40

JPAIR Multidisciplinary Research

Presoaking Treatment of Soybean 
[Glycine max (L.) Merrill] Seeds Using 

Fermented Plant Extracts and Commercial 
Liquid Fertilizer
RENELIZA D. CEJALVO

http://orcid.org 0000-0002-3819-9268
rdcejalvo@up.edu.ph

University of the Philippines Los Baños
Laguna, Philippines

MARIA FATIMA O. MERCADO
mafatima_mercado@yahoo.com

University of the Philippines Los Baños
Laguna, Philippines

Originality: 100% • Grammar Check: 100% •  Plagiarism: 0%

ABSTRACT

The yield of soybean in the Philippines is significantly low. Presoaking is 
one of the seed priming techniques to improve seed quality. This study aimed 
to determine the effects of selected fermented plant extracts and commercial 
organic fertilizer on germination and vigor of soybean seeds. The seeds presoaked 
in organic agriculture inputs such as ipil ipil FPJ (Fermented Plant Juice), squash 
FFJ (Fermented Fruit Juice), commercial organic fertilizer (PSPLOF), and 
water (control). The seeds were then subjected to seed quality tests to evaluate 
germination and vigor. Ipil ipil FPJ and squash FFJ significantly improved the 
percentage germination, first count, vigor index, seedling growth, and seedling 
emergence. Commercial fertilizer showed poor results in seed germination and 

Vol. 34 · October 2018
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7719/jpair.v34i1.628

Print ISSN 2012-3981 
Online ISSN 2244-0445

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons 
Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/


41

International Peer Reviewed Journal

vigor tests. Seeds soaked in water showed high percentage germination but 
have poor vigor. Data were arranged in factorial in Completely Randomized 
Design (CRD) and analyzed using Analysis of Variance (ANOVA). The initial 
seed quality results revealed significantly poor germination and vigor. Therefore, 
presoaking of soybean seeds in ipil ipil FPJ and squash FFJ is recommended to 
improve the germination and vigor of soybean seeds. The results could be useful 
to reduce the cost of soybean production and to enhance the yield of soybean. 

Keywords — Agriculture, agronomy, soybean, seed germination, seed vigor, 
seed priming, seed presoaking, Asia, Philippines

INTRODUCTION

Soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merrill)] is an annual legume that belongs to 
Fabaceae family. United States of America (USA), Brazil, Argentina, China, and 
India are the top producers wherein they comprise about 90% of global soybean 
production (Dourado, Pascoal, Sakomura, Costa, & Biagiotti 2011). Due to 
the high protein content and low price of the soybean meal, it is a significant 
component of the livestock feed (Hartman, West, & Herman 2011). The crop is 
also widely grown for its vegetable oil and for human food consumption that is 
mostly in Asia. Some food uses of soybean include soya oil, soymilk, tofu, tokwa, 
miso, edamame, and soy sauce.

Since the 1970s, soybean has the highest increase in an area of production 
than any other major crop around the world due to increasing demand for meal 
and oil (Hartman, West, & Herman 2011).  However, the volume of production 
of soybean in the Philippines is significantly low.  According to the Bureau of 
Plant Industry (BPI) in 2012, the Philippines’ area of production for soybean is 
just around 1,000 ha. The Philippines highly depends on soybean importation 
from USA, Brazil, Argentina, and China while the annual domestic needs 
have reached up to 300,000 MT. According to United States Department of 
Agriculture (USDA) Foreign Agricultural Service (2014), the Philippines are the 
second largest importer of soybeans from the United States. In the country, about 
70%-90% of domestic production and imports are for animal feed while the 
remaining percentage is for human food consumption and other uses (Manuel, 
Huelgas, & Espanto 1987).

There is a need to increase the germination percentage and vigor of soybean 
since the demand for soybean would increase (Hartman, West, & Herman 2011).  



42

JPAIR Multidisciplinary Research

Currently, the soybean in the country is primarily imported. In general, when the 
germination rate of the crop would increase, then the seeding rate would decrease 
which is favorable for the farmers. When the seed is vigorous, then the soybean 
seeds can combat diseases such as fungi and bacteria and also insect pests that 
injure the crop. Seed vigor would also determine if the seeds could withstand 
stressful environmental conditions.

