J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 5 (2023) 1264 Journal of the Nigerian Society of Physical Sciences Solar Energy Storage by Fuel Cell Technology at Abomey-Calavi (Benin) Odilon Joseph Towanou, Hagninou Elagnon Venance Donnou, Gabin Koto N’Gobi∗, Augustin Enonsi Leodé, Basile Kounouhéwa Laboratoire de Physique du Rayonnement (LPR), Physics Department, University of Abomey-Calavi (UAC), Abomey-Calavi, Benin Republic Abstract West Africa has a great amount of sunshine power, varying between 5 kWh.m−2.day−1 and 7 kWh.m−2.day−1. This power constitutes high energy source in the region. However, several locations in that area have no access to energy because of the lack of suitable technology and projects exploiting the source. The fundamental problem related to sun power or to renewable energies in general is the lack of efficient technology for energy storage. Batteries are generally used for this storage, but once charged, the excess of the energy from the solar photovoltaic panels (PV) is lost. Therefore, it is very important to find a system to recover the excess in order to optimize its use. In this context, hydrogen is considered a very promising candidate to fulfill this function and could become a highly developed energy vector in the future. The very numerous works undertaken over the past decade for the production of electricity by hydrogen fuel cells bear witness to this. The objective of this study is to test a more reliable solar energy storage system by using fuel cell technology. To achieve this, three steps have been necessary: (i) make an electrolyser using materials, (ii) produce hydrogen using a system of PV panels and (iii) convert the hydrogen produced into electricity through a fuel cell. The results obtained indicate a production of 0.020m3 of hydrogen after 150 min with a yield of 85.86%. The production of electricity by a 2 V fuel cell gives an efficiency of 0.0042%. Even if this value is low, a part of the lost energy has been recovered. In view of these results, the improvement of the device for converting chemical energy into electricity deserves to be deeply explored in West Africa. DOI:10.46481/jnsps.2023.1264 Keywords: Hydrogen in Fuel Cell, Electrolysis, Energy storage, Benin Article History : Received: 30 November 2022 Received in revised form: 12 March 2023 Accepted for publication: 14 March 2023 Published: 22 April 2023 c© 2023 The Author(s). Published by the Nigerian Society of Physical Sciences under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0). Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article’s title, journal citation, and DOI. Communicated by: B. J. Falaye 1. Introduction In recent years, issues related to the energy transition and the carbon-free energy production have aroused several inter- ests and reflections [1]. Indeed, fossil fuels are more than ever, largely responsible for the pollution of the atmosphere and the main cause of global warming. The massive introduction of ∗Corresponding author tel. no: +22997228700 Email address: kotgabin36@yahoo.fr (Gabin Koto N’Gobi) electricity based on renewable energies such as solar energy in the production of power has therefore become a priority for the states. With the quick industrial advancement and decreasing costs, they will play an important role in future energy frame- works [2]. However, the development of these sources of en- ergy, with an intermittent regime, requires the use of reliable storage means in order to avoid the problem of destabilization of the distribution network and to make this production suit- able to consumer’s demand [1]. This has therefore led to the emergence of storage as a crucial element in the management 1 Towanou et al. / J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 5 (2023) 1264 2 of energy from renewable sources, allowing energy to be evac- uated into the grid during peak hours when it is more valuable. The use of energy storage techniques is then becoming increas- ingly essential to ensure the accessibility of electrical energy in remote regions [3]. Lead-acid batteries, which are among the most widely used solar components, cannot withstand high cycle rates, nor store a large amount of energy in a small vol- ume [3]. This is why other types of storage technologies are being developed and implemented. In this context, the hydro- gen synthesized from this renewable electricity is considered to be a fairly important storage vector [4]. The combination of