Bragg_53-58.qxd INTRODUCTION NAD-independent variants of Haemophilus para- gallinarum have been isolated from chickens suf- fering from infectious coryza (IC) in South Africa since 1989 (Mouahid, Bisgaard, Morley, Mutters & Mannheim 1992; Horner, Bishop & Haw 1992; Bragg, Coetzee & Verschoor 1993a). Bragg et al. (1993a) established that the genes encoding for NAD independence appear to be car- 53 Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research, 71:53–58 (2004) Evidence of possible evasion of protective immu- nity by NAD-independent isolates of Haemophilus paragallinarum in poultry R.R. BRAGG Department of Microbial, Biochemical and Food Biotechnology, University of the Free State, P.O. Box 399, Bloemfontein, 9300 South Africa. E-mail: BraggRR@sci.uovs.ac.za ABSTRACT BRAGG, R.R. 2004. Evidence of possible evasion of protective immunity by NAD-independent isolates of Haemophilus paragallinarum in poultry. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research, 71:53–58 An indication of the ability of NAD-independent variants of Haemophilus paragallinarum to evade the immune system has been obtained from data obtained from several experiments. Firstly, it was noted that there was a difference in the serovar distribution between the NAD-depend- ent isolates in the 1990s and the NAD-independent isolates, as there was a significant decrease in the incidence of serogroup A NAD-dependent isolates. This can possibly be attributed to the exten- sive use of vaccines. On the other hand, most of the earlier NAD-independent isolates were serovar A. This is a possible indication of evasion of the protective immunity by the NAD-independent iso- lates. Further evidence of possible evasion of the protective immunity was obtained from results obtained when different isolates, both NAD dependent and NAD independent, were tested with a panel of monoclonal antibodies (Mabs). The V1 Mab reaction pattern was only seen in the reference strain 0083 among all of the NAD-dependent isolates tested in South Africa. This Mab was, however, found to react with some of the NAD-independent isolates. Furthermore, the isolation of NAD-dependent isolates in Australia which react with the V1 Mab also suggest possible evasion of the protective immunity by the NAD-independent isolates as no vaccines containing strain 0083 are used in Australia. In order to investigate the hypothesis of immune-evasion by NAD-independent H. paragallinarum, vaccinated and unvaccinated chickens were challenged with a NAD-independent serogroup C iso- late. As a control, chickens were also challenged with NAD-dependent H. paragallinarum of the same serogroup. The results obtained indicate that there is no significant difference in the disease profiles obtained in vaccinated and unvaccinated chickens challenged with the NAD-independent isolate, thus providing further evidence of evasion of the productivity immunity by the NAD-inde- pendent isolates. The ability of the NAD-independent isolates to evade the immune system suggests that a different vaccination strategy, or alternative control methods may be needed for the control of IC caused by these isolates. Keywords: Haemophilus paragallinarum, immunity, infectious coryza, NAD independent Accepted for publication 17 October 2003—Editor ried on a transferable plasmid and they succeeded in transforming reference strains of NAD-dependent H. paragallinarum into NAD-independent isolates. Bragg (2002b) demonstrated that the NAD-inde- pendent isolates appear to be less virulent that the NAD-dependent isolates of the same serovar. Ta- ole, Albertyn, Van Heerden & Bragg (2002) demon- strated that experimentally produced NAD-inde- pendent isolates made from virulent serovar C-3 isolates were less virulent that the wild type NAD- dependent isolates. Bragg, Coetzee & Verschoor (1996) established that there has been a significant change in the sero- var distribution of NAD-dependent H. paragallinarum isolates since the 1970s. They established that in the 1990s, the incidence of serovar A-1 NAD-dependent H. paragallinarum had decreases from 34 % in the 1970s to 5 % in the 1990s and suggested that this decrease was a result of the intensive use of vac- cines, all of which contain serogroup A isolates. On the