Presoaking is one of the solutions to improve the seed germination and vigor 
of soybean.  For the presoaking treatments, this experiment utilized inputs used 
in Organic Agriculture. Organic Agriculture in the Philippines has been gaining 
popularity and was officially recognized when the Republic Act No. 10068 or 
the Organic Agriculture Act of 2010 was enacted into law. Many organizations 
have sprouted gearing towards sustainable, organic, and ecological agriculture. 
Farmers who practice organic agriculture are also utilizing the principles and 
materials used in Korean Natural Farming (KNF) (Zamora and Calub 2016). 
KNF was introduced to farmers through the extension work of non-government 
organizations (NGOs) and State Universities and Colleges (SUCs). KNF 
inputs include Fermented Plant Juice (FPJ), Fermented Fruit Juice (FFJ) and 
other indigenous microorganisms. The fermented plant extracts can be used as 
fertilizers, inducing hormones, prevention of pests and diseases, and increasing 
plant vigor. They can also be good sources of nutrients that can boost crop 
growth. In this study, the FPJ and FFJ will be used as presoaking treatments. 
Besides, a liquid organic fertilizer product of a commercial organic enterprise that 
is also made through fermentation will be used.

OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY

The general objective of the study was to determine the effects of selected fer-
mented plant extracts and a commercial liquid organic fertilizer on the germina-
tion and vigor of soybean (Glycine max) seeds. The specific objectives of the study 
were (1) to evaluate the germination and vigor of soybean seeds presoaked in 
different fermented plant extracts and liquid organic fertilizer; and (2) to identify 
and compare which among the fermented plant extracts and the commercial 
liquid organic fertilizer will improve the germination and vigor of soybean seeds;



43

International Peer Reviewed Journal

METHODOLOGY

Research Design
The experiment was laid out in factorial in a Completely Randomized 

Design (CRD) with four replicates. The seeds per treatment have undergone 
seed quality tests.

Research Site
The study was conducted in Seed Science and Technology Laboratory, 

Institute of Crop Science (ICropS), College of Agriculture and Food Science 
(CAFS), University of the Philippines Los Baños (UPLB), College, Laguna. The 
study was conducted from April to June 2017.

Data gathering and Procedure
Fermented fruit juice (FFJ) using squash (Cucurbita maxima) and a ferment-

ed plant juice (FPJ) using ipil-ipil (Leucaena leucocephala) leaves were prepared. 
Squash fruit and ipil ipil leaves were obtained from a backyard farm in Calinog, 
Iloilo. The plant materials were collected in the morning. Dirt from the plant 
materials collected was removed by shaking and without using water. The fruits 
and leaves were cut into small pieces of about four inches in width. Two kilo-
grams of the plant materials were mixed with one liter of molasses. Each mixture 
was transferred to a plastic pail. The pails were covered with Manila paper and 
tied securely. The combinations in the container were kept away from sunlight 
undisturbed for seven days. The filtrate was strained into a plastic bottle using a 
filter. Two tablespoons of FPJ or FFJ were diluted in one liter of purified water to 
make 3% concentration of the solutions. The solutions served as the pre-soaking 
treatments. 

Commercial Liquid Organic Fertilizer
The liquid organic fertilizer commercially known as Power Solution Pre-

mium Liquid Organic Fertilizer (PSPLOF) was obtained from YCRF Enterprises 
in Biñan, Laguna. ). PSPLOF is included in the official list of Third Party Certi-
fied Organic Operators in the Philippines (Bureau of Agriculture and Fisheries 
Standards (BAFS), 2017).  Two tablespoons of the liquid fertilizer were diluted 
in one liter of water and used as the presoaking treatment.



