499 - 523 Persuading with Narratives.indd 499Palabra Clave - ISSN: 0122-8285 - eISSN: 2027-534X - Vol. 21 No. 2 - Junio de 2018. 499-523 Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence. Effect of Similarity with the Protagonist on Identification and Risk-Perception Juan José Igartua1 Daniela Fiuza2 Recibido: 2017-04-03 Aprobado por pares: 2017-07-12 Enviado a pares: 2017-06-07 Aceptado: 2017-08-15 DOI: 10.5294/pacla.2018.21.2.10 Para citar este artículo / to reference this article / para citar este artigo Igartua, J. J. y Fiuza, D. (2018). Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence. Effect of Similarity with the Protagonist on Identification and Risk-Perception. Palabra Clave, 21(2), 499-523. DOI: 10.5294/pacla.2018.21.2.10 Abstract This study focuses on analysis of the factors that can increase the persuasive effectiveness of information campaigns using narratives. An experiment was carried out in which similarity with the protagonist was manipulated in a video about a victim of gender violence. The protagonist was portrayed as living in Spain, and she was said to be Spanish (high similarity) or Argen- tinian (low similarity). The participants (75 Spanish women) then filled out a questionnaire with measures about emotional impact, identification with the protagonist, and risk perception about becoming a victim of abuse. Re- sults showed that similarity with the protagonist has an indirect influence on risk perception through negative emotions and identification. 1 orcid.org/0000-0002-9865-2714. Universidad de Salamanca, España. jigartua@usal.es 2 orcid.org/0000-0002-0379-5545. Universidad de Salamanca, España. 500 Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence... - Juan José Igartua, Daniela Fiuza Keywords Persuasion; communication psychology; domestic violence (Source: Un- esco Thesaurus). Persuasión con narrativas contra la violencia de género. Efectos de la similitud con el protagonista en la identificación y la percepción de riesgos Resumen Este estudio se enfoca en el análisis de los factores que pueden aumentar la efectividad persuasiva de las campañas de información por medio de narrativas. Se realizó un experimento en el que la similitud con el protagonista se manipuló en un video sobre una víctima de violencia de género. Se describió a la protagonista como si viviera en España y se dijo que era de nacionalidad española (gran similitud) o argentina (baja similitud). A continuación, las participantes (75 mujeres españolas) respondieron un cuestionario con medidas sobre el impacto emocional, la identificación con el protagonista y la percepción del riesgo de convertirse en víctima de abuso. Los resultados mostraron que la similitud con la protagonista tiene una influencia indirecta en la percepción del riesgo a través de las emociones negativas y la identificación. Palabras clave Persuasión; psicología de la comunicación; violencia doméstica (Fuente: Tesauro de la Unesco). 501Palabra Clave - ISSN: 0122-8285 - eISSN: 2027-534X - Vol. 21 No. 2 - Junio de 2018. 499-523 Persuasão com narrativas contra a violência de gênero. Efeitos da semelhança com o protagonista na identificação e a percepção de riscos Resumo Este estudo se enfoca na análise dos fatores que podem aumentar a eficácia persuasiva das campanhas de informação através de narrativas. Realizou-se um experimento em que a semelhança com o protagonista foi manipula- da em um vídeo sobre uma vítima de violência de gênero. Descreveu-se a protagonista como se esta morasse na Espanha, e foi dito que era de na- cionalidade espanhola (grande semelhança) ou argentina (baixo nível de semelhança). A seguir, as participantes (75 mulheres espanholas) respon- deram um questionário com medidas sobre o impacto emocional, a iden- tificação com o protagonista e a percepção do risco de tornar-se vítima de abuso. Os resultados revelaram que a semelhança com a protagonista tem uma influência indireta na percepção do risco através das emoções negati- vas e da identificação. Palavras-chave Persuasão; psicologia da comunicação; violência doméstica (Fonte: Te- sauro da Unesco). 502 Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence... - Juan José Igartua, Daniela Fiuza Introduction This study focuses on analyzing factors that can increase the persuasive- ness of campaigns aimed at confronting social problems (in this case, gen- der violence), using as reference the ones constructed around a narrative. In this context, by narrative we mean a sequence of events that are causal- ly connected (and are therefore not random), using a series of characters whose experience can serve to teach (Hoeken, Kolthoff, & Sanders, 2016). A narrative always provides information (and implicit or explicit arguments) based on which individuals can change or adapt their beliefs, attitudes and behaviors. Research into narrative persuasion studies the processes or mech- anisms that explain how narratives can change attitudes, beliefs or behav- iors (de Graaf, Hoeken, Sanders, & Beentjes, 2012; Green & Brock, 2000; Hoeken & Fikkers, 2014; Igartua & Barrios, 2012). A meta-analysis review has shown that narratives have significant effects on attitudes, beliefs, be- havioral intention and behavior (Braddock & Dillard, 2016). One of the main fields where this line of research is being applied is in health communication from the perspective of entertainment-education (de Graaf, Sanders, & Hoeken, 2016; Igartua & Vega, 2016; Moyer-Gusé, Chung, & Jain, 2011; Robinson & Knobloch-Westerwick, 2017). Many ad- vertising campaigns (whether commercial or socially-oriented) are based on the construction of narrative messages, as in the use of publicity genres called “testimonials,” “slice of life” and other story-based advertisements. Thus, it is important to learn which factors in the design of narratives for the prevention or awareness-raising of social problems (in this study, gender vi- olence) increase their persuasive impact and, therefore, their effectiveness as tools of media intervention. In this study we address the variables relat- ed to the construction of characters (in particular, the similarity between character and audience), reception processes (identification with charac- ters and emotions), and individual differences (modern racism). Similarity, Identification with Characters, and Persuasive Impact Characters are a basic ingredient in any narration, and therefore their de- sign, characteristics, or attributes can condition reception processes and 503Palabra Clave - ISSN: 0122-8285 - eISSN: 2027-534X - Vol. 21 No. 2 - Junio de 2018. 