item: #1 of 83 id: leap-294565 author: Smith, Michael title: A Constitutivist theory o reasons: its promise and parts date: 2013 words: 11127 flesch: 55 summary: As we saw earlier, what we need in order to make this idea seem plausible is some account of the relationship between final goodness and final desire, an ac- count that explains why reasons for final desires should inherit their status as reasons in this way. What Hume says in this passage, translated into modern jargon, is that since final desires (in his terms, “original existences”) do not purport to represent things to be the way they are, they aren’t the sort of psychological state which can be true or false, and hence not the sort of state for which there can be reasons. keywords: account; actions; agent; argument; beliefs; capacities; capacity; certain; concept; conclusion; constitutive; constitutivist; desires; dominant; exercise; fact; final; final desires; good; goodness; hume; ideal; ideal agent; inheritance; instrumental; instrumental desires; knowledge; later; leap; moral; parfit; parts; press; promise; psychological; rational; reasons; required; requirements; smith; standard; story; subsidiary; terms; theory; thesis; things; truth; way; ways; world cache: leap-294565.pdf plain text: leap-294565.txt item: #2 of 83 id: leap-294660 author: Firth, Joanna title: What's So Shameful About Shameful Revelations? date: 2013 words: 10221 flesch: 62 summary: Of course, if forcing ideal luck egalitarian citizens to reveal that their lack of talent will embarrass them severely, this is not good news for luck egal- itarians. Further, the main idea of my paper (that in an ideal luck egalitarian society people would not be ashamed of being untalented) is not discussed in his new paper and the shameful revelations allegation is influential, important and interesting in its own right. keywords: allegation; argument; ashamed; beliefs; benefits; citizens; claim; cognitive; conflict; current; deep; egalitarian; egalitarian society; egalitarianism; emotions; example; fact; fairness; firth; ideal; ideal egalitarian; ideal luck; important; itp; joanna; job; justice; lack; leap; level; luck; luck egalitarian; marketable; moral; natural; norms; order; paper; people; person; point; press; principles; quality; reason; resources; respect; responsible; revelations; self; sense; shameful; shameful revelations; society; state; system; talents; theories; unconditional; university; untalented; value; view; way; welfare; wolff cache: leap-294660.pdf plain text: leap-294660.txt item: #3 of 83 id: leap-294760 author: Hreno, Travis title: Jury Nullifications and the Bad Faith Juror date: 2013 words: 6422 flesch: 57 summary: Keywords: jury, jury nullification, fully-informed juries, jurors’ rights, judi- cial instructions. However, even those who see jury nullification to be a somewhat per- nicious element of the jury system do not advocate trying to remove the abil- ity to so act from the jury.2 One of the most active controversies regarding jury nullification, how- ever, both in the courts and among legal theorists, centers on whether juries ought to be informed that they have this ability to nullify 3. keywords: anarchy; arguments; bad; case; community; convictions; crime; criminal; defendant; depth; discussion; dyke; element; evidence; fact; fair; faith; free; guilty; horowitz; hreno; instance; instruction; judge; judicial; juries; jurors; jury; jury nullification; justice; law; leap; legal; maryland; nullification; nullification instruction; order; rni; states; system; time; trial; united; van; verdict; way cache: leap-294760.pdf plain text: leap-294760.txt item: #4 of 83 id: leap-294761 author: Lippert-Rasmussen, Kasper title: Global Injustice and Redistributive Wars date: 2013 words: 10936 flesch: 56 summary: I do not claim (i) that Pogge’s analysis is correct; (ii) that, as a matter of fact, it is morally permissible for poor countries to wage redis- tributive wars against rich countries; (iii) that it is not the case that anything that is impermissible for poor countries to do in the latter situation involving military aggression —e. g. deliberately targeting rich civilians— is impermis- sible in redistributive wars as well. An obvious question now arises: would poor countries not similarly be engaged in a just —perhaps even morally permissible— war, were they to take up arms to force us —people living in rich countries— to 1. keywords: account; affairs; aggression; analysis; bellum; case; causal; certain; citizens; claim; correct; costs; countries; country; deaths; defence; defensive; difference; distinction; ethics; fact; global; global poor; global poverty; global structure; harm; human; injustice; international; kasper; killing; leap; liable; lippert; mcmahan; means; military; military aggression; moral; number; oxford; people; permissible; pogge; poor; poor countries; poor people; poverty; press; proportionality; question; rasmussen; reason; redistributive; redistributive wars; relevant; requirement; rich; rich countries; rich people; rights; second; self; situation; states; structure; unjust; unjust global; view; waging; war; wars; way; world; year cache: leap-294761.pdf plain text: leap-294761.txt item: #5 of 83 id: leap-294762 author: Pogge, Thomas title: Poverty and Violence date: 2013 words: 12048 flesch: 52 summary: Perhaps most members of rich countries are too old for military service, their electorates are extremely concerned about security and willing to sacrifice much of their wealth to restore (a less unjust) peace once the war proves not to be a walk-over, and poor countries have also acquired weap- ons of mass destruction and can draw on vast pools of young men eager to join their armies” (Lippert-Rasmussen 2013: 81-82). First, because foodstuffs are tradable commodities, their prices in poor countries are uniformly higher than the World Bank’s purchasing power parities suggest— fully 50 percent higher on average (Pogge 2010: n. 127). keywords: account; affluent; affluent countries; africa; analogy; analysis; arrangements; attack; attackers; bank; beings; casualties; cause; change; citizens; civilians; claim; component; condition; consequences; correct; countries; country; developed; development; domestic; economic; elites; example; fact; forfeiture; global; global poverty; government; half; harm; household; human; income; india; inequality; institutional; international; island; january; judgment; large; leap; liable; life; lippert; lippertrasmussen; making; marines; massive; military; moral; n.d; number; order; oxford; people; percent; permissible; person; pogge; political; poor; poor countries; poorer; population; poverty; power; powerful; press; rasmussen; reasons; redistributive; redistributive war; resort; responsibility; rich; rich countries; richest; right; rules; second; self; severe; share; states; supranational; theory; thomas; trade; true; united; unjust; url; view; violence; war; wars; world; world poverty; wrong cache: leap-294762.pdf plain text: leap-294762.txt item: #6 of 83 id: leap-294784 author: Horta, Oscar title: Zoopolis, Interventions and the State of Nature date: 2013 words: 5521 flesch: 54 summary: In fact, most assume that we have no reason to aid them because (a) we have no such moral obligations or (b) such animals do not really need our help. They starve to death, are killed by other animals or die in other ways. keywords: aid; animals; arguments; authors; autonomy; bad; challenges; claim; communities; community; death; domestic; donaldson; environment; ethics; existence; fact; flourishing; food; form; good; help; horta; humans; individuals; intervention; kymlicka; leap; life; lives; members; nature; need; new; nonhuman; oscar; political; population; predation; press; problem; significant; situation; social; sovereignty; species; state; strategists; suffering; theory; university; valuable; wild; zoopolis cache: leap-294784.pdf plain text: leap-294784.txt item: #7 of 83 id: leap-294785 author: Alasdair, Cochrane title: Cosmozoopolis: the Case Against Group-Differentiated Animal Rights date: 2013 words: 6750 flesch: 49 summary: I have argued that Donaldson and Kymlicka mistakenly fail to extend to wild animals rights they grant to domesticated animals, such as the rights to political concern, political agency, residency and protection from predation. In particular, it argues that the theory of animal rights developed in Zoopolis is vulnerable to some of the critiques that are made against theories which differentiate the rights of humans on the basis of group-based distinctions. keywords: agency; animal rights; animals; basis; capacities; case; citizenship; claim; cochrane; communities; community; cosmozoopolis; course; differentiated; discussion; donaldson; duties; entitlements; example; group; human; important; individuals; interests; justice; kymlicka; leap; life; liminal; non; oxford; paper; particular; point; political; position; predation; press; protection; relational; relevant; residency; rights; secure; sentient; sovereignty; theories; theory; universal; university; wild; wild animals; zoopolis cache: leap-294785.pdf plain text: leap-294785.txt item: #8 of 83 id: leap-294786 author: Donaldson, Sue; Kymlicka, Will title: A Defense of Animal Citizens and Sovereigns date: 2013 words: 8696 flesch: 45 summary: Our reply will focus on three key issues: 1) the underlying moral basis for a group-differentiated theory of animal rights; 2) the chal- lenge of defining the nature and scope of wild animal sovereignty, and 3) the problem of policing nature. LEAP, 1 (2013) A Defense of Animal Citizens and Sovereigns* SUE DONALDSON AND WILL KYMLICK A Queen’s University Abstract In their commentaries on Zoopolis, Alasdair Cochrane and Oscar Horta raise several challenges to our argument for a “political theory of animal rights”, and to the specific models of animal citizenship and animal sovereignty we offer. keywords: agency; animal communities; animal rights; animals; approach; basic; better; borders; care; case; certain; circumstances; citizenship; claims; clear; cochrane; collective; communities; community; cosmopolitanism; cycles; defense; dependent; different; donaldson; duties; ecological; food; forms; group; habitat; health; horta; human; humanitarian; important; individual; interests; intervention; justice; kolers; kymlicka; leap; life; lives; management; members; membership; mobility; moral; nature; need; outside; oxford; place; political; predation; press; public; purpose; relations; resources; responsibility; rights; societies; society; sovereignty; species; specific; states; sue; suffering; terrestrial; territory; theory; universal; view; ways; wild; wild animals; zoopolis cache: leap-294786.pdf plain text: leap-294786.txt item: #9 of 83 id: leap-297539 author: Arneson, Richard J. title: What Do We Owe to Poor Families? date: 2014 words: 12401 flesch: 55 summary: I want to focus on the subset of poor children and poor adult family members who are also low in the ensemble of personal traits that constitute native ability. In considering the desirability from a social justice standpoint of pronatalist and pro-marriage public policies, we need to be considering not simply what is desirable from the standpoint of an adult person who is poor, but also what is good for poor children. keywords: adults; arneson; arrangements; available; benefits; better; cambridge; casal; case; childrearing; children; circumstances; claim; collective; conditions; cooperative; costs; distribution; duties; duty; dworkin; earth; economic; education; efforts; egalitarian; equal; essay; ethics; example; existence; fact; fair; fairness; families; family; good; group; hart; help; income; increase; individuals; initial; justice; leap; legal; life; likely; lives; low; market; marriage; meaningful; members; moral; need; new; nonprocreators; obligations; opportunities; oxford; parenting; parents; pay; people; person; policies; policy; poor; population; practice; press; principle; prospects; public; rawls; rescue; resources; responsible; richard; right; scheme; sex; share; skills; social; society; special; stable; state; successful; term; u.s; university; view; voluntary; way; ways; williams; women; work; world; worse cache: leap-297539.pdf plain text: leap-297539.txt item: #10 of 83 id: leap-297544 author: González-Ricoy, Iñigo title: Firms, States, and Democracy: A Qualified Defense of the Parallel Case Argument date: 2014 words: 11545 flesch: 56 summary: For, even if it were, it would also apply to firms, given that certain tasks can also be insulated from workers’ control in democratic firms. The parallel-case argument does not imply that democratic firms ought to include this sort of insulation. keywords: affected; analogy; argument; association; business; capital; case; case argument; citizens; competition; contrast; control; costly; costs; country; decisions; democracy; democratic; democratic firms; difference; economic; effects; efficiency; employees; employment; enterprises; example; exercise; exit; expertise; features; firms; following; freedom; goals; gonzález; governance; hand; influence; interests; internal; job; journal; justification; labor; lack; leap; making; managers; market; need; new; non; number; officials; open; oxford; paper; parallel; philosophy; political; potential; power; present; press; public; purposes; reason; relevant; ricoy; rights; second; section; similarities; social; sort; states; sufficient; supply; university; voluntariness; voluntary; workers; workplace; workplace democracy; íñigo cache: leap-297544.pdf plain text: leap-297544.txt item: #11 of 83 id: leap-297557 author: Temkin, Larry title: Rethinking the Good – A Small Taste date: 2014 words: 15891 flesch: 57 summary: Many people have worried about the implausibly Rethinking the Good – A Small Taste 63 LEAP 2 (2014) The problem is that despite its great appeal, the Internal Aspects View doesn’t