AN INVESTIGATION INTO THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ANAEROBIC WORK CAPACITY, PERCENTAGE BODY FAT AND THE GRADE OF ASTHMA IN ASTHMATICS AND A HEALTHY CONTROL GROUP M Burger, M Geyer, W Regel, G M Smit, E Terblanche and J A Hendry* SUMMARY The goal of this study was to compare the anaerobic working capacity of asthmatic children to that of a healthy control group and to ascertain the relationship between the degree of asthma, anaerobic exercise and percentage body fat. A total of 41 children, 21 asthmatics and 20 healthy children (13-18 years) were tested. Three variables - percentage body fat, pulmonary function and fitness - were measured. It was found that there is very little difference between the asthmatic and the healthy child, with regard to anthropome­ tric measurements, fitness and anaerobic working capacity. A poor correlation was found between percentage body fat, pulmonary function and anaerobic working capacity. The results further showed that there is a slight correlation be­ tween the percentage body fat and anaerobic working ca­ pacity. This tendency can only be confirmed with a larger random sample of children. The researchers conclude that asthmatics, irrespective of the degree of asthma, are not restricted as far as anaerobic activities are concerned. They can therefore lead a normal healthy life and, as far as anaerobic exercise is concerned, can compete on equal terms with healthy children. INTRODUCTION T he physiotherapy profession is growing increasingly in te r­ ested in exercise-induced bronchospasm (E IB ) because eighty p e r­ cent of all asthm atics develop EIB . Most research deals with the cardio respiratory fitness o f as thm atics while most experimental groups consist o f patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease o r heterogeneous patients with obstructive airway disease2,3’4,5. T he researchers noted that th ere was a definite deficiency in the lite ratu re providing a well controlled study o f a hom ogeneous group of patients and an age- equivalent control group. The fact th at such a large percentage of children suffer from asthm a served as motivation fo r the use of schoolgoing children in this study. Since the anaerobic working capacity o f asthm atics had not been previously docum ented, the question arose w hether asthm atics suffered the sam e limitations with anaerobic exercise as with aerobic exercise. It was also not known w hether the degree of asthm a and the physical build were limiting factors for anaerobic working c apac­ ity. LITERATURE REVIEW A pproximately 18% o f all children, 18 years and younger. O PSOMM ING Die doel van die studie was om die anaerobiese werkkapasiteit van asmalyers en 'n gesonde kontrole groep te vergelyk en om die verband tussen die graad van asma, anaerobiese werkkapasiteit en persentasie liggaamsvet te ondersoek. ’n Totaal van 41 kinders (21 asmalyers en 20 gesonde kinders), tussen die ouderdom 13-18 jaar is getoets. Drie veranderlikes - persentasie liggaamsvet, pulmonere funksie en fiksheid - is ge- meet. Daar is min verskille t.o.v. antropometrie en fiksheid tussen die asmalyers en die gesonde kontrole groep gevind. Die anaerobiese werkkapasiteit van die asmalyers en die kontrole groep het nie verskil nie en daar was 'n swak korrelasie tussen die persentasie lig g a a m s v e t, p u lm o n e re fun ksie en a n a e ro b ie s e w e rkkap asiteit. Die resultate toon voorts dat daar ’n klein waarskynlikheid is dat daar ’n verband bestaan tussen persentasie liggaamsvet en an ­ aerobiese werkkapasiteit, asook dat asmalyers geneig is tot 'n hoer persentasie liggaamsvet. Hierdie tendens kan egter