J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 4 (2022) 848 Journal of the Nigerian Society of Physical Sciences The Type II Topp-Leone-G Power Series Distribution with Applications on Bladder Cancer Boikanyo Makubate∗, Broderick O. Oluyede, Marang Pearl Matsuokwane, Lesego Gabaitiri, Simbarashe Chamunorwa Botswana International University of Science and Technology, P. Bag 16, Palapye, Botswana Abstract Statistical distributions are important in modeling the real life of an item and therefore proper distributions that provide useful information for sound conclusions and decisions are needed. For that reason, the demand for developing new generalized distributions have become appropriate for data that have both monotonic and non-monotonic hazard rate functions. In this paper, we develop a new distribution called the Type II Topp-Leone-G Power Series (TIITLGPS) distribution by compounding the Type II Topp-Leone-G (TIITLG) distribution with the power series distribution. Statistical properties of the TIITLGPS distribution are obtained. A variety of shapes for the densities and hazard rate are presented of the considered special case. A simulation study to examine the efficiency of the maximum likelihood estimates is also conducted. Finally, the bladder cancer data example is analyzed for illustrative purposes, it is displayed that the introduced distribution provides better fit when compared to other non-nested distributions considered in this work. DOI:10.46481/jnsps.2022.848 Keywords: Type II Topp-Leone-G Distribution, Power Series Distribution, Maximum Likelihood Estimation. Article History : Received: 12 May 2022 Received in revised form: 16 July 2022 Accepted for publication: 20 July 2022 Published: 15 August 2022 c© 2022 The Author(s). Published by the Nigerian Society of Physical Sciences under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0). Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article’s title, journal citation, and DOI. Communicated by: B. J. Falaye 1. Introduction Statistical distributions are of tremendous importance in real lifetime analysis in various fields such as clinical studies, medical studies, biological studies and environmental studies, just to mention few. Several classical distributions have been derived over past years for modeling data. However, data aris- ing from public health and other areas may not fit the classical distributions. Therefore, modifications of the well-established distributions are highly recommended to obtain more flexible new families of distributions. These generalized distributions ∗Corresponding author tel. no: Email address: makubateb@biust.ac.bw. (Boikanyo Makubate ) have proved to be crucial in capturing heavily tailed, and where the hazard rate function is non-monotonic (uni-modal, bathtub, upside bathtub or upside bathtub followed by bathtub) and im- proving the goodness-of-fit in empirical distribution. Thus, in- creased demand in generating new families of distributions that provide flexibility in lifetime phenomenon data modeling. The Topp-Leone (TL) distribution, proposed by Topp and Leone [1] as a lifetime model, is one of the distributions used within the theory and practice of statistics. It has proven to be a useful lifetime model through its applicability in different fields such as medical and actuarial sciences. Ghitany et al. [2] stud- ied the TL distribution by providing some reliability measures while Vicaria et al. [3] introduced a two-sided generalized ver- sion of the TL distribution. Other various families of extended 1 Makubate et