key: cord-254121-soiloa5l
authors: Jani, Bhautesh Dinesh; Pell, Jill P; McGagh, Dylan; Liyanage, Harshana; Kelly, Dave; de Lusignan, Simon; Weatherburn, Christopher J; Burns, Ronnie; Sullivan, Frank M; Mair, Frances S
title: Recording COVID-19 consultations: review of symptoms, risk factors, and proposed SNOMED CT terms
date: 2020-08-26
journal: BJGP open
DOI: 10.3399/bjgpopen20x101125
sha: 
doc_id: 254121
cord_uid: soiloa5l

BACKGROUND: There is an urgent need for epidemiological research in primary care to develop risk assessment processes for patients presenting with COVID-19, but lack of a standardised approach to data collection is a significant barrier to implementation. AIM: To collate a list of relevant symptoms, assessment items, demographics, and lifestyle and health conditions associated with COVID-19, and match these data items with corresponding SNOMED CT clinical terms to support the development and implementation of consultation templates. DESIGN & SETTING: Published and preprint literature for systematic reviews, meta-analyses, and clinical guidelines describing the symptoms, assessment items, demographics, and/or lifestyle and health conditions associated with COVID-19 and its complications were reviewed. Corresponding clinical concepts from SNOMED CT, a widely used structured clinical vocabulary for electronic primary care health records, were identified. METHOD: Guidelines and published and unpublished reviews (N = 61) were utilised to collate a list of relevant data items for COVID-19 consultations. The NHS Digital SNOMED CT Browser was used to identify concept and descriptive identifiers. Key implementation challenges were conceptualised through a Normalisation Process Theory (NPT) lens. RESULTS: In total, 32 symptoms, eight demographic and lifestyle features, 25 health conditions, and 20 assessment items relevant to COVID-19 were identified, with proposed corresponding SNOMED CT concepts. These data items can be adapted into a consultation template for COVID-19. Key implementation challenges include: 1) engaging with key stakeholders to achieve ’buy in’; and 2) ensuring any template is usable within practice settings. CONCLUSION: Consultation templates for COVID-19 are needed to standardise data collection, facilitate research and learning, and potentially improve quality of care for COVID-19.

The COVID-19 pandemic is an unprecedented global health challenge. Understanding of the epidemiology and clinical features of COVID-19 is rapidly evolving. New evidence is constantly emerging, with articles being published or uploaded on preprint servers regularly and various public health bodies, nationally and internationally, releasing their respective guidelines.

COVID-19 consultations in primary care are further complicated by contextual factors. In the UK, most of the consultations for patients with COVID-19 related symptoms are conducted remotely. [1] [2] [3] This usually involves more than one screen being used at the same time, which makes it challenging for GPs to accurately recall and record all relevant clinical features during their consultation with patients with suspected COVID-19 symptoms. When the consultation is in-person in the surgery, personal protective equipment (PPE) restricts normal recording patterns, and this is even worse during home visits.

Good quality epidemiological studies are urgently needed to understand COVID-19. 4 Most of the epidemiological studies until now have been conducted in secondary care. 5 There is an urgent need for high-quality primary care epidemiological studies for COVID-19. Recently, the use of COVID-19 specific codes have been recommended but these codes mainly cover process measures and diagnostic terms, not clinical presentation features such as symptoms and assessment. 6, 7 Previous research has suggested that only 37% of clinical problems were coded in primary care records. 8 Underreporting of relevant clinical features for COVID-19 in primary care is likely during COVID-19 related consultations, which will be a significant hindrance for high quality primary care research. A computerised, conditionspecific template has previously been shown to improve the quality of care and recording in primary care, and it could be implemented for COVID-19. 9 The aim of this study was to collate a list of relevant symptoms, assessment items, demographics, and lifestyle and health conditions associated with COVID-19 and its complications, and match these data items with proposed examples of corresponding SNOMED CT clinical terms, which will support the development and implementation of primary care consultation templates. The clinical utility of any template developed based on this work will be to help clinicians record consultations for patients presenting with suspected COVID-19 related symptoms in primary care.

The review of clinical terms involved three distinct stages: 1) search of clinical guidelines, and published and preprint literature to collate the list of relevant clinical data items for COVID-19 consultation; 2) identify examples of corresponding SNOMED CT codes that map to the identified clinical data items; and 3) conceptualise implementation challenges through an NPT lens.

