Research Note An Early Proterozoic U-Pb zircon age from an Eskolabreen Formation gneiss in southern Ny Friesland, Spitsbergen YU. A. BALASHOV. A. N. LARIONOV. L. F. GANNIBAL. A. N . SIROTKIN, A. M. TEBENKOV. G . 1 . RYUNGENEN and Y. OHTA .. Balashov, Yu. A . , Larionov, A. N.. Gannibal. L. F.. Sirotkin. A . N., Tebenkov, A. M.. Ryiingenen, G . I . & Ohta. Y. 1993: An Early Proterozoic U-Pb zircon age from an Eskolabreen Formation gneiss in southern N y Friesland. Spitsbergen. Polar Research 12(2), 147-152. A preliminary U/Pb zircon age determination has been carried out on a grey gneiss of the Eskolabreen Formation, the lowest observable lithostratigraphic unit of Precambrian metamorphic rocks in southern Ny Friesland. NE Spitsbergen. The obtained age, ca. 2,400Ma, is considered to be a metamorphic age and suggests an Early Proterozoic tectonothermal event. Yu. A . Balashou, A . N . Larionov, L . F. Cannibal, and C . I . Ryungenen. Laboratory of Isotope Geochem- istry, Geological Institute, Kola Science Centre. Russian Academv of Sciences, 14 Fersman Str., 184200 Apatity, Russia; A . M . Tebenkov and A . N . Sirorkin, Polar Marine Geological Exploration Expedition. 24 Pobedu Sir., I89510 Lomonosou-St. Petershurg. Russia: Y. Ohta. Norsk Polarinstitutt. P. 0. Box 5072 Majorstua, N-0301 Oslo. Norway. Introduction Rcccnt gcochronological works on the pre-Caledonian base- ment of Svalbard have revealed not only a late Middle Pro- terozoic tectonothermal event, the Grenvillian (Peucat et al. 1989: Tebcnkov ct al. 1991: Balashov et al. 1992; Gee et al. in press), hut also a late Early Proterozoic event (Gee et al. 1992; Gavrilenko & Kamensky 1992) and some Early Proterozoic and older U-Pb zircon upper interccpt ages (Peucat et al. 1989; Balashov ct at. 1992) and Sm-Nd model ages (Bernard-Griffiths et al. 1993). Since the N y Friesland area, northeastern Spitsbergen. has complex structures (Manby 1990: Gee et at. 1992) and the largest distribution of the pre-Devonian crystalline basement. Early Proterozoic rocks can naturally be expected. This note reports an Early Proterozoic U-Pb zircon age obtained from a gneiss of the Eskolabreen Formation, the lowest litho- stratigraphic division of the basement rock succession as defined by Harland et at. (1966). Geological setting N y Friesland occupies the middle part of the basement areas of northern Svalbard (Fig. I ) . The structure in the southern part of Ny Friesland is dominated by an asymmetric antiform, the Atomfjella antiform (Harland 1959). The axis plunges gently to the north. The western limb of the antiform is cut by a steep fault zone, dipping 5C-80" to the west, which is a part of the N-S trending Billefjorden Fault Zone (Harland et al. 1974), the latter down throws to the west. Some Carboniferous cover has been preserved on the basement block in the east side of Austfjordcn. The castern limb of the antiform is cut by a steep E dipping, partly thrust. fault within the antiform and the Finlandvcggcn Group is in contact with the Harkerbrcen Group (Table 1 ) by this fault. Along the eastern margin of the antiform the Harkerbreen Group is in contact with the Mossel series (Krasil'BEikov 1973) or the Planetfjella Group of the upper Stubendorffbreen Supergroup (Harland et at. 1966) by a W- dipping thrust fault. The core of the antiform is composed of the Smutsbreen and the Eskolabreen Formations of the Finlandveggen Group (Harland et at. 