*Corresponding Author

P-ISSN: 1978-8118
E-ISSN: 2460-710X

1

Lingua Cultura, 15(1), July 2021, 1-9
DOI: 10.21512/lc.v15i1.6990

THE INTERPLAY OF MEANING BETWEEN VERBAL AND VISUAL 
TEXTS IN A JAPANESE CHILDREN’S BOOK

Dewi Puspitasari*

Department of Language and Literature, Faculty of Cultural Studies, Universitas Brawijaya
Jl. Veteran, Ketawanggede, Malang 65415, Indonesia 

d_puspitasari@ub.ac.id

Received: 27th January 2021/Revised: 08th March 2021/Accepted: 08th March 2021

How to Cite: Puspitasari, D. (2021). The interplay of meaning between verbal and visual texts
in a Japanese children’s book. Lingua Cultura, 15(1), 1-9. https://doi.org/10.21512/lc.v15i1.6990

ABSTRACT

The research aimed to interpret the meaning of aspects in the verbal and visual texts to identify whether these two texts 
created interplay. It was intended to understand the meaning conveyed by the writer and illustrator in a Japanese children’s 
book entitled ‘Kuroino’ (Little Shadow). The research used the approaches for verbal text analysis by Halliday about 
Systemic Functional Linguistics (SFL), and visual text analysis by Kress and van Leeuwen about Visual Grammar (VG). 
The research method was descriptive qualitative by explaining two data types: clauses in the Japanese language and images 
in the storybook. The data analysis of every aspect in the three metafunctions of language and the three metafunctions of 
images show the meaning that completes each other. In the analysis of ideational meaning, interpersonal meaning, and 
textual meaning, the writer narrates the friendship and adventure of ‘Kuroino’ (the Black) and Watashi (I). Meanwhile, in 
the analysis of representational meaning, interactive meaning, and compositional meaning, the illustrator describes two 
characters in a book entitled ‘Kuroino’ as the focuses in some pictures. Besides, the illustrator describes the background 
in detail as if he invites the reader to participate in the adventure of these two characters. Although verbal and visual texts 
describe a story from two different perspectives, in ‘Kuroino’, these texts collaborate to create a message in the story with 
synergy and meaning to be easily understood by the readers by maintaining the entertainment aspect in a story narrated. 

Keywords: text meaning, three metafunctions, verbal text, visual text, Japanese children’s book 

INTRODUCTION

Reading plays an essential role in child 
development. Reading activity is like eating healthy 
food; it simultaneously brings pleasure and benefits, 
such as improving cognitive development and language 
skill (Attiyat, 2019; Maharsi, Ghali, & Salma, 2019). 
However, an annual survey conducted by The National 
Federation University Co-operative Association shows 
that most of the students in Japan do not read the book 
for pleasure. From 10.021 samples, 53,1% of students 
answer in this way. Moreover, the student’s average 
daily reading time has decreased to 23,6 minutes per 
day (Steele, Zhang, & Song, 2018). Nowadays, local 
governments and schools in Japan promote Morning 
Reading Program to improve the reading interest since 
childhood. Based on the Morning Reading Promotion 
Association survey in June 2019, reading activities 
increase to 80% in elementary school and 50% in 
junior high school (Kimura, 2019). The morning 
reading program is expected to form the behavior 

pattern to favor reading activity since childhood.
Since childhood, reading activity serves to 

prepare quality generation with broad insight and 
pleasure from the reading book (Irhandayaningsih, 
2019; Tse et al., 2017). Book generally used by the 
parent to introduce reading activity since childhood 
is illustrated children’s storybook. The illustrated 
children’s storybook plays a fundamental role in life, 
entertainment, and education for children in several 
ways (Maximo, 2019; Qiu, 2019). Illustrated storybook 
is believed to represent a place or country and describe 
how people live so that readers can understand the 
local culture from a site (Belcher, 2018; Ratminingsih 
& Budasi, 2018). Illustrated storybook defines the 
physical characteristics, reflects how to behave, and 
describes role in a story. In other words, an illustrated 
book can be understood as a book composed of two 
elements, namely narrative or verbal text and picture 
or visual text (Hermawan & Sukyadi, 2017).

Wee, Kura, and Kim (2018) have discovered 
several social values illustrated in illustrated children’s 



2 LINGUA CULTURA, Vol. 15 No. 1, July 2021, 1-9   

storybooks, such as harmony, empathy, faithfulness, 
and patience in Japanese society. Besides, most of the 
children’s storybooks from 1990 to 2016 for the age of 
3-8 years old illustrate and tell about Japanese cultures, 
such as clothes, food, entertainment, traditional 
activity, tradition, social behavior that reflect the 
value and belief of Japanese people, historical 
events, and political issues. According to Cao and 
Yin (2016), most of the research about children’s 
literature is categorized into the perspective of genre 
and context; and the interaction between readers 
and text. Many kinds of research from the genre and 
content perspectives have been frequently conducted, 
but research from a linguistic perspective is still rare 
and is not yet wholly done. Thus, the research aims to 
investigate the illustrated storybook with a linguistic 
resource approach. It is expected that the research 
can provide a contribution to recommend children’s 
literature from a different perspective for the reader. 
Application of the linguistic resource uses Systemic 
Functional Linguistics (SFL) and Visual Grammar 
(VG) approaches, which serve as a valid tool to know 
how children’s literature can affect children.

