








key: cord-009688-kjx6cvzh
authors: Zhao, Ze-Yu; Chen, Qi; Zhao, Bin; Hannah, Mikah Ngwanguong; Wang, Ning; Wang, Yu-Xin; Xuan, Xian-Fa; Rui, Jia; Chu, Mei-Jie; Yu, Shan-Shan; Wang, Yao; Liu, Xing-Chun; An, Ran; Pan, Li-Li; Chiang, Yi-Chen; Su, Yan-Hua; Zhao, Ben-Hua; Chen, Tian-Mu
title: Relative transmissibility of shigellosis among male and female individuals: a modeling study in Hubei Province, China
date: 2020-04-17
journal: Infect Dis Poverty
DOI: 10.1186/s40249-020-00654-x
sha: 
doc_id: 9688
cord_uid: kjx6cvzh

BACKGROUND: Developing countries exhibit a high disease burden from shigellosis. Owing to the different incidences in males and females, this study aims to analyze the features involved in the transmission of shigellosis among male (subscript m) and female (subscript f) individuals using a newly developed sex-based model. METHODS: The data of reported shigellosis cases were collected from the China Information System for Disease Control and Prevention in Hubei Province from 2005 to 2017. A sex-based Susceptible–Exposed–Infectious/Asymptomatic–Recovered (SEIAR) model was applied to explore the dataset, and a sex-age-based SEIAR model was applied in 2010 to explore the sex- and age-specific transmissions. RESULTS: From 2005 to 2017, 130 770 shigellosis cases (including 73 981 male and 56 789 female cases) were reported in Hubei Province. The SEIAR model exhibited a significant fitting effect with the shigellosis data (P < 0.001). The median values of the shigellosis transmission were 2.3225 × 10(8) for SAR(mm) (secondary attack rate from male to male), 2.5729 × 10(8) for SAR(mf), 2.7630 × 10(-8) for SAR(fm), and 2.1061 × 10(-8) for SAR(ff). The top five mean values of the transmission relative rate in 2010 (where the subscript 1 was defined as male and age ≤ 5 years, 2 was male and age 6 to 59 years, 3 was male and age ≥ 60 years, 4 was female and age ≤ 5 years, 5 was female and age 6 to 59 years, and 6 was male and age ≥ 60 years) were 5.76 × 10(-8) for β(61), 5.32 × 10(-8) for β(31), 4.01 × 10(-8) for β(34), 7.52 × 10(-9) for β(62), and 6.04 × 10(-9) for β(64). CONCLUSIONS: The transmissibility of shigellosis differed among male and female individuals. The transmissibility between the genders was higher than that within the genders, particularly female-to-male transmission. The most important route in children (age ≤ 5 years) was transmission from the elderly (age ≥ 60 years). Therefore, the greatest interventions should be applied in females and the elderly.

old [1] . According to the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention (China CDC), approximately 150 000 to 450 000 cases were reported annually within the period 2005 to 2014 [2] . Although there have been an improvement in the quality of water and sanitation, shigellosis remains a major public health problem in several developing countries, including China [3, 4] .

Bacillary dysentery is an infectious intestinal disease that can be transmitted via the consumption of contaminated food or water [5] . Humans are the only natural host for Shigella spp.. In recent years, numerous reports have demonstrated that the incidence of shigellosis within males is higher than that within females [6] [7] [8] . The incidence of shigellosis, a water/food born disease, is directly related to the hygiene behaviours such as regular hand washing [9] . A study has indicated that the sanitary state in females is always higher than that in males [10] . Does this mean that the transmission features differ between male and female? A study has reported that shigellosis primarily occurs from person-toperson [1] . Thus, the water/food-to-person route has been interrupted. Moreover, many studies have indicated different incidences in individuals of various ages [1, 8, 11] . In this study, we aimed to explore the interpersonal transmission further.

