Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

 LET: Linguistics, Literature and English Teaching Journal 
||Volume||13||Issue||1||Pages||1-28||2023|| 

|P-ISSN: 20869606; E-ISSN: 25492454| 
Available online at: http://jurnal.uin-antasari.ac.id/index.php 

 

Developing Supplementary Materials for Reading Skill by Using 

Local Wisdom 

 
Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

yayukatili@unima.ac.id  

State University of Manado, Indonesia 

 

Article History: 

Received: 04 April 2023 

Accepted: 15 June 2023 

The purposes of this study are to describe the 

students’ needs and to design supplementary 

materials for reading skill by using local wisdom 

for second-grade students of MTs Al Khairaat 

Gorontalo. By using Research and Development 

Method, the results of this study show that 1) 

students need materials which were related to the 

description of tourism objects, warning about 

cleanliness and the local story. 2) Students prefer 

to read text which consisted of 200-300 words. 3) 

Students want to answer 5 W + 1 H questions and 

True False questions in reading activities. 4) 

Students want to match the vocabularies with the 

pictures in vocabulary building activity. 5) 

Students want to fill in blank sentences in 

grsmmar activity. 6) Students want to work in 

group and the teacher should help them when 

they had a problem in the classroom. The content 

of the materials should be developed in an 

interesting and easy way, language used must be 

appropriate to the students’ language level, build 

cultural awareness and motivated students to 

read. Therefore, by integrating local wisdom into 

supplementary reading materials, the students 

and the teacher feel easy and motivated in the 

teaching and learning process.  

Keywords: 

Supplementary Materials; 

Reading Skill; Local Wisdom 

 

 

 

http://jurnal.uin-antasari.ac.id/index.php
mailto:yayukatili@unima.ac.id


Page | 2 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

INTRODUCTION 

Developing supplementary materials is very important to enhance students’ 

knowledge, needs, and abilities in Reading. In addition, it is very useful to help 

teachers to motivate the students to get information from the text. McDonough, 

Shaw, and Masuhara (2013, p.p. 121-122) explain that teachers should provide 

students with a purpose for reading by supplying materials that stimulate the 

students’ interest. Thus, by developing supplementary reading materials, the teacher 

can make the classroom setting or situation will more effective and interactive so 

that the students are easier to fulfill their needs.  

Currently, most of the schools apply curriculum 2013 and use printed books 

as the sources of teaching and learning English in the classroom. The textbooks 

provided many materials which is allowed the students to read, to think, to get 

information and to develop their reading skill scientifically. As stated by Kucer 

(2005, p.p. 122-128) that reading is an act of meaning making, a goal directed, 

purposeful, selective and contrastive process through print. When the students read, 

they will use their background knowledge and purpose in reading the text. Moreover, 

Williams (1984) classifies reading skills into (1) getting general information from a 

text, (2) getting specific information from a text, and (3) for pleasure or for interest 

(in McDonough, Shaw and Masuhara, 2013, p. 111). Additionally, Tomlinson and 

Masuhara (2004) explain that the materials should focus to the students’ needs. 

Thus, it is important for the teacher to develop reading material which are fulfil the 

students’ needs in learning English. 

In addition, Mts Al Khairaat Gorontalo is one of the schools which applied 

curriculum 2013 and use English textbook which published by the government in 

teaching and learning English. Additionally, the teacher uses the textbook When 

English Rings A Bell as a core material for teaching English subject at second grade 

students. Additionally, the contents of the materials are generally arranged by the 

government and appropriate with curriculum 2013. Curriculum 2013 offers the 

opportunities for students to develop English competencies about society problems 

and cultures. The students as the culture generation should proud and apply the 



Page | 3 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

culture of the society. However, based on the data which obtained from the 

observation showed that learning and the teaching English particularly reading in 

MTs Al-Khairaat is less effective because the students get the reading material 

which is not relevant with their surroundings. To illustrate, in descriptive text 

materials, it is given the description about the place which the students never seen 

before. So, they only guess it without know the real description. Based on interview 

which conducted at the next day, the students explained that they were not interested 

in reading activity because the materials’ topic were too difficult for them. It was 

hard for them to find the meaning of the text. The problems are the students always 

ask the meaning of every word from the text to teacher during reading process. Thus, 

between the teachers and the students get difficulties because the materials are 

unfamiliar and not easy to understand by the students.  

In contrast, in the process of reading activities, the students should get 

reading text which are connected with their real-life context. So, they can predict 

and guess what are the main idea or the content of the text. However, the facts which 

happened at that school showed that the content of the materials does not fulfil the 

students’ needs because they explained that they need more interesting reading 

materials which are easy, understandable and interesting to develop their skill. Thus, 

it is important for the teachers to develop the supplementary materials as the ways 

to support the core textbook given by the government. 

Additionally, supplementary materials are one of the learning sources which 

used by the teacher and students in teaching and learning process. It as the additional 

materials which designed by the teacher to support students’ needs. Additionally, it 

also will help the teacher to fulfil the materials from the core books which published 

by the government. It gives the teacher chances to be creative to design and to 

develop their own teaching materials based on their students’ learning experiences, 

needs and real-life context. Tomlinson (2008, p. 283) argues that locally developed 

materials are characterized by inclusion of local content and familiar settings. 