The authors searched PubMed, the preprint server medRxiv, and centre for evidence-based medicine websites for reviews using 'COVID-19' as a keyword on 14 May 2020 . The PubMed search resulted in 963 articles, while 548 articles were found on preprint server medRxiv. The inclusion criteria were systematic reviews and meta-analyses relating to symptoms, sociodemographic and lifestyle factors, past medical history, and assessment of COVID-19 . As the focus was related to primary care assessment, reviews relating to blood tests and imaging for COVID-19 were excluded. Twentyone systematic reviews on preprint servers and 24 published systematic reviews from PubMed were identified. The authors searched for COVID-19 related guidelines on Public Health England, Health Protection Scotland, Public Health Wales, British Medical Journal (BMJ), Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP), National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), and World Health Organization (WHO) websites. Sixteen clinical guidelines were considered for collating the list of COVID-19 consultation data items described above.

SNOMED CT is the most comprehensive structured clinical terminology in use around the world and can be used in electronic health records (http://www. snomed. org/ snomed-ct/ why-snomed-ct). This international clinical terminology has been implemented across various health and care settings, including primary and secondary care. Principles outlined in Data Quality Guidance: Transitioning from Read to SNOMED CT by NHS Digital were used for choosing examples of proposed SNOMED CT clinical terms. 10 First, the authors referred to appropriate SNOMED hierarchies, for example, 'disorders' or 'situation' for recording health conditions, and 'finding' or 'observable entity' for recording symptoms and signs. Only SNOMED CT codes that had equivalent Read codes were considered, as Read codes are still in use in general practice in Scotland. Codes that were regarded as 'inactive' and no longer in use were also excluded. SNOMED CT UK edition (version 20200415) was interrogated by the NHS Digital web browser to search for terms and identifiers for each of the clinical data items identified from the previous step. Additionally, the SNOMED CT code identified was matched to the corresponding Read version 2 codes using NHS Digital browser. 11 Table 1 Symptoms and assessment items relevant for COVID-19 primary care consultation with respective SNOMED CT concept identifiers Symptoms (with respective SNOMED CT concept identifiers)

Primary care assessment (with respective SNOMED CT concept identifiers) Conceptualising implementation of consultation template GP consultation templates are often viewed as less patient-centred and potentially disruptive to communication. 12 The majority of existing consultation templates are used for management of longterm conditions; however, they have also been used for recording management of acute infections. 13 Widespread adaptation of a template in a short timeframe can provide significant implementation challenges. An NPT lens was used to conceptualise these challenges and corresponding key strategies to deal with those challenges. 14

In total, searches identified 32 symptoms associated with COVID-19 presentation from 10 guidelines, 1,3,15-22 13 published reviews, 23-35 and 12 preprint reviews. [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] See Table 1 for the list of symptoms and proposed corresponding SNOMED CT codes. The symptoms of COVID-19 were heterogenous in nature and included flu-like; respiratory; gastrointestinal; central nervous system; ear, nose, and throat; and eye symptoms reported in the literature.

The clinical domain of primary care assessment for COVID-19 had the least number of supporting reviews (two preprint reviews) 39, 48 and the majority of the data items included were on the basis of clinical guidelines, [1] [2] [3] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] 49, 50 which in turn were based on expert opinions ( Table 1 ). The data items included for COVID-19 assessment were based on data items validated for general practice consultations, but not specifically for COVID-19 (for example, telephone consultation for suspected sepsis 49 and use of the NEWS2 tool 1 ).

Demographic factors (age, sex, and ethnicity) were reported to be relevant for COVID-19 susceptibility and complications by two guidelines, 15,20 10 published reviews, 5, 25, 26, 28, 30, 33, [51] [52] [53] [54] and seven preprint reviews. 37, 43, [55] [56] [57] [58] [59] Lifestyle factors (working, smoking, and body mass index) were reported to be relevant for COVID-19 related assessment by two guidelines, 15,20 one published review, 51 and seven preprint reviews. 37, 43, [55] [56] [57] 59, 60 Individuals working in the health profession were regarded as high risk by one guideline. 20 See Table 2 for the list of relevant demographics and lifestyle factors, and examples of corresponding SNOMED CT codes (apart from clinical terms for age and sex, which are usually recorded in all primary care records).