other hand, Miflin, Horner, Blackall, Chen, Bishop, Morrow, Yamaguchi & Iritani (1994) report- ed that all of the NAD-independent South African isolates which they had received were serogroup A isolates. These isolates were, however, collected from a localized area of South Africa. Bragg, Grey- ling & Verschoor (1997) reported on a much wider collection of NAD-independent isolates and they also isolated serogroup C NAD-independent iso- lates for the first time, and they indicated that the incidence of serogroup A NAD-independent isolates was 58 %. One possible explanation for the difference in the incidence of the serogroup A isolates among the NAD-dependent and NAD-independent isolates could possibly be the evasion of protective immuni- ty by the NAD-independent isolates. Bragg et al. (1996) suggested that the decrease in the inci- dence of serogroup A NAD-dependent isolates could be as a result of intensive use of vaccines, all of which contain a serogroup A isolate. The fact that a large number of NAD-independent isolates were found to be serogroup A at a time when the incidence of serogroup A isolates amongst the NAD-dependent strains was decreasing, suggests that the NAD-independent isolates might be able to evade the protective immunity in the birds. Further indications of the possible evasion of the protective immunity by NAD-independent isolates of H. paragallinarum was obtained from monoclon- al antibody studies performed by Bragg, Coetzee & Verschoor (1993b) and Bragg, Gunter, Coetzee & Verschoor 1997b) who investigated the possibilities of using a panel of Mabs established by Verschoor, Coetzee & Visser (1989) for the serotyping of H. paragallinarum. Although these Mabs detected certain antigens in H. paragallinarum (either protein or lipopolysaccha- ride in nature) (Bragg et al. 1997b), they could not be used for any meaningful serological classifica- tion of H. paragallinarum. However, during this work, large numbers of isolates of H. paragallinarum, both NAD dependent and NAD independent, were examined with this panel of Mabs (Bragg et al. 1993b, 1997b). One Mab was of particular interest. This was the Mab termed V1, which detected a lipopolysaccharide of between 13.8–14 kDa (Bragg et al. 1997b). This Mab was found to react only with the reference strain 0083. None of the South African NAD-dependent field isolates of H. paragal- linarum reacted with this Mab. A small sample of NAD-dependent field isolates of H. paragallinarum (kindly supplied by Dr P. J. Blackall, Department of Primary Industries, Brisbane, Australia) were test- ed with these Mabs. One of the wild type Australian field isolates (as well as the mutant derived from it) reacted with the V1 Mab (Bragg et al. 1997b). When examining the NAD-independent isolates, 12.5 % of the isolates were found to react with the V1 Mab (Bragg et al. 1997b). This was in sharp contrast to the situation in the NAD-dependent iso- lates. In South Africa, many of the registered IC vac- cines contain isolate 0083. In Australia, no imported IC vaccines have been used and all of the IC vac- cines used contain Australian isolates (Blackall 1991; Blackall & Reid 1987; Blackall, Eaves, Rogers & Firth 1992). Thus, strain 0083 has not been used in vaccines in Australia (Blackall, per- sonal communication 1997). The isolation of NAD- dependent field isolates in Australia which express the antigen detected by the V1 Mab, and the high incidence of NAD-independent field isolates react- ing with this Mab, suggested a possible immune- evasion by the NAD-independent isolates. Until recently, one of the problems faced when attempting to verify the hypothesis of immune-eva- sion by the NAD-independent isolates was the exis- tence of a suitable challenge model where the pro- tective effects of a vaccine could be accurately measured. Bragg (2002a) established a new chal- lenge model for IC that facilitates the comparison of the virulence of different isolates and also allows for the accurate comparison of the efficacy of different vaccines. 