In model studies of shigellosis, the distribution of time and space has been a greater focus than population-based research [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] . A study demonstrated that the Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious/Asymptomatic-Recovered-Water/Food (SEIARW) model exhibited a significant fitting effect with outbreak data in a school [17] . However, it did not estimate the transmissibility of bacillary dysentery between males and females. Considering that water makes less of a contribution in the transmission, a sex-based Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious/Asymptomatic-Recovered (SEIAR) model was applied to explore the dataset from Hubei Province. The secondary attack rate (SAR), which is defined as the probability of an infected person infecting a susceptible person during his or her entire infectious period, was adopted to assess the relative transmissibility of shigellosis between males and females. In this study, shigellosis cases reported in Hubei Province, China, were collected. The SEIAR model was applied to fit the data, calculate the related index, and determine the transmissibility of shigellosis between males and females. With the aim of exploring the transmission features in different gender and age groups, the SEIAR model was adopted to fit the data of shigellosis cases reported from 2005 to 2017 in Hubei Province, China.

A mathematical study was implemented using a sexand age-based model to analyze the transmission characteristics of reported shigellosis cases in Hubei Province, China, from 2005 to 2017. In this study, we divided the research process into three parts (Fig. 1) . First, we developed the model according to the natural history and transmission mechanism in different genders. Second, we acquired the model parameters by reference and curve fitting. Finally, we adopted indicators to estimate the transmissibility in different genders and to explore the transmission features in different age groups further.

The dataset of the shigellosis cases was collected from the China Information System for Disease Control and Prevention in Hubei Province from 2005 to 2017. The dataset included gender, age, occupation, address, date of onset, and date of diagnosis. In this study, people were divided into two groups according to gender. The information of the population, such as the birth rate, death rate and total population were obtained from the Hubei Statistical Yearbook.

The SEIAR model was developed according to the natural history of shigellosis among male and female individuals (Fig. 2) . We used the subscripts m to represent male and f to represent female. The pattern followed by the model was person to person, which consisted of susceptible (S m , S f ), exposed (E m , E f ), symptomatic (I m , I f ), asymptomatic (A m , A f ) and recovered (R m , R f ) individuals. Definitions of the epidemiological classes are summarized in Table 1 . In the model, we assumed that: a) Susceptible individuals of different genders become infected by contact with infected/asymptomatic people. b) The relative rate of transmission among male and female individuals is β mm and β ff , respectively. c) The relative rate of transmission from male to female is β mf and from female to male is β fm .

Moreover, we assumed that in both male and female:

a) The disease does not spread vertically, and individuals born in various groups are all susceptible. The natural birth rate is br and the natural mortality rate is dr. b) According to a new review [1] , the transmission of shigellosis mainly occurs from person-to-person. Meanwhile, our pilot study indicated a minor contribution of water/food (Additional file 1). Therefore, we assumed that the water/food to person transmission route had been cut off. c) The (1-p) E (0 ≤ p ≤ 1) number of exposed individuals will change to infected person I following an incubation period, while a further pE number of exposed individuals will become asymptomatic person A following a latent period (the period during which the exposed individuals become an asymptomatic person). d) The removal speed from I and A is positively proportional to the number of people in both groups, and the proportional coefficients are γ and γ', respectively, whereas 1/γ and 1/γ' are the infectious period of I and A. e) The infected person will die as a result of the disease and the case fatality rate is f.

The model is expressed as follows: 

The left side of the equation indicates the instantaneous rate of change of S, E, I, A and R at time t. In the model, the SAR was calculated as follows:

Considering that the transmissibility could relate to different ages (we considered three age groups based on the age distribution of the reported shigellosis incidences in the province), we divided individuals into six groups. The subscript 1 was defined as male and age ≤ 5 years, 2 was male and age 6 to 59 years, 3 was male and age ≥ 60 years, 4 was female and age ≤ 5 years, 5 was female and age 6 to 59 years, and 6 was male and age ≥ 60 years. Thereafter, we constructed a sex-age-based SEIAR model. We calculated the ratios x, y, and z (from the results of sex-based SEIAR model) in four transmission routes of the different genders to increase the reliability of the estimated parameters. We set β ff as β 0 and 

The framework is presented in Fig. 3 and its equation is provided in Additional file 2. According to the reported incidence of shigellosis from 2005 to 2017 in Hubei Province, we selected the year 2010 to quantify the transmissibility in the different sex and age groups (Fig. 4a) . Meanwhile, we compared Wuhan City with Yichang City based on the different incidence in both cities of Hubei Province in 2010 (Fig. 4b) .

