CLINICAL & BASIC RESEARCH SQU Med J, November 2011, Vol. 11, Iss. 4, pp. 492-496, Epub. 25th Oct 11 Submitted 27th Apr 11 Revision Req. 18th Jul 11, Revision recd. 29th Jul 11 Accepted 24th Sep 11 السيطرة على املعلومات، الرعاية الصحية الفعالة، املمارسة املبنية على الدليل وجرّاح األنف واألذن واحلنجرة ديبا بهارجافا، يو�ضف ال�ضعيدي، كاملي�س بهارجافا، را�ضد العربي امللخ�ص: الهدف: درا�ضة �ضلوك احل�ضول على املعلومات لدى جّراحي الأنف والأذن واحلنجرة يف ُعمان، ورغبتهم للتعلم واكت�ضاب مهارات املمار�ضة املبنية على الدليل. الطريقة: اأجريت هذه الدرا�ضة املقطعية عرب توزيع ا�ضتبيان على 63 من اجلراحني العاملني بجراحة الأنف والأذن الأنف جلراحة وطنيا موؤمترا ح�ضورهم اأثناء ال�ضت�ضاري( اإىل املقيم من التخ�ض�س درجات خمتلف )ت�ضمل ُعمان يف واحلنجرة 10 عن تزيد خربة امل�ضاركني من %57 لدى وكان كامل، ا�ضتبيانا واأربعني ت�ضعة ا�ضتلم مت النتائج: .2010 يناير يف واحلنجرة �ضنوات، وكان 60% منهم يعملون يف م�ضت�ضفيات الرعاية الثالثية. ظهر باأن 38.8% منهم على اتفاق تام و 36.7% على اتفاق جزئي من اأكرث لدى كان للمر�ضى. فعالة �ضحية رعاية تقدمي وبالتايل الرعاية، نوعية حت�ضني �ضاأنها من الدليل على املبنية املمار�ضة باأن اأبدى الطبية. الرعاية اأداء اأثناء الأ�ضبوع يف اأكرث اأو �ضوؤال )11( 18.4% منهم لدى كان بينما الأ�ضبوع، يف اأ�ضئلة )1-5( %46.9 69.4% من اجلراحني ا�ضتعدادا لكت�ضاب مهارات ال�ضيطرة على املعلومات. كانت هناك علقة ارتباط اإح�ضائية بني عدد �ضنوات اخلربة، وعدد الأ�ضئلة، والرغبة يف اكت�ضاب مهارات ال�ضيطرة على املعلومات. اخلال�صة: تبني ازدياد اأهمية م�ضادر ال�ضبكة الدولية اأثناء املمار�ضة اكت�ضاب من التمكن ال�رسوري من اأنه يعتقدون ل ُعمان يف واحلنجرة الأنف جراحة يف العاملني اجلراحني معظم اليومية. ال�رسيرية مهارات املعلومات فح�ضب، بل اإن الرعاية ال�ضحية الفعالة تعتمد على هذه املهارات وعلى املمار�ضة املبنية على الدليل. واأظهر غالبية تقدمي على الخت�ضا�س بهذا اجلراحني مل�ضاعدة امل�ضتقبل يف حيوية �ضتكون املهارات هذه املهارات. هذه لكت�ضاب الرغبة امل�ضاركني حلول فعالة يف الرعاية ال�ضحية. مفتاح الكلمات: اإدارة املعلومات، رعاية �ضحية فعالة، ُعمان، طب مبني على الدليل، ممار�ضة قائمة على الدليل، ال�ضبكة الدولية. abstract: Objectives: The objectives of this study were to study the information-seeking behaviour of otolaryngologists in Oman, and their willingness to learn and acquire evidence-based practice (EBP) skills. Methods: A cross-sectional survey was carried out by distribution of a questionnaire to 63 otolaryngologists (ranging from residents to consultants) employed in Oman who attended a national otolaryngology meeting in January 2010. Results: Forty-nine completed questionnaires were received; 57% of the respondents had more than 10 years’ experience, and 60% were from tertiary care; 38.8% “totally agreed”, and 36.7% “partially agreed” that EBP would improve the quality of care and thus provide effective health care to patients. More than 46.9% had 1–5 questions per week, 18.4% had 11 or more questions per week at the point-of-care; 69.4% were willing to acquire information mastery skills. There was a statistical correlation between the number of years of experience, the number of questions, and willingness to acquire information mastery skills. Conclusion: In day-to-day clinical practice, web-based resources are of increasing significance. Most otolaryngologists in Oman not only believed that it is essential to acquire information mastery skills, but also that effective health care depends on such skills and on EBP. Most were willing to acquire these skills. In the future, these skills will be vital in helping otolaryngologists deliver effective health care solutions. Keywords: Information Management; Effective health care; Oman; Evidence-based medicine; Evidence-based practice; Internet; Point-of-care. Information Mastery, Effective Health Care, Evidence-Based Practice and the Otolaryngologist *Deepa Bhargava,1 Yousef Al-Saidi,1 Kamlesh Bhargava,2 Rashid Al-Abri1 CLINICAL & BASIC RESEARCH Departments of 1Surgery and 2Family Medicine & Public Health, Sultan Qaboos University Hospital, Muscat, Oman. *Corresponding Author email: deepaent@gmail.com Advances in Knowledge 1. In medical literature there are very few studies on information mastery in general and none in the field of otolaryngology. 