al. / J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 4 (2022) 848 2 distributions have been introduced. For instance, the Topp- Leone-Gompertz-G family by Oluyede et al. [4], the exponenti- ated Odd Weibull-Topp-Leone-G family by Chamunorwa et al. [5] and the type II Generalized Topp-Leone family by Hassan et al. [6]. For any baseline distribution, G(x; ψ), the cdf of the Type II Topp-Leone-G (TIITLG)[7, 8] family of distributions is given by FT I IT LG (x; b,ψ) = 1 − [1 − G 2(x; ψ)]b, (1) where b > 0 and ψ is a parameter vector. The survival function associated with 1 is given by S T I IT LG (x; b,ψ) = [1 − G 2(x; ψ)]b. (2) Suppose that a series system has N components at a given time where N is a discrete random variable with a power series distri- bution (truncated at zero) and probability mass function (pmf) P(N = n) = anθn C(θ) , n = 1, 2, ..., where an ≥ 0 depends only on n, C(θ) = ∑ ∞ n=1 anθ n and θ ∈ (0, s) (s can be ∞) is chosen such that C(θ) is finite and its three derivatives with respect to θ are defined and given by C′(.), C′′(.) and C′′′(.), respectively. The power se- ries family of distributions [9, 10, 11] includes Binomial, Pois- son, Geometric and Logarithmic distributions. Given N, sup- pose (X1, X2, ...XN ) ∼ T I IT LG are the independent and iden- tically distributed failure times of the N components. Let X=min(X1, ..., XN ), then the conditional cdf of X|N = n is given by FX|N=n(x) = 1 − [S T I I−T L−G (x; ψ)] n, x > 0. (3) The Type II Topp-Leone-G Power Series (TIITLGPS) class of distributions is defined by the marginal cdf of X. The cdf of X ∼ T I IT LGPS is given by FT I IT LGPS (x; θ, b,ψ) = 1 − C(θ(1 − G2(x; ψ))b) C(θ) . (4) Table 1 shows some sub-classes of the TIITLGPS distribution. The density function associated with equation (4) is given by fT I IT LGPS (x; θ, b,ψ) = 2bθg(x; ψ)G(x; ψ) ×[1 − G2(x; ψ)]b−1 C′ ( θ[1 − G2(x; ψ)]b ) C(θ) , (5) where C′(θ) = ∑ ∞ n=1 nanθ n−1. The hazard function (hrf) is given by hT I IT LGPS (x; θ, b,ψ) = 2bθg(x; ψ)G(x; ψ)[1 − G2(x; ψ)]b−1 C(θ(1 − G2(x; ψ))b) ×C′ ( θ[1 − G2(x; ψ)]b ) . The quantile function of the TIITLGPS distribution is given by Q(x) = G−1 (1 − [ C−1(C(θ)(1 − u)) θ ]1/b )1/2 , (6) where G−1 is the inverse of the baseline distribution. Note that, the TIITLG family of distribution defined in equation (1) is a limiting special case of the TIITLGPS class of distribu- tions when θ → 0+. Using the binomial expansion, we express the pdf in 5 as fT I IT LGPS (x; θ, b,ψ) = ∞∑ m=0 Vmgm(x; ψ), (7) where gm(x; ψ) = (2m + 2)g(x; ψ)G 2m+1(x; ψ) (8) is the Exp-G distribution with power parameter 2m + 2, and Vm = ∞∑ n=0 (−1)m2b(n + 1)a(n+1)θ(n+1) C(θ)(2m + 2) ( b(n + 1) − 1 m ) . (9) Thus, the statistical properties of the TIITLGPS class of dis- tributions including rth moment, incomplete moment, the mo- ment generating function, the rth moment of residual life, the rth moment of reversed residual life, mean deviations, Bonferroni curves and Lorenz curves can be obtained directly from those of the Exp-G family of the distributions. For, more informa- tion regarding the properties of Exp-G distributions the reader is refereed to [12-21]. The primary motivation for developing the Type II Topp-Leone- G Power Series (TIITLGPS) family of distributions is the ver- satility and flexibility derived from compounding continuous distributions in public health field. The proposed distribution exhibit both monotonic, non-monotic hazard rate functions and heavy tailed data sets, which is a common phenomenon with medical data especially cancer data. Figure 1b shows that the special case TIITLWP distribution can capture