reflect the thinking that many people often engage in when assessing outcomes! keywords: alternatives; arguments; article; aspects; aspects view; average; axiom; better; case; comparative; day; different; duration; fact; factors; features; good; goodness; heaven; hell; ideals; intense; internal; leap; level; life; like; lives; living; long; month; mosquito; narrow; narrow person; number; outcome; pain; parfit; particular; people; person; plausible; practical; principle; question; reasoning; relevant; respect; rethinking; second; significant; small; spectrum; taste; temkin; terms; things; time; total; transitivity; view; worse; years cache: leap-297557.pdf plain text: leap-297557.txt item: #12 of 83 id: leap-297559 author: Horta, Oscar title: In Defense of the Internal Aspects View: Person-Affecting Reasons, Spectrum Arguments and Inconsistent Intuitions date: 2014 words: 9771 flesch: 61 summary: The paper does not defend a person-affecting view over an impersonal one, but it argues that although there are intuitive person-affecting principles that entail an Essentially Comparative View, the intuitions that support these principles can also be acommodated by other principles that are compatible with the Internal Aspects View. Keywords: betterness, Essentially Comparative View, Internal Aspects View, person-affecting reasons, Spectrum Arguments, transitivity. keywords: according; arguments; aspects; aspects view; best; better; betterness; case; certain; claim; comparative; comparisons; different; identity; inconsistent; individuals; internal; internal aspects; intuitions; leap; moral; narrow; normative; option; outcomes; pain; person; possible; principles; problem; reasons; spectrum; temkin; time; transitive; transitivity; view; way; worse cache: leap-297559.pdf plain text: leap-297559.txt item: #13 of 83 id: leap-297560 author: Temkin, Larry title: Reply to Horta: Spectrum Arguments, the “Unhelpfulness” of Rejecting Transitivity, and Implications for Moral Realism date: 2014 words: 5700 flesch: 53 summary: Reply to Horta 109 LEAP 2 (2014) Let me begin by acknowledging my gratitude to Oscar Horta for his thoughtful and sensitive comments in his article “In Defense of the Internal Aspects View: Person-Affecting Reasons, Spectrum Arguments and Inconsistent Intuitions” (Horta, 2014), and also for the generous spirit he displayed in presenting them. 108 ISSN 2341-1465 LEAP 2 (2014): 108-119 Reply to Horta: Spectrum Arguments, the “Unhelpfulness” of Rejecting Transitivity, and Implications for Moral Realism L ARRY TEMKIN Rutgers University Abstract This article responds to Oscar Horta’s article “In Defense of the Internal Aspects View: Person-Affecting Reasons, Spectrum Arguments and Inconsistent Intuitions”. keywords: alternatives; arguments; article; axioms; better; comparative; context; dependent; different; factors; good; horta; ideals; leap; moral; outcome; people; person; possible; principles; reasons; relation; relevant; second; significant; sophie; spectrum; standard; temkin; transitivity; view cache: leap-297560.pdf plain text: leap-297560.txt item: #14 of 83 id: leap-297561 author: Persson, Ingmar title: Internal or External Grounds for the Nontransitivity of “Better/Worse than” date: 2014 words: 9462 flesch: 52 summary: Likewise, according Internal or External Grounds 133 LEAP 2 (2014) to some metaethical theories, the relation between value properties and the properties they’re supposed to supervene on is entailment as in the case of the determinable properties under discussion. It’s only if value properties and secondary properties are taken as supervenient in a sense which, like mine, implies that they’re entirely distinct from their bases that my argument rules out transitive sameness with respect to them. keywords: argument; better; case; comparative; comparison; considered; difference; duration; external; having; intensity; internal; intrinsic; leap; ness; outcomes; pain; perfect; possible; primary; properties; property; regards; relation; respect; sense; similar; similarity; sufficient; supervenient; temkin; terms; things; transitive; transitivity; true; units; university; value; view; virtue; worse; yellow cache: leap-297561.pdf plain text: leap-297561.txt item: #15 of 83 id: leap-297562 author: Temkin, Larry title: Reply to Persson: Intransitivity and the Internal Aspects View date: 2014 words: 7159 flesch: 53 summary: The value bases for outcome X, Bx, determine X’s value, K, the value bases for outcome Y, By, determine Y’s value, L, and the value bases for outcome Z, Bz, determine Z’s value, In his article, Persson argues in favor of an account of supervenience that would be compatible with both an Internal Aspects View, and the nontransitivity of the “better or worse than” relations. keywords: add; arguments; aspects; aspects view; better; case; claims; comparative; different; features; good; goodness; ideals; internal; internal aspects; leap; outcomes; people; persson; principle; similar; spectrum; standard; supervenient; temkin; transitivity; value; view; way cache: leap-297562.pdf plain text: leap-297562.txt item: #16 of 83 id: leap-297563 author: Hassoun, Nicole title: Globalization and Global Justice in Review date: 2014 words: 5306 flesch: 52 summary: Coercive institutions do continue to exercise this force (insofar as they remain coercive institutions). Globalization and Global Justice starts by giving a new argument for the conclusion that coercive international institutions —whose subjects who are likely to face sanctions for violation of their rules— must ensure that everyone they coerce secures basic necessities like food, water and medicines. keywords: able; argument; autonomy; autonomy argument; basic; book; care; coercion; coercive; coercive institutions; conclusion; conditions; consent; countries; education; emotional; exercise; food; force; freedom; ggj; global; globalization; goods; hassoun; health; individuals; instance; institutions; international; international institutions; justice; leap; legitimacy; liberals; libertarians; necessary; need; new; nicole; obligations; people; possible; premise; review; rights; rules; sanctions; second; secure; significant; social; subjects; sufficient; sufficient autonomy; water; world cache: leap-297563.pdf plain text: leap-297563.txt item: #17 of 83 id: leap-297564 author: Goodman, Charles title: Libertarian Welfare Rights: Can We Expel Them? date: 2014 words: 5163 flesch: 53 summary: Nor would the 170 Charles Goodman LEAP 2 (2014) libertarian state arbitrarily confiscate their property. No residents will any longer be in a position to claim libertarian welfare rights against the state. keywords: actual; annie; argument; autonomous; autonomous persons; autonomy; basic; citizens; claim; coercive; consent; defense; global; hassoun; institutions; justice; law; leap; legitimacy; libertarian; libertarian state; locke; moral; natural; need; non; persons; pogge; poor; position; positive; premise; property; punishment; resources; result; rights; self; state; territory; theory; way; welfare cache: leap-297564.pdf plain text: leap-297564.txt item: #18 of 83 id: leap-297565 author: Stone, Peter title: Social Contract Theory in the Global Context date: 2014 words: 5649 flesch: 52 summary: This problem pushes consent theory towards counting as “consent” actions or omissions that would not count as consent in other contexts. Few who have considered consent theory have defended actual consent since John Locke” (95). keywords: able; actual; argument; autonomy; coercive; conception; consent; consent theory; contract; democratic; different; dissent; emphasis; global; hassoun; hypothetical; idea; institutions; justice; leap; legitimacy; liberal; libertarians; obligations; original; people; peter; political; poor; positive; press; rawls; rights; rule; social; social contract; stone; subjects; terms; theorists; theory; tradition; understanding; world cache: leap-297565.pdf plain text: leap-297565.txt item: #19 of 83 id: leap-297566 author: Tan, Kok-Chor title: Sufficiency, Equality and the Consequences of Global Coercion date: 2014 words: 9352 flesch: 45 summary: She calls this the “third wave” in global justice which she takes to be distinct on the one side from “statism” that supports only humanitarian duties, and on the other from “cosmopolitanism” that enjoins global egalitarian duties. Laura Valentini argues that the existence of global coercion triggers global distributive duties more demanding than mere humanitarianism, but not necessarily as demanding as cosmopolitan egalitarian duties. keywords: account; argument; autonomy; basic; blake; case; claim; coercion; coercive; commitments; consent; consequences; debate; demanding; different; distributive; domestic; duties; duty; economic; egalitarian; egalitarianism; equality; fact; form; freedom; global; global coercion; global egalitarian; global justice; global order; hassoun; humanitarian; individuals; institutional; justice; leap; libertarian; moral; nagel; needs; non; normative; obligations; order; people; persons; pogge; point; poor; poverty; principles; relevant; rights; significant; standard; state; sufficiency; systematic; tan; valentini; way; world cache: leap-297566.pdf plain text: leap-297566.txt item: #20 of 83 id: leap-297567 author: Hassoun, Nicole title: Legitimate Coercion: What Consent Can and Cannot Do date: 2014 words: 3882 flesch: 58 summary: If states can ensure their subjects secure the capacities they need to consent, the cost of doing so cannot justify riding rough-shod over basic libertarian rights. He wants to know what libertarian rights states violate if they do not ensure that people secure basic capacities. keywords: able; actual; annie; argument; autonomous; autonomy; basic; capacities; claim; coercion; coercive; consent; free; freedom; goodman; idea; institutions; land; leap; legitimate; libertarians; people; property; rights; rule; secure; state; stone; subjects; sufficient; tan cache: leap-297567.pdf plain text: leap-297567.txt item: #21 of 83 id: leap-297568 author: Valentini, Laura title: Two Pictures of the Global-justice Debate: A Reply to Tan date: 2014 words: 3267 flesch: 49 summary: IntroductIon Kok-chor tan’s review essay offers an internal critique of my perspective on global justice. tan grants my coercion-based account of the triggers of justice-obligations, but takes issue with my claim that, on that account, “global justice requires more than statist assistance, but less than full-blown cosmopolitan equality” (Valentini 2011: 20, quoted in tan 2014: 201). keywords: account; book; borders; coercion; cosmopolitanism; debate; distributive; domestic; economic; egalitarian; equality; global; goods; international; justice; leap; obligations; oxford; political; press; principles; question; recipients; relevant; socio; states; statism; statists; systemic; tan; trade; valentini; view; world cache: leap-297568.pdf plain text: leap-297568.txt item: #22 of 83 id: leap-297569 author: Tan, Kok-Chor title: A Brief Rejoinder to Valentini date: 2014 words: 1170 flesch: 33 summary: In my view, Valentini’s position as clarified in her reply is more clearly a variant of cosmopolitan egalitarianism. Valentini offers two reasons why her position is distinctive from cosmopolitan egalitarianism and occupies a middle position. keywords: cosmopolitan; distributive; egalitarianism; equality; global; ground; justice; obligations; point; position; recipients; states; valentini cache: leap-297569.pdf plain text: leap-297569.txt item: #23 of 83 id: leap-297570 author: , title: Whole number (2) date: 2014 words: 106535 flesch: 54 summary: although there are many other good arguments for aiding the global poor, the book attempts to address two kinds of skeptics: libertarians and statists. But other people have different intuitions. keywords: able; acceptable; according; account; actual; actual consent; addition; additive; affairs; affected; aggregationist; aid; alternatives; analogy; annie; anti; appeal; approach; argument; arneson; arrangements; article; aspects view; assistance; autonomous; autonomy; autonomy argument; available; average; axiom; bad; bases; basic; benefits; best; better; betterness; bites; blake; book; business; cambridge; capacities; capital; care; casal; case; case argument; central; certain; childrearing; children; choice; chor; circumstances; citizens; claim; clear; coercion; coercive; coercive institutions; commitments; comparative; comparative view; compare; comparison; compatible; conception; concern; concerned; conclusion; conditions; consent; consent theory; consequences; considered; context; contract; contrary; control; cosmopolitan; costs; countries; course; day; debate; decisions; defense; degree; democracy; democratic; dependent; determined; diagram; differences; different; disagreement; discussion; dissent; distinct; distributive; domestic; duration; duties; duty; e.g.; economic; education; effects; egalitarian; egalitarianism; emphasis; employees; equality; ethics; example; exercise; exist; existence; extent; external; face; fact; factors; fair; families; features; firms; focus; following; follows; food; force; form; freedom; fundamental; general; generates; global; global coercion; global egalitarian; global justice; global order; globalization; goals; gonzález; good; goodman; goodness; great; greater; grounds; group; hand; hart; harvard; hassoun; having; health; heaven; hell; help; high; hold; horta; humanitarian; hypothetical; ideals; identity; iii; impersonal; implications; important; inconsistent; individuals; ingmar; initial; instance; institutions; intense; intensity; interesting; interests; internal; internal aspects; internal view; international; intrinsic; intuitions; issue; job; john; journal; judgments; justice; justification; justified; key; kind; kok; labor; lack; land; large; larry; law; leap; legal; legitimacy; level; liberals; libertarian; libertarian