Previous research with a similar topic that 
combined SFL and VG approaches has been done. 
The differences of previous research are on the 
research scope and data source used. Sembiante, 
Baxley, and Cavallaro (2018) have used illustrated 
children’s storybook with a specific theme, namely 
issues discussed in children’s storybook from the 
diaspora (a work by an immigrant writer in a place). 
That research also applies the theory about critical 
literacy. Meanwhile, the studies conducted by 
Hayakawa (2015); Hermawan and Sukyadi (2017); 
Koutsikou and Christidou (2019); Moya Guijarro and 
Pinar Sanz (2008); Qiu (2019); Zohrabi, Dobakhti, 
and Mohammadpour (2019) have used a themed 
storybook with different languages focuses, such as 
the Indonesian language, Greek language, English, 
and Mandarin language. Meanwhile, research with 
illustrated children’s storybooks in the Japanese 
language is still limited to date. Previous research 
using data in the Japanese language is conducted by 
Inako (2017); Indrowaty et al. (2018); Murray (2020) 
on the translation and advertisement in the Japanese 
language.

Since research using data in children’s 
storybooks in the Japanese language is limited, the 
research investigates a children’s storybook entitled 
Kuroino (Little Shadow) written and illustrated 
by Tanaka (2019). The research combines two 
approaches, namely SFL, as stated by Halliday 
and Matthiessen (2014), and VG by Kress and van 
Leeuwen (2020). These two leading theories are based 
on analyzing verbal and visual texts in a book entitled 
Kuroino. Thus, it can identify the role of verbal and 
visual texts in the storybook and create a meaningful 
story. Verbal text analysis uses a theory of SFL about 
three metafunctions of language, including ideational 
meaning, interpersonal meaning, and textual meaning 
(Halliday & Matthiessen, 2014). Meanwhile, visual 

text analysis uses VG theory about three metafunctions 
of the image, including representational meaning, 
interactive meaning, and compositional meaning 
(Kress & van Leeuwen, 2020). Applying these two 
theories is expected to interpret the meaning of aspects 
in verbal and visual texts. Thus, a comprehensive 
understanding of the message conveyed by the writer 
and illustrator can be obtained. 

METHODS

The research method is descriptive qualitative. 
The research procedure resulted in descriptive data 
in the form of written words or speeches from people 
and observed behavior. It is intended to understand the 
phenomenon as experienced by the research subject, 
namely behavior, perception, motivation, action, and 
holistically by describing in words and language in a 
specific context by using several scientific methods 
(Miles, Huberman, & Saldafia, 2020). The approach 
is used to investigate verbal and visual elements in the 
illustrated children’s storybook with the description in 
words.

Data are provided with the listening method that 
obtained by listening to the use of language with tapping 
and note-taking techniques (Sudaryanto, 2015). These 
techniques are applied by reading data sources, namely 
illustrated children’s storybook entitled Kuroino (Little 
Shadow) by Tanaka (2019). This book is a children’s 
storybook recommended by the Japanese Board on 
Books for Young People (JBBY) in 2020. JBBY was 
established in 1978 as a part of The International 
Board on Books for Young People (IBBY). Missions 
from IBBY and JBBY create a peaceful future for 
children around the world through the book (Doi et al., 
2020). Kuroino is a book for children older than three 
years old (preschool children). It has won awards, 
Winner of the Nami Concours Purple Island Prize and 
Shogakukan Children’s Book Award.

Data analysis is conducted to answer problems 
in the research; (1) to analyze verbal text (35 clauses) 
using a theory of three metafunctions of language, 
namely ideational meaning, interpersonal meaning, 
and textual meaning by Halliday & Matthiessen 
(2014) and thematic progression by Danes in (Kizil 
& Kushch, 2019) and Eggins in (Gunawan & Aziza, 
2017; Yunita, 2018); and (2) to analyze visual text 
using three metafunctions of the image by Kress & van 
Leeuwen (2020), including representational meaning, 
interactive meaning, and compositional meaning. After 
conducting the analysis, in the discussion section, the 
researcher sees the relevance of meaning in verbal 
and visual texts based on the relationship stated by 
Liu (2019), whether or not it creates a relation with 
synergy and meaning.

The result of data analysis is presented in the 
form of verbal and visual texts. The verbal text is 
written using the hiragana alphabet with alphabetic 
transcriptions, while visual text in the form of 
image representation is in a book entitled Kuroino. 



3The Interplay of Meaning  .... (Dewi Puspitasari)      

Data are presented using the informal presentation 
method, using words without formulation or symbol 
(Sudaryanto, 2015). The result of data analysis is 
presented in descriptive form with some images in the 
children’s storybook as a part of data analysis. 

RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS

Data analysis is described in two phases: verbal 
and visual meaning analysis in illustrated children’s 
storybook entitled Kuroino (Little Shadow). The 
discussion describes a relation between verbal text 
and visual text in the book Kuroino, whether they 
complete each other and easy to understand. The 
researcher analyzes the clause in verbal text from three 
perspectives. First, every clause in a book Kuroino 
is classified based on the clause system. The clause 
is then deconstructed based on the Mood system, 
transitivity structure, and theme-rheme structure. 
After analysis, the researcher interprets the verbal text 
based on lexico-grammatical choices as stated in the 
clause. Lexico-grammatical choices are a reflection of 
meaning in text comprehensively (Ngongo, Dethan, & 
Hyna, 2018; Raeisi, Dastjerdi, & Raeisi, 2019).