net met ’n groter steekproef bewys word. Die navorsers het tot die gevolgtrekking gekom dat asmalyers, ongeag die graad van asma, nie beperkinge ervaar t.o.v. anaero­ biese tipe aktiwiteite nie en dus met gesonde kinders op gelyke vlak kan kompeteer. experience some form of chronic respiratory dysfunction at som e stage. F o u r percent of these children a re asthm atics . A ccording to the literature 2 -6 % of the world population suffers from bronchial asthm a , while 6 0 -8 0 % of all asthm atics also suffer from EIB. From this it can be seen that at least 5% of the world 7 population of asthm atics also develops bronchospasm with exercise . In 1988 it was found that 6.5% o f whites and 3,5% o f coloureds - between 6 and 18 ^ycars - in the n o rth ern suburbs o f C ape Town suffered from EIB . M ost asthm atics develop a noticeable degree of bronchospasm as a result o f exercise, which greatly restricts their extram ural a c ti­ vities and sport and can lead to social and psychological problem s. Exercise induced bronchospasm (E IB ) is not related to age, sex o r the degree of asthma*. It is found in patients with o r w ithout a positive skin test. In som e asthm atics EIB is the only form o f asthm a which they experience. In 1976 it was found that, while a raised fitness level did not necessarily free the asthm atic from EIB, it could well lead to an improved physical work capacity7. In 1989 asthm atics (at age 25) were found to have a higher V O 2 maximum (maximal oxygen vol­ um e) and a norm al work capacity on maximum work loading if they had followed a regular exercise program m e from a early age (a p ­ proximately 10 years). This could be due to an e arlie r exposure to an exercise program m e o r to a higher m otivation . * M Burger, M Geyer, W Regel, G M Smit B S C in Physiotherapy I V 1990 E T erblanche Lecturer, D e partm ent o f Physiology, University o f Stellenbosch J A H endry Lecturer, D e partm ent o f Physiotherapy, University o f Stellenbosch Bladsy 28 Fisioterapie, Mei 1991, dee147 no 2 R ep ro du ce d by S ab in et G at ew ay u nd er li ce nc e gr an te d by th e P ub lis he r (d at ed 2 01 3. ) T o d a te nearly all research has been aim ed at the effect of aerobic exercise program m es on the cardiorespiratory function of p a tie n ts w ith c h ro n ic o b s tru c tiv e a irw a y d ise a s e . M o s t s tu d ie s h ave 1 0 1 1 1Z13shown the advantage o f exercise program m es ’ , while o th e r researchers have established a erobic exercise program m es to test cardiorespiratory fitness12,14. As far as can be ascertained, the anaerobic w ork capacity of asthm atics has not yet been studied. Since ordinary activities are mainly anaerobic in nature, it is im portant , to know how fa r a sth m a ­ tics a re lim ited with these. A cute asthm atics, fo r whom aerobic activities lead to severe bronchospasm , m ight possibly also benefit from anaerobic types o f activity. METHOD Hypothesis T he anaerobic w ork capacity o f asthm atics and non-asthm atics should not differ. T he correlation between the degree of asthm a and the anaerobic w ork capacity should indicate w hether asthm a as such is a limiting factor for physical activity. A naerobic exercise lasts less than 2 m inutes while exercise-induced asthm a only m anifests a fte r 6 minutes. Study structure A case controlled study was carried o ut on 41 white children (21 asthm atics and 20 healthy children) between the ages of 13 and 18 years, selected from 3 high schools in the n orthern suburbs of C ape Town by m eans o f a random test. T he test subjects had to comply with the following criteria: Cases: • M ale o r female • 