54 Immunity by NAD-independent isolates Haemophilus paragallinarum in poultry This challenge model is based largely on the vari- ous challenge models used by various authors (Bragg 2002a), but in this model a numerical score is given to the clinical signs. The numerical scores can be used to construct a graphic representation of the disease profile over a 20-day period. By superimposing the disease profiles of two different isolates, or from two different vaccination pro- grammes, comparisons can be established. This data also lends itself to statistical analysis. This challenge model is used to confirm the hypothesis of immune-evasion by NAD-independent isolates of H. paragallinarum. MATERIALS AND METHODS Twenty unvaccinated commercial layer chickens were obtained from a supplier of point-of-lay chick- ens. These chickens were obtained at 11 weeks of age before they were vaccinated against IC. These chickens were collected from a site with no previ- ous history of IC and were housed in disinfected layer facilities until they were used in the experi- ments. Another 20 unvaccinated commercial layer chick- ens were obtained from the same flock and were vaccinated with an experimental vaccine containing South African isolates of serovars A-1, B-1, C-2 and C-3 H. paragallinarum when at 12 weeks of age. They were re-vaccinated at 16 weeks of age. Both vaccinated and unvaccinated chickens remained in the facilities until they were 25 weeks of age and were producing eggs. The protective capability of this vaccine was previously verified and will be reported on separately. All four different serovars of H. paragallinarum have been included in the exper- imental vaccine as it has been well established that there is limited cross protection between the differ- ent serogroups (Rimler, Davis & Page 1977; Kume, Sawata & Nakase 1980a, b). When they were 25 weeks of age, the vaccinated and unvaccinated chickens were subdivided into two groups of ten vaccinated and two groups of ten unvaccinated chickens. They were placed in cages of a battery in such a way such that ten chickens were placed into the top five cages (two chickens per cage) and ten chickens in the bottom row of cages. The vaccinated chickens were placed in the cages on one side of the battery, while the unvac- cinated chickens were placed in those on the other side. One group of the vaccinated and one group of the unvaccinated birds was challenged with strain 1343 [a South African field isolate of NAD-independent H. paragallinarum (Bragg 2002b)] while the remain- ing two groups were challenged with strain 46 C-3 [an NAD-dependent field isolate of H. paragallina- rum (Bragg 2002a)] according to the methods used by Bragg (2002a). The clinical signs in the birds were recorded and scored for a 20-day period. The severity of the clinical signs was given a numerical value according to the methods described by Bragg (2002a) and disease profiles were plotted. RESULTS The results of the scoring of the clinical signs in the groups that were challenged with NAD-dependent serovar C-3 were used to produce a graphic repre- sentation of the course of the disease which is given in Fig. 1. Similarly the disease profiles obtained in the chickens challenged with the NAD-independent serovar C-3 are given in Fig. 2. Mean disease scores for each of the different experimental groups, as calculated from the disease profiles, are reflected in Table 1. A statistical analysis of the disease profiles obtained was performed using a t test and the results obtained are shown in Table 1. 55 R.R. BRAGG TABLE 1 Summary of the disease scores and profiles obtained when vaccinated and unvaccinated chickens challenged with serovar C-3 isolates of NAD-dependent and NAD-independent isolates of H. paragallinarum Isolate Vaccinated Mean disease score Significance Highest score Duration (days)# C-3 (Dep*) Yes 0.45 0.000358 1.6 12 C-3 (Dep) No 1.85 4.2 15 C-3 (Indep**) Yes 0.375 0.389 1.2 15 C-3 (Indep) No 0.415 1.3 19 # Calculated as the last day on which clinical signs were seen in the group of chickens * NAD dependent ** NAD independent DISCUSSION It can be seen from this experiment that chickens which were vaccinated with an experimental vac- cine were not protected against challenge with an NAD-independent isolate of H. paragallinarum. It was also demonstrated in this experiment that the experimental vaccine used in this experiment pro- vided protection to the NAD-dependent isolate of the same serovar. It is well known