solar PV and fuel cell power could offer a feasible solution to the challenge of continuous power supply, especially in geo- graphic areas where renewable resources are abundantly avail- able [4, 5], as in West Africa. The depletion of fossil fuel skocks consequently places hydrogen as one of the major energy carri- ers of the future and the electrolysis of water at low temperature indeed offers prospects for the future with high potential [6, 7]. Discovered by Sir William Grove in 1839, the concern of the fuel cell is not a recent technology. It has been the subject of numerous works since centuries. Today, several researchers and industrial companies are still working constantly, giving much more interest to hydrogen production in order to improve en- ergy storage’s performance. Authors, such as Faias et al. [8], Achkari & Fadar [3], Ibrahim et al. [9], Ofualagba et al. [10], Zhang et al. [11], Staffell et al. [12] , Okolie et al. [13], Yue et al. [14] found that fuel cell technology is too expensive to compete with cheap methods of generating and storing electricity, but its future de- velopment and its advantages need its integration into the list of the main suitable renewable energy sources. Other authors have demonstrated the interest of fuel cell application in micro grid systems, based on some attractive characteristics such as being a clean, non-polluting and highly flexible energy resource [5]. Pellow et al. [15] estimate that energy storage with a regener- ative hydrogen fuel cell represents an attractive technology to reach efficient energy storage. It can lead to the development of more sustainable, efficient and robust hybrid renewable en- ergy systems. According to Singla et al. [4] and Belmonte et al. [15], Benchrifa et al. [1], Derbal et al. [17], the production of hydrogen by thermochemical cycles is more promising than the conventional methods of reforming and gasification of fossil resources with the advantage of having lower impact on the en- vironment. Rabih [6] has contributed to a better understanding of the electrochemical phenomena, responsible of the storage and release of electricity as well as the conversion of chemi- cal energy into electrical energy. As for Akinsola et al. [18], they constructed a fuel cell using three different materials with different electrodes ((Bitter leaf and Copper electrodes (BCu), Bitter leaf and Carbon electrodes (BC) and Water leaf and Car- bon electrodes (WC)). The authors then noticed that the cells made from bitter leaf with a carbon electrode have the highest open circuit voltage, short circuit current and generated power and increase with time. It is clear that the storage of energy from the production of hydrogen by the electrolysis of water and its conversion into electricity via the fuel cell is a technol- ogy which deserves special attention for its use in the optimal evacuation of electrical energy produced from renewable en- ergy sources. Unfortunately, in Benin, as in many West African countries the technology is still at an embryonic stage and little work has focused on this domain of research in order to ensure its mastery such as the studies of Fopah-Lele et al. [19], Jumare [20]. The objective of this study is to produce hydrogen from the electrolysis of water in order to supply a fuel cell for the production of electricity. The renewable energy source used is a solar field installed to supply the Physics Department in the University of Abomey-Calavi. The electrolyser was made using a well-defined method with suitable materials. The quantity of hydrogen produced according to the chosen experimental pro- tocol is measured using a gas recorder and is stored in an air chamber. From a proton exchange fuel cell (PEM) powered by the air chamber, electricity is produced. Finally, the production yields of hydrogen and electricity are evaluated. 2. Materials and Methods 2.1. Materials 2.1.1. The electrolyser The production of hydrogen from the electrolysis of water requires the construction of an electrolyser. The material used for this purpose is presented in figure 1. It is composed of plexi- glass, vices, nuts, seals, stainless steel plates, a connection pipe, end fittings, a valve and an air chamber. 2.1.2. The Gas logger The gas recorder used during the experiment is presented in figure 2. Its essential characteristics are as follows: Pmax = 0.5bar; Qmax = 6m3.h−1; Qmin = 0.04m3.h−1; Qt = 0.6m3.h−1. 