13-18 years • Must a tte n d High Schools A,B o r C, which are representative o f high schools in the north ern suburbs o f C ape Town • G ra d e I, II, o r III asthm atics • O ne o r m ore asthm a attacks in the past 12 m onths • N o u p p e r airways diseases for at least 6 weeks before testing. Controls: • M ust a ttend High Schools A, B o r C, which a re representative of high schools in the north ern suburbs o f C ape Town • The sam e age, sex and height, ± 2 c m , a s th e te s t g ro u p . Figure 1: Grading of asthma according to dlnical history H e a lth y 20 G ra d e II 15 Procedure E ach prospective subject com pleted a clinical questionnaire from which the degree of asthm a was established (Figure 1). It was then decided w hether the subject satisfied the criteria fo r inclusion. Next, th ree variables w ere m easured, viz. percentage body fat, pulmonary functions and fitness. T he percentage body fat was d e term ined by anthropom etric m easurem ents, viz. height, m ass, bi-epicondylar m easurem ent and skinfolds. Spirom etric m easurem ents fo r determ ination o f forced expiratory volum e (F E V i), forced vital capacity (FV C ) and peak expiratory flow ra te (P E F R ) w ere carried o ut by m eans of a M innato A u tospiro before and a fte r a fitness test. T he fitness test consisted o f six isotonic exercises in the form of a circular program m e, i.e. sit-ups, upright bounces, push-ups, walk­ ing test, short runs and “b u rp e e s”. B ecause the a n aerobic work capacity was being m easured by high im pact isotonic exercise o f less than 2 m inutes duration, each exercise lasted only 30 seconds with a rest period of two m inutes betw een each station. F ifteen seconds a fte r th e subject com pleted a station, his/her pulse was taken fo r 30 seconds. RESULTS T he a n th ro p o m etric m easurem ents, spirom etry and fitness test yielded the following results. Anthropometry: T h e difference betw een the asthm atics and the control g ro u p ’s param eters was not statistically significant - specifically also n ot on the percentage body fat. Spirometry: All the pre-exercise values o f the asthm atics w ere low er than those o f the control children. T h e re w ere, however, two w hose values w e r e s ta tis tic a lly sig n ific a n tly lo w e r i.e. t h e v o lu m e re la tio n s h ip (F E V i/F V C % ) and the flow tim es 50 (F50) (T able 1). A fte r c o m ­ pletion o f the fitness test th ere was again a significant d ro p in the F E V i/F V C % and F50 of the asthm atics and also in th e ir F E V i (T able 2). TABLE 1: PRE-EXERCISE SPIROMETRY Asthma Control FEV1 2 .8 7 ± 0 .5 5 3 .1 8 + 0 .7 3 FVC 3 .5 9 ± 0.65 3 .6 8 -0 .8 5 FEVi/FVC%* 8 0 .1 0 ± 8 .0 8 86.61 ± 5 .1 0 PEFR 6 .6 5 ± 1 .3 0 6 .9 6 ± 1 .7 6 F50* 3.10 ± 0.98 4.07 ± 1.07 (M e a n ± sd) * p < 0.05 TABLE 2: SPIROMETRY AFTER EXERCISE (pre-post) Asthma Control FEVi -7 .5 5 ± 1 4 .00 0.68 ± 3 .3 6 FVC -5.31 ± 10.76 -1.33 ± 4 .2 7 FEV|/FVC%* -2.77 ± 6.19 2 .1 0 ± 2 .5 7 PEFR -8.80 ±17.54 -1.44 ± 8 .1 0 F50* -2 3 .3 0 ± 4 1 .04 1.00 ± 6 .4 4 (M e a n ± sd) p < 0.05 Six of the 21 asthm atics showed a d ro p o f m ore th an 10% in th eir F E V i a fte r the fitness test. They therefore had a positive response to exercise and could be considered to b e exercise-induced asthm atics. Fitness test: T he anaerobic work capacity was calculated by adding to g eth e r the total n um ber of a tte m p ts at all 6 stations and, while th ere w as no statistically significant difference, the asthm atics recorded few er a t ­ tem pts p e r exercise than the c o ntrol children. T he h e a r ra te of the asthm atics during the fitness test was uniformly