L a r y n g e a l Behaviour and Fluency-inducing Therapy Marlene Behrmann MA (Speech Path.) (Witwatersrand) Department of Speech Pathology and Audiology, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg Itemed behaviour of an adult stutterer was assessed pre- and post-therapy intervention. I n t e r v e n t i o n comprised a fluency based ram^directedto the modification ofphonatory behaviour and rate reduction. Electrolaryngographic tracings, as well as seventy and T ^ L ratZs Vere obtained pre- ail post-intervention. Results revealed a marked change in all measurements post-intervention, m- ^cating the effectiveness of therapy. The 'efficacy of the electrolaryngograph as a measurement tool was illustrated and the results are considered in the light of the current literature on phonatory disturbance in stuttering. TelTZfegedrag van >n volwasse hakkelaar is pre- en post-terapeutiese ingryping ondersoek. Ingryping het uit'n vlotheidsgebaseerde ^roe^am ger'g °p d'e ^ S m van fonatoriese gedrag en vermindering van spoed, bestaan. Eiektrolaringeografiese op ekeninge asook Zoliin o ' die graad en.frelensie van die hakkelgedrag, is voor en na terapeutiese ingryping verkry. Die doeltreffendheid van terapfe isbewys deurdat η opvallende verskil t.o.v. alle post-ingrypingsmetings gemerk is. Die effektiwiteit van die elektrol^og aaf as meetinstnment is aangetoon en die resultate is teen die agtergrond van die huidige literatuur i. v. m. fonatoriese asking in hakkel bespreek. program is to establish rate control and this dimension together with the emphasis on phonatory adjustments, has currently proved to be the most effective variable handled in treatment (Andrews et al. 1982). The Stutter Free therapy program falls within the 'Speak More Fluently' school of stuttering therapy, as discussed by Gregory (1979). These approaches, also known as the fluency-inducing ther- apies, advocate the establishment, maintenance and transfer of an entirely new speech pattern. The call for clearer delineation and identification of the factors which contribute to the success or failure of stuttering therapy has been made by Boberg, Howie and Woods (1979) and continued research into the outcome of therapy is neces- sary both to predict the amount of change and to enhance and modify existing treatment regimes. The concept of an organic etiology of stuttering is not a novel one, stuttering having been ascribed to, among others, neurological causes, auditory perception problems and biochemical factors (Van Riper 1978). Recently, numerous allusions to abnormal laryngeal functioning of stutterers have been made, but whether this abnor- mal functioning is due to etiological or symptomatological factors is as yet undetermined and may indeed prove unanswerable. Several writers have stated that the problem resides in the larynx itself whilst others have suggested that an overriding neural com- ponent is responsible for the disturbed phonatory behaviour (Con- ture, McCall and Brewer 1977). The stutterer's inability to initiate phonation and to make vocalization adjustments has been examined (Adams and Reis 1971), as hasjvoice onset time problems (Cross and Luper 1979) and unusuajl abductory laryngeal behaviour (Schwartz 1974). Perkins (1981) has concluded that there exists a "mistiming and excessive contraction of laryngeal and supraglottal muscles". One of the difficulties in examining the laryngeal behaviour of stut- terers arises from the lack of testing equipment. The development of the electrolaryngograph affords the researcher the opportunity of investigating the phonatory pattern of a speaker in a non-invasive manner (Fourcin and Abberton 1971). This technique which pro- vides a dynamic, instantaneous and simple method for assessing vocal fold contact and for examining the laryngeal behaviour of stutterers, has not been extensively applied to stuttering nor has it been used to evaluate the laryngeal behaviour pre- and post- intervention. The laryngographic tracings are obtained by placing two electrodes on either side of the thyroid cartilage. The output is derived from the voltage variations which result in the changing conductance of the vocal fold configurations. A potential application of the electrolaryngograph is as a means of examining laryngeal functioning following therapy which has been instituted specifically to modify vocal fold movement. One such therapy program, "Stutter Free Speech" (Shames