2.1.3. The Fuel cell Figure 3 shows the fuel cell (PHYWE, PEM fuel cell, Order Number : 06747.00, Germany) that was used to generate elec- tricity in this study. It is a proton exchange membrane (PEM) battery with a voltage equal to 2 V. 2.2. Methods The experimental protocol for the realization of the electrol- yser, production and storage of hydrogen as well as the produc- tion of electricity is presented in sections 2.2.1, 2.2.2 and 2.2.3. During the experiment, we can enumerate two phases which are not synchronized. First, hydrogen is produced and stored. Then this gas stored at the end of this first phase is used to pro- duce electricity. The yield calculation method for the various operations mentioned above is set out in section 2.2.4. 2.2.1. Realization of the electrolyser For the realization of the electrolyser, we first took the mea- surements of various samples of materials. The cutting of the stainless-steel plates and the plexiglass according to the dimen- sions (1cm by 1cm by 2mn thick for the stainless-steel plates and 13cm by 13cm by 1cm thick for the plexiglass) was carried out. The stainless-steel plates and the two pieces of Plexiglas 2 Towanou et al. / J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 5 (2023) 1264 3 Figure 1: Material used to build the electrolyser (a) Plexiglas, screws and nuts, (b) Gaskets, (c) Stainless steel plates, (d) Connection pipe, (e) End caps, (f) Valve and g ) inner tube Figure 2: Gas Logger Figure 3: Fuel cell : (a) view from the side and (b) View from the top have been perforated. The stainless-steel plates were then ar- ranged one after the other, leaving between them approximately 2 mm of space occupied by rubber seals serving as insulation. Everything is held together by the two pieces of plexiglas. We thus obtain the electrolyser illustrated in figure 4. Figure 4: Electrolyser : (a) view from the top, (b) view from the side 2.2.2. Production of hydrogen by the electrolysis of water A very specific protocol was followed for the production of hydrogen: • Measure a mass m= 4g of sodium bicarbonate in a tank; • Add 1.5 l of water to the same tank, shake to homogenize; • Carry out the assembly by placing a voltmeter in paral- lel with the terminals of the electrolyser to measure the electrical voltage; • Measure current intensity over time; • Close the circuit and start the stopwatch; • During the experiment, check and note the value of the voltage U and the intensity I; • Measure the amount of gas produced using the gas log- ger; • Estimate production time. The electrolyser is powered by a mini solar field made up of 8 power solar panels of 180 Wc each installed on the roof of the Physics Department. The current supplied by this source varies during the day. Figure 5 shows the assembly carried out as well as the the power source of the electrolyser. Under the effect of gravity, the mixture contained in the tank (1) reaches the level of the electrolyser (5) thanks to the connection pipe (3). This mixture undergoes the action of electric current to form a gaseous mixture consisting essentially of hydrogen and oxygen. This gaseous mixture reaches the bottom of the bottle containing water (7) where part of the oxygen dissolves, but the hydrogen which cannot dissolve rises to the surface creating bubbles. It thus continues on its way through the gas meter (8) to be finally stored in the air chamber (2). 2.2.3. Production of electricity by the fuel cell The production of electricity by the fuel cell takes place in several stages. It is: • Perform the purge (supply the cell with hydrogen for a few seconds to remove impurities from the cell); • Close the lower fuel cell valves; • Connect the hydrogen tank to the pipe on the anode side; 3 Towanou et al. / J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 5 (2023) 1264 4 Figure 5: : Hydrogen production and storage system: (1) Electrolytic solution tank, (2) Air chamber, (3) Connection pipe, (4) Multimeter, (5) Electrolyzer, (6) Current clamp, (7) Bottle containing water, (8) Gas logger • The pipe on the cathode side is supplied with oxygen from the air The fuel cell is therefore supplied at the anode by the hydrogen produced and at the cathode by the oxygen in the air. The latter mounted in series with a resistor allowed us to know the vari- ation of the voltage and the intensity produced by the battery as a function of time. Figure 6 presents an overview of the test bench made for the production of electricity. 