higher than th at o f the c o ntrol children, indicating g re ater effort. T hese differences, however, w ere again not statistically signi­ ficant (F igure 2). Physiotherapy, May 1991, vol 41 no 2 Page 29 R ep ro du ce d by S ab in et G at ew ay u nd er li ce nc e gr an te d by th e P ub lis he r (d at ed 2 01 3. ) Boehringer Ingelheim nebulising solutions R ep ro du ce d by S ab in et G at ew ay u nd er li ce nc e gr an te d by th e P ub lis he r (d at ed 2 01 3. ) New—Atrovent Inhalant Solution Unit Pose Vials • Added always to your standard B2 solution • Precise dose every time • Simple and convenient • Preservative-free Bisolvon® solution • Reduces bronchial and nasal secretion viscosity • Facilitates mucocilliary transport and expectoration Boehringer /J A Inhalation Ingelheim Therapy Creating a better clim ate for your patients S2 S2 S2 Atrovent 0,025% Inhalant Solution. Each ml contains 0,250 mg ipratropium bromide Reg. No. Q /1 0.2.1/117 Atrovent U.D.V. 0,5 mg/2 ml Inhalant Solution. Each 2 ml contains 0,5 mg ipratropium bromide (preservative free) Reg. No. X /10.2.1/322 Bisolvon Solution Each 5 ml contains bromhexine HC110 mg Ref. No. G642 (Act 101/1965) For further information about these and our other products, please contact; Boehringer Ingelheim (Pty) Ltd Reg. No. (69/08619/07) Private Bag X3032, Randburg, 2125 SPEC TR U M 113122 R ep ro du ce d by S ab in et G at ew ay u nd er li ce nc e gr an te d by th e P ub lis he r (d at ed 2 01 3. ) PI 1964; 22:229-237. 2. M orton A R, Fitch KD, H ahn AG. Physical activity and the asthm atic. The Physician and Sports M edicine 1981; 6:51-64. 3. Marley WP. Asthm a and Exercise, a review. A m C o n T h erJ 1977 (July - August). 4. T erblanche E. Die voorkoms van oefeninp-geinduseerde brongospasma onder kinders en dieeffek daarvan o p hulle funksionelestatus. MSc Thesis, University o f Stellenbosch, 1988. 5. W alter R, F rontera MD, R ichard P, A dam s PD. E ndurance Exercise: Norm al Physiology and L im itations Imposed by Pathological Processes (P a rt 1). The Physician a n d Sports m edicine 1986; 14(8):94-104. 6. Tecklin JS. Physical T herapy fo r Children with C hronic Lung D isease. Phys Ther 1981; 61:1774-1781. 7. Fitch KD, Godfrey S. A sthm a and A thletic Perform ance. JA M A 1976; 236:152-157. 8. Khan AU, Olson D L. Physical Therapy and Exercise-Induced B ronchos­ pasm. Phys Ther 1975; 55:878-880. 9. Fridberg S, Bevegard S, G raff-Lonnevig V, H allback I. A sthm a from Bladsy 32 Fisioterapie, Mei 1991, deel 47 no 2 R ep ro du ce d by S ab in et G at ew ay u nd er li ce nc e gr an te d by th e P ub lis he r (d at ed 2 01 3. ) childhood until adulthood. A follow-up study of 20 subjects with special reference to work capacity and pulm onary gas exchange. J Allergy Clin Im m u n o l 1989; 84(2):183-190. 10. C hristie D. Physical training in chronic obstructive lung disease. B rM e d J 1968; 2:150-151. 11. C ockcroft A E, Saunders MJ, B erry G . R andom ised controlled trial of rehabilitation in chronic respiratory disability. Thorax 1981; 36:200- 203. 12. McGavin C R , G u pta SP, M cH ardy G JR . Twelve m inute walking test for assessing disability in chronic bronchitis. B r M e d J 1976; 1:822-823. 13. McGavin C R , G upta SP, Lloyd EL, M cH ardy G JR . Physical re habilita­ tion for the chronic bronchitic: results of a controlled trial of exercises in the hom e. Thorax 1977; 32:307-311. 14. Mungall 1PF, H ainsw orth R . A ssessm ent of respiratory function in patients with chronic obstructive airways disease. Thorax 1979; 34:254- 258. 15. Sly M R , H a rp e r R T , R osselot 1. T he effect of physical conditioning upon asthm atic children. A n n Allergy 1972; 30:86-94. 