.ac.ir Alireza Ebrahimi et al. dyspnea, pain, nausea, seizures, agitation, anxiety, depression and grief, which can develop differently from one person to another (40 - 45). However, palliative care organizations have been mostly focused on physical care and the medical treatment of suffering rather than the psychological, sociological and spiritual aspects of death. Studies have shown that health-care professionals could be frustrated due to compassion fatigue and burnout while providing PPC. This might be due to interaction problems, disagreements on decisions, lack of system support such as excessive workload and workforce unavailability, subjugated grief, and legal issues (6). Palliative care practitioners have reported a feeling of “powerlessness” over dying patients, and that “there is always something more to be done”; thus the pressure of choosing between acting or not acting arises in daily communications with patients as well as in the philosophy of good death (46). Most of our participants (75%) claimed that they practiced PPC but about half of them stated that they did not have adequate information about PPC. Most of the applicants who asserted they had received training in PPC said they had obtained information in this field from medical education resources. Most of the participants evaluated their satisfaction with palliative care services as somewhat satisfactory; however, they were mostly not pleased with the appreciation of medical services by families of dying patients. Our data also revealed that improper palliative care services may be due to a number of reasons such as lack of education in physicians and nurses, insufficiency of educational courses and workshops about PPC, problems in identification of poor-prognosis symptoms, inadequate understanding of the principles of PPC, lack of resources, shortage of research in PPC, lack of time and workforce, cultural differences between health-care providers and patients’ families, absence of a systematic approach and role modeling around PPC, and insufficient family education. Our applicants also declared that some problems could be related to the families of dying patients, for instance they might have difficulty deciding on the continuation of treatments, or attempt to obtain information from unauthorized persons. Although most of our applicants admitted to some difficulties in starting palliative care discussions, they said that they mostly informed patients’ families about the situation, but they did not involve the children in educational meetings. Insufficient education both in families and health- care providers may also lead to certain misunderstandings about PPC. The consequences may include: failure to recognize the terminal condition of the disease, emotional complications, inconsistencies in terms of rituals and spiritual beliefs, being sued by the dying children’s families, and impairment of the families’ trust in the health- care system. Most of the participants insisted that the families must be the ones to make the decision to start palliative care; however, informing them after deciding to start PPC was also perceived as favorable. Our results also depicted that although physicians mostly provided psychological and spiritual support to the families of dying children, they generally preferred the task to be left to other groups such as nurses and psychologists. Even though decreasing the economic burden of dying patients is a major concern in PPC, it did not appear to be particularly important for our participants. On the other hand, our physicians mostly insisted on the effectiveness and early initiation of PPC in dying patients in order to reduce suffering and end-of-life complications for these patients. Our participants also perceived psychological and spiritual support to be the most important challenges to pediatric palliative care; thus, further investigations are required in order to provide comprehensive guidelines in this field. Conclusion Of the numerous issues that could be considered as challenges to the implementation of PPC mentioned above, the spiritual and psychological aspects of PPC were found to be the most important ones. The results showed that it is essential to educate patients’ families as well as health-care providers, and that educational courses and obligatory guidelines would be helpful in this case. Investigations are still highly required to determine other demands and considerations regarding provision of a comprehensive guideline on PPC. Acknowledgments This study was extracted from the doctorate thesis of Alireza Ebrahimi and was supported by Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran. The authors would like to thank the personnel of the Department of Medical Ethics and Shiraz Medical School in Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran. We would also like to express our gratitude to Dr. Soheil Ashkani-Esfahani and the SIMR Co. for editing and improving the text. Conflict of Interests None declared. Page 7 of 13 J Med Ethics Hist Med 11: 16, December, 2018 jmehm.tums.ac.ir Alireza Ebrahimi et al. References 1. Gwyther L, Brennan F, Harding R. Advancing palliative care as a human right. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2009; 38(5): 767-74. 2. Anonymous. The universal declaration of human rights. [Cited on December 2018]; Available from: https://www.ohchr.org/EN/UDHR/Documents/UDHR_Translations/eng.pdf 3. Anonymous. WHO definition of palliative care. [Cited on December 2018]; Available from: http://www.who.int/cancer/palliative/definition/en/ 4. Albers G, Echteld MA, de Vet HC, Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD, van der Linden MH, Deliens L. Content and spiritual items of quality-of-life instruments appropriate for use in palliative care: a review. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2010; 40(2): 290-300. 5. Thompson A. Paediatric palliative care. Paediatrics and Child Health. 2015. 25(10): 458-62. 6. Liben S1, Papadatou D, Wolfe J. Paediatric palliative care: challenges and emerging ideas. Lancet. 2008; 371(9615): 852-64. 7. Anonymous. A guide to children's palliative care (Cited on December 2018); Available from: http://www.togetherforshortlives.org.uk/assets/0001/1649/ACT_Guide_to_Developing_Services.pdf 8. Collins JJ1, Fitzgerald DA. Palliative care and paediatric respiratory medicine. Paediatr Respir Rev. 2006. 7(4): 281-7. 9. Klick JC1, Hauer J. Pediatric palliative care. Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care. 2010; 40(6): 120-51. 10. Waechter EH. Children's awareness of fatal illness. The American Journal of Nursing. 1971; 1168-72. 11. Hinds PS1, Drew D, Oakes LL, et al. End-of-life care preferences of pediatric patients with cancer. J Clin Oncol. 2005; 23(36): 9146-54. 12. Ladd RE, Forman EN. Adolescent decision-making: giving weight to age-specific values. Theor Med. 1995; 16(4): 333-45. 13. Anonymous. Informed consent, parental permission, and assent in pediatric practice: committee on bioethics, American academy of pediatrics. Pediatrics.1995; 95(2): 314-17. 14. Weir RF, Peters C. Affirming the decisions adolescents make about life and death. Hastings Cent Rep. 1997; 27(6): 29-40. 15. Doig C, Burgess E. Withholding life-sustaining treatment: Are adolescents competent to make these decisions? CMAJ. 2000; 162(11): 1585-88. 16. Himebauch A1, Arnold RM, May C. Grief in children and developmental concepts of death# 138. J Palliat Med. 2008; 11(2): 242-3. 17. Poltorak, D.Y. and J.P. Glazer, The development of children's understanding of death: cognitive and psychodynamic considerations. Child Adolesc Psychiatr Clin N Am. 2006; 15(3): 567-73. 18. Rando TA. Parental Loss of a Child. USA: Research Press Pub; 1986. 19. Youngblut JM, Brooten D. Perinatal and pediatric issues in palliative and end-of-life care from the 2011 summit on the science of compassion. Nurs Outlook. 2012; 60(6): 343-50. 20. Binger CM, Ablin AR, Feuerstein RC, Kushner JH, Zoger S, Mikkelsen C. Childhood leukemia: emotional impact on patient and family. The New England Journal of Medicine. 1969; 280(8): 414-8. 21. Hazzard A, Weston J, Gutterres C. After a child's death: factors related to parental bereavement. J Dev Behav Pediatr. 1992; 13(1): 24-30. 22. Thayer P. Spiritual care of children and parents. In: Armstrong-Dailey A, Zarbock S. Hospice Care for Children, 2nd ed. New York: Oxford University Press; 2001, p.172-89. 23. Davies B, Eng B. Special issues in bereavement and staff support. In: Doyle D, Hanks GWC, MacDonald N, Calman K. Oxford Textbook of Palliative Medicine, 2nd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1998, p. 1086- 95. 24. Lannen PK, Wolfe J, Prigerson HG, Onelov E, Kreicbergs UC. Unresolved grief in a national sample of bereaved parents: impaired mental and physical health 4 to 9 years later. J Clin Oncol. 2008; 26(36): 5870-6. 25. Melin-Johansson C, Axelsson I, Jonsson Grundberg M, Hallqvist F. When a child dies: parents' experiences of palliative care—an integrative literature review. J Pediatr Nurs. 2014; 29(6): 660-9. 26. Davies B, Collins J, Steele R, Cook K, Distler V, Brenner A. Parents' and children's perspectives of a children's hospice bereavement program. J Palliat Care. 2007; 23(1): 14-23. 27. Wilkinson S, Croy P, King M, Barnes J. Are we getting it right? parents' perceptions of hospice child bereavement support services. Palliat Med. 2007; 21(5): 401-7. 28. Meyer EC, Burns JP, Griffith JL, Truog RD. Parental perspectives on end-of-life care in the pediatric intensive care unit. Crit Care Med. 2002; 30(1): 226-31. Page 8 of 13 J Med Ethics Hist Med 11: 16, December, 2018 jmehm.tums.ac.ir Alireza Ebrahimi et al. 29. Bedell SE, Cadenhead K, Graboys TB. The doctor's letter of condolence. N Engl J Med. 2001; 344(15): 1162-4. 30. Fins JJ, Nilson EG. An approach to educating residents about palliative care and clinical ethics. Acad Med. 2000; 75(6): 662-5. 31. Field MJ, Cassel CK. Approaching death: improving care at the end of life. Health Prog. 2011; 92(1): 25. 32. Michelson KN, Ryan AD, Jovanovic B, Frader J. Pediatric residents' and fellows' perspectives on palliative care education. J Palliat Med. 2009; 12(5): 451-7. 33. Davies B, Sehring SA, Partridge JC, et al. Barriers to palliative care for children: perceptions of pediatric health care providers. Pediatrics. 2008; 121(2): 282-288. 34. Meyer EC, Ritholz MD, Burns JP, Truog RD. Improving the quality of end-of-life care in the pediatric intensive care unit: parents' priorities and recommendations. Pediatrics. 2006; 117(3): 649-57. 35. Chang HT, Lin MH, Chen CK, Hwang SJ, Hwang IH, Chen YC. Hospice palliative care article publications: an analysis of the Web of Science database from 1993 to 2013. J Chin Med Assoc. 2016; 79(1): 29-33. 36. Solomon MZ, Sellers DE, Heller KS, et al. New and lingering controversies in pediatric end-of-life care. Pediatrics. 2005; 116(4): 872-83. 37. Zimmermann C. Acceptance of dying: a discourse analysis of palliative care literature. Soc Sci Med. 2012; 75(1): 217-24. 38. Qaseem, A., et al., Evidence-Based Interventions to Improve the Palliative Care of Pain, Dyspnea, and Depression at the end of life: a clinical practice guideline from the American college of physicians. Ann Intern Med. 2008; 148(2): 141-6. 39. Hinds PS, Schum L, Baker JN, Wolfe J. Key factors affecting dying children and their families. J Palliat Med. 2005; 8 (Suppl 1): S70-8. 40. Anonymous. Ethics and the care of critically ill infants and children. American academy of pediatrics committee on bioethics. Pediatrics. 