499-523 persuasive impact (Moyer-Gusé, 2008). In the field of narrative persua- sion, it has been shown that identification with characters plays an import- ant mediating role: For a narrative to cause a persuasive impact there must be a high identification with the characters involved (de Graaf et al., 2012; Hoeken & Fikkers, 2014; Igartua & Barrios, 2012; Igartua & Vega, 2016). In this context, identification with characters is a cognitive-affective process that takes place during reception (reading, viewing) of the narrative mes- sage, and that is linked to perspective-taking or cognitive empathy (putting oneself in the shoes of the character), emotional empathy (feeling the same emotions as the character), and the temporary loss of self-awareness (the receiver of the narrative imagines being the character, taking on his or her identity, and becoming merged with the character) (Cohen, 2001; Igartua & Barrios, 2012; Moyer-Gusé, 2008). Previous research has shown that the characteristics of characters con- dition reception processes (such as appraisal of the character, emotions and identification) (Hoeken & Sinkeldam, 2014), that identification plays an important role in emotional activation (the greater the identification, the greater the emotional impact) (Hoeken, Kolthoff, & Sanders, 2016), and that, in addition, it is an important mechanism in explaining the impact of narratives on attitudes (together with emotions) (de Graaf et al., 2012; Igartua & Vega, 2016). To date, there has been little research into the factors involved in the construction of characters that can increase identification and, indirectly, persuasive impact. One line of research in this field is related to the effect that similarity between the protagonist of the narrative and the audience has on identification, and on the persuasive effectiveness of the story (Chen, Bell, & Taylor, 2016; de Graaf, 2014; Hoeken, Kolthoff, & Sanders, 2016). Similarity describes a process through which a message receiver assesses the extent to which he or she shares certain traits with the message pro- tagonist. Similarity can be based on objective traits (such as demograph- ic aspects, gender, or nationality) but also on psychological or subjective characteristics (such as personality, beliefs, opinions, or values). It is as- sumed that both perceived similarity and similarity in objective attributes 504 Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence... - Juan José Igartua, Daniela Fiuza increase identification and, indirectly, affect attitudes. In fact, it has even been maintained that similarity is a prerequisite for identification with a character, since identification involves a merging of identities (Cohen, 2001). In other words, it is assumed that, the greater the similarity to a character, the greater the identification, leading to our first hypothesis: H1: Similarity with the protagonist of an awareness-raising narrative on gender violence will cause greater identification with that character. Previous research into the effect of similarity on persuasive impact has been carried out using written stories or short stories. Similarity has been manipulated experimentally by varying the characteristics of the main char- acter in the story and at the same time taking into account the situation or characteristics of the study participants or receivers (Chen et al., 2016; de Graaf, 2014; Hoeken et al., 2016). For example, in the study carried out by de Graaf (2014), information about where the main character of the narrative lived was manipulated (with her parents or in a student dorm); at the same time, the participants were asked with whom they lived. High similarity was assumed if the place of residence of the character coincided with the place of the residence of the person reading the story. In this case, it can be said that similarity was manipulated in demographic terms (place of residence). The narrative was focused on health topics (the main charac- ter had cancer and the narrative described how she faced the disease), and the persuasive objective was to increase risk perception, since risk percep- tion has been considered a determinant factor in preventive or health be- havior and can also be considered an indicator of awareness. In this context, an important effect of the narrative messages used in entertainment-educa- tion is that they reduce the perception of invulnerability and, as a result, in- crease risk perception (“this could happen to me”), which has an influence on intentions of preventive behavior or helps individuals to be alert to sit- uations of risk in the future (Moyer-Gusé, 2008). The results showed that similarity with the character had an influence on perceived similarity and furthermore increased risk perception (de Graaf, 2014). Thus, similarity had an attitudinal effect consistent with the contents of the narrative. Tak- ing these results into account, we postulated the second hypothesis of the study in relation to the effect of similarity on risk perception. 505Palabra Clave - ISSN: 0122-8285 - eISSN: 2027-534X - Vol. 21 No. 2 - Junio de 2018. 499-523 H2: Similarity with the protagonist of an awareness-raising narrative on gender violence will induce a greater perception of the risk of be- coming a victim of abuse. Social Perception of Gender Violence, Immigration, and Modern Racism Taking research into narrative persuasion as a reference, it is worth positing that, when awareness-raising campaigns are carried out in relation to gen- der violence using narratives (based on testimonials or slice of life, for ex- ample), the messages should have protagonists who produce a high sense of identification among women. In this context, identification can be facil- itated when the protagonist of the narrative is perceived as similar by the audience (women in particular, as the potential victims of abuse). In the research carried out for this study, we took into account a demographic as- pect to manipulate the similarity experimentally: the nationality of the pro- tagonist of the narrative. There are several lines of research that justify the choice of this characteristic. The first thing to highlight is that content analysis studies about the reporting of gender violence have shown that this topic is usually associat- ed with immigration. For example, the news may show that foreign wom- en or immigrants are the ones most suffering from gender abuse, or when gender violence is reported, the victim’s nationality is