upside-down bathtub followed by bathtub and uni-modal shapes hazard rate function(s). Furthermore, from Bladder Cancer data modeling example presented, the introduced distribution captures well heavy tailed data and has better fit compared to some of the selected generalizations in this work. This paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 some mathe- matical properties of the new model are presented. Parameter estimation via the method of the maximum likelihood is given in Section 3. Some special models of TIITLGPS class of dis- tributions are presented in Section 4. In Section 5, a simulation study is done. Section 6 contain applications to bladder cancer data set. Concluding remarks are given in Section 7. 2. Some mathematical properties of the TIITLGPS 2.1. Moments and moment generating function This section discusses the rth moment, mth incomplete mo- ment, moment generating function and residual and reversed residual life of the TII-TL-GPS. The rth moment of the TII-TL- GPS can be represented as µr = E(X r ) = ∞∑ m=0 Vm ∫ ∞ 0 xr gm(x; ψ)d x (10) 2 Makubate et al. / J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 4 (2022) 848 3 Table 1. Sub-Classes of the TIITLGPS Distribution Distribution an C(θ) cdf Type II Topp-Leone G Poisson (n!)−1 eθ − 1 1 - e θ ( [1−G2 (x;ψ)]b ) −1 eθ−1 Type II Topp-Leone G Geometric 1 θ(1 − θ)−1 1 - ( [1−G2 (x;ψ)]b ) (1−θ) 1−θ ( 1−G2 (x;ψ) )b Type II Topp-Leone G Logarithmic n−1 − log(1 − θ) 1 - log ( 1−θ[1−G2 (x;ψ)]b ) log(1−θ) Type II Topp-Leone G Binomial ( m n ) (1 + θ)m − 1 1 - ( 1+θ[1−G2 (x;ψ)]b )m −1 (1+θ)m−1 where gm(x; ψ) and Vm are defined in (8) and (9) respec- tively and 2p+2 is the power parameter. The mth incomplete moment can be obtained in the following way µm(y) = ∞∑ p=0 Vp ∫ y 0 xr gp(x; ψ)d x. (11) The moment generating function of the TII-TL-GPS is rep- resented as: Mx(t) = E(e tx) = ∞∑ p=0 Vp ∫ ∞ 0 etxgp(x; ψ)d x. (12) We state the following two theorems and provide the proofs at https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wMwiSK60cj0unyRqA– pwFKBbWGaP9ta/view?usp=sharing. Theorem 2.1. Let X1, X2, .., Xm be a random sample of size m from the TIITLGPS class of distributions and X1:m < X2:m < ... < Xm:m denote the corresponding ordered random sample of size m. The pdf of the ith order statistic, Xi:m is given by fi:m(x) = ∞∑ s=0 ηsgs(x; ψ), where gs(x; ψ) = (2s + 2)g(x; ψ)G2s+1(x; ψ) is the Exp-G distri- bution with power parameter 2s + 2 and ηs = ∞∑ j,n,k,z=0 m! (i − 1)!(m − i)! × 2b(n + 1)a(n+1)θz+n+1(−1) j+k+sdz,k Ck+1(θ) × ( m − i j )( j + i − 1 k )( b(z + n + 1) − 1 s ) (2s + 2). Theorem 2.2. The Rényi entropy for TIITLGPS class of dis- tributions is given by IR(ν) = 1 1 −ν log  ∞∑ s=0 Wse (1−ν)IREG  , where IREG = 1 1 −υ log ( ∫ ∞ 0 [ ( 2s ν + 2)g(x; ψ)G 2s ν +1(x; ψ) ]ν d x ) is the Rényi entropy of Exp-G distribution with power parame- ter ( 2s ν + 2) and Ws = ∞∑ z=0 (2b)ν dz,νθ z+ν(−1)s ( b(ν + z) −ν s ) 1 ( 2s ν + 2)ν . 3. Maximum Likelihood estimation This section uses the method of maximum likelihood to es- timate unknown parameters of the TIITLGPS class of distribu- tions. Let x1, x2, ..., xn be a random sample from a TIITLGPS distribution given in equation (5), then the log-likelihood of the parameter vector φ = (b,θ,ψ)T is given by: `(φ) = nlog2 + nlogb + nlogθ + n∑ i=1 logG(xi; ψ) +(b − 1) n∑ i=1 log[1 − G2(xi; ψ)] −nlogC(θ) + n∑ i=1 logC′ ( θ[1 − G2(xi; ψ)] b ) . The components of the score function are obtained by finding the partial derivatives (with respect to the parameters θ, b and ψ, respectively). They are given by: Uθ = n θ − nC′(θ) C(θ) + n∑ i=1 ( C′′ ( θ[1 − G2(xi; ψ)]b )) [1 − G2(xi; ψ)] C′ ( θ[1 − G2(xi; ψ)]b ) , Ub = n b + n∑ i=1 [1 − G2(xi; ψ)] + n∑ i=1 ( C′′ ( θ[1 − G2(xi; ψ)]b )) C′ ( θ[1 − G2(xi; ψ)]b ) [1 − G2(xi; ψ)]b ×log[1 − G2(xi; ψ)] 3 Makubate et al. / J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 4 (2022) 848 4 and Uψ = (b − 1) n∑ i=1 1 [1 − G2(xi; ψ)] ∂[1 − G2(x; ψ)] ∂ψ + n∑ i=1 ∂G(xi ; psi) ∂ψ G(xi; ψ) + n∑ i=1 ∂g(xi ; psi) ∂ψ g(xi; ψ) + n∑ i=1 ( C′′ ( θ[1 − G2(xi; ψ)]b )) C′ ( θ[1 − G2(xi; ψ)]b ) ×2bθ[1 − G2(xi,ψ)] b−1G(xi; ψ) ∂G(xi; ψ) ∂ψ . Note that these equations are non-linear and can not be solved analytically, but can be solved numerically using software like R language. 4. Some Special Models This section considers and presents some special cases of the TIITLGPS class of distributions when the baseline distribu- tions are Weibull and Burr XII distributions. 4.1. Type-II-Topp-Leone-Weibull-Poisson (TIITLWP) Distribu- tion The cdf and pdf of the TIITLWP distribution are given by FT I IT LW P(x; θ, b,α,λ) = 1 − e ( θ [ 1− ( 1−e−λx α )2]b) −1 eθ − 1 and fT I IT LW P(x; θ, b,α,λ) = 2αbθλx α−1e−λx α ( 1 − e−λx α ) [ 1 − ( 1 − e−λx α )2]b−1 × e ( θ [ 1− ( 1−e−λx α )2]b) eθ − 1 , respectively, for θ, b,α,λ and x > 0. Figures 1(a) and 1(b) show the plots of the pdfs and hrfs, respec- tively, for the TIITLWP distribution for selected parameter val- ues. Plots of the TIITLWP pdf exhibit different shapes includ- ing almost symmetric, left-skewed, right-skewed, and reverse- J shapes. Plots of the hrf of the TIITLWP distribution show different shapes including increasing, decreasing, upside-down bathtub and uni-modal shapes. The cdf, pdf and plots (pdf and hrfs plots) of Type- II-Topp-Leone-Weibull-Geometric (TIITLWG), Type-II-Topp- Leone-Burr XII-Poisson (TIITLBXIIP), Type-II-Topp-Leone- Burr XII-Geometric (TIITLBXIIG) distributions can be seen at https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wMwiSK60cj0unyRqA– pwFKBbWGaP9ta/view?usp=sharing. (a) (b) Figure 1. Pdfs and hrfs plots for the TIITLWP distribution 5. Simulation Study In this section, we conduct Monte Carlo simulation study to assess the performance of maximum likelihood estimates of the TIITLWP distribution. We generated N=1000 samples of size n= 100, 200, 400 and 800 with the help of the R package. We consider simulations for the following sets of initial parameters values (I: α = 1.0, b = 0.5,λ = 1.5,θ = 1.0), (II: α = 0.5, b = 0.5,λ = 0.5,θ = 1.0), (III: α = 1.5, b = 0.5,λ = 0.5,θ = 1.0), and (IV: α = 0.5, b = 4 Makubate et al. / J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 4 (2022) 848 5 Table 2. Parameter estimates and goodness-of-fit statistics for various models fitted for cancer patients data set Estimates Statistics Model α b λ θ −2 log L AIC AICC BIC W∗ A∗ K-S p-value TIITLWP 0.7361 3.0338 0.0749 3.6985 819.4 827.4 827.8 838.9 0.0226 0.1495 0.0371 0.9945 (0.1340) (8.2303) (0.1021) (2.4628) α λ γ θ OWTLLLoGL 1.0089 0.4757 9.7751 1.2905×10−9 826.4 834.4 834.7 845.8 0.0925 0.6058 0.0574 0.7930 (0.3164) (0.1060) (3.1140) (0.0033) p α β λ EGEL 1.0729×10−8 0.8922 1.1774 1.3292 826.2 834.2 834.6 845.6 0.1135 0.6819 0.0707 0.5442 (0.0095) (0.6760) (0.1426) (10.0710) a b α β EPLP 5.8448×10−8 0.5647 0.82441 2.7914 820.9 828.9 829.2 840.3 0.0391 0.2563 0.0428 0.9733 (0.0196) (0.1021) (0.3150) (1.3114) c s α λ EBXIIP 1.0223 1.5133 1.9338 7.8251×10−9 871.7 879.7 880.0 891.1 0.2452 1.600 0.2481 2.872×10−7 (0.0902) (0.2426) (0.2105) (0.0085) a b λ θ BOL-U 1.1799 2.8446 3.2800 ×105 7.6115 ×106 826.4 834.4 834.7 845.8 0.1186 0.7117 0.0734 0.4955 (0.1329) (0.3599) (3.1630 ×10−6) (1.3631 ×10−7) β λ θ γ ELOLLoGW 