1966; Krasil'Sfikov 1973; Harland 1985, 1992). The Smutsbreen Formation consists of grey biotite gneisses with or without garnet and distinctive marble layers. The latter are in both the lower and upper parts, and small amounts of calc- silicate-gneisses and amphibolites also present. The Esko- labreen Formation is the lowest observable lithostratigraphic unit and is composed of garnet-hornblende-biotite- and horn- blende-biotite gneisses. amphibolites and granitic gneisses. These rocks have upper amphibolite facies mineral assemblages of high temperature scries with andalusite-sillimanite, while the rocks of this formation in the limbs have kyanite-garnet-mica assemblages without sillimanite. indicating a lower temperature condition than in the core and an intermediate temperature- pressure series. The FlPtan granite in the northern part of Ny Friesland (Fig. 1) has a 1,788 + 53/-45 Ma U-Pb zircon isochron age. It also 148 Yu. A. Balashou et al. Fig. 1. Generalized geological map of southern Ny Friesland. with the sample locality. lnsertcd map: Solid square = map area, dashed area = prc-Devonian basement, NF = Ny Friesland, F = Flatan granite. Legend: Cb = Carboniferous. PI = Planetfjella Group or Mosscl series. Rt = Ritlervatnet Formation, Hk = Polhem o r Harkerbreen Formation. Sm = Smutsbreen Formation. Es = Eskolabrecn Formation, Ft = fault and thrust, Ant = Atomfjella antiform. S with a solid circle = sample locality. yielded zircon single grain ages of ca. 1.70UMa (Gee ct al. 1992). This granite possibly intruded in the gneisses and amphibolitcs of the Polhem Formation in the lower part of the Harkerbreen Group (Table 1). Thus the protoliths of the gneisses and amphibolites are of Early Proterozoic. Ultramafic rocks separating the Polhem Formation from the Planetfjella Group have yielded a ca. 1.8 G a age and a biotite concentrated rock adjacent to them gives an age of 500Ma. both by the K-Ar method (Gavrilenko & Kamensky 1992). though the reliability of these K-Ar data is a matter of debate. This note presents a preliminary U-Pb zircon age obtained from an Eskolabreen Formation gneiss in southern Ny Fries- land. This age was orally presented by Balashov in August 1993 at Turku, Finland. Materials and methods Sample description A grey gneiss (ca. 30 kg) from the Eskolabreen Formation in the middle-southern side of Stubendorffbreen has becn used for this isotopic study. The locality is shown in Fig. I . The rock is a coarse-grained, feldspar porphyroblastic, garnet-hornblende- biotite gneiss with a modal composition of 2.%30% quartz, 2.5- 30% plagioclase (An,&, 3 U % K-feldspar, 10% biotite, 1- 2% hornblende and I-2% garnet with accessories of apatitc, zircon, monazite and opaques; the secondary minerals are chlor- ite, sericite and epidote. This gneiss forms persistent layers, u p to 5 m in each thick- A n Early Proterozoic U - P b zircon age from an Eskolabreen Formation 149 Sarrbreen Fm Vassfaret Fm. Bangenhuk Fm. Rittervatnet Fm. Harkerbreen Fm. Fig. 2 . Morphotypes of the zircon grains. scanning electro-micrographs. Upper left, morphotype 1 , x480, upper right, morphotype 1 x IhX; lower left and lower right morphotypc 2, both x 240. D s 3 (D iii 3 v) Table 1. Lithostratigraphic schemes of Middle and Early Proterozoic successions in Ny Fricsland, aftcr Harland ct a l . (19%) and Krasil'sfikov (1Y73) Smutsbreen Fm. Eskolabreen Fm. Harland et al. 1966 Planetfjellet Group 2 I' I 0, S ~ r b r e e n Fm. Vassfaret Fm. 0 2 Bangenhuk Fm. i3e Rittervatnet Fm. 6 s Polhem Fm. 3 (D Krasilscikov 1973 Mossel series T ab le 2 . Is o to p ic a n al ys es o f U a n d P b fr o m t h e zi rc on f ra ct io ns o f th e m o rp h o ty p e 1 fr o m t h e E sk o la b re en g ne is s '0 7P b / % '0 7P b / % '0 6P b er r 2 3 5 U er r 0 . 