44

JPAIR Multidisciplinary Research

Presoaking Treatment
Soybean seeds (PSB Sy2) were obtained from Brown Gold Isabela Organic 

Enterprises. The initial percentage germination and vigor were determined.
Soybean seeds were first washed in running water for 5-10 minutes to re-

move dirt and other contaminants. The seeds were then rinsed with distilled 
water. Clean seeds were presoaked in different treatments at room temperature. 
The seeds were immersed entirely in the following treatments: Water, FPJ (Ipil 
ipil leaves), FFJ (Squash), and Liquid Organic Fertilizer. For each treatment, 600 
soybean seeds were used (200 each for seed germination, vigor index, and seed-
ling emergence). After presoaking, the seeds were blot-dried with a clean paper 
towel before performing seed quality evaluation. 

Data collection

Percentage germination
For each treatment, 200 presoaked soybean seeds, divided into four repli-

cates were sown in moistened paper towels. The paper towels were kept moist 
with an adequate amount of distilled water throughout the germination period. 
The first count was done five days after sowing (DAS) while the final count was 
done eight DAS. The percentage germination was determined using the formula:

Seed Vigor
First count. The first count was obtained by determining the total number of 

germinated seeds on the standard germination set-up five DAS.
Vigor Index.  The vigor index was determined through the speed of germina-

tion test. For each replicate, 50 seeds were sown on moist paper towels. Seedlings 
with 2 mm radicle protrusion were considered germinated. The number of seed-
lings with 2mm radicle protrusion was counted daily from the day after planting 
until the eighth day and was removed from the set-up. Summation of the germi-
nated seedlings over the nth number of the day was used to determine the speed 
of germination or vigor index. The vigor index was computed using the formula: 

Vigor index = (n/1) + (n/2) + (n/3) + … + (n/8)

Where n = number of germinated seedlings. 



45

International Peer Reviewed Journal

Seedling Growth Rate (Seedling Length, Root and Shoot Length, and Biomass). 
Randomly selected seedlings from the standard germination test were used. From 
the four replicates, ten (10) seedlings were selected for the test. The seedling 
length, and the root and shoot length (cm) of the chosen seedlings were measured 
using a ruler. The seedlings were oven-dried for 72 hours at 70°C. The oven-dried 
seedlings were weighed to determine the dry weight in grams (g).

Seedling Emergence. Fifty (50) seeds were sown to test the seedling emer-
gence per replicate in unsterilized soil that was obtained from the ICropS, UPLB, 
College, Laguna. The set-up was supplied with an adequate amount of water 
throughout the experiment. The number of healthy seedlings that emerged was 
counted on the eighth day after sowing. The seedling emergence percentage was 
computed using the formula:

Data Analysis
 The data was analyzed using Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) of STAR 2.0.1 

software developed by the International Rice Research Institute (IRRI). The 
mean comparison was interpreted using the Least Significant Difference (LSD).

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Initial Seed Quality
Table 1 shows the initial seed quality of soybean, which included seed 

germination and vigor. The initial percentage germination, vigor index, shoot 
length, root length, seedling length, and seedling emergence were significantly 
lower than the results of presoaked seeds in different treatments for the same 
parameter. The standard germination percentage for soybean in generally higher 
than 80% (Egli and TeKrony, 1995). The initial seedling biomass was higher 
than the treated seeds.



46

JPAIR Multidisciplinary Research

Table 1. Initial Seed Quality of Soybean Seeds
Parameter Value

Percent germination 84%

Vigor Index 42.58

Shoot Length 7.51 cm

Root Length 5.97 cm

Seedling Length 13.48 cm

Seedling Biomass 0.61g

Seedling Emergence 72%

Germination Percentage
The results of the ANOVA showed that the presoaking treatments were 

highly significantly different (Pr<0.01) from each other. There are various effects 
to soybean seeds among presoaking treatments. Results shown in Table 2 implies 
that ipil ipil FPJ, squash FFJ, and water treatments were effective in improving 
the percent germination of soybean seeds, from an initial of 84% to 97%, 97%, 
and 95%, respectively. Although ipil ipil FPJ showed the highest percentage 
germination, it should be noted that this was not significantly different from 
that of squash FFJ and water (control). The effect of commercial fertilizer was 
comparable to the results of the initial percentage germination.  

Table 2. Percentage Germination of Soybean Seeds Presoaked in Different 
Presoaking Treatments.