stated, indicating whether she is a foreigner or an immigrant (Román, García, & Álvarez, 2011). Thus, the stereotype of gender violence is shown to be something inherent to “other cultures” (Erez, Adelman, & Gregory, 2009; Wright & Benson, 2010). In relation to this, different surveys about the social per- ception of gender violence carried out in Spain have shown that respon- dents consider that there are more perpetrators among foreigners than among the Spanish, and they also perceive that foreign women are more vulnerable to gender violence (Meil, 2014). In fact, one of the myths of gender violence is to think that it only occurs in underdeveloped coun- tries (Bosch-Fiol & Ferrer-Pérez, 2012). As a result, it is worth postulat- ing that prejudice against immigrants could interfere in the effectiveness of campaigns against gender violence with immigrant women as protag- 506 Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence... - Juan José Igartua, Daniela Fiuza onists, given that they may stimulate a lower risk perception and cause a lower identification with the victims, especially among individuals who reject immigration more strongly. In this context, it was found that prejudice against immigrants is as- sociated with more negative attitudes and emotions towards immigrants in everyday situations. It is logical to think that this effect will also mani- fest in a situation of parasocial intergroup contact, such as when watching a narrative message about gender violence with an immigrant as the pro- tagonist. In fact, it has been pointed out that individuals show ingroup fa- voritism when choosing the contents of media entertainment: They prefer to consume entertainment products that have characters from their same group (defined by criteria such as gender, age, ethnic origin, or nationali- ty) (Park, 2012). Prejudice towards immigrants can be conceptualized from several different theoretical perspectives, giving rise to different forms of measure- ment. In this study we based our research on the concept of modern racism (McConahay, Hardee, & Batts, 1981). Modern racism is a subtle form of prejudice and is linked to ambivalent reactions towards persons of a specif- ic outgroup (in our case, immigrants). On one hand, a person who shows a high level of modern racism thinks that immigrants (or other ethnic mi- norities) break the rules and values of the host society; in addition, they believe that they “ask for too much”; they think that the government or in- stitutions devote excessive social or economic resources to protect immi- grants, that their own group is being ignored or harmed in some way, and therefore they feel a certain resentment towards these groups. For these reasons, modern racism is associated with reactions of mistrust and avoid- ance of contact with persons of the out-group and also with feeling un- comfortable, insecure, distrustful and less positive about them (Gaertner & Dovidio, 1986). Research into modern racism and its links to processes of reception and narrative persuasion is scant (Eno & Ewoldsen, 2010; Igartua & Fru- tos, 2017). Eno and Ewoldsen (2010) observed that individuals’ prior lev- 507Palabra Clave - ISSN: 0122-8285 - eISSN: 2027-534X - Vol. 21 No. 2 - Junio de 2018. 499-523 el of prejudice towards people of color (measured by the scale of modern racism) influenced how participants interpreted a film with an anti-racist message. Moreover, it has been observed that people with a high level of prejudice (high on the modern racism scale) experienced a lower empathic identification with the immigrant protagonists in films. However, it was also observed that watching a movie with a message of empathy towards immi- grants caused greater identification with the immigrant characters, which in turn induced more positive attitudes towards immigration, but this process only took place among individuals with a low or moderate level of mod- ern racism (Igartua & Frutos, 2017). This means that modern racism, as a measure of prejudice towards immigrants, can interfere in reception pro- cesses, conditioning narrative persuasion processes. Thus, in the research presented here, it is expected that prejudice towards immigrants (modern racism) will act as a moderating variable: Individuals with greater prejudice towards immigrants will experience greater identification when the protag- onist of the message meant to raise awareness of gender violence is present- ed as Spanish than when she is presented as a foreigner. H3: Among participants with a low level of modern racism, the sim- ilarity will not affect their identification. However, among the partic- ipants with a high level of modern racism, the similarity will induce a high identification. Finally, we postulate a moderated mediation model (Hayes, 2013), which involves simultaneously analyzing the role of modern racism (as moderating variable) and identification with character (as mediating vari- able) to explain the indirect effect of similarity in the risk perception of be- coming a victim of gender abuse. H4: Similarity with the protagonist of the narrative will stimulate greater identification, which in turn will be associated with a greater risk perception of being a victim of gender abuse; this process, how- ever, will take place only among individuals with a high level of mod- ern racism. 508 Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence... - Juan José Igartua, Daniela Fiuza Method Participants Seventy-five women participated in the research study. All of them were Spanish university students with a mean age of 20.29 (SD = 1.81). Their par- ticipation was voluntary and they did not receive any compensation for tak- ing part in the study. We used a convenience sample that is a nonprobability sampling method especially used in experimental research (Hayes, 2005).3 Design and procedure A random two-group design was chosen, the independent variable being similarity in demographic terms (nationality) with the protagonist of a vid- eo narrative (a public service announcement constructed as a narrative that tells the story of Maria, a victim of gender violence) with two conditions: low similarity (the protagonist is presented as an Argentinian woman living in Madrid, and thus a foreign immigrant) or high similarity (the protago- nist is presented as a Spanish woman living in Madrid). The manipulation was carried out by editing the video shown to the participants. The participants were invited to join the study (individually), and once they had agreed, they were randomly assigned to one of the two experimen- tal conditions. Before viewing the video, they had to answer a questionnaire intended to collect information about the following variables: prejudice to- wards immigrants (modern racism scale), age and nationality (to remove any women who were not Spanish from the study). They were then shown a video (on a laptop) and immediately afterward they were asked to com- plete a second questionnaire aimed at collecting information about the re- ception processes (the emotions felt, identification, enjoyment), about the risk perception of becoming a victim of gender violence, and, finally, they were asked if they recalled the nationality of the protagonist. 