1 3 3 4 0. 14 4. 56 7 0. 31 0 . 1 4 8 0 0. 71 6. 88 8 0 . 7 6 0. 14 91 0. 21 7. 47 3 0. 37 0 . 1 4 4 6 0 . 3 5 7. 52 4 0. 45 0. 12 95 0 . 8 2 4 .2 31 0 . 9 6 0 . 1 3 5 0 0. 13 5. 34 0 0. 28 - .a b 10 . - 1 2 3 4 5 6 - 20 6P b / % 2 3 a U er r 0 . 2 4 8 3 0. 27 0. 33 76 0 . 2 6 0 . 3 6 3 4 0 . 3 0 0 . 3 7 7 3 0 . 2 6 0 . 2 3 6 9 0. 35 0 . 2 8 6 9 0. 24 S iz e o f fr ac ti o n s b m ) 5 0 - 7 5 7 5 - 1 0 0 > l o o > l o o < 5 0 < l o o - W ei g h t Im g l - 0. 8 1. 7 1 0 . 0 8. 6 0. 9 0 . 6 U P b P b p p m ra d io co m m on ge n ic p p m p p ln 3 4 6 9 3 . 9 0 . 6 4 18 9 70 .7 < 0 . 0 0 1 20 3 83 .3 0 . 2 3 15 6 65 .6 0 . 5 2 2 9 4 6 4 . 7 3 0 . 5 0 3 2 7 10 1. 4 1. 02 1 1 3 1 8 3. 8 6 0 6 0 11 .0 4 2 4 5 3. 7 IS O T O P IC R A T IO S (m ea su re d ) ZO G Pb / % 'O 'P b er r 7. 38 6 0. 10 6. 69 3 0. 70 6. 66 2 0 . 2 0 6 . 8 2 2 0. 30 4 . 2 1 6 0 . 2 2 7 . 2 5 3 0 . 0 8 2 06 P b / % 20 sP b er r 7. 05 8 0. 14 7. 10 2 0. 50 6. 10 7 0. 30 6 . 4 8 4 0. 15 2. 45 4 0. 44 7 . 6 8 3 0. 31 A g e (M a ) (c al cu la te d ) R H O '0 7P b / '0 7P b/ 20 6P b i 20 6p b 2 3 5 " 2 3 8 u 0. 89 7 2 1 4 3 17 43 1 4 3 0 0. 34 9 2 3 2 3 2 0 9 7 18 75 0. 81 9 2 3 3 6 2 1 7 0 1 9 9 8 0 . 6 2 6 2 2 8 3 2 1 7 6 2 0 6 4 0 . 5 5 6 2 0 9 2 1 6 8 0 1 3 7 0 0. 88 8 2 1 6 4 15 75 16 26 A n Early Proterozoic U - P b zircon age f r o m an Eskolabreen Formation 151 ness, altcrnating with pink granitic gncisses and thin amphibo- lites of hornblende-biotite gncisscs and is located about l00m below thc uppcr boundary of the Eskolabreen Formation in the core of the Atomfjclla antiform. Many isoclinal fold hinges occur within layers and the gneissosities arc all of tcctonic- metamorphic in origin. Zircons Two morphotypes of zircon grains arc distinguished in the rock (Fig. 2): ( I ) Grains with facets of ( 1 1 1 ) . (311). (110). (100) and wide bulging margins between them. having apparent oval or roundcd outlines with the width/lcngth ratios 1.5-2.5. They have smooth surfaces and arc commonly transparent. yellow to brownish in colour. Some grains have thin overgrowths at thc pinacles. (2) Prismatic grains with ( 1 1 I ) and (100) facets. These have relativcly rough surfaces and the width/length ratios are 2-3.5. The colours are similar to morphotypc I . but darker and not as clear duc to thc rougher surfaccs. Zircons of both morphotypcs have some inclusions of brown nccdlcs. probably thorite. and glass-liquid bubbles. The surfaces of grains do not show any abrasion pattern as usually seen on the surfaces of detrital grains. Thermal-ion mass-spectrometry studies on both types of zircon grains show a large difference in 2"7Pb/zHPb age (ca. 2.36 and 1.87 Ga), indicating at least two generations of the grains. The zircons of morphotype 2 have not been analysed in this preliminary study because they are considered to have a complex history of crystallization and would therefore give results difficult to interpretate. Six size fractions of morphotypc 1 zircon grains have been chosen for the prcsent U/Pb analyscs. Only transparent grains without ovcrgrowth at the pinacles have bccn