In total, 25 health conditions were identified with COVID-19 vulnerability and/or complications, reported by two guidelines, 15,20 16 published reviews 5, [25] [26] [27] [28] [30] [31] [32] [33] 54, [61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] and 10 preprint reviews. 37, 39, 42, 45, 47, 57, 59, 60, 67, 68 The list of conditions included the 'high-risk' or 'extremely vulnerable from COVID-19' criteria based on guidelines issued by Public Health England and Health Protection Scotland. 69, 70 The list included a breadth of conditions ranging from cardiovascular, respiratory, immunosuppressed conditions, and previous cancer (see Table 2 for the list of medical conditions and the proposed examples of corresponding SNOMED CT codes). The mapping Read version 2 codes for the SNOMED CT codes identified are listed in Supplementary file Tables S1-4.

There is an extensive literature regarding barriers and facilitators to digital health implementation. 71 This literature has demonstrated the importance of considering implementation issues whenever introducing any new digital health system, including those relating to electronic medical record systems. 72 While electronic medical record systems are fully integrated within general practice in the UK, changes to functionality or uptake and utilisation of new templates within electronic medical record systems may not become widespread unless potential barriers or facilitators to use are considered. 73 NPT is a theory of implementation that has been used extensively over the last decade to understand how new service innovations, particularly digital health innovations, can become embedded and implemented, or not, as part of routine practice. 14 It suggests the need to consider issues relating to: coherence, how people make sense of a new way of working; cognitive participation, the engagement work required to get people to 'buy into' adopting a new way of working; collective action, the work of operationalising a new digital tool; and reflexive monitoring, the work of appraising, judging, or adapting a new digital innovation. There is evidence that considering and addressing such issues at the start of any new digital intervention will enhance the likelihood of routine embedding as part of normal practice. Table 3 outlines key issues that should be addressed in order to enhance uptake and utilisation of any new COVID-19 template. As a proof of concept, a COVID-19 consultation Table 3 Key Normalisation Process Theory-informed implementation issues to consider when introducing a new COVID-19 template Coherence Ensuring that potential users are aware of the new template and that they understand the rationale for trying to promote utilisation with every COVID-19 patient.

Engagement with users will be key to ensure they will invest time using the template.

Ensuring that the use of the template should assist primary care clinicians in recording relevant clinical items rather than act as a hindrance or source of additional work.

Ensuring users are clear that the items included in the template are evidence based and that it is clinically worthwhile to record the data items within the template. Champions within the GP workforce can be valuable to promote uptake.

Collective action Any template needs to be easy to navigate and use. A template that is too time-consuming to complete is unlikely to achieve widespread utilisation. Consequently, any template needs to be embedded in the currently used electronic medical record system.

Providing feedback to users regarding data collected from the template will enable them to see the potential benefits and learning that can be gained through use of the template. Providing a mechanism to allow iterative feedback so that the template can be improved in line with user comments would also be important.

template prototype using data items relevant for symptoms and assessment was developed at a practice level in EMIS (Figure 1) . Such consultation template prototypes may have to be modified after operationalisation, based on user feedback.

The authors identified 32 symptoms, 20 assessment items, eight demographic and lifestyle features, and 25 health conditions relevant for recording in COVID-19 primary care consultations. The supporting evidence base for these data items comprised of 16 clinical guidelines, 24 published, and 21 unpublished systematic reviews. The authors propose examples of corresponding clinical terms for all clinical data items from the SNOMED CT browser, which can be used to develop consultation templates for different primary care IT system providers. The authors also discuss the likely implementation challenges and potential solutions for large scale roll out of a COVID-19 consultation template. The contents of any COVID-19 consultation template may have to be adapted in future as knowledge and understanding evolves.

This is the first study to collate a list of relevant clinical items and corresponding clinical terms for COVID-19 consultation. The search for preprint servers enabled the authors to include the most upto-date evidence, with the caveat that these platforms publish rapid non-peer reviewed literature. This study also outlines an implementation blueprint using a well-known theoretical framework for complex interventions.

There are several limitations. First, the authors did not employ a systematic search strategy for the literature review, and did not conduct a quality appraisal of the included studies as these were not the objectives of this study. The study objective was to facilitate standardised data collection, which in turn can lead to high quality research and strengthen the evidence base. Several data items were included from preprint studies that have not undergone the scrutiny of peer review, and future evidence may suggest that recording of these data items is not necessary for risk assessment in primary care.