and Flor- ance 1980) is designed to modify the phonatory behaviour of the speaker through continuous phonation. A further purpose of this Die Suid-Afrikaanse Tydskrif vir Kommunikasieafwykings, Vol. 32, 1985 METHODOLOGY The aim of the current study is to evaluate the change in a stut- terer's laryngeal behaviour following a therapy program designed to intervene at the level of phonation. The applicability of the elec- trolaryngograph as a measurement tool of laryngeal behaviour will also be considered. A single case study design was selected in accordance with Per- kins (1983) proposal that studies "with an Ν of 1" support the ten- dency away from hypothetical speculation and provide much needed empirical evidence. SUBJECT DESCRIPTION The subject, S, was a 31 year old male who had stuttered since early childhood. No family history of stuttering had been report- ed. S had received therapy previously but there had been no ob- servable change in his speech pattern. No previous history of laryngeal pathology had been noted. S presented as aPhase lV ad- vanced stutterer, According to Luper and M u l d e r s ( 1964) classifi- cation system. His speech pattern was charactered by severe blocks and hard contacts, tense repetitions and interjections of phonemic a i d non-phonemic utterances. Tension loci were identified as the Hps, tongue, laryngeal area and abdomen. Secondary behavtours © SASHA 1985 R ep ro du ce d by S ab in et G at ew ay u nd er li ce nc e gr an te d by th e P ub lis he r (d at ed 2 01 2) 46 Marlene Behrmann included eye blinking, head jerks, lip tremor and flaring of the nos- trils. Respiratory disturbances were evident in frequent pausing, gasping and speaking on residual air. Fluency facilitating techniques (utilised prior to the implementation of a therapy program) such as whispering, choral speaking and slowed speech produced a decrease in the frequency and severity of stuttering. S obtained a score of 12.9 on the Erikson S24 (1969) scale which suggests that he viewed himself in a positive light prior to intervention. PRE-INTERVENTION SPEECH ASSESSMENT The need for comprehensive assessment pre-intervention has been highlighted by Andrews, Guitar and Howie (1981). A pre- intervention percentage of syllables stuttered (%SS) and a mean syllable per minute (SPM) were computed in order to describe the frequency and severity of the stutter pattern. A sample of S's speech was collected including a spontaneous speech sample, a reading sample and a telephone call interchange. These varying conditions were included since Bloodstein (1975) contended that the stutter pattern varies under different circumstances. For the purposes of , this study, stuttering was defined as "any sound or syllable repeti- tion, block, prolongation or effortful emission of a word or syl- lable" (Ingham, Andrews and Winkler 1972). The pre-intervention %SS were 26,5%, 18,2% and31,4% for the three samples outlined above. These figures are suggestive of a se- vere stutter pattern in comparison with previous studies (Goldsmith and Anderson 1984) and support the classification of S as a Phase IV advanced stutterer. The mean SPM counts were 139,5, 132 and 123 for the three samples and are all slow compared with the norm of 196 SPM for normal speaking adult males (Andrews and Ingham 1971), thus confirming the diagnosis of a severe stutter pattern. The electrolaryngographic examination was conducted using a Uher 4200 report Stereo I.C. Tape Recorder with a M816 directional microphone to record the subject's spoken output while the Min- gograf inkjet recorder traced the laryngeal information. The sub- ject was seated in a comfortable position with the microphone at a distance of 30mm from the lips. Tracings were made on both a spontaneous speech sample and a reading sample. Owing to prac- tical difficulties the tracings could not be carried out during a tele- phone conversation. The dimensions for analysing the laryngographic tracings were selected to yield a comprehensive pic- ture of laryngeal functioning. Examples of the pre-intervention trac- ings are presented in Figures la and lb which reflect the spontaneous speech and reading samples respectively. a. Regularity of the wave - this dimension refers to the maintenance of a stable vibratory pattern which is achieved through the laryn- geal musculature and through air pressure control. Much variabil- ^ ^ ^ ^ — r ^ m i m ^ ^ - v w s / w v w · — ivvv-