2.2.4. Estimation of the efficiency of the electrolyser and the fuel cell During electrolysis of water, the amount of hydrogen re- leased responds to Faraday’s first law which states that the amount of substance released during electrolysis at an electrode is proportional to time and electric current. The amount of elec- tricity (Q) carried by a current (I) for a duration (∆t) is given by equation 1: Q = I × ∆t (1) The experiment lasted for ∆t =150 minutes for a average current evaluated at I = 1.64 A and an average voltage of U = 37 V. The hydrogen production yield is given by [21]: r1 = V (H2ex perimental) V (H2theorical) (2) V (H2ex perimental) is the volume of hydrogen produced by the electrolyser. The theoretical hydrogen volume V (H2)theorical is evaluated as follows: V (H2theorical) = nQVm zF (3) Vm is the molar volume (Vm = 24L.mol−1 ), F the Fara- day constant, F = 96,500C.mol−1 and z is the number of electrons necessary to produce a gas molecule. For hydrogen (2H+ + 2e− → H2), z = 2,n is the number of positive plates of the electrolyser. In the case of this study n is equal to 7. The efficiency of the fuel cell is given by the ratio between the energy supplied (E f ) by the cell and that received (Er ) during electrolysis: r2 = U I∆t U p IPt (4) Up is the average voltage of the fuel cell evaluated to 0.5 V and Ip the average current (0.1A), t is the duration of the electricity production experience by the fuel cell (480s). Figure 6: : Electricity production by the fuel cell 3. Results and discussion 3.1. Results 3.1.1. Evolution of hydrogen production The volume of hydrogen produced noted during the experi- ment enabled us to collect data on the evolution of this produc- tion over time. These data made it possible to obtain the figure 7. At the end of the 150 min of water electrolysis, a volume of 0.02 m3 of cumulative hydrogen was produced. This accu- mulation can be adjusted by simple linear regression. Three production accumulation phases can be reported (0-50min; 50- 100min; 100-150min). During the first 50 minutes, the cu- mulative volume of hydrogen has a lower slope evaluated at 8.8×10−5m3.min−1. The hydrogen production at the end of this period is estimated at 0.0044 m3 according to the graph in fig- ure 7. The following 50 min show a less marked linearity in the hydrogen production with a higher slope of the cumula- tion estimated at 1.12.10−4m3.min−1. Indeed, between 50 and 80 min, there is an increase in the accumulation of hydrogen evaluated at 39.73%. But between 80 and 90 min there is a sudden jump in the total from 0.0073 m3 to 0.0096 m3 evalu- ated at 23.95%. From 90 min to 100 min, there is a very slight increase in the cumulative gas production (0.096 to 0.01 m3). During the last phase (100 min to 150 min), the production of hydrogen doubled. It went from 0.01 m3 to 0.02 m3 with a slope of 2.10−4m3.min−1. We therefore observe an increase in the evolution slope of the cumulative hydrogen production from 8.8.10−5m3.min−1 to 2×10−4m3.min−1 during the three phases. The instantaneous quantity of hydrogen produced and stored is not constant but therefore increases over time. These results are confirmed by the work of Rabih [6]. 4 Towanou et al. / J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 5 (2023) 1264 5 Figure 7: : Evolution of the volume of hydrogen produced as a function of time 3.1.2. Variation of the intensity of the current at the level of the electrolyser During the hydrogen production phase, the intensity passing through the electrolyser varied as a function of time. Figure 8 illustrates this variation over the duration of the experiment. There is a fluctuation of the intensity of the current over time. It reaches its peak after 60 min of experimentation around 2.4 A. The lowest value of the intensity of the current after the start of the operation is 1.2 A observed after 140 min of hydro- gen production. This variation in the intensity of the current at the level of the electrolyser would be due to the intermittence of the sunshine which does not prevent the evolution of the pro- duction of hydrogen over time. During the experiment, it was also noticed that a decrease in the intensity of the current low- ers the production and that an increase leads to an increase in the production. This observation is true because the volume of hydrogen produced at each moment depends on the quantity of electricity. Moreover, in the work of Yue et al. [14], the authors state that a higher current defines a higher hydrogen production rate. 3.1.3. Production of