selected. Fraction 4 was air-abraded to remove the inner part and fraction 6 was additionally milled. Isotope anulyses and results Extraction of U and Pb was performed by Krogh's (1973) method. Aftcr being washed with diluted nitric acid, the zircon grains were dissolved in 2 ml H F in teflon capsules and heated in aluminium bombs in an oven at 185°C for some days. Aftcr dissolution and aliquotation. thc ID part was spiked with a mixed 235U-208Pb tracer. U and Pb wcrc separated by ion- exchange using 6.2 M HCI and water. Total blank during the experiments were 0.05 ng for U and 0.1-0.5 ng for Pb. Thc sample was loaded with nitric acid on a double Re filament for U and with silica gel and phosphoric acid on a single Re filament for Pb. Both wcrc analyscd with a MI- 1201-T single collector mass spectrometer. The results of the measurements were corrcctcd for blanks of 0.5 ng for Pb and 0.05 ng of U . and common lead using Stacey & Kramer's model (1975) for an age of 2.450 Ma. The results of U and P b isotope analyses are given in Table 2 and the obtained isochron is illustrated in Fig. 3. The four fractions define a discordia with an upper intercept of 2.415 + -34 Ma and a lower intercept of 624 + -68 Ma, with MSWD = 6.9. Two fractions, 4 and 6, are off from the discordia, probably duc to later thermal effects and/or contamination during the air-abrasion for fraction 4. E'a#] 0.44 Fig. 3 . U-Pb concordia diagram. Number of sample refers to Table 2. Discussion Close structural observations of the Stubendorffbreen Supergroup in this area show that all layered and banded structures in the rocks are of tectonic origin: no stratigraphic (scnsu stricto) definition is therefore possible and the suc- cessions must be defined as lithostratigraphic of tectono- stratigraphic units (Manby 1990; Gee et al. in press). The protoliths of the rocks of the Harkcrbrcen and Fin- landveggcn Groups have been considered to be areno-argil- laceous and arkosic sediments and hi-modal igneous rocks of mostly eruptive origin. The volcanigenic origin of somc of these rocks has also been discussed by Manhy (IWO) and Sirotkin (unpubl. report). The latter author suggested a difference in a sedimentary environment for these groups, an extensional deep sea basin for the Finlandveggen Group and a transgressional shallow sea - subaerial basin for thc Harkerbrcen Group. All previous authors agreed that these two groups bclong to a large volcani-sedimentary succcssion without any orogenic break within it. though all observed contacts bctwccn thc two groups are cut by thrust o r steep fault in southern Ny Friesland. The obtained U-Pb upper interccpt age can be considered as a metamorphic zircon age, judging from the transparent colour. smooth surfaces lacking any trace of abrasion and the absence of any clearly zoned structure. This age is applicable to both the Eskolabreen and the Smutsbreen Formations. since these are conformable both in structure and metamorphism. but this age is not applicable to the Harkerbreen Group since this group is separated by faults from the Smutsbreen Formation in this area. This U-Pb upper intercept age suggests an older tec- tonothermal event than the emplacement of the Flitan granite at ca. 1.7 G a (Gee et al. 1992) in Ny Friesland. Similar ages of ca. 2.4-2SGa have also been obtained recently from U-Pb upper intercepts of zircon from a quartz porphyryrhyolite clasts in a conglomerate-pyroclastic unit of the northwestern Hornsund (Balashov et al. 1992). 