Migraciones internacionales 22.indd


RESEÑA BIBLIOGRÁFICA

[287]

As historical scholarship demon-
strates, over the longue durée of 
civilizations, migration has been 
the rule, rather than the exception 
in global human history. In South 
America, while Ecuadorian men 
and women have been no stran-
gers to internal migration, they 
have only actively participated 
in international migration since 
the 1970s. Much like other Latin 
American countries—El Salva-
dor, the Dominican Republic and 
Mexico—Ecuador is now a major 
exporter of labour and importer of 
remittances.1 The study of Ecua-
dor as a nation of immigrants and 
emigrants is astutely brought to 
light in Chiara Pagnotta’s well-
written Italian monograph, At-
traversando lo stagno: Storie della 
migrazione ecuadoriana in Eur-
opa tra continuità e cambiamento 

(1997-2007). Pagnotta, a histor-
ian from the University of Genoa 
has spent several years crossing the 
Atlantic Ocean to collect life stor-
ies of migrants and non-migrants 
through fieldwork conducted in 
three countries across two contin-
ents. The analysis takes the reader 
from several cities of departure in 
Ecuador, specifically in the prov-
inces of Loja, Guayas and Pichin-
cha (including Ecuador’s capital, 
Quito) to the European cities of 
Genoa and Madrid, two cosmo-
politan cities that have witnessed 

Attraversando lo stagno: Storie della migrazione 
ecuadoriana in Europa tra continuità 
e cambiamento (1997-2007)

Chiara Pagnotta, 2010, Rome, Centro d’Informazione e Stampa 
Universitaria (CISU).

Sonia CANCIAN
Concordia University/Université de Montréal

1 Chiara Pagnotta, 2010, Attra  ver-
san   do lo stagno: Storie della migrazione 
ecua  doriana in Europa tra continuità e 
cambiamento (1997-2007), p. 28. Cited 
in Brad Jokisch, 2001, “Desde Nueva 
York a Madrid: Tendencias en la emigra-
ción ecuatoriana”, Ecuador Debate, num. 
54, december, pp. 59-84.

Migraciones internacionales 22.indd   287Migraciones internacionales 22.indd   287 05/12/2011   10:54:31 a.m.05/12/2011   10:54:31 a.m.



MIGRACIONES INTERNACIONALES, VOL. 6, NÚM. 3, ENERO-JUNIO DE 2012288

the arrival of large concentrations 
of migrants. 

A theoretical framework, a well-
documented historical context of 
Ecuador in the latter part of the 
twentieth century, and a variety 
of oral history accounts infuse the 
study. This gender-based analy-
sis is viewed through the lens of 
intersectionality, in other words, 
from the perspective of power re-
lations exercised in ethnicity, gen-
der, class, sexuality and age (p. 
22). The nearly forty life stories of 
Ecuadorian families interviewed 
by Pagnotta focus on the trans-
national lives of women—single 
women, married women, divorced 
women, women in common-law 
relationships, mothers, sisters, 
daughters, and grand mothers. By 
unders cor ing women’s experienc-
es, Pag       notta demonstrates that the 
feminization of migration is not 
a new phenomenon. For decades, 
Ecuadorian women have joined 
the throngs of women who have 
migrated globally from South to 
North, and others who migrated 
within the Southern hemisphere 
(p. 12). As the author notes, mi-
gration is intrinsically related to 
power relations exercised in Ec-
uadorian families and the nation’s 
gender-based hierarchical struc-
tures. Feminist scholarship has 
long argued that gender dispar-

ities are recreated and perpetuated 
in the family. This study demon-
strates that families continue to 
be at the root of gender inequities.

The monograph examines the 
intersections of gender, class, and 
ethnicity in sending and receiving 
communities. It identifies the ways 
these factors have contribut ed to 
migrants’ decision over their des-
tination. It discusses whether these 
dynamics gave rise to a diversity 
of migrant networks or to paral-
lel spatial and social trajectories 
among migrants and non-migrants 
(p. 14). Further, Attra       ver   sando lo 
Stagno—meaning “crossing the 
pond” (in other words, the At-
lantic Ocean), brings to light the 
connections, worldviews, social 
representations and moral values 
that col lectively under pin Ecua-
dorian transnational societies. In 
so doing, it underscores the links 
that emerge in reality and in dis-
course (p. 14).

Briefly, Chapter One traces the 
history of Ecuadorian migration, 
the project’s research methodol-
ogy, the fieldwork and life stor-
ies, and the transnational analysis 
conducted in Ecuador, Spain and 
Italy from an intersectional per-
spective (p. 22). Here, Pagnotta 
discusses the correlations between 
sending and receiving commun-
ities, and underscores the mi-

Migraciones internacionales 22.indd   288Migraciones internacionales 22.indd   288 05/12/2011   10:54:31 a.m.05/12/2011   10:54:31 a.m.



RESEÑA BIBLIOGR ÁFICA 289

grants’ experiences and the spaces 
they occupied, their interactions 
with the environment, and the 
views migrants held of themselves 
and the world. The analysis deft-
ly illustrates ways in which the 
circulation of goods, money, ideas 
and lifestyles are vectors for social 
and economic change in locations 
of departure and arrival. The 
second chapter addresses the so-
cial and cultural practices of mi-
grants who experienced a duality 
in identity and belongingness. It 
also analyzes ways in which mi-
gration has impacted the lives of 
migrants and non-migrants. Pag-
notta describes the dynamics that 
developed internally in the circu-
lation of family migration and the 
economic ties—namely through 
remittances—that developed be-
tween the places of origin and 
arrival (p. 74). The third chapter 
examines national identities in 
the Ecuadorian diaspora of fe  male 
migrants who were frequently 
the first members in their fam-
ilies to leave for Europe. Next, 
the author examines how ethnic, 
national and local identities have 
been transformed in sending com-
munities (p. 140). What emerges 
is a heterogeneous Ecuadorian 
identity within a global world. 
In the fourth and last chapter of 

the book, Pagnotta explores the 
myriad of ways in which Ecua-
dor has changed as a result of 
migration (with three million 
Ec    ua   dor ians living abroad). She 
examines who these migrants 
were, whether they shared an 
identical social environment, and 
what their reasons for migrating 
were. Through three case studies, 
she describes the life trajectories 
of migrants, and the tensions that 
emerged between their places of 
origin and arrival from a gender 
perspective (p. 182).

In short, by examining how 
Ecuadorian women and men have 
been impacted by migration—
with the inclusion of insightful 
excerpts of life stories, this excel-
lent monograph squarely situates 
Ecuador and its peoples as part of 
a global world on the move. 

Overall, Attraversando lo Stag-
no by Chiara Pagnotta is well 
worth the attention of students 
and scholars in history, migration 
studies, and related fields in the 
humanities and social sciences. 
Its contribution to scholarship is 
unquestionable. English—and 
Spanish—language readers will 
certainly benefit from this study. 
A translation of the book is highly 
recommended.

Migraciones internacionales 22.indd   289Migraciones internacionales 22.indd   289 05/12/2011   10:54:31 a.m.05/12/2011   10:54:31 a.m.



Migraciones internacionales 22.indd   290Migraciones internacionales 22.indd   290 05/12/2011   10:54:31 a.m.05/12/2011   10:54:31 a.m.