6.1173×10−5 0.0378 2.9053 1.0478 828.2 836.2 836.5 847.6 0.1314 0.7864 0.0700 0.5573 (0.4015) (0.0061) (8.4383 ×10−5) (0.0676) (a) (b) Figure 2. Fitted densities and probability plots for cancer patients data 1.0,λ = 1.5,θ = 0.5). Simulation results are shown at https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wMwiSK60cj0unyRqA– pwFKBbWGaP9ta/view?usp=sharing. The results show that as the sample size increases, the estimates approach the true parameter values, since root mean square errors (RMSE) and average bias decays toward zero for all the parameters. 6. Applications and Discussion In this section, we demonstrate the applicability of the TIITLWP distribution to bladder cancer data set. We compared the TIITLWP distribution to six non-nested models. We use the nlm function in R software to estimate model parameters. We present the model parameters estimates (standard errors in parenthesis) and the goodness-of-fit-statistics. We assessed model performance using -2loglikelihood (-2 log L), Akaike Information Criterion (AIC), Consistent Akaike Information Criterion (AICC), Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC), Cramer-von-Mises (W∗), and Andersen-Darling (A∗) (see Chen and Balakrishnan [23] for details). These statistics are used to verify which model fits the given data well. The smaller the values of these statistics, the better the model. Kolmogorov-Smirnov (K-S) statistic (and its p-value) and sum of squares (SS) from probability plots were also used to assess the fit of the model. The smaller the KS value and the higher the p-value for the K-S statistic the better the model. Tables 2 shows model parameters estimates (standard errors in parentheses) and several goodness-of-fit statistics. Figure 2 shows fitted densities and probability plots (as described by Chambers et al. [22]) to demonstrate how well our model fits the selected data sets. The non-nested models considered in this paper are the exponentiated generalized logarithmic (EGEL) distribution by 5 Makubate et al. / J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 4 (2022) 848 6 Oluyede et al. [24], odd Weibull-Topp-Leone-log logistic log- arithmic (OWTLLLoGL) distribution by Oluyede et al. [25], exponentiated power Lindley Poisson (EPLP) distribution by Pararai et al. [21], exponentiated Burr XII Poisson (EBXIIP) distribution by da Silva et al. [12], beta odd Lindley-Uniform (BOL-U) distribution by Chipepa et al. [26] and exponential Lindley odd log-logistic Weibull (ELOLLoGW) distribution by Korkmaz[15]. The pdfs of the non-nested models can be seen at https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wMwiSK60cj0unyRqA– pwFKBbWGaP9ta/view?usp=sharing. For the EBXIIP and ELOLLW distributions we consider k = 1 and α = 1, respectively. 6.1. Bladder Cancer Patients Data This data set represents remission times of a random sample of 128 bladder cancer patients. For more information regard- ing the bladder cancer data set, Lee and Wang [27] is recom- mended. From the values of the goodness-of-fit statistics A∗, W∗, K-S and the p-value of the K-S statistic as shown in Table 2, we conclude that the TIITLWP model performs better than the non- nested models considered in this paper. Figures 2(a) and 2(b) show the fitted densities and probability plots for the TIITLWP model. We observe that the TIITLWP model has better fit to ex- treme tailed data compared to the selected competitive models. 