electricity through the fuel cell During the experiment, the supplied current and the volt- age at the terminals of the fuel cell were measured. The data collected made it possible to obtain the graphs in figure 9. The voltage and the current intensity measured from the fuel cell show a variation in the form of a bell over time. These two electrical quantities evolve in an increasing way for a period of about 120 s where they reach their peak evaluated at 1.019 V and 0.25 A. After 120 s, the voltage and the intensity decrease until they cancel out after 480 s. As a result, a strong correlation is observed between these two electrical quantities. The voltage across the terminals of the fuel cell is therefore a linear function of the intensity of the current. These results are consistent with the work of Saı̈sset et al. [22] and Soldi et al. [21]. 3.1.4. Efficiency of water electrolysis and power generation The values of the efficiency of the water electrolysis oper- ation, of the electricity production by the fuel cell and of the Figure 8: : Current intensity as a function of time Figure 9: : Electrical quantities measured during the production of elec- tricity by the fuel cell as a function of time, a) Voltage produced by the fuel cell and b) Intensity produced by the fuel cell whole system are presented in Table 1. Table 1: Hydrogen and electricity production efficiency Hydrogen production Electricity production Fuel cell (Electrolyser) (Fuel cell) electrolyser Yield (%) 85.86 0.0042 0.36 The efficiency values of water electrolysis were estimated at 85.86%; that of the fuel cell at 0.0042% and the one of the electrolyser-fuel cell at 0.36%. These values are quite low, in particular those of the cell and consequently of the electrolyser- fuel cell system. This could be due to the different losses recorded during the process of transforming chemical energy into electrical energy. 3.2. Discussion The electrolysis of water efficiency values and the produc- tion of electricity by the fuel cell are compared with the results obtained in other similar studies encountered in the literature. The different yield values observed are summarized by authors in Table 2. The values of the production of hydrogen efficiency by the electrolysis of water proposed in the studies of Soldi et al. [21] and Laurencelle [24] are between 63 and 85%. These values are 5 Towanou et al. / J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 5 (2023) 1264 6 Table 2: Comparison of hydrogen and electricity production yields Authors Efficiency of Fuel cell Overall (Electrolyser) (%) Efficiency (%) performance (%) Yilanci et al.. [7] - - 0.88-9.7 Soldi et al. [21] 68.05-85.02 - 4.36-4.99 Tsakiris [23] - 59 23 Ogawa et al. [28] - 40-55 - Giddey et al. [30] - 35-45 - Gautam and Ikram [26] - 50-60 - Ceran [27] - - 25-45 Pellow et al. [15] - 47 30 Töpler and Lehmann [32] - 40 - Hodges et al. [31] - 55 35-39 quite close to that obtained in the present study which is 85.8% and thus confirm our results. In view of these results, the exper- imental protocol adopted for the realization of the electrolyser can be validated. Several other authors such as Tsakiris [23], Laurencelle [24], Cheung et al. [25], Gautam and Ikram [26], Pellow et al. [15], Ogawa et al. [28], Giddey et al. [30], Labbé [29], Hoogers [31], Töpler and Lehmann [32], Hodges et al. [33], Stolten et al. [34], Srinivasan [35] studied the power gen- eration efficiency of the proton exchange membrane fuel cell. The values proposed by these authors vary from 35% to 60% and are much higher than the yield obtained in this study, eval- uated at 0.0042%. It is therefore noted that the greatest losses observed are concentrated during the conversion of chemical energy into electrical energy via the fuel cell. They could be due to the fact that the electrolyser cells do not produce hydro- gen at the storage pressure. According to the work of Yilanci et al. [7], Soldi et al. [21], Tsakiris [23], Laurencelle [24], Ceran [27], Pellow et al. [15], Hodges et al. [33], Stolten et al. [34] the overall efficiency of electricity production from the proton exchange fuel cell is between 0.88% and 39%. This yield, even though low, is much higher than the yield of the present study estimated at 0.36% and is due to the very low yield observed at the level of the battery. However, it should be noted that ac- cording to Achkari and Fadar [3], even if the idea of storing energy in hydrogen is not desirable by the authors due to