3 “In convenience sampling, the sample consists of people most readily accessible or willing to be part in the study (…). Convenience samples using undergraduate students are especially common in the social sciences” (Crano, Brewer, & Lac, 2015, p. 234). In fact, Hayes (2005) has pointed out that “true probability sampling is rarely ever done in communication research” (p. 41). While the probability sampling methods are the best approach to make population inferences, nonprobability sampling (like using convenience samples) is a valid approach to make process inferences (see, Hayes, 2005, pp. 41–44, for a definition of the concept of process inference). 509Palabra Clave - ISSN: 0122-8285 - eISSN: 2027-534X - Vol. 21 No. 2 - Junio de 2018. 499-523 The video production used was based on an awareness-raising cam- paign against gender violence and abuse sponsored by the government of Argentina and it showed several explicit situations of gender abuse and vi- olence in a family setting. The video was edited (some dialogues were tak- en out, some music and subtitles were added) to create versions of the same running time (2 minutes and 5 seconds) where the viewer could read the subtitled dialogue and therefore no Argentinian or Spanish accent would be heard that would condition the reception process. The experimental manipulation involved presenting the following information in text on the screen to introduce the protagonist (duration: 8 seconds): “Maria, Span- ish [Argentinian], 43 years old. She has been living in Madrid for 6 years. She is the mother of 3 children and has been married to Juan, her abuser, for 15 years. This is her story…” After introducing the protagonist, the im- ages move ahead with scenes of violence perpetrated by Maria’s husband, Juan. The video images are accompanied by music with a sad tone and a se- ries of subtitles with expressions by Juan and by Maria. The texts were the same in the two experimental conditions. The public service announce- ment ends with an image in which the protagonist is seen unfolding a piece of paper with a helpline telephone number on it and the following written message: “Another kind of life is possible; we all have the right to live with- out violence; report him!” The dramatic element (increased by the soundtrack) was meant to cause an emotional impact, to have the participants put themselves in the victim’s shoes (Maria), and to induce them to think that Maria’s situation could happen to anyone (that is, to activate risk perception) and that, there- fore, they should be prepared and know how to act. Indeed, the end of the short film contains a message of hope and proposes a clear idea with respect to gender violence, encouraging women to report it and change their lives. Measures Prejudice towards immigrants. This variable was measured using the Mod- ern Racism Scale by McConahay et al. (1981). The scale consists of 10 items (e.g., “in recent years, immigrants have done better economical- ly than they deserve”; ranging from 1 = strongly disagree to 7 = strongly 510 Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence... - Juan José Igartua, Daniela Fiuza agree). A modern racism index was created by adding up all the items af- ter recoding two reverse item, and a Cronbach’s alpha of .84 was obtained (M = 2.32, SD = 0.86). Negative emotions. Participants were asked: “How did you feel while watching the video? Think of the different things that happened in the vid- eo you have just watched and indicate, on a scale of 0 (nothing) to 4 (very much), how much you experienced the following feelings.” The scale was comprised of 10 items referring to negative emotions (e.g., anger, disgust, sadness; fear; α = .78; M = 1.86, SD = 0.69). Enjoyment. The participants were asked the following: “How would you assess, overall, the video you’ve just watched? (ranging from 1 = I didn’t like it at all, to 10 = I liked it a lot; M = 6.10, SD = 2.11).” Identification with the protagonist. This was evaluated with a scale con- sisting of 11 items (Igartua & Barrios, 2012), designed to measure retro- spectively the participant’s identification with the protagonist of the public service announcement, Maria (e.g., “I experienced Maria’s emotional reac- tions in myself ”; ranging from 1 = not at all, to 5 = a lot). An index of iden- tification with Maria was created based on calculating the average of the scores in the 11 items (α = .87; M = 3.17, SD = 0.72). Risk perception with respect to gender violence. A three-item scale was used to assess this factor: “How likely do you think it is that you could per- sonally find yourself involved in a situation of gender violence?” “How like- ly do you think it is that a person similar to you (in age, educational level, social class) could find herself involved in a situation of gender violence?” And, “How likely do you think it is that a person from your surroundings could find herself involved in a situation of gender violence? (ranging from 1 = not at all, to 10 = very).” Principal components factor analysis showed that the three variables considered measured a single latent factor that ex- plained 70.40 % of the variance. We therefore created a risk perception in- dex of falling victim to abuse based on calculating the average of the scores in the three items (α = .78; M = 4.75, SD = 1.96). 511Palabra Clave - ISSN: 0122-8285 - eISSN: 2027-534X - Vol. 21 No. 2 - Junio de 2018. 