








key: cord-337096-ulc7mnwb
authors: Okazawa, Mitsushi; Suzuki, Sadao
title: Japanese tactics for suppressing COVID-19 spread
date: 2020-07-14
journal: Public Health
DOI: 10.1016/j.puhe.2020.07.012
sha: 
doc_id: 337096
cord_uid: ulc7mnwb

Abstract COVID-19 infection is overwhelming the world and death toll is steadily increasing. The first wave in Japan seemed to converge with lower death rate than that in most developed countries. In this letter, we describe how Japanese government suppressed the first wave of COPD-19 spread.

Letter to the editor, SARS-CoV-2 infection is overwhelming the world, and the COVID-19 death toll is steadily increasing. The first wave of infection in Japan seemed to culminate with a death rate lower than that in most developed countries [1] .

Since the outbreak in a cruise ship harbored in Yokohama, the Japanese government on February 7 th , designated COVID-19 as a "designated infectious disease" comparable with second category diseases such as tuberculosis, poliomyelitis, SARS, MERS, diphtheria, H5N1 and H7N9 influenzas based on the infectious disease law. By law, a complete contact survey had to be performed by a public health center (Hokenjo) and the identified patient had to be reported to the prefectural government and isolated. All medical bills are covered through public expenses. Currently, PCR is the only reliable test for identifying patients; however, sensitivity of PCR tests is only up to 70% [2] . Although specificity is very high, there is still a possibility of obtaining false-positive results because of contamination or low quality of the test kits [3] . Indeed, false positive results were revealed in two cities in Japan, leading us to assume that the specificity of PCR is lower than 100% and the positive predictive value may be low if it is used for screening tests in the community with low prevalence. In contrast, if PCR is used on symptomatic patients, the positive predictive value must be high for identifying truly infected subjects. The Expert Meeting on New Coronavirus Disease Control (EMNDC) of the Japanese government set a plan for the identification of clusters through truly infected patients based on the complete contact survey. The key role of this plan was performed by "Hokenjo". They initially performed PCR only for the following individuals: those with body temperature > 37.5 ºC for 4 days, history of returning from travel abroad or to the cities of outbreak in the past 2 weeks, contact with the sick patients, and serious illness with pneumonia. The government also reinforced travel restrictions to and from other countries. The initial guidelines were effective in identifying truly infected patients and clusters, preventing people in panic from rushing to the hospital for PCR testing, and isolating infected subjects and sick patients for supportive therapy. The initial guidelines also seemed to protect hospitals from medical overload.

Hokenjo has profound expertise in conducting sick contact surveys, which had been established through tuberculosis management. The identification of clusters has two significant benefits. First, infected patients could be isolated or hospitalised depending on their condition. Second, the cluster investigation group in EMNDC could use the data for predicting the trend of spread. They used the SIR epidemiological model for prediction of the disease spread [4] , as illustrated in Figure 1 . The peak and the duration before convergence of the infectious curve (thick line) will vary based on the infectious coefficient "β", recovery coefficient "γ" and basic reproduction number "R0". β is thought to be dependent on the infectious ability of the virus, frequency of people's social contact, distance between individuals, housing situation, prevention method, and ultimately the vaccine. γ is thought to be dependent on effective medicines. R0 is the expected number of subjects directly infected from one infectious subject where all the other subjects are susceptible to infection, and was estimated to be ~2.4 for COVID19 in Japan [5 6] . During the spread of infection, the effective reproduction number "Rt", which is the average number of subjects who become infected by infectious subjects, was calculated using daily data. Rt was larger than 1 from mid-March to the end of March, indicating that infectious subjects increased toward a peak, as shown in Figure 2 . Since we do not have effective vaccines or medicines for the prevention of COVID-19 infection, EMNDC proposed recommendations to prevent crowded situations, close physical contact with other people, and closed areas with poor ventilation (3Cs) to decrease the infectious coefficient β. The government made a slogan: Avoid 3Cs and Stay home. At the same time, EMNDC pointed out that night clubs, bars, cabarets, karaoke clubs, and game houses were at high risk to create clusters. They also postulated that an 80% restriction in social activity would be necessary for converging the spread of infection in a month by achieving an Rt of ~0.5. The slogan was repeatedly broadcasted on television channels every day, to convince people that the only method to suppress COVID-19 spread would be to follow the slogan. Since the Japanese public tends to be diligent and co-operative, a large number of people had already tried to fulfil the recommendations before the declaration of the state of emergency on April 7 th . The following are the possible factors that could 

) travel restrictions, (5) precise prediction of the spread using the data of truly infected patients

Variation in False-Negative Rate of Reverse Transcriptase Polymerase Chain Reaction-Based SARS-CoV-2 Tests by Time Since Exposure

False positive in reverse transcription PCR testing for SARS-Cov-2. Secondary False positive in reverse transcription PCR testing for SARS

Discussion: the Kermack-McKendrick epidemic threshold theorem

Prediction of the Epidemic Peak of Coronavirus Disease in Japan

Estimation of the reproductive number of novel coronavirus (COVID-19) and the probable outbreak size on the Diamond Princess cruise ship: A data-driven analysis