Presoaking treatment Percentage germination (%)

Commercial Fertilizer 85  b

Ipil ipil FPJ 97  a

Squash FFJ 97  a

Water (Control) 95  a

Means with the same letter are not significantly different.

Seed Vigor
First count

The number of normal seedlings five DAS were counted, and the result 
indicated the level of vigor of the seeds.  The effect for the first count of soybean 
seeds (Table 3) was observed to be the same as the results in germination set up. 



47

International Peer Reviewed Journal

Ipil ipil FPJ, squash FFJ, and water treatments showed significantly vigorous 
seeds than commercial fertilizer, which is not significantly different with the 
initial first count (Appendix 15).

At five DAS, there were no additional germinated seeds noted. Therefore, 
the soybean seeds that were presoaked in different treatments germinated on 
or before five DAS. Fungi affected most of the seeds that did not germinate 
specifically in those treatments that have low percent germination.

Table 3. The First Count of Soybean Seeds Presoaked in Different Presoaking 
Treatments.
Presoaking treatment Number of seeds germinated

Commercial Fertilizer 43  b

Ipil ipil 49 a

Squash 49 a

Water (Control) 47 a
Means with the same letter are not significantly different.

Vigor Index
 The ANOVA revealed a highly significant difference (Pr<0.01) for presoaking 

treatments concerning the vigor index. 
The vigor index was measured through the speed of germination test. The 

vigor index of soybean seeds presoaked in different fermented extracts and 
commercial liquid fertilizer is shown in Table 4. Presoaking in ipil ipil FPJ proved 
to be most effective in increasing the vigor index. However, its result was not 
significantly different with water (control). Commercial fertilizer constantly 
showed poor performance.

Table 4. Vigor Index of Soybean Seeds Presoaked for 1 Hour and 12 Hours in 
Different Fermented Extracts and Commercial Liquid Fertilizer.

Presoaking treatments Presoaking treatment means

Comm. Fert. 38.78    c

Ipil Ipil FPJ 46.54 a

Squash FFJ 44.22   b

Water (Control) 44.37 ab
Means with the same letter are not significantly different.



48

JPAIR Multidisciplinary Research

Shoot Length
The ANOVA revealed that the presoaking treatments in shoot length have a 

highly significant difference (Pr<0.01) from each other
Table 5 shows the shoot length of soybean seeds presoaked in different 

presoaking treatments and commercial liquid fertilizer. The results of ipil ipil 
FPJ and squash FFJ showed no significant difference with that of water (control). 
Commercial fertilizer was observed to have the shortest shoot. The initial shoot 
length is significantly lower than the shoot length of soybean seeds presoaked 
in different presoaking treatments. Therefore, it is necessary to presoak soybean 
seeds to promote shoot growth.

Table 5. Shoot Length of Soybean Seeds Presoaked in Different Presoaking 
Treatments
Presoaking treatments Presoaking treatment means

Comm. Fert. 8.96      c

Ipil Ipil FPJ 12.45   a

Squash FFJ 12.58   a

Water (Control) 11.90   b

Means with the same letter are not significantly different.

Root Length
The results of the ANOVA reveal that presoaking treatments in root length 

are highly significantly different (Pr<0.01). The root length of soybean seeds 
presoaked in different presoaking treatments (Table 6) reveals that ipil ipil FPJ 
has significantly longer root than all the other treatments followed by squash FFJ 
and water, respectively. Commercial fertilizer was noted to inhibit root growth 
substantially.

Table 6. Root Length (cm) of Soybean Seeds Presoaked in Different Presoaking 
Treatments
Presoaking treatments Presoaking treatment means

Comm. Fert. 4.32    d

Ipil Ipil FPJ 7.62 a

Squash FFJ 6.61   b

Water (Control) 5.60   c
Means with the same letter are not significantly different.



49

International Peer Reviewed Journal

Seedling Length
The ANOVA revealed a highly significant difference (Pr<0.01) for presoaking 

treatments in seedling length. The comparisons of different presoaking treatment 
mean in Table 7 show that ipil ipil FPJ and squash FFJ significantly improved 
the seedling growth of soybean seeds compared to water (control) treatment and 
the initial seedling length. Commercial fertilizer exhibited poor performance in 
seedling length and showed seedling growth inhibition when compared to the 
initial seedling length.