Therefore, it is important to develop supplementary materials for students’ reading 

skill by using the students’ surrounding or local wisdom. 



Page | 4 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

 In addition, Wagiran (2011) explains local wisdom as ceremony, tradition, 

tourist spot, tourism, museum, art, legend, norm, environment, healthy and etc. 

Otherwise, Tomlinson (2014, p. 324) explains that the teachers can help the students 

to understand the materials by modifying and supplementing the materials. Thus, it 

is important to combine local wisdom of Indonesia in supplementary reading 

materials for enhancing students’ ability. 

Otherwise, the teachers need to design the materials based on the learning’s 

goal, students’ needs and use local wisdom of Indonesia as the content of their 

materials. To illustrate the topic is about descriptive text and the teachers asks 

students to learn how to make to read a descriptive text about the local wisdom. It is 

because there are many culture, environmental problems and traditional stories that 

begin disappear in Indonesia now. So, the teachers need to design the materials 

which can enhance and increase the students’ awareness about the local wisdom in 

their regions. Consequently, they can read and explain the message of the text. So, 

they can understand and get the message of text related to their real-life context. 

Therefore, the purposes of this study are to describe the students needs and design 

the supplementary reading materials for the second-grade students of Mts Alkhairaat 

Gorontalo City.  

METHOD 

This research used R & D (Research and Development) method. According 

to Borg and Gall (1983, p. 771) research and development method was a process 

used to develop and to validate educational products. This research used their 

framework to develop supplementary reading materials based on the students’ 

needs. There were some steps of research and development method such as; 

Research and Information Collecting, Planning, Develop Preliminary Form of 

Product, Preliminary Field Testing, Main Product Revision, Main Field Testing, 

Operational Product Revision, Operational Product Field Testing, Final Product 

Revision and Dissemination/Implementation. 

This research used observation, interview, questionnaire, document analysis 

and focus group discussion in collecting the data.  



Page | 5 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

In this research and development, Borg and Hall (1989, p. 775) explained 

some techniques of conducting R&D that the researcher used in this study. They 

were; 

Research and information collecting (need analysis) 

In this step, the researcher used some instruments such as observation, 

interview, questionnaires and document protocol to get the data about the students 

needs’ competency and teaching tools of teaching and learning English in the 

classroom.  

Observation 

In this research, the observation was undertaken to find out the English 

teaching learning process in at second grade students of MTs Al Khairaat Gorontalo 

and the English textbook that the teacher used. The aims of observation were to 

explain the situation, activities, the participant and the relationship between them 

and the situation (Setiady, 2006, p. 239). In the process of observation, the researcher 

observed and saw the process of teaching and learning English in the classroom in 

some meetings. Therefore, the indicators of the observation were students and the 

teacher in the classroom. 

Interview 

 In this research, the researcher conducted face to face interview to the 

English teacher about how and what the students’ difficulties in reading activities. 

Setiady (2006, p. 243) explained that interview was one of the instrument by giving 

the participant questions related to the topic of the research. The researcher used 

unstructured interview to get deep information about students’ current competence 

and difficulties in reading activity. Therefore, the researcher used audio recorder to 

record teacher’ voices. So, data could be listened again after the interview in order 

to check again the result of interview. 

Questionnaire 

 The researcher used questionnaires from Richard (2001), Hutchinson and 

Walters (1987) and Nunan (2004) to analyze students’ needs in reading. The 



Page | 6 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

indicators of the questionnaires were the targets’ needs, the learning needs of the 

students, procedures, setting, teacher role and the students’ role in the classroom. 

Thus, the questionnaire helped the researcher to design appropriate materials for 

students.  

 Additionally, the researcher also used validation sheet or questionaries for 

expert verification which adapted from Suseno (2014, p. 58) in order to get some 

input about the materials that already developed. Besides, the researcher also used 

students’ validation sheet or the students’ response questionaries to get information 

about how the students response after got the materials. (See the instruments in 

appendix) 

Document Analysis 

 Document was one of the important instruments in collecting data. Setiady 

(2006, p. 249) explained that document could be used to get scientific data and it 

was easy to find. The researcher used documents such as syllabus, lesson plan and 

the textbooks as references to get the valid data.  

Planning (design) 

After finding out the student’s needs by conducting some steps above, the 

researcher designed the supplementary materials by designing course grid, lesson 

plan, the reading materials and tasks for students. 

Develop preliminary form of product (re-design) 

 After designing the syllabus, lesson plan, materials and task , the researcher 

re-designed it by paying attention to students’ needs data over and over and also for 

the needs that used in the next step namely preliminary field testing. The researcher 

also conducted focus group discussion with the English teacher. 

Focus Group Discussion 

 This focus discussion (FGD) is addressed to the teacher for discussing the 

contents of the material and the textbooks that the researcher had been designed. So, 

the aim of the focus group discussion in this research was to get the teacher 

arguments or inputs about the materials design. 



Page | 7 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

Preliminary Field Testing 

 In this time, the researcher applied the supplementary reading materials by 

using local wisdom to the small class.  