2. The results of this study revealed that most otolaryngologists are aware of the relevance of information mastery, effective health care and Deepa Bhargava, Yousef Al-Saidi, Kamlesh Bhargava and Rashid Al-Abri Clinical and Basic Research | 493 The goal of medicine has always been to provide care to patients in a way that will help them live to their fullest capacity with the minimum amount of pain and discomfort. Not only has the identification of ways to provide better medical care improved, but also this information is coming to us at an accelerated pace. New treatments are constantly being found, and older approaches are continually becoming obsolete. Physicians and surgeons are being asked to retool their whole approach to information. Now they have to be information managers, continually learning and updating their approach to medical care as medical knowledge continues to evolve. Information mastery has been defined as “applied science that allows clinicians to harness resources in the information age”. It is a set of skills that will help medical professional be as up-to-date as their patients by obtaining the most valid and relevant information in the least amount of time.1 Information mastery was defined as: Usefulness of an information = Relevance x Validity Work The usefulness of any information is directly proportional to its relevance and its validity; however, if too much work is required to obtain that information its usefulness diminishes.1 Information mastery is an outgrowth of the movement towards evidence-based medicine (EBM), which first started in 1981.2 The constant increase in the body of medical knowledge is a source of frustration and anxiety amongst health professionals in general and medical students in particular. Every day new diagnostic tests and treatments are being introduced. Patients are also becoming better informed through the media and the Internet stimulating a new passion for life-long learning in academia, professional environments, work place and at home.3 There is a need for evidence-based knowledge at the point-of-care as most physicians and surgeons have unmet information needs, besides day-to- day clinical dilemmas and differences in opinions. Medical research continues to expand at an exponential rate. The task of clinicians striving to practice EBM medicine seems to be getting bigger with doctors increasingly having to rely on Internet- based resources.4 Today otolaryngologists are not expected to know everything, but should be able to access and assess information when required, to be information masters rather than encyclopedias of medical information. The aim of this study is therefore to examine the information-seeking behaviour and attitudes of otolaryngologists in Oman and the impact of information technology on their day-to- day practice. Methods This cross-sectional study was carried out in January 2010 at the annual meeting of otolaryngologists in Oman. All sixty-three otolaryngologists present were requested to participate in the study by completing a questionnaire which was distributed to them. The questionnaire was created and designed by two co-authors of this article (DB and KB). It comprised 4 sections and 15 statements/questions. Questions covered demographics (including number of years of experience); information mastery needs; availability of information mastery tools, and attitudes to information mastery and EBM. The questionnaire was subjected to internal and external validation. Internal validation included evidence-based practice (EBP) in day-to-day practice. 3. The knowledge that 69% would like to acquire skills for practising EBP would help in determining the educational needs of this cohort. 4. The study revealed a direct statistical correlation between otolaryngologists with less than 5 years clinical experience and a reluctance to acquire EBP skills; this cohort also had fewer questions arising from their day-to-day practice of otolaryngology. This needs to be addressed if effective health care is to be provided to patients in Oman by future otolaryngologists. Applications to Patient Care 1. This study showed that otolaryngologists, faced by information overload, lack of time, assessments of quality of care and patients informed by internet research, can improve their knowledge, the quality of their care, and protect themselves from litigation by acquiring information mastery skills. 2. Information mastery skills can help in solving day-to-day clinical dilemmas and differences of opinion, and meet currently unmet information needs at the point of patient care. Information Mastery, Effective Health Care, Evidence-Based Practice and the Otolaryngologist 494 | SQU Medical Journal, November 2011, Volume 11, Issue 4 piloting the questionnaire with four experts who analysed its linguistic, face, and content validity. Following internal validation, the questionnaire was edited and arranged in a logical, brief, simple, clear, concise, unambiguous and user-friendly format; unnecessary and repetitive questions were detected and deleted. The effectiveness of the questionnaire was determined by the survey itself and its reliability was found to be satisfactory. The