Table 7. Seedling Length (cm) of Soybean Seeds Presoaked in Different Presoaking 
Treatments
Presoaking treatment Presoaking treatment means

Comm. Fert. 13.28      d

Ipil Ipil FPJ 20.08 a

Squash FFJ 19.18  b

Water (Control) 17.52    c
Means with the same letter are not significantly different.

Seedling Biomass
There are highly significant differences (Pr<0.01) in seedling biomass for 

different presoaking treatments. The results of the seedling biomass of soybean 
seeds presoaked in different presoaking (Table 8) show that ipil ipil FPJ, and 
squash FFJ significantly increased the seedling biomass of soybean compared to 
water (control) treatment. Seeds presoaked in commercial fertilizer have more 
massive seedling biomass than water (control), but the results between the two 
treatments are not significantly different. 

Table 8. Seedling Biomass (g) of Soybean Seeds Presoaked in different Presoaking 
Treatments
Presoaking treatment Presoaking treatment means

Comm. Fert. 0.54  bc

Ipil Ipil FPJ 0.62 a

Squash FFJ 0.58 ab

Water (Control) 0.49    c
Means with the same letter are not significantly different.



50

JPAIR Multidisciplinary Research

The initial seedling biomass value is relatively high. The result for the initial 
seedling biomass is not significantly different with ipil ipil FPJ and squash FFJ, 
which have massive seedling biomass among the treatments.

Seedling Emergence
The ANOVA for the seedling emergence of soybean seeds reveals that 

there is no significant difference in different presoaking treatments for seedling 
emergence.

 Table 9 shows the seedling emergence of soybean seeds presoaked in different 
presoaking treatment. The different presoaking treatment showed almost no 
significant differences. The initial seedling emergence percentage is significantly 
lower than all the treatments. Therefore, to improve the seedling emergence 
percentage, presoaking of seeds in fermented extracts is necessary. 

Table 9. Seedling Emergence (%) of Soybean Seeds Presoaked in Different 
Presoaking Treatments

Presoaking treatment Presoaking treatment mean

Comm. Fert. 91.75

Ipil Ipil FPJ 90.33

Squash FFJ 98.67

Water (Control) 80.63
Means with the same letter are not significantly different.

Initial Seed Quality
 The initial seed quality results for percentage germination, first count, vigor 

index, seedling growth rate, and seedling biomass were significantly lower than 
that of the treated seeds. The initial seedling biomass, however, was more massive 
than the pre-soaked seeds. This could be the effect of the attached fungi and other 
pathogens, which could have added weight to seedling biomass. It was observed 
that the seeds that were not presoaked in any treatment were significantly 
affected with fungi and other pathogens. The untreated soybean seeds showed 
poor performance in germination and vigor. This infers that the seeds that have 
not undergone presoaking will have a low percentage of surviving in the field 
where the soil has harmful bacteria and fungi, the pH may be detrimental to the 
plant, there are weeds to compete for nutrients, and other natural stresses that 
can injure and affect the growth of the crop.



51

International Peer Reviewed Journal

Presoaking Treatments
Ipil ipil FPJ significantly improved the performance of soybean seeds in 

percentage germination. It also showed vigorous seeds in different vigor tests 
such as first count, vigor index, seedling growth rate, and seedling emergence. 
Based on the results from various parameters, it was usually on top among the 
other treatments; therefore, ipil ipil FPJ was effective in enhancing the percentage 
germination and vigor of soybean seeds.

The efficiency of ipil ipil FPJ can be attributed to the different nutrients, 
vitamins, and microorganisms present in the fermented extract. Since ipil ipil 
contains high nitrogen content, the protein contents of soybean seeds may 
have been increased resulting in increased germination and vigor. This is on par 
with the study of Warraich, Basra, Ahmad, Ahmed, & Aftab in 2002 on wheat 
(Triticum aestivum) wherein seeds from plots that were fertilized with nitrogen 
resulted in increased final germination percentage. 