Based on clause analysis in a book Kuroino, it 
can be known that most of the clauses (77%) belong to 
the Mood indicative-declarative type. These clauses, 
which served as proposition-giving, are statements 
that exchange information, not goods and services. It 
can be interpreted interpersonally that in a text entitled 
Kuroino, the writer provides information or tells a 
story about the friendship between Kuroino (the Black) 
and Watashi (I). Meanwhile, 23% of clauses belong to 
Mood indicative-interrogative type, classified into 9% 
in polar, and 14% in asking the question. The writer 
interpersonally provides information and involves 
readers in an adventure experienced by Kuroino and 
Watashi. An example is a simple question asked by 
Watashi「はいっていいの?」Haitte iino? ‘Is it true 
I can go inside there?’, readers are indirectly invited to 
enjoy an adventure together in this story.

Transitivity analysis in a book entitled Kuroino 
(see Table 1) shows that the most frequently identified 
process is material (43%). The writer uses the words, 
such as「する」suru ‘to do’,「行く」iku ‘to go’,「
潜って」kugutte iku ‘to crawl’,「歩く」aruku ‘to 
walk’, and so on to describe adventure by Kuroino 
and Watashi when they met. In the existential process 
(20%), the writer uses words「いた」ita ‘there is’,
「何かしら」nani kashira ‘what is there’,「ああ、
お父さん」aa otousan ‘there is father’, and so on. 
When enjoying the adventure, Kuroino and Watashi 
invite the readers to participate in their experience 
by asking questions, such as「ああ、あれは何かし
ら?Aa, are wa nani kashira? ‘What is there?’, which 
asks about the existence of a thing.

Meanwhile, mental process (14%), relational 
process (11%), and verbal process (9%) in Kuroino 
text are sequential in terms of amount. In the mental 
process, the writer uses the words「よく見てみ

よう」yoku mite miyou ‘to try seeing thoroughly’ 
and「聞こえた」kikoeta ‘to be heard’ to describe a 
process that explains perception from Kuroino and 
Watashi. Relation process shows intensity relation 
and meaning extension relation in a clause「山は
ふわふわで暖かかった」Yama wa fuwafuwa de 
atatakakatta ‘Its mound is soft and warm’. This clause 
has the attributive relational process, in which the 
participant is called carrier (yama ‘mound’) followed 
with attribute (fuwafuwa de atatakakatta ‘soft and 
warm’). Thus, it can be understood that attribute 
shows condition, trait, and characteristics owned by 
a carrier. The verbal process shows notification or 
proclamation, such as「おもいきって声をかけた
ら」Omoikitte koe wo kaketara ‘I dare myself to greet 
him’. The verbal process has sayer (I) and verbiage (to 
greet him). Meanwhile, the behavioral process is not 
found in Kuroino text.

Based on transitivity analysis, the writer 
ideationally states imaginary adventure in detail, as 
experienced by two figures in the story, Kuroino and 
Watashi. Kuroino invites Watashi into a fictional world 
to visit the playground in which its entrance was in 
oshiire ‘wardrobe’. In the park, they play happily, run 
everywhere, skate on a tree, and fall asleep on soft fur. 
The writer asks readers to participate in their adventure 
using questions and invitations. It seems that readers 
also participate in their experience.

Table 1 Amount of Process Type in Kuroino

Processes Absolute 
Values

Values in Percentages

Material 16 46
Mental 5 14
Verbal 3 9
Relational 4 11
Behavioral 0 0
Existential 7 20
Total 35 100

There are many relevant theories to analyze 
textual meaning. In this dimension, the clause is 
viewed as a meaning source used for organizing 
information and message (Halliday & Matthiessen, 
2014). The report considered the vital thing is 
prioritized by positioning in front of clause (theme), 
while the next part completes information (rheme). 
The theme is divided into three types, namely topical 
theme, interpersonal theme, and textual theme. The 
topical theme is the only thematic element required 
in the clause, implied in co(n)text or explicitly stated 
since it is mixed with some transitivity elements 
(Alamiri, 2018; Pasaribu, Sinambela, & Manik, 2020). 
Halliday and Matthiessen (2014) have asserted that 
the sentence theme expands from the beginning to 
meet its transitivity function. The researcher’s basis 



4 LINGUA CULTURA, Vol. 15 No. 1, July 2021, 1-9   

is to investigate thematization in periodicity (SFL) in 
text Kuroino. Besides, considering objectives of the 
research to examine patterns in theme development 
and information distribution, which is coherence in the 
text is by combining the theory of thematic progression 
stated by Danes in (Kizil & Kushch, 2019) and Eggins 
in (Gunawan & Aziza, 2017; Yunita, 2018), namely 
thematic progression with a linear theme, thematic 
progression with a continuous (constant) theme, and 
thematic progression with derived themes.