Main Product Revision (Expert Verification) 

 This step involved some experts’ validation such as English lecturer and 

English teacher who had a lot of experiences related to this research. This step was 

also used for revise the result based on the discussions and suggestions from the 

experts validation sheet. 

Main Field Testing  

 The researcher applied it in the small class. This was the last step of 

conducting this research, the researcher did not continue to the next steps. 

Then, the researcher organized and transcribed the data to start the data 

analysis. There were several steps to analyze the data based on Creswell theory 

(2009, p. 185-192). 1) Organized and prepared data for analysis 2) Read through all 

the data 3) began detailed analysis with a coding process 4) Used the coding process 

to generate a description of setting or participants in this research 5) Advanced how 

the description and themes will be represented in the narrative. 6) the final step in 

this research was interpreted the meaning of the research data. 

FINDINGS AND DISCUSSIONS 

Findings 

The descriptions of the target needs and the learning needs are presented in 

the table below. 

Table 1. Needs Analysis Results 

Needs 

Analysis 

Component 

Aspect Questions Categories of 

Response 

Number 

of 

Answers 

Target Needs Goals The goal of 

learning English 

To support my 

carrier 

 

73.52 % 

 

 Necessities Level of 

competency 

Notice 94.11 % 



Page | 8 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

Students Needs 

in future 

 Necessities Your English 

competencies 

will be used as… 

 

A tool for 

helping to master 

knowledge about 

my region with 

reading English  

50% 

 Lacks Your level of 

competency 

now… 

Beginner 70.58% 

 

 

 Lacks  Learning 

materials used in 

the classroom 

Teacher’s 

explanation 

73.52% 

 Lacks  In learning 

English, 

particularly 

reading 

activities, the 

problems that I 

face is… 

Understanding 

the meaning of 

every 

vocabulary 

 

35.29% 

 

 Wants After learning 

English, I can… 

Master English 

vocabularies 

67.64 % 

 

Learning 

Needs 

Input Input that I want 

in reading is… 

Text with picture 

and audio 

50% 

 

  The length of 

text input 

approximately… 

200-300 words 

 

32.35% 

 

  The topic of 

descriptive text 

that I want is 

about… 

Tourism objects 52.94% 

 

  The topic of 

narrative text 

that I want is 

about… 

Legend 41.17% 

 

  The topic of 

notice text that I 

want is about… 

- Warning to 
keep the 

tourism 

object 

- Warning 
about keep 

the 

environment 

35.29% 

 

 

 

 

 

The material 

design, text and 

Picture and 

colourful 

88.23% 

 



Page | 9 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

 

 

 

 

layout should 

have…. 

 

 Procedure The kinds of 

activity in 

reading is… 

Reading text and 

answer the 5W + 

1 H questions 

50% 

 

 

  The kinds of 

activity after 

reading a text 

Answering true 

or false 

questions 

38.23% 

  The kinds for 

learning 

vocabulary is… 

Matching 

vocabulary with 

picture 

 

47.05% 

 

 

  The kinds of 

activity for 

learning 

grammar is… 

Writing blank 

sentence with the 

available 

grammar  

50% 

 

 

 

Setting The type of  

class  

management I  

want to carry  

the tasks is …. 

Group 52.94% 

 

 Learner role In the learning  

process, I  

would prefer 

to…. 

Ask to teacher if 

don’t understand 

 

35.29% 

 

 

 Teacher role In the learning  

process, I want  

my teacher to… 

Help the students 

when they get 

problems 

55.88% 

 

 

 

Based on the table above, the data shows that the students need materials 

which can improve their reading ability because they have lack of vocabularies. 

Thus, they cannot understand the information from the text, when they are reading 

a text. Thus, it is important to design materials based on the students’ needs.  

Target needs 

Goals 

Goal refers to general intentions behind the learning. Learning goals of 

students of MTs Al Khairaat Kota Gorontalo is presented below:   



Page | 10 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

 

Figure 1. Target Needs: Goals 

Figure 1 shows the students goals or purposes in learning English in the 

classroom. Additionally, the data presents that 25 students aim to learn English for 

supporting their career. It means that they learn English to support their job in the 

future. Additionally, there are 4 students aim to learn English for helping them to 

learn information from abroad.  

Necessities. 

Necessities are related to what the learners should know or achieve in order 

to function effectively in the target situation. In this study, the results of students’ 

necessities are presented: 

 

Figure 2. Target Needs: Necessities 

Figure 2. presents about what the students should know or achieve in the 

classroom. This is the second question in questionaries. The data shows that 32 

students need to master English in notice level. Additionally, 2 students wanted to 

master English in intermediate level.  

2

25

4 3

0

10

20

30

To pass the national

examination

To support my carrier To help for learning

information from

abroad

To communicate with

foreigner

The goal of learning English 

0
2

32

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beginner Intermediate Notice

Level of competency that students need 



Page | 11 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

 

Figure 3. Target Needs: Necessities 

Figure 3 presents about the third question in the questionaries about the 

functions of students English competencies in the future. There are 17 students will 

use their English competencies as a tool for helping to master knowledge about their 

region with reading English reading text, while 14 students will use their English 

competencies as a tool for communicating with their friends. 

Lacks. 