data were analysed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS, Chicago, IL, USA, Version 16) and correlations were studied. The significant differences in the percentages between the groups were studied using the chi-square test. A P value (two tailed) of less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant. Results A total of 49 completed questionnaires were received. The demographic data is shown in Table 1. A total of 57% of respondents had more than 10 years experience, while 60% were from tertiary care. A total of 38.8% “totally agreed” and 36.7% “partially agreed” that EBP would improve the quality of care [Figure 1]. “Questions” were defined as questions which required the otolaryngologists to undertake further investigations during the care of a specific patient. More than 46.9% had 1-5 questions per week at the point-of-care; 18.4% had 11 or more questions per week. A significant finding was that 12% had less than one question per week; all these responders had less than 5 years of experience [Figure 2]. On the topic of information mastery skills, 69.4% of respondents were willing to acquire them. There was a statistical correlation between the number of years of experience, the number of questions, and willingness to acquire information mastery skills. These results reveal that more experienced otolaryngologists had higher information needs, and vice versa [Figure 3]. Discussion This study examined the impact of information technology, with a EBP focus, on the way otolaryngologists in Oman sought to answer clinical queries. Most of the otolaryngologists (75.5%) agreed partially or totally that the quality of health care depended on evidence at point-of-care and that EBP would improve the quality of care. It would have been interesting to know the thoughts of the respondents regarding factors other than EBP that influenced the quality of patient care, but that was outside the scope of the present study. There was a positive correlation between the number of years of experience and the number of questions which occurred each week. This finding is in contradiction to the expectation that lesser- experienced surgeons would have more questions. Some of the possible explanations for the junior otolaryngologists’ small number of weekly questions and low interest in developing information mastery skills could be lack of time, other priorities, a preoccupation with developing surgical skills and the need to study for examinations. This attitude 0 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% 50.0% Questions P e r c e n t < 1 per week 1-5 per week 6-10 per week 11 or more per week 12.2% 46.9% 22.5% 18.4% Figure 2: Number of questions arising in daily practice of otolaryngologists in Oman. 36.78 6.1218.37 36.73 totally agree totally disagree partially disagree partially agree Quality care and EBM Figure 1: Percentage response to question on belief that quality of care depends on evidence-based practice correlated to number of years experience. Deepa Bhargava, Yousef Al-Saidi, Kamlesh Bhargava and Rashid Al-Abri Clinical and Basic Research | 495 needs to be addressed in the interest of the quality of their education and patient care with the ultimate goal of enhancing their skills in both knowledge- acquisition and surgery. In a study carried out in 1994, Covell et al. found that physicians had two questions for every three patients seen, and that 40% of clinical questions raised during in-patient consultations were on medical facts.6 These findings appear similar to those found in the present study where more than 46.9% of respondents had 1-5 questions per week. Translating knowledge into practice can close the gap between good and best care. No matter what source we choose, we would like to spend the least amount of time and energy to find the best information.7 The problem with using clinical experience alone is its validity although certainly using one’s own experience to meet information needs involves minimal work. A study conducted in the USA showed that 49% of causes of family physician errors, as perceived by physicians, were due to a lack of knowledge about the medical aspects of the case.8 In another study, it was also found that family physicians do not pursue answers to 64% of their clinical questions, but when answers are pursued, they can be found for 80% questions.8 We have a very similar experience in our team as invariably as we have been able to retrieve answers to most of the clinical questions asked. The imperative of training junior doctors to utilise information technology resources competently was found to be a strongly held belief among