state; life; like; likely; limited; little; lives; living; locke; long; longer; main; making; managers; market; marriage; matter; meaningful; means; members; mere; mind; model; month; moral; mosquito; nagel; narrow; natural; nature; necessary; need; new; new people; nicole; non; nonprocreators; normative; note; notion; number; object; obligations; offer; officials; ones; open; opportunities; option; order; original; outcomes; oxford; pain; paper; parallel; parents; parfit; particular; pay; people; perfect; person; philosophical; philosophy; plausible; pogge; point; policies; policy; political; poor; population; position; positive; possibility; possible; potential; poverty; power; practical; practice; premise; present; press; principle; problem; properties; property; prospects; public; purposes; question; rawls; realm; reason; reasoning; recipients; regards; relation; relationship; relevant; reply; rescue; resources; respect; response; responsibility; result; rethinking; review; richard; ricoy; rights; rise; role; rules; second; section; secure; self; sense; set; share; significant; similar; similarities; similarity; single; situation; small; social; society; socio; sort; special; spectrum; spectrum arguments; stable; standard; standard view; state; status; stone; strong; structure; subjects; sufficient; supervenient; supply; support; system; systematic; tan; taste; temkin; temkin leap; terms; theories; theorists; theory; things; think; thought; time; torture; total; trade; transitive; transitivity; true; turn; understanding; units; university; use; utility; valentini; value; version; view; virtue; voluntary; water; way; ways; welfare; wellbeing; wide; williams; women; workers; workplace; world; worse; worth; years; york cache: leap-297570.pdf plain text: leap-297570.txt item: #24 of 83 id: leap-313495 author: Da Silva, Michael title: Offsetting the harms of extinction date: 2015 words: 10930 flesch: 58 summary: i meless perspective it is hard to identif y good reasons why it should matter that human extinction comes later rather than sooner” (2002: 253). This raises issues in moral mathematics that can be fruitfully explored in extinction cases. keywords: alternative; bad; badness; benefits; best; better; broome; cases; certain; choice; circumstances; claim; common; comparative; conclusion; continued; current; death; development; earlier; earth; effects; existence; extinction; future; future generations; future persons; generations; good; greater; harms; hat; high; highest; highest high; history; human; humanity; impartial; impersonal; intuitions; large; leap; level; life; likely; lives; long; longer; loss; mcmahan; michael; moral; non; number; offer; outcome; people; periods; persons; pill; place; plausible; possible; potential; potential future; potential persons; potential utility; preferable; principle; reason; relative; repugnant; result; return; salesman; scenarios; silva; similar; species; time; true; utility; value; view; world; worse; worth; years cache: leap-313495.pdf plain text: leap-313495.txt item: #25 of 83 id: leap-313497 author: Blumenson, Eric title: The Limits of Moral Argument: Reason and Conviction in Tadros' Philosophy of Punishment date: 2015 words: 13053 flesch: 57 summary: In his highly regarded 2011 book The Ends of Harm and in papers since refining some of his views,2 Tadros offers a truly original justification for state punishment, and does so with impressive dept h How does Tadros get all the way from the permissibility of defensive force to the permissibility of state punishment? keywords: absence; aggressor; argument; argumentative; basis; benefit; best; better; blumenson; bob; boulder; case; chain; choice; citizens; claims; compensation; compensatory; conclusion; considered; contingent; convictions; counter; crime; criminal; critique; defense; defensive; degree; desert; deterrence; different; distended; duties; duty; duty view; ends; equilibrium; eric; example; factors; force; future; general; good; greater; grounds; guilty; harm; hat; ill; individual; inf; innocent; intuitive; judgments; justice; justification; kind; law; leap; liability; liable; limits; means; methodology; moral; moral argument; necessary; negative; new; non; note; obligation; offender; particular; people; person; philosophy; point; press; principle; problem; proportionality; protective; punishing; punishment; question; rationale; rawls; reason; reasoning; remedy; required; residual; resources; response; retributive; retributivism; right; second; section; self; sentences; sentencing; specific; state; step; subject; suffering; support; system; t hat; tadros; theories; theory; threat; time; truth; university; use; utilitarian; victim; victor; view; way; work; wrongdoer; wrongful cache: leap-313497.pdf plain text: leap-313497.txt item: #26 of 83 id: leap-313504 author: Tadros, Victor title: Response to Blumenson date: 2015 words: 7730 flesch: 65 summary: 1. METHODOLOGY Blumenson thinks that the fact that there are many duties, with uncertain scope, involved in DV provides some reason to reject that view. Any system of state punishment is enormously costly. keywords: account; argument; blumenson; claim; compensation; criminal; desert; duties; duty; ends; example; fact; forfeiture; good; great; harm; hat; idea; law; leap; maximum; means; moral; negative; nozick; offender; oxford; particular; people; permissible; person; plausible; punishment; question; reason; response; rights; satisfied; state; steps; tadros; theory; threat; threshold; true; victim; view; virtue; way; wrongdoers; wrongdoing cache: leap-313504.pdf plain text: leap-313504.txt item: #27 of 83 id: leap-313505 author: Casal, Paula title: Unjust Gender Inequalities date: 2015 words: 2140 flesch: 56 summary: In addition, each instance of gender inequality Van Parijs describes is a lso intrig uing in its ow n right, and not only as an illustration of t he general problem just described. The va lue of discussing t hese questions, stressed by Van Parijs’ response “Real Freedom for All Women (and Men),” thus extends well beyond feminism. keywords: claim; concerns; discrimination; distributive; educational; example; exchange; fact; focus; gender; greater; hat; hormones; incarceration; inequalities; inequality; injustice; leap; male; men; miguel; opportunities; parijs; prostitutes; puzzle; rates; respects; second; sexual; slave; social; society; university; unjust; van; women cache: leap-313505.pdf plain text: leap-313505.txt item: #28 of 83 id: leap-313506 author: Van Parijs, Philippe title: Four Puzzles on Gender Equality date: 2015 words: 4971 flesch: 56 summary: Indeed, under the French or British system of single-member constituencies, and on the reasonable assumption that women form the majority of the voting public in every one of them, women have the power to make sure that only women get into the parliamentary assembly. LEAP 3 (2015) Four Puzzles on Gender Equality PHILIPPE VA N PA R IJS Université Catholique de Louvain Abstract There are dimensions a long which men seem to be disadvantaged, on average, relative to women. keywords: advantage; annual; assumption; audience; average; belgium; brussels; care; case; difference; dimensions; doubt; educational; electoral; example; expectancy; fact; favor; female; form; gap; gender; greater; group; higher; income; inequalities; inequality; injustice; leap; life; longer; majority; members; money; parijs; people; philippe; point; political; poor; power; prison; puzzles; real; significant; social; system; thought; time; unjust; vote; way; women; years cache: leap-313506.pdf plain text: leap-313506.txt item: #29 of 83 id: leap-313507 author: Casal, Paula title: Distributive Justice and Female Longevity date: 2015 words: 7864 flesch: 59 summary: If these explanations are correct, Van Parijs’ assumption that, if longevity has a biological explanation, then men’s lack of female longevity is unjust, would be a non sequitur. Van Parijs may want to reject Dworkin’s account and all forms of egalitarian liberalism that conclude men’s lack of female longevity is not unjust, and he may be able to offer good reasons for doing so. keywords: advantage; age; area; behavior; benefit; cambridge; care; casal; case; causes; choice; claim; compensation; condition; consequences; contrast; costs; death; difference; distributive; dworkin; egalitarian; elderly; example; expectancy; explanation; extra; factors; far; female; female longevity; fig; final; gap; gendered; greater; humans; income; individuals; inequality; injustice; justice; kekes; lack; large; leap; liability; liberal; liberalism; life; lifestyles; likely; longer; longevity; males; man; men; natural; non; offspring; oxford; parijs; paula; pay; people; plausible; press; relative; resources; scanlon; second; segall; self; sex; significant; social; society; species; trait; unfair; university; unjust; value; van; van parijs; view; violence; way; williams; women; years; young; younger cache: leap-313507.pdf plain text: leap-313507.txt item: #30 of 83 id: leap-313508 author: Mora, Jesús title: Women's Greater Educational Efforts as a Consequence of Inequality date: 2015 words: 4153 flesch: 56 summary: Therefore, the situation of women in access to leadership is hindered by the interplay of first, the assumption of their lack of competence to exercise power and, second, t he negat ive percept ion of t hose women who at tempt to put leadership-associated abilities into practice. It seems, then, that educated women are penalized for being women less than less educated women are by all those who select them as either employees or as co-parents or partners. keywords: access; addition; bianchi; careers; children; consequence; different; domains; domestic; economic; education; efforts; employment; explanation; exploitation; face; fact; families; female; gender; greater; group; harder; higher; home; ies; income; inequality; injustice; jesús; job; labor; leadership; leap; mora; mse; need; occupations; parenting; parijs; positions; poverty; power; protection; qualified; review; risk; school; single; social; traditional; van; women; work; workplace cache: leap-313508.pdf plain text: leap-313508.txt item: #31 of 83 id: leap-313509 author: Vandamme, Pierre-Étienne title: Do Women Enjoy a Political Advantage? Majority Position and Democratic Justice date: 2015 words: 3762 flesch: 52 summary: first, t hat women form a potential majority in all constituencies with universal suffrage where they enjoy longer life expectancy. LEAP 3 (2015) Do Women Enjoy a Political Advantage? keywords: active; advantage; cambridge; common; countries; democracy; democratic; domination; education; elections; electoral; expectancy; fact; favor; gender; group; higher; imbalance; inequality; injustice; interests; leap; level; life; majority; minority; norris; opportunities; parijs; participation; people; political; politics; potential; power; press; puzzles; stevens; turnout; unequal; university; unjust; use; van; van parijs; vote; women cache: leap-313509.pdf plain text: leap-313509.txt item: #32 of 83 id: leap-313510 author: Ottonelli, Valeria title: A Blatant Case of Over-Accommodation date: 2015 words: 5071 flesch: 48 summary: Men represent 93% of political leaders (heads of state or heads of government) in the world;7 88% of U.S. State Governors are men; 88% of mayors of U.S. major cities are male; 8 in Europe, 66% of members of National Supreme Courts are men;9 LEAP 3 (2015) A Blatant Case of Over-Accommodation1 VA L E R I A OT TON E L L I Genova University Abstract Van Parijs asks whether the fact that men engage in regrettable behavior at much higher rates than women could be seen as a “handicap” due to their hormonal set-up, and therefore as a dimension of gender inequality to men’s disadvantage. keywords: accommodation; affected; aggressive; assumptions; behavior; blatant; careless; case; causes; central; character; competitive; constitution; course; dangerous; disabilities; disability; disadvantage; discussion; equality; europe; example; fact; february; gender; handicap; hat; high; higher; hormonal; hormones; http://www.unwomen.org/en/what-we-do/leadership-and-political-participation/facts; incarceration; injustice; ions; journal; leap; levels; likely; majority; male; medical; men; notion; order; ottonelli; parijs; people; physical; political; press; prone; puzzle; rates; resources; risk; sexual; social; society; taking; terms; testosterone; trait; unempathetic; university; unwarranted; valeria; van; van parijs; violence; welfare; western; women; world cache: leap-313510.pdf plain text: leap-313510.txt item: #33 of 83 id: leap-313511 author: Schouten, Gina title: Are Unequal Incarceration Rates Unjust to Men? date: 2015 words: 7442 flesch: 58 summary: Second, t here is ev idence t hat men increasingly do prefer gender ega l ita r ia n pa r t nersh ips a nd a la rger sha re of ca reg iv Just as many women would have been better off with more opportunities for stimulation and esteem in the world of paid work, many men would have been better off with more opportunities for the intimacy and fulfillment that caregiving 145 keywords: ante; better; caregiving; choice; contingencies; costly; costs; crime; criminality; differences; disadvantage; division; education; effects; elevated; endowment; ethics; fact; female; gender; gendered; genetic; gina; goods; greater; harmful; harms; heir; higher; incarceration; incommensurable; inequalities; inequality; inf; injustice; intuition; labor; leap; life; likelier; likelihood; likely; male; men; natural; norms; oxford; parijs; point; press; propensity; prospects; puzzle; question; rates; reasons; reform; relevant; response; role; schouten; share; social; terms; unchosen; unequal; university; unjust; urgency; urgent; victims; violence; violent; way; women; work; worse cache: leap-313511.pdf plain text: leap-313511.txt item: #34 of 83 id: leap-313512 author: De Miguel, Ana title: The Rich also Cry date: 2015 words: 4651 flesch: 63 