Lacks refer to the gap between what the learners know already and what the 

learners do not know. Therefore, to know the gap, there are some comparisons 

between the students’ current proficiency and the required proficiency to the target 

situation. In this study, the data about students’ lacks are presented as follows. 

 

Figure 4. Target Needs: Lacks 

14

3

17

0
0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

A tool to communicate

with my friends

A tool for writing a

formal text and non-

formal situation

A tool for helping to

master knowledge about

my region with reading

English

Others…

The function of students English competencies

24

10

0
0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beginner Intermediate Notice

The students level of competency now



Page | 12 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

The fourth question about students’ lack is presented in figure 4. That 

question is to know the current level of students’ English proficiency level. The 

answer of the question then will be compared to the proficiency level which is 

required in the target situation. From the table, the proficiency level of the most 

students of grade 8 of Mts Al Khairaat Kota Gorontalo is beginner. It is shown in 

the table that 24 students are at the beginner proficiency level. While, 10 students 

are in intermediate level.  

 

Figure 5. Target Needs: Lacks 

Figure 5 shows the results of the question about students’ lacks. The purpose 

of this question is to know the students’ difficulties in learning English. From the 

table, there are 25 of the students say that they learning English only from the 

teacher’s explanation. Additionally, there are 6 students’ answer that they are 

learning the materials from the textbook. 

Table 2. Interview Results 

Question Answer 

How do you teach reading to the 

students? 

I teach them by using textbook “When 

English Rings a Bell”. It was from the 

government. The materials are too 

general so cannot fulfil what the 

students should get from the materials. 

The students cannot use hand phone at 

school so it is hard for them to find the 

other sources of materials. So, I only 

teach them from the textbook and 

explain it use the whiteboard. 

6

2

25

0
0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Textbook Photocopy Teacher's

explanation

Various

textbook

Internet Various

resources

Learning materials used in the classroom now.



Page | 13 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

Table 2 shows that the teacher only use the textbook from the government 

“When English Rings a Bell”. So, it is hard for the students to understand the 

materials because the materials are too general. The teacher and the students cannot 

use internet because they are forbid to bring mobile phone to school. So, the students 

get the materials only from one textbook and the teacher explanation through 

whiteboard. 

 

Figure 6. Target Needs: Lacks 

Figure 6 shows the results of the second question about students’ lacks. The 

purpose of this question is to know the students’ weakness and difficulties in 

learning English. From the table, there are 12 of the students say that they get 

difficulties in understanding the meaning of the vocabularies. Additionally, there are 

9 students’ answer that they are get difficulties in getting all the meaning and the 

information of the text.  

This is supported by the result of the interview with the English teacher at 

Mts Alkhairaat Kota Gorontalo.  

Table 3. Interview Results 

Question Answer 

What are the students’ difficulties in 

the classroom? 

The students were difficult in 

understanding the meaning of the text. 

They did not master English 

vocabularies. So, the teaching and 

learning were not active because the 

students’ needs a lot of time in 

translating the words in the text 

because the text were not familiar with 

them. They do it until some meetings. 

They also need many explanations 

from me as the teacher when did the 

reading tasks. 

6

12
9

4
2 1 0

0

5

10

15

The students' problems in reading



Page | 14 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

  Table 3 shows that the students have difficulties in vocabularies. They are 

difficult to get the information from the text so they cannot answer the task. The 

students’ have difficulty in doing the task in reading the activity because they need 

a lot of time to translate the text into Indonesia.  

Wants 

Wants is related to the learners’ expectation after finishing their study. The 

results of students wants are presented below. 

 

Figure 7. Target Needs: Wants 

Figure 7 shows that there are 23 students who want to be able to master 

English vocabularies. Also, there are 6 students want to be able to speak English 

fluently.  

Learning needs 

Input 

Inputs referred to the types of data that will be used by the learners in learning 

English. The data below provided the description about the inputs of the students at 

MTs Al khairaat Kota Gorontalo.  

 

Figure 8. Learning Needs: Reading input 

6
1

23

3
1 0

0
5

10
15
20
25

Speak English

fluently

Write text

fluently by

using English

Master

English

vocabularies

Reading

English text

fluently

Using the

correct

English

grammar

Others

The students' want after learning English

2
5

10

17

0
0

5

10

15

20

Authentic

materials like

magazines,

newspaper, etc

Text depend on

the context

Text and list of

new vocabulary

Text with picture

and audio

Other

Input that the students want in reading 



Page | 15 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

Figure 8 presents the inputs for learning reading. There are 17 students who 

want the reading input in the form of text with pictures and audio. The second 

tendency of the desired input for reading is chosen by 10 of the students. They 

wanted to get reading input like text with the list of new vocabulary. 

 

Figure 9. Learning Needs: Reading input 

Figure 9 shows there are 11 of the total students who believe that the suitable 

reading input is texts have length 200-300 words. The second alternative for length 

of reading input are 150-200 words. It is chosen by 9 of total students.   

 

Figure 10. Learning Needs: Reading input 

Figure 10 shows there are 18 students need reading input material for 

descriptive text or topic about tourism objects. Additionally, there are 7 students 

needed materials that has topic about people or hero. In conclusion, most of the 

students needed material which has a topic about tourism object and also the rest 

about people or hero.  

