Editorial

PROFILE 8, 2007. ISSN 1657-0790. Bogotá, Colombia. Pages 5-8 5

Editorial

“We are talking about new forms of ‘research’, until recently an elite 
practice — we need professors to back off a little to create communicative 
space”.�

“Orlando Fals Borda is one of the great leaders of the participatory action 
research (PAR) movement in South America. Moreover, he has succeeded 
in making his work and ideas known in the northern hemisphere. This is 
no mean feat when ideas have tended to flow from north to south. One 
of Borda’s great skills has been his ability to network educationalists and 
intellectuals from the world of education across the boundary that divides 
the so-called ‘developed world’ from the ‘underdeveloped world’. His work 
has particularly attracted the attention of university-based educationals 
trying to reconstruct educational research in a form that places it at the 
service of hope for greater social justice”.�

The quotes above gather some of the lessons we have learned from 
some of the most well-known pioneers of teacher research. Their 
ideology, as well as those of the practitioners, researchers, professors, and 
preservice teachers who have developed an array of  papers, unites many 
people all over the world and has been the steering force to maintain our 
publication. 

Our efforts to strengthening investigation in the area of English 
language teaching have in turn had an impact on communicating 
what is done by professionals of different educational levels and with 
different degrees of expertise in the teaching and research arenas. 
More and more contributors have evidenced their interest in our 
journal by sending their contributions and thus accepting the norms 
of our evaluation process. Thanks to their reliance on PROFILE as a 
communicative space and the rigor and dedication of the members 
of our advisory and editorial committees, I can now introduce the 
contents of this year’s number.

1 McTaggart, R. (2007). The role of professors in participatory action research. Seminario 
internacional  investigación acción y educación en contextos de pobreza. CD Memorias. Bogotá: Universidad 
de la Salle.

2 Elliot, J. (2007). Reinstating social hope through participatory action research. In C. O’Hanlon, J. 
Elliott, O. Zuber-Skerritt, S. Grundy, R. McTaggart, & S. Kemmis. Action research and education in contexts 
of poverty. A tribute to the life and work of professor Orlando Fals Borda (pp. 35-47). Bogotá: Universidad 
de la Salle.

PROFILE 8.indd   5 28/09/2007   12:42:10 a.m.



Cárdenas Beltrán

 Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Facultad de Ciencias Humanas, Departamento de Lenguas Extranjeras6

I am very pleased to welcome professors Robin McTaggart (James 
Cook University, Australia) and John Elliot (University of East Anglia, 
United Kingdom). Their ideas have been vital for those of us who 
practice classroom research and believe in the possibility of working 
together to make education stronger through investigation, academic 
discussion and sharing. 

Encouraging practitioners, with little or no experience in writing 
academic reports, to publish the results of their classroom inquiries has 
been the cornerstone of our publication. To do so, teachers who have 
participated in the teacher development programmes led by the Foreign 
Languages Department of the Universidad Nacional de Colombia, 
need constant communication with their tutors and assistance. This is 
precisely the support given by Elizabeth González and María Eugenia 
López. Many thanks to them too. 

The eleven articles contained in this number reflect teachers’ interests 
in areas such as the implementation of given methods, innovations, and 
teacher education. Let us take a look at the aspects they address.

Our first section – Issues from teacher researchers – begins with 
two papers by school teachers who carried out action research in public 
schools in Bogotá. Two teachers share with us their analysis of children’s 
English language learning evidences when engaging in project work. 
Their paper is the result of an attempt to explore this approach by 
integrating the contents of the syllabus for fifth grade. The other paper 
tells us how a group of teachers used the skimming technique as a means 
to guide students in decoding written texts.

The next three articles inform us about the handling of certain issues 
with adolescents in different teaching contexts. We present the results of 
an action research project carried out to minimize discipline problems 
and negative class participation in a language school in Brazil. After 
that we can learn about the way an inquiry project was developed as an 
alternative to promoting a meaningful learning context.  Then, we come 
across another action research report on the use of cooperative learning 
strategies to improve students’ oral production in the English class. 

The last two articles of the first part of our journal are written by 
teacher educators. Observing the professional development of a group 
of foreign language teacher educators and preservice teachers constitutes 
the focal point of an investigation that accounts for the knowledge, skills 
and attitudes these teachers developed through their participation in 
a study group. Reference is also made to the skills and attitudes the 
facilitator of the study group developed through her role in it. Then, 
we include the results of an exploration of public schools in-service 

PROFILE 8.indd   6 28/09/2007   12:42:11 a.m.



  
 Editorial

PROFILE 8, 2007. ISSN 1657-0790. Bogotá, Colombia. Pages 5-8 7

teachers’ implementation of cooperative learning. The study uncovers 
how a group of teachers set the conditions to create a cooperative 
learning environment as well as some perceptions their educators have 
of themselves as initiators in guiding their students in this pedagogical 
experience. 

The section on issues from novice teacher researchers makes us 
think not only on the importance of disseminating the work carried 
out by teachers who are just finishing their undergraduate studies, but 
on the way they could work collaboratively to help solve problems faced 
by their own partners. I would like to draw your attention to the paper 
included in this part of our journal, because it focuses on the course of 
action undertaken in a tutorial plan to support the English speaking 
skill of an Inga indigenous student who had difficulties learning English 
as a third language in an initial teacher education programme.

We close this number with three papers referring to innovations 
conducted in three different countries. We find two experiences on the 
design and implementation of in-service programmes for primary school 
teachers. To start with, a holistic professional development program for 
elementary school English teachers in Colombia directed towards target 
language improvement and pedagogical reflection is described. School-
based and learner-centered, the program is characteristic of a synthetic, 
progressive, process-oriented curriculum which, according to the 
authors, can be considered as a viable professional development effort 
at the elementary school level in our country. After that, we present a 
paper which examines how the Common European Framework of 
Reference was employed as a tool for the purpose of devising a language 
certificate meant to assess the competence needed for effective teaching 
at primary school level in Italy. I am sure these two papers will generate 
rich discussion and reflection upon the definition of ongoing teacher-
education programmes. I hope they also shed light on decisions to adopt 
tailor-made programmes or to account for those created on the basis of 
knowledge of our teaching realities and local expertise.

The last paper touches on an important aspect in English language 
teaching: pronunciation. Though we cannot deny that working on 
intonation in a foreign-language learning environment may pose a 
serious challenge for teachers whose mother tongue differs from the 
target language, the author highlights the importance of the intonation 
system for formal pronunciation teaching and challenges us to try out 
David Brazil’s Discourse Intonation approach with beginners. 

Finally, I wish to share with all of you that our journal has been 
indexed in SciELO-Scientific Library Online. This is not only a 

PROFILE 8.indd   7 28/09/2007   12:42:11 a.m.



Cárdenas Beltrán

 Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Facultad de Ciencias Humanas, Departamento de Lenguas Extranjeras8

recognition of our scientific standards, but an opportunity to guarantee 
universal visibility and accessibility on the Internet. From now on, you can 
read our traditional printed version as well as the full papers by accessing  
http://www.scielo.org.co/scielo.php/script_sci_alphabetic/lng_pt/nrm_iso

I do hope you enjoy this publication and look forward to your 
continuing contributions and comments on our work.

Melba Libia Cárdenas Beltrán
Journal Editor

PROFILE 8.indd   8 28/09/2007   12:42:11 a.m.