Seeds that were pre-soaked in ipil ipil FPJ may have absorbed water faster 
during its germination resulting to significantly high first count and vigor index. 
Hara and Toriyama (1998) observed that seed lot of rice (Oryza sativa) with a 
higher amount of nitrogen applied showed faster water absorption, more rapid 
seedling emergence and more uniform emergence than the seed lot with low 
nitrogen content. 

Seeds soaked in Ipil ipil FPJ were observed to have the best performance in 
seedling growth rate test (shoot length, root length, seedling length, and seedling 
biomass). Nitrogen that is abundant in ipil ipil is necessary to promote initial 
growth in soybean (Ohyama et al., 2013). Other effects of the essential nutrients 
present in ipil ipil FPJ may have interacted to produce positive results in seedling 
growth. Also, application of nitrogen results in increased biomass yield and 
protein yield (Blumenthal, Baltensperger, Cassman, Mason, & Pavlista 2008).  

Ipil ipil FPJ, Squash FFJ, and commercial fertilizer significantly enhanced 
the seedling emergence percentage of soybean seeds. These fermented treatments 
contain Lactic Acid Bacteria (LAB) and also essential nutrients. Hamed, Moustafa, 
& Abdel-Aziz (2011) concluded that the LAB have growth promoting-effects. 
Therefore, seeds presoaked in the fermented treatments were able to combat 
fungi and bacteria, thus, resulted in successful and improved seedling emergence 
compared to the initial seedling emergence value. Also, the enzymes for metabolic 
processes may have been activated. 

However, it was evident that ipil ipil FPJ has relatively lower seedling 
emergence percentage than the other fermented extracts. Some emerged soybean 



52

JPAIR Multidisciplinary Research

seedlings presoaked in ipil ipil FPJ may have been affected by pathogens present 
in the unsterilized soil that resulted in decayed seedlings. Ohyama et al. (2013) 
reported that too much nitrogen applied to plants could make them more 
attracted to insects and diseases. 

Squash FFJ
 Squash FFJ was also effective in improving the performance of soybean seeds 

in percentage germination, first count, vigor index, seedling growth rate, and 
seedling emergence. Squash FFJ produced the most vigorous seeds in seedling 
emergence test.

 Squash FFJ was also a good source of essential nutrients that resulted in high 
germination percentage and vigor of soybean seeds. Also, squash fruit has high 
vitamin A and phosphorus (P) content. Provision of a more considerable amount 
of P may have increased adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and deoxyribonucleic 
acid (DNA) that triggered metabolic processes resulting in high percentage 
germination and vigor. The results for squash FFJ are in agreement with the study 
of Zeļonka et al. (2005) in which seed coating with phosphorus of spring barley 
(Hordeum vulgare) resulted to higher germination percentage, greater chlorophyll 
content in the shoots and increased physiological activity.

Seeds pre-soaked in squash FFJ showed good performance on seedling growth 
rate test. The results were on par with the effect of phosphorus on shoot growth. 
The findings were also supported by the study of Shah, Ara, & Shafi (2011) 
on Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus) seeds that were soaked to P solutions which 
showed better seedling growth compared to seeds soaked in water. Inadequate P 
can affect shoot and root growth negatively.

 
Commercial Fertilizer

Commercial fertilizer showed poor results that are significantly lower or 
comparable with that of initial seed quality values in almost all of the parameters. 
However, its result for seedling emergence was considerably higher than that of 
control.

The commercial fertilizer is a mixture of water, molasses, sugar, fresh milk, 
lemongrass (Cymbopogon citratus), oregano (Origanum vulgare), malunggay 
(Moringa oleifera), garlic (Allium sativum), ginger (Zingiber officinale), chicken 
manure, and mill ash. The ingredients as mentioned earlier may have exhibited 
detrimental effects on soybean seeds resulting in poor performance.

The concentration of the commercial liquid fertilizer used in this experiment 
may have been too high. Szopinska (2013) stated that high levels of lactic acid 



53

International Peer Reviewed Journal

that is present in commercial fertilizer could reduce the germination and vigor 
of seeds. The concentration could have been moderated to achieve the optimum 
potential of the commercial liquid fertilizer. 