Information distribution on Kuroino text is 
textually stated through thematization with details 
of 27 (77%) unmarked topical themes and 8 (23%) 
marked topical themes. Realizing the unmarked 
topical theme means that Kuroino text has the main 
issue, as stated the most frequently through Kuroino 
and Watashi. The marked topical theme, circumstances 
from adverbs of time such as ‘when going home’ and 
‘today’ is used to described adventure in detail. The 
interpersonal theme is not found in Kuroino’s text. 
However, the textual theme is found in 20 clauses 
(57%) from the whole text. The textual theme is 
realized with internal conjunction (7%), external 
conjunction (23%), and continuous marker (27%). 
The use internal and external conjunctions, in a                                                                
clause「塀の穴をくぐっていくと、花のにおい、
草のにおい」Hei no ana wo kugutte iku to, hana no 
nioi, kusa no nioi ‘I crawled under wall hole in a house, 
after reaching the yard, I smelt flower and grasses’ is 
used to combine experience gradually and in detail, 
as done by two figures. Besides, continuative markers, 
such as「ああ」aa ‘wow’,「へえ」hee ‘eh?’,「あ
れえ」aree ‘eh’ and so on are used to show emotion 
experienced by Watashi. The information presented in 
Kuroino’s text tends to be organized through various 
occurrences at the clause level. Thus, it can identify a 
relation between theme and rheme in every clause in 
Kuroino text. For example, a wave from the center of 
the sea flows to the beach. This movement describes 
information flow in the text, which is continuous. Thus, 
in periodicity, text context is easy to be understood.

Theme development and information distribution 
in paragraph show that thematic progression with a 
linear theme is 27 (80%), and thematic progression 
with a continuous (constant) theme is 7 (20%). The 
data presented is a representation of the whole data 
in the Kuroino book. Data 1 belongs to thematic 
progression with a linear theme.

「くろいのはやまをどんどんのぼってい
く。やまはふわふわで、あたたかかった。
ふかふかのけにつつまれて、くろいのとい
っしょにねむった。」
Kuroino wa yama wo dondon nobotte iku. Yama 
wa fuwafuwa de, atatakakatta. Fukafuka no ke 
ni tsutsumarete, kuroino to isshoni nemutta
 (Kuroino quickly climbed a mound. The mound 
was soft and warm. Then, I fell asleep with 
Kuroino covered by soft fur.)

The data shows that theme in the clause is 

developed from rheme in previous clauses, such as 
‘when Kuroino climbed a mound’, followed with a 
theme which describes the mound ‘Its mound was 
soft and warm’, and it is told that ‘they fell asleep 
on the mound’. This theme development dominates 
Kuroino’s text following Denis’s statement in Rezayi 
and Moghani (2018) about thematic progression with a 
linear theme, which is frequently found in fundamental 
reading material. Using this type will facilitate the 
reader in understanding the story plot.

Although thematic progression with a linear 
theme is the most dominant in text, another type is 
found in the text in the beginning and end, as shown 
in Data 2. Data 2 belong to thematic progression 
with a continuous (constant) theme, namely theme 
development based on the initial theme. At the 
beginning of the clause, Watashi and Kuroino meet 
for the first time, while the theme is developed from 
meetings with Kuroino in several opportunities. In this 
case, it is not explicitly stated in the next clauses since 
the Japanese language is known as a language with 
ellipsis of the word in a text when still discussing the 
same theme. Meanwhile, data in thematic progression 
with derived themes are not found in the text. The 
researcher assumes that topic development using this 
type will be difficult to understand by the reader older 
than three years.

「ひとりでかえるいつものみち、へいのう
えにくろいのがいた。[…] つぎにみたとき
は、バスていにすわっていた。あ、また。
きょうは、ちゃんとよくみてみよう。」                                                                                                                                                
Hitori de kaeru itsumo no michi, hei no ue ni 
kuroino gai ta. …tsugi ni mita toki wa, basutei 
ni suwatte ita. A, mata. Kyou wa, chanto yoku 
mite miyou.
On the way which I usually passed, I saw 
Kuroino creature on the wall. The next day, I 
saw him sitting at the bus stop. Wow, he is there 
again. Today, I will try finding out about him. 

After analyzing verbal text from the book 
Kuroino, the analysis focuses on three metafunctions 
of image (Kress & van Leeuwen, 2020) related to three 
metafunctions of language (Halliday & Matthiessen, 
2014), namely representational, interactive, and 
compositional. The relation between SFL and VG in 
Table 2 as stated by Liu (2019). Thus, it can be said 
that the researcher treats the image as a language in 
this analysis phase provided that the picture is believed 
as a verbal language to realize its metafunction.

Table 2 Three Strands of Meta-functions in
SFL and VG

SFL VG
Ideational Representational

Interpersonal Interactive
Textual Compositional



5The Interplay of Meaning  .... (Dewi Puspitasari)      

Analysis of visual text data uses representational 
meaning, interactive meaning, and compositional 
meaning by Kress and van Leeuwen (2020). 
Representational meaning refers to the faithful 
reproduction of people’s objective world, human 
activities, places, and even people’s inner world. 
Kress and van Leeuwen (2020) have viewed that 
representational meaning can be obtained from 
two processes: narrative and conceptual processes. 
The vector is a criterion to identify whether it is the 
narrative process or a conceptual process. Besides, 
finding representational meaning reveals the relation 
between the represented participants (object in an 
image, a living creature, or inanimate object). The 
interaction process between defined participants is 
realized in a vector.