6
5

9

11

3

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

< 100 words 100-150

words

150-200

words

200-300

words

> 300 words Others

The length of text input 

18

7

3 3

1
2

0
0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

Tourism

objects

People/hero Building Traditional

House

Environment Culture Others

The topic of descriptive text 



Page | 16 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

 

Figure 11. Learning Needs: Reading input 

From figure 11 above, there are 14 of the total students believed that the 

suitable reading input of narrative texts is a legend. The second alternative for 

narrative text topics are myth and life story of a hero. It is chosen by 8 and 8 of the 

total students. 

 

Figure 12. Learning Needs: Reading input 

From figure 12 above, there are 12 students wanted to get reading input 

about notice related to warning about keeping the tourism object. Similarly, 12 

students also wanted to get topic about warning of how to keep the environment. 

While, 6 students’ needs reading input about cleanliness. 

 

Figure 13. Learning Needs: Reading input 

14

8

4

8

0

5

10

15

Legend Myth Fable Life story of a hero

The topic of narrative text

12

6

12

3

1
0

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

Warning to keep

the tourism

object

Warning about

cleanliness

Warning about

keep the

environment

Warning about

culture

Warning about

healthy

Others

The topic of caution text 

30

0
4

0 0
0

10

20

30

40

Picture and colorful Only text Illustration and

colorful picture

Only picture Other

Text and layout 



Page | 17 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

Figure 4.13 above shows that the material design for reading should include 

of colourful picture. It chosen by 30 students. Also, there are 4 students want to get 

reading materials with illustration and colourful picture.  

Procedures 

Procedures specify what learners will actually do with the inputs that form 

the point of departure for the learning task.  Therefore, here are the results of the 

questionnaire which is administered to know the desired procedures for learning of 

the students of MTs Al Khairaat Kota Gorontalo. 

 

Figure Learning Needs: Procedures. 

Figure 14. shows the desired procedures for learning reading. From the table, 

there are 17 of the students who want the activities for learning reading like reading 

text and answer question (5 W + 1 H). The second alternative is reading text and 

translating it into Indonesia which is chosen by 15 of the students.   

 

Figure 15. Learning Needs: Procedures 

1

17

0

15

1
0 0

0
2
4
6
8

10
12
14
16
18

The kinds of activity in reading 

13

4

13

2

0
1

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

Answer the

questions

Fill in the

blank

sentences

Answer

True and

False

Match the

words with

sentences

Answer

questions

orally

Arrange the

paragraph

Retell the

story orally

Others

Activity after reading a text



Page | 18 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

Figure 15 shows the desired procedures after reading a text. From the table, 

there are 13 of the students who want the activities after reading like answer question 

(5 W + 1 H). The second alternative is choosing True or False which is chosen by 

13 of the students.   

 

Figure 16. Learning Needs procedures 

Figure 16 presents about the procedure of learning reading particularly 

vocabularies. 16 students want to learning vocabulary by matching it with the 

pictures. While, 16 students want to learn vocabularies by matching it with its 

definition 

 

Figure 17. Learning Needs: Procedures 

 Figure 17 presents about the kinds of the activity for learning grammar. 

There are 17 students need the kind of the activity for learning grammar by writing 

the blank sentence with the available sentence structure (grammar). While, 10 

students need the kind of learning grammar activity to identify incorrect sentence in 

text.  

12

16

3
0

3

0

5

10

15

20

Matching

vocabulary with

its definition

Matching

vocabulary with

picture

Completing text

or paragraph with

available

vocabulary

Completing

sentence or

paragraph by

own words

Other

The kinds for learning vocabulary 

10

5
2

17

0

5

10

15

20

Identifying incorrect
sentence in text

Correcting incorrect
sentence in text

Writing sentence with
particular structure

Writing blank sentence
with the available

grammar

The kinds of activity for learning grammar 



Page | 19 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

Setting 

 Settings refer to the classroom arrangement in completing the task for 

example, individual work, pair work or group work.  The preferred classroom 

settings of students of Mts Al Khairaat Kota Gorontalo were presented below.   

Figure 18. Learning Needs: Setting 

 Figure18 shows the type of class management that the students wanted to 

carry the tasks. There are 18 students want to do the task with group. While, there 

are 10 students want do the task with their pair.  

Learner role 

 Learner role refer to what the learners need to do in completing the task. The 

following table shows the preferred role of the students in this study. 

 

Figure 19. Learning Needs: Students’ role 

Figure 19 shows that there are 12 students preferred to ask the teacher if they 

do not understand with the materials. While, 11 students preferred to listen the 

teacher explanation in the classroom. 

5

10

18

1 0
0

5

10

15

20

Individual In pair Group Whole class

activities

Others

The type of class management I want to carry the tasks 

11

8

1
2

12

0
0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

Listen teacher

explanation

Discuss with

pair to answer

question

Write teacher

explanation
Ask question 

to friends 

when don’t 

understand

Ask to teacher 

if don’t 

understand

Others

The students' role in class



Page | 20 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

Teacher role 

Teacher’s role refer to the types of functions teachers are expected to fulfil. 

The following table presents the results of the questionnaire which ask the desired 

teacher’s role of the students of MTs Al Khairaat Kota Gorontalo.   