152 Yu. A. Balashou et al. Thc Caledonian and Precambrian rocks of Ny Fricsland have becn compared with those of East Greenland (Harland 1985; Gee et al. 1992). There the 4 1 0 k m thick Krummcdal sup- racrustal sequence (Higgins 1988) has been metamorphosed during the Grenvillian period (e.g, Peucat et al. 1985), while much older U-Pb zircon uppcr intcrccpt agcs. ca. 1.9-3.OGa (Hanscn & Friderichsen 1987; Hansen el al. 1987) and ca. 2.5 Ma (Peucat et al. 1985) have also bccn rcportcd. Howevcr. thcsc rocks are involved in complex gneiss-migmatite structures and the discrimination between Middle and Early Proterozoic rocks has not yet been completed. Thc palinspastic position of Svalbard before Cenozoic ocean spreading is not too far from northern Ellcsmcrc Island. and a structural unit of Calcdonian affinity, Pcarya, has bccn rccog- nizcd in that area (Trettin 1987). Recent U-Pb zircon studies on the Caledonian and older rocks in Pcarya yielded older agcs than thc Grcnvillian, ca. 2.1 and ca. 2.2Ga (Trettin et al. 1992). Both are considered to be from inherited zircons, but no geological constraints arc known yct. No correlative geological event has cvcr bccn observed in the present area which corresponds with thc lower intercept age, ca. 625 Ma. But a fcw similar Rb-Sr and K-Ar ages arc known in the northern parts of Nordaustlandct (Hamilton & Sandford 1964; Ohta 1992). A similar agc for cclogitic meta- gabbroic rock has been obtained from Biskayerhalveya (Peucat ct al. 1989). This period corresponds to the time of the Baikalian event in the southeastern Barcnts Sea rcgion: however, all these agcs in Svalbard are from igneous rocks and no distinguishing structural event of this period has yet hccn rccognizcd. Acknowledgements. - T h e authors arc gratcful for critical com- ments to the manuscript given by D. G. Gee, University of Lund. Sweden, and A. Johansson. Swedish Museum of Natural History, Stockholm. Wc would also likc to thank A . A. Krasil'SEikov, Polar Marine Geological Expedition. Lomono- sov. Russia, for organizing of the projcct. References Balashov, Yu. A , , Fedotov, J . A., Skufjin, P. K., Sharkov. I. V . . Kravchcnko. M. P., Shcrstobitova. G . M. & Uliancnko, N. A. 1992: Evoljucia vulcanizma v pcchengskoy osadochno- vulkanogennoy tolsche PO Rb-Sr izotoponym dannym. Tezisy XI11 Simpvsiuma geochimii isotopov. Moskwa, GEOCHI, Rossijskaja Academija Nauk. Pp. 1 6 1 7 (in Russian). Bernard-Griffiths, J . , Pcucat. J. J . & Ohta. Y. 1993: Age and nature of protoliths in a Caledonian blueschist-eclogite complex of western Spitsbergen: a combined approach of U- Pb, Sm-Nd and REE wholc rock systcms. Lithos 30. 81-90, Bojanova, T . B. & Jacovenchuk, V. N. 1992: U-Pb datirovanie baddeleita i zirkona granofirovyh porod Imandra-Varzugskoy struktury. Doklady Rossijskoj Academi i Nauk 322, 136141 (in Russian). Gavrilenko, B. V. & Kamensky, 1. L., 1992: K-Ar isochronnyi vozrast i isotopy kalija v hyperbasitovoj dake na poluostrove Mosscl, Ny Fricsland, Spitsbergen. Geochimija 2, 1 2 6 1 2 9 (in Russian). Gee, D. G., Bjorklund, L. & Stolen, L-K. (in press): Early Proterozoic basement in Ny Friedand.-Implications for the Caledonian tectonics of Svalbard. Tectonophysics. Gcc. D. G . , Schouenborg. B.. Peucat, J . J . , Abakumov, S . A., Krasil'Sfikov, A. A . & Tebenkov, A . M. 1992: New evidence of basement in the Svalbard Caledonidcs: Early Proterozoic zircon agcs from Ny Friedand granites. Norsk Geol. Tirlsskr. 