the low yield of the technology, they are convinced that the fuel cell is still likely to play a role in the future due to the large storage potential. Research efforts will undoubtedly lead to its large-scale use in the years to come. The system proposed in this study deserves to be improved in order to increase the effi- ciency of the conversion of chemical energy into electrical en- ergy. This involves, for instance, reviewing the heat exchange between the electrolyser cells and their environment, monitor- ing the increase in the operating temperature of the electrolyser and of the battery, which is generally a source of malfunction in system and gas storage pressure. 4. Conclusion In the present study, electricity was produced by a fuel cell fueled by hydrogen obtained by the electrolysis of water. An experimental protocol was followed both for the realization of the electrolyser and for the production of hydrogen and elec- tricity. The yields of these different operations were evaluated and compared with those proposed in the literature. The main results are as follows: • After 150 min of experimentation, a quantity of 0.02 m3 of hydrogen gas has been produced and the evolution curve of this production follows a simple linear regres- sion; • The voltage variation curve as a function of the intensity of the current measured at the terminals of the fuel cell is a linear function; • The gas and electricity production yields are evaluated at 85.86% and 0.0042% respectively. The overall effi- ciency of the electrolyser-fuel cell system is estimated at 0.36%. These values except those of the electrolyser are quite low and much lower than those encountered in the literature. In short, a part of the energy lost by renewable energy sys- tems via batteries can be recovered. The low yield obtained shows that it is necessary to improve the whole system, possibly size and design a fuel cell or optimize the storage of the hydro- gen produced. Significant research and development efforts re- main to be provided in order to improve the performance of our system and to identify applications that are well suited to their use. Hydrogen, as a storage element and as a fuel, offers a con- crete solution to the intermittency of renewable energy sources, energy losses in batteries and the depletion of fossil resources while respecting the environment. Acknowledgments The authors thank the Bachelor School in Renewable En- ergy of the Faculty of Science and Technology (FAST) at the University of Abomey-Calavi (UAC) through the ”Laboratoire de Physique du Rayonnement (LPR)” and the Abomey-Calavi University’s MasterCard foundation program for funding our participation to the 3rd German-West African Conference on Sustainable and Renewable Energy Systems (SusRES) at the University of Kara (Togo). References [1] R. Benchrifa, A. Bennouna & D. Zejli, “Rôle de l’hydrogène dans le stockage de l’électricité a base des énergies renouvelables”, Revue des Energies Renouvelables 7 (2007) 103. [2] S. A. Khalil, “Performance Evaluation and Statistical Analysis of Solar Energy Modeling: A Review and Case Study”, J. Nig. Soc. Phys. 4 (2022) 911. [3] O. Achkari, & A. El Fadar, “Renewable Energy Storage Technologies- A Review”, Proceedings of Engineering and Technology-PET 35 (2018) 69. 6 Towanou et al. / J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 5 (2023) 1264 7 [4] M. K. Singla, P. Nijhawan, & A. S. Oberoi, “Solar-PV and Fuel Cell Based Hybrid Power Solution for Remote Locations”, International Jour- nal of Engineering and Advanced Technology (IJEAT) 9 (2019) 861. [5] D. Akinyele, E. Olabode, & A. Amole, “Review of Fuel Cell Technolo- gies and Applications for Sustainable Microgrid Systems” Inventions 5 (2020) 42. [6] S. Rabih, “Contribution a la modélisation de systèmes réversibles de types électrolyseur et pile a hydrogène en vue de leur couplage aux générateurs photovoltaı̈ques”, Université Paul Sabatier de Toulouse (2008) 183. [7] A. Yilanci, I. Dincer, & H. K. Ozturk, “A review on solar-hydrogen/fuel cell hybrid energy systems for stationary applications”, Progress in En- ergy and Combustion Science 35 (2009) 231. [8] S. Faias, P. Santos, J. Sousa, & R. Castro, “An Overview on Short and Long-Term Response Energy Storage Devices for Power Systems Appli- cations” RE and PQJ 1 (2008) 442. [9] H. Ibrahima, A. Ilinca, & J. Perron, “Energy storage systems- Characteristics and comparisons”, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 12 (2008) 