Water (Control) Treatment
Seeds that were presoaked in water significantly improved the percentage 

germination compared to the initial seed quality values. Water treatment showed 
a relatively weak result in seedling growth rate. 

Seeds soaked in water may have imbibed adequate amount of water needed 
for the seeds to germinate. The physiological process may have been triggered, 
thereby, resulting in a high germination rate and vigor index. Also, there was no 
possibility of allelopathic effects by water.

The seeds presoaked in water have no nutrients to acquire, therefore, 
regarding seedling growth rate, seeds soaked in water showed relatively poor 
performance compared to the fermented treatments and its performance in 
percentage germination and vigor index. In contrast, seeds presoaked in the 
fermented treatments have additional nutrients to absorb. Soybean seeds still 
need additional nutrients during germination for greater yield. To promote 
the initial growth of soybean, N is applied as a starter fertilizer (Ohyama et al., 
2013). Water treatment has significantly longer seedling than the initial seedling 
length value but lower than the fermented treatments. Water may have supplied 
the seeds with an adequate amount of moisture. However, it lacked nutrients 
and other beneficial microorganisms that are present in fermented extracts. Seeds 
presoaked in water have the lightest seedling biomass among the treatments.

Water treatment showed significantly low seedling emergence percentage. 
Seeds soaked in water were not equipped with beneficial microorganisms to 
combat the harmful pathogens present in the unsterilized soil. Also, there are no 
essential nutrients supplied to the seeds to thrive and to grow vigorously in the 
stressful environment.

CONCLUSIONS

Presoaking of soybean seeds was necessary to improve the germination and 
vigor of soybean seeds. The result for the initial seed quality was significantly 
lower than the treated seeds. The untreated seeds were more prone to pathogens 
than the pre-soaked seeds.



54

JPAIR Multidisciplinary Research

Ipil ipil FPJ and squash FFJ significantly enhanced the germination and vigor 
of soybean seeds. Therefore, it is recommended to use these fermented extracts as 
presoaking treatments since they contain microorganisms and essential nutrients.

Commercial fertilizer did not improve the germination and vigor of soybean 
seeds. The results for commercial fertilizer were either comparable to or lower than 
that of the initial seed quality. There might be a need to adjust the concentration 
of the commercial fertilizer when it is used for presoaking of soybean seeds.

Seeds soaked in water significantly improved the percentage germination 
of soybean seeds. However, the seeds were not vigorous since they showed low 
seedling growth and seedling emergence percentage.

This study recommends presoaking of soybean seeds in ipil ipil FPJ and 
squash FFJ to improve the percentage germination and vigor of soybean seeds 
significantly. However, further studies are necessary to determine the optimum 
presoaking period and concentration of the fermented extracts. Also, the floating 
seeds during the presoaking process should be removed and should not be 
included in seed quality testing. An adequate amount of water should be supplied 
in seedling emergence test. It would be better if the amount of water provided 
for each treatment would be uniform. Further studies could also include NPK 
analysis of the FPJ and FFJ.  

TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH

The findings of this study may be translated to the farmers who engage in 
Organic Farming and other farmers who opt to use less synthetic fertilizers. The 
effect of fermented plant extracts on soybean may give an idea to the farmers on 
what could be the effect to other crops that are related to soybean. Hence, wise 
decision making that could lead to higher yields and profits can be attained. The 
methodology of this study will also give an idea to the farmers and entrepreneurs 
on how they can optimize the product for achieving their purpose. 