1996; 98(1): 149-52. 41. Anonymous. Palliative care for children: committee on bioethics and committee on hospital care. Pediatrics. 2000; 106(2): 351-7. 42. Collins JJ. Intractable pain in children with terminal cancer. J Palliat Care.1996; 12(3): 29-34. 43. Sirkiä K, Hovi L, Pouttu J, Saarinen-Pihkala UM. Pain medication during terminal care of children with cancer. J Pain Symptom Manage. 1998; 15(4): 220-6. 44. Cassel CK. Principles for Care of Patients at the End of Life: An Emerging Consensus among the Specialties of Medicine. USA; 1999. 45. Lorenz KA, Lynn J, Dy SM, Shugarman LR, et al. Evidence for improving palliative care at the end of life: a systematic review. Ann Intern Med. 2008; 148(2): 147-59. 46. McNamara B. Good enough death: autonomy and choice in Australian palliative care. Soc Sci Med. 2004; 58(5): 929-38. Page 9 of 13 J Med Ethics Hist Med 11: 16, December, 2018 jmehm.tums.ac.ir Alireza Ebrahimi et al. Appendix Appendix 1- Evaluation of validity and the reliability of the questionnaires by using Cronbach’s alpha test Question No. Cronbach’s Alpha 1 0.877 2 1 3 1 4 0.954 5 1 6 0.926 7 0.993 8 0.962 9 0.963 10 1 11 0.953 12 1 13 1 14 1 15 1 16 0.884 17 1 18 0.985 19 1 20 0.640 21 0.802 22 0.964 23 0.883 24 0.768 25 0.808 26 0.889 27 0.982 28 0.958 29 0.985 30 0.986 31 0.864 32 0.960 33 1 34 0.859 35 0.924 Question No. Cronbach’s Alpha 36 0.924 37 0.673 38 0.734 39 0.628 40 0.728 41 0.803 42 0.304 43 0.784 44 0.829 45 0.881 46 0.611 47 0.968 48 0.931 49 1 50 0.951 51 0.961 52 1 53 1 54 0.974 55 1 56 0.909 57 0.980 58 0.970 59 0.975 60 0.689 61 0.988 62 1 63 0.898 64 0.961 65 0.758 66 0.941 Page 10 of 13 J Med Ethics Hist Med 11: 16, December, 2018 jmehm.tums.ac.ir Alireza Ebrahimi et al. Appendix 2- The finalized questionnaire evaluating participants’ satisfaction with palliative care services Items Completely satisfactory = 5 Satisfactory = 4 Somewhat satisfactory = 3 Unsatisfactory = 2 Completely unsatisfactory = 1 How do you evaluate the facilities prepared by all medical provider sections for dying patients? Completely satisfactory Satisfactory Somewhat satisfactory Unsatisfactory Completely unsatisfactory How do you evaluate the appreciation of medical services by families of dying patients? Completely satisfactory Satisfactory Somewhat satisfactory Unsatisfactory Completely unsatisfactory How do you evaluate the pediatric palliative care in Intensive Care Units? Completely satisfactory Satisfactory Somewhat satisfactory Unsatisfactory Completely unsatisfactory How do you evaluate yourself implementing pediatric palliative care? Completely satisfactory Satisfactory Somewhat satisfactory Unsatisfactory Completely unsatisfactory General topics and ethical challenges to implementation of pediatric palliative care How many times do you encounter ethical issues with regard to pediatric palliative care? Always Once a week 2 - 3 times until now 1 time until now Never Patients’ relatives obtain information from unauthorized individuals instead of their cognizant healthcare providers. Always Once a week 2 - 3 times until now 1 time until now Never Families have difficulty deciding on continuation of invasive treatments. Always Once a week 2 - 3 times until now 1 time until now Never The lack of suitable facilities and plots limits dying patients and their families’ privacy. Always Once a week 2 - 3 times until now 1 time until now Never The nursing team’s lack of education about pediatric palliative care limits provision of appropriate services. Always Once a week 2 - 3 times until now 1 time until now Never The lack of applicable guidelines about approaching dying children limits proper pediatric palliative care. Always Once a week 2 - 3 times until now 1 time until now Never It seems very difficult to me to start a discussion about palliative care. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Physicians’ lack of education about pediatric palliative care limits provision of appropriate services. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree I provide the information to dying patients and their families about altering curative treatments to palliative therapy. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree I announce the diagnosis of the life-threatening disease in a meeting to patients’ families. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree I ask the dying children to participate in these meetings. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree I explain the DNR protocol to the patients’ families. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Patients’ families are not prepared to accept that their child’s disease is incurable. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree It is very challenging for me to discuss altering curative treatments to palliative therapy with patients and their families. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree I feel awkward facing the families’ reactions, and I do not know what to tell them. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Patients’ families do not understand the terminal nature of the disease, so I do not explain the situation to them. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Altering curative treatments to palliative care could hurt the families’ trust in the health-care system that did not cure their child’s disease. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Patients’ families must decide whether to start palliative care or not. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Page 11 of 13 J Med Ethics Hist Med 11: 16, December, 2018 jmehm.tums.ac.ir Alireza Ebrahimi et al. Patients’ families must be informed after the decision has been made to start palliative care. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree I am afraid of discussing the cessation of curative treatments. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Families have difficulty deciding on the DNR protocol or termination of mechanical ventilation. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree I assist the patients and their families with spiritual and psychological support. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree I control the expiring patient’s symptoms (such as nausea, vomiting, constipation) sufficiently. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree I can identify the poor-prognosis symptoms in dying patients. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Initiation of palliative care resembles doing nothing for the patients. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Palliative care has been designed to decrease the economic burden of dying patients. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Continuation of curative treatments in dying patients seems illogical sometimes. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree In patients with life-threatening conditions, early initiation of palliative care could be more beneficial. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Even if there is no hope for treatment of the disease, we must continue the curative and invasive therapies. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree We must continue invasive treatments for dying patients because we could be sued by their families. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Doctors do not accept their patients are dying. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree We must discuss the situation of every expiring patient uniquely, considering their conditions. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree No matter how long I have practiced in the field of pediatric palliative care, encountering children who are suffering from end of life conditions is difficult for me. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree We must actively participate in the field of palliative care during our education. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Doctors have a significant role in supporting the patients and their families through psychological and spiritual help. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Psychological and spiritual support must be provided by other groups such as psychologists and nurses. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Due to lack of time and workforce, it is not possible to provide patients and their families with psychological support. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Due to cultural differences between families and healthcare providers, psychological support is unachievable. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Lessening the dying patients’ physical symptoms is the most important challenge in palliative care. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Providing the physiological needs of terminal patients must be the first priority in palliative care. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Providing the patients and their families with appropriate information is the greatest challenge. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Providing psychological and spiritual support is the most important challenge in this field. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Optional Questions: Palliative care services are important in dealing with patients. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree I have difficulty understanding the principles of palliative care. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree There is a lack of information and resources in palliative care. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Palliative care should be practiced by anesthesiologists. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Palliative care should be practiced by oncologists. Totally Mostly Somewhat Unsure Disagree Page 12 of 13 J Med Ethics Hist Med 11: 16, December, 2018 jmehm.tums.ac.ir Alireza Ebrahimi et al. agree agree agree Specialists should be trained in palliative care. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Palliative care should be provided in primary care facilities. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree There should be units that are specialized in palliative care. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Palliative care must be provided in patients’ homes. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree I believe authorized education must be promoted in this field, and I will participate in this education. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree The best way to train in this field is to capture the attendings’ experiences and bedside teachings. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree The best way to train in this field is to experience the situation individually. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree The best way to train in this field is to participate in related conferences. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Interdisciplinary groups must be appointed between different factions of the health-care system to improve palliative care. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Educating patients and their families is necessary for the improvement of palliative care. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree More studies and investigations must be conducted in this field in order to enhance the application of suitable palliative care. Totally agree Mostly agree Somewhat agree Unsure Disagree Page 13 of 13