According to the epidemiological characteristics of shigellosis and our previous study [17] , we set k and γ' as 0.3125 and 0.0286, respectively. The proportions of asymptomatic individuals were reported to range from 0.0037 to 0.2700 [18] [19] [20] . We set p = 0.1 in the SEIAR model. The incubation of shigellosis was reported to range from 1 to 3 days [21] [22] [23] . Therefore, we set ω as 0.3333 to 1.000. The symptoms generally last for 1 week, but certain people may experience symptoms for several weeks [24, 25] . We assumed the course of the disease was up to 3 weeks. Therefore, we set γ as 0.0477 to 0.1428. The fatality rate of the disease reported in a study decreased from 0.00088 to 0.00031 from 1991 to 2000 [26] . Considering that the fatality rate of shigellosis is extremely low [27] , we set f = 0. The values of β mm , β ff , β mf and β fm were generated by curve fitting using the SEIAR model and the reported shigellosis data. The definitions, ranges and sources of the parameters are displayed in Table 2 .

We performed a "knock-out" simulation to explore the roles of the different β values. The theory of the "knockout" simulation was come from originates from the gene "knock-out" technique (an experimental technique used in genetics in which a normal gene is replaced by a defective gene either at the exact same chromosomal sitehence, the normal gene is 'knocked out' by the defective gene-as occurs with the yeast genome, or the deoxyribonucleic acid is inserted at random sites, as occurs in [28] . In the model, we always estimated the contribution of one parameter by setting it to 0 to calculate the decreasing number of cases or total attack rate. For example, the contribution of the parameter β fm simulated by the model was the decreasing number of cases when we set it to 0.

Therefore, "knock-out" simulation (interrupting the different shigellosis transmission routes among males and females) was performed in five scenarios in our study: A) β mm = 0; B) β mf = 0; C) β ff = 0; D) β fm = 0; and E) control (no intervention). was employed for the model simulation. The simulation methods were as previously described [17, [29] [30] [31] [32] . According to our previous published studies [33, 34] , we assumed that heterogeneity of the transmissibility existed during an ascending trend and a descending trend. The annual data were therefore divided into numerous parts and the simulated time step was a day; for example, the data of 2010 were divided into 13 parts ( Moreover, SPSS 21.0 (IBM Corp, Armonk, NY, USA) was used to calculate the coefficient of determination (R 2 ) by curve fitting, which was adopted to judge the model goodness of fit.

Because nine parameters, namely k, ω, γ, γ', p, br, dr, f and q, were obtained from references and the Hubei Statistical Yearbook, uncertainty existed influence in the model. In our model, the nine parameters were split into 1000 values, as indicated in Table 2 . Considering that the simulated model method was the same in each year, we performed sensitivity analysis in 2010 (a middle reported incidence and case in Fig. 4a ). 

The results of the curve fitting indicated that the SEIAR model fitted the data effectively (Fig. 7) . The R 2 values of the SEIAR model for the different genders each year are presented in Table 3 . In 2010, the reported data of all individual groups exhibited a significant fitting effect with simulated data in Hubei Province (Fig. 8) , Wuhan City, and Yichang City (Fig. 9 ).

According to Fig. 10 , the results of the "knock-out" simulation demonstrated that the number of cases in the different genders using the parameters β mm = 0, β ff = 0, β mf = 0 and β fm = 0 were lower than that in the control group. When β fm = 0, the number of cases decreased the most in the different genders.

In 2010, a total of 12 340 cases were reported in Hubei Province (873 cases in Yichang City and 5 899 cases in Wuhan City). The "knock-out" simulation demonstrated similar results of the contribution in four transmission routes between Wuhan and Yichang City, but different results from Hubei Province (Fig. 11) . Fig. 12 presents the difference between the mean and 95% confidence interval (CI) from 2005 to 2017 when using β mm , β ff , β mf and β fm . The mean value was 1.9240 × 10 -9 (95% CI: 1.6621 × 10 -9 to 6.6121 × 10 -9 ) when using β mm , 1.5645 × 10 -9 (95% CI: 1.3521 × 10 -9 to 1.7769 × 10 9 ) when using β ff , 2.1572 × 10 -9 (95% CI: 1.9159 × 10 -9 to 2.3986 × 10 -9 ) when using β fm, and 1.8750 × 10 -9 (95% CI: 1.6846 × 10 -9 to 2.0654 × 10 -9 ) when using β mf .