summary: He tries to describe some possible advantages women have compared to men and comes up with these: women outlive the men they look after; women earn less but study more; women have less political representation but vote more; women are the victims of crime rather than the perpetrators; and women tend to be those whose body is sold, rather than the client or pimp (Van Parijs 2015). Wow, men must be really envious! keywords: alleged; ana; audience; brothels; cause; class; desire; fact; female; feminists; focus; gender; girls; greedier; handicap; handicapped; help; ill; itch; ith; kahn; leap; libido; life; losses; maid; male; man; men; miguel; naked; need; paper; parijs; pateman; people; philippe; philosopher; pity; poor; preference; problem; prostitutes; prostitution; rape; relief; reputation; rich; sex; sexual; strauss; super; thing; thinking; thirst; understanding; van; van parijs; way; weakness; women; world; young cache: leap-313512.pdf plain text: leap-313512.txt item: #35 of 83 id: leap-313513 author: Van Parijs, Philippe title: Real Freedom for all Women (and Men): A Reply date: 2015 words: 7327 flesch: 57 summary: con st it ute i ncom men su r able for m s of injust ice, a nd if a n unjust inequa lit y develops in favor of women, t his would not reduce but further worsen gender injustice. Above all, it questions the very idea of discussing issues of gender and justice in terms of “gender justice,” i.e., of justice between two categories of human beings. keywords: advantage; average; basic; behavior; better; care; casal; case; categorical; categories; challenge; comments; conception; consequences; cost; demands; difference; disadvantage; discussion; distinction; dworkinian; education; example; expectancy; favor; female; form; freedom; gap; gender; gender justice; genuine; good; greater; hat; health; higher; human; incarceration; income; inequalities; inequality; ing; injustice; interests; issues; justice; leap; level; life; longer; longevity; majority; male; man; miguel; mora; need; order; parijs; particular; pattern; philippe; point; political; power; preference; pro; public; puzzles; question; real; real freedom; response; schouten; sense; social; social justice; sort; specific; terms; time; unconditional; unjust; way; women; years cache: leap-313513.pdf plain text: leap-313513.txt item: #36 of 83 id: leap-313514 author: Williams, Andrew title: Family Values: An Introduction date: 2015 words: 518 flesch: 45 summary: In recent years, some of the most notable contributions to the emerging debate have arisen v ia joint work by Harr y Brighouse and Adam Sw ift, leading eventually to the publication of their book, Family Values: The Ethics of Parent-Child Relationships (Brighouse and Swift, 2014). LEAP 3 (2016) Family Values: An Introduction ANdREw wILLIAmS ICREA & Universitat Pompeu Fabra keywords: account; brighouse; family; inf; institutions; interests; leap; luence; political; role; swift; values cache: leap-313514.pdf plain text: leap-313514.txt item: #37 of 83 id: leap-313515 author: Stroud, Sarah title: Egalitarian Family Values? date: 2015 words: 6541 flesch: 60 summary: Brighouse and Swift endorse the concern but think that the great value of family relationship goods is nonetheless sufficient to vindicate the existence of the family. Brighouse and Swift thus seem overly optimistic when they say early on that they will “offer an account of ‘family values properly understood’ … that mitigates—massively mitigates—the conf lict with equality” (2014: 4; added emphasis). keywords: action; adults; argument; bequeath; bequests; brighouse; case; certain; child; child relationship; children; consequentialist; desirable; distinctive; distribution; egalitarian; equality; ethics; existence; fair; familial; families; family; family values; goods; great; important; interests; intrinsic; issue; justification; kind; leap; life; love; moral; need; new; objection; opportunity; oxford; parental; parenting; parents; particular; people; place; possible; privileges; prohibit; putative; question; realization; reason; relationship; rights; sarah; set; significant; stroud; swift; thing; valuable; values; way; wealth; world cache: leap-313515.pdf plain text: leap-313515.txt item: #38 of 83 id: leap-313516 author: Gheaus, Anca title: Is There a Right to Parent? date: 2015 words: 5869 flesch: 57 summary: According to their dual-interest account, adults’ interest in parenting plays a role in explaining why less than optimal parents can exercise legitimate authority over children. Keywords: parents, children, right to parent One of the main questions to which Family Values offers an answer is how to just if y t he fa mi ly g iven keywords: account; adequate; adults; anca; appeal; arrangements; authoritative; authority; best; brighouse; case; challenge; childrearing; children; close; combination; contribution; control; defense; development; different; duty; fact; family; features; flourishing; fundamental; gheaus; good; hat; individuals; interest; intimacy; intimate; leap; legitimate; liberal; life; like; lives; moral; parent; parental; parenting; particular; people; possible; power; powerful; raising; reason; refugees; relationship; responsibility; right; swift; time; unique; value; way; willing cache: leap-313516.pdf plain text: leap-313516.txt item: #39 of 83 id: leap-313517 author: Ferracioli, Luara title: Why the Family? date: 2015 words: 7440 flesch: 52 summary: In order to explain why it is good for adults to parent children even when children could conceivably fare better under alternative arrangements, we need to say something about the interest parents have in playing their own role in the relationship. An alternative to both these views is the “dual-interest” account of child rearing.5 keywords: account; adults; authority; autonomous; autonomy; basic; brighouse; capable; caring; child; child relationship; childhood; children; claim; competent; context; continuity; desideratum; discussion; disposition; dual; exercise; fact; family; ferracioli; fiduciary; good; ground; hat; interest; interest account; intimate; justification; leap; liberal; life; lives; love; loving; luara; mode; need; non; parent; parental; parenting; particular; paternalism; public; question; relationship; right; robust; role; section; skills; sort; special; state; swift; theory; true; university; valuable; value cache: leap-313517.pdf plain text: leap-313517.txt item: #40 of 83 id: leap-313518 author: Brighouse, Harry; Swift, Adam title: Advantage, Authority, Autonomy and Continuity: A Response to Ferracioli, Gheaus and Stroud date: 2015 words: 10743 flesch: 56 summary: According to Stroud (2016: 184), “there is no issue facing us as a society, to be settled collectively, about how to bring up children: there are only individual adults who want to parent children”. The mere fact that individual adults want to parent children is not sufficient to establish the moral propriety of their doing so. keywords: account; adam; adulthood; adults; advantage; approach; arrangements; authority; autonomy; best; better; brighouse; case; challenge; child relationship; childhood; childrearing; children; circumstances; claim; considerations; content; continuity; control; different; distributive; dual; equality; ethics; exercise; fact; fair; familial; family; ferracioli; fiduciary; future; game; general; gheaus; good; harry; hat; important; interactions; interests; justification; kind; leap; liberal; life; lives; moral; need; non; opportunity; parental; parented; parenting; parents; particular; people; possible; question; raising; refugees; relationship; relevant; response; right; role; second; socializing; specific; stroud; swift; terms; theory; things; valuable; value; view; way; ways; world; wrong cache: leap-313518.pdf plain text: leap-313518.txt item: #41 of 83 id: leap-313606 author: , title: Whole number (3) date: 2015 words: 111175 flesch: 56 summary: First, t hat women form a potential majority in all constituencies with universal suffrage where they enjoy longer life expectancy. “hormona l inequa lit y” is t he claim t hat men are handicapped by possessing more hormones linked to undesirable behaviors such as those involving imprudence or aggression. keywords: absence; abstract; access; accommodation; account; acting; action; activities; adam; additional; adequate; adulthood; adults; advantage; affairs; aggressive; aggressor; alive; alleged; alternative; answer; appeal; appealing; approach; appropriate; argue; argument; argumentative; arrangements; aspect; assumption; attempt; attention; attractive; audience; authority; authors; autonomous; autonomy; available; average; background; bad; badness; balance; basic; behavior; beings; believe; benefit; best; better; bibliography; biological; birth; blumenson; blumenson leap; bob; body; books; brief; brighouse; calculations; cambridge; capable; capacity; care; careers; caregiving; caring; casal; case; causes; central; certain; chain; challenge; chance; character; child relationship; childhood; childrearing; children; choice; circumstances; citizens; claim; clear; close; comments; committed; common; comparative; compatible; compensation; compensatory; competent; complex; conception; concerned; concerns; conclusion; condition; confidence; consequences; consequentialist; considerations; considered; constitution; constraint; context; contingent; continued; continuity; contrary; contrast; contribution; control; controversial; core; correct; cost; costly; counter; countries; country; course; crime; criminal; criminality; critics; cultural; current; dangerous; deal; death; debate; decisions; defense; defensive; degree; demands; democracy; democratic; desert; desideratum; desirable; desire; deterrence; developed; development; differences; different; difficult; dimensions; direct; disabilities; disadvantage; discrimination; discussion; disposition; distinctive; distributive; division; domestic; domination; doubt; duties; duty; duty view; dworkin; earlier; early; earth; easy; economic; educated; education; effective; effects; efforts; egalitarian; elderly; elections; electoral; element; emphasis; empirical; endorse; ends; engage; eric; essential; ethics; european; ex t; example; exercise; existence; exit; expectancy; experience; explanation; exploitation; extent; extinction; extra; fabra; face; fact; factors; fair; false; familial; families; family; family values; far; favor; features; february; female; feminists; ferracioli; ferzan; fiduciary; final; flourishing; focus; following; force; forfeiture; form; freedom; fundamental; future; game; gap; gender; gender equality; gender inequality; gender justice; gendered; general; generations; generis; genetic; gheaus; gina; giving; good; grateful; greater; grounds; group; handicap; handicapped; hard; harder; harm; harmful; harry; harvard; health; help; hen; high; higher; highest; history; home; hope; hormonal; hormones; human; humanity; ia l; idea; iii; ill; imbalance; impact; impartial; impersonal; implications; important; incarceration; income; increase; independent; individuals; inequalities; inequality; inf; ing; injustice; innocent; instance; institutions; interactions; interesting; interests; intimacy; intimate; intrinsic; introduction; intuition; intuitive; issues; ith; jesús; job; jobs; john; journal; justice; justification; kahn; kekes; key; keywords; kind; know; l l; l ly; l t; labor; lack; large; later; law; ld t; lead; leadership; leap; legal; legitimate; level; liability; liable; liberal; lict; life; lifestyles; lifetime; like; likelier; likelihood; likely; limited; limits; little; lives; longer; longevity; look; loss; louvain; love; loving; luara; luence; main; majority; making; males; matter; maximum; mcmahan; means; medical; members; men; men women; mere; michael; miguel; mind; minority; missing; monetary; money; moral; n t; natural; nature; nd t; necessary; need; negative; new; ng t; non; normative; norms; note; nozick; number; objection; obligation; obvious; offender; offer; offspring; opportunities; opportunity; options; order; original; ottonelli; outcome; outside; overall; oxford; paper; parent; parent children; parental; parented; parenting; parijs; parijs leap; participation; particular; parties; partner; pateman; paternalism; paula; pay; people; period; permissible; person; perspective; philippe; philosophers; philosophical; philosophy; physical; picture; piece; pill; place; plausibility; plausible; play; playing; point; policies; policy; political; politics; pompeu; poor; population; position; positive; possibility; possible; potential; poverty; power; powerful; preferable; preference; present; press; previous; prima; princeton; principle; prison; privileges; problem; problematic; process; progress; propensity; prospects; prostitutes; prostitution; protection; provide; public; punishing; punishment; putative; puzzles; qualified; question; r t; r y; raising; rates; rationale; rawls; reach; real; reason; reasoning; recent; refugees; regard; relationship; relative; relevant; remedy; rents; reply; repugnant; required; resources; respect; response; responsibility; responsible; result; retributivism; return; review; rich; right; risk; robust; role; rom; s t; sake; satisfied; scanlon; scenarios; school; schouten; scope; second; section; secure; self; sense; separate; services; set; sex; sexual; shou; significant; silva; similar; simple; situation; skills; small; smaller; social; socialization; societies; society; sort; special; species; specific; standard; start; state; status; step; strauss; strong; stroud; studies; subject; substantial; successful; suffering; sufficient; suggestion; sui; support; sure; swift; swift leap; system; t hat; t heir; t hem; t hese; t ia; t icu; t ion; t t; tadros; tadros leap; task; tax; tendency; terms; testosterone; theories; theorists; theory; thing; thinking; thought; threat; threshold; time; today; total; trait; treatment; true; truth; turnout; unchosen; unconditional; understanding; unequal; unfair; unique; united; university; university