1221. [10] G. Ofualagba, I. K. Charles, & O. A. Okiemute, “Solar Hydrogen Fuel Cell Technology, Principle, Applications and Market”, Journal of Energy Technologies and Policy 2 (2012) 32. [11] F. Zhang, P. Zhao, M. Niub & J. Maddy, “The Survey of Key Technologies in Hydrogen Energy Storage”, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 41 (2016) 14535. [12] I. Staffell, D. Scamman, A. V. Abad, P. Balcombe, P. E. Dodds, P. Ekins, N. Shah & K. R. Ward, “The role of hydrogen and fuel cells in the global energy system”, Energy Environ Sci. 12 (2019) 463. [13] J. A. Okolie, B. R. Patra, A. Mukherjee, S. Nanda, A. K. Dalai, & J. A. Kozinski, “Futuristic applications of hydrogen in energy, biorefining, aerospace, pharmaceuticals and metallurgy”, International journal of hy- drogen energy 46 (2021) 8885. [14] M. Yue, H. Lambert, E. Pahon, R. Roche, S. Jemei, & D. Hissel, “Hy- drogen energy systems: A critical review of technologies, applications, trends and challenges”, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 146 (2021) 11118. [15] M. A. Pellow, C. J. M. Emmott, C. J. Barnhart, & S. M. Benson, “Hydro- gen or batteries for grid storage? A net energy analysis”, Energy Environ. Sci. 8 (2015) 1938. [16] N. Belmonte, C. Luetto, S. Staulo, P. Rizzi, & M. Baricco, “Case Studies of Energy Storage with Fuel Cells and Batteries for Stationary and Mobile Applications”, Challenges 8 (2017) 1. [17] H. Derbal, M. Belhamel & A. M’Raoui, “L’hydrogène, vecteur énergétique solaire”, Revue des Energies Renouvelables (2007) 235. [18] S. I. Akinsola, A. B. Alabi, M. A. Soliu, & T. Akomolafe, “Optimization of Method and Components of Enzymatic Fuel Cells”, Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 1 (2019) 143. [19] A. Fopah-Lele, A. Kabore-Kere, J. G. Tamba & I. Yaya-Nadjo, “Solar electricity storage through green hydrogen production: A case study”, International Journal of Energy Research 45 (2021) 13007. [20] I. A. Jumare, “Design of Standalone Photovoltaics (PV) / Biogas Hybrid Power System with Hydrogen Storage: Case of Northern Nigeria”, Inter- national Journal of Engineering Research Technology (IJERT) 8 (2019) 313. [21] B. Soldi, I. Gökalp, A. Zeroual, M. Aı̈t Lachgar et A. Aymard, “Concep- tion et réalisation d’un système de production d’hydrogène a l’aide d’un dispositif de catalyse”, Revue des Energies Renouvelables 12 (2009) 149. [22] R. Saı̈sset, G. Fontes, C. Turpin & S. Astier, “énergies renouvelables et pile a combustible dans l’enseignement pratique du génie électrique Jour- nal sur l’enseignement des sciences et technologies de l’information et des systèmes”, Hors-Série 4 (2005) 9. [23] A. Tsakiris, Analysis of hydrogen fuel cell and battery efficiency, World Sustainable Energy Days 2019, Young Energy Researchers Conference Wels/Austria, 2019. [24] F. Laurencelle, étude d’un système d’énergies Renouvelables a base d’hydrogène, Université du Québec a trois-rivières Mémoire de Master, 2001. [25] K. Y. Cheung, S. T. Cheung, R. G. De Silva, M. P. Juvonen, R. Singh, & J. J. Woo, Large-Scale Energy Storage Systems, Imperial College London, 2003. [26] D. Gautam, S. Anjum, & S. Ikram, “Proton Exchange Membrane (PEM) in Fuel Cells: A Review”, The IUP Journal of Chemistry 3 (2010) 51. [27] B. Ceran, “A comparative analysis of energy storage technologies”, En- ergy policy journal 21 (2018) 97. [28] T. Ogawa, M. Takeuchi, and Y. Kajikawa, “Comprehensive analysis of trends and emerging technologies in all types of fuel cells based on a computational method”, Sustainability 10 (2018) 458. [29] J. Labbé, L’hydrogène électrolytique comme moyen de stockage d’électricité pour systèmes photovoltaı̈ques isolés, l’Ecole des Mines de Paris, 2006. [30] S. Giddey, S. P. S. Badwal, A. Kulkarni, C. Munnings, “A comprehensive review of direct carbon fuel cell technology”, Progress in Energy and Combustion Science 38 (2012) 360. [31] G. Hoogers, Fuel Cell Technology Handbook, CRC Press: Boca Raton, FL, USA, 2002. [32] J. Töpler, & J. Lehmann, Hydrogen and Fuel Cell: Technologies and Market Perspectives, Springer: Berlin/Heidelberg, 2016. [33] J. Hodges, W. Geary, S. Graham, P. Hooker & R. Goff, Injecting hydrogen into the gas network-a literature search, Health and Safety Laboratory, Buxton, 2015. [34] D. Stolten, R. C. Samsun, & N. Garland, Fuel Cells - Data, Facts and Figures, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, 2015. [35] S. Srinivasan, Fuel cells: from fundamentals to applications, New York Springer, 2006. 7