The Effects of Application of Erythrina bruci Biomass and Inorganic Fertilizers .......... Journal of Tropical Crop Science Vol. 10 No. 2, June 2023 www.j-tropical-crops.com 139 The Effects of Application of Erythrina bruci Biomass and Inorganic Fertilizers On Wheat Productivity in Southwestern Ethiopia. Zelalem Addis Musse* South Agricultural Research Institute in Bonga Agricultural Research Center, P.O. Box 101, Bonga, Ethiopia *Corresponding author; email: zelalemaddis660@gmail.com Abstract Soil fertility depletion is emerging as a serious challenge causing low crop yields and food insecurity in Ethiopia. An experiment was conducted in two cropping seasons 2016 to 2018 to investigate the effects of the application of Erythrina biomass and nitrogen fertilizer on soil properties and wheat yields in southwestern Ethiopia. Treatments were the recommended N and P fertilizers, 50% of the standard rate of Erythrina + 50% of the recommended N, 25% Erythrina + 75% N, 75% of the standard rate of Erythrina + 25% of the standard rate of N, 100% of the standard rate of Erythrina, and 50% of the standard rate of Erythrina, and without fertilizer as the control. The experiment was arranged in a randomized complete block design with three replications. Application of Erythrina and nitrogen fertilizer increased soil organic carbon (OC), total nitrogen (TN), and cation exchange capacity (CEC) compared to before fertilizer application or the control. Plots amended with 25% Erythrina + 75% of the recommended N provided the highest above ground biomass (8.98 t.ha-1) and grain yield (3.453 t.ha-1) and it was higher than the 100% chemical fertilizer treatment. Conversely, the lowest above ground biomass (5.44 t.ha-1) and grain yields (1.958 t.ha-1) were obtained from the control. Our study demonstrated that an integrated nutrient management which combines organic and chemical fertilizer can improve soil properties and increase wheat yield in the highlands of southwestern Ethiopia. Keywords: organic amendment, soil properties, organic fertilizer, leguminous trees Introduction Soil fertility depletion is emerging as a serious challenge causing low crop yields and food insecurity in Ethiopia. The decline in soil fertility is the main challenge to crop production in the South Region. Continuous cultivation, inadequate application of organic nutrient sources, and soil erosion account for reduced soil fertility (Tamado and Mitiku, 2017). Organic fertilizers can improve the physico-chemical properties of the soil (Abiy, 2018). The use of organic fertilizers such as farmyard manures, compost, green manures, and biomass of leguminous trees is an alternative way to improve soil fertility and soil physical properties (Abebe, 2018). Wassie (2012) reported that application of Erythrina biomass at 10 t.ha-1 + half of the recommended rate of N and P, or 23 kg.ha-1 of N and 23 kg.ha-1 of P increased wheat grain yield by 189%. In addition, the cost of inorganic fertilizer could be reduced by half using Erythrina biomass as organic supplement while obtaining superior yield of wheat than either source applied alone. Erythrina is one of the locally available trees and can be used as the source of organic matters for the crop. Erythrina is grown as live fence and farm boundary plant at Chena Woreda of Kaffa Zone. It is a legume species, an N-fixing, easily propagate, nutrient rich leguminous tree and can be easily exploited as source of organic source fertilizer by small scale farmers for crop production and soil fertility amendment. Application of inorganic fertilizers has been promoted to overcome low soil fertility and reduced crop yields. The raising costs of fertilizers with lack of financial resources farmers limits the required use of inorganic fertilizers for optimum yield. Moreover, the efficiency of the chemical nitrogen fertilizers is very low in Ethiopia, and it varies with crops, soil types, and management practices. Therefore, it is important to study if the application of organic in combination with inorganic fertilizers can improve soil fertility, increase nutrient use efficiency and crop yield. Several studies have shown that green manure and leguminous trees could improve soil fertility and increase crop yields. However, this practice has not widely adopted and used in Ethiopia. One of the possible reasons could be the exotic origin