Implementation of a COVID-19 consultation template is likely to face similar challenges to those observed with implementation of other general practice consultation templates. The previous positive experiences with the use of a template have included providing a structured consultation and being more comprehensive, while the use of a template has also been perceived as less patient-centred and more focused on a biomedical agenda. 12, 74, 75 The uptake of a template in clinical practice is not likely to be universal; clinicians may need prompting and the template may require reinforcing to improve utilisation. 13 There have been very few primary care-based studies of COVID-19, and these studies have not been able to report on symptoms or assessment due to inconsistencies in recording of symptoms in primary care. 76, 77 Implications for research and practice

The list of clinical terms can lead to the development of COVID-19 consultation templates, which in turn will help with standardised data collection and high quality research. A consultation template can potentially help with quality of clinical care and record keeping by facilitating comprehensive coverage of various clinical domains relevant to COVID-19. 78 The use of a consultation template along with coding of other process measures included in the recently published ontology 79 and SNOMED CT codes on COVID-19 released by NHS Digital 80 can also help with disease surveillance. Several data items related to demographics, lifestyle, and past medical history may already be recorded in patient's existing primary care records. These items are still included in the template as they will be relevant in out-of-hours settings where this information may not be readily available. The authors acknowledge that the codes presented are only examples for recording the relevant clinical data items. In practice, there are often multiple ways of recording a single data item and previous research has suggested evidence of considerable heterogeneity in SNOMED CT coding. 81, 82 A professional consensus exercise will be needed among clinician users to agree on appropriate SNOMED CT clinical terms. The use of a COVID-19 consultation template has the potential to offer consistency in data collection, albeit with some variations in codes used to record clinical data items.

There are no funders to report for this article.

No ethical approval was required.

Freely submitted; externally peer reviewed.

SdeL is Director of the Royal College of General Practitioners, Research and Surveillance Centre (English national surveillance system). SdeL has received commercial funding for investigator led research, and belongs to advisory boards, but not related to COVID-19 and all through his university.

Date of onset of symptoms SCTID

Fatigue-symptom (finding) SCTID: 272060000 (common)

Has a sore throat SCTID: 162388002 (common)

Bloodstained sputum SCTID 61281005

Diarrhoea SCTID: 62315008 24. Abdominal pain SCTID: 21522001 25. Gastrointestinal haemorrhage SCTID: 74474003 26. Nasal symptoms SCTID

nasal congestion SCTID: 272034001 29. Respiratory symptom SCTID: 161920001 30

Rockwood Clinical Frailty Scale SCTID: 445414007 2. Dyspnoea on exertion SCTID: 60845006 3. Breathless at rest (finding) SCTID

Ability to perform activities of everyday life SCTID: 284545001 5. Unable to climb stairs SCTID: 165247006 6. Normal fluid intake SCTID: 161843009 7

Anuria (finding) SCTID: 2472002 10. Unable to stand (finding

Peripheral oxygen saturation SCTID

O/E = on examination. SCTID = SNOMED CT Identifier References 1. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. COVID-19 rapid guideline: managing suspected or confirmed pneumonia in adults in the community

Covid-19: a remote assessment in primary care

Guide to triaging patients with potential symptoms

Defining the epidemiology of Covid-19 -studies needed

Prediction models for diagnosis and prognosis of covid-19 infection: systematic review and critical appraisal

To monitor the COVID-19 pandemic we need better quality primary care data

COVID-19 coding in primary care

The content of general practice consultations: cross-sectional study based on video recordings

Computerized condition-specific templates for improving care of geriatric syndromes in a primary care setting

Data Quality Guidance: transitioning from Read to SNOMED CT. Version 5

Read v2 to SNOMED CT mapping lookup

Computer templates in chronic disease management: ethnographic case study in general practice

Improving assessment of children with suspected respiratory tract infection in general practice

Using Normalization Process Theory in feasibility studies and process evaluations of complex healthcare interventions: a systematic review

COVID-19)

COVID-19: investigation and initial clinical management of possible cases

COVID-19) INTERIM guidance for primary care management of patients presenting to primary care

Coronavirus disease 2019 (covid-19): a guide for UK GPs

COVID-19 Scottish primary care hub triage guide

International Severe Acute Respiratory and Emerging Infection ConsortiumCase record form instructions: severe acute respiratory infection clinical characterisation data tools

Assessment of COVID-19 in primary care

Signs and symptoms to determine if a patient presenting in primary care or hospital outpatient settings has COVID-19 disease

Systematic review of COVID-19 in children shows milder cases and a better prognosis than adults

Prevalence and severity of corona virus disease 2019 (COVID-19): a systematic review and meta-analysis

Risk factors of critical & mortal COVID-19 cases: a systematic literature review and meta-analysis

Imaging and clinical features of patients with 2019 novel coronavirus SARS-CoV-2: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Outcome of coronavirus spectrum infections (SARS, MERS, COVID 1 -19) during pregnancy: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Clinical characteristics of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) in China: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Gastrointestinal manifestations of SARS-CoV-2 infection and virus load in fecal samples from a Hong Kong cohort: systematic review and meta-analysis