 

Figure 20. Learning Needs: Teacher role 

From figure above, there are 19 students expect the teacher to help the 

students when they got problems in the teaching and learning process, while 8 

students want the teacher to give the illustration or the example of the topic that will 

be given to them.  

Discussion 

The purposes of this study are to develop and to produce supplementary 

materials for reading skill by using local wisdom for second grade students of MTs 

Al Khairaat Gorontalo based on the students’ needs. There were 34 students from 

one class who participated in this research. The materials developed based on the 

result of the students’ needs from the questionnaires, teacher’s interview, focus 

group discussion with the teacher and document analysis (syllabus, lesson plan, 

students’ score achievement, English textbook). Therefore, the materials have been 

designed based on the students’ needs in learning reading.  

5

8

19

0
2

0
2
4
6
8

10
12
14
16
18
20

Give task and

discussing it

next meeting

Give task

illustration or

example about

the topic that

will be given to

the students

Help the

students when

they get

problems

Walk and

correct

comment the

students work

one by one

Others

the teacher role in class



Page | 21 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

Additionally, the theory from Shaw and Masuhara (2013, p.p 121-122) 

explained that the teachers should provide students with a purpose for reading by 

supplying materials that stimulate the students’ interest. Thus, by developing 

supplementary reading materials, the teacher can make the classroom setting or 

situation will more effective and interactive so that the students are easier to 

understand and to get specific information from the text. Based on the findings of 

this research, the students are very motivated and enthusiastic because the materials 

design correlated with the local wisdom of Gorontalo. As Gorontalo people, they are 

very excited with the materials because there are many things that they could learn 

such as tourism objects, culture and traditional stories around Gorontalo Province. 

Needs Analysis Results 

The result of needs analysis was used to design the reading materials in this 

research. Hutchinson and Waters (1987, p.p. 54-56) state that needs analysis is used 

to identify what the students’ goal, necessities, lacks and wants in the target 

situation. In addition, Nunan (2004) explains that the teacher should design the 

materials based on the procedures of the teaching and learning, the setting, teacher 

and students’ role. This study uses those theories to get the students’ needs in 

teaching and learning reading. Moreover, based on the data which got from the 

questionnaires, the students’ need materials which can build their English 

vocabularies. The data show that the students’ goal in learning English is to support 

their carrier in the future (looked at the table 4.1, p. 48).  

In addition, Richard (2001, p. 53) explains that the purpose of needs analysis 

is to determine current levels of language proficiency of the students. Related to the 

theory, the data of this research shows that the students’ level of competencies that 

they needed was notice level. They competencies after learn English would be used 

as a tool for helping them to master knowledge about their region through reading a 

text. In addition, the students’ level of competency now was beginner level. They 

problems in reading activities were understanding the meaning of vocabularies when 

they read a text. Because of their lacks, they want to master English vocabularies 



Page | 22 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

from the materials design. Thus, the results can be used to design the reading 

materials. 

Besides, the findings also show that the students needed reading materials in 

the form of text and its pictures. While the length of the text must consist of 200 to 

300 words. The topic of the text descriptive is tourism objects in Gorontalo. The 

topics of caution text were warning to keep the tourism objects and warning about 

keep the environment clean. Otherwise, the materials design must have colourful 

pictures. Meanwhile, the procedures of reading activities that the students want were 

reading a text and answer 5 W + 1 H questions (what, who, why, when, where and 

how). They also want to answer true and false questions to assess their reading 

ability such as got the general and specific information from the text. In addition, 

they want to match the vocabularies with its pictures in vocabulary building activity. 

Also, they want to fill in the blank sentences in grammar activity (language focus). 

The students also want to work in group so they can ask their friends or teacher when 

they did not understand with the materials. They also want the teacher to help them 

when they got problems. Therefore, the students can develop their reading ability 

based on their needs. Consequently, needs analysis results used to design the reading 

materials at Mts Alkhairaat Gorontalo City. 

The Materials Design 

The theory from Tomlinson (2014, p. 22) explains that good qualities of the 

materials should help the learner to develop cultural awareness and sensitivity, 

reflect the reality of language use, help learners to learn in ways similar to the 

circumstances in which they will have to use language, help to create readiness to 

learn and achieve affective engagement. Thus, the study develops the course grid of 

the materials design based on the theory of Tomlinson (2014) and used the theory to 

develop good qualities of the materials. 

 In addition, the researcher develops materials into three units based on the 

curriculum analysis for Junior High School level. The data from document analysis 

show that the students should learn about “Descriptive Text”, Caution Text” and 

“Narrative Text” in the second semester. So, the first unit of the material design was 



Page | 23 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

descriptive text. In this unit, the students should be able to identify and to understand 

the structures, language features and function of descriptive text. The second unit is 

caution text. The students should be able to identify and to understand the meaning 

of short caution text based on its language features and function. The last unit of the 

materials design is narrative text. The standard competencies that they must be 

achieved were the students should be able to identify the structures, language 

features and function of short narrative text. Therefore, by analysing the standard 

competencies the researcher designs the course grid.  