press; unjust; unlikely; urgent; useful; utility; valuable; value; van; van parijs; vandamme; version; victim; victor; view; violence; violent; virtue; vote; voting; vulnerable; w ith; way; ways; weighty; welfare; williams; willing; women; words; work; workplace; world; worry; worse; worth; wou; wrong; wrongdoer; wrongdoing; wrongful; y t; years; york; young; younger cache: leap-313606.pdf plain text: leap-313606.txt item: #42 of 83 id: leap-321399 author: Davis, Ryan W. title: Which Moral Requiriments Does Constituvism Support? date: 2016 words: 10930 flesch: 55 summary: 192).5 In any case, once we grant that ideal agents finally desire to not interfere with and to help other agents, then we can quickly see that they have reasons to do the same. I acknowledge as much; it is important that the case I describe here could not arise among ideal agents. keywords: account; action; agent; attitudes; belief; better; cambridge; capacities; capacity; case; choice; coherence; coherent; concern; conf; constitutivist; davis; desires; dominant; drug; duties; ethics; example; exercise; final; future; helping; ideal; ideal agent; interference; interfering; judgment; kind; leap; lict; likely; moral; moral requirements; morality; non; obligated; obligations; oxford; philosophical; philosophy; possible; press; psychology; question; rational; rational capacities; reasons; relative; requirements; respect; robustly; ryan; self; set; smith; standard; story; support; university; user; version; way; world cache: leap-321399.pdf plain text: leap-321399.txt item: #43 of 83 id: leap-321400 author: Guelke, John; Sorell, Tom title: Violations of privacy and law : The case of Stalking date: 2016 words: 13662 flesch: 50 summary: If mental vulnerability is prolonged in time, as often occurs in stalking cases, the harm caused is proportionally greater. What is missing in many cases of harassment but present in nearly all cases of stalking is the wish on the part of the harassers to be permanently 23 http://w w w.cps.gov.uk/legal/s_to_u/stalking_and_harassment/#a02a 24 Sometimes in stalking cases additional people will assist the stalker —see for example Fine (1997) —but this is exceptional. keywords: access; account; acquaintance; activity; agent; alarm; american; associated; attempt; attention; autonomy; behavior; bodily; body; case; category; close; common; conduct; contact; control; core; course; crime; davis; deep; deliberation; different; distress; dynamics; example; exposure; family; fear; feminist; fine; following; form; gender; guelke; harassment; harm; home; home space; human; individual; information; interest; intimacy; intrusion; invasion; john; kind; law; laws; leap; legislation; life; likely; meloy; mental; mind; moral; mullen; need; new; non; obsessive; offense; people; persistent; person; personal; personality; physical; place; point; political; power; presence; press; prior; privacy; private; protection; psychological; public; pursuit; range; rape; ref; relationship; review; right; romantic; section; self; sense; set; sexual; social; sorell.indd; space; stalker; stalking; stasi; state; surveillance; target; threat; tom; university; unwanted; value; victim; violations; violence; violent; way; women; wrong; zones cache: leap-321400.pdf plain text: leap-321400.txt item: #44 of 83 id: leap-321401 author: Ryberg, Jesper title: Compulsory Medication, Trial Competence, and Penal Theory date: 2016 words: 10335 flesch: 42 summary: In this article it is argued that the reason that has constituted the main argument in favor of forcible medication of defendants —namely, that the state has an essential interest in convicting and sentencing defendants who are guilty of crime —is not as strong as has been assumed and may even, under certain conditions, speak against the use of forcible medication of trial incompetent defendants. Be that as it may, let us now start take a closer view on the arguments that have been advanced for and against forcible medication of trial incompetent defendants. keywords: acceptable; answer; approach; argument; bringing; case; clear; competence; compulsory; conditions; considerations; correct; court; crime; criminal; defendants; different; discussion; e.g.; effect; fact; favor; forcible; forcible medication; general; ill; incompetent; incompetent defendants; instance; interest; jesper; justice; law; leap; medical; medication; mental; moral; non; number; objection; obvious; order; overpunishment; penal; people; perspective; point; prevention; proportionate; psychotropic; punishing; punishment; question; reasons; regard; retributivist; ryberg.indd; sell; state; strong; suffering; terms; theoretical; theory; treatment; trial; trial competence; trial incompetent; use; utilitarian; view; way cache: leap-321401.pdf plain text: leap-321401.txt item: #45 of 83 id: leap-321403 author: Blake, Michael; Brock, Gillian title: Justice, Fairness, and the Brain Drain date: 2016 words: 1554 flesch: 53 summary: Such emigration also represents a regressive transfer of wealth, as those educated by an impoverished society frequently use that education to benefit the more well-off. The effects of such emigration may also undermine those institutions that are necessary for the administration of justice. keywords: blake; brain; brock; emigration; exit; form; global; inequality; injustice; justice; malawi; medical; particular; people; policies; professionals; question; right; states; unjust; world cache: leap-321403.pdf plain text: leap-321403.txt item: #46 of 83 id: leap-321404 author: Oberman, Kieran title: Emigration in a Time of Cholera: Freedom, Brain Drain, and Human Rights date: 2016 words: 9283 flesch: 60 summary: Rather it involves recognizing that the right is sometimes in tension with other human rights, such as the right to health. Keywords: emigration, immigration, freedom, brain drain, human rights, Michael Blake, Gillian Brock. keywords: absolute; article; attachments; basic; benefit; blake; brain; brock; case; cholera; coercion; compensation; compulsory; conditions; costs; countries; country; curtailment; duty; efficacy; emergency; emigration; emigration restrictions; fact; freedom; governments; group; human; human rights; important; interest; international; justification; justified; kieran; law; leap; life; necessity; need; oberman; options; party; people; person; poor; poverty; problem; programs; proportionality; relationships; restrictions; rich; right; section; service; severe; skilled; states; time; violation; workers; world cache: leap-321404.pdf plain text: leap-321404.txt item: #47 of 83 id: leap-321405 author: Kollar, Eszter title: The Distinction Between Taxation and Public Service in the Debate on Emigration date: 2016 words: 4343 flesch: 53 summary: 03 Kollar.indd The Distinction Between Taxation and Public Service in the Debate on Emigration1 E SZ T E R KOL L A R Goethe University Frankfurt AbSTRAcT Are taxation and public service requirement for prospective emigrants justifiable in a liberal state? By contrast, Blake thinks that public service is impermissible, and only justified under emergency conditions when the liberal state itself is under threat. keywords: account; benefits; blake; brock; conditions; cooperation; distinction; drain; emergency; emigrants; emigration; extreme; fabre; fair; idea; justice; justification; kollar; labor; leap; liberal; life; medical; moral; need; normative; obligations; persons; plans; public; public service; reciprocity; requirement; resources; right; service; skills; social; state; talents; taxation; terms; use; way cache: leap-321405.pdf plain text: leap-321405.txt item: #48 of 83 id: leap-321406 author: Rapoport, Hillel title: Who is Afraid of the Brain Drain? A Development Economist's View date: 2016 words: 5963 flesch: 50 summary: The main cross-country study is a paper I have co-authored with Michel Beine and Frederic Docquier (2008).3 We proceed in two steps: we first estimate the elasticity of human capital to skilled emigration, measuring how emigration prospects for the highly-skilled affect gross human capital formation in home countries, controlling for past human capital levels and a series of country-characteristics. I posit that there are dynamic and long-term effects of high skilled emigration that work through indirect channels to benefit the countries of origin, for instance through international trade and investment, social remittances, and incentive schemes for the ones left behind. keywords: afraid; brain; brain drain; british; brock; cake; capital; case; certain; countries; country; development; diffusion; docquier; economic; economist; economy; educated; education; effect; emigration; ethnic; evidence; example; experience; fact; following; formation; forthcoming; gain; global; high; higher; hillel; home; human; human capital; incentive; income; international; journal; leap; literature; losses; migrants; origin; people; percent; policy; political; prospects; rapoport; remittances; restrictions; review; skilled; stock; studies; terms; trade; university; variable; view; wage; workers; world cache: leap-321406.pdf plain text: leap-321406.txt item: #49 of 83 id: leap-321407 author: Carens, Joseph H. title: Expanding the Brain Drain Debate date: 2016 words: 6431 flesch: 58 summary: From that perspective, most people from poor states don’t have a moral claim to entry into rich states, whether they are talented and skilled or not, and rich states thus do no wrong in excluding them. So, the key question is whether, under those circumstances, restrictions on immigration by rich states would be morally permissible, or perhaps even morally obligatory, if the restrictions helped to contribute to a reduction in emigration that would be beneficial to poor states. keywords: acceptable; admission; blake; book; brain drain; brock; carens; citizens; debate; discussion; drain; duties; duty; emigration; entry; exit; focus; global; human; important; interests; justice; leap; legal; medical; moral; people; permissible; personnel; policies; policy; poor; poor states; problem; question; respect; restrictions; rich; rich states; right; skilled; social; states; training; use; view; way cache: leap-321407.pdf plain text: leap-321407.txt item: #50 of 83 id: leap-321408 author: Blake, Michael title: Ethics, Politics, and Emigration date: 2016 words: 7482 flesch: 60 summary: This is why, for me, Fabré’s argument 5 I would note, in passing, that the libertarian view would include both money and the body as subject to this sort of pre-political right; Robert Nozick’s vision of the minimal state is produced precisely from the conviction that people have natural rights both to the body and to what that body acquires through labor and transfer. We do not simply appeal to altruism and moral duty in the course of seeking justification for inequality. keywords: blake; body; brain; carens; coercion; coercive; collective; course; distinct; duties; duty; emigration; end; ethical; ethics; forms; great; instance; institutions; justice; justification; kollar; labor; law; leap; life; love; making; migrants; money; moral; oberman; particular; people; permissible; point; policy; political; politics; problem; question; rawls; reason; reference; right; self; social; society; sort; state; subject; thought; use; view; way; world; wrong cache: leap-321408.pdf plain text: leap-321408.txt item: #51 of 83 id: leap-321409 author: Brock, Gillian title: Responsabilities in an Unjust World: A Reply to Carens, Kollar, Oberman, and Rapoport date: 2016 words: 9369 flesch: 53 summary: In particular, I argue that carefully crafted compulsory service and taxation programs may permissibly be used by such states under certain conditions. In the last section I have argued why developing countries may make use of carefully crafted programs that incentivize or require such service, such as all of (CS1)-(CS5) discussed in the previous section. keywords: argument; basic; brain; brock; carens; case; certain; citizens; community; compulsory; conditions; contributions; core; countries; country; decent; development; docquier; duties; economic; education; effects; empirical; evidence; fair; focus; gillian; high; human; important; institutions; issues; justice; kollar; leap; liberal; liberties; liberty; losses; medical; migration; moral; needs; oberman; origin; particular; people; play; policies; political; poor; press; problems; programs; question; rapoport; rawls; relevant; reply; responsibilities; restrictions; rights; section; service; skilled; skills; social; states; sufficient; taxation; terms; training; university; unjust; use; view; ways; world; year cache: leap-321409.pdf plain text: leap-321409.txt item: #52 of 83 id: leap-321412 author: Martí, José Luis title: Symposium on Thomas Christiano's Views on the Legitimacy of the International Order date: 2016 words: 1183 flesch: 35 summary: 0 Introducción.indd Symposium on Thomas Christiano’s Views on the Legitimacy of the International Order JOSÉ LU IS M A RT Í Pompeu Fabra University Thomas Christiano, one of the more prominent democratic theorists today (Christiano 1996, 2007), is developing some of the most refined and inf luential normative views on the legitimacy of global institutions and international law (Christiano 2006, 2010, 2011a, 2011b, 2012, 2013), with contributions to more specific issues like immigration (Christiano 2008b, 2017) and climate change (Christiano 2015), among others. C. Holder and D. Reidy, 301–325, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. —2012: “The Legitimacy of International Institutions”, in Routledge Companion to Philosophy of Law, ed. keywords: blake; cambridge; christiano; democracy; democratic; global; immigration; institutions; international; justice; law; lef; legitimacy; order; oxford; philosophy; press; states; symposium; university cache: leap-321412.pdf plain text: leap-321412.txt item: #53 of 83 id: leap-321413 author: Álvarez, David title: Democratic Legitimacy, International Institutions and Cosmopolitan Disaggregation date: 2016 words: 4823 flesch: 26 summary: Global duties related to subsidiary responsibilities regarding basic human rights and development belong to the proto-constitutional architecture of global legitimacy. But if we agree that global duties constitute external standards of legitimacy, then representative systems that are intrinsically biased against the fulfillment of these obligations cannot be fully legitimate. keywords: affected; alvarez.indd; authority; case; change; christiano; citizens; claims; climate; common; conception; conditions; consent; cooperation; cosmopolitan; david; deliberation; democracy; democratic; democratic legitimacy; domestic; duties; equality; external; fair; fda; global; goals; individuals; institutions; instrumental; interests; international; international institutions; international legitimacy; intrinsic; justice; leap; legitimacy; limits; making; members; model; moral; order; political; public; public equality; realization; ref; representative; scope; self; stakes; standards; state; state consent; system; value; voluntary; way; world; álvarez cache: leap-321413.pdf plain text: leap-321413.txt item: #54 of 83 id: leap-321414 author: Lefkowitz, David title: Democracy, Legitimacy, and Global Governance date: 2016 words: 5680 flesch: 39 summary: For Christiano law is fully (and inherently) legitimate if and only if it is the product of a law- making process that satisfies the principle of public equality: specifically, a democratic decision-making process in the case of a common world, and free and fair agreement where submission to a common rule is morally optional. International law and institutions can enjoy some legitimacy on instrumental grounds, however, even if they are neither democratic nor the product of agreement in free and fair conditions. keywords: act; agents; argument; authority; christiano; cognitive; common; complex; conditions; democracy; democratic; duty; equal; fda; fundamental; global; global democracy; global governance; governance; greater; individuals; institutions; interests; international; international law; judgment; justice; law; leap; legal; legitimacy; likely; moral; order; political; public; question; reason; rules; set; standard; states; subjects; valentini; world cache: leap-321414.pdf plain text: leap-321414.txt item: #55 of 83 id: leap-321415 author: Blake, Michael title: Migration, Legitimacy, and International Society : A Reply to Thomas Christiano date: 2016 words: 3813 flesch: 52 summary: I think this isn’t right – or, rather, that it isn’t quite right; treaties and collective decision-making can be useful tools, and perhaps correctives to the blindness of individual states, but they are no more than that. On my view, we need not think that multilateral institutions are the rightful home for legitimate policy; individual states have more freedom, to define and pursue their goals, than that. keywords: agent; authority; best; bodies; christiano; club; collective; course; democracies; democratic; dialogue; duties; duty; existing; global; good; individual; institutions; international; leap; legitimacy; like; likely; means; migration; moral; particular; pre; reason; right; sierra; society; states; true; united; view; world cache: leap-321415.pdf plain text: leap-321415.txt item: #56 of 83 id: leap-321417 author: Christiano, Thomas title: Replies to David Álvarez, David Lefkowitz, and Michael Blake date: 2016 words: 7383 flesch: 50 summary: So developing states normally have a significant deficit of power relative to developed states. If we think that part of the explanation for why citizens care about other distant fellow citizens is that they are forced to deal with them in a democratic system, the same may hold between persons of wealthy states and those of developing states when developed states are required to deal with developing states in a fairer way. keywords: aims; alvarez; authority; basic; blake; christiano; citizens; community; consent; cooperation; cosmopolitan; countries; david; decision; democratic; development; different; disagreement; global; good; important; institutions; interests; international; international community; international political; international system; justice; kind; leap; making; mandatory; mandatory aims; members; michael; moral; order; persons; political; political community; political system; poverty; power; process; pursuit; reasonable; reasons; refusal; replies; requirement; set; significant; societies; society; states; system; trade; way; world cache: leap-321417.pdf plain text: leap-321417.txt item: #57 of 83 id: leap-338376 author: Doucet, Mathieu title: Just Say No (For Now): The Ethics of Illegal Drug Use date: 2017 words: 9496 flesch: 52 summary: Second, the unequal ways in which drug laws are enforced make drug use by many an unethical exercise of privilege. In fact, drug laws turn out to represent an interesting exception case within the broader debate about this obligation, and I argue that it is the very injustice of the law that generates the reasons not to violate it. keywords: african; alcohol; americans; argument; cambridge; civil; clothing; conditions; consumer; costs; crime; criminal; democratic; disobedience; doucet; drug; drug laws; drug prohibition; drug trade; drug use; enforcement; ethics; example; existence; exploitative; fact; garment; general; harms; health; illegal; illegal drug; important; incarceration; independent; injustice; institutions; laws; leap; legalization; likely; majority; marijuana; mathieu; moral; moral reasons; obligation; people; policy; privilege; production; prohibition; public; reasons; recreational; responsible; result; second; significant; social; state; strong; trade; unethical; university; unjust; url; use; users; violence; violent; war; way; ways; white; workers cache: leap-338376.pdf plain text: leap-338376.txt item: #58 of 83 id: leap-338412 author: PARR, TOM title: Symposium on Julie Rose’s Free Time: An Introduction date: 2017 words: 722 flesch: 57 summary: This Symposium brings together a series of thought-provoking papers that explore Rose’s arguments in further detail in order to advance the debate around the equitable distribution of free time, as well as a range of related issues. Jeppe von Platz attempts to expose a serious ambiguity in Rose’s arguments: either she relies on a “vacuous notion of fairness” or, contrary to what Rose claims to have established, what citizens can claim is merely an adequate share of free time. keywords: citizens; fair; free; introduction; julie; leap; parr; rose; share; symposium; time; tom cache: leap-338412.pdf plain text: leap-338412.txt item: #59 of 83 id: leap-338413 author: ROSE, JULIE L. title: A Précis of Free Time date: 2017 words: 1862 flesch: 56 summary: Access to shared free time may be realized by providing citizens with vast amounts of free time, greater work schedule flexibility, or a common period of free time. ROSE Dartmouth College Every citizen is entitled, as a matter of justice, to a fair share of free time. keywords: argument; basic; cambridge; citizens; claims; core; effective; fair; free; free time; freedoms; good; hours; justice; liberal; means; needs; press; principle; resource; theories; time; use; work cache: leap-338413.pdf plain text: leap-338413.txt item: #60 of 83 id: leap-338414 author: GOODIN, ROBERT E. title: Freeing Up Time date: 2017 words: 4133 flesch: 64 summary: Keywords: discretionary time; free time; temporal autonomy 1. In the US, people in childless dual- earner households have around 94 hours per week of discretionary time, 7 As Rose (2016: 46-7; cf. 87) acknowledges, in order for it to play a role in a public theory of justice, we need a concept of free time such that it is possible to reliably and verifiably know whether an individual possesses a given amount of it or not. keywords: activities; autonomy; basic; cambridge; care; child; children; choice; common; control; discretionary; equality; free; goodin; health; hours; household; important; income; labor; leap; life; measure; necessary; parents; people; policies; policy; poverty; press; public; rose; social; society; standard; tasks; temporal; time; university; use; way; welfare; work cache: leap-338414.pdf plain text: leap-338414.txt item: #61 of 83 id: leap-338415 author: VON PLATZ, JEPPE title: Free Time, Freedom, and Fairness date: 2017 words: 6384 flesch: 56 summary: Free time is a subject of justice; it has been neglected by political philosophy, and all citizens have a claim to free time. Free time is of concern to justice, both because free time is necessary for exercising basic liberties and because free time is an all-purpose means.3 keywords: argument; basic; benefits; burdens; citizens; claim; conclusion; cooperative; cooperative fairness; distributive; economic; effective; enabling; exercise; fair; fair share; fairness; free; free time; freedoms; freedoms principle; general; justice; leap; legitimate; liberties; means; notion; principle; purpose; resources; rose; share; social; subject; time; work cache: leap-338415.pdf plain text: leap-338415.txt item: #62 of 83 id: leap-338416 author: STANCZYK, LUCAS title: Free Time and Economic Class date: 2017 words: 5754 flesch: 56 summary: , Julie Rose argues that all citizens must be understood to have a claim to a fair share of free time. In the first part of this essay, I outline Rose’s theory of free time and explain why her discussion should be regarded as an important advance on existing thinking about the requirements of liberal egalitarian justice. keywords: able; aff; basic; claim; class; conception; day; different; distributive; economic; fair; fair share; free; free time; harried; heiress; hours; income; justice; law; leap; liberal; long; luent; needs; number; order; overtime; people; person; policy; professionals; reason; regulations; rose; second; share; time; use; wealth; work; workers; working cache: leap-338416.pdf plain text: leap-338416.txt item: #63 of 83 id: leap-338417 author: TERLAZZO, ROSA title: Entitlement and Free Time date: 2017 words: 6559 flesch: 48 summary: But remember, my aim here is modest: I simply aim to use Rose’s framework to give an initial account of whether some other good – that is, a sense of moral entitlement – might, like free time, both prove necessary to guarantee effective freedom of basic liberties, and meet the criteria for being a resource distributable by a liberal egalitarian state. W hile fostering an early 96 Rosa Terlazzo LEAP 5 (2017) sense of moral entitlement does not then guarantee effective freedom to exercise basic liberties throughout the course of a lifetime, it both allows citizens to adopt a wide variety of comprehensive doctrines in adulthood, and makes more provisional the internal obstacles to effective freedom that those doctrines might include. keywords: basic; basic liberties; citizens; conceptions; count; criteria; distribution; effective; egalitarian; entitlement; exercise; feasibility; free; free time; freedom; good; harvey; inequalities; irma; justice; leap; liberal; liberties; life; lives; means; moral; moral entitlement; neutrality; obstacle; order; person; political; principle; publicity; purpose; resource; rose; second; self; sense; set; social; state; time; use; way; wealth cache: leap-338417.pdf plain text: leap-338417.txt item: #64 of 83 id: leap-338418 author: LIM, DESIREE title: Domination and the (Instrumental) Case for Free Time date: 2017 words: 7565 flesch: 44 summary: I claim that, unlike liberal egalitarians like Julie Rose, who can make a straightforward case for free time, republicans’ theoretical commitments make it more appropriate for them to throw their weight behind a portion of time specially allotted for political activity. As a consequence, setting aside a window of time specially devoted to political activities, rather than free time in itself, is more consistent with the republican project. keywords: activities; activity; arbitrary; argument; capacity; case; checking; citizens; civic; conditions; consuming; contestation; decisions; desiree; distribution; domination; egalitarian; employers; engagement; example; exercise; exit; fair; free time; freedom; gourevitch; important; instrumental; interests; interference; justification; labor; leap; liberal; likely; lim; making; mechanisms; necessary; need; non; order; organizations; participation; people; personal; pettit; political; power; processes; reasons; relationship; republican; republicanism; right; rose; section; shares; state; students; subjects; sufficient; time; union; university; use; view; workers; workplace cache: leap-338418.pdf plain text: leap-338418.txt item: #65 of 83 id: leap-338419 author: ROSE, JULIE L. title: Justice and the Resource of Time: a Reply to Goodin, Terlazzo, von Platz, Stanczyk, and Lim date: 2017 words: 8039 flesch: 54 summary: In addition, a society can realize a just distribution of time by ensuring that citizens have access to free time (e.g. counteracting overemployment, see Rose 2016: 60, 78–81, 138–40), and entitling citizens to a greater portion of a society’s aggregate available free time, even if at the cost of lower rates of economic growth (Rose 2016: 128–34). I am grateful for their thoughtful comments which, drawing on their own work and the book, broaden and advance the discussion of free time as a matter of justice in new and fruitful directions. keywords: approach; argument; basic; case; circumstances; citizens; claims; conception; conditions; conf; distributive; effective; effective use; entitlement; equal; exercise; fair; free citizens; free time; freedoms; goodin; grounds; hours; instance; julie; justice; leap; liberties; lict; lim; long; necessary; necessary time; needs; new; occupational; opportunities; people; pettit; platz; political; press; principle; professionals; protections; question; reply; republican; resource; response; rose; second; set; shares; social; society; stanczyk; terlazzo; theories; theory; university; use; von; von platz; ways; wealth; work cache: leap-338419.pdf plain text: leap-338419.txt item: #66 of 83 id: leap-338420 author: AXELSEN, DAVID V.; NIELSEN, LASSE; VANDAMME, PIERRE-ÉTIENNE title: Introduction date: 2017 words: 2691 flesch: 53 summary: As Huseby argues, there are several formulations concerning the threshold of sufficient autonomy in Shields’ book, and not all of them point in the same direction. Danielle Zwarthoed also discusses the principle of sufficient autonomy, yet in relation with Shields’ views on education. keywords: autonomy; axelsen; better; casal; child; equality; freedom; inequalities; interests; justice; leap; nielsen; objections; parents; people; pierre; press; principle; priority; reasons; shields; shift; sufficiency; sufficientarianism; thesis; threshold; university; upbringing; vandamme; view; étienne cache: leap-338420.pdf plain text: leap-338420.txt item: #67 of 83 id: leap-338421 author: VANDAMME, PIERRE-ÉTIENNE title: Why not More Equality? Sufficientarianism and Inequalities above the Threshold date: 2017 words: 5351 flesch: 48 summary: 15 Note that although most sufficiency principles are less demanding in terms of redistributions than their egalitarian alternatives, a responsibility insensitive principle of sufficiency (especially with a high threshold) might be very demanding as it would require frequent transfers of resources to the imprudent, for example (see Gosseries 2011: 486-487). 