Participants in illustrated storybook Kuroino are 
Kuroino (the Black) and Watashi (I). Watashi is a girl 
aged 3-5 years. Watashi meets Kuroino for the first 
time when walking home. She sees a black creature 
sitting on the wall. The position of Watashi is on the 
lower left while staring at Kuroino. Meanwhile, the 
position of Kuroino is on the upper right while he looks 
around. Condition in the place shows a quiet street. 
The vector in Figure 1 is realized through stare from 
Watashi to Kuroino. Thus, Watashi is a reactor, while 
Kuroino becomes a phenomenon. Based on the vector, 
the relation between objects in the image belongs to 
the narrative process. 

Figure 1 Narrative Process Image

Some visual data in a book Kuroino can be 
categorized into a narrative process that presents 
actions and characters’ actions in their spatial 
arrangements. The spatial reference is often used to 
express feeling in Figure 2 with verbal data「ねえ、
してるかな…」Nee, shiteru kana… ‘Hey, what are 
you doing?’

Besides expressing a feeling, the narrative 
process is shown from vector between Watashi and 
Kuroino in images 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 
14, 15, 26, 29, and 31, who try communicating to play 
together.

Visual data also have a conceptual process, 
namely static (no vector), and represented participants 
in terms of their more generalized and more or less 
stable and timeless essence in terms of class, structure, 

or meaning.  It can be seen in Figure 3.

Figure 2 Action/Reaction Image

Figure 3 Conceptual Symbolic Image

Figure 3 shows Kuroino giving the flower 
to Watashi in a park where they do their exciting 
adventure. Although its color is monochrome (black 
and white), it clearly shows plants and flowers in 
the park, representing a beautiful place. Conceptual 
process is also shown in images 13, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 
21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 27, 28, 30, and 32. Visual data in 
the narrative process shows an amount that is almost 
the same as the conceptual process. It shows that the 
writer and illustrator in Kuroino invite the reader to 
enjoy Kuroino and Watashi’s adventure by enjoying 
the environment where the experience takes place.

The illustrated book’s interactive meaning is 
used to develop and maintain interaction between 
the message or image-maker and reader. According 
to Kress & van Leeuwen (2020), some dimensions 
compile interactive meaning, namely contact, social 
distance, attitude, and modality. Contact in the visual 
text is established through the gaze from represented 
participants. In terms of gaze, represented participants 
in Kuroino do not directly communicate with the 
reader; all images belong to offer pictures. Kuroino 
and Watashi continuously stare at each other in all 
activities (e.g., walking on street, park, house) without 
involving the reader in any way besides receiving or 
refusing information made by the illustrator.

Social distance in images can determine the 
social relation between represented participants 



6 LINGUA CULTURA, Vol. 15 No. 1, July 2021, 1-9   

and the reader. Most of the pictures illustrated in 
Kuroino book belong to a far social distance, in which 
participants show their full body and readers can see 
the whole space. Thus, it can be said that the relation 
which dominates represented participants and reader 
is formal and impersonal. The illustrator does it as an 
effort to show readers (children) that these figures are 
from the imaginary world, not the real one. Besides, 
there are images in the category of far personal distance 
and close personal distance, in which participants are 
shown from shoulder to waist, so a relationship is 
established between represented participant and reader 
in the intimate and personal category. It shows that the 
story presented is from the imaginary world and the 
real world (Watashi is on the highway).

The next structure that establishes relation is 
the angle. There are two perspectives discussed by 
Kress & van Leeuwen (2020), namely horizontal and 
vertical. Images in Kuroino are horizontally illustrated, 
so it can be said that illustrator and reader are involved 
with Watashi and Kuroino. Represented participants 
are shown in medium angle, in which relation between 
participant and reader is at the same level, so there is no 
dominance. At the same time, another dimension is a 
modality, how readers assess realism shown in images. 
Kuroino provides images in monochrome color, 
categorized into low modality in color differentiation 
aspect. However, in some contextualization aspects; 
representation, depth, illumination, and brightness can 
be categorized into high modality since the illustrated 
images are highly detailed in participant, background, 
a full representation of light and shade, and maximal 
degree of brightness.

Compositional meaning is achieved by the 
layout of the image, which consists of information 
value, salience, and framing (Kress & van Leeuwen, 
2020). The first principle is information value. It is 
the placement of several elements that give specific 
value, specific as in ‘center/margin’ and ‘given/new’. 
In Kuroino, Watashi and Kuroino’s participants are 
usually in the center of the image, as if they provide 
essential information from the whole picture. Thus, it 
can be said that these two participants are dominant 
in some pictures. Information structure given in the 
double-page book, Kuroino, shows the domination of 
verbal text on the left (given) and visual text on the 
right (new), as shown in Figure 4.

Figure 4 Compositional Meaning (Given/New Information)

Although it seems that visual and verbal texts 
are separated, they have relevance that completes each 
other. Represented participants, Kuroino and Watashi, 
are enjoying ocha (Japanese tea) with verbal text「で
も、お話はしないね」Demo, ohanashi wa shinaine 
‘But, Kuroino is not saying any single word at all’. It 
shows that they are enjoying a drink while looking at 
the park without saying any word.