that protection afforded by a H. paragallinarum vaccine is depend- ent of the serovar used to make the vaccine (Rimler et al. 1977; Kume et al. 1980a, b). The use of the experimental challenge model pro- posed by Bragg (2002a) has shown that the NAD- independent isolates have the ability to evade the immune system. It can be seen from Fig. 2 that the overall diseases profiles in the vaccinated and un- vaccinated chickens are similar. It was found that there is not a significant difference between the two profiles (P = 0.389). It is evident from the graph in Fig. 2 that the development of clinical signs in the vaccinated birds was delayed when compared to that of unvaccinated birds and that the duration of clinical signs was shorter in the vaccinated birds. However, the highest daily disease scores of the two groups of birds were found to be very similar (Table 1). This is in contrast to the results obtained when the birds were challenged with the NAD- dependent isolates. The data obtained revealed that there is a significant difference (P = 0.000358) between the disease profiles obtained for the vac- cinated and unvaccinated birds. These results indi- cate that the vaccine used in this experiment pro- vided protection when the birds were challenged with the NAD-dependent serovar C-3 isolate. 56 Immunity by NAD-independent isolates Haemophilus paragallinarum in poultry ���������� ���� �� � � � � � � � � � �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� � � �� ������ ���� ������ �� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� � � � �� �� � � � � �� � �� ���������� ���� �� � � � �� �� � � � � �� � �� �� �� �� �� � ��� ��� � � � � � � � � � �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� � � �� ������ ���� ������ FIG. 1 Disease profiles of vaccinated and unvaccinated chickens challenged with an NAD- dependent serovar C-3 isolate of H. paragallinarum FIG. 2 Disease profiles of vaccinated and unvaccinated chickens challenged with an NAD- independent serovar C-3 isolate of H. paragallinarum These findings strongly suggest that the NAD-inde- pendent isolate was capable of evading the protec- tive immunity induced in the vaccinated birds and support the hypothesis of immune-evasion by NAD-independent strains which was postulated from results obtained from previously described work. One possible explanation for the ability of the NAD- independent isolates to evade the immune system could be that the acquisition of the genes for NAD independence, which appear to be plasmid mediat- ed and allow H. paragallinarum to use other niches in the sinuses of the chicken. It is possible that the NAD-dependent isolates need to colonize areas in the sinus with a rich blood supply, thus allowing for the drawing of the needed NAD from the circulating blood stream. However, if the birds had been vac- cinated with inactivated bacterins against H. para- gallinarum, the circulating blood would also have contained specific antibodies against the different serovars of H. paragallinarum (depending on the composition of the vaccine). If the acquisition of NAD independence is freeing the bacteria from their dependence on drawing NAD for the blood supply, this might allow them to grow in other areas of the sinuses. It would be interesting to investigate the locations of NAD-dependent and NAD-inde- pendent strains of H. paragallinarum in the sinuses of experimentally infected chickens. CONCLUSIONS It would appear, from the results obtained in this experiment that the NAD-independent isolates appeared to have been able to evade the immune system in the vaccinated chickens. If this hypothe- sis is correct, there is a need for an alternative vac- cination strategy, or some other disease control strategy, for the control of IC caused by the NAD- independent variants, such as the stimulation of local immunity in the upper respiratory tract of the chickens. Other disease control methods could in- clude improved biosecurity through the use of non- toxic disinfectants as described recently by Bragg (2004). Fortunately, it would appear that the NAD- independent isolates of serogroup C H. paragalli- narum are less virulent that the NAD-dependent strains (Bragg 2002b; Taole et al. 2002). ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I am are grateful to the National Research Foun- dation (GUN No. 2053243) for funding aspects of this work. We are also grateful to Avimune (Pty) Ltd. for supplying the monoclonal antibodies for the work performed previously. REFERENCES BLACKALL, P.J. 1991. An evaluation of the cross-protection afforded by inactivated infectious coryza vaccines. Australian Veterinary Journal, 68:266–267. BLACKALL, P.J. & REID, G.G. 1987. Further efficacy studies on inactivated aluminum-hydroxide adsorbed vaccines against Infectious coryza. Avian Diseases, 31:527–532. BLACKALL, P.J., EAVES, L.E., ROGERS, D.G. & FIRTH, G. 1992. An evaluation of Inactivated Infectious coryza vac- cines containing a double emulsion adjuvant system. Avian Diseases, 36:632–636. BRAGG, R.R. 2002a. Virulence of South African isolates of Haemophilus paragallinarum. Part 1. NAD-dependent field isolates. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research, 69: 63–169. BRAGG, R.R. 2002b. Virulence of South African isolates of Haemophilus paragallinarum. Part 2. Naturally occurring NAD-independent field isolates. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research, 71:71–175. BRAGG, R.R. 2004. Limitation of the spread and impact of infec- tious coryza through the use of a continuous disinfection pro- gramme. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research, 71: 1–8. BRAGG, R.R., COETZEE, L. & VERSCHOOR, J.A. 1993a. Plas- mid encoded NAD-independence in some South African iso- lates of Haemophilus paragallinarum. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research, 60:147–152. BRAGG, R.R., COETZEE, L. & VERSCHOOR, J.A. 1993b. Monoclonal antibody characterization of South African field isolates of Haemophilus paragallinarum. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research, 60:181–187. BRAGG, R.R., COETZEE, L. & VERSCHOOR, J.A. 1996. Changes in the incidence of the different serovars of Haem- ophilus paragallinarum in South Africa: a possible explana- tion for vaccination failure. Onderstepoort Journal of Veter- inary Research, 63:217–226. BRAGG, R.R., GREYLING, J.M. & VERSCHOOR, J.A. 1997a. Isolation and identification of NAD-independent bacteria from chickens with symptoms of infectious coryza. Avian Pathol- ogy, 26:595–606. BRAGG, R.R. GUNTER, N.J., COETZEE, L. & VERSCHOOR, J.A. 1997b. Monoclonal antibody characterization of refer- ence isolates of different serogroups of Haemophilus para- gallinarum. Avian Pathology, 26:749–764. HORNER, R.F., BISHOP, G.C. & HAW, C. 1992. An upper res- piratory disease of commercial poultry resembling infectious coryza, but caused by a V factor independent bacterium. Avian Pathology, 21:421–427. KUME, K., SAWATA, A. & NAKASE, Y. 1980a. Immunological relationship between Page’s and Sawata’s serotype strains of Haemophilus paragallinarum. The Veterinary Record, 41: 757–760. KUME, K., SAWATA, A. & NAKASE, Y. 1980b. Relationship between protective activity and antigen structure of Haem- ophilus paragallinarum serotypes 1 and 2. American Journal of Veterinary Research, 41:97–100. 57 R.R. BRAGG MIFLIN, J.K., HORNER, R.F., BLACKALL, P.J., CHEN, X., BISHOP, G.C., MORROW, C.J., YAMAGUCHI, T. & IRITANI, Y. 1994. Phenotypic and molecular characterization of V- factor (NAD)-independent Haemophilus paragallinarum. Avian Diseases, 39:304–308. MOUAHID, M., BISGAARD, M., MORLEY, A.J., MUTTERS, R. & MANNHEIM, W. 1992. Occurrence of V-factor (NAD) independent isolates of Haemophilus paragallinarum. Veter- inary Microbiology, 31:363–368. RIMLER, R.B., DAVIS, R.B. & PAGE, R.K. 1977. Infectious coryza: Cross-protection studies, using seven strains of Haemophilus paragallinarum. American Journal of Veterinary Research, 38:1587–1598. TAOLE, M., ALBERTYN, J., VAN HEERDEN, E. & BRAGG, R.R. 2002. Virulence of South African isolates of Haemoph- ilus paragallinarum. Part 3: experimentally produced NAD- independent isolate. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research, 69:89–196. VERSCHOOR, J.A., COETZEE, L. & VISSER, L. 1989. Mono- clonal antibodies characterization of two field strains of Haemophilus paragallinarum isolated from vaccinated layer hens. Avian Diseases, 33:219–225. 58 Immunity by NAD-independent isolates Haemophilus paragallinarum in poultry