of the plants species with farm-level hesitancy for adopting. Journal of Tropical Crop Science Vol. 10 No. 2, June 2023 www.j-tropical-crops.com 140 Zelalem Addis Musse The other reason is the limited effort made by researchers and extension personnel to identify and deploy them in the right niches (Wassie et al., 2009). Leaves of Erythrina are commonly used as animal feed during dry season and its litter is excellent source of organic matter that can maintain soil fertility (Eyasu, 2002). However, the information is scarce on the use of Erythrina for improving soil fertility. So, it is essential to study the effect of application Erythrina biomass alone or in combination with the inorganic fertilizers on the yield of wheat in the south region to determine the effects of Erythrina biomass and inorganic fertilizers for wheat production. Material and Methods Description of Study Area The experiment was conducted at Chena District of Kaffa Zone, South-Western Ethiopia, in 2016-2018 main cropping seasons, i.e. from July to November. The site in Chena district is located at latitude of 7°05.67´ N, longitude of 35°42.989´ E and altitude of 2135 meters above sea level. The rainfall pattern of this area is characterized by bimodal distribution with small rainy season ‘Belg’ (March-June) and main rainy seasons ‘Meher’ (July-November). The average annual rainfall data from Wushwush Meteorological Station was 1367 mm. The maximum temperature of cropping season varied from 22.1 to 26.60C; the minimum temperature varied from 10.0 to 13.10C. The soil analysis of the study sites before sowing of the crop showed that the soil texture of the experimental fields was clay loam with medium CEC, low organic carbon content, total N, and available P (Table 1). Experimental Design and Experimentation The experiment was conducted in 2016-2018 on the farmers‘ field of Chena Woreda of Kaffa Zone. Wheat variety “Daphe” was used as a test crop. A cultural practice was carried out based on the recommendation of the crop (Wasihun, 2022). The experiment consists of seven treatments: control (no fertilizer), recommended N and P (46 kg.ha-1 of N, 46 kg.ha-1 of P), 50% of the recommended rate of Erythrina + 50% of the recommended rate of N, 25% of the recommended rate of Erythrina + 75% of the recommended rate of N, 75% of the recommended rate of Erythrina + 25% of the recommended rate of N, 100% of the recommended rate of Erythrina and 50% of the recommended rate of Erythrina. The experiments was laid out in randomized block design with three replication (plot). Each plot was 5m x 5m (25 m2) with the net harvestable area of 4 m x 4 m (16 m2) having 1 m space between plots and 1 m between blocks. Rows were being spaced 0.2 m interval. All data was subjected to analysis of variance. Sources of N and P was urea and triple super phosphate (TSP). Half dose of P and N were applied at planting and the remaining half dose was applied 35 days later. Erythrina biomass consisting of young leaves and twigs were chopped into small Figure 1. Geographical location of the study area at Chena District of Kaffa Zone, South-Western Ethiopia. The Effects of Application of Erythrina bruci Biomass and Inorganic Fertilizers .......... Journal of Tropical Crop Science Vol. 10 No. 2, June 2023 www.j-tropical-crops.com 141 pieces to enhance decomposition. The chopped parts were then incorporated into the soil one month before planting of testing crop. A total of 15 composite soil samples from 15 spots, collected from 0-20 cm soil depth, were taken using auger before planting for analysis of texture, pH, CEC (cation exchange capacity), OC (organic carbon), total N (total nitrogen), and the available P. Erythrina Nutrient Analysis Erythrina leaves and twigs were sampled from six randomly selected healthy trees for nutrient analysis. Three branches were selected, the lower, the middle and the upper tree canopy. The samples were mixed and composite samples were analyzed for N, P and K content. Samples were air dried and milled to pass through 1 mm diameter mesh size. Total N content was analyzed using micro-Kjeldahl’s method and P and K contents was determined using dry ashing methods that described by Anderson and Ingram (1996). The young twigs and leaves of Erythrina bruci contain 4.83% N, 0.38% P and 2.24% K. Plant Growth Measurements Agronomic parameters including