Salience is the second principle of layout 
discussed by Kress & van Leeuwen (2020). It refers to 
the degree to which an element of composition or design 
draws attention to itself. It includes all participant 
elements made to attract readers, such as size, the 
sharpness of focus, tonal contrasts, color contrasts, 
placement in the visual field, and perspective. The 
researcher uses not all aspects in salience to analyze 
since visual text data on Kuroino is monochrome. As 
shown in Figure 2, the size of Kuroino and Watashi 
is almost like a human being in general based on 
proportion with the environmental condition (image 
background). Although the researcher cannot use 
color as an aspect to be analyzed, the tonal contrast of 
the image is detailed, as shown in Figure 3. It shows 
how the illustrator describes a park full of beautiful 
flowers as if they have many colors. When Kuroino 
and Watashi focus on some stories, they are described 
as the center’s position, more oversized shape, and 
more plain background.

The third principle of composition is discussed 
by Kress & van Leeuwen (2020). There is no framing 
in Kuroino, which indicates involvement and absence 
of social distance between represented participants 
and readers (children). The lack of structure creates 
intersemiotic compositional cooperation between 
visual and verbal, which relates to each other and 
provides a taste of unity.

After analyzing meaning based on verbal and 
visual texts, the researcher interprets the meaning, 
whether or not it completes each other. Thus, it can be 
understood the meaning to be conveyed by the writer 
and illustrator, whether or not it synergizes and has 
meaning. The researcher describes a relation in verbal 
and visual texts based on an opinion stated by Liu 
(2019), in which every aspect of meaning in the three 
metafunctions of language will be compared with that 
in the three metafunctions of image.

Analysis of ideational meaning in the verbal 
text shows the domination of Mood indicative-
declarative, a clause which states information about 
the adventure of the represented participant. It is 
supported by representational meaning in the visual 
text, which is almost the same between narrative 
and conceptual processes. It can be interpreted that 
the writer and illustrator in Kuroino invite the reader 
to enjoy the adventure by Kuroino and Watashi by 
enjoying the environment where the incident occurred. 
Besides, interpersonal meaning shows the domination 
of material processes (46%) and existential processes 
(20%), which tend to be found in children’s stories. 
Children’s narrative explains what is done by the 
character and represents what is thought and felt.



7The Interplay of Meaning  .... (Dewi Puspitasari)      

Besides, interactive meaning in the visual 
text uses analysis elements, namely contact, social 
distance, attitude, and modality. Data analysis shows 
the represented participants between imaginary 
and real worlds. As demonstrated by formal and 
impersonal domination in the social space; what is 
done by the designated participant without approval 
or rejection from readers (viewed from offer image); 
the relation between participant and reader at the same 
level (horizontally shown from the perspective and 
medium angle); in realism, illustration seems real with 
beautiful details, though illustrated using black and 
white color. 

Textual meaning in the verbal text uses thematic 
progression theory. It shows linear theme domination, 
though thematic progression with a continuous 
(constant) theme on story plot is also found. It exhibits 
a strong relation in a clause that delivers an information 
message with two main characters in the story. The 
story is told in a structured and thematic way with a 
simple pattern easily understood by the reader. It is 
supported by compositional meaning in the visual text, 
which is evident with a visual component in detailed 
black and white images describing two characters, a 
girl and a black creature, in an imaginary adventure. 
It is related to environmental aspects of nature, such 
as highway, park, house, tree, flower, and others as 
additional aspects of the two characters’ support story.

CONCLUSIONS
 The research conclusion shows that in verbal 

text, the meaning of a clause in a book entitled Kuroino, 
which is analyzed by using the three metafunctions 
of language, shows the meaning relevance. The 
interpersonal meaning states information exchange 
(indicative-declarative) between writer and reader 
about friendship and adventure between Kuroino 
and Watashi. It is supported by ideational meaning 
(transitivity analysis) that the writer conveys an 
imaginary adventure in detail, which is experienced 
by these two characters. Besides, in the textual 
meaning, which shows the domination of thematic 
progression with a linear theme, the writer develops 
theme and distribution of information (e.g., following 
one after another) in text, so the story about friendship 
and adventure between these two characters is easily 
understood. Meanwhile, meaning in the visual text, 
which is analyzed using the three metafunctions 
of images, shows the meaning of relevance. 
Representational meaning shows the same amount 
between the narrative process and conceptual process, 
provided that the illustrator in a book entitled Kuroino 
invites the readers to participate in adventure while 
enjoying the surrounding environment or condition. 
The illustrator expects to develop and maintain the 
relationship with readers, as shown in interactive 
meaning. Besides, the structure of information 
provided in a double-page book entitled Kuroino 
shows the domination of a ‘given-new’ structure. 

Thus, although it seems that verbal and visual texts are 
separated, they have a relevance that completes each 
other. Based on the explanation, the meaning in verbal 
and visual texts of a storybook entitled Kuroino creates 
a relation that synergizes each other and has meaning. 
The writer and the illustrator create a message which 
completes each other.