499-523 Results Preliminary Analyses First, we checked whether significant differences existed between the par- ticipants in the two experimental conditions in the age, enjoyment and negative emotions. No statistically significant differences were observed in age (t(73) = -0.72, p = .468) and on enjoyment (t(71) = 1.49, p = .140). However, similarity with the protagonist had a statistically significant effect on the negative emotions (t(70) = 2.24, p < .028). The participants who viewed the public service announcement to raise awareness of gender vio- lence in which the protagonist was said to be Spanish experienced more in- tense negative emotions (M = 2.02, SD = 0.62) compared to the participants who watched the video in which the victim of gender abuse was presented as an immigrant (M = 1.67, SD = 0.72). Finally, we tested whether the experimental manipulation had been successful, that is, whether the participants’ recall of Maria’s nationality was consistent with the version of the video they were shown. Statistically sig- nificant differences were found in their recall of the protagonist’s nationality (χ2 (2, N = 75) = 48.36, p < .001). Among the participants who viewed the video in which the woman was presented as Spanish, 60 % correctly iden- tified her nationality. In the case of the participants who were told that the woman was Argentinian, 77.1 % correctly recalled this fact. Overall, it can be said that the experimental manipulation worked, given that the infor- mation on the woman’s nationality (only presented at the beginning of the video for 8 seconds) was recalled by most of the participants and in a way consistent with the version they had been randomly assigned. Hypothesis 1: Effect of similarity on identification with the protagonist The effect of similarity on identification with the protagonist was not sta- tistically significant (t(69) = 0.09, p = .926). Identification with the pro- tagonist was similar both when she was presented as being Spanish (M = 3.17, SD = 0.69) and when presented as Argentinian (M = 3.16, SD = 0.77). Further, we performed a mediation analysis (with PROCESS macro, model 512 Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence... - Juan José Igartua, Daniela Fiuza 4; Hayes, 2013), and it was found that similarity exerts an indirect effect on identification by means of negative emotions (B indirect effect = .16, SE = .09, 95 % CI [.01, .41]). That is, similarity induced a deeper experience of negative emotions (B = .35, SE = .17, p < .041) and these, in turn, were associated with a greater identification with the protagonist of the public service an- nouncement regarding gender violence (B = .46, SE = .11, p < .001). There- fore, H1 was partially supported empirically. Hypothesis 2: Effect of similarity on the risk perception of becoming a victim of abuse H2 was tested through multiple linear regression analysis in which the in- dependent variable was the experimental condition (0 = low similarity, 1 = high similarity to the protagonist), the negative emotions index was intro- duced in the analysis as a covariate, and the risk perception index for gender violence was the dependent variable. It was observed that similarity had no statistically significant effect on risk perception (β = -.18, p = .129). More- over, negative emotions did not affect the dependent variable (β = .02, p = .816). Thus, H2 was not confirmed by the data. Hypothesis 3: Effect of modern racism as a moderator variable of the relation between similarity and identification To test H3, we used the PROCESS macro (model 1), which allowed us to analyze whether there was an interaction effect between similarity and mod- ern racism on the identification with the protagonist. It was observed that the interaction effect was not statistically significant (B = .25, SE = .22, p = .259), that is, that the impact of similarity on identification was not moder- ated by modern racism. Therefore, H3 is not supported empirically. Mod- ern racism did affect identification (B = -.33, SE = .15, p < .039), that is, the higher the level of modern racism, the less the identification, regardless of the version viewed by the participants. Since differences in the negative emotions were observed, we tested whether that effect could be moderated by modern racism. To do so, we again employed the PROCESS macro (model 1), observing that the inter- action effect was statistically significant (B = .52, SE = .18, p < .006), that 513Palabra Clave - ISSN: 0122-8285 - eISSN: 2027-534X - Vol. 21 No. 2 - Junio de 2018. 499-523 is, the impact of similarity on negative emotions was moderated by modern racism. Analysis of the conditional effect of similarity on negative emotions showed that that effect was not statistically significant among the partici- pants with a low score in modern racism (B = -.13, SE = .22, p = .548), was marginally significant when the participants showed a moderate level of modern racism (B = .30, SE = .15, p = .052), and it was statistically signifi- cant in cases where modern racism was high (B = .75, SE = .22, p < .001). These results show that similarity induced more negative emotions, but only when the modern racism levels were moderate to high (Figure 1). Figure 1. Moderating effect of modern racism (MR) on the relation between similarity with the protagonist and experiencing negative emotions Hypothesis 4: Indirect effect of similarity on risk perception Hypothesis 4 postulated a moderated mediation model in an attempt to un- derstand the roles played by identification with the protagonist in the pub- lic service announcement as a mediating variable of the effect of similarity on risk perception, but also taking into account the role of modern racism Source: Own elaboration. 514 Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence... - Juan José Igartua, Daniela Fiuza as a moderating variable. To test this hypothesis, we used the PROCESS macro (model 7) for SPSS developed by Hayes (2013). This macro makes it possible to test different mediational models based on the bootstrapping technique. Model 7 of this procedure allowed us to calculate the condition- al indirect effects, that is, to analyze the effect of an independent variable (similarity to the protagonist of the video) on a dependent variable (risk perception), through a mediating variable (identification with the protag- onist) and for different levels of a moderating variable (modern racism). In our study, the conditional indirect effects were calculated using 10,000 bootstrapping samples, generating confidence intervals of the bias-correct- ed bootstrap type. The results showed that, as had been previously observed, similari- ty did not significantly affect identification (B = -.46, SE = .54, p = .388). The moderating effect of modern racism on the relation between similar- ity and identification was not statistically significant either (B = .25, SE = .22, p = .259), although