LITERATURE CITED

Blumenthal, J. M., Baltensperger, D. D., Cassman, K. G., Mason, S. C., & 
Pavlista, A. D. (2008). Importance and effect of nitrogen on crop quality 
and health. In  Nitrogen in the Environment (Second Edition)  (pp. 51-70). 
https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-374347-3.00003-2

https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-374347-3.00003-2


55

International Peer Reviewed Journal

[BAFS] Bureau of Agriculture and Fisheries Standards. 2017. Retrieved from: 
http://www.bafps.da.gov.ph/images/OFFICIAL_LIST_Third-party_
Certified_Organic_Operators_as_of_23_Jan_2017.pdf

Dourado, L. R. B., Pascoal, L. A. F., Sakomura, N. K., Costa, F. G. P., & Biagiotti, 
D. (2011). Soybeans (Glycine max) and soybean products in poultry and 
swine nutrition. In  Recent trends for enhancing the diversity and quality of 
soybean products. InTech. https://goo.gl/tqaZm1

Egli, D. B., & TeKrony, D. M. (1995). Soybean seed germination, vigor and field 
emergence.  Seed Science and Technology (Switzerland). v. 23 (3). Retrieved 
from https://goo.gl/pFFoa8

Hamed, H. A., Moustafa, Y. A., & Abdel-Aziz, S. M. (2011). In vivo efficacy 
of lactic acid bacteria in biological control against Fusarium oxysporum for 
protection of tomato plant. Life Science Journal, 8(4), 462-468. https://goo.
gl/axmHvW

Hara, Y., & Toriyama, K. (1998). Seed nitrogen accelerates the rates of 
germination, emergence, and establishment of rice plants.  Soil Science and 
Plant Nutrition,  44(3), 359-366. https://doi.org/10.1080/00380768.1998.
10414457

Hartman, G. L., West, E. D., & Herman, T. K. (2011). Crops that feed the 
World 2. Soybean—worldwide production, use, and constraints caused by 
pathogens and pests. Food Security, 3(1), 5-17. https://goo.gl/2Lxb7i

Manuel, P. C., Huelgas, R. R., & Espanto, L. H. (1987). Adoption of Soybean in 
Lupao, Nueva Ecija, the Philippines. https://goo.gl/5Q55qS

Ohyama, T., Minagawa, R., Ishikawa, S., Yamamoto, M., Hung, N. V. P., Ohtake, 
N., ... & Takahashi, Y. (2013). Soybean seed production and nitrogen 
nutrition. In A comprehensive survey of international soybean research-Genetics, 
physiology, agronomy and nitrogen relationships. Intech. https://goo.gl/psQyE5

Shah, A. R., Ara, N., & Shafi, G. (2011). Seed priming with phosphorus increased 
germination and yield of okra. African Journal of Agricultural Research, 6(16), 
3859-3876. https://doi.org/10.5897/AJAR11.564

https://goo.gl/tqaZm1
https://goo.gl/pFFoa8
https://goo.gl/axmHvW
https://goo.gl/axmHvW
https://doi.org/10.1080/00380768.1998.10414457
https://doi.org/10.1080/00380768.1998.10414457
https://goo.gl/2Lxb7i
https://goo.gl/5Q55qS
https://goo.gl/psQyE5
https://doi.org/10.5897/AJAR11.564


56

JPAIR Multidisciplinary Research

Szopinska, D. (2013). The effects of organic acids treatment on germination, 
vigour and health of zinnia (Zinnia elegans Jacq.) seeds.  Acta Scientiarum 
Polonorum. Hortorum Cultus, 12(5). https://goo.gl/tHGBeJ

[USDA] United States Department of Agriculture Foreign Agricultural Service. 
(2014). Retrieved from https://www.fas.usda.gov/regions/philippines

Warraich, E. A., Basra, S. M. A., Ahmad, N., Ahmed, R., & Aftab, M. U. H. A. 
M. M. A. D. (2002). Effect of nitrogen on grain quality and vigour in wheat 
(Triticum aestivum L.). International Journal of Agriculture and Biology, 4(4), 
517-520. https://goo.gl/LGzPk2

Zamora, O. B., & Calub, B. M. (2016), Organic agriculture technologies and systems 
developed and adapted by farmers in the Philippines. Philippines: Department 
of Agriculture-Bureau of Agricultural Research (DA-BAR) and University of 
the Philippines Los Baños (UPLB). ISBN No. 978-971-0347-46-9 

https://goo.gl/tHGBeJ
https://www.fas.usda.gov/regions/philippines
https://goo.gl/LGzPk2