The results of the SAR from 2005 to 2017 are presented in Fig. 13 . The median value of SAR mm was 2.32 CI: 3.23 × 10 -9 to 1.18 × 10 -8 ) and β 64 (mean: 6.04 × 10 -9 , 95% CI: 2.41 × 10 -9 to 9.67 × 10 -9 ).

Based on the 1000 times that the model ran, the model was not sensitive to the parameters br, dr, f, q and γ'. The number of cases set were the same for the mean, meanstandard deviation (SD) and mean + SD values (Fig. 15 ). Our model was slight sensitive with parameters ω, k and p (Fig. 16a,b,c) . Meanwhile, high sensitivity to parameter γ (0.0741) was demonstrated, as illustrated in Fig. 16d .

Several mathematical models (such as the time-series Susceptible-Infectious-Recovered and SEIARW) have been established to determine the dynamics of shigellosis [17, 35] . However, our study is the first to clarify the Fig. 11 The results to simulate the contribution of β during the transmission in different genders. a: Male; b: Female; β mm = 0, interrupt transmission among male; β ff = 0, interrupt transmission among female; β fm = 0, interrupt transmission from female to male; β mf = 0, interrupt transmission from male to female; None: control transmission of shigellosis between both genders globally. In this study, we used the SEIAR model to study the transmission of the water/food-borne infectious disease and explored the transmission routes in the different sex-age groups further. The results provide guiding significance for controlling the prevalence of shigellosis.

According to R 2 of the linear regression, the SEIAR model exhibited a high goodness of fit with the reported data in the different genders. Moreover, it was consistent with the results of previous research [17] , suggesting that the model was suitable for this study. According to the results of the sensitivity analysis, the model was more sensitive to parameter γ. Therefore, the results would be more reliable if γ was collected from real data, instead of from the literature.

In recent years, although the incidence of shigellosis exhibited a decreasing trend in China [6, 26, 36] , relatively high levels still occurred in Hubei Province from 2005 to 2017. Different incidences of shigellosis cases in males and females were observed by the descriptive epidemiology [37, 38] . However, few clarifications of the causes of this difference and the transmission features have been provided. A study indicated that there were more cases in males than in females (the male-to-female ratio was 1.3:1), which is consistent with our results in the descriptive epidemiology [39] . The transmission pattern of shigellosis has shifted from water/food-to-person to person-to-person, with high risk groups being particularly men who have sex with other men (MSM) in developed countries [1] . Meanwhile, numerous studies have reported that the incidence in males is higher than that in female [6] [7] [8] . Does this mean that the transmissibility of shigellosis among males is stronger than that among females? The SEIAR model was developed to verify this hypothesis. However, we obtained the number of cases in five hypotheses using "knock-out" simulation. When β fm = 0, the number of cases decreased the most in both genders, which means that female-to-male transmission contributed significantly during the transmission. Therefore, it is important to isolate and treat female cases as well as to strengthen personal health.

In this study, we modelled the reported data from two cities in Hubei Province. The results of the "knock-out" simulation demonstrated that the decreasing trend of Wuhan City was similar to that of Yichang City, but both exhibited a certain disparity Fig. 12 The parameter of β mm , β ff , β mf and β fm during the transmission from 2005 to 2017 in Hubei. a: β mm , transmission relative rate among male; b: β ff , transmission relative rate among female; c: β mf , transmission relative rate from male to female; d: β fm , transmission relative rate from female to male Fig. 13 The SAR mm , SAR mf , SAR fm and SAR ff estimated by model from 2005 to 2017 in Hubei. SAR: secondary attack rate; subscript mm, among male; mf, from male to female; fm, from female to male; ff, among female compared to the results of Hubei Province. According to Fig. 9 , there were differences in the cases reported from Wuhan City and Yichang City for 2010. Both cities exhibited similar ascending and descending trends during each time for the same gender, but the results differed from those of Hubei Province. This could be related to the proportion of male and female cases reported daily. Regional differences may not be the main influential factor for the incidences in terms of gender.