16. B ooker HA. Exercise Training a nd B reathing C ontrol in Patients with C hronic Airflow L im itations. Physiotherapy 1984; 70(7):258-260. CLASSIFIED ADVERTISEMENTS GEKLASSIFISEERDE ADVERTENSIES LOCUM AVAILABLE PLAASVERVANGER BESK1KBAAR Locum available for work in Durban, C a p e Town or Jo h a n ­ nesburg, from June to August 1991: full days. Telephone (031) 23-2308 (w), (031) 52-2198 (h). PRACTICES FOR SALE PRAKTYKE TE KOOP NOORDLIKE PRETORIA Praktyk te koop. Gevestigde praktyk in mediese sentrum. KONTAK: Hanneli Strasheim: Telefoon (012) 55-6759(w) (012) 57 -637 7(h). PRETORIA, EASTERN SUBURBS Well established practice for sale in this growing area! Fully eq uippe d - pleasant surroundings. CONTACT: Mrs A Bolsens (012) 64-2161 after hours. EQUIPMENT FOR SALE APPARAAT TE KOOP Bird Mark 8 Respirator plus various accessories (nebulisers, masks, oxygen regulator, instruction and various booklets etc.). Price: R2.800. CONTACT: Mr W P Roets (03931) 74225. BETHLEHEM Tru-Trac traksie, Medeci Interferensie, Ultraklank, Devilbiss, Minidyne. KONTAK: Kara Pellissier (01431) 32163. PREMISES TO LET PERSELE TE HUUR CAPE TOWN Consulting rooms to let in occupa tion al therapy practice in Kenilworth. CONTACT: Hilary Henderson (021) 61-7834 or (021) 61-5435. BRYANSTON M edical Suite available to share with dentist. Fully eq uip p e d an d staffed in Bryanston. CONTACT: Dr A van der Walt (011) 706-7704(w). NOTICES KENNISGEW1NGS CYRILDENE Freda Storger wishes to inform her colleagues that the te le ­ ph on e num ber that a p p e a re d in the new private practition- ers booklet is incorrect. The new telephone num ber is (011) 453-8176. Freda re­ spectfully asks all members to c h a n g e this num ber in their booklet. GRABOUW Jeanine van der Merwe wil g ra a g haar kollegas in kennis stel d a t sy haar praktyk g e o p e n het te Grabouw. Telefoon (024) 594603. COURSES KURSUSSE REFRESHER COURSE DATES: 1 3 - 3 0 May 1991 VENUE: Johannesburg Hospital, Physiotherapy Department ENQUIRIES: Miss P Blake (011) 488-3210, (011) 488-4210. ORTHO-PAEDIATRIC EXERCISES FOR BABIES Course in Johannesburg by Agnes W enham: “Physiotherapy for Mother an d Child". Limited to 6 participants. Tuesdays an d Thursdays 9.30 to 11.30, 6 August to 12 September 1991. Fee R600. 27 Sixth Avenue, Parktown North 2193. Telephone (011) 788-5028. ACUPUNCTURE COURSE MODULE 1 Presented by the Private Practitioners Association Northern Transvaal Branch VENUE: Jakaranda Hospital, Muckleneuk, Pretoria DATES: 15 an d 16 June 1991 FEES: SASP Members: R250: Non-Members R350. Please send your ap plication, together with the appropriate fe e to the Treasurer, P O Box 14513, Verwoerdburg 0140. ENQUIRIES: (012) 628-9654 or (012) 63-1638. THE HOLISTIC APPROACH TO THE KNEE JOINT Presented by Southern Transvaal DATES: 29 an d 30 June 1991 VENUE: Johannesburg Hospital Physiotherapy Department FEE: SASP Members: R250; Non-Members R350; Cancellation fee: R100. Limited to 40 participants Teas a n d lunches included. Please send your application, together with the appropriate fee to Caren Fleishman, 20 John Mackenzie Drive, Em- marentia 2195. ENQUIRIES: Caren Fleishman (011) 884-1981 (w) or Ian Seels (011) 442-7641 (h).A WORK IN THE UNITED STATES PHYSIOTHERAPISTS EXCELLENT JOBS We handle all licensure and visa paperwork. Minimum commitment of one year required. TRN fees paid by employer Write or phone collect: THERAPY RESOURCE NETWORK P O Box 5430 Plymouth, Michigan 48170, USA Phone (313) 455-6660 Physiotherapy, May 1991, vol 41 no 2 Page 33 R ep ro du ce d by S ab in et G at ew ay u nd er li ce nc e gr an te d by th e P ub lis he r (d at ed 2 01 3. )