 Additionally, the course grid described the basics competencies, indicators, 

unit title, learning materials and the activities in teaching and learning process. After 

designed the course grid, the researcher designs the first draft of the materials into 

three unit. The materials design in each unit consists of “Warm Up”, “Reading 

Activities”, “Info”, “Vocabularies Building”, “Language Focus”, “Evaluation”, 

“Reflection” and “Glossary.” Besides, there are seven tasks in each unit. In 

descriptive text unit, the students matched the pictures with the name of tourism 

objects in the box. It was in the warm up activity. In reading activity, the students 

read and get the general and specific information from the text. Then, they answered 

5 W+1 H questions which consisted of 10 numbers. Additionally, they learn the 

structure, definition and function of descriptive text in info section. Moreover, they 

also built their vocabularies by matching the pictures with the words in the box 

provided. The vocabularies are very important because it always use in Gorontalo 

art such as rattan, bamboo, shawl and others. Therefore, the students can add their 

vocabularies from the vocabularies building section. 

 Furthermore, in language focus section the students learn the features of 

descriptive text particularly simple present tense. The materials provide the list of 

simple present or verb one and its sentence’ examples. When, they get the 

information, they answer fill in the blank sentences. Then they evaluate their 

understanding about the text in evaluation section. At the end of the materials the 

students reflected their knowledge and skills about descriptive text by answering 

some questions. The materials also provide the list of the vocabularies which were 



Page | 24 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

difficult for the students so that they could learnt it in English and Indonesia 

meaning.  

The arrangements of the materials in each unit are similar. The differences 

only in the contents of the materials such as caution text discuss about how to use 

prohibition sentences and narrative text discuss about simple past tense. This 

material has been designed to fulfil the students and need so that they can enjoy and 

feel easy when reading the text. Additionally, the steps of the activities in the 

materials design follow the rules of curriculum 2013 from observing until 

communicating activities. So, the materials can be used in the teaching reading to 

the students.  

Additionally, the content of the materials uses local wisdom of Gorontalo 

made students interested with the materials. Local wisdom materials including the 

ethics, moral value, how to preserve the environment and the myth or the legend 

from the society. By combining local wisdom into the reading text, the students get 

the knowledge and information related to their surroundings. Thus, this study uses 

some tourism objects of Gorontalo and the traditional stories of Gorontalo.  

Tomlinson (2014) explains that local wisdom materials were written by local 

teachers, have advisors, be content meaning focuses, be text driven, focused on the 

known needs and wants of the target users of the materials and localised the activities 

in the sense of helping the learners to make connections with their own lives. Thus, 

the researcher used the theory to design the materials. Meanwhile, by using 

Tomlinson’s (2014) theory, the researcher designs these materials. The researcher 

re-designed it from the result of the focus group discussion with the English teacher 

of Mts Alkhairaat. There is one part that must be changed in materials development. 

It was in the glossary. Based on the result of focus group discussion with the English 

teacher, the students must know the Indonesian meaning of the vocabularies from 

the glossary. It is because the list of the vocabularies which has been designed only 

have the English meaning. Therefore, based on the result of the (FGD) Focus Group 

Discussion, the researcher added the content of the materials in the Glossary section.  



Page | 25 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

Based on the result of the experts’ verification sheet, from 25 questions, the 

number of points “Strongly Agree” were 21 and “Agree” are 4. Both of the experts 

had similar verifications. This is very important to improve the weakness of the 

materials. Moreover, the result of expert verifications shows that there were some 

spelling and grammar mistakes in the materials contents that the researcher needed 

to revise. Because of that the researcher revise the grammatical mistakes and added 

some pictures in the materials particularly in “Unit 1”, “Unit 2” and “Unit 3”. 

Tomlinson (2014) explains that the good materials should reflect the reality of 

language use. Therefore, the researcher provides the correct vocabularies and 

sentences structures in the materials.  

After revising the materials, the researcher tries out the materials into class 

VIII A which consisted of 34 students. They are special class because they had high 

learning achievement in Mts Alkhairaat Gorontalo City. In this Main Field Testing, 

the researcher find that the students were very motivated in learning the materials. 

It is because all the contents of the materials taught about local wisdom of Gorontalo. 

It means that the materials develop the students’ awareness about their local 

knowledge and culture. It is supported by theory from Tomlinson (2014) which 

explained that the good materials should help the students to develop cultural 

awareness. Thus, the materials are very useful in the teaching and learning process 

at Mts Alkhairaat Gorontalo City. 

After main filed testing, the researcher finds that there were 34 students 

could develop their reading skills in English and knowledge about Gorontalo 

content. It based on the data from the students’ responses sheets. The data present 

that most of the students interested with the content of the materials, the design and 

activities (tasks) from the materials. The students are easier to understand the 

structure, language features and function of functional text such as descriptive, 

caution and narrative text from the reading materials. Thus, the students can get the 

specific and general information from the text which provided from the materials.  

Additionally, Williams (1984) classifies reading into (1) getting general 

information from a text, (2) getting specific information from a text, and (3) for 



Page | 26 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

pleasure or for interest (in McDonough, Shaw and Masuhara, 2013, p. 111). This 

theory related to the materials design of this research. The students develop their 

reading skill by getting general information from text in Warm Up activities. Then, 

they got specific information from the text in Reading activities. Last, they get many 

interesting pictures related to their context so they feel excited in the teaching and 

learning process. Thus, they can build their reading skills through the materials. 