responders in a somewhat similar study of paediatricians;9 however, the provision of access to online resources may not result in the application of EBM to patient care. In a survey of UK paediatricians carried out while they were on call, Riodan et al. found that very few of them used EBM resources to make on call decisions although they had access them.10 They concluded that a better utilisation of resources might be to train doctors to be ‘practitioners of EBM’ and so to know where to find preprocessed evidence and how to apply it— rather than be able to perform complex critical appraisal through training in clinical epidemiology. In a review of online evidence-based resources, Krupski et al. commented that the use of electronic databases of pre-appraised evidence can greatly expedite the search for high quality evidence. This can then be integrated with the patient’s individual circumstances to provide translational research at the point-of-care.11 The study had some limitations: the small number of otolaryngologists in Oman, and a limited representation of them at the meeting where the data was gathered. Another limitation was that the survey respondents ranged from junior to senior otolaryngologists. Conclusion In day-to-day clinical practice at the point- of-care, Internet resources are of increasing significance. In this study, most otolaryngologists believed that quality of care depended on EBP and information mastery skills. The number of clinical queries at the point-of-care was directly correlated to the number of years of clinical practice experience of the respondents. Most of the 0 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% Years experience P e r c e n t less than 1 year no EBP yes 1-5 years 6-10 years more than 10 years 2.0% 6.2% 10.2%12.2% 12.2% 44.4% 6.1% 6.1% Figure 3: Relationship between number of years of experience and willingness to acquire information mastery skills for evidence=based practice (EBP). Table 1: Demographic data on the survey respondents Demographic Category Percentage of respondents GRADE Consultants 37 Specialists 22 Postgraduate trainees 41 AGE GROUP >40 Years 57 < 40 Years 43 GENDER Female 47 Male 53 Information Mastery, Effective Health Care, Evidence-Based Practice and the Otolaryngologist 496 | SQU Medical Journal, November 2011, Volume 11, Issue 4 otolaryngologists surveyed were willing to acquire information mastery skills. The reluctance of junior otolaryngologists to acquire these skills in addition to surgical skills needs to be addressed. To address the ever changing world of medical knowledge and to keep up with the advances in medicine, we propose that otolaryngologists should incorporate into their practice the skills of information mastery in order to keep updated, and provide the best possible care thus improving the quality of care and the patients’ heath-related quality of life. c o n f l i c t o f i n t e r e s t The authors reported no conflict of interest. References 1. Shaughnessy AF, Slawson DC. Introduction to information mastery In: Rosser WW, Slawson DC, Shaughnessy AF, Eds. Information Mastery: Evidence-Based Family Medicine. 2nd ed. London: BC Decker Hamilton, 2004. Pp. 1–4. 2. Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics, McMaster University Health Science Center. How to read clinical journals: Why to read them and how to start reading them critically. Can Med Assoc J 1981; 124:555–8. 3. Sedory HSE. Internet platform for life long learning: A continuum of opportunity. Otolaryngol Clin North Am 2007; 40:1275–93. 4. Hurwitz SR, Slawson DC. Should we be teaching information management instead of evidence-based medicine? Clin Orthop Relat Res 2010; 10:468. 5. Slawson DC, Shaughnessy AF, Bennett JH. Becoming a medical information master: Feeling good about not knowing everything. J Fam Pract 1994; 38:505– 13. 6. Covell DG, Uman GC, Manning PR. Information needs in office practice: Are they being met? Ann Intern Med 1985; 103:596–9. 7. Ely JW, Levinson W, Elder NC, Mainous AG, Vinson DC. Perceived causes of family physicians’ errors. J Fam Prac 1995; 40:37–44. 8. Ely JW, Osheroff JA, Ebell MH, Bergus GR, Levy BT, Chambliss ML, et al. Analysis of questions asked by family doctors regarding patient care. BMJ 1999; 319:358–61. 9. Prendiville TW, Saunder J, Fitzsimons J. Information seeking behavior of paediatricians accessing web based resources. Arch Dis Child 2009; 94:633–5. 10. Riordan FAI, Boyle EM, Philips B. Best paediatric evidence; Is it accessible and used on call? Arch Dis Child 2004; 89:469–71. 11. Krupski TL, Dahm P, Fesperman SF, Schardt CM. How to perform a literature search J Urol 2008; 179:264–70.