modern racism did affect identification (B = -.33, SE = .15, p < .039). Identification with the protagonist was associated with higher risk perception (B = .83, SE = .29, p < .006), but no conditional in- direct effect turned out to be statistically significant, and therefore the mod- erated mediation index was not statistically significant either (IMM = .21, SE = .22, 95 % CI [-.14, .76]). From these results, it can be deduced that identification with the protagonist does play a relevant role in the activa- tion of risk perception. In any case, since similarity did not affect identifi- cation and modern racism did not exert a moderating effect, H4 was not confirmed by the data. Taking into account that modern racism moderated the effect of simi- larity on the negative emotions experienced, affected identification, and that identification significantly influenced risk perception, we tested a new medi- ational model. A mediation model with two mediators was postulated (neg- ative emotions and identification) that operate in sequence to determine the indirect effect of similarity on risk perception, and modern racism was included as a covariable. The PROCESS macro was again used to test this model, but, on this occasion, model 6 (Hayes, 2013) was used. The analy- sis performed (see Figure 2) revealed that similarity was positively associ- 515Palabra Clave - ISSN: 0122-8285 - eISSN: 2027-534X - Vol. 21 No. 2 - Junio de 2018. 499-523 ated in a statistically significant way with experiencing negative emotions (B = .35, SE = .17, p < .041). In turn, the negative emotions were statisti- cally associated with identification with the protagonist (B = .46, SE = .11, p < .001). Finally, identification significantly influenced risk perception (B = .76, SE = .36, p < .039). In addition, the indirect effect of similarity on risk perception after including the two mediating variables considered to operate in sequence (negative emotions g identification) turned out to be statistically significant (B indirect effect = .12, SE = .10, 95 % CI [.001, .45]). Figure 2. Results of the mediation model: The indirect effect of similarity on risk perception through negative emotions and identification with the protagonist (showing the unstandardized regression coefficients, B) Conclusions and Discussion The results of our experimental study shed light on the importance of sim- ilarity with the protagonist of entertainment-education narratives applied, in this case, to campaigns aimed at raising awareness of gender violence. This study also makes a significant contribution to research into narrative persuasion and the role of emotions and identification with characters as explanatory mechanisms (de Graaf, 2014; de Graaf et al., 2012; Hoeken & Source: Own elaboration. 516 Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence... - Juan José Igartua, Daniela Fiuza Fikkers, 2014; Hoeken et al., 2016; Hoeken & Sinkeldam, 2014; Igartua & Barrios, 2012; Igartua & Vega, 2016). Although the hypotheses formulated were not completely corrob- orated by the analysis, important results were obtained towards progress in this research field. The first hypothesis posited a direct effect of similar- ity on identification; however, what we found was that similarity exerts an indirect effect on identification by means of negative emotions. This result is important because it indicates that only narratives that have characters similar to the audience to which they are addressed will have the potential to provoke identification with the protagonist, through an emotional route. The third hypothesis posited that the effect of similarity on identi- fication would be conditioned by the previous level of prejudice the par- ticipants felt towards immigrants. In this context, modern racism has been pointed out in previous studies as a relevant variable for understanding in- tergroup relations (McConahay et al., 1981) and the process of reception and impact of fictional feature-length movies in which significant exam- ples of relations between characters pertaining to ethnic or cultural mi- norities and characters of the ingroup are shown (Eno & Ewoldsen, 2010; Igartua & Frutos, 2017). The results show that modern racism (taken as a measure of prejudice towards immigrants) did not condition identifica- tion. However, two significant results were indeed obtained in this context: first, that the individuals with a higher level of modern racism identified less with the protagonist of the narrative (regardless of her nationality); and second, that modern racism moderated the relation between similari- ty and negative emotions. The results allow us to confirm that similarity exerts a differential ef- fect on experiencing negative emotions when watching a dramatic narra- tive about a woman who is a victim of gender violence, as a function of modern racism. The participants with a low level of modern racism react- ed in a similar way as far as negative emotions were concerned when faced with a story whose protagonist was either an immigrant woman or a Span- ish native. However, the participants who showed a high level of prejudice towards immigrants experienced more intense negative emotions when 517Palabra Clave - ISSN: 0122-8285 - eISSN: 2027-534X - Vol. 21 No. 2 - Junio de 2018. 499-523 they were told that the protagonist victim of gender violence was Spanish than when she was said to be a foreign immigrant to Spain. In other words, for individuals with a high level of prejudice towards immigrants, the “dra- ma” of the Spanish Maria caused more unease than the same drama expe- rienced by the immigrant Maria. Thus, it has been possible to confirm that individuals’ previous level of prejudice towards immigrants conditions their reception processes (ex- periencing negative emotions and identification). Although modern rac- ism did not moderate the relation between similarity and identification, it did reduce the level of identification regardless of the demographic char- acteristics of the protagonist of the narrative. Moreover, modern racism moderated the relation between similarity and negative emotions. These results can be interpreted by taking the following elements into account: a) gender violence is presented in the news as a problem affecting most- ly immigrants, b) gender violence is perceived as affecting underdeveloped countries to a greater extent, and, c) immigrant women are thought to be more vulnerable to gender abuse (Bosch-Fiol & Ferrer-Pérez, 2012; Meil, 2014; Román et al., 2011). The second