Consequently, those the three units of the materials can develop the students’ 

ability in reading because the contents appropriate with students’ needs. Also, the 

materials have been verified with the two experts in material development research. 

Thus, the design materials have been developed well because it can be used and 

understand by the teacher and the students at Mts Alkhairaat Gorontalo City 

CONCLUSIONS AND SUGGESTIONS 

Conclusion 

The supplementary materials are one of the learning sources which used by 

the teacher and students in teaching and learning process. It as the additional 

materials which designed by the teacher to support students’ needs. Additionally, it 

also will help the teacher to fulfil the materials from the core books which published 

by the government. Thus, the supplementary materials design of this study fulfils 

the students need in English. It is because the content of the materials based on the 

students’ needs. It means that the materials facilitate the students to practice their 

reading skill. Materials contain an interesting input and be presented in an easy way. 

The language are appropriate with the students’ language level. It means that the 

language used helps the students to understand the materials easily. The students can 

develop their reading skills because materials build their cultural awareness and the 

materials motivated them in learning English. Therefore, by using these 

supplementary materials the students and the teacher feel easy and motivated in the 

teaching and learning process.  

 

 



Page | 27 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

Sugesstion 

The teacher should know the framework and procedures for materials 

development to produce good teaching materials which are based on the students’ 

needs and curriculum. Furthermore, the students should use the supplementary 

materials to enrich their knowledge and reading skill. Also, the next researcher could 

gain the information from this study about how to develop supplementary materials. 

REFERENCES 

Abbasi. Z. (2015). The Effect of Supplementary Materials on Reading 

Comprehension Improvement of Iranian Female High School EFL Learners 

Based on Gaj and Khate Sefid Text Books. 

Borg and Gall (1983). Educational Research, An Introduction. New York and 

London. Longman Inc. 

Brown, H. D. (2001). Language Assessment Principle and Classroom Practice. New 

York: Longman. 

Creswell, J. (2009). Research Design. California: Sage publications. 

Departemen Pendidikan dan Kebudayaan Republik Indonesia. (2014). Kurikulum 

2013. Badan Pengembangan Sumber Daya Manusia Pendidikan dan 

Kebudayaan penjamin Mutu Pendidikan. 

Duffy, G. G. (2009). Explaining Reading. London: The Guilford Press 

Fetzer, A. (2004). Recontextualizing Context: Grammaticality Meets 

Appropriateness. Amsterdam: John Benjamins B.V. 

Howarth, P. (2001). Process Speaking to Repeat Yourself. 39-44. 

Kementerian dan Kebudayaan Republik Indonesia. (2014). Buku Guru Bahasa 

Inggris. Jakarta: Balitbang.  

Kucer, S, B. (2005). Dimensions of Literacy. London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates 

Machmud, M. (2013). Heritage Media and Local Wisdom of Indonesian Society. 

Global Journal of Human Social Science and Arts Humanities. 13. 

Masuhara, H and Tomlinson, B. (2004). Developing Language Course Materilas. 

Singapore: Seameo regional Language Centre. 

McDouggh, J., Shaw, C., Masuhara, H. (2013). Materials and Methods in ELT. 

USA: Wiley Blackwell. 

Monoarfa, M. (2015). Developing Instructional Materials for Speaking Skill to 

Promote Communicative Interaction: Gorontalo. UNG 



Page | 28 

Yayu Anggraini H. Katili 

LET: Linguistics, Literature and Language Teaching Journal Vol. 13 No. 1 2023 

Richard. (1985). Approach and Method in Language Teaching. Cambridge: 

Cambridge University Press. 

Richard, C.J. (2001). Curriculum Development in language teaching. Cambridge 

University Press. 

Setiady, B. (2006). Metode Penelitian untuk Pengajaran Bahasa Asing Pendekatan 

Kuantitatif dan Kualitatif. Yogyakarta: Graha Ilmu. 

Singsomboon, T. (2014). Tourism Promotion and the Use of Local Wisdom through 

Creative Tourism Process. International Journal of Business Tourism and 

Applied Sciences. 2. 

Tarigan, H. G. (1990). Prinsip-prinsip Dasar Metode Riset Pengajaran dan 

Pembelajaran Bahasa. Bandung: Angkasa. 

Thonbury & Slade. (2006). Conversation: from Description to Pedagogy. 

Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.  

Tomlinson, B. (2008). English Language Learning Materials. London: Continuum 

International Publishing Group.  

Tomlinson, B (2014). Developing Materials for Language Teaching. London: 

Library Congress of Cataloging in Publication Data. 

Undang-undang Republik Indonesia tentang Guru dan Dosen Nomor 14. (2005). 

Thakur, V. S. (2015). Using Supplementary Materials in the Teaching of English: 

Pedagogic Scope and Applications   

Torky, S. A. (2006). The Effectiveness of a Task Based Instruction Program in 

Developing. 

Wagiran. (2011). Pengembangan Pendidikan Kearifan Lokal dalam mendukung 

Pembangunan Provinsi Daerah Istimewa Yogyakarta 2020. Jurnal 

Penelitian dan Pengembangan. Vol. III.