137 LEAP 5 (2017) Why not More Equality? I E N N E VA N DA M M E University of Louvain ABSTRACT For people starting from a presumption in favor of equality, the very idea of a sufficiency threshold where the demands of justice would stop because everyone has enough is puzzling. keywords: agnosticism; choice; conception; considerations; discontinuity; egalitarian; egalitarianism; equality; example; focus; gosseries; ideal; indifference; inequalities; injustice; justice; leap; luck; moral; negative; nielsen; outcome; partial; people; philosophy; political; pragmatic; press; principle; priority; reasons; residual; shields; shift; sufficiency; sufficientarianism; theory; thesis; threshold; university; vandamme; view; xelsen cache: leap-338421.pdf plain text: leap-338421.txt item: #68 of 83 id: leap-338423 author: HUSEBY, ROBERT title: Sufficient Autonomy and Satiable Reasons date: 2017 words: 4145 flesch: 60 summary: On this view, sufficient autonomy does not (necessarily) demand full autonomy, but autonomy to some degree that is deemed sufficient for some other reason. It seems then, that if the principle of sufficient autonomy is satiable (with respect to autonomy), it is likely to be so at such a high level that it is hard to detect a relevant shift. keywords: autonomous; autonomy; change; clear; conditions; freedom; huseby; justice; leap; level; non; options; people; person; powers; principle; reasons; relevant; satiability; satiable; shields; shift; social; sufficient; sufficient autonomy; sufficientarianism; thesis; threshold; view cache: leap-338423.pdf plain text: leap-338423.txt item: #69 of 83 id: leap-338424 author: MILLS, CHRIS title: On the Limits of the Principle of Sufficient Autonomy date: 2017 words: 4463 flesch: 53 summary: This relationship explains why it is no objection to argue that the principle of sufficient autonomy does not provide us with enough autonomy to secure freedom. He suggests that the fact that we owe sufficient autonomy to all should inform how we justify education for autonomy to groups who reject autonomy’s value, how we educate in order to facilitate the discovery and development of talents, and how we conceive of the broader requirements of fair equality of opportunity (83). keywords: argument; autonomous; autonomy; cambridge; capacities; coercion; conditions; constitutive; decision; defense; distributive; example; external; freedom; frustration; good; important; instrumental; interest; justice; leap; limits; non; objection; option; order; plausible; press; principle; reasons; role; shields; sufficient; sufficient autonomy; threats; true; uniform; university; value; welfarism cache: leap-338424.pdf plain text: leap-338424.txt item: #70 of 83 id: leap-338425 author: ZWARTHOED, DANIELLE title: The Principle of Sufficient Autonomy and Mandatory Autonomy Education date: 2017 words: 5738 flesch: 51 summary: This essay develops a version of the instrumental argument and argues this version can do the work of supporting mandatory autonomy education as well as the principle of sufficient autonomy, and perhaps even better (Section 2). The instrumental argument for autonomy education affirms that autonomy is good because it leads to something else, namely well-being or f lourishing. keywords: account; argument; autonomous; autonomy; autonomy education; capacity; case; children; communities; conception; degree; discovery; economic; education; equality; extent; fair; freedom; goals; good; implications; instrumental; justice; leap; life; mandatory; mary; members; necessary; non; opportunities; opportunity; people; person; philosophy; principle; raz; reasons; requirement; shields; social; sufficient; sufficient autonomy; sufficientarianism; talents; valid; value; version; way; zwarthoed cache: leap-338425.pdf plain text: leap-338425.txt item: #71 of 83 id: leap-338426 author: GHEAUS, ANCA title: Sufficientarian Parenting Must be Child-Centered date: 2017 words: 3984 flesch: 54 summary: I agree with Shields’ conclusion that adequate parents cannot lose custody merely because a better parent is willing to take over. This will not satisfy Shields, nor any of the dual-interest theorists who want to show that, independent of such empirical matters, adequate parents have a right to continue to parent.5 However, there is a reason why a change in custody away from adequate parents is impermissible even when the child would really be better off with extraordinarily good parents. keywords: account; adequate; appeal; authority; better; brighouse; cases; change; child; children; custodians; custody; dual; gheaus; good; interest; justice; leap; moral; non; opportunity; parent; parenting; relationship; right; shields; substitutable; sufficientarian; swift cache: leap-338426.pdf plain text: leap-338426.txt item: #72 of 83 id: leap-338427 author: HARB, SIBA; AXELSEN, DAVID V. title: Owing Me, Owing You: Sufficiency, Demandingness, and Global Justice date: 2017 words: 5334 flesch: 51 summary: But nothing in Sangiovanni’s account commits him to assigning higher stringency to domestic duties of justice over global duties. In this article, we f lesh out and scrutinize the main elements of Liam Shields’ considerations about global justice in his recent book, Just Enough. keywords: account; axelsen; basic; compatriots; considerations; content; cosmopolitan; debate; demandingness; different; dimension; distributive; domestic; duties; duty; foreigners; fulfillment; global; global justice; higher; justice; leap; miller; needs; new; obligations; positions; priority; realms; reasons; sangiovanni; shields; shift; statist; stringency; sufficiency; terms; threshold; view cache: leap-338427.pdf plain text: leap-338427.txt item: #73 of 83 id: leap-338428 author: SHIELDS, LIAM title: Reply to Critics date: 2017 words: 9374 flesch: 56 summary: This is just to say there are good reasons to be pluralist and this comes from the problems there are with monist views. D OI : 10. 310 0 9/L E A P. 2017.V 5.18 211 LEAP 5 (2017) Reply to Critics good and better than has been thought because sufficiency principles have an indispensable and extensive role in our thought. keywords: account; arguments; authority; autonomy; benefits; better; book; case; chapter; children; claim; compatriots; conditions; different; distributive; education; equality; example; freedom; gheaus; good; huseby; important; instrumental; interests; issue; justice; leap; moral; negative; nielsen; non; numbers; objection; opportunity; parents; particular; plausible; point; position; possible; principle; priority; reasons; reply; response; role; satiable; shields; shift; social; sufficient; sufficient autonomy; sufficientarianism; talents; thesis; threshold; vandamme; view; way cache: leap-338428.pdf plain text: leap-338428.txt item: #74 of 83 id: leap-338444 author: , title: Whole number (5) date: 2017 words: 103281 flesch: 54 summary: In Free Time, Julie Rose argues that “justice requires that all citizens have a fair share of free time” (2016: 4; see also 1, 5, 17, 63, 68, 73, 85, 92, 128). Free time is a subject of justice; it has been neglected by political philosophy, and all citizens have a claim to free time. keywords: ability; able; absence; absolute; abstract; access; account; action; activities; activity; additional; adequate; advance; aff; agnostic; alcohol; alternative; americans; amounts; anderson; appeal; approach; appropriate; arbitrary; argument; authority; autonomous; autonomy; autonomy education; autonomy shields; available; axelsen; background; basic; basic liberties; basic needs; beliefs; benefits; best; better; bibliography; book; brighouse; burdens; cambridge; capacities; capacity; care; casal; case; central; certain; change; chapter; checking; children; choice; circumstances; citizens; claim; class; clear; coercion; comments; commitments; common; communities; community; compatible; compatriots; complete; conception; concern; concerned; conclusion; conditions; conf; consider; considerations; constitutive; content; contributions; control; cooperative; core; cosmopolitan; costs; course; critical; critics; custody; danielle; david; day; debate; deception; decisions; defense; degree; deliberative; demandingness; demands; democratic; development; different; dimension; discontinuity; discovery; discretionary time; discussion; distinction; distributive; distributive justice; domestic; domination; drug; drug use; duties; duty; economic; economic justice; educational; educational justice; effective; effective freedoms; effective use; egalitarian; egalitarianism; empirical; employers; enabling; ends; engagement; entitled; entitlement; equality; essay; ethics; example; exercise; existence; extent; external; fact; fair; fair equality; fair share; fairness; family; focus; following; follows; foreigners; form; formal; free citizens; free time; freedom; freedoms principle; fundamental; general; gheaus; giving; global; global justice; goals; good; goodin; gourevitch; greater; grounds; guarantee; hand; harms; harvard; harvey; help; higher; history; hours; huseby; idea; illegal; implications; important; income; indifference; individual; inequalities; informed; injustice; instance; institutions; instrumental; interest; interesting; introduction; irma; issue; job; journal; julie; justice; justification; kind; labor; lack; large; law; laws; lead; leap; leave; legitimate; level; liam; liberal; liberalism; liberties; liberty; lict; life; like; likely; limit; line; little; live; long; look; luck; luent; main; majority; making; mandatory autonomy; marijuana; mary; matter; means; measure; mechanisms; members; mills; money; moral; moral reasons; nature; necessary time; needs; negative; new; nielsen; non; norms; note; notion; number; objection; obligation; offers; open; opportunities; opportunity; options; order; oxford; paper; parenting; parents; partial; participation; particular; pay; people; person; personal; pettit; philosophical; philosophy; pierre; platz; plausible; point; policies; policy; political; position; positive; possibility; possible; potential; poverty; power; practical; practice; pragmatic; press; princeton; principle; prioritarianism; priority; problem; production; professionals; prohibition; prospects; protections; public; purpose; pursuit; question; range; rate; rawls; rawlsian; raz; reach; reading; real; reasoning; reasons; recreational; ref; related; relationship; relative; relevant; reply; republican; republicanism; requirement; residual; resources; respect; response; responsibility; result; right; risk; robert; role; rose; rules; sangiovanni; satiability; satiable; second; section; secure; self; sense; set; share; shields; shields leap; shift; significant; similar; skills; social; social conditions; social justice; societies; society; special; specific; spend; stanczyk; standard; state; statist; status; stringency; strong; stronger; subject; substitutable; sufficiency; sufficiency principle; sufficiency threshold; sufficient autonomy; sufficient free; sufficient time; sufficientarianism; suggests; support; system; talents; temporal; temporal autonomy; terlazzo; terms; theoretical; theories; theorists; theory; thesis; things; thinking; threats; threshold; time people; time use; trade; true; turn; understanding; unethical; university; university press; unjust; upper; use; users; valid; valuable; value; vandamme; version; view; violence; von; vulnerable; way; ways; wealth; weight; welfare; welfarism; words; work; work time; workers; working; workplace; world; worse; york; zwarthoed cache: leap-338444.pdf plain text: leap-338444.txt item: #75 of 83 id: leap-338445 author: NIELSEN, LASSE title: Shielding Sufficientarianism from the Shift date: 2017 words: 4544 flesch: 58 summary: Thus, for example, sufficiency views, even when very generic, are always vulnerable to objections stressing the intuitive dissatisfaction with the implication that above some threshold T, the inequality between the super-rich and those who barely have enough would not be a concern of justice (Casal 2007). Section 4 defends upper limit sufficientarianism as a more plausible version of sufficientarianism than Shields’ account. keywords: absolute; assumption; distributive; egalitarianism; fairness; figure; generic; goods; inequalities; journal; justice; leap; level; limit; moral; nielsen; non; numbers; paper; people; person; philosophy; plausible; prioritarianism; priority; reason; relevant; responsibility; section; shields; shift; shift thesis; sufficiency; sufficientarianism; table; thesis; threshold; upper; value; view; welfare cache: leap-338445.pdf plain text: leap-338445.txt item: #76 of 83 id: leap-348103 author: Stark, Cynthia A. title: The Presumption of Equality date: 2018 words: 9400 flesch: 56 summary: 2) Therefore, distributive equality is the “moral default”: it is the distribution from which departures must be justified. 