Coronavirus disease 2019 during pregnancy: a systematic review of reported cases

Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) infection in children and adolescents: a systematic review

A systematic scoping review of COVID-19 during pregnancy and childbirth

Latin American Network of Coronavirus Disease 2019-COVID-19 Research. Clinical, laboratory and imaging features of COVID-19: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Clinical presentation of COVID-19: a systematic review focusing on upper airway symptoms

Central nervous system manifestations of COVID-19: a systematic review

Clinical manifestations of children with COVID-19: a systematic review

Risk factors for mortality in patients with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) infection: a systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies

In patients of COVID-19, what are the symptoms and clinical features of mild and moderate cases

What clinical features or scoring system, if any, might best predict a benefit from hospital admission for patients with COVID-19?

COVID-19 infection during pregnancy: a systematic review to summarize possible symptoms, treatments, and pregnancy outcomes

Clinical characteristics of COVID-19 infection in pregnant women: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Case fatality rate in COVID-19: a systematic review and metaanalysis

Risk factors for severe corona virus disease 2019 (COVID-19) patients : a systematic review and meta analysis

Clinical and paraclinical characteristics of COVID-19 patients: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Laboratory findings, signs and symptoms, clinical outcomes of patients with COVID-19 infection: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis

Comparison of severe and non-severe COVID-19 pneumonia: review and metaanalysis

Systematic review and meta-analysis of predictive symptoms and comorbidities for severe COVID-19 infection

NEWS (or NEWS2) score when assessing possible COVID-19 patients in primary care?

GP/ OOH telephone triage sepsis tool

COVID-19 evidence summary clinical management

COVID-19 and smoking: a systematic review of the evidence

A systematic review of COVID-19 epidemiology based on current evidence

Clinical characteristics and diagnostic challenges of pediatric COVID-19: a systematic review and meta-analysis

How is immunosuppressive status affecting children and adults in SARS-CoV-2 infection? A systematic review

COVID-19-related mortality by age groups in Europe: a meta-analysis

Smoking is associated with COVID-19 progression: a meta-analysis

The relationship of COVID-19 severity with cardiovascular disease and its traditional risk factors: a systematic review and meta-analysis

COVID-19 clinical characteristics, and sex-specific risk of mortality: systematic review and meta-analysis

Incidence, clinical characteristics and prognostic factor of patients with COVID-19: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Prevalence, severity and mortality associated with COPD and smoking in patients with COVID-19: a rapid systematic review and meta-analysis

Associations between immune-suppressive and stimulating drugs and novel COVID-19-a systematic review of current evidence

Does comorbidity increase the risk of patients with COVID-19: evidence from metaanalysis

Prevalence of underlying diseases in hospitalized patients with COVID-19: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Arterial hypertension and risk of death in patients with COVID-19 infection: systematic review and meta-analysis

Prevalence of comorbidities and its effects in patients infected with SARS-CoV-2: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Diabetes mellitus is associated with increased mortality and severity of disease in COVID-19 pneumonia -a systematic review, meta-analysis, and meta-regression

Cardiovascular diseases burden in COVID-19: systematic review and meta-analysis

Effects of hypertension, diabetes and coronary heart disease on COVID-19 diseases severity: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Guidance on shielding and protecting people who are clinically extremely vulnerable from COVID-19

Search criteria for highest risk patients for shielding

Factors that promote or inhibit the implementation of e-health systems: an explanatory systematic review

Implementation and adoption of nationwide electronic health records in secondary care in England: final qualitative results from prospective national evaluation in "early adopter" hospitals

A study of general practitioners' perspectives on electronic medical records systems in NHSScotland

Effects of exam room EHR use on doctor-patient communication: a systematic literature review

A computer template to enhance patient-centredness in multimorbidity reviews: a qualitative evaluation in primary care

Risk factors for SARS-CoV-2 among patients in the Oxford Royal College of General Practitioners Research and Surveillance Centre primary care network: a cross-sectional study

OpenSAFELY: factors associated with COVID-19-related hospital death in the linked electronic health records of 17 million adult NHS patients

A learning health care system using computer-aided diagnosis

COVID-19 surveillance ontology

COVID-19 SNOMED CT codes by groups 20200401v1.0

Comparing heterogeneous SNOMED CT coding of clinical research concepts by examining normalized expressions

Variation of SNOMED CT coding of clinical research concepts among coding experts