It can be said that Kuroino is one of the picture 
books made for children using simple vocabulary and 
a simple plot to tell a story. It is supported with a visual 
presentation to keep the storyline, so children can easily 
understand the story without double meaning. Besides, 
verbal and visual texts avoid monotonous aspects from 
the story. The implication of the research is expected 
to enrich the reference related to the implementation 
of SFL and VG in Japanese children’s picture books. It 
can also give a contribution to recommending quality 
children’s literature from the perspective of linguistics. 
The limitation of the research is indicated by using one 
data source only, a picture book for children older than 
three years, the suggestion for the next research is the 
use of several picture books for children of several 
ages. Besides, it can be focused on a storybook with 
a specific theme (e.g., fable or others) in the Japanese 
language. 

REFERENCES

Alamiri, Z. (2018). SFL-based analysis of thematic structure 
of the Qurʾān (19:41-50): Some reflections. The 
Buckingham Journal of Language and Linguistics, 
11, 21-52. https://doi.org/10.5750/bjll.v11i0.1560.

Attiyat, N. M. A. (2019). The impact of pleasure reading 
on enhancing writing achievement and reading 
comprehension. Arab World English Journal, 
10(1), 155-165. https://doi.org/10.24093/awej/
vol10no1.14.

Belcher, C. (2018). Culture through children’s picture 
books: A new kind of reading or a new kind of child? 
IAFOR Journal of Cultural Studies, 3(2), 29-41. 
https://doi.org/10.22492/ijcs.3.2.03.

Cao, Y., & Yin, J. (2016). A new perspective to study 
children’s literature: From the systemic functional 
grammar perspective. Linguistics and Literature 
Studies, 4(6), 433-440. https://doi.org/10.13189/
lls.2016.040607.

Doi, Y., Hiromatsu, Y., Nogami, A., Sakuma, Y., & Shiozaki, 
J. (2020). Japanese children’s books 2020: JBBY’s 
recommendations for young readers throughout the 
world. (Y. Sakuma, Ed.). Tokyo: Poplar Publishing 
Co., Ltd.

Gunawan, W., & Aziza, F. (2017). Theme and thematic 
progression of undergraduate thesis: Investigating 
meaning making in academic writing. Indonesian 
Journal of Applied Linguistics, 7(2), 413-424. 
https://doi.org/10.17509/ijal.v7i2.8350.

Halliday, M. A. K., & Matthiessen, C. M. I. M. (2014). 
Halliday’s introduction to functional grammar: 
Fourth edition. London and New York: Routledge. 
https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203431269.



8 LINGUA CULTURA, Vol. 15 No. 1, July 2021, 1-9   

Hayakawa, C. (2015). The system of relationships between 
words and pictures in picturebooks. Japanese 
Journal of Systemic Functional Linguistics, 8, 115-
140.

Hermawan, B., & Sukyadi, D. (2017). Ideational and 
interpersonal meanings of children narratives in 
Indonesian picturebooks. Indonesian Journal of 
Applied Linguistics, 7(2), 404-412. https://doi.
org/10.17509/ijal.v7i2.8139.

Inako, A. (2017). But the meaning disappears when translated 
into English: Glossing choices in a discourse semantic 
exploration of Japanese. In P. Chappell & J. S. Knox 
(Eds.), Transforming Contexts: Papers from The 44th 
International Systemic Functional Congress (pp. 
5-11). Wollongong: The Organising Committee of 
the 44th International Systemic Functional Congress.

Indrowaty, S. A., Djatmika, D., Purnanto, D., & Hariri, 
T. (2018). Analyzing the structure and the texture 
of Japanese advertisement (A systemic functional 
linguistics approach). In 4th PRASASTI International 
Conference on Recent Linguistics Research (Vol. 
166, pp. 293-301). Hong Kong: Atlantis Press. 
https://doi.org/10.2991/prasasti-18.2018.56.

Irhandayaningsih, A. (2019). Menanamkan budaya 
membaca pada anak usia dini. Anuva, 3(2), 109-118. 
https://doi.org/10.14710/anuva.3.2.109-118.

Kimura, H. (2019). Data-based discussion on education 
and children in Japan 4: Issues regarding Japanese 
children’s reading--In association with the effects 
of reading. Retrieved September 9, 2020, from 
https://www.childresearch.net/projects/data_
Japan/2019_02.html.

Kizil, M., & Kushch, E. (2019). Thematic progression and 
its types in English literary and legislative texts. 
Advanced Education, 2019(12), 181-187. https://doi.
org/10.20535/2410-8286.142658.

Koutsikou, M., & Christidou, V. (2019). The interplay 
between interpersonal and compositional meanings 
in multimodal texts about animals for young children. 
Punctum, 5(1), 114-137. https://doi.org/10.18680/
hss.2018.0008.

Kress, G., & van Leeuwen, T. (2020). Reading images (3rd 
Ed.). London and New York: Routledge. Retrieved 
from https://www.routledge.com/Reading-Images-
The-Grammar-of-Visual-Design/Kress-Leeuwen/p/
book/9780415672573.

Liu, S. (2019). A multimodal discourse analysis of the 
interactive meaning in public service advertisement. 
Journal of Advances in Linguistics, 10, 1523-1534. 
https://doi.org/10.24297/jal.v10i0.8196.