tiller number, grain yield, above-ground biomass, plant height, spike length and thousand seed weight were measured. The data were subjected to analysis of variance using the SAS system version 9.4 (SAS, 2000) and the significance of means was established using the least significant difference method (LSD). Results and Discussion Soil Analysis Results The soil properties after the application of treatments was shown in Table 2. The soil chemical properties (organic carbon, total nitrogen, available phosphorus, and CEC had changed compared to before planting. Integration of leguminous tree and inorganic fertilizer increases both CEC and organic carbon in the soil. The changes in CEC and organic carbon indicated that Erythrina biomass was decomposing and contributed nutrients to the soil. Effects of Erythrina Biomass and Chemical Fertilizer Application on Wheat Yield and Yield Components The effects of Erythrina biomass on wheat yield and yield component in both years are significant (P <0.05, Table 3). The maximum grain yield (3.453 t.ha-1), above ground biomass (8.98 t.ha-1) and tiller number (8.22) was obtained by the application of 25% Erythrina with 75% N as compared to control that gives the lowest yields (Table 3). Application of 100% Erythrina gives the highest spike length and Table 1. Initial soil physicochemical characteristics of the experimental sites. Soil parameters Value Rating References Textural class Clay loam - pH 6.03 Slightly acidic Hazelton and Murphy (2007) Organic carbon (%) 1.52 Low Hazelton and Murphy (2007) Total N (%) 0.11 low Tekalign (1991) Available P (mg.g-1) 7.10 Low Tekalign (1991) CEC (cmol.kg-1) 18.05 Medium Landon (1991) Table 2. Soil properties after Erythrina + chemical fertilizer application Treatment pH-H2O OC (%) TN (%) CEC (me.100g-1) Av.P (ppm) Control 5.05 3.57 0.31 18.4 4.21 Recommended NP 5.86 4.81 0.42 25.6 3.67 50% Erythrina + 50% N 6.05 5.00 0.42 23.2 5.05 25% Erythrina + 75% N 5.76 4.28 0.37 21.8 4.68 75% Erythrina + 25% N 5.93 4.95 0.42 24.0 4.87 100% Erythrina N 6.02 5.47 0.48 25.8 4.11 50% Erythrina N 5.77 3.57 0.31 20.4 3.18 Note: OC=organic carbon, TN=total nitrogen, CEC=cation exchange capacity, Av.P =available phosphorus; 100% Erythrina = 4 t.ha-1 fresh biomass. Journal of Tropical Crop Science Vol. 10 No. 2, June 2023 www.j-tropical-crops.com 142 Zelalem Addis Musse plant height as compared to control. The increase of plant height and spike length in response to the increasing N from both Erythrina and nitrogen may be accredited to the increase of availability of N that enhanced wheat vegetative growth. Our results agree with Moniruzzaman et al. (2009) who recorded maximum plant height of French snap bean from the application of 120 kg N.ha-1 and the minimum height was recorded from the control treatment. Another finding conducted by Mostafa and Zohair (2014) demonstrated that application of 100 kg N.ha-1 and chicken manure to snap bean in sandy soil significantly increased plant height by scoring the highest value (22.8) as compared to control (11.7). On the other hand, one-thousand seed weight (TSW) was significantly affected at (P<0.05) by the application 50% Erythrina with nitrogen. Maximum value of the one-thousand seed weight (44.37 g) was recorded from the application of 50% Erythrina as compared to control treatment (Table 3). The result agrees with Hossain et al. (2018) who reported that an application of combined organic (5 t.ha-1 bio-slurry) and inorganic fertilizers increasing one-thousand seed weight in treated plots over the control/untreated plots. Conclusion Our study demonstrated that application of Erythrina biomass at 25% of the recommended dose combined with 75% nitrogen (34.5 kg.ha-1 N) resulted in the highest yield and yield components, and it was higher over the 100% chemical fertilizer treatment. These results showed that the requirements for the chemical nitrogen could be reduced by the application of Erythrina biomass. Therefore, application of 1 t.ha-1 Erythrina biomass with 34.5 kg.ha-1 N inorganic nitrogen can be suggested for wheat production in Chena District of Kaffa Zone, South-Western Ethiopia. Future studies should be conducted across similar agro-ecologies to potentially reduce the use of chemical fertilizer without reducing yields. Acknowledgments The author thank Bonga Agricultural Research Center for their supports