3) Departures from equality are justified when they are expressions of agency. 4) Therefore, departures produced by choice are justified. 5) “Distributive arrangements” that ref lect luck and not choice fail to treat people as moral equals. 2) Therefore, distributive equality is the “moral default”: it is the distribution from which departures must be justified. 3) Departures from equality are justified when they are expressions of moral agency. 4) Therefore, departures produced by choice are justified. 5) Departures from equality that ref lect luck and not choice fail to 6 Tan (2012: 89-90) claims that he is not in fact arguing for the egalitarian default. keywords: account; arbitrary; argument; benchmark; burden; case; causes; choice; claim; cohen; default; departures; difference; distributions; distributive; division; egalitarian; egalitarianism; equality; goods; ground; hurley; idea; inequalities; justice; justification; justified; leap; luck; moral; pareto; people; persons; philosophy; point; presumption; principle; problem; proof; rawls; reason; second; shares; social; stark; status; tan; university; unjust; view; way; wealth; worth cache: leap-348103.pdf plain text: leap-348103.txt item: #77 of 83 id: leap-348104 author: Dietrich, Frank title: Natural Resources, Collective Self-Determination, and Secession date: 2018 words: 12842 flesch: 43 summary: Natural Resources, Collective Self-Determination, and Secession 33 LEAP 6 (2018) have commercially exploited the raw materials to their own advantage.6 The resolution on peoples’ permanent sovereignty over natural resources paved the way for the inclusion of resource rights in the two human rights treaties of 1966. The aim of this paper is to clarify how the doctrine of peoples’ sovereignty over natural resources is related to their right to political self-determination. keywords: account; actors; argument; authority; cambridge; capacity; case; claim; collective; collective self; common; concept; concerned; conf; conservation; control; control rights; country; cultural; decisions; determination; determination right; development; dietrich; different; duty; economic; entitled; entitlement; exploitation; extraction; frank; global; goals; harm; human; important; income; instance; instrumentalist; international; interpretation; journal; justice; labor; land; law; leap; locke; materials; moral; nations; natural resources; natural wealth; necessary; need; options; order; ownership; oxford; parties; peoples; permanent; permanent sovereignty; philosophy; political; political self; population; possible; press; principle; property; property rights; question; raw; reasons; relevant; resolution; resource rights; resource sovereignty; revenues; right; rump; secession; second; section; self; selfdetermination; separatist; set; share; social; sovereignty; state; territorial; territory; theory; university; use; value; view; wealth cache: leap-348104.pdf plain text: leap-348104.txt item: #78 of 83 id: leap-348105 author: Montero, Julio title: The Philosophy of Social and Economic Human Rights date: 2018 words: 2403 flesch: 36 summary: As we see, socioeconomic human rights raise a number of questions of critical import for human rights theory and practice: what concrete measures must nations undertake to fulfill the socioeconomic rights of their inhabitants? As the title suggests, the main topic the volume addresses has to do with the nature, justification and implementation of socioeconomic human rights. keywords: africa; available; core; courts; covenant; decisive; democratic; essential; governments; human; human rights; implementation; individuals; international; leap; measures; minimum; obligations; people; philosophy; policies; political; poverty; realization; resources; rights; satisfaction; social; socioeconomic; socioeconomic human; socioeconomic rights; south; state; view cache: leap-348105.pdf plain text: leap-348105.txt item: #79 of 83 id: leap-348106 author: Garreta Leclercq, Mariano title: Socioeconomic Human Rights, Autonomy and the Cost of Error date: 2018 words: 4991 flesch: 48 summary: If B neglects such fundamental moral right, she would be treating those involved as mere instruments for the achievement of her own goals, rather than agents whose interests and projects have a weight of their own and are irreducible to interests and projects of other individuals. This is because even though her potential victims may lack relevant technical knowledge, they have a fundamental right to veto any unilateral decisions on the part of B. To enjoy such right they just need to know that the costs of a mistake are high for themselves and that the chance that the scientist is mistaken is significant. keywords: authorization; autonomy; available; case; citizens; civil; control; cost; covenant; decision; democratic; error; eshr; experts; fabre; fundamental; high; human; human rights; implementation; important; individuals; knowledge; leap; life; maximum; measures; moral; normative; people; policy; political; potential; present; press; progressive; realization; research; resources; result; rights; risk; satisfaction; scientist; social; socioeconomic; socioeconomic human; status; unilateral; university; view cache: leap-348106.pdf plain text: leap-348106.txt item: #80 of 83 id: leap-348107 author: Rivera-López, Eduardo title: Social Rights and Deontological Constraints date: 2018 words: 7454 flesch: 54 summary: What I want to show instead is that, beyond terminology and political use, social rights are normatively different from classical rights and that this may have some significant institutional implications: while classical rights (or relevant aspects of them) can plausibly be conceived as “deontological constraints” (in a sense to be explained), social rights (or relevant aspects of them) cannot. I reject the traditional identification of classical rights with negative rights and of social rights with positive rights, and endorse instead the widely accepted account that both classical and social rights are bundles of negative and positive “incidents” (concrete rights). keywords: abstract; adequate; basic; case; certain; claim; classical; classical rights; conceptual; constraints; correlative; dc rights; deontological; different; duties; duty; example; food; fulfillment; goal; health; housing; human; human rights; important; incidents; intervention; judge; kind; leap; means; needs; negative; negative incidents; negative rights; people; point; political; positive; positive incidents; poverty; question; reason; relevant; resources; rights; satisfaction; sense; set; shue; social; social rights; specific; state; subsistence; torture; use; view; way cache: leap-348107.pdf plain text: leap-348107.txt item: #81 of 83 id: leap-348108 author: Meckled-Garcia, Saladin title: Two (Different) Types of Human Rights Duty date: 2018 words: 12999 flesch: 47 summary: In 5 I show why some key objections to this distinction between the two models and its application to human rights duties do not work. Treating human rights duties as unconditional requirements to fulfil basic interests misses this complexity. keywords: account; action; aims; appropriate; associated; available; basic; benefits; bilchitz; burdens; case; categorical; certain; cescr; circumstances; citizens; claim; considerations; content; contribution; core; decisive; decisive reasons; different; distinction; distributive; duties; duty; economic; ecosoc; example; fairness; focus; form; fulfilment; garcia; health; human; human rights; idea; important; interests; justice; justified; kind; leap; level; life; limits; matter; meaningful; means; model; moral; need; obligations; opportunities; outcomes; oxford; people; person; personal; point; political; press; principle; problem; projects; provision; question; reasoning; reasons; resources; rights; rights duty; saladin; satisfaction; sense; set; social; specific; state; terms; theory; types; university; way; weighing; weighing reasons; weight cache: leap-348108.pdf plain text: leap-348108.txt item: #82 of 83 id: leap-348109 author: Morales, Leticia title: The Democratic Case for a Basic Income date: 2018 words: 7288 flesch: 37 summary: On the other hand, for Pateman basic income appears to impact primarily by granting workers the opportunity to refuse employment. Keywords: democracy, political participation, material preconditions, social rights, income security, basic income. keywords: argument; basic; basic income; cambridge; case; citizens; citizenship; decision; democracy; democratic; democratic case; different; economic; emancipation; employment; enjoyment; equal; exit; family; focus; formal; freedom; fundamental; goodhart; government; human; ideal; impact; important; income; individual; institutions; justice; justification; leap; leticia; life; making; material; michael; money; morales; necessary; opportunities; opportunity; order; parijs; participation; pateman; pettit; policy; political; political participation; poverty; press; process; public; recent; right; role; scheme; secure; security; self; social; society; standing; unconditional; universal; university; value; van; view; vote; wispelaere; work cache: leap-348109.pdf plain text: leap-348109.txt item: #83 of 83 id: leap-348113 author: , title: Whole Number (6) date: 2018 words: 58304 flesch: 47 summary: In this respect, Pateman (2004: 94) finds inspiration in the writings of sociologist T.H. Marshall (1950), who divides citizenship into three different components – civil rights, political rights and social rights – and maintains that social citizenship involves an equality of status which requires “a direct sense of community membership based on loyalty to a 6 In many proposals children and adults are covered by slightly different schemes (Van Parijs and Vanderborght 2017). The discussion on resource rights continued during the drafting process of the United Nations’ two major human rights covenants. keywords: 2015; abstract; access; account; actions; adequate; agency; aims; alternative; analysis; approach; appropriate; arbitrary; argument; article; authority; authors; autonomy; available; available resources; basic; basic income; basic rights; benchmark; benefits; best; better; bilchitz; burdens; cambridge; capacity; care; case; categorical; causes; certain; cescr; choice; circumstances; citizens; citizenship; civil; claim; classical rights; clear; cohen; collective; common; community; component; concept; conception; conceptual; concerned; conditions; conf; considerations; constraints; content; contribution; control rights; core; cost; country; course; courts; covenant; crucial; cultural rights; dc rights; debate; decision; decisive; default; demands; democracy; democratic; deontological; departures; determination; determination rights; development; dietrich; differences; different; discussion; distinction; distributions; distributive; distributive equality; division; duties; duty; dworkin; economic; ecosoc rights; education; effects; egalitarian; entitled; equality; error; eshr; essential; ethics; example; exercise; existence; exploitation; extent; extraction; fabre; fair; fairness; focus; food; form; frank; freedom; fulfillment; fundamental; fundamental rights; future; garcia; general; genuine; global; goals; goodhart; goods; government; ground; hand; harm; having; housing; human rights; idea; impact; implementation; important; incidents; income; income rights; independent; individual; inequalities; inf; innocent; instance; institutions; interests; international; interpretation; journal; justice; justification; justified; kind; knowledge; labor; lack; law; leap; legal; legitimate; level; liberal; life; limits; literature; lives; living; locke; long; luck; main; making; materials; matter; meaningful; means; measures; members; minimum; model; moral; morales; nations; natural resources; necessary; need; negative; negative rights; new; non; normative; notion; number; objection; obligations; ones; opportunities; opportunity; options; order; ownership; oxford; oxford university; paper; pareto; participation; particular; parties; pateman; people; permanent; personal; persons; perspective; philosophical; philosophy; plausible; pogge; point; policies; policy; political; political participation; political philosophy; political rights; political self; poor; population; position; positive; positive rights; possible; potential; poverty; practice; present; press; presumption; principle; problem; process; progressive; projects; proof; property rights; provision; public; question; rawls; realization; reasonable; reasoning; reasons; ref; relevant; research; resource rights; respect; responsible; result; revenues; rights duties; rights duty; rights obligations; risk; role; rule; rump; saladin; satisfaction; secession; second; section; secure; self; selfdetermination; sense; set; share; significant; similar; situation; social justice; social rights; society; socioeconomic human; socioeconomic rights; sovereignty; special; specific; standards; standing; stark; state; status; strong; subject; subsistence; sufficient; system; tax; terms; territorial rights; territories; territory; theories; theory; time; true; types; unconditional; understanding; united; universal; university; university press; unjust; use; valuable; value; view; vote; way; wealth; weighing; weight; work; world; worth; york cache: leap-348113.pdf plain text: leap-348113.txt