Maharsi, I., Ghali, M. I., & Salma, M. U. (2019). High school 
students’ reading habit and perception on reading 
for pleasure. International Journal of Indonesian 
Education and Teaching, 3(2), 204-214. https://doi.
org/10.24071/ijiet.2019.030108.

Maximo, M. (2019). Storybook reading strategies to 
enhance English skills with preschool children in 
Honduras. Paradigma Revista de Investigacion 
Educativa, 26(41), 46-68. http://dx.doi.org/10.5377/
paradigma.v26i41.7975.

Miles, M. B., Huberman, A. M., & Saldafia, J. (2020). 

Qualitative data analysis: A methods sourcebook 
(Fourth). Los Angeles, London, New Delhi, 
Singapore, Washington DC, Melbourne: Sage 
Publications, Inc.

Moya Guijarro, J., & Pinar Sanz, M. J. (2008). Compositional, 
interpersonal and representational meanings in 
a children’s narrrative: A multimodal discourse 
analysis. Journal of Pragmatics, 40(9), 1601-1619. 
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pragma.2008.04.019.

Murray, N. (2020). A multimodal analysis using an exemplar 
from Japanese television advertising. Athens Journal 
of Mass Media and Communications, 6(3), 161-176. 
https://doi.org/10.30958/ajmmc.6-3-2.

Ngongo, M., Dethan, M., & Hyna, H. B. (2018). 
Metafunction meaning realization in lexicogrammar 
of sermon texts on language and cultural month, 
Kupang town: A systemic functional linguistic 
approach. In International Conference on Language 
Phenomena in Multimodal Communication (Vol. 
228, pp. 214-225). Netherland: Atlantis Press. 
https://doi.org/10.2991/klua-18.2018.31.

Pasaribu, A. N., Sinambela, E., & Manik, S. (2020). The 
contributions of systemic functional linguistics 
to literary text analysis. International Journal of 
Linguistics, Literature and Translation (IJLLT), 
3(9), 81-86. https://doi.org/10.32996/ijllt.

Qiu, Q. (2019). A multimodal analysis of the interplay 
between visual and verbal semiotics in creating 
messages in Chinese picture books. CS Canada 
Studies in Literature and Language, 19(3), 44-50. 
https://doi.org/10.3968/11444.

Raeisi, M., Dastjerdi, H. V., & Raeisi, M. (2019). Lexico-
grammatical analysis of native and non-native 
abstracts based on Halliday’s SFL model. Theory 
and Practice in Language Studies, 9(11), 1388. 
https://doi.org/10.17507/tpls.0911.03.

Ratminingsih, N. M., & Budasi, I. G. (2018). Local culture-
based picture storybooks for teaching English for 
young learners. In A. G. Abdullah, J. Foley, I. G. N. 
A. Suryaputra, & A. Hellman (Eds.), SHS Web of 
Conferences (Vol. 42, p. 00016). Bali: EDP Sciences. 
https://doi.org/10.1051/shsconf/20184200016.

Rezayi, S. T., & Moghani, H. (2018). The status of theme 
types and thematic progression patterns in English 
written biography texts: A systemic functional 
approach. Linguistics Journal, 12(1), 45-69.

Sembiante, S. F., Baxley, T. P., & Cavallaro, C. J. (2018). 
What’s in a name? A critical literacy and functional 
linguistic analysis of immigrant acculturation in 
contemporary picture books. Diaspora, Indigenous, 
and Minority Education, 12(1), 28-41. https://doi.or
g/10.1080/15595692.2017.1350640.

Steele, D., Zhang, R., & Song, S. (2018). The impact of 
manga on Japanese students’ reading habits. In ACM 
International Conference Proceeding Series (pp. 
206-211). Bali, Indonesia: ACM Digital Library. 
https://doi.org/10.1145/3291078.3291112.

Sudaryanto. (2015). Metode dan aneka teknik analisis 
bahasa. Yogyakarta: Sanata Dharma University 
Press.

Tanaka, K. (2019). Kuroi no. Tokyo: Kaiseisha.



9The Interplay of Meaning  .... (Dewi Puspitasari)      

Tse, S. K., Zhu, Y., Hui, S. Y., & Ng, H. W. (2017). The 
effects of home reading activities during preschool 
and grade 4 on the effects of home reading activities 
during preschool and grade 4 on children’s reading 
performance in Chinese and English in Hong Kong. 
Australian Journal of Education, 61(1), 5-23. https://
doi.org/10.1177%2F0004944116689093.

Wee, S.-J., Kura, K., & Kim, J. (2018). Unpacking Japanese 
culture in children’s picture books: Culturally 
authentic representation and historical events/
political issues. Reading Horizons: A Journal of 
Literacy and Language Arts, 57(2), 35-55.

Yunita, S. (2018). Theme and thematic progression in 
students’ recount texts. Indonesian Journal of 
Applied Linguistics, 7(3), 524-530. https://doi.
org/10.17509/ijal.v7i3.9797.

Zohrabi, M., Dobakhti, L., & Mohammadpour, E. 
(2019). Interpersonal meanings in children’s 
storybooks. Iranian Journal of Language Teaching 
Research, 7(2), 39-64. https://dx.doi.org/10.30466/
ijltr.2019.120697.