7. Conclusions The demand of developing new families of distributions from classical ones has been of interest among authors in the past years. A new distribution called the TIITLGPS distribu- tion is developed which combines the TIITL-G with the power series to provide compound TIITL-GPS family of distributions with better performance compared to selected models. We study some of mathematical properties of the new family of dis- tributions, such as ordinary moment, quantile functions, order statistics and Rényi entropy. We discuss maximum likelihood estimates of the model parameters for bladder cancer data. Ad- ditionally, the performance of the MLEs of the two selected members is assessed via Monte Carlo simulation studies based on two criteria; bias and RMSE. The study exhibits a good per- formance when estimating the parameters of the proposed fam- ily using the maximum likelihood method. Finally, the special case of the new distribution applied to the bladder cancer data set and a simulation study demonstrate its usefulness and poten- tiality to analysis of lifetime data. We hope that the proposed distribution will attract wider application in various fields such as health, survival and lifetime data, finance, insurance, among others. Future Work • Take into consideration bivariate extensions of proposed model via copulas like the Farlie-Gumbel-Margestern Copulas, Ali-Mikhail-Haq copula, Clayton copula and Rényi entropy copula. • Apply different parameter estimation techniques such as Bayesian technique, weighted least squares (WLS), max- imum product of spacings (MPS) on the proposed mod- els. Limitations • We derive mathematical and statistical properties from the exponentiated G distribution cause its a bit compli- cated to derive them straight from the TIITLGPS pdf. • The model can not perform well on some data sets. References [1] C. W. Topp & F. C. Leone, ”A Family of J-shaped Frequency Func- tions”, Journal of the American Statistical Association 50 (1955) 209. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/01621459.1955.10501259. [2] M. E. Ghitany, S. Kotz & M. Xie, ”On Some Reliability Mea- sures and their Stochastic Orderings for the Topp-Leone Dis- tribution”, Journal of Applied Statistics 32 (2005) 715. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02664760500079613 [3] D. Vicaria, J. R. V. Dorp & S. Kotz, ”Two-Sided Generalized Topp and Leone (TS-GTL) Distributions”, Journal of Applied Statistics 35 (2008) 1115. [4] B. Oluyede, S. Chamunorwa, F. Chipepa & M. Alizadeh, ”The Topp-Leone-Gompertz-G Family of Distributions with Applica- tions”, Journal of Statistics and Management Systems (2022) DOI https://doi.org/10.1080/09720510.2021.1972623. [5] S. Chamunorwa, B. Oluyede, B. Makubate & F. Chipepa ”The exponen- tiated Odd Weibull-Topp-Leone-G Family of Distributions: Model, Prop- erties and Applications”, Pakistan Journal of Statistics 37 (2021) 143-158. Doi: https://www.pakjs.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/372-05.pdf. [6] A. Hassan, M. Elgarhy, & A. Zubair, ”Type II Generalized Topp-Leone Family of Distributions: Properties and Applications”, Journal of data science: JDS (2019) doi: 10.6339/JDS.201910 17(4).0001. [7] A. Al-Shomrani, O.Arif, A. Shawky, S. Hanif & M. Q. Shahbaz, ”Topp Leone Family of Distributions: Some Properties and Application”, Pak- istan Journal of Statistics and Operation Research 12 (2016) 443. DOI: 10.18187/pjsor.v12i3.1458. [8] M. Elgarhy, M. Arslan Nasir, F.Jamal & G. Gamze Ozel, ”The Type II Topp-Leone Generated Family of Distributions : Properties and Applica- tions”, Journal of Statistics and Management Systems 21 (2018) 1529- 1551. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09720510.2018.1516725. [9] N. L. Johnson, S. Kotz & N. Balakrishnan, Continuous Distributions, Vol- ume 1, John Wiley and Sons, New York, NY (1994). [10] B. Makubate, B. Oluyede & M. Gabanakgosi, ”A New Lindley-Burr XII Distribution: Model, Properties and Applications”, International Journal of Statistics and Probability 10 (2021) 33. DOI:10.5539/ijsp.v10n4p33 [11] B. Makubate, B. Oluyede & G. Motsewabagale, ”Dagum Power Series Class of Distribution with Applications to Lifetime Data”, Research and Reviews: Journal of Statistics and Mathematical Sciences, 92 (2019) 76. [12] R. V. da Silva, F. Gomes-Silva, M. W. A. Ramos, G. M. Cordeiro & E. M. M. Ortega, ”The Exponentiated Burr XII Poisson Distribution with Ap- plication to Lifetime Data”, International Journal of Statistics and Proba- bility 347 (2015) 1399. [13] R. C. Gupta, P. L. Gupta & R. D. Gupta, ”Modeling failure time data by Lehmann alternatives”,Comm. Statist. Theory Methods 27 (1998) 887. [14] R. D.Gupta & D. Kundu, ”Generalized exponential distributions”, Aust.N.Z.J.Stat. 41 (1999) 173-188. [15] M. C. Korkmaz, H. M. Yousof & Hamedani, G. G., ”The Exponential Lindley Odd Log-Logistic-G Family: Properties, Characterizations and Applications”, Journal of Statistical Theory and Applications 17 (2018) 554-571.DOI: https://doi.org/10.2991/jsta.2018.17.3.10 [16] G. S. Mudholkar & D. K. Srivastava, ”Exponentiated Weibull family for analysing bathtub failure rate data”, IEEE Trans. Reliab. 42 (1993) 299. [17] G. S. Mudholkar, D. K. Srivastava & Freimer, M., ”The Exponentiated Weibull family: A reanalysis of the bus-motor-failure data”, Technomet- rics 37 (1995) 436. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/1269735 6 Makubate et al. / J. Nig. Soc. Phys. Sci. 4 (2022) 848 7 [18] S. Nadarajah, ”The Exponentiated Gumbel distribution with climate application”, Environmetrics 17 (2005) 13-23. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/env.739 [19] S. Nadarajah & Kotz, S., ”The Exponentiated-type distributions”, Acta Appl. Math. 92 (2006) 97-111. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10440-006- 9055-0 [20] S. Nadarajah & A. K.Gupta, ”The Exponentiated gamma distribution with application to drought data”, Calcutta Statist. Assoc. Bull. 59 (2007) 29. [21] M. Pararai, G. Warahena-Liyanage & B.Oluyede, ”Exponentiated Power Lindley Poisson Distribution: Properties and Application”, Commu- nications in Statistics-Theory and Methods 46 (2017) 4726, doi: 10.1080/03610926.2015.1076473. [22] J. Chambers, W. Cleveland, B. Kleiner & P. Tukey, ”Graphical Methods of Data Analysis”, Chapman and Hall (1983) [23] G. Chen & N. Balakrishnan, ”A General Purpose Approximate Goodness- of-Fit Test”, Journal of Quality Technology 27(1995) 154. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00224065.1995.11979578 [24] B. Oluyede, B. Mashabe, A. Fagbamigbe, B. Makubate & D. Wan- duku, ”The Exponentiated Generalized Power Series: Family of Distri- butions: Theory, Properties and Applications”, Heliyon, 6 (2020) doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2020.e04653. [25] B. Oluyede, F. Chipepa & D. Wanduku, ”The Odd Weibull-Topp-Leone- G Power Series Family of Distributions: Model, Properties, and Applica- tions”, Journal of Nonlinear Science and Application 14 (2021) 60. doi: 10.22436/jnsa.014.04.06. [26] F. Chipepa, B. Oluyede & B. Makubate, ”A New Generalized Family of Odd Lindley-G Distributions with Application”, International Journal of Statistics and Probability 8 (2019) doi:10.5539/ijsp.v8n6p1. [27] E. T.Lee & J. W. Wang, Statistical Methods for Survival Data Analysis, 3rd Edn., John Wiley and Sons, New York, ISBN: 9780471458555 (2003) 534. 7