hypothesis postulated an effect of similarity on the risk perception of becoming a victim of gender violence. In turn, the fourth hy- pothesis posited an explanation of that relation taking into account the role of identification (as a mediating variable) and modern racism (as a moder- ating variable). Although the moderated mediation model postulated did not turn out to be significant, it was observed that similarity did exert an indirect effect on risk perception through negative emotions and identifi- cation. Regardless of the participants’ level of modern racism, a narrative with a main character similar in demographic terms caused more negative emotions to be felt, which led to greater identification with the character and, in turn, was associated with a greater risk perception of becoming a vic- tim of abuse. It can thus be affirmed that similarity in demographic terms (nationality, in this case) is a relevant process in increasing identification with the protagonist of the story through inducing emotions, and that this conditions the persuasive impact. On a theoretical level, these results en- dorse the centrality of similarity, (negative) emotions and identification in 518 Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence... - Juan José Igartua, Daniela Fiuza explaining narrative persuasion processes and converge with the results of previous studies (de Graaf, 2014; Hoeken et al., 2016). The present study provides evidence on the relationship between similarity with the charac- ter and identification, a subject of open debate in current research on nar- rative persuasion, since previous research has yielded contradictory results (see, de Graaf et al., 2016; Tukachinsky, 2014). The result of the mediational analysis is consistent with those ob- tained in the study by Hoeken and Sinkeldam (2014), even though these authors postulated an inverse sequence (and in their study, they did not manipulate similarity but rather the attractiveness of the character). In the present study, it is evident that a highly intense dramatic narrative (show- ing examples of incidents of physical abuse) immediately provokes negative emotions, which can lead spectators to identify with and put themselves in the place of the victim. Given the dramatic nature of the scenes shown in the video, it is logical that identification is not a requirement for produc- ing emotional impact; rather, the latter takes place as an automatic process. Once the spectators have put themselves in the protagonist’s shoes, it is logical to expect their risk or vulnerability perception to increase. In this regard, a previous study showed that identification with the main characters of a TV series that broached the consequences of an undesired teenage preg- nancy increased the audience’s risk perception and this in turn stimulated a higher behavioral intention to prevent pregnancy (Moyer-Gusé & Nabi, 2010). Thus, the findings of our study are consistent with the idea that peo- ple are susceptible to attitudes shown by characters in narratives (de Graaf et al., 2012). It can be confirmed that the process is posited as follows: If the protagonist of a narrative is perceived as similar, a cognitive-emotion- al connection with that character takes place more easily; this will cause the opinions, beliefs and attitudes of the character to have a greater impact on the audience, because when people identify with a character, they are more likely to take on the character’s point of view than when that connec- tion does not exist. One limitation of this study has to do with the manipulation of the nationality of the protagonist. It was observed that recall of the nationali- 519Palabra Clave - ISSN: 0122-8285 - eISSN: 2027-534X - Vol. 21 No. 2 - Junio de 2018. 499-523 ty was not the same in the two conditions, such that a significant percent- age of the individuals who saw the video in which the protagonist was said to be Argentinian either thought she was Spanish (11.4 %) or could not recall the information (11.4 %). Despite the fact that the large majority of participants correctly identified the nationality of the protagonist in both experimental conditions (more than 60 %, when the information was only presented at the beginning of the video and only lasted 8 seconds), it is very likely that the manipulation of the similarity would have yielded stronger effects in regard to identification if the protagonist had been described as Moroccan, given that, as of today, Moroccan immigrants are the immigrant group that arouses most dislike in Spanish public opinion (Cea D’Ancona & Valles Martínez, 2014). In future studies, narratives with protagonists who are immigrants pertaining to stigmatized groups should be used (Chung & Slater, 2013). Other factors involved in the construction of characters that could increase their similarity should also be looked into. With respect to the practical implications of the results of our study, and in relation to the development of campaigns for raising awareness of gender violence, it would be advisable to work with narratives in which the nationality of the protagonist is not indicated (or shown indirectly), as this can condition the effectiveness of the message (see, Igartua, 2013, where experimental evidence is provided on the attitudinal impact of crime news that alludes to the nationality of offenders). Campaigns designed to raise awareness of gender violence that feature protagonists who are immigrants (as a stigmatized out-group) could reinforce stereotypes about the link be- tween immigration and gender violence, and thus have a pernicious effect, instead of contributing to the eradication of gender violence. Recall that the positive indirect effect of similarity on risk perception means that, when similarity is low, a lower risk perception is stimulated. References Bosch-Fiol, E., & Ferrer-Pérez, V. A. (2012). Nuevo mapa de los mitos sobre la violencia de género en el siglo XXI [New map of the myths about gender violence in XXI century]. Psicothema, 24(4), 548–554. 