and facilitation of the study and publication. References Abebe, A. (2018). Nitrogen release dynamics of Erythrina abyssinica and Erythrina brucei litter as influenced by polyphenol, lignin and nitrogen contents. Journal of Environment and Earth Science 8, 11-19. Abiy, G., Getahun, Y., and Shiferaw, B. (2018). Effect of different rates of Erythrina biomass transfer combined with different nitrogen and phosphorus rates on yield and yield components of wheat at Masha Woreda, Southwestern Ethiopia. International Journal of Research in Agricultural Sciences 5, 2348- 3997. Anderson, J.M. and Ingram, S.J. (1996). “Tropical Soil Biology and Fertility: A Handbook of Methods” 2nd edition. CAB International, Oxford, UK. Table 3. Effect of Erythrina and chemical fertilizer on yield and yield component on wheat Treatments PH (cm) TN SL (cm) TSW (g) Above ground biomass (t.ha-1) Grain yield (t.ha-1) Control 75.62b 4.75c 7.30b 35.32d 5.44c 1.958c Recommended NP 78.77ab 6.77b 7.85a 42.42ab 7.78ab 2.887b 50% Erythrina+ 50% N 80.47a 6.90ab 7.77a 42.03ab 7.96ab 2.963ab 25% Erythrina+ 75% N 78.28ab 8.22a 7.52ab 37.80cd 8.98a 3.453a 75% Erythrina + 25% N 76.53b 6.73b 7.66ab 41.62ab 7.67ab 3.021ab 100% Erythrina 80.68a 6.52b 7.78a 40.40bd 7.68ab 2.993ab 50% Erythrina 77.60ab 6.03bc 7.65ab 44.37a 7.06ab 2.766b LSD 1.83 0.72 0.22 1.98 0.641 0.274 CV% 3.68 17.41 4.55 7.69 13.47 15.09 Note: Means followed by the same letter (s) within the column are not significantly different according to LSD at P ≤ 0.05. PH= plant height, TN= tiller number, SL= spike length, TSW = one-thousand seed weight. The treatment of 100% Erythrina equals 4 t.ha-1 Erythrina biomass; the recommended NP is 46 kg N.ha-1 or 100 kg.ha-1 Urea, and 46 kg.ha-1 P2O5 or 100 kg.ha -1 TSP. The Effects of Application of Erythrina bruci Biomass and Inorganic Fertilizers .......... Journal of Tropical Crop Science Vol. 10 No. 2, June 2023 www.j-tropical-crops.com 143 Eyasu, E. (2002). “Farmer’s Perception of Soil Fertility Change and Management”. SOS SAHEL and Institute of Sustainable Development, Addis Ababa. Ethiopia. Hazelton, P., and Murphy, B. (2007). “Interpreting Soil Test Results: What Do All The Numbers Mean?” 2nd ed. 152p. CSIRO Publishing. Hossain, M.N, Sarker, U.K., Uddin, M.R., Rehana, S., Hoque M.M.I., and Islam, M.A. (2018). Effects of bio-slurry with chemical fertilizer on the performance of some high yielding varieties of Boro rice (Oryza sativa L.). Journal of Archives of Agriculture and Environmental Science 3, 109-115. Landon, J.R. (1991). "Tropical Soil Manual: Handbook for Soil Survey and Agricultural Land Evaluation in the Tropics and Sub- tropics." Longman Scientific and Technical, Longman Group. United Kingdom. Moniruzzaman, M., Halim, G.M.A., and Firoz, Z.A. (2009). Performances of French bean as influenced by plant density and nitrogen application. Journal of Agricultural Research 34, 105-111. Mostafa, N.F., and Zohair, M.M. (2014). Influence of organic nitrogen on the snap bean grown in sandy soil. International Journal of Agriculture and Biology 16, 65-72. Tamado,T., and Mitiku, W. (2017). Effect of combined application of organic and mineral nitrogen and phosphorus fertilizer on soil physicochemical properties and grain yield of food barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) in Kaffa Zone, Southwestern Ethiopia. Momona Ethiopian Journal of Science 9, 242-261. Tekalign, T. (1991). “Soil, Plant, Water, Fertilizer, Animal Manure and Compost Analysis”. Working Document No. 13. International Livestock Research Center for Africa. Addis Ababa. Wasihun, Y. (2022). Review on sesame (Sesamum indicum L.) production challenges and opportunities in Ethiopia. World Journal of Agriculture and Soil Science 8, 2641-6379. Wassie, H. (2012). Appraisal of Erythrina brucei as a source for soil nutrition on Nitisols of South Ethiopia. International Journal of Agriculture and Biology 14, 371-376. Wassie, H., Shiferaw, B., and Kelsa, K. (2009). Integrated soil fertility management options for sustainable crop production: review of research findings from southern regional state of Ethiopia. In “Improved Natural Resource Management Technologies for Food Security, Poverty Reduction and Sustainable Development”. Proceedings of the 10th Conference Ethiopian Society of Soil Science pp. 163–175. EIAR, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.