Compared to HIV which exhibits different transmissibility in different genders, shigellosis is not particularly highly contagious in the different genders [40] . Our results demonstrated that the mean values of the transmission parameters among males and females, from male to female, and from female to male are differed, with the following order: β fm > β mm > β mf > β ff . The median values of the SAR exhibited the following order: SAR fm > SAR mf > SAR mm > SAR ff . Because a model of the total population in Hubei was constructed, the value of SAR was small and within the neighborhood of zero. However, this did not affect the quantification of the transmissibility of shigellosis. A previous study indicated a high incidence in MSM in developed countries owing to unprotected sex and oro-anal contact [1] . However, the proportion of MSM in China is not large. This finding may be related to the fact that the contact rate between males and females, such as kissing, embracing, and shaking hands, is higher than within genders. The results indicate that the most significant transmission route is from female to male. Superior hygiene behaviours may be responsible for the lower female than male incidences. The greatest reason that males are more susceptible than females may be related to superior lifestyle habits, such as hand washing, in female individuals than in males. Moreover, females generally carry out more tasks such as cooking in the home. This finding suggests the importance of emphasizing the importance of washing hands before cooking for females.

The results of this study are consistent with those of most research [41, 42] , which have indicated a heavy disease burden in children under 6 years. There is no doubt that children have a relatively high susceptibility compared to other ages. Furthermore, it is apparent that children often exhibit poor habits such as not washing their hands after using the toilet or before meals. Our results demonstrate that the main transmission route is from the elderly to children. There is a custom in China whereby young parents leave their children in the grandparents' care. This suggests that the most important intervention may be the need to cut off transmission from the elderly. According to the epidemic characteristics of bacterial dysentery, control measures could be implemented in terms of following aspects: a) Focus on females cooking in the home and grandparents caring for grandchildren, such as advocating hand washing. b) Encourage effective hygiene habits to reduce the susceptibility of male individuals and children. c) Reduce the frequency of social behaviour such as kissing, embracing and shaking hands. Fig. 14 The transmission relative rate in different age and gender groups in 2010. β 0 : transmission relative rate within female; β ij refers to transmission relative rate of gender and age group from i to j, i and j represent subscript 1 to 6, subscript 1 was defined as male and ≤ 5 years old, 2 was male and between 6 to 59 years old, 3 was male and ≥ 60 years old, 4 was female and ≤ 5 years old, 5 was female and between 6 to 59 years old, and 6 was female and ≥ 60 years old; The data of 2010 were divided into 22 stages based on the following simulated periods, Limitations Several influential factors contributed to the year 2010 being considered for estimating the transmission features in the different age groups. It is possible that the transmission would vary according to changes in human behaviour. Thus, further research is required to explore the transmission characteristics of Hubei Province. Numerous studies have indicated that Shigella consists of four species, namely dysenteriae, boydii, flexneri, and sonnei, among which the final two are the most common in low-and middle-income countries [36, 43, 44] . In our study, the dataset was obtained from routine infectious disease surveillance of the CDC in Hubei Province with no reported information regarding the Shigella species. We believe that it is highly necessary to estimate the transmissibility in different Shigella species. Additional data for the different species will need to be collected for analysis. The results have been affected given that we supposed that β w = 0 in the SEIAR model and ignored environmental factors (such as water and food). Moreover, owing to the limited availability of data, sociological components (for example, occupations, and cultural and societal backgrounds) were not considered in the model. Additional data relating to sociological factors need to be collected for analysis. Finally, the parameters of the SEIAR model were obtained from relevant references and the Hubei Statistical Yearbook, and not from a firsthand data, which had an impact on the accuracy of our model.

In Hubei Province, the incidence of shigellosis in males is higher than that in females. The transmissibility between the genders is higher than that within the genders, particularly female-to-male transmission. The main transmission route in children (age ≤ 5 years) is transmission from the elderly (age ≥ 60 years). Therefore, the greatest interventions should be applied in females and the elderly.

Supplementary information accompanies this paper at https://doi.org/10. 1186/s40249-020-00654-x.

Additional file 1 The contribution of β w in SEIARW model.

Additional file 2. Sex-age based SEIAR model.