7 2 , 181-190. Hamilton, E. 1. & Sandford, K. S. 1964: Rubidium-Strontium agcs from North-East Land (Spitsbergcn). Nature 201, 1 2 0 6 1209. Hansen, B. T . & Friedcrichsen. J. D. 1987: lsotopic age dating in Livcrpool Land. East Greenland. Gr0n. Geol. Under- s0gelse Rapp. 134. 25-37. Hansen, B. T . , Steiger. R. H., Hcnrikscn. N. & Borchardt. B. 1987: U-Pb and Rb-Sr agc determinations on Caledonian plutonic rocks in the ccntral part of the Scorcshy Sund rcgion. East Greenland. Gron. Geol. Unders0gelse Rapp. 134. 5-24. Harland, W. B. 1959: The Caledonian sequence in Ny Fricsland. Spitsbergcn. Q. J . Geol. S O C . London 114. 307-342. Harland, W. B. 1985: Calcdonidc Svalvard. Pp. 999-1001l in Gee, D. G. & Sturl, B. (eds.): The Caledinide orvgrny - Scandinavia and related areas, Part 2 . John Wilcy & Sons. Chichester. Harland. W. B. 1992: The Ny Fricsland Orogcn. Spitsbcrgcn. Geol. Mag. 129. 67Y-708. Harland, W. B.. Wallis, R. H . &Gayer. R. A . 1966: A rcvision of the Lower Hecla Hoek Succession in ccntral north Spits- bergen and correlation clsewherc. Geol. Mag. 103, 70!-97. Harland. W. B . , Cutbill, J . L., Friend. P. F., Cobbctt. D. J.. Holiday, D. W.. Maton. P. I . . Parkcr. J . R. & Wallis, R. H. 1974: The Billdfjorden Fault Zone, Spitsbcrgcn. Norsk Polarinrt. Skr. 161. 72 pp. Higgins, A . K. 1988: The Krummcdal supracrustal scqucncc in East Grecnland. Pp. &96 in Winchcstcr, J . A . (ed.): L u f f Proterozoic stratigraphy of the northern Atlantic region. Blackie. Glasgow. Krasil'Sfikov, A . A. 1973: Strstigrafija i palcotcctonica Docam- brijuranncgo Palcozoya Spitsbergen. Trudy lnstituta Geologii Arktiki 172, 1-119 (in Russian). Krogh, T. E . 1973: A low-contamination method for hydro- thermal dissolution of zircons and extraction of U and Pb for isotopic age determinations. Gevrhemica et Cosmochemica Acta 37,485-494. Manby, G . M. 1990: The petrology of the Harkcrbrccn Group. Ny Friedand, Svalbard: protoliths and tectonic significance. Geol. Mag. 127. 129-146. Ohta, Y . 1992: Recent understanding of the Svalbard basement in the light of new radiometric age determinations, Norsk Geologisk Tidskrift 72, 1-6. Peucat, J. J.. Tisserant, D., Caby. R. & Claucr, N. 1985: Resistance of zircons to resetting in a prograde metamorphic sequence of Caledonian age, East Greenland. Can. J . Earth Sci. 22, 330-338. Peucat, J . J . . Ohta. Y. & Gee, D. G. and Bernard-Griffiths, J. 1989: U-Pb, Sr and Nd evidence for Grcnvillian and latest Proterozoic tectonothcrmal activity in the Spitsbcrgcn Calc- donidcs. Arctic Ocean. Lithos 22, 275-285. Staccy. J. S. & Kramer, J. D. 1Y75: Approximationofterrestrial lead isotope evolution by a two-stage model. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 26, 207-221, Tebenkov. A . M. Balashov. Yu. A. & Krasil'Sfikov, A. A . 1991; Trace of pre-Paleozoic events in Svalbard Caledonides. Terra Abstract Supplement 4 to Teru Nova 3 . p. 32. Trettin, H. P. 1987: Pearya: a composit tcrrane with Caledonian affinities in northern Ellesmere Island. Can. J . Earth Sci. 2 4 , 224245. Trettin, H. P., Parrish, R. R. & Ruddick, J . C. 1W2: Ncw U- Pb and 40Ar-39Ar age determinations from northcrn Ellcs- mere and Axel Heibergh islands. Northwcst Territories and their tectonic significance. Radiogenic Age and Isotopic Studies: Report 6 , Geol. Survey of Canada. Paper 92-2. S 3 0 .