520 Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence... - Juan José Igartua, Daniela Fiuza Braddock, K., & Dillard, J. P. (2016). Meta-analytic evidence for the per- suasive effect of narratives on beliefs, attitudes, intentions, and behaviors. Communication Monographs, 83(4), 446–467. doi: 10.1080/03637751.2015.1128555 Cea D’Ancona, M. A., & Valles Martínez, M. (2014). Evolución del racismo, la xenofobia y otras formas conexas de intolerancia en España [Evolu- tion of racism, xenophobia and related intolerance in Spain]. Madrid: OBERAXE, Ministerio de Empleo y Seguridad Social. Chen, M., Bell, R . A., & Taylor, L. D. (2016). Narrator point of view and persuasion in health narratives: The role of protagonist–reader sim- ilarity, identification, and self-Referencing. Journal of Health Commu- nication, 21(8), 908–918. doi: 10.1080/10810730.2016.1177147 Chung, A. H., & Slater, M. D. (2013). Reducing stigma and out-group dis- tinctions through perspective-taking in narratives. Journal of Com- munication, 35(3), 442–463. doi: 10.1111/jcom.12050 Cohen, J. (2001). Defining identification: A theoretical look at the identi- fication of audiences with media characters. Mass Communication & Society, 4(3), 245–264. doi: 10.1207/S15327825MCS0403_01 Crano, W. D., Brewer, M. B., & Lac, A. (2015). Principles and methods of so- cial research. New York, NY: Routledge (3er edition). de Graaf, A. (2014). The effectiveness of adaptation of the protagonist in narrative impact: Similarity influences health beliefs through self-referencing. Human Communication Research, 40(1), 73–90. doi: 10.1111/hcre.12015 de Graaf, A., Hoeken, H., Sanders, J., & Beentjes, J. W. J. (2012). Identifica- tion as a mechanism of narrative persuasion. Communication Re- search, 39(6), 802–823. doi: 10.1177/0093650211408594 521Palabra Clave - ISSN: 0122-8285 - eISSN: 2027-534X - Vol. 21 No. 2 - Junio de 2018. 499-523 de Graaf, A., Sanders, J., & Hoeken, H. (2016). Characteristics of narrative interventions and health effects: A review of the content, form, and context of narratives in health-related narrative persuasion research. Review of Communication Research, 4, 88–131. doi: 10.12840 Eno, C. A., & Ewoldsen, D. R . (2010). The influence of explicitly and implicitly measured prejudice on interpretations of and re- actions to black film. Media Psycholog y, 13(1), 1–30. doi: 10.1080/15213260903562909 Erez, E., Adelman, M., & Gregory, C. (2009). Intersections of immigration and domestic violence: Voices of battered immigrant women. Fem- inist Criminology, 4(1), 32–56. doi: 10.1177/1557085108325413 Gaertner, S. L., & Dovidio, J. F. (1986). The aversive form of racism. In J. F. Dovidio & S. L. Gaertner (Eds.), Prejudice, discrimination, and racism (pp. 61–89). San Diego, CA: Academic Press. Green, M. C., & Brock, T. C. (2000). The role of transportation in the per- suasiveness of public narratives. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 79(5), 701–721. doi: 10.1037//0022-3514.79.5.701 Hayes, A. F. (2005). Statistical methods for communication science. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrecne Erlbaum Associates. Hayes, A. F. (2013). Introduction to mediation, moderation, and conditional process analysis. A regression-based approach. New York, NY: Guil- ford Press. Hoeken, H., & Fikkers, K. M. (2014). Issue-relevant thinking and identifi- cation as mechanisms of narrative persuasion. Poetics, 44, 84–99. doi: 10.1016/j.poetic.2014.05.001 Hoeken, H., Kolthoff, M., & Sanders, J. (2016). Story perspective and character similarity as drivers of identification and narrative per- 522 Persuading with Narratives Against Gender Violence... - Juan José Igartua, Daniela Fiuza suasion. Human Communication Research, 42(2), 292–311. doi: 10.1111/hcre.12076 Hoeken, H., & Sinkeldam, J. (2014). The role of identification and per- ception of just outcome in evoking emotions in narrative persua- sion. Journal of Communication, 64(5), 935–955. doi: 10.1111/ jcom.12114 Igartua, J. J. (2013). Attitudinal impact and cognitive channelling of immi- gration stereotypes through the news. Revista Latina de Comuni- cación Social, 68, 599–621. Igartua, J. J., & Barrios, I. (2012). Changing real-world beliefs with contro- versial movies: Processes and mechanisms of narrative persuasion. Journal of Communication, 62(3), 514–531. doi: 10.1111/j.1460- 2466.2012.01640.x Igartua, J. J., & Frutos, F. J. (2017). Enhancing attitudes toward stigma- tized groups with movies: Mediating and moderating processes of narrative persuasion. International Journal of Communication, 11, 158–177. Igartua, J. J., & Vega, J. (2016). Identification with characters, elaboration, and counterarguing in entertainment-education interventions through audiovisual fiction. Journal of Health Communication, 21(3), 293–300. doi: 10.1080/10810730.2015.1064494 McConahay, J. B., Hardee, B. B., & Batts, V. (1981). Has racism declined in America? It depends on who is asking and what is asked. The Jour- nal of Conflict Resolution, 25(4), 563–579. Meil, G. (2014). Percepción social de la violencia de género [Social percep- tion of gender violence]. Madrid: Ministerio de Sanidad, Servi- cios Sociales e Igualdad. 523Palabra Clave - ISSN: 0122-8285 - eISSN: 2027-534X - Vol. 21 No. 2 - Junio de 2018. 499-523 Moyer-Gusé, E. (2008). Toward a theor y of entertainment persua- sion: Explaining the persuasive effects of entertainment-edu- cation messages. Communication Theory, 18(3), 407–425. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-2885.2008.00328.x Moyer-Gusé, E., Chung, A. H., & Jain, P. (2011). Identification with char- acters and discussion of taboo topics after exposure to an enter- tainment narrative about sexual health. Journal of Communication, 61(3), 387–406. doi: 10.1111/j.1460-2466.2011.01551.x Moyer-Gusé, E., & Nabi, R . L. (2010). Explaining the effects of narrative in an entertainment television program: Overcoming resistance to persuasion. Human Communication Research, 36(1), 26–52. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-2958.2009.01367.x Park, S.-Y. (2012). Mediated intergroup contact: Concept explication, syn- thesis, and application. Mass Communication and Society, 15(1), 136–159. doi: 10.1080/15205436.2011.558804 Robinson, M. J., & Knobloch-Westerwick, S. (2017). Bedtime stories that work: The effect of protagonist liking on narrative persuasion. Health Com- munication, 32(3), 339–346. doi: 10.1080/10410236.2016.1138381 Román, M., García, A., & Álvarez, S. (2011). Tratamiento informativo de la mujer inmigrante en la prensa española [Information process- ing of immigrant women in Spanish newspapers]. Cuadernos de Información, 29, 173–186. Tukachinsky, R . (2014). Experimental manipulation of psychological in- volvement with media. Communication Methods and Measures, 8(1), 1–33. doi: 10.1080/19312458.2013.873777 Wright, E. M., & Benson, M. L. (2010). Immigration and intimate partner violence: Exploring the immigrant paradox. Social Problems, 57(3), 480–503. doi: 10.1525/sp.2010.57.3.480