CDC: Center for Disease Control and Prevention; SEIARW: Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious/Asymptomatic-Recovered-Water/Food; SEIAR: Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious/Asymptomatic-Recovered; SAR: Secondary attack rate; CI: Confidence interval; SD: Standard deviation; MSM: Men who have sex with other men

Environmental drivers and predicted risk of bacillary dysentery in Southwest China

The global burden of diarrhoeal disease

Regional disparities in the burden of disease attributable to unsafe water and poor sanitation in China. B World Health Organ

Multistate shigellosis outbreak and commercially prepared food, United States

Spatiotemporal characteristics of bacillary dysentery from 2005 to 2017 in Zhejiang Province

Spatial-temporal pattern and risk factor analysis of bacillary dysentery in the Beijing-Tianjin-Tangshan urban region of China

The changing epidemiology of bacillary dysentery and characteristics of antimicrobial resistance of Shigella isolated in China from

Gender and the hygiene hypothesis

Risk factors for shigellosis in Thailand

Effects of ambient temperature on bacillary dysentery: a multi-city analysis in Anhui Province

Impact of meteorological factors on the incidence of bacillary dysentery in Beijing, China: a time series analysis

Meteorological variables and bacillary dysentery cases in Changsha City, China

Patterns of bacillary dysentery in China

Socio-economic factors of bacillary dysentery based on spatial correlation analysis in Guangxi Province

Spatiotemporal risk of bacillary dysentery and sensitivity to meteorological factors in Hunan Province

Investigation of key interventions for shigellosis outbreak control in China

Risk factors for secondary transmission of Shigella infection within households: implications for current prevention policy

Detection of intra-familial transmission of shigella infection using conventional serotyping and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis

Asymptomatic salmonella, Shigella and intestinal parasites among primary school children in the eastern province

World Health Organization. Foodborne Disease Outbreaks, Guidelines for investigation and control. Geneva: WHO

An outbreak of foodborne infection caused by Shigella sonnei in West Bengal, India

A school outbreak of Shigella sonnei infection in China: clinical features, antibiotic susceptibility and molecular epidemiology

A Brief History of Shigella

Prevention CfDCa: Shigella -Shigellosis. 2020

Trend and disease burden of bacillary dysentery in China

Global burden of Shigella infections: implications for vaccine development and implementation of control strategies

Gene Knockout Technique. 2020

The effectiveness of age-specific isolation policies on epidemics of influenza a (H1N1) in a large City in central South China

Evidence-based interventions of Norovirus outbreaks in China

Risk of imported Ebola virus disease in China

Simulation of key interventions for seasonal influenza outbreak control at school in Changsha

Estimating the transmissibility of hand, foot, and mouth disease by a dynamic model

Transmissibility of acute haemorrhagic conjunctivitis in small-scale outbreaks in Hunan Province

Dynamics of shigellosis epidemics: estimating individual-level transmission and reporting rates from national epidemiologic data sets

An 11-year study of shigellosis and Shigella species in Taiyuan, China: active surveillance, epidemic characteristics, and molecular serotyping

The epidemiological influence of climatic factors on shigellosis incidence rates in Korea

Spatial-temporal detection of risk factors for bacillary dysentery in Beijing

Identifying high-risk areas of bacillary dysentery and associated meteorological factors in Wuhan

Mathematical models for HIV transmission dynamics: tools for social and behavioral science research

Burden and aetiology of diarrhoeal disease in infants and young children in developing countries (the global enteric multicenter study, GEMS): a prospective, case-control study

Use of quantitative molecular diagnostic methods to identify causes of diarrhoea in children: a reanalysis of the GEMS case-control study

Shift in serotype distribution of Shigella species in China

University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston. 1996; Chapter 22

We thank the staff members in the hospitals, local health departments, and local CDCs for their valuable assistance in coordinating data collection. 

Authors' contributions TC, BZ, and ZZ designed the study. QC collected data. TC, ZZ, QC, BZ, NW, YW, XX, JR, SY, MC, YW, XL, RA, LP, and YS and performed the analysis. TC, ZZ, NW, and MNH wrote the first draft of this paper. All authors contributed to the writing of the manuscript. The author(s) read and approved the final manuscript. Availability of data and materials Extra data is available by emailing to Dr. Qi Chen (317342267@qq.com) on reasonable request.

This effort of disease control was part of CDC's routine responsibility in Hubei Province, China. Therefore, institutional review and informed consent were not required for this study. All data analysed were anonymized.

Not applicable. 

